FACTORS INFLUENCING SUPPLY AND DEMAND OF ORGANIC FOOD Presented By: Maida Asif Ayesha Ishaq Sharrel Palous WHAT IS ORGANIC FOOD? Organic foods are foods produced by organic farming. Synthetic pesticides and chemical fertilizers are not allowed, although certain organically approved pesticides may be used under limited conditions. In general, organic foods are also not processed using irradiation, industrial solvents, or synthetic food additives. Organic farming in general features cultural, biological, and mechanical practices that foster cycling of resources, promote ecological balance, and conserve biodiversity. http://www.organic.org/home/faq CONVENTIONAL FOOD VS ORGANIC FOOD http://lcnutritionsolutions.com/tag/organic-food/ ORGANIC FOODS DEFINED 100% Organic • Only organically-produced ingredients and processing aids • Specific processing methods • Specific nutritional labeling Organic • 95% organically produced ingredients • Specific processing methods • Specific nutritional labeling Made with Organic Ingredients • At least 70% organic ingredients • Specific ingredients noted • Specific processing methods http://www.fda.gov/ohrms/dockets/dockets/06p0094/06p-0094-cp00001-05-Tab-04-Food-Marketing-Institute-vol1.pdf ORGANIC FARMING DEFINED: As defined by FAO (1999) “Organic farming is an environmental friendly ecosystem management in which, use of all kinds of synthetic inputs are eliminated”. The area delineated for “organic farming” forbids use of synthetic fertilizers, pesticides, veterinary drugs, hormones, Genetically Modified Seeds (GM seeds) and breeds, additives, preservatives etc. These are replaced with site specific management system that maintain and increase long term soil fertility and prevent pest and diseases www.pide.org.pk/pdf/Seminar/Seminar82.pdf ORGANIC AGRICULTURE IN PAKISTAN the organic agriculture is still in its infancy in Pakistan. Current products include organic rice, organic sesame seed, organic wheat, organic Kinno fruit and juice concentrate, and organic mango fruit and pulp. Tremendous opportunities exist in a wide range of organic foods including fruits and vegetables, cereals and grain, beef, poultry and eggs, honey and several other processed products. This implies that with proper guidance, support and strategies, the Pakistani farmers should be capable to cater for the domestic demand and penetrate the foreign organic food markets as well. http://www.pakistaneconomist.com/issue2003/issue29/ f&m4.asp STATE OF ORGANIC AGRICULTURE WORLDhttp://www.pakistaneconomist.com/issue2003 /issue29/f&m4.asp WIDE Country Organic Hectares % of agriculture land Number of organic farms Australia 10,500,000 2.31 1,380 Argentina 3,192,000 1.89 1,900 Italy 1,230,000 7.94 56,440 U.S.A. 950,000 0.23 6,949 U.K. 679,631 3.96 3,981 Spain 485,079 1.66 15,607 Canada 430,600 0.58 3,236 France 419,750 1.40 10,364 China 301,295 0.06 2,910 Austria 285,500 11.30 18,292 India 41,000 0.03 5,661 Pakistan 2,009 0.08 405 Liechtenstein 690 17.00 35 LEGISLATION OF ORGANIC FOOD Organic food production within the EU is strictly regulated. EU rules apply to the organic production and to the labelling and control of organic products. Organic control bodies (CBs) license individual organic operators. They are approved by Defra. You must be registered with one of the CBs, comply with their standards and meet their requirements in order to market your produce as ‘organic’. (Text book) DEMAND FOR ORGANIC FOOD IN US Sales of organic food have grown by 20 percent annually, and experts predict that the industry's share of the U.S. food market is expected to grow from about 2 percent to roughly 3.5 percent by the end of the decade. The United States now spends more than $1 billion a year to import organic food, according to the USDA, and the ratio of imported to exported products is now about 8to-1. www.bayjournal.com/article/demand_for_organic_food_growing_faster_than_domesti c_supply DEMAND OF ORGANIC FOOD IN PAKISTAN Organic products for sale at a farmers market in Islamabad. (Photo by by Aamir Saeed) According to the Pakistan Agriculture Research Council, the total area under organic agriculture has grown from 35,000 acres in 2005 to 150,000 acres in 2010. An estimated 33% of farmers in Pakistan are going organic and this number is projected to double in the next couple of years. “The demand for organic products is high in the market and I earned three times more just in six months,” said Khalid, who first cultivated organic vegetables in 2011. Encouraged by the success, he then started growing organic wheat on his sprawling seven acres of farmland in an Islamabad