COMMISSION ON RESTITUTION OF
LAND RIGHTS
PRESENTATION TO
PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE
LAND RESTITUTION CLAIMANTS
PETITION
04th AUGUST 2010, CAPE TOWN
Under the Rule of Law,
The Orderly Way,
The Peaceful Way,
The Patriotic Way,
The Sustainable Way,
The South African Way.
FACTUAL INFORMATION:
STELLENBOSCH CLAIMANTS
.
Claimants
No of Beneficiaries
Property Description
O. Osman, G.G February, B. Alexander, B. Pool, J. P Coetsee, N
Jonathan, EM Lawrence, E Sacks, JJ Jacobs, A Parker, Methodist
Church of Southern Africa, Stellenbosch Onderlinge Vereniging, S.
Adams/ Volkskerk Van Suid Afrika
10 Families, 5 Church Community
(still to determine accurate numbers, pending verification to be
completed)
Erf 27 , 28,29,30,31, 173, 2530,4876, 4877, 4878, 4879, 4880,
2615, 2522, 69, 2494 2552,2533,
5234,2537,2538,2524,2526,6180, 602, 603, 605,608, 612,
613,622,623 6659, 6590,6589,9672, 604, 607, 2506, Stellenbosch,
Lot2 Prtn of Stellenbosch Ext1,
Current Status
Negotiation and settlement stages
Settlement Agreement
None in place yet
Cost of settlement
Requires restoration of original properties and/or alternative land.
Price to be determined once negotiations is completed.
Overview on
implementation
To be determined once negotiations is completed and agreements
reached.
Challenges
Land release agreements,
2
FACTUAL INFORMATION: CONSTANTIA
Claimant
Van der Ross Family Trust, Heuvel Family, James Family Claim, Sadien Family Trust, J Williams Family, Davids
Family Claim, V Kriel Family Claim, O Sadien Family Claim, CE Seaborne, Van der Ross, Van Kradenberg, Kherekar,
E Sadien Samsodien Smith Southgate A Karriem Kherekar Ebrahim Jappie Solomon Sadien Pelston Petersen
Peterson B C Oiver Lesch S Matthews T J Ndzame Marco Hendricks Johannes Jacob Joseph Jacobs Kherekar
Beukes Julie Coenraad Damon EC Deane Dennison Daniels F Dhansay Fortuin Fritz Dennison April Brenner S Sadien
M Takay A Daniels Rawoot Rawbotham Solomon Smith Samuels AD Rawbotham
Financial Compensation: Beukes David William, Brenner Ebrahim, Hartnack Steven Charles Benjamin, Petersen Maria
Margaretha
No of
63 Families
Beneficiaries
Property
Description
5 Greendales Constantia, 12 Tokai Road, (Erf 1398, Constantia), Erf 67288, Constantia, Sillery Road Constantia, Cloetes
Cottages, Constantia, Erf 2548,Erf 2549,Erf 2550 Constantia, Erf 4196,10426 Constantia, Farm Constantia, Strawberry Road
Constantia, Erf 2565 Constantia, Strawberry Lane, Erf 4724 Constantia, Koch Cottages, Ladiesmile Road Constantia, Erf 4682
Constantia, Smuts Cottages Constantia, Lot 1 Spaanschemat River River Erf 1191 Constantia, Erf 4724 Constantia, Erf 1339
Constantia, Erf 1191 Constantia,,Portion 53 (a portion of portion Erf 555 Constantia 11)of the farm Sillery No 1092, Erf 2274
Constantia, Erf 2234 Constantia, 3 Paggas Vlei Constantia, 2 Paggas Vlei Constantia, Number 2 Lot 4 Ladies Mile Rd, Erf 4198
Constantia, 3 Paggas Vlei Constantia, Cloetes C/O Kendal & Spaanschemat Road Constantia, Cottages,Paggasvlei,Constantia,
Erf 4728 Constantia, Ladies Mile Road Constantia(1), Ladies Mile Road (2)Constantia, Erf 8630 Constanti, Ladies Mile Road
Constantia, Ladies Mile Road(3) Constantia, Brink Cottages,Paggas Vlei Road,Constantia, Ladies Mile Road(4) Constantia, Erf
2269 Constantia, Solomon Cottage, Spaanschemat River(2) Constantia, Lot 13 Sillery Rd Constantia, 6 Paggasvlei, Constantia,
Erf 8453 Constantia, Cloetes Cottage Constantia, Erf 2274 Constantia, Erf 5802,5803 Constantia, 42A Cranco Avenue, Kirsten
Cottages, 49 Arsenal Road Constantia, 3 Strawberry Lane Constantia, A4 Ladies Mile Road Constantia, Erf 9005 Constantia, Erf
5801 Constantia, C/O Kendal & Spaanschemat Road Constantia, Erf 2970 Constantia, Portion 50 & 51(Portions of portion 11)of
the farm Sillery.No.1092 Cape Division Constantia, Els Cottage - Tokai Road Constantia, Erf 5317 Constantia, Erf 2970
Constantia.
