“Hear” We Go Again “Hear” We Go Again Adapted from “OPPS” written by Louisiana State University Overview Brain-based strategies engages the student in making connections between waves and sound. The concepts of pitch, frequency, sound travel through different materials are developed through interactive models, appropriate visual representations, and alternative assessment. The real world application of music is highlighted throughout the learning series. National Science Education Standards: As a result of activities in grades k-4, all students should develop Content Standard A: Science as Inquiry Abilities necessary to do scientific inquiry - asking simple questions about objects, organisms and events in the environment, plan and conduct investigations using simple equipment and tools to collect data and extend senses, use data to give an explanation to observations, and communicate their ideas and results to others. Content Standard B: Physical Science Give students a chance to increase their understanding of the characteristics of objects and materials that they encounter daily. Through the observation, manipulation, and classification of common objects children will develop the understanding that sound is produced by vibrating objects. The pitch of the sound can be varied by changing the rate of vibration. Louisiana Benchmarks/GLE# Science as Inquiry 1. 2. 3. Ask questions about objects and events in the environment Pose questions that can be answered by using students’ own observations, scientific knowledge, and testable scientific investigations Use observations to design and conduct simple investigations or experiments to answer testable questions 4. Predict and anticipate possible outcomes 5. Identify variables to ensure that only one experimental variable is tested at a time. 6. Use a variety of methods and materials and multiple trials to investigate ideas (observe, measure, accurately record data) 7. Use five senses to describe observations 10. Express data in a variety of ways by constructing illustrations, graphs, charts, tables, concept maps, and oral and written explanations as appropriate 12. Use a variety of appropriate formats to describe procedures and to express ideas about demonstrations or experiments (e.g., drawings, journals, reports, presentations, exhibitions, portfolios) 13. Identify and use appropriate safety procedures and equipment when conducting investigations (e.g., gloves, goggles, hair ties) 15. Distinguish between what is known and what is unknown in scientific investigations 18. Base explanations and logical inferences on scientific knowledge, observations, and scientific evidence. 21. Use evidence from previous investigations to ask additional questions and to initiate further explorations Physical Science 3rd Grade 27. Use the words high/low to compare the pitch of sound and the words loud/soft to compare the volume (amplitude) of sound 4th Grade 28. Explain the relationship between volume (amplitude) of sound and energy required to produce the sound 29. Compare the rates at which sound travels through solids, liquids, and gases 30. Explain the relationship between frequency (rate of vibration) and pitch Making Sound Students Explore How Sound is Produced Getting Started: 1. Organize material so the each cooperative group will be given a variety of items to explore. 2. Based on student needs and previous experience, plan effectively in order to provide the adequate time needed 3. Copy student sheets. 4. Obtain materials for group presentation. 5. Practice with your own set of items in order to be familiar with the student results and experience. Materials (per group) Rubber bands of different sizes strung over a shoe box or tacked to a piece of cardboard Balloon stretched over a tin can Rice or beads placed into a film canister or baby food jar Plastic bottles of different sizes (test tubes, pipes of different sizes may also be used) ** If time is limited you can give each group a different item to explore and report their observations to the group. Materials for demonstrations: **See “visual vibrations” demonstrations handout for list of materials Procedure: 1. Assemble students in cooperative groups. 2. Cooperative groups will complete “Making Sound” probe. Have each group briefly share their answers. Do not discuss the answers with them at this point; the groups will come back to the probe and re-evaluate their answers. 3. Inform groups that they will be engaged in an exploration to determine how sound is made. Point out that each group will have a specific set of materials to work from but each group is to come up with as many different observations as they can, recording each in learning logs with a description of the process. 4. Have materials manager collect materials and challenge groups to explore as instructed. 5. Following the exploration: have groups share findings, creating a master list on the board, overhead, or newsprint based on group discussion. 