UNIVERSITY OF MAIDUGURI Maiduguri, Nigeria CENTRE FOR DISTANCE LEARNING EDUCATION CEA 308– CEA 308_ UNIT:2 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION ii CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– Published UNIT: 2 2008© All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form, by mimeograph or any other means without prior permission in writing from the University of Maiduguri. This text forms part of the learning package for the academic programme of the Centre for Distance Learning, University of Maiduguri. Further enquiries should be directed to the: Coordinator Centre for Distance Learning University of Maiduguri P. M. B. 1069 Maiduguri, Nigeria. This text is being published by the authority of the Senate, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri – Nigeria. ISBN: 978-8133- iii CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 P R E F A C E This study unit has been prepared for learners so that they can do most of the study on their own. The structure of the study unit is different from that of conventional textbook. The course writers have made efforts to make the study material rich enough but learners need to do some extra reading for further enrichment of the knowledge required. The learners are expected to make best use of library facilities and where feasible, use the Internet. References are provided to guide the selection of reading materials required. The University expresses its profound gratitude to our course writers and editors for making this possible. Their efforts will no doubt help in improving access to University education. iv CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 Professor M. M. Daura Ag. Vice-Chancellor v CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 HOW TO STUDY THE UNIT You are welcome to this study Unit. The unit is arranged to simplify your study. In each topic of the unit, we have introduction, objectives, in-text, summary and self-assessment exercise. The study unit should be 6-8 hours to complete. Tutors will be available at designated contact centers for tutorial. The center expects you to plan your work well. Should you wish to read further you could supplement the study with more information from the list of references and suggested readings available in the study unit. PRACTICE EXERCISES/TESTS 1. Self-Assessment Exercises (SAES) This is provided at the end of each topic. The exercise can help you to assess whether or not you have actually studied and understood the topic. Solutions to the exercises are provided at the end of the study unit for you to assess yourself. 2. Tutor-Marked Assignment (TMA) vi CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 This is provided at the end of the study Unit. It is a form of examination type questions for you to answer and send to the center. You are expected to work on your own in responding to the assignments. The TMA forms part of your continuous assessment (C.A.) scores, which will be marked and returned to you. In addition, you will also write an end of Semester Examination, which will be added to your TMA scores. Finally, the center wishes you success as you go through the different units of your study. vii CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 INTRODUCTION TO THE COURSE You are welcomed to this study unit. You will be introduced to the Comparative Adult Education. The unit aims at providing you with the necessary tools for understanding the bases of the study of Comparative Adult Education. This course units addresses seven topics. Topic1 explains the problems facing Adult Education. Topic 2 highlights on the reasons for the study of comparative Adult Education. Topic 3 centers on the origin or development of the study of Comparative Adult Education. Topic 4 discusses the population for Comparative Adult Education. Topic 5 addresses the future of Comparative Adult Education. Topic 6 focuses on the comparison between the teachers of Adult Education and that of the formal school system and finally topic 7 descended on comparison between the developments of Adult Education in Nigeria and Sudan. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 1 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– CEA 308: UNIT: 2 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNITS: 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGES PREFACE - - - - - - - - iii - - - - - - - - - - PROBLEMS FACING ADULT EDUCATION - - HOW TO STUDY THE UNIT - iv INTRODUCTION TO THE COURSE 1 TOPICS: 1. 2. 3 REASONS FOR STUDY OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION - 3. - - - 7 ORIGINS/DEVELOPMENT OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION - 4. - - - - - 11 POPULATION FOR COMPARATIVE ADULT CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 2 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– EDUCATION - - - - - UNIT: 2 - - - - 14 5. THE FUTURE OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION - - - - - 18 6. COMPARISON BETWEEN THE TEACHERS OF ADULT EDUCATION AND THOSE OF FORMAL SCHOOL - - - - - - 22 7. COMPARISON BETWEEN NIGERIA AND SUDANESE ADULT EDUCATION - - - - - 26 SOLUTION TO EXERCISES CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 3 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 TOPIC 1: TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGES 1.0 TOPIC 1: PROBLEMS FACING ADULT EDUCATION - 3 1.1 INTRODUCTION - - - - - - - - 4 1.2 OBJECTIVES - - - - - - - - 4 1.3 IN-TEXT - - - - - - - - 4 1.3.1 PROBLEMS FACING ADULT EDUCATION - - - 4 1.4 SUMMARY - - - - - - - 5 1.5 SELF- ASSESSMENT EXERCISES - - - - - 6 1.6 REFERENCE - - - - - - 6 1.7 SUGGESTED READING - - - - - - 6 - - - - - CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 4 CEA 308– 1.0 TOPIC : COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 PROBLEMS FACING ADULT EDUCATION 1.1 INTRODUCTION: This topic examines the problems facing Adult Education as a discipline since it is only of recent that comparative studies of Adult Education came to be. The topic shall also provide possible solutions to some of the enumerated problems. 1.2 OBJECTIVES At the end of the topic, students should be able to: i. Identify major problems facing Adult Education as a discipline, and ii. Enumerate some possible solutions to the identified problems. 