SECOR DAVID A. JEFFREY, Ph.D. Senior Risk Assessment Scientist Ph.D. B.S. Organic Chemistry, 1985 University of California, Berkeley Chemistry, 1979 State University of New York, Buffalo Dr. Jeffrey has over 10 years of professional experience as a risk assessment consultant. Additionally, he has 10 years of experience in the chemical sciences. Dr. Jeffrey is an environmental organic chemist, with expertise in fate and transport modeling, risk assessment (human health, including radionuclides), life cycle assessment (LCA), and litigation support (including expert witness). His fate and transport experience includes approximately 120 projects involving modeling chemical vapor emissions from soil and groundwater, fugitive dust emissions during ambient or construction site conditions; intrusion of chemical vapors into indoor environments; and plant uptake of chemicals. Litigation support experience includes expert trial testimony. Dr. Jeffrey has managed and performed numerous human health risk assessments, ranging from screening-level evaluations to complex, multi-pathway/receptor/scenario sites. Regulatory environments have included the State of California (DTSC, CAPCOA, various Regional Water Quality Control Boards), U.S.EPA Regions 9 and 10, EPA CERCLA/Superfund and RCRA. Dr. Jeffrey also has significant experience managing and conducting site risk assessments under the various RBCA protocols for sites containing petroleum-derived contaminants, including ASTM and TNRCC. He has published and presented on numerous technical topics in a variety of formats. Special interests include MTBE, the risk assessment consequences of variability in chemical property determinations, and quantitative structure-reactivity/mobility/toxicity. Dr. Jeffrey is also knowledgeable in the area of cost recovery from commercial liability insurers for pollution insurance policies. Previous professional activities included extensive research laboratory experience, including familiarity with instrumental analysis (GC, GC-MS, IR, UV and NMR). Other previous experience includes predictive computer modeling and information retrieval software. Dr. Jeffrey’s selected project experience is presented below. Project Experience Risk Assessment/Toxicology Performed a risk assessment for a release of home heating oil at a residence in Washington State under USEPA Region 10 and Washington Department of Ecology guidelines for TPH-impacted sites. This assessment included the development of a fate and transport modeling approach for the evaluation of the volatile fraction of home heating oil, and the potential intrusion of chemical vapors into a basement. Major contributor to a $180,000 risk assessment of the Alaska-Juneau mine in Juneau, Alaska, performed under USEPA Region 10 and Alaska Department of Environmental Quality guidelines. The assessment considered human and ecological exposure to metals and organic chemicals leached from the mine under D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 1 storm runoff conditions, potentially impacting a nearby creek (recreational and subsistence exposure scenarios) which recharges groundwater used by the City of Juneau as a drinking water supply. Performed a tiered “RBCA” risk assessment for an active service station-minimart located in Beaverton, Oregon, under USEPA Region 10 and Oregon Department of Environmental Quality. The assessment considered both soil and groundwater contamination by BTEX, and offsite migration of a BTEX groundwater plume to potentially impact a restaurant via groundwater volatilization and indoor air vapor intrusion. Major contributor to technical approach for Baseline Risk Assessment (BRA) and data collection (RI) for a large refinery site in Illinois; the site is a strong candidate for USEPA Superfund/NPL listing. The site includes approximately 40 SWMUs, now under CERCLA oversight, a significant ecological component (nearby wetlands), and a potentially threatened residential community. Developed technical fate and transport modeling approaches for three USEPA Superfund sites: 1) Hunters Point Naval Shipyard (U.S. Navy: San Francisco, California), 2) Fort Ord (U.S. Army: Monterey, California), and the Lowry Landfill (Denver, Colorado). These approaches involved multipathway exposure scenarios, dust generation, volatile emissions, and plant root uptake of soil chemicals. Worked for several months for the U.S. Department of Energy (USDOE) as part of a national, multiconsultant project team focusing on risks to human health and the environment from contaminants (mostly radioactive) at the Hanford site in Washington State. Synthesized information from various risk-related documents and reports to ultimately support congressional testimony on findings and recommendations for remediation activities at Hanford. Evaluated technical methods for assessing health impacts from exposures to cesium, strontium, tritium, and uranium. Evaluated the significance of volatilization of commonly used pesticides following spray application to