suburb. http://www.thethirdpole.net/pakistan-farmers-go-organic/ WHY PEOPLE DEMAND ORGANIC FOOD? Parents tend to be motivated by health concerns. The Organic Trade Association found that nearly half of parents surveyed—48 percent—were motivated to buy organic food because they believe it is healthier for themselves and their children. Other motivators for parents include concerns over the effects of pesticides, hormones and antibiotics on children, and avoidance of highly processed food and artificial ingredients. When researchers look at a broader population than parents, however, they get different reasons for purchasing organic food. Of the respondents in the NPR poll who prefer organic food, 36 % are motivated by a desire to support local farms. 34% wish to avoid toxins in their food, 17 %believe that organic food is better for the environment, 13 % say that organic food tastes better and 11% believe organic food is safer. http://www.cias.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/growing-demand.pdf PRICE PREMIUMS The percentage of consumers who purchase organic foods affects the relationship among the market statistics. In 2000, 49 percent of nonbuyers in theUnited States named price as a barrier to purchase compared with 33 percent in 1998. Retailers in the United States also cite price as a barrier to offering organic foods. EXAMINING THE COST OF AN ALLORGANIC DIET CHERYL BROWN AND MARK SPEROW The total cost for the TFP food lists for two weeks of organic products is $383.71, compared to $257.72 for the same quantities of non-organic products. Thus the average weekly cost for a family of four to purchase organic foods is $191.85 versus $128.66 for non-organic; the family pays, on average, $63.23 per week or 49% more for the all-organic diet. Income for a family of four that wants to consume an all-organic diet would have to be 49% higher to maintain the same budget share for food-at-home compared to that for a non-organic diet. http://ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/26759/1/360100 20.pdf PRICE COMPARISONS: ORGANIC VS. CONVENTIONAL FOODS Food Item Name Milk Dairy Conventio $3.39/g Glen Milk nal al 2% $0.03/fl.o z O Organics Organic 2% Milk $0.05/fl. oz Foster Chick Farms en Chicken Breast O Organics Chicken Breast Type Organic Price $6.59/g al Price Per Unit Conventio $3.59/lb $0.22/oz nal Organic $8.99/lb $0.56/oz http://www.popsugar.com/smart-living/Conventional-vs-Organic-GroceryPrices-18342929 QUALITY: Shelflife Taste • Some organic food have shorter shelf life that deteriorates quality of organic food. • Sometimes lack of good taste also become a hurdle in increase of demand of organic food. • Nutrient content can be affected by fertilizers and pesticides; nutrient density is greater in organic crops; and animals fed organically have better health. Nutritious • Organic food tends to have in it, significantly higher levels of all 21 nutrients analyzed compared with conventional produce including value vitamin C (27% more), Mg (29% more), Fe (21% more) and 14% more • Phosphorus www.pide.org.pk/pdf/Seminar/Seminar82.pdf POTENTIAL OF ORGANIC FARMING IN PAKISTAN • If proper planning and fore sighted measures are timely taken, Pakistan has one of the greatest potential among the developing countries. • Millions of acres of highly fertile and productive-virgin lands under the command of five mega dams Akhori,BhashaDiamer, Kalabagh, Kuramtangi and Munda to be built by 2016 at a cost of $ 25 billions can be the potential areas for delineation as ‘organic farming’ areas. • The ‘organic farming’ will have a direct impact to alleviate poverty by providing large scale employment to unskilled semi-skilled labor www.pide.org.pk/pdf/Seminar/Seminar82.pd f EXAMPLE FROM LOCAL ENVIRONMENT There are a few organic food companies in Karachi already, the most well-known is Sungold Organic who supply chemical-free, naturally grown vegetables, which they irrigate with potable water on their farm in Malir to various restaurants and supermarkets in the city. They also produce their own natural fertilizer. They have a long list of available vegetables, including broccoli, carrots and eggplant and can deliver to your doorstep as well. CONT…. Naimat Milk is another natural milk company in Lahore that delivers milk from both cows and buffaloes fed natural feed to your doorstep. They can also deliver desi eggs and desi chickens. Their milk comes covered with a thick layer of cream, like it used to in the old days before doodwallahs became commercialized! http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthread.php?161 332-Organic-Food-in-Pakistan! CREDIBILITY