UNIVERSITI TUNKU ABDUL RAHMAN FACULTY OF ARTS AND SOCIAL SCIENCE APPENDICES APPENDIX 1 CURRENT SCHEDULES OF INDUSTRIAL TRAINING FAS (Perak Campus) NO 1. 4 5 6 COURSES DURATION* Industrial Attachment Committee Members – Department Representative Cik Norlis Binti Ismail (Email: norlis@utar.edu.my) Bachelor of Communication (Hons) Advertising 28 May 2012 – 26 August 2012 (13 weeks) Bachelor of Communication (Hons) Journalism *Oral Presentation: 27 August 2012 – 30 August 2012 (Week 14) 28 May 2012 – 26 August 2012 (13 weeks) Bachelor of Social Science (Hons) Psychology *Oral Presentation: 27 August 2012 – 30 August 2012 (Week 14) 28 May 2012 – 26 August 2012 (13 weeks) Ms. Wirawahida binti Kamarul Zaman (Email: wirawahida@utar.edu.my) Bachelor of Communication (Hons) Public Relations *Oral Presentation: 27 August 2012 – 30 August 2012 (Week 14) 28 May 2012 – 26 August 2012 (13 weeks) Mr. Pong Kok Shiong (Email: pongks@utar.edu.my) Bachelor of Arts (Hons) English Language *Oral Presentation: 27 August 2012 – 30 August 2012 (Week 14) 16 Jan 2012 – 15 April 2012 Mr. Ang Siong Huat (Email: angsh@utar.edu.my) Mr. Teh Boon Teck (Email: tehbt@utar.edu.my) Ms. Yeow Jian Hui (Email: yeowjh@utar.edu.my) Ms. Joginder Kaur a/p Bhan Singh (Email: joginderk@utar.edu.my) *Oral Presentation: 16 April 2012 – 22 April 2012 (Week 14) * The faculty reserves the right to make changes to the duration stated in the schedules of industrial training APPENDIX 2 MARKING SCHEME OF INDUSTRIAL TRAINING FINAL REPORT ASSESSMENT Psgychology, English Language, Public Relations, Journalism, & Advertising Departments Name Prog Tutorial Lecturer : : : : Date: Marks for industrial training (Final report) Organization background : Application of theories & Learning outcome Appendices / References Bi-weekly report On-site supervisor's evaluation marks: Oral Presentatation Total Grade (Pass/Fail) / 05% : / 20% : : : : : : / 10% / 15% / 40% / 10% /100% Appendix 3 SYNOPSIS OF COURSE Bachelor of Communication (Hons) Public Relations The programme addresses the needs of the communication industry for public relations professionals who have technical competence as well as an appreciation of the role of Public Relations in Malaysia within a global environment. Students will develop their communication skills in a range of contexts, and enhance their creative abilities, analytical skills and management capabilities. The programme also emphasises in-depth understanding of communication theory. In terms of application, students will produce media kits, news releases and audio-visual presentations. They will also learn to organise press conferences, events and exhibitions. Students are also introduced to fundamentals of advertising such as copywriting and media planning. They develop an understanding of the advertising profession and industry. Advertising is a related field in communication in which graduates in public relations may seek employment. Bachelor of Communication (Hons) Journalism The programme produces professional media personnel – journalists in particular who are in the forefront of professional and technical development in this area of specialisation. Students develop a strong foundation in communication, research, analytical and writing skills. Knowledge and in-depth understanding of mass communication theory is emphasized. Throughout the programme students acquire a mature understanding of cultural issues and public policies within the Malaysian environment and global context. Bachelor of Communication (Hons) Advertising This programme provides in-depth knowledge of the advertising field, and also introduces other areas of mass communication such as public relations. Students learn how to integrate the various communication tools into a integrated advertising campaign. In addition, students will be provided a solid foundation on the latest in multimedia communication developments. Bachelor of Social Science (Hons) Psychology This programme is aimed at building in-depth knowledge and appreciation of the concepts and theories of psychology. It equips students with knowledge of psychology and a mature understanding of the range of applications of that knowledge. Emphasis is placed on the relevance of the units of study to meet the changing needs of the Malaysian socio-economic environment. This programme also exposes students to alternative forms of counselling, such as e-counselling, other than the traditional face to face counselling. Bachelor of Arts (Hons) English Language This programme aims to produce graduates with in-depth knowledge and understanding of the theories and use of the English language in the modern world. It provides them with a strong foundation and the necessary language skills to keep abreast of the latest developments in English and linguistic studies as well as to communicate proficiently and competently in international