Name: WJEC GCSE Catering Controlled Practical Assessment Task 2 – 40% of final GCSE For Task 2 you will produce a written assessment consisting of 10 pages / 20sides of A4 and a practical exam of a 2 course meal that shows all your skills as a cook. Work will be marked as follows: 1. � Investigating and planning the task (25 marks) 2. � Carrying out the task (Practical exam) (40 marks) 3. � Evaluating the task (15 marks) WJEC allow 30 hours of logged time. They want work presented using ICT and font size no larger than 12. The final meal should serve 2 people. Photographic evidence of all parts of the assessment is essential. Task 2 Brief Celebrity chefs have been promoting the importance of a healthy diet. As a school caterer you have been asked to produce and serve a two course meal that would encourage healthy eating in the school canteen. Important dates: (Write into your planner) Start date: 5th Nov 2014 Work to be completed: Investigation including practical testing Planning of Task (Menu choice, reasons for choice, plan for making) Carrying Out the Task (Practical exam) Evaluating the Task FINAL HAND IN DEADLINE Finished by: 10th December 2014 17th December 2014 w/c 12th Jan 2015 4th Feb 2015 6th Feb 2015 Also available on www.keswickfood.weebly.com and Shared>Secondary>Technology>GCSE catering>Practical task 2 1 Contents Mark Criteria 3 Introduction 4 Investigation 4 Nutrition 4 Recipe Trials 5 Menu choice 5 Reasons for choice 5 Ingredients List 6 Time Plan 6 Evaluation 6 Suitability of the chosen dishes for the task 6 Consumer Acceptability: Flavour, Texture and Appearance 6 Nutrition evaluation 7 Cost per Portion 7 Improvements 7 Appendices (Appendix) 7 Practical skill level 8 Cost calculations 9 Catering Terminology 10 Practical exam guide 11 2 Marking Criteria Investigation and Planning 0–5 6-12 13-19 20-25 Limited understanding of the task Little information from restricted sources A poor choice of dishes mostly low skill. Basic understanding of the task Some information from restricted sources A restricted choice of dishes mostly medium and low skill Good understanding of the task Reasons for choice No reasons given and no reference to cost or nutritional value. Some reasons given with general comments on cost and nutritional value Order of work Plan for making lacks detail Order of work is sequential. Reasonable understanding of the task. Relevant information from at least 4 sources Dishes chosen are suitable to task and there are some medium and high skill dishes Reasons given and realistic reference made to cost and nutritional value findings from investigation Order of work is clear and timings are realistic some quality and safety points included Written presentation Poor expression hampers communication Writing is structured clearly, relatively few errors Writing is well structured and fit for purpose, clearly expressed and largely error-free. Specialist terminology Little or no use of specialist terminology. Writing shows some structure; expression is adequate although errors are apparent Limited use of specialist terminology. Correct use of specialist terminology. Appropriate use of terminology throughout. Task analysis Investigation Menu choice Detailed, concise research from a wide range of relevant sources A good choice of dishes chosen Valid reasons given and accurate analysis of cost and nutritional value based on investigation results A detailed, dovetailed and logical order of work with a good range of relevant quality and safety points A*= 23-25 A=20-22 B=17-19 C= 13-16 D=10-12 E=7-9 F=3-6 G=2-3 Evaluation 0–3 4-7 8-11 12-15 Acceptability to customers (Including appearance, flavour, texture) Description of meal given but little or no reference to customers or changes and improvements that are needed. Brief analysis of meal’s appearance, flavour and texture. Some reference to customer and possible changes/ improvements Clear evaluation of appearance, flavour and texture and comment referring to acceptability to customer and changes or improvements that are needed. Analysis and evaluation of nutrition content Evaluation of cost of meal and profit margins Little or no reference to nutrition Limited attempt at nutrition analysis. Brief comment Nutritional analysis is accurate and results explained. Detailed analysis of appearance, flavour and texture and appropriate measure of acceptability to customer (Customer rating results/ Star profiles from a few different testers). Comment relates to test results