Women's Studies 4114 – FA 2014 Transnational Feminism Monday and Wednesday 2:30 – 4:00 RB-2026 Dr. Jenny Roth jroth@lakeheadu.ca Office: RB-2014 ph: 766-7116 Office Hours: Wednesdays 9:45 –10:45 am, or by appointment (contact Admin Assistant) Women’s Studies office: Ms. Melissa Hrabok, Administrative Assistant melissa.hrabok@lakeheadu.ca Office: RB-2012 Ph: 343-8625 Office Hours: Mon. to Fri. 8:30 – 12:00 WELCOME to Women's Studies 4114. In this seminar course, we will explore how women around the world define women's issues in the context of their own cultures and histories. Instructor and students will discuss connections across cultures and between the local and global such as indigenous human rights, sex trafficking, poverty, security of borders and bodies, water and food, housing and access to resources, literacy, religion, migrant workers and globalization. By the end of the term, students will have developed a working understanding of the transnational connections between issues, peoples, and activisms. Students will also develop writing, seminar, presentation and analytical skills. TEXTS The following textbook is required and is available at the Bookstore for purchase, and on reserve in the library. I have also provided alternate locations to source some of the readings, where they are available. Lee, Janet and Susan Shaw, eds. Women Worldwide: Transnational Feminist Perspectives on Women. Toronto: McGraw Hill, 2011. ASSIGNMENTS & GRADING Participation, due in course Transnational Reflections, sign up sheet Transnational You, 6 Oct 14 Research Paper, 27 Oct 14 / 19 Nov 14 20% details below (2 x 15%) 30% details below 20% details below 30% details below All assignments will be formatted in: Times New Roman, 12 pt font, double-spaced, with 1-inch margins. Assignments not meeting these format requirements will have 5% deducted from the grade. 1 All assignments will be handed in, in hard copy, at the beginning of the class in which they are due. Any assignment not handed in at the start of class will garner a day’s late penalty. Assignments will be deducted 5% for each day late, including Saturdays and Sundays. Assignments over 7 days late will not be accepted without appropriate documentation. Emailed, faxed, or other forms of assignment will not be accepted. Please do not assume that handing your assignment in at the Women’s Studies office means that I have received it. Make sure I have your assignment when it is due to avoid late penalties. Participation 20% This seminar course requires that you come to class prepared to engage with the weekly topic and readings, the Instructor and your peers. Discussion Participation rubric (with thanks to Allegheny College) A grade: You regularly initiate discussion. You come to class thoroughly familiar with the required reading(s) and are prepared to raise questions, open discussion, identify topics of interest, and to actively engage other students in the discussion. Obviously, this does not mean monopolizing the discussion, shutting others down when they contribute, or talking for its own sake. You show respect for topic facilitation, your peers, and clear knowledge about the weeks' reading topics. B grade: You participate regularly and productively. You come to class having done the readings, and willing to engage. You differ from an A-grade discussant in that the latter do not rely on the instructor's questions to set the agenda for discussion. C grade: You participate on a regular basis, though less frequently than a B-grade student. Cgrade discussants' participation may indicate that they are not well-prepared for class, or have not given thought to the assigned materials (e.g.: you speak of personal experience without making connections with the weeks' readings). D grade: You contribute only infrequently to the discussion. D-grade discussants' contributions indicate that they are not well prepared for class, or have not given thought to the assigned materials. F grade: You do not contribute to class discussion OR your participation throughout the term indicates that you have not done the readings or given thought to the topics. Participation is impossible if you are absent. 