BSC2011C: Principles of Biology II Welcome! Welcome and thank you for enrolling in this course! I think you will enjoy our time together! For some, this may be your first online course. If you are not a computer whiz, don’t worry. You don’t need to be. From a computer standpoint, everything is simple to use and easy to navigate. Please take a few minutes to read the syllabus in its entirety. Exploring all the topics in this syllabus and related links will help you succeed in this course. I am looking forward to working with you and having a great semester! Professor Daudi K. Langat BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Professor Information Professor: Virtual Office Hours: Virtual Contact Methods: Office Location: Office Phone: Email: Daudi K. Langat, PhD By Appointment Google Chat or Yahoo IM Virtual 1-415-952-6428 daudi.langat@fscj.edu Instructor Response You can anticipate responses to inquiries and questions within 24 - 48 hours of receipt. Campus Information This online course is offered by the Florida State College at Jacksonville Open Campus. For questions or concerns, please feel free to call the Campus Resource Center (904-997-2628). For technical assistance, please contact the Help Desk at 877-572-8895 or (904) 632-3151 or via http://www.fscj.edu/campus-life/student-computing-resources/. Course Description This course is a continuation of Principles of Biology I and recommended for science students transferring to four-year institutions. The course material emphasizes survey of the kingdoms, evolution and selected ecological topics and includes a required laboratory experience to reinforce subject matter. Learning Outcomes Upon completion of the course, the student will be able to: Explain and apply major concepts in population genetics, taxonomy and phylogeny and organism systematics and evolution. Demonstrate knowledge of scientific method. Communicate scientific ideas through oral or written assignments. Interpret scientific models such as formulas, graphs, tables and schematics, draw inferences from them and recognize their limitations. Demonstrate problem-solving methods in situations that are encountered outside of the classroom. Demonstrate proper laboratory technique including safety in the use and care of laboratory equipment and materials. Dissection and examination of a variety of invertebrates and vertebrates, such as: Ascaris, earthworm, clam, crayfish, starfish, shark, frog, fetal pig. Demonstrate proper laboratory technique including safety in the use and care of laboratory equipment and materials. Page 2 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Course Information Course Number/Title: BSC2011C: Principles of Biology II Reference Number: 416599 Number of Credit Hours: 4 Term/Year/Session/Length: Spring 2015, Session B (12 weeks, Feb 2 – May 1, 2015) Course prerequisites: BSC2010C: Principles of Biology I Important Dates Class Begins February 2, 2015 100% Refund Deadline February 9, 2015 Non-Attendance Drop February 10 - 17, 2015 Withdraw with “W” Deadline April 1, 2015 Course Evaluation April 20 – May 1, 2015 Class Ends May 1, 2015 These dates are critical for this course. Additional critical dates for this course can be found by choosing the appropriate term links in the Academic and Registration Calendars (http://www.fscj.edu/academics/academic-calendar) at the Florida State College at Jacksonville website. Instructional Materials and Equipment If you have not done so already, obtain your textbook and related course materials. Visit your nearest campus bookstore or order online via the student portal, Connections (https://connections.fscj.edu/web/guest/home), or the Follett Online Bookstore (http://www.bkstr.com). Be sure to order using your course and instructor’s name and the six-digit course reference number. Please note that some courses, particularly math and science, may require a text plus additional software or a publisher Web access code. If purchasing a used text, be sure to check on and obtain all required materials. Required Text/Materials Textbook Campbell Biology 9th edition by Reese et al. Benjamin Cummings Publishers (2011). ISBN: 978-0-321-69730-1 Page 3 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Lab Materials/ Kits: Order your lab kits early - do NOT delay. NOTE: You can order from Carolina via their website http://www.Carolina.com or by phone at 800-334.5551. From time to time Carolina may change their website, but you will still be able to find the items you need by typing the item number into the web page search box. Kit 1: Carolina Young Scientist's Animal Dissection Kit (#221021) contains earthworm, crayfish, grasshopper, frog, plus dissection materials) - $16.75 Kit 2: Carolina Starfish, Preserved (#SPEC 26502 - PS) - Students MUST call Carolina (800.334.5551) to order this item for home shipping. More information about Carolina's Perfect Solution is available in the Perfect Solution MSDS. NOTE: If you are pregnant or think you might be, please read the information about Pregnancy and Dissection on Carolina Lab's website. Digital Camera: You will need a digital camera to complete the labs. Any digital camera will do, even the camera on a cell phone, as long as it takes clear images that you are able to upload into your lab report document. Online Delivery System This course will be delivered using the Blackboard Learn™ course management system. Blackboard™ Supported Browsers for Blackboard Version 9.1 SP13 View Blackboard’s Supported Browsers and Operating Systems (http://blackboard.force.com/publickbarticleview?id=kAB700000008Oom) to see if your browser and operating system are compatible. Please note the following when reviewing the Blackboard compatibility ratings. Certified: 100% Compatible Compatible: Compatible in most areas, but could have some incompatibility issues Unsupported: Not tested and not recommended Technology Requirements Reliable and consistent computer and Internet access is encouraged to successfully participate in and complete online courses. Ensure that your computer meets the minimum system requirements noted below and on the Florida State College at Jacksonville Online Learning site (http://www.fscj.edu/academics/online-learning). Please use the following checklist to determine your computer readiness. You should own or have access to: An email account Computer with high speed access to the Internet Page 4 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Access to College computers when needed Virus-checking software Word-processing software Software and plug-Ins that may include (choose the titles for the free downloads) o Adobe Acrobat Reader (http://get.adobe.com/reader/) o Flash Player (http://get.adobe.com/flashplayer/) o Java (http://www.java.com/en/download/manual.jsp) o Shockwave Player (http://get.adobe.com/shockwave/) o VLC (http://www.videolan.org/) It is a good idea to check your computer at the beginning of each course and a couple of times throughout the term to ensure you have all the necessary software and plug-ins to use the Blackboard online system and course features. After logging in to Blackboard, choose the Browser Checker link. Review the results and choose the links to the recommended software. Please note that you will need to turn off your pop-up blocker to use all features of this online course. Accessibility If you require specific accommodations to complete this course, contact the Florida State College at Jacksonville Office of Services for Students with Disabilities (http://www.fscj.edu/admissionsaid/services-for-students-with-disabilities), located at 101 W State St, Room A1020, Jacksonville, FL 32202 with additional offices at Kent, North, and South campuses. You may reach the main OSSD office at (904) 633-8488. Your Course Participation and Assessments Learning Communities Students learn through interactions with each other, with their instructor, and with the course material. A major goal of this course is to encourage you to build learning communities within the course. This course has special forums to aid in building our learning community. We will use the discussion area to meet each other and share our thoughts and concerns. The “Questions for the Professor” discussion forum is used for general questions about course content, navigation, or flow. Please do not ask personal or specific grade-related questions in this forum, send individual communication instead. The “Cyber Café” is available to discuss items of interest to you and your classmates. Please remember that in all discussion forums, you must follow all netiquette rules and guidelines. Assigned Work In each module, you may have individual activities to complete. Detailed information, instructions, and rubrics for each assignment can be found below and in the module folders of the online classroom. To see all the assignments due in this course, refer to the Calendar of Activities below. Be sure to check the Calendar of Activities carefully for due dates on all assigned work. Some weeks may require completion of more than one module. Page 5 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Original Writing, Style, and Sources Written assignments must adhere to APA style guidelines. Writing style resources are available in the Tools and Resources folder within your Blackboard classroom. Your written assignments should be original writing and include citations as described in the APA style guide. Turnitin® is an online tool that