agricultural fields, using Jury’s Behavior Assessment Model for the U.S. EPA, Office of Policy Planning and Evaluation, Washington, D.C. Managed a project researching the status of Life Cycle Assessment in the U.S. for the Japanese government. The project involved an extensive literature search, using sophisticated, on-line databases and the internet, careful review, analysis, and summary of relevant materials obtained from the literature search, and a comprehensive report on SECOR’s findings, presented to the client. Prepared color graphics for site closure report illustrating trends in groundwater monitoring well chemical concentrations for a site that was the subject of a risk-based corrective action (RBCA) analysis, also performed by D. Jeffrey. The lead oversight regulatory agency, the Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB) - San Francisco Bay Region, plans to use these graphics as instructional materials in RBCA courses offered nationally. Developed conceptual site models (CSMs) under RCRA for a large, active petrochemical refinery located in Ponca City, Oklahoma. The refinery contained numerous solid waste management units (SWMUs). CSMs were developed separately for each SWMU and considered both potential human and ecological exposures to site-related chemicals. Prior to CSM development, detected concentrations of metals were screened against a dataset representing refinery background concentrations. This background screen allowed for the elimination of several metals from the Corrective Measures Study (CMS) process. D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 2 Developed risk-based action levels (RBALs) under RCRA for a Ponca City, Oklahoma refinery. The RBALs were estimated based on an extensive exposure pathway analysis that was performed during the development of CSMs for SWMUs at the refinery. These RBALs were computed to account for multiple chemical exposures, for both carcinogens and non-carcinogens. A target organ approach was used to account for multiple exposure to noncarcinogens. Intake assumptions used to estimate RBALs were obtained from the recent USEPA Exposure Factors Handbook (1996). Acceptable, risk-based target groundwater concentrations of vinyl chloride at a landfill were computed. These target concentrations were computed based on the assumed migration of vinyl chloride to a nearby, downgradient creek which is hydraulically connected to the shallow aquifer underlying the landfill. Two intermittent recreator exposure scenarios were developed to allow the estimation of risk-based landfill groundwater concentrations at the point of compliance (POC) imposed by the regulatory agency (California RWQCB): 1) volatilization of vinyl chloride from surface water at the groundwater-creek recharge point and subsequent inhalation of chemical vapors by a fishing receptor, and 2) dermal contact, incidental ingestion of surface water, and inhalation of chemical vapors by a swimmer receptor. A creek dilution factor (CDF) was conservatively estimated to account for the expected attenuation of vinyl chloride concentrations due to migration from the POC to the creek recharge point. This factor was estimated based on aquifer and creek parameters (e.g., flow rates, cross-sectional areas), and on the estimated volume of the vinyl chloride plume. Additionally, a creek volatilization factor (CVF) was computed to account for the expected attenuation in chemical concentrations due to volatilization from surface water and outdoor air dispersion. The CVF was estimated using surface water volatilization and outdoor air dispersion models. A quantitative uncertainty analysis was also performed, which examined the variability in some of the CDF and CVF parameter values. The resulting target POC concentration(s) was(were) found to be significantly higher than the initial recommended regulatory threshold of 5 micrograms per liter (g/L). This evaluation was used by the client to negotiate a less restrictive POC concentration for future site management and monitoring activities. Developed a novel analysis of the physical (short-term) risks associated with the proposed remediation of a hazardous chromium waste site in New Jersey. Results of the analysis indicated that the physical risks associated with the excavation and long-distance transport of large volumes of contaminated soil far outweighed the chemical hazard posed by the presence of the soil contaminants, and that remediation would be inappropriate. Served as Task Manager for performing a risk assessment involving both potential human and ecological exposure via complex exposure pathways, including human ingestion of beef cattle grazing on plants subject to uptake of chemicals via off-site deposition of wind-blown dusts, and predatory (hawks) consumption of woodrats who feed on plants subject to deposition. Included metals (lead), PAHs, and some volatile organic compounds (VOCs) as contaminants of concern. Estimated risks from exposure to lead using the EPA’s UBK-model for children, and