Executive Summary 1 Social Media in Afghanistan Measuring the usage & perceptions of the Afghan population Implemented by: www.ez-afghanistan.de 2 Executive Summary The emergence of social media has had a profound impact on communications in Afghanistan. Whilst the majority of users perceive that the medium presents both issues and opportunities, it’s apparent that social media is becoming increasingly relevant to the lives of an increasing number of Afghans. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH with technical support of ATR consulting conducted an in-depth qualitative and quantitative study to examine the typical social media users in Kabul and six Northern provinces of Afghanistan. The study investigated why and how social media is used, risks and opportunities for social media in the context of Afghan culture and how better to engage with Afghans through this medium. A summary of major findings is as follows. Languages in social media English 62.1% Dari 30.1% Pashtu 3.3% Social media platforms Facebook 87.8% Google+ 12.9% Youtube 5.8% Twitter 3.8% User with Facebook profile Men 97.5% Women 12.9% Social Media is becoming increasingly relevant in the lives of Afghan users Afghan social media users predominantly do so at a moderate to high intensity, with 27.8%1 of users logging on several times a day and 21.3% logging on more than five times per day. Men are more likely to be intensive users, logging on more frequently and for a greater length of time than female users. Both male and female users report that the time they spend on social media has increased from the previous year and 73.6% expect it to continue to increase. This is typically attributed to an increased capacity to use social media, and an increased relevance in the lives of users as more Afghans adopt the medium. English is the dominant language with which respondents use social media (62.1% of users), followed by Dari (30.1%), a very small proportion of users (3.3%) are using Pashtu on social media. Facebook is by far the dominant social media platform in Afghanistan with 87.8% of users having a Facebook profile. The next most prominent platform is Google+ (12.9% of users) followed by Youtube (5.8% of users) and Twitter (3.8%). Men are notably more likely to have a Facebook profile than women (97.5% compared to 78.1% of women). 1 A total sample of 1,184 respondents were interviewed Executive Summary Despite increasing usage considerable barriers remain for Afghans to use social media Barriers to Afghans accessing social media tend to be derived from either a lack of access, including a lack of electricity or the inability to afford an internet connection, lack of education (including illiteracy) and/or lack of capacity to use a smartphone/computer or social media platform, or cultural restrictions, such as concerns over inappropriate content. Afghan small-medium sized enterprises have yet to utilize on a large scale the marketing potential of social media. This is typically attributed to a lack of capacity, resources, and a lack of familiarity of the Afghan public in being marketed to in this fashion. Social Media increases connectedness; within Afghanistan and abroad Youth and members of civil society organisations (CSOs) report using social media as a means to connect and mobilize people, including youth in other countries. Businessmen typically use social media for connectivity with suppliers and customers, both in Afghanistan and abroad. Politicians and the general public both report that social media increases the accessibility of politicians, and their connectivity with their constituents. Journalists benefit from social media’s lack of regulations to both collect and disseminate information more widely, as well as opportunities to connect with journalists abroad. 3 Barriers to Afghans accessing social media lack of electricity no internet connection lack of education lack of capacity cultural restrictions Social Media and Connectedness connect and mobilize people in CSOs connect suppliers and customers increases the accessibility of politicians and connectivity with their constituents Journalists collect and disseminate informations more widely Social Media plays an important role for both recreational and non-recreational/civic purposes Afghans use of social media is quite evenly balanced between social/recreational uses; such as connecting with people, discussing sport, movies and celebrities, playing games and shopping and ‘non-recreational’/civic uses of following news, participating in debates, posting political messages and mobilizing people. Men are more civically active on social media and tend to seek new connections, whilst female users are more reserved in their online presence; less civically active and more likely to engage with friends and family and people they already know. Users based in Kabul and in urban areas are more civically/politically active through social media than users in rural/provincial areas. www.ez-afghanistan.de 4 Afghans are moderately trusting of the information they receive on social media, however remain mindful of the risks The majority of Afghan social media users (59.6%) report that they trust ‘somewhat’ the information shared on social media, however there is a consensus that there are risks involved. Perceptions of risks tend to be centered on inappropriate content and/or misinformation/propaganda that has the potential to worsen ethnic or other tensions and fuel conflict. Users based in Kabul who tend to be the most diverse and the most intense users of social media are also the most conscious of the risks involved. Despite the risks, there is significant potential for social media to have beneficial outcomes for Afghanistan Significant potential for social media 82.3% of users perceive there are opportunities for the government of Afghanistan to engage more with the population through social media. The majority of users perceive that social media had a positive impact on the 2014 election campaign, increasing the connectivity between the candidates and the public, and allowing people who otherwise may not have been able to be involved the opportunity to participate in the campaign. 82.3% of users perceive there are opportunities for the government of Afghanistan to engage more with the population through social media. Overall Afghan social media users perceive that there are significant opportunities for social media to have a positive impact on their country. Recurring themes include the opportunities for more Afghans to become better informed, the increased connectivity and accountability between politicians and their constituents as well as the potential unifying influence of social media; promoting the achievements of Afghanistan and national pride. Recommendations 5 Recommendations Findings of the study strongly suggest the uptake of social media in Afghanistan is increasing and will continue to do so at an increasing rate. It is recommended that this study be repeated on a national level with an expanded sample size to include non-users to obtain a comprehensive picture of the overall penetration of social media in Afghanistan. Findings suggest that Afghan social media users are more likely to be highly educated, politically active and socially mobile, or what could be referred to as ‘agents of change’ in Afghan culture. Thus social media could be a highly effective means of engaging with this important demographic group. However any programmatic activity must take into account that social media users – although increasing – remain a minority in Afghanistan. Prior to selecting social media as the means with which to engage with a target