Personal Finance Curriculum 2008 Acknowledgements The Personal Finance Curriculum Development Group (PFCG) would gratefully like to acknowledge the following people in their contributions to the creation of this document. Kam Bahia Gord Burt Scott Kuntz Andrew Leonard Stephanie Reinhart Andrea Robertson Lindsay Seidler Dan Benesh Josh LeBlanc Bettina Welsh Nicole Markewich Megan Charlton Tessa Jordan Jeannie Thompson Mike Knight PFCG would also like to thank all the other teachers who took the time to aid us in finding what personal financial information is most important for students to know. Most of you will know who you are. Thank you to Dr. Cyril Kesten of the University of Regina for being a driving force in the creating, compilation, and, hopefully, the initiation of this curriculum document. i Table of Contents Acknowledgements i Philosophy and Rationale 2 Aim, Goals, and Foundational Objectives 2 Course Component and Considerations 3 Core Modules 4-201 Module 1 – Economics of Personal Finance 4-10 Module 2 – Decision Making and Money Basics 11-28 Module 3 – Banking Services 29-63 Module 4 – Income and Taxation 64-69 Module 5 – Introduction to Budgeting 71-103 Module 6 – Savings and Investing 105-121 Module 7 – Credit and Credit Cards 123-163 Module 8 – Consumer Protection and Online Activity 165-169 Module 9 – Renting, Leasing, Buying, and Insuring 171-201 Philosophy and Rationale With the increasing debt loads of students and the rising number of personal bankruptcies, the need for financial management skills is greater than ever. This curriculum was created in order to address this growing concern, and the course is designed to provide students with a broad base of knowledge and skills related to personal financial management. The areas covered in the course are relevant to high school students and cover issues and topics they will encounter in the future – whether they decide to pursue post-secondary education or enter the workforce. This curriculum seeks to give students the knowledge and skills they need to be financially literate and operate successfully in the business world, and their personal lives. Aim, Goals, and Foundational Objectives Aim: The aim of Personal Finance is to provide students at the Secondary Level with basic skills in financial literacy. Goals: Awareness: To develop an awareness and understanding of personal finance and personal economic decision-making. Business Environment: To respond to business decisions as informed consumers. Personal-Use Skills: To develop work habits, attitudes, problems solving skills and independent thinking skills that will enhance personal and work experiences. Self-Image and Business Attitudes: To develop a positive self-image and essential business attitudes necessary as a consumer. - 2 of 201- Foundational Objective To help prepare students for personal financial decision making. Course Components and Considerations This Personal Finance course is designed to help students make informed decisions in order to protect their scarce resources. This curriculum outlines important financial situations that students will most likely be in. The modules were placed in a specific sequence in order for the course to flow smoothly. However, the modules may be rearranged as desired to suit the student’s needs. Although all modules have been designated as core modules the teacher may focus on particular modules and delete others. The most critical requirements upon completion of this course are the ability to make informed financial decisions and the ability to protect finances for financial freedom. It is important for students to develop an awareness of the business environment in which they must interact. Students must be equipped with knowledge about options and vulnerabilities when making major purchases. It is important that students realize that they are in control of their finances and they can gain knowledge to make the best financial decisions. It also important that students understand that they can protect themselves from fraudulent and misleading information. - 3 of 201- Module 1: Economics of Personal Finance (Core) Suggested Time: 5 – 10 hours Level: Introductory Prerequisite: None. Module Overview: This module will introduce economic topics that can be referred upon throughout the rest of the course. Foundational Objectives: To recognize the importance of scarcity, and how it underlies our entire world. To recognize the difference between direct costs and opportunity costs of any decision made in everyday living. To be able to identify the positives and negatives of Canada’s free market system. To be able to identify and define what a market is, and how supply and demand will affect that market in various ways. To be able to define and give examples of price elasticity. Common Essential Learnings Foundational Objectives: To engrain the key concepts of Canada’s economy into the students’ lives. (PSVS) To support the development of a positive attitude to life-long learning, as it pertains to the changing economic structure of our society. (IL) To apply a knowledge of numbers in determining the monetary differences between the direct costs and opportunity costs of any decision. (NUM) To enable students to understand and use proper vocabulary and expressions are key terms in the major topics of economics that will relate later to personal finance. (COM) To support students in being able to think critically, and in making choices that are economically sound. (CCT) Learning Objective Notes Why is it difficult or easy at various times to find a job? Why has Canadian money been worth more or less than United States money in our history? Should governments legislate pollution 1.1 To define and understand emissions? Why can professional athletes make more money than what economics is and why it is the Prime Minister of Canada? Why are men paid more money in important to study it. (COM, wages than women? Should medical care be provided free of PSVS) charge to all residents of Canada? The answer to all of these questions fall within the subject matter of economics. An adequate understanding of economic issues is - 4 of 201- becoming more and more essential to everyday living. The dictionary definition of economics is “the science that deals with the production, distribution, and use of goods, money, natural resources, and services”. This definition does not provide a real understanding of the subject. One important element of economics is missing from the definition – scarcity. Without scarcity, there would be no need to study economics. The website listed as the first resource in this section claims three reasons to study economics: economics is interesting, economics is useful, economics is a good basis for a career. The second website listed some statements as “We all make economic decisions every day of our lives, and economics can help to improve our decision making. Economics offers a way of thinking about the world that enables us to make the best of what we have,” and “Economics provides you with the knowledge and insight necessary to understand the impact of developments in business, society and the world economy. It enables you to understand the decisions of households, firms and governments based on human behaviour, beliefs, structure, constraints and need.” Scarcity – in economics, the term scarcity refers to anything that is available only in a limited supply. Almost everything in our world is scarce. On an individual basis, time and money are our most scarce resources. If there is a limited amount of a resource or commodity, a decision must be made about how to use that commodity. 1.2 To define, describe, and demonstrate how scarcity is the basics of economics and the entire world. For example, there are only 24 hours in a day. However, a certain amount of time has to be set aside for sleeping, eating, studying, working, recreation, etc… A decision has to be made about how best to use the time available. Also, not many people have unlimited monetary resources, so we must decide how to allocate it over various purchases. Resources are used to produce goods and services. These resources that belong to a country can be classified into three groups: land, labour, and capital. Land – Includes more than just square kilometres; it includes all water, animals, vegetation, minerals, everything! - 5 of 201- Labour – Refers to the population of a country that can produce work, or will be able to produce work in the future. Labour also refers to the variety of skills, level of education, and technical training of the population. Capital – Refers to man-made items that are used to produce goods and services. Despite the seemingly large amount of these capital goods, (computers, factories, tools, vehicles, power plants, airports, etc…), any country will still have a limited amount of these, and decisions have to be made to determine how to allocate their usage. Direct costs are simply the price or cost incurred by a buyer to obtain the product. If you buy a slurpee, the direct cost of that item is a) the costs incurred in driving to get it, b) the cost of the slurpee, and c) the costs incurred in driving home. However, there could be another cost involved, too. Unlike most costs discussed in economics, an opportunity cost is not always a number. The opportunity cost of any action is simply the next best alternative to that action - or put more simply, "What you would have done if you didn't make the choice that you did". 1.3 To identify direct costs and opportunity costs, and identify them in daily decisions in everyday life. I have a number of alternatives of how to spend my Friday night: I can go to the movies; I can stay home and watch the baseball game on TV, or go out for coffee with friends. If I choose to go to the movies, my opportunity cost of that action is what I would have chose if I had not gone to the movies - either watching the baseball game or going out for coffee with friends. Note that an opportunity cost only considers the next best alternative to an action, not the entire set of alternatives. Opportunity costs are usually easier to understand if you have an example: if a shipwrecked sailor on a desert island is capable of catching 10 fish or harvesting 5 coconuts in one day, then the opportunity cost of producing one coconut is two fish (10 fish / 5 coconuts). That is a simple example, but much more detailed ones are available online. A free market is a market in which prices of goods and services are arranged completely by the mutual consent of sellers and buyers. By definition, in a free market environment buyers and sellers do not coerce or mislead each other nor are they coerced - 6 of 201- by a third party. (Wikipedia) 1.4 To understand the free market system, and factors that influence it. The free market revolves around a topic called the price system. This simply means that businesses will try to sell their products for the highest possible profit. This may seem bad at first, however, when competition arises, these prices often naturally fall to a level that is marginally profitable for these companies. This permits efficiency in price changes. Every consumer is giving their input without knowing it, by purchasing sale items, or not purchasing items that are overpriced. This also permits consumers to transfer information to sellers. If competition ensues, businesses are more likely to research and adopt the most efficient and cost effective ways of creating their good. The disadvantage of the market system is that consumers may not always make the well-informed choices that they should. Advertising helps bridge this gap, but this can be faulty or misleading, too. Another disadvantage is when competition does not exist. Businesses can hold natural monopolies on a product, and especially if their product is a required one, they can reach huge profit margins for a short time. Hopefully, in this situation, the government would step in. When a company has a huge profit margin for even a short period of time, they will typically be “undersold” by other companies willing to sell a similar product for a cheaper price, thus forcing the other companies to compete with their prices as well. 1.5 To be able to explain supply and demand and the factors changing them. The essence of supply and demand is simply when a product is highly desired in a market (in high demand), naturally producers and sellers of that product can charge higher prices for it, and likely make more money, because that product will be scarce. Conversely, when a product is not highly desired in a market (in low demand), producers will often have to lower their price just to clear the good out, or turn any profit at all. Similarly, this works in the reverse direction. If a product is very scarce, regardless of how many people actually desire it, it can often be sold at a high price because it is very difficult to find (and implicitly difficult to product or manufacture). If a product is abundant (and implicitly easy to produce or - 7 of 201- manufacture), it will often be a very competitive market where producers scarcely make a profit, but hope to sell a large quantity of their item. Many things will affect supply and the marketplace accordingly. Price, production costs, technological change, government regulations, psychology of owner, and weather conditions. Factors affecting demand are: price, change in price of substitute (or comparable) products, change in the price of complementary (items that are needed to use the product, ie. gas for a car), incomes, tastes and preferences (of individual or society), expectations of future prices (sales, dollar fluctuations, market fluctuations), numbers and characteristics of buyers, expectations of future incomes, and taxes on income. - 8 of 201- Resources http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_market Working with Economics, 6th ed. H. Richard Hird http://www.netmba.com/econ/micro/cost/opportunity/ http://economics.about.com/od/opportunitycosts/f/opportunitycost.htm http://www.palgrave.com/skills4study/subjectareas/economics/why.asp http://whystudyeconomics.ac.uk/faq/economics.htm - 9 of 201- This page is intentionally left blank for notes. - 10 of 201- Module 2: Decision Making and Money Basics (Core) Suggested Time: 5-10 hours Level: Introductory Prerequisite: None Module Overview: This module will be used as an introductory Module in the Personal Finance Curriculum in which students will be introduced to foundational knowledge. This knowledge will be used as a platform and is required in order for students to fully understand concepts regarding Personal Financial concepts and the decisions that are incorporated into managing Personal Financial matters. Every day a student encounters situations where decisions must be made. These decisions may be simple or more complex, such as “should I buy a new car or a used car?” That is why decision making is an imperative component when dealing with personal financial matters. This module will provide students with an opportunity to learn more about the decision making process, and factors, both internal/external, that affect the decision making process. Students will also be able to explore common decision making strategies and economic influences on decision making. Risks associated with decision making will be discussed as well as basic economic terms such as opportunity cost, distinguishing between needs and wants, cost benefit analysis, and the 2 different kinds of money, tangible and intangible. Essentially, the goal of this module is to provide an understanding and an awareness of the factors that can influence decisions, introduce basic decision-making methodologies, and provide structured practice in analyzing a problem, identifying options, and making a decision. Module Objectives: To demonstrate an understanding of the decision making process that must be used when making decisions regarding an individuals resources (money), and then display, implement, and apply those strategies. To demonstrate an understanding of the different components of the decision making process and the factors that influence a decision To help students understand the basic economic terms and functions that influence decision making in Personal Finance To help students become aware of the risks associated with decision making regarding their resources Common Essential Learning Foundational Objectives: To allow students to use various strategies to create awareness of their thought process (CCT) To strengthen understanding within the Personal Finance curriculum by applying knowledge of numbers and their interrelationships (N) To take on more responsibility for their learning as their competence develops (IL) - 11 of 201- Learning Objective Notes To begin this module, a fun, easy quiz should be taken as a pretest. This quiz will show both, students and teachers, how much knowledge pertaining to Personal Finance each student holds. 2.1 To evaluate how much students already know about money, saving, and goal setting This quiz will cover topics such as debit cards, interest rates, school loans, etc. The quiz can be taken at http://www.yourmoney.cba.ca/tsam/en/tsam/know_yourself/popq uiz/ Students should be well aware of the decision making process in order to make mature decisions in terms of personal financial matters. Teachers should introduce and explain the decision making process and explain how it is relevant when making decisions concerning student’s resources. The Decision Making Process consists of the following steps: 2.2 To identify some of the decisions students are trying to make and apply the decision making process Identify the problem Gather information and list the possible alternatives Consider consequences of each alternative Select the best course of action Evaluate the results In order for students to be able to understand the process, teachers can ask students to identify three decisions they are trying to make. Examples may include: Going to a party Moving away from home Buying a car Buying a home Finding a new job Students should attempt to apply the decision making process (Appendix A) and work through one of these decisions. 2.3 To identify and role play various decision making strategies Students should be familiar with the various decision making strategies that can be used and applied when making decisions. Teachers should facilitate a brainstorming sessions in which - 12 of 201- students must list as many strategies as possible. Teachers can then give students a matching activity in which they must link the decision making strategy to the definition (Appendix B). In order to practice decision making strategies, students may role play using important decisions identified in Learning Objective 2.2. Teacher should initiate a class discussion and ask students to determine how well they think their strategies worked. Teacher should explain to students the purpose of exploring various decision making strategies is important. When students are going to make their own decision regarding their resources, these strategies will be advantageous. The following scenario can be used as an example: spontaneity Choosing the first option that comes to mind; giving little or no consideration to the consequences of the choice. This may be used by some students when trying to find a new car. When a student first gets their license, all they are really concerned about it getting that car, whether used or new. The excitement overlooks the process of exploring different options and finding the most REASONABLE choice 2.4 To analyze a decision and identify the steps being used in the decision making process and the decision making strategies being used 2.5 To implement the decision making process by setting both short term and long term goals Students should become very familiar with the steps in the decision making process. Everyday, they will be making decision regarding their resources so they must be able to implement the decision making process to real life situations. Ask students to observe their parents, older siblings, or guardian’s decisions for one day. This can involve going to the grocery store, bank, running basic errands, and/or at work. Have students identify the decision making strategies being used and also have students document the decision making process using the sheet provided (Appendix A). It would be a good idea for students to get their ideas on paper in order to apply, understand, and implement the decision making process. The following web site helps students organize and set both short term and long term goals. - 13 of 201- http://www.yourmoney.cba.ca/tsam/en/tsam/know_yourself/settin g_goals/ Once students have completed this activity, they can use the steps in the decision making process to evaluate their goals. 2.6 To determine and identify different factors that might influence a student’s choice of strategies Each time a student is going to make a decision, there will be internal or external factors that will influence their decision. Factors may include: Values: what is important to you or your family? E.g.: Getting a degree or getting a job straight from high school Peers: the people you know influence your decision. E.g.: Your friends have been working all summer and want to go on a trip before the school year starts. Can you afford to? Are you financially stable? Habits: you are accustomed to doing it this way. E.g.: Go to school all day, and then have to go to work, come home and do homework all night. Teacher may also want to distinguish between internal and external factors. For example, internal factors may include individual’s values, whereas external factors would include the influence of peers. See Appendix C for a complete list of factors. Students must be aware that economic conditions influence decisions regarding student’s limited resources. The teacher must emphasize that all decisions are centered on economic terms and actions. 2.7 To investigate the different economic influences on decision making Using the internet, Students can possible economic conditions that they feel might be influential when making decisions regarding their resources. (Appendix D) Research may include the following: Higher prices result in more expensive goods and services and lower buying power of the dollar Increases in consumer spending for certain goods and services can result in additional jobs in those industries Lower interest rate encourage consumer spending High unemployment results in less consumer spending A growing GDP usually indicates expanded economic - 14 of 201- growth in a country While students are researching, they can fill in the economic conditions influence sheet (Appendix E) in which they fill in o The economic condition o Trend o Possible influences that these conditions may have on their personal financial decisions For example: 1. Economic condition= low interest rate 2. Trend= encourages consumer spending 3. This will influence my personal financial decision because I will be willing to spend more money on products and services Resource: http://www.practicalmoneyskills.ca/moneyskills/students/pdfs/s_l esson01_makingdec.pdf Students should be able to distinguish between a NEED and a WANT. They must be able to recognize that all their unlimited wants and needs cannot be satisfied by their limited resources, such as money. An example activity: Students can be given a scenario in which they are given a certain amount of money and they must choose products or services from a list of things, or they could go back through the previous day and list all the products or services they 2.8 To analyze and compare the encountered. Examples may include, buying lunch at school, difference between needs and buying a new pair of shoes, or getting a haircut. Either way, wants, and define both students must have a certain amount of money left over to give opportunity cost and cost back to the teacher. (Sample assignment: Appendix F) benefit analysis Students must also be able to define opportunity cost. Opportunity cost refers to what a person gives up when a decision is made. The cost, or trade off, may involve one or more of your resources (time, money, effort, etc.) Students could now go back through the list of products and services given or ones they used/consumed in the previous day and look at which activities/products they chose. They can now determine and list what the opportunity cost was associated with their decisions. For example, if a student chose to spend their money on a new pair of shoes, the opportunity cost was not getting a needed hair cut, or not eating lunch that day. - 15 of 201- Students must also be able to understand cost-benefit, and apply it. Cost benefit analysis is an important technique for appraisal. It will help students determine whether a planned action will turn out good or bad. Students will be faced with decisions everyday; they must be able to recognize the costs and benefits pertaining to every decision. Students can be given a list of scenarios, and for each, the must determine both the costs and benefits and determine whether the costs will overshadow the benefits or vies-versa. Example: Student wants to play for the high school soccer team Costs: not as much free time to do other things, cost of equipment, sacrifice of weekends for tournaments Benefits: become a better athlete, keep fit, making new friends, teamwork Assignment: Cost-Benefit Analysis (Appendix G) The time value of money can be used to measure financial opportunity costs using interest calculations. 2.9 To investigate the time value of money and how it can affect students’ decision making process For example: spending $1,000 from a savings account that pays 4 percent interest a year means an opportunity cost of $40in lost interest. Calculation: $1,000 x .04 (4 percent) x 1 year = $40 Over 10 years, that $40 a year (saved at 4 percent) would have a value of over $480 when taking into account compound interest. Students should be aware that interest rates can be used for many personal financial matters. They can range from credit card balances to home ownership. Teachers do not have to go in-depth with this learning objective since it will be covered in more depth in later Modules. The main goal here is for students to realize that interest rates do exist and will influence and impact student’s financial decisions. 2.10 To explore the risks associated with decision making Risks are associated with every decision regarding an individual’s resources. More applicable, are the risks associated to personal and financial decision making. - 16 of 201- A jigsaw activity may be used in which each student in a home group must become an expert on one of the following risks: Income risk Inflation risk Interest rate risk Liquidity risk Personal risk Once each student has had time to research their required area, they will then go back to their home group and teach their peers about their risk. At the end of this activity, each student will have had a chance to teach their peers, and be taught by their peers. (A full description of each risk: Appendix H) Resource: http://www.practicalmoneyskills.ca/moneyskills/students/pdfs/s_l esson01_makingdec.pdf Now that students have gained knowledge pertaining to decision making, they have completed the first initial stage that is required in order to make mature and productive decisions regarding their resources. Remind students that the decision making process is vital in terms of Personal Finance because students will be making decisions everyday concerning their unlimited resources. They must have pre-requisite knowledge that will assist these students in making 2.11 To identify and distinguish rational decisions and evaluating all alternatives and outcomes. between the two different kinds of money The next step is to gain direct knowledge pertaining to Personal Finance by becoming experts on money and all components’ associated with money (which the following modules will cover). Students should be aware of the different kinds of money. They should know that money can be tangible and intangible. An example of tangible money would be a coin or a bill, whereas an example of intangible money would be a bank deposit slip. - 17 of 201- Appendix A: The Decision Making Process Name: __________________ Date:___________________ THE DECISION MAKING PROCESS Identify the problem → Gather information and list possible alternatives → → → → Consider the consequences of each alternative → → → → Select the best course of action → Evaluate the results → - 18 of 201- Appendix B: Decision Making Strategies (Can be used as a matching activity) Agonizing: Accumulating so much information that analyzing the options becomes overwhelming. Avoidance: Choosing the option that is most likely to avoid the worst possible result. Compliance: Going along with family, school, work, or peer expectations. Desire: Choosing the option that might achieve the best result, regardless of the risk involved. Destiny: Letting outside forces decide; leaving the decision up to fate. Inspiration: Doing something because “it feels right” or because “it just seems like the right thing to do.” Intention: Choosing an option that will be both intellectually and emotionally satisfying. Procrastination: Postponing thought and action until options are limited. Security: Choosing the option that will bring some success, offend the fewest people, and pose the least risk. Spontaneity: Choosing the first option that comes to mind; giving little or no consideration to the consequences of the choice. Synthesis: Choosing the option that has a good chance to succeed and which you like the best. - 19 of 201- Appendix C: Factors that influence a decision A. Values ■ What is important to your family, others in your culture? B. Peers ■ People you know ■ Pressure for positive or negative behaviors C. Habits ■ You are accustomed to doing it this way D. Feelings (love, anger, frustration, ambivalence, rejection) ■ If you do make a certain decision ■ If you don’t make a certain decision E. Family ■ Your family’s preference ■ Decisions other family members have made F. Risks and consequences ■ What (or how much) you stand to win ■ What (or how much) you stand to lose G. Age ■ Minor ■ Adult - 20 of 201- Appendix D: Economic Conditions that influence decision making These economic factors may influence personal and financial decisions: Consumer prices: changes in the buying power of the dollar, inflation Consumer spending: demand for goods and services Gross domestic product (GDP): total value of goods and services produced within the country Housing starts: the number of new homes being built Interest rates: the cost of borrowing money Money supply: funds available for spending in the economy Stock market index: indicate general trends in the value of stocks Unemployment: the number of people without employment who are willing to work - 21 of 201- Appendix E Name:________________ Date:_______________ Researching Current Economic Conditions Changing economic factors affect the decisions we make. Using newspaper business pages, Internet, or other sources of economic news, obtain information about current economic trends that influence various saving, investing, spending, and borrowing decisions. For example, higher interest rates make borrowing more expensive; however, higher interest rates make saving more attractive. Economics factor Recent Trends Possible influences on personal financial decisions Interest rate Consumer Prices Other Other - 22 of 201- Appendix F Name: ________________ Date: _________________ Economic Influences on Decision Making 1. List all the activities you took part in yesterday… 2. List any products or services that were purchased… 3. From question 2, list everything you consider to be a need vs. everything you consider to be want… 4. From the list of activities you took part in, list the opportunity cost of each… 5. Explain the cost-benefit analysis of going to a Rolling Stones concert on a school night… - 23 of 201- Appendix F: Answer Key Name: ________________ Date: _________________ Economic Influences on Decision Making 1. List all the activities you took part in yesterday… Homework, driving, running, class, coaching 2. List any products or services that were purchased… 2 ice caps, gas, gum, time for the parking meter 3. From question 2, list everything you consider to be a need vs. everything you consider to be want… Need: gas, parking money Want: ice caps, gum 4. From the list of activities you took part in, list the opportunity cost of each… Going class: could have stayed home and worked on homework vs. not behind Running: staying fit vs. time to work on homework Coaching: gave up watching my favourite tv shows, time away from school 5. Explain the cost-benefit analysis of going to see a Rolling Stones concert on a school night… Cost: staying up late on a school night, the cost of ticket Benefit: Participating in a once in a life time event, may get the go back stage - 24 of 201- Appendix G: Cost Benefit Analysis Scenarios 1. Regina hosting the 2012 Olympics (Look at all sides, including tourism, new sporting complex that needs to built, accommodation, traffic control ie: widen certain roads, intersections, etc.) COST: BENEFITS: 2. Once you are done high school, you really want to take a trip to Europe for 3 weeks (include factors such as: saving, summer job, going alone, friends, exchange rate, accommodations, transportation, etc.) COSTS: BENEFITS: 3. You just got your license and you are really excited to buy a new car. However, you have only saved enough to buy a used one; this includes the money you borrowed from your parents. There is no warranty, but it is in your price range. COSTS: BENEFITS: - 25 of 201- Appendix H Risks Associated with Decision Making Risks are associated with every decision. The following are common risks related to personal and financial decision making: Income risk: changing jobs or reduced spending by consumers can result in a lower income or loss of one’s employment. Career changes or job loss can result in a lower income and reduced buying power. Inflation risk: rising prices cause lower buying power. Buying an item later may mean a higher price. Interest-rate risk: changing interest rates affect your costs (when borrowing) and your benefits (when saving or investing). Liquidity risk: certain types of savings, guaranteed investment certificates (GICs) and investments (real estate) may be difficult to convert to cash quickly. Personal risks: factors that may create a less than desirable situation. Personal risk may be in the form of inconvenience, embarrassment, safety, or health concerns. - 26 of 201- Resources Canadian Bankers Association. http://www.cba.ca/en/default.asp Canadian Foundation for Economic Education. Resources and programs available for downloading and purchasing. http://www.cfee.org/en/ Practical Money Skills. http://www.practicalmoneyskills.ca/moneyskills/ Your Money. http://www.yourmoney.cba.ca/en/tsam/ - 27 of 201- This page intentionally left blank for notes. - 28 of 201- Module 3: Banking Services (Core) Suggested Time: 15 – 20 hours Level: Introductory Prerequisite: None. Module Overview: This module will introduce the student to the variety of products and services that banks have to offer. Students will be given the opportunity to explore, investigate and make decisions about which financial institutions supply the best service for their banking needs. Students will become familiar with the variety of means to monitor the activity on their account and reconcile their records to those of the banks. Foundational Objectives: To understand the basic products and services that financial institutions offer. To compare and evaluate the services offered by the different financial institutions in Canada. To explore the use of technology in banking and how electronic banking aids the individual in monitoring and tracking account activity. To be able to understand one’s bank statement and the procedures used in completing a bank reconciliation. Common Essential Learnings Foundational Objectives: To enable students to make sound decisions about their banking choices that which will carry-forward to adulthood. (IL) To educate students on modern ways to do banking, through the internet, telephone and at ABM’s. (TL) To enable students to understand bank terminology and jargon and to promote the use of appropriate communication skills through class presentations. (COM) To promote decision making characteristics which students will use to make sound choices in terms of what financial institution to use, and what types of accounts are appropriate. (CCT) To use mathematics skills in doing a bank reconciliation and tracking activity in a bank account. (NUM) Learning Objective Notes Banks are part of everyday society in Canada. They provide services which help us monitor and control our spending. They provide a safe and secure place for us to store our money. They help us earn interest and budget our spending. - 29 of 201- Teachers need to find out what students already know about banks. A variety of instructional strategies could be used to determine what the student already knows, including: Pretest Whole class discussion Brainstorming KWL 3.1 To identify and understand the variety of services that banks offer. Questions to ask the students may include: Why do we have bank accounts? See Appendix A Why do banks exist? What do banks offer? What are the advantages/disadvantages of using a bank? Teachers should find out who in the class has a bank account, and why they chose to bank with that financial institution. Ask the students that don’t have a bank account about where they keep their money. Introduce products and services that banks offer (www.cba.ca): Chequing accounts Savings accounts Loans Electronic funds transfers Cheques Interest Money Orders Certified Cheques Overdraft Protection Pre-authorized payments Bill payments Teachers may want to go further to explain the difference between a chequing account and a savings account. See Appendix B for a description of the three types of accounts, including the rare ‘combination account’. 