scans written assignments for signs of plagiarism and may be used to screen your assignment submissions. Please go to Turnitin® (http://www.turnitin.com/en_us/products/overview) for information about originality checks and reports, and to What is Plagiarism? (http://www.plagiarism.org/) for plagiarism prevention resources. Submission of plagiarized work will result in failure of the course. Wikipedia is a tertiary (condensed) source of information and should not be used as a reference in your assignments and papers. It is, however, a good resource for finding primary and secondary sources that may be acceptable. Laboratory Activities Specific laboratory exercises can be found within select modules. Detailed instructions for each exercise, as well as completion criteria, will also be found there. Some of your lab exercises involve dissections and subsequent documentation of that activity. Other lab activities may involve your use and summary of simulations, demonstrations, and/or presentations. All lab exercises should be submitted using the scientific method format. Your instructor has provided a sample report as an attachment to Laboratory Activity 1 in Module 1. You are strongly urged to plan ahead for your laboratory exercises. Some, especially the dissections, may require a significant investment of time each week. You will submit your completed lab exercises to the instructor using the Lab Submissions drop boxes in Blackboard. Each Laboratory Report is graded using the Laboratory Report Rubric included at the end of this syllabus and in the Blackboard classroom. Discussions You will participate in 11 graded discussions. Discussions are worth up to 20 points each and a possible total of 220 points toward your final grade. The links to the forums are located in the Course Content area. Our discussions are an opportunity to have thoughtful discussions about a given topic. The questions raised will be general in nature and ask you to think deeply. In each discussion forum, you will be required to give a thoughtful and comprehensive response of at least five to eight sentences that are reflective and well-written, as well as respond to at least two other people. The discussion begins when other class members read what you wrote and respond. Class members are expected to contribute original thoughts as well as respond to classmates' posts. In your responses, ask your classmates questions, expand on one of their ideas, and/or ask for clarity on one of their points. Reply politely if you disagree. Page 6 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Please note that you should complete all of the readings for the module prior to posting your discussion response. You are expected to post in correct sentence and paragraph format. Remember to check for correct spelling and grammar. Discussions are graded using the Discussion Rubric included at the end of this syllabus and in the Blackboard classroom. Quizzes At the end of each week's work are quizzes covering the chapters covered that week. Chapter quizzes give you the opportunity to check your understanding of the material in each chapter. Each chapter quiz has 10 questions pulled randomly from a question bank. Each question is worth 1 point for a total of 10 possible points for each quiz. Exams There are 4 exams in this course. Each exam consists of questions pulled randomly from the test banks for the assigned chapters. Each exam is worth 100 points toward your total points. Course Grade Your final letter grade will be determined by totaling the points earned on all graded coursework. ASSIGNED WORK POINTS GRADE POINTS Discussion forums (11 @20 points) 220 A 900-1000 Laboratory Activities (11 @20 points) 220 B 800-899 Quizzes (3 @ 20; 10 @10 points) 160 C 700-799 Exams (4 @100 points) 400 D 600-699 1000 F 0-599 Total Points FN Grade – Failure for Non-Attendance A Failure for Non-Attendance (FN) grade indicates that a student has failed a course due to nonattendance. It is calculated as an “F” in the student’s grade point average. For students receiving financial aid, failure for non-attendance may require the student to refund to the College all or part of the aid received. The FN grade will be assigned by the faculty member at any time following the final withdrawal date for the course. For additional information, please review the grading system and policies in the College catalog. I Grade - Incomplete Incomplete (I) grades may be awarded based on the criteria in the College catalog. See the College’s page on Grading policies (http://floridastatecollegecatalog.fscj.edu/content.php?catoid=21&navoid=2569#incomplete) for more information. Page 7 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Repeating the Course You may