Great Lessons for Women’s History Era of Reform Lesson Guide Presented by TCI Assessments, Assessment Key, and Guide to Reading Notes: Have been removed from this doc. www.teachtci.com (800) 497-6138 R e s p o n s e C H A P T E R G r o u p 18 An Era of Reform To what extent did the reform movements of the mid-1800s improve life for Americans? Overview Materials Students examine the reform movements of the mid-1800s to evaluate to what extent they improved life for Americans. In a Response Group activity, they debate the extent to which grievances from the Declaration of Sentiments have been redressed today. History Alive! The United States Through Industrialism Interactive Student Notebooks Visual 18 Lesson Masters Objectives In the course of reading this chapter and participating in the classroom activity, students will Social Studies • analyze how transcendentalism contributed to the spirit of reform. • describe the conditions in prisons, in schools, for slaves, and for women in the mid-1800s, and identify the reform movements that resulted. • Student Handouts 18A and 18B (1 of each for every 3 students) • Information Master 18 (1 transparency) • Vocabulary Development handout (1 per student, on colored paper) • evaluate how well reform movements improved life for Americans. • explain the contributions of such reformers as Horace Mann, William Lloyd Garrison, Frederick Douglas, and Elizabeth Cady Stanton. • debate the degree to which the grievances from the Declaration of Sentiments have been redressed today. Language Arts • deliver persuasive presentations. Social Studies Vocabulary Key Content Terms reform, Second Great Awakening, transcendentalism, abolitionist, Seneca Falls Convention, Declaration of Sentiments Academic Vocabulary intuition, conform, individualism, devote An Era of Reform 247 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com P l a n n i n g G u i d e Activity Suggested Time Materials Preview 15 minutes • Interactive Student Notebooks • Visual 18 Vocabulary Development 30–40 minutes • History Alive! The United States Through Industrialism • Interactive Student Notebooks • Vocabulary Development handout Response Group 75 minutes (1.5 regular periods) (0.75 block period) • History Alive! The United States Through Industrialism • Student Handouts 18A and 18B • Information Master 18 Processing 20 minutes • Interactive Student Notebooks Assessment 40 minutes • Chapter 18 Assessment 248 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com P r o c e d u r e s Preview 1 Have students analyze a reform song. Project Visual 18: Let Us All Speak Our Minds and have a volunteer read the lyrics aloud. Then have students complete the Preview questions. 2 Have students share their responses in pairs or with the class. 3 Explain the connection between the Preview and Chapter 18. Tell students that this song was written in the 1800s to protest the unequal treatment of women. During this period, reformers—people who work to improve and correct injustices—strove not only to end slavery and improve education, but also to promote equal rights for women. In this chapter, students will examine the reform movements of the period to evaluate the extent to which they improved life for Americans. Vocabulary Development 1 Introduce the Key Content Terms. Have students locate the Key Content Terms for the chapter in their Interactive Student Notebooks. These are important terms that will help them understand the main ideas of the chapter. Ask volunteers to identify any familiar terms and how they might be used in a sentence. 2 Have students complete a Vocabulary Development handout. Give each student a copy of the Vocabulary Development handout of your choice from the Reading Toolkit at the back of the Lesson Masters. These handouts provide extra practice and support, depending on your students’ needs. Review the completed handout by asking volunteers to share one answer for each term. Reading 1 Introduce the Essential Question and have students read Section 18.1. Have students identify the Essential Question: To what extent did the reform movements of the mid-1800s improve life for Americans? Then have them read Section 18.1. Afterward, have them use information from the reading and the image that opens the chapter to propose some possible answers to the Essential Question. V i s u a l 1 8 History Alive! The United States Through Industrialism 41 Let Us All Speak Our Minds Men tell us ’tis fit that wives should submit To their husbands, submissively, weakly Tho’ whatever they say their wives should obey, Unquestioning, stupidly, meekly. Our husbands would make us their own dictum