TOPIC 1 INTRODUCTION TO STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT UNIT STRUCTURE 1.1 EVOLUTION OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT 1.1.1 Business Policy Maturing Into Strategic Management (a)Contents of Business Policy Undergoing drastic change (b) Changing Management Planning Perspective 1.1.2 The Four Phases of Development in Strategic Management Phase 1 Basic financial planning Phase 2 Forecast-based planning Phase 3 Externally oriented planning Phase 4 Strategic Management 1.2 CHANGES IN THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT 1.3 BENEFITS OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT LEARNING OBJECTIVES Upon completion of this topic, you should be able to: Describe the evolution and development of strategic management Identify the major factors contributing to changes in the current business scenario Explain the benefits and pitfalls of strategic management 1.0 INTRODUCTION The origin of Strategic Management then known as 1Business Policy can be traced back to 1911 when the Harvard Business School introduced a course in Management. The objective of the course was to increase the general management capability of students. However, the real impetus for introducing Business Policy in the curriculum dates back to 1959 when it became popular as a guideline for thinking and action by those who make decisions. Figure1.1: Breaking out of traditional style of management Later Business Policy became Strategic management. Harvard Business School introduced this as a distinct subject in the 1980s. Initially the focus of Strategic management was to help students learn how to integrate the various functional areas of business management (like accounting, human resource management, finance, production, accounting and marketing) so as to understand Figure1.2: the interrelationship and linkages of each of the functions areas with Strategic the operations and management of the entire organisation. management course became popular Later on the many changes in the business environment compelled organisations to make varied changes in the structure in order to cope with the rapid dynamic business environment. As a result, the field of strategic management evolved as it stands today. Such attempt made by business houses has reaped big benefits to organisations. As a result, there has been a constant endeavour to add knowledge to this subject. All courses on management have included it as a subject whereby students learn how strategy relates the firm to its environment, and how it could be used for managing the future or competing for future by creating a sustainable competitive advantage for the organisation. 1.1 EVOLUTION OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT Harvard Business School was the first to introduce a course known as Business Policy for practicing managers for a culminating experience. The course was structured to create opportunities for participants to integrate knowledge of what they had learned in different business fields and use the knowledge in analysing business related problems. 2The course focused on integrating the various functional areas of business administration like accounting, management, marketing, human resources, finance and production. It was designed to develop the ability of the learner to apply the knowledge learned in previous courses to solve problems in business organisations. Thus, the course concentrated on providing formal training and experience in handling issues affecting the business Figure1.3: Harvard Business School introduced the course known as Business Policy. environment and systematic and analytical thinking in resolving problems affecting the performance of organisations. However, the real impetus for introducing Business Policy in the curriculum came with the publication of two reports in 1959. The Gordon d Howell Report and Ford Foundation had recommended a Capstone Course of business in order to provide an opportunity for students to gather what they have learned in separate business fields and utilise this knowledge in the analysis of complex business problems. From then on business policy course has been included in all business administration programmes both at the graduate and post-graduate level. 1.1.1 Business Policy maturing into Strategic Management The evolution of strategic management can be divided into two phases. The first relates to the contents of what constitutes the subject of Business Policy and the other relates to the development of strategic management with a more focused approach to management planning (a) Contents of Business Policy undergoing drastic change Gradually over the years, the content of Business Policy has undergone vast changes keeping in mind that the focus of business policy has shifted keeping in mind the needs of the business. The major factors responsible for this shift in focus are: Increasing responsibilities of managers in organisations Powerful changes taking place in the business environment Introduction of case studies as a learning methodology Other environmental factors affecting the performance of the organisation at large. Initially when it was introduced as a subject in Harvard Business School, the subject included only the opinions and view of top management. The participants were encouraged to do role-plays by assuming top positions in an organisation. Their actions and reactions to be various problems affecting the organisations were analysed. This gave participants an opportunity to learn from the experiences of others in resolving issues facing the organisation. Such analysis was extended to include the influence of factors such as economics, social, political and technology, which was by then gaining importance. Another factor that changed the perspective of Business Policy was the Industrial Recovery of the 1980s that brought about massive changes in every sphere