OF ORGANIC STANDARDS AND AUDITING SYSTEM Credibility and certification also affect consumer’s demand of organic food. Establishment of EU crop production standards resulted in boost in consumer’s demand. POTENTIAL OF ORGANIC FARMING IN PAKISTAN • If proper planning and fore sighted measures are timely taken, Pakistan has one of the greatest potential among the developing countries. • Millions of acres of highly fertile and productive-virgin lands under the command of five mega dams Akhori, Bhasha-Diamer, Kalabagh, Kuramtangi and Munda to be built by 2016 at a cost of $ 25 billions can be the potential areas for delineation as ‘organic farming’ areas. • The ‘organic farming’ will have a direct impact to alleviate poverty by providing large scale employment to unskilled semi-skilled labor APPLICATION IN LOCAL ENVIRONMENT Organic farming should be applied in poultry in Pakistan. There is a dire need of this as broiler chicken have antibiotics and dangerous feed. Steps should be taken so there will be a balance between supply and demand of organic chicken. AVAILABILITY Demand of organic food depends: Product Availability That insured by continual supply (season) Text- page no. 203 Barriers – with increase in production the barriers issues can be cover come. STATE OF ECONOMY With recession when people are stop buying – luxury item the buying of organic products was also decreased . Factor behind this: High un- employment High un employment inversely proportion less buying power Text- page no. 203 CREDIBILITY OF ORGANIC STANDARDS AND AUDITING SYSTEM: Demand of organic products affected by: Credibility of the organic industry Consumers' perception of the standards, sector bodies and certification agencies e.g. UK- news paper : report showed what promised to be organic ( a pork from pig weaned) was actually not full filling the organic standards.- this decreased the sales of pork by 40%- regardless it was produced in UK or Germany. Text- page no. 203 SOLUTION: EU and UK agencies Boost consumers confidence - Ultimately increased demand This helps in increases market Text- page no. 204 In 1990s’ EU organic crop production stand. http://nofavt.org/programs/organic-certification DEMAND OF ORGANIC FOOD IN CONTEXT OF GENDER ( SPAIN CASE STUDY) Back ground/ issue: consumers due to periodic food scandals as well as to certain technological advances- GMO and food irradiation results in concern towards Organic food. Demands for food safety, quality guarantees and additional information about food production methods. Solution: This is causing agro food businesses to adapt to satisfy such demands while simultaneously trying to become differentiated so they can defend their competitive – by using Organic icon R Olivas,2012, http://revistas.inia.es/index.php/sjar/article/view/2213 STRATEGY: Through awareness campaigns, TV ads and print media they create a distress and then giving solution to consumer that is Organic food. Research conducted on 420 Organic Food consumers. Questionnaire and other means and through research they found out the females are more motivated for organic food than males. Agro food also involve environmental factor (environment friendly food) plus point – to encourage men also to buy Organic Food. R Olivas,2012, http://revistas.inia.es/index.php/sjar/article/view/2213 CONCLUSION: In conclusion the basic commercial strategy for increasing organic food consumption in Spain would be for businesses as well as the government to conduct communication campaigns addressed basically to women clear promoters of healthy eating in the home. R Olivas,2012, http://revistas.inia.es/index.php/sjar/article/view/2213 LOCAL EXAMPLE: Khalis food Market organizes the event in Lahore, Feb. 3rd 2014. Purpose: Event organizer Rizwan said, “Our idea was to bridge the gap between the people growing products and the people looking for it”, Sustainability: Set goal to further expand events and so they and common masses can find out the organic food growers and products----------to promote organic food market. Rina Saeed khan, April 30-2014 http://www.dawn.com/news/794899/the-khalis-foodmovement SCENARIO OF ORGANIC FOOD MARKETPAKISTAN In Pakistan People started taking interest in word organic. There are number of organic brands and companies that are working in different area of Pakistan: Khalis Food Market Koshar market… Islamabad Mehjabeen Abidi-Habib’s organic garden is what it should be — useful and delightful Dali, Ethnic, Zoya, MOC- brands that work to increase brand loyal customers Hunza Organics, run by Zahid Durrani in Lahore, and it has been certified by the Control Union in the