3.2 To introduce, identify, and define terms commonly used in Introduce a variety of terms used in the banking industry. Please refer to Appendix C: ‘Terminology list’. Teacher could use a variety of instructional strategies to teach the - 30 of 201- banking. terms, such as: A matching exercise A worksheet Credit Unions are very popular in Saskatchewan. It’s important for students to understand the difference between a Credit Union and a bank. A Credit Union is very similar to a bank with the major difference being that they are member-owned and they are provincially regulated, rather than banks which are federally regulated. 3.3 To differentiate between a bank and a Credit Union. Services between Credit Unions vary as some are more specialized, while others are more general. Teachers could provide students with a brochure from both a Credit Union and a bank. Ask the students to compare the language used and the services offered that differentiate the two. For more information that distinguishes between the two types of financial institutions, refer to: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewPub.asp?fl=6&sl=23&docid=35&pg= 3 http://www.saskcu.com/ The banking industry offers the individual consumer a variety of choices to think about when selecting a financial institution. It is important to select a bank based on your individual needs. 3.4 To identify the contributing factors that impacts an individual’s choice of financial institution. Which bank is close to you? Which has the most convenient ABM’s? Which has the lowest fees? Which offers the product suite that you need? When comparing the different financial institutions, look at the following features (www.practicalmoneyskills.ca): Monthly fees Per-transaction charges Balance requirements Interest rate How rates are calculated - 31 of 201- How soon you can draw against a deposit NSF cheque charges On your cheque On a cheque you deposited ATM charges Debit card charge Stop payment fees Charges for printed cheques Locations/number of branches Bank hours Teachers could give students the opportunity to compare two different financial institutions of their choice based on the above questions. Teachers could do this as a jigsaw activity where each member of the group becomes the ‘expert’ on their financial institution. Appendix D has information for researching a chequing account for different financial institutions. It may be useful to invite a bank representative to come to your class to speak about bank services. Students need to come up with a list of questions that will help them identify the purpose of the account they want to open (www.cba.ca): 3.5 To explore, identify and choose which type of account to open. i. Do you only want to build your savings? In that case, you may want an account where you will get interest. ii. Do you expect to do many transactions? If so, your best choice is likely an account in which you pay a flat fee service charge. iii. Do you want to use the account mainly for savings, but maybe write a cheque now and again? Your best choice may be a combination account for which you pay a service charge every time you write a cheque. iv. Will you make withdrawals and bill payments at your branch? v. Will you use the ABM? vi. Will you use telephone banking? vii. Will you use Internet banking on your computer? viii. Will you use a debit card for purchases? ix. How many transactions will you do each month? x. What will you pay in fees each month? xi. What type of records do you want to keep? xii. Do you need to have your cancelled cheques returned? - 32 of 201- xiii. Can you keep track of your account activity with a basic bank book or a monthly statement? Appendix E has a worksheet to help students evaluate a bank based on its location and service charges and it compares the services of two different banks. Look at ways to reduce your service charges. The Canadian Banker Association lists the following ideas for saving money on service charges: 3.6 Identify the variety of fees that apply to a chequing account and explore methods and ideas on how to reduce your charges. Always use ABM’s from your bank. Ask about service plans that meet your needs. Make one large withdrawal rather than many small ones. Ask about accounts that waive service charges if you maintain a minimum monthly balance. Ask about youth/student service plans Don’t use overdraft (usually $5 + 21% annual interest) Look at an online calculator that compares the major financial institutions service fee plan at: http://consumer.ic.gc.ca/epic/site/oca-bc.nsf/en/ca00669e.html Give students a few scenarios where they have to choose between banks strictly based on the bank’s service charge packages. Please refer to Appendix F for an activity using the above online calculator. 3.7 To determine the types of identification needed to open a bank account and to demonstrate how to fill out an application for a bank account. Banks take privacy and security very seriously. They also have governmental regulations that they must follow. If you do not have proper identification, you will be denied services. It is important for students to know what identification is required to open an account. In order to open a new bank account, or to simply get a new bank card (if yours is lost), you must provide specific identification. Appendix G has a chart that highlights the type of identification needed to get a bank card. The teacher could ask students to identify the types of identification they already have. For legal, regulatory purposes, banks need to collect certain information about its clients to meet federal regulations around money laundering. - 33 of 201- Appendix H has an example application form that will need to be filled out to get a bank account, but an actual application form from a local bank is desirable. With today’s technology, there are many methods with which an individual can do their banking. They can do their banking: 1. 2. 3. 4. At the branch On the internet On the phone At an ABM The teacher could also add: Electronic Banking (direct deposits, preauthorized payments, Interac). There are advantages and disadvantages to each method of banking. The Canadian Bankers Association provides a useful summary of each method, and adds several tips to maintain the privacy and security of an individual’s accounts. A jigsaw activity where students teach the class about the advantages and disadvantages of each method of banking could be used. 3.8 To learn about the advantages and disadvantages of the different methods for how an individual can do their banking. Please refer to Appendix I to find the Canadian Bankers Association’s summary or at: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewpub.asp?fl=3&sl=251&tl=253&docid=19 &pg=9 For interesting statistics on how Canadians do their banking, refer to: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewDocument.asp?fl=6&sl=111&tl=&docid =526&pg=1 Or: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewDocument.asp?fl=6&sl=111&tl=&docid =247&pg=1 For some humour, cartoonstock.com has some cartoons based on using a bank machine: http://www.cartoonstock.com/directory/b/bank_machine.asp 3.9 To educate students about how to do online banking. Many Canadians are turning towards doing their banking online. Each of the major banks in Canada encourages its customers to use online banking to monitor the activity on their accounts. - 34 of 201- Students should explore the world of online banking. Each of the banks offers an online tutorial on how to use online banking. Here are the links to the various online tutorials: 1. http://www.cibc.com/ca/demos/welcome.html 2. http://www.rbcroyalbank.com/RBC:Re726Y71A8UAAQvoZxs/ online/index.html 3. http://www.tdcanadatrust.com/webtour5/screen1.jsp 4. http://www8.bmo.com/BMOOnlineTour/english/english/takeato ur.html 5. http://www.scotiabank.com/cda/content/0,,CID10637_LIDen,00 .html Each student should have the opportunity to explore one of the demos. A questionnaire could be developed asking questions about how to: transfer money, pay bills, retrieve account history, change your address, change your password, etc… Individuals need to protect their bank accounts from theft. There are numerous ways that a fraudster could gain access to a person’s account. Teachers could ask students what they already know about ensuring the security of their account. Students could be asked to create a poster describing ways to maintain security for one of the following banking areas. 3.10 To identify techniques to maximize the security of your accounts. Teachers need to explore safety techniques with students. There are certain security tips associated with: Using online banking Using Telephone banking Writing cheques Using ABM’s Using Interac Direct Payment Appendix J has some practical tips for ensuring the security of your account. 3.11 To demonstrate how to write a cheque properly. Although cheques are not being used to the same extent they were in the past, they are still used in Canada and students may start using them as soon as they get their first apartment. For the most part, rent is still paid with a cheque. Students need to learn how to write a cheque. The teacher should go over the basics of how to write the cheque as well as how to endorse - 35 of 201- it. Practicalmoneyskills.com provides a useful description of how to write a cheque. This description is available in Appendix K. 3.12 To demonstrate how to keep a running balance in a chequing account. In a typical bank account, you may find transactions such as, debit purchases, cheques clearing, EFT deposits, ABM deposits, debit purchases, payments, etc… It is important for the student to know how to keep a running balance of their account. Online banking is very useful for helping students monitor the activity in their account, but many banks do not provide a running balance. In Appendix L, you will find an activity that asks students to keep a running balance of an account. Appendix M has an answer key. Students should know that it is important to monitor the activity on their account. They have 60 days from the date a transaction was posted, or should have been posted to an account to notify the bank of the error. 3.13 To be able to complete a bank reconciliation. One way to guarantee that the individual and the bank have the same information is to do a bank reconciliation. A bank reconciliation matches and compares figures from the individual’s records (cheque register) to the bank statement. Upon completion, the balance of your records and the bank statement should match. A bank reconciliation has a four step process: Obtain the current balance from your bank statement. Add any deposits that you have recorded in your cheque register but that are not on this statement. Subtract any outstanding cheques (cheques you have written but that have not yet cleared the banking system). Compare the result with the current balance in your cheque register. Refer to Appendix N for a bank reconciliation activity and Appendix O for the answer key. 3.14 To understand your legal obligations in terms of how you use your bank account, and how the banks protect against fraud and theft. Unfortunately for everyone, there are individuals who abuse the banking system. There are numerous example of bank fraud, from copying cards, to depositing empty envelopes. Banks take fraud and security matters very seriously, and a one-time need, may have long lasting ramifications for your banking. - 36 of 201- For example, if you make a deposit for $500, but there was nothing in the envelope (empty envelope), then you withdraw the $500, you are committing a fraud. This will stay with you forever. Students need to understand the ways that banks protect against fraud, by; Placing holds on an account Limiting the ability to withdraw cash or use Interac Account restrictions – (ex: can only deposit) Blocking an account Account messages that limit ability to apply for new products - 37 of 201- Appendix A (Source: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewPub.asp?fl=6&sl=23&docid=19&pg=2) Why have a bank account? Safety and Security: A bank is a safe place to keep your money when you are not using it. Your money and your personal information are protected. Savings: A savings account is a way to save your money so it will be available for both your short-term and long-term needs. Earn interest: On some bank accounts, the bank pays you a sum of money called interest. This interest helps your money make more money. The more money in your account and the longer you leave it in, the more interest you will earn. Access to a variety of banking services: A bank account is not just a place to store money. Many people use banks to process transactions and do other financial activities. For example, if you have an account called a “chequing account,” one of the ways you may pay bills is by cheque. This is a written order to the bank to pay a certain amount of money from your account. To pay your rent, for instance, you can write a cheque and mail it – rather than go to a bank, take out cash and bring it to your landlord yourself. There are many different banking services you can use, including getting assistance from your bank's customer service representatives, paying bills, using banking machines, making direct debit purchases and having direct deposit of money owed to you. Many of these services are discussed in this booklet. Record-keeping: With a bank account, you receive account records to help you keep track of your money. This way, you know how much you spend and what you spend it on. Convenience: A bank account offers convenience in helping you manage your money. For example, with a bank account you will be able to get a bank card, also called a debit card, which allows you to use over 16,500 banking machines across Canada. Banking machines provide 24hour access for making deposits, withdrawals, paying bills and transferring money. A bank account also gives you access to telephone or Internet banking, where you use your phone or computer to do things like pay bills, transfer money between accounts and get updates on your account. It's a good reference: When you need a loan or want to apply for a credit card, your bank account shows how you have handled your finances in the past. This is a good reference that may help you get your loan or credit card application approved. - 38 of 201- Appendix B (Source: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewPub.asp?fl=6&sl=23&docid=19&pg=3) Banks offer three general types of accounts: i. savings account ii. chequing account iii. combination account Each bank has different names for these accounts. But whatever name is used, each type of account will have most of the same features. Look at these features and your personal needs to decide which suits you best. Then, look at the service charges. One type of account you may wish to consider is the joint account. This is an account opened by two or more people who can each put money into it. One or more people may have to sign when taking money out. The Savings Account If you want to save some money for your short-term needs, think about opening a savings account. This type of account is a good choice if you don’t need to use your money right away or you don’t intend on having much account activity in a month. The bank will pay you interest. The amount of interest will vary, depending on the type of account you choose and interest rates in general. You may take your money out any time. The Chequing Account If you want to keep some money handy for paying bills or personal expenses, you should think about opening a chequing account. This type of account is good for money you expect to need from day to day. You may take your money out at any time in person, at a bank machine, by writing a cheque or by direct payment. Chequing accounts usually have lower service fees than savings accounts. Some chequing accounts do not pay interest and some do (a chequing account usually pays a lower rate of interest than a savings account). Ask your bank for more information. The Combination Account If you want to save some money but you also want to keep some handy to cover expenses and manage your day-to-day finances, you should consider opening a combination account. This type of account is part savings and part chequing. You may take your money out any time in person, at a bank machine, by writing a cheque or by direct payment. Interest is usually paid on these accounts on amounts above a set level. - 39 of 201- Appendix C (Source: adapted from: www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Lesson 6, Teachers guide) Banking Terminology: Account Money deposited with a financial institution for investment and/or safekeeping purposes. Assets Items of monetary value (e.g., house, land, car), owned by an individual or a company. ABM Acronym for automated banking machine. ATM Acronym for automated teller machine. Balance An outstanding amount of money. In banking, balance refers to the amount of money in a particular account. In credit, balance refers to amount owed. Bank An establishment for lending, issuing, borrowing, exchanging, and safeguarding money. Certified cheque A cheque issued by a bank, drawn on its own funds rather than on one of its depositors. Chartered bank Non-governmental financial institutions. Sometimes called full-service banks because they provide a wide range of services, such as chequing and savings accounts, credit and loan arrangements, and safety deposit box rentals. Chartered banks also sell and redeem savings bonds. Cheque Any written document instructing a bank to pay money from the writer’s account. Chequing account An account for which the holder can write cheques. Chequing accounts pay less interest than savings accounts, or none at all. Credit Union A member-owned financial institution, either provincially or federally chartered. Often more competitive than banks and trust companies because its nonprofit status makes its operating costs lower. Debit Card A banking card enhanced with ATM (automated teller machine) and point-of-sale (POS) features that can be used to purchase goods and services electronically. The card replaces cash or cheques. Transactions are deducted from the cardholder’s bank account either immediately or within one to three days. Depending upon the type of card, a debit card may require a signature or entering a PIN number into special equipment. Debit cards may also be used to make Interac® Direct Payments (IDP). Internet banking (cyberbanking) Allows a person to conduct banking activities such as transferring money between accounts or paying bills from their personal account using the Internet. - 40 of 201- Interest The fee paid for the use of money. Interest may be paid, for example, by an individual to a bank for credit card use, or by a bank to an individual for holding a savings account; interest is expressed in terms of annual percentage rate (APR). Joint account A savings or chequing account established in the names of more than one person (e.g., parent/child, wife/husband). Mortgage A long-term loan obtained by individuals to buy a home that legally transfers ownership from the debtor to the creditor until the debt is paid. NSF Non sufficient funds NSF cheque (bounced cheque) A cheque that a bank has refused to cash or pay because there are not enough funds to cover the amount written on it, in the account of the person who wrote the cheque. Overdraft A cheque written for more money than is currently in the account. If the bank refuses to cash the cheque, it is said to have “bounced.” Passbook (Bankbook) A booklet given by the bank to the depositor to record deposits, withdrawals, and interest earned on a savings account. Personal identification number (pin) It is a unique number or code entered by a customer when using an ATM, or accessing INTERAC®, PLUS® or CIRRUS® service. Reconciliation Checking all bank account papers to make sure that bank’s records and yours agree. Savings account A bank account that accrues interest in exchange for use of the money on deposit. Service charge A monthly fee a bank charges for handling an account. Stop payment A request made to a bank to not pay a specific cheque. If requested soon enough, the cheque will not be debited from the payer’s account. Normally there is a charge for this service. Withdrawal An amount of money taken out of an account in cash, by cheque or debit card, or by automatic withdrawal. - 41 of 201- Appendix D Information needed to compare chequing accounts Fees: What are the monthly service plans and what are the associated charges? What are the per use charges with the account of choice? How much does it cost to order cheques? Are there fees for simply inquiring about your account? Are there fees for using the ABM, online banking, telephone banking or at the teller? Other charges: What are the costs associated with overdraft protection? What is the stop payment fee? What does it cost to get a certified cheque or money order? Location: Where is the branch located? Is it close to your home, school? What are their hours of operation? Are they open on Saturdays? Does this bank have many ABM’s available in your city / town? Interest: What is the interest rate earned on your account balance? Do you have to maintain a minimum monthly balance to earn the interest? What happens if your balance drops below the minimum? How is the interest calculated? Compounded monthly? Daily? Annually? Restrictions: Is your deposit insured by the Canadian Deposit Insurance Company (CDIC) Are your deposits held? If so, for how long? How much do you have access to after you deposit your funds? Special features: Will the bank issue a temporary cheque? Does the bank offer overdraft protection? Are there discounts for students / youth? - 42 of 201- Appendix E Help for choosing a chequing account Bank #1 _______________ Bank #2 _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Account #1: Name: Monthly Charge: Interest paid? Rate? _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Account #2: Name: Monthly Charge: Interest paid? Rate? _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Account #3: Name: Monthly Charge: Interest paid? Rate? _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ _______________ Name of the bank: Where is the nearest location to your: Home: School: How many ABM’s are available? What hours are they open? Are they open on Saturday? How many branches are there in your city? Do you qualify for a youth account? If so, what are its features? Do you qualify for a student account? If so, what are its features? What types of chequing accounts do they offer? How can you do your banking? Any fees? ABM’s Telephone Banking Online Banking In Branch Cost per withdrawal; At bank-owned ABM At other FI’s ABM At bank teller Free Cheques? Stop Cheque fee? - 43 of 201- Appendix F Compare service charges for different financial institutions Please go to: http://consumer.ic.gc.ca/epic/site/oca-bc.nsf/en/ca00669e.html and What is your lowest monthly balance? ($) How many paycheques are directly deposited to your account each month? How many cheques do you write each month? How many Interac direct payment purchases do you make each month? How many pre-authorized debits are made each month? Choose the type of banking you perform each month (Choose all that apply): Branch, Bank machine, Phone banking, Computer banking $200 2 1 15 6 Choose all Click : Withdrawals Bill payments Transfers between deposit accounts Account history enquiries 2 0 1 0 Withdrawals your Institutions bank machines Withdrawals at other institutions bank machines Bill payments Transfers between deposit accounts Account History Enquiries 5 3 0 0 0 Bill payments Transfers between deposit accounts Balance enquiries Account History Enquiries 0 0 2 0 Bill payments Transfers between deposit accounts Balance enquiries Account History Enquiries 5 5 5 3 - To be assigned by teacher Best type of account: Name Service Charge Second best type of account Name Service Charge _________ _________ _________ _________ - 44 of 201- Appendix G (Source: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewPub.asp?fl=6&sl=23&docid=19&pg=8) Opening your bank account Identification is needed to meet federal laws and it helps the bank ensure that only you and those you authorize have access to the money in your account. You can provide identification in two different ways: You can provide two pieces of identification. One piece must come from Part A of the list on page 10. The second piece may come from Part A or Part B; OR You can provide one piece of identification from Part A, and have confirmation of your identity by someone of good standing from the community where the bank is located, or a client of that bank in good standing. - 45 of 201- Appendix H (Source: www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Lesson 6, In-class Activities) Opening a Chequing Account - 46 of 201- Appendix I (Source: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewpub.asp?fl=3&sl=251&tl=253&docid=19&pg=9) Using your account and ways of banking Once you have opened an account, you have many options on how to use it to do your banking. Banking At Your Branch Doing your banking at a branch means going in person where a customer service representative will handle your needs. There are many activities you can do at a branch – three common ones are: (1) making deposits, (2) making cash withdrawals, and (3) cashing cheques. Let's look at each of these. Making Deposits Making a deposit means putting money (cash or cheque) into your account. To do this, you may be asked to fill in a deposit slip. Some banks, however, are “paperless”, meaning you bring your deposit to the customer service representative and a deposit slip is completed for you by that representative. You will be asked to sign this deposit slip showing the amount of your deposit. You may request a receipt for this transaction to keep as a record of your deposit or you may have your passbook updated showing the deposit. Some “paperless” banks may ask you to swipe your debit card and enter your PIN at the counter, allowing you to make your deposit electronically on the PIN pad. When you deposit a cheque, there may be a delay before you can take the money in cash. This is called a “hold” on the money being deposited. This is to give the bank time to make sure that the cheque is good. If you are a regular customer at the bank and deposit a federal or provincial government cheque, there should not be a delay. But if you are a new customer and deposit a cheque written on an account at a different bank, you can expect to wait a number of days before you can take the money out of your account. Making cash withdrawals Making cash withdrawals means taking money out of your account in person. One way to do this is to fill in a withdrawal slip. Every bank has a different form, but all of them ask for the same type of information. In the same way you make “paperless” deposits, you can also make “paperless” withdrawals at some banks. A customer service representative will help you by completing a withdrawal slip. You will be asked to sign this withdrawal slip showing the amount of cash you have received. You may request a receipt for this transaction to keep as a record of your withdrawal, or you may have your passbook updated showing the withdrawal. Other “paperless” banks may ask you to swipe your debit card and enter your PIN at the counter, allowing you to make your withdrawal electronically on a PIN pad. Cashing cheques - 47 of 201- If you are cashing a cheque which has been made out to you, you must endorse it. Endorsing means signing it on the back. Here is how to endorse a cheque: Look at the face (front) of the cheque. Note how your name is spelled. Turn the cheque over. On the back, sign your name. If you are depositing your cheque, print “for deposit only” and the account number on the back. Be sure to sign your cheque at the bank in front of the customer service representative. The reason to do this is because once the cheque is endorsed, anyone can cash it. Writing cheques One way of paying for things or taking money out of your chequing account is by writing a cheque. A cheque is a written order to the bank to pay a certain amount of money from your account. It is important to remember that you must have the money in your account on the day the cheque is dated. It is illegal to write a cheque if you know there will not be enough money in the account to cover the amount. A cheque is not money but it is used like money. To take money out by cheque, you must fill in a cheque. It may be a personalized cheque or a nonpersonalized cheque. It is usually better to use a personalized cheque if you have one. Holds on cheques you deposit Banks may apply “holds” on funds deposited by cheque to provide an opportunity for the cheque to clear – in other words, to make sure that the person or company who wrote the cheque is still willing and able to cover the amount of the cheque. Holds help protect depositors and banks from losses due to invalid cheques – for example, those returned as N.S.F. or those written for fraudulent purposes. The hold period must allow time not only for the cheque to clear through the automated cheque clearing system, but also to be manually returned to the branch of the account holder who cashed it. When you open an account, or upon request, your bank will give you a statement of the bank’s hold policies explaining the maximum amount of time it can take for a cheque to clear and have the funds deposited to your account. Direct deposit Direct deposit means that money that is owed to you (like paycheques and government cheques) is electronically put into your account. Direct deposit ensures that you have instant access to your funds, and there is no hold on them because the funds are guaranteed. Clients expecting to receive money from federal, provincial or municipal governments can ask for payment by “direct deposit”. As well, many companies arrange to pay their employees through direct deposit. Electronic banking - 48 of 201- Banking in Canada has changed dramatically over the past few years. In the past, you would visit your branch and a teller would handle your banking. Today people conduct only 30 per cent of their business in the branch. The