and any changes or improvements needed. Nutritional analysis is accurate and results evaluated in relation to the task.. Little attempt made to cost the meal. Little or no reference to profit margins Brief attempt made to cost the meal and calculate profit margins Costing completed accurately for all dishes and evaluated with reference to profit margins and portion sizes. Improvements and developments No Suggestions made May make unrealistic or irrelevant suggestions Written presentation Information is poorly organised. and frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar. Specialist Terminology Little or no use of specialist Language. Information shows evidence of structure expression conveys meaning but errors are apparent in spelling, punctuation and grammar. Limited use of specialist language Costing completed for all dishes and evaluated with reference to profit margins and portion sizes. Some suggestions made for improvements and developments related to evaluation of acceptability, nutrition and costing Information is well organised. Some errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar. Good use of specialist language Very good use of specialist language A*= 14-15 A=12-13 B=10-11 C= 8-9 D=6-7 E=4-5 F=2-3 G=1 Planning /25 Making /40 Evaluation /15 Several suggestions made for improvements and developments related to evaluation of acceptability, nutrition and costing Information is well organised and presented in a highly appropriate manner. Few errors in spelling, punctuation and grammar. Total /80 Grade Boundary: A*= 74-80 A= 63-73 B= 53-62 C= 42-52 D= 31-41 E= 21-30 F= 11-20 G=5-10 3 Please use the following as a guide to the lay out of your controlled assessment. Examples can be found on the shared area: Shared>Secondary>Technology>GCSE Catering> Year 11> Practical Task 2 Page Example Page 1: Titles and description ( = All should include this in investigation. > = for grades A and B you should also try these points too) In exam user area Open word and save as “Task 2” Insert Header with Name and Candidate number Feedback → ? Task 2 Outline: Copy the task. Highlight the key words in the task outline Analysis of task: Explain… What you think the task is asking you to do. What you need to investigate in order to complete the task. How you could carry out the investigation eg websites, books, recipe trials, taste testing, surveys etc Page 2-7: Investigation Page 8: Nutritional Information Investigation What does healthy eating mean? Why is healthy eating so important? How can cooking be made healthier? Who or what promotes or affects healthy eating in schools? Eg ‘Healthy Schools’, the ‘5 a day’ campaign, Change 4 Life etc Identify some of the Celebrity Chefs trying to promote healthy eating and what they wanted to do to school meals Explain the impact one or more of these celebrity chefs have had. (Food Standards in schools) Investigate the quality and range of convenience food available to the school caterer, do some practical testing and label analysis of nutrition. Investigate the cost and budget allowances for school meals in the UKs What types of meals are “customers” demanding. (Both parent who pay and children who eat) Investigate the UK food seasons and how recipes can be adapted to use seasonal produce What changes there have been in customer demand in recent years (popularity of seasonal and locally grown foods, free range foods, organic foods and fair trade)? Remember to write a source for any info Eg (Source: Mrs M’s Nutrition lesson) (Source: www.bbc.co.uk/food) Nutritional Knowledge Explain of the main nutrients (plus fibre and water) why we need them and what foods are good sources. Investigate the nutritional requirements for children in schools Look at the nutritional requirements for school children with special dietary needs or who have food allergies or intolerances. 4 Page 9 and 10: Testing recipes Testing recipes: Produce a table or mind map of starters, mains with accompaniments and desserts that would be suitable for the task. Annotate with skills and healthy eating comments Adapt recipes to meet nutritional guidelines. Test some meals as trials for your practical task and write up each one with skill level, cost, appearance, taste and texture Look at recipes and menus for school children with special dietary needs. Plan a week’s menus for school children in either a primary or secondary school. Remember that cost is an important factor as well as nutritional balance and choosing food that children will enjoy. Page 11, 12 &13: Menu Choice/ Reasons for choice/ Plan for making Choosing your menu: Now you must decide on what you will make for your two-course meal. Look at your chosen recipes ideas and think about the VARIETY and RANGE of: Colours, textures and flavours. Are you showing a variety of cooking methods (e.g., boiling, baking, frying, grilling, etc.)