the DTSC’s LEAD spread model for adults. Managed and performed numerous RBCA risk assessments under ASTM, California, and Texas (TNRCC) protocols. Developed quantitative structure-property relationship for alkylbenzenes, and used results to estimate chemical properties for a chemical used in the detergent industry, dodecylbenzene (DDB). Utilized DDB properties as SESOIL inputs to show no impact to aquifer from DDB in soil. D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 3 Served as Task Manager and contributing author of a multipathway baseline risk assessment for a National Priorities List (NPL) site at Fort Ord, California. Included PAHs, metals (lead), and pesticides as contaminants. Evaluated the post-deposition removal of particles containing naturally occurring radionuclides emitted from coal-fired power plants using Cowherd’s wind erosion model and the Universal Soil Loss Equation. Developed a technical approach for, and managed, project involving quantitative characterization of emissions from the open burning of waste solvents containing chemicals used in the manufacture of explosives, under California AB 2588. Work product used by client as part of TEIR. Conducted AB 2588 risk assessments for several Southern California sites. Responsible for coordination and organization of tasks with air modeling team, interpretation of results, developing alternative risk assessments using exposure parameters other than those required by CAPCOA, and writing the final reports. Developed modeling approaches for several assessments involving the estimation of risks due to the presence of chemicals in soils during remediation or construction/development (dust generation), including an evaluation of the volatilization potential of DDT, DDE, and DDD. Supervised junior staff in the performance of complex exposure assessment modeling involving both vapor and dust generation. Developed site-specific, risk-based concentrations for chemicals remaining in soil and groundwater at a former nitrogen fertilizer facility in Southern California for future soil removal workers (construction workers) and future on-site residents living in homes built on concrete slab-on-grade foundations. Extensive soil volatilization modeling was performed for ammonia, using a modification of a sophisticated leaching model (VLEACH), and incorporating mass balance (finite-source modeling) and the effect of a (partially) clean fill layer. Modeling was also conducted to estimate the effects of dusts generated during soil removal activities for nitrite and nitrate. Managed and performed a $40,000 fate and transport modeling component for multipathway risk assessment involving VOC fumigants, pesticides, herbicides, and metals in site soil. Helped develop structure and protocol of an electronic database containing fate and transport data. Successfully managed a risk assessment involving dermal and ingestion exposure to PCBs in soil for workers involved with construction at the site. Performed all tasks related to the development of a multi-pathway risk assessment that included an appraisal of both human health and ecological hazards posed by pesticides, PCBs, and metals in soil at Fort Ord, California. Developed a quantitative approach for applying fate and transport considerations in an ecological risk assessment to aid in the identification of chemicals of concern. Developed simple screening models for the evaluation of vapor emissions from contaminated groundwater used for irrigation or as a wetting agent during soil bioremediation. D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 4 Played a major role in preparation of risk assessments of four neighboring sites located in a complex urban area. Addressed determination of potential health hazards due to lead exposures during development of sites into low-income housing units. Helped develop a Maximum Credible Accident (MCA) exposure scenario for the storage of waste fuel components, as well as the responses to public comment regarding the operation of a new (proposed) Northern California hazardous waste incinerator facility. Litigation Support Provided expert trial testimony in successful defense of client charged with endangering waters of the State of California. Testimony included the chemistry and fate of chromium; in particular, the trivalent and hexavalent forms and their behavior in the environment were described. Provided litigation support for defense counsel in highly publicized cases involving chromium exposures in New Jersey. Specifically, the inhalation carcinogenity of the hexavalent form of chromium was a major issue. Litigation support services included identification of potential experts (including screening of candidates), and briefings on scientific and technical issues anticipated during the case. Served as an expert witness for a national law firm in a California Proposition 65 case involving air emissions of ethylene oxide from the client’s hospital sterilization facility. Provided defense counsel with information and