repeat a course in an attempt to improve a grade previously earned. However, you are limited in your attempts to courses where a “D,” “F,” or “FN” grade was earned. You have only three total attempts in any course, including the original grade, repeat grades, and withdrawals. Upon the third attempt in a course, you must be given an “A,” “B,” “C,” “D,” or “F”. When you repeat a course at Florida State College, only the last grade earned is calculated in your cumulative grade point average (GPA). If you have an excessive number of “W” or “FN” grades and repeat courses to improve your GPA, you may jeopardize your admission to programs in the Florida State University System (SUS) or other institutions. Page 8 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Calendar of Activities The Calendar of Activities is a summary of the lessons and course activities for each module. See each specific Module page for directions on how to complete each assignment. Special Note: The instructor reserves the right to modify this syllabus. You will be notified of any changes. Week Week 1 Feb 2–8 Week 2 Feb 9 - 15 Week 3 Feb Module, Topic(s) & Reading(s) Module 1: The Evolution of Populations / Phylogeny and the Tree of Life Assigned Work Points Possible Student Contract Required Greetings & Introductions discussion forum 0 Campbell: Chapter 23 (The Evolution of Populations) and Chapter 26 (Phylogeny and the Tree of Life) Supplemental Activity 1: Natural Selection 0 See the Module 1 page for additional readings and resources. Laboratory Activity 1: Taxonomy & Phylogeny 20 Module 1 Quiz (Ch. 23 and 26) 20 Laboratory Activity 2: Prokaryotes 20 Discussion 1: Spread of Disease 20 Module 2 Quiz (Ch. 19 and 27) 20 Laboratory Activity 3: Protists 20 Module 3 Quiz (Ch. 28) 10 Exam 1 (Ch. 19, 23, 26, and 27) 100 Module 2: Viruses, Bacteria and Archaea Campbell: Chapter 19 (Viruses) and Chapter 27 (Bacteria and Archaea) See the Module 2 page for additional readings and resources. Module 3: Protists Campbell: Chapter 28 (Protists) 16 – 22 See the Module 3 page for additional readings and resources. Week 4 Module 4: Kingdom Fungi Feb 23 Mar 1 Campbell: Chapter 31 (Fungi) See the Module 4 page for additional readings and resources. Laboratory Activity 4: Fungi Discussion 2: Current Issues in Fungi Module 4 Quiz (Ch. 31) Due Date Feb 8 Feb 15 Feb 22 20 20 Mar 1 10 Page 9 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Week 4 (cont) Feb 23 Mar 1 Week 5 Mar 2-8 Week 6 Mar 9 - 15 Laboratory Activity 5: Seedless Plants 20 Discussion 3: Current Issues in Seedless Plants 20 Module 5 Quiz (Ch. 29) 10 Module 6: Kingdom Plantae (Seed Plants) Laboratory Activity 6: Seed Plants 20 Campbell: Chapter 30 (Plant Diversity II: The Evolution of Seed Plants) Discussion 4: Seed Plants and Humans 20 See the Module 6 page for additional readings and resources. Module 6 Quiz (Ch. 30) 10 Module 7: Kingdom Animalia: Overview of Animal Diversity Discussion 5: Classifying Organisms 20 Campbell: Chapter 32 (An Overview of Animal Diversity) Module 7 Quiz (Ch. 32) 10 Exam 2 (Chapter 28, 29, 30, & 31) 100 Module 5: Kingdom Plantae (Seedless Plants) Campbell: Chapter 29 (Plant Diversity I: How Plants Colonized Land) See the Module 5 page for additional readings and resources. See the Module 7 page for additional readings and resources March 16 - 22 Campbell: Chapter 33 (An Introduction to Invertebrates) pages 666 - 683 ONLY Mar 23 - 29 Mar 8 Mar 15 SPRING BREAK – NO CLASSES Module 8: Kingdom Animalia: Invertebrates, part 1 Week 7 Mar 1 See the Module 8 page for additional readings and resources. Laboratory Activity 7: Earthworm Dissection 20 Discussion 6: Current Issues in Sponges 20 Mar 29 Module 9: Kingdom Animalia: Invertebrates, part 2 Laboratory Activity 8: Arthropod Dissection 20 Campbell: Chapter 33 (An Introduction to Invertebrates) pages 683 - 694 ONLY Laboratory Activity 9: Sea Star Dissection 20 See the Module 9 page for additional readings and resources. Module 9 Quiz (Ch. 33) 10 Page 10 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Module 10: Kingdom Animalia: Vertebrates, part 1 Campbell: Chapter 34 (The Origin and Evolution of Vertebrates) pages 697 - 714 ONLY Week 8 See the Module 10 page for additional readings and resources. Laboratory Activity 10: Frog dissection 20 Supplemental Activity 2: Mammal Skulls 0 Apr 5 Mar 30 Apr 5 Module 11: Kingdom Animalia: Vertebrates, part 2 Discussion 7: Insignificance and Evolution 20 Module 11 Quiz (Ch. 34) 10 Module 12: Ecology and the Biosphere Discussion 8: Biome Tour 20 Campbell: Chapter 52 (An Introduction to Ecology and the Biosphere) Module 12 Quiz (Ch. 52) 10 See the Module 12 page for additional readings and resources. Exam 3 (Ch 32, 33, and 34) 100 Laboratory Activity 11: Population Biology - "How Does Competition Affect Population Growth in Protozoans?" 