rest of the time they use self-service banking – the Automated Banking Machine, banking by telephone, through the Internet on a personal computer or making purchases with a debit card. This type of banking has become popular because it is more convenient and saves time and money on service charges. Automated Banking Machines Most banks today offer self-service banking through ABMs. You can find ABMs in banks, shopping malls, gas stations, convenience stores, supermarkets, airports, train stations, etc. In most cases, ABMs can be used 24-hours a day, seven days a week. Full-service ABMs can be used to: 4. withdraw cash 5. deposit cash or cheques 6. pay bills 7. transfer money from one account to another 8. get your account balance 9. some allow you to update your passbook or obtain an account statement 10. machines with an Interac logo allow you to access your account from another financial institution’s ABM The cost of using an ABM depends on your bank. Most banks charge a transaction fee which is deducted from the account. To save on these service charges, you can sign up for a monthly service plan which allows you to conduct a certain number of transactions for a set fee. Plans vary according to your financial institution. - 49 of 201- How to use an ABM You must fill out an application form at your bank. Your bank will give you a special card (a debit card) and a number called a Personal Identification Number (PIN). If you want to create your own PIN, most banks have a special machine where you can choose the number yourself. You will also get a cardholder agreement. Your PIN is your electronic signature – the same as your signature on a cheque. That’s why it’s important to keep this number private. Don’t write it down on the card or in your wallet. Never tell anyone your PIN and never let anyone use your card. Every bank has different rules about how much money you can take out at one time, when deposits will be credited to your account, etc. Ask for details when you apply for your debit card. Different customers get different limits, too, depending on their past experiences in using financial services. Your cardholder agreement will tell you what to do if your card is lost or stolen. When you want to use an ABM, push your debit card into the slot and follow the instructions on the screen. The exact words that come up on the screen may be different, depending on where you bank. But the meaning will be similar. You will be asked to press in your PIN. If you make a mistake, a message will let you know that the PIN is incorrect. Begin again. If you punch in an incorrect PIN a certain number of times, the machine may not allow you to try again or it may take your card. You will have to go to your bank during regular hours and get a new PIN or a new card. Once you have correctly entered your PIN, you will be asked to press the key for the type of transaction you want to do (withdrawal, deposit, bill payment, transfer). Press the account you want to access (chequing, savings, etc.). Next, enter the amount using the number keys. Some ABMs have pre-programmed numbers in amounts varying from $20.00 to $200.00. If you want to make a pre-programmed amount withdrawal, all you need to do is press the amount button. The machine will ask you if the amount is correct. If it is, press the “OK” key. If not, press the “CORRECT/ CHANGE” key or press “CANCEL” and start over. When you are finished, remove your card, cash and transaction record. The transaction record is a slip of paper with the details of what you just did and the balance left in your account. Always check it right away to make sure it is correct. Then use it to check your next account statement or passbook update. If you have a problem when using an ABM, get help as soon as possible. Most problems are easy to solve. Quickly report any problems so that the bank can solve them. TIP: When choosing your Personal Identification Number (PIN), make sure it is not obvious. Don’t pick your address, telephone number or birth date. - 50 of 201- Interac ® Direct Payment When you have a debit card, you can also use it to pay for purchases in a store. This is called Interac Direct Payment (IDP). This way of paying for things has become very popular over the past few years. Many stores, gas stations, supermarkets and movie theatres have a small machine called a point-of-sale terminal. When you swipe your card through this machine and key in your PIN, money is automatically transferred from your account to the store’s account. You have now paid. This is a safe and convenient way of shopping because you no longer need to carry large amounts of cash or a cheque book. Using direct payment: When you buy something or want to pay for a service at a shop that accepts Interac Direct Payment, you will be asked to “swipe” your card through a point-of-sale terminal. This also may be done by the merchant. You will then be given a PIN pad and asked to verify the amount of the purchase (Is the purchase amount OK? If it is, press “OK”.) Next you will be asked to choose an account – savings or chequing – from which the funds are to be withdrawn. You are then asked to enter your PIN. Use your hand or body as a shield to prevent others from watching you enter your PIN in order to protect your personal information. This number and your bank account number and balance remain confidential and secure. The merchant has no way of knowing any of this information. You are asked to press the “OK” button and are notified when the transaction is finished. The money for the purchase is directly taken from your account and credited to the merchant’s account. For some point-of-sale terminals, you may be asked to pay a fee to use them. The cost of this fee will be displayed on the keypad, and you will be asked if you want to continue with the transaction. You can press “YES” to pay the fee and continue the transaction, or you can press “NO” to cancel the transaction. It is your choice to continue the transaction or cancel it. You are given a printed record of the transaction. Save this record and either write it in your cheque book register or save it to compare against your monthly bank statement. If you don’t have enough money in your account to cover the purchase, your transaction will be denied. There may also be a daily limit on how much you can purchase with IDP. - 51 of 201- Telephone banking This is a quick, easy and convenient way to do your banking 24-hours a day, seven days a week. You can bank from home, work or even when you’re out of town using a telephone. For telephone banking you need an account and a debit card. To get started, just visit a branch or call your bank’s 1-800 telephone number for more information on how to register. You choose a personal password or access number that you use every time you phone the telephone banking number. Do not share this information with anyone. You can register your bank account(s) and the account number of each bill you will be paying, for example, your phone bill, credit card, hydro bill, tax bill, etc. Service charges vary depending on how much you use telephone banking. Some banks may include this as part of a service plan or may offer the service free if you maintain a minimum monthly balance. Once your account is set up, all you have to do is dial the number and follow the voice instructions. You will be asked to enter your debit card number and your confidential access number. With telephone banking, you may be able to: pay bills and transfer funds immediately check your account balance and activity get an interim bank statement or hear a list of your recent transactions make postdated bill payments check past bill payment and postdated bill payment information With telephone banking, you also have the option of talking to a banking representative who can help you: apply for a loan, a mortgage or renew a mortgage (during certain hours – check with your bank) order cheques request a stop payment on a cheque find out if a cheque went through your account sign up for a service plan invest in GIC and term deposits Each bank may offer different services and different ways to access telephone banking. Ask your bank for details about the services they offer through telephone banking. What you cannot do with telephone banking is deposit or withdraw cash. - 52 of 201- Banking by computer (Internet banking) Now you can also do your banking through the Internet on your computer. You can: transfer money between your accounts pay bills make postdated bill payments check on your account balance or activity download your transactions to financial software (Quicken, Money) There are two ways you can do your banking by computer: through a special computer connection to your bank using its software or through your bank’s website. Either way, if you are interested in doing some of your banking activities through your computer, ask for more information at your bank. What you cannot do with computer banking is deposit or withdraw cash. If you are thinking about computer or telephone banking, consider the following: What are the access fees? What is the transaction fee each time you access the service? Which service package best meets your needs? - 53 of 201- Appendix J Security Tips Cheque safety Do not sign a blank cheque or write a cheque payable to “Cash” before you go to the bank branch or ABM. If it is lost or stolen, it may be cashed by anyone who presents it. Never lend anyone a cheque or deposit slip from your cheque book. Never sign the back of a cheque (endorse) until you give it to the customer service representative. If it is lost, anyone could cash it. If your cheques are lost or stolen, notify your branch immediately. ABM and Direct Payment security tips Your debit card is the key to your account(s). It is for your personal use only. Keep your card in a safe place and never let anyone else use it. Protect your Personal Identification Number (PIN). It is your electronic signature. Never write it down – memorize it. When you decide on a PIN, avoid the obvious – your telephone number, date of birth, address, etc. Never tell anyone your PIN. You are the only person who should know it. Always conduct your ABM transactions when and where you feel most secure. If you are uncomfortable about using the machine for any reason, do it later or go to another location. To ensure privacy when conducting an ABM or debit transaction, shield yourself to prevent others from watching you enter your PIN. After finishing an ABM or debit transaction, remember to take your card and, if provided, your transaction record. When making a withdrawal from an ABM, count the cash received and put it away immediately before leaving the machine. If your card is lost, stolen or not returned by an ABM, call your financial institution immediately. Most institutions have 1-800 telephone numbers and/or 24-hour service for lost or stolen cards. Each customer has their own daily limit for withdrawals, and you have the choice of lowering your daily withdrawal limit. Contact your bank to request this change. Review your bank statements or passbook regularly. Report any unusual transactions immediately to your bank. If you are the victim of debit card fraud, the matter will be investigated immediately by your bank. If fraud has occurred, your money will be returned to you by your bank. ABM robberies are not common, but if it should happen, remember that your safety comes first. Report the incident to the police and to your bank. - 54 of 201- Security tips for Online and Telephone Banking Canada’s Internet and telephone banking systems are very secure and customers can safely do their banking online or on the phone. You can help to protect yourself from fraud by taking a few simple precautions: Change your password often and use a combination of letters and numbers in your password Never share your password Always look for the closed lock or unbroken key symbols on your computer when entering private information. This means your transactions will be securely transmitted across the Internet. Always be careful when receiving or responding to unknown e-mails, especially if you are being asked for your password, SIN or other private information. - 55 of 201- Appendix K – (Source: www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Lesson 6, In-class Activities) How to write a cheque - 56 of 201- Appendix L (Source: www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Lesson 6, In-class Activities) Keeping a Running Balance Record deposits and keep a running balance in the cheque register below. On May 26, your balance is $527.96. On May 27, you write cheque #107 to your landlord, Mrs.Wilson, for $226.00. On May 28, you use your debit card at Food Mart for $22.52. On June 1, you write a cheque for $156.32 to Gateway Motors for your car payment. On June 1, you realize your cheque to Gateway Motors should have been for $165.23, so you void the first cheque and write a new cheque for $165.23. On June 2, you write a cheque to your phone company for $62.77. On June 2, you use your ATM card to withdraw $20.00. On June 15, your paycheque for $425.00 is automatically deposited. On June 15, you use your debit card at Gifts Plus to buy a $18.99 birthday present for your mother. On June 15, you write a cheque for $246.45 to XYZ Insurance Co. to cover your insurance premium. On June 22, you transfer $100.00 online from your chequing account to your savings account. On June 24, you use your debit card at Gas Up to fill up your car. You spend $12.88. On June 28, you use your ATM card to withdraw $30.00 from your chequing account. Cheque # Date Description Transaction Deposit Amount Balance - 57 of 201- Amount opening 527.96 Use the cheque register you just completed to answer the following questions: What was your account balance on May 30? Could you have paid your car insurance payment on June 1 instead of June 15? If not, why? The love of your life has been in a bad mood lately, and you think an expensive present might help. You’ve found a leather jacket on sale for $189.00. Can you afford to buy the jacket on June 8? What will your account balance be if you do? The hottest new band in town has just released a CD. It costs $21.99. Can you afford to buy the CD on June 2? What will your account balance be if you do? What was your account balance after you withdrew $30.00 on June 28? What was the amount of cheque #111, to whom did you write it, and for what? - 58 of 201- Appendix M (Source: www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Lesson 6, In-class Activities) Keeping a Running Balance – Answer Key Cheque # opening 107 D. card 108 109 110 ATM ATM D. Card 111 ATM D. Card ATM Date 5/27 5/28 6/1 6/1 6/1 6/2 6/2 6/15 6/15 6/15 6/22 6/24 6/28 Description Transaction Amount Mrs. Wilson Debit card, Food Mart Gateway Motors Void Cheque #108 Gateway Motors Phone Company Cash Withdrawal Deposit Debit Card, gift for mom XYZ Insurance Transfer to Savings Debit Card – Gas Up Withdrawal Deposit Amount Balance 527.96 301.96 279.44 123.12 279.44 114.21 51.44 31.44 466.44 437.46 191.00 91.00 78.12 48.12 226.00 22.52 156.32 156.32 165.23 62.77 20.00 425.00 18.99 246.46 100.00 12.88 30.00 1. What was your account balance on May 30? $279.44 2. Could you have paid your car insurance payment on June 1 instead of June 15? If not, why? No—the payment was $246.45 but the account balance on June 1 was only $114.21 3. The love of your life has been in a bad mood lately, and you think an expensive present might help. You’ve found a leather jacket on sale for $189.00. Can you afford to buy the jacket on June 8? What will your account balance be if you do? No—the account will be overdrawn by $157.56 4. The hottest new band in town has just released a CD. It costs $21.99. Can you afford tobuy the CD on June 2? What will your account balance be if you do? Yes—$9.45 5. What was your account balance after you withdrew $30.00 on June 28? $48.12 6. What was the amount of check #111, to whom did you write it, and for what? $246.45 to XYZ Insurance for a car insurance payment - 59 of 201- Appendix N (Source: www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Lesson 6, In-class Activities) Bank Reconciliation Activity Use the bank statement, the cheque register, and the reconciliation worksheet on the following page to balance this chequebook. - 60 of 201- - 61 of 201- Appendix O – (Source: www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Lesson 6, In-class Activities) Bank Reconciliation Answer Key - 62 of 201- This page intentionally left blank for notes. - 63 of 201- Module 4: Income and Taxation (Core) Suggested Time: 10 – 15 hours Level: Introductory Prerequisite: Module 2: Decision Making and Money Basics Module Overview: This module will build upon Module 1 by exploring payroll, paycheques, deductions off of paycheques and personal income tax. Foundational Objectives: To recognize the importance of income To recognize the importance of payroll functions within the business environment. To demonstrate an understanding of gross pay and the deductions taken off of paycheques. To develop an understanding of personal taxation Common Essential Learnings Foundational Objectives: To support students in developing a better understanding of personal, moral, social and cultural aspects of income. (PSVS) To support the development of a positive attitude to life-long learning, as it pertains to the changing economic structure of our society. (IL) To apply a knowledge of numbers and interrelationships to assist in the calculation and estimation of income. (NUM) To enable students to understand and use proper vocabulary and expressions that characterizes income. (COM) Learning Objective Notes Canada Customs and Revenue Agency publishes “Teaching Taxes Program” each year. This can provide useful information for this module for both teacher and students. Payroll records are required by law. There are both federal and provincial laws governing the paying of employees. 4.1 To define and determine why payroll records are important (COM) Students should be aware of the consequences of not reporting all earned income. They should also be aware of what can happen when an employer does not report employee deductions and taxes to Canada Customs and Revenues. Resources: “Teaching Taxes Program” Student workbook Canada Customs and Revenue – Payroll - 64 of 201- Examine what a social insurance card is and the forms that need to be filled out to apply for one. 4.2 To examine the collection of necessary data to process payroll for employers Examine the TD-1 form that needs to be filled out by each new employee, so that a net claim can be established, so that income tax may be deducted from pay. Resources: Social Insurance Fact Sheet Social Insurance Form 2007 Saskatchewan Personal Tax Credits Return (TD-1) Discuss the various methods by which employees are paid: hourly, monthly, commission, combination salary, piece work compensation etc. Examples should be given to students of where the various methods may be used. Employees may be paid weekly, bi-weekly, monthly, semi-monthly etc. In pairs get students to find jobs that include different ways in which employees can be paid in want ads. Students should evaluate which method of earnings is most advantageous. Be sure students understand the difference between working on commission and getting commission plus salary. Provide examples from the community 4.3 To define and calculate various methods of gross pay (COM) Students should be able to calculate gross wages involving regular pay, overtime pay, vacation pay, piecework earnings. Investigate jobs that work by piece (carpenters, mechanics etc.). Report on several occupations that earn salary by piece. Be sure to give descriptions of the job its self, the amount of money paid for each job and the time it takes to complete certain jobs. Students should be able to calculate earnings from straight commission or base wage plus commission. Students should be able to determine the difference between gross pay and net pay. Students should be able to calculate weekly, monthly and yearly net pay. Provide students with examples of limitations within the workforce (ex. Employee may be docked 15 minutes off their pay check if they arrive 1 minute late for work.) - 65 of 201- Resources: Use local want ads from newspapers, advertisements or the internet. Ready for Work Identify compulsory deductions required by law in Canada, stating the benefits derived from each and the approximate yearly minimum and maximum contributions. Natives working on a reserve are not subject to federal or provincial tax deductions. If the employment is off the reserve, they are subject to deduction of federal and provincial tax as applicable. 4.4 To examine compulsory and voluntary employee deductions from gross pay Canada Pension Plan (CPP). What is its purpose? (pension due to retirement, death, orphans benefits, or disability) Note: Both employer and individual contribute to pension plan. Natives working on a reserve and contributing under the Public Service Superannuation Act (PSSA) are subject to Canada Pension Plan deductions. Natives working on a reserve who are not contributors under the PSSA are ineligible to contribute to the Canada Pension Plan. The amount of contribution (deducted each pay period) is calculated by using earnings for the year, minus a basic personal exemption. The result is then multiplied by the contribution rate. You have to pay CPP when you turn 18 and continue until you turn 70. What are the current provincial and federal rates of income tax? Resource: CPP/EI Premiums Employment Insurance (EI). What is its purpose? (benefits for regular or special job loss, maternity leave, parental leave, and some benefits for sickness). There is no age limit for EI contributions. Natives employed by the federal government are subject to deduction for Unemployment Insurance. The amount of contribution is a percentage of insurable earnings (generally, gross pay). What are the current provincial and federal rates of income tax? Resource: CPP/EI Premiums The purpose of income tax: to raise money for federal and provincial governments. What do they use the money for? Review and discuss the need to know the net claim code of the employee - 66 of 201- when deducting income tax. Resource: Employers Guide – Payroll deductions Garnishment: What is it? What are the limits? What is the responsibility of the employer? Identify voluntary deductions (insurance plans, Canada Savings Bond, contributions, staff association dues, charitable donations, maintenance of dependants etc.) Resource: Deductions from Pay If appropriate students may inquire about deductions that are made on their own or on a relatives pay cheque. (Source deductions from Revenue Canada) Students may bring in their own paycheque to look at. 4.5 To examine the effect of payroll regulations and The Labour Standards Act Students should be aware of deductions that may be affected by The Labour Standards Act. Some deductions that could be affected are union dues, group insurance, employee purchases and health insurance. Resource: Ready for Work Students should be aware of the employers’ responsibilities. By law they must prepare a T4 slip for each employee by the end of February following the year in which they worked. 4.6 To recognize the importance of payroll information in the preparation of T4 slips and in the preparation of Records of Employment for employees leaving the workforce. 4.7 To become familiar with the components of the personal income tax form and its terminology (IL) A T4 slip shows gross earnings for the year, CPP and EI contributions, and tax deducted at source. After the year end data is taken, balances should return to zero. Resources: T4 Form T4 Slip Information A Record of Employment must be completed when an employee leaves a place of employment. Resource: Record of Employment (ROE) Identify the major components of a personal income tax return: Calculation of total income Calculation of taxable income Calculation of non-refundable tax credits Self employment sections Personal amounts Tax payable - 67 of 201- Resources: “Teaching Taxes Program” available free from Canada Customs and Revenue Agency General Income Tax and Benefits Guide Students should prepare a personal income tax return based on realistic simulations. 4.8 To demonstrate the ability to do a personal income tax return Simulations should be based upon realistic student experiences in the community (part time jobs etc.) Resource: “Teaching Taxes Program” available free from Canada Customs and Revenue Agency Students should be able to explain how they all fit together. 4.9 To summarize and explain the importance of payroll functions, gross pay, deductions off of paycheques and personal income tax. Students summarize the need for payroll functions and the need for income tax. How does each individual benefit from income tax? Income tax is deducted by the employer, but is assessed by each tax payer on a yearly basis. - 68 of 201- Works Cited Canada Revenue Agency. (2007). Payroll. Online April 7, 2007 at http://www.craarc.gc.ca/tax/business/topics/payroll/menu-e.html Canada Revenue Agency. (2007). Online April 7, 2007 at http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/menu-e.html Canada Revenue Agency. (2007). Teaching Taxes Program. Online April 7, 2007 at http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/teachtax/ Canadian Tax and Financial Information. (2007). Taxtips. Online April 10, 2007 at http://www.taxtips.ca/ Government of Saskatchewan. (2006). Record of Employment. Online April 10, 2007 at http://www.cbsc.org/servlet/ContentServer?cid=1081944194722&pagename=CBSC_SK %2Fdisplay&lang=en&c=Regs Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. (2004). Social Insurance. Online April 7, 2007 at http://www.privcom.gc.ca/index_e.asp Saskatchewan Labour. (2006). Ready for Work. Online April 11, 2007 at http://www.readyforwork.sk.ca/ Saskatchewan Learning. (2003). Accounting 10, 20 and 30: Curriculum Guide. Evergreen Curriculum. Online April 5, 2007 at http://www.sasked.gov.sk.ca/docs/account/accounting2003/index.html Saskatchewan Learning. (1995). Mathematics 10, 20: Curriculum Guide. Evergreen Curriculum. Online April 5, 2007 at http://www.sasked.gov.sk.ca/docs/secmath/secmath.html Treasury Board of Canada. (1991). Deductions from pay. Online April 9, 2007 at http://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/pubs_pol/hrpubs/TBM_11A/dwnld/6_e.rtf - 69 of 201- This page intentionally left blank for notes. - 70 of 201- Module 5: Introduction to Budgeting (Core) Suggested Time: 5-10 hours Level: Introductory Prerequisite: None Module Overview: This module will introduce students to the concept of and characteristics of budgeting, and the importance of financial responsibility in managing their money. It will help students to recognize that a major factor in being financially solvent is to spend less than one earns and to save the difference. A personal budget is a tool that can assist an individual stay within his or her income. This module will explain budgeting and how sound financial decisions can increase a person’s standard of living and wealth and outlines the various stages of preparing a budget. Finally, this module will help students apply decision making to personal financial choices (planning, maintaining and analyzing money management) through readings, exercises and the creation of a budget. Module Objectives: To understand budgeting and its role in and contribution to personal financial responsibility, the future, and community life. Good financial management skills require the abilities to establish a budget and understand the trade-offs required to adhere to a budget. To show how budgeting helps consumers balance income, spending and savings goals. To develop a budget plan that can be used as a planning tool for a use in attaining a specific opportunity or goal. To have students apply what they know about budgets to make sound financial decisions. Common Essential Leanings Module Objectives: To enable students to use language (listening, speaking, reading, writing) for differing audiences and purposes relevant to the students, budgeting and financial responsibility. (COM) To seek information through a steadily expanding network of options including libraries, databases, individuals, and agencies. (CCT) To promote both intuitive, imaginative thought and the ability to evaluate ideas, processes, experiences, and objects in meaningful contexts. (CCT) To enable students to think for themselves and to recognize the limits of individual reflection and the need to contribute to and build upon mutual understandings. (IL) - 71 of 201- Learning Objectives Notes Students should be aware that individuals use budgets to itemize and manage their income, expenses, and savings. In order to be financially sound, it’s important to spend less than you earn. 5.1 To define and explore the meaning of budgeting and how it relates to problem solving and financial responsibility. Students may complete a checklist or rating scale of their budgeting skills at the beginning of the course, at selected intervals throughout the course, and again at the end of the course. This will help determine the progress made in achieving budgeting skills. This will also help students identify and assess their personal abilities and capitalize on those that contribute positively to the achievement of their goals. (See Appendix A & B for Budgeting Pre-Test) When students learn budgeting vocabulary and skills early, they are more likely to be successful money managers. Good financial management skills require the abilities to establish a budget. Ask students to define key terms they believe are critical to budgeting success. Encourage students to discuss each term fully and to use them as springboards to think of others. Students should have an extensive list of terms and definitions when they are done. 5.2 To define key terminology associated with budgeting. As each term is discussed, students should write the definition and additional details they feel are important. This process will help them review for a potential test. In this activity, students should indicate if they agree or disagree with the following statements, as the instructor reads them. A budget is a record of fixed expenses. Interest earned on investments should be considered as part of a budget. A budget helps you plan for the fun things in your life, so you can feel good about how you spend your money. - 72 of 201- Flexible budgets are more likely to be followed. Budgets aren’t necessary to reach your financial goals. Savings should be paid first in every budget. No one really uses budgets anymore. A budget is too much trouble to follow. Budgets are too restrictive. Students could then compare their responses with a partner and discuss why they chose the answers they did. (See Appendix E) To help students understand the trade-offs required to adhere to a budget and explain how limited personal financial resources affect the choices people make. Some budgeting characteristics are learned and gained through experience, while others seem to be innate. In a class discussion, students should examine the budgeting characteristics identified and assign them (with reasons) to the categories of learned and innate. Teachers may also wish to explain the concept of Opportunity Cost at this point. 5.3 To evaluate the consequences of personal financial decisions and explore types of expenses Discuss the differences between Needs vs. Wants (See Appendix M for a sample activity called “Do I REALLY need that?) Discuss the difference between needs and wants and give a few examples. (For example, we need clothing; but we may want the latest fashions. Teachers may wish to direct the discussion toward buying a home. What are the needs and wants of a family?) As you discuss, write the students' answers on the blackboard. Types of Expenses • Fixed Expenses: These expenses occur regularly and don’t change from month to month. Examples of fixed expenses are rent and car payments. • Flexible Expenses: Like fixed expenses, flexible expenses occur on a regular basis. The difference is that with flexible expenses, you have some control over how - 73 of 201- much you spend. Examples of flexible expenses include food and gasoline. • Discretionary Expenses: This is money that you choose to spend – like money for CDs or movies or having pizza with friends. It also includes the money that you save. (See Appendix K for activity) The difference between a family and individual budget should be introduced. Teachers may wish to conduct a brainstorming session around the critical items that are present in a family and individual budgets. 5.4 To examine the skills necessary for using financial information for individual or family use. A good personal budget: • covers basic expenses that occur on a routine basis • has money available for unexpected expenses, and includes regular savings for future expenses. Tips for sticking to a personal budget: • Keep your budget in mind when you shop! • Be prepared to make large purchases by saving money over time. • Compare prices for similar items at different stores. (See Appendix I for sample budget and Appendix P for activities) The concept and process of Decision Making was introduced in Module 1. Teachers may wish to review this procedure and emphasize the importance of setting reasonable aspirations, targets, and deadlines. 5.5 To help students prioritize personal and financial goals. A financial planner could be invited to the class to discuss the importance of setting financial goals. Students should be heavily involved in making the arrangements for visit. Prior to the visit, students should be involved in developing questions to stimulate discussion. Students should also be involved in introducing the - 74 of 201- guest, interviewing, making the thank-you statement afterward, and sending a letter of thanks. (See Appendix O for “Budget Busters” activity) Planning for a venture is a key to success. Planning begins after the careful selection and evaluation of goals and ideas. 