Delivering Your Speech Steven A. Beebe & Susan J. Beebe Speech vs. Talking The Power of Speech Delivery • • • Delivery is important. Not just what is said, but how it is said. Nonverbal Communication: communication other than written or spoken that creates meaning. The Power of Speech Delivery • • • 65% of a message’s meaning is based on nonverbals. Speakers can lose credibility if delivery disappoints listeners (Nonverbal Expectancy Theory). Emotions can spread to listeners (Emotional Contagion). When nonverbals and verbals contradict, listeners believe nonverbals more. The Jabberwock (Lewis Carroll – Through the Looking Glass) 'Twas brillig, and the slithy toves Did gyre and gimble in the wabe; All mimsy were the borogoves, And the mome raths outgrabe. "Beware the Jabberwock, my son! The jaws that bite, the claws that catch! Beware the Jubjub bird, and shun The frumious Bandersnatch!" He took his vorpal sword in hand: Long time the manxome foe he sought— So rested he by the Tumtum tree, And stood awhile in thought. And as in uffish thought he stood, The Jabberwock, with eyes of flame, Came whiffling through the tulgey wood, And burbled as it came! One, two! One, two! and through and through The vorpal blade went snicker-snack! He left it dead, and with its head He went galumphing back. "And hast thou slain the Jabberwock? Come to my arms, my beamish boy! O frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!" He chortled in his joy. 'Twas brillig, and the slithy toves Did gyre and gimble in the wabe; All mimsy were the borogoves, And the mome raths outgrabe. The Power of Speech Delivery • • • Delivery is important. Not just what is said, but how it is said. Nonverbal Communication: communication other than written or spoken that creates meaning. Methods of Delivery Manuscript Word for word reading Memorized Recalled from your mind Impromptu good: accurate when talking about sensitive issues. bad: limited adaptability. good: strong eye contact. bad: could forget & sound “stiff.” Given good: sounding informal & with little stronger eye-contact. or no bad: can be poorly organized; preparation limited research. Extemporaneous Prepared good: conversational, planned. speaking bad: requires rehearsal & with limited editing. notes Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery • • • • • • • Good eye contact. Effective gestures. Good movements. Structured posture. Strong facial expression. Effective vocal delivery. Appropriate physical appearance. SPEECH EVALUATION CHART Speaker Grade Subject Content: Date Time Excellent Good Fair Poor Comment Excellent Good Fair Poor Comment Aroused Attention Purpose Made Clear Organization Supporting Material Visual Aids Effective Delivery: Rate Loudness Voice Quality Eye Contact Posture Gestures Comments: Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Good eye contact • • • • Is established with entire audience. Connects with people; for 2 – 3 seconds or more. Does not look above heads. Varies naturally (not mechanically). Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective gestures • • Use of hands to emphasize key ideas. Functions of gestures: • Repeat: illustrate • Contradict: oppose • Substitute: replace • Complement: enhance • Emphasize: accentuate • Regulate: control Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective gestures • • • • • Are natural. Are definite & have a purpose. Are consistent with your words. Do not call attention to themselves. Are appropriate to the audience and occasion. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective movement should • • • • • Be controlled. Be made with a purpose. Create closeness with the audience. Highlight transitions. Not be overdone. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective posture •Can enhance credibility. •Can intensify emotions. •Is adjusted to the occasion: • Informal (more relaxed). • Formal (more professional). •Means to stand up straight. •Don’t slump or slouch. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective facial expression • • • Should reflect the mood of the speech. Should reflect the purpose also. Should be sincere. Remember: Listeners see face before hearing words. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective vocal delivery • • • • • Adequate volume. Clear articulation. Non-distracting dialect. Solid pronunciation. Display vocal variety. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective vocal delivery • Adequate volume: Loud enough to create desired effect, while also allowing people to hear message. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective vocal delivery Clear articulation (enunciation): producing clear sounds of each syllable & word. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Weak articulation “Wanna” “Lemme” “Whadayado” “Seeya” “Soun” Strong articulation 1. “Want to” 2. “Let me” 3. “What do you do” 4. “See you” 5. “Sound” Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective vocal delivery Dialect: pronunciation related to an ethnic group or geographical region. Distracting 1. “Earl” (New York) 2. “Cuber” (Boston) 3. “Raahtin” (Rochester) Non-distracting 1. “Oil” 2. “Cuba” 3. “Rotten” Note: dialects generally okay, as long as content is not distracting. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective vocal delivery Pronunciation: use of sounds to form words clearly and accurately. Weak pronunciation 1. “Febuary” 2. “Actchally” 3. “Aks” Strong pronunciation 1. “February" 2. “Actually” 3. “Ask” Note: work to prolong sounds that can get mispronounced. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective vocal delivery • • Vocal variety: diverse qualities of voice. 1. Pitch: highness & lowness of voice. 2. Inflections: changes in pitch. 