1.3 IN-TEXT 1.3.1 PROBLEMS FACING ADULT EDUCATION Adult Education as a discipline in the field of Education is faced with a number of problems which affect the pace of its development. These problems according to Anyanwu (1999) have negative impact at both national and international levels. It is of recent that Adult Education received international exchanges of practitioners and also participation in international organization and international studies as compared with disciplines like economics in the social sciences and psychology in education. Major problems facing Adult Education among other things include the following; i. Ignorance of its tenets and purpose. In most developing countries of the world and Nigeria in particular, many people are ignorant of its tenets and purpose. Many including policy makers do not know the importance of Adult Education in enabling personal and national development. ii. Inadequate provision of facilities. Due to the ignorance of the purpose and importance of Adult Education in national development, in most developing countries and Nigeria in particular, it is confronted within adequate provision of facilities. Most chief executives in the states and policy makers do not consider it important enough to attract adequate budgetary allocation. iii. Failure to utilize Adult Education for development purposes. Adult Education in most developing countries is not used as an instrument for the initiation and implementation of development programms. There is no adequate and well planned mass mobilization of people to participate in Adult Education programmes. Hence, this affects the pace of development in many developing countries and Nigeria in particular. Many development programmes in most developing countries and Nigeria in particular failed because they were not CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 5 CEA 308– iv. v. vi. vii. viii. 1.4 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 channelled and implemented through the appropriate Agencies responsible for Adult Education programmes. In Nigeria many Adult Education programmes are carried not by agencies not conversant with Adult Education programmes such as the defunct Mass Mobilization for Social Justice and Economy Recovery (MAMSER); the Directorate for Foods, Roads and Rural Infrastructure (DFRRI), the National Directorate for Employment (NDE), and the National Orientation Agency (NOA) etc MAMSER, DFFRI, NDE and NOA. Poor funding. Many governments of developing countries and Nigeria in particular fail to provide enough funds for Adult Education programmes. As a result of the limitation of funds, not every aspiration can be fulfilled. In most states and local government areas of Nigeria, the funds that could be used for development of Adult Education are diverted to formal schools and/or other projects. Overemphasis on formal education. In most developing countries and Nigeria in particular emphasis is placed on formal education. Education generally is not seen or viewed as a right for citizens should be available to all and according to ones needs, ability and interest and to continue through life. Importance in national development is undermined. In most developing countries of the world and Nigeria for instance, the importance of Adult Education in the scheme of national development is not yet fully appreciated. Since most chief executives and policy makers as well as other well placed individuals in the society have lukewarm attitudes towards Adult Education, it is not regarded as fostering the provision of vocational, professional, general, social, cultural and recreational education for all men and women that are desirous of continuing their development. Lack of contact between Adult Education practitioners and policy-makers. There is generally a wide-gap between the operators of Adult Education programmes at the grass-root level and the policy-makers, since policy-makers are not in close contact with those engaged in the operation of Adult Education programmes at the grassroots. This makes many policy makers to be ignorant of the actual needs and aspiration of the adult learners in the communities. Consequently, it leads to withdrawal of many adult learners from the programmes. Pretensions of ignorance by policy makers. A good number of policy-makers and chief executives in most developing countries and Nigeria in particular, pretended ignorance of what Adult Education is all about. Apart from the policy-makers and the chief executives, generally people have narrow perception of the concept Adult Education. They receive Adult Education as merely an education capable of bringing to the illiterate masses knowledge of how to read and write and calculate. (3rs). SUMMARY CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 6 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 The topic examined and discussed the various problems facing Adult Education. The problems identified do not only affect Adult Education at the global scene but the people who are to benefit from the programmes. 1.5 SELF-ASSESSMENT EXERCISES 1. Mention any five problems affecting the smooth implementation of Adult Education programmes in your state. 2. How do you think the problems can be minimized? 1.6 REFERENCES Anyanwu, C.N. (1999). Comparative Studies in Adult Education Ibadan, Gabesther, Educational Publishers. Lowe, J. (1970). Adult Education and Nation Building Edinburgh. (Edinburgh University Press). 1.7 SUGGESTED READING Anyanwu, C.N. (1983). An Approach to Comparative Adult Education Owerri. African Educational Services Ltd. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 7 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 TOPIC 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS 2.0 TOPIC: PAGES REASONS FOR THE STUDY OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION - - - - 7 2.1 INTRODUCTION - - - - - - - 8 2.2 OBJECTIVES - - - - - - - 8 2.3 IN-TEXT - - - - - - - 8 2.3.1 REASONS FOR LEARNING THE COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION 2.4 SUMMARY - - 2.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE 2.6 REFERENCES 2.7 SUGGESTED READING - - - - - - - - 8 - - - - - 9 - - - - 9 - - - - - 10 - - - - - 10 CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 8 CEA 308– 2.0 TOPIC: COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION REASONS FOR THE STUDY UNIT: 2 OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION 2.1 INTRODUCTION The reasons for the study of comparative Adult Education is numerous, but mainly intellectual. Adult Educators and Educationist study programmes of Adult Education in various countries of the world in order to know what happen in other countries and compare with what is obtained in their country and make rooms for possible adjustment and improvement. According to Thomas (1970, p.230) studying Comparative Adult Education is worthwhile, because “an important quality of being human is to learn”. Therefore the knowledge obtained from the study of Comparative Adult Education seeks to analyze the causes which may have produced such similarities or differences, reasons underlying such situations and solutions attempted for any problems arising there from. 2.1 OBJECTIVES At the end of the topic, students should be able to: i. Differentiate their country’s educational system form those of foreign ones. ii. Enumerate the reasons for learning Comparative Adult Education. 