White Paper DRAFT Committee Report: The Sustainability Institute Initiative at WWU April 22, 2011 Table of Contents Executive Summary ......................................................................................................................... 3 Part I: Sustainability in Higher Education ....................................................................................... 6 Characteristics ..................................................................................................................... 7 Significance ........................................................................................................................ 8 Trends ................................................................................................................................. 9 Part II: Sustainability at Western ..................................................................................................... 9 Mission and Strategic Goals ............................................................................................. 10 Campus Operations and Business Practices...................................................................... 11 Curriculum ........................................................................................................................ 13 Programs ........................................................................................................................... 14 Transdisciplinary Initiatives.............................................................................................. 15 Courses.............................................................................................................................. 16 Learning Centers ............................................................................................................... 17 Research ............................................................................................................................ 18 Student Initiatives ............................................................................................................. 18 Regional and Global Partners ........................................................................................... 19 Memberships and Affiliations........................................................................................... 20 Part III: Current Challenges at Western ......................................................................................... 20 Financial............................................................................................................................ 20 Structural ........................................................................................................................... 21 Student Access and Defining Sustainability ..................................................................... 21 Part IV: The Sustainability Initiative at Western ........................................................................... 22 Background ....................................................................................................................... 22 Sustainability Academy .................................................................................................... 23 Sustainability Institute Initiative ....................................................................................... 24 Part V: Rationale for The Sustainability Institute at Western ........................................................ 27 Teaching............................................................................................................................ 27 Sustainability Literacy Course Sequence .......................................................................... 28 Sustainability Internship Program..................................................................................... 28 Sustainability Courses and Research ................................................................................ 29 Community Outreach ........................................................................................................ 30 Maintaining Organizational Frameworks ......................................................................... 31 Fundraising ....................................................................................................................... 32 Part VI: Considerations for Funding .............................................................................................. 31 Part VII: Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 32 List of Figures ................................................................................................................................ 35 List of Appendices ......................................................................................................................... 35 2 Executive Summary 10 Recommendations for Establishing the WWU Institute of Sustainability The Institute proposal calls for a phased-in approach over the next one or two biennium. The next, or second phase, proposes establishing a coordinator or director position. In addition, honoraria support is proposed for faculty involved in the sustainability literacy courses, with a small amount for student support. Each program/project and initiative was cost estimated separately. The total funding figure for a fully established Institute was endowment in the amount of $2.5 million or $100,000 annually for the biennium. Provost Office Director, Sustainability Institute Initiative Deans, Colleges Collaboration s Affiliated Faculty Team Teaching Collaborations Departmental Faculty Sustainability Student Advising Opportunities Departmental Courses Literacy I, II, III GUR Feeder Courses Majors and Minors Research Interdisciplinarity & Funding Research Outreach Sustainability & Western Brand Outreach Sustainability Practices and Applied Learning Strategies Figure 1: Current Activities of the Sustainability Institute For Western to continue its progress toward being recognized for its innovative sustainability efforts, our recommendation is for the development of the Sustainability Institute at Western that will comprehensively focus Western’s sustainability efforts in the three common higher education functions of education, research, and community outreach. The Sustainability Institute seeks to foster the collaborative, interdisciplinary education of critical thinkers who will lead, inspire, and engage their communities toward a sustainable world. 