UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Suspense Accounts and the Correction of Errors Lecture Notes Errors generally occur because of incorrect posting to the general ledger accounts. They are classified into two categories based on how they affect the Trial Balance agreement, that is: 1. Errors Affecting the Trial Balance Agreement 2. Errors Not Affecting the Trial Balance Agreement Trial Balance – A tool used to test the arithmetic accuracy of entries posted to the General Ledger. Errors Affecting the Trial Balance Agreement These errors mean that the total of the debit columns in the Trial Balance will not be the same as the total of the credit columns. This is so because such error breaks the rule of double entry. For instance, suppose we have made only one error in our books. We received cash $103 on May 1, 2005 from H Singh and we enter it as: Cash Book 2005 May 1 Cash $ H Singh Bank $ 103 Sales Ledger H Singh 2005 May 1 Cash $ 13 We have put $103 on the debit side of our books, and $13 on the credit side. When we draw up the trial balance its totals will be different by $90; i.e. $103 - $13 = $90. Some errors that will lead to the Trial Balance not being equal include 1. Errors in extraction of the Trial Balance 2. Errors of Casting - Incorrect additions in any account 3. Errors of Transposition 4. Errors of Omission - Making an entry on only one side of the accounts e.g. a debit but no credit 5. Errors of Commission 6. Entering a different amount on the debit side from the amount on the credit side LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Errors of Transposition An error of Transposition is when two digits in an amount are accidentally recorded the wrong way round. For example, suppose that a sale is recorded in the sales account as $6,843, but it has been incorrectly recorded in the total receivables account as $6,483. The error is the transposition of the 4 and the 8. The consequence is that the total debits will not be equal to total credits. You can often detect a transposition error by checking whether the difference between debits and credits can be divided exactly by 9. For example, $6,843 - $6,483 = $360; $360 ÷ 9 = 40. Errors of Omission An error of omission that affects the Trial Balance Agreement means making a debit or credit entry, but not the corresponding double entry. Suppose a business receives an invoice from a supplier for $300, and the trade payables account was credited, but the debit entry was omitted from the purchases account. In this case, the total credits would not equal the total debits, because the total debits are $300 less than they ought to be. Errors of Commission This is where an entry is made two times on one side of the account. For example two debit entries or two credit entries. This will cause the Trial Balance not to agree since there will either excess debits or excess credits. Suspense Account A suspense account is a temporary account which can be opened for a number of reasons. The most common reasons are: 1. When the trial balance totals does not agree, it is made to agree by inserting the amount of the difference between the two sides in a Suspense Account. A suspense account is opened in the general ledger and the difference is recorded on the relevant side. See Example below: H Mohamed and Sons Trial Balance as on December 31, 2005 ____________________________________________________________________________________ Dr. $ 200,500 Totals after all the accounts have been listed Suspense Account 200,500 Credit $ 200,410 90 200,500 Suspense Account 2005 Dec 31 Difference per Trial Balance LECTURE NOTES $ 90 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART 2. The bookkeeper of a business knows where to post one side (e.g. Credit Side) of a transaction, but does not know where to post the other side (e.g. Debit Side). For example, a cash payment might be made and must obviously be credited to cash. But the bookkeeper may not know that the payment is for, and so will not know which account to debit. Suspense Account and Statement of Financial Position If the errors are not found before the final accounts are prepared, the suspense account balance will be included in the Statement of Financial Position. If the balance is a credit balance it should be included on the Capital and Liabilities side. When the balance is a debit balance, it should be shown on the Assets side of the Statement. Correction of Errors The error whenever found after a suspense account has been opened must be corrected by using double entry. For these entries: 1. One entry must be in the suspense account 2. One entry must be in the account where the error was made For example if the credit of $90 was an under casting of sales the journal entry to correct it is as follows: The Journal Suspense Sales Being correction of Sales account that was understated Debit 90 Credit 90 For all errors: 1. The double entry must be carried out, being a debit entry and a credit entry; 2. A journal entry must be made; otherwise, afterwards, it may not be possible to understand why the entries were made in the double entry records. You are required to open the Suspense Account to record the difference and make the relevant Journal entry to correct each of the following: Practice 1 – The bookkeeper of Mixem Gladly Co. made a transposition error when entering an amount for sales in the sales account. Instead of entering the correct amount of $37,453 he entered $37,543. Practice 2 – When Guttersnipe paid the monthly salary to its office staff, the payment of $5,250 was correctly entered in the cash account, but the bookkeeper omitted to debit the office salaries account. Practice 3 – A credit customer pays $460 of the $660 he owes to Ashdown Tree Felling Contractors, but Ashdown’s bookkeeper debits $460 on the receivables account in the nominal ledger by mistake instead of crediting the payment received. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Suspense Accounts might contain several items If more than one error or unidentifiable posting to a ledger account arise during an accounting period, they will all be merged together in the same suspense account. Until the causes of the errors are discovered, the bookkeepers are unlikely to know exactly how many errors there are. As all errors are discovered and corrected the Suspense Account should be reduced to NIL balance. Suspense Accounts are Temporary A Suspense Account can only be temporary. Postings to a Suspense Account are only made when the bookkeeper doesn’t know yet what to do, or when an error has occurred. Mysteries must be solved, and errors must be corrected. Under no circumstances should there still be a suspense account when it comes to preparing the Statement of Financial Position of a business. The suspense account must be cleared and all the correcting entries made before the final accounts are drawn up. EXAMPLE A trial balance is extracted from the books of I Legge, a fruits wholesaler at December 31, 2003 $ Capital January 1, 2003 Sales Purchases Inventory January 1, 2003 Overheads Debtors Creditors Fixed Assets at Cost Depreciation Drawings Bank $ 41,200 132,380 66,410 4,300 19,204 8,760 12,244 30,000 11,000 9,100 63,240 201,014 ______ 196,824 Clearly the Trial Balance does not balance and there is a difference of $4,190. To make it balance the suspense account can be opened, thus: Suspense Account 2003 $ Dec 31 Difference per Trial Balance 4,190 On inspection and investigation of his records the difference in the trial balance was found to be because of the following errors: 1. A credit sale to Lemon of $264 was entered in the books as $246. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART 2. A purchase from Pear of $320 was entered on Pear’s account but omitted from the purchases account. 3. A receipt from Apple of $3,000 being a bad debt recovered was entered in the cash book but not credited to any account. 4. A drawing of $200 was debited to drawings account as $2,000 5. A credit note to Nutt of $136 was omitted from the books altogether. 6. An invoice for $290 from G Plum was credited in error to both G Plum and H Plum. ANSWER THE JOURNAL Date Debit $ Details Credit $ Trade Receivable (Lemon) (1) 18 Sales 18 Being correction of debtor account understated Purchases 320 Suspense (2) 320 Being recording credit purchase deleted from the purchases account (3) Suspense Trade Receivable 3,000 3,000 Being recording of Bad debts recovered but not credited to the Debtors (4) Suspense Drawings 1,800 1,800 Being corrections of drawings account overstated (5) Sales Returns Trade Receivable (Nutt) 136 136 Being correction of transaction deleted from the books H Plum (6) 290 Suspense 290 Being correction of credit note entered in error to creditor LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART HOME ASSIGNMENT: Draw up Ledger accounts for journal entries above and reconstruct Trial Balance The Effect of Errors on Profits If an error affects items only in the Statement of Financial Position, then the original calculated profit will not need altering. However, if the error is one of the figures shown in the Income Statement, then the original profit will need altering. EXAMPLE 2 At the year end of T Down & Co. an imbalance in the Trial Balance was revealed which resulted in the creation of a suspense account with a credit balance of $1,040. Investigations revealed the following errors. 1. A sale of goods on credit for $1,000 had been omitted from the sales account. 2. Delivery and installation costs of $240 on a new plant had been recorded as a revenue expense. 3. Cash discount of $150 on paying a supplier, JW, had been taken, even though the payment was made outside the time limit. 4. Inventory of stationery at the end of the period of $240 had been ignored. 5. A purchase of raw materials of $350 had been recorded in the purchases account as $850. 6. The purchase returns day book included a sales credit note for $230 which had been entered correctly in the account of the customer concerned, but included with purchase returns in the nominal ledger. Required: (a) Prepare journal entries to correct each of the above errors. Narratives are not required. (b) Open a suspense account and show the corrections to be made. (c) Prior to the discovery of the errors, T Down and Co’s gross profit for the year was calculated at $35,750 and the Net Profit for the year at $18,500. ANSWER The Journal Date (1) (2) (3) Debit $ Details Suspense a/c Credit $ 1,000 Sales 1,000 Plant 240 Delivery Cost 240 Cash discount received 150 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART JW a/c 150 (4) Inventory of Stationery Stationery Expense 240 (5) Suspense a/c Purchases 500 Purchases returns 230 Sales Returns Suspense a/c 230 (6) 240 500 460 (b) Suspense Account (1) (4) Sales Purchases $ 1,000 500 (6) 1,500 End of year balance Purchases returns/sales returns (c) $ Gross profit originally reported Sales omitted Plant costs wrongly allocated Incorrect recording of purchases Sales credit note wrongly allocated Adjusted gross profit 35,750 1,000 240 500 (460) 37,030 Net profit originally reported Adjustments to gross profit $(37,030 – 35,750) Cash discounts incorrectly taken Stationery inventory Adjusted net profit 18,500 1,280 (150) 240 19,870 LECTURE NOTES $ 1,040 460 1,500 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Errors Not Affecting the Trial Balance These errors result in the same amount of debits being entered as there are credits or in no entry being made on either the debit or credit side. This means that, if the trial balance had balanced before the error, then it would have also balanced after the error. The Journal The correction of all errors should be done via the General Journal before posting to the relevant Ledger Accounts. However, the journal is the only tool used to correct errors that does not affect the Trial Balance. Otherwise a suspense account has to be opened first, and later cleared to a journal entry. In fact, the journal entries should be made before completing the double entry accounts for the transaction. The journal requires a debit and equal credit entry for each ‘transaction’, i.e. for each correction. This means that if the total debits equal total credits before a journal is made then they will still be equal after the journal entry is made. Similarly, if total debits and total credits are unequal before a journal entry is made, then they will still be unequal (by the same amount) after it is made. Errors of Commission This is where the correct amounts are entered, but in the wrong person’s account or where a debit or credit entry is entered in the wrong account. These usually occur where the bookkeeper makes a mistake in carrying out his or her task in recording transactions in the accounts Example: T Long paid us a cheque of $50 on May 18, 2005. It is correctly entered in the cash book, but it is entered by mistake in the account for T. Lee. This means that there has been both a debit of $50 and a credit of $50. It has appeared in the personal account as: T. Lee 2005 May 18 Bank $ 50 The error was found on May 31, 2005. We will now have to correct this. This needs two entries: 1. A debit of $50 in the account of T. Lee to cancel out the error on the credit side in that account; 2. A credit of $50 in the account of T. Long – this is where it should have been entered originally. The account will now appear as follows: T. Lee 2005 $ 2005 $ May 31 T. Long: error corrected (1) 50 May 18 Bank 50 2005 May 1 Balance b/d T. Long $ 2005 50 May 31 T. Lee: error corrected (2) LECTURE NOTES $ 50 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The Journal 2005 May 31 T. Lee Debit 50 Credit T. Long 50 Cash received . . . entered in wrong personal account, now corrected Putting a debit or a credit entry in the wrong account – If telephone expenses of $540 are debited to the electricity account, an error of commission would have occurred. The result is that although total debits and credits balance, telephone expenses are understated by $540 and electricity expenses are overstated by the same amount. Errors of Principle This is where an item is entered in the wrong type of account. An error of principle involves making a double entry in the belief that the transaction is being entered in the correct accounts, but subsequently finding out that the accounting entry breaks the ‘rules’ of an accounting principle or concept. For instance, the purchase of a non-current asset or fixed asset (Capital Expenditure) should be debited to a non-current asset or fixed asset account. If in error it is debited to a motor expense account (Revenue Expenditure), then it has been entered in the wrong type of account. E.g. The purchase of a motor lorry $5,500 by cheque on May 14, 2005 has been debited in error to the motor expenses account. In the cash book it is shown correctly. This means that there has been both a debit $5,500 and a credit of $5,500. This will appear in the expense account as: 2005 May 14 Bank Motor Expenses $ 5,500 The error is found on May 31, 2005. We will now correct it. Two entries are needed: 1. A debit in the motor lorry account of $5,500 to put it where it should have been entered; 2. A credit of $5,500 in the motor expenses account to cancel the error. The accounts will now appear as follows. 2005 May 31 Motor Expenses (1) Motor Lorry $ 5,500 2005 May 14 Bank Motor Expenses $ 2005 $ 5,500 May 31 Motor Lorry: error corrected (2) 5,500 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The Journal 2005 May 31 Motor Lorry Motor Expenses Correction of error whereby purchase of motor Lorry was debited to motor expenses account. Debit 5,500 Credit 5,500 Similarly, suppose that the proprietor of the business sometimes takes cash out of the till for his own personal use and during a certain year these withdrawals on account of profit amount to $280. The bookkeeper states that he reduced the cash sales by $280 so that the cash book could be made to balance. This would be an error of principle, and the result of it would be that the withdrawal account is understated by$280, and so is the total value of sales in the sales account. Errors of Original Entry These occur where the original amount is incorrect. For instance, if a cash sale of $150 to T. Marley on May 13, 2005 had been entered as both a debit and a credit as $130. The account will appear: Cash 2005 May 13 Sales $ 130 Sales 2005 May 13 Cash $ 130 When the error is found on May 31, 2005 the entries needed to correct it are: Cash 2005 $ May 13 Sales 130 May 31 Sales: error correct 20 Sales 2005 May 13 Cash May 31 Cash: error corrected $ 130 20 The Journal 2005 May 31 Debit 20? Cash Credit Sales Account 20 Correction of error: sales of $150 had been incorrectly entered as $130. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART In addition, let’s suppose total daily credit sales in the sales day book should be $28,425, but are incorrectly added up as 28,825. The total sales in the sales day are then used to credit total sales and debit total receivables in the ledger accounts. Although total debits are still equal, they are incorrect by $400. Errors of Omission These errors are where transactions are not entered into the books or failing to record a transaction at all. For instance, if we purchased goods from C. Richards for $250 but did not enter it in the accounts there would be nil debits and nil credits. When we find the error on May 31, 2005 the entries to record it will be: 2005 May 31 C. Richards: error corrected Purchases $ 250 C. Richards 2005 May 31 Purchases: error corrected $ 250 The Journal 2005 May 31 Purchases C. Richards Correction of error: purchases omitted from books Debit 250 Credit 250 Compensating Errors These are errors that cancel out each other, that is the under or overstating of a debit and credit balance account by the same amount. They are errors which are coincidentally, equal and opposite of one another. Let us take a case where the sales journal is added up to be $100 too much. In the same period the purchases journal is also added up to be $100 too much. If these were the only errors in our books, the trial balance totals would equal each other. Both totals would be wrong – they would both be $100 too much – but they would be equal. If in fact the incorrect totals had purchases $7,900 and sales $ 9,900, the accounts would have appeared as: Sales 2005 $ May 31 Sales Journal 9,900 Purchases 2005 $ May 31 Purchases Journal 7,900 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART When corrected, the accounts will be: 2005 May 31 the Journal: error corrected Sales $ 2005 100 May 31 Sales Journal $ 9,900 2005 May 31 Purchases Journal Purchases $ 2005 7,900 May 31 the Journal: error corrected $ 100 The journal entries to correct these two errors will be: The Journal 2005 May 31 Sales account Purchases Correction of compensating error: totals of both Purchases and sales journals incorrectly added up $100 too much Debit 100 Credit 100 Complete Reversal of Entries The correct amounts are entered in the correct accounts, but each item is shown on the wrong side of each account. There has been both a debit and credit entry of equal amounts. For instance, a cheque for $200 paid to D Charles was debited in the cash book and credited in D Charles account. 2005 May 28 D Charles 2005 Cash $ Cash Book (A) Bank $ 2005 200 D. Charles (A) $ 2005 May 28 Bank This is incorrect. It should have been as follows: 1. Debit: D Charles $200 2. Credit: Bank $200 LECTURE NOTES Cash $ Bank $ $ 200 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Both items have been entered in the correct accounts, but each on the wrong side of its account. Correction of such an error is more difficult to understand than other errors. Let us look at how the items would have appeared if we had done it correctly in the first place. We will show the letter (B) behind the account names: Cash Book Cash Bank Cash Bank 2005 $ $ 2005 $ $ May 28 D Charles 200 2005 May 28 Bank D. Charles $ 2005 200 $ When we found the error on May 31, by using double entry we have to make the amounts shown to cancel the error be twice the amount the error. This is because we need to do the following: 1. We have to cancel the error; this means entering the following amounts Debit: D Charles $200 Credit: Bank $200 2. We have to now correctly enter the transaction Debit: D Charles $200 Credit: Bank $200 All together, then, the entries to correct the error are twice the amounts first entered. When corrected the accounts appear as follows, marked (C): Cash Book Cash Bank Cash Bank 2005 $ $ 2005 $ $ May 28 D. Charles 200 May 31 D Charles: error corrected 400 2005 May 31 Bank: error corrected D. Charles $ 2005 400 May 28 Bank LECTURE NOTES $ 200 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART You can see that accounts (C) give the same final answer as accounts (B): $ (B) Debit: D. Charles Credit: Bank (C) Debit: D. Charles (400 – 200) Credit: Bank (400 – 200) $ 200 200 200 200 The Journal 2005 May 31 D. Charles Bank Payment of $200 on May 28, 2005 to D. Charles incorrectly credited to his account, and debited to bank: error now corrected. Debit 400 Credit 400 Casting You will often notice the use of the expression ‘to cast’, which means to add up. Overcastting means incorrectly adding up a column of figures to give an answer that is greater that it should be; under casting means incorrectly adding up a column of figures to give an answer than is less than it should be. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Suspense Accounts and the Correction of Errors Worksheet1 QUESTION 1 The trial balance of Dick and Doris at 31.12.04 showed: Dick Dr Capital 1.1.04 Inventory 1.1.04 Purchases and sales Expenses Drawings Receivables and Payables Fixed Assets at Cost Depreciation to 31.12.04 Bank 2,567 15,908 6,200 5,700 3,400 12,700 Doris Cr 12,608 28,981 2,300 Dr 3,510 40,700 17,500 10,322 15,680 10,438 6,230 4,006 Cr 23,876 70,432 5,600 3,428 4,810 For Dick, the following errors were found: a) b) c) d) Drawings of $200 were debited in error to expense. Purchased goods $36 from Fred, a supplier, and debited to his account. The sum due from Alf was omitted from the trial balance - $80. Drawings by Dick of inventory valued at $45 were made in June 2004 and not recorded in the books. e) A payment of casual wages $80 was entered in the cash book but the double entry was not completed. f) Non Current Assets purchases of $380 were entered as $830 in the Non Current Assets Account. For Doris, the following errors were found: a) The account of Joshua, a customer was extracted in error as $354 instead of $454. b) A payment for advertising $190 was credited in the expenses account. c) An invoice for goods purchased for resale from Wally $278 was omitted from the books altogether. d) The sales invoice to Hodge was correctly entered in the sales day book as $560 but entered in the Hodge’s account as $650. e) The payment of an advertising account to Noos Ltd $50 was debited in the expenses account and also in Noos Ltd account. The Original invoice was correctly entered in Noos Ltd account. f) The balance of Geoff’s account was entered as $320 Debit In fact the two sided of his account totaled DR $890 CR $534. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Required for each business: a) Compute the difference of the trial balance (suspense account). b) Identify and correct the errors. c) Produce an amended trial balance and show that it now balances. Question 2 The following errors in the books of J. Holt have been found. a) Equipment bought $2,500 by cheque has been debited to general expenses account. b) $149 received from E. Grey has been correctly entered in the cash book but debited to Grey’s account. c) Goods sold $973 to J. Crook have been entered in error as $937. d) A discount allowed to P. Paul of $44 has been debited to the discounts allowed account as $144. e) $135 goods bought from D.D. Ltd have been credited to B.B Ltd. From the above you are to: State how each error affects the agreement of the trial balance totals; 1) State which errors will affect net profits, and how. 2) State which errors will affect gross profits, and how. 3) State which of the above is: a) An error of principle? b) An error of commission? c) An error of original entry? f) Show the journal entries needed to correct each error – narratives are required. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Question 3 The following is a trial balance, which has been incorrectly drawn up. Trial Balance as at 31 January 2009 Capital 1 February 2008 Drawings Inventory 1 February 2008 Trade Receivables Furniture and fittings Cash in hand Trade Payables Sales Sales Returns Discount received Business expenses Purchases $ 5,500 2,800 $ 2,597 2,130 1,750 1,020 2,735 7,430 85 46 950 4,380 16,446 14,977 In addition to the mistakes evident above, the following errors were also discovered. a) A payment of $75 made to a creditor had not been posted from the cash book into the payables ledger. b) A cheque for $56 received from a customer had been correctly entered in the cash book but posted to the customer’s account as $50. c) A purchase of fittings $120 had been included in the purchases account. d) The total of the discounts allowed column in the cash book of $38 had not been posted into the nominal ledger. e) A page of the sales day book was correctly totaled as $564 but carries forward as $456. Show the trial balance as it would appear after all the errors had been corrected. You are required to show all working. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Control Account Lecture Notes A Control Account is an account that checks the arithmetic accuracy of the Nominal Ledger. It is a composition of different ledger account balances. Control accounts are used chiefly for trade receivables and payables: A Receivable Control Account is an account in which records are kept of transactions involving all receivables in total. The balance on the receivables control account at any time will be the total amount due to the business at that time from its receivables. A Payables Control Account is an account in which records are kept of transactions involving all payables in total, and the balance on this account at any time will be the total amount owed by the business at that time to its payables. Other Control Accounts Although control accounts are used mainly in accounting for receivables and payables, they can also be kept for other items, such as inventories, wages and salaries, and cash. The most important idea to remember, however, is that a control account is an account which keeps a total record for a collective item (e.g. receivables), which in reality consists of many individual items (e.g. individual trade accounts receivable). Control Accounts and Personal Accounts The personal accounts of individual customers of the business are kept in the receivables ledger, and the amount owed by each receivable will be a balance on his personal account. The amount owed by all the receivables together (i.e. all the trade account receivables) will be a balance on the receivables control account. At any time the balance on the receivables control account should be equal to the sum of the individual balances on the personal accounts in the receivables ledger. A control account is however an (impersonal) ledger account which will appear in the nominal ledger. Control Accounts; another form of Trial Balance A trial balance is usually drawn up to test the arithmetical accuracy of the accounts, but there are certain errors that are not revealed by such a trial balance. If the trial balance totals disagreed, for a small business the books could be easily and quickly checked so as to find the errors. However, when the firm has grown and the accounting work has been divided up so that there are several or many ledgers. Any errors could be very difficult to find. We would have to check every item in every ledger. What is required is a type of trial balance for each ledger, and this requirement is met by the Control LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Account. This ensures that it is only the ledgers whose control accounts do not balance that need detailed checking to find errors. The Principle of Control Accounts The principle on which control accounts is based is as follows: If the opening balance of an account is known, together with the information of the additions and deductions entered in the account, the closing balance can be calculated. Example Receivables Ledger 2002 May 1 May 4 May 30 2002 May 1 May 28 2002 May 1 May 15 2002 May 1 Balance b/d Sales Sales Balance b/d Sales Balance b/d Sales Balance b/d T. Sangster $ 2002 850 May 7 900 May 7 350 May 31 2,100 P. Mayall $ 2002 1,500 May 9 400 May 14 May 14 May 31 1,900 K. Wingfield $ 2002 750 May 20 600 May 31 1,350 C. Shenton $ 2002 450 May 28 450 LECTURE NOTES Bank Discount Allowed Balance c/d $ 820 30 1,250 2,100 Sales Returns Bank Discount Allowed Balance c/d $ 200 900 20 780 1,900 Sales Returns Balance c/d $ 110 1,240 1,350 Bad Debts $ 450 450 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART A control account, in this case a Receivables Control Account, would consist only of the totals of each of the items in the receivables ledger: May 1 Balance b/d: $850 + $1,500 + $750 + $450 = $3,550 Sales in May: $900 + $350 + $400 + $600 = $2,250 Cheques received in May: $820 + $900 = $1,720 Discounts allowed in May: $30 + $20 = $50 Sales Returns in May: $200 + $110 = $310 Bad Debts written off in May: $450 Now looking at the totals it is possible to draw up a receivables control account. Debits are shown as usual on the left-hand side, and credits on the right-hand side. Receivables Control Account 2002 $ 2002 $ May 1 Balance b/d 3,550 May 31 Sales Returns 310 May 31 Sales for the Month 2,250 May 31 Bank 1,720 May 31 Discount Allowed 50 May 31 Bad debts 310 May 31 Balance c/d 3,270 5,800 5,800 When the balance c/d of the receivables control account ($3,270) is matched with the sum of the balance c/d in the receivables ledger ($1,250 + $780 + $1,240 = $3,270), it proves that the entries made in the receivables ledger are correct. The Purpose of Control Accounts 1. The main purpose of a control account is to act as a check on the accuracy of the entries made in the receivables ledger and payables ledger. The total of a list of all the balances extracted from the ledger should equal the balance on the control account. If not, a mistake, or even many mistakes, may have been made and will have to be found. 