The Solar System
How can we determine the size of the Solar system,
and the sizes of planets, moons etc?
Some simple geometric arguments allowed even the
ancient astronomers to get good estimates
Basic Geometry: the skinny triangle
Objects in the sky have a pretty small angular size:
that is, they aren’t very big/wide
The moon is only 0.5 degree diameter
Most celestial objects have sizes of about 1 “ (1
arcsecond) or less
1 arcmin = 1/60 degree
1 arcsec = 1/60 arcmin = 1/3600 degree
For angles where <<1 radian we can
approximate sin~
E.g. for =1 deg=0.017453 rad,
sin=0.017452
Thus we can relate an object’s physical size D, to
its distance r and angular size :
D
2r 360
Size and Shape of Earth
Evidence that the Earth is round:
At sea, land at sea level disappears before hills
Ship hulls vanish before their masts
The altitude of stars depends on latitude
The shadow of a lunar eclipse is always circular
Eratosthenes calculated the size of the Earth using a
simple geometric argument
Compare the height of the Sun at two different
locations, at the same time.
Result was very close to the known value today
Distance to the Moon
Eclipses show the Moon is between Earth/ Sun
Lunar eclipses can be used to determine the
distance to the moon
Since we know the diameter of the Earth
(13000 km), and the angular size of the Sun
(0.53 deg) we can work out the size of
Earth’s shadow.
Comparison with the angular size of the
shadow on the moon gives the distance to
the moon, about 350,000 km.
Distance to the Sun:
Aristarchos used another simple geometric
argument, based on the phases of the Moon
When moon is in quarter phase, Earth-MoonSun must form a right-triangle
By measuring the angle between the Moon
and Sun, as viewed from Earth, you can solve
the triangle
The angle is 89.75 degrees, very difficult to
measure accurately. The distance to the
Sun is then 350,000/cos(89.75). Since the
angle is close to 90 deg, the cosine is close
to zero. A small error in measurement leads
to a very wrong answer.
Planetary Motions
Planets are observed to move relative to the
background stars
Motion is generally regular, but sometimes shows
retrograde motion that was very difficult to
explain in geocentric theories
Led to use of epicycles
In a heliocentric theory retrograde motion is a
natural consequence of the inner planets orbiting
more quickly than the outer planets
Distances to planets can be determined using simple
geometric calculations
Interior: measure angle between planet and the
Sun at greatest elongation (when they are
farthest apart)
Exterior: measure same angle, separated in time
by planet’s orbital period.
Copernicus had excellent values for all of the
known planets, but they were less precise for
the outermost ones (Jupiter and Saturn)
because their periods are long enough that
fewer oppositions could be observed
Kepler’s Laws
Based on very accurate orbital data obtained by Tycho
Brahe, Kepler derived three laws of orbital motion:
1. A planet orbits the Sun in an ellipse, with
the Sun at one focus
2. A line connecting a planet to the Sun sweeps
out equal areas in equal time intervals
3. P2=a3, where P is the period and a is the
average distance from the Sun.
Some useful equations (valid when M>>m):
4 2 a 3
G( M m)
General form of K3:
P2
Energy equation:
E
Vis-Viva equation:
1 1
v 2 (r ) 2GM
r 2a
GMm m 2 GMm
v
2a
2
r
In all of these:
M is the mass of the heavier body
m is the mass of the smaller body
a is the size of the semimajor axis
v is the orbital velocity
r is the distance between M and m
P is the orbital period
E is the total energy