Tara Garrett Reintroducing The Outsiders in Context, Focusing on Conflict Jackson MS is a Portland Public School in Southwest Portland, right between Tigard and Lake Oswego, just off of the I-5 and 99E. The school serves about 600 students, and I am currently teaching two seventh grade Language Arts classes of approximately 30 students each: each class has at least three students with IEP’s, and at least two ELL students. The school is primarily middle class, about 75% white, and is an accurate reflection of the West Portland Park neighborhood that the school is located in. The students have been quite busy lately, and because of time constraints, haven’t had time until recently to finish reading up The Outsiders. The students started the novel in October, read it through most of November, and then were side-tracked: in December, they wrote a paper that analyzed their own writing, and compared it to a mentor text, then by my work sample (which was on Twisted Fairy Tales) which they finished in January, and lastly, by their OAKS writing assessments, which they did at the beginning of February. They finally have a good solid week (barring the snow days we expect on Thursday, and perhaps Friday), to finish reading the novel. Instead of leading them back into the novel cold, I wanted to try and relate the novel as best I could to other topics that they’re currently working on, so that they could immediately relate what they’re reading to ideas that they are currently engaging in. In their Social Studies class, they are working on a Leonard Bernstein art unit that is focusing on Conflict, using the game of chess as a metaphor. Since The Outsiders is about individual characters struggling with conflict, both on an individual level, and at a group level, this seemed just right: it would give the kids an excellent focal point on which to examine the remaining chapters of the novel. My goal/learning objective is for the students to be able to identify different examples of conflict between characters and groups of characters in the novel, and be able to draw parallels to examples of conflict that they see in reality. Essential Question: What is the nature of conflict? Unit Question: Where can you draw parallels between the conflicts that S.E. Hinton was writing about in The Outsiders, and the conflicts that we see occurring in reality? Lesson Questions: What do you know about the time that S.E. Hinton was writing in? What was happening (politically, socially, and culturally) during the period that the protagonists were living in? Why didn’t S.E. Hinton include much cultural context in her novel? Where have you seen conflict in the presentation, and in the novel: between groups of people? Between individuals? Where have you seen conflict in the novel: o Between groups of people? o Between individuals? Where are conflicts started in the novel? Use concrete examples. What conflicts are being perpetuated in the novel? Use concrete examples. Connection to state standards: EL.07.RE.02: Listen to, read, and understand a wide variety of informational and narrative text, including classic and contemporary literature, poetry, magazines, newspapers, reference materials, and online information. EL.07.RE.03: Make connections to text, within text, and among texts across the subject areas. EL.07.RE.04: Demonstrate listening comprehension of more complex text through class and/or small group interpretive discussions across the subject areas. Background Knowledge: Students should be reading at a fifth grade reading level, and should have read the first six chapters of The Outsiders in order to apply the information from the lessons, but need have little to no prior knowledge of 1960’s current events. Tuesday, February 16th: Reintroducing “The Outsiders” in Context, Focus on Conflict Grade: 7th Learning Objectives for today’s lesson, i.e. students will be able to: Identify at least three historical events that will provide context for The Outsiders. Identify at least one example from the text of how context has improved their understanding of the novel. Identify at least two examples from the presentation, and one example from the book, that are an example of conflict. Connection to state standards: EL.07.RE.02: Listen to, read, and understand a wide variety of informational and narrative text, including classic and contemporary literature, poetry, magazines, newspapers, reference materials, and online information. EL.07.RE.03: Make connections to text, within text, and among texts across the subject areas. EL.07.RE.04: Demonstrate listening comprehension of more complex text through class and/or small group interpretive discussions across the subject areas. Student prior knowledge: Students should be reading at a fifth grade reading level, and should have read the first four chapters of The Outsiders in order to apply the information from the lesson, but need have little to no prior knowledge of 1960’s current events. Materials: Prezi presentation: “America: 1965” Writing journal Technology: Computer with internet connection (for the Prezi) Projector attached to computer Essential Question: What is the nature of conflict? Unit Question: Where can you draw parallels between the conflicts that S.E. Hinton was writing about in The Outsiders, and the conflicts that we see occurring in reality? Lesson Questions: What do you know about the time that S.E. Hinton was writing in? What was happening (politically, socially, culturally) during the period that the protagonists were living in? Why didn’t S.E. Hinton include much cultural context in her novel? Where have you seen conflict in the presentation, and in the novel: between groups of people? Between individuals? Key Concepts: It’s important to read a story in context, so that you can better understand the characters and the setting, and the impact that it has on plot. In 1965, the year that The Outsiders was written: o President Lyndon Johnson was president o The Vietnam War was escalating: 150,000 troops were sent overseas o Public protest of the war escalated, both in the media, and in the streets o The Beatles and Elvis Presley were pop idols o Dune and The Biography of Malcolm X were published Every single example of 1960’s current events listed above is an example of a conflict. There are conflicts between individuals, and between groups of people, in The Outsiders: inside of the protagonist’s family, in his school, and in his town. Class-work: 1 hour Free-write topic: What was the world like for the characters and/or the author of The Outsiders? 