2012 Six-Year Plan Review OLD DOMINION UNIVERSITY September 27, 2012 General Comments: 1. Reallocations: The General Assembly provided specific reallocation amounts for all higher education institutions as part of their appropriation. Please include a statement in your remarks indicating whether or not you have met your reallocation requirement. If you have not met your reallocation requirement, please provide an explanation. Old Dominion University has met the reallocation requirements of $1,361,685 in fiscal year 2013 and will reallocate $1,815,581 in fiscal year 2014 (as identified in the Six-Year Plan) from current E&G program funds to support institutional initiatives that help meet statewide goals. The reallocations as identified in the Six-Year Plan include: $475,000 in FY2013 and $200,000 in FY2014 to increase student employment opportunities on campus; $180,000 in FY2013 and $360,000 in FY2014 to streamline business services, enhance customer service and utilize technology to automate business processes; $706,685 in FY2013 to address faculty compression and competitive salary offers. Additional reallocations in FY2014 will include $241,581 to increase the summer school courses and enrollments; $150,000 for Quality Enhancements in student learning; $154,000 for student success programs; $360,000 to develop on-line instruction; and $350,000 for expansion of STEM and health care degree programs. 2. Financial Aid: (a) All schools are required to provide a detailed narrative on their financial aid plan. This narrative should include steps that the institution is taking to mitigate the impact of the increase in tuition on low-income and middle-income students. The narrative should also include the definition of middle-income that the institution is using and the size of their student population receiving aid that falls within that definition. It would also be helpful to know what portion of financial aid is going to each student group, i.e. low-income aid recipients, middle-income aid recipients. Please include the narrative on the Financial Aid worksheet. (b) If your institution does use T&F revenue for financial aid, please state this on the Financial Aid worksheet. (c) If the amount of T&F revenue collected for financial aid does not equal the amount disbursed for financial aid, please note the difference and how these additional funds were used. (a) Old Dominion University (ODU) awards financial aid to students showing need in low and middle income groups after other federal and state aid is awarded. The process is as follows: Package students with federal and state aid and grants first. For students in lower and middle income groups whose financial needs have not been met using federal and state aid, award institutional aid. The inclusion of middle income students will address unmet need and ensure that middle income students are not left behind. Additionally, the University has invested over $500,000 in our Learn and Earn Advantage Program (LEAP), a program created to specifically meet the growing financial challenges faced by students in middle income ranges. Freshman students whose income levels do not qualify for Federal Work Study are offered the opportunity to participate in LEAP. The program allows students to work on campus for 15 hours per week, renewable for one additional year. National statistics verify that students who work on campus have a better retention and graduation rate than students who work off campus. At ODU, more than 50% of our students work more than 20 hours per week, and the LEAP program allows them to do so in a supportive environment conducive to a successful higher education experience. ODU used the definitions of low and middle income provided by SCHEV. Table 1. Definition of Low and Middle Income Categories for financial aid purposes Family of 4 Family of 6 Family of 8 Low Income 22,350 44,700 29,990 59,980 37,630 75,260 Middle Income 44,700 78,225 59,980 104,965 75,260 131,705 Table 2. (b) Students by Income category who received institutional scholarships. scholarships are funded with tuition and student fee revenue. Family of >=4 < 6 Family of >=6 <8 Family of >=8 These Low Income 179 38 5 Middle Income 292 41 9 (c ) If the amount of T&F revenue collected for financial aid does not equal the amount disbursed for financial aid, the difference reverts to the institutional scholarship fund balance to be used to provide additional one-time scholarships in the subsequent year. 3. General Fund Assumptions: All schools are required to provide a detailed summary of the assumptions they are using for their financial projections, i.e. assuming zero incremental increase in general fund appropriation. Old Dominion University’s plan includes a 3.3% tuition and 4.4% fee increase in FY2013 and a 6% tuition and 4% fee increase in FY2014. These increases will generate approximately $8.4 million in nongeneral fund revenue in FY2013 ($4.2M E&G and $4.2M Auxiliary) and $11.3 million in additional nongeneral fund revenue in FY2014 ($7.3M E&G and $4.0M Auxiliary). Requests for nongeneral fund appropriation increases were approved by the Secretary of Education and submitted in the Budget Process on September 21, 2012. These nongeneral funds will be used to invest in instruction and academic support, student recruitment and retention initiatives, campus infrastructure, and campus life and retention programs. Without any increase in general fund support, the University will not be able to fulfill many of the goals outlined in its Six-Year Plan. However, should the University receive additional General Fund dollars, we will contemplate lowering the assumed tuition and fee increase for FY14, similar to the University’s tuition and fee actions for FY13. 