Foo Yun Shuen Cassandra Gan Ding Han Jin Shuai Tran Viet Son Woo Kai Mun Dennis Project Work 2010 Project Task 2 - Alternatives Group Project Proposal 10S6H Choice of topic: Obesity is posing a growing threat to nations all over the world and to Singapore [see table 1] There were 1.6 billion overweight adults aged 15 and above and at least 400 million obese adults worldwide in 20051. Table 1: Prevalence of obesity among adults from 18 to 69 years old in Singapore2 Disease Prevalence in 1992 Prevalence in 1998 Prevalence in 2004 Obesity (BMI ≥ 5.1% 6.0% 6.9% 21.1% 24.4% 25.6% 30) Overweight (25 ≤ BMI ≤ 29.9) Obesity causes physical diseases such as cardiovascular diseases as well as psychological problem such as depression. Current measures: Trim and Fit Courses, including swimming, running, etc. Cooperation from tuck-shop vendors to sell healthy foods Involvement of parents 1 World Health Organisation statistic Adapted from National Health Survey2, http://www.pacifichealthsummit.org/downloads/Obesity%20Prevention%20and%20Control%20Efforts%20in%20Singapore%20%202008%20Case%20Study.pdf 2 Page 1 of 15 Approaches mostly targeting parents and teachers Students follow without really understand the reason, or find no joy in doing it (current methods and measures are not refreshing) Case study of how USA adopted various approaches to reduce the amount of carbon dioxide emitted into the atmosphere: Similarity between Case study and Problem Both obesity and rising concentration of atmospheric carbon dioxide 3 (CO2) are posing an increasing threat, on health and environment separately, to the society. Global warming due to rising atmospheric concentration of CO2 USA has adopted various strategies to solve this problem Based on natural settings and available resources of the concerned areas. Approach 1: Enhancing Oil Recovery Project4 Figure 1: How carbon dioxide can be used to enhance oil recovery o Kansas, USA o Oil firms and ethanol energy plants 3 Carbon dioxide CO2, accounted for global warming as it traps the heat due to incoming solar radiation and prevent it from escaping back to the atmosphere 4 Enhancing Oil Recovery Project. Kansas, USA. Funded by US Department of Energy. It uses carbon dioxide emitted from an ethanol plant to exert pressure on the remaining oil underground as well as greatly reduce the viscosity of crude oil, thus push them to the surface Page 2 of 15 o Utilise harmful CO2, but can only be installed near depleted oil field to minimise cost of gas transportation Approach 2: Switching to alternative source of energy Figure 2: Nellis Air Force Base Photovoltaic Power Plant o Photovoltaic Power Plant5 o Utilise solar energy, but occupying large areas and can only be set up at areas receiving sufficient amount of sunlight Lessons learnt: o Different methods are suitable for different situations o Profits can only be maximised in favorable conditions Proposal: Aim: o Preventing obesity rate from rising o Tackle the problem using fun and appealing approaches to students o Greater outreach to students 5 Nellis Air Force Base Photovoltaic Power Plant, Nevada, USA. The system size is 14 megawatt covering an area of 140 acres. Operating since 2007, it will help reduce carbon emission by 24,000 tons over 30 years Page 3 of 15 Target audience: o Students Obese/Overweight (Approach: Cure) Of acceptable weight (Approach: Prevention) Approach 1: Raising awareness of student population regarding healthy diet and joy of physical exercising. o Tailor-made approaches to suit different students Note: The students can be categorised using carefully crafted survey questions. Since the survey questions are free of ill intent, students ought to be able to answer honestly. Group 1 Directed at students who attempt losing weight unhealthily Broadcasting the harmfulness of unhealthy methods of weightloss such as Dieting (liquid diet – replacing solid food with fluids, carbohydrate diet – abstinence from starchy foods) Refusal to eat (anorexia) Inducing vomiting after meals (bulimia) Teaching the importance of healthy diet and exercising and its advantages over the inappropriate weight-loss methods as mentioned above Education on nutrition – showcasing different types of foods, their calorie count and explaining that not taking in certain foods might instead be detrimental to weight-loss efforts It is apparent that more and more youths are using Page 4 of 15 Smartphones such as iPhone, HTC Hero etc., which are touch screen phones. This leads to the possibility of the following application: Instead of having a lock icon on the lock interface of the Smartphone, there can be a great number of pictures of food, of a great variety (healthy and unhealthy) on the interface. In order to unlock the phone, one has to drag 3 food items with a particular characteristic (eg. contains natural sweeteners / high in fibre / contains antioxidants) to the image of an obese man on the lock interface; the man will then become thin and the phone will be unlocked. This will help to educate the general public on the different types of foods and their consumption benefits. Group 2 Directed at students who lack willpower Showcasing the harmfulness of obesity (See below) Encouraging peer motivation Usage of Twitter and Facebook Garnering support and help, or at least understanding, from others is crucial to weight