Financial Compensation:1 Brinks Cottage, Constantia; Ferguson Cottage, Constantia, 9 Silverhurst Cottage, Constantia, Cloetes
Cottage, Strawberry Lane, Constantia
Current Status
Negotiation to release land
Financial Compensation: S42d stage
Settlement
None in place yet, pending finalization of negotiations
Agreement
Financial Compensation: Financial award
Cost of settlement Costing to be finalized after negotiations are completed.
Overview on
To be finalized after negotiations are completed.
implementation
Financial Compensation:
Financial award
3
Challenges
Land release by municipality
Financial Compensation: Lack of funds
FACTUAL INFORMATION:
CLAREMONT/NEWLANDS
Claimant
Whittle Priscilla Edith, Haman Margaret, Mohamed Abdula & Ebrahim, Dudley
Richard Owner, Williams, Mogamat Syfant, Vallie Amina Deva Arvind Kumar,
Dayaram Khundoobha, Deva Arvind Kumar
11 Families
No of Beneficiaries
21 Norfolk Street Harfield Village, Claremont
Property Description
Current Status
94 1st Avenue Claremont, Erf 48637 Newlands, Erf 48671 Newlands, Erf 48150
Newlands, Erf 48637 Newlands, Erf 96633 Newlands, Erf 96633 Newlands, Erf
54017 Claremont, 26 Dunsan Street, Claremont, Erf 53649, Claremont, 80 Surrey
Street, Claremont, Erf 96638 Newlands, Erf 96641 & 96642 Newlands, Erf
48641,48642,48330, Erf 96638 Newlands, Erf 96641 & 96642 Newlands
Negotiation, awaiting release of land by City of Cape Town and Public Works
Research of claims for financial award.
Settlement Agreement Draft Business Plan in place, pending release of land and finalization of research.
Cost of settlement
Overview on
implementation
Challenges
Restoration: pending release of land
Financial Compensation: Pending finalization of research reports.
Pending release of land for restoration claims.
Financial Award for Financial Compensation claims
Financial Coland mpensation: RRelease of by City of Cape Town and Public
Works,
Research stages
4
FACTUAL INFORMATION: HOUTBAY (2ND PHASE)
DEVELOPMENT
LP Demingo, Tape, MH Allie, CJ Driver, Van Der Ross, G Kader
Claimants
No of Beneficiaries
17
Property Description
Beach Road, HoutBay, Erven 789 Barry Road, Hout Bay, Erven
752, 755 HoutBay, Erven 491, 494 HoutBay, Off Pyne Streetn
Penzanca Street, HoutBay, Erven 755, 753 Hout Bay
Current Status
Negotiation Stage with Municipality
Settlement Agreement
Alternative Land.
Pending release of land.
Cost of settlement
Pending release of land.
Overview on implementation
Challenges
Pending release of land.