50% or more absences from the course will mandate an F-grade for participation, inclusive of the written 1-2 paragraph response. Transnational Reflections 30% (ca. 20 min. presentations) “We do not learn from experience. Experience has to be arrested, examined, analysed, considered and negotiated in order to shift it to knowledge” -- Aitchison and Graham cited in Stroobants et al (2007:30) Throughout the term, we will cover topics which may be emotionally charged, troubling, or difficult to consider. In order to foster a safe classroom space in which we can examine many of the issues facing women around the world, and our own roles or positions in relation to those issues and global politics, you will do reflections on your experiences reading two weeks’ topics and present your findings to the class. To prepare your reflections you will use The Kolb Cycle for reflective learning (Kolb 1984), adapted to reading and reflection. Please move through the tabled steps below as you develop your presentation, 2 and bear in mind that affective learning (reflecting on why something makes us feel a certain way and thereby coming to new knowledge and understanding about our relationship to the topic, or the topic itself) is an important part of intellectual development which can lead to substantive personal and social change: Concrete Experience: Doing or having an experience Reflective Observation: Reviewing and reflecting on your experience Abstract Conceptualization: Moving toward new knowledge and understanding by adding informed / educational knowledge to your reflection Active Experimentation: Planning and practice on the basis of what you have learned what did you experience in your engagement with the week’s topic? what specific moments in your engagement with the topic stand out as important to your experience? what do you think were the good things about your experience with the week’s topic? what do you think were the challenging things about your experience? how might your experience have been affected by your own social location? your experiences or life history? how can transnational feminist theory be applied to your experience in order to help make sense of it? to move from experience towards understanding and action? what did you learn by experiencing, and reflecting on your experience of, the week’s topic? what plans or actions can you envision or suggest based on your newfound knowledge? Please prepare your reflection to hand in at the end of class, and use appropriate scholarly citations and formats. Transnational You 20% Due October 6, 2014 3-5 pages, excluding title page and bibliography We are all transnational, although transnational policies, practices, and histories create different experiences for each of us in our unique global and historical positions. Who are you, transnationally? In what ways can you recognize yourself as a transnational citizen caught up in transnational power structures? Remember to cite any paraphrased ideas from the course readings or lectures as you write your paper. I will expect to see 4 scholarly sources used in your work, 2 of which will come from the course readings. Research Paper 30% Topic proposal for feedback due October 27, 2014 Final paper due November 19, 2014 4-6 pages, excluding title page and bibliography Unfortunately, this class is only long enough to scratch the surface of some of the issues and trends 3 affecting girls and women around the world. The research paper is an opportunity for you to explore a topic you found or find particularly interesting in depth. Choose a topic related to transnational feminist action, and analyze it using the tools provided to you by the course. You will use a total of at least 5 scholarly readings, 2 of which are from different weeks of the course readings. Your topic proposal for feedback from your peers and me will be discussed in class on October 27, 2014. At that time, you will break into groups and give each other feedback. I’ll help the groups by providing things to look for in the proposal. I will then collect your proposal, and have it back to you by November 3, 2014 with brief feedback from me. There is no grade for your proposal, but your paper will be significantly better off because of it. When you prepare your proposal / topic, consider and include: Why does the topic / issue / problem / phenomenon you chose interest you? What is it about the topic that you want to discover or explore? (these first two questions will provide you with the thesis for your paper) Which readings from the course are