5.6 To identify various forms of money management. One of the key purposes of budgeting is to help to determine when changes are necessary and to allow time to make them. Are the students able to come up with an example or two to support this statement? A teacher may want to involve the elements of critical and creative thinking. Creative thinking skills include: 5.7 To understand how limited personal financial resources affect the choices people make and the ways budgeting can help. ability to think creatively ability to solve problems confidence to make a decision and act upon it ability to set goals, develop a plan to achieve them, and carry out the plan Techniques for problem solving as described by Edward de Bono can be used at this stage. Awareness of and experience with the six functions of the thinking hats is essential for students to see things and view situations in different ways. Edward de Bono’s “white, blue and green hat thinking” can be emphasized here. By wearing the various coloured hats the students would look at their decisions from various perspectives and decide if what they want to do is a good course of action. (See Appendix L for activity) Students should examine their current saving and spending behaviors and patterns to get an idea of how much money they have on a weekly, bi-weekly or monthly basis. - 75 of 201- 5.8 To begin creating a budget Ask the students to brainstorm the qualities needed to be successful at budgeting. A concept map could be used help the students develop a picture of the budget and what is required. Teachers may also want to discuss the 3 R’s of money handling: Three R’s of Money Handling Reality – you’ll have limited amount of time and money Responsibility – handling your money wisely Restraint – show restrain and save for what you want most, not what looks good now (See Appendix C & D for steps in creating a budget) Students should monitor and track their spending and saving habits for a period of time specified by the teacher. Teachers may also to summarize personal budgeting practices and demonstrate these skills in a variety of situations. 5.9 To monitor spending, income and saving patterns and habits. Teachers may wish to use the following activity: Ask how many students stopped at a store at some point during the day. Find out how much they spent and on what. Compute the cost of stopping at the convenience store every weekday during an eight-week period. Hopefully they will see the amount of money that was being wasted by buying coffee or muffins on the way to school, ask the class how to save money. Students should realized that if they had bought the items at the grocery store and packed a lunch daily, the cost over an eight-week period would drop and they would have saved money. This exercise should spark a conversation about spending habits and how to curb them but still maintain a fulfilling life. Many students will already be practicing some of these budgeting skills. It is important for students to identify situations where this is occurring. - 76 of 201- For example, if a student is saving for a car, works in (or has parents working in) a financial institution, or has a part-time job, he or she can identify budgeting personal qualities practiced. (See Appendix J for budget tracking sheet) Students should set goals for changes they can make during this course of study or in the future. Students should be aware of where they are now, what characteristics they currently possess, and how they plan to grow. Do they like to take risks? What risks do they see as part of their near future? Students should consider ways to overcome any shortcomings. Have students prepare a projected budget of income. Reinforce the usefulness of a recordkeeping system to verify and modify the budget. Budgeting is a process that can be accomplished by following a general step-by-step guide. 5.10 To design a budget for earning, spending, saving, and investing. A general budgeting framework helps answer the following questions: What is to be done? Why is it being done? Where will this be done? When will this be done? Who will do it? How will it be done? Elements of a budget could be planned as a jigsaw activity. The jigsaw structure promotes positive interdependence and also provides a simple method to ensure individual accountability. The basic premise of jigsaw is to divide a problem into sections, one for each group member. Each student receives resources to complete only his/her part. The students who are responsible for the same section join together and form a new, temporary focus group whose purpose is for the students to - 77 of 201- 1. master the concepts in their section, and 2. to develop a strategy for teaching what they have learned to the other students in their original collaborative learning group. Teachers may wish to have their students make short presentations on their projects and turn in a written analysis. The presentations should show an example of an individual budget. The students should list the necessary items in their own budget and be ready to justify each item. As an extra task, teachers may wish to give the students a specific amount of money to divide among their budget. Have students reconvene one week later to discuss what was bought and how one might further cut back on expenses and save money. (See Appendix F for budget creation, Appendix H for budget worksheets, Appendix J for budget tracking) - 78 of 201- Key Terminology Asset - items of ownership convertible into cash; total resources of a person or business, as cash. Budget – A plan for managing income and expenses Cash Flow\Decision Making – a measure of the money you receive and the money you spend Delayed Gratification – is giving up something you want now in return for something better later Fixed Expense - a cost that does not change from period to period or that changes only very slightly. Fixed expenses are usually paid on a regular basis, such as week to week, month to month, quarter to quarter or year to year. Typical household fixed expenses are mortgage or rent payments, car payments, real estate taxes and insurance premiums. Financial planning – the process of defining goals, developing a plan to achieve them and putting the plan into action. Goals – are clearly, identified destinations of where you want to go, something you want or need, which you acquire by taking certain steps. Gross Income – The total amount of income earned before deductions are made. Liabilities - anything that is owed to someone else. Needs – are essentials, the basics such as: food, clothing, a place to sleep. Net Income – Amount of income left after deductions are taken. Opportunity Cost - The cost of an alternative that must be forgone in order to pursue a certain action. Put another way, the benefits you could have received by taking an alternative action. Scarcity - Insufficiency of amount or supply or a shortage Variable Expenses – Expenses which vary from week to week or month to month (clothing, food, etc.) Values – are simple beliefs and practices in your life that are important to you. Many factors such as: family, friends, religion, culture, etc. all influence your values. Wants – simply increase the quality of living, such as: eating out, entertainment, or simply things that are fun. - 79 of 201- Appendix A Personal Finance Pretest Budgeting Name: _________________________ Date: _______ Class Period: ____________________ Grade: ______ Objectives: A: Explain how scarcity affects economic decisions. B: Prioritize personal and financial goals. C: Construct a plan to achieve those goals. D: Examine current saving and spending behaviors and patterns. E: Identify key terms such as gross pay, net pay, deductions and benefits. F: Explain the types of benefits provided by employers. G: Distinguish between required and optional deductions. H: Identify key terms such as disposable income, variable, fixed and period expenses. I: Develop a budget. Define scarcity and explain its effects on economy. Define “goal” and list 2 short-term and 2 long-term personal goals. List 2 short-term and 2 longterm financial goals. Create a plan to achieve one of the goals listed in your answer to the previous question. - 80 of 201- Appendix B Name: ________________________________ Budgeting Directions: Evaluate the student by checking the appropriate number or letter to indicate the degree of competency. The rating for each task should reflect employability readiness rather than the grades given in class. Rating Scale: 0 No Exposure – no experience or knowledge in this area 1 Not Mastered – requires instruction and close supervision 2 Requires Supervision – can perform job completely with limited supervision 3 Mastered – can work independently with no supervision 0 1 2 3 B. Set goals for a budget and financial plan List the steps of the decision-making process Identify short- and long-term financial goals Identify primary and supplemental income sources Identify anticipated expenses Notes: Develop a filing system for personal finance records Identify the roles and costs of insurance in financial planning (e.g., auto, property, life, health) Prepare a personal property inventory Construct a personal spending/savings (budget) plan according to short- and long-term goals Describe how cost of living affects our financial plan Other: Other: - 81 of 201- Appendix C A budgeting plan can help you: Stay out of debt Identify areas for potential savings Provide a cushion for unforeseen expenses Save money for short and long-term goals Avoid impulse spending Establish financial control and direction Seven Steps towards Developing a useful Budget Know what you want to accomplish. You must have an idea about what you want out of life, and you should write down your goals. These goals are the things you should be working toward. It is not enough to just want to save money: you should know what you are saving for. The first step in creating an effective budget is to know what is important to you and to write it down in the form of goals. Identify Income and Expenditures. Gather all paycheck stubs, statements, payment booklets, check registers, credit card statements/bills, and receipts. Divide annual salaries by 12 to identify monthly amounts. Feel free to create your own categories and make “best guess” estimates as to certain amounts. Plan. Create anticipated spending amounts for each category. Use our recommendations in the following list to help you. Housing: 23-33% Life/Car Insurance: 4-6% Food: 12-20% Charities: 5-10% Transportation: 7-10% Personal Debt Repayment: 8-18% Entertainment/Recreation: 4-6% Clothing: 4-7% Savings: 5-10% Medical: 3-5% Monitor Your Spending. The second step of creating an effective budget is generating a statement that accurately reflects your income and expenses for a month or for another specified period of time. Certain methods of payment are easier to track than others. Checks and credit cards, for example, leave an automatic paper trail that is easy to examine at the end of a week or a month. Cash, on the other hand, is more difficult to track because an automatic physical record is not created each time it is used. To accurately track all expenses, - 82 of 201- you must keep a notebook in which you record expenditures paid for in cash, or better yet, to do it electronically. Budgeting software (if available) may also be helpful as you track your expenses. Software such as Intuit Quicken or Microsoft Money can cut down on the time necessary to follow your finances. Such software is especially useful if it is tied to your bank and credit card companies through the Internet. Budgeting software is a great investment that can save you time if it is set up and run properly, but it is not required to become financially self-reliant. Implement your budget. Record all income and expenses in their proper categories: accurate record keeping is a crucial part of good budgeting. Add up all the amounts listed in each category, and make a note of how much you have left over in each category at the end of each week. Be financially prudent—don’t buy things that you don't need or that you haven’t budgeted for. Adjust your plan as necessary to make it work for you. Try to be financially prudent and use each month as a learning experience to help you do better in the next month. Review Your Progress. Compare your actual spending to your spending plan. Note any discrepancies between the two amounts to find areas that need special attention. Examine your spending to reduce or eliminate some expenses. Look for alternative ways to decrease or increase savings, income, and expenditures. Your life is constantly changing and that includes your financial situation. Review your spending plan at least once a month. Make Changes. As you review your spending plan monthly and assess whether it meets your changing needs, adjust expenses and/or income to reach your long-range financial goals. Rework your budget as often as need by: Working with a budgeting sheet Incorporating unforeseen events Comparing planned expenses with actual expenses Designing a budget, keeping personal and financial goals in mind Some tips for maintaining a budget are: Become a good consumer o Learn how to get the most for your money. Exercise will-power and self-control o Try to not indulge in unnecessary spending Develop a good record-keeping system and maintain a workable budget o Evaluate your budget regularly - 83 of 201- Appendix D The Budgeting Process Phase 1: Assess your personal and financial situation (needs, values, life situation) Phase 6: Phase 2: Review financial progress and revise budgeted amounts Set Personal and Financial Goals Phase 3: Phase 5: Compare your budget to what you have actually spent Create a budget for fixed and variable expenses based on projected income Phase 4: Monitor current spending (saving, investing) patterns Phase 1: Assess your personal and financial situation What are your needs vs. wants, what do you value and what is your current situation? Phase 2: Set Personal and Financial Goals You will need to first identify and prioritize some of your personal and financial goals. Ask what are my goals? And why should I set goals? Remember goals help you get what you want; they help you reach your destination. Goals are separated into three goal ranges: Short-term goals (1-4 weeks) Medium-term goals (2-12 months) Long-term goals (1 year or longer) - 84 of 201- What are the goal setting guidelines? Prioritize your goals. Educational Goals Social Goals Financial Goals Family Goals Health/Physical Goals Recreational Goals List your goals What goals are the most important to you? Next to your goals indicate whether they are short-term goals, medium- term goals, long-term goals. What can you do to work toward your goals? Next to your top 6 goals, identify what can you be doing now to work toward this goal. What resources do you need to achieve your goals? Personal (abilities, skills, time, education, etc.) External (money, car, tools, etc.) Next to your top 6 goals, identify what resources you need to achieve each goal. To obtain your goals you need to know how you will be able to financially achieve them. Phase 3: Create A Budget For Fixed And Variable Expenses Based On Projected Income. You will want to create and maintain a personal budget that supports your personal and financial goals. You will first need to identify and estimate any current sources of income. Sources might include: a job, parents, alimony/child Support, investments You can also list any near future sources of income. Knowing your financial situation, answer the following two questions: How does it feel to be financially dependent? How does it feel to be financially independent? If your answers don’t make you feel good, you might want to think about ways you can change your sources of income. You also need to be able to identify and estimate your expenses, which will include: Fixed regular monthly expenses Fixed irregular monthly expenses Flexible monthly expenses - 85 of 201- In addition, identify and estimate your future expenses, which you can begin by keeping a record of everything you spend. You will want to know what financial goals you have for obtaining those plans. Because of life changes you will need to learn to cope with changes, plan for new situations that might occur and plan for changing conditions that may increase or decrease your expenses. Once you know what your income and expenses are you can keep your personal and financial goals in mind and set the money aside to help meet those financial goals. Then you can balance your budget each month by compare your income to your expenses making sure that you income is GREATER than your expenses. You will want to continually look at your budget and rework it if necessary to make sure your budget shows that your income is greater than your expenses. Now that you have a budget you are on your way to achieving your goals, and you can identify the steps you need to take and the resources you will need. Phase 4: Monitor Current Spending (Saving, Investing) Patterns To do this you can identify and examine your current spending behaviors and patterns by keeping track of everything spend in one month and are able to answer the following questions: What did you buy? Can you see a pattern in your spending habits? Of what you spent your money on, what were your NEEDS? And what were your WANTS? How did you decide what to spend and where to spend it? Categorize how money is currently spent (e.g., clothing, food, CDs, car, etc.) Cash Flow\Decision Making – a measure of the money you receive and the money you spend Opportunity Cost – choosing one option by giving up another and both may be good Delayed Gratification – is giving up something you want now in return for something better later What might make a habitual Spender turn into a Saver? What could turn a Saver into a Spender? Phase 5: Compare the Budget You Prepared To What You Have Actually Spent For the Last Month Make sure that you are comparing the budget you have planned for your self to meet your personal and financial goals is the same as what you are spending your money on. Refer to phase 4 and change income, expenses, any patterns of spending, saving and or investing that you need so that your budget and what you spend match. Phase 6: Review Financial Progress and Revise Budgeted Amounts - 86 of 201- If you are not able to live with the budget you prepare, then revise your budget amounts so that it will still allow for you to meet your personal and financial goals, yet allow you to be successful in your current situation. To make a financial plan, you will need to identify a few factors that are associated with financial planning. Theses are: needs, wants, values and goals (covered in Key Terms). Needs – are essentials, the basics such as: food, clothing, a place to sleep. Wants – simply increase the quality of living, such as: eating out, entertainment, or simply things that are fun. However, life can go on with out them. Needs should ALWAYS come before wants. A good financial plan distinguishes between needs and wants. Needs and wants for everyone will vary depending in individual values. Values – are simple beliefs and practices in your life that are important to you. Many factors such as: family, friends, religion, culture, etc. all influence your values. Once you recognize your values, you can identify your needs, wants, goals and what is important to you and how you spend your money. Goals – are clearly, identified destinations of where you want to go, something you want or need, which you acquire by taking certain steps. Goals need to be in writing and based on your values. To do this, define your goals in a “SMART” way. SMART goals are: S - Specific M - Measurable A - Attainable R - Realistic T - Time Bound - 87 of 201- Appendix E What do you think of when you hear the word “budget”? Reasons to budget include: To determine how much money you have to spend To decide how you want to spend your money To determine how to spend money in the future To learn to live on less than available income To stay out of financial trouble What does it take to budget? Choosing a budgeting period Estimating expenses and income Balancing expenses and income What does a budget do for you? Puts you in control Helps you create a visual spending picture Helps you prevent impulses spending Helps you decide what you can and cannot afford Enables you to keep track of how you spend your money Helps you create a savings plan Helps you decide how you can protect yourself against the financial consequences of unforeseen events - 88 of 201- Appendix F Create Your Own Budget Worksheet Here is a sample personal budget for you to complete. Instructions • First, decide what period of time you are budgeting for. • Next, estimate your income (from jobs, allowance, gifts, etc.) for that period of time. Write these items in the “Description” column (A), and the amounts in the “Income” column (B). • After entering any income, add that amount to the total money you have available (D). That is how much money you have available now. • Identify each of your expenses during that time period. • For each expense, ask yourself if it’s fixed, flexible, or discretionary. • After entering each expense (A and C), subtract that amount from the total money you have available. That is how much money you have available now (D). • Decide how much money you will save during this time period. Enter this as an expense (C). • Consider what you will do with any extra money you have available after you have identified all the items you will buy. • Decide what you will need to do if you don’t have enough money available for all the items you want or need buy. - 89 of 201- Appendix G Create Your Own Budget Worksheet Monthly Budget for: ______________________________________________ A Description B Income C D Expenses $Available TOTALS - 90 of 201- Appendix H Create a budget: You get your first job, and you’re ready to move into an apartment and live on your own. How do you know what kind of life you can afford? Will you have enough money to make it in between paychecks? Let’s see. Here’s a chance for you to see for yourself how to figure it out. Set up a budget for yourself. Start by creating a spending diary. Record all of your income and purchases for the next two weeks and use this information as the basis for creating a monthly budget for you to follow. (Be aware that it might take a month or two to refine your budget.) Category INCOME: Budget Amount Actual Amount Difference INCOME SUBTOTAL EXPENSES: EXPENSES SUBTOTAL NET INCOME (Income - Expenses) - 91 of 201- Appendix I Sample Budget Roy Thomas, a full-time tour guide, has an annual salary of $15,000. After he pays his taxes and health insurance, his annual salary is $12,000. This is what Roy's monthly budget looks like: Income (after tax & health insurance) $1000 Savings interest earned $ Total Income $1004 4 Fixed Expenses Housing/Utilities $350 Telephone $ 30 Transportation $200 Credit/Student Loan $100 Savings $ 71 Total Fixed Expenses $751 Variable Expenses Clothing/Personal Care $ 50 Food $110 Household Supplies $ 25 Medicine/Health Supplies $ 18 Entertainment $ 50 $253 Total Variable Expenses Total Expenses $1004 Comparison Total Cash Available $1004 Less Total Expenses $1004 Cash Balance $ 0 Appendix J - 92 of 201- Daily Budget Tracking Worksheet Date Item Income Expense Balance TOTAL - 93 of 201- Appendix K Further Activities Graphs, Lists, Charts, and Surveys Make a list of your wants and needs. Analyze your list. Arrange your need in order of priority. Graph how you spent all of your money last week. (First make a list of the categories and dollar amount for each.) Survey 25 students outside of your class to discover what they spend most of their money on. Make a chart of the results. If you had a job that paid $825 per month and you were living alone, make a monthly budget chart to show how you would spend your money. If you earned $15 per week as a student, make a weekly budget chart to show the items and amount of money spent on each. Discuss the subject of budgeting with students and why it is useful. Many college students discover too late that they need to learn how to budget their money. Therefore, learning about budgeting and how to create a budget will be helpful in establishing good money spending habits. The reason why people create a budget is to better plan on how to utilize limited financial resources. A college budget needs to be focused on the income sources and expenses that are more common for the college student. Use the budget worksheets page included to create a budget. A budget is broken down into two main sections, income and expenses. Income includes wages, money from parents, student loads, scholarships, grants, etc. Expenses include rent, room, and board, utilities, groceries, shopping, entertainment, car and transportation, tuition, books, supplies, and other expenses. For this worksheet, a monthly budget is used. However, monthly, yearly, or a budget for the school semester may be used in practice. Compare sources of income to expenses. Is this person above or below budget? Discussion questions: Why is it helpful to have a budget? What can someone do if their expenses are greater than their sources of income? What can they do with the extra money if they have more income than expenses? - 94 of 201- Appendix L Financial Plan Assignment Describe a time when you wanted to buy something but you didn’t have enough money to pay for it. Explain ways you could save money for something you wanted to buy. What are some examples of things you or you family need to buy versus things you’d like to have? What are some reasons you might want a written plan for how you are going to spend your money? Once you’ve learned how to select the appropriate career, how to determine the amount of money you will be making and how to read your first paycheck, you will need to start making the most of your hard earned money. You will want to do this so that you can make your money meet your goals, whether it be to go to school, get a new car, or house, or become a millionaire someday. To do this you will need to do some financial planning for the future and budgeting for the present and near future. Your assignment is to think through the things you want to accomplish in life. This is not a short term assignment, and it is likely the most important part of your entire financial plan. The purpose of this assignment is to have you write down your goals for your future and determine where you want to be in the next day, week, month, year, or lifetime. Be very specific with the goals that you set. And while some goals will change over time, many of the goals which define your future actions need be made only once. As you think through your goals, recognize that there are many different ways to organize them. You can organize them by time frame: short-term, less than one year; medium term, more than one year and less than ten years; and long-term, more than ten years. You can organize them by responsibility: family, work, education, church, etc. And you can organize them by priorities, with your highest priority goals first. Once you have your goals you have to start planning for them in order to make them a reality. - 95 of 201- Appendix M Do I REALLY need that? NEEDS WANTS 3 bedrooms (many children) Fireplace Yard Quiet street Close to subway or bus Walk to schools, stores, library Parking Big fenced-in yard No lead paint Many windows Part I: Not everyone will have the same needs and wants. Create your own needs/wants list to consider when buying a home. This activity will help to establish priorities when doing a home search. Needs: Wants: Part II: Use your needs/wants list to write a paragraph about what you need and what you want in a house and why. - 96 of 201- Appendix N Activity 1: Life Expectancy Use the life expectancy calculator at http://www.livingto100.com/quiz.htm to determine the expected length of your own life. All life expectancy tables are built on averages. In fact, of course, some individuals will live longer and others less than the average person. What is your life expectancy? Your parents? Your grandparents? What factors might increase or decrease life expectancy? How long can you expect to be retired if you retire at 55? 65? 70? Do you think life expectancy will increase or decrease in the future? Along the horizontal axis of your timeline, enter your birth date and estimated expiration date. Activity 2: Work Life Expectancy Why is the work life expectancy almost eleven years less than the social security retirement age? [The work life expectancy takes into account many things which are not included in the social security age. First, a person may leave the work force because of sickness or death. Women leave the work force to raise children.] The full social security retirement age is 67. This is 11 years more than the work life expectancy of 56 years. The work life expectancy shows the number of years one expects to be in the workforce earning wages and benefit. The work life expectancy is therefore a better tool for calculating how much your retirement benefits will be and how many years you have to save for retirement. Add your work life expectancy to your timeline: the starting date for your work life and retirement date. Estimate your annual income over the same period of years and plot. You can also calculate your parents' work life and social security retirement dates and add them to your timeline. Activity 3: Filling out the Time Line Fit other important dates on your timeline. These might include: [These events can vary.] Graduation from high school and college Year married First car First child and when the child will go to college and get married First house and when you expect to stop making payments on your home (~30 years.) - 97 of 201- - 98 of 201- Appendix O Have students complete the following “Budget Busters” activity. 1. Give yourself five points if you have a budget. 2. Give yourself five points if you have a checkbook. 3. Deduct a point if you have ever bounced a check. 4. Deduct a point if you bought something this week without comparison shopping. 5. Give yourself a pint if you bought a store brand, rather than a name brand item this week. 6. Give yourself five points if you have a savings account. 7. Give yourself five points if you added any money to your savings account this week. 8. Give yourself five points if you pay your own car insurance (or part of it) 9. Deduct five points if you routinely carry more than $10.00 in your purse or wallet. 