? Are you showing a variety of skills? eg - ‘Rubbing-in’ (e.g pastry-making) ‘Creaming’ (e.g pineapple upside-down pudding, piped biscuits). ‘Whisking’ (e.g gateau, Swiss roll and roulade). ‘Sauce making’ (e.g béchamel, custard). ‘Yeast mixtures’ (e.g pizza, bread rolls). Dishes using meat, chicken and fish (e.g., chicken chasseur, lasagna, fish pie). Menu Choice List your 2 course meal as it would be shown on a menu with accompaniments Reasons for choice: (Explain why you have chosen the meal you will make and what you will serve with them. Use Specialist Catering terminology where ever possible) Points to include …. Time: Can you make them in the time available? Explain the order you might make things in to have them all ready at the same time Nutrition: Explain how your meal meets the nutritional needs of the task. Think about the Eatwell Plate and the nutritional needs of school children. Practical Skills: Explain the practical skill you will demonstrate. Explain if they are high, medium or low skill. Cost: Is the cost of the ingredients reasonable for a school meals menu? Explain which are the expensive ingredients and how the overall costs can be reduced. Equipment: Explain how you can use labour saving/ quality improving equipment – such as a food processor, hand blender, food mixer, bread maker, pasta maker to make these dishes? Appearance, taste and texture: Do the dishes balance in colour, taste and texture? For example: do you use cheese in each dish? Are all the dishes soft? Are all the dishes red? 5 Ingredients list General 50g plain flour Plain chocolate to grate as decoration Fruit and veg 3 lemons Meat 200g chicken Fish Dairy 300ml double cream 50g butter 150g cream cheese Ingredients list Use your recipes to write and overall shopping list grouping the foods into types eg Fruit and veg etc Time plan Now you need to plan how you will cook and serve them within the time allowed. Draw a table like the one below and list what you need to do and in what order you will tackle tasks. Try colour coding each different dish so help keep your planning clear. Include clean as you go at appropraite times in your plan. The following dishes should be prepared first; bread, pastry, mousses, desserts that need to be chilled/set, cakes that need to cool before decorating. Add times for each stage of your practical to help keep you on track Add quality and safety point points to the special points column In the special points column you need to include health, safety and hygiene, cooking temperatures, cooling temperatures, storage places. You have 15 minutes mise-en-place and 1 ¾ hours cooking and 15 mins clean up Example and guidelines: Time START TIME: 11:15 Action MISE-EN-PLACE Marks allocated for preparation of self, preparation of work area, collection and weighing ingredients, collection of equipment, utensils and serving dishes. NO COOKING IN THIS TIME Special Points GOOD CONSIDERATION NEEDS TO BE SHOWN TO HEALTH & SAFETY TO GET MAXIMUM MARKS…TRY TO GET A HEALTH & SAFETY POINT FOR EACH STAGE OF MAKING. COOKING START TIME: 11.30 START COOKING! Sequence. Marks are allocated for showing a logical sequence of work reflecting methodical thinking, e.g., dishes which require the longest cooking, or a lengthy time for setting, should be made first. Correct methods of preparation should be recorded, consistency of food (if applicable), cooking times Reference should be made to: Adjustments in oven temperatures. Check length of cooking time for vegetables to serve hot. Meals should be served in sequence. Clearing up should be mentioned at least once. Use of seasoning. Tests for readiness. Use of oven gloves Garnish and decoration. Use different colours to help distinguish between each dish. (e.g., Dish 1 – Red, Dish 2 – Green etc.) Always allow yourself 10 minutes for presentation, garnishing and serving. HAVE A NEW ROW FOR EACH STAGE. THIS HELPS YOU TO KEEP YOUR TIMINGS AND HEALTH & SAFETY ORGANISED! END TIME: 1.30 Completion. Marks allocated for presentation and serving of meal/foods, clean work surfaces or units, clearing up generally, turning off