A footprint to soil and plant health Diagnose plant health problems – AHCPCM501A Workforce Innovations Program Project 275 Materials produced by Regional Skills Training Pty Ltd Funding provided by the DIISRTE Workforce Innovations Program AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems WEB Activity I Fact I Website Contents 01 About yourself 3 02 Trouble with website links 3 03 How are these materials used 3 04 What are these learning materials about 4 05 Employability skills 5 06 Unit descriptor and how the unit applies to your workplace 5 07 Monitor factors that influence plant health 6 08 Diagnose plant health problems 17 09 Remedy plant health problems 37 10 Evaluate treatment program 43 11 Summary of key innovations/opportunities identified as a result of adopting these skills 48 12 Bibliography and source material 49 13 Being confident about your skill levels 52 14 Assessment 54 Copyright Notice Bridging the Gap between Chemical and Organic Food and Fibre Production. These interactive workbooks were produced by Regional Skills Training and funded by Department of Industry, Innovation, Science, Research and Tertiary Education, Workforce Innovations Program and are intended for free use to any student, RTO or school. Note that any work is copyright and should not be reproduced or copied for commercial gain. 2 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 1 About yourself Please fill in your details below and save this PDF to your files. Name Phone Email 2 Trouble with website links Sometimes you may click on a web link and the site will say it is not available. Please revisit the site when you are next working on your resource materials as web sites are sometimes “off line” for maintenance reasons. If you are consistently unable to access a site you are free to answer any associated work book activity or assessment question by searching for and finding an alternative site that you feel is applicable. PLEASE INCLUDE THE LINK IN YOUR ANSWERS so we know where to look to check your information. 3 How are these materials used This workbook has a strong focus on the self‑directed application of knowledge. Completing this workbook and all formative assessments will thoroughly prepare you for your summative assessment. On successful completion of appropriate summative assessments provided by your Registered Training Organisation (RTO), you will achieve competency in this unit. Please complete the feedback form at the back of the unit and advise us of any links that do not work. Please complete the feedback form at the back of the unit and advise us of any links that do not work 3 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems This workbook has a focus on those working in an arboricultural or horticultural enterprise required to diagnose and resolve plant health problems. 4 What are these learning materials about This workbook applies to any person working in an agricultural or horticultural enterprise where they are required to diagnose and resolve plant health problems. The scope of this workbook includes the following activities: • Identify plant species and describe their growing requirements and characteristics • Assess the suitability of the growing environment and the level of beneficial organisms • Diagnose and record plant disorders and diseases • Formulate a weed, pest or disease control program using the principles of Integrated Pest Management • Implement modifications to plant growing conditions • Document a treatment program report. • Plant nutrition issues associated with the growth media used, and horticultural region for specific plant species. • Weeds, pests and disease detection methods, taxonomic identification, life cycle stages and characteristic symptoms for the specific horticultural plants of the enterprise. • Chemical, cultural and biological control methods included in the integrated pest management (IPM) strategy of the enterprise. • Chemical use, toxicity and compatibility with target plants, growth media, and environmental characteristics of the horticultural region. • Sustainable horticultural practices relevant to the enterprise and/or horticultural region. • Evaluation procedures, including cost/benefit analysis, for plant and growth media treatments in relation to plant health, enterprise budget and performance targets. Enterprise and industry record keeping and reporting policies and requirements: • Workplace health and safety (WHS) hazards associated with activities to promote plant health and the controls necessary to remove or minimise risks associated with them. This workbook has a strong focus on the self-directed application of knowledge with substantial depth in the areas of: • Plant anatomy, morphology, physiology, histology, pathology, taxonomy and nomenclature. • Taxonomic descriptions, horticultural function, cultural and growth requirements, and target growth and performance characteristics of specific horticultural plants for the achievement of enterprise production and business plans. 4 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 5 Employability Skills This workbook provides an opportunity to develop and apply employability skills that are learnt throughout work and life to your job. The statements below list the typical employability skills that would be applied in a situation related to diagnosing and resolving plant health problems for an agricultural or horticultural enterprise. In completing your daily work tasks and activities and summative assessments related to this unit of competence, you must be able to demonstrate that you are applying the “employability skills” listed below to this competency. • • • • Communication skills Identify and accurately report problems Organisational and teamwork skills Technological skills and using mathematical ideas and techniques. 6 UNIT DESCRIPTOR AND HOW THE UNIT APPLIES TO YOUR WORKPLACE This unit of competency covers the process of diagnosing and resolving plant health problems. This is achieved by developing, implementing and reviewing a weed, pest or disease control program using sustainable practices. Acronyms used in this workbook AAAC Australian Association of Agricultural Consultants AIAST Agricultural Science and Technology BCA Biological Control Agent CRCNPB Cooperative Research Centre for National Plant Biosecurity DECCW Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water DPI Department of Primary Industry EMS Environmental Management System FS-IRMS Farming Systems Insecticide Resistance Management Strategy HAL Horticulture Australia Ltd IPM Integrated Pest Management N Nitrogen NASAA National Association for Sustainable Agriculture Australia WHS Workplace Health and Safety PHA Plant Health Australia PHDS Plant Health Diagnostic Service QA Quality Assurance SIT Sterile Insect Technique TSWV Tomato Spotted Wilt Virus USDA United States Department of Agriculture WFT Western Flower Thrips WHP Withholding Period WUE Water Use Efficiency 5 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 7 W EB Monitor Factors That Influence Plant Health As an introduction to this entire workbook, please take some time to review the following YouTube videos. These videos ‘set the scene’ for what you are about to learn throughout this workbook. www.youtube.com/watch?v=CmsZG7T5l6g W EB This provides an overview of how Integrated Pest Management principles have been applied by Peter Schreurs and Sons at their Vegetable Farm in Victoria. www.youtube.com/watch?v=VER4_4PSiF0. Integrated Pest Management (USA; 2004) As you can see from these videos, there is a lot to consider when planning, implementing and reviewing a pest and disease management program. To do so effectively, takes considerable time, research and commitment so that a holistic, sustainable pest and disease management approach is able to be adopted. The process of understanding plant health is the same irrespective of the plant/crop type. We need to understand the plants that we are working with and what a healthy plant looks like. Only then can we identify if that plant is not healthy. This section will cover the following topics: The plant species is correctly identified (preferably genus and species to ensure you are correct). The seasonal growth stages of the plant are determined (to support the development of an appropriate health management plan specific to the plant type). Day to day cultural practices are recorded (knowing the cultural practices is critical to developing a complete plant health management system). Characteristics of the growing environment that affect the growth of a specific plant species are determined. Throughout the workbook you will complete a variety of activities. Please complete all activities in the context of your workplace. Activities are divided into a sequence that allows you to develop a plant health calendar useful to your workplace. Activities will include: • Identify plant species for your enterprise • Prepare a seasonal growth calendar for major plant species • Identify and review current record keeping practices • Identify climate and environmental conditions for major plant species relevant to your enterprise • Identify and review current climate and environmental growing condition records • Identify beneficial organisms relevant to your enterprise, the benefit they provide and how to monitor their prevalence Identifying your plant species Identification of affected plants is one of the first steps in diagnosing a plant disease. Both scientific and common names of the plant should be noted. Common names should not be relied upon since some distinctly different plant species may have the same common name, and the common name used in one area may be used for a completely different species in another area. In addition to knowing the common and scientific names of your plants, it is important to know the specific variety or cultivar, whenever possible. A great variation in susceptibility to a specific disease may occur within different cultivars of a plant species. For example, when we look at the susceptibility of wheat to wheat stem rust caused by Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici, we know that all wheat cultivars are not susceptible to all races of P. graminis. The major control measure for this disease is based on planting wheat cultivars each year that are resistant to the pathogen races predicted to be present during the growing season. Tomato cultivars having the “Better Boy” genetic background are generally resistant to root-knot nematodes while those with the genetic background of the variety “Rutgers” are susceptible, so knowing the genetic background of a cultivar can be important. Climatic data and environmental growing conditions are recorded to allow for accurate assessments of how the climate and environment may affect plant health. The presence of beneficial and non beneficial organisms is recorded to allow for accurate assessments of how they may affect plant health. 