take Without ever a wherefore or why for it. But I don’t and I can’t, and I won’t and I shan’t, No, I will speak my mind if I die for it. For we know it’s all fudge to say man’s the best judge Of what should be, and shouldn’t, and so on. That woman should bow, nor attempt to say how She considers that matters should go on. I never yet gave up myself thus a slave, However my husband might try for it. For I can’t and I won’t, and I shan’t and I don’t, But I will speak my mind if I die for it. And all ladies I hope who’ve with husbands to cope, With the rights of the sex will not trifle. We all, if we choose our tongues but to use, Can all opposition soon stifle. Let man if he will then bid us be still, And silent, a price he’ll pay high for it. For we won’t and we can’t, and we don’t and we shan’t, Let us all speak our minds if we die for it. (Composed by J. G. Maeder and William Brough) © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute Visual 18 Vocabulary Development: Metaphors Have students analyze the term Second Great Awakening as a metaphor. Begin by contrasting the literal and figurative senses of the word awakening. Guide students to consider how the modifier great elevates the idea of an awakening and helps intensify the term’s positive connotations. 2 Have students complete the Reading Notes for Sections 18.2 to 18.6. Remind them to use the Key Content Terms where appropriate as they complete their Reading Notes. Have several volunteers share their responses, and use Guide to Reading Notes 18 to check their answers. An Era of Reform 249 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com P r o c e d u r e s Response Group 1 Place students in groups of three and introduce the activity. Explain that they will examine and discuss three excerpts from the Declaration of Sentiments and then debate the extent to which women have achieved equal rights today. 2 Prepare groups for the activity. Distribute Student Handout 18A: Reflecting on the Declaration of Sentiments to each group and review the steps. Make sure groups understand the terms grievance (formal complaint) and redress (correction of an unfair condition). Then distribute Student Handout 18B: Fact Sheet on Women in the United States Today to each group and explain that groups will use these facts to defend their placements on a spectrum. 3 Have students work with Excerpt A on Student Handout 18A. After about five minutes, have a few groups share their rephrased excerpts. Then give groups time to mark the spectrum and find supporting evidence to defend their placements. Remind them to prepare a spokesperson for the upcoming discussion. 4 Have groups mark the class spectrum. Place Information Master 18: Class Spectrum on the projector, but do not turn the projector on. Assign each group a number. Then have the spokespersons come up to the projector and mark the spectrum using their group numbers. 5 Facilitate a class discussion. Turn on the projector, and call on the first spokesperson to defend his or her group’s placement. Then call on other spokespersons to share their placements. Require each to begin by saying, “(Name of previous spokesperson), our group agrees/disagrees with your group’s placement because . . .” End the discussion when all new ideas have been voiced. S t u d e n t H a n d o u t 1 8 A Step 2: With your group, discuss the extent to which this grievance has been redressed today. Place an X on the spectrum to show your response. S t u d e n t Somewhat Redressed Not Redressed H a n d o u t 1 8 A Totally Redressed Reflecting on the Declaration of Sentiments Step 3: List evidence from the mid-1800s and today that supports your placement. You will work with your group to analyze three excerpts from the Declaration of Sentiments, the document created at the Seneca Falls Convention. Excerpt A He has never permitted her to exercise her inalienable [undeniable] right to the elective franchise [vote]. He has compelled her to submit to laws, in the formation of which she had no voice. Step 4: Prepare a new spokesperson to defend your placement. Step 1: Rewrite Excerpt A, using simpler language that a classmate would understand. In the excerpt, “he” refers to the general male population of the United States. Excerpt C He has created a false public sentiment by giving to the world a different code of morals for men and women. Step 2: Discuss the extent to which this grievance has been redressed today. Place an X on theStep spectrum to show your C, response. 