of business, especially in information technology. This brought about a big change in the way organisations conduct their business. In the meantime, new concepts such as social responsibility and ethical behaviour of the organisation such as a concept for safety and health of employees, pollution control were developed and these increased the expectations of the society from the organisations. Last but not the least, the micro-level management expectations of the stakeholders from the organisation such as good corporate governance, transparency in operations and social equity in organisational management also contributed to the change in the business and non-business environment. (b) Changing Management Planning Perspective One of the major functions of the management is planning. Planning is important as it helps an organisation manage itself more effectively and efficiently. Planning initially stressed only on having clear goals and objectives and preparing budgets for resource allocation. However, the changing dynamic environment of business has compelled organisations to make suitable changes and adjustments in light of such changes in the business environment. This has ultimately resulted in organisations developing a strategic approach to undertaking the management function. Figure 1.4: Strategic approach to planning 1.1.2 The Four Phases of Development in Strategic Management Constant efforts of 3 Frederick W. Glueck, Stephan P. Kaufman, and A. Steven Walleck lead to the study of the evolution of strategic management in 120 companies. 4 Their study has led to conclude that strategic planning in most organisations evolves in four sequential phases as detailed below: Phase 1 Basic financial planning The Phase 1, which deals with basic Figure1.5: financial planning, makes organisations involve Planning themselves in preparing and meeting annual budgets. Budgets lead to the deciding of financial targets. 5This also ensures that revenues and costs are carefully monitored. Though the emphasis is on short-term financial planning, the primary focus is on the functional aspects of the organisation. During this phase, it is difficult to find organisations worrying about the long term future aspects of the business. Basic Financial Phase 2 Forecast-based planning. The Phase 2, which relates to forecasting based planning, covers a period longer than the one covered by the budget period. 6 Organisations expect their managers to make forecasts that are more refined and to become aware of their external environment. The managers are also expected to analyse the effects of the environment of the organisations. This requires organisations in phase 2 to make more judicious resource allocation to help organisation compete for a long-term competitive position. Figure1.6: Forecast-based planning Phase 3 Externally oriented planning. 7 seen Organisations in Phase 3 are attempting marketplace to understand phenomena. basic Organisations begin by searching for new ways to define and satisfy customer needs. This phase differs from the other two phases in the sense that it requires corporate planners to identify a number of alternative courses of action for top management. Evaluation of strategic alternatives Figure1.7: Externally oriented planning is made by top management in a formalised manner to plan their actions. Phase 4 Strategic Management8 Organisations in Phase 4 actively involve themselves in trying to make strategic planning and management a single process. Such integration is made possible with the help of three elements: pervasive strategic thinking (managers all levels think strategically), comprehensive planning process, and supportive value system. ` Figure1.8: Strategic management Thus, according to Gluck et al. (1982), strategic management evolved through four phases of development. Figure1.9: Gluck's four phases of development in strategic management The evolvement in strategic management has prompted the business policy course to evolve from phase 1 to phase 4, which is more complex and dynamic, and gradually to the present day strategic management course. To summarise, the business policy course was concerned with integrating all the functional areas of business and providing experience in solving real-life problems, which have a multifunctional impact on the organisation. Strategic management, however, is concerned with all that was discussed in the business policy course but also incorporates the external factors that have a major impact on the organisation, and consequently determines the long-term direction of the organisation by formulating plans, implementing the plans and making evaluation and control of the plans that were set for the organisation. Furthermore, the strategic management area involves strategic issues, which have a long-term impact on the organisation. CHECK YOUR PROGRESS 1. Discuss the evolution of business policy into strategic management. 2. List any four new uses of Information Technology for a business. 1.2 CHANGES IN THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT Every business is forced to operate in two environments called as the internal and external environments. The external environment in which firms operate lies outside them. It is this external environment, which is constantly changing. Some of these changes are so drastic that every firm takes notice of them. Figure1.10: Changes in business environment Such changes may require the immediate attention and action of the firms. However, there could be changes, which take place slowly, and it may at times take many years for the firms in the industry to realise the change and they may go unnoticed for many more years. The external environment thus poses a number of challenges for the firms. Changes take place in the external environment may assume different shapes and provide fresh challenges. For a whole industry change effects in the following