useful to your topic, and why? (pull some useful quotes out of them for your proposal so that you’re ahead of the game when you begin your writing) Do you need to speak with a reference librarian in order to get help finding the scholarly readings outside the textbook? (if you do, don’t hesitate to ask them – they’re very helpful!) Notes on Plagiarism / Academic Dishonesty Keep a printout or photocopy of all your work, as well as any research notes and drafts that produce assignments. “Plagiarism” includes: 1. Plagiarism of ideas occurs where an idea of an author or speaker is incorporated into the body of an assignment as though it were the writer's own idea, no credit is given the person through citation. 2. Plagiarism of words occurs when phrases, sentences, tables or illustrations of an author or speaker are incorporated without citation. 3. Plagiarism of ideas and words occurs where words and an idea(s) of an author or speaker are incorporated into the body of a written assignment as though they were the writers' own words and ideas without citation. The following rules shall govern the treatment of candidates who have been found guilty of attempting to obtain academic credit dishonestly. (a) The minimum penalty for a candidate found guilty of plagiarism, or of cheating on any part of a course will be a zero for the work concerned. (b) A candidate found guilty of cheating on a formal examination or a test, or of serious or repeated plagiarism, or of unofficially obtaining a copy of the examination paper before the examination is scheduled to be written, will receive zero for the course and may be expelled from the University. A copy of the “Code of Student Behaviour and Disciplinary Procedures” including sections on plagiarism and other forms of misconduct may be obtained from the University's website, or from the 4 Office of the Registrar. Learning Needs If you have needs regarding the format or the due dates for the readings or assignments, you must make sure that I am informed. The appropriate form can be obtained from the Student Success Centre. Class Expectations, alongside the Student Code of Conduct You can expect from me that: I will provide you with feedback on rough drafts that I receive one week prior to the due date, if you want to provide them; I will stick to the course outline; I will encourage your learning, and support you in an inclusive and intellectually dynamic environment; I will hand back assignments two weeks after their due date; I will provide you with a mid-term participation estimate when I hand back your mid-term essay based on your work in the first half of the course; I will be available during my posted office hours to discuss any aspect of the course, and to answer more general questions you may have about the university system; I will check my work email during regular work hours (8:30 am – 4:30 pm), and will respond to your email as soon as I can during those times; I will do my best to give you enough information to succeed in this course. I will expect from you that: You will speak to me during office hours when you have questions about the course, the materials, your assignments, or your program; You will be in the classroom, ready to begin at 2:30; You will respect social and cultural differences. All participants have the right to hold, defend, and promote their opinion, but this right exists alongside regulations that protect all individuals' right to education without discrimination or harassment on the basis of gender, race, religion, class, sexual orientation, ability, age, place of origin, etc.; You will respect differences in political awareness and educational development. Use of tech for purposes other than note-taking or text book referencing Please feel free to use your technology as you will, so long as it doesn’t disturb those around you. If your use of technology disturbs the classroom environment in any way, including distracting me or your peers, you are in breach of the Student Code of Conduct, and will lose your tech privileges in the classroom for the duration of the course – no exceptions. 