1: Rewrite Excerpt using simpler language. Not Redressed Somewhat Redressed Totally Redressed Step 2: With your group, discuss the extent to which this grievance has been Step 3: List evidence from the mid-1800s today supports your redressed today. Place anand X on thethat spectrum below toplacement. show your response. Use your book and Student Handout 18B to help you. Not Redressed Somewhat Redressed Totally Redressed Step 3: List evidence from the mid-1800s and today that supports your placement. Step 4: Prepare a spokesperson to defend your placement to the class. Excerpt B Step 4: Prepare nearly a new spokesperson to defend your placement. He has monopolized [dominated] all the profitable employments, and from those she is permitted to follow, she receives but a scanty remuneration [pay]. 194 Chapter 18 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute Step 1: Rewrite Excerpt B, using simpler language. An Era of Reform © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute 193 Student Handout 18A S t u d e n t H a n d o u t 1 8 B Fact Sheet on Women in the United States Today Use these facts, in addition to the information in your book, to help you prepare for the discussions about the Declaration of Sentiments. • Women have the right to vote in every state. • In 2009, six of the 50 U.S. governors were women. • In 2009, 17 of the 100 U.S. senators and 76 of the 435 House of Representatives members were women. • As of 2009, there has never been a female president or vice president. A woman was nominated twice as a candidate for the vice presidency. • In 1972, 26% of men and women polled said they would not vote for a woman for president. In 2007, 12% of people polled said they would be less likely to vote for a woman for president. • In 2008, women earned approximately 78¢ for every dollar men earned. • On average, women make $434,000 less in their lifetimes than men. • In 2008, of the 500 largest businesses in the United States, 15.7% of the top officers were women, up from 8.7% in 1995. • In 1980, 13% of doctors were women. In 2006, 28% of doctors were women. • In 1983, 15% of lawyers were women. In 2007, 33% of lawyers were women. • In 2007, 25% of computer programmers, 82% of social workers, and 59% of realtors were women. • In 2007, 33% of women ages 25 to 29 attained a bachelor’s degree or higher compared to 26% of men. • In 1970, one in 27 girls participated in high school varsity sports. In 2008, more than one in three girls participated in high school varsity sports. • In 2008, over 42% to 49% of high school students taking the Advanced Placement tests in calculus were female. In the same year, 59% of those taking biology and 48% of those taking chemistry were female. An Era of Reform © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute 195 Student Handout 18B I n f o r m a t i o n M a s t e r 1 8 Class Spectrum Totally Redressed 6 Repeat Steps 3 to 5 with Excerpts B and C. Before having groups mark the class spectrum, erase the previous marks. Somewhat Redressed 7 Debrief the activity. Ask, • In what areas have women made the most progress since the Seneca Falls Convention? Why do you think so? Not Redressed • In what areas have women made the least progress since the Seneca Falls Convention? Why do you think so? 196 Chapter 18 • What actions are women and men taking today to continue to redress the grievances in the Declaration of Sentiments? © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute Information Master 18 • To what extent did the reform movements of the mid-1800s improve life for prisoners? Schoolchildren? African Americans? 250 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com P r o c e d u r e s Processing Have students complete the Processing activity. Students will create a “report card” evaluating the reform movements of the period. Consider having students share their evaluations with a partner or the class. Quicker Coverage Shorten the Activity Eliminate one or two of the excerpts from Student Handout 18A. Deeper Coverage Analyze More Excerpts Choose additional excerpts from the Declaration of Sentiments, such as those below, for groups to analyze and discuss following the procedure from the activity. Depending on the excerpts, you may want to give students additional statistics as well. • “He has denied her the facilities for obtaining a thorough education, all colleges being closed against her.” • “He closes against her all the avenues to wealth and distinction, which he considers most honorable to himself. As a teacher of theology, medicine, or law, she is not known.” • “He has taken from her all right in property, even to the wages she earns.” Research Additional Facts Restructure the activity by having students analyze all three excerpts at one time. For each excerpt, ask them to research additional facts to support their placements on the spectrum. Then facilitate a discussion for each excerpt. An Era of Reform 251 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com R e a d i n g F u r t h e r Brook Farm and the Utopian Dream 1 Discuss the ideal of creating a “perfect” community. Ask a volunteer to read aloud the Preamble to the U.S. Constitution. Talk about the fact that people have a long history of trying to create the best society possible— whether on a national level or as a community. 