5
FACTUAL INFORMATION:
HOUTBAY FINANCIAL CLAIMANTS
Claimant
S Mouton, NC Adonis, Valet Pietersen, MDP Wichman, LH
Wichman, FG Wagner, ZJ Newman, J Bonzaier, R Fisher, G Kader,
D Papier
No of Beneficiaries
22 beneficiaries
Property Description
I Promenade Way Hout Bay, Erf 4320 HoutBay, Bel Road Hout Bay,
Erven 1055, 655 Hout Bay, Promenade Road Hout Bay, Oakhurst
Farm Hout Bay, Vleiplaas Empire Avenue, Hout Bay, Erf 2397 Hout
Bay, 2 Beach Road, Hout Bay, Erven 752, 753 Hout Bay, Beach
Road, Hout Bay
Current Status
Settled
Settlement Agreement
Financial Compensation
Cost of settlement
Each claimant has received R17 500.00
Financial Compensation
Overview on implementation
Challenges
None
6
FACTUAL INFORMATION: KIRSTENBOSCH –
PROTEA VILLAGE 46 FORMER TENANTS
Claimant
No of Beneficiaries
H.J. Williams, H.H. Williams, V.C. Williams, Smith, AJ Williams,
DJ Willaims, RG Williams, NA Smith, BC September, Sulmor R F
Schwartz, Fisher, V.E. Abrahams, Pelston, Paune, A.N Muller, G.A
Mclean, N.B Mohammad, R.F.De Mink, LJ Lamohr, JW Lawrence,
LM Jones, AS Julie, F Jacobs, Jacobs, Josephus, KC Jacobs, J
Jacobs, C Julie, Johnson, WEG Idas, JJ Hyde, ML Hector, M
Ficks, Dryding, J De La Cruz, Davids, G Van Gussling, JH Bowler,
AA Basson, DR Abrahams, ES Ackerman, Abrahams, Albertus,
Adonis,
46
Current Status
3,4, 5, 6 Bishopscourt Estate Protea Village,11 & 13c Steyman
Cottage, Protea Village, 6 Bishopcourt Estate, 4, 21, 46, 24 , 25,
32, 20, 31, 33, 11A, 42A, 29, 48, 10A, 29, 40, 11,
34,35,36,37,5,23B, 48, 11, 8, 5, 41,37A, 24, 13A, 13B28 Stegman
Cottages, Erf 242, Protea Village, 6 Bishopscourt Estate Protea
Village, 5 Garden Cottage, Protea Village, Rondavel Cottage
Protea Village. 18 Bishops Court, Protea Village,4 Kirsten Drive
Protea Village,
Settled
Settlement Agreement
Financial Compensation
Cost of settlement
R805 000,00
Overview on implementation
The former tenants opted for the Standard Settlement Offer for
tenancy rights
The neighbors disagreed with the settlement and the issue is in 7
court.
Property Description
Challenges
FACTUAL INFORMATION: RAAPKRAAL
Claimants
Swartz Bernard, Swartz Peter, Macuphe Selinah, Franke
Gerald, Daniels Priscilla, Levin Thomas, Davids Michae, CC
Hendrickse
No of Beneficiaries
24
Property Description
Raapkraal Cottages, Retreat, 28 Raapkraal Cottages,
Retreat, Raapkraal Cottages, Retreat, 24 Raapkraal
Cottages, Retreat, 16 Raapkraal Cottages, Retreat, 24
Raapkraal Cottages, Retreat, Raapkraal Cottages, Retreat,
Raapkraal Cottages, Retreat
Current Status
4Unsettled,
4 Settled
Settlement Agreement
Alternative Land
Financial Compensation
Cost of settlement
Alternative Land
Financial Compensation: R88680-00
Pending release of land.
Overview on implementation
Release of land.
Challenges
8
FACTUAL INFORMATION: GOODWOOD,
WINDERMERE, KENSINGTON CLAIMANTS (171)
Claimants
IFD Tromp, B Gamba, F Adams, MA Hassiem, J Jacobs , Telemachus, AA Draga, CM Jacobs
, K Parker, JDC Jacobs , LA Daniels, CM Fingers, MH Sonday, L Domingo, REO Petersen,
RG Julius, RH Lucas, BC Arendse, S Isaacs, G Palekar, N Christians, W Meyer, RE
Hendricks, D Herbert, CF Leukes, AJ Lopez, A Boswel, MM Davids, P Cruywagen, Johannes
Davids, HA Parker, SR Suleiman Roopen, DV Jacobs, CA Marias, M M Hectar, MGA
Mohamed Ganief Allie, M Mevy Ross, H.Khan,, JP Michael Leroux, MM Khan, MH Sungay,
FW Malgas, D.R.Paris, Mr. Van der velt, Ms E.J Frangch, Ms Williams / Okkers, Mr. Valley,
Mr.k Robertson, Mrs M.E Baardman, NM Miller, J Wilson, F Mukudden, YB Terblanche, L
Mentoor, R Bongxi, A Hay, Ms Goddard, Crace Monica Beerninkel, Swano, Mr. Dyantyi, MV
Prince, Simon Joseph, L. Stuurman, Mohammed B Mukkuddem, Schalkwyk family, January
family, Thomas family, Daniels family, D.Contradie family, Learner family case, Mr N Mezichel,
CL.Johnson, E Jeptha, Mrs. Telling, Omar Khan, Joseph Wilson, K Vokozela , JWE Castle, J