5 Weekly Topics & Readings Wk. 1: Sept. 8 / 10 Introduction to the Course Readings: None this week, welcome! Be prepared for lecture notes and writing. Goals: Historicize transnational feminism Define “transnational” and “transnational feminisms” and “TFN’s”: the foundations for our course Looking ahead: strategies for discussion and knowledge-building Revisit the concepts of intersectional feminism, social location and power structures In-class brief write-up of your understanding of transnationalism and your position in relation to it to share Wk. 2: Sept. 15 / 17 Why Transnational Feminisms? Required Readings: Wagner, C. “Women Still Have a Long Way to Go” p. 47i MacKinnon, C. “Are Women Human?” pp. 48-9ii Desai, M. “The Messy Relationship Between Feminisms and Globalization” pp. 50-3iii Mohanty, C.T. “Under Western Eyes: Scholarship and Colonial Discourse” pp. 53-7iv Gordimer, N. “Comrades” pp. 58-60 Abiola, H. “Edge of the Earth” pp. 60-1 Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? What are some pitfalls of transnational feminism? What are some strategies we can adopt to try to avoid those pitfalls? Wk. 3: Sept. 22 / 24 Global Politics of the Body Required Readings: Tabuchi, H. “Transgender Identity in Japan” pp. 131-2v Figert, A. “Premenstrual Syndrome as Scientific and Cultural Artifact” pp. 132-141vi Newman, L. “Perfectly Normal” pp. 142-148 Associated Press (2007). “Spain Bans Skinny Mannequins” pp. 148-9vii Takeuchi Cullen, L. “Changing Faces” pp. 149-154viii Agasin, M. “Mi Estomago (My Belly)” p. 154ix Zine, J. “Unveiled Sentiments: Gendered Islamophobia and Experiences of Veiling Among Muslim Girls in Canadian Islamic School” pp. 155-67x Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? What are “body politics”? In what ways are “body politics” global? Where is your body positioned in the transnational ideological construction of the body? Wk. 4: Sept. 29 / Oct. 1 Transnational Sexualities Required Readings: Kempadoo, K. “Toward a Vision of Sexual and Economic Justice” pp. 195-7 Rifaat, A. “Distant View of a Minaret” pp. 197-9 Kemp, K. “Cambodian Sex Workers” pp. 199-200xi Irin. “Sex Tourism Booming” pp. 200-202xii 6 Endsjø. D.Ø. “Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Rights and the Religious Relativism of Human Rights” pp. 202-5xiii Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? What others ways can you think of that sexualities are constructed differently across cultures? How do you see patriarchy intersecting with the sex trade? the construction of sexualities? Wk. 5: Oct. 6 / 8 Reproductive Freedoms ***Transnational You paper is due Oct. 6 at the start of class*** Required Readings Ahmed Obaid, T. “Investing in Reproductive Health and Rights” pp. 277-279xiv Fairbanks, K. and Hofman, H. “The ‘Morning After’ Pill: Debates and Conflicts in Ireland and the U.S.” pp. 279-282 Ramashwar, S. “Postpartum Depression in China” pp. 282-4xv Girish, U. “For India’s Daughters, a Dark Birth Day” pp. 284-6xvi Ewig, C. “Hijacking Global Feminism: Feminists, the Catholic Church, and the Family Planning Debacle in Peru” pp. 286-9xvii Golombok, S. “Unusual Families” pp. 295-300xviii Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? How do reproductive freedoms for women connect with women’s rights? ecological concerns? family violence? economic security? any other connections you can think of? Why do you think women still have to struggle for bodily autonomy, even though bodily autonomy is identified by international laws as a basic human right? Wk. 6: Oct. 13 Long Weekend Holiday / 15 Transnational Violence Against Women Required Readings: Bloch, C. “The Conservation of Energy” p. 378 Lehrer, J. et. al. “Prevalence of and Risk Factors for Sexual Victimization in College Women in Chile” pp. 378-85xix Amnesty International. “Killed in the Name of Honor” pp. 385-8xx Shank, M. “No Longer Silent” pp. 388-9xxi CBS News and Peter Finn. “War Against Women: Congo and Kosovo” pp. 389-94xxii Semple, K. “Domestic Violence in Afghanistan” pp. 394-6xxiii Drake, I. “Finding Dignity in Exile” pp. 396-8xxiv Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? What connections can you see between the many different forms of violence against women? How is violence against women exacerbated or mitigated by institutions, power structures, etc.? Wk. 7: Oct. 20 / 22 Working Women, Globally Required Readings: Rowling, M. “Women Farmers Toil to Expand Africa’s Food Supply” pp. 423-4xxv Hussain, S. “Women and Tourism” pp. 424-7xxvi Ting, S. “Assembly Line” pp. 427-8 Ross, M. “Oil, Islam, and Women” pp. 428-37xxvii Kincaid, J. “Girl” pp. 437-8xxviii 7 Kelley, S. and