6. Perform “visual vibration” demonstrations as part of the concept development process. ** Do at least two of the demonstrations 7. Revisit the “Making Sound” Probe and have students re-evaluate their answers and make corrections as needed. Have each group discuss any changes they have made to their answers based on their new knowledge. Safety Notes: Make sure to instruct students on expected behavior before starting the exploration. You may want to tape the rubber bands to the box to prevent rubber bands being used as a weapon. Make sure the film canisters are sealed tightly (may want to glue top to bottom) to prevent a mess with the rice. Use caution when using electrical equipment. If students blow across the pipes or bottles, wash pipes with alcohol or a solution of 2 tsp. of Clorox per gallon of water. Making Sound Probe Purpose: The purpose of this assessment probe is to elicit students’ ideas about sound production. The task specifically probes to determine whether students recognize that sounds result from vibrations produced by an object or by objects or materials in contact with the object listed. Explanation Sound is a form of energy caused by back-and-forth vibrations. All the objects on the list involve the production of sound as a result of vibration of the object itself or the material it comes in contract with, such as air. Some vibrations are obvious, such as watching the strings plucked on a guitar. Other vibrations are so small that you can’t see them. Some vibrations that cannot be seen can be felt. For example, when you put your fingers over your vocal cords, you can feel the vibrations created when you speak. The loudness of a sound depends on the size of vibrations. The size of vibrations is called their amplitude. Increasing or decreasing the amplitude changes the loudness of a sound. Leaves rustling in a gentle wind create sound with a low amplitude of vibrations, whereas a blaring radio speaker creates sound with a high amplitude. Vibrations also affect the pitch of a sound. Pitch describes how high or low the notes are that are produced by the vibrations of the object. Pitch is affected by changing the frequency of the vibrations-how quickly or slowly the object vibrates. The more vibrations that occur per second, the higher the frequency and the higher the pitch of the sound. Elementary Instruction By the end of the elementary grades, most students have had opportunities to learn about sound and how sound is made. Early ideas about sound are connected to position and motion of objects. Teaching and learning about sound is primarily observational and includes having students identify different types of sound and their sources, observe vibration of sound-making objects, and relate loudness and pitch to different types of sound production. The emphasis at this developmental stage is on the objects, even though in some cases it is the air that is in contact with the object that is the source of vibration. Because the notion of vibrating air is a more abstract idea at the elementary level and not directly observable, the national standards focus on vibrating objects at the elementary level. Ideas about vibration and pitch are gradelevel expectations described in the national standards. Students at this level often learn about sound through the context of musical instruments. As a results students may become contextbound in their understanding of how sound is produced and may fail to generalize across different examples. Making Sound (Student Sheet) Directions: All of the objects listed below make sounds. Put an X next to the objects you thing involve vibrations in producing sound. ___ guitar strings ____ clapped hands ___ singer ____ snapped fingers ___ drum ____ flute ___ barking dog ____ piano ___ popped balloon ____ crumpled paper Explain your thinking: What “rule” did you used to decide which objects involve vibrations in producing sound? ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ Making Sound Student Sheet Using the objects on your tray, make as many different sounds as possible. Write your observations of what you do to the instrument, what sound you hear and what you see the object doing Making Sound Student Sheet Using the objects on your tray, make as many different sounds as possible. Write your observations of what you do to the instrument, what sound you hear and what you see the object doing “Visual Vibrations” Demonstrations It is often difficult to see that an object or material that is making a sound is vibrating. The following demonstrations, all of which are suitable to use with children, make these vibrations visible. These observations can also be used to demonstrate that vibrations move through air and the concept of frequency of vibrations. Bubble Machine Materials: 4 straws, string, liquid detergent, 1 Tsp glycerin, pie pan Make bubble solution in the pie pan by mixing four parts water to one part liquid detergent. Add 1 Tsp. glycerin to bubble solution. Make a bubble blowing frame by running a long string of about 4 straw lengths through 4 straws and tying the ends of the string together. Dip the frame into the frame into the bubble solution until a soap film forms. Hold the frame so the soap film hangs vertically just in front of the loudspeaker of a radio that is playing loud music. You can also create a variety of sounds (from the “Making Sound” probe) behind the film bubble. Observation: What happens to the film bubble when sound is produced? Dancing Beads Materials: Radio with exposed