EQUIPPING FOR SERVICE: A STUDY OF EPHESIANS 4:7-16 ____________________ A Term Paper Presented To Dr. Richard Oster Harding Graduate School of Religion Memphis, Tennessee ____________________ As A Requirement in Course 7210 Ephesians and Contemporary Ministry ____________________ by G. K. Pennington March 19, 2006 Setting the Scope of the Paper The focus of this paper is on the concept expressed by the apostle Paul in Eph. 4:7-16.1 This passage addresses Christians and their need for an intentional preparation in ministry and service. Unity and stability of the “body of Christ” are best experienced when we are firmly rooted in a maturity and faith that comes to us as a gift of the Christ. The source for the “equipping” expressed in this passage is the exalted Christ. The ultimate goal of this study is to better understand how these concepts inform my ministry. Contextual Issues It is important to give attention to the historical context and the occasion of the letter. Robert H. Gundry points to Paul’s other letters and concludes that this book is different because it does not address a “particular circumstance or controversy.”2 Guthrie says this is a All biblical references in this paper, unless otherwise identified, are taken from the New International Version. 1 Robert H. Gundry, A Survey of the New Testament, 4th ed. (Zondervan, 1970; reprint, Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2003), 421. 2 2 3 difficulty but points to the circular letter theory and Paul’s imprisonment, thinking this may set the occasion related to the writer’s circumstance instead of the reader’s.3 I understand that as an explanation for the higher level of Christology. However, in similar circumstances while writing other Prison Epistles, Paul addressed specific concerns and highlighted an equally impeccable Christology. Colossians. This can be observed clearly in The authors of Introduction to the New Testament, reflecting on the absence of a clear purpose, note that the teachings of Ephesians “may well have been greatly needed in more than one first century situation.”4 This could mean that Paul would not have been as direct in addressing issues if multiple congregations were the intended audience. I don’t agree with this contention when I consider the book of Galatians being a classic example of multiple congregations needing instruction but Paul’s being very direct. Donald Guthrie, New Testament Introduction, 4th ed. (Leicester, England: Apollos, 1961; reprint, Downers Grove, IL: Intervarsity Press, 1990), 535. He indicates that Paul’s being in prison could have allowed him the opportunity to contemplate the issues of the letter. Imprisonment could have cut him off from sources of information about congregational conflicts, thus limiting his ability to address them. 3 D. A. Carson, Douglas J. Moo, Leon Morris., An Introduction to the New Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1992), 312. 4 4 Markus Barth, considering the structure of the book of Ephesians, notes there are two major sections. The first section, Chapters 1-3, has a beginning “address” and the second, Chapters 4-6, has “the final blessing.”5 . He labels the first three chapters as “dogmatic or kerygmatic” and the last three chapters as “ethical, didactic, or parenetic.” 6 I prefer O’Brien’s terminology, “The New Humanity in a Divine Creation” or “…in Earthly Life,” believing that for the average person they are better understood.7 Identifying the Pericope of Choice Identifying the proper extent of the pericope for this study presents us with a challenge. Eph. 4:1-16 addresses several aspects of unity to which Christians are called. This calling is initiated in Eph. 4:1 with a consideration of the qualities of life to be lived by Christians in light of the “glory” God deserves. The nature of the calling is rooted in the description of what God has done for those Karl Barth, Church Dogmatics: Index with Aids for the Preacher, ed. Very Rev. Prof. T. F. Torrance Rev. Prof. G. W. Bromiley (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark LTD, 1977), 53. 5 6 Ibid. Peter T. O'Brien, The Letter to the Ephesians (Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 1999), 88, 271. 