Proposal For Trail Assessment and Planning Services Arcadia Project Grand Traverse Regional Land Conservancy Submitted By: International Mountain Bicycling Association Trail Solutions Program Scott Linnenburger May 13, 2005 Introduction The IMBA Trail Solutions team specializes in the planning, design, and construction of recreation trails that are low maintenance, sustainable, and that meet the experiential demands of all manner of trail users. IMBA Trail Solutions is honored to present this proposal for a Trail Plan and to be part of the team working toward the Arcadia Project’s potential as a model for sustainable recreation, agriculture, and land conservation. IMBA believes a well-designed trail: 1. 2. 3. 4. Protects the environment; Requires little maintenance; Meets the needs of its users; and Minimizes conflict between different user groups. If any one of these four values is overemphasized at the expense of another, the trail could cause irreparable damage to the resource, provide an unsafe or negative experience for visitors, or deplete a maintenance budget. Building on this credo, IMBA Trail Solutions will focus on four key concepts that result in a trail system that highlights the Arcadia property and provides steady year-round recreation. First, the trail system must be sustainable, having minimal impact on the landscape for generations to come. Second, it must provide a large and diverse visitor base with an optimized recreational experience. Third, the trails must be creatively planned to enhance the internal connectivity of property’s different ecosystems and land uses. Fourth, the trail system must be planned to draw a steady flow of visitors and leave them with a very positive experience, a better understanding of the landscape, and an inherent desire to return. Developing a successful trail system is highly dependent on a cooperative relationship between the Grand Traverse Regional Land Conservancy, IMBA’s Trail Specialist, the Michigan Mountain Bicycling Association, and the property’s visitors. This is not only the optimal way to bring great ideas to the forefront, but a vital first step in creating a stewardship attitude with visitors of the area. As a non-profit organization with a mission to create, enhance, and preserve trail opportunities, IMBA keenly understands the ever-increasing role of users of the trails in achieving quality management of the land’s resources and the need to create a broader constituency of support for the preservation of open space. IMBA Trail Solutions believes that one of the best strategies to achieve this goal is by putting the public on beautiful trails that passively interpret the landscape for the trail user and create a feeling of being very close to that land. The final product of the field reconnaissance and cooperative brainstorming will be the Trails Plan. IMBA Trail Solutions professionals have been recognized around the world for expertise in designing and constructing trails as well as building a trails community. Experience History Initiated in late 2002, Trail Solutions has quickly been recognized as one of the country’s premier trail contractors. From an initial staff of two Trail Specialists, the Trail Solutions team now employs two fulltime and three part-time Trail Specialists and a full time Coordinator for the team’s trail design and construction projects. In the last three years, Trail Solutions has designed over 250 miles and constructed over 50 miles of shared use trail. All Trail Solutions staff members spent at least two years prior to their current positions working for the Subaru/IMBA Trail Care Crew, and collectively have undertaken trail assessment, design, construction, or maintenance on over 500 trails in all 50 states and over a dozen foreign countries. This has allowed our staff to build an incredible knowledge base pertaining to trail design and construction in almost all physiographic regions, trail user matrices, and land management mandates. Trail Solutions is an active member of the Professional Trailbuilders Association (PTBA), the only group of professional trail contractors in the country. Trail Solutions staff also sits on the Board of PTBA and has provided three-day trailbuilding seminars at the 2003 and 2004 Annual PTBA Conference. Trail Solutions staff also participate in the National Trails Training Partnership and Federal Interagency Trails Council, public-private partnerships to improve the