3 Recommendation One: Interim Director of Institute Successful models of institutes of sustainability throughout the country build around a senior faculty member who brings experience and strong expertise to the teaching and scholarship of sustainability. Such an individual integrates classroom and research strengths with the ability to bridge across departments and colleges. The work of the director would be to interrelate the broad spectrum of external constituencies that harbor desires for assistance and educational support for their private and public enterprises. Support is recommended in the form of a salary and compensation base for the director/senior professor and course release similar to other departmental chair positions. Recommendation Two: Sustainability General Education Sequence For the integrative “interdisciplinarity” of sustainability to be adequately addressed at Western, new models for course development must be supported and further developed. Currently, the ways in which new courses and/or programs are initiated makes integrated interdisciplinary course development difficult. The fact that current curriculum and/or program proposals must be spearheaded from within individual Departments, is challenging to the inherently interdisciplinary nature of sustainability related inquiry. The Sustainability Institute advocates for developing new models for course and/or program initiation to allow for an alternative process that enables integrated. For example, the successfully piloted sustainability general education sequence that includes Sustainability Literacy I, II, and III are currently offered as experimental courses through Huxley. The experiential and integral structure of the course sequence includes the participation of over 30 faculty from every college and 15 different disciplines. This course sequence lays the groundwork for students to major or minor in sustainability-related programs. With the addition of 2-3 existing companion courses to compliment the Sustainability Literacy sequence, an interdisciplinary General Education sequence can be offered to Western students. Because of the new forms of pedagogical approaches taken in these courses, we recommend support for a Faculty Sustainability Curriculum Coordinator, for participating faculty honoraria, and for student teaching assistance. Recommendation Three: Sustainability Curriculum Development Over 85 Western faculty representing all colleges at WWU have been conducting classes and/or engaging in the research of sustainability in their fields for years. Support for faculty engaged in sustainability curriculum development is recommended in the form of honoraria, fellowships, or release time. Our vision of sustainability education at Western is to build new models for integrated and active learning by using the best available practices in student learning and engagement, which demands the redesign of courses and curricula through a broad sustainability agenda that transcends curricular constraints that currently isolate content knowledge from broader student-learning goals. 4 Recommendation Four: Student Support We recommend the Institute’s coordination of student research under work study, internships, class projects, and leadership opportunities to further individual and team student learning in applied sustainability research. Recommendation Five: Research Initiatives and Knowledge Creation The scope of sustainability research at Western is multi-faceted and portrays a commitment to the multidisciplinary collaborative style of problem solving essential to addressing environmental, social, and economic needs. Within this framework lies the need to further define what and how sustainability research contributes to the varied disciplines and professions that Western engages. Equally as timely is the need for Western to collect data regarding the market demand for sustainability education in regards to graduate employment for students and in relationship to global scholarship for students and faculty. The Sustainability Institute would serve as a resource for developing and sharing applied research that informs the practices of faculty and students. Support is recommended to provide grants to faculty for the development of applied research projects that investigate the critical academic and societal questions invoked by sustainability practices in higher education Recommendation Six: Service Learning and Local and Global Partnerships Because sustainability is more a way of thinking and behaving than a science, there is a need for innovative and flexible pathways to provide students and faculty opportunities for global study and collaboration. In addition to the many opportunities available at Western for students to engage in actionlearning locally and globally, there has been an enormous increase in sustainability education programs offered outside of Western that students are increasingly integrating into their course of study through study abroad programs or independent learning credits. In addition to student interest in these emerging programs of study, faculty teaching sustainability-related topics understand the need for global partnerships that can be facilitated through regional projects facilitated through Western that are aligned with global initiatives. We recommend the Sustainability Institute as a hub where these partnerships can be identified, assessed, and integrated among faculty and students. Recommendation Seven: Public Model of Sustainability Education We are a sustainability leader in many ways among state universities like us, but we are not as competitive in our initiatives as private colleges and universities. One of the criteria for a public model of sustainability education is accessibility, which may require Western to be creative with credits, enrollment, extended education, and tuition-based programs. We recommend the Sustainability Institute as a resource for conducting up-to-date research on existing models at other state universities and doing benefit-analysis for incorporating similar models at Western based on student initiated feedback. Recommendation Eight: Outreach As part of their market and branding research two years ago, the Lyric company of Seattle highlighted the result of their research under five categories. In each of the five, sustainability was a focal point for Lyrics recommendations. There is a “powerful desire to make a difference and have