10. Give yourself five points if you have a method of recording what you spend. The students total their points. The winner is the person with the most points. Discuss this activity as a class. - 99 of 201- Appendix P “Some Money Facts” $ The average person spends money three times a day. $ A movie with popcorn and a soft drink can easily cost $20 $ Just one soft drink a day for .99c adds up to $361.35 in a year $ What’s the biggest expense item for teenagers? FOOD! To help students understand why preparing a budget is important, discuss the following example: How would you like to drive on a road with no rules or guidelines? Perhaps not even having a map to show you where you are going? When you operate without a personal budget, you are doing the same thing with your money. You are spending your money without a guideline or plan. Activity 1: Collage (you can also give this to students as homework the day before) Make a collage using clippings from newspapers and magazines which reflect our values about money. Discuss the following: How are values (the money you spend, the car you drive, the activities you enjoy, the clothes you wear, the friends you choose) expressed in your home? What is the predominant theme in the clippings you chose: health, friends, family, Material comforts, beauty, church, education, etc.? Why are these values and goals important to you? Activity 2: Have all students stand up. If they can not go with out spending money on the following they need to sit down. “For the rest of your life you cannot spend money on…. “ (Sit down if they cannot go with out spending money) Opening day for movies, Manicure/pedicure, Golfing/club memberships, Hairstyles that have expensive treatments (color, perms, etc.), Cell phones, Going out to dinner 2x a week, Vacations in high seasons, Name brand clothes 87% of retires are retiring with $10,000 or less Wealth is not what you spend but your net worth or accumulative wealth, what you have. 80% of millionaires have accumulated slow and steady What is the portrait of a millionaire? Live in same city/town for over 20 years Live below their means Married 1 time and still married Usually owns a chain of stores or similar At age 20 if you save $200.00 a month at 10% interest you will be a millionaire by the age of 55. What is your financial plan? Ways to improve your finances - 100 of 201- Make more money Cut your expenses “Wait and win the lottery” system You need to be proactive to improve your financial system. Part of having a financial plan is having a budget. Discussion: What is a Budget? Why do you have a budget? Have students share their answers in pairs. After students have shared their answer in pairs have the class discuss their definitions. A budget shows you where your money goes. Budgets serve as a record and can be a great help to you when computing taxes. Budgeting strengthens family communications. Budgeting increases sharing, both in setting a plan and evaluating spending patterns; it is beneficial, for financial matters can be a real source of conflict and even cause divorce in some marriages. Define budgeting terms as students take notes: Discuss with students what is included in a budget for a family in a given month? Brainstorm a list and record it on the board (2 volunteers write on board). How does the typical family spend their money? Remember living expenses vary depending on where you live, age, and personal goals. But the typical family spends their income the following way: Housing 14% Recreation Food 22% Medical/Dental Clothing 10% Transportation Personal 2% Utilities, Home Repairs Other 9% and Improvements 7% 8% 14% 14% Family Budget Activity: For the next four days students will create a monthly budget project for a family using the monthly income of $2,000 per month (1 day=1 week, so groups get installments of $500 each day (week), which they have to deposit in order to use.) If they choose to be single they get $800 per month ($200 a week). Try to not give them that option unless they are absent from class or other reasons. The teacher will assign students into groups of four. Students will decide on their family name that will appear on their paycheck. - 101 of 201- On the fifth day students will have time to develop their journal/folder (in any format they choose). This should include what their budget looked like, why they chose what they did, how they adjusted for unforeseen expenses, any other problems they ran into, things they did particularly well, and things they could have done better. Using the percent amount next to the each category students will multiply it by their monthly income to figure out the amount they can spend on a certain category. Once students have figured out their monthly budget complete the following steps each day. Students will write a check out for their Utility bills and all other bills. Explain to students that a bill will be paid by them each day. Students create budget for expenses on brainstorming list (must find actual products and prices from newspapers, store flyers, the Internet, old bills (mock), etc.). Describe what is expected in journal entries. Students look in newspapers, etc. to find a place to live, food, etc. These prices are to be entered into the budget. Working copy of budget should be completed and students should reflect on how their group came up with such a budget. They should discuss any problems, concerns, benefits, etc. in their journals. - 102 of 201- Resources Budgeting Lesson ideas. http://www.uen.org/Lessonplan/preview.cgi?LPid=4606 General Financial Literacy. http://www.uen.org/core/core.do?courseNum=520802#14172 Life Expectancy Timeline. http://www.econedlink.org/lessons/index.cfm?lesson=EM128&page=teacher Seven steps to creating a budget. http://www.bankrate.com/brm/news/financial_literacy/Jan07_budgeting_howto_a1.asp?prodtype =pfin National Council for Economic Education (NCEE) Virtual Economics CD Rom – www.ncee.org - 103 of 201- This page intentionally left blank for notes. - 104 of 201- Module 6: Savings and Investing (Core) Suggested Time: 10 – 15 hours Level: Introductory Pre-requisite: None. Module Overview This module introduces the students to the basic principles of investing, so that they will have a general understanding and knowledge on the topic. Students will learn key investment concepts, and explore the basic investment vehicles and the advantages and disadvantages of each. This module will help students to understand short-term vs. long-term investing, risk vs. reward, and simple vs. compound interest. Foundational Objectives To implement basic concepts of investing. To inform students on the importance of investing. To help students realize and understand the various types of investment vehicles available to them. To demonstrate how interest works and how individuals can use interest to their advantage. To demonstrate how time can impact your investment. Common Essential Learning’s Foundational Objectives To enable students to make smart sensible decisions about investing and what kinds of investment vehicles meet their financial goals. (IL) To use mathematical skills for calculating simple interest and compound interest. (NUM) To develop an understanding of how technology has allowed many changes and conveniences for monitoring and tracking our investing and savings. (TL) To promote decision making abilities in trying to match our investing goals with the appropriate investment vehicles by contemplating our risk tolerance and length of time to accomplish these goals. (CCT) To enable students to communicate effectively with each other on group work activities involving sharing expertise on their chosen investment vehicles. (COM) Learning Objectives Notes Students should have a general knowledge on what investing means. Ask students for their understanding and opinions of investing. Get students to brainstorm a list of words that they think would fall under the category of investing (this can be done in groups or as an entire class). - 105 of 201- 6.1 To develop an understanding of what investing is and why it’s important to us. Let students know that there are many different ways in which they can invest their money. Find out how many different types of investment vehicles they know and what they know about each one (again, this can be done by brainstorming as group work or as an entire class). Finally, students need to know why investing is important. Discuss reasons why people may want to invest their money. Include things such as tax breaks, increase value of personal wealth, and saving for retirement. See if students can come up with other reasons why investing is important. 6.2 To identify the basics of investing and what individuals need to know before he/she gets started. Students will learn the proper steps to getting started in investing. They should learn how to: Develop a personal investment strategy -knowledge of financial markets -your financial assets -your risk tolerance level -how much you plan to invest Establish investment objectives -what do you need from your investment portfolio, and when you need it Understand tolerance for risk. This includes factors such as: -time horizons (time you have to meet your financial goals) -cash requirements (extent to which you depend on investments to meet day-to-day expenses) -emotional factors (emotional responses to risk and to changes in the value of your investments) Understand the importance of diversification -don’t put all your eggs in one basket Choose the right asset mix. There are three basic categories of investment products or assets: -equity investments -debt investments -cash or cash equivalents Recognize the limits of their investment knowledge -before investing, assess your own investment knowledge and experience -avoid investment products you don’t fully understand Do their investment homework -spend time doing your own investment research Understand basic investment characteristics including: - 106 of 201- -expected return -investment risk -marketability Ask the students the question “Why save?” Get students to give purpose or reasons for saving money. Some answers might include: -in case of emergencies -to take advantage of unforeseen opportunities -to help reach financial goals Explain to students what short-term savings is. Saving for the short term is generally from one month up to a year and usually deals with smaller amounts of money. Saving for short-term goals is generally done with a savings account. Ask students to give examples of things they might save for in the short term. Students may brainstorm as individuals or as a group. Now ask the students how they might go about saving the required funds necessary. 6.3 To distinguish between shortterm and long-term savings. Now explain to students what long-term savings is. Saving for the long term is generally a time period of over a year and deals with larger money values. Saving for long-term goals may involve different types of investing. Ask the students to give examples of things they might save for in the long term. Once again, students should brainstorm ideas. Get students to think up ways in which they might save for the funds necessary. The teacher should introduce the concept of “pay yourself first” as a means of saving for both the short and long term. Explain that this idea requires the individual to practice three qualities: -commitment -discipline -delayed gratification 6.4 To define and distinguish between compound interest vs. simple interest. Students will learn the general concept of simple interest and how to calculate it. Inform students of the definition and the components used to calculate simple interest: I = Prt Where, I = interest - 107 of 201- P = principal r = interest rate (per year) t = time (in years or fraction of a year) Examples of simple interest can be found using the following link: http://www.moneyinstructor.com/art/simpleinterest.asp The teacher can demonstrate a couple examples and then have students practice work sheets on their own. Once students have a good grasp of simple interest, the concept of compound interest will be introduced. Compound interest is calculated using the following formula: S = P(1+i)^n Where, S = amount P = principal i = interest rate per conversion period n = total number of conversion periods Examples of compound interest can be found using the following link: http://www.moneyinstructor.com/art/compoundinterest.asp The teacher should demonstrate several examples, as this concept and calculation is more difficult. Students should practice compound interest by completing questions on their own. Introduce the idea of savings accounts to students as a means for short term saving. Have students talk to friends, relatives, and parents about the various methods they use for saving depending on the financial goals. 6.5 To analyze the basics of savings, as well as compare advantages and disadvantages of saving as opposed to investing. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of savings accounts: Advantages -simple way to earn interest -money is easily accessible -no risk involved -can have smaller amounts of money Disadvantages -low rate of interest -fees, charges, and penalties -may include a balance requirement - 108 of 201- Teacher and students may add to these lists of advantages and disadvantages. Inform students that there are a number of different savings accounts that vary between financial institutions. Have the class research different financial institutions and compare and contrast the features and rates from different savings accounts. Students will then present their findings to the rest of the class. Teacher should emphasize the importance of starting to invest at an early age. Explain how years of compound interest can add up exponentially. Show investment chart included in Appendix A. 6.6 To explore the importance of investing at an early age and introduce the basic categories of investing. Introduce the three main categories of investing which include: Cash and cash equivalents (like savings accounts, treasury bills and money market mutual funds). This category is virtually risk-free but produces the lowest returns. Fixed-income investments (like GICs or Government Income Certificates, bonds, and income mutual funds). This category offers higher returns and provides a regular source of investment income. Equity investments (like stocks and equity mutual funds). This category contains high-risk assets which can grow in value if the holder can wait it out, but can also result in greater losses as well. Have students research various investments in each category and compare what characteristics they have and what kinds of returns they yield. Show students how we, as Canadians, tend to invest. Refer to Appendix B. 6.7 To identify the various kinds of investments vehicles and their characteristics. Teacher should introduce the 2 basic types of investments that investment vehicles fall under. These categories are called: Lending investment – when you loan your money to an institution, a company, or an individual and in return you receive interest payments, as well as the principal at the end of the loan period. Examples include Canada Savings Bonds, GICs, and Corporate Bonds. Ownership Investment – means that you become the actual owner or part-owner of your investment. Examples include stocks and real estate. - 109 of 201- The teacher can introduce the various kinds of basic investment vehicles available, as well as their characteristics. A list of investment vehicles is provided in Appendix C. A good instructional strategy to use would be jig saw, where students are divided up into groups with each member of the group given an investment vehicle to research and study. The groups are then divided up into groups of students who are all researching the same topic. After the students have mastered their topic, they will reconvene back into their original groups to teach the other members about their findings. Teacher should discuss retirement plans and their importance. In Canada there are three types of retirement plans: Employer-sponsored retirement plans Government pensions Your own savings and investments The teacher should create discussion amongst the class on topics of retirement such as: -how much money will you need per year to live off of once you retire. -at what age do you plan on retiring. -what will you need to put away each year to achieve your goal. 6.8 To introduce and analyze the importance of Retirement Plans and how they work. Give the characteristics of how retirement plans work: Federal income tax is not immediately due on money put into a retirement account or on the interest it makes. Income tax is paid when the interest is withdrawn. Penalty charges apply if money is withdrawn before retirement age. Income after retirement is usually lower, so tax rate is lower as well. The teacher may want to introduce the students to a retirement calculator on the internet and let them play around with it. The teacher can also give scenarios or questions for the students to figure out on the retirement calculator. This will help them get more familiar with retirement planning. A retirement calculator can be found at the following web site: http://moneycentral.msn.com/retire/planner.aspx - 110 of 201- The teacher should inform students about what investment fraud is and give examples. Some examples are provided in Appendix D. The teacher can get students to research more kinds of investment fraud on the internet. 6.9 To investigate and inform students on investment fraud. Discuss with students how someone could protect themselves from becoming a victim of investment fraud. Some actions to take include the following: Ask questions until your satisfied that you know exactly what the investment offer is. Get a second opinion about the investment from a trusted advisor. Never buy over the phone or online without first investigating the source of the offer. Avoid investment opportunities promising large returns in a short amount of time that seems too good to be true. They probably are. - 111 of 201- Appendix A Suzanne and Jack both save $1,000 per year ($83.33 per month or $19.23 per week). The money each saves earns 10% interest per year. Suzanne starts at age 22 and stops at age 30. Jack starts at age 30 and stops at age 65. On the face of it, you might think Jack will look better in the long run, having saved for a full 35 years (as compared to Suzanne's eight-year effort). But the reality of long-term savings isn't always what it appears. The chart below demonstrates the value of starting to save your money early. In this example, Suzanne only invested a total of $8,000. But by age 65, she will enjoy net earnings of $380,865. Jack, on the other hand, will have put away a full $35,000 by his 65th birthday. But his net earnings will be $294,039 -- $86,826 less than Suzanne's. Jack never caught up. Age 22 Suzanne Savings Jack Invests Savings Invests 1,000 1,100 0 0 23 1,000 2,310 0 0 24 1,000 3,641 0 0 25 1,000 5,105 0 0 26 1,000 6,716 0 0 27 1,000 8,487 0 0 28 1,000 10,436 0 0 29 1,000 12,579 0 0 30 0 13,837 1,000 1,100 31 0 15,221 1,000 2,310 32 0 16,743 1,000 3,641 33 0 18,418 1,000 5,105 34 0 20,259 1,000 6,716 35 0 22,285 1,000 8,487 36 0 24,514 1,000 10,436 37 0 26,965 1,000 12,579 38 0 29,662 1,000 14,937 39 0 32,628 1,000 17,531 40 0 35,891 1,000 20,384 41 0 39,480 1,000 23,523 42 0 43,428 1,000 26,975 43 0 47,771 1,000 30,772 - 112 of 201- 44 0 52,548 1,000 34,950 45 0 57,802 1,000 39,545 46 0 63,583 1,000 44,599 47 0 69,941 1,000 50,159 48 0 76,935 1,000 56,275 49 0 84,628 1,000 63,002 50 0 93,091 1,000 70,403 51 0 102,400 1,000 78,543 52 0 112,640 1,000 87,497 53 0 123,904 1,000 97,347 54 0 136,295 1,000 108,182 55 0 149,924 1,000 120,100 56 0 164,917 1,000 133,210 57 0 181,409 1,000 147,631 58 0 199,549 1,000 163,494 59 0 219,504 1,000 180,943 60 0 241,455 1,000 200,138 61 0 265,600 1,000 221,252 62 0 292,160 1,000 244,477 63 0 321,376 1,000 270,024 64 0 353,514 1,000 298,127 65 0 388,865 1,000 329,039 Value at age $388,865 65 Value at age $329,039 65 Less Total Less Total $(8,000) $(35,000) Contributions Contributions Net Earnings $380,865 Net Earnings $294,039 - 113 of 201- Appendix B How we invest (according to the Canadian Banker's Association) 40% of Canadians have mutual funds 20% have Canada Savings Bonds 18% have individual stocks 17% have GICs (terms of more than one year) 15% have GICs (one year or less) 11% have provincial savings bonds 8% have other bonds issued by government or corporations 7% have off-shore investments 6% have T-Bills 4% have index-linked GICs. - 114 of 201- Appendix C Options: Lending Investments (Cash/Cash Equivalent and Income) Savings Account An account held with a financial institution Safe vehicle for short-term savings of any amount High liquidity (easy to cash) Canada Savings Bond (CSB) A special type of bond issued by the federal government, purchased through financial institutions Available only at specific times Pay a fixed interest rate, subject to periodic adjustment by the government Safe, guaranteed by the government and highly liquid (although the new Canada Premium Bond is only cashable once a year on its anniversary date) Unlike other bonds, cannot be traded Available in various amounts and for as little as $100 Government Treasury Bill (T-Bill) Short-term investment: terms of one month to a year (considered a cash-equivalent) Safe, government-backed Don't pay a specified interest rate, rather T-Bills have a face value; you purchase them at a "discount" (less than the face value) and then redeem it at face value; the difference is your return Available in different amounts starting at $1,000 Can be purchased from most financial institutions Term Deposit / Guaranteed Investment Certificate (GIC) Term investments offered by financial institutions for a set period Terms range from less than a month to 10 years. New "market-linked" GICs guarantee principal, but returns are linked to some stock market index Terms range from less than a month to 10 years Available in various amounts Bankers' Acceptance (BA) Short-term debt issued by corporations that is guaranteed by a bank Highly liquid (terms to maturity of less than a year) Considered safe, low-risk Purchased at a discount on the "face value", the amount you will receive when the debt matures Offer a fixed return, based on the difference between the discounted purchase price and the face value Largely used by high net worth individuals, as they are typically available in amounts of $100,000 and up - 115 of 201- Commercial Paper Similar to BAs, but without the guarantee of a bank Available through financial institutions Government Bond Issued by the federal and provincial governments and available through most financial institutions Set at fixed interest rate, for a specified term Safe (guaranteed to maturity by the issuing government) and liquid Come in terms of one to 30 years Can be sold in the bond market before maturity Corporate Bond Issued by a corporation and available through a brokerage house Set at fixed interest rate, for a specified term Backed by specific assets of the issuing company Come in terms of one to 30 years and in various types Can be sold in the bond market before maturity Debenture Type of corporate bond, but not secured by specific company assets. Simply based on the general reputation of the issuing company. Mortgage-Backed Securities Fixed-rate investments that represent an ownership share in a pool of mortgages insured by the federal government's Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation Minimum investment of $5,000; terms range from one to 10 years Receive a monthly payment that is a blend of principal and interest accruing from the pool of mortgages Options: Equity Investments Stocks Stocks are issued by corporations where the investor becomes a partial owner of the corporation by buying shares (also called stocks) of the company. There are two main categories of stocks: "common" and "preferred." These are described in more detail below. Stocks are traded on stock exchanges, or over-the-counter markets. Share prices and returns on stocks fluctuate with the market, and there is no guarantee of income. Common Shares / Stock With common shares, investors typically have voting rights Common shares are usually purchased for potential capital appreciation If the company makes money, investors share in the profits; if the company suffers a poor year or the markets decline, their share values may fall and dividends are unlikely - 116 of 201- Blue Chip Stocks are typically stocks of large, stable and actively traded companies with a record of regular dividend payments Penny Stocks are low-cost common shares (typically under $1), usually purchased for speculative purposes and issued by start-up or unproven corporations seeking capital for expansion Small-, Mid- and Large-Cap Stocks are the results of corporations of all sizes issuing common shares to raise money; generally, the smaller the corporation, the higher the risk Preferred Shares / Stock Are regarded as bond-like investments Normally purchased by investors who want a steady stream of dividends, rather than capital appreciation Pay a dividend that is higher-yielding than common shares Value and share price influenced more by interest-rate trends than by company's earnings Don't typically give voting rights They are preferred because you get a preferential claim to the assets/profits ahead of common shareholders Precious Metals Gold, silver and other precious metals Held in form of bullion (the actual metal) or certificates of ownership Commodities Bulk goods such as grains, metals, oil and foods Traded on commodities exchanges. Derivatives A security whose value depends on the market value of something else, such as a stock or commodity They are complex investments used by sophisticated investors for speculative purposes or to help manage risk (as a hedge against changing market conditions) "Options" and "futures" are examples of derivatives; an option gives the investor the right to buy or sell a specific security at a given price before a specified date; a futures contract obligates the investor to buy or sell a specified amount of an asset at a set price on a certain date Options: Mutual Funds Today, 40% of Canadians hold some $290 billion in more than 1,300 different mutual funds. A mutual fund is an investment product -- made up of several investors' contributions -- that a professional fund manager invests in a variety of securities. This pool of wealth might be invested in a specific market or geographic sector, in blue-chip companies or in small company stocks. There are also "green" funds that only invest in environmentally friendly companies. The manager monitors the investments on an on-going basis. - 117 of 201- Because mutual funds are overseen by a manager, investing in them frees up individual investors from having to continually research and manage their own investments. Mutual funds are also appealing because they: Offer access to a wide range of investments Are widely available (most financial institutions have a broad assortment on offer) Are easy to buy (you can buy mutual funds through regular account withdrawals at most financial institutions) Give you the opportunity to have "instant diversification" Fees All mutual funds charge the Management Expense Ratio (MER), which is the annual cost of managing and operating the fund. But there are other fees, too. It's important to inquire about them. They include: Acquisition or disposal fees ("no load" mutual funds are those that don't charge this fee) Initial fee (this "front-end load" is charged when you buy a mutual fund) Selling fee (this "back-end load" is charged when you sell a mutual fund) Options: Real Estate Some people put their money to work in other areas of investments. Perhaps the most common is real estate. With this type of investing, owners may be able to earn rental income and -- assuming real-estate prices continue to rise -- see their capital investment appreciate over time. Ways to invest Buy a house, live in it, possibly spend some time and money improving it, and sell it later at a profit Buy income property (such as an apartment block or a commercial building) and rent it out Buy land and hold it until it rises in value Advantages Excellent protection against inflation Disadvantages Can be difficult to convert into cash It's a specialized type of investment that requires study and knowledge of the market Capital gains If you're venturing into real-estate investing, you need to brush up on the concept of capital gains. Capital gains are profits realized from the sale of a capital asset such as a share, bond or real estate (if the real estate is not your principal residence). If a share is bought at $26 and sold at $30, there's a capital gain of $4. These profits are tax-deferred, which means you don't have to - 118 of 201- pay the tax on them until the asset is sold. In 2000, the Government of Canada reduced the capital-gains inclusion rate from three-quarters to one-half. The inclusion rate is the portion of a capital gain that is subject to income tax. As a result, Canada's typical top tax rate on capital gains is now about two percentage points lower than in the United States. If you buy property for the sole purpose of renting it out (rental property), you will be required to pay capital gains tax if there is a capital gain on the property. For instance, if you bought property for $200,000, and at the time of sale, it is worth $250,000, you will be taxed on the $50,000 gain on the property. If however, you are selling your principal residence, and make a profit on the sale, you will not be subject to capital gains tax. - 119 of 201- Appendix D Some of the most common investment fraud schemes include: West African Letter Scam Individuals claiming to be high-ranking government officials or royal-family members from developing nations send an e-mail requesting help removing large quantities of money from an account. They ask people to show good faith by depositing funds in a mutually accessible bank account or to provide a bank account number, in which they will deposit the money. The individuals then drain the bank accounts and head for the hills. Prime Bank Schemes Scam artists lead investors to believe that they can participate in a secret trading regime through the world's most prestigious banks. Affinity Fraud With this deception, scam artists hoodwink a group of individuals by joining a common-interest or ethnic club and pretending to be "one of them." Promissory Notes These short-term loans, often sold as insurance products, promise high returns for the benefit of borrowing your money. The companies offering the "investments" are often non-existent. Pyramid Schemes A Pyramid Scheme is a multi-level marketing (MLM) program that cannot support itself because advancing within the system (and earning money) depends on recruiting other people into it, rather than selling a product or service. Offshore Investment Scams Here, Canadians fall for the oft-heard promise that their Canadian dollars can flourish in an offshore (usually warm-weather) tax haven. Swindlers convince people to give them money with extravagant claims that they have no intention of fulfilling. - 120 of 201- References http://moneycentral.msn.com/retire/planner.aspx http://www.practicalmoneyskills.ca/moneyskills/students/budgeting.cfm http://www.moneyinstructor.com/invest.asp http://www.younginvestor.com/teachers/grades1012/articleDifferentInvestmentsGoals.as p http://www.frbatlanta.org/invoke.cfm?objectid=83FD49BB-9AF0-11D5898400508BB89A83&method=display http://arkedu.state.ar.us/curriculum/pdf/peronal_finance.pdf http://missouricareereducation.org/CDs/PersonalFinance/persfin.pdf - 121 of 201- This page intentionally left blank for notes. - 122 of 201- Module 7: Credit and Credit Cards(Core) Created by: Andrea Robertson and Lindsay Seidler Suggested Time: 15 – 20 hours Level: Introductory Prerequisite: Module 2: Decision Making and Money Basics, and Module 5: Budgeting Module Overview: This module provides students with a clear understanding of credit. It explores credit planning, reasons for an increasing popularity in credit, as well as why people lend or do not lend money. The importance of credit-worthiness is also examined along with ways to keep a good credit rating. The primary focus of this module is to prepare students to be successful decision-makers about credit in their future. This module will also build upon Module 5 by exploring further the nature of credit cards, their proper use, and the responsibility required in being credit card holder. Foundational Objectives: To develop an awareness of reasons why people use or don’t use credit. To become familiar with questions that should be asked when planning a credit purchase. To increase knowledge of the various types of credit available today. To incorporate the 20/10 rule when calculating what you can afford. To distinguish the different types of values that people hold about credit through the use of interviews. To demonstrate an understanding of credit cards and the advantages and disadvantages of having a credit card. To demonstrate an understanding of the components of a credit card and the financial responsibilities undertaken when possessing one. To seek information through a steadily expanding network of options including libraries, databases, individuals, and agencies To display an awareness of credit card theft and fraud and ways to protect one’s credit card. To promote both intuitive, imaginative thought and the ability to evaluate ideas, processes, experiences, and objects in meaningful contexts. To enable students to think for themselves and to recognize the limits of individual reflection and the need to contribute to and build upon mutual understandings. Common Essential Learning’s Foundational Objectives: To enable students to use language (listening, speaking, reading, writing) relevant to the students and credit during presentations. (COM) To seek information from a number of options including family, friends, and people within the community. (IL) - 123 of 201- To develop the skills and appropriate mathematics associated with the 20/10 rule. (NUM) To promote both intuitive thought and the ability to evaluate scenarios when answering credit planning questions. (CCT) To understand the benefit that credit knowledge will serve in their personal lives. (PSVS) To recognize the capabilities of the Internet when collecting information and conducting research, and how they can best be utilized. (TL) To enable students to understand and use the vocabulary structures and forms of expression that characterize credit cards. (COM) To enable students to think for themselves and recognize the responsibilities attached to being a credit card holder, and the need to thoroughly examine and analyze a wide range of credit cards before deciding to apply for one. (CCT) To employ the appropriate mathematics in determining the cost to the consumer of credit cards. (NUM) Learning Objective Notes Credit is a promise to pay money in the future in exchange for the right to receive goods &/or services or even money (cash) right now. Credit is also known as an asset- one that has been loaned out in hopes that one will pay it back. Teachers may want to brainstorm with the class what would be some reasons why people use credit. Brainstorming will vary. 7.1 To introduce the concept of credit. To explore reasons why people use credit, and why people wouldn’t use credit. To help the class come up with reasons to use credit, the teacher could bring in some travel magazines, store catalogues or sale flyers. Some possible answers may include: *Pay for ‘big’ purchases Example: Boxing day sale on TV for one day only and you don’t have enough money in your account. *Emergencies Example: Your fridge breaks down and is full of groceries that will go bad if you don’t replace it. Or your roof is leaking during a rainy season. - 124 of 201- * Family Vacations Example: Someone in your family is getting married in the Bahamas and since it’s short notice you don’t have enough saved up. Now the class will discuss reasons why people wouldn’t want to use credit. Some examples the teacher may want to give are: -Debt and financial trouble -People start to rely on them too much -Impulsive spending -Stress and worry about paying it back -Having to pay it back along with your present day expenses is a real burden. -the cost of interest - ‘Credit dealers’, ‘shady pawnshops’, or ‘loan sharks’ that do not follow government regulations could charge up to 300% interest! The teacher can bring in magazines and newspaper for students to make a collage of 5 items they think would be a good reason to use credit, and 5 items that wouldn’t be necessary to use credit for. If there is no access to those items teachers can get students to just draw or list their items. Students should have an explanation for each item on their collage/list. Students should have an idea of what credit is, and why people may use or not use credit. The class should be divided into small groups or pairs (depending on the class). First as a class, the teacher will go over questions that must be asked when planning a credit purchase. They are: 7.2 To develop an understanding of questions that must be asked when planning a credit purchase. What goals do you hope to accomplish in making your decision? What are the alternatives? If any? What are the benefits of purchasing your item using credit? What are the costs associated purchasing your item using credit? And finally the students will make a decision based on their responses to the questions The teacher will give students scenarios. They will answer the credit planning questions before coming to a decision. *See Appendix A for a worksheet with scenarios and a table with the questions for students to answer. Worksheet Modified from Economic Education Web. Found at http://ecedweb.unomaha.edu/k-12/home.cfm - 125 of 201- 7.3 To explore what has contributed to the increasing popularity of credit. Teacher could propose a question like “What has increased the popularity of credit?” Students could break off into small groups and try to come up with as many reasons as possible for the first ten minutes of class. Then, an overhead could be put up with the various things that have contributed to credit becoming so popular. Task: During the week, students could interview an older relative, or neighbour as well as someone younger that has used credit in the past or is currently using it. They will try to get at least 3 different answers from each person as to why that person thinks credit has become so popular over the years. The students could present their findings and the class could have a discussion on what makes the older generation feel differently from the younger one, if there is any difference at all. The interview activity will help the class explore reasons from outside sources that hopefully weren’t discovered in class. However if answers are the same it will show support for the overhead presented earlier. There are no specific right or wrong answers on this. *See Appendix B for a sample overhead. Teachers should introduce some motives for lending such as: • Family/ Friends- in that they want to be helpful if you are in need • Financial Institutions like banks- Interest (money) can be earned 7.4 To be aware of the motives behind people lending or not lending money through acting. Teacher should also introduce some motives people have for not lending such as: • May ruin relationships with family and friends if the credit use is abused • Have no job/ salary in order to pay back debts • People no longer have trust in you • Total debt to service ratio (20/10 Rule) Students could be paired up and they will have to role-play a reason why someone would lend money or not lending money, it’s their choice. They can either use one that the teacher has introduced or one that they come up with on their own. Their role-play should be no longer than 2 minutes. Some sample scenarios are found at Appendix C. - 126 of 201- The scenario that they choose to act out can have sound, visuals, and props but cannot give away any specific names of people, places, or things. (Example: If you are acting out that you are buying a prom dress, you don’t actually say the word prom dress) The first pair to guess what is being acted out will receive a point. Someone will be designated to keep track of all pairs’ scores. This activity could go on for an entire class, or as long as the teacher feels necessary. This gets the class thinking of scenarios and motives that can surround lending. Teacher should explain the 3 principal types of consumer credit. They are: *Single-Payment credit *Instalment credit *Revolving credit. 