and local platforms such as conferences and forums. Students are also introduced to the general area of mass communication with emphasis on journalism. APPENDIX 4 ASSESSMENT OF INDUSTRIAL TRAINING ASSESSMENT CRITERIA (PSYCHOLOGY, ENGLISH LANGUAGE, ADVERTISING, JOURNALISM, & PUBLIC RELATIONS) FINAL REPORT: Organization Background Application of theories & Learning Outcome References / Appendices / Format Bi-weekly Reports On-site Supervisor Evaluation Oral Presentation 05% 20% 10% 15% 40% 10% TOTAL 100% STUDENT FINAL REPORT All interns are required to submit a final report to their Examiners during their Oral Presentation. Interns are required to submit a final report and conduct oral presentation. TWO comb-bound hardcopies and one softcopy in a CD are required for assessment of your work. The final report, not including appendix, should be around 15 to a maximum of 20 pages. The report must be prepared according to the following specifications: 1. FORMAT A4 sized, double-spacing, 12pt, Times New Roman, APA referencing system. Report must be comb-bound. 2. TABLE OF CONTENT I) II) Organization background (Total 5%) Mission & visions/ goals of Organization (3%) Organizational Structure (2%) Application of Theories & Learning Outcome (Total 20%) (1) Application of Theory to Work Performed (10%) Specify the tasks you undertook. What did you learn from the overall industrial attachment – workrelated? Relate it with theories, models, work procedures learnt in class. This is to evaluate how much of theory is actually applied. How did your participation fit into the overall activities of the department and organization? (2) Self-Development & Learning Outcome (10%) How did this industrial attachment contribute to your professional development? Specify the new learned skills, knowledge, or experiences acquired. III) Appendices/ References (Total 10%) Include all your BI-WEEKLY REORTS Samples of work done (e.g. newspaper articles, brochures you designed, cases or clients that you have managed, etc. - it would be good to get your work endorsed by your on-site supervisor/s) IV) Bi-weekly report (Total 15%) Students need to submit their weekly report to their respective in-site supervisor every 2 weeks (week 2,4,6,8,10,12) (6 bi-weekly report x 2 marks = 12 marks, overall submission on time x 3 mark) V) Oral Presentation (Total 10%) Criteria: Verbal & non-verbal skills, timing, and content. STUDENT FINAL REPORT ASSESSMENT CRITERIA Organization background 5% Application of Theories & Learning Outcome 20% Appendices & References 10% Bi-weekly report 15% On-site supervisor’s evaluation marks 40% Oral presentation 10% TOTAL 100% ON-SITE SUPERVISOR ASSESSMENT (weightage = 40%) Behaviour and Attitude Knowledge Skills Performance TOTAL ( 8 items X 4 marks ) ( 2 items X 4 marks ) ( 9 items X 4 marks ) ( 6 items X 4 marks ) 32 marks 8 marks 36 marks 24 marks 100 marks APPENDIX 5 SYLLABUS FOR INDUSTRIAL TRAINING 2.2. Detailed Information on Every Subject (Year 3 Trimester 3) Psychology No 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Information On Every subject Unit Name: Industrial Training Code: UAPG3006 Classification: Major Credit Hours: 6 Practical : 210 Contact Hours ;Report Writing : 40 Contact hours. Trimester/ year offered : 1 / 3 Pre-requisite(If Any ): Completed a minimum of 70 credit hours (major and minor subjects inclusive of subjects with transfer of credits). Mode of Delivery: Practical Assessment System and Breakdown of Marks (100%): (Grading system: Pass or Fail only) Report (90%) Organisation background 5% Application of theories & learning outcome 20% Appendices / References 10% Bi-Weekly report 15% On-site supervisor’s evaluation marks 40% Oral Presentation 10% Total 100% Academic Staff teaching Unit : All Academic Staff 9. Objective of Unit: 1. To allow students to undertake their industrial training by learning and applying psychological and counselling skills in the real-life settings 2. To develop soft skills like leadership, problem-solving, communication in the work environment 3. To understand the strengths and weaknesses of the mental health as well as educational training industry 10. Learning Outcome of Unit : After completing this unit the students will be able to : 1. Apply the psychology concepts and theories in real-life settings 2. Demonstrate soft skills such as interpersonal skills, team-work, leadership and discipline in their work environment 3. Provide valuable feedback to both students and lecturers as an effort to encourage longitudinal research as well as to design programs for the mental health and educational training industry growth of the society 11. 12. 