Netherlands. http://jang.com.pk/thenews/may2013-weekly/nos-12-05-2013/spr.htm Rina Saeed- 2008(FridayTimes)https://lahorenama.wordpress.com/.../lahore-goesgreen-roshni’s-german PAKISTAN ORGANIC MARKET Alien •The word is not alien but people know it as Khalis and other names. •Number of brands, companies and NGOs working there in Pakistan. • The Roshni organic is one of many organic product producing name. • Its been growing number of vegetables, nuts and also running bakery. Roshni • The location is out side Lahore- Roshni village …. Number of Organic people with and without special needs come together to live and to work • rice, wheat, potatoes, carrots, chillies, okra, herbs, pumpkins, and a number of fruits. • it has been making pure whole meal bread for a few years Product now in Lahore and they have a home delivery system in s addition to supplying their bread to Pioneer store. http://www.roshni.org.pk/ The forces behind supply are: Roshni Village Roshni Organic Bakery Roshni Organic Shop Rina Saeed2008(FridayTimes)https://lahorenama.wordpress.com/.../laho re-goes-green-roshni’s-german SUPPLY CASE STUDY: DEPICTING THE EFFECTIVENESS IN DELIVERANCE OF ORGANIC STUFF THROUGH PLANNING Background: ROFN is an initiative of the Centre for Systems Studies at the University of Hull Business School, UK to create an effective network to which small organic businesses can cohere without sacrificing autonomy. Issue: working with isolated businesses facing problems. the project is based on establishing new partnerships between local growers and distributors, and with local consumers, restaurants, schools and hospitals. Georgina Holt 2007,http://aof.revues.org/479#tocto2n4 AIM: The research project aims to support networking practices by improving the regional organization, logistics and technical infrastructure of organic producers and retailers in North Yorkshire. Solution: The project uses internet systems to set new standards of user Friendliness Functionality Effectiveness Georgina Holt, 2007 [http://aof.revues.org/479#tocto2n4] STRATEGY: An e-bay-like method of assessment, providing feedback on all transactions and from all users, will be used to develop indicators: Quality Value Speed of payment Speed of delivery. Georgina Holt, 2007 [http://aof.revues.org/479#tocto2n4] CONCLUSION: Such a sophisticated information community would allow buyers to find out what is coming into harvest and who has surpluses, and enable growers to assess demand, share good practice and plan planting. Georgina Holt, 2007 [http://aof.revues.org/479#tocto2n4] SUPPLY CHAIN OF ORGANIC PRODUCT Consumer 11% of households across the UK Raw material 20 farms Retailers Supplier supermarke t chains Calon Wen a Welsh organic milk cooperative Manufactur er Rachel’s Organic http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/sep/23/organic-food-drink-sectorstabilises-sales-rise THE ORGANIC MEAT COMPANY (LOCAL EXAMPLE) THE ORGANIC MEAT COMPANY PVT LTD is a high class meat processing company fulfilling all the international standard food hygiene GMP The processing plant of - company is located in Karachi. http://theorganicmeatcompany.net/ HYPOTHESIZE WORK: Issue: Target customers- unidentified Consumer preferred- cheap meat (non-organic one) Nonstrategic SCM Solution: Apply Lean supply chain Internet – awareness and advertising ( reduce cost) Campaigns – significance of organic Target customers- middle and upper class people of Karachi ( poor- affordability issue) Collaboration with rural area people that are raising organic animals THE ORGANIC MEAT COMPANY Go for LEAN SCM High light the weakness Involve technolo gy EDI KPI and JIT Improvement in sales and value Less wastage and more profit Compet ent manger KPI- finding out the actual no. of consumer – needed organic meat Agriculture produce from organic products honey, fruits , vegetables etc. are exclusively high price Varied in come due to varied fertility Organic farming under strict surveillance of International Certifying Agencies In conversion checks required to prove absence of synthetic input Existing Irrigated Land Prime land with high quality produce Invite International Certifying Agency to delineate prime land for high quality produce Soil fertility & other tests to delineate best area & to confirm absence of Synthetic input Million of acres of potential virgin land under the command of 5 mega dams Million of acres of potential virgin land under the command of 5 mega dams Educating farmers regarding huge profits and seeking their consent to follow the regulations, control measures and standard 15.13 Million hectares potential land (cultivable