7.5 To list and understand the three principal types of consumer credit. It is suggested to use Appendix D as a handout for students. Students could be asked to write a mini quiz the following day to show their understanding. *NOTE* This particular objective would not be necessary in order to do the entire module successfully. However it helps to supplement the next learning objective. The teacher may want to consider having a loan or credit expert from a local financial institution do a presentation on the various types of credit that are out there today. 7.6 To discover the various types of credit that are available. In addition to that, students could do a matching exercise before the guest speaker comes to see how much they already know about the various types of credit. See Appendix E for a sample matching exercise. After the presentations, teachers could randomly assign students a specific type of credit in which they will become experts on. - 127 of 201- They could use a computer lab and the Internet in order to find information on their credit type. Each student could create a PowerPoint presentation, based on his or her findings. Students could be involved in evaluating their peers for the presentations. Some students may end up doing the same credit source. The 3 C's of credit comprise your entire financial life. It is important for students to learn about the 3 C’s of credit because in order for them to be considered to receive credit, their Character, Capacity, and Capital (Collateral) will be looked at. And, being prepared and knowing what they will look at will improve your chances to get the credit you are hoping for. The lender views each of the 3 C’s of credit independently as well as collectively. And, depending on whom you are going through to get the money, all places have guidelines for analyzing the 3 C’s. 7.7 To identify the 3 C’s of credit. To analyze whether someone is credit worthy and the importance of having good credit. An overhead that the teacher may want to use is found at Appendix F. Teachers may also want the class to then rate people based on the 3 C’s, as they decide whether or not the person is credit-worthy! Activity can be found also in Appendix F following the overhead. * Note: Students need to know that in some instances Collateral is the term used for the concept of Capital. Sources: http://myhomelender.com/3Cs.html http://www.econedlink.org/lessons/index.cfm?lesson=EM481&pa ge=teacher http://www.econedlink.org/lessons/EM481/docs/em481_Who_is_ Creditworthy.swf There are 3 well known credit bureaus when getting your credit rated. They are: •Experian •TransUnion •Equifax Experian is a global leader in providing analytical and information - 128 of 201- services to organizations and consumers to help manage the risk and reward of commercial and financial decisions. They support clients in more than 60 countries. TransUnion is a global leader in credit and information management. They have worked with businesses and consumers for over 30 years to gather, analyze and deliver the critical information needed to build strong economies throughout the world. The result? Businesses can better manage risk and customer relationships. And consumers can better understand and manage credit so they can achieve their financial goals. 7.8 To examine 3 well-known credit bureaus that keep track of one’s credit rating. To introduce the concept of FICO. Equifax Canada Inc. is the leader in the consumer and commercial credit reporting and information services industry. Even though many Canadians have never looked at their own credit report, it’s very important! Equifax Canada Inc. has designed a Consumer Information Centre to inform you about credit reporting in general, how to obtain a copy of your credit report, and helpful tips on credit ratings. FICO scores are the credit scores most lenders use to determine your credit risk. You have three FICO scores, one for each of the three credit bureaus – Experian, TransUnion, and Equifax. Each score is based on information the credit bureau keeps on file about you. Your FICO score can range from 300-850. The higher your FICO score the lower your payments are due to lower interest rates. FICO is an acronym for the creators of the FICO score, Fair Isaac Credit Organization. Your 3 FICO scores affect both how much and what loan terms (interest rate, etc.) lenders will offer you at any given time. Students must know that they have the right to review their own credit files and correct or challenge any unfavorable items. The FICO score takes into account various factors in each of these five areas: payment history, current level of indebtedness, types of credit used and length of credit history and new credit in determining credit risk. Teachers may want to take students into a computer lab to go over the frequently asked questions found at the Equifax website at: http://www.equifax.com/EFX_Canada/consumer_information_ce ntre/faqs_e.html - 129 of 201- 7.8 continued… Depending on class size, the teacher may want to have each student learn an answer to one or two of the FAQ’s. Then, a jigsaw activity could take place where each student teaches what he or she has learned, while learning from the rest of the class. Sources: http://www.myfico.com/CreditEducation/ http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/ficoscore.asp http://www.experiangroup.com/corporate/about/ http://www.transunion.com/corporate/aboutUs/whoWeAre.page 7.9 To identify ways to establish and maintain credit worthiness. Building a good credit record and maintaining it is an important step in reaching financial independence and can be established by: • Making at least the minimum payment due. • Paying all your debts on time. • Knowing your financial situation and ability to repay before you borrow. • Be honest in filling out credit applications. The only protection for the lender who has been lied to is to conduct a through investigation of every applicant. • Read and understand a credit contract before signing it. It’s your responsibility to know what you are committing to. • Accept the consequences of nonpayment or late payment. There may be a late charge and you owe it. If you default, you may lose your collateral or other assets. Source: http://www.chase.com/ccp/index.jsp?pg_name=ccpmapp/shared/ marketing/page/what_is_credit Students should realize by now that they should only take on as much debt as they can afford! 7.10 To analyze the 20/10 rule in understanding what you can afford when using credit. Teachers can introduce the 20/10 rule. A handout for students can be found at Appendix G. Scenarios of different characters could be given to the class in order to calculate what they can afford using credit. For example, Susie may want to purchase some new clothes for a new job that she recently got. She believes that it will cost her around $150. Her monthly net income is $1,000 and her fixed monthly rent is $400. Will she be able to carry a safe debt load for the month if she buys new clothes worth $150? You would take her $1,000 monthly net income x 10% to get - 130 of 201- $100. Her fixed monthly rent (mortgage payment) is not counted as part of the 10%. So Susie could say that she has a safe debt load of $100. If she chooses to spend $150 on new clothes she is spending more than she can actually afford! When you use the 20/10 rule you are helping to find what your safe debt load is. It should be stressed that when you are finding your safe debt load you don’t take into account any monthly rent expenses. An excellent activity to go through as a class is found after the 20 / 10 rule handout. Students could participate in a fun interactive game on credit from the Money Talks website found at: http://www.moneytalks.ucr.edu/english/games/game_credit_matc h.htm Other related excellent sites *http://googolplex.cuna.org/20988/cnote/story.html?doc_id=888 *http://googolplex.cuna.org/20988/cnote/creditscore/start.htm Teachers should introduce and provide a definition for a credit card and explain how a credit card differs from a debit card. (Debit cards were discussed in Module 3: Banking Services) As a review, teachers should inform students that although debit cards and credit cards are similar, there is a distinct difference. The difference is that a debit card draws funds directly from your chequing account, while a credit card draws funds from an available line of credit 7.11 To introduce the basics of credit cards and the difference between a debit card and a credit card Teachers should introduce and explain terminology relating to credit cards such as annual fee, interest rate, cash advance, grace period, and minimum payment (see Glossary). A credit card is first and foremost a convenient and flexible payment tool accepted at 620,000 outlets in Canada and 30 million locations worldwide. Among its many features it provides: Access to unsecured credit (no collateral required against amounts charged) Interest-free payment from time of purchase to the end of the billing period Instant payment of purchases, allowing for instant receipt - 131 of 201- of goods and services 24/7 access Fraud protection Other rewards and benefits, such as air travel points, car insurance, damage and loss insurance, and extended warranty programs Teachers may also want to discuss the do’s and don’ts of credit cards at this point: When applying for a credit card – shop around (look at various sources) Read and understand the contract: - read the contract carefully - don’t rush into signing anything - obtain a copy of the contract once you have signed it - know the penalties for missed payments Know your cost - figure out total cost when paying with credit - make the largest payments possible - know the penalties for missed payments - don’t be misled into thinking that smaller payments are better Teachers may also want to provide students with background information about the use of credit cards and statistical information (See Appendix). The Canadian Bankers’ Association has relevant and up-to-date information regarding the use of credit cards (visit the following website: http://www.cba.ca/en/viewDocument.asp?fl=5&sl=111&tl=&doci d=246&pg=1) The following website also has a great quiz on credit cards which could be used to determine the students’ prior knowledge on credit cards and then again at the end of the unit as a post-test. http://googolplex.cuna.org/20988/cnote/plas_surg/start.htm The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada also has a credit card quiz which could be given to students or used by the teacher for additional information: http://www.fcacacfc.gc.ca/eng/consumers/ITools/Quizzes/CreditCardQuiz.asp?sn =0 - 132 of 201- The four major credit card networks are MasterCard, Visa, Discover, and American Express. 7.12 To identify and analyze the major distributors of credit cards A jigsaw strategy could be used by having teams of four, with one member of each team researching the costs and features of a standard credit card for one of the four major networks (See Appendix H for instructions and sample worksheet). The following websites may aid the students in their research: http://www.visa.ca/en/personal/cardsandproducts/ http://www.mastercard.com/ca/gateway/en/index.html http://www.americanexpress.com/canada/en/homepage/default.sht ml?ca_en_nu=global http://www.discovercard.com/discover/data/home.shtml Exploration of other networks such as Diner’s Club and Bankcard could also be undertaken. A guest speaker from a bank or other financial institution may also be a useful resource in helping students to understand the credit cards available. Students should be familiar with the advantages and disadvantages of credit cards. Teachers could facilitate a brainstorming session or research activity with students searching the Internet or other resources for information relating to the advantages and disadvantages of credit cards. Some advantages of credit cards are: 7.13 To determine the advantages and disadvantages of credit cards 1. Purchasing Power and Ease of Purchase - credit cards make it easier to buy items 2. Protection of Purchases – credit cards sometimes offer additional protection if something one has bought was stolen, damaged, or lost. 3. Building a Credit Line – having a credit card and using it wisely will help to build a good credit history 4. Emergencies – credit cards are useful in emergencies and situations which may lead to the necessity of a large purchase 5. Other Benefits – bonuses such as air miles, travel discounts, and special insurances. Some disadvantages of credit cards are: - 133 of 201- Blowing your Budget – credit cards encourage people to spend money that they do not have. High Interest Rates and Increased Debt – credit card companies can charge an enormous amount of interest on each balance that the holder can’t pay at the end of each month Credit Card Fraud – credit cards and credit card numbers can be stolen, and someone can use this information to rack up debts. Students should be introduced to a credit card application form and know what the credit card company requires and how they will be approved. (See attached pdf file for a sample application form). Students should also be aware that banks distribute credit cards for the major networks, so should they want to apply for a credit card, they can visit their financial institution to obtain an application form and discuss their options. 7.14 To examine the credit card application process Basic information required when filling out an application form include date of birth, address, social insurance number, and driver’s license number. Teachers may also want to discuss pre-approved credit card offers that are mailed to prospective clients. Students could bring samples of these offers, by asking their parents if they receive any and then bringing those to class. Students could then compare the different offers being made and spend time reading the ‘fine print’ to see what hidden fees and costs exist with such an offer. The time companies take to approve a credit card varies dependent on the type of card. Generally, the better one’s credit rating is, the faster the response time is for a credit card application – once the decision has been made, the credit card will notify the applicant by mail. 7.15 To analyze the components of a credit card statement Students should become familiar with the credit card statement to ensure they understand the components and what information the statement provides. A credit card statement will show all purchases and payments the holder has made using their credit card. Each statement will cover a set period of time, usually a month. Purchases and payments made since the date of the last statement will be shown - 134 of 201- on the current statement. Other components of a credit card statement include: Account Name and Number – reference number that should be quoted when making inquiries Statement Date – transactions up to this date will be shown Previous Balance – amount owed on your credit card statement Finance Charges (if any) – interest charges on outstanding amounts New Transactions – details of new transactions Payments & Credits – payments made on the account Credit Limit – upper limit available on the credit card Available credit – amount one can spend (difference between credit limit and new balance Minimum payment (and due date) Monthly Interest – the minimum amount due on the account Students could be given an activity where a credit card statement is analyzed (See Appendix I for sample activity and answer key). Students should be familiar with calculating simple and compound interest based on Module 4: Savings and Investing. Teachers should explain how any interest accrued on a credit card works against the holder (as opposed to a savings initiative). 7.16 To investigate the interest component of a credit card and discover the impact of carrying a balance on a credit card. 7.17 To explore the meaning and purposes of a credit card limit Students should also understand that card issuers make money from the interest payments that consumers are required to pay if they don’t pay off their bill each month. The more a credit card holder pays each month, the less their interest payment will be in the end. An example to illustrate the impact of carrying a balance and how the amount of the payment made affects the amount of debt could be used (see Appendix J). A credit limit is the maximum amount that a credit card company will allow a card holder to borrow on a single card. Some lenders will allow a borrower to exceed this limit, but then subject the borrower to fines or penalties A credit limit is much more than a cut-off point for spending – it’s a reflection of how a particular credit card company gauges one’s credit worthiness and one’s likeliness to charge away on their credit card. Students should be aware that they can turn down offers to raise their credit limit from the credit card companies simply by calling the issuer and asking them to either stop increasing their limits at - 135 of 201- all times or at one particular time. The main motivation that credit card companies have for increasing a credit limit is their bottom line. Credit limits provide advantages – they serve to protect the borrower from getting in over their heads and borrowing too much money and they also protect the lender from being overexposed to borrower’s getting too far into debt. Credit limits may also restrict the borrowing capacity of the borrower, reducing the value of items that they can purchase. Students should identify and analyze current credit card scams and theft and come up with ideas on how card holders can protect themselves. Warnings about credit card scams often come through email and students should be encouraged to look for these notices or ask their parents if they have received any. Students could also page through newspapers or search online for stories on how credit cards have been stolen and who has been the victim. 7.18 To explore how credit cards are stolen The RCMP website: (http://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/scams/ccandpc_e.htm) has current statistics on counterfeiting and credit card fraud (See Appendix K for 2005 statistics). In 2007 many credit card numbers were jeopardized after a thief hacked into the database for HomeSense and Winners. Credit card companies responded to the hacking by issuing new credit cards to all of their customers. Students should be encouraged to investigate the scams and also how credit card companies respond to the crimes. Students should become aware of the steps they can take if they find unauthorized transactions their account and how to protect themselves from unauthorized transactions. 7.19 To determine how to handle unauthorized transactions and to determine ways to protect credit cards from theft and fraud Teachers could facilitate a brainstorming session and have students come up with their own ideas how to protect from credit card fraud. The following are ways which credit card holders can protect themselves from unauthorized transactions: As soon as you receive a new card, sign the back. Cancel and destroy any cards you no longer need. Make sure your monthly credit card statement lists only - 136 of 201- the transactions you made during the month. If you notice any unauthorized transactions, report them immediately to your credit card issuer. Don't give personal information or your credit card account number over the phone or the Internet unless you're dealing with a company you know and trust. Keep your personal information safe. This includes your date of birth, your social insurance number (SIN) and all your other personal identification. Request your credit file from the credit bureaus at least once a year to make sure it's accurate. Keep any record of your personal identification number (PIN) separate from your credit card and never disclose it to anyone. The following are the steps which holders can take if they find unauthorized transactions on their statement: Contact the credit card issuer and report the unauthorized transactions Check the credit card agreement – the agreement must explain the maximum liability in the case of lost or stolen credit cards, or the unauthorized use of the credit card. Find out if the credit card company has a “zero-liability policy” on unauthorized transactions. The following is a list of 10 things that holders can do to protect their credit cards: Never leave your cards unattended at work. There are more credit card thefts in the workplace than in any other single location. If your credit card is programmed to access an Automated Banking Machine (ABM), protect your Personal Identification Number (PIN) or security code. Don't write it down, memorize it. Don't leave your credit cards in your vehicle. A very high proportion of credit cards are stolen from motor vehicles. Always check your card when returned to you after a purchase. Make sure it is your card. When travelling, carry your cards with you or make sure they are in a secure location. Report lost or stolen cards immediately. Most fraudulent use of cards takes place within days of their - 137 of 201- being lost or stolen. Sign the back of a new card as soon you get it. Destroy unwanted cards so no one else can use them. Make a list of all your cards and their numbers. This key information is helpful when reporting lost or stolen cards. Always check your monthly statement. Make sure the charges are yours. Never give your card number over the phone unless you are dealing with a reputable company. The only time you should give it is when you have called to place an order. Students should also be familiar with charge cards offered by retail stores such as The Bay, Zellers, Canadian Tire, and Sears. Students should also identify the pros and cons of retail charge cards and be aware of how these cards differ from credit and debit cards. 7.20 To explore the nature of credit cards (retail cards) distributed by retail outlets Students should research these cards and compare the costs and features to that of a regular credit card. The results of the retail card investigation can be compared to the results from the “Shopping for Credit” activity in objective 7.12. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada has compared the features of four retail cards at the following website: http://www.fcacacfc.gc.ca/eng/publications/CreditCardsYou/pdfs/Retail-e.pdf - 138 of 201- Appendix A Planning Your Credit Purchase Directions: For each situation listed below, complete questions on the Activity sheet, to help determine decisions that need to be made when planning to make a credit purchase. Each person named also is expected to pay all credit card balances and fees. Situation 1 Jennifer is a senior in high school. Her parents gave her a credit card and told her that she may use the card only in case of an emergency. As she was walking across the Mall, she saw the perfect dress for the senior prom in a store window display. The prom is two weeks away. The tag on the dress was $125.00. Also on the window was a sign: One day only, all items 25% off ticket price. Jennifer’s grandmother, a dressmaker, told her if she needed a special outfit, she would be willing to sew it for her. What should Jennifer do? Situation 2 Tony spends much of each day in his car commuting from home to school and work. His parents gave him a credit card to be used only for emergencies. Recently, the radio in his car went on the blink. He enjoys listening to music on his long drives. He went to the repair shop and was told it would cost $75.00 to diagnose the problem. To fix the problem, he would have to pay additional costs for labour and parts. The repairperson told Tony that his shop had a special sale on a portable CD player for $150.00. What should Tony do? Situation 3 Sarah is a college student who had volunteered to drive three members of her debate team to the state debate championship in a city 75 miles away. As they were approaching a small town half way to their destination, they stopped at a fast food restaurant to get something to eat. When they got back into the car, the car would not start. The girls got out and pushed the car to the gas station next door. Sarah was told her battery was dead and a new one would cost $80. If the girls pooled all their money, they would have just enough money to purchase the battery. Sarah could have the car jump-started and hope that the battery will recharge itself during the rest of the trip. The service station attendant will accept her credit card. Sarah is responsible for paying all her auto repair bills. What should Sarah do? Situation 4 Jason is an honours pre-med student at the state university. He is on a very limited budget. Each semester, he charges his tuition and fees. He pays for his books with money in his savings account, which has only $30 left. One of his professors strongly recommended that he purchase books on an optional reading list that cost $250 to better prepare him for medical school entrance exams. A high score on the entrance exam may help Jason get a scholarship to attend medical school. What should Jason do? - 139 of 201- Glossary of Key Terms Annual Fee A charge levied each year for use of a credit card. It's billed directly to your monthly statement. However, many credit cards come without an annual fee. Annual Interest Rate The annual interest rate charged on purchases that don't benefit from the interest-free period. There is no interest-free period for cash advances or balance transfers, and interest is charged from the day you withdraw the funds. Balance Transfer The transfer of an outstanding credit card balance from one card to another, usually between different institutions. The new card issuer usually charges interest from the day the amount is transferred to the new card -- there is no interest-free period. Cash Advance The withdrawal of funds from your credit card, up to the credit limit allowed. The amount you withdraw may be subject to daily limits. There is no interestfree period, so interest is charged from the day you withdraw the funds. Convenience Cheque A cheque provided by the credit card issuer and drawn on your credit card account. You can use a convenience cheque the same way you would a personal cheque. When you use a convenience cheque, the transaction is treated as a cash advance for the purposes of calculating interest charges - there is no interest-free period and you're charged interest until you pay back the amount of the cheque in full. Grace Period The grace period is the time between the statement date and the payment due date, and is determined by the credit card issuer. The grace period usually varies between 15 and 26 days and is part of the interest-free period. The grace period may not apply unless you meet certain conditions. Interest-Free Period The interest-free period on new purchases starts on the date you make a purchase and ends when the credit card issuer begins charging you interest on that purchase. The interest-free period includes the grace period determined by the credit card issuer. It may not apply unless certain conditions are met. Minimum Payment The minimum amount payable each month on your credit card balance. Penalty Interest Rate The rate at which penalty charges are calculated. It only applies to charge cards. Prime Rate The interest rate a financial institution charges on loans to its best customers. Reference Rate A base rate, such as the Prime Rate, used in the calculations of variable credit card interest rates. Reward Program A program offered by credit card issuers that gives cardholders rewards for using their credit card. You collect reward points every time you charge a - 140 of 201- purchase to your card. You can usually redeem these points in merchandise, travel or cash, depending on the program. Security Deposit The amount you deposit with a credit card issuer as security to obtain a secured credit card. Glossary terms taken from: http://www.fcac-acfc.gc.ca/eng/publications/CreditCardsYou/glossary_e.asp?pm=1 - 141 of 201- ACTIVITY SHEET What goals do you hope to accomplish in making your decision? What are the alternatives? What are the benefits of purchasing the item using credit? What are the costs associated with purchasing your item using credit? Make a decision • Which alternative best matches your goal? • What do you gain with each alternative? • What do you give up with each alternative? Modified Source: http://ecedweb.unomaha.edu/k-12/home.cfm - 142 of 201- Appendix B What has contributed to credit becoming so popular? • People are more willing to take on debt than in the past. • There are more funds available for borrowing. Example: the 1930’s (Dirty 30’s) there was no such thing and people wouldn’t even dream of it. And, today people have the luxury to borrow money. • People are better off today, meaning a higher ability to pay off debt. • Borrowing (credit) is popular due to higher prices of things. Example: As prices of products and services rise so does the need to borrow * The higher price of gas may cause some people to have to borrow money just in order to drive their vehicle! • People are more confident and knowledgeable which gives them belief in using credit. • Today most households are dual-income allowing the ability to use more credit and pay it back more easily. • Lifestyle: People are living more for today, and not waiting for tomorrow! • People think they need to live up to friends and families spending habits so they use credit. The saying “Keeping up with the Jones” applies here. • Can you think of any others? Source: The Canadian Banker’s Association – A teaching aid for grades 9 11 (1984 - 143 of 201- Appendix C People lend scenario: Grandfather writes a cheque to you in order to help pay for your tuition. He feels good about lending you the money since you are the only grandchild. People lend scenario: You have good credit, so the bank has no problem in loaning you some money in order to finance your first home. People lend scenario: A stranger sees that you need some extra change in order to ride the bus. They offer the money without holding back. People lend scenario: Your best friend and you are shopping. She / He recognizes that you don’t have any money to buy your prom dress/ dress suit so they put it on their visa if you agree to pay it back later. People lend scenario: Zellers hooks you up with a Charge card for their store. They have a high interest, but because you shop their all the time you think it is a good idea to have. You buy something at the store, and the cashier emphasizes that you have earned ______ amount of HBC rewards today for using their card. People don’t lend scenario: You have always mooched money from your brother. You don’t have any money to buy Christmas presents and you ask to borrow some money until you get paid. But, your brother is sick of lending you money and wants you to finally learn your lesson by not helping you out this time. People don’t lend scenario: You have a credit card in which you have failed to make even the minimum payments on for several months. You are at the Brick wanting to buy an item and the salesperson recommends putting it on a Brick card. But, when they do a credit check on you, you are denied due to all the debt you already have. People don’t lend scenario: You have gone to college on student loans, and you owe in total $50,000. You don’t have a job, and you haven’t paid any of it back yet. You go to a Saturn dealership thinking it would be a good idea to get a new vehicle, but when they find out that you aren’t working and have no income, they don’t want to lend you any money for the car. - 144 of 201- Appendix D - 145 of 201- Appendix E Matching Credit Match the correct credit type to its proper description by drawing a line that connects the two. Charge Accounts You give your jewelry or other possessions to the pawnbroker, and they lend you a small amount of money for a few days. You then have to pay the money back to retrieve your goods; otherwise the pawnbroker gets to keep the items. Consumer Loans Tend to be from Financial Institutions from any period of time from 1 month to 7 years. Pawnbroking Purchases like “3 Easy Payments of $49.95!” from infomercials. You must watch interest fees associated with this type of credit. Mortgage Loans Your bank allows you to temporarily take extra money out of your current account. However you are expected to pay it back quickly otherwise interest will be very expensive Overdraft Funds that may be used to start, improve, or expand a business. Business Loans Credit accounts from stores like the Bay, SEARS, or Zellers. Installment buying Primarily used when purchasing property. - 146 of 201- Source used in the creation of the worksheet: http://www.thesite.org/homelawandmoney/money/creditanddebt/typesofcredit Answer Key - 147 of 201- Appendix F - 148 of 201- - 149 of 201- - 150 of 201- Appendix G - 151 of 201- - 152 of 201- Answer Key - How much can they safely carry? 