an impact... in the 5 community… (and) for the environment”. “The Western Hook” is sustainability and environmental stewardship (which is) embedded deeply in the consciousness with opportunities for hands-on student involvement. The Institute can play a key role in coordinating efforts of making community connections between service learning opportunities and academic internships and projects and public and private partners in matters related to sustainable solutions. Recommendation Nine: Sustainability Recognition and Promotional Development Although Western has a long tradition of being a leader in environmental education and stewardship, further recognition and communication of Western Sustainability amidst the larger global conversation on sustainability education is necessary. The Institute would serve as a clearinghouse of programs and projects, faculty expertise, and student involvement for articulating how these goals are supported through sustainability initiatives at Western. The Sustainability Institute would also serve as a boundary-spanning entity reaching across colleges and out into governments, businesses, non-profits, and institutions to articulate collaborative efforts and potential partnerships toward reimagining and redesigning higher education to meet the context of the 21st century. Recommendation Ten: Capitalize on Funding Opportunities The broadest need for the development of the Sustainability Institute is to capitalize on the growing awareness among all sectors of society that in order to meet the great challenges of the 21st century there needs to be more sustainable thinking and practices. Colleges and universities are uniquely positioned to bring together a collective of complimentary resources and knowledge particularly suited to solving large complex issues like sustainability. The colleges and universities that have broadly and deeply embraced sustainability efforts are succeeding in reputation and fund-raising. They have become the recognized leaders in the race to infuse the values of sustainability into their institutional culture; they have moved sustainability from good intentions to realizing the vision of meeting the challenges of this century. Western’s Institute of Sustainability has the potential to move an already strong operational program and expand Western’s fundraising efforts to serve a public increasingly looking for answers and the faculty, students, and institutions that seek to lead the efforts to find the answers. Part I: Sustainability in Higher Education With the increasing emphasis on sustainability in modern business culture and changes in personal lives, it has become clear that the higher education sector represents one of the greatest opportunities to advance a more sustainable society. To appreciate the impact of this opportunity, consider the scope of higher education’s annual expenditures in purchasing, employment, enrollment, building construction, and energy consumption. Higher education is also the incubator for future leaders, as well as a site for research, innovation, and demonstration for a variety of sustainable practices. Higher education prepares most of the professionals who lead and influence society. As a public institution, it creates significant economic, social, and environmental footprints. It also has the unique freedom derived from academic pursuit, as well as the critical mass and diversity of skills to develop new ideas and to engage in bold experimentation in sustainable business and living practices. Higher education provides the ideal context 6 for conducting critical research and helping develop new ideas and technologies, as well as raise the level of discourse regarding societal challenges.1 Characteristics In a 2010 International Residential Training Workshop on Universities & Education for Sustainable Development held in Greece, the principles and methods for sustainability in higher education were outlined and included a commitment by faculty, staff, governance, and operations to promote socially just, economically prosperous, and environmentally benign principles to create what they refer to as a “whole institute approach” to sustainability. 2 A whole institute approach to sustainability in higher education generally involves a multi-tiered strategy of Curriculum, Research and Operations. While there has been a recent increase in popular discourse on sustainability, the 3 pillars of sustainability shown in Figure 3—economic, social, and environmental—are not a new challenge to higher education. Figure 3: Sustainability Triad: The Triple Bottom Line Teaching and research in higher education has been instrumental in advancing sustainability education in regards to social, economic, and environmental impacts. However, a whole institute approach to sustainability asks higher education to acknowledge the intricate connections between social, economic, and environmental systems, and to consider the impact an interconnected approach to curriculum and research will have on the university’s core business practices. Curriculum and research that address sustainability is at the nexus of social, economic, and environmental concerns. Therefore, teachers and 1 The Sustainability Movement in Higher Education: An Overview. by James L. Elder with Jean MacGregor, December, 2008 2 Sustainable Mediterranean, Residential Training Workshop on Universities & Education for Sustainable Development. Amfissa, Greece 23-28 May 2010. 7 researchers committed to sustainability education often find themselves working across increasingly diverse subject areas to analyze issues, evaluate actions, and implement positive change. In higher education, such transdisciplinary inquiry is understood as the “sustainability imperative,” which requires experimental and extended teaching and learning models that explore questions, problems, or issues too broad to be adequately studied within a single discipline or even a university. The sustainability imperative aims at a complex understanding of the inherent transdisciplinary nature of knowledge. A summary of literature on the topic of sustainability in higher education, establishes the following criteria for sustainability education: Regional projects integrated with global initiatives; Orientation toward systems or integrated thinking; Commitment to the multi-disciplinary collaborative style of problem solving essential to addressing environmental, social and economic needs; Collaboration with