7 5 “in Christ,” Eph. 1:3.8 O’Brien9, looking at the larger picture of these verses, notes that they address “Unity, Diversity, and Maturity within the Body of Christ.”10 sees these verses falling into two subdivisions. He Verses 1- 6 open the discussion of unity as “an Urgent Concern”11 while verses 7-16 address “Diversity in Unity That Leads to Maturity.”12 While the two sections are connected with the unity theme, this study is going to focus on the latter verses with the goal of maturity in mind. O’Brien cites verses 7-16 as an “envelope” or “(inclusio)” framed by the use of “each one” in the beginning and ending verses.13 The Source of Christian Growth is the Ascended Christ The NIV does not clearly translate and emphasize (“dwre>aj”) in verse 7.14 8 The KJV, NASV, and the ESV do Ibid., 273. D. A. Carson considers this to be the “best Englishlanguage commentary available. D. A. Carson, New Testament Commentary Survey (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2001), 93. 9 10 O'Brien, 271. 11 Ibid., 273. 12 Ibid., 286. 13 Ibid., 286. The Greek New Testament. 4th ed. Edited by Barbara Aland, Kurt Aland, Johannes Karvaidopoulos, Carlo M. Martini, Bruce Metzger. London: United Bible Societies, 14 6 emphasize it in their translations. Bauer gives a similar rendering as the NIV, “to the measure that Christ has given…”15 The difficulty I see with the absence of an emphasis on “gifts” is that when we get to verse 11 “…He gave some to be…” we are left guessing what has been given. Is it grace as in God’s favor or is it God’s favor in various gifts? In verses 8-10 Paul uses the language of Psalm 68 to set a foundation for the authority of Christ. O’Brien sees the use of the Psalm as a means of bringing creditable substance to the giver of these gifts.16 Martin takes the view that the meaning of Psalm 68 and what Paul intended in Ephesians was “almost the opposite.”17 There is the question of what is meant by the Christ descending in verses 8-10. Ralph Martin offers three possible models and does not settle the issue. Instead he highlights the enthronement. …the author is emphasizing Christ victory in his 1993, 662. This is the primary source for the Greek terms used in this paper. Walter Bauer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, 2d ed., ed. F. Wilbur Gingrich William F. Arndt, Frederick W. Danker. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1979), 210. 15 16 Ibid., 288-293. Ralph P. Martin, Ephesians, Colossians, and Philemon, Interpretation: A Biblical Commentary for Teaching and Preaching, ed. James Luther Mays (Louisville, KY: John Knox Press, 1991), 50. 17 7 return to the Father and his subsequent bestowal of gifts as he came back to earth in the form of the Spirit.18 Perkins believes the “form and content” of these verses limits His descending to the earth as in the incarnation.19 Taking issue with some translations he believes contribute to a misunderstanding he says ‘“The lower parts of the earth”’ (NRSV) and ‘“the lower earthly regions”’ (NIV) are suitably ambiguous translations.”20 I agree, believing the intention of the passage is limited to the incarnation. I find that the form of the story of Jesus about the rich man and Lazarus seems to limit movement in the realm of the dead. If that were true, what would Jesus do in preaching to the lost after death, other than torment them? The state of the dead is truly fixed. With the gifts come responsibility It is my conviction that the heart of the pericope is verses 11-12a. It is the working part of the passage. Verses 7-10 are foundational to show the empowerment that comes from an enthroned Christ. 18 Verses 12b-16 are more Martin, 50. Leander E. Keck, ed. (Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press, 2000), vol. XI, The New Interpreter’s Bible, by Perkins, Pheme, 421. 19 20 Ibid. 8 results oriented coming through the “equipping” process. Brooks and Winebery use verse 11 of our pericope as an example of an “Alternative Pronoun.21 The resulting construction based on this use of the article with “ue>n” and “de>” is “…some apostles…” and “…others…” Best argues, in what I believe to be the correct position, that the “apostles and prophets” in Ephesians can be shown to be a responsible role of service from the past with “the evangelist, shepherds and teachers” having a viable role for today.22 In verses 11-16, we are brought back to the discussion of gifts.23 This part of the pericope is a “single Greek sentence” which “links a list of teaching functions in the community (vv. 11-12) with the need for the church to grow to perfection (vv. 13-16).”24 This is not unusual in this letter when we consider the very long Greek sentence of James Brooks, Carlton L. Winbery., Syntax of New Testament Greek (Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1970), 77. 21 Ernest Best, Essays on Ephesians (Edinburgh, Scotland: T & T Clark Ltd., 1997), 162. He points here to the aorist “e`dwken” indicating the potential for a misunderstanding that some of these roles are not given as gifts today. See page 157-160 for a fuller discussion what he calls the “fulfilled ministries.” 