2.3 IN-TEXT 2.3.1 REASONS FOR LEARNING COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION The reasons for the study of Comparative Adult Education among other things include the following: i. New knowledge in the field of Education. Comparative Adult Education is an area of study recently added to the range of research and teaching in Education. Therefore as a field of study, there is need for vigorous pursuing to enable Adult Educators and Educationists to become fully acquainted with the system and how best it can be co-opted into their country’s Educational system. Bereday (1964, P.5) added that “Education is a mirror held against the face of the people, any system of Education tells without error, the nature of the society that embraces it”. Based on this, what are the lessons the nations have learnt from the early founders of Education in Nigeria? The ArabCDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 9 CEA 308– ii. iii. COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 Muslim Scholars in the north and the Portuguese traders /Portuguese Catholic Christian Missionaries in the South? What are socio-economic, political, cultural and social implications has the two religions have on their followers in these regions? Deduce lessons from past mistakes. The study of Comparative Adult Education does not only aid Adult Educators and Educationalists to know how other countries carry out their Educational system but also help them to understand how their country’s educational system differ from others. Knoll, (1979, P.15) added that, to understand others with a view to understand ourselves and evaluating our achievements, enable us to deduce lessons from our own system from the achievements and mistakes of other system and it can also help us to access educational issues and problems from a wider perspective than could otherwise be the case. Thus, in other words, when we are aware of other people’s point of view, we can be in better position to accommodate our shortcomings with good faith and further adjust and give room for better positioning of problems. Inject-in-new and fresh ideas. The knowledge obtained from the study of Comparative Adult Education may enable both Adult Educators and Educationalists to bring in new and fresh ideas. It will also enable them carrying out critical thinking and analyzing the Educational system under study so that it can benefit all and sundry. Lowe (1975) added that “knowledge of the existence of effective methods of procedure and successful solutions to educational problems in another country may be a tool for practical purposes through analogy and emulation in one’s country”. Apart from injecting-in-new and fresh ideas into the Educational system, Lowe (1975) further enumerated the benefits of the study of Comparative Adult Education to include: a. To clarify whether certain behavior patterns are characteristics of a certain culture, or whether they are valid for the generality of humanity. b. They also offer help in Education to those who wish to work in other countries and other cultures. c. They offer fruitful type of study for those who wish to learn more about other people and other countries. d. They gave the individual an increased and deeper understanding of his own view and own culture. e. They offer systematic and rational aids for the decision whether the impact of cultural or educational influences from outside should be accepted and copied or rejected and repulsed . f. They are necessary preliminary for research work which extends over several countries and several cultures. g. They deliver experiences and hypothesis which prove themselves useful in the estimation of the possible effects and consequences of considered innovation in Education. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 10 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 2.4 SUMMARY This topic gave an overview of the major reasons for studying Comparative Adult Education. It also enumerated some benefits derived from the study. 2.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISES 1. Why do we study Comparative Adult Education? 2. Give two reasons derived from the study of Comparative Adult Education? 2.6 REFERENCES Bereday, G.Z.F. (1964). Comparative Methods in Education New York, (Rinehart, Halt and Winston). Knoll, J.H. (1979). The Importance and use of Comparative Studies in Adult Education in the Framework of Academic Course of Study. 2.7 SUGGESTED READING Anyanwu, C.N. (1983). An Approach to Comparative Adult Education. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 11 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 TOPIC 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE 3.0 TOPIC: MEANING AND ORIGIN OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION - - - - 11 3.1 INTRODUCTION - - - - - - - 12 3.2 OBJECTIVES - - - - - - - 12 3.3 IN-TEXT - - - - - - - 12 - 12 - 3.3.1 MEANING OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION 3.3.2 ADVANTAGES OF COMPARATIVE STUDIES IN ADULT EDUCATION - - - - - - 12 3.4 SUMMARY - - - - - - - 13 3.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE - - - - - 13 3.6 REFERENCES - - - - - - 13 3.7 SUGGESTED READING - - - - - - 13 - - CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 12 CEA 308– 3.0 TOPIC: COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 MEANING AND ORIGIN OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION 3.1 INTRODUCTION In this topic, we shall examine the meaning and origin of the concept Comparative Adult Education. We shall also consider the advantages derived from the study of Comparative Adult Education. 3.2 OBJECTIVES At the end of this topic, students should be able to: i. Define the term Comparative Adult Education. ii. Enumerate the advantages of the study of Comparative Adult Education. 3.3 IN-TEXT 3.3.1 MEANING OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION The concept Comparative Adult Education refers to a process of comparing, analyzing and coming up with differences in programmes of Adult Education in selected countries of the world, especially among the developing ones. Anyanwu (1983) added that “the possibilities of learning from one country to improve ones practice at home is widely recognized as an important means of improving the quality of Comparative Studies in Adult Education”. Anyanwu (1983) further called for review of relevant experience in other countries and a consideration of particular programme in a comparative framework, in order to minimize the major problems facing Adult Education in both developed and developing countries. These problems among other things include ignorance, tenets and purpose of Adult Education. 