1 PREPARED FOR: Ms. SAMRA JAVED Faculty of Interpersonal Communication Skills College of Business Management Karachi. PREPARED BY Shahid Raza Id # 2007-3-20-7289 06. September.2008 2 Letter of Authorization September 06, 2008 Dear Readers I am the student of Health Management MBA program at Institute of Business Management (IoBM), where as course requirement of Interpersonal Communication Skills, I am authorized by Madam Samra Javed to submit this Term report on "Conflict Management" The content of this report reflects the practical life scenario and I have tried my level best to justify the valuable information gathered Sincerely Shahid Raza MHM 3 Letter of Transmittal September 06, 2008 Madam Samra Javed Course Facilitator Institute of Business Management Karachi Dear Madam: The Term Paper is on “Conflict Management” which you authorized me to submit. This informative report unveils the major areas of concerns faced in the working and daily life environment. Review the report and if there is need for further clarification or elaboration, contact me at information below. Sincerely Shahid Raza MHM 2007-3-20-7289 Cell: 0333-2705509 shahidnraza@yahoo.com 4 Letter of Acknowledgement September 06, 2008 Dear Reader I praise Allah All Mighty for giving me the courage and strength to complete the task of writing the report on “Conflict Management”. This report would be incomplete without the impeccable support and guidance received from Madam Samra Javed, our course facilitator of Interpersonal Communication Skills at the IoBM. Sincerely Shahid Raza MHM 5 INTRODUCTION When people think of the word conflict, they often think of wars or violence. However, conflict exists at all levels of society in all sorts of situations. It is easy to forget that we experience conflict every day of our lives. Conflict happens when two or more people or groups have, or think they have, incompatible goals Conflict is a fact of life. God made each of us in his own image, but he also made us unique. Therefore some of our views and opinions will differ from those of others. Conflict often occurs because of a lack of respect for one another’s needs and views. However, in most cases we resolve the conflict. From a personal level to international level, good communication is usually used to overcome differences and to reach an agreement before violence breaks out. At a personal level, we often do not realize we are overcoming our differences. It is important to remember that conflict can be creative. Conflict is sometimes necessary to bring justice where injustice exists. It can provide an opportunity for new social and political systems to be established and can help to shape the future. However, when conflict becomes violent it will usually do more harm than good. After violent conflict, it is often difficult to see the opportunities for a better future due to the widespread destruction of infrastructure and livelihoods, the breakdown of trust and the suffering caused through bereavement, trauma, grief and anger. It is also likely that such social change could have occurred before the conflict became violent. Definition Conflict may be defined as a struggle or contest between people with opposing needs, ideas, beliefs, values, or goals. However, the results of conflict are not predetermined. Conflict might escalate and lead to nonproductive results, or conflict can be beneficially resolved and lead to quality final products. TYPES OF CONFLICT There are many different types of conflict experienced by communities all around the world. We suggest four categories into which most conflicts will fall 1. No Conflict: Any peaceful community is likely to face conflict sometimes, although communities in this category are good at resolving conflict before it develops. 6 2. Surface conflict: This has shallow or no roots. It may be due to misunderstanding of goals, which can be addressed by improved communication and the conscious effort of opposing groups to understand each other’s needs and opinions. 3. Latent conflict: This is conflict below the surface. It might need to be brought out into the open before it can be effectively addressed. 4. Open conflict: This conflict is very visible and has deep roots, sometimes over several generations. Both the causes and the effects need to be addressed OTHER WAY OF CLASSIFICATION1 1. Pseudo Conflict: Conflict triggered by a lack of understanding and miscommunication. 2. Simple Conflict: Conflict that stems from different ideas, definitions, perceptions or goals. 3. Ego Conflict: Conflict that is based on personal issues; conflicting partners attack each other’s self esteem. Causes of conflict Gender Self-concept Expectations Situation Position (Power) Communication skills 7 CONFLICT MANAGEMENT Conflict management is the principle that all conflicts cannot necessarily be resolved, but learning how to manage conflicts can decrease the odds of nonproductive escalation. Conflict management involves acquiring skills related to conflict resolution, self-awareness about conflict modes, conflict communication skills, and establishing a structure for management of conflict in your environment. Physiologically we respond to conflict in one of two ways—we want to “get away from the conflict” or we are ready to “take on anyone who comes our way.” CONFLICT MANAGEMENT SKILLS All people can benefit, both personally and professionally, from learning conflict 2 management skills. Typically we respond to conflict by using one of five modes: Competing Avoiding Accommodating Compromising Collaborating COMPETING The competing conflict mode is high assertiveness and low cooperation. Times when the competing mode is appropriate are when quick action needs to be taken, when unpopular decisions need to be made, when vital issues must be handled, or when one is protecting self-interests. Competing Skills Arguing or Debating Using Rank or Influence Asserting your Opinions and feelings Avoiding The avoiding mode is low assertiveness and low cooperation. Many times people will avoid conflicts out of fear of engaging in a conflict or because they do not have confidence in their conflict management skills. Times when the avoiding mode is appropriate are when you have issues of low importance, to reduce tensions, to buy some time, or when you are in a position of lower power 8 Avoiding Skills Ability to withdraw • Ability to sidestep issues • Ability to leave things unresolved • Sense of timing Accommodating The accommodating mode is low assertiveness and high cooperation. Times when the accommodating mode is appropriate are to show reasonableness, develop performance, create good will, or keep peace. Some people use the accommodating mode when the issue or outcome is of low importance to them. The accommodating mode can be problematic when one uses the mode to “keep a tally” or to be a martyr. For example, if you keep a list of the number of times you have accommodated someone and then you expect that person to realize, without your communicating to the person, that she/he should now accommodate you. Accommodating Skills Forgetting your desires • Selflessness • Ability to yield • Obeying orders Compromising The compromising mode is moderate assertiveness and moderate cooperation. Some people define compromise as “giving up more than you want,” while others see compromise as both parties winning. Times when the compromising mode is appropriate are when you are dealing with issues of moderate importance, when you have equal power status, or when you have a strong commitment for resolution. Compromising mode can also be used as a temporary solution when there are time constraints. 