C-19-1 Minicase 19 Disney’s 100-Year Bonds The Walt Disney Company is a diversified, international entertainment firm whose operations, through its subsidiaries, include theme parks and resorts, film studios, consumer products, television networks, radio networks, cable networks, newspapers and magazines. Disney owns such household names as ABC Television, The Disney Channel, Disney Land, and Disney MGM Studios, among others. Recently, Disney announced that it was offering a $300 million bond issue. This, in and of itself, would not be remarkable. However, the bond offering may have a maturity of 100 years. Bond issues of more than 30 years have been rare over the past several decades, especially since the high inflation and high interest rate years in the 1970s and 1980s. Pricing the yield on a 100-year bond issue would be difficult. Accurate information on the yield curve, for any given level of risk, only exists for bonds with up to 30 years to maturity. Consider the yield curve in Exhibit 19-1 which reports the yields for A1 and A2 rated bonds by Moody’s Investors Service. What yield would a 100-year bond issue need? To complicate the matter, its long-term debt was rated A1 by Moody’s Investors Service and AA- by Standard & Poor’s. These are slightly different rating so that one rating would predict a different required yield than the other. Lastly, Disney decided to issue callable bonds. For the right to redeem the bonds early, Disney will pay a premium over noncallable bonds. demanded for a 100-year issue? This case explores these issues. What call option premium is C-19-2 Disney’s Environment1 The theme parks and resorts segment has generated roughly 40% of its total revenue, filmed entertainment has accounted for roughly 40%, and consumer products has generated the remaining 20%. Disney recently acquired Capital Cities/ABC and with it ABC Television and ABC Radio. Exhibit 19-2 reports Disney’s balance sheet for the end of its latest two fiscal years. Additionally, it contains the unaudited balance sheet for the latest quarter before the bond issue. Exhibit 19-3 shows Disney’s income statements for the latest two fiscal years and the most recent quarterly statement. Disney paid a quarterly dividend of $0.0625 per share, up from $0.0525 for the same quarter in the prior year. Disney’s recent operations have been affected by several important factors leading up to the bond issue. First, the impact of the adoption of the methods of accounting prescribed by Statement of Financial Accounting Standards (SFAS) No. 106, Employers’ Accounting for Postretirement Benefits Other Than Pensions, and SFAS No. 109, Accounting for Income Taxes, each had a negative net impact. Recent results for the theme parks and resorts have been affected by slightly higher attendance at Disneyland, Disney World, and Tokyo Disneyland. Per capital spending increased due to price increases. Occupied room nights and occupancy levels at the Florida resorts increased. Losses from the Euro Disney investment are expected to continue into the fourth quarter, covering the The information in this section was taken in large part from Disney’s Quarterly Report, Form 10-Q, obtained from EdgarPlus. 1 C-19-3 peak summer season. Disney and Euro Disney are currently reviewing the financial structure and development strategy of the Euro Disney theme park. Disney has agreed to help finance Euro Disney’s capital expansion and working capital requirements over the short-term. Disney’s filmed entertainment business reflected highly successful domestic home video releases of Beauty and the Beast, and Pinocchio. The international release of Beauty and the Beast, Sister Act and Jungle Book were also successful. The strong performance of Aladdin domestically, was partially offset by poor performances of Aspen Extreme, A Far Off Place, Bound by Honor, Life with Mikey, and Swing Kids. Details of the Debt Issue2 Disney has registered a long-term bond issue with the SEC. Disney plans to offer $300 million of senior debentures. One of the alternatives it is considering is 100-year bonds paying 7.55% APR and allowing Disney to redeem them at par beginning 30 years after issue. The investment banking firm Morgan Stanley & Co. has advised Disney throughout the process of selecting the debt issue’s maturity, coupon, call features, etc. However, both Morgan Stanley and Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith Inc. would share the underwriting of the issue. The two investment banking firms agreed to purchase principal amounts of $150 million each to resell on the primary market. 2 The information in this section was taken from Disney, $300,000,000 Senior Debentures, Prospectus. C-19-4 Choosing a Debt Issue Disney has decided to issue additional long-term debt. Its investment bankers have advised that a 100-year debt issue might be possible. Disney is conservatively capitalized. Its long-term debt is rated A1 by Moody’s Investors Service and AA- by Standard & Poor’s. Its current capitalization is provided in Panel A of Exhibit 19-5, and its interest coverage for the latest 12 months is reported in Panel B of Exhibit 19-5. Interest rates have decreased for the past few years and are near their lowest levels in the past twenty years. This has made very long-term debt an attractive financing alternative. At the same time, many investors in long-term fixed-rate debt have come to believe that the United States had inflation under control and that long-term interest rates are unlikely to return to the very high levels experienced in the 1980s. They think that long-term interest rates might even decline further because the gap between long-term Treasury yields (6.40% for the 