6 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 1 List the plant species that are the most important to your enterprise. Clearly these species will be quite different based on your business type e.g.: • • • • • • Cropping Nursery Vegetable growing Pasture for livestock Viticulture, Production horticulture i.e. citrus Park, garden, tree management, natural area management Complete the table below related to the plant species and “typical” plant health problems for these species. Remember that the species you select must be applicable to your enterprise. Select the 4 plant species most significant to your workplace. Against your 4 selected plant species you are required to list the 3 most significant health problems that may affect the plant. Plant species Health problem The seasonal growth stages of the plant are determined Plant growth is reasonably predictable. If the way in which a plant grows and therefore subsequently responds to the environment (e.g. temperature, rainfall) and management practices (e.g. grazing, cropping, pruning, pest and disease control) is understood, then you can work towards management strategies that work with nature and promote plant health. As such, understanding the seasonal growth stages of a plant is essential to the development of successful management strategies? Specifically research your enterprise plant species and complete activity 2 on the next page. The following extracts are provided as a guide to useful resources related to plant growth. W EB Grains Research and Development Corporation; “Cereal Growth Stages”; ISBN 1-875477-40-3; Australia; 2005; pp2,5 Health problem Health problem Meat and Livestock Australia; “Pasture Growth”; Australia. W EB www.mla.com.au/Livestock-production/Grazingand-pasture-management/Improved-pasture/ Pasture-growth Growth Stages in Fruit Trees, from Dormant to Fruit Set, P. J. Chapman and Gertrude A. Catlin WE http://fls.cals.cornell.edu/OCRPDF/58a.pdf B The Four Stages Of Tree Growth W EB http://fwf.ag.utk.edu/physlab/tree_module/ index.html www.grdc.com.au/uploads/documents/GRDC%20 Cereal%20Growth%20Stages%20Guide1.pdf 7 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 2 For the 4 major plant species identified in activity 1 you are now required to prepare a seasonal growth calendar for each species. Please include average rainfall and temperature range for each season in your region as the climatic data is an important tool when diagnosing plant health problems. Plant name Season, climate conditions What growth occurs? Season, climate conditions What growth occurs? Season, climate conditions What growth occurs? What Season, growth climate conditions occurs? Cultural practices used on each plant species are recorded Irrespective of the type of plant species or the type of production system, an enterprise must maintain good record keeping and monitoring related to plant cultural practices. Without accurate and up to date records, agricultural and horticultural producers have no evidence that what they are doing is working towards an improvement in plant health or pest/disease management. The level of record keeping that is completed on your enterprise will depend upon your specific requirements. There is no perfect formula to record keeping. Some producers find that keeping clear notes in a diary works well for them, others use spreadsheets on their computers or industry specific computer software programs. Regardless of the method, it is important that all relevant management activities be accurately and consistently recorded over a period of time. This will: • Ensure accurate recording of plant cultural practices and factors that are variable such as the weather • Enable you to monitor what is working well and what requires improvement • Provide you with the baseline and comparative data required to make informed decisions about plant health and developing effective pest and disease programs. Also remember that record keeping practices are dynamic. They should change over time as you develop an understanding of the data that you require to manage your enterprise. If you are a member of an industry organisation (e.g. Meat and Livestock Australia), or an organisation like TreeNet you will find examples of record keeping practices and templates through their relevant websites and publications. 8 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 3 Ask yourself the following questions and provide an honest appraisal: What records do I keep that monitor plant health and cultural practices? Do the records meet my needs and provide the enterprise with appropriate data e.g. consider whether you can make informed decisions based on these records (now and in the future)? What improvements could I make? What benefits would these improvements provide? 9 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Search the internet and find organisations/industry associations that provide you with information, recording systems and data that is appropriate to your business and the applicable plant species. Include ALL of the websites that may be useful. Web site address and name Why is this website applicable to your workplace, business and the plant species you work with? 10 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems The following statements are extracts. These are provided to help you consider appropriate record keeping practices for your enterprise. W EB Department of Primary Industries Victoria; “Section 5: Paddock Record Keeping and Farm Monitoring”; Australia; 2011. www.dpi.vic.gov.au/agriculture/farmingmanagement/business-management/ems-invictorian-agriculture/stage-two-ems/paddockrecord-keeping Keeping good records is essential for monitoring your progress towards achieving your goals and targets. Keeping accurate records such as spray records, procedures, crop yields and rotations is crucial to making sure there is a consistent and traceable approach to plant health management. W EB National Association for Sustainable Agriculture Australia Limited; “NASAA ORGANIC STANDARD”; Australia; 2012; pp17-18. Grains Research and Development Corporation; “GRDC Paddock Diary; W Australia; 2012. EB www.grdc.com.au/~/media/5BC8A5E760164EEC 84969FCE710DF552.pdf Australian Farm Record Keeping Software: W www.dpi.qld.gov.au/documents/ BusinessAndTrade_ServicesAndGeneral/AFSDSoftware-catalogue.pdf EB W EB Grow Data www.growdata.com.au/index.php?option=com_ content&view=article&id=49&Itemid=2 Native Vegetation Health http://live.greeningaustralia.org.au/ nativevegetation/pages/page112.html W EB www.nasaa.com.au/data/pdfs/AAAA%20 NASAA%20Organic%20Standard%2006-022012.pdf The operator is to maintain records that enable NASAA to scrutinise the products and processes that are used on the property. Records are the most acceptable and consistent way of supporting the operator’s organic production and handling claims and provide the basis for ongoing monitoring of management strategies. 11 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 4 Review the previous activity now that you have had time to research other record keeping systems. For each of your selected plant species answer the following questions. Plant species What additional records or new record keeping Why/how will these records contribute to systems would you like to incorporate into plant health? your enterprise? Characteristics of the growing environment that affect the growth of a specific plant species are determined By now you have an understanding of the species that are important to your operation, relevant seasonal growing conditions and what actions you currently take on a day-to-day basis to manage these species. You now need to determine the characteristics of the growing environment that affect the growth of these species. With this knowledge you will be able to determine: • If the desired plant species will grow well within the constraints of your enterprise/climate. What characteristics of the growing environment are: • Within your control and can therefore be managed? • Beyond your control? The internet provides a number of sources to identify growing conditions for plant species within a geographical area (e.g. State Departments of Primary Industries) or an industry (e.g. grower organisations). Other sources of information may include: • Publications/Internet • Local professionals such as wholesale nursery suppliers, rural produce suppliers, landcare groups, council weed control officers, agronomists, TreeNet • Industry networks • Neighbours (particularly leading, innovative and successful managers) 12 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 5 For each species identified in activity 1 research the characteristics of your growing environment that affect the growth of these specie. Include mitigation actions and information sources. Plant species What growing environment characteristics typically affect this plant? What actions can realistically be taken to minimise negative affects? Include information/ internet source to substantiate your data Climatic data and environmental growing conditions are recorded Determining what records to keep can be challenging. If record keeping requirements become too onerous or are of little relevance to your enterprise, you are unlikely to continue keeping them. Conduct your own research to gain an appreciation of the different types of records that producers use. Use this research to form an opinion about the records you keep and whether they are meeting your needs. 13 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 6 Ask yourself the following questions and provide an honest appraisal. What records do I keep that monitor climatic and environmental growing conditions for my enterprise and applicable plant species? You need to be certain that the records you keep allow you to extract useful data. From the records listed above, what data is available and how is this data used? What improvements could I make to: • How I collect and record information? • What information I collect? • How I analyse and use the data? What benefits would suggested changes to record keeping provide? 14 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems The presence of beneficial organisms is recorded according to enterprise guidelines Historically, commercial horticulture and agriculture, as well as the management of amenity recreation spaces and natural resources, have routinely used chemicals (pesticides and herbicides) as a ‘one stop shop’ for the management of pests and diseases. For many situations, it was/is the first and last solution applied. The problems of this approach are now becoming more apparent. As pests and diseases continue to evolve and become resistant to many of these treatments, the treatments become stronger and more frequent. Stronger and more frequent treatments not only kill the pests and diseases but they also kill the beneficial organisms. • Diversity of soil life – Note how many different varieties of soil animals you see such as ants, beetles, spiders, slaters, millipedes etc. It is the variety that is important, not the numbers. • Earthworms – Higher numbers of earthworms indicate conditions that are favourable (more organic matter, high pH, low chemical residues). Mostly these are also conditions favourable for plant growth. • Microbes in the soil (bacteria, protozoans and fungi) play a major role in the break-down of soil organic matter. Sustainable management practices may still include the need for chemicals, but preferably as a last resort. Nature provides a host of beneficial organisms whose role it is to attack pests/diseases. This creates a win/win opportunity for land managers and the environment. A land manager must understand the whole eco system, including the important role of beneficial organisms and the need to manage environments to support these organisms. CESAR; “Back Pocket Guide – Beneficial Insects in Southern and Western Grains Regions”; GRDC; Australia. For your workplace you need to ask the following questions: www.cesaraustralia.com/sustainable-agriculture/ success-stories/ • What organisms are of benefit to my enterprise? • Can I recognise these organisms in the field? • How many of these organisms do I have (type and volume)? • Where can I source these organisms? • How can I monitor and promote their populations? Information about pests and beneficial insects applicable to growers establishing integrated pest management (IPM) programs on their properties. Review the following extracts and conduct your own research before completing activity 7. Tuckombil Landcare Inc., NSW