The Capital Asset Pricing Model

The Capital Asset Pricing Model
Author: Andre Perold
By Maia
This article describes the theory behind CAPM model. This model answers to the
question, how risk affects expected return. CAPM was developed by Sharpe, Treynor, Lintner
and Mossin. It is based on the idea that not all risks should affect asset prices. A risk that can be
diversified away is not a risk at all.
When the returns on assets within a portfolio are perfectly positively correlated , the
portfolio risk is weighted average of the risks of the assets, however, when the assets are not
perfectly correlated, there is a nonlinear relationship between portfolio riskand the risks of the
underlying assets. The risk of one asset will be always offset by another asset, so the standard
deviation of the portfolio is always less than one. The expected return on a portfolio is just a
weighted average of the expected returns of the underlying asset.
Efficient frontier- for each level of expected return, we can solve the portfolio
combination of assets that has the lowest risk.
The Sharpe Ratio- slope of the CML. Sharpe Ratio=( return- risk-free rate)/ standard
deviation of the asset. All combinations of AssetH with risk-free borrowing or lending have the
same Sharpe Ratio. The asset of choice- if you could choose only obe risky asset- the one with
the highest Sharpe ratio. Given this choice you have to make the second decision, which is how
much of asset to hold. The answer depends on your risk tolerance.
Fund separation- investors with the same beliefs about expected returns, risks and
correlation will invest in the portfolio of risky assets that has the highest Sharpe ratio. They will
differ in the allocatiojns between this fund and risk-free lending or borrowing.
Improving a Sharpe Ratio of the portfolio
- Adding a stock that is uncorrelated with the existing portfolio. The stock has no effect on
the risk of the portfolio. This is a substitute for investing in risk-free asset.
- Adding a stock that is Perfectly Correlated with the Existing portfoilio. Investing in the
stock becomes a substitute for investing in the portfolio itself. Returns of the portfolio and the
stock move together in the same ration plus constant. If it’s return is perfectly correlated to the
portfolio, the stock can still be added. The Sharpe ration of the portfolio will increase if the stock
expected return exceed that of the portfolio. This occurs when alfa>0, or equivalently if risk
premium of the stock is bigger than betta multiplied with the risk premium of the portfolio.
- Adding the stock that is imperfectly correlated with the portfolio. The stock’s reutrn can be
separated into a return component that is perfectly correlated to the portfolio and that is
uncorrelated. The one that is uncorrelated can be diversified. The standard deviation of the stock
is the standard deviation of the perfectly correlated component. This risk can be mimicked
through investing Betta proportion on this stock and one minus betta into riskless asset. We can
conclude that adding a stock to the portfolio can improve the Sharpe ration of risk premium of
the asset is bigger than betta times the portfolio risk premium.
Assumptions for CAPM
1) Investors are risk averse
2) Capital markets are perfect- no transaction costs, no restrictions for short selling, no
taxes, inormation is costless and available to everyone, all investors can borrow and lend
at risk-free rate.
3) All investors have access to the same investment opportunities.
4) Investors all make the same estimates of asset’s expected return, standarad deviation of
return and correlations among the assets. Investors will determine the same Sharpe Ratio.
For the market to be in equilibrium the price of each asset must be such that investors
collectively decide to hold exactly the supply of the asset.
The Sharpe Ration of any asset is no higher than the Sharpe Ratio of the Market Portfolio, since
correlation cannot be bigger than one (Sharpe Ration of an asset= correlation multiplied with the
Sharpe ration of the portfolio).
A high Beta Stock will have a high stand-alone risk, but a stock need not have a high beta to
have a high stand- alone risk.
Beta of the portfolio is the weighted average of the betas of the stock in the portfolios. All assets
must lie on the Securities Market Line. Not all of the stand-alone risk of an asset is priced into its
expected return, just that portion of the risk that is correlated with the market portfolio.Stock’s
expected return does not depend on the growth rate of its expected future cash flows. In order to
know the return, we need to know Betta, according to CAPM.
Is the CAPM useful?
- Suboptimal diversification ( not all investors hold the same portfolio). There is also a
home bias in international investing. In almost all countries, foreign ownership of assets
is low, meaning that investors tend to hold predominantly home country assets.
- Performance measurement. Investors need to assess performance based on returns that
have been appropriately risk adjusted.
- Even if it does not perfectly describe the current world, it still might predict future
investor behaviour.
- This is a benchmark for undestanding capital market phenomena.
Extensions of the CAPM- International CAPM. Investors care about the main risk factormarket and are also concerned about real currency fluctuations.
Size cannot be a risk factor that affects return, since small firms would then just combine and
form big firms.
The CAPM tells us that ownership of assets by diversified investors lowers their expected
returns and raises prices. Moreover, investors, who hold undiversified portfolios are likely to be
taking risks for which they are not being paid.
The Capital Asset Pricing Model
 The cost of equity capital in the past was calculated:
Return = (Dividend per share/Price per share) + Div. growth rate
From the perspective of modern finance, this is wrong as cost of capital (assets) determine cost
of equity, not vice versa.
Adding the asset that perfectly positively correlates with other asset will not diversify
away unique risk. This is the same as investing in portfolio itself.
(!) International diversification is not optimal nowadays. Investors prefer to hold more
home country assets because it is cheaper in terms of taxes and direct expenses but they
do not pay much attention to the fact that broad international diversification can reduce
unique risk up to 90 per cent.
In order to compare fund performance, we need to adjust portfolios for market risk.
Achieve high return with high beta (risk) for assets is easier, but to get high return with
low asset beta is much harder and requires a lot of skills.
(!) Modifying assumptions of CAPM will lead to appearance of new terms to hold
equilibrium. Example: International CAPM which should include betas/risk for currency
movements and other risks that are viewed differently by different investor segments.
Related flashcards


31 cards

Lehman Brothers

18 cards

American investors

85 cards

Disney India

17 cards

Create Flashcards