2. The control accounts also assist in the location of errors, where postings to the control accounts are made daily or weekly or even monthly. It would be a formidable task to locate errors at the end of a year, say, given the number of transactions. By using the control account, a comparison with the individual balances in the receivables and payables ledger can be made for every week or day of the month, and the error found much more quickly than if control accounts did not exist. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART 3. Where there is a separation of clerical (bookkeeping) duties, the control account provides an internal check. The person posting entries to the control accounts will act as a check on a different person (s) whose job it is to post to the receivables and payables ledger accounts. 4. To provide total receivables and payables balances more quickly for producing a trial balance or Statement of Financial Position. A single balance on a control account is obviously extracted more simply and quickly than many individual balances in the receivables or payables ledger. This means also that the number of accounts in the double entry bookkeeping system can be to a manageable size, since the personal accounts are memorandum accounts only. The Agreement of the Control Account and the Ledgers The control accounts should be balanced regularly (at least monthly), and the balance on the account agreed with the sum of the individual debtors or suppliers balances extracted from the receivables or payables ledgers respectively. If the balances do not agree it maybe because of one or more of the following reasons: 1. An incorrect amount may be posted to the control account because of a miscast of the total in the books of original entry (i.e. adding up incorrectly the total value of invoices or payments). The nominal ledger debit and credit postings will then balance, but the control account balance will not agree with the sum of individual balances extracted from the (memorandum) receivables ledger or payables ledger. A journal entry must then be made in the nominal ledger to correct the control account and the corresponding sales or expense account. 2. A transposition error may occur in posting an individual’s balance from the books of prime entry to memorandum ledger, e.g. a sale to C Cloning of $250 might be posted to his account as $520. The sum of the balances extracted from the memorandum must be corrected. No accounting entry would be required to do this, except to alter the figure in C Cloning’s account. 3. A transaction may be recorded in the control account and not in the memorandum ledger, or vice versa. This requires an entry in the ledger that has been missed out which means a double posting if the control account has to be corrected, and a single posting if it is the individual’s balance in the memorandum that is at fault. 4. The sum of balances extracted from the memorandum ledger may be incorrectly extracted or miscast. This would involve simply correcting the total of the balances. It should be noted that The Personal Accounts in the receivables ledger are memorandum accounts, because they are not a part of the double entry system. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Control Account Flow Chart of Receivables B = $150 B = $200 Cheques received A = $120 Invoices A = $100 Sales Day Book $ A 100 B 200 Total 300 Receivables Ledger [Personal Accounts] A B 100 120 200 150 =$20 Cr = $50 Dr Overall Balance * = $30 Dr Sales Account Receivables Account [Control A/c) $ Dr Total Sales 300 Dr Total Cash 270 Balance * 30 Dr Cr Total Sales $300 LECTURE NOTES Cash Book $ A 120 B 150 Total $ 270 Cash Account Cr Total Cash $270 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Information for Control Accounts Information is found in the following places to draw up the control accounts Receivables Control Account Source 1. Opening Trade Receivables List of individual receivables balances drawn up at the end of previous period. Opening Trade Receivables in the Statement of Financial Position. 2. Credit Sales Total from Sales Day Book 3. Sales Returns Total from Sales Returns Day Book 4. Cheques Received Cash book: cash column on received side. List extracted or total of a special column which has been included in the cash book. 5. Cash Received Cash book: cash column on received side. List extracted or total of a special column which has been included in the cash book. 6. Closing Trade Receivables List of individuals receivables balances drawn up at end of the current period. 7. Discount Allowed Receipts side of the Cash Book Payables Control Account Source 1. Opening Trade Payables List of individual payables balances drawn up at the end of previous period. Opening Trade Payables in the Statement of Financial Position. 2. Credit Purchases Total from Purchases Day Book 3. Purchases Returns Total from Purchases Returns Day Book 4. Cheques Paid Cash book: bank column on payments side. List extracted or total of a special column which has been included in the cash book. 5. Cash Paid Cash book: cash column on payments side. List extracted or total of a special column which has been included in the cash book. 6. Closing Trade Payables List of individual payables balances drawn up at end of the current period. 7. Discount Received Payments side of the cash book LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Opening and Closing Balances The opening balance in the receivable control and payables control account will be on the debit side and credit side respectively, which is similar to the receivables ledgers and the payables ledger. Opening credit balances which would have been closing debit balances in the previous period are unusual in the receivables control account. They however represent debtors to whom the business owes money, probably as a result of the over-payment of debts or for advance payment of debts for which no invoices have yet been sent. Likewise, opening debit balances and closing credit balance in the payables control account would represent suppliers who owe the business money, perhaps because the business has overpaid or because a credit note is awaited for returned goods. Other Transfers Bad Debts Transfers to bad debts accounts will have to be recorded in the receivables control account as they involve entries in the receivables ledgers. Contra Entries A contra entry is whereby the same firm is both a supplier and customer and inter-indebtedness is set off. This will also need to be entered in the control accounts. An example of this is as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4. The firm has sold A. Hope $600 goods on May 1, 2005 Hope has supplied the firm with $880 goods on May 12, 2005 The $600 owing by Hope is set off against $600 owing to him on May 30, 2005. This leaves $280 owing to Hope on May 31, 2005 2002 May 1 Sales (1) Receivables Ledger A. Hope $ 2002 600 May 30 Set-off: Payables Ledger (3) 600 2002 May 30 May 31 Set-off: Rec. Ledger Balance c/d (3) (4) Payables Ledger A. Hope $ 2002 600 May 12 280 880 LECTURE NOTES $ 600 600 Purchases (2) $ 880 880 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The transfer of the $600 will therefore appear on the credit side of the receivables control account and on the debit side of the payables control account. Relevant entries must be made in the journal. When doing contra entry (set-offs) in the control you have to think of it as cash received and cash paid, for the entries go on the same sides of the control account as these items. Thus a contra item will appear on the credit side of the receivables control account (the same side as cash received from trade receivables) and will appear on the debit side of the payables control account (the same side as cash paid to creditors would appear). Exercise 2006 $ Aug 1 Receivables Ledger: Debit Balances Aug 1 Receivables Ledger: Credit Balances Aug 31 Transactions for the month: Cash Received Cheques received Sales Discount Allowed Return Inwards Cash refunded to a customer who had overpaid her account At the end of the month: Receivables Ledger: Debit Balances Receivables Ledger: Credit Balances 2006 Aug 1 Aug 31 Balance b/d Sales for the Month Cash Refunded Balance c/d Receivables Control Account $ 2006 3,816 Aug 1 Balance b/d 7,090 Aug 31 Cash 37 Bank 40 Discount Allowed Return Inwards Balance c/d 10,983 LECTURE NOTES 3,816 22 104 6,239 7,090 298 164 37 4,156 40 $ 22 104 6,239 298 164 4,156 10,983 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Control Account Worksheet 2 1. You are to prepare a receivables control account from the following. Deduce the closing figure of sales ledger balances as at 31 March 2008. 2008 Mar 1 $ 6,708 Receivables ledger balance Total for March: Discounts allowed Cash and cheques received from debtors Sales Day Book Bad debts written off Sales Returns Day Book Mar 31 Receivables ledger balances 300 8,970 11,500 115 210 ? 2. You are to prepare a payables control account from the following. As the final figure of payables ledger balances at 30 November is missing, you will have to deduce that figure. 2004 Nov 1 Payables ledger balance $ 7,560 Total for November: Discounts received Purchases Returns Day Book Cash and cheques paid to payables Purchases Day Book Nov 30 Payables ledger balances 240 355 9,850 11,100 ? 3. Prepare a receivables control account from the following. 2005 May 1 Debit balances $ 6,420 Total for May: Sales Day Book Cash and cheques received from debtors Discounts allowed Debit balances in the receivables ledger set off against credit balances in the payables ledger May 31 Receivables ledger balances Credit balances LECTURE NOTES 12,800 10,370 395 145 ? 50 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Single Entry and Incomplete Records Lecture Notes Incomplete records problems occur when a business does not have a full set of accounting records, for one of the following reasons: The proprietor of the business does not keep a full set of accounts. Some of the business accounts are accidentally lost or destroyed. Given the above situations, the problem for the accountant is to prepare a set of year-end accounts for the business; i.e. an Income Statement and a Statement of Financial Position from incomplete information. Since the business does not have a full set of accounts, preparing the final accounts is not a simple matter of closing off accounts and transferring balances to the Trading, Income and Expense Account, or showing outstanding balances in the Statement of Financial Position. The task of preparing the final accounts involves the following: (a) Establishing the cost of purchases and other expenses (b) Establishing the total amount of sales (c) Establishing the amount of accounts payable, accruals, accounts receivable and prepayments at the end of the year. The great merit of incomplete records problems is that they focus attention on the relationship between cash received and paid, sales and accounts receivable, purchases and accounts payable, inventory, as well as calling for the preparation of final accounts. In Accounting, the Double Entry Principle is very critical for keeping complete records to produce financial statements. However, small businesses owners are not always aware of this principle. As such, they may tend to document the transactions that occur in their business in a diary format. In addition, they may also leave out certain critical information that is important to producing financial information. This information may be needed for different reasons such as, obtaining credit, accessing a loan, income tax purposes or accessing the performance of the business. As such, the accountant has to use the Single Entry and Incomplete Records approach to calculate the business’ profit. One way is to see “Profit as an Increase in Capital”. Profit as an Increase in Capital – The Business Equation Unless there has been an introduction of extra cash or resources into the firm, the only way that capital can be increased is by making profits. Therefore, profits can be found by comparing capital at the end of the last period with that at the end of this period. For instance, if a firm’s capital at the end of 2004 was $2,000 and 2005 it was $3,000 with no extra resources introduced or withdrawn (drawings) then: Net Profit = This Year’s Capital $3,000 - Last Year’s Capital $2,000 = LECTURE NOTES $1,000 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART If there had been drawings of $700, then the profits would have been calculated as follows: This Year’s Capital $3,000 = Last Year’s Capital $2,000 Net Profit + ? Drawings - $700 If the above formula is transposed to find the missing figure then profits will be: $2,000 - $3,000 + $700 = $1,700 Example H. Williams has not kept proper bookkeeping records, but he has kept notes in diary form of the transactions of his business. He is able to give to you details of his assets and liabilities as at December 31, 2005 and at December 31, 2006 as follows: At December 31, 2005: Assets: Motor Van $1,000; Fixtures $700; Inventory $850; Trade Accounts Receivables $950; Bank $1,100, Cash $100 Liabilities: Trade Payable $200; Loan from J Austin $600 At December 31, 2006: Assets: Motor Van (after depreciation) $800; Fixtures (after depreciation) $630; Inventory $990; Trade Accounts Receivables $1,240; Bank $1,700, Cash $200 Liabilities: Trade Payable $300; Loan from J Austin $400; Drawings $900 A Statement of Affairs will have to be drawn up as at 2005 and 2006. A Statement of Affairs is a statement from which the capital is deduced by estimating assets and liabilities. Then Capital = Assets – Liabilities. H. Williams Statement of Affairs as at December 31, 2005 Non Current Assets Motor Van Fixtures $ Current Assets Inventory Trade Accounts Receivables Bank Cash $ 1,000 700 1,700 850 950 1,100 100 3,000 4,700 Total Assets LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART H. Williams Statement of Affairs as at December 31, 2005 Capital and Liabilities Proprietor’s Capital (difference) 3,900 Non-Current Liabilities Loan from J Austin 600 Current Liabilities Trade Accounts Payable Total Capital and Liabilities 200 4,700 H. Williams Statement of Affairs as at December 31, 2006 Non-current Assets Motor Van Fixtures $ Current Assets Inventory Trade Accounts Receivables Bank Cash $ 800 630 1,430 990 1,240 1,700 200 4,130 5,560 Total Assets Capital and Liabilities Proprietor’s Capital Balance as at Jan 1, 2006 Add Net Profit (C) (B) Less Drawings (A) Non-Current Liabilities Loan from J Austin Current Liabilities Trade Accounts Payable Total Capital and Liabilities LECTURE NOTES 3,900 1,860 5,760 900 4,860 400 300 5,560 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Opening Capital + Net Profits – Drawings = Closing Capital We will have to find the profit by working backwards: (A) is Non-Current Liabilities + Current Liabilities – Total Assets = $5,260 – $400 = $4,860 (B) is (A [Closing Capital]) + Drawings = $4,860 + $900 = $5,760 (C) is (B) – Opening Capital = $1,860 This method of calculating profits is unsatisfactory as it is much more informative when an Income Statement can be drawn up. A business would have exactly the same Income Statement and Statement of Financial Position whether they kept their books by single entry or by double entry. However, whereas the double entry uses the trial balance in preparing the final accounts, the single entry will have to arrive at the same answer by the following five steps using the example of J. Frank: The accountant discerns the following details of transactions for J. Frank’s retail store for the year ended December 31, 2005: 1. The sales are mostly on a credit basis. No record of sales has been made, but $10,000 has been received $9,500 by cheque and $500 by cash, from persons to whom goods have been sold. 2. Amount paid by cheque to suppliers during the year =$7,200. 3. Expenses paid during the year: by cheque, rent $200, general expenses $180; by cash rent $50 4. J. Frank took $10 cash per week (for 52 weeks) as drawings. 5. Other information available: Trade Accounts Receivables Trade Accounts Payables Rent owing Bank balance Cash Balance Inventory At Dec. 31, 2004 $ 1,100 400 1,130 80 1,590 At Dec. 31, 2005 $ 1,320 650 50 3,050 10 1,700 6. The only Non-Current Asset consists of fixtures which were valued at December 31, 2004 at $800. These are to be depreciated at 10% per annum. The approach to incomplete records questions is to build up the information given so as to complete the necessary double entry. This may involve reconstructing control accounts for: Cash and Bank Trade Accounts Receivable and Payable LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Stage 1 – Determine the Opening Position of the Company Draw up an Opening Statement of Financial Position to determine the company’s opening position. This would also be the company’s financial position at the closing day of the last financial period. J. Frank Statement of Financial Position as at December 31, 2004 Non-Current Assets Fixtures $ Current Assets Inventory Trade Accounts Receivable Bank Cash $ 800 1,590 1,100 1,130 80 3,900 4,700 Capital and Liabilities Proprietor’s Capital (difference) 4,300 Current Liabilities Trade Accounts Payable Total Capital and Liabilities 400 4,700 Stage 2 – The Cash Book Information about cash receipts or payments might be needed to establish: (a) The amount of purchases during a period (b) The amount of credit sales during a period Other items of receipts or payments might be relevant to establishing: (a) The amount of cash sales (b) The amount of certain expenses in the Income Statement (c) The amount of withdrawals on the account of profit by the business proprietor A small business will not keep a day-to-day record of its cash receipts and payments (cash book), since many of its sales and payment transactions are for cash (i.e. notes, coins, cheques, or credit cards). However, where there appears to be a sizeable volume of receipts and payments in cash (i.e. notes and coins), then it would be helpful to construct a two column cash book. Two Column Cash Book is a cash book with one column for receipts and payments, and one for money paid into and out of the business bank account. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART A cash and bank summary is drawn up showing the totals of each separate item plus opening and closing balances: Cash Bank Cash Bank $ $ $ $ Balance b/d 80 1,130 Suppliers 7,200 Receipt from Receivables 500 9,500 Rent 50 200 General Expense 180 Drawings 520 Balance c/d 10 3,050 580 10,630 580 10,630 Theft of cash from the till When cash is stolen from the till, the amount stolen will be a credit entry in the cash book, and a debit in the either the net profit section (Income and Expenses Account) of the Income Statement or insurance claim account, depending on whether the business is insured. The missing figure for the cash sales, if this has to be calculated, must not ignore cash received but later stolen. Stage 3 – Calculate Purchases and Sales Figures It is necessary to calculate the figures for sales and purchases to be shown in the trading account. Credit Sales and Trade Accounts Receivable If a business does not keep a record of its sales on credit, the value of these sales can be derived from the opening balance of trade accounts receivable, the closing balance of trade accounts receivable, and the payments received from customers during the period. The sales figure will only equal receipts where all the sales are for cash. Therefore, the receipts figures need adjusting to find sales. This can only be done by constructing a receivables control account, the sales figure being the one needed to make the totals agree or using the following formula: Formula for Credit Sales Payments from trade accounts receivable Less Opening balance of trade accounts receivable (these represent sales in a previous period) Add Closing balance of trade accounts receivable (since these represent sales in the current period for which cash payments has not yet been received) The receivables control account usually looks like the receivables ledger account. Receivables Control Account $ Balance b/d 1,100 Receipts: Cash Sales (missing figure) 10,220 Cheque Balance c/d 11,320 LECTURE NOTES X (X) X X $ 500 9,500 1,320 11,320 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Irrecoverable Debts (Bad Debts) If there are irrecoverable debts during the period, the value of sales will be increased by the amount of irrecoverable debts written off, no matter whether they relate to opening receivables or credit sales during the current period. The same interrelationship between credit sales, cash from receivables, and opening and closing receivables balances can be used to derive a missing figure for cash from receivables, or opening or closing receivables, given the values for the three other items. For example, if we know that opening receivables are $7,600, closing receivables are $3,200 and credit sales for the period are $69,400, then cash from receivables during the period would be as follows: Opening Balance b/d Sales (on credit) Receivables Control Account $ 6,700 Cash Receipts (Balancing Figure) 69,400 Closing Balance c/d 76,100 $ 72,900 3,200 76,100 An alternative way of presenting the same calculation would be: Opening balance of accounts receivable Credit Sales during the period Total Money owed to the business Less Closing balance of accounts receivable Equals cash received during the period 6,700 69,400 76,100 (3,200) 72,900 Purchases and Trade Accounts Payable A similar relationship exists between purchases of inventory during a period, the opening and closing balances for trade accounts payable, and amounts paid to suppliers during the period. In double entry, purchases mean the goods that have been bought in the period, irrespective of whether they have been paid for or not during that time. The figure of payments to suppliers must therefore be adjusted to find the figure for purchases. If we wish to calculate an unknown amount for purchases, the amount would be as follows: Payments to Trade Accounts Payable Less Opening balance on trade accounts payable (these debts, paid in the current period, Relate to purchases in a previous period) Add Closing balance of trade accounts payable (since these represent purchases in the current period for which payment has not yet been made) Goods bought in this year, that is purchases LECTURE NOTES X (X) X X UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Paid during the year Less payments made, but which were for goods which were purchased in a previous (payables 31/12/2004) Add purchases made in this year, but for which Payments has yet not been payment (creditors 31/12/2005) Goods bought in this year, that is purchases TROY J. WISHART 7,200 400 6,800 650 7,450 The same answer could have been obtained if the information had been in the form of a payables control T-account, the figure for purchases being the amount required to make the account totals agree. Cash paid to suppliers Balance c/d Payables Control Account $ 7,200 Balance b/d 650 Purchases (missing figure) 7,850 $ 400 7,450 7,850 Stage 4 – Calculate Expenses Where there are no accrued or prepaid expenses, either at the beginning or end of the accounting period, then expenses paid will equal expenses used up during the period. These figures will be charged to the Income Statement. On the other hand, where such prepayments or accruals exist, then an expense account should be drawn up for that particular item using the opening balance b/f, the closing balance c/f and cash payments for the item during the period. A prepayment in the expense account will have a debit opening balance b/f since it is a current asset. On the other hand, an accrual in the expense account will have a credit opening balance b/f since it is a current liability. When all known items are entered, the missing figure will be the expenses to be charged for the accounting period. In this case, only the rent account needs to be drawn up. Rent $ $ Cheques 200 Rent (missing figure) 300 Cash 50 Accrued c/d 50 300 300 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Stage 5 – Produce Closing Financial Statements It is now practicable to produce closing financial statements since key figures have been found. J. Frank Income Statement for the year ended December 31, 2005 $ Sales (Stage3) Less Cost of Goods Sold: Opening Inventory Add Purchases (Stage 3) Less Closing Inventory Gross Profit Less Expenses Rent (Stage 4) General expense Depreciation Net Profit 1,590 7,450 9,040 1,700 300 180 80 $ 10,220 7,430 2,880 560 2,320 H. Williams Statement of Affairs as at December 31, 2006 Non-Current Assets Fixtures Less Depreciation $ 800 80 Current Assets Inventory Trade Accounts Receivables Bank Cash $ 720 1,700 1,320 3,050 10 6,080 6,800 Total Assets LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART H. Williams Statement of Affairs as at December 31, 2006 Capital and Liabilities Proprietor’s Capital Balance as at Jan 1, 2005 (Stage 1) Add Net Profit 4,300 2,320 6,620 520 6,100 Less Drawings Current Liabilities Trade Accounts Payables Rent Owing Total Capital and Liabilities 650 50 700 6,800 Disadvantages of Single Entry Recording Someone without a double entry set of books will not be able to ascertain the following easily Trade Receivables – They will not know who owes money, how much and how long the money has been owed. Trade Payables – They will not know to whom they owe money, how much and how long it has been owed. No proper checks on amounts paid – for non-current assets over the years. No proper checks on amounts owing – for loans. It will also make it easier for employees to defraud the business, e.g. by destroying sales invoices and getting money from the debtor for doing this. A More Comprehensive Approach to Incomplete Records Step 1 – If possible, and if it is not already known, establish the Opening Statement of Financial Position and the Proprietor’s Interest (Capital). Step 2 – Open up accounts for a two column cash book (if cash sales are significant and there are payments in cash out of the till), a trade receivable Control Account, a trade payables control account. Step 3 – Enter the opening balances in these accounts. Step 4 – Work though the information you are given line by line; and each item should be entered into the appropriate account if it is relevant to one or more of these four accounts. You should also try to recognize each item as an ‘income or expense item or a ‘closing statement of financial position item’. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART It may be necessary to calculate an amount for withdrawals on account and an amount for noncurrent asset depreciation. Step 5 – Look for the balancing figures in your accounts. In particular you might be looking for a value for credit sales, cash sales, purchases, the cost of goods sold, the cost of goods stolen or destroyed, or the closing bank balance. Calculate these missing figures, and make any necessary double entry (e.g. to the trading account from trade accounts payable for purchases, to the trading account from the cash book for cash sales, and to the trading account from trade accounts receivable for credit sales). Step 6 – Now complete the income statement and statement of financial position. Working T-accounts might be needed where there are accruals and prepayments. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Single Entry and Incomplete Records Worksheet 1. On 1 August 2006 S. Phillips started his business with $1,000 in his bank account. After the end of his first year of trading he realized that, because of his lack of bookkeeping knowledge, he was unable to prepare a statement of financial position. He was, however, able to produce the following data for the year ended 31 July 2007. Furniture Motor vehicles (cost $2,100) Inventory Trade Accounts Payable Cash in hand Balance at bank (overdrawn) Trade Accounts Receivable Loan from B. Smith Drawings $ 800 1,600 2,700 3,300 50 1,000 1,600 200 3,000 You are required to: (a) ascertain his profit or loss for the year ended 31 July 2007; (b) prepare his Statement of Financial Position as at 31 July 2007, showing clearly all the totals and subtotals normally found in a such a statement. 2. J. Marcano is a dealer who has not kept proper books of account. At 31 August 2006 her state of affairs was as follows. Cash Bank balance Fixtures Inventory Trade Accounts Receivables Trade Accounts Payable Motor van (at valuation) $ 115 2,209 3,500 16,740 11,890 9,952 3,500 During the year to 31 August 2007 her drawings amounted to $7,560. Winnings from a football pool $12,800 were put into the business. Extra fixtures were bought for $2,000. At 31 August 2007 J. Marcano’s assets and liabilities were: cash, $84; bank overdraft, $165; inventory, $24,891; trade payables for goods, $6,002; payables for expenses, $236; fixtures to be depreciated, $300; motor van to be valued at $2,800; trade receivables, $15,821; prepaid expenses, $72. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Draw up a statement showing the profit or loss made by Marcano for the year ended 31 August 2007. 3. A Hernandez is a sole trader who, although keeping very good records, does not operate a full double entry. The following figures have been taken from her records. Cash at bank Office furniture Inventory Cash in hand 31 March 2008 $ 1,460 600 2,320 60 31 March 2009 $ 1,740 500 2,620 80 Trade Accounts Receivable on 31 March 2008 amounted to $2,980 and sales for the year ended 31 March 2009 to $11,520. During the year ended 31 March 2009 cash received from receivables amounted to $10,820. Trade Accounts Payables on 31 March 2008 amounted to $1,880 and purchases for the year ended 31 March 2009 to $8,120. During the year ended 31 March 2009 cash paid to trade payables amounted to $7,780. During the year to 31 March 2009 no bad debts were incurred. Also, during the same period there was neither discount allowed nor discount received. Required: Calculate receivables and payables as at 31 March 2009; (a) calculate Hernandez’ capital as at 31 March 2008 and 31 March 2009; (b) calculate her net profit for the year ended 31 March 2009, allowing for the fact that during that year her drawings amounted to $2,540. Note: Calculations must be shown. 4. S. Agnew has lost his record of sales, and you will have to deduce the sales figure. The summary of his bank account for the year ended 31 December 2006 is as follows. Receipts from receivables Extra capital introduced $ 67,595 3,000 Balance 1 Jan 2006 Suppliers for goods Motor expenses Rent and rates General expenses Fixtures bought Drawings _____ Balance 31 Dec 2006 70,595 LECTURE NOTES $ 2,059 49,382 4,624 3,728 846 3,500 1,364 5,092 70,595 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART A cash loan of $500 had been received on 1 July 2006. Interest is to be paid on this at the rate of 16% per annum. Cash payments were as follows: $ 6,070 406 707 Drawings Suppliers General expenses Cash received from receivables was $6,630 Motor vans owned by the firm had cost $8,000 in January 2004, and depreciation should be written off at 25% using the reducing balance method. Fixtures costing $2,000 had been bought in January 2003 and depreciation is being written off at the rate of 10%, using the straight-line method. The following information is also given. 31.12.2005 $ Inventory 10,500 Cash in hand 165 Trade Payables 6,238 Trade Receivables 16,840 Motor expenses owing 123 Rent paid in advance 115 Rent owing - (a) (b) (c) (d) 31.12.2006 $ 11,370 112 4,187 19,385 238 230 You are required to: draw up the receivables and payables control accounts; draw up the cash account summary for the year; calculate opening capital as on 1 January 2006; prepare the Income Statement for the year ended 31 December 2006 and a Statement of Financial Position as at that date. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Partnership Lecture Notes 1 Definition The Partnership Act of 1890 defines partnership as: ‘The relationship which subsists between persons carrying on a business in common with a view to profit.’ Thus: (a) Partnership is a relationship. In fact it is a relationship requiring the utmost trust and cooperation between the partners. (b) Partnership is a business relationship. It is concerned with two or more people who jointly own and a manage a business (c) The objective of the partnership is to make a profit which has to be shared in some ways by the partners. The Need for Partnerships There are various reasons for multiple ownership: The capital required is more than one person can provide The experience or ability required to manage the business cannot be found in one person alone. Many people want to share management instead of doing everything on their own. NOTE: There are two types of multiple ownership: Partnerships and Limited Companies. Nature of a Partnership A partnership has the following characteristics It is formed to make profits. It must obey the law given in the Partnership Act of the Caribbean Commonwealth. The partnership laws in each of the Caribbean countries are very similar to one another. The differences are minor ones and may be ignored. The basic law from which the various countries’ laws have evolved is the UK partnership Act 1890. Normally there can be a minimum of 2 partners and a maximum of 20 partners. Exceptions are banks, where there cannot be more than 10 persons. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Each partner (except for limited partners) must pay his or her share of any debt that the partnership cannot pay. If necessary, partners can be forced to sell all their private possessions to pay their share of the debts. This is what is meant by unlimited liability. Limited Partners Limited partners are not liable for the debts of the company and have the following characteristics: Their liability for the debts of the partnership is limited to the capital they have put in. They can lose that capital, but they cannot be asked for any more money to pay the debts. They are not allowed to take part in the management of the partnership business. Not all the partners in a partnership can be limited partners: there must be at least one with unlimited liability. Partnership Agreements Agreements in writing are not necessary. However, it is better if a proper written agreement is drawn up by a lawyer or accountant. Where there is a proper written agreement there will be fewer problems between partners, and less confusion about what has been agreed. Contents of Partnership Agreements The essence of a partnership is the agreement. Partners must agree about all aspects of the conduct of the business and of the relationship between the partners. Some of the aspects which must be covered by the agreement are: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) (j) Who the partners are. How much each should contribute to the partnership capital. When the partnership should commence. How long the partnership should last. How profits should be shared. How much each partner may draw from the business. Hours of work, holidays etc. What happens if a partner dies, retires, becomes bankrupt, medically incapable or insane. The extent to which partners can engage in other business activities. Commercial matters – products, premises, rate of expansion, employment policy etc. The usual accounting contents are: The capital to be contributed by each partner The ratio in which profits (or losses) are to be shared The rate of interest, if any, to be paid on capital before the profits are shared The rate of interest, if any, to be charged on partners’ drawings LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Salaries to be paid to partners Arrangements for the admission of new partners Procedures to be carried out when a partner retires or dies. The agreement may be a formal one – a deed drawn up by a solicitor and signed by all the partners – or it may be written less formally, perhaps in the form of the exchange of letters or minutes of a meeting or it may merely be the conduct of the parties. The assumption behind the latter is that the agreement is what the partners do. For example, if the written partnership agreement says that the partners may take two weeks holiday each a year but they actually take four weeks each, then their agreement is not what the written agreement says but what they do. In practice, failure to agree in advance on some aspect of the partnership affairs may lead to acrimony and even collapse of the partnership. If There is no Partnership Agreement A special section of the Partnership Act of 1890 covers this situation. If there is no partnership agreement, written or otherwise, the following provisions will apply: Profits and losses will be shared equally There is to be no interest on capital No interest is to be charged on drawings Salaries are not allowed The Law The General Law was codified in the Partnership Act 1890 and that relations between partners are governed by their partnership agreement whether this be expressed, or implied by the conduct of the parties. The number of partners in a partnership permissible in law is restricted to 20 except for certain professional partnerships – accountants, doctors, solicitors, chartered loss adjusters etc. Section 24 of the Partnership Act of 1890 states how profits are to be shared in the absence of an agreement. Profit Sharing Partners can share the profits of their business in any way they like. Many partnerships share profits in ways which reflect the differing contributions made by the partners to business, for example: (a) Capital Invested: For example suppose the capitals were Allen $2,000 and Beet $1,000. Many people would share the profits in the ratio of two-thirds, one-thirds, even though the work to be done by each partner is similar. Consider too the capital ratio sharing of profits when one partner has put in $99,000 and the other $1,000 as capital. In this case, one partner would get 99/100ths while the other would get only 1/100th! To overcome the difficulty of compensating for the investment of extra capital the concept of Interest on Capital was devised. (b) Time spent on business. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART (c) Expertise or experience. (d) Seniority Some profit sharing arrangements are complex. For example, in the partnership of Dick, Eddie and Fred they agreed that: (a) Each should have a part of the profit equivalent to 10% of their capital at the beginning of the year. This reflects the different amounts of capital each has tied up in the partnership business. (b) Dick should have $7,000 of the profit to reflect the fact that he alone works full time on the business and thus foregoes the salary he could have earned elsewhere. (c) Eddie should have a share of the profit equal to 2% of the sales to reflect the special expertise he has in obtaining customers. (d) Any remaining profit should be shared equally. Interest on Capital If the work to be done by each partner is of equal value but the capital contributed is unequal, it is reasonable to grant interest on the partners’ capitals. This interest is treated as a deduction prior to the calculation of profits and their distribution according to the profit-sharing ratio. The rate of interest is a matter of agreement between the partners, but it should equal the return they would have received if they had invested the capital elsewhere. Taking Allen and Beet’s firm again, but sharing the profits equally after charging 5% per annum interest on capital, the division of profits are shown below. Allen has received $250 more than Beet, this being adequate return (in the partners’ estimation) for her having invested an extra $1,000 in the firm for five years. Years Net Profits Interest on Capitals Allen Beet Remainder Shared Allen ½ Beet ½ Summary Interest on Capital Balance of profits 1 $ 1,800 2 $ 2400 3 $ 3,000 4 $ 3,000 5 $ 3,600 100 50 100 50 100 50 100 50 100 50 = 500 = 250 825 825 1,125 1,125 1,425 1,425 1,425 1,425 1,725 1,725 = 6525 = 6525 Allen $ 500 6,525 7,025 Beet $ 250 6,525 6,775 LECTURE NOTES Total $ UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Interest on Drawings It is obviously in the best interests of the firm if cash is withdrawn from the firm by the partners in accordance with the two basic principles of as little as possible and as late as possible. The more cash that is left in the firm, the more expansion can be financed, the greater the economics of having ample cash to take advantage of bargains and not missing out on cash discounts, and so on. To deter the partners from taking out cash unnecessarily, the concept can be used of charging the partners interest on each withdrawal, calculated from the date of withdrawal to the end of the financial year. The amount charged to them helps to swell the profits divisible between the partners. The rate of interest should be sufficient to achieve this without being too harsh. Suppose Allen and Beet have decided to charge interest on drawings at 5% per annum, and that their year-end was December 31. The Drawings made are shown below: Allen Interest Drawings 1 January 1 March 1 May 1 July 1 October $ 100 240 120 240 80 Beet Interest Drawings 1 January 1 August 1 December $100 x 5% x 12 months $240 x 5% x 10 months $120 x 5% x 8 months $240 x 5% x 6 months $80 x 5% x 3 months Interest Charged to Allen $ 5 10 4 6 1 26 $ 60 480 240 $60 x 5% x 12 months $480 x 5% x 5 months $240 x 5% x 1 month Interest Charged to Beet $ 3 10 1 14 Salaries to Partners One partner may have more responsibility or tasks than the others. As a reward for this, rather than change the profit and loss-sharing ratio, he or she may have their salary deducted before sharing the balance of profits. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Exercise Taylor and Clarke have been in partnership for one year, sharing profits and losses in the ratio of threefifths to Taylor and two-fifths to Clarke. They are entitled to 5% per annum interest on capital, Taylor having $2,000 capital and Clarke $6,000. Clarke is to have a salary of $500. They charge interest on drawings, Taylor being charged $50 and Clarke $100. The net profit, before any distributions to the partners, amounted to $5,000 for the year ended December 31, 2007. Taylor and Clarke’s Distribution of Profits $ Net Profit Add Charges for interest on drawings: Taylor Clarke $ $ 5,000 50 100 150 5,150 Less Clarke’s Salary Interest on Capital: Taylor Clarke 500 100 300 400 Balance of profits Shared Taylor 3/5 Clarke 2/5 900 4,250 2,550 1,700 4,250 The $5,000 net profits have therefore been shared as follows: Balance of profits Interest on capital Salary Less Interest on drawings Taylor Clarke $ $ 2,550 1,700 100 300 500 2,650 2,500 50 100 2,600 2,400 $5,000 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The Final Accounts If the sales, inventory and expenses of a partnership were exactly as those of a sole trader, then the Income Statement would be identical to those prepared for the sole trader. However, a partnership has an extra section shown under the Income Statement. This section is called the Appropriation Account, and it is in this account that the distribution of profits is shown. The heading to the Income Statement does not include the words ‘appropriation account’. It is purely an accounting custom not to include it in the heading. Taylor and Clarke Income Statement for the year ended December 31, 2007 $ Sales Less Cost of goods sold: Purchases Less Closing Inventory Gross Profit 41,500 4,500 Less Expenses: Pay Rent and Rates General expenses Net Profit Add Charges for interest on drawings: Taylor Clarke Clarke’s Salary Interest on Capital: Taylor Clarke Balance of profits/Residual Profits Shared Taylor 3/5 ths Clarke 2/5 ths $ 2,400 3,200 900 50 100 Less $ 48,500 37,000 11,500 6,500 5,000 150 5,150 500 100 300 400 2,550 1,700 900 4,250 4,250 With a sole trader, all of the profits belong to the sole trader, but in a partnership the profit is shared among the partners. Consequently an additional account is required to show the appropriation of the profit among the partners. The profit is shared in accordance with the agreement. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Capital Accounts At the formation of a new partnership, the partners may agree to put into the partnership from their private resources, cash and/or other assets to an agreed value. The amount of such resources put in by a partner is his capital. Usually the partners agree that no partner will withdraw resources from the partnership in such a way that the capital is reduced. A partner’s capital account will only change by agreement or on the occurrence of events such as a change in the profit sharing ratio or on the death or the retirement of a partner, or the admission of a new partner. Each Partner will want to know exactly the value of his or her holding in the firm. We can say that this consists of: The original capital put into the firm by the partner His or her share of the profits, interest on capital (if any), salary (if any), less interest on drawings (if any) and drawings themselves – in other words, this is really the amount of undrawn profits. Current Accounts If a profit is made by a partnership, it means that the net assets of the partnership have increased by the amount of the profit. Each partner’s share of the profit is credited to his current account. The balance standing to the credit of a partner’s current account represents the maximum amount that the partner can withdraw from the partnership assets. Thus a partner can only make drawings up to the amount of his accumulated share of profits. The current account represents undrawn profits. Capital Accounts without Current Accounts Many partnerships simply have capital accounts without partners’ current accounts. In these cases, the capital account represents a mixture of capital subscribed and undrawn profits. There is therefore no maximum put on partners’ drawings by the division between capital and current accounts and restriction of another sort has to be agreed upon (Perhaps a weekly amount and an annual drawing when profits have been calculated). Now we could have an account for each partner which would contain both kinds of information. The balance on this account would fluctuate each year as drawings very rarely exactly equal profits. This is rather like a capital account in a sole trader’s business. Because the balance fluctuates, these are called Fluctuating Capital Accounts. On the other hand, we could keep the original capital figure in an account for each partner. These we would keep at the same figure, and we would call these Fixed Capital Accounts. We would show the share of the profits and interest on capital for each partner in separate accounts called Current Accounts. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Assume that both Taylor and Clarke withdrew $2,000 from their business: Fixed Capital Accounts plus Current Accounts 2007 Dec 31 Dec 31 Dec 31 2007 Dec 31 Dec 31 Dec 31 Cash: drawings Profit and loss Appropriation account: Interest on Drawings Balance c/d Cash: drawings Profit and loss Appropriation account: Interest on Drawings Balance c/d Taylor: Capital 2007 Jan 1 Bank (Cash introduced) $ 2,000 Clarke: Capital 2007 Jan 1 Bank (Cash introduced) $ 6,000 Taylor: Current Account $ 2007 2,000 Dec 31 Profit and loss appropriation account: Interest on Capital 50 Share of profits 600 2,650 2008 Jan 1 Balance b/d Clarke: Current Account $ 2007 2,000 Dec 31 Profit and loss appropriation account: Interest on Capital 100 Share of profits 400 Salary 2,500 2008 Jan 1 Balance b/d LECTURE NOTES $ 100 2,550 2,650 600 $ 300 1,700 500 2,500 400 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Fluctuating Capital Accounts 2007 Dec 31 Dec 31 Dec 31 Taylor: Capital Account $ 2007 2,000 Jan 1 Bank Dec 31 Profit and loss appropriation account: 50 Interest on Capital 2,600 Share of profits 4,650 Cash: drawings Profit and loss Appropriation account: Interest on Drawings Balance c/d 2008 Jan 1 2007 Dec 31 Dec 31 Dec 31 $ 2,000 100 2,550 4,650 Balance b/d 2,600 Clarke: Capital Account $ 2007 2,000 Jan 1 Bank Dec 31 Profit and loss appropriation account: 100 Interest on Capital 6,400 Share of profits Salary 8,500 2008 Jan 1 Balance b/d Cash: drawings Profit and loss Appropriation account: Interest on Drawings Balance c/d $ 6,000 300 1,700 500 8,500 6,400 Columnar Form of the Fluctuating Capital Account Capital Accounts Taylor Clarke 2007 Dec 31 Dec 31 Dec 31 Cash: drawings Profit and loss Appropriation account: Interest on Drawings Balance c/d $ 2,000 $ 2007 2,000 Jan 1 Dec 31 50 2,600 100 6,400 4,650 8,500 Bank Profit and loss appropriation account: Interest on Capital Share of profits Salary Taylor Clarke $ 2,000 $ 6,000 100 2,550 300 1,700 500 8,500 4,650 2008 Jan 1 Balance b/d LECTURE NOTES 2,600 6,400 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The Preference of Fixed Capital Accounts The keeping of fixed capital accounts plus current accounts is considered preferable to fluctuating capital accounts. When partners are taking out greater amounts than the share of the profits they are entitled to, this is shown by a debit balance on the current account and so acts as a warning. Statement of Financial Position The statement of financial position formats of a partnership are the same as for sole traders. The difference is that instead of a single capital account for the proprietor, there are several accounts (and perhaps current accounts), one for each partner. In simple cases, the full accounts can be given, showing separately, opening balance, share of profit, drawings closing balance. But in more complex cases, the detail is usually put in a separate schedule and only the final balances put on the statement of financial position. Fixed Capital Statement of Financial Position (Extract) Capital $ 2,000 6,000 8,000 Taylor Clarke Current Accounts Taylor $ Clarke $ 100 Interest on Capital Salary Share of profits $ $ 300 500 1,700 2,500 2,550 2,650 Less Drawings Less Interest on drawings 2,000 50 2,050 600 2,000 100 2,100 400 1,000 9,000 Fluctuating Capital Statement of Financial Position (Extract) Capital Taylor $ Cash Introduced Interest on Capital Salary Share of profits Less Drawings Less Interest on drawings Clarke $ 2,000 100 $ 2,550 4,650 2,000 50 2,050 2,600 2,000 100 LECTURE NOTES $ 6,000 300 500 1,700 8,500 $ 2,100 6,400 9,000 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART If one of the current accounts had finished in debit, for instance if the current account of Clarke had finished up as $400 debit, the abbreviation Dr. would appear and the balances would appear net in the totals column: Closing balances Taylor Clarke $ 600 $ 400 Dr. $ 200 If the net figure turned out to be a debit figure, then this would be deducted from the total of the capital accounts. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Partnership Worksheet 1 1. For the year ended 31 December 2006, their capital accounts remained fixed at the following amounts: $ Stephens 6,000 Owen 4,000 Jones 2,000 They have agreed to give each other 10% interest per annum on their capital accounts. In addition to the above, partnership salaries of $3,000 for Owen and $1,000 for Jones are to be charged. The net profit of the partnership, before taking any of the above into account, was $25,200. You are required to draw up the appropriation account of the partnership for the year ended 31 December 2006. 2. Draw up a income statement appropriation account for the year ended 31 December 2007 and statement of financial position extracts at that date, from the following: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Net profit $30,350 Interest to be charged on capitals: Williams, $2,000; Powell, $1,500; Howe, $900. Interest to be charged on drawings: Williams, $240; Powell, $180; Howe, $130. Salaries to be credited: Powell, $2,000; Howe, $3,500. Profits to be shared: Williams, 50%; Powell, 30%; Howe 20%. Current accounts: Williams $1,860; Powell $946; Howe, $717. Capital accounts: Williams, $40,000; Powell $30,000; Howe, $18,000. Drawings: Williams, $9,200; Powell, $7,100; Howe, $6,900. 3. Mendez and Marshall are in partnership, sharing profits and losses equally. The following is their trial balance as at 30 June 2006. Buildings at cost Fixtures at cost Provision for depreciation: fixtures Trade Receivables Trade Payables LECTURE NOTES Dr. $ 50,000 11,000 Cr. $ 3,300 16,243 11,150 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Cash at bank Inventory at 30 June 2005 Sales Purchases Carriage outwards Discounts allowed Loan interest: Khan Office expenses Pay Bad debts Provision for bad debts Loan from J. Khan Capital: Mendez Marshall Current accounts: Mendez Marshall Drawings: Mendez Marshall TROY J. WISHART 677 41,979 123,650 85,416 1,288 115 4,000 2,416 18,917 503 400 40,000 35,000 29,500 1,306 298 6,400 5,650 ______ 244,604 ======= _______ 244,604 ======= Prepare a income statement and appropriation account for the year ended 30 June 2006, and a statement of financial position as at that date. 1. Inventory, 30 June 2006: $56,340. 2. Expense to be accrued: office expenses, $96; pay, $200. 3. Depreciate fixtures 10% on reducing balance basis. Depreciate buildings $1,000. 4. Reduce provision for bad debts to $320. 5. Partnership salary: $800 to Mendez. Not yet entered. 6. Interest on drawings: Mendez, $180, Marshall, $120. 7. Interest on capital account balance at 10%. 4. Q and P have similar businesses and decide to amalgamate and form a partnership. On 1 January 2005 they had the following assets and liabilities: Equipment Trade Receivables Inventory Premises Motor van Trade Payables Q $ 7,000 2,100 12,000 15,000 1,970 P $ 8,000 3,900 9,000 7,200 2,040 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA Prepaid expenses Expenses owing ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 300 430 TROY J. WISHART 230 790 From 1 January 2005, they agreed that: 1. profits and losses would be shared equally; 2. interest on capital at 10% would be allowed; 3. P was to get a salary of $2,000 per annum; 4. Interest on drawings at 10% per annum would be charged; for 2005 this amounted to $120 for Q and $200 for P. For the year to 31 December 2005, a net profit of $23,680 was made. Q’s drawings were $5,200 and P’s, $8,400. You are required to: (a) ascertain opening capitals; (b) draw up a profit and loss appropriation account for the year ended 31 December 2005; (c) draw up capital accounts as they would be shown in the statement of financial position as at 31 December 2005, assuming fluctuating capital accounts are to be used. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Partnership Lecture Notes 2 – Goodwill and Changes in Partnership Goodwill – Definition The excess amount that has to be paid to acquire a part or the whole of a business as a going concern over and above the value of the assets owned by the business. Suppose you have been in business for some years and you want to sell up. How much would you ask as the total sale price of the business? You decide to list how much you could get for each asset if sold separately. This list might be as follows: $ Buildings 225,000 Machinery 75,000 Trade Receivable 60,000 Inventory 40,000 400,000 Instead, however, you sell the whole of the business as a going concerning to Ms Lee for $450,000. She has therefore paid $50,000 more than the total for all the assets. This extra payment of $50,000 is for what is called Goodwill. Ms. Lee has paid this because she wanted to take over the business as a going concern. Thus, Purchased goodwill = Total price – Value of Identifiable Assets Note: A business that is a Going Concern is based on the concept that a business will continue for a long time. Goodwill has been judicially described as ‘the probability that the customers of a business will continue to patronize the business on a change of ownership’. Goodwill can be personal to proprietor, in which case customers will cease to patronize the business on a change of ownership. Goodwill like any other scarce commodity is worth what a buyer will pay a willing seller. The value, or price if it is to be sold, is normally reached by negotiation or in cases of dispute by independent arbitration. Reasons for Payment of Goodwill In buying an existing business which has been established for some time, there may be quite a few possible advantages. For example: There is a large number of regular customers who will continue to deal with the business under a new owner The business has a good reputation It has efficient and reliable employees It is in a good location LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART It has good contacts with suppliers These advantages are not available to completely new business and as such, people will pay an extra amount for goodwill when buying an existing business. However, Goodwill will only exist in a business if it has had a good reputation. If the business has a bad reputation, an inefficient workforce and other negative factors, no one will want to pay an extra amount for goodwill. Methods of Calculating of Goodwill Various methods are used to help buyer and seller come to an agreed figure. The calculations give buyer and seller a figure with which to begin discussions of the value of the business. Very often each industry has its own customary way of calculating goodwill. Average Sales Method In many retail businesses the yearly sales for the past few years are multiplied by an agreed figure. For instance, suppose that it is agreed that the goodwill should be three times the average yearly sales for the last two years. Then the calculations maybe: Year 2005 2006 Total Average annual sales = $300,000 ÷ 2 = $150,000 Goodwill = 3 × $150,000 = $450,000 Sales $ 140,000 160,000 300,000 Annual Fees Method Professional firms such as accountants or lawyers, often use a method based on gross annual income of fees, before charging expenses. For instance, a firm of accountants is selling its business. It is asking for goodwill that is two and a half times the average annual fees received for the last two years. Year 2005 2006 Total Average annual fees = $400,000 ÷ 2 = $200,000 Goodwill = 2.5 × $200,000 = $500,000 Annual Fees $ 180,000 220,000 400,000 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Average Net Annual Profits Method The average net profit for a number of years is multiplied by a stated amount. Suppose goodwill is taken four times the average net annual profits for the past three years: Year Annual Fees $ 2004 62,000 2005 69,000 2006 79,000 Total 210,000 Average net annual profits = $210,000 ÷ 3 = $70,000 Goodwill = 4 × $70,000 = $280,000 Super Profits Method Super profits are what are left of the net profit after allowances have been made for the services of the proprietor and the use of his or her capital. It is calculated as follows: $ Annual net Profits Less Remuneration proprietor would have earned for similar work elsewhere Interest that would have been earned If capital had been invested elsewhere Annual super profits $ 80,000 20,000 10,000 30,000 50,000 The annual super profits are then multiplied by a number agreed by the seller and purchaser of the business. Changes in Partnership Overtime a partnership can experience several changes that affect how accounting for the partnership’s operations is done. Some of those changes maybe one of the following a) A decision to change in profit/loss ratio. b) Introduction of a new partner c) Retirement of a partner. Most of these changes involve the valuation of Goodwill. When a change occurs in a partnership which is a going concern such that goodwill has value then the following procedures are required: a) Agree on the value of goodwill LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART b) Write up the goodwill account, by debiting goodwill and crediting the pre-change partners in the prechange profit/loss sharing ratio. c) Write down the goodwill to nil, by crediting goodwill account and debiting the post-change partners in the post-change profit/loss sharing ratio. d) Assets other than goodwill are sometimes involved and are treated in the same way. Change in Profit Sharing Ratio Partnerships for some reason or another would often decide to change their profit sharing ratio, either to accommodate a partner’s lesser or greater involvement or contribution to the partnership’s firm. As a result of this change in their profit sharing ratio adjustments have to be made to the partnerships share in the goodwill and fixed assets to compensate the partners loosing and charge partners gaining. Example The partners, Graham and Keith of Truckbits, share profits equally and the partnership statement of financial position at June 30, 2004 was: $ $ Non-Current Assets 35,000 Capital: Graham 30,000 Current Assets 28,000 Keith 18,500 ______ Current Liabilities 14,500 63,000 63,000 The partners agreed that as Graham wished to take a smaller part in the partnership business, the profit sharing ratio should change to 2:3 with a salary of $5,000 a year to Keith. For the purpose of the change only, goodwill was agreed at a value of $30,000 and non-current assets at a value of $47,000. These changes in value were not to be incorporated in the books. Answer Graham (a) Keith (a) Goodwill Account $ 15,000 Graham (b) 15,000 Keith (b) 30,000 Balance b/f Graham (a) Keith (a) Non-current Assets $ 35,000 Graham (b) 6,000 Keith (b) 6,000 Balance c/f 47,000 LECTURE NOTES $ 12,000 18,000 30,000 $ 4,800 7,200 35,000 47,000 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA Goodwill (b) Non-current Assets (b) Balance c/f ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Graham $ 12,000 4,800 34,200 51,000 Capital Accounts Keith $ 18,000 Balance b/f 7,200 Goodwill (a) 14,300 Non-currents Assets (a) 39,500 TROY J. WISHART Graham 30,000 15,000 6,000 Keith $ 18,500 15,000 6,000 51,000 39,500 Notes: a) Goodwill and non-current assets are written up to their agreed values ($30,000 and $47,000) by credits to the partners’ accounts in the old profit sharing ratio (equal shares). b) Goodwill and non-current assets are written down to their continuing book values (nil and $35,000) by debits to the partners’ accounts in the new profit sharing ratios (2:3). c) The salary part of the profit sharing formula is irrelevant for this purpose. Admission of a New Partner New partners may be admitted to a partnership for one of three reasons: 1. As an additional partner, either because the firm has grown or because someone is needed who has different skills to those of the existing partners; 2. To replace a partner who is leaving the firm: this might be because of the retirement or death of a partner 3. To bring in additional capital. The capital to be brought into a business by a new partner is dependent on the agreement drawn up between the old partners and the new partners. Goodwill on Admission of New Partners A new partner will be entitled to a share in the profits, and normally, will also be entitled to the same share in goodwill. It is expected that the new partner will be charged for taking over that share of the goodwill. However, the true value of goodwill can be established only when the business is sold, but for various reasons of fairness between partners it is valued the best way possible when there is no imminent sale of the business. Calculation of Goodwill Adjustments The procedure for charging a new partner for taking over a share of the goodwill is as follows: 1. Show the value of goodwill divided between the original partners in the old profit and losssharing ratios. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART 2. Then show the value of goodwill divided between the partners in the new partnership in the new profit- and loss-sharing ratio. 3. Goodwill gain shown: charge partners for the gain. Goodwill loss shown: give partners an allowance for their losses. Example A and B are in partnership, sharing profits and losses equally. C is admitted as a new partner. The three partners will share profits and losses one-third each. Total goodwill is valued at $60,000. Partners A Stage 1 Stage 2 Old New Share of Share of profit profit goodwill goodwill Shares shares $ $ ½ 30,000 1/3 20,000 Stage 3 Gained or loss To compensate for loss To charge for gain $ 10,000 Cr. A Capital (Lost) B C ½ 30,000 60,000 1/3 20,000 1/3 20,000 10,000 Cr. B Capital (Lost) 20,000 (Gained) Dr. C Capital 60,000 This means that A and B need to have their capitals increased by $10,000 each. C needs his capital reducing by $20,000. You may well wonder why A and B should have their capitals increased by $10,000 each, i.e. receive a credit $10,000 in each of their capital accounts. They have each given up part of their ownership of an asset, in this case goodwill, to the new partner C. C could be charged for this, which is done by debiting his capital account by $20,000. As it is A and B that have passed over to him part of their ownership, the corresponding credits should be made in their capital accounts for $10,000 each. If this were not done they would have given up their shares of the goodwill for nothing. Example 2 D and E are in partnership sharing profits ½ each. A new partner F is admitted. Profits will now be shared D one-fifth 1/5, and E and F two-fifths each. D and E have therefore not kept their shares equal to each other. Goodwill is valued at $60,000. As a result of the admission of F, D’s capital will increase by $18,000; E’s capital is to be increased by $6,000; and F needs his capital reduced by $24,000. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA Partners D E ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Stage 1 Stage 2 Old New Share of Share of profit profit goodwill goodwill shares Shares $ $ 30,000 1/5 12,000 ½ ½ F 30,000 - 2/5 24,000 2/5 24,000 60,000 TROY J. WISHART Stage 3 Gained or loss To compensate for loss To charge for gain $ 18,000 Cr. D Capital (Lost) 6,000 Cr. E Capital (Lost) 24,000 Dr. F Capital (Gained) 60,000 Accounting Entries for Goodwill Adjustments These depend on how the partners wish to arrange the adjustment. Three methods are usually used: 1) Private Arrangement – Cash is paid by the new partner privately to the old partners for his or her share of the goodwill. No goodwill account is opened. Therefore, in the above example F would therefore give $24,000 in cash: $18,000 to D and $6,000 to E. D and E would bank these amounts in their private bank accounts. No entry would be made for this in the accounts of the partnership. 2) Formal Arrangement – Cash is paid by the new partner into the business bank account for his or her share of the goodwill. No goodwill account is opened. Assume that the capital balances before F was admitted were D $50,000 and E $50,000, and F was to pay in $50,000 as capital plus $24,000 for goodwill. The entries would be as follows: Capital Accounts Adjustments for gain of goodwill D E F D E F $ $ $ $ 50,000 $ 50,000 $ Balances b/f 24,000 Cash for capital Balance c/d 50,000 68,000 56,000 50,000 Adjustments for loss of goodwill 18,000 Cash for goodwill 68,000 56,000 74,000 6,000 24,000 68,000 56,000 74,000 3) No Arrangement – A goodwill account is opened. No extra cash is to be paid by the new partner for the goodwill. The opening capitals were D$50,000; E $50,000; F paid in $50,000 as capital. The action required is as follows: LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART a) Debit goodwill account with total value of goodwill. Credit capitals of old partners with their shares of goodwill in old profit ratios. b) Debit adjustments gains to partners’ capitals. Credit adjustment losses to partners’ capital. Goodwill $ Value Divided: D Capital E Capital $ 30,000 30,000 Balance c/d 60,000 60,000 60,000 Capital Accounts Adjustments for gain of goodwill D E F $ $ $ D Balances b/f E $ $ 50,000 50,000 $ 24,000 Cash for capital Balance c/d F 50,000 98,000 86,000 26,000 Goodwill adjustments 30,000 30,000 Adjustments for loss of goodwill 18,000 98,000 86,000 50,000 98,000 6,000 86,000 50,000 Premiums for Goodwill The amounts paid in by the new partners, or charged to them, for goodwill is often known as a Premium. Modern Accounting Theory for Goodwill Modern Accounting theory for goodwill requires that Goodwill should only be created to facilitate a change in the partnership. After this change has been done, goodwill should be written down to nil since goodwill is a subjective asset that inflates the statement of financial position. Accounting theory requires that the true picture of the firm’s financial position be reported. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Example Jonathan and Diane are in partnership sharing profits equally and with a statement of financial position as at July 31, 2005. $ 100,000 ______ 100,000 Net Assets Capital: Johnaton Diane $ 60,000 40,000 100,000 On August 1, 2005, Tina was admitted to the partnership and brought in $30,000 cash. Profit sharing was to be in equal shares. It was agreed that goodwill was worth $24,000 and that no goodwill account was to be maintained in the books. Goodwill Account $ 12,000 Johnaton 12,000 Diane Tina 24,000 Johnaton Diane Goodwill Balance c/f Johnaton $ 8,000 64,000 72,000 Capital Accounts Diane Tina $ $ 8,000 8,000 Balance b/f 44,000 22,000 Goodwill Cash 52,000 30,000 $ 8,000 8,000 8,000 24,000 Johnaton $ 60,000 12,000 Diane $ 40,000 12,000 Tina $ 30,000 72,000 52,000 30,000 Retirement of Partnership In theory, the retirement of a partner from the partnership involves the dissolution of the partnership and the setting up of a new partnership of the non-retiring partners from the old partnership. In practice the assets and liabilities of the partnership are usually carried through to the partnership and the books continued. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The steps required on the retirement of a partner are: 1. Determine the value of goodwill 2. Write up the value of goodwill as: Dr Goodwill Cr Partners in their profit sharing ratio 3. Charge any assets taken by the retiring partner to his account. 4. Making any required adjustments to the value of any assets or liabilities with corresponding entries in the capital accounts of any profits/losses in profit sharing ratio. 5. Write down value of goodwill to nil by: Dr Capital accounts of remaining partners Cr Goodwill In the new profit sharing ratio 6. Re-titling the capital (together with current account) of the retiring partner as a loan to the new partnership. Example Bill, Moon and Hartland are in partnership sharing profits equally. On December 31, 1991 their Statement of Financial Position showed: $ Plant and Vehicles Inventory Trade Receivables Cash at Bank 28,000 14,000 21,700 6,800 70,500 $ Capital: Bill Moon Hartland Current Liabilities 31,100 17,000 11,900 10,500 70,500 On January 1, 1992, Bill retired and it was agreed that, in accordance with the partnership agreement: Goodwill was valued at $34,000 Bill should take a car (written down value $2,800) at a valuation of $4,000. Bill should take $5,000 immediately and leave the balance on loan bearing interest at 10%. Repayment would be in two installments at the ends of 1992 and 1993. The new profit sharing ratio between the remaining partners was to remain in equal shares. Show: a) The capital accounts and loan account in the books of the old partnership; b) The Statement of Financial Position of the new partnership after the retirement. Answer a) Capital and loan accounts in the books of the old partnership. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART We will begin with an account to show the realization of the car which is taken by Bill: Realization Account $ 2,800 Transfer to Bill Car at Book value Profit on realization Bill Moon Hartland Car withdrawn Cash Transfer Loan Balance c/f $ 4,000 400 400 400 4,000 Bill $ 4,000 5,000 22,500 31,500 4,000 Capital Accounts Moon Hartland $ $ Balance b/f Profit Bill $ 31,100 400 Moon Hartland $ $ 17,000 11,900 400 400 17,400 17,400 31,500 17,400 12,300 12,300 b) Statement of Financial Position of the new partnership: $ Plant and Vehicles 25,200 Capital: Moon Inventory 14,000 Hartland Trade Receivables 21,700 Loan Bill Cash at Bank 1,800 Current Liabilities 62,700 LECTURE NOTES $ 17,400 12,300 22,500 10,500 62,700 12,300 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Partnership Worksheet 2 – Goodwill and Changes in Partnership 1. June Graves and Cyril Regis want you to value the goodwill of their business, which they are going to sell. You advise them that for their kind of business the ‘average sales method’ is appropriate. They say that they would agree to a valuation of four times the average yearly sales for the last three years. The sales for the last three years have been: 2001, $240,000; 2002, $280,000; 2003, $275,000. Show your calculation of the value of goodwill. 2. Scott and Simpson are selling their dental practice. They are asking a figure for goodwill which is five times the average annual fees received for the last four years. The fees received were as follows: 2001 2002 2003 2004 $ 163,500 181,000 178,500 201,000 You are required to calculate the value of goodwill in accordance with the above figures. 3. James Barnes is selling his business. He has worked full-time in the business. Drawings, as they should be, have been charged up to his capital account, not to the profit and loss account. The cash that Barnes has invested in the business amounts to $200,000. If he had invested it elsewhere he would have been able to get interest on it of 12%. Barnes is a qualified engineer. If he had not been working in his own business he could have been employed elsewhere for $60,000 a year. His accountant advises him to value his goodwill at a figure equaling five years of ‘super profits’. Required: Calculate the value of goodwill at the figure stipulated by the accountant, given the above information and the fact that his annual net profits amount to $110,000. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART 4. Marshall and Russell are in partnership sharing profits and losses in the ratio of Marshall twothirds, Russell one-third. A new partner, Sangster, is introduced. Profits will be shared in the ratio; Marshall one-half, Russell one-quarter, Sangster one-quarter. Just before the introduction of Sangster, the statement of financial position had been as set out below. Statement of Financial Position as at 31 December 2004 ______________________________________________________________________________ $ $ Non-current Assets Building 11,000 Current assets Inventory Trade Receivables Bank 6,000 2,000 1,000 9,000 20,000 Capital and Liabilities: Marshall Russell 10,000 8,000 Current liabilities Trade Payables 2,000 18,000 2,000 20,000 Show the different statement of financial positions given the different situations below after Sangster is introduced on 1 January 2005. (a) Sangster pays in a $8,000 cheque for capital, plus another $3,000 for his share of the goodwill; or instead (b) Sangster pays in an $8,000 cheque for capital; the $3,000 for goodwill is paid privately by him to Marshall & Russell; or instead (c) a goodwill account is to be opened of total estimated value $12,000. Sangster pays into the business a cheque for $8,000 only in respect of capital. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Partnership Lecture Notes 3 – Dissolution of Partnerships The Dissolution of a partnership may be caused by many factors including: a) Insolvency – the inability to continue because the partnership cannot meet its financial obligations. b) A decision of the partners not to continue, in order perhaps that each may go his own way. c) The term of the partnership has expired, or the purpose for which the partnership was created has been accomplished. d) One partner has given notice to the other partner(s) e) The partnership is now illegal e.g. one partner can no longer legally own a business f) There is a court order, e.g. When one of the partners is certified as being of unsound mind or a partner is unable to perform his part of the partnership contract. g) The death or retirement of Partner. The Realization Account The dissolution of partnership involves the disposal (realization) of the assets. Inevitably the amounts realized will differ from the book value and a profit or loss will result. The bookkeeping is: a) Debit the realization account Credit the Asset Account with the book values of the assets being realized. b) Debit the Creditors A/c and Credit the realization account with the creditors who will be paid off. c) Debit the Cash Book and Credit the realization account with the proceeds of disposal of the assets. d) Debit the realization account and credit the cash book with the amount paid to creditors e) Distribute the overall difference (profit or loss) among the partners in the profit sharing ratio by debiting (in case of a profit) or crediting (in case of a loss) the realization and credit (in case of a profit) or debit (in case of a loss) the partners’ capital a/c. f) Complete the dissolution by paying to partners the balances on their capital/current accounts by debiting the partners’ capital a/c and crediting the cash book. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Example The statement of financial position of Vanessa and Julie at December 31, 2004 was as follows: $ $ Non-Current Assets Current Assets Inventory 6,800 Trade Rec. 4,750 Cash at Bank 150 $ 14,000 Capital: Vanessa Julie Current Accounts Vanessa Julie Trade Payables 11,700 _____ 25,700 10,000 9,000 1,900 1,700 3,100 25,700 The partnership was dissolved at January 31, 2005 a) The motor cars included in non-current assets were taken by the partners at agreed values as Vanessa $2,000, Julie $3,000 b) The remainder of the non-current assets were sold for $12,000 c) The Inventory was sold at auction for $4,300 d) The trade receivables realized $4,600 e) The trade payables were paid off less a 5% discount f) Expenses of realization were $250 g) The profit sharing formula is :10% interest on capital, Balance 3:2 Required: Show relevant accounts in the dissolution Non-current Assets Inventory Trade Receivables Trade Payables Expenses Profit on realization: Vanessa 153 Julie 102 Realization Account $ 14,000 Car taken by Vanessa 6,800 Car Taken by Julie 4,750 Proceeds of sales of NC assets 2,945 Proceeds of sales of Inventory 250 Trade Receivables Trade Payables 255 29,000 LECTURE NOTES $ 2,000 3,000 12,000 4,300 4,600 3,100 29,000 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Cash $ Balance b/d Proceeds from Non-current Assets Proceeds from Inventory Proceeds from Trade Receivables 150 12,000 4,300 4,600 21,050 Vanessa $ 2,000 10,053 Cars Cash 12,053 $ 2,945 250 Trade Payables Expenses Vanessa 10,053 Julie 7,802 Capital Accounts Julie $ 3,000 Balance b/f 7,802 Current accounts b/f Share of profit on realization 10,802 17,855 21,050 Vanessa $ 10,000 1,900 Julie $ 9,000 1,700 153 102 12,053 10,802 Procedures for Dissolution of Partnership a) Assets to be realized are debited to realization account. b) The proceeds of the realization are credited to realization account and debited to cash or in the case of the partners’ cars to the partners. c) Trade Payables are usually put through the realization account if a profit or loss is involved, as here. d) There are often some expenses of realization e) The profit/loss is shared in profit/loss sharing ratio – the interest on capital part of the formula is irrelevant as no efflux ion of time is involved. f) There is no need to show the account of the assets as they are simply (eg): Inventory Account $ $ Balance B/d 6,800 Transfer to Realization a/c 6,800 6,800 6,800 g) The capital and current accounts are put together in the dissolution of a partnership, since their difference is no longer relevant. As a going concern capital accounts are not payable to partners as they are permanent capital. Current accounts are payable to partners as they are undrawn profits. h) When all the assets have been realized and the creditors paid off, there are only three balances left: An Asset – cash 17,855 Two Liabilities: Vanessa 10,053 Julie 7,802 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The asset matches the liabilities and can be used to pay them off, leaving no balances at all in the double entry system. Partners owing the Partnership at Dissolution The case of Garner v Murray 1904 addresses the issue of when a partner finishing up in a debit (i.e. owing the partnership money) and has no assets. In such, cases the remaining partners are debited with the balance in accordance with the ratio of their partnership capital accounts. The rule is not followed in all countries and in USA and elsewhere the loss would be debited in profit/loss sharing ratio. Example Tom, Roger, and James are in partnership sharing profits equally. Their statement of financial position at May 31, 2004 was: $ Non-current Assets Inventory Trade Receivables $ 6,006 9,500 7,800 Capital: Tom Roger James Trade Payables Overdraft _____ 23,306 On June 1, 2004 the partnership was dissolved and the following happened: 1. The assets were sold to RPH Ltd for $20,000 only 2. The trade payables were settled for $6,103 3. James was declared bankrupt with no assets Non-current Assets Inventory Trade Receivables Cash paid to Creditors Realization Account $ 6,006 RPH Ltd - Cash 9,500 Trade Payables 7,800 Loss on Realization: Tom 6,103 Roger James 29,409 4,000 3,000 416 6,250 9,640 23,306 $ 20,000 6,250 1,053 1,053 1,053 3,159 29,409 Cash RPH Ltd $ 20,000 Balance b/f Trade Payables Tom Roger 20,000 LECTURE NOTES $ 9,640 6,103 2,583 1,674 20,000 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA Share in Loss Gv M Cash ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Tom $ 1,053 364 2,583 4,000 Capital Accounts Roger James $ $ 1,053 1,053 Balance b/f 273 Gv M 1,674 3,000 1,053 TROY J. WISHART Tom $ 4,000 Roger $ 3,000 James $ 416 637 4,000 3,000 1,053 How to Work Problem a) The first step is to open a realization account and transfer to it all the assets and the Trade Payables. b) The proceeds from the sale of assets $20,000 are credited to the realization account and debited to cash. c) Cash is credited and realization account debited with the payment to the Trade Payables. d) The loss on realization is credited to realization account and debited in equal shares (the profit/loss sharing ratio). e) James’s account is in debit, meaning that he owes the partnership $637. As he is bankrupt he cannot pay it so the debit balance has to be written off. This is done by debiting the remaining partners in accordance with the rule in Garner v Murray 1904. Thus the amount is apportioned in the ratio of their last agreed capital accounts ($4,000:$3,000). f) The only remaining balances are cash Dr. $4,257 and the capital accounts of Tom Cr. $2,583 and Roger $1,674. The books are cleared by payments to the partners. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Accounting for Limited Liability Companies Lecture Notes Definition A Limited Liability Company is an organization owned by its shareholders, whose liability is limited to their share capital. The Need for limited Liability Companies There are two reasons why there is a need for limited companies: 1. Expansion of the Company and the need for additional capital 2. Safe guarding owners’ private assets through Limited Liability Types of Limited Companies 1. Private Companies 2. Public Companies A Private Company: Has a minimum membership of 2 Does not have more than 50 members (in Jamaica not more than 20), although there also can be extra members who are working or have worked for the company. Must ask people to buy company shares privately: it cannot do so in public. Any company that does not follow the above is a public company. It must have at least 7 members and can have as many members as it wants. Characteristics of Limited Companies These include: 1. Legal Personality: a company is regarded as having separate legal personality. It is an artificial person that can own, make contracts, sue and be sued. The company is a separate entity distinct from those who own it. 2. Perpetual Succession: As a company is a separate entity, its ownership can change without changing the company itself. 3. Limited Liability: The owners of a company (known as its members or its shareholders) are not liable for the debts of the company. 4. Stockholders are not Corporate Agents – A Limited Liability Company acts through its agents, who are officers or managers of the company. Stockholders/shareholders who are not officers LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART or managers of the corporation do not have the power to bind the corporation to contracts. This is referred to as lack of mutual agency. Instead stockholders participate in the affairs of the company by voting in stockholder meetings. 5. Corporate Tax – Corporations are subject to the same property and payroll taxes as sole proprietorships and partnerships. However, Limited Liability Companies are subject to additional taxes not levied on either of these other forms of companies, that is, Corporation Tax. This results in the income of a Limited Liability Company being taxed twice, first as income of the company and second as personal income to shareholders when cash is distributed to them as dividends. This is called double taxation. 6. Owners can Manage – All owners of a Limited Liability Company can be involved in managing the business without losing liability protection. 7. Residual Equity –When a company has only one class of stock it is identified as common stock. Common stock represents residual equity, meaning that creditors rank ahead of common shareholders if the corporation is liquidated. What Does Limited Liability mean? Limited Liability means that the owners’ liability for a company’s debts in the event that the company dissolves is equal to the amount of shares they have invested in the company. This means that they will lose the monies they have invested for their shares in the company in the event that the company’s assets cannot pay for its debt. However, shareholders who have partly paid for their shares can be forced to pay the balance owing on the shares. Thus limited liability is a major advantage of turning a business into a limited liability company. However, in practice, banks will normally seek personal guarantees from shareholders before making loans or granting an overdraft facility and so the advantage of limited liability is lost to a small owner managed business. Another advantage is that the retirement or death of one of its members does not necessitate dissolution and re-formation of the firm. Disadvantages of Limited Liability Companies Compliance with national legislation in having to prepare annual accounts and have them audited, file annual returns and keep statutory books. Greater administrative and financial burden. Compliance with national accounting standards and /or IFRS Any formation and registration costs LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Shareholders Those persons who would have applied for, bought, and received shares from a Limited Company, which ultimately means that they gain ownership in the company. A Shareholder usually receives a share of the profits called Dividends. Shares are usually issued to shareholders at par value or may exceed their par value. For example, a company might issue 100,000 $1 shares at a price of $1.20 each. Subscribers will then pay a total of $120,000. The issued share capital of the company would be shown in its accounts at par values, $100,000; the excess of $20,000 is described not as share capital, but as Share Premium or Capital paid-up in excess of par value. Rights of Shareholders When investors buy a company’s stock, they acquire all specific rights granted by the company’s charter to shareholders. They also acquire general rights granted shareholders by the law. Common Shareholders usually have the general right to: 1. Vote at shareholders meeting 2. Sell or otherwise dispose of their share 3. Purchase their proportional share of any common stock later issued by the corporation. This right is called Preemptive Right. It protects shareholders proportionate interest in the corporation. For example, a shareholder who owns 25% of a company’s common stock has the first opportunity to buy 25% of any new common stock issued. This enables the stockholder to maintain a 25% interest if desired. 4. Share equally with other common stockholders in any dividends. This means each common share receives the same dividend. 