population, detailed information on the level of access of that population should be sought. Three separate yet interlinked barriers to accessing social media should be considered: Physical access; factors such as the availability of electricity in the local area or the ability of the target population to afford an internet connection, Capacity; the presence of the necessary education (including literacy) and technical skills to use the internet and access social media, Culture; locally specific information on interpretations of what is considered inappropriate content and how this may impact the uptake of social media in the local population Social media use is predominantly confined to the private sphere or work environment with very little use of public internet facilities (internet cafés, computers in universities, libraries etc.). The reasons behind this trend may warrant further investigation to determine whether it is the result of a lack of such facilities, a lack of familiarity with using social media in public settings or other cultural issue. Interventions could then be tailored to increase the availability and usage of public facilities to increase access to social media. www.ez-afghanistan.de 6 Through engaging with politicians, promoting candidates and activities such as participating in online debates, social media facilitates new ways for Afghans to participate in the political process. Interventions to increase access may have positive outcomes for the political participation of groups who otherwise may have fewer opportunities such as women, youth, certain tribal groups etc. In the long term, social media may also be a means for such groups to have an increased participation in the public sphere in general, which may have beneficial social implications. Mindful strategies necessary Projects to increase access could thus be accompanied by education programs and awareness building programs regarding ethics and the responsible use of social media. However, strategies to increase access to social media need to be extremely mindful of the potential negative uses of the medium. An increased proportion of the population using social media may result in an increased circulation of inflammatory propaganda and a worsening of existing tensions. Projects to increase access could thus be accompanied by education programs and awareness building programs regarding ethics and the responsible use of social media. Engagement strategies need to take into consideration diversity within a target population, in particular differences between male, female, urban and rural users. For example the potential implications of the more ‘reserved’ online presence of Afghan women-the lower propensity to upload photos and move beyond existing social networks-and the lower propensity of rural users to be politically active must be taken into consideration in the design of interventions. Strategies to engage with journalists should leverage the strengths of social media over traditional media; in particular the lack of regulation and the lack of cost. For example the opportunities for increased connections and diversity of sources could facilitate an increased quality of reportage, both within Afghanistan and abroad. Whilst the lack of regulation and ‘decentralization’ of control may increase the independence of journalists. However as above, interventions must be mindful of potential negative uses of social media. Thus interventions to improve journalists’ use of social media could also be accompanied by capacity building in journalistic ethics and standards, such as truthfulness, accuracy and objectivity. Recommendations Interventions could target capacity gaps in small-medium enterprises (SMEs) use of social media effectively to market themselves to customers. National or international experts could provide online coaching on topics such as self-promotion, generating likes, generating fresh content, tailored micro marketing etc. to increase Afghan SMEs ability to capitalize on the low cost opportunities for marketing offered by social media that are currently being missed. Where the local conditions permit, social media could be promoted more at the provincial and district level as an effective means for politicians to engage with their constituents and vice versa. Interventions could highlight the mutually beneficial effects of increased accountability and increased connectivity social media brings to the political process. This could be achieved through the identification and training of key ‘focal points’ in the districts; respected individuals with large networks, such as teachers, key members of CSOs etc. who could serve as role models for others in the use of social media to engage with politicians. 7 Self-promotion and micro marketing Low cost opportunities for marketing offered by social media. www.ez-afghanistan.de 8 Contents 9 Contents Executive Summary 2 Recommendations i) Methodology ii) Data analysis 5 10 11 1. How Afghans use Social Media 1.1. Profile of the typical user 1.2. Frequency of social media usage 1.3. Times of day social media is used 1.4. Locations of social media use 1.5. Most Popular social media platforms in Afghanistan 1.6. Time spent on social media 1.7. Perceived changes in time spent on social media 1.8. Devices used to access social media 1.9. Language used to access social media 12 14 14 15 15 15 16 17 17 17 2. Why Afghans use Social Media 2.1. Most common uses of social media in Afghanistan 2.2. Most discussed topics on Afghan social media 2.3. Uses of social media by target audience 2.3.1. Youth/Members of CSOs 2.3.2. Businessmen 2.3.3. Politicians 2.3.4. Journalists 20 20 21 22 22 22 24 25 3. Issues of Social Media in Afghanistan 3.1. Barriers to accessing social media 3.1.1. Access 3.1.2. Capacity 3.1.3. Culture 3.2. Levels of trust in the information shared on social media 3.3. Risks of social media usage 26 28 28 28 28 29 30 4. Opportunities for Social Media in Afghanistan 4.1. Differences between social and traditional media 4.2. The role of social media in the 2014 presidential elections 4.3. Government engagement through social media 32 34 35 36 5. Annex 1: Training of field staff & quality control Annex 2: Tables 37 38 www.ez-afghanistan.de 10 i. Methodology ATR Consulting developed a comprehensive research methodology to examine the ways in which Afghans use social media, and their perceptions of the roles, impacts and opportunities of the technology in their country. Number of Respondents Respondents by Provinceby Province inin%% Badakhshan Takhar 11 11 Samangan Kunduz 11 11 11 11 33 Baghlan Balkh Kabul Utilizing both qualitative and quantitative data collection tools the following activities were implemented: Quantitative: A questionnaire including multiple choice and closed-ended questions to identify the ways in which Afghans use social media, including: Who uses social media, How is social media used, Why is social media used, Barriers to using social media, Risks of using social media, Opportunities for social media. Qualitative: Six focus group discussions (FGDs) and six key informant interviews (KIIs) were conducted to complement the information obtained through the questionnaire and gain an insight into the uses of social media by four key target audiences; youth/members of CSO’s, politicians, businessmen and journalists. Respondents by Gender, Age & Location Respondents by Gender, Age & Location Urban 790 Rural Quantitative data was collected in six Northern provinces of Balkh, Kunduz, Baghlan, Takhar, Samangan and Badakhshan as well as in Kabul. Provinces were selected in conjunction with GIZ for their representativeness of the Afghan population who use social media, and their status as key focal areas for German-Afghan Development Cooperation activities. In order to ensure representativeness of the sample, quotas for the different genders, ages and locations were applied to give an adequate conception of the diversity of social media users in Afghanistan. 