2 Have students read the Chapter 18 Reading Further. Ask students to summarize George Ripley’s goals for Brook Farm. Ask, Why do you think writer Nathaniel Hawthorne enjoyed physical labor at first? Why do you think he eventually changed his mind? 3 Compare Brook Farm to communes in the 1960s. Tell the class that in the 1960s, many people formed communes with the idea of creating more ideal communities than they found in mainstream society. Talk about ways in which the young people filled with the spirit of “newness” in the 1860s were similar to the hippie culture of the 1960s. 4 Discuss life at Brook Farm. Ask, Would you have liked to have lived at Brook Farm? Why or why not? 5 Have students complete the Chapter 18 Reading Further in their Interactive Student Notebooks. Invite students to share their storyboards. If possible, post them in a classroom display. Encourage students to describe and compare their utopian communities. Discuss how the utopias reflect differences from the society in which students live. An Era of Reform 253 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com D i f f e r e n t i a t i n g I n s t r u c t i o n English Language Learners Learners with Special Education Needs Provide an Alternative Preview Have students write responses to the following questions, and discuss their responses as a class. Support the Activity Consider these tips: • Do you think girls and boys are treated equally in the classroom? In the workplace? • Do you think women in the United States have the same rights as men? Why or why not? • How do you think male and female roles in the United States have changed since the mid-1800s? Provide Paraphrased Excerpts For the activity, provide students with the following rewordings for the Declaration of Sentiments excerpts. • Excerpt A: Men do not allow women to vote. Women have no say in the creation of laws. • Excerpt B: Men have the jobs that pay the most. Women’s jobs pay very little. • Give students copies of Student Handouts 18A and 18B ahead of time to familiarize them with the activity. • Assign students to be the spokesperson for Excerpt B. Highlight some of the facts on Student Handout 18B that may help them determine where to mark the spectrum. • Have students prepare cue cards to use during the class discussions. Encourage them to outline what they might say to the class and to include at least one statistic from Student Handout 18B. • Appoint one student as the facilitator for each round. Have this student call on spokespersons. Advanced Learners Write a Letter to a Reformer In lieu of the Processing activity, have students write a letter to one of the reformers discussed in the chapter. The letter should contain • Excerpt C: Men expect women to have different morals than men. Learners Reading and Writing Below Grade Level • an introduction that reviews some of the reformer’s accomplishments. Highlight Main Ideas Give students photocopies of the chapter. For the Reading Notes for Section 18.2, have students highlight information about transcendentalism. For Sections 18.3, 18.4, and 18.6, have them highlight information pertaining to conditions in one color and reforms in a second color. For Section 18.5, have them highlight information about William Lloyd Garrison in one color, Frederick Douglas in a second color, and Sojourner Truth in a third color. • two paragraphs that describe the extent to which the related reform movement improved life for Americans. • a conclusion that discusses whether the issues of the reform movement have been totally redressed today. Students will need to do additional research to address some of these points. 