3.3.2 ADVANTAGES OF COMPARATIVE STUDIES IN ADULT EDUCATION The advantages that are derived from the study of Comparative Adult Education include the following: CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 13 CEA 308– i. ii. iii. iv. v. COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 Governments of both developed and developing countries become aware of development in the area of Adult Education and make efforts to improve them for the benefit of their citizens. Proper funding. The knowledge of Comparative Adult Education will enable Governments especially that of developing countries to properly fund Adult Education programmes in their countries. The knowledge of Comparative Adult Education will help especially the developing countries to know that Adult Education is beyond a mere basic literacy. And they therefore embark on variety of programmes. Avoidance of duplication of programmes. In developing countries and Nigeria in particular, there is duplication of programmes of Adult Education as a result of many agencies responsible for delivering the programmes. These agencies include the National Commission for Mass Literacy Adult and Nonformal Education, MAMSER, DFRRI, NDE, BETTER-LIFE and even clubs which are interested in allowing their members to learn how to read and write. Critical appraisal. A sound knowledge of Comparative Adult Education will be useful to both Adult Educators and Educationalists, especially when conducting seminars, workshops, lectures where there is need to critically appraise Adult Education and its programmes at the global scene. 3.4 SUMMARY The topic has attempted to define the concept Comparative Adult Education. It also enumerated some advantages derived from the study of Comparative Adult Education. 3.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE 1. What do you understand by the concept Comparative Adult Education? 2. What are the advantages derived from the study of Comparative Adult Education. 3.6 REFERENCES Anyanwu, C.N. (1981). Principles and Practices of Adult Education and Community Development. Ibadan, (Abiprint Publishing Company) Anyanwu, C.N. (1983). An Approach to Comparative Adult Education Owerri. African Educational Services Ltd. 3.7 SUGGESTED READING Anyanwu, C.N. (1983). An Approach to Comparative Adult Education Owerri. African Education Services Ltd. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 14 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri UNIT: 2 15 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 TOPIC 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE 4.0 TOPIC: TARGET POPULATION FOR COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION - - - - 14 4.1 INTRODUCTION - - - - - - - 15 4.2 OBJECTIVES - - - - - - - 15 4.3 IN-TEXT - - - - - - - 15 - - - - - 15 4.3.2 PHYSICALLY CHALLENGED ADULTS - - - 15 4.3.3 ABILITY IN DISABILITY - - - - - - 16 4.4 SUMMARY - - - - - - 16 4.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE - - - - 16 4.6 REFERENCES - - - - - 17 4.7 SUGGESTED READING - - - - - 17 - 4.3.1 NORMAL/ABLED ADULTS - - - - CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 16 CEA 308– 4.0 TOPIC: COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 TARGET POPULATION FOR COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION 4.1 INTRODUCTION This topic examines the population for Comparative studies in Adult Education. The Target population for Adult Education is a major problem throughout the world. The target population in developing countries where illiteracy rate is very high is very small whereas the population in developed countries where illiteracy rate is very low is very high, Igbalajabi (1992). However, whether in developed or developing countries of the world, the target population is classified into two: Normal Adults and Physically Challenged Adults. 4.2 OBJECTIVES At the end of the topic, students should be able to: i. Differentiate normal adults from physically challenged adults. ii. Differentiate programmes of Adult Education in developed countries from that of developing countries. 4.3 IN-TEXT 4.3.1 NORMAL/ABLED ADULTS These are men and women who have not experienced any form of disability but have not been oportuned to benefit from the formal school system during their childhood. In most developing countries of the world, Adult Education programmes are for the normal/abled adults just to enable them master the skills of reading, writing and an element of elementary calculation (3rs). In Nigeria, only 25% of the normal adults that requires Adult Education programmes had the chance in 1990 with Kano State leading, followed by Bauchi. Whereas in the year 2000 Borno State was at the top. This could be as a result of incorporating Western system of education in most of its Tsangaya centers. Annual report UNICEF D (2006). 4.3.2 PHYSICALLY CHALLENGED ADULTS These are men and women who have suffered some physical deformation. These deformation could be as a result of accident or nature. In both developing and developed countries of the world we have people who are born blind, deaf or have CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 17 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 no hands or legs. But cases of accident leading to deformation is less in developed countries as compared with developing countries. Igbalajabi (1992) These categories of physically challenged adults either in developed or developing countries require Adult Education programmes. However, in most developing countries and Nigeria in particular, no much has been done in this area. Apart from the rehabilitation centers established by the Christian missionaries, there is no single state in Nigeria that has standard rehabilitation center for its physically challenged adults. Even those who were rehabilitated later on end up on the streets begging. However, in most developed countries of the world, apart from the fact that the population of their literate adults is very high up to 80-90%, their physically challenged adults which is 10-20% are adequately taken care of. Igbalajabi (1992). 4.3.3 ABILITY IN DISABILITY The concept ability refers to knowledge, skills or other natural gifts that can assist man or woman to be useful not only to himself but to the society. Whereas, disability refers to some kinds of deficiency either physically, morally, emotionally, psychologically, socially or mentally which affects his/her normal performance. The concept ability in disability according to Igbolajabi (1992) simply means that “though we may be disabled but there is an element of potentials in us that makes us human beings and allow us to think rationally”. The concept ability in disability was introduced in the area of Adult Education just in 1985 in America by the National Association for Adult Education with special learning needs. The National Association for Adults with special learning needs classified their membership as follows: i. Physically challenged adults due to social and moral problems. These categories of adults include the destitute and the homeless. ii. Physically challenged adults due to psychological problems. These include adult that experience stress, tension and anxiety, worries, high blood pressure and hypertension. iii. Physically challenged adults due to social rejection in the community. This include jobless graduates, prison inmates etc. iv. Physically challenged due to lack of basic amenities such as money, clothing and shelter. On the comparative basis, physically challenged adults that receive Adult Education programmes in developed countries are foundationally productive. In such countries there are lawyers, Academic and medical doctors, nurses, judges as well as other positions in the military services that are physically challenged. Recently, in America, a blind man is made a Governor. However, in most developing countries, and Nigeria in particular, even those that were rehabilitated at the rehabilitation centres, end up begging for alarms on the street. 