5 minutes Prezi Presentation: “America: 1965” –spend the majority of the lesson talking through the presentation, drawing out prior knowledge from students, making connections between prior knowledge, the presentation, and the novel. Emphasize conflict, specifically through the Vietnam War, The Beatles v. Elvis, and the Civil Rights movement. 40 minutes Free-write topic: What did you learn from the presentation that makes something from the novel more relevant/make more sense? Where did you find conflict, culturally or politically, in the 1960’s? Where do you see conflict in The Outsiders? How are the conflicts similar/different? 10 minutes Homework: To read up to Chapter Seven of The Outsiders, so that when the students start reading again on Wednesday, they’ll be at the same place. Students are encouraged to google/youtube the Beatles, Elvis Presley, Sonny & Cher, the Ed Sullivan Show, clips of President Kennedy, of Vietnam War protestors, or anything else relevant to the period that catches their attention. Differentiation: Linguistically diverse learners: o The presentation has a lot of visuals, which will help illustrate the captions and the discussion. o The majority of the class is being spent in discussion: most ELL students have a greater facility with verbal skills before their reading/writing skills, so spending the majority of the class in discussion with the teacher and classmates should help with comprehension. Culturally diverse learners: o The majority of the presentation is focused on major events and popular figures/literature from 1965; I’ve referenced several culturally relevant events (like the publication of “The Autobiography of Malcolm X” and the Civil Rights Movement). o Students are encouraged to share their histories (relevantly) to provide more context for their classmates. Cognitively diverse learners: o The lesson appeals to a broad range of learning styles and developments: the presentation is visually and aurally appealing, the discussion is excellent for verbal learners, and the writing will give linguistic learners a good place to learn. o The lesson will appeal to cognitively diverse learners because all of the students are relatively equal in their lack of prior knowledge. Assessment and Criteria: Children will be formatively assessed throughout the class on their participation, on their contribution(s) to the conversation, and on evidence that they are paying attention and interacting with the presentation. Summatively, students will be assessed based on their journal entries, which should answer the posited questions as clearly and thoroughly as possible. Rationale/Reflection: S.E. Hinton doesn’t provide much in the way of context (culturally, politically, current event-ly). This bothers me, because it is too difficult to read a novel in a vacuum, and too easy for students to impose their own ideas onto a text when they don’t have that contextual knowledge. So the Prezi that I created gave the students a (very broad) overview of 1965, which is the year that Hinton write The Outsiders. Class discussion covered the entire period, from major events that happened under the Kennedy administration, to the pop stars, famous books and movies that came, all up to the end of the Vietnam War in the 1970’s. Although the students were eager to discuss their background knowledge about the period, and to connect it to what they were seeing in the presentation, they had a difficult time connecting the information directly to the novel—which is fair, seeing as Hinton rarely wrote places that make those connections simple, aside from those which I included directly in the presentation. I tried to make clear parallels between attitudes and social standards that Hinton used in her novel, and the major events of 1965, the national attitudes, social standards, etc. that we can see through the different events. The students are studying “Conflict” as a theme (and a Bernstein Unit) in their Social Studies class, so I wanted to continue emphasizing the theme of conflict in their reading of the novel, because The Outsiders is all about conflict, both between individuals, and between groups (classes, particularly). Because of time constraints, the students haven’t picked up The Outsiders in about four weeks, so I really wanted to re-introduce them to the novel with something sticky. They had so little prior knowledge of the time period, that I felt like I was teaching more of a social studies lesson than I was language arts. I also feel like the students might understand a lot better the social pressures that the characters are so clearly living with. Wednesday, February 17th: Reading The Outsiders with a focus on Conflict Grade: 7th Learning Objectives for today’s lesson, i.e. students will be able to: Read a substantial portion of the novel. Identify at least two examples of conflict in