Social 10-1 Chapter One – To what extent does globalization shape your identity? Teacher Notes Students will: - Explore ways in which individuals and collectives express identities (traditions, language, religion, spirituality, the arts, attire, relationship to land, ideological beliefs, role modeling) Prologue Definitions - Increasing international division of labour and integrating national economies through trade of goods and services and international corporate investment. All being boasted by the development of new technologies. (International Monetary Fund, Horst Köhler) o Trade and economic focus - Development of a globalized economic system due to the work of transnational and banking corporations outside of the control of national governments. o Market economic focus - The expansion of market capitalism transforming societies due to technological developments. All leading to a social and economic interdependence. o Economic and technology focus Key Concepts to Understand for Chapter Question Globalization - The process by which the world’s citizens are becoming increasingly connected and interdependent. Globalization is promoted by anything that tends to connect the global community: o With trade with other countries; o When companies branch out form one country to another; o When we are influenced by the media and entertainment form other nations; o When we exchange ideas and information with other nations. Identity To begin to gain an understanding of our own connection to globalization we need to begin to see how we identify ourselves. Once we have this understanding we can begin to see where we ourselves are connected to other parts of the world or perhaps where our own identity may be vulnerable to outside influences. - Identity is who you are. Identify is expressed by things such as o traditions (e.g., Hockey Night in Canada) o role modeling (e.g., heroes, mentors) o languages o religion/spirituality o the arts (e.g., music, dance) o attire (e.g., clothing, body markings) o farmers, hunters, stewards) o ideological beliefs(e.g., political views, personal mottos). o Ethnicity o o o o o o o o o Experiences Location Geography values/beliefs personality friends family economic status physical features Student Task – My Identity Make reference to figure 1-16 to gain a further idea of what is sought. - Make a list of aspects about you are based on the above suggestions of how we express our identity. o Once your list is complete we will begin to examine the difference between individual identity and collective identity. Collectives or Collective Identity ‘We/Us’ o A group to which a person belongs to and identifies with. We can belong to collectives based on many criteria. The Catholic church is a collective. Being a student at NDC is a collective. Speaking a sort of slang or jargon as a group such as skaters is an example of being a part of a collective. o When we belong to a collective, we often share its values, norms, traditions, rituals, etc. Individual Identity ‘I’ o Elements that are unique to who we are and use to separate ourselves from others. - Individual and Collective Identities – how do we express them? - Context o The context will differ the definition of your identity Circumstances and surroundings Determine the response you give o The differing contexts in which you find yourself will define the many aspects of your identity. Our Identities – Where will we see change???? Traditions - Traditions are repetitive actions that are done for purpose or a meaning by individuals or collectives. o As an individual, an example would be, a widowed husband may have the individual tradition of visiting his wife’s grave site on the anniversary of her death. o As a collective, an example would be, a stereotypical Canadian traditions expressed by members of this collective is to watch Hockey Night In Canada on Saturday nights or to observe Remembrance Day on November 11. Language (23-24, 27-29) - We express our identities through the language we speak, the body language we use, the expressions and slang we choose, etc. o For example, an immigrant from China may embrace their new culture and reject their old culture by not speaking in their native tongue. o In contrast, an immigrant from China may reside in a “China Town” in a large city and speak their language deliberately and frequently as a means to express their connection to their original identity. o If we choose to be a “skater”, we might adopt the slang and jargon of that group. This is another example of how we express who we are by adopting the language of the collective. Religion (30-31) - We express our identities by accepting the rules and general guidelines of a community of believers. o For example, as a Muslim you remove your footwear before entering a mosque. o As a Catholic, you bless yourself when you enter a church and you accept common beliefs such as the Creed, the Beatitudes, and the teaching in Scriptures. Spirituality - Spirituality is the concept of focusing on things related to the soul or spirit. Often, spirituality is more individualistic than religion. o For example, one person may feel more spiritual while connected to nature, while another feels more spiritual when engaged in communal prayer. The Arts (18-19) - We can express our identities by involvement in the arts such as music, drama, dance, and graphic art. We can also belong to a collective in this regard such as theatre company or symphony. Attire (25) - This relates to the way we present