Heart of Darkness 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad Tough language Author was polish, so his vocabulary is not in sync with ours, uses many big words in regular usage Story: o About a man Marlow o He is the storyteller o Dream imagery o About his experience traveling into Africa, - which he calls the heart of darkness A) Europeans didn’t think Africa was a civilized place Prejudice against Africans – less sophisticated, more animal like Because they believe this, there was a movement in Europe called colonism or imperialism When you take your culture and “gift it” onto someone else o They may view it as opposing on them Book debates whether this is a good or bad thing o Book explores both sides of it Which is true, and what it says about us, if the more destructive side is really the truth B) His journey could be read as a symbolic journey into the heart of his deepest self Dream imagery would show this He is finding out things about himself that are scary , painful and enlightening Story Setting is a boat on the river Thames o People sitting on a boat but cant travel since it is too windy Narrator believes that the English culture is the best culture ever o Believes in the righteousness of the imperial ideal o Sitting there with other unnamed characters Tells us that Marlow is an individual, primary character Begins by saying that this place (London) too was once uncivilized Talks about humanity – why powerful countries always want to take over lesser ones o Says we are fascinated by the horrible (“fascination by abomination”) We are all drawn towards terrible things Says that when you think about imperialism it isn’t really noble o The book is a criticism of colonialism and imperialism o What redeems it is the noble idea, some believe that we are truly spreading light onto the darkness Unclear whether total criticism or also a defense Marlow has experienced it first hand and will show us what it truly looks like (Kurtz) o Marlow is going on a journey and Kurtz is his goal He had gone into Africa with the nobleness intentions, but there are reports that something is wrong with him, he may be sick – Marlow is to go to talk to him, and possibly bring him back Marlow is going to tell these people on the boat the story of his journey o the idea of the time was that going into a savage place would often bring your own darkness out Marlow is told about Kurtz for the first time o When being told about his the word “interior” is used – shows that you have to go into your self to find more o Kurtz is also a symbol o Find out that Kurtz is one of the most successful ivory explorers, one of the great representatives of English colonialism As Marlow gets ready to go, he finds out that many people feel threatened by Kurtz o This makes Marlow like him more o Thinks that he has held up to his values Meets someone talking about Kurtz who was the chief of the inner station o Again “inner” Marlow thinks that Kurtz will offer him the answers, the truth, which he hopes will show him the light Tells the others that he had such an experience, but that they wont even hear it, its like trying to remember a dream (its impossible) o Also he cant see the people hes talking to, it is black, they may all be asleep The writer is addressing this He then talks about when he was going up the river o Said that in this time, you were not yourself anymore, you found out who your really are o Their past came back to them o It was a place you cant understand, even though its all still you cant understand it – “the stillness of an implacable force brooding over an intrutable intention” o Thinks this new place may be what a human being really is Says what we do for money is so meaningless, when you see what real existence is, the “inner truth is hidden” Feels that Kurtz can explain why we are here, what it all means o the further he gets the more questions he has, and the more he thinks that Kurtz can answer them scared that these people who he thought were inhumane, may be humane – that’s what we really are gets closer and closer to Kurtz finds out that Kurtz is supposed to write report about the savages o he goes out there with the intetion of helping them get rid of their customs o after being there for a long time he stopped writing the report, but instead writes a summation of what it is all about o he wrote “exterminate all the brutes!” thought that the Europeans are here for this reason and that is what they enjoy doing they want to get rid of that that frightens them and what they think is unworthy we learn that he has changed, he is no longer a noble Englishman, rather he has realized what he desires, and he has allowed himself to do this at full force o by the time Marlow meets Kurtz he bares little resemblence to the original Kurtz he has became a cannibal a leader of an African tribe they worship him he has stakes around his house with skulls on them they were facing in though – suggests he likes to look at them, also that he would talk to them at night he has gone completely to the other side,, embraced his darkness and savagery Kurtz is now dying o Dies and his last words are “The horror! The horror!” o Marlow is very impressed with Kurtz that he was able to see the truth By the time Kurtz died he had been part of every type of culture He had embraces his heart of darkness He made a judgment of what life is about – it is all a horror Marlow thinks that if you have the courage to do this then you live a much truer life When Marlow goes back to England he meets his fiancé o She asks him for his last words He replies that the last word was her name He recognizes the truth, but not willing to live with the consequences 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess Purpose of strange language: Modern literary period is known for experimentation o Book has personality, something new and different Read with different mind set, have to learn the books vocabulary, see it the way he sees it Separates you from this world Language is indicative of who he is, he is able to hold on to his own personality o Since through his voice, we start to sympathize with him Section o Allows us access to his mind and individuality Chooses to speak in this language, but is able to speak in the others o Big theme of book, being able to choose Alex and his friends use this language to separate themselves, to identify themselves o They feel nothing towards society – don’t love or hate them Shown the way he acts towards others If the book was written in regular English people wouldn’t want to read it, it would be too violent, but the language separates us from the nature of the acts, we are not emotionally vested in it 1 sets the stage on the world that Burgess invents we meet Alex and his Droogs o Alex likes classical music, violence, sex and drugs Two types of monsters o Alex and droogs o State Could relate to cold war (time period when written) The state has no control, but so much power See difference between day and night – world they exist o The day the state cares, but at night the state doesn’t matter o The state wants the people who hang out at night to be quieted, the kids are doing it for them Seen on page 17, and with author of clockwork orange Chapter Chapter o Easier to let people rebelling quiet each other, they then can control the other aspects of society Law and order are controlled absolutely, by keeping everyone under there control, the chaos is a controlled chaos A world where control by government is becoming more prevalent o Because of new types of psychology, little by little the government will control everyone, the first part of the book is about a vision in this world Even the kids are products of the state Alex is both a victimizer but also a product of this world, terrible parenting, a world that uses him as an example o Unlike his friends he has a bit of individiuaity one: Sense that written texts are starting to disappear o Tells us the book will be a lot about language How we use it, how cultures shape it Looked for real feeling, sense of being alive o Drugs in milk bar three: Alex has an affinity for classical music o When listening to music he was thinking of violence and sex The writer may have chosen classical music for these things is to break the stereotypes of people with good taste in music as good people o Tells us that there is more to Alex then we would think Chapter five: Upset that he is losing control and with Dim o Dreamt about it as well Chapter six: Went into a house with many cats, milk everywhere, a statue of Beethoven and an old women o Alex artistic side made him feel different the others, at some point they were going to turn on him, feet that he is so different He is starting to become his own person, so the others think he needs to be taken away Chapter 7: Police coming, Alex caught and brought to jail Alex is different in jail Finds out the women he broke into had died Find out he’s fifteen o Feel bad for him o Not responsible, in a world that he is neglected and abandoned by his family Start to sympathize, did he create himself, or did the world create him Section 2: The new state makes the people what they want, makes them “good”, but what is good? Is it good if you are programmed or is that time of goodness empty o They make him “good” by feeling bad when he sees bad things Chapter one: Same first line as first chapter, but different speaker Give him a number Chapter Chapter o Little by little he is surrendering his identity In jail he listens to music, stays violent, and reads the old testament A Chaplin tries to help Alex Likes old testament and likes it, then starts to read new testament, starts to seem himself like Jesus, taking the sins of the world two: Tell him they will try a new technique on him Is going to be set free, but his freedom comes with the inability to make choices o Redefines freedom three: Tell Alex that they will make him the first recipient of the Ludovico technique Inside he feels that something may wrong The Chaplin responds that it may not be nice to be good, it may be horrible to be good He asks what does God want, goodness or the choice of goodness, is a man who chooses the bad, better then the man who has to choose the good Passing to a place beyond the reach of prayer In a sense you have truly chosen the good o The chaplain is the voice of the author, part of the system but doesn’t believe in it I know what there doing has rationality, but it cant be good Chapter seven: Section He is brought in front of the authorities as a demonstration, but is unable to do it, since he feels sick His music is also taken away o Author is suggesting you cant have goodness without taking away a person individuality Clockwork orange – an orange is messy, its unpredictable, the society is turning this orange into a mechanism The guy is hitting and mocking Alex o willing to lick his boots, but instead he kicks him the Chaplin says that he has no real choice, its insincere, he ceases to be a wrong doer and a creature capable of moral choice o doctor that these are subtleties that must be sacrificed it works, God help the lot of us three: His parents don’t need him Dim has become a policeman o Seems ironic, but in reality all these people were always manipulated by government system He then meets R Alexender, author of clockwork orange, raped his wife o Has the same name as Alex o Became leader of rebel group, that wants to undermine the government