394 Above 31 579 15 -30 605 Male 594 Female 590 0 400 i) Presentation of the sample 800 Methodology | Data analysis 11 A quota was set for a minimum total sample of 1.152, including 384 respondents from Kabul and 128 in each of the six provinces respectively, a minimum of 384 rural respondents and 768 urban respondents across all provinces, 576 male respondents and 576 female respondents. Larger samples in urban areas and in Kabul reflect the higher concentration of social media users in these areas. Sample sizes allowed for statistically significant comparisons to be drawn between the usage patterns of different groups. The quota was exceeded slightly with a total sample collected of 1.184 respondents. In addition to gender, age and location, respondent’s educational attainment and employment status were also recorded. Respondents Respondentsby byEmployment EmploymentType Type in % Employed 63 Student 11 Unemployed 7 Housewife 3 Retired 0 0 20 40 60 ii) Data analysis To obtain a comprehensive picture of social media use in Afghanistan, data was analysed by gender, location (urban/rural, Kabul based/Northern provinces) and age (15-30/older than 31). All statistics presented in the report have a confidence level of 95% and a maximum confidence interval of 5. Margin of errors for each sample group are presented below. Sample Name Total Size Margin of Error (%) Overall 1.184 2.85 Female 590 4.03 Male 594 4.02 15–30 605 3.98 Above 31 579 4.07 Rural 394 4.94 Urban 790 3.49 Respondents Respondentsby byEducational EducationalAttainment Attainment in % 68 University 27 High School Low Level/ No Education 3 Primary School 2 0 40 80 www.ez-afghanistan.de 12 Executive Summary 1. 13 How Afghans use Social Media In general users tend to be highly educated by Afghan standards, with 67.9% possessing a university degree and 62.1% speaking English. The majority of users are employed (63.4%) with a significant proportion of students (21.6%). The most intensive users by frequency, duration of use and membership to different platforms are concentrated in Kabul and other urban areas. www.ez-afghanistan.de 14 1. How Afghans use Social Media 1.1. Profile of the typical user Frequency of Social Media Use: overall Frequency of Social Media Use: Overall In general users tend to be highly educated by Afghan standards, with 67.9% possessing a university degree and 62.1% speaking English. The majority of users are employed (63.4%) with a significant proportion of students (21.6%). The most intensive users by frequency, duration of use and membership to different platforms are concentrated in Kabul and other urban areas. in % Several times a dayy 28 Once a dayy 23 More than five times a dayy 18 A few times a weekk 9 Once a weekk 8 Rarelyy 7 I am logged on all dayy 4 w I don't know 2 0 1.2. Frequency of social media usage 20 40 Men are more likely to be intensive users of social media, being 20.6% more likely than women to be logged on more than five times per day. Women predominantly log onto social media once per day. The most intensive users are more likely to be located outside of Kabul; with users based in the Northern provinces 12.4% more likely to log on more than five times per day. A user’s age or location in an urban or rural area was found to have no significant bearing on the frequency with which they logged on to social media. TimesofofDay day onSocial to Social Times to to loglog on to Media:Media: overall overall in % 21,4 20 15 13,2 14,4 15,0 10,4 9,7 10 5 In general Afghan social media users are frequently logging on and engaging with different platforms. 72% of social media users log on at least once per day, with 49.1% of total users logging on multiple times every day. For more information “Table 1: Frequency of Social Media Use by Gender, Location & Age” on page <?>. 2,4 0 05:00- 08:00- 12:00- 16:00- 20:00- After I do not 08:00 12:00 16:00 20:00 22:00 22:00 know 67.9 % of social media users possess a university degree and speak English majority of users are employed 62.1 % (63.4 %) 2 How Afghans use Social Media 1.3. Times of day social media is used 15 Locations Media Use: overall Locationsof of Social Social Media Use: Overall Afghans use of social media is generally consistent throughout the day with a small peak in the evening between 8pm and 10pm. in % At home 73 Office (at work) 1.4. Locations of social media use The majority of Afghan social media users do so at home (72.9%). This trend is more pronounced among female users (86.8% compared to 58.9% of men), whilst men are more likely to use social media at work (26.8% compared to 10.5% of women). Users in urban areas were also more likely to use social media at home (72.3% compared to 53.8% of rural users) whilst users above 30 were more likely to be using social media at work (28.6% compared to 18.0% of users under 30). 23 In public places (internet cafes etc.) 5 During commuting 2 Other 1 I do not know 1 0 40 80 For more information “Table 2: Location of Social Media Use: by Gender, Location & Age” on page 38. MostPopular Popular Social Media Platforms: Most Social Media Platforms: overall overall 1.5. Most Popular social media platforms in Afghanistan Facebook is overwhelmingly the most popular platform in Afghanistan, with 87.8% of social media users reporting having a Facebook profile. Google+ is the second most popular platform, with 12.9% of Afghan users, followed by Youtube and Twitter (5.8% and 3.8% respectively). Facebook is more widely used by Afghan men than Afghan women (97.5% compared to 78.1% of women). Men are also more likely to have a Twitter profile (6.6% compared to 1.0% of women). Women however have a greater presence on Google+ (16.8% compared to 8.8% of men). Users based in Kabul are the ‘broadest’ users of social media; the most likely to have profiles on a number of different platforms. None of the users surveyed reported blogging. For more information “Table 3: Most Popular Social Media Platforms: by Gender, Location & Age” on page 38. in % 88 facebook 13 google+ youtube 6 other 5 twitter 4 whatsapp 2 paywast 2 linkedin 1 instagram 1 blogs 0 0 40 80 www.ez-afghanistan.de 16 1.6. Time spent on social media Time spentonon Social (weekly): Media: overall Time Spent Facebook overall in % Less than an hour 23,8 1–3 hours 23,8 3–5 hours 12,8 More than 10 hours 10,2 5–10 hours 8,3 7,7 I don't know 0 The largest proportion of Afghan social media users (47.6%) spend less than three hours logged on to social media1 per week. However a small proportion (10.2%) are intensive users, spending on average more than 10 hours per week logged on. In addition to logging on more frequently, Afghan men are more likely to use social media for longer than Afghan women (14.3% logged on for more than 10 hours per week compared to 6.1% of women). Urban users are also more likely to spend a greater amount of time logged on than rural users (12.9% logged on for more than 10 hours a week compared to 4.8% of rural users), whilst users in Kabul were the most likely to be logged on for more than 10 hours per week. For more information “Table 4: Time spent on Facebook by Gender, Location & Age” on page <?>. 