ourselves. An individual may express their individualism by dressing uniquely. Whereas, an individual may express their connection to a collective by dressing according to its standards (athlete, farmer, etc) o Examples include the clothes, tattoos, piercings, jewelry, and religious accessories such as turbans, swords, crucifixes, etc. Relationship to Land - How we interact with our physical surroundings communicates our identity. o An agricultural society may dress in rugged attire and show respect for the land on which they make their living. o First Nations groups have a deep connection to the land upon which they were dependent to make their living. Ideology - A systematic set of beliefs that provides a fairly thorough picture of the world that a group of people accepts as true. Individuals and Collectives many different political ideologies such as fascism, conservatism, liberalism, or communism. - There are other ideologies without any connection to politics or economics. An example would be environmentalism. Environmentalists value our natural world and preserving it for future generations. o An adherence to traditional family values would be another ideology. Role Modeling (21-22) - Individuals and Collectives are influenced by the example of those that come before us; these are our role models. Our parents are often our most significant role models. - However, there are other role models based on the nature of the other collectives we are a part of. o The captain of our sports team may be a role model, and the leader of a gang would be one as well. Often our ability to act as a role model, or be influenced by a role model, is shaped by the situation we are in. Case Studies 1. The Lubicon Cree of Northern Alberta, page 32 a. How should their identity be defined? b. How was the community connected to globalization? c. How was their identity impacted? i. To what extent should globalization be embraced? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfYsrBW8B2I&list=PLA7FB4350C537C468&in dex=1 2. The Democratic Republic of Congo, page 36 a. How should their identity be defined? b. How was the community connected to globalization? c. How was their identity impacted? i. To what extent should globalization be embraced? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3OWj1ZGn4uM Points of View, page 39 1. Examine the point of view of Satya Das and prepare an answer for… a. How does globalization shape identity? i. Choose phrasing, wording from the quote to support your ideas. 2. Examine the quotes from Kofi Annan and Long Litt Woon and prepare an answer for… a. To what extent should we embrace globalization i. Choose phrasing from the source to support your answer. - Satya Dat, journalist and immigrant to Canada - - o Key words Borderless world Identity has many forms Accommodating the diversity Diversity o Globalization shaping identity Teaching us to accept many or diverse identities as we become more connected. Kofi Annan, secretary general of United Nations o Key words Dreary uniformity Promises increased prosperity Widen existing gaps Tremendous potential Careful management o Globalization shaping identity Globalization has many positive yet many negative potentials Long Litt Woon o Key Words Identity, Norwegian and Malaysia o Globalization shaping Identity As we develop our identity as we become more globalized, there is an assumption that we lose aspects of our identity. Source - Using the factors affecting identity in this section of the curriculum, ask the students to identify examples of Canadian Identity located on the bills in the diagram below. - $5 = Hockey (Traditions) - Ice (Relationship to Land) - Toque (Attire) - $10= Peacekeeping (Ideologies) - $20 = Bill Reid Artwork (The Arts) - $50= Famous Five (Role Modeling) - All = French & English (Language) Benchmark Skills and Processes Addressed: Page # and Activity Description Benchmark Skills and Processes Time Recommendatio n Spirituality/Religion/Role Models/Traditions. Page 20. Analyze photos. ---------------------------------------Attire/Traditions. Page 21. Analyze photos. ---------------------------------------Identity. Page 22.Chart. ---------------------------------------Attire. Page 23. Analyze Photos. ---------------------------------------Language. Page 24. ---------------------------------------Attire. Page 26. Analyze Photos. ---------------------------------------Language. Page 29. Critical & Creative Thinking Oral, Written, and Visual Literacy ---------------------------------Critical & Creative Thinking Oral, Written, and Visual Literacy ---------------------------------Critical & Creative Thinking Oral, Written, and Visual Literacy Critical and Creative Thinking ---------------------------------Critical & Creative Thinking. ---------------------------------Critical & Creative Thinking Oral, Written, and Visual Literacy ---------------------------------------Critical & Creative Thinking Oral, Written, and Visual Literacy 10 Good --10 Good --20 Very Good --10 --- Good 10 Good --10 Good Social 10-1 Chapter Two – To what extent do identity and the forces of globalization shape each other? Teacher Notes Students will: - Explore understandings and dimensions of globalization (political, economic, social, other contemporary examples) Forces of Globalization What are the sources driving the interaction between all global citizens and nations? Trade - The basic action of exchanging one product for another. People trade with one another to obtain goods and services