businesses, industries, governments, and NGOS worldwide; and Multi-disciplinary teaching and research at the intersection of environmental, economic, and social goals. In addition to the teaching, learning, and development of concepts and tools for sustainability education, sustainability methods in higher education also requires policy and program implementation to encourage collaboration between disciplines, with other colleges and universities, and within local and global communities. In comparison, the role of operations in advancing sustainability in higher education initiatives are more easily achieved within existing models of operations within universities and typically involves reducing overhead and environmental costs through innovations regarding energy usage, waste material, construction, water consumption and distribution, food distribution, etc. Significance At a time when employment opportunities are challenging to find and maintain for graduates, sustainable innovations in private business, not-for-profit organizations, and governmental organizations have provided relief through an increase in green jobs that are not dependent on or reproductions of failing economic models and traditional business practices. Recent reports on business trends also suggest an increase of jobs in “sustainability” indicates a growing interest in business models that emphasize not only efficiency, but also inter-communication, collaboration, and environmental consideration. Graduates with a background in sustainability education are equipped to support the future of urban growth and community development, rural lands preservation and utilization, and developments in green business, which are increasingly being sought out as effective ways to integrate social, economic, and environmental components under the broad banner of sustainability. In fact, seventy-eight percent of businesses surveyed by the National Environmental Education Foundation said that the value of environmental and sustainability knowledge as a hiring factor will increase over the next five years with 8 the majority of respondents agreeing that “in the future, all jobs will be green jobs.”3 According to Alan Hardcastle, from the WSU Extension Energy Program, rather than a separate green economy, we have a “greening economy.” Following this trend, sixty-six percent of the nearly 16,000 college applicants and parents surveyed by the Princeton Review last year said they would value having information about a college's commitment to the environment in making their decision.4 In September 2009 Time reported that 40 percent of consumers made purchases because they liked the social or political values of the company. By providing guidance in sustainability at the level of higher education, the university can develop methods for advancing sustainable development as a means for fostering economic growth. Higher Education Trends Currently, more than 665 U.S. colleges and universities in all 50 states, representing a student population of over 5.6 million, have signed the American College & University Presidents' Climate Commitment, which is an institutional pledge to integrate climate and sustainability into education and research, and to pursue climate neutrality in campus operations.5 However, other commitments towards sustainability education in a college or university are not as easily defined and require students, faculty, and administration to determine how much they will prioritize university-wide efforts toward sustainable practices. For some universities, sustainability on campus is a list of disconnected activities and programs that, while increasing in numbers, have not led to establishing a unified vision of sustainability or a whole institute approach. For others, such as Arizona State University, the effect of sustainability on higher education has led to the development of the Global Institute of Sustainability [GIS] as a means of achieving ASU’s vision for sustainability. The GIS is a hub for ASU’s comprehensive sustainability effort. According to the GIS’s web site, ASU’s framework for addressing the challenges of sustainability builds upon four cornerstones spanning disciplines, campuses, and institutional boundaries: Education, Research, Business Practices, and Global Partnerships and Transformation. Part II: Sustainability at Western Western Washington University has a foundational history of sustainability in university operations, curriculum, student initiatives, etc., as well as a long tradition of being a leader in environmental education and stewardship through two generations of students, faculty, and staff. As a publicly purposed university, Western recognizes that higher education is the incubator for the nation’s future leaders and is the channel by which innovative ideas and practices can be realized for the betterment of society. 3 Companies Cite Growing Interest, March 2009, [http://www.greenbiz.com/news/2009/03/19/companies-citegrowing-interest-need-and-value-environmental-smarts-survey]. 4 The Princeton Review Gives 703 Colleges Green Ratings, [http://www.princetonreview.com/green/pressrelease.aspx]. 9 In January 2009, members of the Faculty Sustainability Academy [FSA] developed A Timeline of Sustainable Development Initiatives at Western Washington University & Whatcom County [See Figure 2]. Figure 4: Sustainability Timeline at Western Washington University The timeline tracks the history of sustainability at Western through 26 university and 15 county events beginning in 1962 with the Institutes for Freshwater Studies and Watershed Studies and including: 1969Huxley College of the Environment; 1972-Department of Engineering Technology, Vehicle Research Institute; 1979-AS Environmental Center; 1979-The Planet Magazine; 1979-AS Recycle Center; 1983Outback Farm; 1993-Learning, Environment, Action, Discovery (LEAD), Huxley College; 1995Transportation Management Program; 1991-Campus Planning Studio; 1996-Fairhven Organic Gardening Course & Applied Human Ecology (Sustainable Systems Course); 1998-Custodial Services Environmental Preferable Practices; 1999-Institutional Campus Master Plan; 2000-Student Recreation Fee for LEED Certified Recreation Center; 2000-Green Landscaping Practices; 2005-Sustainable Design Minor; 2005-100% Renewable Energy Fee voted by students; 2005-WWU Sustainability Committee; 2006-Woodring Teaching for a Positive Future; 2006-Office of Sustainability and Coordinator of Sustainability; 2007-Signing