ways: Changes take place very often in customers' needs and requirements. Customers always desire to have new, better and cheaper products. As technologies develop, it acts as a source of encouragement for new companies to enter the business with better quality of products and economical ways of management. As companies take advantage of new technologies, the employees' need to be trained to equip them with new skills associated with the new technologies. The business house operates in an external environment which has new laws are passed on a regular basis affecting working conditions, wages payable, etc.. Gradually reliability of traditional sources of supplies of raw materials and components begins to decline. Constantly new source of supply is identified. As industry reaches saturation levels, banks and other investors lose interest in financing the industry. Industry’s activities invite the attention and interest of pressure groups The industry no longer attracts talents with high calibre The external business environment also includes for individual firms their competition, who may bring in improved production methods, innovate new ways to compete, expand their market geography, find new ways to recruit key human resource. Firms and industries should be able to withstand the test, which relates to how fast and effectively it analyses, recognises significant changes, and adapts to them. CHECK YOUR PROGRESS Discuss the changes that are taking place in the business environment as of today. Explain the role of different levels of management in trying to cope with the changes in the business environment. 1.3 BENEFITS OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT 9 Many studies carried out have proved that a firm paying attention to strategic management will be able to outperform those that do not. Strategic planning brings about a judicious allocation of resources and improves coordination between various divisions of the organisation. 10 Authors give various reasons as to why organisations should employ strategic management. Many research studies show both financial and nonfinancial benefits which can be derived from a strategic management approach to decision making. Financial Benefits11 Figure1.11: Financial The financial benefits of strategic management are benefits obvious when we try to find an answer to the question why should a firm adopt strategic management. Many renowned authors like Eastlack and McDonald (1970), Thune and House (1970), Ansoff et. al. (1971), Karger and Malik (1975), and Hofer and Schendel (1978) have conducted research to prove the advantage of adopting strategic management. The results indicate that formalised strategic management (strategic planning) does result in superior performance by organisations. 12 Every study conducted was able to provide convincing evidence to show an increase in profitability because of strategy formulation and implementation. The formalised strategic management process helps improve profits, sales, and return on assets. Organisations that adopt a strategic management approach can expect that the new system will lead to improved financial performance. Nonfinancial Benefits13 Apart from an increase in the profitability of the management is seen firm, to strategic have many behavioural effects that in turn could improve the welfare of the firm. Figure1.12: Nonfinancial benefits Yoo and Digman demonstrate that strategic management is crucial for decision making to handle and manage uncertainty. They have given the advantages of strategic management: i. It prepares to expect and plan for future difficulties and opportunities. ii. It gives employees defined objectives and directions for the growth of the organisation. iii. It results in more effective and better performance compared to non-strategic management organisations. iv. It raises the motivation and satisfaction of employees. v. It results in swifter and better decision-making vi. It results in cost savings. Moreover, Greenley has also asserted that strategic management offers the following process and personal benefits: i. It allows for identification, prioritisation, and exploitation of opportunities. ii. It provides an objective view of management problems. iii. It represents a framework for improved coordination and control of activities. iv. It minimises the effects of adverse conditions and changes. v. It allows major decisions to support better-established objectives. vi. It allows more effective allocation of time and resources to identified opportunities. vii. It allows fewer resources and less time to be devoted to correcting erroneous decisions. viii. It creates a framework for internal communication among personnel. ix. It helps to integrate the behaviour of individuals into a total effort. x. It provides a basic for the clarification of individual responsibilities. xi. It gives encouragement to forward thinking. xii. It provides a cooperative, integrated, and enthusiastic approach to tackling problems and opportunities. xiii. It encourages a favourable attitude towards change. xiv. It gives a degree of discipline and formality to the management of a business. These and other research studies have concluded that strategic management is an integral and important function of organisation life. However, successful organisations are successful for many reasons: adequate resources, good products and services, and so on. While not panaceas, the strategic management process is a powerful tool. It values lies with executive and the ability to use this strategic management tool in effectively managing the enterprise. 