Sengupta, S. “Banking on Women” pp. 438-43xxix Burk, M. “The 40-Percent Rule” pp. 443-4 Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? How are you caught up in the working structures for women, globally? your foremothers? Wk. 8: Oct. 27 / 29 Women and the Environment ** Paper topic proposal due Oct. 27 at start of class** Required Readings: Hemmati, M. et. al. “Temperatures Rising: Four Essays on a Theme: Women and Climate Change” 474-87xxx Trask, H-K. “Waikīkī” pp. 487-8 Meallem, I. and Garb, Y. “Bedouin Women and Waste Related Hazards” pp. 488-93xxxi Taylor, D. “An Ugly Picture for Flower Workers and Their Children” pp. 493-4xxxii Rother, H-A. “Poverty, Pests, and Pesticides” pp. 494-8xxxiii Vaughan, G. “The World of the Gift Economy” pp. 498-501xxxiv Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? What connections can you see between your hometown industry(ies) and women and environmental politics? Your own environmental awareness? Gender and the environment / environmental movements? Wk. 9: Nov. 3 / 5 Women and Politics Required Readings: Rogers, K. “Revenge” p. 528 McDonald, A. “Please Mind the Gap” pp. 528-9xxxv Woods, E. “Leading Women” pp. 529-31 Dowl, A. “Women’s Worlds” pp. 531-2 McAllister, L. “Dal Dy Dir/Stand Your Ground: International Lessons on Women’s Equality from a Small Nation” pp. 532-9xxxvi Delgado, J. and Zwarteveen, M. “The Public and Private Domain of the Everyday Politics of Water” pp. 539-45xxxvii Tyler, P. “The Post-Katrina, Semiseparate World of Gender Politics” pp. 545-52xxxviii Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? What are the purposes of women’s political involvement? How politically involved are you? Wk. 10: Nov. 10 / 12 Women, War, and Peace Required Readings: Borden, M. “The City in the Desert” pp. 579-81 Herbert, W. “Children of War” pp. 581-5xxxix Ferris, E. “Abuse of Power: Sexual Exploitation of Refugee Women and Girls” 585-9xl Zeijl, F. van. “Rape in Darfur” pp. 589-91xli Eisler, R. “Building Cultures of Peace: Four Cornerstones” pp. 591-6xlii Maraini, D. “Plaza de Mayo” pp. 596-7 Abu Lughod, L. “Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving?” pp. 597-606xliii 8 Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? Is there peace for women? How do violences against women and state / military violences intersect? Wk. 11: Nov. 17 / 19 Integrated Themes **Research Paper due November 19th at the start of class** Required Readings Payne, J. “Janice, Marvelyn, and Michelle: USA” pp. 628-30xliv The Associated Press. “Keren: Honduras” pp. 630-1 Brown, P. “Jacqueline, Isata, and Adele: Uganda, Sierra Leone, and Rwanda” pp. 631-4 Hoh, W. K. “Srey: Cambodia” pp. 634-6 Itano, N. “Mantombi Nyawo: South Africa” 636-8xlv Mehta, A. K. and Gupta, S. “Parvati and Fatima: India” 638-40 Nelson, E. “Thembi: South Africa” pp. 640-5xlvi Scheier, R. “Mama’s Club: Uganda” pp. 645-6xlvii UNAIDS. “Tatiana and Dina: Russia and Ukraine” pp. 646-xlviii Name some of the issues that appear in this week’s readings. Which readings resonated with you the most, and why? How do the readings this week do transnational feminism? What strategies can you see in the readings to work towards integrating transnational themes while including cultural specificities? Wk. 12: Nov. 24 / 26 Your choice! Of the remaining chapters, choose the one that interests you the most. Draw out the main theme of the chapter and bring some specific things you learned that interested you the most. I’ll put groups of similar-readers together at the start of the week for a quick discussion and you can work as a team, as – as a group – we find the exciting connections across the different interest areas, and bring to each other information about how to consider local possibilities or alliances to work towards change. Choose from Chapters: 2 World Media (pp. 85-102); 5 Politics of Women’s Health (pp. 228-247); or 7 Families in Global Context (pp. 324-340). Library e-journals: “Progress Report on Discrimination Against Women: Women Still Have a Long Way to Go, a UN Committee Reports.” The Futurist 42.3 (2008): 9. ii Library reserve: MacKinnon, Catharine. Are Women Human? And Other International Dialogues. iii Library e-journals: Gender & Society 21.6 (2007): 797-803. iv Library e-journals: boundary 2 12.3 (1984): 333-358. v Online: http://www.dallasvoice.com/japanese-transgender-community-emerges-1021171.html vi Library e-journals: Integrative Physiological & Behavioral Science 40.2 (2005): 102-113. vii Online: http://www.nbcnews.com/id/17596139/ns/health-health_care/t/adios-spain-bans-skinny-mannequinsstores/#.U9kdIvldXoE viii Online: http://content.