4.4 SUMMARY CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 18 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 This topic examined the target population for Adult Education Programmes in both developed and developing countries. It also explained the concept ability in disability and its effects on physically challenged Adults in developed and developing countries. 4.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE 1. Differentiate between Abled and Physically challenged Adults. 2. Define the concept Ability in Disability. 4.6 REFERENCES Anyawu, C.N. (1982) Community Education and Development. The Experience in West Africa, Ibadan (Abiprint Publishing Company). Igbalajabi, M.C. (1992) Special Education Lecture Notes, Department of Continuing Education and Extension Service, Unimaid, Unpublished. 4.7 SUGGESTED READINGS Anyawu, C.N. (1982) Community Education and Development. The Experience in West Africa, Ibadan (Abiprint Publishing Company). CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 19 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 TOPIC 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE 5.0 TOPIC: THE FUTURE OF COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION 18 5.1 INTRODUCTION 19 5.2 OBJECTIVES 19 5.3 IN-TEXT 19 5.3.1 THE PRESENT POSITION OF ADULT EDUCATION 19 5.3.2 AREAS OF CONSIDERATION TO FURTHER DEVELOP ADULT EDUCATION 19 5.4 SUMMARY 20 5.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE 20 5.6 REFERENCES 21 5.7 SUGGESTED READING 21 CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 20 CEA 308– 5.0 TOPIC: COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION THE EFFECT OF COMPARATIVE UNIT: 2 ADULT EUCATION 5.1 INTRODUCTION In this topic, we shall examine the future of Comparative Adult Education with emphasis on areas that should be addressed so that the study can be improved in future. 5.2 OBJECTIVE At the end of the topic, students should be able to: i. Assess the present position of Adult Education. ii. Areas of consideration for further development of Adult Education. 5.3 IN-TEXT 5.3.1 PRESENT POSITION OF ADULT EDUCATION Among the major problems facing Adult Education in both developed and developing countries of the world, is that of its meaning, tenents and purpose, Fajonyomi (2003). However, with the knowledge of comparative adult education between different countries of the world, Adult Education has now gained more, recognition in both developed and developing countries of the world. Many countries now perceive Adult Education as a tool for national development. This is so because most problems that are facing these countries need immediate and urgent solutions that cannot wait for the children from the formal school system to finish before solutions to such problems are found; rather it’s the adults that are conditioned to effect such changes. Programmes of Adult Education activities which call for immediate and urgent social changes are in the areas of literacy education, vocational training, Agriculture, health education, political/education, population education, citizenship etc. it is a tool through which both the developed and developing countries are saved from either poverty, ignorance, disease and other problems. 5.3.2 AREAS OF CONSIDERATION TO FURTHER DEVELOP ADULT EDUCATION Based on the present analysis of comparative Adult Education, the future of the study will be bright and goal oriented if the following areas are properly addressed. 1. Provision of funds. Budgetary allocation to Adult Education at all levels of the governments should be increased. International organizations and CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 21 CEA 308– 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 philanthropists should double their contributions to the services of Adult Education. Societies should be dynamic. With the daily changes in the world of science and technology, societies should brace up and respond to new changes and also be carried alone. Cordial relationship. For study of comparative Adult Education to be successful all through, there must be cordial relationship or cooperation with Philosophers, sociologists, historians, economists, natural scientists, statisticians, linguists and political scientists. Conferences – Conferences in Adult Education on inter-continental basis will aid Adult Education. Information and data collected will contribute to policy discussions and problems identified will be solved through cross-fertilization of ideas among different countries of the world. International understanding. International barrier of ignorance should be broken in order to pave way for exchange of ideas and information about Adult Education practice in other countries of the world. Freedom and equal participation: People should be given the unreserved opportunities and freedom to fully participate in matters that affect their well being as individuals as well as communities. The people’s freedom and equal participation will bring about higher interest in Adult Education and further enhances the development of comparative studies in Adult Education. Appreciation of values and beliefs. Practices of Adult Education in different parts of the world are affected by different societal culture, values, beliefs and other factors. These differences can be appreciated if issues relating to planning of Adult Education, the diffusion of innovation, curriculum development and training programmes are harmonized. Research priority. Both developed and developing countries of the world learn from each other. Based on this, developing countries of the world should be given free and upper hands in research work by the development countries and also recognized in the scheme of educational advancement. Researchers, experts and educationists from the developing countries should be encouraged at all levels to conduct conferences and workshops as their inputs towards comparative studies in Adult Education. If this is done, it will contribute to international education development. Encourage cultural diffusion. Although countries learn from other countries, in order to promote their Adult Education Programmes, new ideas and innovations from one country to another has to be properly monitored, studied and modified before such culture is adopted. Proper methodology. The methodology for the comparative studies in Adult Education should be dynamic. Therefore all researchers, experts and educationists should employ the appropriate methodology for study of comparative Adult Education throughout the world. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 22 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 5.4 SUMMARY The topic examined the present position of Adult Education and dealt with appropriate areas for the future development of comparative studies in Adult Education. 5.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISES 1. What is the present position of Adult Education in your country? 2. Mention one four areas that should be considered for further development of comparative Adult Education. 5.6 REFERENCES Anyanwu, C.N. (1999) Element of Comparative Adult Education. Ibadan: Babesther Educational Publishers. Lawal, B.O. (1999) Comparative Adult Education: Lagos. Stirling Holden Publishers. 5.7 SUGGESTED READING Anyanwu, C.N. (1999) Element of Comparative Adult Education. Ibadan: Gabesther Educational Publishers. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 23 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 TOPIC 6 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE 6.0 TOPIC: COMPARISON BETWEEN THE TEACHERS OF ADULT EDUCATION AND TEACHERS IN FORMAL SCHOOL SYSTEM 22 6.1 INTRODUCTION 23 6.2 OBJECTIVES 23 6.3 IN-TEXT 23 6.3.1 FORMAL/NON FORMAL EDUCATION TEACHERS 23 6.4 SUMMARY 25 6.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE 25 6.6 REFERENCES 25 6.7 SUGGESTED READING 25 CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 24 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– 6.0 TOPIC: UNIT: 2 COMPARISON BETWEEN THE TEACHERS OF ADULT EDUCATION AND TEACHERS IN FORMAL SCHOOL SYSTEM 6.1 INTRODUCTION In this topic, we shall examine the major difference between teachers from the formal school system and those from the Adult Education. The knowledge will enable us know the expected roles of teachers in the two types of education and how they impact knowledge to learners in their areas of operation. 6.2 OBJECTIVES At the end of the topic, students should be able to:i. Compare the role of teachers in the formal school system to that of Adult Education. ii. Explain the important roles in imparting knowledge to pupils/students and Adult learners respectively. 6.3 IN-TEXT 6.3.1 DIFFERENCES BETWEEN FORMAL SCHOOL AND ADULT EDUCATION TEACHERS The primary objective of organizing a class either for pupils/students or adults is to bring the teacher and the learners into personal contact in order to benefit from learning. The role of teachers in teaching – learning is however different in Adult Education and that of formal Education. The differences are as shown below. i. Mode of teaching. In formal education schools the mode of teaching is known as pedagogy. In this mode of teaching, the teacher is professional expert while the learners are passive receivers of knowledge. The mode of teaching among adult is known as andragogy. This mode of teaching decentralized teaching-learning among teachers and learners. In most cases, the teacher does not claim to be the only all knowing. He seeks learners opinion and experiences on subjects under study. Sometimes in teaching adults, the two mode of teaching are used in order to achieve a greater success. ii. Varied background of experience. In Adult Education most of the adult learners are matured people with a rich and varied background of experience. These group of people have their own contributions to make to the learning process. They could also decide to withdraw once their interests and opinions are not properly taken care of. Teachers, especially CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 25 CEA 308– iii. iv. v. vi. vii. COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 those teaching Adults, should bear this in mind and permit the maximum use of the learners wealth of experience. However, in the formal school system pupils/students have limited experience and rely most on their teachers to provide the necessary required information. In Adult Education, the responsibility for success in organization rests squarely on the adult instructor more than formal education. The success of the programme depends on the fitness and ability of the Adult instructor to sustain the interest of the Adult learners. These Adult learners are attending classes because they wish to attend and not compulsory. They could also decide to withdraw if they so wish. Unlike pupils/students in the formal school system whose primary objective is to be trained and get certificate. The pursuit of paper qualification keeps the class together, no matter how dull the teacher may be. Even in universities where there is autonomy, there is kind compulsion to attend lectures. Human sympathy and understanding. A good teacher of Adult Education must be some one who have the gift of human sympathy and understandings to enable him get the confidence of his learners. He needs to get closer to his learners to get their particular interest or otherwise and motivate them to overcome all forms of bitterness of learning. However, the teacher from the formal school system in most cases, do not get much closer to his pupils/students to know their various interest or otherwise. Since formal school system is certificate oriented which prepares pupils/students for future, the needs for closer interpersonal relationship is not there. Problems in learning process. The Adult Education teachers appreciates the problems and difficulties of his learners. These problems may include sight which may require special sitting arrangement in the class, family problems etc which may make the adult learner to come late. The Adult teacher should bear all these in mind and continue to encourage the adult learners. However, in the formal school system, such problems are not easily appreciated by their teachers. Problems in learning process. Adult learners by their nature have some learning problems. They do not readily assimilate facts like young ones due to old age, they are faced with among other things short-term memory and long-term memory problems. Also they do not learn by note. Therefore, Adult Education teachers should be aware of these and other special problems of Adult learning. However, in the formal school system, the teacher is free to move very fast because this pupils/students can easily understand him and are also capable of learning by rote. The pupils/students from the formal school system are still young and are not affected by aging problems. Classes are heterogeneous. The teacher of the Adult Education Programmes will find learners of different age group and of different occupational background. He is therefore expected to make the class have CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 26 CEA 308– viii. ix. x. COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 a sense of common loyalty capable of generating good group work. The teacher should also be aware of different interest