1.) $1360 x 10%= $136 - $116 = $20 for the month 2.) $3500 x 12 months = $42,000 income for the year. Then, $42,000 x 20% = $8,400 - $7,000 = $1,400 for the year 3.) $2,500 x 10% = $250 dollars safe debt load for the month. Then, $250 - $68 car insurance - $ 167 car payment = $15 dollars for the month. - 153 of 201- Appendix H Names of Team Members: ____________________ ____________________ __________________ __________________ Shopping for Credit Credit card costs and features can vary greatly. This exercise will give you the chance to shop for and compare the costs and feature of different credit cards. Directions Break into teams of four. In your groups, assign each person one of the four major credit card networks discussed in class (reminder: Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Discover). Use the attached worksheet to research the costs and features of the standard (basic) credit card for the network you have been assigned. When you are done researching, come back to your team and as a group, answer the following questions. Hand in one copy per team. 1. Which credit card has the highest annual percentage rate and how much is it? 2. What method is used to calculate the monthly finance charges for the first major credit card? 3. Do any of the cards have annual fees? Which ones? How much is the fee 4. Is there a transaction fee on any card? If so, which card and how much is it? 5. Is there a minimum finance charge on any of the credit cards? How much is it? 6. Do any of the credit cards charge a fee for late payments? How much is it? 7. Which credit card has the longest grace period? How long is it? Based on Visa’s Choices and Decisions Activity 8-1 www.practicalmoneyskills.ca - 154 of 201- Shopping for Credit - Worksheet Directions Use the following worksheet to record information about your assigned credit card. Credit Card Network Company Name, Address, Phone Website Locations where card is accepted Annual Fee (if any) Grace Period Annual Percentage Rate Finance charge calculation method Credit Limit Minimum payment Other Fees (such as late payments) Other features - 155 of 201- Appendix I Name: ____________________ Credit Card Statements A credit card statement provides information such as how and when you’ve used your credit card, how much you owe, how much interest you’re paying to use the card, how much your minimum payments is, and how much credit you have left. Knowing how to read your credit card statement can also help you catch unauthorized charges and/or billing errors. Directions Use the attached credit card statement to answer the following questions: 1. What is the date of the statement? 2. What is the Annual Percentage Rate (APR)? 3. What is the new balance? 4. What was the previous balance? 5. How many charges were made during the billing cycle? 6. How many credits and payments were made during the billing cycle? 7. Were there any charges for late payments? If so, how much were the charges? 8. What is the total amount of the credit line? 9. What is total amount of credit available? - 156 of 201- 10. What is the total amount of charges made during the current billing period? 11. What is the account number on the statement? 12. Where should the payment be sent? Based on Visa’s Choices and Decisions Activity 8-2 www.practicalmoneyskills.ca - 157 of 201- Based on Visa’s Choices and Decisions Activity 8-2 www.practicalmoneyskills.ca - 158 of 201- Credit Card Statements A credit card statement provides information such as how and when you’ve used your credit card, how much you owe, how much interest you’re paying to use the card, how much your minimum payments is, and how much credit you have left. Knowing how to read your credit card statement can also help you catch unauthorized charges and/or billing errors. Directions Use the attached credit card statement to answer the following questions: 1. What is the date of the statement? 2/13/01 2. What is the Annual Percentage Rate (APR)? 3. What is the new balance? 17.5% $125.24 4. What was the previous balance? $168.80 5. How many charges were made during the billing cycle? Five 6. How many credits and payments were made during the billing cycle? One 7. Were there any charges for late payments? If so, how much were the charges? No, there were no late payment charges. 8. What is the total amount of the credit line? $1,200 9. What is total amount of credit available? $1,074.76 10. What is the total amount of charges made during the current billing period? $125.24 11. What is the account number on the statement? 4125-239-412 - 159 of 201- 12. Where should the payment be sent? Your First Bank, Box 1234, Anytown, Canada Based on Visa’s Choices and Decisions Activity 8-2 www.practicalmoneyskills.ca Appendix J Understanding Interest borrowed from http://www.investopedia.com/articles/01/061301.asp Let’s say John and Jane both have $2,000 debt on their credit cards, which require a minimum payment of 3%, or $10, whichever is higher. Both are strapped for cash, but Jane manages to pay an extra $10 on top of her minimum monthly payments. John pays only the minimum. Each month John and Jane are charged a 20% annual interest on their cards’ outstanding balance. So, when John and Jane make payments, part of those payments go to paying interest and part goes to the principal. Here is the break down of the numbers for the first month of John’s credit card debt: Principal: $2,000 Interest: $33.33 ($2,000 x (1+20%/12)) Payment: $60 (3% of remaining principal balance) Principal Repayment: $26.67 ($60-33.33) Remaining Balance: $1,973.33 ($2,000 - $26.67) These calculations are done every month until the credit card debt is paid off. In the end, John pays $4,240 in total over 15 years to absolve the $2,000 in credit card debt. The interest that John pays over the 15 years totals $2,240, higher than the original credit card debt. Here is the break down of the numbers for the first month of Jane’s credit card debt: - 160 of 201- Principal: $2,000 Interest: $33.33 ($2,000 x (1+20%/12)) Payment: $70 (3% of remaining principal balance + $10) Principal Repayment: $36.67 ($70-33.33) Remaining Balance: $1,963.33 ($2,000 - $36.67) Since Jane paid an extra $10 a month, she pays a total $3,276 over seven years to absolve the $2,000 in credit card debt. Jane pays a total $1,276 in interest. The extra $10 a month saves Jane almost $1,000, and cuts her repayment period by more than seven years! Every little bit counts. Paying twice your minimum or more can drastically cut down the time it takes to pay off the balance, which in turn leads to lower interest charges. - 161 of 201- Appendix K Credit Card Fraud Statistics (From the RCMP website: http://www.rcmpgrc.gc.ca/scams/ccandpc_e.htm) Overview At the end of fiscal year 2005, approximately 56.4 million credit cards were in circulation across the country, with a sales volume exceeding $190.6 billion (MasterCard and Visa). Payment card counterfeiters are now using the latest computer devices (embossers, encoders, and decoders often supported by computers) to read, modify, and implant magnetic stripe information on counterfeit payment cards. Phoney identification has been used to obtain government assistance, personal loans, unemployment insurance benefits and for other schemes victimizing governments, individuals, and corporate bodies. Payment Card Partner Losses by type 2005 Category $ Loss $14,771,080 Lost $26,112,623 Stolen $7,856,411 Non receipt $8,909,580 Fraudulent applications $126,824,292 Counterfeit $88,364,181 Fraudulent use of account $7,305,414 Miscellaneous, not defined TOTAL $280,143,582 No. of accounts 25,363 40,827 3,803 4,872 114,795 147,911 5,069 342,640 $ Avg. loss per account $586.75 $638.86 $2,041.71 $1,733.24 $1,050.02 $595.86 $1,496.07 $798.00 CATEGORIES OF CREDIT CARD FRAUD The criminal use of credit cards can be divided into the following categories: Counterfeit credit card use: This represents the largest category of credit card fraud, involving Canadian issued cards, with 37% of all dollar losses. Organized criminals have acquired the technology that allows them to "skim" the data contained on magnetic stripes, manufacture phoney cards, and overcome such protective features as holograms. Cards lost by or stolen from the cardholder: Lost and stolen cards represent 23% of all card fraud losses. Typically the cards are stolen from the workplace, vehicles, health clubs, golf clubs, etc. Fraud committed without the actual use of a card (no-card fraud): No-Card Fraud accounts for 10% of the all losses. Deceptive Telemarketers and now fraudulent Internet Web Sites obtain specific card details from their victims, while promoting the sale of exaggerated or non-existent goods and services. This in turn results in fraudulent charges against victims' accounts. Fraud committed on cards not received by the legitimate cardholder (non-receipt - 162 of 201- fraud): Non-Receipt Fraud where cards are intercepted prior to delivery to the cardholder account for 7% of all losses. Losses attributable to mail theft have declined as a result of "card activation" programs, where cardholders must call their financial institution to confirm their identity before the card is activated. In 1992 this category accounted for 16 % of the losses. Cards fraudulently obtained by criminals who have made false applications: Fraudulent Applications involve the criminal impersonation of creditworthy persons in order to acquire credit cards. Although false application losses represent only 4% of all losses, the numbers are increasing - 163 of 201- This page intentionally left blank for notes. - 164 of 201- Module 8: Consumer Protection (Core) Suggested Time: 15 – 20 hours Level: Introductory Prerequisite: None Module Overview: This module will provide the opportunity for students to understand and explore methods for protecting their finances. Students will have the opportunity to explore, discuss and evaluate ways to protect them from being taken advantage of. Foundational Objectives: To understand and explore ways consumers might be able to make informed decisions to protect their finances. To explore options when ones financial situation is threatened. Common Essential Learnings Foundational Objectives: To enable students to make sound decisions about their purchases that which will carry-forward to adulthood. (IL) To educate students on modern ways to do purchasing online. (TL) To enable students to understand consumer security through role play. (COM) To promote decision making characteristics which students will use to make sound choices in purchasing and recognizing scams/frauds. (CCT) Learning Objectives Notes Students are purchasing and using cell phones at a greater rate than ever before. Students need to be aware of the options available when deciding which cell phone to purchase and service contract. 8.1 To identify and understand basic cell phone requirements and contracts. Before signing a contract students may want to consider the following: Prepaid vs. monthly payments Minutes required Features The store Network coverage Credit check – co-signer needed? Hardware requirements - 165 of 201- 8.2 To understand methods for purchasing online and the need for security when purchasing online. Customer Service The Contract – is everything promised in writing? Many Canadians are turning towards doing their purchasing online. Students could consider the following: Paypal Delivery policies, tracking shipping Sending money orders What to do when the seller or buyer does something suspicious Procedures for attainment of cash or item, e.g. personal exchanges Return Polices Privacy Online auctions Refer to: PayPal_Safety.PDF (E-Commerce) Consumer bankruptcies were up by 12%, April 2008 compared to April 2007 in Canada. Bankruptcy is a legal process by which you may be discharged from most of your debts. The purpose is to permit an honest, but unfortunate debtor to obtain a discharge from most debts, subject to reasonable conditions. 8.3 To identify, define, and describe the features and terminology related to bankruptcy. There are three different ways to go into bankruptcy: * voluntary assignment - where insolvent persons make an assignment of all their assets for the general benefit of all creditors; * involuntary assignment - when a creditor files a petition in a provincial court for a receiving order against the debtor's assets, known as being petitioned into bankruptcy; and * deemed bankruptcy - when a proposal in bankruptcy under the Bankruptcy Insolvency Act has failed. You have to send a copy of the court-issued assignment in bankruptcy, a Bankruptcy Notice, or document entitled First Meeting of Creditors to your tax services office. Usually, the Business Number of a bankrupt client will be closed after discharge. The bankrupt has the right to earn a living. For this purpose, the bankrupt is allowed to engage in or continue a taxable business activity outside of the estate, after a bankruptcy. For more information on bankruptcies: http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/tax/business/topics/lifeevents/bankruptcy/bankruptcy-e.html - 166 of 201- Identity fraud, the theft and use of personal information for criminal purposes, is one of the fastest growing crimes in Canada. All Canadians should be aware of the need to protect their personal information and ensure their identity and finances are not compromised. 8.5 To explore scams and frauds and ways to protect oneself from invasion. Students may explore the following topics: Faked E-Commerce Sites Phishing Pharming SMiShing Vishing Prize Pitch Auction Fraud Malicious Software Wireless Communications Public Access Communications Job Offers Scams False charities Counterfeit Cheques Counterfeit Money Travel Scams Shoulder Surfing and Eavesdropping Telemarketing Fraud 900 Scams A collection agency is a business that obtains or arranges for payment of money owed to either a persona or a company. Having a good credit history and credit score is important. 8.6 To explore collection agencies and their effects on one’s credit rating. Lenders usually review your credit history and score when deciding whether or not to grant you a loan or credit, and landlords may use your credit history to decide whether or not they will rent to you. If your credit history or score is poor, a lender may refuse to give you a loan or you may have to pay a higher interest rate. Refer to: Canadian Consumer Handbook 2007.pdf A will is a legal document in which a person states how his or her property will be dealt with after death. A will usually names one or more executors who distribute the property as directed by the will. Even if someone has few assets, handling the estate is simpler and - 167 of 201- 8.7 To explore wills and estate planning. less expensive when a will exists. Key Terms: Estate Probate Living Will Executor Power of Attorney - 168 of 201- References http://www.joingod.com/faq/faq.php?answer=199&cat_name=Safety%20and%20purchas ing%20online&category_id=12#199 http://www.mass.gov/?pageID=cagoterminal&L=4&L0=Home&L1=Community+Safety &L2=Cyber+Crime+%26+Internet+Safety&L3=Online+Safety+for+Consumers&sid=Ca go&b=terminalcontent&f=community_Cybercrime_Purchasing_Online&csid=Cago http://cmcweb.ca/epic/site/cmc-cmc.nsf/en/fe00101e.html#Shopping http://www.ic.gc.ca/epic/site/oca-bc.nsf/en/h_ca02224e.html http://reviews.cnet.com/4520-7609_7-5537615-5.html http://www.googobits.com/articles/p0-1518-a-guide-to-purchasing-a-cell-phone.html http://www.webgrrls.com/resources/viewarticle.php?newsid=135 http://www.overstock.com/cell-phone-buying-guide.html http://www.phonebusters.com/english/index.html http://www.rcmp.ca/scams/canadian_practical_guide_e.htm http://www.rcmp.ca/scams/student_guide_e.htm http://www.ic.gc.ca/epic/site/oca-bc.nsf/en/h_ca02228e.html Plea - http://www.plea.org/ - 169 of 201- This page intentionally left blank for notes. - 170 of 201- Module 9: Renting, Leasing, Buying, and Insuring (Big Ticket Items) Suggested Time: 5-15 hours (variables depend on group, school, economic status) Level: Introductory Prerequisite: None. Module Overview: This module will introduce students to the differences between buying and renting property. Students will also explore the advantages and disadvantages of each and learn what is involved in both processes. In addition to this, students will learn the importance of protecting their assets through the purchase of insurance. Foundational Objectives: To understand the difference between renting and buying, and the advantages and disadvantages of each, and when to do each. To investigate the types of resources and research that may be used to evaluate and plan the purchase of property. To analyze the costs and benefits of home ownership. To assess opportunities for home ownership or rental in the community and to develop those opportunities by applying personal experience, knowledge, and expertise. To decide between purchasing, renting, or leasing of a vehicle, and when and why people do each type. To understand the costs, risks, and benefits associated with the insurance of a house, automobile, or other big purchase. Common Essential Leanings Foundational Objectives: To enable students to understand the first step in changing spending patterns with the goal of purchasing a house. (IL) To help students realize exactly how they are spending their money and how much of it they are spending. (NUM) To contribute to the development of critical and creative thinkers. (CCT) To promote both intuitive thought and the ability to evaluate ideas, processes, experiences, and objects in meaningful contexts in order to properly identify the advantages and disadvantages of home ownership vs. rental. (CCT) To enlighten students as to the costs and risks associated with insuring their large purchases. (PSVS) - 171 of 201- Learning Objectives Notes When students learn terminology and its meaning early, they are more likely to be successful in their decision making. 9.1 To understand the terminology related to buying or renting property. Teachers may wish to have a brainstorming session with the students. Write the terms "to rent" and "to buy" on the blackboard and jot down students responses. Some key terms to look for are loan, bank, owe, lease, contract, security, deposit, mortgage, condominium, taxes, and foreclosure. Ask students to define key terms they believe are critical to buying and renting. Encourage students to discuss each term fully and to use them as springboards to think of others. Students should have an extensive list of terms and definitions when they are done. As each term is discussed, students should write the definition and additional details they feel are important. This process will help them review for a potential test. Teachers may wish to facilitate another brainstorming sessions on the pros and cons of home ownership. Students should be prepared to justify their answers and discuss why they consider a certain item to be an advantage or disadvantage. 9.2 To explore the advantages and disadvantages of home ownership Students should be aware that not everyone will agree with their responses. For example, some students may think yard work is an advantage (gardening, etc.), while others may be too busy for it and consider it a disadvantage. See below for some advantages and disadvantages. Advantages Build equity Gain tax advantages Have stable monthly payments Have a place for your family to live - 172 of 201- Gain a sense of community Disadvantages Usually costs more Ties up your cash Selling the house may not be possible during the first few years of ownership Moving is more difficult and complicated You may not have as much flexibility in choosing a new job location You will need to spend money on maintenance and repairs to maintain the home No guarantee that your home will increase in value See Appendix A L & M for more detail After having learned budgeting and credit in previous modules students should not factor in saving for a house. 9.3 To determine the factors that influences one’s decision to rent or buy. Factors may include: Time, finances (budgets), short and long term costs, credit rating, anticipated future costs, current and future financial situation (new job or job loss). See Appendix A, C, I 9.4 To ascertain where to look for a house for sale 9.5 To compare the monetary costs of renting vs. buying a home 9.6 To determine the factors that dictate where you want to live Students should realize that there are many places where they could find out how to find houses for sale. See Appendix H for “Where do I look for a house?” handout. Students should brainstorm what they think the costs of running a house vs. an apartment are. Appendix D for monetary comparison and Appendix E Ask students to share some of their wants and needs from their lists. - 173 of 201- Depending on the size of the audience and the time available you may want to write responses on chart paper or white board. Answers may include location, schools, safety, friendly neighbors, and good investment. Appendix B for “Neighbourhood” handout 9.7 To determine the most suitable house or apartment to suit student needs Have students write down what is in their “dream house” looks like and what is inside of it. Appendix D & G Invite a real estate agent into the classroom. Students should make the arrangements. Prior to the visit, students should be involved in developing questions to stimulate discussion. 9.8 To understand the various professionals associated with real estate and their roles Students should also be involved in introducing the guest, interviewing, making the thank-you statement afterward, and sending a letter of thanks. Appendix K “What is a Real Estate Agent” handout Also see Appendix B for “Neighbourhood” handout and Appendix G for I’ve decided I want THIS house… now what?” handout. These can be used as basis for questions. * PRINCIPAL: How much; depends on your down payment 9.9 To define and understand the basics of Mortgages * INTEREST: How much the lender charges to borrow the money * TIME: 15-30 years * Longer time means smaller monthly payments but more interest * Shorter time means larger monthly payments but less - 174 of 201- interest * POINTS: A percentage of the loan. You can pay additional percentage at closing, and this will reduce the interest payments you make over the course of the loan. The two most common ways to borrow * FIXED-RATE (15, 20, 25, or 30 years) MORTGAGE: You agree to pay the same interest throughout. * ARM (adjustable-rate mortgage): At the beginning of the loan, you get a lower interest rate (between 1 and 3 percent less), but the figure can rise after the first year. Some mortgages will protect you from very high increases. The mortgage will limit how high the interest can go. This is called a cap. It is either 5 to 7 percent over market rate or a certain percentage. Appendix F & J “Mortgage Research” handout Students should become familiar with the following insurance terms: 9.10 To understand the terminology related to insurance. Liability Deductible Claim Premium Act of God Exclusions Depreciation Teachers may wish to have a brainstorming session with the students to see what the students already know and to come up with other insurance terms that are not listed above. 9.11 To understand the need for insurance. Students should become familiar with the concept that insurance is a form of risk management mainly used to avoid against the risk of a contingent loss. Students should understand the concept of opportunity - 175 of 201- cost. They should realize that though you may never need insurance the cost to you is much more manageable than should you have to rebuild your home or buy a new car. Students should become aware that there are two separate ways to insure you car in Saskatchewan. Students should become aware that everyone must insure their car through license plates. Students should become familiar with the deductible, liability and claims process with this option. 9.12 To understand the way car insurance works in Saskatchewan Students should also become aware of additional package policies. There are many companies that offer different packages in the market. Students should become aware of some of the basic options such as deductible, liability, glass coverage and replacement cost on new vehicles. Teachers should contact SGI to request a guest speaker to come in and give a presentation on Safe Driver Discounts, because many students are unfamiliar with surcharges and discounts, and how one accident can severely affect their driver rating. Students should become familiar with the different ways that home insurance premiums are based. 9.13 To understand the way home insurance is sold in Saskatchewan. Students should also know what is and what is not typically covered under home insurance, and the most common exclusions. Students should know how an “act of god” is dealt with by insurance companies. 9.14 To become familiar with different insurance companies in their area. Students should become familiar with the difference between an insurance broker and a insurance company. Students should be able to list some of the local insurance brokers in their area - 176 of 201- Students should be able to list some of the insurance companies that sell insurance in their area. 9.15 To evaluate different policies from different companies. A teacher may ask a local insurance broker to come in and show the students the different options they have available to them when purchasing car or home insurance. - 177 of 201- Key Terminology Adjustable-Rate loans: the rate you pay changes according to a set formula as interest rates fluctuate on the open market. Amenity: a feature of the home or property that serves as a benefit to the buyer but that is not necessary to its use; may be natural (like location, Woods, water) or man-made (like a swimming pool or garden). Borrower: a person who has been approved to receive a loan and is then obligated to repay it and any additional fees according to the loan terms. Budget: a detailed record of all income earned and spent during a specific period of time. Closing: also known as settlement, this is the time at which the property is formally sold and transferred from the seller to the buyer; it is at this time that the borrower takes on the loan obligation, pays all closing costs, and receives title from the seller. Closing costs: customary costs above and beyond the sale price of the property that must be paid to cover the transfer of ownership at closing; these costs generally vary by geographic location and are typically detailed to the borrower after submission of a loan application. Commission: an amount, usually a percentage of the property sales price, that is collected by a real estate professional as a fee for negotiating the transaction. Credit history: A record of an individual's current and past debt payments. Debt-to-income ratio: a comparison of gross income to housing and non-housing expenses; With the FHA, the-monthly mortgage payment should be no more than 29% of monthly gross income (before taxes) and the mortgage payment combined with nonhousing debts should not exceed 41% of income Deed: the document that transfers ownership of a property. - 178 of 201- Down payment: The amount of money a buyer agrees to give the seller when a sales agreement is signed. Complete financing is later secured with a lender. Fixed-rate mortgage: a mortgage with payments that remain the same throughout the life of the loan because the interest rate and other terms are fixed and do not change. Fixer-upper: A house that needs refurbishment or remodeling. It usually sells at a below-market price. Home inspection: an examination of the structure and mechanical systems to determine a home's safety; makes the potential homebuyer aware of any repairs that may be needed. Inflation: the number of dollars in circulation exceeds the amount of goods and services available for purchase; inflation results in a decrease in the dollar's value. Mortgage: a lien on the property that secures the Promise to repay a loan. Offer: indication by a potential buyer of a willingness to purchase a home at a specific price; generally put forth in writing. Pre-approve: lender commits to lend to a potential borrower; commitment remains as long as the borrower still meets the qualification requirements at the time of purchase. Principal: the amount borrowed from a lender; doesn't include interest or additional fees. Real estate agent: an individual who is licensed to negotiate and arrange real estate sales; works for a real estate broker. Survey: a property diagram that indicates legal boundaries, easements, encroachments, rights of way, improvement locations, etc. Claim: A request for a payment of a loss under an insurance policy Deductibles: Deductibles are the amounts you pay to cover a loss before you are entitled to payment by your insurer. Just about every policy has a deductible, usually ranging from $500 to $5000. The deductible is subtracted from the total amount paid by your - 179 of 201- insurer. For example, if your claim is $3,000 and your deductible is $500, you will pay $500 and the insurer will pay $2,500. Deductibles are designed to discourage small claims, since the purpose of insurance is to protect you from catastrophic losses, not minor inconveniences. Liability: Liability insurance protects against third party claims for bodily injury and property damage caused by you. Depreciation: Depreciation is a measure of the loss in value of an item over time resulting from wear or obsolescence. Acts of God: Acts of God are considered natural disasters that could not have been reasonably prevented or avoided. Most standard forms cover the perils of hurricanes and tornadoes. Lightning and hail are classified as named perils. Coverage for flood or earthquake is not automatic in standard policies but may be available in most cases for an additional premium. Flood or earthquake coverage is likely to be more expensive and difficult to obtain in areas susceptible to these perils. Exclusions: Exclusions are items, perils or situations that are not covered by your policy. Your insurer might exclude anything from long-term mold damage to natural disasters, computer data or high-speed watercraft. Other common exclusions include avoidable damage from termites or rodents, water seepage, frozen pipes, intentional damage and high value items such as art and jewelry. - 180 of 201- Appendix A Should I rent or buy? To evaluate whether renting or buying is best for you, let’s consider some of the pros and cons of each choice. Renting may be better if: You move often. Unless you live in one place at least five to seven years, you may lose money when selling your home. If you cannot sell, you may become a landlord by having to rent your home. You are unfamiliar with the area. Before buying a home, you may want to identify a neighborhood and rent there first to determine its ultimate long-term desirability. You are low on cash to cover the down payment and initial costs involved in purchasing a home. Renting now to save for a down payment and closing costs makes sense. You do not care to commit the time, effort, and expense of maintaining a home. 1. The costs of maintaining a home greatly exceed those of renting. If you cannot imagine not calling a landlord to fix the backed-up drain, you should rent. Buying may be better if: You are moving to an area enjoying high appreciation in the value of residential property. If an area’s homes are appreciating at rates of 5 to 10% a year, your home’s increased value should offset the costs of selling it should you be transferred. You can afford to buy a home that will allow you to itemize on your tax return and allow you to deduct other items like charitable contributions. It must be expensive enough that the interest paid and real estate taxes nearly equal or exceed the standard deduction. You own pets that may be frowned upon by landlords. It is often difficult, if not impossible, to rent when you have large dogs or multiple dogs and cats. You are ready for stability and a sense of community. Buying a home automatically commits you to an area and a neighborhood. You become interested in zoning laws, tax rates, the city’s/county’s plans for expansion and growth, and the appearance of your neighbor’s property. - 181 of 201- Additional Costs to home ownership Initial fees to be paid upon purchase are: 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. Legal fees including services at $575.00, dispersements at $200.00 and a transfer tax of $225.00, for a total of $1,000.00 Survey certificate of $500.00 Mortgage application fee of $75.00 Cost of appraisal at $200.00 Cost of appliances new or used