BUSINESS CASE: BLOW BACK TANK PRODUCTION FACILITY FOR: THE COUNTY OF NEWELL #4 June 5, 2008 Prepared by: Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd 1455 Toshack Road West St. Paul, MB, R4A 8A6 outlook@outlookmarketresearch.com DISCLAIMER: This study was produced with information that was considered factual and dependable at the time of formulation. However, the oil industry is evolving at a rapid pace and is somewhat unpredictable. Therefore, those considering an investment in the energy industry should consider the information contained herein as a general example and must conduct further in depth research into the potential viability of oil and gas enterprises. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Situation Analysis 4 1.1 Introduction: The Opportunity 1.1.1 Unconventional Gas 4 4 1.1.2 The Fracturing (Fracing) Process 7 1.1.3 9 Blow Back Tanks 1.2 Current Situation and Environmental Analysis 10 1.2.1 Environmental Scan 10 1.2.2 Political Environment 11 1.2.3 Economic Environment 11 1.2.4 Social Environment 13 1.2.5 Technology 14 1.2.6 Labour Relations 15 1.3 Project Partners 2. Operation Analysis 15 16 2.1 Location 16 2.2 Plant 16 2.3 Process 16 2.4 Transportation 16 2.5 Personnel 16 2.6 Management 17 2.7 Business Administration 17 2.8 Regulatory 17 3. Marketing Analysis 18 3.1 Market Research 18 3.2 Marketing Strategy 18 3.2.1 Target Market 18 3.2.2 Sustainable Competitive Advantage 19 3.3 Marketing Plan COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 19 2 4. Financial Analysis 20 4.1 Estimate Capital Costs 20 4.2 Estimated Operating Revenues & Expenses 20 4.21 Assessing Demand 20 4.211 County of Newell Demand 21 4.212 Alberta Demand 21 4.213 Saskatchewan Demand 22 4.214 U.S. Demand 22 4.215 Rental Revenues 23 4.216 Existing Supply 23 4.217 Overall Trends 23 4.22 Revenue Estimation 24 4.23 Financial Projections 25 4.3 Estimated ROI 26 4.4 Break Even Analysis 26 .5. Conclusion 27 Appendix 1: Blowback Tank Drawings 28 COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 3 1. SITUATION ANALYSIS 1.1 INTRODUCTION: THE OPPORTUNITY This first section outlines the nature of the challenge in extracting natural gas in some areas, the fracing process that is used to help with the extraction, and how blowback tanks fit into the fracing process. 1.1.1 Unconventional Gas (Low Deliverability and Low Pressure Gas Resources) Canada has large deposits of natural gas in the subject categories that are ordinarily difficult and expensive to produce. These are located in low permeability complex reservoirs and coal deposits. However, through the development of new technologies and efficient management policies, the feasibility and economics of producing these resources have improved substantially. As a result, large volumes of natural gas can be produced more economically. The techniques used include: • • • • • • • Low cost drilling methods such as coiled tubing drilling Under-balanced drilling Efficient well stimulation methods including acid and fracture treatments Drilling multiple wells from single drilling sites Drilling wells that allow simultaneous production from multiple, vertically stacked reservoirs Developing low cost gathering and compression systems Achieving economies of scale by drilling large numbers of wells and developing the supporting infrastructure in single well coordinated programs New Markets British Columbia and Saskatchewan are on the verge of a huge oil and natural gas exploration boom as companies pour hundreds of millions of dollars into land rights. Alberta, during its 2004-06 boom years, saw billions of dollars flood into the provincial treasury, peaking in 2006 with a stunning $3.4-billion paid to scoop up fast-disappearing exploration territory, especially in the oil sands. And now, there are new prospects in neighbouring provinces. B.C. achieved $152-million from its latest sale of exploration rights. Buoyed by high natural gas prices and big exploration prospects, energy companies are rushing to stake a claim in the province's northeast. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 4 In February 2008 Saskatchewan took in $197-million in a single sale of exploration rights, by far its biggest-ever sale – and almost as much as it previously generated in an entire year. Stoked by $100-a-barrel oil, companies are in a frenzy over the Bakken play in the southeast part of the province, where interest has percolated in recent years and has now exploded. New exploration rights are closely correlated with drilling activity, which remains active in Alberta but is poised to notably broaden beyond the province. The pace of gas well drilling is a good indicator of future gas production (because of the time lag of bringing new wells into production and attaching them to the pipeline grid). In January 2008, 1,346 gas wells were drilled, a 21% decrease from the January 2007 level.1 The Colorado shales are thought to have around 300 Tcf of gas in place. Over 50,000 wells have been drilled through the Colorado shales chasing deeper conventional gas targets. The Newell Region of Alberta contains natural gas reserves that account for approximately seventy-five percent of total area’s oil and gas production. “The Cretaceous Colorado is one of the biggest untapped unconventional gas resources in North America, which to date has had little commercial success and has been waiting for technological breakthroughs. 2 The Petroleum Services Association of Canada (PSAC) predicts that 14,500 wells will be drilled across the country in 2008. At the drilling peak - in 2005 - over 25,000 wells were drilled. PSAC predicts a 10 per cent increase in drilling in 2008 over 2007 levels for British Columbia. And the association forecasts a three per cent increase in drilling for both Saskatchewan and Manitoba. 3 New Technologies Beyond high commodity prices and strong prospects, advances in technology underpin the industry's new look at B.C. and Saskatchewan. Horizontal drilling techniques, and better fracturing of subsurface reservoirs, is helping unlock previously difficult-to-recover oil and gas. 4 Canadian gas companies have developed successful strategies for making natural gas from coal (NGC) flow economically from some of the country’s coal seams and 1 Canadian Natural Gas: Monthly Market Update – January 2008, Natural Gas Division, Petroleum Resources Branch, Energy Sector, Natural Resources Canada. 2008_1_English206OAD-19022008-6775 2 Unconventional gas explorers lay technical foundations for shale gas development across Canada. http://www.oilandgasinquirer.com/articles.asp?ID=503 3 http://www.oilandgasinquirer.com/articles.asp?ID=516 4 The Globe and Mail, Alberta's energy crown threatened, DAVID EBNER, March 27, 2008. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 5 unconventional tight reservoirs. Work is progressing to tap Canada’s shale gas resource, pegged at around 900 trillion cubic feet (Tcf). A number of companies are working to exploit thermogenic shale gas in western Canada, largely in two areas. Some are targeting deeper thermogenic shales in northern Alberta and British Columbia. Others are targeting hybrid plays in southeastern Alberta. The hot spot for thermogenic shale gas exploration right now is the Horn River Basin, 55 km northeast of Fort Nelson in northeastern B.C. Total land sales in the Horn River region have exceeded $240 million in the last two years. Because producers are still competing for land in the area, not much information has been released on the play. Northeastern B.C. is thought to have a shale gas resource of around 250 Tcf. The hot spot for biogenic shale exploration in Canada is the Colorado Cretaceous Group of shales stretching across central Alberta and Saskatchewan. Here, junior explorers Stealth Ventures Ltd. and PanTerra Resource Corp. have been testing the potential of over one million acres of exploration lands. PanTerra announced it has acquired Stealth’s 50 per cent working interest in all of the PanTerra-operated, jointventure shale gas properties in Saskatchewan. Stealth is continuing to explore its Alberta shale gas properties. To date, Stealth has been drilling one well per section, successfully testing the geological concept, testing different completion technologies, and earning land. Preliminary analysis indicates higher density spacing of more than four wells per section may ultimately be required to maximize recovery from these tight rock formations. The company says that as the project progresses to the development stage, better target identification and technology application could lead to increased productivity and drainage per well. Fracing Fracing technology can be expected to play an increasingly critical role in the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin’s (WCSB’s) natural gas sector as unconventional gas-particularly that from tight formations, coal bed methane (CBM), and shales - accounts for an ever bigger share of the region’s natural gas production. Already, unconventional gas accounts for a significant share of the WCSB’s total daily production of about 16 Bcf/d. The development of unconventional gas in the WCSB with the help of fracing technology is becoming an increasingly pressing issue because, as PTAC notes, conventional natural gas production from the region has already peaked. The Canadian Society for Unconventional Gas (CSUG) anticipates that by 2025, unconventional gas will account for 80 per cent of new drilling and 50 per cent of total gas production. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 6 Dave Browne, technical manager for Trican Well Service Ltd., says, “Volumes can vary quite a bit. Large frac jobs are becoming more common because reservoirs are of poorer quality.” Many less challenging reservoirs have been developed; the low-hanging fruit is mostly picked. But, as Browne observes, it’s still about getting the wellbore to the pay zone—despite the change between present and past conditions. “In the old days, the natural permeability of the rock was so good that quite often you didn’t need to frac hardly at all,” he says. “Now, we are going into shale. Before we were in carbonate and sandstone with good permeability. Now, it’s poor quality sandstone that’s the majority.” Getting at the gas in shale and poor-quality sandstone is now possible, thanks to large frac jobs. This can entail as many as 20 or more pump trucks used to push 200 tonnes of sand into the formation. Large frac jobs can cost a million dollars, so quality, reliable equipment that includes modern five-plunger or quintuplex pumps can be critical to a successful operation. Although Browne says that a million-dollar frac job means “you need the well to be capable of producing a couple of million cubic feet a day,” the prize could make it worthwhile. The frac could pay for itself in less than six months. “In Texas, with some large fracs, they are getting 20 trillion cubic feet a day,” he says. 5 By 2010, North American natural gas demand will approach 30 Tcf per year. To meet this demand, producers will have to increasingly turn to unconventional resources such as shale gas. Shale gas is a large potential resource in the WCSB. The GTI estimates conservatively that there is approximately 86 Tcf of shale gas contained in the shales that make up the majority of the sedimentary package. Technological advances in completions and well stimulation in the US is increasing recovery factors and improving the economics of marginal shale gas fields. 1.1.2 The Fracturing (Fracing) Process Canada has always been a leader in technological advancement of the energy industry. As shale gas becomes a greater focus in Canada industry, new technologies will no doubt be developed to meet the needs of the domestic industry. Experience gained in the commercial development of tight gas sands in Canada will likely contribute to the successful development of shale gas. Gas shales are attracting an increasing amount of attention from Canadian exploration companies and the trend is expected to increase. The hydrocarbon volume stored within gas shales in Canada is huge. The experience with gas shales in the US has proven the economic viability of the resource. Each basin and sedimentary unit in Canada will have its own unique characteristics and challenges. The low permeability 5 CBM and tight gas push demand for high-tech fracing, http://www.oilandgasinquirer.com/articles.asp?ID=518 COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 7 shale gas reservoirs in Canada will require innovative stimulation and completion solutions. Canadian explorers can be expected to rise to the challenge in the very near future. 6 With tight gas, the paths for the gas flow are very narrow making it difficult for the gas to effectively flow through the reservoir for long distances. Well stimulation (fracing) is required for ‘tight’ gas. Well stimulation through a ‘fracture treatment’ (what those in industry call a ‘frac’) opens up these paths so they are wide enough to allow gas flow. Often an oil or gas bearing formations may contain large quantities of oil or gas, but have a poor flow rate due to low permeability, or from damage caused by clogging of the formation during drilling. This is particularly true for tight sands, oil and gas shales and coal-bed methane. Hydraulic fracturing is a technique used to create fractures that extend from the well bore into rock or coal formations. Typically, in order to create fractures a mixture of water, proppants (sand or ceramic beads) and chemicals is pumped into the rock or coal formation. These fractures allow the oil or gas to travel more easily from the rock pores, where the oil or gas is trapped, to the production well. Think of it as a honeycomb and you are trying to create connections between the holes in the comb so the gas may find a passage through the otherwise impermeable rock. Fracing technology involves pumping fluids under pressure underground in order to fracture the formation by inducing cracks and thus improving permeability. It uses two main components. One is a fluid, which, with the right viscosity and other properties, carries the second component, typically sand, ceramic, or some other solid that holds the newly induced cracks open. That second component is known as the proppant. Eventually, the formation will not be able to absorb the fluid as quickly as it is being injected. At this point, the pressure created causes the formation to crack or fracture. The fractures are held open by the proppants, and the oil or gas is then able to flow through the fractures to the well. Some of the fracturing fluids are pumped out of the well and into surface pits or tanks during the process of extracting oil, gas and any produced water. These fracturing fluids must be collected when bringing the well back into production. Here is where large blow-back tanks are required to contain the accumulated refuse upon reintegration of well production. 