o Takes him into his home but then realizes that he is the one who raped his wife Chapter Chapter o Wants to use Alex as propaganda If he is a martyr it can be a rallying point They try to drive him to suicide five: Decided to commit suicide, and jumps o But doesn’t die six: When he is awakened he is freed from government treatment He is back to the old Alex, got it all back He felt like he was cured o Original American book ended here Thought Americans wanted a more cynical meaning Burgess wanted a more conventional meaning, with 21 chapters (become an adult) Wanted Alex to go through youth, but end as a man with choice Chapter seven: Starts with a similar beginning Makes a choice to end his violent ways, but still keeps his individuality and artistic side Tells us that he is no longer young o Ends in a conventional way, he makes a choice, but the conventional one He still has language, music, personality Done not because he was trained, but because he has grown up through choice A society cant make you good, but people who evolve naturally will choose morality, if imposed it is meaningless Book is a satire, fear of future, vision of young, hope for them What is unique is the way the message is presented to us Modest Proposal + Wuthering Heights Yossi Quint A modest proposal: Got Ericas notes Wuthering Heights Two major narrators o Mr. Lockwood In the beginning of the book in the present, he goes to rent a house near wuthering heights and thruscross grange Get an idea of characters from name of house Wutheirng – windy, intense, emotional o Heathcliff belongs here Thrushcross – a thrush is a bird, cross – Christianity, very traditional, religious, orderly o Lockwood belongs in this type of place o Nelly o Mr lockwood starts it then nelly takes over then goes back to lockwood Genealogy Main characters o Heathcliff Byronic hero – Byron was a poet who wrote about a certain type of men, the type of men who were known as this had to be handsome, dark (misanthropically, mysterious, violent, passionate), who seemed to be nursing some type of grievance against the world, which makes women drawn to them Chapter 1: Begins 1801 (reading a diary) Nelly telling story to Lockwood and we are reading this o Reading is important, since a recurring image is language and reading, literacy, words o Besides nelly telling the story, many characters tell her stories She is sometimes a participant, someone’s an observer, and sometimes just heard it from someone else And then Lockwood tells it to us o Lockwood edited Nelly words By the time it gets to us its been totally distorted Suggests philosophically that there is no true or real story Lockwood is not reliable Why would Emily Bronte do all of these things to distance us and confuse us, and to tell us that there is no central truth? o Empowers every individual reader (+ subjectivity) Begins with date, seems chronological, but isn’t o Pieces of puzzle hear, just not in order Lockwood going to visit his landlord o Says it’s a perfect place for someone that hates others Heathcliff is often referred to as tabulas rasa – blank slate o The character isn’t as identifiable as a reflection of the person who’s describing it o You write upon it, you create it, either in the way you observe or the way you mold him People see what they want to see + when he is introduced no one knows where he comes from or who his parents are Created out of his environment Lockwood is revealing something about himself o He would like to be Byronic and a misanthrope But he isn’t He is very much the opposite Lockwood says hello to Heathcliff and Heathcliff just nods, doesn’t respond o A man of few words o Uses words for their usefulness o Says what he feels Presents himself as he is, not worried about hw is he perceived On the other hand, Heathcliff is verbose The entire first part of the novel is about Lockwood and major themes, only after that do we enter the real story Lockwood sees Heathcliff as very reserved, even more so then him – example of tabulas rasa o Lockwood wanted to have the same picture of himself Names o Lockwood Closed, boring o Heathcliff Alive, dangerous, daring o Names have nothing in common Funny that Lockwood thinks they are so similar Lockwoods tells a story of how he liked this girl and she liked him but he didn’t say anything and she left o Real story: he liked her and stared at her which the girl was scared of and she left why is he the narrator? o We know he want tell the truth but will present the facts o Enabling us to read the story as we want o He represents a type of society that the author wants to satirize The world of men, convention, the typical city dweller, or typical author In a male centric world, having a narrator who is a man makes the reader more comfortable, but the real narrator is nelly, but the man filters it This allows the lower class women to have a lot more integrity when contrasted to Lockwood’s voice o When she published it she wanted a fake name on the cover, didn’t think people were ready for a female writer But name was ambiguous Heathcliff gets everything wrong o Tries to pet the dog Heathcliff doesn’t want the dog to be spoiled He starts to make weird faces at the dog Chapter 2: Two levels of reading (for comes down to dinner… servant girl… runs out of house to wuthering heights) – this isn’t just a short walk, its four miles o He may be a snob, may be awkward o Or he is excited by this women, physical excitement Cant deal with his desires Runs away from them The snow storm is so bad, that he has to stay at Wuthering heights for the night He stays in old Cathys old room o Cathy I – girl who grew up with Heathcliff o Cathy II (or little Catherine) – is Cathys daughter 3: Sees written in the desk Catherine Earnshaw Catherine Heathcliff Chapter Catherine Linton o This awakens Lockwood o He wants to explore this o Catherine in writing these names she has shown her confusion, as well as predicted her future What’s also interesting is that her daughters future is reversed, she starts as a Linton, then becomes a Heathcliff and finally Earnshaw This shows that the generations are going in circles, one women does one thing, the other does the opposite No progress will be made, time will not alter anything essential Also a supernatural feeling about Wuthering heights This is emphasized when Lockwood goes to sleep Lockwood dreams of a noise at night, and he is annoyed and thinks it’s a branch hitting the window, he goes to move the branch away but instead feel the fingers of a small ice cold hand The voice said “Let me in, let me in” Lockwood takes the hand and tries to cut its wrist o Shows us that when he is afraid he is willing to do whatever needs to be done He lies to the ghost so that it will let him go And then puts books against the window Heathcliff hears him and is angry that he is sleeping in this room, so he throws him out and sends him to another room Lockwood then observes through a key hole what Heathcliff does He sees Heathcliff yelling for Cathy to come in o Heathcliff and Lockwood are opposite o Heathcliff loved Cathy and it’s a love that he is holding onto, he is obsessed Chapter 4 Pg. 32 narration shifts from lockwood to nelly o We go back to wuthering heights, where the original Mr and Mrs Rarnshaw live They have two children Hinley and Catherine One day Mr Earnshaw brings home a boy (Heathcliff) o The reaction isn’t very good He’s dark and he’s a gypsy Hindley is particularly upset (it threatens his place in the family) o This may be included in the book since it’s a story about prejudice, and since he is somewhat different he is never Chapter treated the same as others, and as the consequence of that he becomes this monster figure Tells the story of how he found it o He may not have found it, but had an affair, which may show why they had a closer relationship o This also adds another dimension to Cathy and Heathcliff Incest… Even Nelly an outsider calls him “it” and not him 6 Hindley becomes the master of wuthering heights after his parents die o He has no one standing between him and cathy and Heathcliff This makes cathy and Heathcliff closer together One day they run away together and find themselves near thrush cross grange o It’s beautiful (opposite of wuthering heights), there are even a brother and sister (mirror image of sibilings) Heathcliff returns home without cathy, since cathy was injured by the dog their and was invited to be cared for at the lintons home Heathcliff returns to nelly and tells her what he saw o Heathcliff says he doesn’t envy, he has nothing but disdain for their “petted lives” (pg. 44) o Shows the comparison between the two Thruscross – absolute security, materilisitc But when they get what they want they just want more, they wont have the close relationship that he and cathy have Book starts to ask the questions, which is better Cathy stays at thruscross grange for five weeks and marks the divide of Cathy and Heathcliff o Makes Cathy aware of an alternative life When she returned she was whitened from not being outdoors and working Chapter She sees Heathcliff as dirty and lesser, which upsets Heathcliff greatly since everyone judged him but cathy, and now cathy does too 9 Edgar Linton decides he likes Cathy and Cathy is torn between the two Mr. Linton came in to the house to see Nelly hiding Haerton in the cupboard He grabs nelly and threatens to stab her with a death Nelly responds that shed rather be shot o She’s used to this, wants to calm him down Note: What’s Emily bronte really saying o Lockwood is trying to rape nelly Not just physical violence, but also sexual violence o This shows us how bad things are it also shows us why cathy chose edgar over Heathcliff Even if she loves Heathcliff more, she needs a refuge Heathcliff is sitting outside the door and Nelly knows this, but nelly tells cathy hes in the stable She tells nelly that edgar linton asked him to marry him o And she accepted him She says how she loves all the things that surround edgar o She wants a good life, security, possessions Nelly points this out o May want to reveal her shallowness to Heathcliff o Maybe Nelly wants Heathcliff She tells nelly that she is acting rationally o She is going against her emotions to her secure life She says that she knows that she is denying her own heart Says she doesn’t belong in heaven, she belongs in hell with Heathcliff o But she chooses heaven for the comfort It would degrade her to marry Heathcliff o He has a lower status, and has lost his humanity since she had been treated so poorly With this Heathcliff leaves Chapter Chapter o He doesn’t hear the next part Cathy says that in the long run she might be able to help Heathcliff o Trying to rationalize it My relationship with Edgar is about the now, my eternal part is with Heathcliff o I am Heathcliff, but I will never be with him Nelly goes to live with Cathy o Abandones Haerton for Hindley to raise 10 Nelly sees Heathcliff for the first time since he ran away o Sees beneath the civilized demeanor is the same rage and passion Isabella sees Heathcliff and is attracted to him, and tells cathy o She may be desperate o She may be jealous that cathy stole edgar, and now wants to get even Cathy gives her a very strong warning o Isabella feels that cathy had a chance and now has a life, she wants to know why she cant Cathy calls Isabelle and Heathcliff in to the library o She comments to Heathcliff – it’s not nelly Saying that nelly