Louw, G George, CC Lyner, K Vokozela, RH Tobin,
E. Kader, A. Khan, H. Khan, L. Isaacs, M.A. Jada, E. Naylor, S. Naidu, J. Nelson, S.
Ebrahim, D.J. Adams, A.L. Williams, C.M.A. Van Wyk, J.M.A. Blankenberg, C.P. Don, F.K.
Chetty, D.M.H. Ebrahim, E.J. Marney, M.A. Amien, M. Hartley, E. Strachan, D.V. Jacobs, B.
W. Xotyeni, A.G. Msizi, E.H. Balla, R. Jaga, J. Abdurahman, J. Parker, P.P. Mthimka, M.R.
Smith, S. Felix, I. Salie, E. Daniels, M. Jappie, M.A. Parker, A.J. Johnson, G.P. Ronne, Y.
Price, L. Phooko, L.H. Ferreira, M.A. Abrahams, E. Moerat, Z. Moerat, J. Le Roux, Mr
Solomon, A. Kleinsmith, E.W. Grever, N.A. Gazgay, M.A. Abbass, A. Geyer, R. Jones, R.
Khan Parker, UA Abbas
Cornelius January, CR February, WE Johnston, Mrs r Jacobs, M Dowling, CJ Joorst, Gary
Jasen, SE Badebhorst, SN De Wet, NG Mayaba, E Orr, K Martin,ERP Malan, JJ Van Diemen,
9
AE Mathee, Z Mookrey, L Schoeman, MB Mukkuddem, KW Sausman, GB Parker
FACTUAL INFORMATION: GOODWOOD,
WINDERMERE, KENSINGTON CLAIMANTS (171)
CONTINUED
No of
Beneficiaries
Property
Description
Current
Status
Settlement
Agreement
Cost of
settlement
Overview on
implementati
on
Challenges
171 Primary Claimants
(still to determine accurate numbers, pending verification to be completed)
Erf 1334, Erf 1750, Erf 19174, Erf 12816, Erf 14989, Erf 10147, Erf 1342, Erf 3284, Erf 1536,
Erf 12021, Erf 3897, Erf 11496, Erf 12573, Erf 13520, Erf 3338, Erf 3846, Erf 3133, Erf 3166,
Erf 12887, Erf 11689, Erf 3622 ,3643, Erf 1357, Erf 12814 ,12794, Erf 11986, Erf 12746, Erf
6688, Erf 4391, Erf 1316, Erven 113445 ,113442, Erf 113694 ,113213, Erf 1374, Erf 3145, Erven
9217,9228,9227, Erf 5110, Erf 2592, Erf 1671,1532
Erven 22572, 22573, 21359, 21358 &21516, Erf 23057, Erf 23377, Erf 21318, Erf 23607, Erf
21208, Erf 59374, Erf 59404, Erf 59397, Erf 58682, Erf 59699, Erf 60121, Erf 58681, Erf 59354,
Erven 59501,59502,59503, Erven 1313,1314,1052, Erf 688, Erf 1822, Erf 1432, Erf 588, Erf
702, Erf 4133, Erf 302, Erf 311, Erven 6464,6465,6467,6468, Erf 1012, Erf 297, Erf 408, Erf
376, Erven 11668 & 1837, Erf 1927, Erf 3180,
Negotiation and settlement stages
None in place yet
Requires restoration of original properties and/or alternative land. Price to be determined once
negotiations is completed.
To be determined once negotiations is completed and agreements reached.
Land release agreements,
10
THANK YOU/ BAIE DANKIE
MRS BEVERLEY JANSEN
REGIONAL LAND CLAIMS COMMISSIONER,
WESTERN CAPE
Private Bag X9163 / 04TH FLOOR, MATRIX
HOUSE,
73 STRAND STREET,
8000
Telephone number: (021) 426 2930
Fax number: (021) 422 4206
E-mail address: Fwilliams@dla.gov.za
Website address: http://land.pwv.gov.za
11