speakers, tiny plastic beads, small bits of Styrofoam or grains of rice Lay radio down so that the speaker faces upward. Turn the radio on. Put a few beads (or grains) on the speaker. If possible, change the treble/bass setting (more bass the better the beads will vibrate.) Observation: What are the beads (grains) doing when sound is produced? Layer Pen Vibrations Materials: Laser pen ( or flashlight with a narrow beam), Large tin can with ends removed and taped for safety, small mirror, balloon, masking tape, radio Place a tightly stretched rubber balloon around one end of the tin can and secure it with tape. Attach a small mirror to the middle of the balloon on the outside of the can. Aim the laser pin at the mirror and have it reflect on a screen, ceiling, or white board. You may need to attach the pin or flashlight to an object to keep it stationary. Have someone talk into the open end of the can or aim the radio loud speakers (with good bass) toward the open end of the tin can. Observation: What happens to the light dot as sound is produced? Water Waves Materials: pie pan, water, tuning fork Fill the pie pan ½ full of water. Strike the tuning fork and place the tip of the fork in the water. Observations: What did the tuning forks vibration do to the water? Making Music Students Explore Relationships between frequency/pitch and sound/amplitude Getting Started: 1. Cut wire coat hangers to get a long strip of wire. 2. Make copies of student handouts. Materials: Metal rod Procedure: 1. Review terms: frequency, pitch, amplitude, and loudness 2. Demonstrate how to make the metal rod vibrate. 3. Let the students explore the relationships. 4. Discuss the relationships between frequency/pitch and amplitude/loudness Safety Note: Make sure to tape one end of the metal rod to prevent injury to the students hands. Teacher Note: It would be a good idea to mark the areas on the metal rod with tape that well get the best results to prevent confusion. Frequency/Pitch and Sound and Amplitude Relationships (Student Sheet) A. Frequency/Pitch 1. Place metal rod so that about 5 cm of it extend over the edge of a table. 2. Place your hand over the part of the rod lying on the table. (Push it tight against the table) 3. Pluck the rod to make it vibrate. 4. Listen carefully to the sound generated and watch the vibration of the steel rod. 5. Now extend the rod outward. 6. Pluck the rod again and listen carefully to the sound generated and watch the vibration of the steel rod. 7. Extend the rod outward several times listening carefully to the sound generated. Questions: 1. How did the rods vibration (frequency) change as the rod became longer? 2. How did the Pitch (high and low) change as the rod became longer? 3. What relationship is there between the pitch (high or low)of sound and frequency (the vibration of an object)? B. Amplitude/sound 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Place metal rod so that about 5 cm of it extend over the edge of a table. Place your hand over the part of the rod lying on the table.(Push it tight against the table) Pluck the rod and release the rod to make it vibrate. Listen carefully to the sound generated. Now pluck the rod harder and carefully listen to the sound. Questions: 1. When you plucked the rod harder how did the sound change? 2. Which rod took more energy to pluck? 3. Based on question 2, which wave had more amplitude the first wave or second wave produced? 4. What is the relationship between the amplitude and the loudness of a sound produced? Speed of Sound in a solid, liquid and Gas Purpose: These activities allow students to determine what types of matter sound can travel through. Once students understand that sound can travel through solids, liquids, and gas they can compare the speed of sound in these types of matter. Getting Started: 1. Fill bags with sand, water, and air. 2. Copy student handouts. Materials: ** each group will get a bag of sand, water, and air Sand Water Air Zip lock bags Procedure: 1. Give students the three bags. Allow them to determine if sound can travel through the different states of matter. 2. Discuss what the students observed. 3. Let the students graph the data for the speed of sound and determine how the speed changes in different media. 4. Discuss the students’ results. Teachers notes: Make sure to remove the air from the sand and water bags to prevent confusion. If you are to make a premade graph for the students to paste into their journals, let the students label their own axis to practice determining independent and dependent variables. Sound in a Solid, Liquid and Gas (Student Sheet) Problem: Can Sound travel through a solid, liquid, and gas? Hypothesis: Write your prediction. Procedure: 1. Hold the bag of sand (Solid) up to your ear. 2. Carefully put your finger in the other ear to block all other sound. 3. Have a partner lightly flick the bag that is held up to your ear. 4. Write your observations of the sound you hear or write no sound if you did not hear any sound. 