254 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com E n h a n c i n g L e a r n i n g Enrichment Resources Literature Recommendations Find out more about the reform movements of the mid-1800s by exploring the following resources for History Alive! The United States Through Industrialism at www.teachtci.com. The following books offer opportunities to extend the content in this chapter. Enrichment Readings These in-depth readings encourage students to explore selected topics related to the chapter. You may also find readings that relate the chapter’s content directly to your state’s curriculum. Internet Resources These recommended Web sites provide useful and engaging content that reinforces skills development and mastery of subjects within the chapter. Sojourner Truth: Abolitionist and Women’s Rights Activist by Catherine Bernard (Berkeley Heights, NJ: Enslow Publishers, 2001) A Journey into the Transcendentalists’ New England by R. Todd Felton (Berkeley, CA: Roaring Forties Press, 2006) Time for Courage by Kathryn Lasky (New York: Scholastic, 2001) An Era of Reform 255 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com U n i t 6 C H A P T E R 18 An Era of Reform To what extent did the reform movements of the mid-1800s improve life for Americans? P R E V I E W Read the lyrics to the song “Let Us All Speak Our Minds.” Then answer these questions on a separate sheet of paper: 1. How would you describe the mood created by the lyrics? R E A D I N G 2. Why do you think women would write and sing a song like this? 3. To what extent do you think the complaints mentioned in this song are still valid today? N O T E S Key Content Terms As you complete the Reading Notes, use these terms in your answers. reform transcendentalism Seneca Falls Convention Second Great Awakening abolitionists Declaration of Sentiments Section 18.2 1. What was the optimistic message of the Second Great Awakening? 2. Explain how this quotation by Henry David Thoreau reflects the philosophy of transcendentalism: “If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music he hears.” 3. How did transcendentalism contribute to the spirit of reform? An Era of Reform 171 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute USI_ISN_18.indd 171 www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com 5/10/10 4:58 PM C h a p t e r 1 8 Section 18.3 1. Complete the flowchart to show the conditions in prisons during the mid-1800s and the reforms that were passed. Conditions in Prisons Reforms • Inmates were bound in chains. • Public asylums were created for the mentally ill. 2. Complete the sensory figure of Dorothea Dix to show her possible thoughts, feelings, and experiences. With my eyes, I see . . . With my heart, I feel . . . With my hands, I write . . . With my feet, I travel to prisons to document the horrible conditions. Dorothea Dix 172 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute USI_ISN_18.indd 172 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com 5/10/10 4:58 PM C h a p t e r 1 8 Section 18.4 1. Complete the flowchart to show the conditions of public education in the mid-1800s and the reforms that were passed. Conditions of Public Education Reforms • Few areas had public schools. • In Massachusetts, citizens voted to build better schools. 2. Complete the sensory figure of Horace Mann to show his possible thoughts, feelings, and experiences. With my eyes, I see . . . With my mouth, I speak out for . . . With my heart, I believe that women and African Americans . . . Horace Mann An Era of Reform 173 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute USI_ISN_18.indd 173 www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com 5/10/10 4:58 PM C h a p t e r 1 8 Section 18.5 Complete the sensory figures to show the possible thoughts, feelings, and experiences of each abolitionist. With my ears, I hear . . . With my heart, I feel . . . With my hands, I write . . . William Lloyd Garrison With my eyes, I see . . . With my mouth, I speak . . . With my hands, I write . . . Frederick Douglass With my eyes, I see . . . With my mouth, I speak out . . . With my heart, I feel . . . Sojourner Truth 174 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute USI_ISN_18.indd 174 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com 5/10/10 4:58 PM C h a p t e r 1 8 Section 18.6 1. Complete the flowchart to show the conditions of women in the mid-1800s and the reforms that were passed. Conditions of Women Reforms • Women could not vote or hold office. • New York gave women control over their property and wages. 