Property tax and water & sewage adjustments Window coverings Moving expenses Hook-up fees for cable, telephone and power Miscellaneous (lawnmower, shovels, rakes, paint & painting supplies, ladders, tools, etc...) And once the home is purchased, the monthly expenses attributed to owning the property start. Civic Water & Sewer as well as other charges must be paid. So do property taxes and insurance. And then whether it's summer fall or winter, the property must be maintained. Lawn mowing, fall cleanup & snow removal are all chores that need to be done around the home and in many cases some expensive equipment may need to be purchased to do this maintenance. Then there's the maintenance that the house itself needs. Either way, if the homeowner does these task themselves to save money but winds up with less free time; or pays someone else to do it for them, these are all costs that should be examined prior to buying. In today's world, there are many kinds of places to live. Did you list any of these options? Single-family homes. These come in all sizes, and styles; they may be built on very large or very small pieces of land (lots); and they may be located in many different types of neighborhoods. Multiple family homes. These include apartments, duplexes, and town homes 1. Apartments, too, come in a variety of styles and sizes. Some are in highrise buildings, others are in smaller buildings with only a few units; some may be in a huge complex (many apartment buildings clustered together), others may be in a single building; apartments may be located in an area that also features other residential properties, or near a commercial center. Townhouses/duplexes. These are housing units, in which at least two units are attached, sharing a common wall. Townhouses often come in clusters of 4-8 units in one structure; duplexes are just two units. - 182 of 201- Mobile/modular homes. Few "mobile homes" today are actually mobile. Most of these units are set on some type of foundation or footing (pad) in a mobile-home park and are never moved. Some of these homes are quite spacious, but construction is generally less sturdy than in a traditional home. However, they offer a relatively low-price option for someone who wants to own a home. What Do You Want? Let's take a look at your housing needs. Use this checklist to help determine what kind of housing you should consider. Space needs: How many bedrooms do you need? How many bathrooms? Special purpose rooms desired: Recreation/TV Office/study Sewing/crafts/hobby room How much storage space/closet space? Do you need A garage/carport? Parking space(s)? Room for pets? Space for gardening/flowers? Room for play/children? Other outdoors space? Factors for selecting a home: There are other factors to consider in deciding what type of housing you want. [length of time you will live there] [Future housing needs--parents, children, etc.] [distance to work] [medical facilities] [places of worship] [construction of housing] [access to schools/daycare] [location - neighborhood, city, etc.] [fire & police protection] [shopping & recreational facilities] [city services] [new/older home] - 183 of 201- Appendix B Consider the following when looking for a neighborhood: The “Golden Rule of Real Estate” - location, location, and location! However, only you can decide which location is good for you. Do you want to be close to work, to shopping, to public transportation? Take a tour of different neighborhoods. If you have the opportunity to take a househunting trip, find a good city map and the classified ads section of the local newspaper. Survey prospective neighborhoods by selecting a dozen homes from the ads, then make a day of visiting them. The idea here isn’t to find “the” house, but to narrow your search to the most desirable neighborhood. Remember it’s much easier to fix up a house than a neighborhood. Contact a licensed real estate agent to help you with this, especially if you are unfamiliar with the area. Consider your family’s needs. Considerations in this area include driving time to work, shopping, recreation facilities, medical care, places of worship, and the availability of public transportation. Safety. Talk to potential neighbors in various parts of town and in specific neighborhoods in which you might be interested. Ask the local police department for comparative crime statistics. School Districts. This will be easier if you have determined your definition of a “good” district and understand your children’s individual needs. Even if you don’t have schoolaged children, don’t overlook the quality of the school district. This factor may figure prominently in the resale value of your home. High concentration of military families. These neighborhoods have established themselves as attractive to military families. With a steady turnover of incoming and outgoing military families, it may make it easier to sell your home when the time comes. Neighborhood Feel or “Ambiance” Ask people about what they like - or dislike- about where they live, and the first comment is usually about the feel and character of their neighborhood. Don’t underestimate the impact the local area can have on your enjoyment of a property. Here’s how to evaluate a prospective neighborhood: 1. Try to visit the neighborhood you’re considering at different times of the week during work hours, in the evening, and on weekends. 2. Don’t just drive around. Get out of your car and walk. You’ll see and hear things that you might otherwise miss. 3. People are generally more than happy to share their experience of where they live. - 184 of 201- 4. Don’t be shy. Ask people out working in their yards or washing their car what they think about the area. 5. Check to see if there are children playing outside unattended. A child playing is often an indication of how safe their parents feel. 6. Is there too much traffic? Being next to an interstate may make it easier to get to work but it also brings noise and congestion. 7. Consider the noise level. Can you hear airplanes or trains? What about sirens? Are those children who are playing outside going to make you smile or drive you nuts? 8. How does the neighborhood look? Are there public utility substations nearby? 9. What about broadcasting towers or junkyards? Even that park that you’re so happy to be close to might have lights for night games. In addition, you should consider the availability, location, and condition of the following services and amenities: Sidewalks Parks Community centers Sport facilities Playgrounds Curbside garbage and recycling pickup Home mail delivery Snow removal School bus stops - 185 of 201- Appendix C Pros and Cons of Renting: Now that you know the things to consider when deciding what housing will fit your needs, lets take a look at the pros and cons of renting versus buying. Renting has advantages for most people at some point in their lives. This is especially true when you are starting out on your own as a young, single adult. As we noted above, renting an apartment involves no responsibility for repairs, maintenance, and other aspects of home ownership that can be both costly and time-consuming. Rental complexes may also provide many of the recreational facilities you would like, such as a swimming pool and tennis court. Apartments and other rental units often provide laundry facilities, which would save you the initial expense of purchasing laundry equipment. Another advantage of renting is that it provides more mobility or flexibility. As a young person, you are more likely to move rather frequently due to job changes and family changes (getting married, having children), etc. It is easier to move quickly when you are renting, because leases for rentals are easier to get out of than selling a home. A lease is a contract between the landlord and the tenant indicating that the tenant has the right to use a particular living unit for a period of time, such as one year. For this right, the tenant promises to pay the landlord a specified amount of rent over the period of time of the rental. Most leases will allow you to "buy out" of the lease by paying a penalty (often an additional 1-2 month's rent) if the lease is not up when you want to move. In some cases, the landlord will require no additional rent when you move out early if another renter suitable to the landlord is found who will assume your lease. Selling a home when you decide to move is usually a much longer process, taking months and sometimes years. The length of time depends on a number of factors including the available supply and demand for homes in an area and the relative demand for the type of house that you put on the market. For example, if you own a two bedroom older home, and that type of house is not currently popular in your area, your house will likely not be sold very quickly. Another major advantage of renting is that it doesn't require a large outlay of cash. Most rentals require a security deposit (usually equal to 2-3 month's rent), but that is much less than is normally needed for a down payment when buying a home. Monthly cash costs may also be reduced, as utilities may be included in your rent payment. There are, of course, disadvantages to renting. Some were mentioned in the section on "housing needs." Can you identify those? List them here: A major disadvantage of renting is lack of control over the property. The owners/managers of the property are responsible for repairs and general upkeep; if they do not do this well and promptly, you might be stuck with unpleasant (or even unsafe) living conditions (from leaking faucets to broken windows) for some period of time. - 186 of 201- Property owners can raise the rent (with proper notice), making your costs higher. They can also put restrictions on the property, such as not allowing children or pets, and not permitting you to do redecorating. Renting also provides no tax or equity benefits for you. Although you are helping pay the owner's property taxes through your rent, you cannot claim any deduction for these taxes on your tax return. The owner is also gaining equity in his/her property, but you are not. Equity is increased value in any property you own. But, as a renter, you are not building any equity. Pros and Cons of Buying a Home: We've already discussed some advantages of buying a home. List the advantages of buying you already know: Many of the advantages of home ownership have to do with your feelings - pride of ownership; freedom to decorate; landscape and maintain the place to your tastes; security and independence. All of these are aspects of control - your control over the property in which you live. But the biggest advantage of home ownership might be financial. There are several financial advantages including equity; tax deduction for mortgage, interest and property tax deductions. Building up financial equity in a home is one benefit of home ownership. Since most homes increase in value over time, the owner's equity increases. For example, if you buy a home for $180,000 and its market value increases to $200,000 in three years, the difference of $20,000 is an increase in your owner's equity. Of course, the housing market (and economic conditions) vary, so, like any investment, there is no guaranteed return. Another way in which buyers increase their equity is through paying off their debt on the house. Most people do not buy their homes with cash. Instead, they take out a mortgage (debt) on the house. Generally, they make a payment on the mortgage each month, similar to the payments make. With home ownership, though, part of that monthly payment goes toward paying down the debt. As they pay down the debt, buyers gain more equity in their home. Tax benefits are the other advantage of home ownership. In Lesson 6, we will discuss the cost of borrowing money to buy a home. That cost is "mortgage interest" - the money you pay for the use of someone else's money (usually a financial institution's) when you borrow funds to buy a house. Although mortgage interest is a large part of your housing payment, you can deduct this interest from your taxable income on your federal income tax return and (in some states) on your state income tax return. This can save you a fairly substantial amount of income tax. In addition, you will pay property taxes on a home that you own. Those property taxes are also deductible from taxable income on your federal income tax return and some state income tax returns, and thus offer you additional income tax savings. - 187 of 201- Appendix D Should you rent or buy? Owning a home is the ultimate goal for many of us, but many people think they can't afford to buy or own a home. Actually, renting is often as expensive as owning in the short term and more expensive over the long haul. Here's why... The long-term financial benefits of buying a home are so compelling; it makes sense for most people to buy as soon as they have saved the minimum down payment. Even if the mortgage payment is more than your current rent, it is worth scrimping on non-essentials now to end up with more in built up equity, as opposed to wasted rent money. How much home will your rent buy you? Rent vs. Mortgage. Monthly Rent Purchase Price* Loan Amount House (Principal + Interest) Taxes and PMI** Monthly Mortgage Payment Annual Savings $1,100 $145,000 $137,750 $761 $304 $1,065 $420 $1,500 $200,000 $190,000 $1,049 $349 $1,398 $1,224 $1,800 $250,000 $237,500 $1,311 $415 $1,726 $888 $2,300 $325,000 $308,750 $1,705 $502 $2,207 $1,116 $3,000 $400,000 $380,000 $2,098 $662 $2,760 $2,880 *5% down, based on the 5/1 Adjustable Rate of 5.25% APR with Zero Points. - 188 of 201- Appendix E Use the table below to weigh each aspect carefully and to get a clear, unemotional picture of the financial pros and cons of renting and buying. Renting Buying Taxes Sorry, your landlord will reap the tax breaks. Depending on your situation, your tax savings can be significant. Equity You’re not getting it. Once that rent money is gone, it’s gone. Paying the principal amount of your mortgage each month is in effect a "forced savings" over time, you’ll accumulate an amount you can borrow from, or convert to cash upon selling. Investment value You won’t benefit from any increase in the value of the property you rent. It may go up or down, but given historical trends, you’re more likely to gain than loose. Interest costs No worries here. Depending on your mortgage terms, you’ll likely pay a huge amount of interest over the life of the mortgage often much more than the amount of the mortgage itself. Flexibility If you want out, just move when the lease is up. If you want out, you need to go through the time consuming and expensive selling process. Length of stay If your job requires you to move a lot, or if you’re otherwise not ready to commit to one place, renting makes financial sense. Given the costs of buying and selling, you generally need to keep a home for at least a year in order to avoid losing equity. Maintenance It’s not generally something you need to worry about. You need to either do the work, or pay someone else to do it. Monthly costs These are fixed aside from annual rent increases, you know each month what your outlay will be. These are variable there may be months when you have significant repair or maintenance costs. Inflation impact Rents typically rise each year. Because your payments remain the same for the life of the mortgage (at - 189 of 201- least for fixed interest loans), you’re repaying it with ever cheaper dollars. Cash up front An initial deposit is usually required, but is small compared to most mortgage down payments. Your mortgage down payment and closing costs can be a major chunk of change. Security You have no guarantees that your landlord will always renew your lease. As long as you pay the mortgage, your housing’s secure. Fail to make payments, however, and you’ll face the possibility of foreclosure and loss of your house. Capital gains taxes You won’t realize capital gains, so it’s not an issue. Depending on your situation, most or all of the capital gains you realize when you sell your house will be taxfree. Future housing costs Rent never ends. Staying put and paying a mortgage long enough gives you the possibility of "free" housing. Improvements If you’re able to make any improvements at all, you’ll likely pay for it, but the increase in the property’s value will go to the landlord. Remodel and redecorate to your heart’s content, and all the increase in your home’s value is yours to keep. - 190 of 201- Appendix F Fixed-Rate loans A fixed-rate mortgage is so called because its interest rate doesn't change over the life of the loan, no matter what rates do on the open market. Many people feel more comfortable with a fixed rate, because they know their monthly mortgage payments will remain steady over the years, making at least one aspect of their monthly cash flow predictable. The downside is that you pay for that comfort: Lenders charge a higher rate of interest for fixed-rate loans. Why? Because they figure that if interest rates shoot up, they lose the opportunity to make more money on the funds they are lending you. The standard fixed loan lasts for 30 years, but if you can handle higher payments and want to build up your equity in your home faster, you can opt for a 15-year fixed. With a 15-year, you'll get a lower rate and pay much less interest over the life of the loan. The payments each month, however, will be quite a bit higher since they aren't being stretched over so long a period. A fixed rate makes the most sense for those who plan to stay put in their new home for a long time. You pay a little more in interest, but it is stretched over a longer period so the monthly effect can be minimal. And if you're buying when rates are low, locking in a good deal is probably worth it. Adjustable-Rate loans Adjustable-rate loans get their name because the rate you pay changes according to a set formula as interest rates fluctuate on the open market. As noted above, the upside is that lenders charge a lower rate for such loans because you are taking on some of the interestrate risk. This makes your monthly payments lower -- at least in the beginning. Such loans provide a way for many buyers to afford a larger loan amount for a given monthly payment. An adjustable works out wonderfully if rates drop -- something you should never count on. But watch out if interest rates rise. In a year or two, your payments could far exceed what you would have paid for a 30-year fixed. The trick with adjustable-rate loans is to tailor the loan to your needs. Generally, the cheapest rate out there is on a one-year adjustable. (Well, yes, there are even cheaper loans that adjust monthly, but those are too esoteric for most buyers.) With a one-year, your rate can change annually, making these loans particularly risky. Lenders often try to draw you in with "teaser" rates that are especially cheap for the first year, but which will almost certainly jump up the next year. There is a limit to how much an adjustable-rate loan can adjust, however. Lenders limit the amount the rate can be raised, often to no more than two points a year, with a lifetime cap of six points. Moreover, if you are willing to endure the hassle and expense of refinancing after a year, it's possible you'll come out ahead. - 191 of 201- A slightly more expensive option is what's known as a "delayed adjustable." When you see "3-1 adjustable" or "5-1 adjustable" it means that the loan stays fixed for three or five years and then resets annually. The same pattern holds for a 7-1 or a 10-1; the longer the fixed period, the higher the rate. The idea is to match the loan to the amount of time you plan to stay in the house. For instance, if you expect to move after three years, a 3-1 is a great option. After 10 years, you might as well opt for a fixed rate. The price difference will be minimal. "How much cash am I going to have to produce upfront?" These days, not much. Ideally, you would have enough cash for a 20% down payment, closing costs equal to about 3% to 5% of the purchase price, and enough left over to cover two or three months of monthly housing expenses. That gives you a big chunk of equity in your house upfront and makes the lender happy -- something that usually translates into a better deal. The trouble is, coming up with that much cash can be all but impossible for many first-time buyers. After all, we're talking $40,000 on a $150,000 loan or $70,000 on a $250,000 mortgage. If you do not have a 20% down payment, you typically have to insure the mortgage, and that costs typically three cents on each dollar of house value. The good news is that lenders over the last couple of years have become increasingly willing to finance as much as 95% or even 97% of a home. The reason: They can now unload the risk of such loans onto somebody else. To limit their exposure, many lenders regularly sell their loans to the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae), which then bundles them into securities which are eventually sold to investors. It used to be that Fannie Mae only would buy loans for 80% financing. But it recently standardized the lending criteria for 97% financing and will now buy these loans, making lenders much more willing to provide them to you. It's now common for first-time buyers to put down only 5%, or $7,500 on a $150,000 loan. While this sounds enticing, remember that puny down payments have their price. First of all, you start with very little equity in your home. Also, if you don't have 20% to put down, you'll probably have to ante up for mortgage insurance (which protects the bank against default and can top $1,000 a year if you put 5% down on a $200,000 loan). If you are buying in an urban area or have low to moderate income, look into programs offered by your city or state that provide below-market loans with little or no down payment required. If you're really cash-strapped, you can get 100% financing by "piggybacking" a second loan equal to 20% of the purchase price on top of your 80% loan. But that 20% second mortgage will come at a much higher rate. - 192 of 201- Appendix G I’ve decided I want THIS house… now what? Once you have decided on an initial offering price, you are ready to submit a “purchase and sale agreement” to the real estate agent. This is a signed offer to purchase the house for a given price under specified terms. You should be sure you understand all the terms of the contract before you sign it and submit the offer. Real estate agents are required by law to deliver all offers to the seller, even if an offer is far below the seller’s asking price. The purchase and sale agreement is a legally binding offer to purchase a property. It should include at least the following: • Complete legal description of the property; • Amount of the deposit accompanying the offer; • Offering price; • Size of the intended down payment and how the remainder of the purchase will be financed (including the maximum interest rate your clients are willing to pay); • Personal property included. To avoid any misunderstandings or surprises, the contract should list everything that the owner has said will stay with the house or that your clients want the owner to leave behind. Advise your clients not to rely on the seller’s verbal agreement that specific appliances or personal property are included in the sale; • Proposed closing date and occupancy date. The contract may include a provision that the seller will pay rent on a daily basis in the event they haven’t moved out by the agreed-upon date (usually the closing date); • Closing costs to be paid by the seller (see Chapter 5 for details); • Clear title. The contract should state that the purchase is subject to the buyer receiving clear title to the property. Clear title means there are no legal questions as to who owns the property. • All systems in working order. Your clients may want to stipulate that the sellers are responsible for ensuring that the plumbing, heating, mechanical, and electrical systems are in working order at closing; • Length of time the offer is valid (generally three to five days); and • Any contingencies (may include home inspection, property assessment, gas line check etc.) Home buyers are usually expected to submit a “good faith” payment with the offer to show the seller that they are serious about buying the house. There is no set amount, and what is customary differs by location. The deposit check should be made out to the real estate firm that is handling the sale, not to the seller. The earnest money is deposited in an escrow account to be returned to your clients if the seller does not accept their offer within a specified number of days. Be aware that you may forfeit this money if your offer is accepted by the seller and then you decide to back out of the deal. - 193 of 201- Appendix H Where do I look for a house? You should check out as many leads as possible about houses that are for sale. This may include the following: Word of mouth You should let your family, friends and acquaintances know that you’re in the market for a house. “For sale” signs Driving or walking around in search of “for sale” signs may be worthwhile, particularly if you have a good idea of what neighborhood you are interested in. This is a particularly good way to find houses being sold by the owners. Newspaper ads Classified ads in local newspapers are another good source of leads. “Open houses” also are announced in the real estate section, and you can do some initial shopping and comparative pricing by spending weekend afternoons looking at houses being shown by real estate sales professionals. Shoppers’ guides Home finders’ directories featuring pictures and brief descriptions of houses currently on the market may be available at supermarkets, convenience stores, and newsstands. Helping Your Clients Shop for a Home The Internet There are many Web sites that show property listings in Saskatchewan. You can search by location, property types, and specific features. Foreclosure sales When homeowners fail to pay their mortgage, the lender may foreclose and resell the house in order to recover the unpaid loan amount. Often such homes are sold for a belowmarket price. - 194 of 201- Appendix I Budgeting for a house (see Module 5 for budgeting) If you want to buy a house, start by estimating what you can afford and making a budget to buy. Many prospective buyers find it difficult to accumulate enough cash for a down payment, especially if they are saddled with heavy debt. With some discipline and creative strategies, you can probably come up with more cash than you think. Check your current finances and investigate ways to save and raise extra funds. 1. Write down your monthly income, savings, and spending. If you have a lot of high-interest credit debt, try to move your balances to cheaper cards and plan to spend a year paying off as much of that debt as possible. 2. Identify your long-term financial goals. Owning a house may be one, saving enough for retirement may be another. 3. Make a home-buying savings plan. Open a savings account just for this purpose and make regular deposits, even if you put aside just $20 a week. 4. Look for other sources of down payment funds, such as a Roth Individual Retirement Account (IRA). First-time buyers now have access to $10,000 of these funds penalty-free under certain conditions. 5. Cut back on non-essential spending. Your friends and relatives will understand that you can't spend $20 to go to dinner and the movies if you say you're saving to buy a house. Your children will understand, too. In fact, saving to buy a house can be a family activity. 6. Make saving for a house fun. Chart your progress on paper and post it somewhere to remind yourself of your goal. - 195 of 201- Appendix J Mortgage Research Lender #1 Lender #2 Lender #3 1. Lender and contact information: 2. Mortgage type (fixed rate, ARM): Length of loan: 3. Interest rate and points: Quoted rate: Date of quote: Number of points for this rate: 4. Down payment: Minimum down payment needed: 5. Early repayment penalties: Prepayment penalty on the mortgage loan? If yes, how much? 6. Closing costs and fees: Credit report fee: Application fee: Appraisal fee: Other costs: 7. Loan processing time: Locked-in interest rate availability: - 196 of 201- How long lock-in lasts: Time needed after approval to get money: 8. Lock-ins: When lock-ins are available: Any charge for lock-in? What happens if rates drop? 9. Starting interest rate: 10. Rate adjustments: Time before interest? Rate changes? Frequency of rate changes after that? ADJUSTMENT CAPS: Maximum amount the rate can change at one time? Total amount rate can change over the term of the loan? 11. Change to fixed rate: Can ARM be turned to fixed rate? When? Is there a fee for change? - 197 of 201- Appendix K What is a Real Estate Agent? Although these sources will help your clients get started, usually the most efficient method of shopping for a house is to consult a real estate agent. It is important that you understand the relationship between a home buyer and a real estate agent. The buyer typically pays nothing for the agent’s services. Instead, the agent is paid by the seller (usually a commission based on the sales price of the home) and therefore represents the seller’s interest in the transaction. It may be to your advantage to find a real estate professional who will act as a buyer’s agent — that is, who will represent their own interests. They should know in advance how the buyer’s agent is paid. Will they be charged a commission? Or will the buyer’s and seller’s agents split the commission paid by the seller? A real estate agent can provide your clients with an array of services, including the following: • help determine how much they can afford to spend on a house; • generate computer printouts of houses that meet your clients’ specifications; • show your clients houses that meet their requirements; • provide information about communities and neighborhoods, including the prices and features of houses in the area, location of schools, property tax rates, unusual building code regulations, and availability of community services; • present your clients’ purchase offer to the seller; and • provide referrals to mortgage lenders, settlement agents, professional home inspectors, and title companies. - 198 of 201- Appendix L Advantages of Owning a Home If you are thinking about buying a house, consider the following advantages: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. A house is a form of forced savings (you make payments on an asset that may grow in value--many families would never accumulate assets otherwise). Homeowners often have a sense of pride and status in home and community. A homeowner may have a better credit rating (equity in a home improves the credit status of the family and can be used as collateral for an emergency loan). Mortgage payments contribute to an investment, particularly if the property is located where it increases in value over a period of years. Monthly payments remain relatively constant for many years (fixed loan), thus housing costs are stabilized because present and future costs can be estimated and planned. Interest on mortgage monies and taxes are legitimate income tax deductions. The house may increase in value, resulting in a significant gain in net worth. Ownership may contribute to security, especially in retirement years when income normally decreases. A homeowner can borrow against his/her equity, as the value of the house increases against what is owed on it. More space may be available for family members and their activities. A homeowner has freedom to make improvements and changes to the house and surroundings as desired (although a development or association may have restrictions and prohibitions). Home ownership can contribute to the general well-being and sense of "roots" of the family, especially for children. Homeowners generally are concerned about community affairs and how they may affect their property. - 199 of 201- Appendix M Disadvantages of Owning a Home The disadvantages of home ownership may outweigh the advantages for some people because: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. A substantial down payment is needed. A house requires a big commitment in time, emotions, and money. The house may decrease in value if the neighborhood deteriorates or changes quickly; thus resale may be a problem. The homeowner may have limited money for other purchases or activities since his or her money is tied up in the house. Maintenance and repairs may be costly and take a great deal of time and effort. Owning a house requires money for insurance, and a loss of the house as a result of a natural disaster (tornado, flood, hurricane) could mean a serious financial burden. Some families have difficulty budgeting for maintenance, repairs, home improvements, and/or home ownership dues. Real property taxes could increase dramatically. Total housing costs may take too much of the budget, resulting in potential cash flow problems. The family may have higher moving-in costs as new items may have to be purchased for a house. The family may feel less secure if neighbors are not near. The house may be too large after children leave home. Security may be a problem if you travel a lot. Unexpected loss of income due to job termination or unemployment may limit money available for home ownership costs. - 200 of 201- Resources The Investment FAQ. http://invest-faq.com/articles/real-es-rent-vs-buy.html Buying your First Home WebQuest. http://faculty.ncwc.edu/MBrooks/310/Spring04/Kimberly/Final%20Webquest.htm Christine Clay's Buying a Home Web Quest. http://coe.west.asu.edu/students/cclay/webquest.htm The Economics of Homebuying. http://www.econedlink.org/lessons/index.cfm?lesson=NN121&page=teacher Home Buying Readiness Sourcebook. http://alri.org/fmf/tools/index.html Money Management. http://alri.org/fmf/tools/index.html Helping your clients shop for a home. http://www.fanniemae.com/global/pdf/housingcommdev/resourceshomeed/chapter3.pdf;j sessionid=TBYEDKFNK2AWLJ2FECHSFGA Albertabroker.com http://www.albertabroker.com/generalinsuranceinformation/basicinsuranceterms/tabid/67 /Default.aspx SGI Website - http://www.sgi.sk.ca/ - 201 of 201-