22 Perkins, 420. He understands verses 8-10 to be an interruption of the thought process begun in verse 7. 23 24 Ibid., 422. 9 chapter one. David Gordon takes issue with some of the modern translations of verse 12 believing that they reduce “the function of ordained ministry to ‘“equipping”’ saints for service.”25 concerns. A clear issue for him is the “clergy/laity” He believes that “equipping” violates all other teachings in the New Testament “about the ministry of the word.” It is his conviction that the cultural spirit of our time is driving a movement that is undermining the authoritative ministry of the word. His reasoning does not seem as powerful as his emotional appeal to protect the honor due those trained as “clergy.” “clergyhood of believers.”26 He has a fear of the O’Neill agrees with him and argues for a position of authority of ministers over the people of the church.27 He foresees a shrinking church membership where the “official” ministers do not lead and serve.28 Sidney Page weighs in on the discussion noting that a source of the contentions is that we “…are so far David T. Gordon, ed., Equipping Ministry in Ephesians 4:12, vol. 37 (Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society, March 1994), 69. 25 26 Ibid., 78. J. C. O'Neill, "The Work of the Ministry' in Ephesians 4:12 and the New Testament," The Expository Times 14, no. 1 (January 1988), 337 27 28 Ibid., 340. 10 removed from the text.”29 His final solution is to appeal to Chrysostom as a source closer to the time of the writing. Truly, this is a legitimate process. Our distance from the text is an undeniable truth and it has its effect. But that is true for the entire quest for truth we attempt from scripture. Malcolm Warford coming from the Disciples of Christ tradition cautions, “When the church ministry beneath ordination, this ownership of the begins to subsume the nature of the categories of clerical indicates the church has taken church.30 His argument is that the church belongs to God and is not a domain to be claimed by those that minister. is to serve the body and thereby serve Jesus. The minister John Vooys’ article has a margin heading that reads, “This text is not a warrant for “incipient ecclesiasticism.”31 I agree with this position that the church should be in the business of every gifted person serving to strengthen those who are not Paige, Sidney H. T. "Whose Ministry? A Re-Appraisal of Eph 4:12." Novum Testamentum XLVII, no. 1: 26-43. 29 30 Warford, Malcolm L. "The Hope of Our Calling; Thinking About Ministry In The Context Of Ephesians 14:16." Lexington Theological Quarterly 37, no. 1-2 (SpringSummer 2002): 43-59. John Vooys, "No Clergy or Laity: All Christians Are Ministers in the Body of Christ Ephesians 4:11-13," Direction 20, no. 1 (Spring 1991), 87. 31 11 as well blessed. The term in verse 12 “katartismo>n” according to Bauer has some medical implications as in “setting of a bone.”32 The principle of the word is to move something from a weakened state to a position of strength.33 Brunner directs us to sanctification and holiness as a part of God’s work, the process being through “mutual enrichment and mutual service.”34 He advocates for every Christian having the “fullness of Christ” but he says: “…alongside of those who are already strong and as it were, advanced in faith, there are others who are weak and still beginners.”35 Stabilizing Results The “results” of the strong nurturing those weaker is a movement toward unity, maturity, stability, and spiritual growth. A failure in being prepared for “works of service” gives room for infantile and destructive behaviors as Bauer, 418. In his treatment of this word he identifies possible English translations as “preparation”, “restoration”, and “equipping.” 32 I I did on pastoral with the pg. 832 33 see a similarity between this concept and a study “sound doctrine” from the term “u|giai<nw” in the epistles. This term also has medical connotations idea of instruction for healthy living. See Bauer Emil Brunner, The Christian Doctrine of the Church, Faith, and the Consummation, trans. David Cairns and T. H. L. Parker (Zurich and Stuttgart: Zwingli-Verlag, 1960; reprint, Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1962), 290-292. 34 35 Ibid., 292. 