20 Discussion 9: Footprints on the Planet 20 Module 13 Quiz (Ch. 53 and 54) 20 Discussion 10: Ecological Cycling 20 Module 14 Quiz (Ch. 55) 10 Campbell: Chapter 34 (The Origin and Evolution of Vertebrates) pages 714 - 733 ONLY See the Module 11 page for additional readings and resources. Week 9 Apr 6 – 12 Module 13: Population Ecology (Ch. 53, p. 1170-1191) Community Ecology Week 10 Apr 13 - 19 Campbell: Chapter 53 (Population Ecology) AND Chapter 54 (Community Ecology) See the Module 13 page for additional readings and resources. Module 14: Ecosystems Campbell: Chapter 55 (Ecosystems and Restoration Ecology) See the Module 14 page for additional readings and resources. Apr 12 Apr 19 Page 11 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Module 15: Conservation Biology Week 11 Apr 20 - 26 Campbell: Chapter 56 (Conversation Biology and Global Change) Discussion 11: Endangered and Threatened Species 20 Apr 26 See the Module 15 page for additional readings and resources. Module 15 Quiz (Ch. 56) 10 Module 16: Exam 4 Exam 4 (Ch. 52, 53, 54, 55, and 56) 100 Week 12 Apr 27 May 1 Total Points Possible May 1 1000 Course Guidelines/Policies Academic Dishonesty Policy Academic dishonesty, in any form, has severe consequences. Please review the Student Rights and Responsibilities (http://catalog.fscj.edu/content.php?catoid=31&navoid=3998#conduct) section of the College catalog. Attendance Policy Attendance is measured in this course by your weekly access to the online content and timely completion of required course activities. If you fail to sufficiently participate in the online course prior to the official refund deadline, you can be dropped for non-attendance. If the official withdrawal date has passed and you fail to sufficiently progress in the online course, you can be awarded a Failure for Non-Attendance (FN) grade. Late/Make Up Work Policy Lateness in completing assignments is strongly discouraged; all assignments must be completed on time. The “Week” runs from Monday morning (12:01 am) to Sunday night (11:59 pm ET). You must complete and submit all the work due by the end of each week. Late assignments and/or makeup work may be accepted under special circumstances. If you miss any assignments due to unavoidable or unexpected occurrences, please contact the instructor as soon as possible. Expectations of Student Conduct The College’s Expectations of Student Conduct (http://catalog.fscj.edu/content.php?catoid=31&navoid=3998#conduct) extends to the online classroom. It is expected that each of you use appropriate, professional language and respect when Page 12 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II addressing classmates, as well as your instructor, in any part of the online classroom. That same level of professional conduct should extend to all assignments submitted. It is expected that you will not make insulting or inflammatory statements to other members of the class. Read the comments of other classmates thoroughly before entering your remarks and responses. Be positive, thoughtful, and constructive in your comments and responses. Recommendations for Success in this Course Have a place where you can study and set aside an appropriate amount of time to do it. Generally, a 3-credit hour course requires a minimum of 12 hours of self-study time each week in addition to the time spent completing assignments. Practice and repetition are the best way to ensure your mastery of the material. Communicate with your instructor to ask any important questions and to discuss important concepts. Complete all reading assignments and view and review all chapter resources. Complete and review all online course activities. College Resources Florida State College at Jacksonville offers many resources to help you become successful in your course and academic career. A brief description of some of these resources follows. Academic Advising Counselors and advisors are available to assist students with the achievement of their academic goals. Academic advising is available to help students identify appropriate courses, select majors, select transfer institutions and assist with academic problems. Students are encouraged to seek advising on a regular basis in order to achieve their educational objectives. Appointments may be scheduled through the Counseling and Advising Office (http://www.fscj.edu/admissionsaid/counseling-advising). However, students should know that appointment times will be severely impacted during peak registration periods. For more information, visit the Florida State College at Jacksonville Advising page (http://www.fscj.edu/admissions-aid/counseling-advising/advising/). Technical