of Western President’s Climate Commitment; 2007-Alternative Transportation Fee voted by students; 2008-Go For The Green Residence Hall Energy Program; 2008Faculty Sustainability Academy; 2008-Woodring Initiative for Sustainability Education [See Appendix A]. During the drafting of this paper, it was announced that Western made it into the Princeton Review’s “Green College” Guide, which means Western is above the 80th percentile according to their assessment framework. While we did not make it to their “Green Honor Roll” this year, the current progress of the Sustainability Institute Initiative and the Office of Sustainability places Western in competitive advantage for next year. Mission and Strategic Goals 10 Western’s mission and strategic goals articulate the important role that higher education holds in creating a sustainable future and promote Western as a leader for sustainability educational initiatives throughout Washington State and, in particular, among our peer universities across the nation. Mission Western Washington University serves the people of the State of Washington, the nation, and the world by bringing together individuals of diverse backgrounds and perspectives in an inclusive, student-centered university that develops the potential of learners and the well being of communities. The Western Experience described in the university’s mission statement expresses the relevancy of sustainability to Western as a whole: Western promotes scholarly and creative work of significance and applies that scholarship in regional, national, and global communities. Western creates opportunities for students to display leadership, civic engagement, social responsibility, and effective citizenship Western encourages diversity as a means build an effective learning community that, along with community partners, involves its members in active learning, scholarly discourse, and reflection. Western provides a high quality environment that compliments the learning community on a sustainable and attractive campus intentionally designed to support student learning and environmental stewardship. Vision Western will build a stronger Washington by being an international leader in active learning, critical thinking, and in societal problem solving. Strategic Goals Build upon Western's strengths to address critical needs in the State of Washington; Expand student access to rigorous and engaging baccalaureate and graduate education; Foster and promote life-long learning and success in an ever-changing world; Apply Western's expertise and collaborative approach to scholarship, creativity, and research in ways that strengthen communities beyond the campus; Serve as a model for institutional effectiveness, innovation, diversity, and sustainability. Complimentary to Western’s mission, vision, and strategic goals is the universities location in the Pacific Northwest, and more specifically Whatcom County. Whatcom County has won several national recognitions for their gold standard of sustainability, including local business practices, food and farming initiatives, as well as environmental standard awards. Therefore, Western provides a unique forum through which students can be provided with the opportunity to engage in sustainability education through local and global community involvement and diversity in academic perspectives, backgrounds, and interests. Campus Operations and Business Practices From Western’s commitment to green energy and waste reduction, Western incorporates sustainability into many areas of campus operations. Western’s Office of Sustainability is dedicated to furthering 11 Western’s strategic goal of campus sustainability. 12 The Office of Sustainability [OS] Further supporting the commitment by Western toward sustainability, the Office of Sustainability was established in 2006 by Business and Financial Affairs and the WWU Sustainability Committee to give a home to campus sustainability efforts and house the OS staff. At present the office consists of the campus Sustainability Coordinator, one part-time classified staff, and ten part-time student support personnel. The OS coordinates an array of programs and activities that are developed on Western’s campus and focus on the specific dimensions of campus operations as well as provides sustainability consultation to University clients, including the Port of Seattle and Brenthaven. The OS also coordinates an array of programs and activities developed on Western’s campus that focus on the specific dimensions of campus operations. These programs and activities include: Carbon Neutrality – Provides Western with the momentum to become a leader in reducing and offsetting our carbon emissions in order to fight the threat of global warming. Energy – Reducing energy consumption, minimizing harmful emissions related to energy consumption, and increasing energy efficiency. Buildings and Grounds – Incorporating environmentally friendly components into the architecture—in compliance with University standards and State law—that will save enough energy to pay for the building over its lifetime. Waste and Recycling – Decreasing total waste accumulated in campus buildings and commons areas while increasing the proportion of waste diverted from landfills. Food Services – Assisting with local foods procurement, waste reduction, conscientious recycling practices, pollution management, and efficient use of energy and water within compliance of local Health Department policy. Purchasing and Policy – Promoting sustainability begins internally, with localized business practices and a customized University policy. Transportation – Reducing the number of petroleum-fueled motor vehicle trips, enhancing alternative modes of travel, supporting fuel-efficient and alternative fuel vehicles, and promoting human health. These programs and activities are intended to incorporate the major components of university functions and utilities. By setting high standards now Western is in a position to design and implement effective and efficient sustainability programs for other universities, corporations, businesses, and local industry. Supported by the Office of Sustainability, Western has also been nationally recognized for its sustainability efforts in campus operations and business practices in the following areas: Parking and Transportation Office Western’s Alternative Transportation Coordinator and the Parking and Transportation Office efforts of promoting alternatives to single occupant vehicles has yielded state and national recognition. In 2002, Western was recognized as the State agency/institution with the most effective commute trip reduction program, and in 2005, the Environmental Protection Agency designated Western as one of the “Best Workplaces for Commuters” in the country. 