also likes him Heathcliff realizes that Isabella is Edgars heir o Great opportunity to get even with Edgar o Its not about love anymore o Once he has a goal nothing will stand in his way He wants cathy, he wants thruscross grange and wuthering height and then he wants to destroy it all 12 Edgar says that Heathcliff can no longer visit anymore Cathy is upset and locks herself up in the room Edgar is told by nelly that she needs her time and leave her alone o Edgar listens, but cathy wants him to care (she wants the opposite) Cathy is pregnant o Not written, since nelly doesn’t want to include it Chapter Cathy feels as if she is dying Neylly finds out that Isabella ran off with Heathcliff 13 Isabella then writes a letter to Nelly (who’s telling it to Lockwood, who’s telling us) Isabella thinks she made a big mistake and wants Nelly to bring her something from Edgar Talks about violence between Heathcliff and Hindley o How she is mistreated o How wuthering heights is the opposite Chapter Depends on Nelly to save him 14 Heathcliff tells Nelly that he wants to see Catherine before she dies Nelly allows this (since she always listens to Heathcliff) But she also asks him what is going on with Isabella He told her from the beginning that he didn’t love her and would take everything from her o he didn’t lie and he proved this by hanging her dog o Heathcliff is straight to the point He is also very self aware Heathcliff says the more someone suffers the more he wants to hurt it o Says it’s a moral teething The more pain that occurs, the more he gains o Freud says everyone brain has three components Id, superego, and the ego Id – desires Super ego – conscious Ego – balances id and superego o Heathcliff is all Id o Wutheirng heights – id o Thrushcrsos grange – super ego Chapter 15 Heathcliff asks nelly to allow him to visit cathy Nelly brings him in It’s the first and last physical contact that Cathy and Heathcliff have Chapter They meet… Towards the end of her life Cathy wants opening, she feels suffocation from all the enclosure (151) Cathy asks him for forgiveness Heathcliff says she deserves this o That he will be constantly be tormented, while you will have the peace of death o He can forgive the person that broke his heart, but not he person who broke their own heart Nelly was standing here the entire term, but felt awkward since he thought edgar would come home 16 Catherine bore Catherine The elder Catherine then dies (in child birth) o Heathcliffs goal of getting Catherine back is impossible o Now he can only get back at others Very upset, wishes Catherine would haunt him Then hits his head against a tree Catherine wasn’t buried in the traditional place for the linton or earnshaw family o She wasn’t truly part of either world o Literally she was also in two worlds, earth and heaven (or hell) o She may also have not been buried in the church yard since she may have committed suicide (from the beginning of the book to this point the themes are: the consequence of decisions forbidden love Lack of communication and altering of it by Nelly and Lockwood. About following head instead of heart o while book two is about following the heart) Chapter 17 Since Hindley Earnshaws wife died, he was a gambling and drinking attic. He was in total debt to Heathcliff. o He then dies (174) Chapter Chapter The events after his death were told to Nelly by Kenneth (a servant at wuthering heights) who told is to Nockwood, who told us to us… very second hand Nelly upon hearing of the death from the doctor, thinks that Heathcliff may have killed him o We also learn that Nelly is 27 Nelly goes to see Heathcliff and says that Hindley deserves a proper burial o She notices that Heathcliff is proud He got rid of Hindley and Heathcliff now owns wuthering heights and going to take control of Haerton At the funeral Heathcliff tells Haerton I will raise you like your father raised me, and well see how you come out o The irony of Haerton is the crueler Heathcliff is the more he likes Heathcliff 18 Meanwhile cathy is growing up, and Nelly likes her a lot Cathy from the early stages of her life wanted to know more, she wanted to know what was out there (like her mom, she doesn’t like the enclosed world of thruscross grange) o With Nellys help she goes on trips away from thrusscross grange Nelly then meets Haerton for the first time in 12 years o May be that they wandered, or nelly did this purposefully Heathchliff didn’t treat him as awfully as she imagined 19 The second generation has three main characters o Cathy, Haerton, and Linton (Isabellas son) Named Linton Heathcliff as an attack on Heathcliff Haerton was in the first half, but is different since his master is now Heathcliff Nelly describes Linton as being like a girl, since raised entirely by Isabella o He is also weak and sickly and a bit full of himself Chapter 20 Nelly goes to visit Linton and Heathcliff Heathcliff tells Nelly that he doesn’t like his son but he wants to preserve his gentlemen like state, he wants to make him weak but also have superior feeling of others He wants him to inherit thruscross grange and then die, so Heathcliff can inherit everything o If Heathcliff does die first then his descendent will be in control Heathcliff will make Haerton into a monster and Linton into a gentlemen Chapter 21 Chapter Cathy starts to like Linton Heathcliff decides they should marry and this way, no matter what he will inherit thrushcross grange and edgars money Edgar tries to keep them apart, but Heathcliff gets linton to write love letters to cathy Heathcliff thinks Haerton is a lot better then Linton but he wil make linton appear to be better to help his cause Haerton is jealous of Linton and cathy, and them make fun of him 21-27 Heathcliff kidnaps nelly and cathy o Tells cathy that her father is dying but he wont let her visit him, unless he marries linton Chapter 28 Linton is a selfish brat, who wants everything, and believes everything is in his control Heathcliff also manipulates Green, the lawyer so that he doesn’t go to Edgars house to change his will, to make sure Heathcliff doesn’t get anything Edgar dies without a will, so cathy gets all the money, which goes to Linton o Heathcliff closer to ultimate goal But with ultimate goals, the closer you are to getting it, the less it means Going to get it is the meaningful part Chapter 29 Heathcliff opens up Cathys grave to look it Chapter Chapter He wants his body to be placed next to Cathys so that they can bind together in the earth 30-31 Lockwood then comes back in to the story Nelly then moves back to Wuthering heights Linton dies, and all that’s left of everyone Lockwood knew, was Heathcliff, Cathy, Haerton, and Nelly Lockwoods start to think that since Cathy was married and now is their with these two gross people, perhaps I can marry her 32 Lockwood imagines himself as a romantic hero, he wants to believe in fairy tales o This is important since he makes the final thematic judgment on story (as narrator) Haerton and Cathy had always fought since Cathy liked the intellectual and sophisticated type, but now she is forced to be with Haerton o Haerton tells cathy that he wants to learn how to read o So she tries to teach him how to become more literate Lockwood starts to realize that he wont be with her, since there is someone else (Haerton) Haerton while learning to read with Cathy falls in love with her, and he falls in love with him o Together they no longer fear Heathcliff, they realize that together they are or could be stronger then him Chapter 33 We are now past the point that we started in time o Time stalled and now is moving on again Could be saying that Cathy and Haerton relationship redeems, and revitalizes the relationship that was never fulfilled by Cathy and Heathcliff Haerton parallel to Heathcliff, and Cathy to Cathy Heathcliff says he lost his will to destroy them o Realized he wont get any satisfaction to destroy them Since he doesn’t want to do it Everything reminds him of Cathy Has one goal to be with Cathy (and destroy everyon that took her away) Note: The ghost is returning and changing him o Why is the ghost coming now? A. So he doesn’t destroy Cathy and Haerton There to protect daughter Not help Heathcliff, rather destroy him Cathy may have found a deeper connection, Cathy o Her love for Heathcliiff is triumphed B. Seeing Haerton and Cathy in love, reminds Cathy how much she loves Heathcliff and wants to be with him. C. There is no ghost, hes come to the realization that he doesn’t want to destroy them and that he has pushed to far and to hard. This has destroyed his life. D. He is a tragic hero, since this one characteristic which is so strong is what destroys him His obsession with love, destroys him While chasing Cathy, he destroys Cathy’s love Chapter 34 He dies without a will, but he wanted to make a will to disinherit Cathy and Haerton o Knows he is getting ill But he is not able to make it before his death Lockwood returns and we see the end through his point of view o (have to read with skepticism) o sees two ghost couples walking around everything works out for the dead o walks past gravestones under the benign (harmless) sky if he judged this world as harmless he misjudged everything o wants a happy ending asks how can anyone imagine that their not at peace everyone is at peace all this craziness had an ending, a final peaceful ending o Since we mistrust Lockwood we should question this ending Is their afterlife restful or bitter? We are left suspicious of happy ending Emily Brontes view of life is that its not simple, its complex, violent, chaotic Doesn’t want us to take peoples words for granted, rather assert our own conclusions Yossi Quint 1797 Two people William Wordsworth and Samuel Coleridge Wrote poetry called Lyrical Ballads o In which they put forth a new idea about poetry They are the founders of romantic poetry The romantic era is a short lived poetic era, but had and has a tremendous influence on writers, poet, philosophers… o It ends the restoration period (satire, parody) o Emily Brontes Wuthering heights is inspired by the romantic poems of her time o Gets inspiration from nature The World is too much with us - William Wordsworth Sonnet – ABBA ABBA CD CD CD – octave over sextet Title – Focus on individual (“I”), to concerned as a group of people with world concerns o What people think of us, material items, status Line 1: world - society, Late and soon - always o Romantic poets want us to return to nature, the natural world Line 2: spend most of our time getting money + status and spending them. This wastes our feeling, our time, our experience with the real world Line 3: we don’t see nature as having anything to do with us, lost touch o Lost touch with a part of life for so long Line 4: given away our feelings (souls) for these gains, a disgusting gift o Sordid boon – oxymoron – we think it’s a gift, were making progress, but the gift is actually taking away more then it is giving us Line 5: taking place at sea, she is showing her naked self to the moon o Sea personified as a women (“her”), it wants to be touch and seen o We have turned away from a nature who is alive Line 6: the winds are alive Line 7: but right now its like sleeping flowers Line 8: for this we are out of tune, we don’t care o We are an instrument which is out of tune, we have the potential to be great but we not Line 9: All this doesn’t move us, we have lost a part of ourselves Line 10: Telling god he would rather even be a pagan then be one of these people that are out touch with this world o The pagans had what was lacking in this world o The earth, sky, and sea were alive o Give up faith, if I could have this attachment with the natural world Line 11: I would stand on this pleasant area Line 12: If I were a pagan I would see things that we don’t sea anymore Line 13: if I were a pagan I would believe in this shape shifter Line 14: If I were a pagan I would believe in a merman I wandered lonely as a cloud - William Wordsworth Paragraph 1: o Literal: Guy goes a walk in the words, sees a lot of daffodils moving around in the wind o He is lonely, may not be negative, could be an opportunity, a way of exploring ones self o He may be lonely since he is different, cant participate in society then same way everyone else does o Compares himself to a cloud, he is above everyone (cant connect, above everyone – may be alienated or egotistic) o Flowers made him happy, since they are dancing Paragraph 2: o Literal: Endless amount of daffodils dancing o They are continuous and united, while he is alone Alone by choice but envy others Paragraph 3: o Literal: He cant help but be happy when he sees this, o he didn’t realize at the time but these daffodils brought him wealth and happiness that wouldn’t disappear, rather it can stay with him beyond the moment Paragraph 4: o Literal: When I am resting I will think about this o When he is resting, this idea of the daffodils will be with him again Memory is another keep aspect of romanticism (along with nature, individual, regular folk) o Romantic poems come out of: Experience recollected in tranquility The way in which you enrich yourself is by remembering things so that when things are bad, you can re-enrich yourself through memory Even though he is not with the daffodils, he can carry this experience with him and it can offer him comfort in times when he is not as happy The limit is that he is not actually there, its just a memory o There is disconnect between him and the world o The daffodils are totally conformed but they have each other Kubla Khan – Samuel Coleridge The dream of something great, transcended, above individuals o Only reference to man is Kubla Khan, and narrator About child like imaginations Romantics use child like imagination Returning to perfection o Asking question “Why?” do we have to let this apart of our self go, innocence, creativity, imagination… There may be a way to recall these things About his dream, he had fallen asleep (opium induced) he then woke up wanted to write down his dream, which he started to do, then his neighbor knocked on his door, and he forgot the rest of his dream o This is indicated by a skipped line Verse by verse o Xanadu – imaginative. Kubla Khan – great emperor. o He decried that we will build a pleasure home The fact that has decree this, shows he has god like power The idea that man has powers of creation if they wanted it, is a constant idea in romanticism The dome has a sacred river Which goes through caverns that are infinite (measureless) undefinable series of rivers and caverns Continue to the sunless sea So twice five miles of fertile ground Surrounded by walls and tower Gardens bright with curvy rills Trees that smell like incense o o o o o o o o Ancient forests o Sunny spots of greenery Note: His perfection includes a lot of nature, but also walls and towers He wants it all Sun and sunless Seas and mountains Nature and artificial things Disorder and order (five miles) But oh (enthusiasm, pleasure), the deep romantic chasm which slanted o Now talking about man and female Down a green hill It was savage, and holy, enchanted (opposites) Women were yelling for their demon lover (man o Chasm was a yonic symbol from this ceaseless turmoil earth had thick pants (man) a might fountain came out (phallic symbol) swift fast bursts … Nature has become lifeless o Reached crescendo Missed notes- get it No longer line for line Note; When he returns to finish the poem, he cant remember the previous dream, so remembers other thoughts he had that he liked A maid playing on her dulcimer and singing beautifully o Then connects her to the dome I would build the dome air o I would – subjunctive I cant Limitation – can remember, but not fully. Never get back a moment that is lost. o He recognizes that the dream is an impossible dream ironically that failure becomes part of the romantic temperament the sad feeling you get knowing you cant capture the temperament, is such an intense feeling that becomes something that you can cherish and adds to your life (it’s a spark) the dome that is sunny and has caves of ice everyone that heard about this would yell beware,beware o since he is so strong, like Kubla khan describes how his phyischal body would be unkempt o in touch with natural world, not physichal they would circle me o be in awe They wouldn’t be able to look at me o I would be like a god o Believed man good become super Ozymandias By Percey Shelley Named after Ramses II (aka Ozymandias) Line by line o The speaker met a person from an old place o Who said: “there two legs of stoneo In the destert…” near them in the sand o A half sunk head lies with a shattered face who frowns o Wrinkled lip with a sneer look (serious) o This sculpture teaches about the sculptor, he was good at reading people o The emotions still survive in this (the sculptors work still speaks to people) o by looking at this we can extrapolate a meaning about the rest of this person this is what impresses the antic traveler the most, that he can look at something from a long time ago and still see something, since the sculptor was so talented this sculpture was everlasting the creators life was there, while ozymandias work was decrepit work from the heart, the imagination, that is what survives but the sculpture, those who live with integrity, survive Time has shown that someone low on the hierarchies power is much greater then that of high on the hierarchy of that time period o Vanity of human wishes o on the pedestal it says” Ozymandias, King of Kings: o Look on my works, ye, Mighty, and despair!” Statue supposed to celebrate ozymandias Ironic (next three lines) o There were only remains left o A huge boundless wreck o Sands lay everywhere Over time nature took away everything that he built His power is gone, but the sculptures is left This story has three narrators o We listen to Speaker who is filtering guy telling story o The romantic poet has to connect us to the experience of this person The dark side of the poem is that the sculpture is going to disappear as well, already decrepit o Even the artists work who had integrity, will rot and dissapear over time o Life eventually wins 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Victorian period 1832-1900 ruled by queen Victoria o able to quiet romanticism, and create a world which appears to be perfect, absolute progress, reform o England now exporting their vision of life to other countries which they control (have an empire) They thought they are bringing light to the darkness of the world Sounds good, but at the same time, they didn’t ask if they wanted it Many times they impoverished or enslaved them, instead of enlightening them Forced religion on others Point where middle class became the power brokers of society o Important since it’s the middle class that does most of the reading Women read more then men, they had a lot of time since they didn’t work The Victorian era produces the novel o A book that is prose, that tells the story of a persons life o Most novels were written for newspapers Each day they would print a chapter Consequence was that the chapters were very short, but the novels was very long Goes into great detail about all the characters The values that Victoria was putting on the world were absolute values o Rules for everything Implied dress code for society Decorum o Very moral Poetry also changed o Victorian poems tell distinct stories o About relationships, called dramatic monologues A narration spoken to another person, who is in the room, but we don’t here the response that person gives Dover Beach By Mathew Arnold Man is speaking to a women, they are lovers – dramatic monologue o Man calling women to look at a beautiful site o Trying to teach her how to interpret the moment Could assume he’s older Part I – starts with the sea is calm o describes place o says you can see England and France at a particular place that we can see a lot of space o tells her to come to the window, wants to show her sweet, but also telling her what to do o don’t just look also listen, and he tells her how to listen tells her to notice the tide, how it goes back and forth describes the pattern of life Part 2 – starts with Sophocles o Compares his wisdom to Sophocles People who were aware have noticed that there is a connection to the past, something eternal of the observations of intelligent beings o It used to be that religion was everything, people used to have faith, everyone believed and knew what do Tells us this is at the end of the Victorian era New generation will ruin these values o Now I only hear how the tide is retreating Part 3 – starts Ah, love o His solution is form him and his love to keep a little pocket of morality between them They will be an island within their world Got Erica notes for rest, and next poem – Ulysses My last Duchess by Robert Browning Dramatic monologue o The speaker is a rich noblemen named duke Ferrara Poem is about his most recent wife, who has died o A painting of her has sparked memories of her, and she is sharing these memories with a particular painting o Suggestion that she had relationships with others – easily impressed o He thinks she should have respected him more, lack of admiration for him o He still has grudge against her o Talking to counts servant (line 49) Romantically interested in counts daughter May be trying to make sure she will behave Wants to make sure he can train her, says last wife wasn’t tamable Wants his next wife to be trainable o Power hungry He may have killed his last wife Upset with old wife Didn’t give special smile This grew more often I gave commands (wasn’t willing to stoop to her), resulted in all smiles stopping There she stands as if alive o Subtly connecting the two Telling servant that he should let his boss know that he shouldn’t be taken lightly Says nay we’ll go Makes it sounds like they are together Notice Neptune taming a sea horse, a rarity, which is cast in bronze Telling him he wants a tame object He collects objects with his power, not people who act on their own volition Underneath is an irony, as much as he wants a very different wife, the fact that he keeps this pictures tells us that ironically eh is the one he really loves o Deep inside, doenst want tame women o But has big ego so thinks he needs great power Author may be saying that these men that run the world that seem to be elegant and sophisticated are corrupt being Pied Beauty by Gerland Manly Hopkins Praises things that are not traditionally considered beautiful o Pied – spotted Usually not recognized as being pretty Glory be the God who creates thinks that are imperfect o Praising God by prasiging imperfection Sky with several colors Like a braided cow o Has hair coming out of spots Like a spotted fish Lists a bunch of flawed things – birds… Landscape that has different forms and colors (Second paragraph) all people