REPORT ON REVIEW OF INTERNAL AUDIT CAPACITY Draft List of Suggested Audit and Risk Management Related Software 2 April 2009 Tool Box / Kit Audit Management (manage, monitor, report audit issues, working papers, track implementation of recommendations Control Assessment (including self assessment) Audit Risk Assessment (business risks) BPS - BPS Audit - BPS Issues and Action Tracking CCH TeamMate Excel / access Galileo Audit Management System Knowrisk Methodware: - ProAudit Advisor; - Planning Advisor Paisley Auto Audit Pentana Audit Work System (PAWS) ReliantAuditor BPS - BPS Compliance - BPS OpsRisk Cura - Cura Enterprise - Cura Assessor - Cura Survey Magique Risk Management Software Methodware: - COBIT Assessor - Enterprise Risk Assessor Modulo Risk Manager Paisley - Enterprise GRC - On Demand Pentana Audit Work System (PAWS) Cura - Cura Enterprise - Cura Assessor - Cura Survey Integrum Magique Risk Management Software Methodware: - COBIT Assessor - Enterprise Risk Assessor Modulo Risk Manager Paisley - Enterprise GRC - On Demand Pentana Audit Work System (PAWS) ReliantAuditor Tickit On Demand Tool Box / Kit CAATTS Enterprise Risk Management ACL Encase IDEA GRC MS Access MS Excel SAP Assure WebSpy BPS - BPS Compliance - BPS OpsRisk Methodware: - Enterprise Risk Assessor Paisley - Enterprise GRC - On Demand Reply IQ Voting Software RiskShield ACL 1. ACL AuditExchange - world’s first managed analytics platform for audit; designed specifically for audit teams, it dramatically improves productivity and performance; enables the whole team to share and reuse that information more effectively and efficiently by capturing and storing critical audit information in one secure, central location 2. ACL Desktop Edition - provides a unique and powerful combination of data access, analysis and integrated reporting; reads and compares enterprise data allowing the source data to remain intact for complete data quality and integrity; enables immediate visibility into transactional data critical to the organization. 3. Direct Link - adds SAP ERP data selection and extraction capabilities to the data access, analysis, and reporting capabilities of ACL AuditExchange and ACL Desktop Edition to provide a comprehensive solution to help you analyze your SAP ERP data. 4. Continuous Controls Monitoring - continuously and independently analyzes financial transaction data from any ERP, mainframe system, custom-built application to check and validate against organization's control parameters and business rules BPS 1. BPS Audit - comprehensive and easy-to-use platform for today’s busy auditors offering complete audit functionality: Global Audit Planning, Audit Analytics, Risk Libraries, Work Paper Management, Issues and Actions Tracking, and comprehensive Reporting 2. BPS Compliance - single repository of risks and controls can be used to support multiple regulations, reducing overlap and duplicative costs; also includes a full document and evidence management facility and our powerful Risk Management Library (RML) enabling users to incorporate all types of documents, policies and evidence to manage financial, information technology and operational controls 3. BPS OpsRisk - enables risk managers to integrate loss data from a variety of sources to develop a comprehensive view of operational risk exposure; Risk Libraries, RCSA templates, customizable loss event repositories, scenario analyses, KRIs, customizable dashboards and reporting are all supported; BPS OpRisk also includes a full document management facility as well as powerful workflow and notifications facility, which simplifies follow-up and ensures that critical risks get addressed promptly and fully. 4. BPS Issues and Action Tracking - seamlessly integrate outputs from audit, legal, compliance, risk management and business units. Its powerful workflow and notifications facility strengthens risk identification, simplifies follow-up and ensures that critical problems get addressed promptly; includes a full document management facility than can incorporate all types of documents, policies and evidence. CCH – TEAMMATE Components: 1. TeamRisk (assists auditors in creating risk assessments that are compatible with different auditing standards) 2. EWP (audit documentation system) 3. Libraries and TeamStores – Knowledge base and templates 4. TEC – Time and expense capture (web-based application that streamlines the data entry process and makes timesheets available from anywhere) 5. Team Central – (web-based global audit and issues tracking database that accumulates project information and findings from all of your individual CCH TeamMate EWP projects and allows you to track the implementation status of recommendations made by your department) 6. Team Schedule – (provides users with the ability to schedule projects and resources in such a way that there is a clear visual demonstration of personnel assignments and tracking of projects in an annual plan) CURA 1. Cura Enterprise - Manages risk and compliance operations within one flexible, configurable solution; provides easy access to risk and compliance information with the ability to configure custom workflows, calculations, multiple methodologies, a limitless hierarchy, and ‘virtual parameters' to normalize reporting; enables managers to improve insight and oversight of the issues and exposures of the business at a strategic level. 2. Cura Assessor - allows collection, organization and management of GRC elements such as risks, controls, acts, regulations, contracts and documentation. It includes interactive workshop tools to help organizations and consultants conduct risk reviews and analysis in faster more efficient ways than before. 