6 http://www.csug.ca/faqs.html#Na15 COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 8 1.1.3 Blow Back Tanks Blow Back tanks are required to collect the aggregate left over from the process of fracing wells. Blow back tanks are required every time that a well is subjected to the process of fracing and then tanks are in use at each site for a few days to collect the proppant and water. With the large deposits of natural gas in the Newell Region and the constant need to frac these gas wells flow-back tanks are in constant demand. In such great demand that the region should be able to easily support a facility dedicated to the production of such vessels. Past Tank Pricing – Source: EOG Resources A Wendy Grieve of EOG Resources was a solid lead on the past cost of the tanks. Their business in Alberta had 50 tanks built at a cost of $550, 000, but she also said that they had supplied the piping to make the pipe-run from each of the tanks to the well heads. The figure of $11,000 as a price for each on the tanks was the most reliable cost estimate at first. However, EOG had supplied the fabricator with enough pipe to outfit the 50 tanks, which would have to be factored into the total cost of tank production. Not counting the pipe costs, the direct expenses in fabricating the tanks was between $6000 and $7000. Present and Future Tank Pricing – Source: Protech/Delta Oilfield Tanks and Pinnacle Manufacturing Recently a company called Protech/Delta Oilfield Tanks from Colorado built tanks for Anadarko Petroleum in Alberta. They cost $19,900 per tank which they claim is a very good price in today's market. The EOG prices were from 2 years ago. A contact at Protech said the price of steel 2 years ago was only about $0.24 a pound. Right now he said they bus their steel from Cargill at a price of $0.68 a pound and that in July 2008 the price of steel is expected to go to at least $0.78 a pound and may go as high as $0.84 a pound. In fact, Cargill will only quote a price on steel for 48 hours so Protech has been stockpiling steel with Cargill and having to pay them stocking charges to hold the steel to avoid the new higher prices coming along. Protech was also kind enough to provide specs for the tanks. See Appendix 1. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 9 Contacts at Pinnacle Manufacturing in Alabama confirmed the Protech steel numbers. Pinnacle had commented that the Protech tank prices seem to be very reasonable for the type of blowback tanks that the are used in the Alberta market. Other Pricing Information - KDS Tank Rentals KDS Tank Rentals is attempting to sell the business which owns 50 blow back tanks – the asking price is $2.8 million. The tanks are all the same – 20' long, 10' wide and 6' high. Each tank comes with 7 joints of line pipe, a tank riser, bean and a flag for wind direction. The tanks all have skids on them and are easily moved with a bed truck. The tanks are currently working in the shallow gas field located near Cabri, SK. They are rented 11 months out of the year and generate anywhere from $30 to $60 per tank, per day. If they actually earn as much rental income as they claim, each tank might generate income of $9,900 to $19,800 annually ($30 to $60/day for 330 days/year). Flow-Back Tanks In the southern US markets the term flow-back tank is used to describe a similar, but much larger tank. These tanks are in the range of 500 barrels or 70 m3, almost twice the size of the tanks that are used in western Canada (200-275 barrels or 30-40 m3). These flow-back tanks would obviously be used on the much larger fracturing jobs that are common in Texas and similar areas. It appears, from the website information, that these tanks have their own wheels and are transported by hooking them to a highway tractor. The type of tanks that are used in Canada are much smaller and less elaborate than the flow-back tanks, and are designed to be skidded or lifted onto a flatbed trailer to be moved from site to site. 1.2 CURRENT SITUATION AND ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS 1.2.1 Environmental Scan The fact that natural gas is one of the cleanest, cheapest and most efficient sources of energy makes it a necessary component of an environmentally friendly economy. Alberta is home to a large natural gas resource base and accounts for just over 80 per cent of the natural gas produced in Canada. It is estimated that 97 trillion cubic feet (Tcf) of recoverable, conventional natural gas is still beneath Alberta. Alberta’s coal seams could contain as much as an additional COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 10 500 Tcf. While it’s not yet known how much of this coalbed methane is economically recoverable, Alberta’s natural gas supply will meet the needs of Albertans, Canadians and North Americans for the foreseeable future. Another potential unconventional gas source is gas in shale which is still in the very early stages of development in Alberta. Alberta Energy ensures Albertans continue to receive the full value from their gas resource by promoting and encouraging responsible exploration and development of Alberta’s natural gas resources, and calculating and collecting gas royalties. – AB Dept. of Energy 1.2.2 Political Environment It is of little surprise that the Government of Alberta in general is supportive of the oil and gas industry. But one of the reasons that economic development projects such as this are even more attractive is that natural gas is playing an increasingly prominent role in Alberta’s energy sector . Although oil prices grab the headlines, Alberta now receives more royalty from natural gas. Historically, oil and gas royalty payments were about equal, if not more for oil. In 2004-05 natural gas royalties accounted for 76 per cent of royalty revenues for Albertans. As a result, changes in gas prices have a more dramatic effect on government revenues than changes in oil prices. Of