who are original and people we don’t pay attention to whoever is indecisive list oxymorons (also alliteration) o seems to contradict, but he finds praiseworthy Praise God since all of these imperfections emphasize the perfect unchanging beauty of God o Victorians didn’t like change, but he reacted to it differently Note: o Called this a curtailed sonnet Six lines over four and a half This fraction is equal to 8/6 Seems pied, but underneath is equivalency 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM James Joyce Forefront of modernist movement He said everything has already been written, there are no quotation marks o Instead there are dashes o Difficult to tell where quote ends Reasons to do A) Simple: being different B) its not so important what people say, what’s important is what’s going on in a persons mind He wants to take the reader on an inward journey into the consciousness of an individual How do people thing, what do they really think o Finding deeper and more profound meanings that each person harbors inside themselves The Dead Plot: o Party every year at a house Julia and Kates house o Every year different people come to this great party Very formal o This night is a special dinner since the two of them are getting older They are older, the world is changing o People come into the house and take off there coats to get ready for the party, every is waiting for Gabriel Conroy and his wife to come When he comes in the party can really start Need a man to make a speech, carve the goose… He is sophisticated, well traveled.. o Meet various people Meaningless in terms of story Story is about what happens inside Gabriel’s mind We start entering his mind In a way that no one else did There are now theories about the mind o Seeing from inside Called stream of consciousness o Worries about things, gives a speech o The party is over, everyone leaves o He looks up and sees how pretty his wife Excited since spending night without his kids Walks home with her, on the way he is getting excited about rekindling their romantic life o They go to there hotel room Epiphany o Something that happens and you feel it, its internal Sudden revelation o Two types False epiphany Real epiphany o Very often we think we feel something, but we are really missing the point, then there are moments when the truth of our lives washes over us In this book Gabriel experiences a few false epiphanies but at the end he has a significant and momentous epiphany, which at that point life changes Text: 183 Starts with Lilly the maid o We start the story, like a guest, we are welcomed in to the party o She is described as Lilly, the caretakers daughter, it points out two issues: A) class World where class matters, seen based on their family B) gender As a women not described by who she is or what she does, rather what man she is attached to Invited into house Get a sense of life, three older ladies, all live in house o Hints that they demand obedience from people who are lower then them “they would not stand for back answers” o Also give lessons to only upper class families They (and us) are waiting for Gabriel We learn he has conventional ideas about women “takes three mortal hours to dress herself” Gabriel cleans his galoshes o Snow is binding of story, snow gets worse and worse until the story comes to an end Different people have difrent attiudes and responses to the snow we learn about character by how the react to snow o The fact that he is wearing galoshes tells us that he is a world man, since it was not fashionable to wear them in Ireland, rather they were popular in France and England Cares about European fashion o They protect him from the snow whatever the snow is, Gabriel doesn’t want to be part of it o tries to get all vestiges of the snow off of him symbolic and practical likes to be clean and safe men and women have different responsibilities – women go to dressing room tonight is a big night for the snow falling makes polite chit chat with Lilly o asks her about her schooling looks at her like she’s a little girl, doesn’t think that she changed over time o then asks if shes getting married soon Gabriel has conventional notions of gender o She replies, “the men that is now is only all palaver and what they can get out of you” - men just want sex and how they can use you This is totally alien to Gabriel He doesn’t want to know that she has real feelings o Gabriel is embarrassed, feels he made a mistake, tries to clean himself up and get away from her o Tries to cover this up with some money o Lilly tries to give back, but runs away from her Afraid of her Since lie is getting disordered he tries to order himself – fixes tie and cuffs He then thinks about speech, thinks that his quotes are above them o Thinks he is better then them – superiority We meet his wife o She was talking to others about galoshes, she wasn’t trying to run away from snow, she didn’t need the newest things He sees a picture of his mother in her ants house, and remembers that she was somewhat difficult sometimes o His mother thought that his wife was too “country like” from a lower class People from the east of Ireland are higher then those on the west Surprisingly Gabriel married someone from the west, it seems like its not like him However conventional he is, something in him may want more He the has a conversation with a single women named Ivor o Brings up fact that Gretta is from the west, but he replies that her people are, she has evolved though o She then invites on a summer excursion o He replies that he cant he’s going to other places in Europe o She’s upset that he’s running away from his country, to go to others o He’s not interested in this, but her ideas penetrate Sits by the window thinking about speech o Border line between inside and outside o When we entre his mind, we see that he wants to be out in the cold We the reader, know he is scared of the cold, he longs for it but is afraid of it Everyone gets ready for dinner o We learn that the snow is deliberated (associated) with the west (pg. 212) Snow may be freedom and it is also dangerous Gives his speech o Telling the audience what they want to hear o Seems to be that the old was better then then new o Being condescending, the new generation is educated maybe too much so o But he is really insulting the old, that they aren’t, happy that they are almost over o Speech is a big success He is happy, since his role in the night is over, all he has to look forward to is a nice night with his wife Gabriel is waiting for his wife to go home o He looks up to see a skirt, but doesn’t know who’s it is (neither do we – we are now in his consciousness) It is his wife, but he doesn’t really know his wife o He feels a sense of attraction o So in love that he wants to hold onto it for ever, and turn it into art – wants to make it something everlasting Wants to title it distant music Irony – as he is falling in love he is saying how distant he is from her, calls the picture distant music The music isn’t distant to her, but to him – the picture is more about him He only thinks about things through his perspective Before they leave, he again sees the richness of her o He sees her blushing Thinks she is feeling the same sexual emotion as he does He thinks they are always in sync, thinking the same thing But we know that he just sees what he wants to He’s very excited thinks this will be a great night o He wants to be chivalrous and then have se with her Seeing her as model of what a wife should be Remembers beginning of there relationship when he wrote poetry to her, and how great it was o Thought that this moment could redeem there past dullness Could be an epiphany that would change there future Get to hotel room, but she is not reacting the way he wants he to o Starting to get annoyed o He comes and kisses him and tells him that he is so generous He thinks it’s the beginning of a big night But we read it that she is feeling affection, just not an overbearing type o He thinks that of course thinks worked out the way he wanted it to “I think I know what is the matter” o she then replied in an outburst of tears, that she is thinking about the song he asks about it she replies that it reminded him of a person long ago Gabriel thinks its him But she then says it wasn’t It was a childhood boy Gabriel is now getting mad Tells him about a boy when is was younger He asks if they were in love, she doesn’t reply He also has a new theory that she wants to see this boy from the west, on vacation with the women who invited them to the west Misreads her every time She replied that he had died Gabriel asked what was he, he wants to feel better about himself He finds out that he was low class, this makes him feel even worse His whole ego deflates, feels like he is the lowest of the low Asks if they were in love She replies that they were in love in the time He asked what he died from She said he died from me Tells him the story, of how he ran to her house in the rain, got sick, and died Gabirel realized how little he knows about her, that a person from the lower class could have more of a hold on his wife then he can, she will never love him like she loved him He will never have it without risk, without the snow Image of death – big abstract issue, if I don’t risk ill be safe – the other guy risked and died Realizes that he cant escape it, he will die anyways, he is not above it all o Central real epiphany o Pitied her for the first time Starts to think about all the things he got wrong in his life o His awareness of death is overwhelming here Realized he is missing everything in fear of time Thinks its better to live like the other boy then like him o Generous tears filled his eyes Generous is a new type of emotion of Gabriel Doesn’t feel His identity changed It then begins to snow again o It is also a symbol of mutuality We are all the same – the snow touches everyone, it is absurd to think we are all different o It is time to go on a westward journey – to run back towards life It fell on him and where Michael Furey lay buried Connects the living and the dead o It is everywhere o English- 2nd 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Poems Through Elizabethan period, through the Jacobean period, then the puritan and ending in the restoration period Shakespeare All poetry has to do with the issue of time o Parts of life o How to make life meaningful Shakespeare sonnet o Sonnet 14 lines distinct meter and rhyme scheme three types Elizibithin (or Shakespearian) sonnet rhyme scheme o 1st with 3rd, 2nd with 4th …. And 13th and 14th rhyme (a couplet) o ABABCDCDEFEFGG o Each four lines are a quatrain Three of these and one couplet Sonnet Iambic pentameter Iam – two syllables next to each other o First is unstressed, second is stressed Five Iams in a row (10 syllables) 2 Still speaking to the young man Speaker things time is your enemy First quatrain o A1- in forty winters you will grow old Winters are depressing (negative vision of time) o B1- Your forehead is now like a field that is fresh and new, but time will dig holes in your face o A2- the clothing (the superficial) that you look so good now o B2- will eventually be tattered and worth little Time destroys clothes, fashion goes out of style Fresh new self, is constantly falling apart Economic terms used o Summation of first quatrain You will be old, what is beautiful will be ugly, time will take away what you believe is important