equipment, returning equipment to correct storage place. EVERYTHING NEEDS TO BE FINISHED, PRESENTED & CLEARED AWAY BY THIS TIME. Pages 14-20: Evaluation Evaluation: For each course of your meal include: Photo with labels to explain the dishes Suitability of meal for brief and customers For each dish, including accompaniments, you should write about the following: o Why were they suitable for the task, ie a healthy school meal? o Did you include a variety of cooking skills, e.g., sauce-making, pastry-making, bread-making, rubbing-in, creaming, whisking? State which skills you used for each dish. o Did you include a variety of cooking methods, e.g., boiling, baking, toasting, frying, poaching, microwaving? State which methods of cooking you used for each dish. o Time management (was the preparation and cooking time of the dish appropriate for the task?) Did you manage your time well whilst cooking this dish in the exam? Acceptability to customers Write a comment about appearance, taste and texture and your overall opinion of the dish Add a star profile and have results from several testers. Add comments about your testers opinions. 6 Suggest improvements and developments to your meal. Nutrition evaluation Explain how well your dishes meet the eat well plate and healthy eating guidelines from your investigation. Use Explore Food or Food in Focus to do nutritional analysis and comment on how well meal meets healthy eating guidelines and nutritional needs of school children . Evaluation of cost and portion size (Use the costing recipes information on shared area or www.keswickfood.weebly.com website) Calculate cost per portion of raw food and the selling price of the meal. Comment on how reasonable this is for a school meal. Include profits and overheads in your costing calculations and evaluative comments Then add an overall comment about… Improvements If you repeated the task again what improvements could you make. Consider the actual dishes made in relation to nutrition, skills shown, finished appearance, taste and texture of results; time management; final presentation. Explain the reasons for the changes you have suggested. Add comment on any other improvements that could be made to whole project. Consider research, planning and evaluation in this comment Appendixes This is the section to put anything that is too big to go into your 20 pages, for example: Completed questionnaires, interviews and surveys Costing tables, nutritional analysis Photo’s Leaflets, menus, etc... Graphs that are too big to include 7 Food Preparation Skills The following is a guide to the level of skill found in practical dishes. In order to achieve high marks. You need to be aiming for the higher-level skills when they carry out practical assessments. Higher Level Skills: • Pastry making – short crust, pate sucre, choux. • Roux based sauces • Meringues and pavlovas • Meat and fish cookery (using high risk foods) • Decorated cakes and gateaux • Rich yeast doughs • Complex accompaniments and garnishes Medium Skills: Basic Skills: • Puff pastry items that need shaping • Crumbles. but use ready-made pastry. • Sandwiches. • Vegetable and fruit dishes requiring • Pizza with ready-made base. even sizes • Jacket potatoes. e.g. fruit salad, stir fry which show • Simple salads. competent knife skills • Assembling products e.g. using • Cheesecakes and similar desserts. prepared sauces, bought meringue • Simple sauces e.g. red wine sauce. nests, etc. • Simple cakes, biscuits, cookies and scones. • Basic bread doughs G to E candidates are likely to choose dishes that show basic skills only Examples: Apple crumble, baked apples, jacket potato with cheese, coleslaw or beans, French bread pizzas, Spaghetti Bolognese or other pasta dishes using a ready made sauce, sweet and sour dishes using a bought sauce, fruit platters, simple starters like prawn cocktail, etc. D to C candidates are likely to choose dishes from each of the skill levels but will demonstrate mainly medium level skills Examples: Sausage rolls and other items using ready-made puff pastry, cheesecake, all in one sauces, fresh fruit salads, stir fries, fairy cakes with simple decoration, scones, melted method cakes, biscuits and cookies e.g. shortbread, bread rolls, simple meat or fish cookery e.g. cooking fish, chops, steak or chicken pieces (without stuffing or sauces), chicken in simple sauces e.g. chicken chasseur, cold curried chicken salad, kebabs, simple rice and pasta dishes with home made sauces. B to