course, both royalties increase when both oil and gas prices trend upward.7 1.2.3 Economic Environment Canadian Production Canada is the third largest producer of natural gas and the ninth largest producer of crude oil in the world. Two thirds of Canada’s initial conventional hydrocarbon resources are estimated to be onshore Canada’s National Energy Board estimates the total initial resources include 430 billion cubic meters of conventional oil and 17.2 trillion cubic meters of natural gas. In 2004 Canadian production of natural gas amounted to 485 million cubic meters per day while the country exported another 273 million cubic meters per day. Canada's remaining resources of natural gas are estimated by the National Energy Board to be 10.5 trillion cubic meters including developed and prospective resources. Alberta Production Natural gas is the largest single source of resource development revenue for Albertans, accounting for more than $28.2 billion in royalties paid to the Government 7 Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers - http://www.capp.ca COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 11 of Alberta from fiscal 2000/2001 to fiscal 2004/2005. This total represents about 70 per cent of all provincial revenue from non-renewable resources over that period. Natural gas is also responsible for a significant portion of the oil and gas industry’s investment in Alberta, totaling over $90 billion from 2000 to 2004. In addition to heating homes and businesses, over 60 per cent of the natural gas consumed in Alberta is used by the industrial sector. Natural gas is an important raw material for the province’s oil sands and electric power generation industries, which have expanded in recent years as the result of significant investment based on availability of the resource in Alberta. 8 There is also potential for growth into the U.S. sector as Colorado is home to a large untapped shale oil and gas reserve that has yet to be extracted. This along with the Alberta reserves will be another strategic market just waiting to be explored. Figure 1 illustrates the significant number of well completions in Canada, in particularly Alberta, in recent years. Figure 1: Well Completions - Annual Breakdown by Province Figure 1: Well Completions - Annual Breakdown by Province Source - Daily Oil Bulletin Alberta Oil Gas Dry Servicing Saskatchewan Oil Gas Dry Servicing BC Oil Gas Dry Servicing Manitoba Oil Gas Dry Servicing 8 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 290 10,679 792 82 3,034 12,670 884 99 2,771 12,711 1,180 249 2,613 12,754 1,081 200 2,751 11,067 1,031 119 2,358 6,924 1,102 161 2,806 9,165 1,452 134 2,182 1,217 68 73 2,038 1,518 107 61 1,766 1,714 146 65 1,616 1,887 93 44 1,558 2,254 130 64 1,356 1,718 121 74 1,716 1,366 181 71 66 725 46 1 59 1,101 64 7 40 932 76 16 66 972 88 18 88 618 60 9 45 429 55 20 84 640 110 23 281 29 3 313 468 17 0 485 245 9 10 5 122 0 5 0 76 0 9 9 70 0 8 10 80 0 15 21 Alberta Department of Energy - COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 12 Northern Can. Oil Gas Dry Servicing Western Can. Oil Gas Dry Servicing East Coast Oil Gas Dry Servicing Total 3 0 6 0 0 4 0 0 0 2 2 0 1 30 3 0 0 5 3 0 3 2 3 0 3 6 1 1 5,429 12,621 935 159 5,599 15,289 1,072 167 4,822 15,359 1,414 330 4,418 15,616 1,270 262 4,473 13,944 1,233 201 3,832 9,073 1,289 265 4,689 11,177 1,759 308 11 96 8 7 19,272 10 24 4 2 22,171 13 44 9 8 21,999 20 58 12 15 21,671 15 66 16 9 19,957 24 48 26 6 14,571 13 23 9 5 17,983 1.2.4 Social Environment Oil and gas activity continues to form a strong element of the Brooks’ economy. Ongoing drilling and exploration programs mean that these and other companies are going to be in Brooks and the region for a long time. The City of Brooks is one of fastest growing communities in Alberta boasting a population of about 12,500. Brooks is steadily growing with residential and commercial development and a recently completed a state of the art Aquatic Center, a wide range of restaurants, grocery and retail outlets. The city is also awaiting the opening of a new Recreation Center that is currently under construction. Brooks is the largest city in the County of Newell and is located 186 km southeast of Calgary adjacent to the Trans-Canada Highway within the County of Newell. Brooks is only a short distance of 104km from Medicine Hat. The County of Newell’s agricultural industry is a significant contributor to the local and regional economy. Tyson Foods (Lakeside Packers) is the largest employer in the agricultural sector, and community, employing 2,500 workers. Of the 1.5 million acres in the County, there are 282,000 acres that are served by a state-of-the-art pipe and canal irrigation system with water diverted from the Bassano Dam on the Bow River. An additional 165,000 acres are cultivated dryland. Ranching is very strong within the County of Newell. With 930,000 acres of native pasture, the County is home to a very strong and viable cattle ranching industry. The people who call the County of Newell home are one of the strongest resources within the County. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 13 Population • • Brooks has experienced significant growth from 1996 to 2005; and Brooks has become a multi-cultural community with many various religions and cultures including an immigrant population of 1,059. The 2001 census indicated that there were 7,137 citizens within the County of Newell and 2,365 dwellings. Since the 1996 census, the County of Newell has grown at a rate of 11.2% almost a full percentage point above the Provincial growth rate of 10.3%. Bassano Brooks Duchess Rosemary Tilley County of Newell Total Population Population 2001 1,320 11,604 836 366 422 7,137 21,685 Population 2006 1,345 12,498 978 388 381 6,872 22,462 The agricultural economy remains a vital element of the Brooks’ economy. Brooks is located within an area containing 282,000 irrigated farmland acres, 600,000 acres of cultivated dry land farming and another 600,000 acres of native and improved rangeland in the region. The availability of ample water from irrigation projects has assisted the agricultural economy tremendously. In addition, a large range of businesses that offer goods and services to the agricultural sector are also present in Brooks and the surrounding area, including supplies of irrigation equipment and machinery. Brooks operates as the retail and service sector for the community as well as the surrounding region. The growth in population has been paralleled by a growth in the retail and service sector, and new businesses are opening constantly as opportunities arise. As a regional service center, Brooks has a wide range of urban amenities and services, such as retail services, accommodations and eateries, major leisure center, representation from all five major banks and professional, technical and financial services. Because Brooks operates as a regional service center, retail and other service activities are a vital source of employment locally. 