status of trails in the United States. Trail Solutions have been invited to be a part of these groups because of our track record with innovative partnerships and our reputation for designing and building environmentally sustainable trails that require little maintenance over time. To that end, IMBA was contracted by the Federal Highway Administration’s Recreational Trails Program to produce the second edition of IMBA’s trailbuilding manual, now called “Trail Solutions.” All of the manual’s material was provided by IMBA Trail Solutions and Trail Care Crew staff. Relevant Projects Attached to the proposal is a more complete list of Trail Solutions projects, specifications, and references from the last three years. Relevant to the needs of GTRLC are the following projects: Little Creek Mountain Trail Solutions is currently under contract with the Bureau of Land Management in southwestern Utah to provide trail planning services on a 20,000-acre mesa outside St. George, UT. The need for a managed, well thought out trail system on this mesa arose because of widespread archaeological poaching (the mesa includes thousands of rock art sites, at least three Anasazi villages, and numerous other high-density cultural sites). The BLM felt there was a need for increased recreational opportunity in the area and that a very popular trail system, routed near but not on top of the cultural resources would provide a passive deterrent for the poaching. Trail Solutions has developed plans for a four-phase trails development that will equally serve mountain biking, hiking, equestrian, and off-highway vehicle interests, complete with six trailhead locations, dispersed campground locations, and signage planning. When complete, this will be around a 75-mile shared-use trail system. Santos Trail System- Marjorie Harris Cross-Florida Greenway Trail Solutions has contracted with the Florida Office of Greenways and Trails to assess the 35-mile Santos trail system near Ocala, Florida. A spider web of socially developed trails, the system tended to cause disorientation and some of the very technical terrain that is present on the property posed a danger to inexperienced trail users. Trail Solutions planned the recreation of the system into a five-loop set of trails that are designed to accommodate recreational, intermediate, and advanced level trail users in terms of length of the loops and technical challenge that is present. Staunton State Park, Colorado Trail Solutions is currently working with Colorado State Parks to develop a four-season trail system for Colorado’s newest State Park acquisition, a former set of four ranches. The 3,600-acre property’s main amenity will be its trail system and State Parks’ goal is to create a revenue-producing park (based only on parking/trail use fees, camping, and related amenities) that draws a steady stream of visitors during each season with its trail system and backcountry feel. Trail Solutions’ goal is to create a trail system that provides at least two full days of potential use for mountain bikers, hikers, equestrians, Nordic skiers while highlighting the National Park-caliber aesthetic resources of this property. Northern Kettle Moraine State Forest, WI Trail Solutions contracted with Wisconsin DNR to design 15 miles of mountain bike trails within the Northern Kettle Moraine State Forest. WI DNR felt the best management decision on this land was to keep trail uses separate. With the Ice Age Trail, the cross-WI equestrian/snowmobile trail, and 15 miles of existing hiking/Nordic ski trail on 400 acres of property, and the request that trail intersections be kept to a minimum, this project proved very challenging. Trail Solutions was able to create a four-loop system in one trails area with only four intersections of the existing trail system. Black Canyon Trail, Arizona In a partnership with Arizona BLM, Trail Solutions assessed the southern half of the 70-mile Black Canyon trail corridor to make sustainability and management recommendations on this historic cattle and sheep driveway. With many volunteers and potential stewards in the outer-Phoenix area, but no access to the canyon, Trail Solutions brought the hiking, mountain biking, equestrian, wildlife viewing, and motorized recreation communities together around the idea of a Black Canyon Trail System that connected the communities along I-17 with this incredible piece of public land. The trail plan now calls for dozens