Second quatrain o C1- where is your beauty now o D1- where are all the treasures of your youth Treasure – finical term o C2- if you answer by saying your beauty is in your eyes o D2- that would be a shame and an empty praise All eating – you will have eaten all your beauty, would have consumed all of your beauty, the praise you would be giving yourself is worthless Had the potential to create treasure (finical term) instead you are left with something valueless quatrain (solution) E1- you have potential F1- if you have a child it would be realized E2- you would make a profit out of your life Third o o o o F2- prove your beauty through your children Couplet o G1- if you do this when your old o G2- you can still see the beauty in your child In these first two sonnets the older person is telling the younger person that he is special and he should get married and have children and leave something behind o Second sonnet much more aggressive Time is an enemy Sonnet 18 You have to do something to defeat time Even as we lose our beauty we must recreate something of equal or greater value, in that way we as a group defeat times power Thinking about time and his diminishing time and he is worried that something that he found beautiful and meaningful to persist Same older guy to same younger boy Later in the series of speeches Often misunderstood of love sonnet o Since he compliments Same sequence of advice giving o Responsibility, children, death, art, beauty This one seems a lot more positive then the first two that we did o Ends with a positive statement First quatrain o A1- Can I compare you to something beautiful? o B1- You are more beautiful and more consistent You don’t change you keep your beauty o A2- Sometimes its too windy o B2- Summer is short Second quatrain o C1- Sometimes the sun is too hot But you are always perfect o D1- Sometimes its cloudy But not you o C2- If it is a perfect day we know it will pass o D2- Sometimes by chance, sometimes since nature demands it We cant control nature, but you are controlled Third quatrain o E1- But you are eternal, you will not fade o F1- Your fairness does not decline, you keep it always o E2- Death will not be able to brag that he has you o F2- When you have lines on your face you will still be beautiful Could be generational lines, family tree Could be writing Couplet o G1- As long as there are people alive who are breathing and seeing o G2- So long lives this and this gives life to you This could be a child (would make sense with generational line) This could also be the poem or his writing. It could be saying, I cant depend on you, instead of having a child we can keep beauty alive by writing great poetry We will defeat time and death through poetry Ends with life, not death, promise, not failure, statement of satisfaction, sense of possibility 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Terms Simile o Comparison using as or like o Explicit comparison Metaphor o Comparison that is implicit o Doesn’t use as or like Personification o Giving human characteristics to something that is inanimate object, or an abstract idea (love, death…) Apostrophe o Something spoken to someone who is not present at the location Synecdoche/Metonymy o A part of something representing the whole Symbol o Something that stands in for something else o Invented and inherited Invented – invented just for that particular poem Inherited – know from hundreds of years of culture Allegory o A story that stands for something else (symbolic) Paradox o A statement that sounds that it contradicts itself but is true Understatement (Meiosis/Litosis) o Minimize the emotional context of a particular statement o Can be negative affirmation Irony o The opposite o Three types Situational Expect one thing to happen but the opposite occurs Verbal Say something but mean the opposite Dramatic Reader knows more then the character In a poem Poem means more then the speaker thinks he is saying Allusion o A reference to something else Tone o Attitude the poem takes Rhythm o The sounds that the poem makes, created by meter Meter o Alteration of stressed and unstressed syllables Hyperbole o Exaggeration, overstatement Alliteration & consonance o Repetition of vowels or consonant sounds Sonnet o Three types Shakespearian Petracarcan Spenserian Shakespearean o 3 quatrains, 1 couplet o ABABCDCDEFEFGG Petrarchan o Octave followed by a sestet (8 lines followed by 6) o ABBAABBA / ABABABAB followed by CDECDE / CDCDCD o Name after petrach Spenserian o Three qatrains then a couplet o ABABAB BCBC CDCD EE Interlocking rhyme o Name after spenser Octaves o Eight lines Sestets o Six lines Quatrains o Four lines Tercets o Line of three Couplets o Line of two Volta o The space in between the 8 and 6 (octave and sestet) o Means torn o The point at which the meaning of the poem ships Stress o If stressed put a “/” emphasis o If unstressed put a sortive “u” Scansion o The action of figuring out what I stressed and what is not o Note stresses and unstressed Iamb o [u /] o two syllable unit, has an unstressed syllable followed by a stressed one Trochee o (/ u) o stressed syllable followed by an unstressed syllable Anapest o [ uu /] o two unstressed syllables followed by one stressed syllable Dactyle o [// u] o two stressed syllables followed by one unstressed syllable Spondee o [ // ] o two stressed syllables in a row Iambic Pentameter o o o o Most famous type of meter Used by Shakespeare Five units of iambic meter in a row [u/u/u/u/u/] Poems done by classmates 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Whoso List to Hunt Sir Thomas Wyatt took place in the renaissance About a man o He says who ever wants to find a girl (deer), I know where to find one o He isn’t trying anymore since the chase has made him tired o This dear cant be caught since she is of royal class o Whoever tries to chase her is just wasting there time o She seems like she cant be caught but she cant allow herself o o o o to be Could be autobigoraphal ABBAABBACDECDE Petrarchian sonnet Some deer’s in that time were not allowed to be hunted since they belonged to great powers The reader may interpret it to be about a women Why is there a relationship between a hunter and a animal? It says something about his feelings of relationship Not an equal relationship Man gets to own the women But this women was already hunted by a greater hunter o The author thinks a deer is a compliment, they are hunting because they love the deer Deer vs. dear o Last two lines are said by her (the deer) Interprations o Love poem about Anne Bleyn o About a hunting trip o Don’t prey on the unattainable Life doesn’t work that way, you can only get so much with what you have The higher people in society will always win There is always someone who has more power then you Everyone is controlled by someone else, we are all at some level powerless o Recognize the limits of your own power Like a huntsman By Edmond Spencer This poem is part of a greater cycle of sonnets describing his relationship with this Elizabeth Boyle o They are called Amoretti (little love songs) sonnets He used three quatrains and then a couplet o His rhyming scheme is different then Shakespearian ABAB BCBC CDCD EE – Spenserian or interlocking Poem – could be a love poem o The Huntsman is tired after a futile chase o He sits down to rest with his dogs who are also tired o After a long time with futile efforts o The gentle deer came back since it was thirsty and wanted to drink Could be saying his love is coming back becomes he know wants him o Now it is calmer. It didn’t want to run, it was fearless o But when I took its hand it then wanted to run o But now the dear wants to be here o Even though she was wild, in the end she wanted to be there Lesson o Sit back and wait for them to come to you – play hard to get Or he also may think he’s playing hard to get, but he actually tricked himself o Could be saying a relationship has to be with equals Which is strange in the male centric society the author lived in o Relax, don’t be overly crazy Dramatic irony o The speaker thinks in the end he won her o But the poem suggests that she decided she wanted you, she did it her way, you wouldn’t have won anything. She will have the power She is the hunter, he is the hunted But he thinks he is the hunter – irony Sonnet XXXIX By Sir Philip Sidney Astrophel and Stella Shakesperanian sonnet o ABAB ABAB CDCD EE Poem o Bind peace and sleep o Controls intelligence and it sooths anguish o It gives relief from the poor and prisoners o It doesn’t care about your social hierarchy Personification – sleep with indifferent judge o Protects you from sorrow and pain o The speaker feels pain with life Despair (capitol D), shows human aspect of his pain o Sleep settles internal conflicts Civil war alludes to inner conflict o How grateful he is to sleep o o o o o o I’ve says he would help sleep by having nice pillows and bed He wants a quiet dark room that is sound proof Sleep will relieve him and be like a beautiful garden And if these great things Are not good enough for you In sleep you’ll see stellas image Stella is the person who the sonnets are talking about, she is supposed to be Penelope who he lived This person is desperate for sleep since he cant stop thinking about the person he loves He wants to sleep since He may get what he cant have Or hell stop thinking about her If you (sleep) let me sleep you too can see Stella Holy sonnet 10: Batter my heart By John Donne o English poet First half of career wrote love poems, second half religious Used everyday objects as metaphors (often using science) Caused controversy Conceit Type of metaphor that compares two things that seem to be very different from each other Written in Jacobian age (after Elizabethan era) Era know for Metaphysical poets o Use humor paradoxes and abstract reasoning to explore the nature of reality o o o o More humor, discussion of issues that weren’t discussed before, investigating the nature of the world (why are we here, what should we believe in, why do I have fate, life after death, how to live life…) Will use every area of life as part of their poems Mathematics, sciences, objects, bodies… Poem part of series of sonnets o Petrarchian form Octave (8) the nsestet (6) o Rhyme scheme ABBA ABBA CDCD EE o Main idea is that the scientific revolution should not be the focus, rather religion should How to fit fate with science Says religion should come first Written to god says we should return to the old testament where god is harsher and punishes these types of people, unlike the kinder god in the new testament o about desperation, being desperate for something you want but cant push yourself to do Poem o Asks holy trinity to force religion back onto him Three person god is the holy trinity Metaphysical aspect – god beat me up… o Stop doing nothing and start acting Says three things, parallel to trinity Tells god that he is being too easy on them o Wants god to hurt him so he can go to heaven o Be harsher Three things, parallel trinity Like a glass maker (break, blow, burn) Force me to go back to you o He is like a captured town that belongs to someone else The devil took the town but it should be gods o The speaker is trying to let god into his heart but he is unsuccessful since the devil is there Town – heart o god you should defend me acting childish o my reason is leading me to doubt you reason personified as a part of you everything he learns