waste + current fallow) * 22.12 Million hectares irrigated cultivated land * Source:The Road to Organic Farming in Pakistan DR. Abdulrauf , Farooqi www.pide.org.pk/pdf/Seminar/Seminar82.pdf (2012) SUBSIDY LEVEL The level of subsidies that farmers receive to enhance their incomes over that generated by the sale of their produce can affect their decision making concerning conversion to organic production and ultimately the supply of organic commodities. The subsidies are divided into two groups: Specific Organic Subsidies General Conventional Subsidies More chances of converting to organic farming if rate of conversion based subsidy increases Reversed situation Livestock and arable crop production Example: Denmark Conversion to organic is low Source: Food Supply Chain Management .Bourlakis,M.A. and Weightman, P.W.H. 1st Edition, 2004, Blackwell Publishing Limited. Oxford, UK. Pg 206 SUBSIDY LEVEL In the early 1990s, the only two existing EU regulations that relate directly to organic farming were introduced. Regulation 2092/91 • Aided the growth of premium organic markets through certification and labeling. Regulation 2078/92 • It forms a supportive policy environment for the provision of subsidies for conversion to, and support of organic farming. Source: http://orgprints.org/8440/1/holt_Comparison_markets_EU_states.pdf SUBSIDY LEVEL The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) helps agricultural producers either directly or indirectly through different ways. The subsidy system, updated approximately every five years, provides financial support primarily to producers of “commodity crops,” which consist of more than a dozen nonperishable crops. Source: http://orgprints.org/8440/1/holt_Comparison_markets_EU_states.pdf ORGANIC STANDARDS Availability of Organic food Cost of Organic Food Effects Organic Standards Source: Food Supply Chain Management .Bourlakis,M.A. and Weightman, P.W.H. 1st Edition, 2004, Blackwell Publishing Limited. Oxford, UK. Pg 207 ORGANIC STANDARDS Potential impact of standard changes results in the following: The use of copper based fungicides for control of late blight of potatoes. Reduction in conventional yield of potatoes from 60% to 40%. Source: Food Supply Chain Management .Bourlakis,M.A. and Weightman, P.W.H. 1st Edition, 2004, Blackwell Publishing Limited. Oxford, UK. Pg 207 SUPPLY CHAIN AND SERVICES INFRASTRUCTURE Supply Industries Advisors Processors Organic production depends upon infrastructure of : Marketing Channels Technical Information Commercial Production relies on 3 important factors Source: Food Supply Chain Management .Bourlakis,M.A. and Weightman, P.W.H. 1st Edition, 2004, Blackwell Publishing Limited. Oxford, UK. Pg 208 SUN GOLD ORGANIC FARM Started in 2009 in Qasim town , Karachi Production area consist of vegetables Use of organic pesticides which are made of tobacco, garlic, pepper, plant leaves and flowers. Customers are mainly women Online sale of product and also through phone calls. And food packaging is biodegradable. Supplies to retailers and supermarket. Marketing of product in 2010 through horticulture society. KHALIS FOOD MARKET Working in Lahore (Punjab) Khalis food market is using social media as a source of marketing. Organize various events for promotion of their food products. Upper class of society as a target market Source: http://www.khalisfoodmarket.com/p/khalis-inmedia.html ORGANIC SUPPLY CHAINS Farmer to consumer chains • These chains are very popular in Brazil and Hungry. • Organic farmers sell their produces to directly to consumers through organic public marketplaces. Farmer to retailer or supermarket chains • In Brazil producers sell fresh and processed products directly to supermarkets and retail stores. • Similarly, in Thailand retailing company (TOPS) sells the following products: rice, coconut, milk, coffee and shrimps to supermarket. Source: http://www.rural21.com/english/news/detail/article/linking-smallholders-toorganic-supply-chains-what-is-needed-0000426/ ORGANIC SUPPLY CHAINS Farmers to food processor chains Farmer to importer • Basmati rice in India, farmers supply their paddy to rice mills and from there processed rice is packed for shipping and export. • African organic coffee, farmers grows and harvest coffee cherries at their farms. Separation of beans on farm. • Beans are being packed and send directly to importer or through an exporter. Source: http://www.rural21.com/english/news/detail/article/linking-smallholders-toorganic-supply-chains-what-is-needed-0000426/ SUPPLY CHAIN AND SERVICES INFRASTRUCTURE Problem: Availability of limited number of marketing channels and processors