Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns In Nature And The Mathematics Behind It Peng Feng1 1 Department of Physical Sciences and Mathematics Florida Gulf Coast University Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Outline 1 Snowflakes 2 Patterns in Nature Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems 3 Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns 4 A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern 5 Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis 6 A Few Comments Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments No Two Snowflakes Are the Same Source: www.snowcrystals.com, maintained by Kenneth G. Libbrecht Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments 1611, Kepler pondered on the question why snowflakes always exhibit a six-fold symmetry; 1635, mathematician Descartes gave some reasonably accurate description; Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments 1954, Physicist Ukichiro Nakaya performed systematic study on the formation of snowflakes: Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems Outline 1 Snowflakes 2 Patterns in Nature Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems 3 Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns 4 A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern 5 Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis 6 A Few Comments Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems Ripples of Sand Source: Bob Bauer, 2002 Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems Outline 1 Snowflakes 2 Patterns in Nature Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems 3 Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns 4 A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern 5 Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis 6 A Few Comments Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems Shells of South West Florida Source: http://www.meddybemps.com/shells/shells2draw.html Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems Animal Skin Patterns Java fish, Zebra fish, Rabbit fish and Angel fish http://www.panagadivers.com/Diving/Fishes.htm Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems More Animal Skin Patterns Leopard, Zebra Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems Patterns in Bacterial Colony Source Courtesy of Professor Eshel Ben-Jacob Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Patterns in Nonbiological Systems Patterns in Biological Systems More Patterns Nautilus and Romanesco Broccoli: http://www.discoveringfossils.co.uk Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments What is Diffusion? Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Modeling Diffusion u(t, x, y ):the density of a certain chemical compound at time time t and at (x, y ) ∈ R 2 ; Diffusion:The chemical will move from high density places to low density places; Diffusion is the mechanism of many molecular and cellular movement; It can be described by the heat equation ut = ∆u where ∆u := uxx + uyy . Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Modeling Diffusion u(t, x, y ):the density of a certain chemical compound at time time t and at (x, y ) ∈ R 2 ; Diffusion:The chemical will move from high density places to low density places; Diffusion is the mechanism of many molecular and cellular movement; It can be described by the heat equation ut = ∆u where ∆u := uxx + uyy . Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Modeling Diffusion u(t, x, y ):the density of a certain chemical compound at time time t and at (x, y ) ∈ R 2 ; Diffusion:The chemical will move from high density places to low density places; Diffusion is the mechanism of many molecular and cellular movement; It can be described by the heat equation ut = ∆u where ∆u := uxx + uyy . Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Modeling Diffusion u(t, x, y ):the density of a certain chemical compound at time time t and at (x, y ) ∈ R 2 ; Diffusion:The chemical will move from high density places to low density places; Diffusion is the mechanism of many molecular and cellular movement; It can be described by the heat equation ut = ∆u where ∆u := uxx + uyy . Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Simulation of Diffusion Equation Consider the one dimensional equation: ut = kuxx where u(t, x) represents the temperature on a beam at time t and location x, k : heat conductivity or how fast heat will transport; This equation usually coupled with a boundary condition and initial condition. For example u(0, x) = u0 (x) and u(t, 0) = u(t, 1) = 0. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments An Example of Reaction-diffusion System ut = ∆u + λf (u, v ), vt = d∆v + λg(u, v ), ux = 0, x = 0, a, u(x, 0) = u(x, b), vx = 0, x = 0, a, v (x, 0) = v (x, b), u(0, x, y ) = u0 (x, y ), Solution of the P system: λ(k 2 )t W(x, y, t) = ∞ C e cos 2 n,m=0 n,m 2 n 4m k 2 = π2 a 2 + b 2 . Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu t > 0, (x, y ) ∈ (0, a) × (0, b), t > 0, (x, y ) ∈ (0, a) × (0, b), ux (x, 0) = ux (x, b), vx (x, 0) = vx (x, b), v (0, x, y ) = v0 (x, y ). (1) nπx a cos Patterns In Nature mπy , b where Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Few Quick Observations When b is small, striped patterns are more likely (constant along the y axis); When b is large, spotted patterns are more common (Not constant along y axis); Snakes always have rings, but not spots; Animal can have spotted body and striped tail but rarely striped body with a spotted tail. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Few Quick Observations When b is small, striped patterns are more likely (constant along the y axis); When b is large, spotted patterns are more common (Not constant along y axis); Snakes always have rings, but not spots; Animal can have spotted body and striped tail but rarely striped body with a spotted tail. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Few Quick Observations When b is small, striped patterns are more likely (constant along the y axis); When b is large, spotted patterns are more common (Not constant along y axis); Snakes always have rings, but not spots; Animal can have spotted body and striped tail but rarely striped body with a spotted tail. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Few Quick Observations When b is small, striped patterns are more likely (constant along the y axis); When b is large, spotted patterns are more common (Not constant along y axis); Snakes always have rings, but not spots; Animal can have spotted body and striped tail but rarely striped body with a spotted tail. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Few Quick Observations When b is small, striped patterns are more likely (constant along the y axis); When b is large, spotted patterns are more common (Not constant along y axis); Snakes always have rings, but not spots; Animal can have spotted body and striped tail but rarely striped body with a spotted tail. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Examples of Cos in Skin Pattern Valais goat; Belted Galloway Cow(Oreo Cow?); Panda: Found at: Southwestern Switzerland; Scotland; Sichuan Province, China. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Genet; Lemur; Snake: Found at: East Africa; Madagascar, South Africa; Common . Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Turing One of the greatest scientists of 20th century; Turing machine; Father of computer science; Breaking of U-boat Enigma, saving battle of Atla Source: www.turing.org.uk Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Turing’s Diffusion-driven Instability In a system of equations modeling two interactive substances, different diffusion rates could lead to nonhomogeneous distributions of such reactants, i.e., the occurrence of patterns. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Reaction-Diffusion System Consider the hypothetical chemical reactions: U + 2V → 3V (2) V →P (3) Assume: U is fed into the reaction at a constant rate F and precipitate P is removed; Rate of change of U: remove rate uv 2 ; feed rate F (1 − u); Thus ut vt = Du ∆u − uv 2 + F (1 − u) 2 = Dv ∆v + uv − (F + k )v Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature (4) (5) Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Consider the equilibrium solution (u, v ) = (u∗ , v∗ ) of the system ut vt = Du ∆u − uv 2 + F (1 − u) ⇔ = Dv ∆v + uv 2 − (F + k)v √ ⇒ u∗ = 12 1 ± 1 − 4δ2 F , v∗ = 0 = −uv 2 + F (1 − u) uv 2 − (F + k )v 0 = √ 1 2 2δ 1 ∓ 1 − 4δ F . Recall : For y 0 (t) = 1 − y 2 , the equilibrium solution y = 1 is stable⇔ limt→∞ y (t) → 1 for y (t) with suitable initial condition. An idea : Instability of the constant solutions implies possible complicated patterns. Even though the type of patterns will require more detailed analysis. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Pattern Developing Process 1: k=0.062; F=0.05 Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Pattern Developing Process 2: k=0.057; F=0.018 Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Pattern Developing Process 3: k=0.001; F=0.005 Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Phase Diagram for Bacillus Source: K. Kawasaki et. al. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 1997. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Simple Looking Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern bt = Db 5 · {nb 5 b} + nb, n = D ∆n − nb, n t n(x, y , 0) = n0 , b(x, y , 0) = b0 (x, y ) ∂n = ∂b = 0, ∂ν ∂ν Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature in Ω in Ω ∂Ω (6) Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Shouldn’t gene be playing a huge role here??? Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Mutation in Fruit Fly Figure: Bithorax mutant Figure: Antennapedia mutant Caused by a single homeodomain gene. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Figure: Small wing mutant Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Gene Expression Figure: Fushi Tarazu (ftz) mRNA in Drosophila embryo, by in situ hybridization;(Hafen, Kuroiwa and Gehring, Cell, 1984) Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Figure: Another example, courtesy of Sean Carroll, HHMI Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Formation of Somites What is Somite: Paired blocks of mesoderm cells along the vertebrate body axis that form during early vertebrate development and differentiate into dermal skin, bone and muscle. Mouse: 60 somites; Chick: 28 somites; (Every 90 minutes) Snake: can reach up to 500; Gene: Chick: C-hairy-1 Zebrafish: her-1 Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Biology 101 Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Mathematical Model for Gene Regulation in A Cell dp = am(t − τp ) − bp(t), (7) dt dm = f (p(t − τm )) − cm(t), (8) dt τp : time lag between the initiation of the translation and the appearance of a mature protein τm : time lag between transcription and the appearance of a mature mRNA molecule. b and c: degradation rates of proteins and mRNAs, respectively. a is the translational constant. θn f (p) = θkn +p n : Switch-like phenomena. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Parameter a b c k n θ τp τm Value 4.5 molecules/min 0.23 molecules/min 0.23 molecules/min 33 molecules/cell· min 5 40 molecules 2.8 min 10.2 min∼ 31.5 min Table: Estimated parameters for her1 gene. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Let r = τm /τp and we can reduce the system to the following one with dimensionless time t/τp , which is again denoted by t: dp = τp [am(t − 1) − bp(t)], dt dm = τp [f (p(t − r )) − cm(t)]. dt The steady states E ∗ = (p∗ , m∗ ) satisfy (9) (10) am − bp = 0, (11) k θn − cm = 0. θn + pn (12) Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Theoretical Result Theorem √ ka n−1 n When c > bθ n − 1, E ∗ = (p∗ , m∗ ) is asymptotically stable n for all r > 0. When c is small, there exists a critical value r0 such that the steady state E ∗ is asymptotically stable for r ∈ [0, r0 ) and unstable for r > r0 , where ξ2+ − bcτ2p 1 arccos r0 = − 1, (13) ξ+ bc1 τ2p and 1 1 ξ2+ = − (b2 + c 2 )τ2p + τ2p [(b2 − c 2 )2 + 4b2 c12 ]1/2 2 2 Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature (14) Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Future Direction This model only deals with a single cell; It does give us some insight into the mechanism; Modeling the cell network communications can be very complex; One mechanism for cell communication is Delta-Notch Pathway. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments What does it take to model biological problem? A sound understanding and appreciation of the biological problem; A realistic mathematical representation of the important biological phenomena; A biological interpretation of the mathematical analysis and results in terms of insights and predictions. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments What does it take to model biological problem? A sound understanding and appreciation of the biological problem; A realistic mathematical representation of the important biological phenomena; A biological interpretation of the mathematical analysis and results in terms of insights and predictions. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments What does it take to model biological problem? A sound understanding and appreciation of the biological problem; A realistic mathematical representation of the important biological phenomena; A biological interpretation of the mathematical analysis and results in terms of insights and predictions. Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Further Readings Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments A Few People James Murray, Emeritus Professor of Mathematics, University of Washington Philip Maini, Center of Mathematical Biology, University of Oxford Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments E. Ben-Jacob, Tel Aviv University, Former President of Israel Physical Society Hans Meinhardt, Max-Planck Institute Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Are we abusing mathematics? Or are we ignoring it? Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Are we abusing mathematics? Or are we ignoring it? Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature Snowflakes Patterns in Nature Turing Mechanism for Skin Patterns A Mathematical Model for Bacteria Colony Pattern Delay Induced Oscillations in Somitogenesis A Few Comments Thank you! Peng Feng pfeng@fgcu.edu Patterns In Nature