that are: o Not available in their own region, province or nation. (Produce) o Better quality or less expensive. (Clothing) o Different from the goods produced at home. (Automobiles) - Focus within this force of globalization o Transnational Corporations A company that is based in one country while developing and manufacturing its products, or delivering its goods and services, in more than one country. Examples include Wal-Mart, Nike, Coca-cola, McDonalds, Microsoft Transnationals provide jobs and training to those who may not otherwise have the opportunity. Critics often define these jobs as “McJobs” - lowlevel positions requiring little skill. (positive) Transnationals are criticized because the profits they earn go to the country where the company has its headquarters not where the goods are manufactured and sold. (negative) Transportation - Transportation is the process of moving goods to market. Past examples include: camels, horses, carts etc. The movement of people has also changed especially with the invention of the passenger jet. Today, products can be moved farther and faster than ever before by the use of container shipping. - Focus within this force of globalization o Container Shipping Containers or container shipping make shipping cheaper and faster and more efficient. Bigger ships are carrying more transport and product. (Positive) More interaction and encouraged trade between nations. (Positive) Communication Technology - Technologies used to transfer and exchange information. o Computers have revolutionized the flow of information. Digital technology has also led to the development of cell phones, Ipods/Ipads, and digital cameras. The internet has helped businesses and has furthered globalization by allowing online research and purchasing. (Positive) Internet has enabled more communication between individuals, companies, nations, etc. (Positive) The Media - The newspaper, television, radio, online resources (websites) that project information, identity. o The media educates the public more quickly of the happenings throughout the globe with a diversity of voices heard by the audience. The public therefore must be more educated in the biases that exist in the media. Focus within this force of globalization Media in general o Trends in media Media Concentration concentration of ownership of newspapers and other media in the hands of a few large corporations Media Convergence The use of electronic technology to integrate media such as newspapers, books, TV and the Internet – an example would be an Iphone. More becomes accessible to the individual. Impact of the Forces of Globalization Where do we see the impact? Political Dimensions of Globalization (52-53) - Deals with governmental decisions and policies that affect a nation and/or many nations. o The degree to which decisions by nations or organizations impact others beyond their borders. For example- Many nations imposing sanctions on Iran for developing a nuclear energy program. Economic Dimension of Globalization (50-51) - Deals with trade policies, decisions regarding taxation, prices on commodities, and wealth of a population or group. o The degree to which decisions regarding the creation and sharing of goods and wealth impact others beyond their borders. For example – Canada exports natural resources to the USA and imports manufactured goods made from those natural resources, at an increased price. Crude oil is exported to the USA and refined gasoline is imported into Canada. The bulk of profits remain in the USA. Social Dimension of Globalization (55) - Deals with the status of individuals, their rights and freedoms and the impact upon their identities. o The degree to which social interactions between people in the global community shape their individual and collective identities. Environmental Dimension of Globalization (54) - Deals with the impacts on the natural resources and ecosystems. o The degree to which people have a global concern for the health and productivity of the environment. For example, the global concern over the deforestation of the rain forest is an issue the global community has addressed. Example – Banana Wars/Activities The control of banana production in Central and South American countries by large international transnational corporations has led to concerns over political, economic, social and environment rights. The banana wars became a conflict between governments. Economic - Ecuador banana prices are low due to low wages and costs of production. - - - Laws to protect employees in Ecuador are often ignored and threats of union action are dismissed quickly. Working conditions are poor for farmers and employees – on average 6.40$ is earned. Women and children are paid less or not at all. o Children are forced to work to help with the family income. o Education becomes less of a priority for the family. Workers who threaten union action are black listed and soon are unemployed and refused hire because of their actions. Economies of Scale (Save for later in course) o Reduction in cost per unit resulting from increased production, realized through operational efficiencies. Economies of scale can be accomplished because as production increases, the cost of producing each additional unit falls. Political - European governments agreed to aid former colonies in their trade and production of goods – bananas. o These European nations placed no tariffs on their imported goods from Central and South America. o Goods – bananas – from other nations