3. Rate: how fast or slow you speak. 4. Pauses: use of silence. 5. Avoid vocalized pauses (uh, um, er). Vary pitch, inflections, rate and pauses. Characteristics of Effective Speech Delivery Effective vocal delivery • • Personal Appearance. Appropriate wardrobe depends on: • Climate. • Custom. • Culture. • Audience. • Do not violate audience expectations for your appearance. Pause Everyone Persuades Persuasion Defined Process of changing or reinforcing attitudes, beliefs, values or behaviors. • • • • • • Attitudes: likes or dislikes. Beliefs: what is regarded as true or false. Values: enduring ideas of what is right/wrong, good/bad. Attitudes: most likely to change. Values: least likely to change. Behaviors: actions displayed. How Persuasion Works The Classical Rhetoric Approach • • Rhetoric: discovering ways to persuade. Three methods of persuasion: • Ethos - creating audience trust & believability through ethics, character & concern for the audience. • Logos - rational & logical arguments, through sound evidence. • Pathos - emotions that may involve stories, pictures and music. • Ethos, logos & pathos motivate people. How to Motivate Listeners • • • • Dissonance. Listener Needs. Positive Motivation. Negative Motivation. Positive Motivation • Good things will happen if listeners follow speaker’s advice. • Emphasize that positive values will be maintained or restored. • Emphasize benefits & features. • Benefit: a good result appealing to emotions. • Feature: rational cognitive explanation appealing to logic. Negative Motivation • Bad things will happen if speaker’s advice is not followed. • Fear appeals are common. • Threats to loved ones work better. • Fear appeals work better when speaker credibility is higher. • As fear appeals intensify, so do chances of success. Determine your “Persuasive Purpose” • Set a reasonable goal. • Do not expect drastic changes. • Social Judgment Theory: • Listeners in latitude of acceptance: more likely to be convinced. • Listeners in latitude of rejection or noncommitment: may not be convinced. How to Develop Your Persuasive Speech Develop your central idea & main ideas • State central idea as a proposition: (statement seeking audience agreement) 1. Fact: States something is true or false; or it did or did not happen. 2. Value: Judges something (good or bad, right or wrong, etc.). 3. Policy: Advocates change in law, procedure or behavior. • Main ideas should support your proposition. How to Develop Your Persuasive Speech Proposition of Fact National Steel, Inc. has contaminated the city I. Lead samples in city soil match lead isotopes from National Steel, Inc. II. Children living near National Steel, Inc. have blood-lead concentrations higher than the state average. III. Employees of National Steel, Inc. are reporting incidents of cancer. How to Develop Your Persuasive Speech Proposition of Value Reggae music is better than Rock music I. Reggae music communicates a message of equality for all people. II. Reggae music and its rhythms evoke a positive, uplifting mood. III. Reggae music draws upon a variety of cultural and ethnic traditions. How to Develop Your Persuasive Speech Proposition of Policy Our college should abolish academic tenure I. Academic tenure is outdated. II. Academic tenure is abused. III. Academic tenure contributes to ineffective education. Putting Persuasive Principles into Practice • Learn about listeners’ attitudes, beliefs & values. • Create messages that help listeners avoid dissonance. • Shown listeners how plan solves a problem or satisfies needs. • Manage fear appeals: don’t go overboard, and show how the threat can be controlled. A Sample Persuasive Speech Watch the video, and ask yourself: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Is this speech addressing a proposition of fact, value or policy? How does the speaker try to point out cognitive dissonance in the listeners? Which of Maslow’s needs are addressed? What type of organizational pattern does the speaker use? Does the speaker ask for changes in attitudes? Beliefs? Values? Behaviors? What types of sources does the speaker use to substantiate claims? A Sample Persuasive Speech A Sample Persuasive Speech Watch the video, and ask yourself: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Is this speech addressing a proposition of fact, value or policy? How does the speaker try to point out cognitive dissonance in the listeners? Which of Maslow’s needs are addressed? What type of organizational pattern does the speaker use? Does the speaker ask for changes in attitudes? Beliefs? Values? Behaviors? What types of sources does the speaker use to substantiate claims? A Question of Ethics. . . Persuasion “…is the process of adjusting ideas to people and people to ideas.” - Donald C. Bryant, rhetoric scholar Establishing Credibility Also known as ethos. • Audience’s perceptions of the speaker. • Various dimensions: • • Competence- knowledge & skill. • Trustworthiness- believability & honesty. • Dynamism- energy level. • Charisma- charm, talent & magnetism. Enhancing Your Credibility • Credibility established in three places: • Initial credibility: perceptions before speech. • Derived credibility: impressions formed during speech. • Terminal credibility: final impressions, after speech. • Ways to boost credibility: • Well-stressed values and concerns shared with audience. • Well-documented evidence. • Well-organized ideas. • Well-managed delivery. Using Logic and Evidence to Persuade • • Aristotle: “always prove what you state.” • Logos: formal system of rules to reach a conclusion. • Reasoning: drawing a conclusion from the evidence. Understanding Types of Reasoning • • • Inductive Reasoning. Deductive Reasoning. Causal Reasoning. Understanding