9 Compromising Skills Negotiating • Finding a middle ground • Assessing value • Making concessions Collaborating The collaborating mode is high assertiveness and high cooperation. Collaboration has been described as “putting an idea on top of an idea on top of an idea…in order to achieve the best solution to a conflict.” The best solution is defined as a creative solution to the conflict that would not have been generated by a single individual. With such a positive outcome for collaboration, some people will profess that the collaboration mode is always the best conflict mode to use. However, collaborating takes a great deal of time and energy. Therefore, the collaborating mode should be used when the conflict warrants the time and energy. For example, if your team is establishing initial parameters for how to work effectively together, then using the collaborating mode could be quite useful. On the other hand, if your team is in conflict about where to go to lunch today, the time and energy necessary to collaboratively resolve the conflict is probably not beneficial. Times when the collaborative mode is appropriate are when the conflict is important to the people who are constructing an integrative solution, when the issues are too important to compromise, when merging perspectives, when gaining commitment, when improving relationships, or when learning. Collaborating Skills Active listening • Nonthreatening confrontation • Identifying concerns • Analyzing input 10 Stages of conflict in pictorial view 3 1. Pre-conflict DIFFERENCES Discussions and differences can be healthy and productive if met with tolerance. TENSIONS Views become fixed and people begin to criticise their opponents and view them as the enemy. Differences between the groups get worse. The groups become more divided. 2. Confrontation DISPUTES Neither side will admit that they have made mistakes. They become determined. More extreme positions are taken. Threats are made but not carried out. Supporters may engage in demonstrations or other confrontational behaviour. 3. Crisis Peak of conflict with open hostility and/or violence. Communication between sides often stops. HOSTILITIES People become convinced that their views are right. Opponents are mocked, scorned and isolated. Some threats are carried out. VIOLENCE ‘No way back’. ‘They must lose’. Force is used, perhaps physical violence. 11 4. Outcome Force may run its course until one party ‘wins’, another surrenders, a cease-fire is agreed, or all are exhausted. Outsiders may intervene with force to bring violence to a halt. 5. Post-conflict End of violent confrontation. When one side ‘wins’, it may not lead to positive change. It may create new injustices which could result in confrontation (Stage 2) once again. 6. Communication channels opened Both sides agree that a solution is needed. Outsiders may help both sides to communicate. Ways to move forward are established. 7. Mutual understanding 12 People come to understand views of others and respect them. The conflict is described (sometimes mapped) to help find possible solutions. 8. Finding solutions An approach is found that everyone agrees on, whether this uses the law, customary methods or partnership. Solutions are agreed and acted upon 9. Agreement Everyone agrees. They may agree to keep different views but always accept the views of others. It may be helpful to have a written and signed agreement for future reference SUMMARY The goal of this document is to provide the conflict management information that can be beneficial both personally and professionally. Some people think conflict is a topic that should not be discussed and that we should not engage in conflict. Productively engaging in conflict is always valuable. Most people are willing and interested in resolving their conflicts; they just need the appropriate skill set and opportunities in which to practice this skill set. Without a conflict skill set, people want to avoid conflict, hoping it will go away or not wanting to make a “big deal out of nothing.” Research and personal experiences show us that, when we avoid conflict, the conflict actually escalates and our thoughts and feelings become more negative. 13 Through conflict self-awareness we can more effectively manage our conflicts and therefore our professional and personal relationships. Furthermore, by discussing issues related to conflict management, teams can establish an expected protocol to be followed by team members when in conflict. All teams and organizations have a conflict culture (the way the team responds to conflict). However, most teams never discuss what the conflict culture is, therefore providing the opportunity for individual team members to make assumptions that can be counterproductive to the team. Practicing one’s conflict management skills leads to more successful engagement in conflict with outcomes of relief, understanding, better communication, and greater productivity for both the individual and the team. When we manage our conflicts more effectively, we use less energy on the burdensome tasks such as systemic conflict and get to spend more of our energy on our projects at work and building our relationships. Below are references that can assist both individuals and teams to greater conflict management success. References 1. Interpersonal Communication Relating to others. Steven Beebe, Susan J. Beebe, Mark V. Redmond Page 243. 2. Consulting Psychologists Press (CPP). Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument. Palo Alto, CA: (800)624-1765 or available on the World Wide Web at http://www.cpp-db.com. 3. Adapted from Footsteps 36 pages 8–9 using Working with Conflict page 19 14