were taxed thus sold at higher prices in European markets. - A majority of the bananas taxed by European governments were controlled by transnational corporations who protested the preferential treatment given to the former colonies. o The case was taken to the World Trade Organization an international organization that regulates trade and services in the global market. WTO states that members must give equal treatment to members – tariffs on all or none. - European markets were forced to impose the same tariffs on the imports from its former colonies. Environmental - To keep up with the global market, Central and South American banana producing nations clear large tracts of land for banana production. - To earn the most from the market the banana production focuses on one variety of banana; limiting biodiversity in the production. - To ensure strong crops pesticides and herbicides are used to protect the bananas. - Loss of rainforests impacts global warming. - Loss of species impacts biodiversity and food chains. - Pesticides and herbicides impact the health of human, animal and environment in the areas. - The overuse of chemicals has led some transnationals to focus more on organic production. Social - Prices of bananas are maintained at low prices to encourage demand. Banana size, colour, taste and appearance are encouraged to be uniform. Safety is of little importance in the fields so as not to take away from production or costs. Health problems grow amongst populations working and surrounding production. o Any attempts by workers to fix the problem leads often to unemployment and black listing. - Populations are displaced to make room for production – loss of home and way of life. o Way of life disturbed also because of the impact on the environment. Source: How is environmental degradation a Global concern? Challenges to Identity Homogenization - Erases the differences among peoples, and as a result, they become more and more similar. Eg: McDonald’s appearing in countries around the world, the spead of blue jeans etc. o The Negative Effects of homogenization Homogenization is erasing cultural differences so that all people become the same. This homogenization can cause them to lose their own cultural identity such as their language, traditions, religion, and customs. Acculturation - The cultural changes that occur when two cultures accommodate, or adapt, to each other’s world views. When cultures willingly accept the exports of other nations such as music, movies, food, and fashion, we are able to appreciate other cultures and expand our world view. For example, we can get sushi and crepes in Canada. The Metis are an example of a culture that has been formed by merging the French and the First Nation cultures. In Western culture, the infusion of foods from other cultures has created an interesting diversity. Written Japanese borrows characters from the Chinese. Accommodation - A process that occurs when people from different cultures come into contact and accept and create space for one another. The customs, traditions, technologies, beliefs, and languages of both cultures may be affected. o The positive impacts of accommodation People accept one another and live in greater harmony. The Royal Canadian Mounted Police allows Sikhs to wear their turbans. This allows the police force to recruit more people while allowing them to maintain their identity. o The Negative Effects of Accommodation This can be a challenge when the desire for being accommodated by one culture threatens another. For example, there are some Canadians who take issue with the RCMP for allowing Sikhs to deviate from the traditional uniform for religious reason. Another example, is women who don’t want to remove their burkas when voting; this causes a problem for voting officials who are required to identify each voter by photo ID. Assimilation - A process that occurs when the culture of a minority group is absorbed by another culture. The cultural identity of the minority group disappears as its members take on the identity of another culture. - Both accommodation and acculturation may lead to assimilation. They do so, when we go beyond accepting one another’s cultures while maintaining our own, and, instead lose our own. This most often occurs with the culture that is in the minority. - The USA has a “melting pot” philosophy which stresses the value in everyone accepting the American culture and this is an assimilative policy that leads to homogenization of the American culture. In contrast, Canada has an official policy of multiculturalism in which minority cultures are encouraged to retain their customs and traditions. However, historically, the Canadian government had a policy of assimilating the First Nations people when the country was formed in 1867. Cultural revitalization - A process of affirming and promoting people’s individual and collective cultural identity. The positive impacts of cultural revitalization - People can preserve their cultures without them being absorbed into the “industrialstrength blender” of globalization. An example is preserving principles of native architecture in modern buildings. Another example can be found by the diversity of food we might find in a mall’s food court. This allows us to retain our own cultural foods while also sampling those of others. Benchmark Skills and Processes Addressed: Page # and Activity Description Benchmark Skills and Processes Economic / Social / Political Critical and Creative Thinking Written