The Meiji Restoration (1868-1912) was a revolutionary period in Japanese history. With the return of political power to the emperor, Japan was thrust into the modern world in an attempt to avoid Western dominance which was already the fate of China, the Dutch East Indies and the Indian subcontinent. 1868 marked the beginning of a deliberate transformation by Japan and its new leaders in response to the threat posed by the West. Western technology and foreign expertise were imported; modern communications such as the railway and telegraph were established; strategic industries were developed for the purpose of defence; and taxation was reformed to sponsor industry and promote enterprise. By the turn of the twentieth century, Japan had almost achieved a level of economic growth eqnal to that of the Western powers. Along with the success of the Restoration years, Japan adopted excessive Westcmisation. Western ideas, fashion and food dominated the early part of the period. The status of Japanese women, however, did not improve. Under the Meiji Constitution of 1889, they were not accorded with political rights and continned to playa snbordinate role to men. The Meiji Restoration saw Japan's involvement in two snccessfnl wars against China and Russia. With its reputation growing on the world stage, Japan formed an alliance with Britain in 1902 and annexed Korea in 1910. In a period of less than fifty years, Japan was able to retain its independence and find 'a place among the aggressors instead of among the victims of aggression'. responsible for creating the new goverument and initiated many of Meiji's early reforms. The Charter Oath Emperor Meiji and the Charter Oath In April 1868, Emperor Meiji made clear his government's intention to modernise the country when he issued an Imperial Oath of Five Articles (often known in English as the Charter Oath). It became an important statement of imperial policy regarding Japanese reform. By this oath we set up as our aim the establishment of the national weal on a broad basis and the forming of a constitution and laws. The young emperor When Mutsuhito became emperor of Japan in 1867, he was only fifteen years old. In the following year, he dismissed the ruling shogun and ended more than two and a half centuries of Tokugawa rule. His uame or title~ was soon changed to Meiji (meaning 'enlightened rule') and so began a remarkable period of change which historians generally refer to as the Meiji Restoration. The Meiji Restoration marked the real beginning of Japan's modernisation and entry into the international world. It should not be assumed, however, that absolute power was transferred to the emperor. After all, he was still very young and in the early part of his reign Nijo Nariyuki served as regent (seesho). The driving force behind the economic, social and political changes of the Meiji Restoration were the Article 1 Deliberative assemblies shall be widely established and all matters decided by public discussion. Article 2 All classes, bigh and low, shall unite in vigorously can-ying out the administration of affairs of state. Article 3 The common people, no less than the civil and military officials, shall each be allowed to pursue his own calling so that there be no discontent. Article 4 Evil customs of the past shall be broken off and everything based upon the just laws of Nature. Article 5 Knowledge shall be sought throughout the world so as to strengthen the foundations of imperial rule. The fifth article of the Charter Oath was perhaps the most important for Japan as it promoted a new policy of young samurai from the Satsuma, Chashu, Hizen and Tosa clans who had helped defeat the shogun and restore the emperor to power. They were largely Ii. ~2 ')~l~ 't Figure 9.1 An illustration of brick and stone shops on GinzaAvenue, Tokyo, during the Mei;i Restoration I 1I early Meiji government for a number of years, although the Constitution of 1868, having been hastily prepared, proved unworkable and was later abandoned. The end of feudalism The new government's first task was to establish its power over all the 260 feudal domains (han). Some of them had become almost independent states ruled by their daimyo during the final years of the Tokugawa shogunate. Japan's leaders could not hope to create a fully centralised governmeut if they were constantly challenged by powerful lords exercising their feudnl powers. Figure 9.2 Emperor MeUi in a military uniform, adomed with medals modernisation along Western lines. Japan's new leaders realised that unless their country modernised and became strong militarily it would forever be at the mercy of Western demands. The cry of sanna joi was replaced by the ancient Chinese ideal of 'rich country; strong military' (jukoku kyo/wi). One historian later made the following observation. Defence, therefore, became the main task of the new government, while those numerous Japanese whose fear of the Western nations was mingled with admiration of their prowess overseas considered that the adoption of Western material equipment might enable Japan to find a place among the aggressors instead of among the victims of aggression. The Constitution of 1868 I i I Japan's first constitution (Seitaisho} was drawn up in June 1868 to bring the Charter Oath into effect and to define the powers of the new government and the rights of the Japanese people. Its main features were: All authority was vested in a Council of State, or the upper house of the Japanese parliament, known as the D{{jokan • Council members were not elected but chosen according to noble rank • The Deliberative Assembly, or lower house, held little power and was called the Giseikan Assembly members were elected from each clan, city and prefecture of Japan. Only qualified men could hold a seat in the Giseikon. Ruling Japan in the emperor's name, members of the Choshu, Satsuma, Hizen and Tosa clans dominated the The new government was already in control of those han whose military strength had brought about the Meiji Restoration. Having persuaded their own daimyo to give up their feudal rights, the new leaders set about destroying the feudal powers of the rest of the daimyo. On 25 July 1869, Emperor Meiji issued an imperial decree which forced all daimyo to surrender their lands (fiefs) and the powers that went with them. The court nobles [kuge] and the feudal lords [shako] are given the same rank, and are to be called kazoku. Those who have not yet given up their fiefs are to be compelled to hand back their registers. The feudal lords are created chiha'1ji [governors of the han]. Two years later, the process was complete. On 29 August 1871, the fonnerterritories of the shogun were divided into a new system of districts or prefectures known as ken. With Tokyo the new imperial capital, central government had become a political reality in Meiji Japan. ofApril 1868 (Document follov.