1.2.5 Technology A large number of companies in Brooks are involved in the oil and gas service industries, providing goods and services to the exploration side of the industry, and also to the production and delivery side of the business, in terms of maintenance and upgrading of existing wells and pipelines. There are approximately two hundred businesses in the Brooks area that are involved in the oil and gas industry in one form or another. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 14 Agriculture Research The County of Newell is home to a state-of-the-art agriculture research facility. The Crop Diversification Centre is operated by the Province of Alberta. The CDC has been instrumental in research that has developed several strains of crops for production in all areas of the Province and the whole of Canada. The CDC currently operates a full plant genetics laboratory conducting research into new varieties of crops that either are, or potentially could be, grown in the County of Newell No. 4. The CDC conducts research into such crops as sunflower seeds, fruits, especially apples, corn, potatoes and many other crops grown in the County of Newell. 1.2.6 Labour Relations Because of the prosperous economic situation in Alberta in general and the Brooks area in particular, there is an ongoing labour shortage. This is especially true for several of the skilled trades including welders. This will create a challenge which any proposed new tank manufacturing business will have to develop strategies to mitigate. This may include recruiting skilled workers from other provinces or other countries. In the last year the Government of Alberta has become very proactive in helping companies recruiting foreign labour. They have many target programs and information sources for employers looking to recruit from abroad. (See http://www.alberta-canada.com/immigration/employers/index.html) 1.3 PROJECT PARTNERS There are numerous small to medium sized business operating in the Alberta’s energy sector. While it is possible that a larger company might take an interest in this project, it is more likely that a small to medium sized operator would start this venture. One of the reasons that this is an attractive business is the relatively small capitalization that a blowback tank production facility would require. There are several small to medium sized businesses in the Unites States that could set up operations in the County of Newell, seeing as it has proximity to such a large portion of the blow back tank market. It is assumed that a single business or owner would move forward on this project rather than a partnership. However, the County of Newell has demonstrated by sponsoring this business case development that they would be willing to provide assistance to an owner. In addition, the Alberta Department of Energy and various economic development organizations could be of assistance as well. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 15 2. OPERATION ANALYSIS 2.1 LOCATION The Blow-Back tank production facility should be placed within or near the industrial sector in the County of Newell in order to take advantage of the space and close proximity of ancillary services. The existence of wide paved roads would be an added benefit as the need to move large tanks and the trucks associated with the tank hauling could make use of smooth transportation avenues. The County of Newell has the added benefit of being located astride the main artery of transportation in Canada, namely Highway #1. In addition the County of Newell has land designated and zoned as heavy industrial, an ideal location for a the physical plant. 2.2 PLANT A large parcel of land within the County of Newell would be required for the tank facility as storage of materials needed for production as well as an accumulation area for the finished blow-back tanks. The tanks do not require inside storage so only a large outdoor area needed for the tank farm. Please refer to Section 5.1 for more discussion regarding the construction of a plant. 2.3 PROCESS The manufacturing process is expected to be fairly straightforward including primarily metal bending, shaping and welding. The technology in generally not very sophisticated and does not appear to be protected by patents. 2.4 TRANSPORTATION The transportation of the finished tanks seems to be well suited to flatbed trailers with no special equipment or permits needed. The tanks are designed to be skidded or lifted onto and off of flatbed trailers. The construction of trailers themselves could be an offshoot business for the plant. Trailers will be needed regardless to transport a fleet of at least 50 rental units. 2.5 PERSONNEL The manufacturing of these tanks will require a number of specialized trades people including metalworkers and welders. As noted earlier, it is expected to be challenging to COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 16 for a new business to attract these types of skilled workers. Strategies will need to be developed and well executed to recruit these workers from other provinces or other countries. 2.6 MANAGEMENT It is not expected to be difficult to attract the type of management expertise required to operate this type of business. The senior management team will need to be familiar with the metal fabrication industry and should have a good working knowledge of the oil and gas service sector. Hiring someone with solid connections to the major oil exploration companies would be very beneficial (as it is these companies that buy or lease the blow bank tanks for the fracing jobs). 2.7 BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION It is not expected to be difficult to attract the type of business administration skills that will be required to operate this type of business. Brooks has many small and medium sized businesses and the business support infrastructure that these types of companies need (accountants, lawyers, etc.) 2.8 REGULATORY It is does not appear that there are significant regulatory challenges to establishing this type of business in the Brooks area. The practices that are used at the well sites are controlled by regulations and by good business practices. However, there seems to be minimal regulations regarding the construction, movement and use of the tanks themselves. It should be noted that the County of Newell is supporting the development of this business and therefore will be interested in cooperating in any way possible with potential investors. And the Government of Alberta is of course very supportive of new business initiatives in the oil and gas sector. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 17 3. MARKETING ANALYSIS 3.1 MARKET RESEARCH Market research was conducted to determine the nature of the business environment in which this proposed blow back tank manufacturing business would operate. It was challenging to obtain good market research information because the major gas exploration and servicing companies are reluctant to provide information (even when we tried to assure them that we were interested in attracting a new supplier and that this would likely benefit them) This research confirmed that the fracing industry is in a steady growth phase as more and more gas wells are being drilled into “tight” gas beds. These beds require more wells drilled per square mile and more use of fracing services in order to keep the flow rates at acceptable levels than did the conventional wells that were drilled in the past. Each well that is fractured needs to have a blow back tank on site for several days during and after the frac is done. Thus, it seems likely that there will be an ongoing market demand for more tanks each year for the foreseeable future. With 14,500 new wells being drilled in 2008 and similar numbers expected in future years, there is no reason to expect that the demand for blow back tanks will decrease in the foreseeable future. 3.2 MARKETING STRATEGY It seems that an appropriate marketing strategy would be to focus marketing and sales efforts directly on the companies that supply these tanks to the major companies such as EnCana, etc. Some major companies prefer to rent the tanks rather than to own them, but further research will be needed to confirm specifically which companies those are. Alternatively, the tank manufacturing company might choose to set up its own tank rental subsidiary business. It would have to be careful to do this in a way that would no unduly jeopardize its relationship with the other rental companies (they may feel that the tank manufacturing company is, on the one hand, supplying them with tanks and, on the other hand, is going into competition with them for rental customers). In all likelihood, forming a company that is focused on tank manufacturing but has a rental decision makes the most sense. The manufacturing ability will lead to other opportunities in the oil and gas sector and perhaps beyond, but the repeatable source of income that a rental arm provides is very attractive also. 3.2.1 Target Market The primary target market for this proposed new tank manufacturing business will be in the four western Canadian provinces. It will be the companies that rent the tanks to COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 18 The major gas producing companies are expected to be the primary customers for the proposed new business. A potential second target market would be the major gas producers themselves in the same four western provinces (if these companies would see value in purchasing the tanks, rather then renting them). Lastly, the tank manufacturing company will have to explore the North Western Unites States as a market. The push to drill for coal bed methane in states such as Colorado and Montana makes a perfect market for blow back tanks. 3.2.2 Sustainable Competitive Advantage In order to gain a sustainable competitive it is expected that this proposed company will need to identify a positioning strategy that it can effectively execute in order to become one of the: • Low-cost producers of blow back tanks by achieving significant economies of scale in the manufacturing and marketing of tanks; • Innovation leaders in the industry by developing features that add customer value without adding a lot more production costs (i.e. increase profitability) and that others don’t offer and can’t easily copy; or • A high-service renter of tanks to the gas producers (if the gas producers are willing to pay a premium for better service). • Service and reliability are keystones to any business and are of particular import in the ultra competitive world of the energy sector. 3.3 MARKETING PLAN Ancillary Profit Centers The blow back tank production facility could also serve as a welding shop and a metal fabrication business. The shop could even look into the possibility of expanding their business to include production of service rigs which only requires the services of a fabrication shop coupled with the purchasing of the subsequent motors needed to run the rig. The proprietor could also look into the added benefits of not selling the blow-back tanks but rather renting them out to the energy sector. By renting the tanks the proprietor can ensure steady cash flow from tank rentals, and could entertain the possibility of buying the large vehicles required to transport the tanks thereby giving the owner another means to supplement and grow his investment. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 19 4. FINANCIAL ANALYSIS 4.1 ESTIMATE CAPITAL COSTS It is expected that the capital investment required to establish a tank manufacturing business could be moderate – perhaps in the range of $2 million. The manufacturing business would be expected to have ongoing inventories in the $200,000 range. To operate the ancillary tank rental business, it will require the investment of approximately $600,000 (50 tanks at direct costs of $12,000 per tank) in rental tank inventories. It is expected that it should be possible to finance at least 50% of the capital costs plus inventory costs, reducing the equity requirement to the $1.4 million range (50% of $2.8 million). A Metal Fabrication contact at Alberta Investment and Industry Development Branch had thought that a cost of between $100-$150 ft² is appropriate, but he was not sure so he referred us to a local builder. This contactor noted that a great deal of factors that go into building such a facility so he estimates $200-$225 ft² as more appropriate cost. And all our contacts agreed that 10,000 ft2 is a pretty common size for such a facility.9 Of course the details such as over head cranes, height of structure, closeness of utilities etc. could all impact the price of such a structure. The contactor indicated that the structures they build are modular or pre-built which can lower costs. The government contact also noted that a few local businessmen have also bought an already erected building and moving it to site to cut down on costs. 4.2 ESTIMATED OPERATING REVENUES & EXPENSES This case utilizes the Statistics Canada Small Business Profiles to create financial projections for the business model. More specifically we use figures from the North American Industrial Classification System (NAICS) # 33242 which is Metal Tank (Heavy Gauge) Manufacturing. It is narrowed down to the Alberta market, which contained 26 related manufactures in 2006. The Small Business Profiles generate a list of ratios based on the revenue range of the business. So determining the projected demand and therefore revenue is vital to the integrity of the estimations. 4.21 Assessing Demand Estimating potential revenues for a start up business is always difficult. This is especially difficult in an industry where the primary driver (oil wells drilled) can vary dramatically based on myriad of factors. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 20 9 Director, Metal Fabrication, Alberta Employment, Immigration and Industry, Investment and Industry Development Branch and Clark Builders Ltd, Calgary AB We have chosen to develop a model using our ground level knowledge from people and companies in the Alberta oil field. This will be based on past and projected well starts, but there is another pertinent variable that is much more difficult to measure – well re-completions. A re-completion or refinishing is when a well that has died off and then had a frac on it to get it flowing again (in the same formation). Or they can also be used when a deep gas well has stopped producing and they seal that casing off down hole, then come further up into a new formation and frac again to get shallow gas. We will use numbers based on estimations of new wells drilled and existing wells being refinished for sweet gas (natural gas). 4.211 County of Newell Demand In the County of Newell there is approximately 15,000 gas wells. An oil field company in the County of Newell that does down-hole testing said that right now he knows of around 1,200 wells being slated to be drilled in the area this year. But they are fairly confident that the final number will be closer to 2,000 before the drilling season is done. For every well being drilled there is at least 1 tank on site; but usually 2 are more common because of the size of the fracs. But we cannot assume there will be demand for 4,000 tanks (2 x 2,000) because the tanks are moved from site to site. From our contacts in the field, a rule of thumb in the industry is go by a tenth, so if a company is drilling around 200 wells they will rent about 20 tanks and move them around as they punch the holes. So this year alone in the Newell region they would need 200 tanks at a minimum. But we will estimate the number higher because we are not counting well re-completions being done to non-producing wells. So it was suggested by people in the fields that we move the ratio from 1/10 to 1/7. We would estimate the number of tanks needed at 285 for the County of Newell. 4.212 Alberta Demand A plant in the County of Newel region could of course supply tanks to all of Alberta and beyond. So it best is to use the data from the Canadian Association of Oil-well Drilling Contractors website on wells punched. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 21 Figure 2: Alberta Gas Well Completions - Daily Oil Bulletin Wells 2007 10,679 2006 12,670 2005 12,711 2004 12,754 2003 11,067 2002 6,924 2001 9,165 This yields an average of 11,976 gas wells drilled in the province of Alberta over the last 5 years. So using the 1/7 ratio for wells completed over the last 5 years it is estimated that at least 1,711 tanks are in use in the Province of Alberta. 4.213 Saskatchewan Demand Here is the Canadian Association of Oil-well Drilling Contractors well completions data: Figure 3: Saskatchewan Gas Well Completions - Daily Oil Bulletin Wells 2007 1,217 2006 1,518 2005 1,714 2004 1,887 2003 2,254 2002 1,718 2001 1,366 This yields an average of 1,667 gas wells drilled in the province of Saskatchewan over the last 5 years. So using the 1/7 ratio for wells completed over the last 5 years it is estimated that 238 tanks are in use in the Province of Saskatchewan. 4.214 U.S. Demand It is also prudent to consider the immediate geographic market for a Blow Back Tank production facility in the County of Newell, so we must also examine northern US natural gas wells We were unable to locate specific well starts for the last few years, but we did find the number of recent gas producing wells from the Energy Information Administration: Figure 4: US Producing Gas Wells - US Energy Information Administration U.S. Colorado Montana Utah Wyoming 2001 373,304 22,117 4,331 4,601 13,978 2002 387,772 23,554 4,544 3,005 15,608 2003 393,327 18,774 4,539 3,220 18,154 COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 2004 406,147 16,718 4,971 3,657 20,244 2005 425,887 22,691 5,751 4,092 23,734 2006 448,641 20,568 6,578 4,506 25,052 22 There is a general trend upwards, with over 20,000 new wells in the US from 2005 to 2006. And of course drillers punch a lot more wells than actually end up in production. Included are statistics from several states close to Alberta, with the understanding that there will be strong competition for gas field services further south from Texas. It is difficult to say what the exact number of blowback tanks that are used in the North West US, but with coal bed methane extraction which often requires fracing, the number is significant. Approximately 7.5 percent of the total natural gas production in the United States is comprised of coal bed methane. At least 12,000 coal bed methane wells have already been drilled in the Powder River Basin in Wyoming and Montana, and the Bureau of Land Management is expecting 51,000 coal bed methane wells to be drilled in the entire basin by 2010. For comparison, there are only about 1 million operating oil and gas wells in the entire United States.10 4.215 Rental Revenues Tank rental companies are typically very similar in pricing. They charge $1.00 per cubic meter of tank space, so a 35 cubic meter tank would cost $35 per day. Monthly rate is just calculated with the daily rate in mind (30days x $35 = $1,050) unless a customer were to rent multiple tanks. As the number of tanks increase the price per unit drops, so if you were to rent upwards of 20 tanks over a month then the price could come down as low as $800.00 per tank monthly. 4.216 Existing Supply We know that there is insufficient supply in the market, hence the development of this business case. Determining the exact number of tanks in use today is very difficult. The best estimation we could get is 1,000-1,500 from major suppliers, and 200-400 from smaller operations. Of course this does not take into account what shape the tanks are in, and how many are slated for replacement. Along with increasing fracing operations, the age and condition of the existing tanks supply is likely a contributing factor to the shortage. 4.217 Overall Trends Manufacturing shipments for this industry increased at an average compound annual rate of 7.5% per year from 1994 to 2003. 