4. Proposed Cost Saving Measures: All schools are asked to highlight initiatives that are expected to produce cost savings. Over the past 18 months, with the assistance of Ellucian, ODU has been re-engineering its administrative and business processes, to improve both efficiency and effectiveness. Thus far, the University has scrutinized the processes in Accounts Payable, Human Resources/Payroll, and Accounts Receivable, embedded best practices, and substantially reduced costs related to both personnel and non-personnel expenses while improving service delivery. This process works to incorporate the identification of key performance indicators/metrics and the development of follow-on reporting structures to continuously monitor actual performance versus proposed outcomes. To date, the cost savings associated with this initial phase (80% completed) has resulted in the abolishment of eight positions, reduced postage and other non-personnel-related expenses, and has produced tangible improvements in service delivery. These outcomes were recognized by Ellucian through Old Dominion’s selection for the Institutional Performance Award among the company’s 2,300 colleges and universities. In addition University Business selected ODU for one of 16 Model of Efficiency awards. A second phase focused upon Student Financial Aid, Recruitment/Admissions, and Student Records and Registration will begin this fall. Similar results are expected with the second phase. In addition, the University also continues to review its academic programs and support services to identify opportunities for program elimination and/or greater efficiency. Since July 2011 the following efforts have been undertaken: Distance Learning Partners in Progress Initiative to capitalize on changing technologies, growing student expectations, faculty needs, and community college synergies to grow online course capacity and program diversity. Significant progress over the last two years with ongoing collaboration with the addition of 34 academic programs. Ongoing collaboration with NOVA+ODU see http://nova-odu.com/ for a complete online education. Thorough assessment, review, and consultant engagement for examining University assets in Distance Learning, the three Higher Education Centers, and Continuing Education Programs to align resources with a more strategic focus and a rapidly changing marketplace in higher education. Anticipate major organizational changes to realign directions. The automation of the Faculty Activity System for tracking faculty instruction, research and community service. The system module substantially improves upon data collection, analysis and daily utilization of course specific data by all faculty. Collaboration has begun with other Virginia universities to compare and enhance functionality of the system modules for the collective benefit. Significant report programming is underway to standardize customary reports, identify outliers, and integrate with costing methodologies. The refinement of Annual College Reviews of all programs utilizing standard templates in collaboration with Institutional Research & Assessment. This annual review process provides the executive framework for resource allocation and re-allocation issues prior to the budget planning cycle. Implementation of People Admin System for faculty recruitment BPM initiative for automating graduate tuition waivers process and employment Graduate Program Reviews in relation to economic and international trends impacting recruitment 5. Lab Schools Planning Grant: Schools currently receiving lab school planning grants should provide a narrative on their progress and include the amount they received under academic initiatives. Any school considering applying for a planning grant during the next round should include that information in their six-year plan. Not Applicable: Old Dominion University receives no lab school planning grants. 6. Deletion of Strategies/Initiatives: For institutions that deleted initiatives or strategies from their plans, please include a narrative in the comments field outlining your rationale, i.e. lack of funding or change in strategy. Two strategies were deleted: Quality Enhancement Plan and Faculty Salary Compression/Retention. Both of these initiatives were institutional priorities and were funded through a reallocation of resources and supplemented with general and nongeneral funds. 7. Prioritization: Please insert a column to the left of the ‘Delete Initiative’ column on the Academic-Finance worksheet to indicate the priority of each initiative with ‘1” being the highest priority. Refer to attached Six Year Plan Worksheet for priorities. Institution Specific Comments: Old Dominion University 1) Please provide narrative on your collaboration efforts with Fort Monroe for the ODU Military Connection Center. There are approximately 108,000 Navy and Marine Corps personnel stationed in the Hampton Roads region, as well as more that 58,000 retired military men and women, and approximately 118,300 dependents of active duty/civilian personnel. The total Hampton Roads Navy community numbers 318,000 individuals. Each branch of the armed forces is represented in the region, bringing over $11 billion into the economy annually. Around 25% of Old Dominion University’s student population is military-affiliated, and the University is committed to providing these students with the unique support critical to their academic success and their transition from active duty to civilian life. The Old Dominion Military Connection Center, supported as a “Best Practice” by the American Council of Education, would provide a comprehensive model to support our military students as well as the broader military community by providing support services, interdisciplinary research, and outreach programs to the military community. Throughout the past few months, the university has been engaged with both the Secretary of Veterans Affairs and Homeland Security and the First Lady’s Policy Office regarding how the University could partner with the Freedom Center at Fort Monroe to provide the Freedom Center with a Southside presence. The University shares many of the same objectives of the Freedom Center in our dedication to serve as a centralized clearinghouse for military support programs, create a system to vet programs and place them on a centralized online database and resource center for veteran and military resources, collaborate with industry, government, and public organizations to address economic and public policy concerns, seek opportunities for community engagement in veterans and military events or projects, and broaden the delivery of our nationally recognized distance learning network to the military community. It would be advantageous to all for these services to be provided on both the Peninsula and the Southside of Hampton Roads and partnering together will make this a reality. 