·inE to be pointing Rrnn,errlr Meiji and his Building a modern economy 1868-85 In 1868, Japan was anon-industrialised country, Three quarters of the workforce was employed in agriculture or farming and related handicrafts (such as cotton and raw silk) produced nearly 65 per cent of the national income, Most industries still used traditional methods of production with very little emphasis on manufacturing even in large scale enterprises let alone factories. As the old financial and administrative system associated with feudalism disappeared, the great effort to catch up with the West began. Shokusan [(oygo Industria,lisation became a key aim of the Meiji period. Between 1868 and 1881, the foundations of modern industry were laid in Japan. Central to this development was the government policy of sponsoring industry and promoting enterprise known as shokusan koygo. It became a major cornerstone of the restoration program and gave Japan a new economic outlook. This in turn encouraged economic freedom at the expense of the old feudal restraints that had prevailed in Tokugawa Japan. The importance of strategic industries The Meiji leaders realised that if Japan was to become a 'rich country:_ with a 'strong military' it must develop strategic industries on which modern military power depended:"'heavy industry, engineering, mining and shipbuilding. This had begun before the end of the shogunate. Western military industries were first introduced into Japan by some of the stronger clans for defence purposes. Tbe Hizen clan built the first successful reverberatory furnace in 1850 and began producing iron guns in considerable number after 1852. The shogunate soon followed suit. By 1865 it had two modern shipyards in operation at Nagasaki and Yokosuka. With the fall of the shogun, the Meiji government gave priority to developing defence 'industries which could withstand the Western menace. Foreign instructors were employed to give technical training to Japanese workers in munitions plants and shipyards. Various institutions were created for training in the manufacture of guns. Engineering, technical and naval schools were also founded using foreign instructors while the best Japanese students were often sent abroad to master the techniques required in these key industries. Mining was developed on the same lines. The Meiji government took over all of the mines formerly operated by the Bakufu and employed the best foreign experts to increase mineral production. By the end of the Meiji period, Japan ranked as one of the world's largest producers of coal and exporters of copper. Early financial problems With the defeat of the shogun, the Meiji government faced a number of financial problems. The cost involved in crushing the clans hostile to the imperial regime had led to heavy public spending at a time when revenue was very difficult to obtain. In 1868, national government expenditure amounted to thirty million yen while the rnoneygained from land taxes and other sources of income was only three million. This imbalance had a severe effect on the economy, Inflation ran high, internal revenue dropped and the CUlTency lay in a state of chaos as there was no one standard by which to trade. One historian made the following comment. The currency situation was indeed alarming; the monetary circulation comprised not merely of new issues of inconvertible notes, but also gold and silver coins in .varying degrees of value-an inheritance of the shogunate-and about 1500 varieties of clan notes. In order to overcome the early financial problems of the Meiji period, the yen was officially adopted as the basic unit of currency in 1871. In that year, the government suspended the exchange of clan notes or paper money that had been issued by the daimyo ever since the late sixteenth century. By 1879, the replacement of clan notes had been completed. Banking The new land tax At the end of the Tokugawa period, Japan had a higher level of potential savings than most under-developed countries in Asia today. However, it lacked a modern bauking system to collect its untapped wealth and make it available for investment on a large scale. In 1872, the American system of national banking was taken as tbe model for Japan and four national banks were established under pressure from tbe government. By 1875, all were in serious financial trouble due largely to poor management, lack of co-operation and failure to compete with foreign banks and local institutions. In 1882, a centralised, European-style system of banking took the place of the earlier American system. In that year, the Bank of Japan, the nation's first central bank, was formed. It controlled the nation's banking system as a whole and encouraged the development of specialised banks to finance industry, agriculture and foreign trade. The most important of these was the Yokohama Specie Bank which wasfounded in 1880. In 1873, the government needed to reform taxation in order to ease the burden of heavy public spending on new capital for industry. A land tax was introduced. Farmers had to pay 3 per cent of their annual crop to the government. The land tax became Japan's largest source of revenue during the Meiji period and financed its transition to a modern economy. But, although reduced to 2.5 per cent of the annual crop