of the individual members. However, in the formal school system the classes are basically homogeneous. It is much easier in the formal school system to have a common loyalty in the class. The major interest in the formal school system is acquisition of certificate at the end. Challenges, teachers of Adult Education Programmes are supposed to have personal acquisition and ability to master his subjects well. This becomes necessary because Adult learners can ask many questions. Some of these question may require depth research to give answers. Although teachers of the formal school system are also required to have a sound knowledge of their subjects, the challenges they do receive from their pupils/students are not very much challenging in classrooms as compared with teachers of Adult Education. Different target goals. In Adult Education, the teacher is expected to have a good and sound knowledge of his adult learners and background. He should also know that his learners come to classes on voluntary basis and could decide to leave when their interest are not protected. He should therefore do everything possible to motivate them and work towards achieving the set goals. However, in the formal school system, the teacher is required to have a sound knowledge of the subject and not necessarily the detailed social background of his pupils/students. Different subject compartment. In Adult Education one teacher may be responsible for teaching all the adult subjects for the adult learners. However, in the formal school system it may require different teachers teaching different subject. 6.4 SUMMARY The topic discussed major differences between teachers of Adult Education and that of the formal school system. The topic also enumerate ten differences between the two schools. 6.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE 1. Distinguish between teachers of Adult Education and that of the formal school system. 6.6 REFERENCE Lawal B.O. (1999) Comparative Education. Lagos: Sterling Horden. Anyanwu, C.N. (1999) Element of Comparative Adult Education, Ibadan: Gabesther Educational Publishers. 6.7 SUGGESTED READING CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 27 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 Anyanwu, C.N. (1999) Element of Comparative Adult Education, Ibadan. Gabesther Educational Publishers. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 28 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– UNIT: 2 TOPIC 7 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE 7.0 TOPIC: COMPARISON BETWEEN NIGERIAN AND SUDANESE ADULT EDUCATION - - - - 26 7.1 INTRODUCTION - - - - - - - 27 7.2 OBJECTIVES - - - - - - - 27 7.3 IN-TEXT - - - - - - - 27 7.3.1 ADULT EDUCATION IN NIGERIA - - - - 27 7.3.2 ADULT EDUCATION IN SUDAN - - - - 28 7.4 SUMMARY - - - - - 29 7.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE - - - - 29 7.6 REFERENCES - - - - - - 29 7.7 SUGGESTED READING - - - - - - 29 - - - - - CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 29 COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CEA 308– 7.0 TOPIC: COMPARISON BETWEEN UNIT: 2 NIGERIAN AND SUDANESE ADULT EDUCATION 7.1 INTRODUCTION: In this topic we shall examine the similarities and differences in adult education in Nigeria and Sudan. Through comparative adult education we shall find out how these countries have managed and fulfilled their objective of development of adult education in their countries. 7.2 OBJECTIVES At the and of this topic, students should be able to: i. explain the similarities and differences in adult education programmes in their countries. ii. describe how adult education are organized and managed in these countries. 7.3 IN-TEXT 7.3.1 ADULT EDUCATION IN NIGERIA Traditional education in Nigeria was the main prop of the education of the adults before the coming of the Europeans. It constitute for the indigenous communities, the process of accullaturation and development of natural character, Omolewa (1981, p31). It thus brought the needs of the society in line with the demands of the reading and writing involved. As for the introduction of western education in Nigeria, this could be traced back to the early Arab-Muslim traders and the Portuguese Christian Missionaries who came and settled in the north and south regions of the country respectively. Among the Muslim communities in the north and west of Nigeria, literary education in Arabic language was introduced by the wangara Arab traders in Kano between 1349 and 1385. The religion of Islam and Arabic language reached the west in 17th century. The spread of Islamic religion meant the spread of Islamic education as the religion itself is always integrated with every aspect of the life of its adherents. Islamic education promoted the learning of the Quran as well as the Arabic scripts and Islamic thought and culture. Islam and Islamic education was deeply rooted in the north and gradually spread to other parts of the country prior to the advent of the colonial masters. That means Islam had been in North Africa during the medieval period. In the south, education was brought by the Portuguese Christian missionaries as early as 1571. They built adult literacy classes for the followers in order to enable CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 30 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 them learn how to read and write and also understand the language of the white man so that they can communicate and understand each other. Apart from adult literary classes for their immediate followers they built schools and clinics. These works went on simultaneously with the spread of the religion of Christianity to other parts of the country. According to Omolewa, (1981) from 1842 to 1882 all educational administration in the country were in the hands of the Christian missionaries. Even when the colonial masters came, they did not intervene in the administration of such schools. The best they could do was to effect little changes and adopt it as the “nation’s educational system”. Also, the post colonial government in Nigeria adopted the inheritated educational system laid down by the Christian missionaries. 