3. Cura Surveys - enables deployment of required questionnaires, obtain multi level sign-offs, analyze and audit the data, provide automated corrective action notifications to participants, as well as reporting at all levels. ENCASE 1. ENCASE Enterprise - scalable platform that integrates seamlessly with your existing systems to create an enterprise investigative infrastructure; can be tailored to meet unique user needs, including the automation of time-consuming investigative processes, auditing endpoints for sensitive information and eDiscovery. 2. ENCASE eDiscovery - solution for the search, identification, collection, preservation and processing of electronically stored information (ESI) across the enterprise network; enables thorough, networkenabled and court-validated computer investigations of any kind, such as responding to document requests, conducting internal investigations, responding to regulatory inquiries or performing data and compliance auditing, all while maintaining the integrity of the data. 3. ENCASE Information Assurance - Network-enabled; its speed, streamlined and automated processes, scalability and precision allows for mitigation and oftentimes elimination of known and unknown risks. GALILEO AUDIT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM – fully integrated audit management, documentation and reporting system which can be tailored to suit the precise needs of an internal audit, investigations, compliance or other project oriented department. When integrated with MAGIQUE Risk Management System, it provides a full risk-based auditing methodology. IDEA Powerful, easy to use tool that can quickly and accurately import, join, analyze, sample and extract data from almost any source, including reports printed to a file; increases the effectiveness of analysts, accountants, and auditors in the performance of their duties and making valuable analysis feasible as well as practical. With unlimited file size capabilities to access large volumes of data, IDEA can read through millions of records in only seconds. INTEGRUM Used by organisations (SMEs to multinationals) to manage their risk and compliance management systems, including Risk Management, Incident Management, Health & Safety, Environment, Quality, Asset Management, Financial Services, and Corporate Governance.; contains very robust risk assessment and control processes, closed loop corrective action processes, incident management, controlled document management & archive control, audit management, employee training management, supplier and contractor management etc. KNOWRISK A Project Risk Management process and tool that helps you identify, analyze, and respond to Risks. MAGIQUE RISK MANAGEMENT SOFTWARE – integrated web-based system to assist organisations to record, quantify, assess and control risks. METHODWARE 1. Pro Audit Advisor (electronic work paper tool) a. Manage audit findings and recommendations within a single database b. Supports risk-based auditing; c. Design an audit report with bite, then use it as a template for future reporting d. Analyse and understand audit results with powerful sort and filter functions 2. Planning Advisor (risk based audit planning tool) 3. COBIT Assessor (benchmarks IT processes against leading standards in IT management and control) 4. Enterprise Risk Assessor (scalable, flexible and cost effective software solution designed to help organizations manage risk-related data and its associated assessment processes and reporting; manages governance, risk and compliance initiatives) MICROSOFT OFFICE Includes Word Processing, Excel Spreadsheet, Access Database and Powerpoint presentation MODULO Modulo risk Manager – enables the management of risks; evaluates the compliance with market standards and regulations as well as IT environment governance; risk analysis is performed by using a structured methodology, embedded with international risks management rules and standards PAISLEY 1. Paisley Enterprise GRC – Optimized for large enterprise organizations; a comprehensive audit, financial controls management, enterprise risk management, operational risk management, IT governance and compliance software solution purpose-built to address integrated governance, risk and compliance requirements; enables the consistent sharing of definitions and terms, organizational reporting structures, and relationships between controls and the associated audit results. 2. On Demand – Optimized for mid-market and resource constrained organizations; is a comprehensive audit, financial controls management, enterprise risk management, operational risk management, IT governance and compliance software solution; automates processes and eliminates redundant data entry, streamlines risk assessment and control testing efforts, and provides an integrated focus on governance, risk and compliance with minimal investment in IT. 3. Auto Audit – automates key aspects of the audit process including risk assessment, scheduling, work papers and reporting; easy to implement, maintain and use; multi-level risk assessment allows for quick and easy tracking and reporting; allows users to generate a broad array of reports with the touch of a button; stores workpapers in a highly secure and centralized database for a streamlined review process. PENTANA Pentana Audit Work System (PAWS) – complete solution for all your governance, risk and assurance needs. Integrated risk management and internal controls modules make it equally suitable for use by risk departments and for compliance with Sarbanes-Oxley reporting. Web based modules allow direct update of risks, controls, audit questionnaires and the status of outstanding actions. RELIANT ReliantAuditor – continuous risk management solution designed to help audit executives automate audit operations to more effectively manage risk; integrates continuous monitoring with automated control testing and