of miles of loop trails originating from new trailheads in the towns of New River, Black Canyon City, connections to the Black Canyon Trail, and eventually a 200 mile shared-use trail system that connects Phoenix and Prescott, Arizona. Wissahickon Park, Philadelphia, PA Working with the Friends of Wissahickon and the Fairmount Park Commission, Trail Solutions has conducted a full sustainability and maintenance assessment on the 1,800-acre urban park’s historic 55mile trail system, conducted meetings with over 20 stakeholder groups, and is currently developing a plan for the rehabilitation of that entire system. Integrating the trail system with the needs for both environmental restoration and management of the native ecosytems still functioning in the park create a matrix of goals that will provide maximum protection as well as maximum exposure of this urban treasure. Design Process Trail Solutions staff regularly design all trails “on the ground” as sometimes very small variations in trail alignment are the key to the trail’s sustainability, the visitor’s experience on that trail, and the impression left from a visit. The staff is also heavily dependent on accurate data to assist in this process. Our staff works with Trimble hand-held gps units loaded with ArcGIS software to aid in the trail design process. In almost every trail design situation, the optimal season for trail design takes place before full leaf-out when understory visibility and satellite reception is maximized. For this project, we would recommend marking the trail alignments in the field this summer with flagging tape and/or wire stakes and gathering the gps information in the coming fall (it can take twice as long to design and three times as long to design and gps a new trail when leaves are present) to control costs. Following the gps data collection, Trail Solutions can produce and ArcGIS 9.0-compatible map delineating the proposed trail system overlain on property boundary, ecosystem, and land use management information for GTRLC to employ in stewardship decision-making. Trail Solutions is available to lead public meetings, educational classes on trail construction and maintenance, and to work with GTRLC on environmental education planning related to the trail system and the Conservancy’s goals. Key Trail Concepts Concept One- Minimize Environmental Impact A successful trail system will cause minimal impact to the surrounding environment. The trail system on the Arcadia property will be planned to minimize impacts to aquatic, wildlife and geologic resources, as well as protecting the stunning viewsheds and natural aesthetics. Water has the potential to do far more trail damage than any particular user. It is vital to minimize water’s impact by creating rolling contour trails that are constructed across slopes rather than down a slope’s fall line. This type of construction allows water to retain sheet flow when encountering trails rather than focusing its potential erosive power in a channelized manner. Special care will be taken to minimize stream and wetland crossings, and when crossings are necessary, they will be constructed to minimize sediment load to the aquatic ecosystems. The trail system will not adversely impact the biological and geological resources present on the property. Trail Solutions will work closely with GTRLC staff to determine whether areas exist where human activity is detrimental, either in total or seasonally, and account for those constraints in the trail system design. The trails will not require surfacing that may introduce non-native materials and potentially change soil geochemistry and floral assemblage. These natural surface trails will be relatively narrow (less than four feet wide in most cases) and will not create canopy breaks in order to minimize habitat fragmentation potential. The trails will be designed to be minimally obtrusive to the natural landscape. Concept Two- Maximize Visitor Experience Every visitor has an optimal trail experience in mind. Trail Solutions has planned trail systems all over the world to be highly desirable to visitors, whether they are mountain bikers, hikers, equestrians, bird watchers, skiers, or off-highway vehicle enthusiasts. Our staff has spent considerable time canvassing trail user groups to determine the experiences they would like to be provided and worked to develop stacked loop trail systems that meet the varied desires of different user