14 It makes managers think ahead and anticipate problems before they occur. The main benefit of the strategic planning process is that it is continuous dialogue about the organisation’s future between the hierarchical levels in the organisation. In short, strategic management offers the following benefits: i. It helps by providing clarity in the strategic vision for the organisation ii. It helps the firm to focus attention on what is strategically important to the organisation iii. It helps by giving a better understanding of the rapidly changing business environment. CHECK YOUR PROGRESS List the financial uses of strategic management. List the non-financial uses of strategic management. Take a company of your choice and discuss how its strategy has helped it to obtain a sustainable competitive advantage in the market. SUMMARY The origin of Strategic Management then known as Business Policy can be traced back to 1911 when the Harvard Business School introduced a course in Management. Later Business Policy became Strategic management. Harvard Business School introduced this as a distinct subject in the 1980s initially the focus of Strategic management was to help students learn how to integrate the various functional areas of business management. Later on the many changes in the business environment compelled organisations to make varied changes in the structure in order to cope with the rapid dynamic business environment. As a result, the field of strategic management evolved as it stands today. It was designed to develop the ability of the learner to apply the knowledge learned in previous courses to solve problems in business organisations. Thus, the course concentrated on providing formal training and experience in handling issues affecting the business environment and systematic and analytical thinking in resolving problems affecting the performance of organisations. The evolution of strategic management can be divided into two phases. The first relates to the contents of what constitutes the subject of Business Policy and the other relates to the development of strategic management with a more focused approach to management planning. Constant efforts of Frederick W. Glueck, Stephan P. Kaufman, and A. Steven Walleck lead to the study of the evolution of strategic management in 120 companies. Their study has led to conclude that strategic planning in most organisations evolves in four sequential phases The evolvement in strategic management has prompted the business policy course to evolve from phase 1 to phase 4, which is more complex and dynamic, and gradually to the present day strategic management course. Every business is forced to operate in two environments called as the internal and external environments. The external environment in which firms operate lies outside them. It is this external environment, which is constantly changing. Some of these changes are so drastic that every firm takes notice of them. Many studies carried out have proved that a firm paying attention to strategic management will be able to outperform those that do not. Strategic planning brings about a judicious allocation of resources and improves coordination between various divisions of the organisation. KEY TERMS Business Policy Basic Financial Planning Forecast-Based Planning Externally Oriented Planning Financial Benefits Nonfinancial Benefits Strategic Planning Business Environment EXERCISE Short Answer Questions 1. Define business policy. 2. State the reason for the immense importance given to a business policy. 3. Discuss the four phases in the development of strategic management. 4. List the different types of benefits of strategic management. Long Answer Questions 1. Explain the reasons behind including Strategic Management as a course in all management programmes. 2. Are you convinced of the importance of strategic management? If yes, give reasons. 3. Explain the evolution of strategic management in about 300 words. 4. Take two competing organisations and make a comparison on their strategy initiatives. REFERENCES Pratik Tiwari. (2013, March 3). Strategic Management. Retrieved from http://www.slideshare.net/tiwari_prat/20076ipcc-paper7-bvol1cp2 2 Fred r. david (2011) strategic management concepts. Retrieved from http://www.slideshare.net/Chakodi/fred-r-david-2011-strategic-management-concepts 3 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: Developing The Strategic Management Process. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en232 4 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: Developing The Strategic Management Process. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en232 5 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: Developing The Strategic Management Process. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en232 6 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: Developing The Strategic Management Process. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en232 7 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: Developing The Strategic Management Process. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en232 8 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: Developing The Strategic Management Process. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en232 9 Anna University. (n.d.). Strategic management. Retrieved from http://www.slideshare.net/harinh/strategic-management-11835093 10 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: The Importance And Value Of Strategic Management. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en241 11 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: The Importance And Value Of Strategic Management. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en241 12 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: The Importance And Value Of Strategic Management. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en241 13 Ryszard Barnat. (n.d.). Strategic Management :: The Importance And Value Of Strategic Management. Retrieved from http://www.introduction-to-management.24xls.com/en241 14 Anna University. (n.d.). Strategic management. Retrieved from http://www.slideshare.net/harinh/strategic-management-11835093 1