through reason is leading him away from god o o o o finds this odd speaker says he truly loves god and he would be happy to be loved by god but he is married to the devil ( gods enemy) betrothed – married divorce be from the devil almost sexually talking about god take me away instead of the devil if not I will never be free paradoxical o he will be pure if god rapes him typical metaphysical conceit A Valediction Forbidding Mourning By John Donne Vocab o Virtuous – righteous o Profanation - sacrilegious o Laity – ordinary people o Trepidation – fear of something to come o Sublunary – belonging to this world o Elemented – started Title o = Farewell forbidding weeping Poem o As righteous men die o His friends gather around him at his death bed and says he is about to die, some object o Lets not cry (talking to his wife) or make a big deal about it o It would be sacrilegious of our love to make a scene of our parting our relationship (us parting) is like a virtuous man parting, you don’t need to make a big deal since we know there is a happy ending o An earthquake brings harm and fear o Man think about the impact of it o But when the planets move (when the future is changed) o People don’t see it as a big deal Our parting is like the spheres, the laity are like the earthquake o Weak love between is based on sex o And absence destroys the love o But we have such a strong love o That we don’t even know why it is so great o We don’t need this physical contact o Our souls are really one o Even though I have to go o Our souls are not truly parted o Rather are souls are expanding (not diminishing it) Gold to aery thinness beat When gold is hit it becomes a thin sheet and it expands (gets longer) Metaphysical o Fine, were not one big soul, rather two o Just like the two points of a compass o Your soul is like the fixed foot (not moving) o It doesn’t move unless the other one moves as well Two souls, but two souls together Metaphysical o His wife is the foot of the compass that sits in the center o When the other foot grows farther o The center foot leans towards the other o When it comes back the center perks up o This is how you are to me, just like the center foot that leans Obliquely – leaning o Your firmness makes me be just o And come back to where I begin Image of compass is not one that you would expect for love That’s what metaphysical did How to feel that life is meaningful Image of circle also repeats a lot We don’t need to be sad, since together we are perfect Connects it to faith A person who has faith in god, will have a life that goes back to the beginning, things will work out So much faith they don’t need to cry or lament Could be read as love or discussion of belief and fate My poem Vertue by George Herbert (1593-1643) o renaissance men, end of his life he became a priest metaphysical rhyme scheme - ABABCDCDEFEFGEGE everything has its life purpose and ultimately die except for life’s virtuous Poem o Says all the great things about the day o The marriage between earth and sky o The dew will cry since the day is turning to night Personification of dew o The day has to die (when it turns to night) Everything lives for a certain amount of time o The sweet rose whose color is angry and brave (during the day) A rose dies where it lives o The rash gazer cries Oxymoron o Since the rose is in its grave o And ultimately die o Praises spring since its full of sweet days and roses Spring eventuall ends as well o A place where everything sweet is close together o Music (is also sweet) has an end o And eventually dies o Only a sweet and virtuous soul o Like wood which never dies It eventually becomes a soul, like a soul it never gives up just changes form Just as timber doesn’t dies so too a soul never goes away totally Why coal? Religious connotations – when the end of the world comes everything will turn to cold, particularly those people who sinned. This is why on Christmas if your bad you get coal, you will burn in hell for eternity The poem is discussing how everything dies o Day ends, rose dies, spring ends o This type of poem is called memento mory – remember you shall die o At some point in the future when judgment day comes everything will die except one thing, a virtuous soul which is compared to seasoned timber o When timber is put in the fire place it burns, this is when timber burns brightest How is this different then carpe diem? Philosophically the point of view is different Memento moris - remember you will die and life has meaning, season your soul so that you will ultimately be reward Carpe diem is seize the day, who cares about tomorrow Death Be Not Proud By John Donne (1572 – 1631) Petrarchian o ABBA ABBA CDDC EE The entire poem is an apostrophe (talking to anything that is not there) o He is talking to death Poem o Telling death he should not be proud even though people think you are proud People think you are scary but you really aren’t The people who you think you kill you cant You have killed many but you cant kill me and you cant die Your just like resting or sleep, which is nice and peaceful Death is pleasurable You take our best men when they are young You are a rest for them o You let their bones rest and send their soul o Death, you have no control since fate, chance, kings and o o o o o o o o o o o people who commit suicide are causes for death Poison, war, and sickness also kill people Drugs can also kill people. Drugs are betters since there is no pain or suffering Death is just a resting place before we are resurrected till the end of time (Christian…) Death shall be no more, it will die Paradox, telling death to die Death will die when everyone is resurrected since he can no longer cause death Contradicts rest of poem, death will meet this really terrible thing, death. But when humans meet death its not something to be afraid of. Metaphysical. The poem is saying everyone is scared of death, but they shouldn’t be, it’s just a resting place o Speaker is trying to relinquish fear of dying o Very human attempt to deal with grieving and loss For both us and himself o Death is seen as a person so that he isn’t so awesome, just looks scary but really isn’t He is also a person since he is ineffective, since there is eternal life o Answer to death is live a good life and do not harm to others If not religious, this doesn’t apply o An attempt to confront death with logic Very metaphysical Tells death that he hangs out with all these low life’s War, drugs, sickness… Two Daffodils By Robert Herrick o 1591-1674 o born in London, rich famiy o became a goldsmith and then a minister o poems about love is beautiful, time is short, and make the most out of life (Carpe Diem) rhyme scheme is ABCBDDCEAE FGHGIIHJFJ Poem – first stanza o (Talking to daffodils) its sad to see you o Since you die so early o You die even before the sun reached its half way point o Stay longer o Until the day o has gone by o Stay until the evening song Christian service, he was a Christian minister I want to pray together with you Second stanza – compares life to a flower o We also die after a short time o We have a short youth Spring refers to youth o We are quick to die o We will then be like you decaying o We die Our years are like your hours, we get older just like you do And go away Just like the summers rain (which barely comes) And the morning dew (which barely lasts) Do not come back Compares life to these parts of nature These things are forgotten when they are gone, like death Sadness but recognition of beauty and acceptance of death o o o o o To The o Memento mory Talks about prayer o But could also be carpe diem Grab life, since it passes Virgins, To Make Much Of Time By Robert Herrick Rhyme scheme: ABAB CDCD EFEF GHGH Tone of poem is light even though hes talking about heavy ideas Poem o Gather rosebuds while you can Rosebuds = young o But beware that time is flying o A flower which is beautiful and young Comparing a flower to a young lady o Tomorrow you will day Don’t have so much time o The sun this great thing o The higher the sun gets time is going by o Time is almost up Personification – treating the sun as a person Its one circuit, life span becomes shorter by each cycle Showing how fast life goes by, its like a day o And time is going to be up o Age is best when you are young o Since your healthier Says youthfulness is better then age People who are virgins of life should gather their rosebuds now, they shouldn’t wait. Since he can advise them on what choices to make. o Your are getting older, time is being spent o Good times will end so the best time is now Tempus fugit – time flies o Don’t be flirty, use your time wisely Don’t fool around with life o Go spend your time and be happy o If you waste your time o Then you may be forever tart You will be stuck forever, always behind schedule Carpe diem o Don’t wait till tomorrow, there may not be a tomorrowm to gather May be sexual May be about life poems done by Dr. Milowitz 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Elizabethan period 1485-1603 o includes Shakespeare, wyatt, spencer, Sydney a period of order, patterns and structure in literature Elizabeth was a strong leader, she kept things in control o Even though scientific advancements were coming and debates on religious forms, she kept the level of disquiet under control She died in 1603 and was succeeded by King James o Everything changed all the questions that were hovering in the background, came out o This period is called the Jacobean period Jacobian period 1603- 1649 Poetic world changed its focus, starts to deal with questions about life, instead of accepting the order and great chain of being o Metaphysical poets took charge during this time Civil war breaks out in Britain, between Protestant and Catholics Puritan period 1649-60 In 1649 a group of puritans (people who believed everything should revolve around our pure intents) led by Oliver Cromwell too over Started the puritan protectorate o No more king or queen o Parliamentary government England became a theocracy o Cromwell instituted a rule of law that privileged pure Christians over everyone else Theaters were closed Literature and poetry were censored Writers no longer encouraged to write with same type of freedom Very few prominent poets o But one writer who was a puritan and who managed to be a devout puritan and a genuinely great poet/writer was John Milton John Milton He is one of the truly great writers He tries to proselytize people for pertains But his work has ambiguity and questions A great intellectual When he was in his thirties he started to lose his eyesight, probably because he would read so often On His Blindness By John Milton Attempt to deal with his issue of losing his eyesight, he also connected it to a greater theological issue o Can be read literal and symbolic o Losing his eyesight makes him think about the fact that he has one great talent Puritan sonnet o A sonnet that is meant to proselytize, make a person a better puritan What makes Milton better is that his poems are open enough to speak with people who don’t share the same belief system Poem o When I think about that I will not be able to see anymore o Before half my days are over in this world The world is becoming darker and unclear Question is what is he going to do now that this world has changed o My one talent (writing) will be dead (finished) Talking about parabola of talent One man invested his money Another hid it, didn’t