groups. The system will be planned to handle a high volume of trail users by efficiently dispersing them through the network based on the experience being sought and retain the feeling of solitude. Shared-use trails are the best way to meet the demands of a large and varied visitor base. However, precautions must be taken to provide the desired experience while also minimizing the potential for user conflicts. Sightlines, speed considerations, length of trail, aspect, water crossings, and turning platforms must be planned with the potential trail user matrix in mind. High volume trails near facilities will need to be wider, shorter in length, less difficult, and contain long sightlines. Trails that access the further reaches of the park and draw less traffic will be narrower, longer, more challenging, and can safely have shorter sightlines and more natural obstacles. In some cases, the ideal visitor experience is dependent on a singleuse trail. For example, a wildlife-viewing trail will best function with very few trail users and strategically located viewing areas. Concept Three- Enhance Physical and Emotional Connectivity Concurrent trail and facility planning is vital to the success of a trail-based destination. Connectivity provides users with a feeling of cohesion and naturalness that is vital to turning visitors into supporters and citizen stewards. A well-planned trail system disperses users throughout the property. This allows the GTRLC to satisfy visitors’ experience needs even when there is a large number of people on the trails. Planning for this cohesion from the beginning will increase the effective size of the property and draw a larger visitorship. Keeping visitors away from sensitive resources or unsightly views creates an experience that idealizes the land and creates a sense of place, respect, and emotional tie to the property that can turn into volunteer and financial support for similar endeavors. Action Steps Trail Solutions will send a Trail Specialist to the Arcadia site for three-week assessment and planning engagement. Trail Solutions will work with the staff and stakeholders, complete a field survey of the property on both the existing trails and portions of the property without trails. The deliverable product will be the property’s Trail Plan. This plan will contain: 1. Routes and specifications of trails that correspond to a general construction corridor; 2. A general trails development plan outlining primary, secondary, and tertiary steps, timelines, and estimated costs for construction; 3. Recommendations for visitor management and signage (trail kiosk, intersection, and waymarking) that provides direction and interpretation; 4. Recommendations for facilities and management that enhance the Conservancy’s status as a trails destination provider and incredible steward of great land. Cost Structure IMBA’s Trail Specialists are billed at an hourly consulting rate of $60/hour plus expenses. The estimated costs for the field assessment, survey, and trail plan development are as follows: Field Reconnaissance/Staff Interaction 120 hours Trails Plan 40 hours Expenses (including airfare, ground transportation, per diem and supplies) $7,200 $2,400 $2,500 Total Project Cost $12,100 Trail Solutions can schedule time to complete this project between July 5 and July 31, but are currently fully engaged before and after this period. Certainly, expense costs can be minimized if on-site lodging is available and ground transportation is not required. If additional information or clarification is needed, please do not hesitate to contact Scott Linnenburger at (303) 545-9011 or via email, scott@imba.com. Trail Construction Experience Lead Contractor Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Tamarack Mountain Resort, McCall, ID 2003 - 2005 18 miles construction, 12-48” tread width, 48-60” clearing width Mountain bike, hike, Nordic ski Sweco trail dozer, Bobcat mini skid steer, hand construction Jamie Seifert Tamarack Resort PO Box 840 Donnelly, ID 83615 (208) 325-1055 JSeifert@tamarackidaho.com $200,000 Trek Bicycle Corporation, WI 2004, 2005 6.0 miles construction, 24-36” tread width, 36-48” clearing width Mountain bike Ditchwitch SK 500, mini excavator, hand construction Chris Pieck PO Box 183 Waterloo, WI 53594 800-313-8735 Ext. 2903 Chris_Pieck@trekbikes.com $30,000 Rosaryville State Park & Black Hills Regional Park, Maryland 2003 - 2005 3.5 miles construction (7 miles