Helpdesk If you have any problems with Blackboard, viewing online content, email or Connections, visit the Florida State College at Jacksonville Help Desk (http://www.fscj.edu/campus-life/student-computingresources). There you can contact the technical support team directly via live chat or visit the SelfHelp Portal (http://helpdesk.fscj.edu/content/default.aspx). Campus support phone numbers are also included on this page. Please remember that answers to questions about your course materials, tests, quizzes, or assignments can only be provided by your instructor. Library and Learning Commons The Library/Learning Commons (LLC) (http://www.fscj.edu/campus-life/library-learning-commons) is an instructional area of the College designed to offer a variety of teaching, learning and research resources to students enrolled in courses at Florida State College at Jacksonville. LLC services include Page 13 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II individual and small group tutoring; traditional and virtual library services and materials; subjectspecific instruction including orientations; free workshops; study areas; and access to tutorials, computers, and multimedia technology. Tutorials/Online Demonstrations To view demonstrations of common Blackboard and computer activities, go to On Demand Learning Center for Students (http://ondemand.blackboard.com/students.htm). The Next Step I hope you have found this syllabus useful. Your next step is to become familiar with the Blackboard classroom, complete the Student Contract and begin the assignments for Module One. See you in the online course! Rubrics Laboratory Report Rubric Criteria Purpose Hypothesis Levels of Achievement Exemplary Meets Expectations Developing Novice Not Acceptable 4 Points 3.2 Points 2.8 Points 2.4 Points 0 Points The Purpose section is properly titled "Purpose", "Question", or "Problem." It is clearly defined and concise. The Purpose section is properly titled "Purpose", "Question", or "Problem." The Purpose section is titled "Purpose", "Question", or "Problem" however, the definition does not match the title, i.e. it is titled "Question", but uses a statement instead of a question. The Purpose section is not titled "Purpose", "Question", or "Problem" and/or it is difficult to understand. The Purpose section is missing. 4 Points 3.2 Points 2.8 Points 2.4 Points 0 Points The Hypothesis section is logically written as an "If...then" statement. The Hypothesis section is written as an "If...then" statement. The Hypothesis section is written as an "If...then" statement, The Hypothesis section is not written as an "If...then" statement. The Hypothesis section is missing. Page 14 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Materials and Procedures Data and Analysis Sound reasoning is provided to back up the hypothesis. The hypothesis is clearly specific to the lab investigation. Adequate reasoning is provided to back up the hypothesis. The hypothesis is specific to the lab investigation however, no reasoning is provided to back up the hypothesis. The hypothesis is somewhat specific to the lab investigation No reasoning is provided to back up the hypothesis. The hypothesis is not specific to the lab investigation. 4 Points 3.2 Points 2.8 Points 2.4 Points 0 Points The Materials and Procedures section contains a complete list of materials used, as well as a clear and concise explanation of the procedure. The procedure is explained in numerical order and does not skip any steps. The Materials and Procedures section contains a list of materials used, as well as an explanation of the procedure. The procedure is explained in numerical order and does not skip any steps. The Materials and Procedures section contains a list of materials used and/or explanation of the procedure, but not both. The procedure is explained in paragraph form. The Materials and Procedures section is difficult to read and understand. The procedure is fuzzy and illexplained. The Materials and Procedures section is missing. 4 Points 3.2 Points 2.8 Points 2.4 Points 0 Points The Data and Analysis section is contains all data collected or observed. Data is clearly presented in a The Data and Analysis section is contains all data collected or observed. Data is presented in The Data and Analysis section is an acceptable amount of data collected or observed. Data is The Data and Analysis section is poorly presented. There is information missing The Data and Analysis section is missing. Page 15 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Conclusion Cumulative points table, graph, or chart. Formatting, including labels and units, if applicable, is accurate and thorough. a table, graph, or chart. Formatting is acceptable. presented in a table, graph, or chart. There are some format problems with labels, units, or completene ss of data. and/or it is not presented in a table, graph, or chart format. Other major formatting problems exist. 