opinions on the environmental fate and persistence of ETO in air, successfully refuting the State’s claim of a 200 per day air lifetime. Professional Memberships American Chemical Society (ACS) American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) Association of Harvard Chemistry Society for Risk Analysis Society of Environmental Toxicologists and Chemists Professional Certifications and Registrations 40-Hour OSHA Health & Safety Certification (29 CFR 1910.120), 1991 8-Hour OSHA Health & Safety Annual Update Certification, 1996 Professional Training and Continued Education Courses Post-doctoral studies, Synthetic Organic Chemistry, Stanford University, Department of Chemistry Post-doctoral studies, Synthetic Organic Chemistry, University of California/San Francisco, Department of Pharmaceutical Chemistry Graduate studies, Organic Chemistry, Harvard University D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 5 Attended workshop on MTBE: A New LUFT Challenge, Santa Clara Valley Water District, San Jose, California, April 25, 1997 Attended workshop on MTBE: Fate and Transport and Remediation, Association for the Environmental Health of Soils (AEHS), Oxnard, California, March 10, 1997 Completed 1-day short course in Environmental Fate and Transport Modeling, Northern California Chapter of the Society of Environmental Toxicologists and Chemists (NorCal SETAC), Sacramento, California, September 1996 Completed 1-day intensive short course in Effective Use of the Internet for Professionals in Hazardous Waste and Air Quality Management, University of California/Davis Extension, Sacramento, California, July 27, 1996 Completed 1-day intensive short course on Business Writing Basics for Professionals, SkillPath Seminars, San Francisco, California, March 12, 1996 Regular participant in meetings of the Gateway Club (Toastmasters: training in public speaking and presentation), Albany, California, 1995 Completed 1-day intensive short course on ecological risk assessment, University of California/Santa Cruz, July 14, 1995 Publications and Presentations Major contributing author to a major environmental sciences handbook to be published in 2000 by McGrawHill, ed. J. Lehr. As of June, 1999. Contributing sections focused on the environmental fate of important chemical classes. Gave platform presentation on “MTBE; The Problem...and Potential Solutions” in Concord, California for the Northern California Regional Chapter of the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (NorCal SETAC)’s annual meeting, April 26, 1999. Co-instructor (organic) in half-day intensive short course in “Environmental Organic and Inorganic Chemistry: The Nature and Fate of Important Site Contaminants”, presented at the Northern California Regional Chapter of the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (NorCal SETAC)’s Annual Meeting, April 25, 1999. Gave platform presentation on “Chemical Property Variability, Quantitative Uncertainty Analysis, and Consequences in Risk Assessment”, presented at the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) Committee E-47 (Biological Effects and Environmental Fate) Annual Meeting, Seattle, Washington, April 21, 1999. Gave 11/2-hour presentation on the chemistry, properties, regulatory aspects, and risk assessment of MTBE for ARCO Products Company, Las Palmas, California, January 5, 1999. D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 6 Co-instructor (organic) in full day intensive short course in “Environmental Organic and Inorganic Chemistry: The Nature and Fate of Important Site Contaminants”, presented at the national meeting of the Society of Environmental Chemistry and Toxicology (SETAC), Charlotte, North Carolina, November, 1998. Gave platform presentation on “The Human Health Risk Assessment of Oil Spills in the Turkish Straits” in Istanbul, Turkey, for an international conference on Oil Spills in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Regions, organized by the Institute of Environmental Sciences, Bogazici University, Istanbul, Turkey and The School of Engineering, University of Manchester, UK, September 17, 1998. “The Human Health Risk Assessment of Oil Spills in the Turkish Straits”, pre-publication proceedings for presentations at an international conference on Oil Spills in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Regions, organized by the Institute of Environmental Sciences, Bogazici University, Istanbul, Turkey and The School of Engineering, University of Manchester, UK Istanbul, Turkey, September 15-18, 1998. Gave platform presentation on “Chemical Property Variability and Consequences in Risk Assessment” in Reno, Nevada, for the Northern California Regional Chapter of the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (NorCal SETAC), June 22, 1998. Environmental Organic and Inorganic Chemistry - The Nature and Fate of Common Environmental Contaminants. A short course presented at the annual meeting of the Society of Environmental Toxicologists and Chemists (SETAC), San