2. Complete the sensory figure of Elizabeth Cady Stanton to show her possible thoughts, feelings, and experiences. With my eyes, I see . . . With my heart, I feel . . . With my hands, I write . . . Elizabeth Cady Stanton An Era of Reform 175 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute USI_ISN_18.indd 175 www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com 5/10/10 4:58 PM C h a p t e r 1 8 P R O C E S S I N G Evaluate the extent to which the reform movements of the mid-1800s improved life for Americans. For each reform movement, assign a grade. Then list two things the movement did well and two suggestions for improvement. Reform Movement Grade Two Things the Movement Did Well Two Suggestions for Improvement Prison reform movement Education reform movement Abolitionist movement Women’s rights movement 176 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute USI_ISN_18.indd 176 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com 5/10/10 4:58 PM S t u d e n t H a n d o u t 1 8 A Reflecting on the Declaration of Sentiments You will work with your group to analyze three excerpts from the Declaration of Sentiments, the document created at the Seneca Falls Convention. Excerpt A He has never permitted her to exercise her inalienable [undeniable] right to the elective franchise [vote]. He has compelled her to submit to laws, in the formation of which she had no voice. Step 1: Rewrite Excerpt A, using simpler language that a classmate would understand. In the excerpt, “he” refers to the general male population of the United States. Step 2: Discuss the extent to which this grievance has been redressed today. Place an X on the spectrum to show your response. Not Redressed Somewhat Redressed Totally Redressed Step 3: List evidence from the mid-1800s and today that supports your placement. Use your book and Student Handout 18B to help you. Step 4: Prepare a spokesperson to defend your placement to the class. Excerpt B He has monopolized [dominated] nearly all the profitable employments, and from those she is permitted to follow, she receives but a scanty remuneration [pay]. Step 1: Rewrite Excerpt B, using simpler language. An Era of Reform 195 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com S t u d e n t H a n d o u t 1 8 A Step 2: With your group, discuss the extent to which this grievance has been redressed today. Place an X on the spectrum to show your response. Not Redressed Somewhat Redressed Totally Redressed Step 3: List evidence from the mid-1800s and today that supports your placement. Step 4: Prepare a new spokesperson to defend your placement. Excerpt C He has created a false public sentiment by giving to the world a different code of morals for men and women. Step 1: Rewrite Excerpt C, using simpler language. Step 2: With your group, discuss the extent to which this grievance has been redressed today. Place an X on the spectrum below to show your response. Not Redressed Somewhat Redressed Totally Redressed Step 3: List evidence from the mid-1800s and today that supports your placement. Step 4: Prepare a new spokesperson to defend your placement. 196 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com S t u d e n t H a n d o u t 1 8 B Fact Sheet on Women in the United States Today Use these facts, in addition to the information in your book, to help you prepare for the discussions about the Declaration of Sentiments. • Women have the right to vote in every state. • In 2009, six of the 50 U.S. governors were women. • In 2009, 17 of the 100 U.S. senators and 76 of the 435 House of Representatives members were women. • As of 2010, there has never been a female president or vice president. A woman was nominated twice as a candidate for the vice presidency. • In 1972, 26% of men and women polled said they would not vote for a woman for president. In 2007, 12% of people polled said they would be less likely to vote for a woman for president. • In 2008, women earned approximately 78¢ for every dollar men earned. • On average, women make $434,000 less in their lifetimes than men. • In 2008, of the 500 largest businesses in the United States, 15.7% of the top officers were women, up from 8.7% in 1995. • In 1980, 13% of doctors were women. In 2006, 28% of doctors were women. • In 1983, 15% of lawyers were women. In 2007, 33% of lawyers were women. • In 2007, 25% of computer programmers, 82% of social workers, and 59% of realtors were women. • In 2007, 33% of women ages 25 to 29 attained a bachelor’s degree or higher compared to 26% of men. • In 1970, one in 27 girls participated in high school varsity sports. In 2008, more than one in three girls participated in high school varsity sports. • In 2008, over 42% to 49% of high school students taking the Advanced Placement tests in calculus were female. In the same year, 59% of those taking biology and 48% of those taking chemistry were female. An Era of Reform 197 © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com I n f o r m a t i o n M a s t e r 1 8 Not Redressed Somewhat Redressed Totally Redressed Class Spectrum 198 Chapter 18 (c) Teachers' Curriculum Institute © Teachers’ Curriculum Institute www.teachtci.com info@teachtci.com