12 indicated in verse 14. The effect of the gifted training those desiring to improve their skill and knowledge base brings truth flowing from a loving heart. The passage concludes with a picture of a healthy, growing, active body. Integration of these Principles into my Ministry Ministry naturally calls for recognition of our dependence on others. We are dependant on God, Jesus, and the Spirit for gifts of life and spirituality. Without the good gifts that enable us to grow spiritually we would be consigned to a perpetual poisoning of life where brother destroys brother. If I have a sense of spiritual maturity I need to acknowledge first that I have not arrived to a point where no more progress is possible. Wherever I am in my walk in the calling, I have not gotten here by myself. There have been hundreds in the body of Christ that have nurtured, encouraged, instructed, directed, and supported me along the path. If I understand this, I should recognize the need for returning the favor to Jesus, in part by using what I have for the “equipping” of others to step up to the calling. To be an “equipper”, is it essential that I be an expert in any one thing? I believe that we can help others 13 in tasks that are not necessarily our strength. As an example of this, I see Barnabas, the great encourager, bolstering Paul’s ability to be the great spokesperson to the gentiles. Not meaning to detract from Paul as an apostle, it is important to see that he did not function in a vacuum devoid of the strengthening presence of others. I see my roles as being an evangelist and a teacher. I am currently doing a substantial amount of work in “interim pulpit ministry.” Having years of ministry experience, with most of this being full-time, I am able to help congregations make the transition between preachers. A part of this is being the “non-anxious presence”36 in a turbulent time. It is important to help people heal even when the parting with the past minister has been on pleasant terms. transition. There is the need to prepare for After I have used a few weeks to establish a relationship with the congregation, I address this in a sermon titled “Passing the Baton” and follow up with a series of lessons about encouraging and supporting those in ministry and leadership. I make myself available but do not push their use of me in consultation as they go through their selection process. Norman Shawchuck, Roger Heuser., Managing the Congregation: Building Effective Systems to Serve People (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1996), 309. He offers a number of “Rules for Working in a Dysfunctional Organization.” 36 14 I am currently conducting meetings, holding leadership seminars, parenting workshops, retreats for ministry couples, and congregations. Among the gifting opportunities afforded me outside of my church experience has been training in facilitation, problem solving, and planning programs. I have been able to turn elements of these into my ministry of “equipping others” in practical and, I believe, spiritual ways. The primary ministry in which I am currently engaged is teaching college students in the Word and preparing some of them for ministry. The general education Bible courses are an opportunity to “equip” people for a lifetime of Bible learning. If we are able to bring them to an understanding and joy from the stories and structure of the text, they will be better prepared to grow. I believe the goal is a changed spirit that seeks and speaks truth, and is truly transformed by divine love and grace. These people have the potential to be the saints that bring the ground for unity, maturity and growth to unstable situations. In the classes with those headed into various forms of recognized ministry, it is possible for the voice of experience to help students process fears and evaluate their concepts of ministry. They need to know that there 15 are bumps in the road but that they are survivable. Pointing to verse 12 of our text, Ferguson makes the point, “The purpose of ministry is Body building.”37 Regardless of the position we take concerning the text being directed toward equipping of only ministers or everyone, those going into ministry must first be prepared to minister. It is my conviction that the passage under consideration is God exalting the Christ to give credibility and authority to the “gifts” he gives.38 This allows us to nurture others so that they in turn may teach and nurture others. This is consistent with what Paul says to Timothy, “And the things you have heard me say in the presence of many witnesses entrust to reliable men who will also be qualified to teach others.” (2 Tim. 2:2) On occasion when in consultation with a church leadership concerning their work, I have had someone turn to me and say, “You are just not going to let us get away from this equipping thing are you?” is no. The answer If we expect members to effectively do the task of ministry in all its forms, from bathing the sick to Everett Ferguson, The Church of Christ: A Biblical Ecclesiology for Today (Grand Rapids MI: William B. Eerdmans, 1996), 98. 