Agriculture, the Natural Heritage Trust; “Northern Rivers Soil Health Card – A Soil Management Tool Developed by Farmers for Farmers”; Australia; 2002. W EB By testing regularly and keeping the ‘soil health’ cards, you can build up a record of your soil health, and understand the effect of management practices on soil health. Important “pointers” toward good soil health are: W EB Industries NSW; “Dung Beetles Working For You”; Prime Fact 442; Australia; 2007; pp1,2. W EB www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_ file/0011/110171/dung-beetles-working-for-you.pdf By rapidly burying dung pads, dung beetles reduce fly breeding sites and therefore fly numbers. Dung burial also reduces the infective stages of gastrointestinal parasites of livestock. Dung beetles can also clean up pastures and replace nutrients in the soil. The beetles’ tunnels result in greater water retention and less run-off and they improve root penetration and soil aeration. www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_ file/0007/168703/northern-rivers-soil-health-card.pdf 15 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity7 Please complete the following Table 1 and include information about beneficial organisms that are of relevance to your enterprise, business or industry. Identify: • • • • The organism The benefits provided Monitoring requirements (when, where, how, who) Performance indicators that identify good/medium/poor results An example has been included to assist you. Please also include your enterprise details in the table heading. Table 1: <insert your enterprise details>Beneficial Organisms Beneficial Organism Benefits Earthworm Monitoring and Record Keeping When Where Improve soil texture Annual Aerate soil 1 April All Owner operator to conduct paddocks test Improve water filtration Decompose organic matter Provide nutrients via castings (see map) How/Who Materials required (pad and paper to record results, shovel, black plastic sheet) Go to nominated paddock site to commence test (same site each year) Performance Indicator Reference >7 worms (good) www.dpi.nsw. gov.au/__data/ assets/pdf_ file/0007/168703/ northern-riverssoil-health-card. pdf 4-6 worms (medium) <3 worms (poor) Dig up one shovel of soil Place soil on plastic Sort through soil sample and count worms 16 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 8 Environmental and cultural factors that predispose plants to attack by pests and diseases are identified Now that you have an understanding of what a healthy plant looks like and the growth cycles of the plants applicable to your workplace, you need to understand the problems that these plants are predisposed to. Once signs and symptoms of a problem are evident, you need to recognise and diagnose the problem/s correctly. This information is critical and will support decisions about the most appropriate management responses to utilise. “While you cannot change a pest’s basic character, you can adjust management practices to decrease plants vulnerability. Understanding what makes a plant susceptible to pest attack is critical to devising management strategies that reduce plant losses, pesticide use and associated costs. Diagnose Plant Health Problems This section covers the following topics: • Environmental and cultural factors that predispose plants to attack by pests and diseases are identified • The symptoms and signs of plant health problems are identified using accepted nomenclature • The severity and extent of the problem in a plant species are assessed • Observations are compared with published data, historical records and own experience • The possible causes of the plant health problem are determined • Consult with specialist services in severe, complex or rapid onset cases • Plant or soil specimens are sampled and dispatched for specialist diagnosis or laboratory testing where required • Plant disorders and problems are recorded and documented in a report So far you have developed an understanding of the conditions required to promote plant health. Now you need to understand the factors that promote pests and diseases. The following extract provides an excellent introduction to this topic. Monoculture plantings are more susceptible to pest pressure than mixed stands. Specialised diseasecausing organisms and plant-feeding insects are less likely to bother plants that grow amid other types of plants. Not only does a pest find it more difficult to locate its preferred host in a mixture, but the pest’s natural enemies are often more abundant or effective. Conversely, large fields of single plants create an ideal environment for pest attack. When plants are genetically uniform, as most modern varieties are, the opportunity for pest damage is greater still. Plants under stress from drought, a lack of nutrients, soil compaction, or other factors are more vulnerable to pests such as aphids. Practices that promote the growth of healthy plants – ones that are able to better compete with pests or protect against them – are key to minimising pest problems.” (Sustainable Agriculture Network “A Whole Farm Approach to Managing Pests”; United States, P5). W EB http://www.sare.org/Learning-Center/Bulletins/ A-Whole-Farm-Approach-to-Managing-Pests There are a number of environmental and cultural factors that predispose plants to attack by pests and diseases. Understanding these and how they apply to your enterprise is critical when commencing a pest and disease management program. 17 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 8 Start your initial research for this section and identify the main 4 pests and 4 diseases that are likely to affect your enterprise, business or industry sector. Then research the environmental and cultural factors that predispose plants to attack by these pests and diseases. This is a risk assessment activity. It is important that you understand the risks and the conditions that favour the likelihood of the risk being realised. Summarise your findings by completing the table below. Remember to look at the bibliography and source material at the end of this section to get you started in your research. Include source documents that will be of use to you in the future. This will enable you to quickly source information about pests and diseases if they occur. Where possible, also source illustrations. Table 2: <<Insert Enterprise>> Pest and Disease Risks Pest or Disease that is Likely to Affect Your Enterprise Pest Description and Lifecycle Plants Affected Environmental and Cultural Factors that Predispose Plants to Attack Controls Source Psyllid pest Small, yellow green insect about 1-2 mm long that hatches from the plant’s growing terminal in 2-4 days and develops to an adult 10-16 days later. Leucaena species and accessions Humid coastal regions Low humidity and hot/dry or frost conditions www.leucaena.net/ leucaena%20psyllid.pdf Wet season Hot winds Under grazing of crops Heavy grazing Heteropsylla Cubana Cattle movement Spray with Dimethoate insecticide (3-4 wks control but should only be used if pests are likely to threaten young crops) Breeding new cultivars resistant to psyllid in progress (University of Qld) 18 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems The symptoms and signs of plant health problems are identified using accepted nomenclature Symptoms and signs of plant health problems can be broadly defined as follows: • Symptoms are plant reactions or alterations of a plant’s appearance due to a disease or disorder. • Signs are actual pathogen, parts or by-products seen on a diseased host plant. It is important to know what the normal appearance of a plant is before you decide there is a problem. It is also important to remember that appearance can vary with different cultivars. Some plant cultivars have naturally yellow to pale green leaves (e.g. new hosta cultivars, herbs like golden oregano, and coleus varieties) which at first glance appear to have symptoms of under-fertilisation, root stress or soil pH problems. Once the “normal” appearance of the specific plant is determined, several comparisons can be made between the problem plants and healthy plants. Compare characteristics such as: • • • • overall size, shape, and coloration leaf shape, size, coloration, and distribution root distribution and coloration bark, stem or trunk texture and coloration It is also important to note normal events, such as leaf drop, that may occur in a healthy plant. The affected parts of the plants should also be noted. Are there symptoms on the roots, leaves, stems, flowers, or fruit? Is the entire plant involved? Is only one limb or side of a plant involved? Answers to these questions can assist in the identification of the problem. Check for symptoms and signs Describing the characteristic symptoms exhibited by a specimen can be very difficult to do accurately. Because of this, it is often difficult, if not impossible, to determine what is wrong with a plant when a person is describing symptoms without an actual sample to view. W EB Symptoms can often be grouped as follows; for definitions of terms: Underdevelopment of tissues or organs – Examples include such symptoms as stunting of plants, shortened internodes, inadequate development of roots, malformation of leaves, inadequate production of chlorophyll and other pigments, and failure of fruits and flowers to develop. Overdevelopment of tissues or organs – Examples include galls on roots, stems, or leaves, witches’ brooms, and profuse flowering. Necrosis or death of plant parts – These may be some of the most noticeable symptoms, especially when they affect the entire plant, such as wilts or diebacks. Other examples include shoot or leaf blights, leaf spots, and fruit rots. Alteration of normal appearance – Examples include mosaic patterns of light and dark green on leaves, and altered coloration in leaves and flowers. Diseases also involve a progression of symptoms that can vary significantly. The progression of symptoms is one of the most important characteristics associated with problems caused by biotic agents. Diseases can result in primary and secondary symptoms. For example, decayed roots on a tree may be a primary symptom while the toppling over of the tree or wind throw is a secondary symptom. At later stages of a disease, secondary invaders may also obscure the original disease symptoms so that symptoms observed at the later stages of the disease are not typical of the symptoms developed in response to the original pathogen. It is important to look for a progression of disease symptoms in plants exhibiting problems. In some cases, such as improper herbicide usage, symptoms observed may be similar to spots present as a result of an infectious agent. The difference is that with herbicide injury, the symptoms usually appear suddenly and there is no observable progression of symptoms. The spots may also follow spray patterns of the herbicide. Herbicides can cause leaf distortion which may be confused with viral diseases. However, when new leaves form, they will generally be free of symptoms, indicating a lack of symptom progression. www.apsnet.org/edcenter/illglossary/Pages/ default.aspx 19 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Variations in symptoms expressed by diseased plants may lead to an improper diagnosis. Identify symptom variability Variations in symptoms expressed by diseased plants may lead to an improper diagnosis. These variations can result from a couple of factors. It is possible that there is more than one problem present, and in some cases there may be more than one pathogen infecting a plant. Symptoms associated with these infected plants may be significantly different from the symptoms expressed in response to each of the different pathogens acting separately. The