30-year bond) and the projected inflation rate (3%) is relatively high by historical standards. Thus, a 100-year maturity, almost unthinkable just a few years before, is now possible according to Disney’s investment bankers at Morgan Stanley & Co. Disney could issue noncallable long-term bonds at the APRs (with interest payable semiannually) in Exhibit 19-5, Panel C. If it issues 100-year debt, Disney wants to preserve some flexibility to retire it before its maturity. Morgan Stanley advised Disney that it could issue $300 million principal amount of 100-year debt that was callable beginning 30 years from the issue date at an interest cost of 7.55% APR. The initial call price would be 103.02%. The call price would step down to par beginning 50 years after the issue date, as shown in Exhibit 19-4. C-19-5 Questions 1. Estimate the cost of the call option to Disney by calculating the present value of the difference in payments Disney would have to make, assuming it called the bonds after 30 years. Explain what Disney would get in exchange for this cost. 2. Calculate the duration of the 5-, 10-, 30-, and 100-year bonds bearing the interest rates indicated above. Do you see any pattern between duration and offering yield? 3. Show the pro forma impact on Disney’s capitalization and interest coverage from issuing $300 million principal amount of 30-, noncallable 100-, and callable 100-year bonds. 4. Consider the 30-year and 100-year bonds. If Disney issues 30-year bonds now and refunds them with 70-year bonds 30 years from now, what interest rate on the subsequently issued 70-year bonds would make Disney just as well off as if it had issued noncallable 100-year bonds today? (Hint: one approach to solving this problem is to find the interest rate on the 70-year bonds that makes the present value of the two 100-year streams of interest payments equal, using the 100-year new issue rate as the discount rate in both cases.) 5. Consider the callable and noncallable 100-year bonds. If Disney issues callable 100-year bonds now and refunds them at the end of the 30th year with 70-year bonds, what interest rate on the subsequently issued 70-year bonds would make Disney just as well off as if it had issued noncallable 100-year bonds instead? 6. Do you think Disney should issue callable 100-year bonds or one of the other alternatives? Explain. C-19-6 EXHIBIT 19-1 Fair Market Yield Curves Moody’s Investors Service Debt Rating Maturity A1 A2 3MO 3.71% 3.79% 6MO 3.84 3.95 1YR 4.14 4.17 2YR 4.67 4.69 3YR 5.15 5.18 4YR 5.53 5.71 5YR 5.87 6.01 7YR 6.24 6.39 10YR 6.62 6.63 20YR 7.28 7.29 30YR 7.34 7.37 Source: Bloomberg L.P. C-19-7 EXHIBIT 19-2 Disney Condensed Balance Sheets (Dollars in millions) Latest Quarter-End ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents $ 185.7 Investments 1,772.6 Receivables 1,195.5 Merchandise inventories 463.6 Film and television costs 1,116.2 Theme parks, resorts and other property - net 5,120.9 Investment in and advances to Euro Disney 233.5 Other Assets 998.5 Total Assets $11,086.5 LIABILITIES & STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY Accounts and taxes payable and other accrued $ 2,329.8 liabilities Borrowings 1,959.2 Unearned royalty and other advances 863.4 Deferred income taxes 765.0 Stockholders’ equity Common stock 856.4 Retained earnings 5,853.2 Less treasury stock, at cost 684.1 Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity $11,086.5 Source: Disney Quarterly Report, SEC Form 10-Q Filing. Latest Year-End Previous Year-End $ 764.8 1,407.0 1,179.3 462.8 760.5 4,798.7 659.1 829.5 $10,861.7 $ 886.1 782.4 1,128.2 311.9 596.9 4,571.6 1,151.7 $9,428.5 $ 2,172.9 $ 1,730.0 2,222.4 872.8 889.0 2,213.8 859.5 753.9 619.9 5,368.7 664.1 $10,861.7 549.7 4,535.4 664.1 $9,428.5 C-19-8 EXHIBIT 19-3 Disney Consolidated Statements of Income (Dollars in millions) REVENUES Theme parks and resorts Filmed entertainment Consumer products Total Revenue COSTS AND EXPENSES Theme parks and resorts Filmed entertainment Consumer products Total Costs and Expenses OPERATING INCOME CORPORATE ACTIVITIES General & administrative expenses Net investment and interest income (expense) Income (Loss) from investment in Euro Disney Income Before Taxes Income tax NET INCOME Source: Disney Quarterly Report, SEC Form 10-Q Filing. Latest Quarter Latest Year One Year Ago $ 986.1 654.5 296.2 1,936.8 $ 3,306.9 3,115.2 1,081.9 7,504.0 $ 2,794.3 2,593.7 724.0 6,112.0 723.9 519.1 223.9 1,466.9 469.9 2,662.9 2,606.9 798.9 6,068.7 1,435.3 2,247.7 2,275.6 494.2 5,017.5 1,094.5 41.5 (4.2) (30.9) 148.2 (3.5) 11.2 160.8 (14.4) 63.8 401.7 142.6 $ 259.1 1,301.8 485.1 $ 816.7 1,011.9 375.3 $ 636.6 C-19-9 EXHIBIT 19-4 Year of Call and Call Price Schedule Year Redemption Price 2023 103.020% 2024 102.869 2025 102.718 2026 102.567 2027 102.416 2028 102.265 2029 102.114 2030 101.963 2031 101.812 2032 101.661 2033 101.510 2034 101.359 2035 101.208 2036 101.057 2037 100.906 2038 100.755 2039 100.604 2040 100.453 2041 100.302 2042 100.151 2043 and after 100.000 Source: Disney, $300,000,000 7.55% Senior Debentures Due 2093, Pricing Supplement to Prospectus. C-19-10 EXHIBIT 19-5 Capitalization, Interest Coverage, and Bond Issue Rates Panel A CAPITALIZATION (Dollars in millions) Short-term debt LATEST QUARTER-END $503.7 Long-term debt $1,455.5 Stockholders’ equity 5,169.1 Total capitalization 6,624.6 Total capitalization (including short-term debt) $7,128.3 Panel B INTEREST COVERAGE (Dollars in millions) Earnings before interest and taxes LATEST 12 MONTHS $1,640.5 Interest expense 122.4 Interest coverage ratio 13.4x Panel C NONCALLABLE BOND ISSUE RATES OFFERING YIELD MATURITY (YEARS) (APR) 3 5.15% 5 5.85 7 6.25 10 6.60 20 7.25 30 7.35 100 7.35