in ] 876, it remained a heavy burden on Japan's farmers. Figure 10,1 Tokyo railway station in 1872 The land tax as a source of Japanese revenue, 1868-97 Years 1868-81 1890 1897 Land tax as a percentage of ordinary revenue 78% 50% 30% Figure 10.2 Thefirst Japanese steam train, built in 1895 Modern communications The Meiji Restoration brought ecouomic changes to Japan quite quickly. The most visible were modern communications such as the telegraph and railway. In 1872, the first railway line was laid between Tokyo and Yokohama, and within a short time was carrying almost 2 million people a year. A similar liue was built from Kobe to Osaka in 1874 and later extended to Kyoto in 1877. Telegraph lines, which were cheaper to construct and operated at first only within Japan, linked all the major Japanese cities by 1880. The rise of the Zaibatsu In the early years of the Restoration, the Meiji government was the key player in Japan's industrial modernisation. Using foreign instructors, it established the major mines, factories and shipyards. But by the 1880s it needed a new direction to ensure continued economic growth. On 5 November 1880, it published the Regulations on the Transfer of Factories, abandoning the policy of government control of industry. The government began selling off certain industries to private companies, often on very generous telIDS. These favoured companies grew into large business combines called Zaibatsu. Some of the outstauding names among the Zaibat~u . included Mitsui, '{asuda, Furukawa, Kawasaki, Mitsubishi and Sumitomo. Although not all industries were sold off to private interests, the Zaibatsu provided a strong financial base for industry and promoted rapid economic growth when it was most neede? Activities 1 Refer to the illustration of Tokyo railway station .in 1872 and answer the following questions. a What type of scene is depicted? b To What e)<.tent had Japan modernised by 1872?Give examples. C Why (.10 you think this illustration was produced? 2 Why do you think the creation of Japan's first ~team train in 1895 was a major achievement of th~Meiji Restoration? Japan1s cultural revolution The world in thc late nineteenth century was dominated by Western countries such as Britain, France, Germany and the United States of America. Many in Japan felt that in order to be accepted as equals it was necessary to adopt not only Western science and technology, but all aspects of Western culture. During the first two decades of the Meiji Restoration, a fascination for all things Western pervaded society. 'Civilisation and enlightenment' (bummei leailea) became the popular catch-cry as Western liberlli thought was introduccd into Japan in a very short space of time. Many Japauese writers and intellectu~lsrejected their traditional institutions and the learning that underlay them for the path of 'universlli progress' that the West seemed to represent. Fuknzawa Yukichi, perhaps the most a The Japanese living in towns and cities were keen to adopt Western ideas and fashions. Food, clothing and education changed in the attempt to imitate all aspects of Western culture. But Westernisation brought problems for the samurai. . Problems with the sarrru.rai The changes of the Meiji period dramatically affected the lives of the samurai~ as thegovernlIlel1tst~a<iilY removed the privileges they enjoyed. influential writer of the period, was critical of his country's achievements when compared to the West. He believed that Japau could only become strong if it had a revolution in values and ideas. If we compare the knowledge of;the Japanese and the Westerners ... there is not one thing in which we excel ... Who could compare our carts with their locomotives, our swords with their pistols? ... We think that our country is the most sacred, divine 1869 The old feudal hierarchy wasr~pl~ce~ with new social classes. Court officials and daimyo became nobles (kdzdkLt). Samurai were classed as landowners (shizoku) or soldiers (sotsuzoku), and all the remaining classes, inc1udingollfeasts, were gronped together as commoners 1871 The government made the wearing of swords optional and allowed men t6 cut off their topknots. Many samurai refused to do this. Conscription was ir,trodw,ed year-old cOllSCriplts army for three was clear being taken over bYG~~;;;ri;~ed ";."""C.~ In March, the Hatori Ediictjprohibited wearing of swords ceremonial occasions. Saigo Takamori, the ll1.UUm,y Satsuma forces overthrow the 8"i)!?','" 30 000 ex-"amurai government bitter fighting, defeat, and his wuuwc» pelislled hands of the ®l)§rilli anIly. This became kJ"ovvn Rebellion. (heime11). 1872 1876 1877 land; they travel about the world, opening lands and establishiug couutries ... All that Japau has to be prond of ... is its scenery. Fashion and food Under the Tokugawas, the dress of the social classes was strictly ruled. While the upper classes could wear sillcs Figure 11,1 The enlightened, half-enlightened and unenlightened Japanese man Figure 11.2 A scene in a Japanese classroom after the turn of the century and satins, peasants were limited to hemp and cotton. This changed in 1872. The Meiji government decided that Western dress should be woru for all court aud official ceremonies. Later, the cutaway or 'morning coat' (moningu) became the standard dress for formal occasions. Westem-style haircuts became a major symbol of Westeruisation in Japan and as early as 1870 had largely replaced the traditional samurai topknot. Meat eating was encouraged at the expense of traditional Buddhist beliefs wbich considered it immoral. The beef dishes, Sukiyaki and Teriyaki, proved most popular. Bread, beer and dairy products also appeared. Ballroom dancing emerged as a particularly popular pastime in the early Meiji period. An elaborate, twostorey social halI in Tokyo, calIed the Rokumeiken opened in 1883 to hold dances every Sunday night for wealthy husiness people, politicians and foreign diplomats. Its closure in 1889 marked the end of the Japanese craze for Westernisation, as many came to favour a 'return to being Japanese'. Changes in education The