Literacy Dimensions Page 53 – Analyzing Reading Decision Making and Problem Time 30 mins Recommend ation Very Good Solving ---Economic / Social / Political / Environmental Dimensions – Page 55 Making a diagram ---Economic Dimension –Page 56-57 Detecting Bias ---Critical and Creative Thinking Visual Literacy ---40 mins ---Good ---Critical and Creative Thinking Written Literacy ---80 mins ---Very Good Social 10-1 Chapter Three To what extent is identity affected by communication technology and the media in a globalizing world? Student Notes The Medium is the Message - http://www.historica-dominion.ca/content/heritage-minutes/marshallmcluhan?media_type=41&media_category=34 - Notes’ Source: Historica o The means of informing the population has just as much impact as the information being presented. The same information can have different meanings depending on the medium being used to present it. Therefore we need to not only look at the information we are given but how it is being given. Personal - Shared Orally, Blogs Textual – Books, Newspapers, Magazines Visual – Newscasts, Youtube, Film, Documentary Communication technology is changing how we perceive others and the world as well. With faster and more available technology, our world is becoming smaller and divisions between nations are disappearing. - Student Question o Marshall McLuhan introduced two key ideas – the medium is the message and global village. What do both ideas mean? Communication Technology and Media - The type and speed of information we can receive and exchange has led us into a “global village.” For example: MP3, iPod, digital cameras, internet, cell phones. Digital Divide - http://wireless.ictp.it/simulator/ - A division measuring the haves versus the have-nots in terms of communication technology and internet access. o The division is more apparent between developed and developing nations (rich and poor nations) as well as the rich and poor within the nation. - Student Questions o What is the digital divide? o If globalization was to be embraced, how could the digital divide limit any benefits to the globe? Media Concentration and Diversity of Opinion - Transnational media corporations o Global media is dominated by 9 American media corporations. o 85% of world music market o Satellite broadcasting o Magazine and book publishing o Cable broadcasting http://www.mtv.de/home http://www.mtvjapan.com/home http://www.mtv.fr/ http://www.mtvasia.com/ http://park.hongkongdisneyland.com/hkdl/en_US/parks/overview?name=P arkOverviewPage Universalization of the media – aka Americanization - Internet o Strong tool for cultural revitalization and education o Dominated by English language Minority language groups separated geographically and isolated are more likely to fall victim to assimilation because of lack of media sources to reinforce their language and cultural identity. o Techno-isolation http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPW8xmI4w6U We can become more connected to the world through our communication technology devices but we can also become cut off from personal relationships with those closest to us. o We are more likely to communication using a text message as opposed to a phone call or personal contact (visit) - Bias in the Media o Propaganda Ideas and information spread for the purpose of achieving a specific goal Examine who is spreading the ideas and information – do they have an agenda? Is the information one-sided? o Perspective on world issues The perspective is defined by the values, culture and traditions of the nation, region, group or individual. Often the media will present information that reflects these values, culture and traditions of that particular nation, region, group or individual. o Example September 11 – American Perspective vs the Other (Arabic Nations perhaps) o http://www.worldpress.org/wprw.htm Diversity Range of ideas, opinions, values and identities of individuals and collectives. The explosion of communication technology has impacted this diversity. In many cases the explosion has impacted diversity. For example, access to ideas from around the world, leads us to become less diverse. However, this same access to ideas from around the world leads us to be exposed to differing worldviews. Live 8, pages 80-1 What is the purpose? Who was it benefitting? Examine the arguments against (Damon Albarn) and for (Angélique Kidjo) Live 8? o African Artists vs Those of Popular Culture o Are the arguments against the format of Live 8 legitimate o The Untold Stories Pop Culture - Pop culture is short for popular culture and means the culture of the people. It is often associated with American culture and often refers to current cultural trends that are spread by the mass media. - Universalisation o - Hybridization o - When pop culture trends are spread by the mass media, the result is the UNIVERSALIZATION OF POP CULTURE. Because of the mass media, there are worldwide trends common in music, clothing, and entertainment. For example, Sesame Street are shown in 120 countries and it is hard to find a country where you won’t find Nike clothing. Hybridization combines elements of pop culture of one nation with those of another. McDonalds is found all over the world with menus that reflect the local cuisine. o http://www.sesameworkshop.org/our-impact/around-the-world/index.html Sesame Street, example Taking the format of the program of Sesame Street to other nations but adapting to its cultures and values. Film Industry o Some people are trying