4 Points 3.2 Points 2.8 Points 2.4 Points 0 Points The Conclusion section clearly and concisely states whether the hypothesis is correct or not. It provides an excellent discussion or summary of the data and observations, including a logical reasoning for why the results were achieved and the ramifications of the results. The Conclusion section states whether the hypothesis is correct or not. It provides an adequate discussion or summary of the data and observations , including some reasoning for why the results were achieved and the ramifications of the results. The Conclusion section states whether the hypothesis is correct or not, but uses inadequate or incomplete logic to provide a reason why the results were obtained. The Conclusion section does not state whether or not the hypothesis is correct. It includes only a concluding statement. The Conclusion section is missing. Exemplary Meets Standard Developing Novice 14 - 15 points 12 - 13 points Not Acceptable 18- 20 points 16 - 17 points 0-11 points Page 16 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Discussion Rubric Criteria Quality of Initial Post Quality of Response Postings Levels of Achievement Exemplary Meets Expectations Developing Novice Not Acceptable 5 Points 4 Points 3.5 Points 3 Points 0 Points Initial comment fully addresses all aspects of the discussion. Comment includes many personal or professional experiences. Demonstrates excellent critical thinking skills through multiple examples and ideas. Excellent discussion of course readings or other resources if appropriate. Initial comment addresses most aspects of the discussion. Comment includes some personal or professional experience. Demonstrates adequate critical thinking through some examples and ideas. Good discussion of course readings or other resources if appropriate. Initial comment addresses part of the discussion or assigned readings. Comment includes minimal personal or professional experience. Demonstrates minimal critical thinking with minimal examples and ideas. Minimal discussion of course readings or other resources if appropriate. Initial comment minimally addresses discussion. Comment does not include personal or professional experience. Does not demonstrat e critical thinking. No discussion of course readings or other resources if appropriate . No initial posting submitted. 5 Points 4 Points 3.5 Points 3 Points 0 Points Responses are highly reflective, insightful and add to the discussion in a meaningful way moving it forward. Responses are reflective, insightful and add to the discussion. Responses are minimally reflective or insightful and do not significantly add to the discussion in a meaningful way. Responses are present but are not reflective or insightful, but don't add to the discussion. No response postings submitted. Page 17 BSC2011: Principles of Biology II Organization and Technical Aspects of All Posts Posting Quantity and Timeliness Cumulative points 5 Points 4 Points 3.5 Points 3 Points 0 Points Information is exceptionally well organized; spelling and grammar are correct and complete sentences are used. Proper citations are effectively used. Information is well organized; 1-2 spelling and/ or grammar mistakes are evident. Complete sentences are used. Proper citations are used. Organization is scattered; 3-5 spelling and/ or grammar mistakes are evident. Some incomplete sentences used. Citations are used. Information is not well organized; more than 5 spelling and/ or grammar mistakes are evident. Incomplete sentences used. No citations. No postings submitted. 5 Points 4 Points 3.5 Points 3 Points 0 Points Initial posting and at least three quality responses are made prior to the due date listed in the Calendar of Activities. At least one posting is made before 11:59 pm on Wednesday. Initial posting and at least two quality responses are made prior to the due date listed in the Calendar of Activities. At least one posting is made before 11:59 pm on Wednesday. Initial posting and at least one quality responses are made prior to the due date listed in the Calendar of Activities. At least one posting is made before 11:59 pm on Wednesday. Initial posting is made before 11:59 pm on Wednesday . Any response postings are made prior to the due date listed on the Calendar of Activities. Initial posting is not made prior to Wednesday and/or no postings are submitted. Exemplary Meets Standard Developing Novice 14 - 15 points 12 - 13 points Not Acceptable 18- 20 points 16 - 17 points 0-11 points Page 18