the novel: o Between groups of people o Between individuals Connection to state standards: EL.07.RE.02: Listen to, read, and understand a wide variety of informational and narrative text, including classic and contemporary literature, poetry, magazines, newspapers, reference materials, and online information. EL.07.RE.03: Make connections to text, within text, and among texts across the subject areas. EL.07.RE.04: Demonstrate listening comprehension of more complex text through class and/or small group interpretive discussions across the subject areas. Student prior knowledge: Students should be reading at a fifth grade reading level, and should have finished the first six chapters of the novel. Materials: Focus Questions handout Computer Lab: each student needs a computer URL: http://theoutsidersbook.blogspot.com/2005/09/whole-book.html Technology: Computer Lab: each student needs a computer Essential Question: What is the nature of conflict? Unit Question: Where can you draw parallels between the conflicts that S.E. Hinton was writing about in The Outsiders, and the conflicts that we see occurring in reality? Lesson Questions: Where have you seen conflict in the novel: o Between groups of people? o Between individuals? Where are conflicts started in the novel? Use concrete examples. What conflicts are being perpetuated in the novel? Use concrete examples. Key Concepts: The Outsiders is a novel that is entirely about conflict: o Between family members (example: Ponyboy and Darry) o Between individuals (example: Bob and Johnny) o Between groups (example: Greasers and Socs) The conflict that occurs between individuals can be part of a greater conflict in which they are participating (example: Johnny killing Bob is a perpetuation of the conflict between Greasers and Socs). Class-work: 1 hour Hand out the focus questions for this lesson and the following two; describe to the class the day’s activities: go to the computer lab to read (keeping in mind the focus questions), and then pair up to discuss the questions and the reading, emphasizing that they are being allowed to self-select their pairs, and to be responsible. 5 minutes Read The Outsiders on the computers in class silently. 40 minutes Have students pair up through self-selecting (who have you not worked with lately?), and discuss the focus questions that are on the handout they were given at the beginning of class (and which are also posted large on a whiteboard). 10 minutes Go back to a whole-class group to discuss the focus questions, and to evaluate studentgenerated concrete examples from the novel. 5 minutes Homework: Students are encouraged to continue reading The Outsiders during their free time, but are not required to do so, knowing that they need to have the novel completed in the next week, and that they need to manage their time wisely. Differentiation: Linguistically diverse learners: o There is an audio book of The Outsiders available, as well as a tutor in sheltered instruction for ELL students. Culturally diverse learners: o Students are encouraged to share their histories (relevantly) in their pairs to demonstrate the connections they are making to the text. Cognitively diverse learners: o There is an audio book of The Outsiders available for struggling students, and the teacher (and often a tutor for sheltered instruction) is available. Assessment and Criteria: Children will be formatively assessed throughout the class based on how attentive they are to their text, and on my evaluation of their paired discussion, which I will either eavesdrop on, or participate in, depending on whether or not they need some guidance in developing their answers. Rationale/Reflection: Because the class took so long to read the novel, the class book set had to be returned for another class’ use; I found a link for reading the novel online. It will take approximately three days for the class to complete the novel, so that’s how many days I’ve reserved the computer lab for, with students understanding that they need to read the novel on their own time if they feel they won’t be able to complete it inside of class time. Although this lesson doesn’t look that sticky on the surface, it’s all about providing crosscurricular, integrated context for the students, and context is the cognitive Velcro in our minds that holds whole concepts together. It’s relating what they’re seeing in the novel not only to their Social Studies lessons, but also to the current events that we’ve been discussing in class, in terms of the social unrest in the Middle East, and the decisions being made about public education in Wisconsin. The students were great about the silent reading, and they came up with some very perceptive observations during the course of the paired, and then the class discussions, especially in noticing how individuals are caught up in a greater conflict. They tended to focus, on the whole, on individuals, like Ponyboy and Johnny’s particular dilemmas, and it took some guidance in the discussion to get them to discuss conflicts between large groups of people (i.e. that the Socs and the Greasers essentially representing a class conflict), as well as small groups of people (i.e. the individuals who make up the cliques that end up fighting, like Tim Sheppard’s gang, and all of Bob’s high school buddies). The students did get a bit loud and off task during the paired sharing, so I need to address that in the following lesson. Next lesson, I will take a few minutes to model what a productive discussion would look like with another student, and make it clear that anyone can see the difference between a genuine interaction, and social time, between a pair of students, even from across the classroom.