13 Sustainable Food Systems In 2008, the Office of Sustainability and Dining Services initiated funding for a student coordinator to facilitate conversation opportunities regarding sustainable food service on campus and to increase the purchase of foods produced in Whatcom County. The OS position provides students with a hands-on learning experience that includes interfacing with students, staff, faculty members, and local food producers. WWU Sustainability Report The OS, in coordination with students in the WWU Campus Planning Studio, produced the University’s first comprehensive campus sustainability report. This report, presented to the WWU Board of Trustees in December 2008, outlines both programs and guiding metrics that are furthering Western’s pursuit of sustainability. Greenhouse Gas Inventory (GGI) Completing the first requirement of the President’s Climate Commitment, the GGI provides a snapshot of Western’s FY 2007 emissions from electricity use, natural gas combustion, transportation, and other sources. The GGI was used in formulation of the Climate Action Plan for the University. Local and Regional Climate Action Plan The signing of the American College and University President’s Climate Commitment has set Western on a path to climate neutrality. The OS is actively engaged in conversations with Western’s Facilities Management and the Board of Trustees, as well as the local Northwest Higher Education Sustainability Consortium, on a joint “Climate Action Plan” that will provide mutual assistance in pursuit of climate neutrality throughout the State. 10x12 Campaign Western has adopted the global 10x12 Campaign as a University-wide, department-focused effort to reduce utility use on campus and conserve University funds. The campaign promotes sustainability education, utility monitoring, improved building performance, and monetary incentives to participants. The 10x12 campaign implements conservation measures to realize a 10% reduction in pilot building utility consumption by the end of 2012. Sustainable Investing In collaboration with the OS, the University’s Endowment Investment Committee sponsored a 2008 forum on “Principles of Sustainable Investing.” The event brought together Western faculty and administrators with national experts on sustainability and social justice who presented recent research and models for sustainable design. Subsequently, the committee approved a strong investing policy for Western’s public funding portfolio. Curriculum Complimentary to sustainability initiatives in campus operations and business practices, Western’s faculty and students have made a strong commitment to the academic study and exploration of sustainability. On behalf of the Sustainability Academy, Professor Gene Myers of Huxley developed a list 14 in 2008 of Western faculty who have some teaching or scholarly interest in some aspect of sustainability. A faculty-wide survey ascertained that more than 60 faculty members, outside of Huxley College, have professional interest in sustainability. Subsequent surveys have identified nearly 150 faculty members across all colleges and disciplines. Courses and academic programs related to sustainability currently exist in every college at WWU. The courses and programs focus on issues related either directly or indirectly to sustainability related inquiry, innovations, and solutions. They are the result of independent interest, generated mostly by individual faculty members. Unfortunately many of these curricular initiatives work in isolation from other colleges and departments offering complimentary opportunities for both faculty and students to participate in the sustainability imperative of framing inquiry across traditional disciplinary constraints. In 2008, an informal association of Western faculty committed to promoting sustainability learning throughout the university, formed the Sustainability Academy and began their work of defining, uncovering, and supporting sustainability education efforts at Western. Below are some highlights of these curricular efforts at Western, which include programs, initiatives, courses, and learning centers: Programs Sustainable Design Minor The Sustainable Design minor is a collaboration among Engineering Technology, Huxley College, and Fairhaven College. Students gain complimentary skills in environmental studies, urban planning, and design in order to pursue sustainable design careers. A multidisciplinary team of students was awarded a national grant of $40,000 from the Industrial Designers Society of American/Proctor and Gamble for their proposed water quality project in Greece. Vehicle Research Institute [VRI] The VRI, in the College of Science and Technology, offers one of the best total car design curriculums in the world. The laboratory-oriented program focuses on complete vehicle design and fabrication. The VRI has produced dozens of innovative, fuel-efficient cars that have won international awards and have captured the attention of top automobile manufacturers. Renewable Energy Degree (in development) Huxley College of the Environment, College of Science and Technology, and the College of Business and Economics, under the direction of Dean Brad Smith, Dean Arian Norman, and Dean Brian Burton, are developing a curriculum track that will lead to a major in Renewable Energy. Designed to meet the needs of a rapidly expanding green energy economy, the program will integrate research and outreach with a unique interdisciplinary curriculum. The curriculum will include a Bachelor of Arts degree, a Bachelor of Science degree, and the option to minor in science and technology; or policy, economics and business. Graduate degrees in renewable energy will also be offered. Sustainable/Environmental Business Concentration (in development) The College of Business and Economics, in collaboration with the Huxley College of the Environment is developing a degree that degree combines three areas of study that gives graduates the necessary skills to operate in a changing economic and social environment: economics, environmental 15 science, and business sustainability. This degree will address the need for persons working in and