Sociological Perspectives on Health Simon Corneau Jean-François Roy Sociological Perspectives on Health « From a sociological point of view, factors contribute to the evaluation of a person as ‘healthy’ or ‘sick’. » (Schaefer & Smith, 2004). Because health is relative, we can view it in a social context and consider how it varies in different situations or cultures. Functionalist Approach Conflict Approach Interactionist Approach Feminist Approaches Functionalist Approach Illness entails at least a temporary disruption in a person’s social interactions. « Sickness » requires that one take on a particular social role, even if temporary ; the « sick role ». The « sick » are expected to try to get well (e.g., seek medical care) and return to their normal activities. Being sick must be controlled so that not too many people are released from their societal responsibilities at any one time. An overly broad definition of illness would disrupt the workings of a society. Conflict Approach Conflict theorists seek to determine who benefits, who suffers, and who Inequities dominates atin theHealth expense of others in a given Medicalization ofCare Society Delivery situation. There arehas Medicine inequities expanded in health its domain care delivery of expertise within Canada: in recent decades.and northern Once rural a problem areas. is appropriated, There are global it becomes inequities: difficult 25 doctors to view per 1000 theseinissues USA, as shaped less then 1 by persociocultural 1000 in African factors. nations. A « brainmaintains drain » isan absolute Medicine contributing the poor health monopoly overtomany health of developing countries. care procedures. It places « Dumping » of unapproved health care professionals suchor drugsand in developing asfraudulent chiropractors nursecountries. midwifes outside the realm of acceptable medicine. Interactionist Approach Focus on micro-level study of the roles played by health care professionals and patients. The patient is an active actor whose action can have a negative or positive impact on his health. Interactionists also attempt to shed light on the « social meaning » of illness and how they affect one’s self-concept and social interaction; « labelling theory » focus on the effects of the social stigma of the illness (e.g., AIDS, women’s health, homosexuality). Cultural differences in « social meanings » of illness and health care delivery. Feminist Approaches Health is an area of central concern for women. Women form the majority of health workers, of health care users and of caregivers. Research on women’s health has focused on reproductive health issues, overshadowing a range of other health and illness issues; everything was related to the uterus and hormones. There is still sexist bias in the health literature today (Janzen, 1998). Feminists theorists also draw the attention on how multiple minority status intersects to produce varying levels of health and disease (ex : being black and being a lesbian). Morbidity Rates and Populations Sociologists find morbidity rates useful because they reveal that a specific disease occurs more frequently among one segment of a population then another. Social Class Race and Gender Sexual Age Orientation Ethnicity Clearly is associated with differences morbidity andof Females Health profiles care have oneservices ofaofthe life many overriding expectancy often racial assume and concerns ofethnic 81,7 ainpatient and of minorities the males is elderly. mortality Why is class linked towhere ? patient reflect 76,3. heterosexual Gender Asocial difference isrates. most inequalities. and important create attributed aThe insituation to the health behavioural study ofhealth ofCanada’s health the factors and Firstis Crowded living conditions, housing, Nations (drinking less aging likely since reflects and towomen openly dangerous patterns live talk longer; about driving), ofsubstandard years health yetoccupational ofelderly exclusion matters women related limiting hazards to poor diet, stress, limited education, workplace, etc. theirsexual (construction), his receive access little orientation, research to and many women’s ofattention. like the sexual social tendency Social health determinants to support orseek mental health is ofahealth key like income, care (high factor services rate related of education suicide to earlier the health among and and more ofemployment. young older often. gay menmen). and women. Social Capital One of sociology’s main contributions has been to identify social capital as a determinant of health. Many recent studies have explored the links between social capital and health. Social capital may contribute directly to health or may result in policies that are more supportive of healthy outcomes. Social Capital Social capital refers to the institutions, relationships and norms that shape the quality and quantity of a society’s social interactions. (World Bank, 2001) How is it Measured? Social capital as a social determinant of health is measured with non-medical indicators. For example, Key indicators Trust (in others, in institutions) Civic engagement (participation) Social network (social support) Social cohesion (sense of belonging) Income distribution Social Capital and Crime 3 dominant theoretical perspectives 1) Social disorganization: lack of social control 2) Anomie: weakening of behavioural norms 3) Strain theory: lack of opportunities Geographic areas with ↑ levels of social capital have lower homicide rates. High homicide rates may undermine social trust and civic engagement and ↓ the stock of social capital (Rosenfeld et al., 2001). Criminology and Health Health status is affected by socioeconomic status → people from low socioeconomic classes are over-represented in prison → health condition is also affected by the prison context (they live and work with people carrying infectious diseases) Areas of inquiry: Utilization of prison health services Consequences of confinement Aging offenders Policy level Causes of Crime Conditions that make crime more likely: Poverty (women) Wealth (white-collar crime) Drug abuse Who are in Prisons ? Over-representation of native people People of lower socioeconomic status (except for Martha Stewart) Drug related crimes People with mental health problems Prevalence of unhealthy lifestyles: cigarette & alcohol abuse, drug abuse, poor diet, sexual promiscuity (Smith, 2002). Healthy Prisons? High prevalence of HIV/AIDS and Hep C, tuberculosis is coming back Risk factors : Consensual sexual activities Prison rape Drug injection Tattooing All these behaviours are prohibited by the prison code of conduct (affects likelihood of conditional release) ↑ Suicide rate Self mutilation (women) ↑ level of stress (violence and power relations) How to Explain this... Deprivation model (Krebs, 2002) : what do you learn behind bars Importation model (Krebs, 2002) : what do you bring with you in prison How the System Reacts? Condoms: can only be obtained through nurses, one at a time No clean needles; bleach available only in some provinces War on drugs (random testing) That Means… Inmates can become infected while in prison, becoming a threat to the general population when released. CCS Mission: Protection of society Questions (1) ? Do people from lower socioeconomic classes really commit more crime, or are they just more often targeted by official formal control? Can we really « rehabilitate » someone while in prison when we know that the person will return into the same socioeconomic conditions after incarceration (low stock of social capital)? Is a punitive approach appropriate for drug related offences? (Rehab vs. Punishment) Questions (2) ? How would a functionalist analyze the medicalization of society? How would a interactionist analyze AIDS ? How would a conflict theorist analyze links between health and occupation? Some Figures on Social Capital Bowling alone : the collapse and revival of American community. Robert D. Putnam (2000) Source : Putnam, 2000. Source : Putnam, 2000. Source : Putnam, 2000. Source : Putnam, 2000. Source : Putnam, 2000.