13. Synopsis of Unit : This unit explores students to study the behaviour of people at work and in organization. Students as required to undergo a three-month industrial attachment at the beginning of their third year. Typically, they are required to work in two major areas: A. testing and placement (personnel psychology) and B. human relations at work The industrial attachment involving the application of the principles and methods of psychology. Weekly supervisory meetings and written work are required. This experience will prepare the students to the real working environment and enhance the students’ ability to meet the needs of the industry. Students are also required to submit a written report on their industrial attachment. Topic And Notional Hours: During this period, students are encouraged to apply psychological principles and research methods to the respective sector or to practical problems faced during the industrial attachment. Every student is to submit a report by week 1 of semester 1 of Year 3. Contents of report include: - Summary of learning outcomes - In-depth description of learning during industrial attachment. This description should be linked to the learning outcomes (appendices to include samples of work covered, where applicable) - Conclusion on how industrial attachment helps in their growth and development preparation for professional work. Topic Learning Outcome Topic 1 Report Proposed allocation of credit hours to work on the 7 bi-weekly reports and Final Project (3750-5000 words / 15-20 pages) Jam Notional : (+/- 40 hours) Practical MQA Guideline: Total no. of effective learning hour per day 1, 2, 3 Notional Hour L T SL TLT - - 40 40 Topic 2 x total no. of days per week x 14 weeks of training Calculation of Student Effective Learning Hours: 3 hours x 5 working days x 14 weeks of training = 210 hours Jam Notional : (+/- 210 hours) Assessment (100%) 1, 2, 3 - - 210 210 250 6 250 Report (90%) Oral Presentation (10%) Report (90%) Oral Presentation (10%) Total Notional Hours Credit Value Credit Value Main References: Not related English Language No Information on Every Subject 1. Unit Name: INDUSTRIAL TRAINING 2. Code: UALG3006 3. Status: Major 4. Credit Hours: 6 5. Trimester/Year Offered: Year 3 6. Pre-requisite (if any): Completed a minimum of 70 credit hours (inclusive of major, minor, electives and transferred credits). 7. Mode of Delivery: Practical Training 8. Assessement System and Breakdown of Marks (100%): a. Report of Work 5% Organization background 20% Application and understanding of English Language areas/concepts. Description of how learning outcomes are related to experiences /work duties during industrial 100% attachment. Linkage of knowledge to practical. 10% Relevant Appendices, References and Format 9. 10. b. Bi-weekly reports prepared by student 15% c. Supervisor’s report 40% d. Oral Presentation (10-15 mins) 10% Academic Staff Teaching Unit: Supervisors to be appointed from among the department and/or faculty lecturers. Objective of Unit: 11. To provide an opportunity for students to discover, learn about, and familiarise with professional requirements, work culture and discipline. To provide an opportunity for students to observe real-life practices and relevant technical skills applied in projects. To provide opportunity for the industry to identify potential employees from among the industrial trainees and to feedback comments on the programme. To provide students opportunity to share their industrial training experience through oral presentation. Learning Outcome of Unit: At the end of the training, students will be able to: Acquire while working with others soft skills like leadership, problem-solving, communication skills in the work environment such as interpersonal skills. Acquire technical skills while working on projects such as managing & coordinating events, industry-related document preparation such as press release, news reports, feature article, press kits, translating, as well as teaching. Benefit from establishing contacts with potential future employers as well as undertake specific course of action based on industrial training feedback to enhance ability to meet the needs of the industry/job market. Present their industrial training experience through oral presentation. 12. Synopsis of Unit: Students are required to undergo a three and a half months industrial training in the industry at the end of their third year of study. During this period, students will apply their knowledge and gain hands-on experience in the respective sectors. The practical experience will prepare and enhance the student’s ability to meet the needs of the industry. Supervisors at the workplace will submit a report on the student’s development and performance. Students will submit their bi-weekly reports. Students are also required to submit a written report on their industrial training at the end of the industrial training period. Every student is to submit a report to the school by week 15 of Trimester 3 (Year 3, Bachelor). Contents of report include: o Summary of learning