lose any Master yelled at second, talents are meant to be invested used Wondering how he will serve god without this talent Could be read egoistically o I still have the talent but it is now useless Just like his eyes are there but not functioning, he cant write even though he has the same talent Even though I lost my talent I still want to serve him, to do something, that is as important to him as my poetry Otherwise I will be yelled at by god If god yells at me I will be in the position of the Israelites an illusion to the bible, Pharaoh told Israelites to build without giving them the necessary resources I ask but Patience will tell me fondly – angry but still love him o o o o Patience (capitol P) – personification, patience is a person who will give him the answer o He says “ god liked your gift but he doesn’t need it” Patience is chastising the speaker, aren’t you a little bit too prideful, your thinking about your own stature, its your vanity that makes you think this is bad o Either mans work or his gifts, who best: o Those people who go about their burdens that god gives them, those are the people who serve him best god has angels working for him that are a lot better then you (don’t think you’re the one person who can serve him best) o The angels can fly do anything o Don’t just wait passively, wait actively o Paradise Lost 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM John Miltons most famous poem is called Paradise Lost] Takes place in Eden Deals with Adam and Eve getting kicked out, it also shows how satan decided to rebel against god and to eventually take his anger out on Adam and Eve Milton wants to make this as beautiful as it can possibly, since he can make the story as understandable to the common man It’s a long poem – 12 books o We are doing part of first book introduction This story will be about the first time man disobeyed god and the result, which brought death into this world This will be fixed when Jesus returns again Sing heavenly muses o Uses form of epic poem, Odysseus… to tell this Christian story o god is the muse in this story Says that he wants this poem to go above the story of the greek god’s o this epic will be the first true epic, since it is a true story, the story may be showing his pride says that man does not need a middle man between him and god god gave life to earth – sitting on abyss and made it pregnant o Alludes to another pregnancy, Mary Let me see what I cant see – talking about blindness Ultimate goal in poem is to justify the way of god to men The primary topic of this story is to see the cause for Adam and Eves fall The snake first seduced them Or maybe we should start with why Satan rebelled against god in the first place o There wasn’t always a satan, there was heaven and god and Lucifer, and Lucifer decided that he didn’t like being beneath god, so he got a group and rebelled against god. Since they lost god took them all and thrust them into hell. That’s where the story begins Our story begins with satan sitting in hell tied up in unbreakable chains o It starts off in hell since satan is the main character Satan was beaten and confused o Milton may have been drawn to satan since he sees the issue of going from one way of life to another Satan is an a unique position since he is both beaten and destroyed but also immortal – paradoxical His doom may him angrier o Has not given into to defeat He is tormented by this (in presence tense) o Going into his mind o His memory is a terrible thing. Remembers heaven. He has not given up hate o Really believes in his cause o This admirable but also a flaw Describes hell with a fire that burns but does give light (oxymoron) o Gives off its negative characteristics – heat, but not the positive ones – light o Darkness visible – oxymoron Hell is unnatural Opposite of everything else that is normal o Only woe no peace o Torture o Locate hell physically Three times as far from earth as heaven is In Satan’s mind, feel pain o “O” (line 75) feel his pain gets his name when he was sent to hell o his name was Lucifer but since he needed to change his name, he became satan he thinks since he can determine who they are (by choosing his name) hell isn’t as bad as heaven, where people have no choice o same thing happened with Beelzebub looks around and says we looked so beautiful but now we are bound up in these chains and disgusting I never realized how powerful god was o god owes me for showing these other angels how powerful he is o But I will not beg god for forgiveness, I still believe in my cause and I will not repent His cause is that he thinks god is a dictator and he would be a better leader All my soldiers and I shook gods thrown We can continue to do this even in hell Gives his soldiers a pep talk o We will never stop fighting and we may win in the very end o Skip 125-156 Continue speech to Beelzebub o Our job for eternity is to not do good Strangely phrased, instead of saying do bad ,he is saying we are just doing the opposite of what He (god) defines as good (thinks it is evil) o We will be like a constant thorn undermining him o Then he says maybe god isn’t so strong, he cant put up with us, that is why he sent us here, and why he needs guards o We have an opportunity here, our chains have disappeared, lets go start planning our new world o Skip 103-109 Believes he has free will since G-d is leaving him alone, o Dramatic irony –(211-212) but we know now that he doesn’t really have free will, since G-d made him do this since G-d wanted him there 214-242 Satans speech o Is this were will shall spend eternity? o We accept this and we our happy, since if god is in charge then the farthest away from him, is the best place to be. o With the right perspective we can turn heaven to hell and hell to heaven We have the power to change our perception o It doesn’t matter where I am since I am the same person o Here we are at least free (which is more important then comfort) o “Here we may reign secure, and in my choice / To reign is worth Ambition, though in Hell: / Better to reign in Hell then serve in Heaven.” (261-4) the reader and milton both identify themselves with satan this creates a healthy confusion even though satan is eloquent he is wrong, since no one is free this poem shows us how we are like satan, since we too have desires for individuality and power his argument is compelling, which allows different readers to attain different experiences some become better, other agree with satan 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM The puritan period ends in 1660 and the restoration period begins monarchy is restored puritans disbanded new attitude in England, an attitude of great celebration (the puritan period had been very oppressive) this period had happy, optimistic and humorous writing o downside – superficial world, people were very materialistic parody and satire o satire – criticism often in humorous fashion about society Purpose of change o Parody – being presented as something that seems like the thing itself but is in fact an exaggerated imitation No purposes Two great writers – o Jonathan Swift who wrote a Modest Proposal o Alexander Pope who wrote the Rape of the Lock Epic poem Not a real epic, a mock epic, uses epic form (rhyming couplet) to tell a superficial tragedy Central event (superficial tragedy) is the cutting off a lock of hair In a world were appearance is everything, cutting someone’s hair is considered a terrible tragedy The subject matter gives us a sense of a parody The Rape of the Lock Begins near the Thames river (which is personified, as a prideful river), takes place at Hampton court, which is where the queen and parliament would go to do work during the summer time or vacation o Here they plan wars as well as the doom of beautiful women at home Funny since they care equally about these two o Call the queen by her first name, which shows some sign of familiarity o Zeugma – poetic device that uses one verb to describe two different actions Take counsel – take advice Take tea – drink year Satirical since the queen has equal regard for her council as she does for her tea Criticism Most of the time is spent talking about parties and not serious things o Since this is a satire it is not mean spirited, rather it wants change but loves the very thing that its talking about o Some people care about the queens gory while other people cares about materialism People are constantly degrading everyone, killing each others reputation through words o A world of scandal and gossip The judges don’t care about the truth, rather they just want things to be timely Everyone spends too much time in the bathroom every night o Getting ready to go out at night We are introduced to Belinda who’s hair will be cut off o She wants to meet two knights, so that they can play cards o She’s prideful and takes this context very seriously In a world were big things don’t matter, people care about these little things o Sylphs – tiny fairies that try to help Belinda The fact that these gods are so small, tells us that it’s a diminished world Ariel is the chief sylph o The game is compared to a war Velvet plain o (skip to last paragraph 404) o The card game goes on Only Belinda and the baron are left It looks like Belinda will lose but things change and Belinda wins But people are most vulnerable when they are on the top o The game is over and they are having tea and cookies Feeling of celebration o Clarissa, an old and ugly women is introduced She is the villain Most old women have knowledge and experience o Clarissa takes out scissors and gives them to the baron Clarissa could be jealous of Belinda looks If Belinda loses some of her looks, she will feel that the whole world is falling apart o The baron is about to cut her hair, but the sylphs try to stop the scissor They try to get her attention, but are unable to At just thus moment, Ariel (chief sylph) goes into Belinda mind, and sees Belinda thinking of her love This image may show us that she wants to lose her virginity, and Ariel realizes he cant protect her, from something she wants o Her hair is cut o Belinda realized what happened, and she screams Women cry when; husbands die, dogs die, china breaks o The Baron rejoices over his conquest Does this story have a more meaningful point? What does Belinda gain from losing this hair? o There is more to life, Clarisse wants Belinda to learn this. She wants Belinda to gain pride, and thoughtfulness Restoration needs to give up superficiality to embrace something that has more structure 6/13/2009 10:09:00 PM Four periods Elizabethan 1485-1603 o Respect for order o Great chain of being o Sonnet Sidney Spencer Wyatt Shakespeare Know 1564-1616 o Know what a sonnet is, and the different possibly rhyme schemes, may have to figure that out Jacobean 1603-1648 o Questions about religion and faith came to the service o Metaphysical Donne Marvell Herbert Herrick o Know what metaphysical poetry is, difference between this and Elizabethan - conceit Puritan 1649- 1660 o Cromwell is very restrictive and close minded Milton Restoration 1660 - onward o Satire and parody Satire – criticism Parody – imitation o Mock epic poem – imitation epic, satirize society and epic form Pope Format Section on quotes o Given part of poem Must identify by name of poem, poet, period, speaker and who he is speaking to, significance of quote to entire poem Short answers – fill ins o Identifying terms May be an unseen