for certain commodities like oilseed rape, sugar beet etc. Over coming the problem leads to •More Crop production and increase in organic market •Improve efficiencies of crop rotation. Source: Food Supply Chain Management .Bourlakis,M.A. and Weightman, P.W.H. 1st Edition, 2004, Blackwell Publishing Limited. Oxford, UK. Pg 208 MARKETING CHANNELS Farm Shipper Shipper Direct to consumer market Wholesaler/broker Conventional foods retailer Natural foods retailer Food service establishment MARKET PREDICTION MODELS The European market for organic foods in 2000 was valued at US$9.6 million (Soil Association, 2000). It has been predicted that by 2005 the value may be nearer US$21.4 million, a growth of 124% over five years across Europe. Source: Food Supply Chain Management .Bourlakis,M.A. and Weightman, P.W.H. 1st Edition, 2004, Blackwell Publishing Limited. Oxford, UK. Pg 208_209 http://web.mit.edu/edmund_w/www/Agribusiness,%206-7-02.pdf US ORGANIC FOODS MARKET FORECAST 2018 The demand of organic food is high. It is forecasted that the organic food market of the US will grow at the CAGR of about 14% during 2013-18. It has also been forecasted that organic fruits & vegetables will continue dominance by 2018 and with the growth in organic food market revenues, the demand for organic meat, fish, poultry, etc will increase. Source: http://www.techsciresearch.com/2605generated ORGANIC MARKET PREDICTION Source: http://www.techsciresearch.com/2605generated Source: https://securepayment.soilassociation.org/page/contribute/organicmarketreport2015 US ORGANIC MARKET SURVEY 2015 Sales of organic food and non-food products in the United States broke through another record in 2014, totaling $39.1 billion, up 11.3 percent from the previous year. Organic sales now near a milestone 5 percent share of the total food market. The organic dairy sector 11 percent increase in sales in 2014 ($5.46 billion). Source: See more at: https://www.ota.com/what-ota-does/market-analysis#sthash.zMtNqf3B.dpuf Text- page no. 203 MARKET PREDICTION MODELS The market for organic food would increase: The price differential between organic and conventional foods decreases, The market expansion is likely to be slower than predicted: If the quality and availability of organic products increases, or if the confidence in conventional foods reduced. If the price differential between organic and conventional foods increases, If new organic standards are introduced which reduce the production efficiency or quality of products, If confidence in the organic standards or auditing system decreases. Source: Food Supply Chain Management .Bourlakis,M.A. and Weightman, P.W.H. 1st Edition, 2004, Blackwell Publishing Limited. Oxford, UK. Pg 209 MARKET DEVELOPMENT Need of few customers Niche Market Mass Market Builds up Large Market CURRENT SITUATION IN PAKISTAN The organic agriculture is still in its early stage in Pakistan. Farmers and some of the traders consider that the marketing system of organic produce is not so efficient because of low production and poor infrastructure. Tremendous opportunities exist in a wide range of organic foods. There is no company or any agency who specifically deal with organic produce. If marketing and tagging is done there exist potential for better supply chain. Source: http://www.pakistaneconomist.com/issue2003/issue29/f&m4.asp MARKET ANALYSIS OF ORGANIC PRODUCE Labor • Organic farming encourages the use of labor, which is surplus and cheap in Pakistan. • About 45 percent labor is employed in agriculture so there is potential to engage the labor • The conversion from traditional farming to organic farming in many areas of Pakistan is easier because farmers are using less fertilizer, pesticides, herbicides and genetically modified seed due to their high prices and low availability in many areas. Conversion • So another option for farmers and exporters is to exploit the niche market opportunities available in this sector. Certified Producers • Due to less dependence on chemicals and fertilizers for the production of agricultural production Pakistani farmer need only little adjustments in their current production practices. In this way they can easily qualify as certified organic producers. WHEAT SUPPLY CHAIN Farmers Procurement Primary market Provincial Food Department Village market Rural Consumer Terminal Markets Wholesalers Flour Mills Retailers Utility Consumers Source: https://webndbitesoflife.wordpress.com/2013/05/08/organic-foods-vs-commercial-foods-does-itmatter-to-your-health/ Source: http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/jul/11/organic-food-moreantioxidants-study