5. Repeat with the bag of water (liquid) and air (gas). Conclusion: I know that sound can travel through _________because___________. Speed of Sound (student sheet) Problem: Does sound travel faster in a solid, liquid, or gas? Hypothesis: Write your prediction. Use the data below to draw a graph. Below each type of material write whether it is a solid, liquid, or gas. Type of material State of matter Speed of Sound (m/s) Water Air ( 20o C) Steel Helium Gas Glass Alcohol Liquid Gas Solid Gas Solid Liquid 1,437 343 5,000 927 5,640 1,143 Questions: 1. Which state of matter does sound travel through the fastest? 2. Which state of matter does sound travel through the slowest? Music Sticks Experiencing a Real World Application of Concepts Learned Getting Started: 1. Cut the 7 ft ½”PCV Pipe according to the chart below. Note C D E F G A Bb C Length(cm) 32.8 29.2 26.0 24.6 21.9 19.5 18.6 16.4 Frequency(Hz) 262 294 330 349 392 440 466 524 Color yellow Green Blue Purple Brown Red Orange yellow 2. Sand the ends to make them straight, write the corresponding note and draw a corresponding color line on each pipe. 3. Determine the concepts that will be developed or reviewed while using the music sticks. 4. Make transparencies or handouts of music to be played. Materials Per Cooperative Group: 4 music sticks of different lengths Learning logs (optional) Graphing paper Procedure: 1. Give student graphing paper or a pre printed graphing paper. Instruct the students to make a Length Vs. Frequency graph. Have them write the relationship between the length of the stick and the frequency of vibration it produces. Discuss. 2. Give each group 4 music sticks of different lengths. 3. Instruct students on the proper way to play the sticks. 4. Have the groups predict the order of pitch sound from lowest pitch to highest pitch based on the information from the graph. 5. Students can test their hypothesis by playing their music sticks. Extension: Have students play songs with their music sticks. Discuss how music notes are used to correspond with different pitch sounds. Safety Notes: Un-sanded ends of the tubes tend to hurt the palms of the hands. Younger children might have a tendency to swing (and hit) others with these lightweight batons. If students blow across the pipes, wash pipes with alcohol or a solution of 2 tsp. of Clorox per gallon of water. Teacher Notes: The source of any sound is a vibrating object. Almost any object can vibrate and thus be a source of sound. In a PVC pipe, the source (air) is set into vibration by hitting the end of the pipe with the palm of the hand. Once disturbed, air within the tube vibrates creating a certain frequency corresponding to the wavelength of the standing wave. A long wavelength has a low the frequency creating a low pitch. Music Sticks Student Sheet 1. Use the data below in the data table to make a line graph in your journal. How does length of a music stick change the frequency of the vibrating air in the stick? Length(cm) Frequency(Hz) 33 262 29 294 26 330 25 349 22 392 20 440 19 466 16 524 2. Write in your learning log the answer to the following question: How Does length of a music stick change the frequency of the vibrating air in the stick? 3. In your learning logs, predict the order of the sticks: Start with the stick with the lowest pitch and end with the stick with the highest pitch. (You can use the color on the music stick to write your order.) 4. Check to see if your prediction is supported by playing your music sticks. How does the length of a music stick change the frequency of the vibrating air in the stick? Frequency (Hz) 550 525 500 475 450 425 400 375 350 325 300 275 250 225 200 175 150 125 100 75 50 25 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 Length of Music Stick (cm) Background Information What is Sound? Sound and music are parts of our everyday sensory experience. Just as humans have eyes for the detection of light and color, so we are equipped with ears for the detection of sound. We seldom take the time to ponder the characteristics and behaviors of sound and the mechanisms by which sounds are produced, travels, and detected. The basis for an understanding of sound, music and hearing is the physics of waves. Sound is a wave which results from the back and forth vibration of the particles of the medium through which the sound wave is moving. If a sound wave is moving from left to right through air, then particles of air will be displaced both rightward and leftward as the energy of the sound wave passes through it. The motion of the particles are parallel to the direction of the energy transport. This is what characterizes sound waves in air as longitudinal waves. Sound waves require a Medium Another characteristic of sound is that all sound waves require a medium. Sound waves need particles to vibrate to travel and be detected. Most of the sounds that you hear travel through air at least part of the time. But sound waves can also travel through other materials, such as water, glass, and metal. Properties of Sound Imagine you are swimming in a neighborhood pool. You hear many different sounds as you float on the water. Some are high, like the laughter of small children, and some are low like the voices of men. Some sounds are loud, like the BOING of the diving board, and some are soft, like the sound of water lapping on the sides of the pool. The differences between the soundshow high or low and how loud and soft they are—depend on the properties