loss. Groups and pages could be set up on the above networking websites; an online community of people hoping to lose weight would thus be formed and the administrators of the group could post tips Page 5 of 15 and advice from experts regarding weight loss. Members of the group could also post updates on personal progress with weight loss, and this would serve as motivation to others. Helping them set up strict schedules to follow A possible system would be for students to clock in hours of outdoor activity or Physical Education instead of making payment in exchange for canteen food Group 3 Directed at students who do not see the need to lose weight Showcasing the harmfulness of obesity (See below) Introducing them to different sports o With correspondence to the likings and preferences of teenagers today, showcasing the harmfulness of obesity can involve the organisation of competitions such as the design and illustration of comic strips and manga with storylines involving explanations or depictions of the harmfulness of obesity. The winning entry can then be distributed to all students to increase awareness. Besides the above, the following can also help to raise awareness about obesity: o Exhibitions: Posters and video productions (short films) on obesity Workout session / demonstration conducted by professional trainers; all at the exhibition who are interested will be allowed to join in to pick up workout tips o Various booths with laptops to conduct pop quizzes with the participants / allow participants to play specially-designed flash games Page 6 of 15 Players will be required to answer questions regarding the nutrition value of different foods and involving mixing and matching different foods to form the ideal breakfast / lunch / dinner. If the player answers correctly, the character in the Role-Playing Game (RPG) will become slimmer and fitter, but if the player answers incorrectly or inappropriately (i.e. there could have been a better answer but the player answered otherwise), the character becomes fatter and flabbier. The game ends when all questions are answered or if the character reaches the weight range of obesity. Approach 2: Introducing Parkour to the student population as a new and fun sport A 2-day camp comprising the following activities can be organised: First day Seminars/Sharing sessions and Simulation games for parkour training Second day Parkour training and amazing race o Seminars: Videos of parkour will be showcased Experts can be invited to give an insight to parkour o Sharing sessions Page 7 of 15 There will be first-hand accounts by those who have successfully lost weight appropriately and enjoyed the process of it The account will motivate students to lose weight / stay fit o Parkour6 training (Collaborating with the Singapore Parkour Community) Figures 3, 4, 5 and 6: Examples of parkour moves, which can be used as a form of physical training o Amazing race: Participants will need to overcome obstacles along the way to win attractive prizes that will help in their upcoming fight to lose weight and stay fit through exercise The art of overcoming obstacles within one’s path using efficient methods, whereby the movements chosen depends on the speed, angle of approach, body type, and physical make-up of the obstacles. It utilises fast redistribution of body weight and momentum. Training can be conducted by hiring professional trainers. 6 Page 8 of 15 Approach 3: Usage of psychology and humans’ perception of colour in dieting. Color and the appeal of various foods are closely related. Just the sight of food fires neurons in the hypothalamus. The appearance of food largely determines our liking towards it. Figures 7 and 8: A million years ago, when our earliest ancestors were foraging for food, blue, purple and black were "color warning signs" of potentially lethal food. These pictures illustrate how blue, purple and black foods look unappetising and slightly repulsive to humans. Of all the colors in the spectrum, blue is the one that is the appetite suppressant. “A study which involved asking contestants their favorite foods, dying them blue and asking them to eat them showed that blue food is instantly found to be much less appealing, even if it tastes normal.” (Morton, 2008) Blue food is a rare occurrence in nature. There are no leafy blue vegetables, no blue meats, and aside from blueberries and a few blue-purple potatoes from remote spots on the globe, blue does not exist in any significant quantity as a natural food color. Consequently, we don't have an automatic appetite response to blue. As such, we propose to work with canteens in schools to serve food on blue plates, or paint the walls of the canteen blue, or using blue lighting in the cafeteria. Page 9 of 15 On the other hand, colours like red and yellow increase breathing and heart rate and also appetite. White also causes mindless snacking and overeating. This means that canteen stalls selling healthier food can have signs painted red yellow. This also means that unhealthy foods that are white can be dyed other colours with food colouring. Possible problems: Time constraint due to colleges’ tight schedules Difficult to change students’ mindset Safety issues deter students from participating in parkour activities Economic limitations Possible solutions: Events can be carried out during school