disease symptoms exhibited by multiple pathogens infecting a plant may be either more severe or less severe than if the plant were infected with just one of the pathogens. This is commonly seen in multiple infections due to viruses. Look for signs of biotic causal agents Signs of plant disease agents are the observable evidence of the actual disease-causing agent. Signs may include: • the mycelia of a fungal agent • fungal spores • spore-producing bodies Indications of insects causing problems may include: • • • • the actual insect insect frass mite webbing insect eggs Signs are much more specific to disease-causing agents than are symptoms and are extremely useful in the diagnosis of a disease and identification of the agent causing the disease. The use of a hand lens and a knife can be valuable for a diagnostician in the field e.g. • Cutting into the bark of ornamental plants and trees at the soil surface may lead to the observation of mycelial mats of root rot fungi such as Armillaria spp. • Bacterial ooze can be observed by cutting stems and placing them in water. Identify plant part affected – Are symptoms associated with specific plant parts? It is important to note if the symptoms observed are associated with specific plant parts. For example: • Is a wilt observed correlated with a disruption of the vascular system which may be indicated by browning of the vascular system? • Are the roots of the plants abnormal including rots, decreased feeder roots? • Are necrotic lesions observed strictly on younger leaves? The symptoms of some diseases are most commonly seen on specific plant parts and this observation can be important in diagnosis. Riley, M.B., M.R. Williamson, and O. Maloy; “Plant Disease Diagnosis”; The Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/ PHI-I-2002-1021-01; Western Australia; 2002. W www.apsnet.org/edcenter/intropp/topics/Pages/ PlantDiseaseDiagnosis.aspx EB As you can see from this extract, there is a range of factors to consider when identifying the signs and symptoms of health problems. Take some time to have a look at the above article on-line. Signs and symptoms are discussed in detail and accompanied by illustrations. 20 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 9 For each pest and disease listed in activity 7, identify the signs and symptoms that will alert you to the fact that you may have a problem that requires action. Complete the row “signs and symptoms” in Table 3 on page 23 with your findings. Please note, that there is one table per pest and disease and you will be required to update sections in later activities. This will build a list of reference material that will be of use to you in the future. Table 3 : << Enterprise Name> Pest/Disease Profile e.g. Psyllid pest (Heteropsylla cubana) Signs/ Symptoms Symptoms Growing point – dieback, dead heart, distortion, dwarfing; stunting, external feeding, honeydew or sooty mould. Inflorescence – dieback, discoloration panicle, twisting and distortion, dwarfing; stunting, external feeding, fall or shedding, honeydew or sooty mould, blight; necrosis, wilt. Leaves – honeydew or sooty mould, abnormal leaf fall, honeydew or sooty mould. H. cubana nymphs and adults feed on the phloem of shoots, young leaves and, to a lesser extent, flowers. Older leaves are generally not attacked. Massive populations can cause necrosis of shoots, stunting, defoliation, and even death of the tree. Complete defoliation and death of leucaena stands is known to have occurred in some places. H. cubana produces copious amounts of honeydew which gives rise to the development of a black sooty mould on shoots and leaflets. H. cubana infestations are determined largely by the presence of nymphs and adults on the growing tips of Leucaena. Signs Eggs on underside of leaves, psyillid adult (see picture: www.plantwise.org/?dsid=27919andloadmodule=plant wisedatasheetandpage=4270andsite=234) Action Threshold Action Threshold Action <10% of crop affected Monitor Keep abreast of weather forecast and if weather favours outbreak (high rain, humidity), implement IPM controls >10% of crop affected Implement IPM controls 21 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Prevention Cultural Control and Pruning and grazing of new Leucaena shoots. Control Cattle movement through Leucaena stands. Host-Plant Resistance Breeding for resistance against H. cubana has been slow, and the results are largely inconclusive. Some lines of Leucaena lose resistance from generation to generation, year to year, and/or area to area, and others are very susceptible to mealybugs. Studies indicate that some secondary metabolites of Leucaena might impart resistance, but interactions of resistance with environmental factors must be determined in order to direct efforts at obtaining resistance. Resistant or tolerant species of Leucaena (e.g. diversifolia and pallida) do not produce as much fodder as L. leucocephala. Commercialisation of resistant varieties has been considered but the seeds tend to be sterile or fail to germinate. Cuttings generally fare poorly. Biological Control When H. cubana was found in Hawaii in 1984, efforts to find classical biological control agents to use against it began with an IIBC search for natural enemies in tropical America. The survey yielded spiders, coccinelids, mirids, reduviids, phymatids, wasps, ants, syrphids and predatory wasps; and two parasitoid wasps, Psyllaephagus yaseeni and Tamarixia leucaenae, both of which attack nymphs. Each female wasp lays one egg per nymph and can parasitize 50 nymphs; P. yaseeni is endoparasitic and T. leucaenae is ectoparasitic. After careful quarantine, testing, and propagation in the laboratory, P. yaseeni was released in Hawaii in June 1987, where it has become established. T. leucaenae did not propagate well in the laboratory and, therefore, was not released. A third wasp, Sectiliclava sp., from Mexico, parasitizes adult psyllids and is associated with H. cubana in Mexico, but has not been used in Hawaii or elsewhere as a biological control agent. The beetles Olla abdominalis and Curinus coeruleus, originally from Mexico, were released in Hawaii in 1908 and 1922, respectively, for control of scale insects and mealybugs. These generalist predators feed on all stages of H. cubana, but tend not to search widely for prey. Curinus was introduced into Thailand in 1987; India, Myanmar, and Vietnam in 1988; and Guam, Indonesia, the Philippines, Papua New Guinea, and the Northern Mariana Islands (Saipan) in 1989. Olla was introduced into New Caledonia in 1987 and Thailand in 1989. Tropical American pathogens of H. cubana include Conidiobolus coronatus, Entomophthora sp., Hirsutella thomsonii, and Paecilomyces. Applications of American and Asian entomopathogens against H. cubana have not been developed. Keep abreast of research for potential biological controls. Chemical Control For the moment, we are not including any specific chemical control recommendations due to expense and relative ineffectiveness (spraying is effective for 4 weeks only). Source www.leucaena.net/leucaena%20psyllid.pdf www.tropicalforages.info/key/Forages/Media/Html/Leucaena_leucocephala.htm www.plantwise.org/?dsid=27919andloadmodule=plantwisedatasheetandpage=4270andsite=234 22 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 23 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 24 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 25 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 26 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 27 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 28 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 29 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Complete one table for each pest/disease identified. <<Insert Pest/Disease>> Signs/ Symptoms Action Threshold Action Threshold Action Prevention and Control Source 30 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems W EB The severity and extent of the problem in a plant species are assessed Now that you have identified the signs and symptoms of plant problems, you need to determine the severity and extent of the problem. Before taking any pest control action, you need to determine if the problem exceeds a threshold limit, a point at which pest populations or environmental conditions indicate that pest control action must be taken. Sighting a single pest does not always mean control is needed. The level at which pests will become an economic threat is critical to guide future pest control decisions. (US Environmental Protection Agency; “Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Principles”; USA, 2010 www.epa.gov/ pesticides/factsheets/ipm.htm) Can you see that you are gradually building a more complete assessment of the problem at hand? This information will contribute to the decisions you ultimately make about how to manage/control the problem. There is no point ‘reacting’ to symptoms. You need to understand all of the contributory factors so that the management program you put in place is effective and treats the cause of the problem. There are a number of methods that you can use to determine the extent and severity of the problem: Observations • One of the first things that a diagnostician should note is how the diseased plants are distributed over the affected area. • Are they distributed uniformly across an area or are they localised? • Is there a definite pattern to the distribution? For example, does it occur only along the edges of a greenhouse near open windows, next to roadways or driveways, in low spots of a paddock, along a planted row, or is it affecting plants at random in a field? This distribution can be especially important in looking at the possibility of non-infectious problems, such as improper herbicide use or various soil factors, infrastructure/development factors. How prevalent is the problem? • Are all plants affected? Infectious problems generally occur over time and there is a progression of symptoms. Rarely will all of the plants be affected. • Generally, disease problems caused by biotic agents will be observed when they are causing problems on a low percentage of plants at least at the start of the disease, unless there were extenuating circumstances, such as the use of infected seeds. Even then, rarely will 100% infection be observed. • When a problem appears in 100% of the plants, it more commonly results from factors such as soil conditions (deficiencies or toxicities), adverse climatic factors (cold temperatures, hail, drought, etc.), or toxic chemicals (improper pesticide use, growth regulators, air pollutants, such as ozone, etc.). What has been the progression of symptoms on plants in the affected area? • If the symptoms all appeared at the same time and there has been no further development of symptoms, this would indicate a possible episodic event such as a change in temperature or possible improper chemical usage. • If however, the symptoms started in one area and slowly spread to other areas and the severity of disease symptoms changed over time, this would be more indicative of the presence of a biotic agent. Biotic agents can also include insects and mammals, such as voles, which may be feeding on plants in an area. Check for host specificity • Is the problem occurring in only one plant species or are different plant species affected? If different plant species are affected, this suggests the possibility of a non-infectious problem which could be related to cultural or environmental problems. • However, Phytophthora and Pythium root rots can cause problems on many different plant species; therefore, the fact that more than one plant species is affected does not completely eliminate infectious agents. If there is more than one species of plant involved, are these plants closely related and can they be infected by a common pathogen? 