37 See the appendix for a look at my philosophy of ministry. This is an essay that I have written and use as a handout in my “Introduction to Ministry Class” at Ohio Valley University. I also use it in spiritual leadership and ministers’ retreats. I chose not to put the material directly in the paper because I consider it a stand-alone 38 16 ministering in the Word, church leaders must send them forth equipped. demands it. document. The well-being of the Body of Christ BIBLIOGRAPHY Barth, Karl. Church Dogmatics: Index with Aids for the Preacher. Edited by Very Rev. Prof. T. F. Torrance Rev. Prof. G. W. Bromiley. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark LTD, 1977. Bauer, Walter. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. 2d ed. Edited by F. Wilbur Gingrich William F. Arndt, Frederick W. Danker. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1979. Brooks, James, Carlton L. Winbery. Syntax of New Testament Greek. Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1970. Brunner, Emil. The Christian Doctrine of the Church, Faith, and the Consummation. Translated by David Cairns and T. H. L. Parker. Zurich and Stuttgart: Zwingli-Verlag, 1960; reprint, Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1962. Carson, D. A. New Testament Commentary Survey. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2001. Carson, D. A., Douglas J. Moo, Leon Morris. An Introduction to the New Testament. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1992. Ernest Best. Essays on Ephesians. Edinburgh, Scotland: T & T Clark Ltd., 1997. Ferguson, Everett. The Church of Christ: A Biblical Ecclesiology for Today. Grand Rapids MI: William B. Eerdmans, 1996. Gordon, David T., ed. Equipping Ministry in Ephesians 4:12 Vol. 37: Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society, March 1994. 17 18 The Greek New Testament. 4th rev. ed. Edited by Barbara Aland, Kurt Aland, Johannes Karvaidopoulos, Carlo M. Martini, Bruce Metzger. London: United Bible Societies, 1993. Gundry, Robert H. A Survey of the New Testament. 4th ed. Zondervan, 1970; reprint, Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2003. Guthrie, Donald. New Testament Introduction. 4th ed. Leicester, England: Apollos, 1961; reprint, Downers Grove, IL: Intervarsity Press, 1990. The Holy Bible; New International Version. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1978. Leander E. Keck, ed. Vol. XI, The New Interpreter’s Bible, by Pheme Perkins. Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press, 2000. Martin, Ralph P. Ephesians, Colossians, and Philemon. Interpretation: A Biblical Commentary for Teaching and Preaching. Edited by James Luther Mays. Louisville, KY: John Knox Press, 1991. O'Brien, Peter T. The Letter to the Ephesians. Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 1999. O'Neill, J. C. "The Work of the Ministry' in Ephesians 4:12 and the New Testament." The Expository Times 14, no. 1 (January 1988): 42-49. Paige, Sidney H. T. "Whose Ministry? A Re-Appraisal of Eph 4:12." Novum Testamentum XLVII, no. 1: 26-43. Shawchuck, Norman, Roger Heuser. Managing the Congregation: Building Effective Systems to Serve People. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1996. Vooys, John. "No Clergy or Laity: All Christians Are Ministers in the Body of Christ Ephesians 4:11-13." Direction 20, no. 1 (Spring 1991): 88-95. Warford, Malcolm L. "The Hope of Our Calling; Thinking About Ministry In The Context Of Ephesians 1-4:16." Lexington Theological Quarterly 37, no. 1-2 (SpringSummer 2002): 43-59. Appendix 19 CALLED TO SERVE or "Using Our Talents to Form a Better, Stronger Body for Christ." An Essay By G. K. Pennington . 20 21 A Calling for Everyone There is arrogance in the attitude that one person has been called over another for ministry and service. It is clear that not all are called to do the same things but the calling is for everyone. The difficult thing is to recognize our abilities and start by leading from the God-given strengths each of us have. Have you heard the calling? Often, the first hurdle is to realize that we have a uniform calling in Christ; it is a calling to the grace of God that leads us to eternal life. The writer of Hebrews encourages us with these words, "Therefore, brothers and sisters, holy partners in a heavenly calling ..." (Heb 3:1)39 The purpose for this verse is to teach us from where our strength of