to convince us that films and television are economic sectors like any other. This is not true. They shape attitudes, create new notions of style and behaviour and, in doing so, reaffirm or discredit larger social values. A film can either reflect or undercut our sense of identity as individuals or as citizens of nations. David Putnam, former president of Columbia Pictures.Ideas and Opinions o Statistics Canada reports that in 2003/04, Canadian films earned 4.2 per cent of the revenue in movie theatres compared with foreign-made movies which earned 95.8 per cent. o In 2005, four of the top 10 box office movies in Québec were Canadian. Consider the significance of this in the face of the statistics you read about above. o There are many other views on the effects that film and television may have on our identities. To what extent do you think film and television shape your identity? Benchmark Skills and Processes Addressed: Page # and Activity Description Benchmark Skills and Processes Critical and Creative Thinking CommTech & Media – pg 47 Analyzing a graph Visual Literacy Time 10 mins Recommendation Good Diversity – pg 85 Source Analysis Critical and Creative Thinking Written Literacy 30 mins Very Good Comm Tech & Media – pg 86 Analyzing an issue using a chart Critical and Creative Thinking 60 mins Very Good Social 10-1 Chapter Four - To what extent is identity affected by communication technology and the media in a globalizing world? Teacher Notes Affirming and Promoting Language in a Globalizing World, pages 90-3 - What are the causes of endangered and extinct languages? o For Canada: Immigration is leading demographics changes in Canada – percentage of English and French speakers in Canada is shrinking is comparison to outside groups. Allophone speakers – figure 4-2 o Depending on the sources – globally up to 6000, 7000 or even 9000 languages 96% of the global languages are spoken by 4% of the population. Generations of speakers are being lost – younger generations not maintaining the language Education programs for some languages are not available for all. o Where do we see the forces of globalization impacting language? Internet and World Wide Web English dominating the web and internet – American developed New languages becoming available though – now about 21 languages make up 90% of the internet content. o The translation of the internet into more languages is time consuming o What do we learn about language affirmation from Mitali Perkins’ story Magic Carpet? Generational situations – younger generations do not see the importance of history and family histories – language and culture of parents and grandparents. Often when we desire to know our family’s history and culture it is too late. Education is the key to maintain our cultural histories. Affirming and Promoting Culture in a Globalizing World, pages 96-100 - In terms of cultural revitalization are museums helping or harming cultures in reaffirming their identities? o Items important to cultures are taken out of communities and groups to be placed into museums for display, preservation and education G’psgolox Totem pole Krymsky Edmonton Society UNESCO o The question on the value of museums is who is control of the preservation, display and education Aboriginals developing programs and displays of their own materials and history. Governments’ role in affirming and promoting languages and cultures, pages 101-2 - What specific actions has the Canadian Government taken to affirm and promote its cultural diverse population? o Multiculturalism (1971) Recognizing of all cultures within Canada within biculturalism, developed under Prime Minister Pierre Elliot Trudeau Multiculturalism Day: June 27, 2006 o Official Languages Act 1969 An extension of the recognition for both French and English as Canada’s two official languages o Canada Day Poster Contest National initiative from the Federal Department of Heritage for schools o Cultural Content Laws CRTC – 30% Canadian Content on Canadian Radio Stations (1968) 60% Canadian Programming on Canadian Television Stations International Organizations’ role in affirming and promoting languages and cultures, pages - Explain the objectives of the following organizations UNESCO, La Francophonie, and The Assembly of First Nations and the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. How do these organizations aid the cultural revitalization of their respective groups? o UNESCO Works to promote and protect important elements of the world’s history – landscapes, buildings, locations Works as well to promote and protect cultural practices, traditions and languages – dances, songs, language, stories. o La Francophonie An organization of French speaking nations and regions Working to build an international community of individuals based on language connections. Working to promote the concerns of young francophones such as protecting Francophone cultural identity on the Internet o Assembly of First Nations Canadian organization of First Nations within Canada working on the concerns of Canada’s aboriginals, promoting and protecting First Nations’ cultures. Met with other indigenous groups around the world and developed the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Goals of the Assembly and the Declaration include self-determination, treaty rights, and rights over natural resources. According the Assembly the declaration affirms the rights of the First Nations in their preservation of their cultural identity http://www.afn.ca/index.php/en