5. Share equally in any assets remaining after creditors are paid when, and if, the company is liquidated. This means each common share receives the same amount of remaining liquidated assets. 6. Shareholders have the right to receive timely reports on the company’s financial position and results of operations. Share Capital In preparing a statement of financial position the following is applicable: Ordinary and preference share capital Reserves Loan Stock LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART The Capital of Limited Liability Companies The proprietor’s capital in a limited Liability company consists of SHARE CAPITAL. When a company is set up for the first time, it issues shares which are paid for by investors, who then become shareholders of the company. Shares are denominated in units of 25 cents, 50 cents, $1 or whatever seems appropriate. The ‘face value’ of the shares is called their par value (or sometimes the nominal value). Shares Share is the division of capital of a limited company into parts. There are two main types of shares: A. Preference Shares – are shares which confer certain preferential rights on their holder. Preference shares carry the right to a final dividend which is expressed as a percentage of their par value: e.g. 6% $1 preference share carries a right to annual dividend of 6c. Preference dividends; in other words, if the managers of a company wish to pay a dividend (which they are not obliged to do) they must pay any preference dividend first. Otherwise, no ordinary dividend maybe paid. The Rights of Preference Shareholders may be as follows or as set out in the Company’s constitution: Preference shareholders have a priority right over ordinary shareholders to a return of their capital if the company goes into liquidation. Preference shares do not carry a right to vote Classification of Preference Shares Redeemable Preference Shares mean that the company will redeem (repay) the nominal value of those shares at a later date. For example, redeemable 5% $1 preference shares 20X9 means that the company will pay these shareholders$1 for every share they hold on a certain date in 20X9. The shares will then be cancelled and no further dividends paid. Redeemable preference shares are treated like loans and are included as non-current liabilities in the statement of financial position. It is usually reclassified as current liabilities if the redemption becomes due within 12 months. Dividend paid on redeemable preference shares are treated like interest paid on loans and are included in financial costs in the income statement. Irredeemable Preference Shares are treated just like other shares. They form part of equity and their dividends are treated as appropriations of profit. Types of Preference Shares 1. Non-cumulative Preference Shares – These can receive a dividend up to an agreed percentage each year. If the amount paid is less than the maximum agreed amount, the shortage is lost by the shareholders. They cannot carry forward that shortage and get it in the future year. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART 2. Cumulative Preference Shares – These also have an agreed maximum percentage dividend. However any shortage of dividend paid in a year can be carried forward. These arrears of preference dividends will have to be paid before the ordinary shareholders receive anything. B. Ordinary Shares – are shares which are not preferred with regard to dividend payments. Thus a holder only receives divided after fixed dividends have been paid to preference shareholders. There is no upper limit to the amount of dividends they can receive. Generally, however, only part of such remaining profits is distributed, the rest being kept in reserve. Should the company be wound up, any surplus not distributed is shared between the ordinary shareholders. Ordinary shares normally carry voting rights. Ordinary shareholders are thus the effective owners of a company. They own the equity of the business, and any reserves of the business belong to them. Ordinary shareholders are sometimes referred to as equity shareholders. (Preference shareholders are in many ways more like payables of the company, although legally they are members, not payables.) Different Meanings of Share Capital The term ‘share capital’ can have any of the following meanings: Authorized Share Capital – Sometimes known as registered capital or nominal capital. This is the maximum of the share capital, which the company is allowed to issue to shareholders, which can only be changed by agreement. For example The Normandy Company might be authorized by its charter to issue a maximum 500,000 ordinary shares of $1 each. Issued Share Capital – This is the total of the share capital actually issued to shareholders. If all of the authorized share capital has been issued, then both authorized and issued share capital would be the same amount. However, the amount of issued capital cannot exceed the amount of authorized capital. For example, out of the 500,000 ordinary $1 share the Normandy Company issued 400,000 shares. This would leave it the option to issue 100,000 more shares at some time in the future. When share capital is issued, shares are allotted to shareholders. The term allotted share capital is means the same thing as issued share capital. Called-up Capital – When shares are issued or allotted, a company does not always expect to be paid the full amount for the shares at once. It might instead call up only a part of the issue price, and wait until at a later time before it calls up the reminder. Where only part of the amounts payable on each share has been asked for, the total amount asked for on all shares is known as the called-up capital. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART For example, since Normandy Company allotted 400,000 ordinary shares $1, it might call up only, say, 75 cents per share. The issue share capital would be $400,000, but the called-up share capital would only be $300,000 Uncalled Capital – This is the total amount that is to be received in future, but which has not yet been asked for. As such, from the example above the uncalled share capital will be $100,000. Paid up Capital – Like everyone else, investors are not always prompt or reliable payers. When capital is called up shareholders might delay (or even default on payment). This is the total of the amount of share capital that has been paid for by shareholders. It is the amount of calledup capital that has been paid For example, if Normandy only received payments on the share capital called-up of $290,000, then this is their paid up capital and there is $10,000 of calls in arrears. Calls in arrears – The total amount for which payments has been asked for (i.e. called for), but has not yet been paid shareholders. The statement of financial position would appear as follows: Assets Calls in Arrears 10,000 Cash (called-up capital paid) 290,000 300,000 Equity Called-up ordinary share capital (400,000 ordinary shares of $1, with 75c per share called up) 300,000 Issuance of Shares/Stock Stocks or shares for companies are usually issues at: Par Value No-Par Value Stated Value Illustration Dillon Snowboards Inc. was authorized to issue 500,000, $10 Par Value ordinary shares & 100,000, Par Value, $100 preferred shares. The Belize Family was issued 30,000 ordinary shares at par value. Mr. Amsterdam was issued with a similar amount of shares at $12 per share. Lillian was given a special concession to purchase 10,000 par value ordinary shares at $8 per share. Before the company was formed James was issued with 1,000 ordinary @ $40 per share in order to raise funds for pay the startup cost of the company. The directors had also decided just before the share prices were set to issue James with a further 5,000 $40 stated value ordinary shares at $50 per share. Mark was issued with 40,000 par value ordinary shares in exchange for a land valued at $200,000 and building value at LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART $250,0000. Ram’s Consultancy chose to render their services ($30,000) in exchange for 3,000 par value ordinary shares. Dominoes Investments purchased 10,000, par value Preferred shares at $110 per share. Par Value Stock Many stocks carry a value called par value that is established at the time the stock is authorized. Par value stock is a class of stock assigned a par value per share by the company in its charter. Par Value stock can be issued at par, at a premium, or at a discount. In each of these transactions, the stock may be exchanged for either cash or non-cash assets. Issuing Par Value Stock at a par –When we issue common stock at par value, we record amounts for both the asset (s) received and the par value stock issued, Stock is most commonly issued in exchange for cash. Issuing Par Value stock at a Premium –A premium on stock is an amount paid in excess of par by the purchasers of issued stock. When a company sells its stock for more than par value, the stock is said to be issued at a premium. This premium is reported on the statement of financial position as part of stockholders’ equity. It is not revenue and is not listed on the income statement. Accounting for stock sold at a price greater than its par value involves recording the premium separately from par value. This premium accounts is called Contributed Capital Excess of Par Value. This is also called Premium or Common Stock Account. Issuing Par Value at a Discount – A discount on stock is the difference between par value and issue price when the issue price is below par value. If stock is issued at less than par, the discount is debited to a Discount on Common Stock Account. This account is a contra to the common stock account, and its balance is subtracted from the par value of the stock on the statement of financial position. A discount is not an expense and does not appear on the income statement. No-Par Value Stock No-par value stock or simply no-par stock, is stock not assigned a value per share by the corporate charter. When no-par stock is issued and is not assigned a stated value, the amount received by the company becomes legal capital and is recorded as Common Stock. This means the entire proceeds are credited to a no-par stock account. Stated Value Stock Stated value stock is no-par stock that is assigned a “stated” value per share by the directors. When no-par stock is issued and is assigned a stated value, its stated value becomes legal capital and is credited to a no-par stock account. Assuming stated value stock is issued at an amount in excess of the total stated value; the excess is credited to Contributed Capital in Excess of Stated Value, No-Par Common Stock. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Issuing Stock for non-cash Assets A company can receive assets other than cash in exchange for its stock. The company records the assets received at the assets’ market values as of the date of the transaction. The stock given in exchange is recorded at its par (or stated) value with any excess recorded in the Contributed Capital in Excess of Par Account. If reliable market values for the assets received cannot be determined, the market value of the stock given up is used to estimate the assets’ values. Share Issue Costs A company sometimes gives shares of its stock to promoters in exchange for their services in organizing the company. The company receives the intangible asset Organization Cost in exchange for this stock. Issuing Stock through Subscriptions Stock is usually sold for cash and immediately issued. However, companies issue stock through stock subscriptions. A stock Subscription involves selling stock where the investor agrees to buy a certain number of shares at specified future dates and prices. The typical case is when a new company is formed and the organizer recognizes both an immediate and future need for capital. The organizers can sell stock to investors who agree to contribute some cash now and to make additional contributions in the future. Accounting for Common Stock Accounting for the issuance of common stock involves (1) identifying the sources and amounts of contributed capital and (2) keeping contributed capital separate from retained earnings. Issuance of stock affects only contributed capital accounts; no retained earnings accounts are affected. The company should also distinguish between stock issued at par, premium, discount, stated value, or no par value. Issuing Preferred Stock Preferred stock usually has a par value. Like common stock, it can be sold at a price different from par. Separate contributed capital accounts are used to record preferred stock. Issuing no-par preferred stock is similar to issuing no-par common stock. In addition, the entries for issuing preferred stock for non-cash are treated similarly to entries for common stock. Market Value of Shares Market value per share is the price at which a stock is bought or sold outside of the companies issuance or purchases. Market value is influenced by a variety of factors such as expected future earnings, dividends, growth, and other company and economic events. Nearly all these techniques use LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART accounting information as an important input for the valuation process. However, today’s market value of previously issued shares does not affect that organization’s shareholders’ equity accounts. The par value of shares will be different from their market value, which is the price at which someone is prepared to purchase shares in a company from an existing shareholder. If Mr. A Owns 1,000 $1 shares in Z Co. he may sell them to B for $1.60 each. This transfer of existing shares does not affect Z Co’s own financial position in any way whatsoever, and apart from changing the register of members. Z Co. does not have to bother with the sale by Mr. A to Mr. B at all. There are certainly no accounting entries to be made for the share sale. Shares in private companies do not change hands very often, hence their market value is often hard to estimate. Companies listed on a stock exchange are quoted, i.e. it is the market value of the shares which is quoted. Reserves Even though the shareholders receive a share of the profit, not all the profits will be paid out as dividends. The directors calculate the net profit and decide how much to hold back as Reserves. Reserves accounts are accounts that hold appropriated profits to be used in the future. Reserves consists of those unused profits either remaining in the appropriation account, or transferred to a reserve account appropriately titled, e.g. general reserve, fixed assets replacement reserves, etc. All reserves, however, are owned by the ordinary shareholders, who own the ‘equity’ in the company. In most countries, a distinction must be made between the following: (a) Statutory Reserves, which are reserves a company is required to be set up by law, and which are not available for distribution of dividends. (b) Non-Statutory Reserves, which are reserves consisting of profits which are distributable as dividends, if the company so wishes. Statutory reserves are capital reserves (share premium, revaluation) and non-statutory reserves are revenue reserves. Loan Stock or Bonds (Debentures) Limited liability companies may issue loan stock or bonds. These are long-term liabilities and in some countries they are described as loan capital because they are means of raising finance, in the same way as issuing share capital raises finance. They are different from share capital in the following ways: 1. Shareholders are members of a company, while providers of loan capital are creditors. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART 2. Shareholders receive dividends (appropriations of profit) whereas the holders of loan capital are entitled to a fixed rate of interest (an expense charged against revenue). 3. Loan Capital holders can take legal action against a company if their interest is not paid when due, whereas shareholders cannot enforce the payment of dividends. 4. Loan stock is often secured on company assets, whereas shares are not. The holder of loan capital is generally in a less risky position than the shareholder. He has greater security, although his income is fixed and cannot grow, unlike ordinary dividends. Interest is calculated on the par or legal value of loan capital, regardless of its market value. If a company has $700,000 (par value) 12% loan stock in issue, interest of $84,000 will be charged to the income statement per year. Accounting for an Issue of Debentures Another way of raising the necessary finance for a firm is to issue debentures. By this method people lend money to a company, and are given a debenture deed, which show the rate of interest that is to be paid on the debenture each year. The accounting for a debenture issue follows a similar pattern to that of shares. Thus if we had 10 debentures of $1,000 each to issue and exactly this amount was applied for, then the accounts would appear as follows: Illustration Debentures are also called Unsecured Bonds and are backed by the issuer’s general credit standing. Unsecured Bonds are almost always more risky that secured bonds. Because of this added risk, a company generally must be financially strong, to successfully issue debentures at a favorable rate of interest. Companies also can issue debentures whose claims on company’s assets are second to those of other unsecured liabilities. These debentures are called subordinated debentures, meaning these creditors’ claims are subordinated to the claims of some others. Shareholders’ Equity Shareholders’ equity consists of the following: (a) The par value of issued capital (minus any amounts not yet called up on issued shares) (b) Other Equity – consists of four elements:(i) Capital paid in excess of par value (Share premium) (ii) Revaluation Surplus (iii) Reserves (iv) Retained Earnings LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Share Premium – is the difference between the issue price of the share and its par value. If a company does well, the market value of its shares will increase, but not the par value. The difference between cash received by the company and the par value of the new shares issued is transferred to a Share Premium Account. The share premium account cannot be distributed as dividend under any circumstances so as to maintain the capital base of the company and provide some security to creditors. Revaluation Surplus – is the result of an upward revaluation of non-current assets. This is nondistributable as it represents unrealized profits on the revalued assets. It is another capital reserve. The relevant part of a revaluation surplus can only become realized if the asset in question is sold, thus realizing the gain. The revaluation surplus may fall, however, if an asset which had previously been revalued upwards suffered a fall in value in the next revaluation. Retained Earnings – are profits earned by the company and not appropriated by dividends, taxation or transfer to another reserve account. This is the most significant reserve and is variously described as: a) b) c) d) e) Revenue Reserve Retained Profits Accumulated Profits Undistributed Profits Unappropriated Profits Accumulated Retained Earnings over the years can be used to pay dividends even if a loss has been made or profit is low in one particular year. A debit balance on the retained earnings account indicates that the company has accumulated losses. For example, if a company makes a loss of $100,000 in one year, yet has unappropriated profits from previous years totalling $250,000, it can pay a dividend not exceeding $150,000. Financial Statements of Limited Liability Companies The accounting rules and conventions are much the same as for sole traders. Companies will have a cash book, sales day book, purchase day book, journal, sales ledger, purchases ledger and nominal ledger. They will prepare an Income Statement annually and a statement of financial position at the end of the accounting year. The financial statements of limited liability companies are usually governed by national legislation and accounting standards. From an international standpoint, however, the general content of financial statements is governed by IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements. This standard is concerned LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART with financial statements produced for external reporting purposes, that is, external users. The standard looks at the statement of financial position and income statement. Income Statement The Income Statement is the most significant indicator of a company’s financial performance. IAS 1 stipulates that all items of income and expense recognized in a period shall be included in profit and loss unless a standard or an interpretation requires otherwise. The Accounting Concepts used for a Company’s Income Statement are similar to those of a Sole Trader, that is The Matching Concept, that applies to revenue and expenses so that there would be need to adjust for accruals and prepayment. There are two main expenses that are found in a Limited Company’s Income Statements that is different from that of a Sole Trader’s Income Statement: 1. Directors’ Remuneration – Directors are legally employees of the company, appointed by the shareholders. Their remuneration is charged to the main profit and loss account, even when the director is also a shareholder. 2. Loan Stock/Debenture Interest – The term debenture/loan stock refers to monies received by the company as a loan from someone. A special written agreement shows all the agreed terms for the debenture. For this loan, the lender is paid interest at an agreed percentage. This is known as debenture interest. It must be paid even if the company is making a loss. In contrast, dividends are payable only if profits have been made. Debenture interest is an expense to be charged in the main profit and loss account. The Appropriation Account The Appropriation account shows how the profits are to be appropriated or used. Net Profit for the year – This is the net profit brought down from the main profit and loss account. Balance brought forward from the last year – Not all profit may be appropriated during a period. This then will be the balance on the appropriation account, as brought forward from the previous year. Transfers to reserves – The directors may decide that some of the profits should not be included in the calculation of how much should be paid out as dividends. These profits are transferred to reserve accounts. There may be a specific reason for the transfer, such as a need to replace fixed assets; in this case an amount would be transferred to a fixed assets replacement reserve. Or the reason may not be specific; in this case an amount would be transferred to a general reserve account. Amounts written off as goodwill – Goodwill in a company may have amounts written off it from time to time. When this is done the amount written off should be shown in the appropriation account and not in the main profit and loss account. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Amounts written off as preliminary expenses – When a company is formed, there are many kinds of expenses concerned with its formation, e.g. legal expenses and various government taxes. The amount of the preliminary expenses can be written off and charged in the appropriation account. Taxation payable on profits – Taxation is an appropriation of profits and would be shown as a debit in the appropriation account. It affects both the statement of financial position and the income statement; where the charge for the year is shown as a deduction from net profit and as a tax payable (current liability) to the government in the statement of financial position. All companies pay some kind of corporate taxation on the profits they earn, since the company has a separate legal personality. This tax is included in their accounts. Dividends – are appropriations of profit after tax. Out of the remainder of the profits, the directors propose the amount of dividends to be paid. Balance carried forward to next year – After the dividends have been proposed, there will probably be some profits that have not been appropriated. These profits will be carried forward to the following year. These are usually known as retained profits. Interrelationship of Income Statement and Statement of Financial Position When we were with dealing financial statements of sole traders, we transferred the net profit to capital account. In the case of limited liability companies, the net profit is transferred to retained earnings in the statement of changes in equity (SOCIE). The closing balance of the accounts in the SOCIE is then transferred to the statement of financial position. The Statement of Financial Position The statement of financial position must conform to the regulations specified in the Companies Act. Non-current assets – include tangible and intangible operating and financial assets of a longterm nature. They should normally be shown at cost or at some other valuation. In either case the method chosen should be clearly stated. However, only the totals are shown on the face of the statement of financial position; the details are given in the notes. The total depreciation - from the date of purchase to the date of the statement of financial position should be shown clearly in the notes. Current Assets – should be classified as such when it: o is expected to be realized, or is held for sale or consumption in, the entity’s normal operating cycle; or o is held primarily for the purpose of being traded o is expected to be realized within 12 months after the reporting date o is cash or cash equivalent which is not restricted in its use. Equity – Movements in share capital and reserves must be reported in the statement of changes in equity (SOCIE). LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Capital reserves usually have to be set up by law, whereas revenue reserves are appropriations of profit. With a sole trader, profit was added to capital. However, in a limited liability company, share capital and profit have to be disclosed separately, because profit distributable but share capital cannot be distributed. Therefore retained profits are kept in the retained earnings reserve. In addition, the authorized share capital when it is different from the issued share capital is shown as a note. It is not added into the statement of financial position totals. When shares are only partly called up, it is the amount actually called up that appears in the statement of financial position and not the full amount. A total for share capital plus reserves should be shown. Stockholders’ Equity - The equity of a company is known as stockholders’ equity, also called shareholders’ equity or corporate capital. Stockholders’ equity consists of (1) contributed (or paid-up) capital (2) retained earnings. Contributed Capital is the total amount of cash and other assets received by the corporation from its stockholders in exchange from common stock. Retained Earnings is the cumulative net income retained in a company. Concepts – The statement of financial position makes use of the accounting concepts that: Assets = Capital + Liabilities The statement of financial position is also prepared according to the Business Entity Convention (that a business is separate from its owners). Liabilities – are split between current and non-current or as a consequence decision whether or not to classify such. When an entity chooses not to classify it liabilities into current and noncurrent, it should present them broadly in order of their liquidity. Current Liabilities – A liability should be classified as a current liability when it: o is expected to be settled in the entity’s normal operating cycle; or o is due to be settled within 12 months of the reporting date o is held primarily for the purpose of being traded. There are also current liabilities which are not settled as part of the normal operating cycle, but which are due to be settled within 12 months of the reporting date. These include bank overdrafts, income taxes, other non-trade payables and the current portion of interest-bearing liabilities. Any interest-bearing liabilities that are used to finance working capital on a longterm basis, and that are not due to for settlement within 12 months, should be classed as noncurrent liabilities. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Accounting for Limited Liability Companies WORKSHEET Question 1 Draw up a statement of financial position for a limited liability company R.O. Ltd from the following at December 31, 2004 $ Premises at cost 45,000 Machinery at cost 24,000 Fixtures at cost 12,000 Inventory 18,000 Bank 6,000 Trade Receivables 9,000 Depreciation to date: Premises 18,000 Machinery 7,200 Fixtures 4,800 Authorized Share Capital: Ordinary share $1 60,000 Issued Share Capital: fully paid 36,000 Debentures: 10% 18,000 Proposed dividend owing 3,000 Trade Payables 9,000 General Reserve 15,000 Income Statement Profit ? Question 2 C.A. Company Ltd. Manufacturing agricultural implement, made a net profit after taxation of $210,000 for the year to December 31, 2002. Retained profits at December 31, 2001 amounted to $17,000. At the directors’ meeting, the following were agreed. To be transferred to general reserve To be transferred to foreign exchange reserve Goodwill to be written off $ 30,000 5,000 11,000 It has also been agreed that a dividend of 10% be proposed on the ordinary share capital. This amounted to 500,000 shares of $2 each. Preference share dividends of 10% had been paid during the year on 250,000 preference shares of $1 each. You are required to draw up the company’s profit and loss appropriation account for the year ended December 31, 2002. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Question 3 Barton Corporation began operations on January 1, 1999. The following transactions relating to stockholders’ equity occurred in the first two years of the company’s’ operations. 1999 Jan 1 Authorized the issuance of 2 million shares of $5 par value common stock and 100,000 shares of $100 par value, 10 % cumulative, preferred stock. Jan 2 Issued 200,000 shares of common stock for cash at $12 per share. Jan 3 Issued 100,000 shares of common stock in exchange for a building valued at $820,000 and merchandise inventory valued at $380,000. Jan 4 Paid cash to company’s founders for $100,000 of organizations costs; these costs are to be amortized over 10 years. Jan 5 Issued 12,000 shares of preferred stock at $110 per share. 2000 June 4 Issued 100,000 shares of common stock for cash at $15 per share. Required 1. Prepare journal entries to record these transactions. 2. Prepare the stockholders’ equity section of the statement of financial position as at December 31, 1999 and December 31, 2000, based on these transactions. 3. Prepare a schedule showing dividend allocations and dividends per share for 1999 and 2000 given Barton declares the following cash dividend 1999 …. $50,000 2000 …. $300,000 4. Prepare the journal entry for Barton’s issuance of $200,000 shares of common stock for cash at $12 per share assuming: a) Common Stock in no-par stock without a stated value b) Common Stock is no-par stock with a stated value of $10 per share. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Question 4 USB, a limited liability company, has the following trial balance at 31 December 20X9. Debit $’000 100 2,400 2,206 650 Cash at bank Inventory at 1 January 20X9 Administrative expenses Distribution costs Non-current assets at cost: Buildings Plant and equipment Motor vehicles Suspense Accumulated depreciation Buildings Plant and equipment Motor vehicles Retained earnings Trade receivables Purchases Dividend paid Sales revenue Sales tax payable Trade payables Share premium $1 ordinary shares Credit $’000 10,000 1,400 320 1,500 4,000 480 120 560 876 4,200 200 22,352 11,752 1,390 1,050 500 1,000 22,352 The following additional information is relevant. (a) Inventory at 31 December 20X9 was valued at $1,600,000. While doing the inventory count, errors in the previous year’s inventory count were discovered. The inventory brought forward at the beginning of the year should have been $2.2m, not $2.4m as above. (b) Depreciation is to be provided as follows: (i) Buildings at 5% straight line, charged to administrative expenses. (ii) Plant and equipment at 20% on the reducing balance basis, charged to cost of sales. (iii) Motor vehicles at 25% on the reducing balance basis, charged to distribution costs. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART (c) No final dividend is being proposed. (d) A customer has gone bankrupt owing $76,000. This debt is not expected to be recovered and an adjustment should be made. An allowance for receivables of 5% is to be set up. (e) 1 million new ordinary shares were issued at $1.50 on 1 December 20X9. The proceeds have been left in a suspense account. Required Prepare the income statement for the year to 31 December 20X9, a statement of changes in equity and a statement of financial position at that date in accordance with the requirements of International Financial reporting Standards. Ignore taxation. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Reporting & Analyzing Cash Flows Lecture Notes Profitability is a primary goal of most managers. But it is not the only goal. A company cannot achieve or maintain profits without careful management of cash. Manager (internal users) and other users (external users) of information pay close attention to a company’s cash position and the events and transactions affecting cash. Internal users rely on the statement of cash flows to make investing and financing decisions. External users rely on this statement to assess the amount and timing of a company’s cash flows. Information about these events and transactions are reported in the statement of cash flows. International Accounting Standards define cash flows as the Net Monetary Assets – meaning cash demand deposits, and highly liquid investments minus short-term loans. An income statement reports revenues, gains, expenses, and losses on an accrual basis (earned or incurred). The statement of cash flows reports cash received and cash paid for operating, financing, and investing activities. Purpose of the Statement of Cash Flows The purpose of the statement of cash flows is to report all major cash receipts (inflows) and cash payments (outflows) during a period. This includes separately indentifying the cash flows related to operating, investing, and financing activities. The statement of cash flows does more than simply report changes in cash. It is the detailed disclosure of individual cash flows that makes this statement useful to users. Information in this statement helps users answer questions such as: How does a company obtain its cash? Where does a company spend its cash? What explains the change in the cash balance? The statement of cash flows addresses these important questions by summarizing, classifying, and reporting a company’s cash inflows and outflows for each period. Importance of Cash Flows Cash Flows are important because: We look more favourably at a company that is financing its expenditures with cash from operations than one that does it by selling its assets. Information about cash flows also helps users decide whether a company has enough cash to pay its existing debts as they mature. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART It is also relied upon, especially by external users, to evaluate a company’s ability to meet unexpected obligations and pursue unexpected opportunities. Internal users such as managers use cash flow information to plan day-to-day operating activities and make long-term investment decisions. Measuring Cash Flows The Statement of Cash Flows measures the difference between the beginning and ending balances of cash and cash equivalents. Classifying Cash Flows All cash and cash equivalent receipts (except for cash received from selling cash equivalents) and payments are classified and reported on the statement as Operating, Investing, or Financing activities. Individual cash receipts for each of these categories are labeled to identify their source transactions or events. Cash receipts and payments are then summarized for each category by netting them against each other. A net cash inflow (source) occurs when the receipts in a category exceed the payments. A net cash outflow (use) occurs when the payments in a category exceed the receipts. Operating Activities Operating activities include the cash effects of transactions and events that determine net income. Some examples include the production and purchase of merchandise, the sale of goods and services to customers, and expenditures toward administering the business. But not all items in income, such as unusual gains and losses, are operating activities. Cash Inflows: Cash is received from sales to customers, collection on credit sales, lawsuit settlements, interest from borrowers, cash dividends received and selling of trading securities Cash Outflows: Cash is paid for salaries and wages, to lenders for interest, to charities, to purchase trading securities, to suppliers for goods and services, and to government taxes and fines. Investing Activities Investing activities include the (a) purchase and sale of long term assets, (b) the purchase and sale of short term investments other than cash equivalents, and (c) lending and collecting money the company loan to others. However, the interest collected on those loans should be reported as an operating activity. Cash Inflows: Cash is received from selling equity investments, selling (discounting) of loans, collecting principal on loans, selling long-term productive assets and selling debt investments. Cash Outflows: Cash is paid to make loans to others, to purchase debt investments, to purchase longterm assets and to purchase equity investments. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Financing Activities Financing activities include (a) obtaining cash from issuing debt (debentures/bonds) and repaying the amounts borrowed, and (b) obtaining cash from or distributing cash to owners (shares and dividends). These activities all involve transactions with a company’s owners and creditors. They also involve the borrowing and repaying of principal amounts relating to both short and long-term debt. But payments of interest expense are classified as operating activities. Cash Inflows: Cash is received from contributions by owners, issuing bonds and notes, issuing its own equity stock, issuing short-term and long-term debt Cash Outflows: Cash is paid to repay cash loans, to pay withdrawals by owners, to pay dividends to shareholders and to purchase treasury stock. Noncash Investing and Financing There are often important investing and financing activities that do not affect cash receipts or payments. Yet because of their importance and the full disclosure principle, these important noncash investing and financing activities are disclosed at the bottom of the statement of cash flows or in a note to the financial statement. One example of such a transaction is the purchase of long term assets by giving a long term note payable. This transaction involves both investing and financing activities but it does not affect any cash inflows or outflow and is not reported in any of the three sections of the statement of cash flows. Some other examples are: Retirement of debt by issuing shares Conversion of preferred shares to ordinary shares Leasing of assets in capital lease transaction Purchase of long-term asset by issuing a note or bond Exchange of noncash assets for other noncash assets Purchase of noncash assets by issuing equity or debt. Format of the Statement of Cash Flows Accounting standards require companies to include a statement of cash flows in a complete set of financial statements. This statement must report information about a company’s cash receipts and cash payments during the period. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART COMPANY NAME Statement of Cash Flows For the period Ended (Date) $ Cash Flows from operating activities [List of individual inflows and outflows] Net cash provided (used) by operating activities ………..……… Cash Flows from investing activities [List of individual inflows and outflows] Net cash provided (used) by investing activities …………..…… Cash Flows from financing activities [List of individual inflows and outflows] Net cash provided (used) by financing activities ………………. Net increase (decrease) in cash ……………………………….… Cash (and equivalents) balance at the beginning of period Cash (and equivalents) balance at the end of period #### #### #### #### #### #### Preparing the Statement of Cash Flows Preparation of a statement of cash flows involves five (5) steps: 1. Compute the net increase or decrease in cash. It equals the current period cash balance minus the prior period’s cash balance. 2. Compute and report net cash provided (used) by operating activities (using either the direct or indirect method); 3. Compute and report net cash provided (used) by investing activities; 4. Compute and report net cash provided (used) by financing activities ; 5. Compute net cash flows by combining net cash provided (used) by operating, investing and financing activities and prove it by adding it to the beginning cash balance to show it equals the ending balance. Information to Prepare the Statement Information to prepare the statement of cash flows usually comes from three sources: 1. Comparative Statements of Financial Position at the beginning and end of the period. 2. Current Income Statement 3. Additional Information Comparative statements of financial position give us changes in non-cash accounts from the beginning to the end of the period. The current income statement gives us details to help compute cash flows from operating activities. Additional information often includes details on transactions and events helping us explain both the cash flows and noncash investing and financing activities. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Reporting Operating Cash Flows The net cash flows provided (used) by operating activities can be reported in one of two ways: the Direct Method or the Indirect Method. The Direct Method separately lists each major item of operating cash receipts (such as cash received from customers) and each major item of operating cash payments (such as cash paid for merchandise). The cash payments are subtracted from cash receipts to determine the net cash provided (used) by operating activities. The Indirect Method reports net income and then adjusts it for items necessary to give us net cash provided (used) by operating activities. It does not report individual items of cash inflows and cash outflows from operating activities. Instead, the indirect method reports the necessary adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided (used) by operating activities. A common adjustment is a subtraction for depreciation. Since depreciation expense is not a current cash payment, we add depreciation expense back to net income in our process of adjusting net income to get net cash provided (used) by operating activities. The indirect method of reporting cash flows does not provide as much detail about the sources and uses of cash as does the direct method. The direct method also is recommended by the FASB. But since the direct method is not required and the indirect method is arguably easier to compute, most companies report operating cash flows using the indirect method. Direct Method of Reporting We compute cash flows from operating activities under the direct method by adjusting accrual based income statement items to a cash basis. The usual approach is to adjust income statement accounts as follows: Revenue Or Expense Adjustments for Changes in Related SOFP Accounts Some of the major classes of operating cash flows are: Operating Cash Receipts o Customers o Renters o Interest o Dividends Operating Cash Payments o Suppliers o Employees o Operations o Interest o Taxes LECTURE NOTES Cash Receipts Or Cash Payments UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Illustration Financial Statements GENESIS Statement of Financial Position As at December 31, 2000 and 1999 2000 1999 Assets $ $ Non Current Assets Plant Assets 250,000 210,000 Accum. Depreciation 60,000 48,000 Total Non-Current Assets 190,000 162,000 GENESIS Income Statement For Year Ended December 31, 2000 $ $ Sales 590,000 Cost of Goods Sold 300,000 Wages & Op Exp 216,000 Interest Expense 7,000 Depreciation 24,000 (547,000) Current Assets Inventory Trade Receivables Cash Prepaid Expenses Total Current Assets Total Assets Other gains (losses): Loss on sale plant assets Income before taxes Income taxes expense Equity & Liabilities Shareholders’ Equity Ordinary Share, $5 par Retained Earnings Total Shareholders’ Equity Non Current Liabilities Bonds payables Current Liabilities Trade Payables Interest Payables Income Tax Payable Total Current Liabilities Total Liabilities Total Equity and Liabilities 84,000 60,000 17,000 6,000 167,000 357,000 70,000 40,000 12,000 4,000 126,000 288,000 Income from continuing op. (6,000) 37,000 (15,000) 22,000 Extraordinary item: Gain on retirement of debt 95,000 112,000 207,000 80,000 88,000 168,000 90,000 64,000 35,000 3,000 22,000 60,000 150,000 357,000 40,000 4,000 12,000 56,000 120,000 288,000 NET INCOME 16,000 38,000 Genesis discloses additional information about year 2000 transactions as follows: (a) Trade Payables balance result from merchandise purchases (b) Plant assets costing $70,000 are purchased by paying $10,000 cash and issuing $60,000 of bonds payable. (c) Plants assets with an original cost of $30,000 and accumulated depreciation of $12,000 are sold for $12,000 cash. This yields a $6,000 loss. (d) Cash received from issuing 3,000 shares of common stock is $15,000. (e) Paid $18,000 to retire bonds with a book value of $34,000. This yields a $16,000 gain. (f) Cash dividends of $14,000 are declared and paid. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Operating Cash Receipts Genesis suggests only one potential cash receipt- sales to customers. Cash Received from Customers – If all the sales are for cash, the amount of cash received from customers is equal to sales reported on the income statement. But when some are on account, we must adjust the amount of sales revenue for the changes in Trade Receivable. This is done by using a T account analysis as shown below Balance 12/31/1999 Sales Trade Receivable $ 40,000 Cash Collection 590,000 Balance 12/31/2000 630,000 $ 570,000 60,000 630,000 A trade receivable increase implies cash is less than sales and the converse is also true. As such, cash received from customers can also be derived from deducting an increase or adding a decrease in trade receivable to sales. Other cash receipts follow the same logic as above in computing their cash receipts. Therefore we compute cash received from these items by subtracting an increase in their respective receivable or adding a decrease. Operating Cash Payments Genesis shows four (4) operating expenses - cost of goods, wages and other expenses, interest, and taxes – all of which should be analyzed to compute their cash payments for the cash flow statement. Cash Paid for Inventory – Cash paid for inventory is computed by analyzing both the cost of goods sold and the inventory. If all inventories purchased are for cash and the ending balance of inventory is unchanged from the beginning balance, then the amount of cash paid for Inventory equals cost of goods sold. This is usually an uncommon occurrence and as such when the balances in Inventory and Trade Payables change, we must adjust cost of goods sold for changes in both of these accounts to compute cash paid for merchandise. This is a two (2) step adjustment. First, we use the change in the account balance of Inventory along with cost of goods sold amount to compute cost of purchases for the period. If Inventory increases, it implies we bought more than was sold and we add this inventory to cost of goods sold to compute cost of purchases. If Inventory decreases, it implies we bought less than was sold and we subtract the inventory decrease from cost of goods to compute purchases. The second step uses the change in the balance of trade payables along with the amount of cost of purchases to compute cash paid for merchandise. If trade payables decrease, it implies we paid for more goods than we acquired this period, and we then add the trade payables decrease to cost of purchases to compute cash paid for inventory. If trade payables increases, it implies we paid for less LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART than the amount of goods acquired, and we subtract the trade payables increase from the purchases to compute cash paid for merchandise. This is done by using a T account analysis as shown below: Balance 12/31/1999 Cost of Purchases Cash Payments Balance 12/31/2000 Inventory $ 70,000 Cost of goods sold 314,000 Balance 12/31/2000 384,000 $ 300,000 84,000 384,000 Trade Payables $ 319,000 Balance 12/31/1999 35,000 Purchases 354,000 $ 40,000 314,000 354,000 Cash Paid for Wages and Operating Expenses (Excluding Depreciation) – To compute cash paid for wages and other operating expenses, we adjust this amount for any changes in their related statement of financial position accounts. We begin by looking for any prepaid expenses and accrued liabilities related to wages and other operating expenses in the statement of financial position. Genesis has prepaid expenses but no accrued liabilities. This means its adjustment is limited to the change in prepaid expenses. The T account analysis is shown below: Balance 12/31/1999 Cash Payments Prepaid Expenses $ 4,000 Wages & Other Operating Exp. 218,000 Balance 12/31/2000 222,000 $ 216,000 6,000 222,000 If accrued liabilities decrease, it implies we paid cash for more goods or services than received this period, and we must add the decrease in accrued liabilities to the expense amount to get cash paid for these goods or services. If accrued liabilities increase, it implies we paid cash for less than what was acquired and we must subtract this increase in accrued liabilities from the expense amount to get cash paid. Cash Paid for Interest and Income Taxes – The analysis for computing operating cash flows for interest and taxes is similar to that for operating expenses. Both require adjustments to their amounts reported on the income statement for changes in their related statement of financial position accounts. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Interest Payable $ 8,000 Balance 12/31/1999 3,000 Interest Expense Interest Paid Balance 12/31/2000 11,000 Income Taxes Payable $ 5,000 Balance 12/31/1999 22,000 Income taxes Expense 27,000 Interest Paid Balance 12/31/2000 $ 4,000 7,000 11,000 $ 12,000 15,000 27,000 Analysis of Additional Expenses, Gains, or Losses – Genesis has three (3) additional items reported on its income statement: depreciation, loss on sale of assets, and gain on retirement of debt. Depreciation is the allocation of the depreciable cost of a purchased asset and as such it is a noncash expense which results in no cash flows. Sales of assets frequently result in Gains or Losses which is reported as part of net income. However, the gain or loss is not cash flow but the recognition of the difference between the net book value of the asset the cash inflow received. The retirement of a debt usually yields a loss or gain, but the amount recorded does not reflect cash flows. All of the above mentioned noncash items are not reported on the statement of cash flows using the direct method. Depletion and amortization expenses are treated similarly. Summary of Selected Adjustments for Direct Method ITEM From Income Statement Adjustments to get Cash Flow Numbers Receipts: From Sales Sales Revenue From Rent Rent Revenue From Interest Interest Revenue From Dividends Payments: Dividends Revenue To Suppliers For Operations To Employees Cost of Goods Sold Operating Expense Wages (Salaries) Exp. For Interest Interest Expense For Taxes Income Tax Expense Add Less Add Less Add Less Add Less Decrease in Trade Receivable Increase in Trade Receivable Decrease in Rent Receivable Increase in Rent Receivable Decrease in Interest Receivable Increase in Interest Receivable Decrease in Dividends Receivable Increase in Dividends Receivable Add Less Add Less Add Less Add Less Add Less Increase in Inventory Decrease in Inventory Increase in Prepayments Decrease in Prepayments Decrease in Wages (Salaries) Payable Increase in Wages (Salaries) Payable Decrease in Interest Payable Increase in Interest Payable Decrease in Income Tax Payable Increase in Income Tax Payable LECTURE NOTES Add Less Add Less Decrease in Trade Payable Increase in Trade Payable Decrease in Accrued Liabilities Increase in Accrued Liabilities UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Direct Method of Reporting Operating Cash Flows (GENESIS) Cash flows from Operating activities: $ Cash received from Customers 570,000 Cash paid for Inventory (319,000) Cash paid for Wage and Other Operating Expenses (218,000) Cash paid for Interest (8,000) Cash paid for Taxes (5,000) Net Cash provided by Operating Activities TROY J. WISHART $ 20,000 Indirect Method of Reporting Net Income is computed using accrual accounting. Accrual accounting recognizes revenues when earned and expenses when incurred. But revenues and expenses do not necessarily reflect the receipt and payment of cash. The indirect method of computing and reporting net cash flows from operating activities involves adjusting the net income figure to get the cash provided (used) by operating activities. This includes subtracting noncash credits from net income and adding noncash charges (debits) back to net income. However, both the direct and indirect method of reporting net cash flow provided (used) by operating activities. Only the computations and presentation are different. The indirect method does not report individual operating cash inflows or cash outflows. Instead, the indirect method adjusts net income for three types of adjustments. First, there are adjustments for changes in noncash current assets and current liabilities relating to operating activities. Second, there are adjustments to net income statements items involving operating activities that do not affect cash inflows or outflows in the period. Third, there are adjustments to eliminate gains and losses resulting from investments and financing activities (those not part of operating activities). Adjustments for Changes in Noncash Current Assets – Changes in noncash current assets are normally the result of operating activities. Some examples are sales affecting trade receivables and expenses affecting prepayments. Noncash current assets will either decrease or increase depending on whether or not cash is received or paid for their corresponding operating activities. Net Income if adjusted by the cash flows, that results from increases and decreases in noncurrent assets, will adjust the net income figure to get the net cash provided (used) by operating activities. To accomplish this: Increases in noncash current assets are subtracted from net income Decreases in noncash current assets are added to net income In the example of Genesis, the noncash current assets are trade receivables, inventory and prepayments, which corresponds with sales, cost of goods, sold and the expenses on the income statement respectively. Trade Receivables increased by $20,000 in the period from a beginning balance of $40,000 to and ending balance of $60,000. This implies Genesis collected less cash than reported as sales, since some of the sales are in the form of accounts receivable at the end of the period. Inventory also increased by $14,000 in the period from a beginning balance of $70,000 to an ending balance of $84,000. This suggests that Genesis had a greater amount of cash purchases than LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART goods sold this period, the balance of which ends up in the form of inventory. Prepaid Expenses increased by $2,000 in the period from a beginning balance of $4,000 to an ending balance of $6,000. This suggests that the cash payment for expenses was greater than that which was reported. All of these increases in noncash current assets will be added back to Genesis’s Net Income. Adjustments for Changes in Current Liabilities – Similar to current assets changes in noncash current liabilities are normally the result of operating activities. Some examples are purchases affecting trade payables and expenses affecting accruals. The decrease in current liabilities implies that its related Income Statement item was less than the cash actually paid. On other hand, an increase suggests that the related income statement item was greater than the cash actually paid. As such the indirect reporting method for reporting cash flows use the following adjustments: Decreases in current liabilities are subtracted from net income Increases in current liabilities are added to net income The trade payables of Genesis decreased by $5,000 in the period, from the beginning balance of $40,000 to an ending balance of $35,000. This decrease suggests that more money was spent for purchases than was reported and should therefore be subtracted from Net Income. The decrease of $1,000 in interest payable should be treated the same manner as trade payables, since it suggests that more cash was paid for interest than was reported. However, the increase of $10,000 in income taxes payable should be added back to net income, because not all the income taxes deducted was paid. Adjustments for Operating Items not Providing or Using Cash The income statement usually includes certain expenses that do not reflect cash outflows in the period. Examples are depreciation, amortization of intangibles, depletion of natural resources, and bad debt expense. The indirect method for reporting operating cash flows requires that Expenses with no cash outflows are added back to net income. Similarly, when net income includes revenues that do not reflect cash inflows in the period, the indirect method requires that Revenues with no cash inflows are subtracted from net income. The depreciation expense of $24,000 for Genesis should be added back to its net income since there is no cash outflow. Adjustments for Non-operating Items Net income sometimes includes gains or losses that are not part of operating activities but, instead, are classified as either investing or financing activities. Examples are gain or loss from the sale of a non current asset or the retirement of a bond payable. The cash received or paid for the sale or retirement of these items are recorded either under investing or financing activities. Under the indirect method reporting operating cash flows: Non-operating gains are subtracted from net income Non-operating losses are added back to net income LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Hence the loss of $6,000 incurred on the sale of Genesis plant assets should be added back to net income. On the other hand the $16,000 gain on retirement of debt should be subtracted from net income. Summary of Adjustments for Indirect Method Cash flows from Operating activities: Net Income: Add Depreciation Add Depletion Add Amortization Add Loss on Disposal of Non-current Assets Add Loss on Retirement of Debt Less Gain on Disposal of Non-current Assets Less Gain on Retirement of Debt Add Decrease in Noncash Current Asset Less Increase in Noncash Current Asset Add Increase in Current Liability* Less Decrease in Current Liability* Net Cash provided by Operating Activities *Excludes current portion of non-current liabilities and any short-term note payables if unrelated to sales – both are considered financing activities. Indirect Method of Reporting Operating Cash Flows (GENESIS) Cash flows from Operating activities: $ Net Income 38,000 Adjustments: Increase in Trade Receivable (20,000) Increase in Inventory (14,000) Increase in Prepaid Expenses (2,000) Decrease in Trade Payable $ (5,000) Decrease in Interest Payable Increase in Income Taxes Payable Depreciation Expense Loss on Sale of Plant Assets Gain on Retirement of Debts Net Cash provided by Operating Activities (1,000) 10,000 24,000 6,000 (16,000) 20,000 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Cash Flows from Investing Activities The third major step in preparing the statement of cash flows is to compute and report net cash flows from investing activities. This is usually done by identifying changes in all non-current asset accounts and current accounts for notes receivable and investments in equity and debt securities (excluding trading securities). These accounts include plant assets, intangible assets, natural resources, investments, notes. Changes in these accounts are then analyzed using available information to determine their effect, if any, on cash. Results of this analysis are reported in the investing activities section of the statement of cash flows. Reporting of investing activities is identical under the direct method and indirect method. Investing activities include transactions such as (a) the purchase and sale of non-current assets, (b) lending and collecting on notes receivable, and (c) the purchase and sale of short-term investments other than cash equivalents. Information to compute cash flows from investing activities is usually taken from beginning and ending statement of financial position and from the income statement. A three (3) step process in determining net cash provided or used by investing activities: (1) Identify changes in investing-related accounts; (2) Explain these changes using reconstruction analysis; (3) Report cash flow effects. Analysis of Noncurrent Assets Genesis’ financial statements reveal that it purchased and sold plant assets during the period, both of which are investing activities. Plant Assets – For plant assets, we need to identify the changes in both the plant asset account and its related accumulated depreciation account. The first step reveals a $40,000 increase in plant assets from $210,000 to $250,000, and a $12,000 increase in accumulated depreciation from $48,000 to $60,000. What are the reasons for these changes? The second step begins by reviewing the accounts and any additional information available. A plant asset account is affected by both purchases and sales of plant assets. An accumulated depreciation account normally is increased from depreciation and reduced by removing accumulated depreciation on asset sales. Items (b) and (c) of the additional information reported for Genesis are relevant for these accounts. To explain changes in these accounts and to help us understand the cash flows effects, we prepare reconstructed entries. A reconstructed entry is a recreation of an entry from a transaction, it is not the actual entry made by the preparer. Item (b) reported Genesis purchased plant assets costing $70,000 by issuing $60,000 in bonds payable to the seller and paying $10,000 in cash. The reconstructed entry for our analysis of item (b) is: Plant Assets Bonds Payable Cash 70,000 60,000 10,000 This entry reveals a $10,000 cash outflow for assets purchased. It also reveals a noncash investing and financing transaction involving $60,000 of bonds given up for $60,000 of plant assets. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Plant Assets Sale – Item (c) reports Genesis sells plant assets costing $30,000 (with $12,000 of accumulated depreciation) for cash of $12,000, resulting in a loss of $6,000. The reconstructed entry for item (c) is: Cash Accumulated Depreciation Loss on Sales of Plant Assets Plant Assets 12,000 12,000 6,000 30,000 This entry reveals a $12,000 cash inflow for assets sold. The $6,000 loss is computed by comparing the asset book value to the cash received and does not reflect any cash inflow or outflow. The T-account analysis to explain the change in the plant assets account and the accumulated depreciation account are as follows: Plant Assets $ $ Balance 12/31/1999 210,000 Sale 30,000 Purchase 70,000 Balance 12/31/2000 250,000 280,000 280,000 Sale Balance 12/31/2000 Accumulated Depreciation (Plant Assets) $ 12,000 Balance 12/31/1999 60,000 Depreciation Expense 72,000 $ 48,000 24,000 72,000 The third step in our analysis of investing activities is to make the necessary disclosures on the statement of cash flows. Disclosure of the two cash flow effects in the investing section statement appears as follows: Reporting Investing Cash Flows (GENESIS) Cash flows from Investing activities: Cash received from Sale of Plant Assets Cash paid for Purchase of Plant Assets Net Cash provided by Investing Activities $ $ 12,000 (10,000) 2,000 The $60,000 portion of the purchase described in item (b) and financed by issuance of the bonds is a noncash investing and financing activity. This can be reported in a note or in a separate schedule statement. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Analysis of Other Assets – Certain other assets transactions such as those involving current notes receivable and investments in debt and equity securities are considered investing activities and can affect a company’s cash flows. These should be analyzed using the same three-step process as illustrated for noncurrent assets. Cash Flows from Financing Activities The fourth major step in preparing the statement of cash flows is to compute and report net cash flows from financing activities. This is done by identifying changes in all non-current liability accounts (including the current portion of any notes and bonds) and equity accounts. These accounts include long-term debt, notes payable, bonds payable, owner’s capital, common stock, and retained earnings. Changes in these accounts are then analyzed using available information to determine their effect, if any, on cash. Results of this analysis are reported in the financing activities section of the statement. Examples of financing activities are (a) receiving cash from issuing debt and repaying the amounts borrowed and (b) receiving cash from or distributing cash to owners. A three-step process in determining net cash provided (used) by financing activities: (1) Identify changes in financing-related accounts; (2) Explain these changes using reconstruction analysis; (3) Report cash flow effects. Analysis of Noncurrent Liabilities Genesis had only two (2) transactions involving noncurrent liabilities, the noncash issuance of bonds payable to purchase plant assets $60,000 and the cash retirement of bonds payable. The noncash issuance of bonds was already disclosed as a note and as such only the retirement should be analyzed. Bonds Payable Retirement – The comparative statement of financial position reveals an increase of $24,000 in bonds payable from $64,000 to $90,000. Secondly a review should be done on the bonds payable account and any additional information available. Item (e) reports that bonds with a carrying value of $34,000 are retired for $18,000 cash, resulting in a $16,000 gain. The reconstructed entry for the analysis is: Bond Payable Gain on Retirement of Debt Cash 34,000 16,000 18,000 Reconstruction of the entry reveals a cash outflow of $18,000 and a noncash outflow of a gain on retirement of debt. The Bonds Payable account should then be reconstructed to explain the change in the bonds payable account. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Retired Bonds Balance 12/31/2000 Bonds Payable $ 34,000 Balance 12/31/1999 90,000 Issued Bonds 124,000 TROY J. WISHART $ 64,000 60,000 124,000 Analysis of Equity Genesis reveals two transactions involving the issuance of common stock for cash, and the declaration and payment of cash dividends. Common Stock Issuance – The comparative statement of financial position reveals an increase of $15,000 in common stock from $80,000 to $95,000. This change is explained to be the issuance of 3000 shares of common stock at par for $5 per share as indicated by item (d). The reconstructed entry is as follows: Cash 15,000 Common Stock 15,000 The common stock account will look as follows after its reconstruction: Common Stock $ Balance 12/31/1999 Balance 12/31/2000 95,000 Issued Stock 95,000 $ 80,000 15,000 95,000 Cash Dividend Payment – There is an increase of $24,000 in Retained Earnings from $88,000 to $112,000. Item (f) of the additional information partially explains this increase to be payment of dividends to common stockholders of $14,000 Retained Earnings Cash 14,000 14,000 The increase in retained earnings can also be further explained by Net Income from the Income Statement that increases this account as follows: Cash Dividend Balance 12/31/2000 Retained Earnings $ 14,000 Balance 12/31/1999 112,000 Net Income 126,000 LECTURE NOTES $ 88,000 38,000 126,000 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Reporting Financing Cash Flows (GENESIS) Cash flows from financing activities: Cash paid to Retire Bonds Cash received from Issuing of Stock Cash paid for Dividends Net Cash provided by Financing Activities $ TROY J. WISHART $ (18,000) 15,000 (14,000) (17,000) Proving Cash Balances The fifth and final step in preparing the statement is to report the beginning and ending cash balances and prove that the Net Change in Cash is explained by the operating, investing and financing net cash flows. The schedule below shows that the net increase of $5,000 in cash, from $12,000 at the beginning of the period to $17,000 at the end, is reconciled by the net cash flows from Operating ($20,000 inflow), Investing ($2,000 inflow), and Financing ($17,000 outflow) activities. This should be formally reported at the bottom of the statement. Cash flows from: $ Net Cash provided by Operating Activities Net Cash provided by Investing Activities Net Cash provided by Financing Activities Net Increase in Cash Cash Balance at Beginning of 2000 Cash Balance at End of 2000 $ 20,000 2,000 (17,000) 5,000 12,000 17,000 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Complete Statement of Cash Flows (GENESIS) – Direct Method GENESIS Statement of Cash Flows For the Year Ended December 31, 2000 Cash flows from Operating activities: $ Cash received from Customers Cash paid for Inventory 570,000 (319,000) Cash paid for Wage and Other Operating Expenses (218,000) Cash paid for Interest Cash paid for taxes Net Cash provided by Operating Activities $ (8,000) (5,000) 20,000 Cash flows from Investing activities: Cash received from Sale of Plant Assets Cash paid for Purchase of Plant Assets Net Cash provided by Investing Activities 12,000 (10,000) 2,000 Cash flows from financing activities: Cash paid to Retire Bonds Cash received from Issuing of Stock Cash paid for Dividends Net Cash provided by Financing Activities (18,000) 15,000 (14,000) (17,000) Net Increase in Cash Cash Balance at Beginning of 2000 Cash Balance at End of 2000 5,000 12,000 17,000 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Complete Statement of Cash Flows (GENESIS) – Indirect Method GENESIS Statement of Cash Flows For the Year Ended December 31, 2000 Cash flows from Operating activities: Net Income Adjustments: Increase in Trade Receivable Increase in Inventory Increase in Prepaid Expenses $ 38,000 $ (20,000) (14,000) (2,000) Decrease in Trade Payable (5,000) Decrease in Interest Payable Increase in Income Taxes Payable Depreciation Expense Loss on sale of Plant Assets Gain on Retirement of Debts Net Cash provided by Operating Activities (1,000) 10,000 24,000 6,000 (16,000) 20,000 Cash flows from Investing activities: Cash received from Sale of Plant Assets Cash paid for Purchase of Plant Assets Net Cash provided by Investing Activities 12,000 (10,000) 2,000 Cash flows from financing activities: Cash paid to Retire Bonds Cash received from Issuing of Stock Cash paid for Dividends Net Cash used by Financing Activities (18,000) 15,000 (14,000) (17,000) Net Increase in Cash Cash Balance at Beginning of 2000 Cash Balance at End of 2000 5,000 12,000 17,000 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Reporting & Analyzing Cash Flows Worksheet Question 1 Colby Co’s income statement for the year ended 31 December 20X2 and statements of financial position at 31 December 20X1 and 31 December 20X2 were as follows. COLBY CO INCOME STAEMENT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 20X2 $’000 Sales Raw materials consumed Staff costs Depreciation Loss on disposal of non-current asset $’000 720 70 94 118 18 (300) 420 (28) 392 (124) 268 Profit before interest and taxes Interest payable Profit before tax Taxation Profit for the period COLBY CO STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION AS AT 31 DECEMBER 20X2 $’000 Assets Property, plant and equipment Cost Depreciation $’000 1,596 318 20X1 $’000 $’000 1,560 224 1,278 Current assets Inventory Trade receivables Bank 24 76 48 1,336 20 58 56 148 1,426 Total assets Equity and liabilities Capital and reserves Share capital Share premium Retained earnings 360 36 716 340 24 514 1,112 LECTURE NOTES 134 1,470 878 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Non-current liabilities Non-current loans TROY J. WISHART 200 Current liabilities Trade payables Taxation 500 12 102 6 86 114 1,426 92 1,470 During the year, the company paid $90,000 for a new piece of machinery. Dividends paid during 20X2 totalled $66,000. Required Prepare a statement of cash flows for Colby Co for the year ended 31 December 20X2 in accordance with the requirements of IAS 7, using the indirect method. Question 2 Set out below are the financial statements of Shabnum Co. You are the financial controller, faced with the task of implementing IAS 7 Statement of cash flows. SHABNUM CO INCOME STATEMENT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 20X2 $’000 2,553 (1,814) 739 (125) (264) 350 25 (75) 300 (140) 160 Revenue Cost of sales Gross profit Distribution costs Administrative expenses Interest received Interest paid Profit before taxation Taxation Profit for the period SHABNUM CO STATEMENTS OF FINANCIAL POSITION AS AT 31 DECEMBER 20X2 $’000 Assets Non-current assets Property, plant and equipment Intangible assets 380 250 LECTURE NOTES 20X1 $’000 305 200 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Investments Current assets Inventories Receivables Short-term investments Cash in hand Total assets - 25 150 390 50 2 1,222 102 315 1 948 20X2 $’000 Equity and liabilities Equity Share capital ($1 ordinary shares) Share premium account Revaluation reserve Retained earnings Non-current liabilities Loan Current liabilities Trade payables Bank overdraft Taxation Total equity and liabilities 20X1 $’000 200 160 100 260 150 150 91 180 170 50 127 85 120 1,222 119 98 110 948 The following information is available. (a) The proceeds of the sale of non-current asset investments amounted to $30,000. (b) Fixtures and fittings, with an original cost of $85,000 and a net book value of $45,000, were sold for $32,000 during the year. (c) The following information relates to property, plant and equipment 31.12.20X2 $’000 720 340 380 Cost Accumulated depreciation Net book value 31.12.20X1 $’000 595 290 305 (d) 50,000 %1 ordinary shares were issued during the year at a premium of 20c per share. (e) Dividends totaling $80,000 were paid during the year. Required Prepare a statement of cash flows for the year to 31 December 20X2 using the format laid out in IAS 7. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Question 3 UMLAUF COMPANY Income Statement For Year Ended December 31, 2000 $ Sales Cost of Goods Sold Other Operating expenses Depreciation expense Other gains (losses): Loss on sale of equipment Income before taxes Income taxes expense Income from continuing oper. Extraordinary item: Loss on retirement of bonds NET INCOME 222,300 120,300 25,500 $ 446,100 (368,100) (3,300) 74,700 (13,725) 60,975 (825) 60,150 UMLAUF COMPANY Statement of Financial Position As at December 31, 2000 and 1999 $ Assets 2000 Cash 43,050 Trade receivable 34,125 Inventory 156,000 Prepaid expenses 3,600 Equipment 135,825 Accumulated Depreciation (61,950) Total Assets 310,650 $ 1999 23,925 39,825 146,475 1,650 146,700 (47,550) 311,025 Equity & Liabilities Trade payables Income taxes payable Dividend payable Bonds payable Ordinary Share, $10 par value Retained earnings Total Equity and Liabilities 33,750 4,425 4,500 37,500 168,750 62,100 311,025 LECTURE NOTES 28,800 5,100 0 0 168,750 108,000 310,650 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Income Taxes Expense is restated to include the tax effects from the extraordinary loss. This means the $825 extraordinary loss is at its gross amount, and not net of tax. Additional Information: a) All sales are on credit. b) All merchandise purchases are on credit. c) Accounts Payable balances result from merchandise purchases. d) Prepaid expenses relate to “other operating expenses.” e) Equipment costing $21,375 with accumulated depreciation of $11,100 is sold for cash. f) Equipment is purchases for cash. g) Change in the balance of Accumulated Depreciation results from depreciation expense and from the sale of equipment. h) Change in the balance of Retained Earnings results from dividend declarations and net income. Required a) Prepare a statement of cash flows using the direct method for the year 2000. b) Prepare a statement of cash flows using the indirect method for the year 2000. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Analysis of Financial Statements Lecture Notes Basis of Analysis Financial Statement Analysis is the application of analytical tools to general purpose financial statements and related data for business decisions. It involves transforming accounting data into useful information. It reduces uncertainty in decision making and reliance on guesses or hunches, but does not lessen the need for expert judgement. Instead it provides an effective systematic basis for business decisions. Purpose of Analysis The purpose of financial statement analysis is to help users make better decisions. These users include decision makers both internal and external to the company. Internal users of accounting information are those individuals involved in managing and operating the company. They include managers, officers, internal auditors, consultants, and many other important internal decision makers. Internal users make the strategic and operating decisions of the company. The purpose of financial statement analysis for these users is to provide information helpful in improving the company’s efficiency and effectiveness in providing goods and services. External users of accounting information are not directly involved in running the company. They include shareholders, lenders, directors, customers, suppliers, regulators lawyers, brokers and the press. Yet these users are affected by, and sometimes affect the company’s activities. External users rely on financial statement analysis in pursuing their own goals. The common goal of all these users is to evaluate company performance. This includes evaluation of: 1. Past and Current Performance 2. Current Financial Position 3. Future Performance and Risk Building Blocks of Analysis Financial statement analysis focuses on one or more elements of a company’s financial condition or performance. The analysis emphasizes four areas of inquiry with varying degrees of importance. These four areas which are interrelated and are considered the building blocks of financial statement analysis are as follows: 1. Liquidity and Efficiency – ability to meet short term obligations and to efficiently generate revenues. 2. Solvency – ability to generate future revenues and meet long-term obligations. 3. Profitability – ability to provide financial rewards sufficient to attract and retain financing. 4. Market – ability to generate positive market expectations. Applying the building blocks of financial statement analysis involves determining (1) the objectives of the analysis and (2) the relative emphasis among the building blocks. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Information for Analysis Most users rely on general-purpose financial statements that companies publish periodically. Generalpurpose financial statements include the (1) income statements, (2) statement of financial position (3) statement of changes in equity (4) statement of cash flows and (5) notes to the statements. Generalpurpose financial statements are part of financial reporting, which refers to the communication of relevant financial information to decision makers. Standards for Comparisons When computing and interpreting analysis measures as part of our financial statement analysis, we need to decide whether these measures suggest good, bad, or average performance. To make judgments, we need standards for comparisons. Standards for comparisons can include: Intracompany – The company under analysis provides standards for comparisons based on prior performance and relations between its financial items. Competitor – One or more direct competitors of the company under analysis can provide standards for comparisons. Industry – Industry statistics can provide standards of comparisons Guidelines (rules of thumb) – General standards of comparisons can develop from past experiences. These guidelines, or rules of thumb, must be carefully applied since their context is often crucial. All of these standards of comparisons are useful when properly applied; yet analysis measures taken from a selected competitor or group of competitors are often the best. Also, intracompany and industry measures are important parts of all analyses. Guidelines, or rules of thumb, should be applied with care, and then only if they seem reasonable in light of past experience and industry norms. Tools of Analysis There are several tools of financial statement analysis. Three of the most common tools are: 1. Horizontal Analysis – Comparison of a company’s financial condition and performance across time. 2. Vertical Analysis – Comparison of a company’s financial condition and performance to a base amount. 3. Ratio Analysis – Measurement of key relations between financial statement items. Horizontal Analysis Our analysis of a single financial item is important but is of limited value. Instead, our financial analysis needs to use the important relations that exist between items and across time. Much of financial statement analysis involves identifying and describing relations between items, groups of items, and changes in those items. Horizontal analysis is a tool to evaluate changes in financial statement data across time. There are two (2) types of horizontal analysis: 1. Comparative Statements 2. Trend Analysis LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Comparative Statements Comparing amounts for two or more successive periods often helps in the analysis of financial statement data. Comparative financial statements facilitate this comparison by showing financial amounts side-by-side columns on a single statement. Each financial statement if presented in a comparative format. Comparative statements can be done using three approaches: 1. Computation of Dollar Changes and Percent Changes – Comparing financial statements over relatively short time periods-two to three years-is often done by analyzing changes in line items. A change analysis usually includes analysis of absolute dollar amount changes as well as percent changes. Both since dollar changes can sometimes yield large percent changes inconsistent with their importance. For instance, a 50% change from a base figure of $100 is less important than the same percent change from a base amount of $100,000 in the same statement. Reference to dollar amounts is necessary to retain a proper perspective and to assess the importance of changes. We compute the dollar change for a financial statement item as: Dollar Change = Analysis Period Amount – Base Period Amount Where analysis period is the point or period of time for the financial statements under analysis, and base period is the point or period of time for the financial statements used for comparison purposes. We commonly use the prior year as the base period. We compute the percent change by dividing the dollar change by the base period amount and then multiplying this quantity by 100: Percent Change (%) = Analysis Period Amount – Base Period Amount Base Period Amount X 100 While we can always compute a dollar change, we must be aware of a few rules in working with percentages. To illustrate, let’s look at four separate cases in the chart below. Case No. A B C D Base Period $ (4,500) 2,000 10,000 Analysis Period $ 1,500 (1,000) 8,000 0 Dollar Change 6,000 (3,000) 8,000 (10,000) Percentage Change (100%) It is common when using horizontal analysis to compare amounts to either average or median values from prior periods. Comparing changes to average or median values computed from more than one prior period highlights unusual happenings, as average values smooth out erratic or unusual fluctuations. We also commonly round percents and ratios to one or two decimal places. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART But there is no uniform practice on this matter. Computations are as detailed as necessary. This is judged by whether or not rounding potentially affects user’s decisions. Computations should not be so excessively detailed that important relations are lost among a mountain of decimal points. 2. Comparative Statement of Financial Position – One of the most useful comparative statements is the comparative Statement of Financial Position. It consists of amounts from two or more dates arranged side by side. The usefulness of comparative financial statements is often improved by showing each item’s dollar change and percentage change. This type of presentation highlights large dollar and percent changes for decision makers. When the large dollar and percentage changes are highlighted we then try to identify the reasons for these changes and, if possible, determine whether they are favourable or unfavourable. We also follow up on items with small changes when we expected the changes to be large. 3. Comparative Income Statement – A comparative income statement is prepared similar to the comparative statement of financial position. Amounts for two or more periods are placed side by side, with additional columns for dollar and percent changes. Trend Analysis Trend Analysis, also called Trend Percent Analysis or Index Number Trend Analysis, is used to reveal patterns in data for successive periods. It involves computing trend percents for a series of financial numbers. This method of analysis is a variation on the use of percent changes for horizontal analysis. The difference is that trend analysis does not subtract the base period amount in the numerator. To compute trend percents we need to: 1. Select a base period and assign each item in the base period a weight of 100% 2. Express financial numbers from other periods as a percent of its base period number. A Trend Percent, also called an index number, is the amount in the analysis period divided by the amount of the same item from the base period, multiplied by 100 to get the percent form: Trend Percent (%) = Analysis Period Amount Base Period Amount X 100 Analysis of trend percents is often aided by graphical depictions. A line graph is usually used to help identify trends and detect changes in direction or magnitude. Trend analysis of financial statement items also can include comparisons of relations between items on different financial statements. For instance, a comparison of revenues with total assets. An important part of financial statement analysis is identifying questions and areas of concern such as these. They often direct us to important factors bearing on the future of the company under analysis. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Vertical Analysis Vertical Analysis is a tool to evaluate individual financial statement items or a group of items of a specific base amount. We usually define a key aggregate figure as the base, and the base amount is commonly defined as 100%. For instance, an income statement’s base is usually revenue and a statement of financial position’s base is usually total assets. Since the sum of the individual items is also called Common-Size Analysis, which falls into two (2) categories: 1. Common-Size Statements 2. Common-Size Graphics Common-Size Statements Comparative statements show how each item has changed over time, but they do not emphasize the relative importance of each item. We use common common-size statements to reveal changes in the relative importance of each financial statement item. All individual amounts in common-size statements are redefined in terms of common-size percents. A common-size percent is measured by taking each individual financial statement amount under analysis and dividing it by its base amount: Common-size Percent (%) = Analysis Amount Base Amount X 100 1. Common-Size Statement of Financial Statement Position – Common-size statements express each item as a percent of a base amount. The base for a common-size statement of financial position is usually total assets. It is assigned a value of 100%. This implies the total amount of laibilitities plus equity equals 100% since this amount equals total assets. Next, we compute a common-size percent for each asset, liability, and equity items where the base amount is total assets. When we present a company’s successive statement of financial position in this way, changes in the mixture of assets, liabilities, and equity are apparent. 