10 Western Organization of Resource Councils -http://www.worc.org/issues/art_issues/energy_ltrtoepa.html COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 23 Manufacturing value-added for the Metal Tank (Heavy Gauge) Manufacturing industry increased from $216.2 million in 1994 to $375.6 million in 2003, or at approximately an annual compound growth rate of 6.25%. Manufacturing valueadded is defined as the value of shipments plus net change in the inventory of goods in process and finished goods, less the costs of materials and supplies and of the fuel and electricity used. 4.22 Revenue Estimation Sales: After considering all the aforementioned calculations, and talking to companies on the ground, we estimate that there is a demand for approximately 250 blowback tanks per year in the Alberta, Saskatchewan and North-West US region. We will estimate that a local company could capture half of this market and then grow it over time. Estimates are 100 tanks the first year, 125 the second year, and 150 the third year. The type of tank in use is priced at approximately $19,000 per unit. Due to escalating steel prices we will adjust our prices up $3,000 per tank each year. Due to the volatility of steel prices and drilling each year it is only prudent do a three year projection. Rental: Renting the tanks would be a likely source of revenue, since many customers will not want to purchase tanks. During Year 1, the business is expected to put tanks into its rental fleet as they are built and to have the equivalent of 50 tanks for half the season (the equivalent of 25 tanks for the full year).The tanks are expected to rent for $900 per month for 10 months and would be expected to gross $9,000 per tank per year in Year 1, increasing to $10,400 in Year 2 and $11,800 in Year 3 (similar to the projected percentage increases in tank selling prices). That would net $225,000 yearly rental revenue in Year 1 (with the equivalent of just 25 tanks in service), $520,000 in Year 2 (50 tanks) and $590,000 in Year 3. Repair: The repair revenue was difficult to estimate, especially in the first years of operations. After year 1 we will include a $50,000 estimate for the repair and modification of tanks sold, doubling that figure in year 3. Other Sales: It will be prudent to augment the business with other oilfield and tank building services. This is an unexplored market at this point, but it is highly evident that any company able to produce oil field equipment will find alternate sources of revenue in Alberta. Just the welding expertise that will be requires will help the company work into other revenue streams. So we will include a revenue projection for ‘other services’ starting in the second year of operations. There is a $100,000 estimate for year 2, that number doubling in year 3. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 24 4.23 Financial Projections Figure 2 Estimates Revenue Expenses and Profit Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 $2,125,000 $3,420,000 $4,640,000 $2,125,000 $3,270,000 $4,340,000 $0 $150,000 $300,000 $1,120,000 $2,053,350 $2,325,920 $480,000 $510,350 $545,920 $1,440,000 $1,553,000 $1,785,000 $0 $800,000 $810,000 $800,000 $810,000 $815,000 $1,005,000 $1,366,650 $2,314,080 Operating expenses (indirect expenses) $982,300 $1,172,850 $1,482,900 Labour and commissions $360,000 $412,050 $553,500 Amortization and depletion $170,000 $170,000 $170,000 $9,400 $13,400 $18,000 Utilities and telephone/telecommunication $35,000 $43,550 $58,500 Rent $61,100 $87,100 $117,000 $105,400 $108,400 $111,400 Professional and business fees $61,100 $87,100 $117,000 Advertising and promotion $20,000 $26,800 $36,000 $8,000 $10,050 $13,500 $16,000 $20,100 $27,000 $136,300 $194,300 $261,000 Total expenses $2,082,300 $3,206,200 $3,788,820 Net profit/loss $22,700 $193,800 $831,180 Total revenue Sales of goods and services (Tank Sales and Rentals) All other revenues (Service and Other Manufacturing) Cost of sales (direct expenses) Wages and benefits Purchases, materials and sub-contracts Opening Inventory Closing inventory Gross Margin (total revenue minus cost of sales) Repairs and maintenance Interest and bank charges Delivery, shipping and warehouse expenses Insurance Other expenses COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 25 Figure3 Balance Sheet from Statistics Canada Small Business profiles Debt to equity ratio 1.2 Revenue to equity ratio 3.4 Net profit to equity (%) 27.5 Net fixed assets to equity (%) 24.0 Gross margin (%) 36.5 Return on total assets (%) 12.8 4.3 ESTIMATED ROI If this business could be established with a capital investment of $2.8 million and equity investment of $1.4 million as shown in Section 4.1 and if it could generate annual gross margins (gross income minus direct costs) in Year 3 in the range of $2.3 million, it could potentially achieve net income before tax in the range of $0.85 million (gross margin of $2.31 million minus estimated indirect costs of $1.46 million). This level of Gross margin is estimated at 49.9% of sales (well above the 36.5% industry average). That would achieve an estimated ROI of 51% on equity of $1.4 million and an estimated return of 30.4% on total assets of $2.8 million. Both of these values are higher than the Statistics Canada Small Business Averages shown on the previous page of 27.5% (net profit/equity) and 12.8% (return on total assets). 4.4 BREAK EVEN ANALYSIS The level of revenue required to cover fixed costs (indirect costs) would be fairly high because of the capital intensive nature of this type of business, perhaps in the range shown below. For Year 3: The estimated fixed (indirect) costs including administrative and non-manufacturing costs, interest on long-term debt and depreciation ~$1.5 million Estimated contribution margin ~49.9% Revenue required to cover estimated fixed costs ~$3.0 million or 65% of the estimated $4.6 total revenue. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 26 5. CONCLUSION After a significant six month research effort, we have concluded that the County of Newell could support the development of a heavy gauge tank manufacturing facility focusing on blow back tank production. The development of such a plant would be recommended primarily for the following reasons: • There is a ground-level need for more blowback tanks being communicated by companies in the oil and gas sector in the County of Newell, in Alberta, and beyond. • Fracing technology can be expected to play an increasingly critical role in the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin’s natural gas sector as unconventional gasparticularly that from tight formations, coal bed methane, and shales accounts for an ever bigger share of the region’s natural gas production. • Local government is very supportive of this type of project. They will cooperate with investors in any way possible to move the construction of such a plant forward including assistance with regulatory issues, human resources, locating financing, etc. • With over 3,000 gas wells located in the County of Newell, a base market would be right on the manufacture’s doorstep. There are over 10,000 new completions in Alberta each year, and many recompilations done all over the province. In addition, drilling is occurring at an increasing rate in BC, Saskatchewan and the North West United States. • There is significant potential for additional manufacturing businesses to spring from a core tank manufacturing facility. There are billions of dollars invested annually in the oil and gas industry in Alberta, and innovative entrepreneurs that can manufacture products for the industry always have a place. COUNTY OF NEWELL BLOWBACK TANK BUSINESS CASE Outlook Market Research and Consulting Ltd. 27