breaks. Convince them by showing potential threat of obesity Step up safety precautions by introducing safety equipment and keeping the parkour course to a reasonable safety level Ask for sponsorship from willing organisations Feasibility: Appeal to the students’ interest (alternative games/sports are novelties) o Interest in sports can be stimulated in students (encourage students to exercise regularly) First-hand account (conducting of sharing sessions) increases the persuasiveness Page 10 of 15 Manageability: Exhibitions can be held in schools Target audience is restricted to students population only, which makes project more manageable Funding can be sponsored by Health Promotion Board or organisations like SingTel or StarHub who want to use the events to help advertising Methods used to gather information: Primary resources Objectives Interview with Health Promotion Gathering Board officers information about fitness exercises Discuss the feasibility of introducing the alternatives into curriculum. Survey for student population on There will be 2 surveys in total. physical exercises to maintain (i) fitness To see what the students’ concerns are regarding current methods by schools to lose weight and what interests them, so as to design a better approach. (ii) To collect feedback on proposed alternative methods as mentioned above Sample size: Total of 300 students from various Junior Colleges, 16-18 years old. Page 11 of 15 Secondary URL Objectives Singapore www.hpb.gov.sg/default.a To obtain fact and figures Health spx To gather information about past resources Promotion and current efforts in dealing with Board obesity World Health www.who.int/en/ Organisation To obtain information about strategies implemented by other countries Singapore www.le-parkour.sg To learn about parkour and to parkour look for programs organised for community the public Miscellaneous http://www.associatedcont To find out how countries deal websites ent.com/article/1138958/a with similar problems and learn _lesson_from_the_food_s lessons from them hortage_in.html http://news.anu.edu.au/?p =900 http://www.mext.go.jp/b_m enu/hakusho/html/hpae19 9201/hpae199201_2_015. html Page 12 of 15 Steps used to carry out the project: Commencement Date To be completed 6th May Finalisation of Group Project Cassandra 8th May Work Allocation Proposal Viet Son Setting up of GPPedia Ding Han Carrying out of basic research of Jin Shuai (in-charge) current weight measures management Dennis recommended and Cassandra carried out by schools as well as incorrect methods of dieting adopted by students today 15th May Formation of survey questions Viet Son Formation of (email) interview Ding Han questions. *Both the survey and interview should ideally be done online to maximise productivity. Questions to be sent out only after approval from other members. 19th May Surveying Round 1 (Circulation All of surveys) 28th May CT Session (Multimedia All presentation to introduce student *Note: Attaining of Page 13 of 15 population to Parkour games permission to address and other aspects of our cohort- Dennis Proposal - see above) 31st May Surveying Round 2 (Circulation All of surveys) 9th June Sharing session / interviewing of All people who have successfully *Note: lost weight Contacting speakers- of Cassandra and Jin Shuai 20th to 21st June (Exact Conducting of Parkour games All date to be finalised to trial, interviewing (for anecdotal *Note: Contacting ensure all members can evidence) of those who attended organisation be present within the 2 the trial to analyse of and general relevant logistics details days) response 24th June Collation of survey results and All (Editors: Cassandra, analysis of data - All Ding Han) [Our Written Report will consist of the following sections: Abstract / Introduction / Literature Review / Survey Results / Interview Results / Trial Results / Data Analysis / Discussion / Conclusion] ---------------------END--------------------- Page 14 of 15 References: ANU College of Medicine Biology and Environment. (2009, January 08). Beating the global myopia threat. Retrieved from http://news.anu.edu.au/?p=900 Associated Press. (2004, October 05). Singapore takes strict steps against obesity, overweight kids singled out for extra exercise in school. Retrieved from http://www.msnbc.com/id/6124732/ Lee, Warren. (May 2003). Fighting Fat: With TAF in Singapore. Diabetes Voice, 48. Retrieved from http://www.diabetesvoice.org/files/attachments/article_82_en.pdf Low, Serena, Chin, Mien Chew, & Yap, Mabel-Deurenberg. (2009). Review on epidemic of obesity.38(1), 58-58. Retrieved from http://www.annals.edu.sg/pdf/38VolNo1Jan2009/V38N1p57.pdf Morton, J.L. (2008, August 22). Colour Matters – The Effects of Colour on the Body: Appetite. Retrieved from http://www.colormatters.com/appmatters.html National Energy Technology Laboratory (2005, January 10). CO2 Injection Boosts Oil Recovery, Captures Emissions. ScienceDaily . Retrieved from http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/01/050110091718.htm The National Bureau of Asian research. Soon, Grace, Koh, Yang Huang, Wong, Mun Loke, & Lam, Pin Woon. (2008). Obesity Prevention and Control Efforts in Singapore. Retrieved from http://www.pacifichealthsummit.org/downloads/Obesity%20Prevention%20and %20Control%20Efforts%20in%20Singapore%20%202008%20Case%20Study.pdf Page 15 of 15