2. Common-Size Income Statement – Our Analysis usually benefits from an examination of commonsize income statement. The amount of revenues is usually the base amount, and it is assigned a value of 100%. Each common-size income statement item appears as a percent of revenues. If we think of the 100% revenues amount as representing one sales dollar, the remaining items show each revenue dollar is distributed among costs, expenses, and income. Common-Size Graphics There are several tools of common-size analysis. Two of the most common are trend analysis of common-size statements and graphical analysis. The trend analysis of common-size statements is similar to trend analysis of comparative statements discussed under horizontal analysis. An income statement readily lends itself to common-size graphical analysis. Revenues affect nearly every item in an income statement. It is also usually helpful for our analysis to know what portion of revenues is taken up by various costs and expenses. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Graphical analysis is especially useful in evaluating a statement of financial position. It is helpful in assessing two important elements: (1) sources of financing including the distribution among current liabilities, non-current liabilities, equity capital and (2) identification of investing activities including distribution among current assets and non-current assets. Common-size statement of financial position analysis is often extended to examine the composition of subgroups. For instance in assessing liquidity of current assets, it is often important to know what proportion is composed of inventories, and not simply what proportion inventories are of total assets. Common-size financial statements are useful in comparing different companies. This is because financial statements of different companies are recast in common-size format. But common-size statements fail to reflect the relative sizes companies under analysis. Comparison of a company’s common-size statements with competitors’ or industry common size statistics alerts our attention to differences in the structure or distribution of its financial statements, but not their dollar magnitude. Still, major differences should be explored and explained. Ratio Analysis The most common way of comparing accounting numbers to evaluate the performance and risk of a firm is RATIO ANALYSIS. It is useful as a means of Interpreting Accounting Statements or Financial Statements Analysis, which helps users to make better decisions. They provide Internal Users, who are responsible for the strategic and operating decisions of the company, with information helpful in improving the company’s efficiency and effectiveness in providing products and services. While on the other hand, External Users rely on the information derived to make better and more informed decisions. The common goal of these users is to evaluate a company’s performance, which includes (1) past and current performance, (2) current financial position, and (3) future performance and risk. Although ratios provide more meaningful information than absolute numbers alone, the ratios are most useful when analyzed relative to some standard of comparison. That standard of comparison may be: 1. 2. 3. 4. Previous Performance of the same company The performance of a competitor company An Industry average for the particular ratio. General Standards of comparisons that have been developed from past experiences In addition, ratios should be used together with other ratios to give a fair assessment of the company’s performance as well as an explanation to the results of some ratios. The interpretation of the ratios as against the comparative standards is necessary to complete the process of using ratios to analyze financial statements. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Accountants should use ratio analysis for three (3) reasons: 1. They must be familiar with the ways users assess financial information given to them 2. Ratio analysis is helpful for them when participating in operating and financial decisions 3. Independent Auditors use ratio analysis to identify potential audit problems and determine the specific audit procedures that should be performed. Ratio analysis assesses four areas of the financial information of a company: 1. Liquidity and Efficiency – ability to meet short term obligations and to efficiently generate revenues. 2. Solvency – ability to generate future revenues and meet long-term obligations 3. Profitability – ability to provide financial rewards sufficient to attract and retain financing. 4. Market – ability to generate positive market expectations. Liquidity and Efficiency Liquidity refers to the availability of resources to meet short term cash requirements, which is affected by the timing of cash inflows and outflows, along with its prospects for future performance. Our analysis of liquidity is aimed at a company’s capital requirements. Efficiency refers to how productive a company is in using its assets. Efficiency is usually relative to how much revenue is generated for a certain level of assets. Working Capital and Current Ratio Working Capital is current assets less current liabilities. A company needs an adequate amount of working capital to meet current debts, carry sufficient inventories, and take advantage of cash discounts. Current Ratio reflects a company’s ability to pay short-term obligations. It relates current assets to current liabilities as follows: Current Assets Current Ratio = Current Liabilities A high current ratio suggests a strong liquidity position, but a company can also have a strong a current ratio that is too high. An excessively high ratio means that the company has invested too much in current assets. Since current assets don’t normally generate much return on investment, an excessive investment in current assets is not a sufficient use of resources. Many users apply a guideline of 2 to 1 current ratio. However this should be assessed in conjunction with three factors: 1. Type of business 2. Composition of current assets 3. Turnover rate of current asset component LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Acid Test Ratio Acid Test or Quick Ratio focuses on the current assets composition or those assets that can be converted quickly to cash to better assess the company’s ability to meet its short term obligations quickly. Quick assets are cash, short-term investments, accounts receivable, and current notes receivable. Quick Assets Current Assets - Inventory Acid Test Ratio = or Current Liabilities Current Liabilities Accounts Receivable or Debtors Turnover This ratio measures how frequently a company converts its receivables to cash. It may also include other short-term receivables from customers in the denominator along with AR. Accounts Receivable or Debtors Turnover = Net Sales Average Accounts Receivable Inventory Turnover Working capital requirements are affected by how long a company holds inventory before selling it and one such measure is the Inventory Turnover. Inventory Turnover = Cost of Goods Sold Average Inventory Days’ Sales Uncollected Evaluates how frequently a company collects its accounts Days’ Sales Uncollected = Accounts Receivable Net Sales X 365 Days’ Sales in Inventory This ratio estimates how long it will take for inventory to be converted into receivables (or cash). If all sales are on credit Day Sales Inventory are added to Days’ Sales Uncollected to determine how long it will take for inventory to convert into cash. Days’ Sales in Inventory = Ending Inventory Cost of Goods Sold X 365 Total Asset Turnover Total Asset Turnover describes the ability of a company to use its assets to generate sales and is an important part of operating efficiency. Net Sales Total Asset Turnover = Average Totals Assets LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Receivables:Payables Ratio This ratio measures the relationship between how much credit is granted by the business to its customers, that is debtors, and how much credit has been received by the business from its suppliers, that is, creditors. Trade Receivables Receivables:Payables Ratio = Trade Payables Receivables: Sales Ratio This ratio assess how long it takes for our debtors to pay us Trade Receivables Receivables: Sales Ratio = Sales for the Year X 12 Payables: Purchases – Ratio This ratio assesses how long it takes a firm on average to pay its suppliers. The calculation is made as follows: Trade Payables Payables: Purchases Ratio = X 12 Purchases for the Year Solvency or Financing Solvency refers to a company’s long-run financial viability and its ability to cover long-term obligations. One of the most important components of solvency analysis is the composition of a company’s capital structure. Capital Structure refers to a company’s source of financing. This analysis is concerned with a company’s ability to both meet its obligations and provide security to its creditors over the long run. Indicators of this ability include debt and equity ratios, the relation between pledged assets and secured liabilities, and the company’s capacity to earn sufficient income to pay fixed interest charges. Debt and Equity Ratio Debt Ratio assesses the portion of a company’s assets contributed by its owners and the portion contributed by creditors. It expresses total liabilities as a percent of total assets. Debt Ratio = Total Liabilities Total Assets The equity ratio provides complementary information by expressing total equity as a percent of total assets. Equity Ratio = Total Equity Total Assets LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Pledged Assets to Secured Liabilities This ratio is used to evaluate the risk of nonpayment faced by secured creditors. The information needed to compute this ratio is not included in the company’s published financial statements. A generally agreed minimum value is about 2 to 1. But the ratio needs careful interpretation since the Book Value of Assets used by it does not necessarily reflect amounts to be received in the event of liquidity. Book Value of Pledged Assets Pledged Assets to Secured Liabilities = Book Value of Secured Liabilities Times Interest Earned This ratio’s purpose is to reflect the riskiness of repayments with interest to creditors. The amount of income before the deduction of interest charges and income taxes is the amount available to pay interest charges. The larger this ratio, less risky is the company for lenders. A guideline for this ratio says that creditors are reasonably safe if the company earns its fixed interest charges two or more times each year. Income before Interest and Income Taxes Times Interest Earned = Interest Expense Profitability Profitability refers to a company’s ability to generate an adequate return on invested capital and to use its assets efficiently to produce profits (and positive cash flows). Return is judged relative to the level and sources of financing. Profitability is also relevant to solvency. Profitability Ratios attempt to measure a company’s ability to earn an adequate return relative to sales or resources devoted to operations (Assets). Profit Margin on Sales These ratio measures a company’s ability to earn profits from its sales as well as cover its expenses. Net Income Profit Margin = Net Sales Gross Profit as a Percentage of Sales = Gross Profit Net Sales x 100 The amount derived from this ratio is the amount of gross profit for every dollar of sales. Net Profit as a Percentage of Sales = Net Profit Net Sales x 100 The amount derived from this ratio is the amount of Net profit for every dollar of sales. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Return on Total Assets This ratio expresses income as a percentage of the average total assets available to generate that income. Because total assets is partially financed with debt and partially by equity funds, this is an inclusive way of measuring earning power that ignores specific sources of financing. Return on Total Assets = Return on Total Assets = Net Income Average Total Assets Profit Margin on Sales x Total Assets Turnover OR Net Income Average Total Assets = Net Income Net Sales x Net Sales Average Total Assets Return on Shareholders’ Equity The return on shareholder’s equity measures the success of a company in earning net income for its owners. Return on Shareholders’ Equity = Return on Ordinary Shareholders’ Equity = Net Income Average Shareholders’ Equity Net Income - Preferred Dividends Average Ordinary Shareholders’ Equity Market Market Measures are useful when analyzing corporations having publicly traded stock. These market measures use stock price in their computation. Stock price reflects what the market (public) expectations are for the company. This includes both the return and risk characteristics of a company as currently perceived by the market. Price-earnings Ratio This ratio is used as an indicator of the future growth of and risk related to a company’s earnings as perceived by buyers and sellers of the stock. Price-earnings Ratio = Market Price per Share Earnings per Share LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Dividend Yield Dividend Yield is used as a means to compare the dividend-paying performance of different investment alternatives. Dividend Yield = Annual Dividends per Share Market Price per Share LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Analysis of Financial Statements Worksheet Question 1 HOFFMAN CORPORATION Statement of Financial Position As at December 31, 2000 Assets Non Current Assets Plant Assets Inventory Trade Receivables, net Notes Receivable (trade) Short-term investments Cash Prepaid Expenses Total Assets Equity & Liabilities Ordinary Share, $1 par value Retained Earnings Long-term note payable, secured by mortgage on plant assets Trade Payables Accrued wages payables Income Tax Payable Total Equity and Liabilities $ 152,300 31,150 28,200 3,500 7,400 9,000 1,650 233,200 90,000 59,800 62,400 16,500 2,200 2,300 233,200 HOFFMAN CORPORATION Income Statement For Year Ended December 31, 2000 $ $ Sales 348,600 Cost of Goods Sold: Inventory 12/31/1999 32,400 Merchandise purchases 227,900 Goods available for sale 260,300 Inventory 12/31/2000 31,150 Cost of goods Sold (229,150) Gross Profit 119,450 Operating expenses (52,500) Interest expense (3,100) Income before taxes 63,850 Income taxes expense (15,800) NET INCOME 48,050 Assume that all sales are on credit. On the December 31, 1999, the assets totaled $182,400, ordinary shares was $90,000, and retained earnings amounted to $31,300 Required Compute the following: (a) current ratio, (b) acid-test ratio, (c) days’ sales uncollected, (d) merchandise inventory turnover, (e) days’ sales in inventory, (f) ratio of pledged assets to secured liabilities, (g) times interest earned, (h) profit margin, (i) total asset turnover, (j) return on total assets, and (k) return on ordinary shareholders’ equity. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Question 2 THORNHILL COMPANY Comparative Income Statement For Year Ended December 31, 2001, 2000 and 1999 Sales Cost of Goods Sold Gross Profit Selling expenses Administrative expenses TOTAL EXPENSES Income before taxes Income taxes expense NET INCOME $ 2001 444,000 267,288 176,712 62,694 40,137 102,831 73,881 13,764 60,117 $ 2000 340,000 212,500 127,500 46,920 29,920 76,840 50,660 10,370 40,290 $ 1999 236,000 151,040 84,960 31,152 19,470 50,622 34,388 6,962 27,376 THORNHILL COMPANY Statement of Financial Position As at December 31, 2001, 2000 and 1999 $ $ Assets 2001 2000 Current Assets 48,480 37,924 Long-term investments 0 500 Plant and equipment 90,000 96,000 Total Assets 138,480 134,424 $ 1999 50,648 3,720 57,000 111,368 Equity & Liabilities Current Liabilities Ordinary Share Capital Other contributed capital Retained Earnings Total Equity and Liabilities 19,480 54,000 6,000 31,888 111,368 20,200 72,000 9,000 37,280 138,480 19,960 72,000 9,000 33,464 134,424 Required 1. Compute each year’s current ratio 2. Compute 2001 and 2000’s dollar and percentage 3. Compute common size statements for each year for both statements LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Consignment Accounts Lecture Notes Nature of Consignment When a trader sells goods directly to a customer, whether they are in his home country or overseas, these are ordinary sales. However, a trader may send goods to an agent to sell them for him. These are said to be sent on consignment. The main features are: 1. The trader sends goods to the agent. The goods do not belong to the agent; his job is to sell them for the trader. The goods are owned by the trader until they are sold. The trader sending the goods is called the consignor. The agent is called the consignee. 2. The agent will store the goods until they are sold to him. He will have to pay some expenses, but these will later be refunded by the trader. 3. The agent will receive a commission from the trader for his work. 4. The agent will collect the money from the customers to whom he sells the goods. He will pay this over to the trader after deducting his expenses and commission. The statement from the agent to the trader showing this is known as the account sales. Consignment accounts are found mainly in overseas trade. Consignor (The Trader’s) Records For each consignment to an agent a separate consignment account is opened. Think of it as a trading and profit and loss account for each consignment. The purpose is to calculate the net profit or loss on each consignment. Goods consigned and expenses paid by the consignor Double entry needed: Goods consigned (a) Debit Consignment Account Credit Goods sent on consignment account (Inventory) Expenses (b) Debit Consignment Account Credit Cash Book Expenses of the Agent (consignee) and sales receipts When the sales have been completed the consignee will send an “account sales” to the consignor. This will show: LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 $ Sales Less Expenses Commission TROY J. WISHART $ xxx xxx xxx Balance now paid xxx xxx The consignor enters these details in his books. The double entry needed is: Sales (c) Expenses of consignee (d) Commission of consignee (e) Cash received from consignee (f) Debit consignee’s account Credit consignment account Debit consignment account Credit consignee’s account Debit consignment account Credit consignee’s account Debit cash book Credit consignee’s account Example Wills of London, whose financial year ends on December 31, consigned goods to Adams his agent in Canada. All transactions were started and completed in 1998. (a) January 16: Wills consigned goods costing $500 to Adams. (b) February 28: Wills paid carriage to Canada, $50. Adams, the consignee, sends an “account sales” on July 31 when all the goods have been sold. It shows: (c) Sales amounted to $750 (d) Adams’ expenses were: Import duty, $25. Distribution expenses, $30 (e) Commission had been agreed at 6% of sales. This amounted to $45 (f) Adams paid balance owing, $650. Consignment to Adams, Ottawa, Canada 1998 $ 1998 $ Jan 16 Goods sent on consign. (a) 500 July 31 Sales (c) 750 Feb 16 Bank: carriage (b) 50 July 31 Adams: Import Duty (d) 25 Distribution (d) 30 July 31 Adams: Commission (e) 45 July 31 Profit on consignment (P&L) 100 750 750 LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 1998 Goods sent on Consignment $ 1998 Jan 16 Consignment to Adams (a) 1998 July 31 Adams (consignee) (f) 1998 July 31 Consignment: Sales (c) Cash Book $ 1998 500 Jan 16 Consignment to Adams: Carriage (b) Adams (Consignee) $ 1998 750 July 31 Consignment: Import Duty (d) Distribution (d) Commission (e) Bank (f) 750 TROY J. WISHART $ 500 $ 50 $ 25 30 45 650 750 You can see that the main features are: (a) The consignment account is a trading and profit and loss account for one consignment. (b) The consignee’s (Adams) personal account is used to show double entry for items concerning him. All of these details have been shown on the account sales he sent after selling the goods Consignee’s (The Agent’s) Records The only items needed in the consignee’s records will be found from the account sales he sent to the consignor after the goods have been sold. He does not enter, in his double entry, the goods received on consignment. They never belong to him. His job is to sell the goods. Of course he will keep a note of the goods but not in his double entry account records. The double entry needed is: Cash from sales of consignment (c) Debit Cash Book Credit Consignor’s account Payment of consignment (d) Debit Consignor’s account Credit Cash Book Commission earned (e) Debit Consignor’s account Credit Profit and Loss account Cash to settle balance shown on account sales (f) Debit Consignor’s account Credit Cash Book LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Account Sales Adams, Ottawa, Canada. July 31 1998 To Wills London $ Sales of goods received on consignment (c) Less Charges: Import Duty (d) Distribution (d) Commission (e) Bank Draft Enclosed 25 30 45 $ 750 100 650 The double entry accounts in the books of the consignee (Adams) follow: 1998 July 31 July 31 July 31 Bank: Import Duty (d) Distribution (d) Commission transferred to Profit and loss (e) Bank (f) 1998 July 31 Wills: Sales (c) Wills (Consignor) $ 1998 July 31 Bank: Sales 25 30 $ 750 45 650 750 Cash Book $ 1998 750 July 31 Wills: Import Duty (d) July 31 Wills: Distribution (d) July 31 Wills: To settle account (f) Profit and Loss Account (Adams) $ 1998 Commission on Consignment from Wills (e) LECTURE NOTES 750 $ 25 30 650 $ 45 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Bad Debts and Consignments Normally, when an agent sells goods of the consignor he will collect the sale money from the customer. If the customer does not pay his account, the money in respect of this does not have to be paid to the consignor. To make certain he does not have such bad debts, the consignor may pay an extra commission to the agent. When this happens the money for the debt will have to be paid by the agent even though he has not collected it. This extra commission is called del credere commission. Accounting for Incomplete Consignment Sometimes all the goods consigned to an agent are not sold as at the close of the financial year. For instance, if goods are sent in September 1997 and the final sales are made in March 1998. When the consignor prepares his final accounts up to December 31, 1997, there will be an incomplete consignment at the date of the statement of financial position. The main difference between a completed consignment at the statement of financial position and an uncompleted one is that the unsold inventory has to valued and carried down to the following period. This inventory will appear in the statement of financial position of the consignor as a current asset. Example (a) Farr of Chester consigns 10 cases of goods costing $200 per case to Moore in Nairobi on July 1, 1997 (b) Farr pays $250 for carriage and insurance for the whole consignment on July 1, 1997. Farr receives an interim “account sales” with a bank draft from Moore on December 28, 1997. (c) Moore has sold 8 cases of goods for $400 each = $3,200. (d) Moore has paid a total of $150 for landing charges and import duties on receipt of the whole consignment. (e) Moore has paid selling costs, in respect of the 8 cases sold, of $160. (f) Moore has deducted his commission of 10 per cent in respect of the 8 cases sold = 10% x $3,200 = $320. (g) Moore encloses bank draft of $2,570. This is made up of (c) $3,200 – (d) $150 – (e) $160 – (f) $320 = $2,570. Farr now wishes to balance off his consignment account at his financial year end, December 31, 1997, and to transfer the profit to date to his profit and loss account. The consignment account will appear as follows: LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 Consignment to Moore 1997 $ 1997 July 1 Goods on consignment (a) 2,000 Dec 28 July 1 Bank: Carriage and Insurance (b) 250 Dec 28 More: Dec 31 Landing Charges & Import Duties (d) 150 Selling costs (e) 160 Dec 31 Commission (f) 320 Dec 31 Profit on consignment to P&L 800 3,680 1998 Jan 1 Value of unsold inventory (b) b/d Note: TROY J. WISHART $ More: Sale of part consignment (c) Value of unsold Inventory (h) c/d 3,200 480 3,680 480 (h) Value of unsold inventory at December 31, 1997: Goods: 2 cases x $200 each Add Proportion of expenses belonging to 2 unsold cases out of 10 received (b) Carriage 2/10 x $250 (d) Landing charges and duties 2/10 x $150 $ 50 30 $ 400 80 480 There is no proportion of (e) selling costs $160 or (f) commission $320 added to the valuation of the 2 unsold cases. This is because both of these expenses were only for the sale of the 8 cases, and nothing to do with the 2 unsold cases. The profit and loss account for Farr for the year ended December 31, 1997 will include the consignment of $800. The statement of financial position as at December 31, 1997 will include the consignment inventory of $480 as a current asset. The consignee’s account, Moore’s, can be show in Farr’s books as: 1997 Dec 28 Consignment: Sales (c) More (Consignee) $ 1997 3,200 Dec 28 Consignment expenses: Landing charges etc. (d) Selling costs (e) Commission (f) Bank (g) 3,200 LECTURE NOTES $ 150 160 320 2,570 3,200 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Final Completion of Consignment When the remainder of the consignment is sold, the consignment account can be closed. This will be done by transferring the final portion of profit or loss to the consignor’s profit and loss account. The details will be found in the final account sales which the consignee will have sent to the consignor. Continuing from the above example: (i) (j) (k) (l) The final 2 cases of goods were sold for $380 each = $760 Selling costs of these 2 cases were $70 Commission deducted at 10percent = 10% x $760 = $76. Bank draft sent for $614. Made up of (i) $760 – (j) $70 – (k) $76 = $614. Farr’s books: Consignment to Moore 1998 $ 1998 Jan 1 Value of unsold Inventory (h) b/d 480 Mar 31 More: Sale of remainder (i) Mar 31 More: Selling costs (j) 70 Dec 31 Commission (k) 76 Dec 31 Profit on consignment to P&L 134 760 LECTURE NOTES $ 760 760 UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Consignment Accounts Work Sheet Question 1 On February 8, 1998 PJ, a London trader, consigned 120 cases of goods to MB, an agent in New Zealand. The cost of the goods was $25 a case. PJ paid carriage to the port $147 and insurance $93. On March 31, 1998 PJ received and “account sales” from MB, showing that 100 cases had been sold for $3,500 and MB had paid freight , at the rate of $2 a case, and port charges amounting to $186. MB was entitled to a commission of 5% on sales. A sight draft for the net amount due was enclosed with the “account sales”. You are required to show the accounts for the above transactions in the ledger of PJ and to show the transfer to profit and loss account at March 31, 1998. Question 2 (a) Explain the differences between a consignment and a sale. (b) 100 cases of goods costing $3,500 were sent on consignment by X Limited to Y Limited on February 1, 1997. At the same time, X Limited paid delivery expenses of $100 and insurance of $20. On March 1, 1997 an interim “account sales” was received from Y Limited showing that 80 cases had been sold for $63 each and that storage charges of $180 and selling expenses of $100 had been deducted from the account. After also deducting the commission on sales which was agreed at 5% of gross sales, Y Limited settled the balance due to X Limited for goods sold by a bank draft. Required: (i) Prepare the interim “account sales”, and (ii) Prepare the consignment account in the books of X Limited. Question 3 On November 15, 1998, Hughes consigned 300 cases of wooden items to Galvez of Madrid. On December 31, 1998, Galvez forwarded an “account sales”, with a draft for the balance, showing the following transactions: 1) 250 cases sold at $20 each and 50 at $18 each. 2) Port and duty charges $720. 3) Storage and carriage charges $410 4) Commission on sales 5% + 1% del credere. LECTURE NOTES UNIVERSITY OF GUYANA ACT 220 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING 2 TROY J. WISHART Required (a) Prepare the account sales, and (b) Show the consignment inward account in the books of Galvez. Ignore interest. Question 4 Stone consigned goods to Rock on January 1, 1998, their value being $12,000, and it was agreed that Rock should receive a commission of 5% on gross sales. Expenses incurred by Stone for freight and insurance amount to $720. Stone’s financial year ended on March 31, 1998, and an “account sales” made up to that date was received from Rock. This showed that 70% of the goods had been sold for $10,600 but that up March 31, 1998, only $8,600 had been received by Rock in respect of these sales. Expenses in connection with the goods consigned were shown as being $350, and it was also shown that $245 had been incurred in connection with the goods sold. With the account sales, Rock sent a sight draft for the balance shown to be due, and Stone incurred bank charges of $12 on April 10, 1998, in cashing same. Stone received a further “account sales” from Rock made up to June 30, 1998, and this showed that the remainder of the goods had been sold for $4,800 and that $200 had been incurred by way of selling expenses. It also showed that all cash due had been received with the exception of a debt for $120 which had proved to be bad. A sight draft for the balance due was sent with the “account sales” and the bank charged Stone $9 on July 1, 1998, for cashing same. You are required to write up the necessary accounts in Stone’s books to record these transactions. LECTURE NOTES