20 1.7. Perceived changes in time spent on social media Afghans perceive that they are using social media more than in the past; Changes in TimeofSpent Social Media compared with a large majority userson(65.1%) reporting that they had spent more to the Previous Year: overall time this year than the previous year, whilst 14.2% of users reported that they are using social media less this year. Changes in Time Spent on Social Media compared to the Previous Year: overall in % More Time 65 Less time 14 The same amount of time 14 The increase in usage was largely attributed to increased levels of education, increased internet access, an increase in the skill level in using social media, as well as increased relevance of social media to Afghan society as a critical mass of users develop in some areas. 7 I don't know 0 20 40 60 ‘My usage of Social Media has increased a lot in the past five years because I need it more now than I did in the past, also now I inhave more onover how Anticipated Changes Timegained Spent on Socialskills Media theit.’ next Year: overall to use Journalist – Mazar-e Sharif Anticipated Changes in Time Spent on Social Media over the next Year: overall ‘Now the people of Afghanistan realize that social media has an important role in Afghanistan and that it is so helpful and that in the next five years users of social Youth – Mazar-e Sharif media will increase.’ in % More Time 74 I don‘t know 10 The same amount of time 9 Less time 7 0 20 40 60 1 Sample sizes for users of social media platforms other than Facebook did not yield sufficient sample sizes to make statistically significant comparisons between results. However as Facebook represents the overwhelming majority of social media use in Afghanistan, time on Facebook is taken as representative of time spent on social media overall in Afghanistan. 2 How Afghans use Social Media This trend is widely expected to continue, with 73.6% of users perceiving that they will use social media more next year than they do currently. 17 Devices used to access social media 1.8. Devices used to access social media Smartphones are the predominant means to access social media in Afghanistan (76.0% of users) followed by personal computers (28.4%). The prominence of smart phones reflects the wider trend of the exponential expansion in mobile phone penetration in Afghanistan since 20012. Other factors such as difficulties surrounding accessing fixed line infrastructure and various aid programs targeting the expansion of mobile phone services may have further contributed to the prominence of smartphones in accessing social media. A very small portion of users (3%) access social media on public computers (internet café, university, library etc.). This is likely derived in part from a lack of such facilities, but may also be indicative of a cultural lack of familiarity with the concept of using social media in public. Men are more likely than women to access social media on a smartphone (81.5% compared to 70.5% of women) whilst women are the most likely to use a personal computer (31.0% compared to 25.8% of men). Smartphones are also more prevalent amongst users under the age of 30 (84.3% compared to 68.1% of users over 30) and users in rural areas (64.2% compared to 32.4% of urban users). For more information “Table 5: Devices used to access Social Media: by Gender, Location & Age” on page 39. 1.9. Language used to access social media English is the most common language to access social media in Kabul and the Northern provinces (62.1%3 of users) followed by Dari (30.1%), whilst a much smaller proportion of users are accessing social media in Pashtu (3.3%). Men are more likely to access social media in English (73.1% compared to 51.0% of female users), whilst women are more likely to be accessing social media in Dari (39.7% compared to 20.5% of male users). Social media use in English is also far more prevalent in users based in Kabul, urban areas and under 30 years of age. For more information “Table 6: Languages used to access Social Media: by Gender, Location & Age” on page 39 . 2 3 Language used to to access Social Media: overall overall Language used access Social Media: in % 62,1 English Dari/Persian 30,1 Pashtu 3,3 Urdu 0,8 Other 0,4 French 0,2 0 20 40 60 Altai Consulting 2010 ‘Afghan Media in 2010’ p35 Crosschecking this finding against a review of Afghan social media suggests this figure may be over-reported, particularly for Facebook where Dari is more common, Twitter is predominantly used in English www.ez-afghanistan.de 2 2. Why Afghans use Social Media Connection with family and friends is the most common use of social media for Afghans followed by making new connections. Although the predominant uses of social media could be described as either social or entertainment, a significant proportion of Afghan users use social media for ‘non-entertainment’ purposes including; following news, engaging in debates, reporting abuses of human rights and corruption and posting political messages. 20 2. Why Afghans use Social Media 2.1. Most common uses of social media in Afghanistan Most Uses of Social Media: overall overall MostCommon Common Uses of Social Media: Connection with family and friends is the most common use of social media for Afghans followed by making new connections. Although the predominant uses of social media could be described as either social or entertainment, a significant proportion of Afghan users use social media for ‘non-entertainment’ purposes including; following news, engaging in debates, reporting abuses of human rights and corruption and posting political messages. in % Family & Friends News New connections Photos Following individuals There are some notable differences between the ways men and women surveyed use social media. Men are far more likely to use social media to post photos and make new connections. Whilst women are less ‘outgoing’ with their online presence, (i.e. connecting with new people outside their existing social network) with a lower proportion of female users posting photos (37.8% compared to 68.9% of men) and making new connections (33.7% compared to 75.8%). Whilst Afghan men engage with people they know as well as seeking to make new connections, Afghan women appear to predominantly be using social media to engage with people they already know. Browsing products Debates Following groups Reporting on HR & corruption Mobilizing people Organizing events Political messages Games 0 20 40 60 Men are also much more likely to use social media to follow news (72.7% compared to 39.2% of women) and engage in what could be described as the ‘political’ uses of social media, including; engaging in debates, mobilizing people, reporting corruption and human rights abuses and posting political messages. Urban and Kabul-based users have the greatest diversity in their usage of social media; more active in both the civic/political and recreational uses. A user’s age was found to have no significant bearing on why they used social media. +68 % men post photos on social media compared 37.8% of women +33 % women make new connections of social media compared 68.9% of male user 2 Why Afghans use Social Media 21 Usesof of Social Social Media: byby gender Uses Media: gender in % 2.2. Most discussed topics on Afghan social media In keeping with the dominant reasons for Afghans using social media, sport and celebrities were found to be the most discussed topics (39.7% of users) closely followed by domestic politics (38.5%). A notable proportion of users also discuss games and movies, the insurgency and issues specific to their local community. In addition participants reported that social media is frequently used as a platform to discuss the achievements of Afghanistan, and various stories that are seen to contribute to patriotism, the country’s unification and development. Products Political messages Reporting on HR & corruption Mobilizing people Organizing events Following groups Following individuals Debates News ‘We share topics regarding peace and the country being united.’ Politician – Kabul ‘We collect and share information on Islam, the economy, Afghan culture and history etc.’ Youth – Mazar-e Sharif With the exception of sport and celebrities - which men are far more likely to be discussing (50.7% compared to 28.6% of female users) - Afghan men and women are largely discussing the same topics on social media. Kabul-based and urban users are slightly more likely to be discussing domestic politics on social media (48.6% and 46.5% compared to 33.5% and 37.1% of Northern Provinces and rural users respectively). A user’s age was found to have no significant bearing on topics being discussed. For more information “Table 7: Most Discussed Topics on Social Media by Gender, Location & Age” on page 40. 39.7% of social media users discuss sports and celebrities 38.8% of users discuss politics Games New connections Photos Family & Friends 0 20 Male 40 60 80 Female Most discussed Topics on Afghan Social Media: overall Most discussed Topics on Afghan Social Media: overall in % 40 Sport and celebrities 39 Domestic politics Games/movies 9 Community issues 9 Insurgency 9 4 I do not know Economy 3 Foreign Affairs 3 Other 1 Justice issues 1 0 20 40 www.ez-afghanistan.de 22 2.3. Uses of social media by target audience Four key target audiences; youth/members of Civil Society Organizations (CSOs), businessmen, politicians and journalists were asked to elaborate on the specific ways they use social media in their respective occupations. 2.3.1. Youth/Members of CSOs The majority of youth respondents reported that they use social media to receive and share information. This was frequently connected to education and study (including practicing English), however also included themes such as religion and politics. Participants also reported that social media allowed them to connect with politicians. Members of CSOs reported using social media to receive information, connect with groups in different countries, publicize their campaigns and mobilize their members. ‘I use social media for my university lessons; social media also paves the way for youth to reach politicians.’ Youth/CSO Member – Mazar-e Sharif ‘I read about international issues, educational topics, cultural topics and Islamic topics on social media and share this information with my friends.’ Youth – Mazar-e Sharif ‘I am a member of civil society and I use social media. I use Facebook and Google+ for receiving educational information, and I also connect with the different groups. We also share Islamic information.’ Youth/CSO Member – Kabul 2.3.2. Businessmen Afghan businesses are using social media to make connections on both the demand and supply of their enterprises. On the supply side social media is used to establish and maintain relationships with suppliers, as well as to keep abreast of developments in other countries. On the demand side, social media is used to engage with customers, to promote the philosophy and activities of the business and to publicize special offers and promotions etc. For small-medium sized enterprises, it appears there is yet to be a widespread take-up of marketing through social media; larger firms - particularly those in the communication technology and employment sectors- already market extensively through social media. 2 Why Afghans use Social Media 23 For example telecommunications companies MTN, Roshan Connects and Etisalat Wireless each have more than 100,000 fans on Facebook1. Whilst employment websites Jobs in Afghanistan and Wazifa each have approximately 65,000 fans2. Regarding the marketing activities of smaller enterprises, participants reported a lack of knowledge, a lack of resources, declining market conditions leaving less resources available to dedicate to marketing and the lack of familiarity of the Afghan public of being marketed to through this medium as impediments to more Afghan businesses using social media. ‘Social media is useful in any field of business. In foreign countries they perform all kinds of businesses on social media, for example here we sell cars via Facebook, we post images of the car and find customers this way.’ Businessman – Kunduz ‘We are a medium sized business and are not at the stage of advertising our products on Facebook, however we have made many beneficial contacts.’ Businessman – Kunduz ‘We realized we needed wider communication with different countries, Pakistan, Iran and others so we realized we needed to use social media. We need to know about the prices of different items, because these are groceries that we are importing, we need to exact prices that day, so now we are using social media and when prices go up and down we get this information directly.’ Businessman – Kabul ‘We have a Facebook page for the business but we don’t know how to promote it or how to generate more likes.’ Businessman – Kabul 1 2 Socialbakers 2014 ‘Afghanistan Facebook Statistics’ retrieved from http://www.socialbakers.com/facebook-statistics/afghanistan ibid www.ez-afghanistan.de 24 2.3.3. Politicians Politicians in Afghanistan have embraced social media as a means to engage with their constituents. This includes through activities such as campaigning, publicizing different initiatives and achievements, and mobilizing support. Both leading Presidential candidates Dr. Abdullah Abdullah and Ashraf Ghani Ahmadzai maintain an active social media presence. Each candidate has a Facebook page with more than 350,000 fans, and both are regular users of twitter to engage with and mobilize supporters. Politicians also regard the two-way flow of communication through social media as vital for remaining connected to their constituents, being aware of their concerns and responsive to their needs. Several politicians maintain an active personal presence, posting items such as poems and personal images to build their profile. Politicians also saw social media as a useful means to connect with other politicians, both in Afghanistan and abroad. ‘I don’t always have time to use social media myself because I am busy with people, but the staff of the Ministry use it every day to engage with people. The engagement is two-way and people can contact me through social media, especially people such as women and youth that otherwise wouldn’t be able to contact me.’ Politician – Kabul ‘We use social media to spread messages of unity, to bring peace and to mobilize the people, to encourage youth to be active and to pursue an education, to improve themselves. We also use social media to impress the local people with our achievements.’ Politician - Kunduz 2 Why Afghans use Social Media 25 2.3.4. Journalists Journalists in Afghanistan have embraced the use of social media, and rely on it heavily for both receiving and disseminating information. The lack of restrictions and government regulations on social media is seen as highly beneficial to freedom of information, while the ability to access different sources and the lack of cost is seen to improve the quality of reportage. Some journalists also report the degree of anonymity that social media users enjoy allows them to publish information they would not be able to in the traditional media for fear of reprisal. Journalists also report using social media to connect with journalists and organizations in other countries. Many traditional media outlets have also embraced the use of social media, with virtually every major TV and radio outlet maintaining an active twitter account, whilst a lesser proportion maintain a presence on Facebook. ‘In general I publish my reports on social media, as well as other useful information. Officials monitor what is posted, and sometimes they react. For example a few days ago a traffic vehicle was attacked by some unknown people, we reported the incident on Facebook and local officials reacted and conducted an operation in the area.’ Journalist – Kunduz ‘There are opportunities for social media in every profession, for journalists we can receive more information with less costs, this helps us in improving in our jobs. We can give the right information to the people via social media without restrictions.’ Journalist – Kunduz ‘We can share all kinds of messages via social media, like development, reconstruction etc. We contact people via social media and we share important messages with each other. We can publish all kinds of reports on social media and it makes our lives easier because there are no restrictions. Social media improves the information flows and the connections between people.’ Journalist – Mazar-e Sharif www.ez-afghanistan.de 3 3. Issues of Social Media in Afghanistan The emergence of social media in Afghanistan has been accompanied by certain issues, such as barriers to Afghans accessing platforms, and real and perceived risks, on both an individual and collective level of using social media. 28 3. Issues of Social Media in Afghanistan 3.1. Barriers to accessing social media Barriers to using Social Media: overall Barriers to using Social Media: overall in % Can’t afford internet connection 18 Can’t afford device 9 No electricity 7 The largest perceived barrier to accessing social media is not being able to afford an internet connection. Other notable barriers include not being able to afford a smartphone, computer or other device to access the internet and not having electricity1. Inappropriate content 0 Participants of Focus Group Discussions and Key Informant Interviews expressed that there are several different dimensions to the barriers preventing Afghans using social media that can be categorized as pertaining to access, culture and capacity. No interest 0 3.1.1. Access Don’t know how to use device 0 I don’t know 0 Access refers to those economic, developmental or other issues that prevent Afghans accessing social media. For example the lack of electricity and communications infrastructure as well as the costs associated with accessing the internet is cited by many as barriers to more Afghans using social media. Business owners also cite the recent economic downturn coinciding with the uncertainty surrounding the 2014 elections and ISAF troop withdrawal as the reason for businesses not having the resources to dedicate to social media. No time 5 Forbidden to use it 2 0 20 3.1.2. Capacity Capacity refers to a lack of technical skills and knowledge to use social media, with lack of education/illiteracy a barrier for many Afghans. The business sector also cites a lack of knowledge and relevant technical skills as a reason more small and medium enterprises don’t market more through social media. 3.1.3. Culture Culture refers to issues where the topics discussed or content shared on social media is not compatible with dominant Afghan sensibilities. 1 Note that the survey was administered to people who self-identified as social media users, non-users were not interviewed, thus respondents were asked what things in the past had been barriers to them using social media, and what they were perceived were barriers for others 3 Issues of Social Media in Afghanistan Cultural issues also refer to factors specific to the Afghan context that impede the uptake of social media. For example one politician remarked that there are some politicians that could not create a profile for themselves on social media, as their involvement in the civil war meant that they had many enemies who would sabotage their online presence. 29 Trust in the Information shared on Social Media: overall Trust in the Information shared on Social Media: Overall in % Somewhat 60 Yes ‘Still many people don’t have access to social media because of insecurity, poverty and illiteracy.’ Journalist – Kunduz ‘Many people are very resistant to change, they think that the language on social media is bad as well as the content. Also people who were involved in the civil war cannot use social media, they know that if they have a high profile then people will name them as murderers and warlords.’ Politician – Kabul 21 No 9 I do not know 1 0 20 40 60 ‘Frequently there are issues with the government , we receive notices from the Ministry telling us to block certain websites, for example not long ago there was a video on Youtube about the Prophet, and Youtube was blocked for a certain time, this was worldwide and lasted several months.’ Businessman – Kabul 3.2. Levels of trust in the information shared on social media Afghan users have a moderate level of trust in the information circulated on social media. The majority of users (59.6%) report that they trust the information they see on social media ‘somewhat’, whilst 21.4% report that they trust fully the information they see. Not completely trusting information on social media was largely attributed to an awareness of the potential misuses and impunity; that anyone could say whatever they liked. A user’s gender, location and age was found to have no significant bearing on their reported levels of trust. +59% of social media users trust the information they see on social media +21% of social media users fully trust the information they see on social media www.ez-afghanistan.de 30 Perceptions of Social being a Risk: overall Using Social Media poses Media a Risk for Afghans: overall I don't agree 50 I agree completely 16 I don't know 4 0 20 Afghan social media users are mindful that there may be risks involved, with 45.5% either agreeing or agreeing ‘somewhat’ with the statement that using social media poses a risk. Perceptions of risk are largely consistent between male and female users. Interestingly Kabul based users who tend to use a greater number of platforms for a greater variety of purposes also have the highest conception of risk (27.4% of respondents). 29 I agree somewhat 3.3. Risks of social media usage 40 60 For more information “Table 8: Social Media is a Risk: by Gender, Location & Age” on page 40. Perceptions of risk tend to be centered around inappropriate content, harmful cultural influences and the potential for social media to be divisive and fuel conflict. A recurring theme is the potential for social media to be used to spread misinformation that may advance negative ethnic or religious stereotypes and fuel existing and/or reignite historical conflicts. Also mentioned is the fear that the exposure to excessive external influences facilitated by social media will result in a gradual erosion of Afghan culture and traditions, especially among the youth. In addition journalists cite a risk threat of backlash against them for posting certain content on social media. ‘Recently there have been a lot of political discussions on social media, many things were written that should not have been because they fuel conflicts between the people.’ Youth – Kabul ‘Some people use Facebook to disseminate inappropriate news and hurtful videos. These have bad effects on the minds of youths, in our country we have laws to regulate these things but their implementation is weak.’ Journalist – Kunduz 3 Issues of Social Media in Afghanistan ‘It can be very damaging in a situation where social media is used to increase the bias and hatred between two tribes, language groups or religious groups. Social media can allow these bad messages to spread.’ Journalist – Mazar-e Sharif 31 Risks of Social Media Afghans are most concerned Risks of Social Media Afghans are most concerned about: overall about: overall in % 26 Invasion of privacy 21 Bad influence on youth Specifically regarding the types of risks, Afghans are most concerned about invasions of privacy (25.8%) followed by a potential bad influence on youth (21.0%). Inappropriate content and misinformation/propaganda are also notable concerns (18.3% and 16.4% respectively). There are several notable differences in perceptions of risk between male and female social media users. Male users are significantly more concerned about invasions of privacy (32.2% compared to 11.7% of female users), whilst female users are predominantly concerned with social media being a bad influence on youth and a distraction from work/study. Perceptions of risk also differ significantly between locations. Kabul-based and urban users are the most likely to be concerned about inappropriate content, online scams and harmful influences on the youth. Whilst users outside of Kabul are far more likely to be concerned about misinformation and propaganda. A user’s age was found to have no significant bearing on perceptions of risk. For more information “Table 9: Perceptions of Risks of Social Media by Location & Age” on page 40 18 Inappropriate content Misinformation/Propaganda 16 Distraction from work/study 16 11 Scams/online crime 2 I do not know 2 Other 0 20 Risks of Social Media: by gender Risks of Social Media: by gender in % I do not know Other Distraction from work/study Bad influence on youth Scams/online crime Misinformation/Propaganda Inappropriate content Invasion of privacy 0% 20% Male Female www.ez-afghanistan.de 4. Opportunities for Social Media in Afghanistan Afghans perceive several key differences between social and traditional media (television, radio, and printed media) that carry with them risks but also opportunities. The ‘decentralized’ nature of social 4 media and the lack of government control are commonly seen as one of the most significant differences. The potential for the two way flow of information (for example between politicians and their constituents or between suppliers and their customers) is also seen as key. A recurring theme among participants was that the control of traditional media is concentrated in the hands of a few, and is vulnerable to manipulation by external sources. Whilst the costs associated with advertising/engaging through traditional media were prohibitive for the majority of Afghans. 34 4. Opportunities for Social Media in Afghanistan 4.1. Differences between social and traditional media Afghans perceive several key differences between social and traditional media (television, radio, and printed media) that carry with them risks but also opportunities. The ‘decentralized’ nature of social media and the lack of government control are commonly seen as one of the most significant differences. The potential for the two way flow of information (for example between politicians and their constituents or between suppliers and their customers) is also seen as key. A recurring theme among participants was that the control of traditional media is concentrated in the hands of a few, and is vulnerable to manipulation by external sources. Whilst the costs associated with advertising/engaging through traditional media were prohibitive for the majority of Afghans. Some participants noted that social media was only effective in areas where a high proportion of the population were educated. Whereas in other areas, television and radio were still the most effective means of reaching the people. ‘Social media is under the control of the individual, each person can say what he or she wishes.’ Journalist – Kabul ‘It is possible to access social media anywhere, but for traditional media most people don’t have access. Social media allows people to share their own topics but traditional media is controlled by only a few people. Traditional media needs TV, time, space and power etc. whereas social media can be accessed anywhere by anyone.’ Youth – Kabul ‘Social Media works in areas where there is education, in other areas the TV is the most useful means of reaching the people. The radio is also useful in some areas. Traditional media is the most useful in these cases but the issue is that the engagement is only one way. People cannot engage with the government through traditional media.’ Politician - Kabul 4 Opportunities for Social Media in Afghanistan 35 4.2. The role of social media in the 2014 presidential elections in Afghanistan In general Afghan social media users perceive the technology played a positive role on the 2014 Presidential election campaign. By facilitating the increased sharing of information, increased engagement between politicians and the public and providing new ways for people to campaign and show support for candidates, social media had a significant impact on the nature of the campaign in 2014. Some participants reported that for security or other reasons, they would not support their preferred candidate publically, but that social media had provided an avenue for them to participate in the campaign process. However the negative role of social media in spreading misinformation and fuelling conflict during the campaign was also noted. ‘Social media played a very positive role in the elections because each minute reports were available to the people, people could express their ideas, share information and young people could connect with their favorite candidates and ask them questions.’ Youth – Mazar-e Sharif ‘Social media played a very positive role in the elections; it allowed people to campaign for their own candidates without the interference of the government.’ Youth – Kabul www.ez-afghanistan.de 36 4.3. Government engagement through social media The Government of Afghanistan should use Social Media more to engage with the public: The Government of Afghanistan should use Social overall Media more to engage with the public: Overal in % I agree completely 48 I agree somewhat 34 I don't agree 10 I don't know 7 0 10 +82% 20 30 Supportive or somewhat supportive of Government of Afghanistan Social Media engagement 40 50 Afghan users are supportive of the government using social media more to engage with the population, with a total of 82.3% reporting that were supportive or somewhat supportive. A user’s gender, location and age had no significant bearing on levels of support for increased government engagement. Currently the government presence is largely limited to individual politicians. The spokesperson of the Ministry of Interior Sediq Sediqqi maintains a twitter account that is updated regularly (1-2 times per week), whilst various government institutions such as the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) maintain twitter pages that are not regularly updated (1-2 times per month). Afghans perceive there to be significant opportunities for social media use to increase, with beneficial outcomes for the country in the future. Opportunities for increased connectivity between people in different areas, increased connectivity between leaders and the public and potential for increased unification and national pride are recurring themes. Afghans also see an education potential in social media and opportunities for more Afghans to become better informed. There is also the perception that Afghan businesses have an opportunity to capitalize on the new low cost ways to engage with customers, further facilitated by the tendency of Afghans to adopt new communication technologies quickly. ‘Social media can be used in any place at any time, there is more freedom to it, and it is the bridge that builds relationships between people around the country and in different countries.’ Journalist – Kunduz ‘We should work to expand social media until all people of Afghanistan receive information about security, the economy and culture etc. We receive information from our social networks about our world and the things that are important in life.’ Youth – Mazar-e Sharif Annex 1 37 Annex 1: Training of field staff & quality control i) Training of and support to surveyors and field researchers Quantitative data was collected by two male and two female surveyors in Kabul and one surveyor of each gender in the respective Northern provinces. Prior to commencing data collection all surveyors were given four days of training. Qualitative Data was collected by experienced field researchers including ATR permanent staff. Day 1 Theoretical training, including a presentation of ATR, GIZ, the Social media study and overall research objectives, an introduction to social media in Afghanistan, and an exercise on the different roles social media may play in Afghan culture Day 2 Practical exercises on how to administer data collection tools, role-plays to simulate different circumstances likely to be encountered during data collection. Means of increasing willingness to participate means to address normative responses and a review of the finer points of data collection methodologies. Day 3 Practical training focusing on piloting the questionnaire, addressing issues and consolidating lessons learned Day 4 Sharing experiences from the pilot and solidifying lessons learned, coding of questionnaires, monitoring and quality assurance measures, reporting requirements ii) Quality control To ensure data was of an acceptable quality a comprehensive program of monitoring activities accompanied data collection. Monitors travelled to each province under study and conducted unannounced field visits and ‘spot checks’ during data collection. Monitors compiled reports on data collection activities in all provinces, took photos and where feasible voice recordings of data collection, providing daily updates to Research Team Leaders in Kabul. In addition, after the completion of data collection, Monitoring Officers called at random approximately 10% of total respondents to verify that they had been interviewed, crosscheck responses and to obtain feedback on surveyor performance. Field Researchers took photos, full audio recordings and transcripts of all FGDs and KIIs conducted. In addition monitors contacted approximately 15% of FGD participants to further verify that they had been interviewed and obtain feedback on field researcher performance. www.ez-afghanistan.de 38 Annex 2: Tables Table 1: Frequency of Social Media Use by Gender, Location & Age in% Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North Rarely 10.7 Once a week 14.9 4.2 7.4 7.5 8.2 7.1 7.4 7.4 1.5 10.7 7.0 6.1 9.2 7.1 9.3 6.3 12.1 8.1 9.7 13.3 7.2 11.4 6.9 Once a day 29.0 16.8 22.6 23.0 22.8 23.0 21.8 24.0 Several times a day 25.8 29.8 26.1 28.6 30.4 26.5 26.8 28.8 More than five times a day 7.5 28.1 18.3 17.6 9.5 21.9 18.8 16.8 I am logged on all day 2.5 4.5 3.3 3.7 6.4 2.1 3.5 3.6 I don't know 2.5 2.4 3.3 2.0 1.5 2.9 2.6 2.2 A few times a week 15 -30 Above 30 Table 2: Location of Social Media Use: by Gender, Location & Age in % Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North 15 -30 Above 30 Office (at work) 10.5 26.8 17.0 16.8 19.7 25.2 18.0 28.6 At home 86.8 58.9 53.8 72.3 79.3 70.9 80.0 66.1 In public places 1.0 8.2 3.3 4.8 6.4 3.8 6.2 3.1 During commuting 0.8 3.0 0.3 2.3 4.1 0.9 2.6 1.3 Other: 0.0 1.7 2.5 1.3 2.6 0.0 1.4 0.3 I do not know 0.0 0.0 0.5 0.3 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 I am logged on all day 2.5 4.5 3.3 3.7 6.4 2.1 3.5 3.6 I don't know 2.5 2.4 3.3 2.0 1.5 2.9 2.6 2.2 Table 3: Most Popular Social Media Platforms: by Gender, Location & Age in% Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North 78.1 97.5 91.6 85.9 80.1 91.7 91.4 84.1 1.0 6.6 3.0 4.2 7.4 2.0 4.1 3.5 Linkedin 0.5 1.7 1.0 1.1 2.3 0.5 1.2 1.0 Google+ 16.8 8.8 12.4 13.2 18.9 10.0 13.1 12.8 Youtube 5.9 5.7 2.5 7.5 14.3 1.6 6.8 4.8 Paywast 0.3 2.7 1.5 1.5 2.8 0.9 1.5 1.6 Instagram 0.5 0.8 0.3 0.9 1.8 0.1 0.7 0.7 Whatsapp 1.4 2.7 1.0 2.5 4.9 0.6 2.1 1.9 Blogs 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Other 5.8 3.4 2.5 7.8 15.9 1.6 3.0 10.9 Facebook Twitter 15 -30 Above 30 Annex 2 39 Table 4: Time spent on Facebook by Gender, Location & Age in% Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North Less than an hour 23.4 24.2 27.4 22.0 10.7 30.3 26.9 20.6 1-3 hours 19.5 28.1 28.7 21.4 17.4 27.0 26.1 21.4 3-5 hours 12.9 12.8 14.5 12.0 15.6 11.5 13.9 11.7 5-10 hours 5.6 10.9 5.3 9.7 13.0 5.9 6.1 10.5 More than 10 hours 6.1 14.3 4.8 12.9 18.2 6.3 8.8 11.7 I don't know 15 -30 Above 30 10.8 4.5 9.9 6.6 3.8 9.6 8.1 7.3 I am logged on all day 2.5 4.5 3.3 3.7 6.4 2.1 3.5 3.6 I don't know 2.5 2.4 3.3 2.0 1.5 2.9 2.6 2.2 Table 5: Devices used to access Social Media: by Gender, Location & Age in% Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North 15 -30 Above 30 Smartphone 70.5 81.5 64.2 32.4 65.7 81.1 84.3 68.1 Personal computer 31.0 25.8 13.5 31.5 46.0 19.7 25.2 31.4 Public computer 1.2 5.2 1.0 3.4 6.4 1.6 3.6 2.8 Tablet 0.7 0.8 0.0 2.0 3.1 0.8 1.0 2.0 Table 6: Languages used to access Social Media: by Gender, Location & Age in% Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North 15 -30 Above 30 English 51.0 73.1 39.8 65.2 71.9 57.3 72.4 52.2 Dari/Persian 39.7 20.5 34.8 42.8 9.0 40.5 27.3 47.6 Pashtu 1.9 4.7 0.0 3.8 7.2 1.4 2.8 3.8 French 0.0 0.3 0.0 0.3 0.5 0.0 0.2 0.3 Urdu 0.3 1.2 0.0 1.0 2.0 0.1 1.0 0.5 Other 0.0 0.8 0.0 0.6 1.3 4.3 0.7 0.2 www.ez-afghanistan.de 40 Table 7: Most Discussed Topics on Social Media by Gender, Location & Age in% Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North 15 -30 Above 30 Sport and celebrities 28.6 50.7 46.3 36.4 37.8 45.2 42.1 37.4 Entertainment 12.7 5.9 6.6 10.6 9.4 9.9 10.7 7.9 Domestic politics 35.4 41.6 48.6 33.5 37.1 46.5 39.9 37.2 Insurgency 13.6 3.5 12.3 6.7 7.6 10.5 9.0 8.1 Economy 4.4 1.3 0.8 3.9 4.3 2.8 3.1 2.6 Foreign Affairs 2.9 2.4 5.4 1.3 0.8 3.5 2.6 2.6 Community issues 7.1 10.1 16.9 4.5 4.1 11.5 8.1 9.1 Justice issues 1.0 0.7 0.3 1.1 0.8 1.0 0.5 1.2 Other 0.0 2.2 3.3 0.0 0.0 1.6 1.4 0.8 I don’t know 6.6 0.8 5.4 2.9 4.6 3.4 3.6 3.8 Table 8: Social Media is a Risk: by Gender, Location & Age in% Female Male Rural Urban Kabul North No 51.9 47.6 58.6 45.3 32.0 58.5 51.2 48.2 Somewhat 27.6 30.5 25.4 30.9 36.6 25.3 30.7 27.3 Yes 16.6 16.2 10.4 19.4 27.4 11.0 14.2 18.7 3.2 5.2 5.6 3.5 2.3 5.2 3.6 4.8 I don't know 15 -30 Above 30 Table 9: Perceptions of Risks of Social Media by Location & Age in% Rural Urban Kabul North 15 -30 Above 30 15 -30 Above 30 Invasion of privacy 28.2 27.8 23.8 26.9 28.8 23.0 42.1 Inappropriate content 12.7 24.6 33.2 11.0 19.7 17.0 10.7 7.9 Misinformation/Propaganda 17.5 16.1 7.2 20.9 15.5 17.2 39.9 37.2 Scams/online crime 10.2 14.2 18.2 7.9 11.9 10.7 9.0 8.1 Bad influence on youth 19.3 26.5 31.5 15.9 21.1 21.0 8.1 9.1 Distraction from work/study 16.8 21.3 20.5 14.1 19.7 12.9 0.5 1.2 37.4 Other 4.1 2.5 1.0 2.0 1.7 1.7 1.4 0.8 I do not know 1.5 3.2 4.9 1.1 1.7 3.0 3.6 3.8 41 Photo credits: All photos © GIZ, except page 12/13 and 26/27 © ATR Consulting www.ez-afghanistan.de Published by Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH Registered Offices Bonn and Eschborn, Germany Editor ATR Consulting Design Barbara Reuter | barbarareuter-grafik@web.de Photo credits © GIZ, ATR Consulting Contact GIZ Office Kabul Epr-unit-afghanistan@giz.de Iwww.ez-afghanistan.de For questions on the methodology please contact ATR Consulting | contact@atr-consulting.com As of June 2014