Types of Reasoning Inductive Reasoning • • Using specific examples or instances to reach a general or probable conclusion. Used when one can claim that an outcome is probably true because of specific evidence. Understanding Types of Reasoning • • • Testing the Validity of Inductive Reasoning Are there enough specific instances to support the conclusion? Are the specific instances typical? Are the instances recent? Understanding Types of Reasoning Inductive Reasoning: an example I. Students are sneezing in dorms & classrooms. (specific example 1) II. Professors are cancelling classes. (specific example 2) III. Campus Clinic has long waiting lines. (specific example 3) IV. There must be a flu on our campus. (general conclusion) Understanding Types of Reasoning Reasoning by Analogy (a special type of inductive reasoning) • Makes a comparison between two things, entities, processes, etc. • If you conclude what is true for one can be true for the other, then the analog is strong. Understanding Types of Reasoning Testing the Validity of Reasoning by Analogy • Are similarities between both, greater than differences? • Is the conclusion being drawn actually true? Understanding Types of Reasoning Deductive Reasoning • Opposite of induction. • Conclusion (generalization) is more certain than probable. • The more valid or truthful the outcome, the more certain the conclusion. • Start with widely accepted general claim, and then move towards specific conclusion illustrating general claim. Understanding Types of Reasoning Structure of Deductive Reasoning • Syllogism – three-part argument: • Major Premise: widely accepted general statement. • Minor Premise: specific statement that applies to the major premise. • Conclusion: logical outcome, minor premise exemplifies major premise. • The more valid the major premise, the more valid the deduction. Understanding Types of Reasoning Testing the Validity of Deductive Reasoning • Is major premise (general statement) true? • Is minor premise (specific instance) true? Understanding Types of Reasoning Deductive Reasoning: an example I. All tough drug laws introduced in mediumsized communities result in diminished drug-related crimes. (generally accepted statement) II. San Marcos, Texas is a medium-sized community. (specific case supporting general statement) III. San Marcos should institute tough drug laws. (specific conclusion) Understanding Types of Reasoning Causal Reasoning • Relating events to show connection. • To conclude that one or more events caused another event. • Can move from cause to effect. • Can move from effect to cause. Supporting Your Reasoning with Evidence • Use facts. • • • • • • Use valid true examples. Use opinions that enhance credibility. Use sound & reliable statistics. Use reluctant testimony: shows that someone has been convinced. Use new & specific evidence. Use evidence to tell a story. Avoid Faulty Reasoning • Be ethical & appropriate with evidence & reasoning. • Fallacy: false reasoning when someone attempts to persuade without adequate evidence, or with arguments that are irrelevant or inappropriate. Avoid Faulty Reasoning Reasoning Fallacies Causal “Hurricanes are caused by war” (a connection not related) Bandwagon “Everyone knows cell phones are safe” (popularity appeals) Either-Or “Either you’re with us or you’re against us” (only 2 choices) Hasty “Since my niece is failing, city Generalization schools are bad” (quick Conclusion) Avoid Faulty Reasoning Reasoning Fallacies Ad Hominem “What does a divorced man know about parenting?” (personal attack) Red Herring “Let’s not focus on the lawsuit against me; let’s talk about…” (changing the topic to distract) Misplaced “Jessica Simpson says McMillan Authority trucks are best” (not a true expert) Non Sequitur “Support me for Congress – I have 3 children” (ideas do not follow) Using Emotion to Persuade • Can make people feel pleasure or displeasure. • Can make people feel more aroused. • Can make people feel dominance. Tips for Using Emotion to Persuade • Use details that help listeners visualize. • Use emotion-arousing words (“freedom,” “9-11,” “mommy.”) • Delivery should reflect emotions. • Use pictures or images. Tips for Using Emotion to Persuade • Use appropriate metaphors & similes. • Use right amount of fear appeals. • Appeal to several emotions. • Appeal to audience members’ myths. Myth: not necessarily false, but a belief of how people view their world. (e.g., Old West pioneers: strong & adventurous) • Avoid unethical emotional appeals & appeals to listeners’ prejudices (demagoguery). Adapting Ideas to People and People to Ideas Persuading the receptive audience. • Identify with them. • Clearly state your objectivity. • Tell them exactly what you want them to do. • Ask them for an immediate show of support. • Use emotional appeals effectively. • Make it easy for them to take action. Adapting Ideas to People and People to Ideas Persuading the neutral audience. • Capture their attention early. • Stress commonly shared beliefs. • Relate topic to them, their friends, families and loved ones. • Be realistic with the response you want. Adapting Ideas to People and People to Ideas Persuading the unreceptive audience. • • • • • Wait before telling them your purpose. Start with noting areas of agreement. Set realistic goals. Acknowledge how they might oppose you. Clearly tell them any experiences you have. Adapting Ideas to People and People to Ideas Persuading the unreceptive audience. Consider understanding (not advocacy) as your goal. • Summarize common misconceptions people have. • State why misconceptions may seem reasonable. • Dismiss misconceptions, and provide evidence to support your point. • State accurate information you want them to remember.