A* candidates are likely to choose dishes from the high and medium level skills range Examples: Quiche Lorraine (or similar) using short crust pastry, Bakewell tart (or similar) using pate sucre, profiteroles or éclairs using choux pastry, decorated gateau or roulade (whisking method cake), Swiss buns or Chelsea buns made with rich yeast dough, lasagne with béchamel sauce, fish pie, chicken and fish dishes with more elaborate sauces or stuffing, decorated cakes and pastry items that require piping and decoration skills as well as shaping. Look at the table above, highlight your target / challenge grade area and use this as reference for the level of difficulty that needs to be shown in the dishes that you will make. Remember; • If only basic-level skills are shown then a maximum of 16/40 should be awarded. • If mostly medium-level skills are shown a maximum mark of or 26/40 should be awarded. • If mostly high-level skills are shown a maximum mark of 40/40 should be awarded. 8 Working out Costing You need to know the detailed costing of each dish that you are making as you need to comment on it in both the planning and evaluation in order to achieve higher marks. To work out the costing you need to have: Your recipes (with the ingredients & amounts needed) The internet on the Asda website A calculator How to work out costing: 1. Use the website to work out the cost of each ingredient. Remember to work out the price for the amount that you have used not the whole pack. 2. Input this into a costing table and add up the total eg. Dish: Strawberry Gateau Ingredient: Amount: Eggs 3 Caster sugar 75g Plain flour 75g Double cream 250ml Punnet of Strawberries 1 TOTAL SERVES 8 COST PER PORTION SELLING PRICE Cost: In shop 6 for £1.50 £1.99 for 1kg 59p for 1.5kg 89p for 250ml £1.99 per punnet Total in recipe 75 15 The sum is cost paid/ amount bought * amount used 03 Eg 150/6* 3 = 75 89 1 99 3 81 48 1 20 Round up to nearest penny Selling price need to include overheads such as fuel, rent and labour and profits. It is calculated by: Food cost per portion x 100 divided by 40 = selling price 9 Catering Terminology To get high band marks you need to show “Very good use of terminology.” Technical Terms Here are some technical terms that you should use in your written work: Skills for Meat and Vegetables Skills for Cakes and Biscuits Types of Pastry Types of Bread Chopping Creaming Rolls Slicing Shortcrust Rubbing-in Pizza Dicing Flan/Biscuit All–in-one Tortilla Peeling Crust Melting Naan Grating Flaky/Rough/Puff/Choux/Filo Whisking Pitta Julienne General Skills Weighing/Measuring Shaping Cutting Rolling out Folding Beating Sieving Decoration/Garnish Icing Types of Sauces Roux Coating All-in-one Glazing Blended Piping Feathering Drizzling Methods of Cooking Custard Coulis Desserts Whipping Gelatine Chilling Freezing Setting Layering Equipment Blender (hand) Electric whisk Grilling Oven Baking Roasting Bain-marie Hob Boiling Steaming Poaching Braising Shallow frying Deep frying Stir frying Microwave Food Processor Liquidiser Mill/Grinder Pasta maker Ice-cream maker Rice cooker Steamer Electric wok Zester Temperature Probe Key Terms Mise en place – Basic preparation prior to cooking. Accompaniments – Items offered separately to main dish. Al dente – Firm to the bite. Used to describe texture of pasta and vegetables. Au gratin – Sprinkled with cheese or breadcrumbs and browned under the grill (e.g., fish pie, cauliflower cheese). 10 Bain-marie – A container of water to keep foods hot without fear of burning, or to cook something gently (e.g., lemon curd or melting chocolate). Brûlée – Burned cream (e.g. Crème brûlée). Bouquet garni – A small bundle of herbs. Used to flavour soups, stocks, stews or Bolognese sauce. Coulis – Sauce made from fruit or vegetable puree (e.g., Raspberry coulis). Croutons – Cubes of bread that are fried or grilled. Use to garnish soup or salads. En croute – In a pastry case (e.g., salmon en croute). Entrée – Main course. Flambé – To cook with flame by burning away the alcohol (e.g., crepes Suzette). Garnish – Served as part of the main item to make the dish more colourful and appealing. Marinade – A richly spiced liquid used to give flavour and assist in tenderising meat and fish. Puree – A smooth mixture made from food passed through a sieve. Reduce – To concentrate a liquid by boiling or simmering (e.g., when making soups or sauces). Roux – A thickening of cooked flour and fat. Used as the base of a white/béchamel sauce. Sauté – Tossed in hot fat. Vegetable Cuts Brunoises – Vegetables cut into small cubes. Used for sautéing, a chili garnish or making garlic into a paste. Chiffonade – Shredded herbs, lettuce, cabbage etc. Jardinière – Vegetables cut into batons. Idea for stir fries or a vegetable accompaniment. Julienne – Thin matchsticks. Used in stir fries or for a chili garnish. Macédoine – A mixture of finely cut vegetables or fruits, sometimes jellied, and served as a salad, a dessert, or an appetizer. Popular for curries, stews, pastries etc. Paysanne – Squares, circles, triangles, semi circles. Ideal for soup. Carrying out the task (40 marks) In order to gain high marks in this section, candidates need to demonstrate: � High standards of personal hygiene e.g. wearing of apron / whites, hair back, no nail varnish, no jewellery, etc. � Good personal hygiene habits e.g. no licking fingers, tasting with a clean teaspoon, etc. � Safe use of equipment, especially knives, pans and electrical equipment 11 � Selection of the correct tools e.g. correct knife for chopping, peeling, etc. � Use of a wide variety of commodities within the task chosen � Good food hygiene e.g. perishable foods refrigerated and not left on work unit / table, using temperature probes to ensure food is cooked � Neat, organised work � Safe use of cooker � Working to time � Independent working � Good technical skills � Little food waste � Logical sequence of work e.g. food that needs to be cooked for a long time, be set or served cold needs to be made first � A wide variety of skills, including high level skills � High standard of final presentation e.g. portion control, use of garnish and decoration, good colour, correct temperature, correct texture, good flavour, appropriate serving dishes � Good sequencing and dove-tailing of dishes so that all elements of the meal are served at the correct temperatures � Appropriate serving of the meal Presenting Food The aim of a cook is to present food as near perfectly as possible. This involves: • Consistency (how thin or how thick) • Texture (includes crunchy, soft, crisp) • Flavour (includes salty, sweet, sour, bitter, well seasoned) • Seasoning (includes use of herbs, spices, salt and pepper) • Colour (remember white, cream, brown and green are ‘dead’ colours) • Decoration (used on sweet dishes – includes chocolate, cherries, fresh fruit etc • Garnish (used on savoury dishes – includes tomato, parsley, lemon, cucumber, cress, etc.) • Accompaniments – these include colourful vegetables and sauces. As a general rule, do not over season, over-decorate or over fill serving dishes. Chefs gradually learn the skills of tasting food to check for flavour, texture and seasoning. Hot foods should be served hot and not warm, preferably on hot plates. Shaped and dramatic coloured plates can add to the overall appearance and ‘drama’ of food. Cold food should be served cold, but not frozen and always on cold plates. Food probes can be used to check temperatures (if available). Savoury food is usually served in oval dishes or on oval plates if appropriate (with plain doyleys or dish papers) Sweet food is usually served in round dishes or on round plates if appropriate (with pretty doyleys) Consistency: The consistency of food will depend on the size of pan used, the cooking time, the amount of thickener e.g. flour used and the quality of ingredients. It is easier to thin a mixture like a soup or a sauce rather than thicken it. Texture: Tasting food is essential in order to test texture. This includes checking foods like rice, pasta (cooked al dente), and vegetables to ensure they are not over-cooked. Cooking alters the texture of food and an experienced cook will know when the right amount of heat has been applied to give the correct texture e.g. cooking steaks. Contrasting textures are important to give variety and interest to a meal e.g. croutons with soup, wafers and ice cream, cheese and biscuits. Flavour and seasoning: Taste is very important. Good cooks know how to retain the flavour of food and how to alter the flavour of food. To retain flavour chefs need to: • Use food as fresh as possible • Use the least amount of cooking liquid • Use the cooking liquid where possible (for sauces, stocks and gravies) • Use appropriate cooking methods • Prepare, cook and serve in as short a time as possible • Not over-season so that customers cannot taste the natural flavour • Use herbs and strongly flavoured foods with care • Adjust seasoning at the end. 12