Meiji government believed that a modetnised society needed an organised system of education. Under the Tokugawas, ordinary people were taught reading, writing and the abacus (a device of beads strung ou rods used for calculating) in terakoya-smalI makeshift classrooms in people's houses. In 1868 there were nearly 13 000 terakoya in Japan with a total of 837 000 students. Education under Emperor Meiji owed much of its rapid progress to the traditional terakoya system. In 1871, a Ministry of Education Was established to provide education to alI people, regardless of their social class or gender. In 1872, it was decreed that all Japanese children must have at least four years of primary schooling. By 1910, 98 per cent of Japanese students were receiving compulsory education. As schools spread across the country, Japan's first tertiary institution, Tokyo University, was founded in 1877. Nine years later, it was reorganised into a genuine multi-faculty university and became the principal training centre for future government leaders. Other universities were later established in Kyoto (1897), Fukuoka (l9lO) and Sapporo (1918). The Rescript on Education In 1890, Emperor Meiji introduced his famous, 'Rescript on Education', which stressed the importance of harmony and loyalty to the throne. It was given great reverence throughout the land and a copy was display~d in every school and read aloud on special days. The 'Rescript on Education' formed the basis of Japan's philosophy on education until 1945. Part of it read as folIows. , Ye, our subjects, be filial to your parents, affectionate to your brothers and sisters; as husbands and wives be harmonious, as friends true ... pursue leaming and cultivate arts, and thereby develop your intellectual faculties and perfect your moral powers ... always respect the Constitution and observe the laws ... and thus guard and maintain the prosperity of Our Imperial throne. Activities 1 'Y!'ydid Fu1cazawa Yukichi helieve that Japan needed a revolution in values and ideas (Document A)? 2 Study Figure 11.1 and explain how the artist saw the major differences hetween the enlightened, half-enlightened and unenlightened Japanese manofthe Mdji Restoration? 3 What do you uotice about the photograph of a Jap,mese classroom in the early twentieth century (Figure I I.2)? What evidence is there to suggest (hallapan's system of compulsory education had been a success? Consisting mainly of ex-samurai and commoners (heimin), The Freedom and People's Rights Movement demanded a popular assembly or government so that decisions would retlect the will of the people and thus preserve national unity. Itagaki later reorganised this movement into a major political party which took the new name of Liberal Party (Ii)'uta). Ito Hirobumi and the Constitution of 1889 Towards the end of the nineteenth century, it was widely believed that constitutions (systems of fundamental laws and principles of a government) provided the unity that gave Western powers their strength. The Japanese leaders were keen to set up a system of constitutional governrnent Problems with the Constitution of 1868 Under Japan's first constitution kno\Vn;asth" Seitaisho or the 'Constitution of 1868' the Dajdkan, a Grand Council of State consisting ofseyen departments, held all political power. Althoughtlie Dajokan was effective in the early years of rapid economic and social change, it was opposed by different groups because it failed to deal with two basic problems: it did not provide Japan with a modern constitution and a national parliament· that would earn Western respect and popular support. The Freedom and People's Rights Movement During the Restoration, a small group of men known as oligarchs, ruled Japan in the name of Emperor Meiji. These men tolerated little opposition until a number of them left the government over the question of invading Korea (Seikanron) in 1873. This division promoted an important.de~()SFaJis movement which was led by Itagaki Taisuke and called The Freedom and People's Rights Movement (Ii)'u Minken Undo). Towards a new constitution By 1875, the oligarchs recognised the problems with Japan's first constitution in the Osaka Agreement. It called for the creation of a constitutional government in gradual stages and a new body of officials called the Senate (Genroin) was appointed by the emperor to draft a second constitution. Between 1876 and 1878, the Senate prepared four draft constitutions which were too liberal for the powerful oligarchs such as 1wakura Tomomi and Okubo Toshimichi. As a result, Iwakura asked the chief members of the oligarchy to submit their own views on constitutional government in 1879. All complied with fairly cautious statements, except Okuma Shigenobu, who astounded his colleagues with the radical nature of his proposal. He suggested that elections be called immediately and that Japan adopt the full parliamentary system of Britain. As a result, Okuma was forced out of the government, although the constitution movement continued. ln 1881, Emperor Meiji promised the Japanese people that a new parliament would be convened in 1890. We therefore hereby declare that We shall in the 23rd y£ar oLMeiji,. establish a Parliament in order to carry into full effect the determination We have announced, and We charge' Ourfaithful subjects bearing Our commissions to make, in mean time, all necessary preparations to that end. Ito Hiroburni, an ex-samurai who had worked to restore the emperor to power and who was a member of the new government, was the architect of Japan's second constitution, The Constitution of the Empire of Japan (Dai Nilum Teikoku Kempa).' Ito and the Prussian model The son of a peasant farmer, Ito was born in Choshll province in 1841. His long political career spanned nearly the entire Meiji period from his involvement in the struggle to overthrow the Tokugawa shogunate to his assassination by a Korean nationalist in Manchuria in 1909. Apart from becoming prime minister on four occasions, Ito's greatest achievement remains the creation of the Constitution of the Empire of Japan , between 