of the sound waves. The speed of Sound A sound wave is a disturbance which travels through a medium by means of particle-to-particle interaction. As one particle becomes disturbed, it exerts a force on the next adjacent particle, thus disturbing that particle from rest and transporting the energy through the medium. Like any wave, the speed of a sound wave refers to how fast the disturbance is passed from particle to particle. Since the speed of a wave is defined as the distance which a point on a wave (such as a compression or a rarefaction) travels per unit of time, it is often expressed in units of meters/second (abbreviated m/s). In equation form, this is speed = distance/time The faster a sound wave travels, the more distance it will cover in the same period of time. If a sound wave is observed to travel a distance of 700 meters in 2 seconds, then the speed of the wave would be 350 m/s. A slower wave would cover less distance - perhaps 660 meters - in the same time period of 2 seconds and thus have a speed of 330 m/s. Faster waves cover more distance in the same period of time. The phase of matter has a tremendous impact on the speed at which sound travels. In general, solids have the strongest interactions between particles, followed by liquids and then gases. For this reason, longitudinal sound waves travel faster in solids than they do in liquids than they do in gases. vsolids > vliquids > vgases The density of a medium also influences the speed of sound waves. The greater the density of individual particles of the medium, the less responsive they will be to the interactions between neighboring particles and the slower that the wave will be. As stated above, sound waves travel faster in solids than they do in liquids than they do in gases. However, within a single phase of matter, the property of density tends to be the property which has a greatest impact upon the speed of sound. A sound wave will travel faster in a less dense material than a more dense material. Thus, a sound wave will travel nearly three times faster in Helium as it will in air. This is mostly due to the lower mass of Helium particles as compared to air particles. The temperature of a medium will also influence the speed of sound. In general, the cooler the medium, the slower the speed of sound. This happens because particles in cool materials move slower than particles in warmer materials. When the particles move slower, they transmit energy more slowly. Therefore sound travels more slowly in cold air than in hot air. Pitch and Frequency A sound wave, like any other wave, is introduced into a medium by a vibrating object. The vibrating object is the source of the disturbance which moves through the medium. The vibrating object which creates the disturbance could be the vocal chords of a person, the vibrating string and sound board of a guitar or violin, the vibrating tines of a tuning fork, or the vibrating diaphragm of a radio speaker. Regardless of what vibrating object is creating the sound wave, the particles of the medium through which the sound moves is vibrating in a back and forth motion at a given frequency. The frequency of a wave refers to how often the particles of the medium vibrate when a wave passes through the medium. The frequency of a wave is measured as the number of complete back-and-forth vibrations of a particle of the medium per unit of time. If a particle of air undergoes 1000 vibrations in 2 seconds, then the frequency of the wave would be 500 vibrations per second. A commonly used unit for frequency is the Hertz (Hz), where 1 Hertz = 1 vibration/second As sound wave moves through a medium, each particle of the medium vibrates at the same frequency. This is sensible since each particle vibrates due to the motion of its nearest neighbor. The first particle of the medium begins vibrating, at say 500 Hz, and begins to set the second particle into vibrational motion at the same frequency of 500 Hz. The process continues throughout the medium; each particle vibrates at eh same frequency. And of course the frequency at which each particle vibrates is the same as the frequency of the original source of the sound wave. Subsequently, a guitar string vibrating at 500 Hz will set the air particles in the room vibrating at the same frequency of 500 Hz which carries a sound signal to the ear of the listener which is detected as a 500 Hz sound wave. The ears of a human (and other animals) are sensitive detectors capable of detecting the fluctuations in air pressure which impinge upon the eardrum. It is sufficient to say that the human ear is capable of detecting sound waves with a wide range of frequencies, ranging between approximately 20 Hz to 20 000 Hz. Any sound with a frequency below the audible range of hearing (i.e., less than 20 Hz) is known as an infrasound and any sound with a frequency above the audible range of hearing (i.e., more than 20 000 Hz) is known as an ultrasound. Humans are not alone in their ability to detect a wide range of frequencies. Dogs can detect frequencies as low as approximately 50 Hz and as high as 45 000 Hz. Cats can detect frequencies as low as approximately 45 Hz and as high as 85 000 Hz. Bats, being nocturnal creature, must rely on sound echolocation