31 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Information pertaining to the growing environment to which the affected plant has been exposed is a vital piece of the puzzle. Ask Questions • Review the cultural practices and growing environment. It is vital that a diagnostician question the activities that have been conducted around the affected plants. • The problem may not be due to anything that the grower has done; the problem could be related to what his/her neighbour has done. • Information pertaining to the growing environment to which the affected plant has been exposed is a vital piece of the puzzle. • It is especially important to document changes in the environment. Environmental factors to consider include: extreme temperatures (freezing and heat), rainfall, hail, lightning, prolonged drought, temperature inversions (important in possible air pollutant damage and pesticide drift) and prevailing winds. All of these abiotic factors can be important to the problem. • Site factors such as soil type, possible drainage problems, and soil pH should also be evaluated. Cultural and maintenance activities can be significant • What pesticides or other chemicals have been applied? At what rate and when were they applied? Who applied the chemicals? What equipment was used in its application? • What other activities have occurred? Has the highway department been working along the roadway, possibly applying herbicides? • Have any unusual occurrences or weather patterns been noted? • In some cases careful and tactful investigation by the diagnostician may be required because someone may have done something improperly and may be unwilling to admit their error. Research • Keeping abreast of the latest industry based warnings/alerts is a proactive approach to assessing the potential severity and extent that a plant health problem might cause. Networks • Talking with neighbours and other producers in your area to find out what plant health issues are prevalent and their associated severity. Note, what affects one property may not affect a neighbouring property. Expert Advice • Contacting consultants, agronomists, Department of Primary Industry representative to discuss your observations to determine if further surveillance action is warranted. Through a combination of sources, the severity and extent of the problem can be defined to further inform decisions about appropriate controls. 32 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 10 10.1094/PHI-I-2002-1021-01. Building upon activity 9, now consider the action thresholds for each pest/disease that you have identified and consider the action thresholds that must be met before pest control action will be taken. www.apsnet.org/edcenter/intropp/topics/Pages/ PlantDiseaseDiagnosis.aspx Update Table 3 with your findings (row “action threshold”). Remember to add sources to your list as you conduct your research. Now that you have developed a ‘big picture’ view of a plant health problem, you have probably already made some deductions as to the likely cause/causes of the problem. Before you rush in and start thinking about a solution to the problem, take some time to do some further analysis. Confirm your assessment by comparing your observations with other sources. Many of these sources have already been identified previously in this workbook. “I thought I had a major problem with my pasture. The leaves were yellowing and the cattle weren’t going near the stuff. I was thinking that I would have to invest in a major re-mineralisation program – at considerable cost to the business. Then I had a look at my pasture records from previous years and spoke to a few neighbours. These comparisons saved me a fortune. It was a climatic condition that caused the problem and it resolved itself within a season” – anecdote from a pastoralist on the northern rivers of NSW. Consider some of the resources available to you to conduct these comparisons, such as: • Literature resources for possible diseases and disorders. • Indexes listing hosts and their pathogens. • Websites providing information. • Books with background information and host/ pathogen lists. • Compendia for information on specific crops. Have a look at some of the following extracts and online resources. There are literally hundreds of on-line resources dedicated to plant diseases and pests. The trick is to find ones that are credible, independent, work for you/your enterprise/your locality and are regularly updated. W EB Plant Health Australia; “Australian Plant Pest Database, Online Database”, Australia; 2001. http://www.planthealthaustralia.com.au/resources/ australian-plant-pest-database/ W EB CABI Plantwise; “Empowering Farmers, Powering Research – Delivering Improved Food Security”; European Union; 2012. W www.plantwise.org/default. aspx?site=234andpage=4273 ABC Gardening Australia; “ Fact Sheets, Pests, Diseases and Weeds”; Australia; 2011. www.abc.net.au/gardening/factsheets/pests_ diseases_weeds.htm W EB Australasian Plant Pathology Society; NSW; 2012. W www.appsnet.org/public/ (Riley, M.B., M.R. Williamson, and O. Maloy. 2002. Plant Disease Diagnosis. The Plant Health Instructor. DOI: EB EB CSIRO; “Plant Diseases and Pests”; Australia; 2011. W EB www.csiro.au/Organisation-Structure/Divisions/ Plant-Industry/Plant-diseases-and-pests.aspx 33 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 11 Update Table 3 with any additional reference materials/ information sources/advisors (contact details) that will be of ongoing relevance to your enterprise. The Possible Causes of the Plant Health Problem are Determined Now that we have identified that there is a plant health problem, we need to consider the possible causes. Both abiotic (non-living causes) and biotic (living) causes need to be considered. Some examples of these are: • • • • • • • abiotic (non-living agents) damage from chemicals weather mechanical interventions nutritional problems biotic ( living agent) pathogens – parasitic microorganisms that cause diseases W EB Pests – insects or mammals feeding on or damaging plants (National Plant Diagnostic Network; “Diagnosing Plant Problems; Plant Diseases”; NPDN Publication No. 0013; United States; 2008. www.firstdetector.org/jsp/contentPages/power%20 point%20presentations.jsp). How do you tell the difference between a nutritional deficiency (which may present as yellowing leaves) and a disease with the same symptom? This is where you need to become a ‘detective’ and canvass all of the possible causes before drawing any conclusions. The following extracts provide further examples to help improve your knowledge and investigative skills related to possible causes of plant health problems. W EB Brett Summerill and Eve Steinke; “Pests and Diseases of Australian Plants”; Australian Plants On-Line; NSW; 1997. http://anpsa.org.au/APOL5/mar97-4.html Sustainable Agriculture Network “A Whole Farm Approach to Managing Pests”; United States, pp11–13. W EB http://www.sare.org/Learning-Center/Bulletins/AWhole-Farm-Approach-to-Managing-Pests Consult with Specialist Services in Severe, Complex or Rapid Onset Cases By now you have started to formulate a clear understanding of the possible causes of plant problems that affect your enterprise/industry, but what if you have a rapid onset of a plant health problem or you cannot identify the cause of the problem? The cost of pests and diseases to an enterprise can be significant and it is essential to act quickly in instances of rapid or complex onset. Early detection and treatment may prevent further spread of the problem and reduce the risk of further losses. There are many organisations and federal or state government departments that can help with diagnostic services such as: Department of Primary Industries NSW; “Plant Health Diagnostic Service: Plant Pests And Diseases W Identification”; NSW. E www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/aboutus/services/das/plantpests-diseases B This has been included as an example only. Conduct your own research to identify the diagnostic facility most suited to your plant species and workplace needs. Most facilities provide similar services such as: • Specialist plant pathologists and entomologists with the backing of the Agricultural Scientific Collections Unit, which houses Australia’s largest collection of agriculturally significant insects, fungi and plant bacteria. • Diagnosis of crop disease and disorders. • Identification of insect and mite problems. • Chemical resistance testing. • Active surveillance for emerging and exotic diseases. 34 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 12 Identify a situation where you would require independent expertise to assist resolve a plant problem. Who you would consult in this situation and why? What information would you need to provide? What samples would be required? How would you collect these samples? Plant disorders and problems are recorded and documented in a report Once a plant disorder has been identified and the problem confirmed, it is important to keep good records for future reference. Recording the current situation (baseline data) and the activities you implement to resolve the problem will allow you to objectively assess whether the proposed solution is working or not. When similar signs and symptoms occur in the future, you can reference these records as part of your decision making process. W EB The following links provide examples of how plant disorders and problems are recorded and documented. You need to determine what is most relevant, practical and timely (given your available resources) for your own purposes. Records could range from one page with photos to sophisticated reports with detailed scientific analysis. www.planthealthaustralia.com.au www.springer.com/life+sciences/plant+sciences/journal/13314 www.daff.gov.au/aqis/quarantine/pests-diseases/myrtle-rust/myrtle-rust-qa www.agric.wa.gov.au/objtwr/imported_assets/content/_archive/tr095.pdf 35 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 13 Develop a report template that would meet your enterprise requirements and complete an example report for a plant disorder (real or hypothetical). Try and be succinct and use bullet point descriptors where feasible. You will add to this report later in the workbook, so there will be further opportunities to refine it for your enterprise. Also remember that a picture is worth a thousand words, so try to incorporate photos where possible. Your report should include the following information at a minimum: • • • • • • • • • • • Organisation Name of person completing report Date Affected location/s (GPS data if available) Background Environmental and cultural conditions Signs and symptoms Severity and extent of problem Possible causes Tests conducted/persons consulted (include date) Results of consultation 36 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 9 Remedy Plant Health Problems So far in this workbook, you have learned to identify plants, beneficial organisms, pests/weeds and diseases. The importance of correctly diagnosing pests and diseases has been emphasised. So now that you have the knowledge and have correctly diagnosed the problem, you are ready to consider appropriate strategies to resolve the problem. This section covers the following topics: • A weed, pest and disease control program is formulated according to the enterprise Integrated Pest Management (IPM) strategy and production plan. • Resources, tools, equipment and machinery required for work activities are identified, costs/benefits are analysed, and availability confirmed with suppliers, contractors and appropriate personnel. • WHS hazards associated with work activities are identified, risks assessed and controls