outcomes o In-depth description of learning during industrial training. This description should be linked to the learning outcomes (appendices to include samples of work covered, where applicable) o Conclusion on how industrial training helps in their growth and development/ preparation for professional work. Topic Student’s workload for industrial training B-weekly(7 reports) and Final Report(1520 pages) Learning Outcome 1,2,3 1,2,3, P TLT 3 hours x 5 working days x 14 weeks of training 40 210 40 Oral Presentation (10 Minutes) Students will be graded according to FAS Oral Presentation Grading Rubric for IA. 4 10 10 Total 260 260 Jam Kredit 6 Proposed total no. of credit hours for Industrial Training unit : 6 credit hours Proposed allocation of credit hours to work on the 7 bi-weekly reports and Final Project (3750-5000 words / 15-20 pages) (+/- 40 hours) : 1 credit hour Proposed allocation of effective learning hours at work (+/-200 hours) : 5 credit hours Student’s Workload for Industrial Training based on the MQA guideline: = Total no. of effective learning hour per day x total no. of days per week x 14 weeks of training = 3 hours x 5 working days x 14 weeks of training = 210 hours Public Relations, Journalism, & Advertising Information on Every Subject Unit Name: Industrial Training Code: UAMG3016 Classification: MAJOR Credit Hours: 6 Trimester/Year Offered: January or May Trimester/ Year 3 Pre-requisite (if any): Earned 70 credits (major and minor subjects inclusive of subjects with transfer of credits) 7. Mode of Delivery: Practical 8. Assessments System and Breakdown of Marks (100%): (Grading system: Pass or Fail only) a. Report of Work 90% 5% Organization background 20% Application and understanding of Mass Communication subject areas/concepts. Description of how learning outcomes are related to experiences /work duties during industrial attachment. Linkage of knowledge to practical. 10% Relevant appendices, references and format 40% b. On-site supervisor’s report 15% c. Bi-weekly reports prepared by student No 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 9. 10. d. Oral presentation Duration: 10 to 15 minutes Total Academic Staff Teaching Unit: All Lecturers Objective of Unit : 10% 100 To provide an opportunity for students to discover, learn about, and familiarize themselves with professional requirements, work culture and discipline. To provide an opportunity for students to observe real-life practices and relevant technical skills applied in projects. To provide opportunity for the industry to identify potential employees from among the industrial trainees and to provide feedback on the programme. To provide students opportunity to share their industrial training experience through oral presentation. 11. Learning Outcome of Unit: At the end of the training, students will be able to: 12. Synopsis of Unit: 13. Acquire while working with others soft skills like leadership, problem-solving, communication skills in the work environment such as interpersonal skills. Acquire technical skills while working on projects such as managing & coordinating events, industry-related document preparation such as press release, news reports, feature article, press kits, etc. Benefit from establishing contacts with potential future employers as well as undertake specific course of action based on industrial training feedback to enhance ability to meet the needs of the industry/job market. Present their industrial training experience through oral presentation. Students are required to undergo a three and a half months (14 weeks) industrial training in the media industry. During this period, students will apply their knowledge and gain hands-on experience in the respective media sectors. The practical experience will prepare and enhance the student’s ability to meet the needs of the industry. Supervisors at the workplace will submit a report on the student’s development and performance. Students will submit their bi-weekly reports. Students are also required to submit a written report on their industrial training at the end of the industrial training period. Every student is to submit a report to the school. Contents of report include : o Summary of learning outcomes o In-depth description of learning during industrial training. This description should be linked to the learning outcomes (appendices to include samples of work covered, where applicable) o Conclusion on how industrial training helps in their growth and development/ preparation for professional work. Students are required to share their working experience through oral presentation. Topics and Notional Hours: Topic Learning Outcomes Topic 1: Report 1, 2, 3 Notional Hours L T SL 40 TLT 40 1, 2, 3 - 210 Proposed allocation of credit hours to work on the 7 bi-weekly reports and IA Report (3750-5000 words / 15-20 pages Topic 2: Practical MQA Guideline: Total no. of effective learning hour per day x total no. of days per week x 14 - 210 weeks of training Calculation of Student Effective Learning Hours: 3 hours x 5 working days x 14 weeks of training = 210 hours Topic 3: Oral Presentation 4 (10 Minutes) Students will be graded according to FAS Oral Presentation Grading Rubric for IA. Total Notional Hours Credit Value Date of previous version : 2008 Date of current revised version: 3rd September , 2010 6 10 10 260 260 APPENDIX 6 VISITATION REPORT FOR INDUSTRIAL TRAINING Faculty of Arts and Social Science (FAS) Industrial Training Visitation Report Fakulti Sastera dan Sains Sosial Laporan Lawatan Latihan Industri 文学院和社会科学系 实习工作探访报告 Organization Name/ Nama Organisasi/ 机构名称 : ____________________________ Date of visit/ Tarikh Lawatan/ 探访日期 : ____________________________ Time of visit/ Masa Lawatan/ 探访时间 : ____________________________ [Note: Please use a separate form for each student.] Student’s Name/ Nama Pelajar/ 学生名字 Student’s Registration Number/ Nombor Pendaftaran Pelajar/ 学号 *Programme/ Program/ 课程 (AV/PR/ JR/PY) **Department (if any)/ Jabatan (jika ada)/ 部门 (如有) ***Comment (if any)/ Komen (jika ada)/ 评语 (如有) Signature/ Tandatangan/ 签名 InSite Supervisor’s Name/ Nama Penyelia Dalam Tapak/ 学院监督者 * Bachelor of Communication – Major: AV- Advertising, PR- Public Relations, JR- Journalism, PY-Psychology Program Bacelor Komunikasi – Major: AV- Pengiklanan, PR-Perhubungan Awam, JR-Kewartawanan, PY-Psikologi 传播系- 主修: AV- 广告学,PR- 公关学, JR-新闻学, PY- 心理学 ** State the department(s) of which the student is attached to in the Company e.g. Marketing Department. Senaraikan jabatan dimana pelajar sedang bekerja (jika ada), contohnya Jabatan Pemasaran. 请注明学生在公司所属部门。例如:市场部。 *** Please attach a separate sheet if insufficient space to write comments. Sila sertakan lampiran sekiranya ruang tidak mencukupi menulis komen. 请另附一页,如果没有足够的空间来写评语。 # Comments or Suggestions by the on-site supervisor/s (if any): Komen atau Cadangan daripada Penyelia atau Wakil Syarikat (jika ada): 现场监督者的评语或建议 (如有): Signature by On-Site Supervisor or **Company Representative/ Tandatangan Penyelia atau **wakil syarikat/ 现场监督者签名或者 **公司代表 : Name/ Nama/ 姓名: Contact no/ Nombor Telefon/联络号码 : Company Stamp/ Cop Syarikat/ 公司盖章: #In the event that there is more than one supervisor, a representative can be selected. In the event that the supervisor(s) is not available, a company representative (e.g. HR Manager) can sign on his/her behalf. Jika terdapat lebih daripada seorang penyelia atau penyelia tidak dapat hadir semasa lawatan, wakil syarikat (misalnya Pengurus Sumber Manusia) boleh tandatangan bagi pihaknya. 如有多位监督者,请挑选一位代表。 如果现场监督者不在, 公司的一位代表(如人力资源管理器)可以代为 签名。 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ For office use/ Untuk Kegunaan Pejabat/ 办公室使用: Comments/Feedback/Suggestion from Visiting Lecturer: Visiting Lecturer’s Name: Visiting Lecturer’s Signature: Verified by Deputy Dean (Student Development & Industrial Training): Date filed/ Tarikh Fail/提交日期: APPENDIX 7 CONFIDENTIAL STUDENT APPRAISAL FORM OF INDUSTRIAL TRAINING FACULTY OF ARTS AND SOCIAL SCIENCE (FAS) IMPORTANT: This form is CONFIDENTIAL. Please hand the original copy of this form to the UTAR Staff during the Industrial Training Visit. Alternatively, the original copy of this form can be couriered to the UTAR staff directly. Kindly make a copy of this form for your retention. Thank you. This evaluation needs to be done by the immediate on-site supervisor. If there is more than one on-site supervisor, it is recommended that all on-site supervisors evaluate the intern’s work performance separately – the average of all the scores will be taken as the intern’s final score. STUDENT INFORMATION: Name: _________________________________________________ Student ID: ________________________ Programme: □ Bachelor of Arts (Hons.) English Education □ Bachelor of Arts (Hons.) English Language □ Bachelor of Communication (Hons.) Advertising □ Bachelor of Communication (Hons.) Journalism □ Bachelor of Communication (Hons.) Public Relations □ Bachelor of Social Science (Hons.) Psychology Internship Period: From ___/___/20___ to ___/___/20___ Kindly refer to the mark scale provided below in assessing the performance of the intern. Very Poor Poor Fair Good Very Good 0 1 2 3 4 Mark Scale Evaluation Criteria Score 1. Behavior & Attitude a) Grooming/ Personal Appearance /4 b) Overall attendance c) Punctuality d) Compliance to Company Policies e) Interest in Work f) Reliability and Accountability g) Ability to cope h) Acceptance of constructive criticisms and feedback /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 2. Knowledge a) Business knowledge / General knowledge /4 b) Work Ethics / Professionalism /4 /4 3. Skills a) Problem solving b) Interaction within the Work Environment (e.g. supervisor, colleagues) c) Appropriate Interaction with Clients/ External Parties d) Oral Communications Skills e) Written Communication Skills f) Leadership g) Team work h) Technical skills (e.g. computer software, etc) i) Creative thinking /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 4. Performance a) Quality of work performed /4 b) Ability to prioritise and multi-task c) Initiative to learn d) Ability to work independently e) Commitment to work f) Value-added contribution /4 /4 /4 /4 /4 Total: /100 Comments (if any): OnSite Supervisor’s name: : Designation : Tel / HP No. : Signature : Date : Official stamp of the organization : IMPORTANT: This form is CONFIDENTIAL. Please hand the original copy of this form to the UTAR Staff during the Industrial Training Visit. Alternatively, this form can be couriered to the UTAR staff directly. Kindly make a copy of this form for your retention. Thank you. APPENDIX 8 DETAILED MARKING SCHEME OF INDUSTRIAL TRAINING Name Prog Tutorial Lecturer : : : : Date: Marks for industrial training (Final report) Organization background -Goal of Industrial Training (Training objectives etc. ) -Scope of Training ( provide your job specification, role & responsibilities ) Application of theories & Learning outcome -Background information Mission & vision of Organisation -Organisational Structure Organisational Success -Indicators (financial performance and other factors vital for success of company) -Training Placement ( Explain in which department you were assigned,your supervisor and others in that department. -Learning Outcomes Work Performed (Highlight the tasks you undertook & share with us on what you have learnt. Try to relate it with theories, models, work procedures learnt in class.) -Recommendation / Conclusion Explain (constructively) on how the department or company can increase its performance. Identify your own weaknesses and how are you going to overcome it so that you can be more efficient in a similar situation in the near future. Appendices / References -Include all your BI-WEEKLY REORTS Samples of work done (it would be good to get your work endorsed by your on-site supervisor/s) Overall presentation. -Presentation Skills -Sharing of Experiences Bi-weekly report -Punctuality in submitting Bi-weekly Reports -Content -Self-Reflection -Learning Outcomes On-site supervisor's evaluation marks: - Behaviour and Attitude - Knowledge - Skills - Performance : Total /100% Grade : APPENDIX 9 Oral Presentation Grading Rubric Industrial Training Faculty of Arts and Social Science Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman Student Name: ____________________________ Student ID: SCORE: _____/10 _________________ Programme: □ Bachelor of Arts (Hons.) English Education □ Bachelor of Arts (Hons.) English Language □ Bachelor of Communication (Hons.) Advertising □ Bachelor of Communication (Hons.) Journalism □ Bachelor of Communication (Hons.) Public Relations □ Bachelor of Social Science (Hons.) Psychology INSTRUCTIONS: 1. Students for the allotted session must come when the session commences. 2. This sharing session is a group discussion moderated by the Examiners. 3. Students scheduled for any single session are required to share their work experiences with the group. 4. Students are evaluated according to score descriptors in Appendix A. Thank you. Comments (if any): Examiners: …………………..………………….. ……………………..………………….. Name: _________________________ In-Site Supervisor Name: _________________________ Moderator APPENDIX A Score Descriptors for Oral Presentation Indicator PASS FAIL Extent of Sharing Excellent 9 – 10 marks Description of Performance Very confident, interesting, & clear. Demonstrates a very strong positive feeling about industrial training experience. Abundance of material s & details related to training is presented. The trainee’s learning experience is rich. Good 7 – 8 marks Confident, interesting, & voice. Show positive feelings about industrial training experience. Sufficient information with many good points made, lacking in some details. The trainee’s learning experience is good. Fair 5 – 6 marks Fairly confident, interesting, & voice. Occasionally shows positive feelings towards t industrial training experience. Minimal information & details presented. The trainee’s learning experience is average. Poor 3 – 4 marks Not so confident, difficult in maintaining audience’s interest, and lacking clarity. Does not show interest in the industrial training experience.. Very little information and greatly lacking in details. The trainee’s learning experience is poor or insufficient. Very Poor 1 – 2 marks Appears ill-prepared, unable to share industrial training experience. Shows absolutely no interest in industrial training. May think that it was a waste of time. Hardly any information and details. The trainee’s learning experience is unclear or very poor. Absent 0 mark Student is absent for the sharing session.