for navigation and hunting. Bats can detect frequencies as high as 120 000 Hz. Dolphins can detect frequencies as high as 200 000 Hz. While dogs, cats, bats, and dolphins have an unusual ability to detect ultrasound, an elephant possesses the unusual ability to detect infrasound, having an audible range from approximately 5 Hz to approximately 10 000 Hz. The sensation of frequencies is commonly referred to as the pitch of a sound. A high pitch sound corresponds to a high frequency sound wave and a low pitch sound corresponds to a low frequency sound wave. Loudness Is Related to Amplitude A vibrating guitar string forces surrounding air molecules to be compressed and expanded, creating a disturbance. The disturbance then travels from particle to particle through the medium, transporting energy as it moves. The energy which is carried by the disturbance was originally transferred to the medium by the vibrating string. The amount of energy which is transferred to the medium is dependent upon the amplitude of vibrations of the guitar string. If more energy is put into the plucking of the string (that is, more work is done to displace the string a greater amount from its rest position), then the string vibrates with a greater amplitude. The greater amplitude of vibration of the guitar string thus imparts more energy to the medium, causing air particles to be displaced a greater distance from their rest position. Subsequently, the amplitude of vibration of the particles of the medium is increased, corresponding to an increased amount of energy being carried by the particles. Another example is beating of a drum. If you gently tap a bass drum, you will hear a soft rumbling. But if you strike the drum with a large force, you will hear a loud BOOM. By changing the force you use to strike the drum, you change the amount of energy transferred to the drum. The drum moves with a larger vibration and transfers more energy to the surrounding air. This increase in energy causes air particles to vibrate farther from their rest positions (increase in amplitude). The amount of energy which is transported past a given area of the medium per unit of time is known as the intensity of the sound wave. The greater the amplitude of vibrations of the particles of the medium, the greater the rate at which energy is transported through it, and the more intense that the sound wave is. While the intensity of a sound is a very objective quantity which can be measured with sensitive instrumentation, the loudness of a sound is more of a subjective response which will vary with a number of factors. The same sound will not be perceived to have the same loudness to all individuals. Age is one factor which effects the human ear's response to a sound. Quite obviously, your grandparents do not hear like they used to. The same intensity sound would not be perceived to have the same loudness to them as it would to you. Despite the distinction between intensity and loudness, it is safe to state that the more intense sounds will be perceived to be the loudest sounds. Doppler Effect The Doppler effect is a phenomenon observed whenever the source of waves is moving with respect to an observer. The Doppler effect can be described as the effect produced by a moving source of waves in which there is an apparent upward shift in frequency for the observer and the source are approaching and an apparent downward shift in frequency when the observer and the source is receding. The Doppler effect can be observed to occur with all types of waves - most notably water waves, sound waves, and light waves We are most familiar with the Doppler effect because of our experiences with sound waves. Perhaps you recall an instance in which a police car or emergency vehicle was traveling towards you on the highway. As the car approached with its siren blasting, the pitch of the siren sound (a measure of the siren's frequency) was high; and then suddenly after the car passed by, the pitch of the siren sound was low. That was the Doppler effect - a shift in the apparent frequency for a sound wave produced by a moving source. The Doppler effect is observed because the distance between the source of sound and the observer is changing. If the source and the observer are approaching, then the distance is decreasing and if the source and the observer are receding, then the distance is increasing. The source of sound always emits the same frequency. Therefore, for the same period of time, the same number of waves must fit between the source and the observer. If the distance is large, then the waves can be spread apart; but if the distance is small, the waves must be compressed into the smaller distance. For these reasons, if the source is moving towards the observer, the observer perceives sound waves reaching him or her at a more frequent rate (high pitch). And if the source is moving away from the observer, the observer perceives sound waves reaching him or her at a less frequent rate (low pitch). It is important to note that the effect does not result because of an actual change in the frequency of the source. The source puts out the same frequency; the observer only perceives a different frequency because of the relative motion between them.