with business organizations that can analyze the environmental and social issues from multiple perspectives, decide on action steps to deal with those issues, and then implement those action steps successfully. Environmental and Sustainability Education Specialty Area Endorsement In 2009, the Washington Professional Educators Standards Board (PESB) approved a new Specialty Area Endorsement in Environmental and Sustainability Education (ESE) for Washington teachers. The specialty endorsement in ESE is intended to create new roles and leadership opportunities for teachers; offer students new opportunities for learning; and encourage interdisciplinary teaching and learning. Woodring College of Education is currently developing a program leading to the ESE Specialty Area Endorsement. The ESE Specialty Area Endorsement program will be organized in eight 3-credit classes offered during two consecutive summers for a total of 24 credits. All courses are formatted as hybrid (on-line/face to face) during the 6-week summer session. Master of Professional Studies [MPS] in Sustainable Urban Planning and Environmental Policy (in development) Graduates of the MPS in Sustainable Urban Planning program and Environmental Policy can expect to play pivotal roles in the emerging "green collar" job sector to lead communities towards healthier and sustainable futures. Designed to develop career urban planners skilled in sustainable urban planning and environmental policy and knowledgeable about green technologies, this unique program integrates sustainable thinking and insights into every aspect of you’re the program. Post Bac Certificate in Sustainable Urban Planning (in development) Huxley College is exploring the development of a post baccalaureate professional certificate and a graduate professional studies degree program to provide the necessary professional and leadership skills to create sustainable futures. Designed to develop career urban planners and environmental policy professionals, the certificate program integrates sustainable thinking throughout the post-bac curriculum. Transdisciplinary Initiatives The Sustainability Institute Initiative [SII] SII builds an innovative, collaborative institutional structure for the development of a generation of interdisciplinary systems thinkers who can lead, inspire, and engage their communities toward sustainable goals. To accomplish this vision of the Initiative, the Institute will work to dissolve traditional disciplinary boundaries, generate dialogue between the diverse fields of academic discourse, and better understand the concepts and importance of sustainability today and in the future. The Institute will use education, research, and community involvement—the three functions common to university-level academics—as a foundation for moving beyond the existing dependence on shortterm solutions. 16 Courses Urban Transitions Studio Urban Transitions Studio is a collaborative partnership between WWU, Bellingham’s Office of Planning and Community Development, and Sustainable Connections. Beginning in 2010, Western’s Planning Studio participated in a coordinated service learning curriculum that partnered several classes with community and institutional partners in order to develop new urban planning concepts to help Bellingham transition into a more compact, sustainable community. The program is intended to expand student learning by concentrating planning and sustainable development studies over the course of an entire year and incorporating multiple dimensions of the planning process to effect public policy change toward sustainable community development. Campus Sustainability Planning Studio Through the Campus Sustainability Planning Studio students work directly with on and off-campus stakeholders to produce solutions to the sustainability challenges we face such as, energy conservation, waste reduction, sustainable transportation, local foods, green purchasing, sustainable building, sustainability media, and more. Products include research on the WWU student bus pass, local foods procurement, organics waste program expansion, and energy efficiency measures on multiple campus buildings. Social, Economic and Environmental Development Studies (SEEDS) Modeled after the successful program at the University of British Columbia, WWU SEEDS coordinates applied research opportunities related to sustainability. WWU students earn academic credit for their work; instructors become more fully involved in the community; and, staff gains research supporting sustainability in their area of operation. Since 2007, over ten SEEDS projects have been completed involving many academic programs such as Environmental Education, Marketing, Exercise Science, Computer Science, and Electronics Engineering. Writing and Critical Inquiry: English 101 English 101 at Western is a ten-week, composition course generally taken during students' first year of college. It serves approximately 1600-1800 students annually. Since the 2008-2009 academic year all sections of English 101 have used the following text: Sustainable Words: Readings in Consumption and Complexity, Responsibility and Renewal. In addition, 12-15 graduate teaching assistants are mentored annually using these readings on sustainability. Summer Institute’s Teaching for a Positive Future The Summer Institute’s Teaching for a Positive Future provides practical strategies and resources for integrating sustainability concepts into K-12 curriculum, school operations, and teacher preparation programs. Summer and International Study Abroad There are 13 active faculty led summer abroad programs this year each integrating the 3 pillars of sustainability into their goals. For example, Professor Nicholas Zaferatos oversees the award winning International Sustainable Development Studies Planning program on the Greek islands of Kefalonia (2005-2009), Ithaca (2010-2011), and on the island of Haiti (2010-2011. In addition, there is a 17 faculty-led program in Kenya collaborating with local community partners and addressing global modernization through community development projects. These programs provide correspondence between cross-cultural experiences and a major-focus in academics, giving students the opportunity to reflect upon and address cultural, economic, environmental, and social priorities. Learning Centers The Outback [OELS] The student-run Outback Outdoor Experiential Learning Site (OELS) is a joint program of Fairhaven College and the