Francisco, California, November 1997 (with others). Risk-Based Corrective Action Case Study. Presented at UST meeting of the Environmental Law Education Center, Portland, Oregon, October 1997 (with others). Environmental Chemistry of MTBE. Presented at meeting sponsored by the Western States Petroleum Association (WSPA), the Oxygenated Fuels Association (OFA), and the Association of California Water Agencies: MTBE: A Workshop to Explore Needs for Drinking Water Treatment and Research, Sacramento, California, September 1997. The Consequences of Chemical Property Variability in Risk Assessment via Quantitative Uncertainty Analysis. Presented at the annual meeting of the Northern California chapter of the Society of Environmental Toxicologists and Chemists (NorCal SETAC), San Francisco, California, June 1997. Preferred Environmental Compartmentalization of MTBE. Presented at MTBE workshop (AMTBE: A New Luft Challenge), Santa Clara Valley Water District, San Jose, April 1997. Preferred Environmental Compartmentalization of MTBE. Presented at annual meeting of the American Chemical Society (ACS), Division of Environmental Chemistry and Division of Fuel Chemistry, San Francisco, California, April 1997. Chemical Property Variability, Quantitative Uncertainty Analysis, and Consequences in Risk Assessment. Presented at annual West Coast meeting of the Association for the Environmental Health of Soils (AEHS), Oxnard, California, March 1997. D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 7 An Evaluation of Available Soil Volatilization Models. Presented at annual meeting of Northern California Chapter of the Society of Environmental Toxicologists and Chemists (NorCal SETAC), Sacramento, California, August 1996. Applications of Toxicology and Risk Assessment in Montrose-Type Contaminated Property Liability Claims. Presented at monthly meeting of the Mount Diablo Property Association, Pleasant Hill, California, March 1996. The Montrose Decisions and Pollution Insurance Coverage: Role of the Environmental Expert. Article in monthly newsletters of the Mount Diablo Property Association (January 1996), and the Blue Goose Association, February 1996. Chemical Ranking and Scoring: Guidelines for Relative Assessment of Chemicals, Proceedings of the Pellston Workshop on Chemical Ranking and Scoring; February 12-16, 1995; Sandestin, Florida. 1997 (with others). Methodological Issues in Radionuclide Risk Assessment for Coal-Fired Power Plants. Presented at EPRI/DOE International Conference on Managing Hazardous and Particulate Air Pollutants, Toronto, Ontario, August 15, 1995 (with others). Applications of Fate and Transport in Risk Assessment. Presented at ICF Kaiser Engineers, Oakland, California, January 1995. Chemical Property Uncertainties in Quantitative Risk Assessments. Article in quarterly newsletter of the Northern California Chapter of the Society of Environmental Toxicologists and Chemists (NorCal SETAC), Fall 1994. Development of a Fate and Transport Ranking Scheme for Applications in Ecological Risk Assessment. Presented to annual conference of NorCal SETAC, Sacramento, California, May 1993. Development of a Fate and Transport Ranking Scheme for Applications in Ecological Risk Assessment. Poster presented at annual conference of the Society of Environmental Toxicologists and Chemists (SETAC), Cincinnati, Ohio, November 1992. Mathematical Models Used for Estimating Exposure Point Concentrations For Risk Assessment. Presented at Harding Lawson Associates, Novato, California, September 1992. Chemical Risks During Remediation; Development of Dust and Vapor Modeling Approaches. Presented at Harding Lawson Associates, Novato, California, March 1992. The Potential Inhalation Hazard Posed by Dioxin-Contaminated Soil. Published by Chemosphere, 1990 (with others). Computerized Chemical Databases: State-of-the-art Information Retrieval Systems. Presented at various universities, 1989. The New CHIRAS Database. Poster presented at the Gordon Research Conference on Stereochemistry, July 1988. D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 8 Studies of DNA-active Agents: The Synthesis of the Parent Carbocylic Subunit of Neocarzinostatin Chromophore. Published by Tet. Lett., Vol. 29, 1988 (with others). Synthesis of Derivatives of the Novel Tricyclo(4.4.2.01.5)dodecane Skeleton. Published by the Journal of Organic Chemistry, Vol. 51, 1986 (with others). Orthogonene. Published by Tetrahedron, Vol. 40, 1984 (with W. F. Maier). Gamma-alkylation of alpha, beta-Unsaturated Ketones. Gamma-arylsulfonyl Groups as Regioselective Control Elements. Published by Journal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 102, 1980 (with others). Committee Participation Invited member of Steering Committee for the 2nd International Conference on Oil Spills in the Mediterranean and Black Sea Regions: Impact, Contingency Planning, Response, Technology for Containment and Recovery. To be held in Istanbul, Turkey, 31st October - 3rd November 2000. D:\106764915.doc David Jeffrey 3/8/2016 Page 9