1881 and 1889. When Okuma left the government in 1881, Ito moved into a position of unchallenged power, having favoured a gradualist approach in drawing up a second constitution. Determined to base it on the best possible practices of the West, adapted to Japan's special needs, Ito and his colleagues travelled to Europe on a study mission in 1882. On their return in August 1883, Ito decided that a constitutional system that operated under alLabs61ute monarch or emperor was best suited to Japan. The model he adopted was based on the Prussian (German) parliamentary system. Meanwhile, Okuma and his followers, who opposed all constitutional models except the BI'itish, founded a political party called the Progressive Party (Rikken Kaishinto) in an attempt to influence political decisions. Divided into factions, the Progressive Party soon fell apart and Okuma had little choice b)"t to return to the government. In February 1888, he was appointed Foreign Minister of Japan. ~- Figure 12.1 The opening afthefirst session afthe Japanese Die! in the presence ofEmperor Mei;t, 1890 The Meiji Constitution Under Ito's direction, a German, Hermann Roesler, helped to complete the new constitution. On 11 February 1889, Emperor Meiji handed down, as a gift, the written constitution to Prime Minister Count Kuroda. The main points of the constitution were; • The emperor was the absolute ruler or head of state. He was sacred and inviolable and had complete control of the armed forces and the nation's foreign policy. The emperor could dissolve the parliament (known as tbe Diet), create his own legislation, or veto (dismiss) any legislation which carne from the Diet itself. • Individual ministers who belonged to the cabinet (the decision making body of the ruling government) were responsible to the emperor, and not to the Diet. The Diet was comprised of two Houses (a bicameral system): - the House of Peers was the upper house of • The House of Representatives was not a truly representative body for two reasons: - Japanese women could neither vote nor become political representatives of the Diet at this time. - About only 1 per cent of the population had the right to vote due to tax qualifications. Although it appeared that the emperor had far reaching powers under the new constitution, he remained essentially a symbol or figurehead of the nation. The powelful group of oligarchs (genm) often acted in his name. Ito was among these and it is not surprising that there was no mention of their powers in the Constitution of 1889. parliament and acted as a 'House of Review'. Its members were largely former daimyo who were given life appointments. - The House ofRepresentatives was the lower house of parliament which consisted of a group of 300 men who were elected every four years. the he sylnhol or figurehead of In 1876, Japau forced the openi~gbfK6fea; using the same gunboat diplomacy (bullying tactics) that Perry had nsed against itself in 1853, The resulting Treaty of Kanghwa opened three Koreau ports for trade, but more importantly Japau recognised Korea as au independent state in order to detacb it from China's control, Sino-Japanese Wa'r 1 Yamagata Aritomo The Japanese army, under the leadership of Yamagata Aritomo, had decided that for its own security Japan needed some measure of control over Korea, even if it meaut war with China, In 1883 Yamagata saw conflict over Korea as inevitable and stated: ',,, the high-handed attitude of the Chinese toward Korea, which was antagonistic to the interests of Japan, showed OUT officers that a great war was to be expected sooner or later on the continent, and made them eager to acqnire knowledge, for they were as yet quite unfitted for a continental war.' Prelude to war In 1894, a rebellion against the corrupt government of the King of Korea by a popular religious group, the Tong Hak Society, broke out in southern Korea. The Tong Hak Society wished to preserve 'EasternLearning' aud to rid the country of all foreign influence, iucluding Japanese. At the king's request, Chiua aud Japan sent troops to help quash the rebellion. Japan's forces outnumbered the small body of Chinese troops. By the time they arrived in Korea, the rebellion had already been put down by loyal Korean forces. government to inten/erle were eagel' for a mi'litary ~,dlli!"U/',U, eSIJecially Korea's refusal Meiji government. Both countries refused to withdraw their troops. This led to a stalemate, until Ito Hirobumi, the Japaues~ prime minister, demanded sweeping changes to the Korean government, which China refused. On 23 July 1894, Japanese troops seized the king's palace and ordered him to declare Korea's independence from Chiua. As a captive of the Japanese, the King of Korea signed an order expelling the Chinese. Two days later a Chinese troopship, the Kowshing, was sunk by the Imperial Japanese Navy after it had attempted to bring reinforceme.TIts into Korea. A state of war now existed between China aud Japan. The Sino-Japanese War The war with China lasted less than a year and, on both land and sea, the Japanese won decisive victories. News of this success caught the world by surprise aud showed the Western powers the extent to which Japan had quickly mastered the art of modem warfare. One British lieutenant made the following evaluation. " , '% fll!2lYJ(Pili//lflfk@1j11J. ~ - 0f ,," ~~ - " I came to Japan expecting to see some miserable parody of a third-rate European soldier; instead, I find an army in every sense of the word admirably organised, splendidly equipped, thoroughly drilled, aud the strangest thing of all in an Oriental people, cheaply and honestly administered ... Timeline: Sino-Japanese War, 1894-95 1894 Events 1 August 16 September 17 September 21 November Declaration of war Quick Japanese victories at P'yongyang Chinese warships defeated Yalu River Port Artbur, Manchuria falls to the Japanese 1895 Events 12 February Final collapse of Chinese fleet at Weihaiwei Treaty of Shimonoseki ends war 17 April The Japanese soldiers' loss of control at Port Arthur threatened Japan's international reputation, especially with