7.3.2 ADULT EDUCATION IN SUDAN Literary education in Sudan had its base from the Greek Christian missionaries in the early middle ages. The missionaries encouraged the Nubians Priests and clerks to read and write in Greek then, other Sudanese local languages. However, when Christianity was declined in Sudan in 15th century, Islam and Islamic educational took over all religious and educational affairs from the Christian Priests and clerks. Hassan, (1762, P119). Between 1504 – 1821 Islam and Islamic education became very popular and mosque became center for both worship and for educational activities under the Moslem holy man of Fakis under the administration of the Fug-sultanate. But when Sudan was conquered by Egypt in 1821 and brought under the Ottoman administration, new changes in Sudanese educational system were made. Although the Moslem Fakis were allowed to continue with their educational activities, vocational education in areas of agriculture science and public health were introduced and incorporated. When Britain colonized Sudan in 1898, the British Government further ushered in western ideas, secular and missionary educations, but retained Arabic as the language of introduction for official matters. Consequently, when Sudan became independent in 1956, like Nigeria it inherited on educational system whose curricula and structures were based on western education practice, mixture of secular and Islamic subjects. Hence, the development of modern education system in Sudan was gradual and through careful chanelling and wise implementation. This was done to over come any possible fear and suspicion that, the western oriented schools might contaminate their traditional culture and corrupt the morals of the young Moslem generations. On comparative basics both Sudan and Nigeria are countries in Africa. Both were colonized by Britain. Both countries attained independence in 1956 and 1960 respectively. At independence both Sudan and Nigeria were said to have an illiterate rate of 70% therefore both countries require adult education to solve their literacy problems among other things in order to accelerate development. On the differences that exists between these countries, although both were colonized by Britain, Nigeria is termed as a secular state. In the northern part of the country Islamic is the predominant religion while in the south Christianity is the popular religion. The country also adopted her colonized language English as the official language and also CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 31 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 recognized Hausa, Yaruba and Igbo languages as its reginal languages, north, west and east respectively. However, Sudan is regarded as an Islamic state and adopted Arabic language as the official language of the country. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 32 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 7.4 SUMMARY The topic examined literacy development in both Nigeria and Sudan. It also compared the similarities and differences of educational development in these countries. 7.5 SELF ASSESSMENT EXERCISE 1. Explain briefly how literacy education started in Nigeria and Sudan. 2. What are the differences in the development of education in these countries. 7.6 REFERENCES Omolewa M. (1981 P31) Adult Education practice in Nigeria, Ibadan (Evan Brothers) Anyanwu, C.N (1989) Manpower needs and Education Administration in Nigeria 1842 – 1922: A Study of education for colonial dominance. THE EDUCATOR, 1976. Vol II Hassan, Y. F. (1962, P119) Interaction between the traditional and western education in Sudan: Attempt towards synthesis, in Brown G.N and Hiskett. 7.7 SUGGESTED READINGS. Anyanwu, C.N (1989) Manpower needs and Education Administration in Nigeria CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 33 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 SOLUTIONS TO EXERCISES TOPIC: 1 a. Mention any five problems affecting the smooth implementation of Adult Education Programmes in your state. Inadequate infrastructural facilities Poor funding of Adult Education programme Lack of contacts between the policy makers and Adult learners Pretension of ignorance by policy makers Ignorance of its tenents and purpose b. How do you think the problems can be minimized? i. All Adult Educators and Adult Educationists as well as other stakeholders should intensify efforts in the promotion of Adult Education. TOPIC: 2 a. Why do we study comparative Adult Education? We study comparative Adult Education to enable us know what happen in other countries so that we can improve our educational system. b. Give five reasons derived from the study of comparative Adlult Education. New knowledge in the field of education Deduce lesson from past mistake Inject in new and fresh ideas To clarify certain behaviours Offer systematic and rational aids on educational matters TOPIC: 3 a. What is comparative Adult Education? It’s a process of comparing, analyzing and coming up with difference in Adult Education programmes world-wide b. What are the advantages derived from the study of comparative Adult Education? Vast knowledge of Adult Education world-wide. Embarked on variety of programmes. Avoidance of duplication of programmes. TOPIC: 4 a. Differentiate between Abled and Physically challenged Adults. The abled Adult is an individuals without any form of disability while the physically challenged is an individual who suffered a form of deformation. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 34 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri UNIT: 2 35 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 b. Define the concept Ability in Disability. Although the individual is physically challenged, there is an element of potentials in him/her that make him/her human being and think rationally. TOPIC: 5 a. What is the present position of Adult Education in Nigeria? Adult Education in Nigeria is now perceived as a tool for national development and reconstruction. b. Mention any four areas that should be considered for further development of comparative Adult Education. Adequate funding Coordinal relationship Conferences International understanding TOPIC: 6 a. What is the difference between teachers of Adult Education and that of formal school system? Adult Education teachers employ androgogy method of teaching and decentralized the teaching and the learning process while the formal school teachers employ pedagogy method of teaching and centralized the teaching and learning process In Adult Education learners are matured and have experience while in the formal school pupils/student’s depend solely the teachers. The adult teacher appreciates his learner’s problems and difficulties while the formal school teachers overlook most of these problems. TOPIC: 7 a. Who are the founders of Western Education in Nigeria and Sudan? The Christian Missionaries were the founders of Western Education in the two countries. b. What are the educational differences between Sudan and Nigeria? Sudan maintained Arab as its official language despite its colony by Britain while Nigeria picked the language of its colonial masters and also recognized three others Sudan is an Islamic State while Nigeria is a secular State. CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 36 CEA 308– COMPARATIVE ADULT EDUCATION UNIT: 2 TUTOR-MARKED ASSIGNMENT UNIT-TEXT. 1 1. 2. 3. 4. What is comparative Adult Education? Explain why physically challenged Adults are not properly taken care of in the Nigerian Educational System? What are advantaged derived from the study of comparative Adult Education? What are similarities and differences in the practice of Adult Education in Sudan and Nigeria? CDL, University of Maiduguri, Maiduguri 37