service is derived. We are encouraged to keep our eyes on Jesus because everything else fails to supply our needs and the strength to succeed. His model was one of service. "... But I am among you as one who serves." (Luke 22:27) As the saying goes, “The ground is level at the foot of the cross,” concerning our needs and talents. So it is with ministry. It is required, however that the minister be willing to minister. To What Am I Called? It is a calling to serve, service first of all to God. The apostle Paul had a calling to serve God. He says, "For God, whom I serve with my spirit by announcing the gospel of his Son..." (Rom 1:9) Even in his resistance to the gospel, he was committed to serving God. He calls us through his writings to imitate his example and fulfill our commitment as Christians to be focused in our single-minded dedication as well. Israel had struggled with a proper paradigm of life before God. It was there in the narrative and prophecy of their history. The prophet Micah offered a summary saying, "...What does the LORD require of you but to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God?" (Micah 6:8) In Jesus’ day, as in ours, those insisting they were the people of God often overlooked this pattern of godly living. 39All biblical references in this paper are from The Holy Bible, New Revised Standard Version (IA: Iowa Falls: World Bible Publishers, 1989). 22 Secondly, we are called to serve people. Effective ministry can begin when we understand that the best way to serve God is in the serving of people. The model we have from Jesus is to lose ourselves in the service of others. Jesus came to die for people. It is people with whom God longs to have a relationship and covenant. Jesus healed, taught, loved, bathed, served, smelled, and cared for people. In Christian ministry, some serve in overt ways that are visible but some ministry is invisible to “inquiring minds.” Its effect is often unwitnessed even by the minister. It is enough for the faithful servant to know that God and probably the person served know. The goals of ministry often seem beyond our reach! Called to Lead Now and in the Future. She was critical, sour, and feeling unloved, often telling the deeds of the past. Years ago there was great sacrifice and much teaching. Lives were changed. Now lives were being changed but not for the good. The fabric of community split around her like rotting cloth. The problem was that her claim to ministry was in the past. The present was used to remember the past and identify her needs that were not being adequately met. Locked in the past there was no growth, no service, only spiritual disintegration under the banner of “What I did for this church in the past.” We are called to serve now and if God allows, in the future. The past is like leftover manna; if we hoard it, it decays and smells up everything it touches. Paul as a minister had a glorious past but his focus was in the present and the future. He said, “Forgetting what lies behind...I press on toward the goal.” (Phil. 3:13-14) . The chal leng e is to po int th e wa Part of staying active in ministry is to look aggressively for ways to be used. It is imperative that we grow in our sensitivity to the needs of others so we will not miss opportunities to be active. Those who find it easiest to stay active in serving are those who are truly motivated to do it. y!! 23 Called to Grow in Service It is not enough to say I’ll go. The wisdom of God tells us if we are to serve we also must say, “I’ll grow.” “If you indeed cry out for insight, and raise your voice for understanding; if you seek it like silver, and search for it as for hidden treasures-- then you will understand the fear of the LORD and find the knowledge of God.” (Prov. 2:3-5) Seekers of “insight and “understanding” are promised that they will find. The call to be the person of God does not make us that person. We must grow actively into that person, understanding the process is like filling a leaky bucket. When you stop growing you start becoming dry. Called to Lead from the Foot of the Table Most who are called to lead spiritually are not those who sit at the head of the table. They serve in unobtrusive ways helping to meet the needs of others. Often no title or sense of authority accompanies them except the authority of Christ to love each other. It is in the serving that spiritual leaders serve and minister best to Jesus. (Mat. 25:34-40) I am called to serve, where I am, when I am, with what I have, empowered by God to walk with Him and care for what He cares for most- people. God’s work of ministry is a thing of beauty!!