implemented. • A range of modifications to growing conditions that could be considered in a specific situation are identified. • Modifications to growing conditions for a specific plant species are selected and implemented, having regard to cost of damage, marketing requirements and sustainable horticultural practices. A Weed, Pest and Disease Control Program is Formulated According to the Enterprise Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Strategy and Production Plan Throughout this workbook you will be using the term Integrated Pest Management or IPM. There are many definitions of IPM and many other acronyms that you will come across as you research this topic (e.g. integrated pest and weed management, ecological weed management, integrated disease management etc.). Consider that these terms are largely interchangeable and that the basic principles are the same for all of them. The ‘I’ in ‘IPM’ refers to the need to consider many strategies that are complementary to each other to manage pests, weeds and diseases so that a process is integrated. These strategies should be sustainable and work with nature where feasible. Chemical control is but one of the strategies and where it is required (preferably the option of last resort), it should be used wisely. This means using specific narrow spectrum chemicals rather than broad spectrum, used at the most appropriate stage of a pest lifecycle not ‘every 3 months’, using appropriate quantities and so on. Some of the solutions to be considered include a combination of the following: • Cultural – management activities which can be used to make the environment less favourable for pest species, such as crop rotation, rotational grazing, biodiversity of species. • Mechanical – physical removal of pests, slashing, weed rolling, weed steaming. • Genetic – planting cultivars that are resistant to pests or are well adapted to local environmental conditions. • Biological – using one living organism to control another. • Chemical – used only when required and in reduced frequency. IPM is becoming more appropriate as the cost of traditional chemical solutions become more expensive and less effective (due to increased weed/pest/disease resistance) and the insistence for reduced chemical use is voiced by the consumer and general population. It is generally recognised that farmers, horticulturalists and land managers don’t want to apply stronger and stronger chemical controls and customers don’t want to purchase produce that have been treated in this manner. “No matter whether that single tactic is chemical, biological or physical, if it kills 99 percent of a pest population, the few surviving pests will find a way to avoid it or resist it,” “That’s what natural selection is all about.” 37 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Have a look at the following to build your understanding of IPM and its principles. W EB Mike Raupp; the University of Maryland Extension; “Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Basics”; You Tube; USA; 2011. www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqjJg6KGOe4 W EB Ontario Pesticide Ed; “Integrated Pest Management © 2004”; You Tube; Canada; 2011. www.youtube.com/watch?v=VER4_4PSiF0 Now consider the following extract from the NSW Government – Environment and Heritage: “What is integrated pest management? Integrated pest management (IPM) is an environmentally sensitive way of managing pests. It uses a combination of practices and control methods to prevent problems from occurring rather than dealing with them after they have happened. IPM practices include forward planning, regular monitoring and timely decision-making. IPM control methods include: • Biological control, using predators, parasites or microbial pathogens to suppress pests. • Cultural and physical control, using methods such as barriers and traps; adjusting planting location or timing; or crop rotation and cultivation techniques which expose pests to predation or destroy their food, shelter and breeding habitats. • Chemical control, selecting the least toxic pesticides and using them only when needed as opposed to regular preventative spraying. • Plant choice, choosing plant varieties that are resistant to diseases in an area, and matching species to the site. • Genetic control, releasing sterilised male insects to decrease the incidence of successful mating of pest species. • Pheromone control, using pheromones to monitor insect populations in a crop or orchard. IPM can be applied in agricultural and nonagricultural settings, such as the home, garden, workplace and natural spaces and is normally implemented as a four-tiered approach. Set action thresholds: Before taking any pest control action, set an action threshold, which is a point at which pest populations or environmental conditions indicate pest control action must be taken. Sighting a single pest does not always mean control is needed. The level at which pests will become an economic or environmental threat is critical for guiding future pest control decisions. Monitor and identify pests: Not all insects, weeds and other living organisms require control. Many organisms are harmless, and some are beneficial. Monitor for pests and identify them accurately so appropriate control decisions can be made in conjunction with action thresholds. This monitoring and identification removes the possibility that pesticides will be used when they are not really needed or that the wrong kind of pesticide will be used. Prevent pests from becoming a threat: IPM programs prevent pests from becoming a threat. In an agricultural crop, this may mean using methods such as rotating between different crops, selecting pest-resistant varieties or planting pestfree rootstock. These control methods can be very effective and cost-efficient, and present little to no risk to people or the environment. Control: Once monitoring, identification and action thresholds indicate that pest control is required, and preventative methods are no longer effective or available, find the most effective control method that presents the least risk to the environment and human health. Such methods include: • highly targeted chemicals such as pheromones that disrupt pest mating • mechanical controls such as trapping or weeding. 38 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems “If further monitoring, identification and action thresholds indicate that less risky controls are not working, employ additional pest control methods such as targeted spraying of pesticides. The general spraying of non-specific pesticides is a last resort.” (NSW Government – Environment and Heritage; “Integrated Pest Management”; NSW; 2012. www.environment.nsw.gov.au/pesticides/ integratedpestmgmt.htm) You may feel very comfortable or completely daunted by the prospects of developing an IPM for your enterprise. The best plans are ones that make sense to you, are practical and are easy to understand. They may be 1 page or 100 pages, simple or complex. Have a look at some of the following extracts to get a better feel of what an IPM program might look like for your enterprise. W EB Department of Environment and Climate Change NSW; “Section 3 – Integrated Pest Management”; NSW; pp47-58. Nova Science in the News; “Integrated Pest Management – The Good, the Bad and the Genetically Modified”; Australian Academy of Science; W Australia; 2001. E B www.science.org.au/nova/041/041key.htm Sustainable Agriculture Network “A Whole Farm Approach to Managing Pests”; United States. W EB www.sare.org/Learning-Center/Bulletins /A-Whole-Farm-Approach-to-Managing-Pests www.environment.nsw.gov.au/resources/ sustainbus/07588GolfCoursesPt3.pdf W EB Department of Primary Industries, Parks, Water and Environment – Tasmania; “Organic Management of Organic Apples – Integrated Pest Management Poster (IPM)”; Tasmania; 2012. www.dpiw.tas.gov.au/inter.nsf/WebPages/CART82L4FW?open 39 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 14 Outline the contents of an IPM plan for your enterprise, business or industry. Then include some details next to each content heading. The level of detail should be sufficient to clearly identify your needs and those of your staff/contractors and any certifiers (e.g. QA program certifiers). Please be succinct and don’t get bogged down in too much detail. It is a document that outlines your approach to IPM. It should provide you/your staff/contractors with guidelines to help make informed decisions about pest management approaches to be used within the enterprise. You may wish to include tables already completed in this workbook. Before you get started, have a look at the other activities in this section. Your IPM will be developed throughout the workbook, so it will be useful to ‘get a feel’ for all of the components before you start. 40 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Now that you have developed a basic outline for your IPM plan you should be constantly monitoring the enterprise landscape and applying your knowledge to make informed decisions about when to act. As IPM includes an arsenal of different and complementary solutions to be applied, you need to consider which ones could be used to your advantage, pending the specific situation that arises. To recap on what you have learned so far and where you are in the decision making process, consider the following step by step summary. • Know the botanical names of your plants and learn about their preferences and common problems. • Regularly inspect plants in your workplace. Frequent inspection is the best way to discover a problem in its earliest stages, when it can be easier to control. • Consider the general appearance of each plant from a short distance and ask yourself if it looks healthy. Are there any signs or symptoms indicative of a problem? Are there dead areas? Is it wilted? Are any leaves discolored or abnormally curled? • Stop at plants – get out of your vehicle and slowly scan them. Watch for movement that might indicate the presence of an insect or mite. Turn leaves over and look at their undersides. Inspect stems, branches, and leaves for insects, holes, webbing, or split areas. • Identify what you find. Remember that some insects are beneficial for your enterprise. • Decide what threshold is acceptable. Is the damage actually affecting the health of your produce? Will profits be negatively affected? What can you live with? If at this point you have decided that the pest requires intervention, you now need to consider the range of options available to you to select from. Given the approach to the management of pests is integrated, you need to consider the ‘many little hammers’ or strategies that you may have at your disposal to manage pests to acceptable levels. • Cultural – management activities which can be used to make the environment less favorable for pest species. • Mechanical – physical removal of pests. • Biological – using one living organism to control another. • Chemical – used only when required and in reduced frequency. As you research this topic, you will come across different categories. Please be aware that there is no single definitive list, it is a dynamic list. The following extracts provide examples of some strategies that could be used to modify growing conditions and reduce pest incidence and prevalence. Whilst some situations appear unique, the approaches to sustainable pest management are reasonably generic. Use these as a guide and then conduct your own research to determine what strategies are available to you. As a final summary have a look at the following extract on the Principles of Integrated Pest Management. Department of Resources – Primary Industry; Northern Territory Government; “Principles of Integrated Pest Management”; Northern Territory; 2008. W EB www.nt.gov.au/d/Primary_Industry/index. cfm?Header=Principles%20of%20Integrated%20 Pest%20Management Now that you have thoroughly researched and understood the range of options available to you, it is time to select the most appropriate ones and implement them. Choose a method that is most effective against the pests/diseases and least disruptive to other organisms and the environment, and use management methods when the pest/disease is most vulnerable. Remember that an IPM plan is dynamic and as conditions change (e.g. new pests emerge, issues are resolved), you need to review your plan and modify it if required. IPM requires you to ‘learn by doing’ and it involves a combination of art and science. The success of your IPM program will come down to careful observations and the quality of the decisions you make (e.g. when to act, what controls to implement). There will be trial and error involved as there is no single formula that can be applied to meet all of the variables that affect your enterprise. You need to be realistic about the potential outcomes before you embark on an IPM program. If you are certified with a quality assurance program, there may be some elements of IPM that you are already addressing. Whilst consumers may be demanding more ‘clean green’ produce, their understanding of IPM is limited. The generic requirement is probably for ‘chemical free’ food/products/environment. This is not always possible, but any progress you make towards IPM is certainly heading in the right direction. 