nations such as Britain. As a result of their arWY's actions, Japanese diplomats were forced on the defensive as news of the atrocities was publicised worldwide. The Treaty ofShimonoseki On 17 April 1895, China and Japan signed the Treaty of Shimonoseki, officially ending the war. The main provisions of the treaty were: China had to recognise Korea as an independent state • the Liaotung Peninsula, Formosa (Taiwan) and the Pescadores Islands were given to Japan • 4 new Chinese ports opened to Japanese trades Japan gained most-favoured nation rights on China, a privilege long desired China had to pay an indemnity of 200 million taels. The Massacre at Port Arthur The Manchurian fortress of Port Arthur was considered oue of the strongest in Asia. Before the war, a French Admiral declared it would take a mighty force from both land and sea to break into it. His estimate was not far wrong. The Japanese siege of Port Arthur was a bloody, drawn out affair lasting nearly three months. When the fortress finally fell on 21 November 1894, total Japanese losses surprisingly amounted to no more than 300. The same could not be said for the Chinese. According to the rep~)ft of James Creelman, a Western war correspondent, Japanese soldiers, over several days, had massacred up to 60000 Chinese. The full extent of the massacre was later revealed in the diary accounts of a number of Japanese soldiers. Okabe Malao, a trooper in the Ist Division of the Japanese army, recalled the following. As we entered the town of Port Arthur, we saw the head of a Japanese soldier displayed on a wooden stake. This filled us with rage and a desire to clUsh any Chinese soldier. Anyone we saw in the town was killed. The streets were filled with corpses, so many they blocked our way. We killed people in their homes ... We shot some, hacked others ... Firing and slashing, it was unbounded joy. At this time, our artillery troops were at the rear, giving three cheers [banzai] for the emperor. Figure 13.2 'lap the Giant Killer'; a British cartoonist's view of Japan's victory in 1895 infamous Triple Intervention, Russia forced China to Russo-Japanese War 1904--1905 grant it a twenty-five year lease on the Liaotung Peninsula. In doing so, it was also given the right to connect the Chinese Eastern Railway, which ran across Manchuria to the Russian port of Vladivostok, with an extension line south to the major ports of Darren and Port Arthur. This new development, known as the South Manchmian Railway, greatly alarmed Japan. By 1900, Russia had gained considerable control over Mancl;mria through its railway concessions. However, the Russians soon felt their position in the Far East threatened by events in China. Problems in China Ever since its humiliating defeat at the hands ofJapan in 1895, China's political and economic sitnation had deteriorated and anti-foreign feeling had grown. In 1898, a few enlightened Chinese leaders had persuaded their The Triple Intervention Japan's tliumph in the Sino-Japanese War was soon soured by the way the major European powers reacted to its success. In a Triple Interventi()n ",hich shocked the Meiji government;RJIssiael1li~te~t~e diplomatic support of France andGerlIlatlyt()f()rce Japan to give up its claim on the Liaotung 1'9~il1s~Ia.. This action took place on 23 April 1895'.9111ysix days after China's signing of the Treaty of Shimonoseld. Having little choice but to comply to the collective force of three major European powers, Japan gave JIp the Liaotung PeninsJIla in exchange for an additional sum of thirty million taels. One historian later described the impact of the Triple Intervention on Japan. new emperor to adopt far-reaching reforms to prepare China to modernise and meet the challenge of the West. The so-called Hundred Days Reform was crushed by the Empres·s Dowager, Tzu Hsi, who seized power and ruled in the name of the emperor. The Boxer Rebellion The Empress Dowager decided to adopt a strong policy against foreign powers in China. She decreed that China would resist with force any future, unacceptable demands made by the West. Her actions gave rise to a widespread anti-Christian, anti-foreign revolutionary movement in the north of China known as the Boxers or Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists. The name was probably derived from their practice of body streugthening vx.~1;J;i~_~s whichresembl~dboxing. For more than two months in 1900, the Boxers lay siege to the Chinese capital, Peking. During the rebellion, regular Chinese forces were ordered to attack Manchuria. In reply, Russia sent troops stationed in Siberia to crush the Chinese. By October, they had been successful; Japan's emotions had gone full cycle: from cool determination before tak~ng on the Chinese in war; through euphoria O\~er victories Manchuria, an established province of China, was now in in all aspects of the war; to a sense of Westerners in China and on Chinese converts to humiliation that she could not withstand the pressure of the three world bullies. This led to a popular mood of determination to lie low and malce sure by preparedness that this weakness would not be manifested again. Christianity, was finally crushed by an international army that included a Japanese force. Russian designs on Manchuria Russia's designs on Manchmia would by the Japanese. In 1898, three years Russian hands. The Boxer Rebellion, which was really an attack on Anglo-Japanese Alliance Russia's advance iu the Far East worried both Britain and Japan. Less than a year after Boxer rebels had laid siege to Peking, Britain and Japan decided to renew negotiatious towards a formal alliance. Femful of Russian moves in the East and its own diplomatic isolation in the West, Britain saw the benefits of a defensive alliance with Japan. Not all Japanese leaders favoured such an alliance. Many believed an alliance with Rnssia wonld best protect Japan's interests in Korea. Aware of such views in Japan, Francis Bertie, Asian Chief of the British Foreign Office, made the following observation. Unless we attach Japan to ns by something more substantial than