when completed) , 24-36” tread width, 60” clearing width Mountain bike, hike, equestrian Ditchwitch SK 500, hand labor clearing and finishing Austin Steo Mid-Atlantic Off Road Enthusiasts PO BOX 2662 Fairfax, VA 22031 (301) 847-1023 a1s1p1@aol.com $30,000 Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Wakefield Park, VA 2005 3 miles reconstruction (6.5 miles when complete) , 24-36” tread width, 60” clearing width Mountain bike, hike Ditchwitch SK 500, Sweco trail dozer, hand clearing and finishing Bill Hellwig Audrey Moore Recreation Center 8100 Braddock Road Annandale, Virginia (703) 321-7081 Bill.Hellwig@fairfaxcounty.gov $15,000 Lake Lafayette Trail, Tallahassee, FL 2004 1.5 miles construction, 24-36” tread width, 48-60” clearing width Mountain bike, hike Toro mini skid steer, hand construction Dwayne Huffman Tallahassee Parks and Recreation Department 912 Myers Park Drive Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (850) 891- 3866 HuffmanD@talgov.com $10,000 Evans Creek Canyon Trail, Rancho San Rafael Park, NV 2003 1.25 miles construction, 36-48” tread width, 60” clearing width Mountain bike, hike, equestrian Sweco trail dozer, hand construction Patti Bakker Truckee Meadows Trail Association P.O. Box 265 Reno, NV 89504 (775) 786-9955 pbakker@sbcglobal.net $15,000 Trail Contracting Team Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Sumter National Forest/Long Cane Horse Trail 2004 10 miles new construction Mountain Bike, hike, equestrian Sweco trail dozer, Dingo mini skid steer Bill Victor, Long Cane Trails, LLC 149 Chota Dr. Clarks Hill, SC 29821 (803) 278-6177 wmvic32@aol.com $9,500 (Trail Solutions portion of contract) Blue Ridge Parkway/Chestnut Ridge Trail 2004 1 mile new construction, 1.5 miles rehabilitation, 48” tread width Hike, equestrian Sweco trail dozer, Woody Keen, Trail Dynamics, LLC P.O. Box 664 Cedar Mountain, NC 28718 (828) 862-5613 woody@traildynamics.com $7,500 (Trail Solutions portion of contract) Sumter National Forest/Oconee State Park, SC 2004 1 mile new construction, 1.5 miles rehabilitation, 48” tread width Mountain Bike, hike, equestrian Sweco trail dozer, Dingo mini skid steer Woody Keen, Trail Dynamics, LLC PO Box 664 Cedar Mountain, NC 28718 (828) 862-5613 woody@traildynamics.com $9,000 (Trail Solutions portion of contract) Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Constructed: Specifications: Users: Equipment: Contact: Contract Value: Bartram Trail, GA 2003 8 miles new construction, 36’48” tread width, 60” clearing width Mountain bike, hike Sweco trail dozer, Toro and Ibex mini skid steers Bill Victor Long Cane Trails, LLC 149 Chota Dr. Clarks Hill, SC 29821 (803) 278-6177 wmvic32@aol.com $7,000 (Trail Solutions portion of contract Lick Fork Recreation Area, SC 2003 2 miles new construction, 36” tread width, 48” clearing width Mountain bike, hike Toro mini skid steer Bill Victor Long Cane Trails, LLC 149 Chota Dr. Clarks Hill, SC 29821 (803) 278-6177 wmvic32@aol.com $2,500 (Trail Solutions portion of contract) Airstrip, Mine Mountain, Shoals Trail, Dupont State Forest, NC 2003 2.25 miles reconstruction, 36” tread width, 60” clearing width Mountain bike, hike, equestrian Ditchwitch, Toro, Ibex mini skid steers, Ditchwitch mini excavator Woody Keen Friends of Dupont State Forest PO Box 664 Cedar Mountain, NC 28718 (828) 862-5613 trailboss@dupontforest.com $25,000 (Trail Solutions portion of donated services) Trail Planning, Design, and Maintenance Assessment Location: Staunton State Park, CO Year Completed: 2004- 2005 Project Description: Trail corridor planning for a 35-mile trail system in Colorado’s most recent State Park purchase Contact: Dave Giger, Region Manager 1313 Sherman St. Rm. 618 Denver, CO 80203 (303) 866-3203 david.giger@state.co.us Contract Value: $22,000 Location: Wissahickon Park, Philadelphia, PA Year Completed: 2004- 2005 Project Description: Sustainability assessment and redesign of a 54-mile trail system within the largest city park in Philadelphia in an historic valley Contact: Tom Pelikan, Executive Director, Friends of Wissahickon 8708 Germantown Ave. Philadelphia, PA 19118 (215) 247-0417 tom_pelikan@verizon.net Contract Value: $16,000 Location: Little Creek Mesa, UT Year Completed: 2004 Project Description: Trail Planning, Design and Environmental Assessment of a 40-mile shared-use trail system on a large mesa south of St. George, Utah, created, in part, to protect the area from vandalism (cultural