41 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Frequent inspection is the best way to discover a problem in its earliest stages, when it can be easier to control. Activity 15 Update Table 3 (in activity 9) with prevention and control strategies (see relevant row) for each pest/disease already identified. During your research, canvass as many different types of strategies as possible (e.g. cultural, biological, chemical etc.). Update your sources as you find new references of value to your enterprise. 42 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 10 Evaluate Treatment Program Once you have developed an IPM plan, it is in a constant state of implementation. The enterprise / worksite will be monitored for signs/symptoms of plant problems, decisions will be made as to whether interventions are required and if so, these interventions need to be monitored for effectiveness. IPM is a guide for decision making and requires constant monitoring of the enterprise. This section covers the following topics: • • • • • Plants are monitored during treatment Appropriate data is recorded according to enterprise guidelines Observations are compared to expected results Modifications to the treatment program are recommended to client/management Treatment program report is documented and presented to client/management Plants are Monitored During Treatment and Appropriate Data is Recorded According to Enterprise Guidelines To achieve successful implementation of an IPM program, you must be able to monitor and measure the impact of the program to ensure you are achieving the objectives. What is monitoring? Monitoring is the regular gathering and analysis of information needed for your day-to-day management, to ensure a system is being implemented and expected outcomes/objectives are being achieved. Without good record keeping and monitoring, it is difficult for a business to accurately determine that system requirements are being met. This is especially important when there are multiple participants/staff. IPM is not a ‘set and forget’ task. Monitoring is central to its success and you need to remain vigilant. W EB Have a look at this website to appreciate the range of monitoring tools that could be used for integrated pest management in crops and pastures. www.dpi.vic.gov.au/agriculture/farming-management/business-management/ems-in-victorian-agriculture/ environmental-monitoring-tools/herbicide-resistance Now consider your own enterprise/workplace and start thinking about how you would monitor an IPM program. The following extracts may assist you with this process. 43 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems W EB Nursery and Garden Industry Australia Ltd; “Simple Integrated Pest Management (IPM) technique”; Technical Nursery Papers – Issue no. 6; NSW; 2004; p2. www.ngia.com.au/files/nurserypapers/ NP_2004_07.pdf W EB Australasian Biological Control; “IPM and Biological Control”; Australia; 2009. www.goodbugs.org.au/IPMnotes. htm#IPMandBiologicalControl W EB South Australian Research and Development Institute (SARDI); “White Fly”; South Australia. www.sardi.sa.gov.au/pestsdiseases/horticulture/ horticultural_pests/integrated_pest_management/ resources/greenhouse_pests/white_fly W EB South Australian Research and Development Institute (SARDI); “Crop Monitoring Program”; South Australia. www.sardi.sa.gov.au/pestsdiseases/horticulture/ horticultural_pests/integrated_pest_management/ resources/crop_monitoring_program Accurate record keeping is essential to an IPM program. Records will: • Allow observations and results to be analysed to determine if pest management objectives are being met. • Help you manage enterprise plant problems during the current growing season, evaluate management methods, and predict problems in the future. • Illustrate changes in the enterprise environment, physical changes, pest numbers and changes in any damages or loss. • Ensure the IPM program is still followed when changes in staff or contractors occurs. Ultimately, records are there to help you make more informed (and therefore better) decisions. When designing record keeping forms and systems consider: • Legislative and regulatory requirements • Certification requirements (e.g. applicable if you are a member of a QA program). • What will fit within your enterprise policies and procedures? • What will be practical for you to complete (in field and back at the office)? • How you will use the data to make decisions now and in the future? For example, excel spreadsheets enable you to create trend charts for easier comparison of data over time. By now you should clearly recognise that the major requirements for a successful IPM program are: • Inspect plants regularly and closely. • Keep good records. • If chemicals are used, they are a part of the program, not the only treatment. Observations are Compared to Expected Results, Modifications are Made and Clients are Advised Now that you have implemented your IPM plan, monitored the program and recorded the results, you are in a position to determine if you have achieved your objectives. This evaluation process is a practical management tool for understanding and improving the performance of your IPM program and demonstrating its impact. Remember that any evaluation should validate or improve your monitoring and record keeping activities: • Can you easily compare results with expected outcomes? 44 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 16 It is now time to revisit the tables completed for activities 7, 8 and 9. • Select one plant species. • For that species you are then required to select the pest or disease that has the most significant impact on that plant in your workplace. • The plant species and pest that you select should be one that you deal with in the workplace and that has the potential to significantly affect plant health. • Review all of the information you have collated for that pest or disease. You are required to create a Plant Health Sheet written as a simple WORK INSTRUCTION that could be utilised as a work procedure for new employees in your workplace. Remember, it is essential to provide accurate information, but it must be clear and easy to follow. You are encouraged to use dot points, photos and diagrams. Please ensure that your Plant Health Instruction clearly identifies: • • • • • • The plant species by botanical name and include a clear photograph The major pest/disease by common name A photo or diagram and a clear explanation of the symptoms/signs of disease A clear set of monitoring work instructions A clear set of ipm work instructions A process for informing management of modifications to treatments and subsequent updates to plant health instruction sheets. PLANT HEALTH SHEET Plant species – botanical name The major pest/disease by common name Photo or diagram and clear explanation of the symptoms/signs of disease MONITORING work instructions IPM work instructions Process to inform staff Any other information/comments 45 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Whether you are an owner/operator or have multiple staff/contractors it is important to keep a summary report of your IPM activities/outcomes. Treatment program reports (monitoring and findings) is documented and presented to client/management Whether you are an owner/operator or have multiple staff/contractors it is important to keep a summary report of your IPM activities/outcomes. This might consist of: • A written summary of a pest/disease outbreak that was managed and its outcomes • An annual review of the IPM program and its achievements • A power point presentation to staff/management • Informal communications (phone, email) to key stakeholders of program outcomes. Whatever the method, information provided must be accurate, with the outcome clearly articulated and ongoing monitoring and management explained in a manner allowing implementation of a successful strategy. Monitoring and evaluation reports can play many different roles, and the information produced can be put to very different uses such as: • To demonstrate accountability – delivering on promises made to stakeholders. • To convince – using evidence from findings. • To educate – reporting findings to help organisational learning. • To explore and investigate – seeing what works, what does not, and why. • To document – recording and creating corporate memory. • To involve – engaging stakeholders through a participatory process. • To gain support – demonstrating results to help gain support among stakeholders. • To promote understanding – reporting results to enhance understanding of projects, programs, and policies. 46 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Activity 17 As your final activity for this workbook you are required to complete a simple report template for a plant disorder you deal with in your workplace. Do NOT use the same plant disorder as that used for activity 16. Complete all sections of the following table. Organisation and name of person completing report Date Plant Disorder by name Affected location/s – GPS data if available Background Environmental and cultural conditions Signs and symptoms Severity and extent of problem Possible causes Tests conducted/persons consulted Results of consultation Diagnostic information Actions taken Monitoring activities Recommendations Results Description or photo 47 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 11 Summary of Key Innovations/ Opportunities identified as a Result of Adopting These Skills The adoption of new opportunities and key innovations should always be considered from the perspective of the triple bottom line. However each producer will need to determine: • What are the most important aspects of each opportunity and innovation? • How can a new innovation or opportunity be sustainably applied to your business or production system? The summary below is provided as a list of suggestions. It is by no means complete. It is also unrealistic to assume any single business can adopt every opportunity. • Improve understanding and management of conditions required to enable plants to thrive and encourage plant’s own defensive mechanisms/resistance to pests. • Delay development of insecticide resistance (the point where chemicals lose their effectiveness against pests). • Reduce pesticide use and residue levels on produce. • Improve worker safety. • Decrease harm to non-target organisms. • Diminish outbreaks of secondary pests (minor pests that become major as a result of pesticide use). • Reduce environmental contamination. • Lessen spray drift onto neighbouring properties. • Reduce costs. • Improve pest control, plant health and productivity. • Opportunity to differentiate products and capitalise on the growing, maintaining ‘green, chemical free’ food/products/environment that consumers/public are demanding. • Better decisions resulting from timely, complete and accurate monitoring, data recording and information analysis. • Continuous improvement of food and fibre production or our natural and amenity resources as a result of monitoring, reviewing and resolving pest issues. 