general expressions of goodwill, we shall run the risk of her making some arrangements which might be injnrious to our interests. Britain sncceeded. On 30 Jannary 1902, the AngloJapanese Alliance was signed. Its main features were: both countries agreed to recognise the special interests of Britain in China and of Japan in Korea each nation could take necessary measures to protect its special interests if they were threatened by the aggressive action of another power, or by disturbances within China or Korea • both countries promised to remain neutral if either became involved in a war to protect those interests • hoth agreed to aid the other if a third power entered into ky such 'wulon the enemy side • the agreement was to remain in force for five years. Russia and Japan With Blitain, the strongest power in the Far East, as an .ally, Japan was inarnuch stronger position to oppose Rnssian expansion. Most of all the Japanese leaders wanted to get Russia to recognise and respe~t its special position in Korea. One Japanese official provided the following explanation in 1871. At an Imperial Conference in 1903, Japan offered to recognise Russia's rights in Manchuria if Russia would recognise its interests in Korea. Despite lengthy negotiations, Russia wonld only partially agree to Japan's reqnest. It would not agree to Japan's proposal to use Korea for 'strategic purposes' as it might threaten Russia's exclusive line of communication, its railway from Darren and Port Arthur to Vladivostok. When Rnssia refnsed to bndge on the qnestion of Korea, the choice left open to Japan was clear. The Russo-Japanese War Japan decided to win control of Korea at all costs. Withont warning, on 8 Febrnary 1904, Japanese naval forces torpedoed the Russian naval fleet anchored at Port Arthur, causing severe damage. Two days later, war was declared. Within three months, Russian troops had been driven out of Korea. Although snffering heavy losses, the Japanese alwy pushed north into Manchuda, crossing the Yalu River and capturing Port Arthur (after a five month siege) and then the city of Mukden. At sea, the Japanese navy under Admiral Togo routed the Rnssian fleet in the Straits of Tsushima (it had just arrived after spending seven months sailing ronnd the world from the Baltic Sea in Europe). Territory gained in Japanese victories against Russian troops CHINA In naval warfare, Japan is easy for the enemy to attack but hard for ns to defend. Therefore, if we waut to preserve [our] independence permanently, we must possess territory on the continent. There are only two countries ... Japan can seize, China and Korea. Stndents with little expelience iu the world eugage in foolish talk about how harharic and nnprincipled this would be ... To strengthen Japan by war is to show loyalty to our country and to our sovereign. That should he our gniding principle. Figure 14.1 The areas offighting during Ihe Russo-Japanese War. 1904-1905 -I i Figure 14.2 The movement ofRussian troops during the Russo-Japanese War, 1904-1905 Timeline: Russo-Japanese War, 1904-1905 1904 Events 10 February May Japan declares war on Russia Japan's victory in a bloody battle on the Yaln River gave it control of all of Korea Japanese troops moved into the south of Manchnria September 1905 Events 2 Jannary General Nogi, the Japanese Army Commander, captnred Port Arthnr after a five-month siege After a two month land battle, the city of Mukden fell to the Japanese The Russian fleet was destroyed by the Japanese in the battIe of Tsushima. The Treaty of Portsmouth ended the war. March 27-28 May 5 September The Treaty ofPortsmouth The Anglo-Japanese alliance was an important milestone for Japan, but its defeat of Russia was uuprecedented. It was the first time any Asian power had beaten an established European nation. Although this was a remarkable victory, the Japanese forces had incurred serious casualties. As a result both Russia and Japan accepted the offer made by Theodore Roosevelt, President of the United States of America, to act as peacemaker. The signing of the Treaty of Portsmouth (at New Hampshire in the United States of America), on 5 September 1905, finally brought the war to an end. Its main provisions were: Russia recognised Japan's interests in Korea the lease of the Liaotung Peninsula was transferred to Japan Russia surrendered its coutrol of the South Manchurian Railway to the Japanese Japan acquired the southern half of the island of Sakhalin both nations agreed not to interfere with any decision China might malce in the fntnre to develop Manchuria. Figure 14.3 'Chincl'appears slightly in the way.' An American cartoonist's view of the Russo-Japanese War Activities 1 Using Docnment A, explain the emotional impact of the Triple Intervention on Japan, What popular mood emerged from this crisis? 2 Refer to the map of the Russo-Japauese War, 1904-1905 and answer the following questions: a Why might railways have become au importaut target during the conflict? b Suggest reasons why China may have feared a Japanese victory? 3 Examiue Figure 14,3. a Provide a brief historical backgrouud of the events shown in the cartoon. b Describe the main elements of the cartoon, including the metaphors and symbols. c Describe the overall message that the cartoonist is attempting to convey. d What is the main purpose of the cartoon? Is it biased, accurate or effective? This attitude did little to provide a clear impression of Japanese progress during the Meiji Restoration. In 1881 a leading English newspaper in Japan commented on this idea of progress. Effects of the Meiji Restoration Meiji imperialism The Meiji Restoration marked a major turning point in Japanese history. Japan expanded from a closed feudal state into an empire reaching into East Asia. By 1910, Japan had acquired Formosa (Taiwan) as a colony, obtained extensive· economiccpntrol in southern Manchuria, won the southern half of the island of Sakhaliu and annexed Korea. This rapid expansion provided the security for Japaritti pteseIye its independence aud meet the challenge oftheWest.. By the time of Emperor Meiji'sdeath 