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2047454,00.html ix GIC Reserve: from Alexander, J. et al. eds. Women & Ageing: An Anthology by Women. x Library e-journals: Equity & Excellence in Education 39.3 (2006): 239-252. xi Library e-journals: “Cambodian Centre Steers Trafficked Women from Sex Trade.” Herizons 20.3 (2007): 8-9. xii Online: http://www.irinnews.org/report/81528/colombia-sex-tourism-booming-on-the-caribbean-coast xiii Library e-journals: Human Rights Review 6.2 (2005): 102-110. xiv Library e-journals: “Breaking the Cycle of Poverty in Achieving in MDGs.” UN Chronicle 44.4 (2007): 19-20. xv Library e-journals: “In China, Women Who Give Birth to Girls Face an Increased Risk of Postpartum Depression.” International Family Planning Perspectives 33.4 (2007): 191-2. i 9 xvi Online: http://www.csmonitor.com/2005/0209/p11s01-wosc.html Library e-journals: Feminist Studies 32.3 (2006): 632-59. xviii Library e-journals: Reproductive Biomedicine Online 10.Supplement 1 (2005): 9-12. xix Library e-journals: International Family Planning Perspectives 33.4 (2007): 160-75. xx Library reserve for this class. xxi Online (partial), http://www.msmagazine.com/winter2009/NoLongerSilent.asp xxii Online, Essay 1, http://www.cbsnews.com/news/war-against-women/ AND Essay 2, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/inatl/longterm/balkans/stories/rape062799.htm xxiii Online, “Long Viewed as Chattel, Afghan Women Slowly Gain Protection” http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/03/world/asia/03shelter.html?adxnnl=1&fta=y&adxnnlx=1406743281uy+b28av9VoOJxC+tr9AOQ xxiv Online, http://www.yesmagazine.org/issues/a-conspiracy-of-hope/finding-dignity-in-exile xxv Online, http://in.reuters.com/article/2008/12/26/idINIndia-37187320081226 xxvi Online, http://archive.thedailystar.net/newDesign/print_news.php?nid=5303 xxvii Library e-journal, American Political Science Review 102.1 (2008): 107-23. xxviii Library reserve, from Kincaid, Jamaica. At the Bottom of the River. xxix Online (partial), http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-164110795.html xxx Library e-journal, excerpts from: “A Huge Challenge…”; “Temperatures Rising”; “Japanese Women’s Roles in Climate Change Mitigation…”; and “Gendered Struggles for the Commons…” in Women & Environments International Magazine 74/75 Spring/Summer 2007. xxxi Library e-journal, “The Exposure of Bedouin Women to Waste Related Hazards.” Women & Environments International Magazine Fall/Winter 2008 Issue 76/77: 44-8. xxxii Library e-journal, Environmental Health Perspectives 114.8 (2006): A463. xxxiii Library e-journal, Women & Environments International Magazine Fall/Winter 2008 Issue 76/77: 36-40. xxxiv Library e-journal, Off Our Backs 38.1 (2008): 62-65. xxxv Library e-journal, New Statesman November 26, 2007, p. 21. xxxvi Library e-journal, Hecate 32.1 (2006): 107-22 xxxvii Library e-journal, International Feminist Journal of Politics 9.4 (2007): 503-11. xxxviii Library e-journal, The Journal of American History 94.3 (2007): 780-88. xxxix Library e-journal, U.S. News & World Report 137.22 (2004): 44-51. xl Library e-journal, Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 32.3 (2007): 584-90. xli Library e-journal, “War Against Women.” New Internationalist 401 (June 2007): 8-9. xlii Library e-journal, Off Our Backs 38.1 (2008): 44-8. xliii Library e-journal, American Anthropologist 104.3 (2002): 783-90. xliv Online, “Black Women’s Burden: An Epidemic of HIV” http://health.usnews.com/healthnews/articles/2008/09/12/black-womens-burden-an-epidemic-of-hiv xlv Online, “AIDS Leaves South African to Raise Grandchildren” http://womensenews.org/story/international-policyunitednations/050823/aids-leaves-south-african-raise-grandchildren#.U9lBGfldXoE xlvi Online, “Thembi Ngubane” http://www.thebody.com/content/art48013.html xlvii Online, http://womensenews.org/story/hivaids/060723/hiv-positive-women-talk-it-over-in-mamas-club#.U9lCX_ldXoE xlviii Online, “‘Stars Against AIDS’ in Eastern Europe,” http://www.unaids.org/en/Resources/PressCentre/Featurestories/2008/May/20080519easterneuropestarsaids/ xvii 10