48 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 12 Bibliography and Source Material Organisation Standard Legislation Contact Details Web Site Reason for Inclusion Australian Centre for Agricultural Health and Safety – University of Sydney OHS Factsheets www.aghealth.org.au/index. php?id=7 www.aghealth.org.au/index.php Farmer resources for OHS. Biological Farmers of Australia Australian Certified Organic Standard; Version 1; 2010. www.bfa.com.au/ContactUs.aspx www.bfa.com.au Relevant standards included for pest, disease and weed management CABI Plantwise www.plantwise.org/default. aspx?site=234andpage=4328 www.plantwise.org/default. aspx?site=234andpage=4273 Diagnostic support tool for identifying plant health problems – United Nations global tool. CESAR Australia www.cesaraustralia.com/contactus/ www.cesaraustralia.com/ sustainable-agriculture/ The Sustainable Agriculture team are experts in developing and delivering sustainable pest control strategies for broad-acre crops and pastures. T can assist you with invertebrate focused education and training, field and lab research, product development, identifications, monitoring programs, IPM consulting and much more. CSIRO www.csiro.au/en/Portals/Contact. aspx www.csiro.au/OrganisationStructure/Divisions/Plant-Industry/ Plant-diseases-and-pests.aspx CSIRO has extensive capabilities in researching, understanding and tackling various insect pests of plants, plant diseases and weeds. Department of Primary Industries – NSW Regional legislation relevant to pest, weed and disease control www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/aboutus/ about/contact www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/agriculture/ pests-weeds Regional pest, weed and disease control information Department of Primary Industries – QLD Regional legislation relevant to pest, weed and disease control www.daff.qld.gov.au/31_88.htm www.dpi.qld.gov.au/27_4823.htm Regional pest, weed and disease control information Department of Primary Industries – VIC Regional legislation relevant to pest, weed and disease control www.dpi.vic.gov.au/about-us/ contact-us www.dpi.vic.gov.au/agriculture/ pests-diseases-and-weeds Regional pest, weed and disease control information 49 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Organisation Standard Legislation Contact Details Web Site Reason for Inclusion Department of Agriculture and Food – WA Regional legislation relevant to pest, weed and disease control www.agric.wa.gov.au/CONTACT. html?s=320001400 www.agric.wa.gov.au/PC_92916. html?s=320001400,Topic= PC_92916 Regional pest, weed and disease control information Department of Primary Industries, Parks, Water and Environment – TAS Regional legislation relevant to pest, weed and disease control www.dpiw.tas.gov.au/inter.nsf/Fe edbackForm?OpenFormandEma il={dp$w:t^s:g|v:^_;Int%rn%tC||r d$n^t|r www.dpiw.tas.gov.au/inter.nsf/ ThemeNodes/DREN-4VH82R?open Regional pest, weed and disease control information Department of Resources – Primary Industry – NT Regional legislation relevant to pest, weed and disease control www.nt.gov.au/d/Primary_Industry/ index.cfm?header=Key%20 Contacts www.nt.gov.au/d/Primary_Industry/ index.cfm?header=Plants Regional pest, weed and disease control information Farmpoint – Tasmanian Government Regional pest, weed and disease control information www.farmpoint.tas.gov.au/ farmpoint.nsf/v-systempages/ contacts www.farmpoint.tas.gov.au/farmpoint. nsf/Weeds,-Pests-and-iseases/99 AA39142B4F10ACCA2573910013 6D3A Regional pest, weed and disease control information www.farmstyle.com.au/contact www.farmstyle.com.au/news/goodbugs-small-farms-%E2%80%93beginner%E2%80%99s-guide Beneficial organisms and links to books for purchase www.freshcare.com.au/contactUs www.freshcare.com.au Relevant standards included for pest, disease and weed management www.goodbugs.org.au/IPMnotes. htm#IPMandBiologicalControl The site lists all the commercially available beneficial insects in Australia and New Zealand. www.grdc.com.au/director/about/ contactus www.grdc.com.au/director/events/ factsheets Factsheets and a range of resource materials for grain plant health, weed and disease management. Plant health and growing advice Plant health and growing advice Plant health and growing advice Farmstyle Freshcare Freshcare Food Safety and Quality Code of Practice – 3rd Edition. Australasian Biological Control Grains Research and Development Corporation (GRCD) MLA : Meat and Livestock Australia LPA Quality Assurance Manual Email: info@mla.com.au mla.com.au Includes requirements for record keeping relevant to pest, weed and disease control (i.e. paddock records, chemical use records etc.) NSW Government – Environment and Heritage Regulations for keeping records of pesticide use www.environment.nsw.gov.au/ feedback www.environment.nsw.gov.au/ pesticides/risintro.htm Pesticide use regulations (NSW) and IPM overview Plant Health Australia www.environment.nsw.gov.au/ pesticides/integratedpestmgmt.htm APPD Administrator Plant Health Australia Tel: (02) 6215 7700 or APPD@ phau.com.au www.planthealthaustralia.com.au/ resources/australian-plant-pestdatabase/ The Australian Plant Pest Database (APPD) is a national, online database of pests and diseases of Australia’s economically important plants. 50 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Organisation South Australian Research and Development Unit (SARDI) Standard Legislation Contact Details Web Site Reason for Inclusion www.sardi.sa.gov.au/contacts www.sardi.sa.gov.au/pestsdiseases Regional pest, weed and disease control information Pests and diseases research incorporates two of SARDI’s Sustainable Systems science program areas; Plant and Soil Health Entomology Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education (SARE) www.sare.org/Contact-Us www.sare.org www.sare.org/Learning-Center/ Books www.sare.org/Learning-Center/ Books/Manage-Insects-on-YourFarm www.sare.org/Learning-Center/ Books/Steel-in-the-Field Weeds Australia Site Content: www.weeds.org.au Excellent resource for sustainable farming practices. Free online books available for download. A few links have been provided for some of these books (Managing Insects on Your Farm and Steel in the Field). Weed identification site National Weeds Management Facilitator Telephone: (03) 6344 9657 Fax: (03) 6343 1877 51 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 13 Being confident about your skill levels Before commencing on your summative assessment take a few minutes to review this workbook and ensure you feel that you are confident about your skill levels related to this topic. Use the table below to help check your skills. Before commencing your final assessments it is important to review any sections in which you feel unsure. *Remember* It is always OK to ask your assessor/lecturer questions. The following table provides a list of skills and knowledge you should have after completing this workbook. Review this table and: 1. 2. 3. Put a tick in the column if you can do this now and a brief comment as to why you believe you have this skill. Put a tick in the next column if you feel you need more practice and a brief comment as to why. If you require further training, complete the third column listing what training is needed. Show this list to your supervisor or assessor and ask for more time or training before completing the summative assessments. Skills/knowledge you should have I can do this now I need more practice and must review the work before completing final assessments What additional training do I need? Differentiate between pest and disease and nutrient associated symptoms in specific plant species Research information about plant health problems, their diagnosis and remedial treatments available Identify signs and symptoms of plant health problems Determine possible causes of the problem Assess the severity, extent and speed of onset of the problem Implement treatment programs to remedy the diagnosed health problems Document plans and write reports for the understanding of staff, supervisors and contractors Calculate the cost and spatial and logistical requirements of components of the plant health program Record all relevant information according to enterprise and industry standards Comply with legislative requirements Identify hazards, assess risk and implement controls 52 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems Skills/knowledge you should have I can do this now I need more practice and must review the work before completing final assessments What additional training do I need? Comply with WHS requirements of the workplace Communicate orally with staff, supervisors, contractors, suppliers and consultants Plant anatomy, morphology, physiology, histology, pathology, taxonomy and nomenclature Taxonomic descriptions, horticultural/agricultural function, cultural and growth requirements, and target growth and performance characteristics of specific plants for the achievement of enterprise production and business plans Plant nutrition issues associated with the growth media/soil and region for specific plant species Weeds, pests and disease detection methods, taxonomic identification, life cycle stages and characteristic symptoms for the specific plants of the enterprise Chemical, cultural and biological control methods included in the IPM strategy of the enterprise Chemical use, toxicity and compatibility with target plants, growth media, and environmental characteristics of the region Sustainable practices relevant to the enterprise and/or region Evaluation procedures, including cost/benefit analysis, for plant and growth media treatments in relation to plant health, enterprise budget and performance targets Enterprise and industry record keeping and reporting policies and requirements WHS hazards associated with activities to promote plant health and the controls necessary to remove or minimise risks associated with them 53 AHCPCM501A – Diagnose plant health problems 14 Assessment You have now reached the end of this workbook. All of the information and activities you have covered have developed your skills to diagnose plant health problems competently in your workplace. Your competency may be assessed through your successful completion of all formative activities throughout this workbook. Alternatively, your RTO may require completion of a final summative assessment. You will need to discuss this with your RTO. FEEDBACK This workbook has been developed to guide users to access current information related to gaining skills appropriate to their workplace. Please complete the following table notifying us of any errors or suggested improvements. Subject Name Book Number Page What is the error Suggested improvement 10 You Tube video is not accurate Better websites / You Tube example Is there a link to your suggested improvement Additional comments Click here to email your feedback form to RST 54