resource poaching) via recreation development Contact: Cimarron Chacon BLM UT- St. George Field Office 345 East Riverside Drive St. George, Utah 84790 (435) 688-3200 Cimarron_Chacon@ut.blm.gov Contract Value: $75,000 Location: Santos Trails, Marjorie Harris Carr Cross-Florida Greenway , FL Year Completed: 2004 Project Description: Maintenance and Redesign Assessment of 35-mile trail system near Ocala, FL with recommendations for trail reconstruction/reclamation, comprehensive signage, risk/emergency management planning, and freeride development. Contact: Mickey Thomason Florida Office of Greenways and Trails (352) 236-7143 Mickey.Thomason@dep.state.fl.us Contract Value: $9,000 Location: Year Completed: Project Description: Contact: Silver Mountain Resort, Idaho 2004 Assessment of ski area terrain for mountain bike/hike trail system Scott Evans 610 Bunker Ave. Kellogg, ID 83837 (208) 783-1111 ext. 204 scotte@silvermt.com $11,000 Contract Value: Location: Black Canyon Trail, AZ Year Completed: 2004 Project Description: Assessment of 60-mile trail corridor from north of Phoenix to near Prescott, AZ with planning and design of trailheads, nodes of stacked loop trails along the corridor, and recommendations on shared use matrix and volunteer recruitment Contact: Dan Hanson BLM - Phoenix Field Office 21605 N. 7th Avenue Phoenix, AZ 85027-2099 (623) 580-5500 Rich_Hanson@blm.gov Contract Value: $23,000 Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Kettle Moraine State Forest- Northern Unit, WI 2004 Design of 15 miles of singletrack trails within the Greenbush and New Fane Recreation Areas Jerry Leiterman Superintendent KMSF-NU N1765 Highway G Campbellsport WI 53010 (262) 626-2116 Jerome.Leiterman@dnr.state.wi.us $11,500 Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Cheyenne Mountain State Park, CO 2003 Trail design assistance for Arrowhead Trails on a new 13-mile shared-use trail system Rick Dudley CMSP Superintendent 4255 Stinton Road Colorado Springs, CO 80907 (719) 633-4110 rich.Dudley@state.co.us $7,500 Maine Winter Sports Center, Presque Isle, ME 2004 Planning and design of 10-mile shared-use trail system Max Saenger, Chief Operating Officer Loring Commerce Centre 154 Development Drive, Suite E Limestone, ME 04750 (207) 328-0991 max@mainewsc.org $7,000 Hunter’s Creek Park, NY 2003 Sustainability/maintenances assessment and trail planning for 35-mile shared-use trail system in a county park outside Buffalo. John Sundquist Western New York Mountain Bike Association 279 Oakwood Ave. East Aurora, NY 14052 (716) 655-5130, jas@trailmap.us $5,000 Kettle Moraine State Forest- Southern Unit, WI 2003 Planning and design of 6-mile, Emma Carlin trail connector trail Ray Hajewsky Trails Manager KMSF-SU S91 W39091 Hwy. 59 Eagle, WI 53119 Contract Value: (414) 594-6200 $4,300 Trails Education & Training Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Location: Year Completed: Specifications: Contact: Contract Value: Western Trailbuilders Association Conference, Reno, NV 2003, 2004 Conducted three-day advanced trailbuilding seminars focusing on Mountain biking trails techniques Gerry Wilbour, WTBA President, Northwest Trails owner (360) 739-1123 Northwesttrails@hotmail.com $4,000 Palmer Park, Anchorage, AK 2003 Assessment and planning for sustainable trails in 2000-acre park Near Anchorage, AK Kevin Keeler, National Park Service Rivers, Trails, and Conservation (907) 644-3589 kkeeler@gci.net $4,000 Multiple Parks, Australia 2003 15 trailbuilding seminars to city, territory, and commonwealth land Managers and trails advocates on the ecological, social, and Economic benefits of sustainable, shared-use trail systems Tony Scott, Mountain Bike Australia Anthony.scott@anu.edu.au $5,250 Multiple Parks, Ireland 2003 12 trailbuilding seminars to city, county, and federal land Managers and trails advocates on the ecological, social, and Economic benefits of sustainable, shared-use trail systems Claire Barnstable, Countryside Access & Activities Network (028) 9038-3848 $2,500 Trail Construction Equipment Type: Sweco 450 Trail Dozer (owned) Operator/Experience: Rich Edwards/250 hours, Joey Klein/200 hours Training: Tony Boone, Arrowhead Trails Type: Mini skid steer (rented) Operator/Experience: Rich Edwards/500 hours, Mark Schmidt/50 hours Training: self-trained Type: Mini excavator (rented) Operator/Experience: Judd deVall/100 hours, Rich Edwards/100 hours, Mark Schmidt/30 hours Training: self-trained