remediation, risk assessment, audit plan management, and a dynamic risk framework; delivers the two most important outcomes from an audit program: assurance in financial reporting and confidence in corporate controls REPLY – IQ VOTING SOFTWARE Audience response products are known by many names such as interactive voting pads, audience voting keypads, and clickers. These electronic devices quickly record audience member answers to questions during meeting, training, and survey events. The benefits they provide are that they collect valuable data fast, improve retention, improve comprehension, identify priorities, accelerate decision making, build consensus and increase participant interest. Reply Solo handheld base stations can be used anywhere, indoors or outdoors, to perform audience voting at any time without a PC, software, or even any electricity. RISK SHIELD Risk management software solution which allows corporations to manage risk and compliance requirements. SAP ASSURE SAP Assure Suite is a suite of tools to help mitigate risks associated with SAP implementation and optimize control configuration. The suite of tools includes: SAP Assure Controls - Improves assurance by assessing internal controls against best practices. It automatically identifies and reports internal control weaknesses in order to create action plans to mitigate those weaknesses. SAP Assure Integrity - Assists in the identification of integrity risks and fraud by identifying potentially fraudulent transactions, financial statement disclosure concerns, and inappropriate use of privileged user access, duplicate transactions and integrity problems with master data. SAP Assure Security - Monitors the adequacy of security access within an SAP implementation. This toolset can automatically assess the SAP security structure, identify users who have access to sensitive and compatible functions, and outline improvements. SAP GRC SUITE The complexity of the SAP configuration is such that comprehensive continuous control monitoring can only be effectively undertaken by using a customised automated solution. SAP GRC suite of software provides a range of tools for control monitoring in SAP such as access controls, the adequacy of the assignment of roles to users and the associated implications for segregation of duty violations and control conflicts. The suite includes the following products: - Risk management - provides the ability to measure and monitor risk exposure for processes managed through SAP; - Access Control - provides real-time segregation of duties monitoring with the ability to detect and resolve overlapping roles and enforce access and authentication controls; and - Process Control - provides control management for compliance with a range of better practice control frameworks such as Sarbanes-Oxley, Committee of Sponsoring Organisations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) and Control Objectives for Information & Related Technologies (COBiT) and enables configurable custom-automated control tests to enforce compliance. SAP GRC is the SAP proprietary product recommended for continuous control monitoring, as endorsed by Gartner and is now freely available to contributing NSW Government Agencies under the SAP Whole of Government License Agreement. TICKIT ON DEMAND A new generation of risk and compliance software that focuses on simplicity, intuitiveness and ease of use; complies with the Risk Management Standard AS/NZS 4360 and the Compliance Management Standard AS/NZS 3806; provides a structured framework to monitor risk and compliance, identify and assess risks and easily allocate tasks to manage them. VISUAL GOVERNANCE Provides a complete risk and performance structure to manage Enterprise compliance framework.; Integration of Enterprise risk assessment, business process, and policy and procedure management; enables users to dynamically create risk control matrices through an intuitive drag and drop style interface which helps accelerate compliance effort; provides for a fully integrated governance life cycle system to manage all aspects of Enterprise risk-base compliance framework; provides numerous risk attributes, in addition to customizable scales, to properly represent their occurrence likelihood, business impact, classification, associated business processes and systems, calculated financial impact, and other critical information necessary to identify the proper risk mitigation. WEBSPY transforms the raw data in internet and email log files into manageable information, providing a transparent view over organizational Internet, email and network usage. WebSpy’s product catalogue features two main analysis and reporting solutions, Analyzer and Vantage, and a variety of optional addons and tools. The solutions are unobtrusive, scalable and available in different ranges to suit any organizational size or budget. The main solutions do not require the installation of individual monitoring agents, additional network configurations or server installations. WIZSOFT 1. WizWhy - data-mining tool that analyzes the data and issues predictions.; 2. WizRule - innovative data auditing and cleansing application that automatically reveals all the rules in a given data, and points at the deviations from the set of the discovered rules as suspected errors. 3. WizSame - reveals not only identical records but similar records as well; reveals cases where the customer names in two records differ by one character 4. WizCount - WizCount bank and account reconciliation reveals all the matching transactions, thus leaving out the non-reconciled records; makes use of several sophisticated mathematical algorithms that quickly cover the enormous number of one-to-one, one-to-many and many-to-many matching possibilities, and reveal the right ones