1 Japan had strengthened itself through war and 11 1,,12, industry, becoming a modern nation and an imperialist power. -Differing views Not everyone was enthused by the neW possibilities. The yatoi, foreign experts, who came to supervise factories and mines and train Japanese techniciaris, often complained ahout their existence, mainly because they could not or would not try to understand the ways of the Japanese, so different from their own. One histo~ian commented on these attitudes~ Under the unequal treaties and extraterritoriality, wherebyeach foreign subject was governed by his own consulate and was outside the laws of Japan, they tried to exploit their privileges aud regarded their Japanese hosts as merely an awkward set of people with customs that did not conform to their own ideas of 'civilisation', but had to be tolerated because they were a means to riches for themselves. Jap,m for many of them was like a gold-mine. They had to go down into the darkness, remain there for a period, and having grabbed their nuggets, escape back from whence they came. Wealthy we do not think [Japan] will ever become: the advantages conferred by nature, with the exception of climate, and the love of indolence and pleasure of the people themselves, forbid it. The Japanese are a happy race, and being content with little, are not likely to achieve much. At the outbreak of the Russo-Japanese War, a more realistic appraisal of Japan was voiced. Noting the failure of the West to take Japan seriously, the London Times wrote the following on 11 February 1904. The story of the last ten days must have fallen upon the western world with the rapidity of a tropical thunderstorm ... That is the trouhle at the root of the present situation-the past inability of the West to take Japan seriously ... All this is due to the superficial study of Japan which has characterised Western contact with it. We as a nation alone appear to have formed a shrewder estimate ... But for the rest, they ... thought of the nation as a people of pretty dolls dressed in flowered silks and dwelling in paper houses of the capacity of matchboxes. In less than fifty years, Japan had changed from a feudal society to become a world power that could hold a major industrial exhibition in London and defeat an estabiished European power in a full-scale modern war. This was a unique achievement. The plight ofJapanese women Improving the status of women was not one the reforms of the Meiji Restoration. Social customs, economic realities and political and legal systems combined to prevent women from asserting themselves, compelling them to playa subordinate role to men. Fukuzawa Yukichi, an advocate of liberal reform, wrote about the status of women. I l At home she has no personll1property, outside the house she has no status. The house she lives in belongs to male members of the household, and the children sne rears belong to her husbaud. She has no property, no rights, and no children. It is as if she is a parasite in a male household. In 1889, mauy women hoped that they would be given political rights under the new constitution (Dai Nihon Teikoku Kempa). This was not to be. In fact the political situation for women grew more restrictive as the following chart shows. 1882 1889 1898 The Meiji government forbade women from making political speeches. Women were banned from participating in any political activities, even listening to political speeches. The Civil Code gave the head of the extended Japanese family absolute authority. He now had the right to control family property, fix the place of residence of every member of the household and approve or disapprove offarnily marriages and divorces. Wives could not undertake legal action aud under one provision were considered to have the same rights as cripples and disabled At the turn of the twentieth century, Singapore replaced Hong Kong as the centre of brothel prostitution in South East Asia. Japanese prostitutes, brought to Singapore to sustain its sexual economy, soon re31ised that pride or family shame would preveut them ever returning home. Thousauds of Japauese girls, bought or abducted from their parents by procurers (zeegen), found themselves trapped into working in foreign brothels by the threat of violence and the obligation of debts. In his study of prostitution in Singapore between 1870 aud 1940 James Warren described the tragic existence of the karayuki-san (overseas prostitutes). Procurers either used force or deception to lure young ... girls away who, once in tbeir hauds, were held there by money and the brothel owner's power over them. Transported, tbey found themselves at the end of a journey to au allegedly easier way of life in the grip of the brothel-keeper, indebted and with no prospect of regaining their liberty except by repaying the sum advanced to their parents in contract. Invariably they were powerless to protest, with neither knowledge of the local language, money nor clothes, and faced with constant intimidation and encouragement from everybody . ,. to become ~n inmate. persons. The flesh trade Brothels were sanctioned by the Meiji government. Impoverished peasant families, mainly in Kyushu, were often forced to sell their daughters into a life of prostitution either in Japan, bnt more often abroad. For many women, the Restoration years· were a disappointment. Their status in society saw little change despite their contributions to the success and speed of Japan's industrial revolution. The traditional ideal of women as 'good wives and wise mothers' (ryosai kembo) was so ingrained that mauy were simply forced to submit and endure. Activities Figure 15.1 Two karayuki-san posing for the camera in Singapore after the tum of the centwT 1 What do Documents A and B reveal about Western attitudes to Japan during the first two decades of the Meiji Restoration? 2 What effect did Japau's victory in the Russo~Japanese War of 1904-1905 have on Western opinion? Refer to Document C. 3 What restrictions were placed on women during the Meiji Restoration? How did this affect their status in Japanese society?