2) Please clarify the impact (if any) of the addition of Division I football on your athletic fee. The decision by the Board of Visitors to move to Division I football and Conference USA was predicated on the ability to make such a move without reliance on new student athletic fees. 3) Please provide a short narrative on your Advance Virginia initiative. Old Dominion University (ODU) submits for consideration a proposal to modernize and advance a longstanding collaboration with the Virginia Community College System (VCCS), by expanding access to affordable, convenient, quality degree programs in high demand, online. Advance Virginia through 2+2 online will enable citizens of Virginia to complete an undergraduate degree program online by taking the first two years of course work through the community college system and the last two years with Old Dominion. Old Dominion University takes pride in its long history of working in collaboration with other institutions to provide citizens, statewide, access to high quality, public higher education. As early as 1994, Old Dominion University was awarded state funding to establish a partnership with the Virginia Community College System to improve access to degrees in high demand throughout Virginia. For over fifteen (15) years, numerous ODU undergraduate programs have been articulated and thousands of degrees have been awarded, contributing to the growth and economic development in local communities throughout Commonwealth. Together, our institutions can collaborate to leverage our existing relationship and infrastructure to expand access, improve quality, employ new delivery options, and better serve citizens of the Commonwealth by continuing to provide a cost effective solution to acquiring a college education now. Advance Virginia 2+2 will: Create online degrees that are co-owned and co-marketed by ODU and the VCCS colleges to optimize resources at both institutions simplify the student experience by creating a seamless transition from the community college to Old Dominion University reduce the time to degree completion for students across the Commonwealth make better use of consumer resources; and, promotes greater availability of programming in the state Expand access to STEM and health care degree programs by creating new online degree programs, undergraduate 2+2 degree completion programs and graduate programs Expand capacity to provide course development, instruction and student support by hiring additional faculty resources in key program areas. Increase opportunities and decrease time to degree completion by promoting the Guaranteed Admissions Agreement signed September 28, 2009 formally outlining the need for “specifically articulated” agreements for Applied Science degree programs, thus streamlining the student’s experience by eliminating unnecessary coursework. As these agreements are critical to extending the full benefits to potential transfer students, Old Dominion University has been working with the VCCS to put in place current articulation agreements in a variety of program areas. Expand outreach in critical regions of the state by collaborating to promote online solutions for undergraduate degree completion programs, as well as graduate degrees. Due to significant budget reductions in 2007 and 2008, ODU withdrew support at six community college locations and in Northern Virginia. This reduction severely impacted our ability to provide degree opportunities to citizens in SouthSide and Southwest Virginia, as well as in Northern Virginia. Old Dominion University has re-established partnerships with Northern Virginia Community College and Paul D. Camp Community College to promote online degree opportunities in criminal justice, nursing, and psychology beginning in Fall 2011. Migrate programs from live, synchronous models to hybrid or asynchronous models in accelerated formats, to meet student demand for flexible learning opportunities and convenient student services. Adult learners, military affiliates, and traditional students are demanding this convenience and flexibility to accommodate the demands of their individual lifestyles. Create programs with blended field and distance components where students are immersed in real world environments in internships, collaborative projects and work experiences prior to graduation. Utilize a best practice distance learning infrastructure that combines the most compelling collaboration capacity, two-way interaction, group interaction, mobile interaction, media and resource sharing, and other advanced electronic capability that permit advanced instructional activities at a distance. Further, Old Dominion will scale up the instructional demand by supplementing full-time faculty with adjunct instructors trained in the online learning environment. Thanks in part to the University’s extensive background in distance learning activity and course development; the Office of Distance Learning’s Center for Learning Technologies has instructional design teams available to collaborate with faculty subject matter experts to produce online courses. Focusing on online degree programs in the areas of science, engineering, mathematics, and health care, the 2+2 Partnership will support practical, high demand fields across the Commonwealth. Expanding upon the on-site 2+2 Partnership between the VCCS and Old Dominion University leverages existing resources and past investments in this area and expands access to academic programs through various synchronous and asynchronous delivery options. Promoting 2+2 online to high school juniors and seniors will provide families, struggling to make ends meet, an affordable solution to the high costs of a college education. Providing high school student’s information about this opportunity will permit planning upon entry to the community college for continuation through the bachelor’s degree. By collaborating with the Community College System to develop online programs that align with military experience, the 2+2 Partnership provides these students an opportunity to complete an undergraduate or graduate degree that fits their lifestyle and their career goals. With college credits already under their belts, many of these individuals, and others like them, will benefit from the opportunity to have their existing credits assessed for transfer and the convenience of online courses.