Associated Students that covers five acres at the south end of campus. Since its inception almost forty years ago, the OELS has served students pursuing environmental sustainability and holistic community involvement in an applied, hands-on approach, both formally (through coursework) and informally through gardening activity. Major sustainability focuses at the OELS include small-scale, diverse food production in an urban setting and wetlands restoration. In addition to formal courses and active learning projects, a steady procession of workshops and short courses on sustainable food production take place during the academic year and are open to students, staff, and the greater Bellingham community. Shannon Point Marine Center Shannon Point Marine Center in Anacortes provides academic programs, research opportunities, and applied-learning engagement for both undergraduates and Master's students and incorporates state-ofthe-art investigative techniques to analyze data in the field and laboratory. Faculty from the Center have been researching Northwest waters for the effects of urbanization and manufacturing-related contamination on marine life for decades. The Education for Sustainable Development Center (under development) The Center, to be located in the Woodring College of Education, will address the worldwide need to integrate sustainability into the education of children in Pre-K to Secondary school. The Center will accomplish this goal through three types of activities: providing direct professional development services for Teachers, School Administrators and Teacher Educators by sponsoring classes, seminars, workshops, conferences, leadership summits and summer institutes; supporting applied research focusing on best practices in ESD by sponsoring Faculty Research Fellowships, Graduate Student Assistantships, and Collaborative Inquiry Partnerships; and contributing to the knowledge base in Education for Sustainable Development by sponsoring international faculty exchanges, visiting lecture series, and various dissemination projects in print and digital formats. The Center also will work actively with national and international networks addressing teacher education and ESD. In summary, Western has a strong history and reputation as a university committed to sustainability in operations, curriculum, research, applied learning, and community involvement. Retaining and building upon Western’s preeminence, however, requires increased collaboration; a lessening of barriers and disciplinary silos that inhibit collaboration; increased coordination of the rapidly growing numbers of courses, programs, and initiatives; and increased visibility of Western’s many and diverse contributions to the “sustainability imperative.” 18 Research There are almost 200 academic research grants presently underway at Western with a grant total of $4.7 million dollars. While the faculty in the colleges of Science & Technology and Huxley College of the Environment produce the bulk of the grant funding, grant-funded projects are applied for and received across the six colleges and include both academic departments and non-academic departments of the University. The Office of Research and Sponsored Programs supports all public grant recipients and publishes a listing of current grants at Western received by each division, department, and individual. The grants are not aggregated or indicated by research description or by funding source. For this reason, it is difficult to determine the research activity of Western’s faculty in the combined areas of social, economic, and environmental factors related to sustainability. With the assistance of members of the Faculty Sustainability Academy, the Sustainability Institute Initiative has been able to assess the current grants at Western and apply the definition of Sustainability (and environmental science) Research developed by Academy members to develop an aggregated listing of sustainability-related research among faculty members, departments, and colleges. The assessment has resulted in an identification of 43 current grant projects that meet the definition totaling nearly 30 percent of all current grants and contracts at Western. Student Initiatives Each Associated Student [AS] club is student-initiated and sustained. Therefore, they are a good representation of student interests at Western. Of the 2010-2011 active student clubs, nearly 1/5 are directly formed around sustainability initiatives while close to 25 percent deal with sustainability issues through the course of their overall work. The membership and activities of the AS clubs are inherently interdisciplinary. Such coalitions have been instrumental to the promotion and success of the globally recognized student-led initiatives advancing sustainability at Western. Green Energy Initiative Led by students enrolled in an entrepreneurial management course in the College of Business and Economics, Western students took an active leadership role in the Green Energy movement by passing the Green Energy Initiative in 2004. Beginning in 2005, Western has been obtaining 100 percent of its electricity from renewable resources and the university is now ranked eighth on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s list of the nation’s top 10 green energy purchasers in higher education. Green Energy Fee As part of the Green Energy Fee, which received an overwhelming student vote in-favor in 2010, Western students have initiated an educational fund to support student research projects in sustainability by promoting renewable energy research, energy conservation, and community involvement with food production and purchasing. The Office of Sustainability and the student Green Fee Advisor is currently managing the program. In addition, faculty serving on the Sustainability Academy provide expertise and advising for the various projects. 19 The Resident Resource Awareness [ResRAP] ResRAP promotes leadership in energy and material conservation in campus residence halls through elected sustainability representatives, known as EcoReps. In 2009, the ResRAP coordinator and EcoReps saved the University over $17,000 in electrical energy costs. EcoReps educate and promote sustainable choices to their fellow residents and create opportunities for positive impacts in their hall and local communities. Western Student Transportation Program [WST] The AS, in conjunction with the Division of Business and Financial Affairs, developed the WST after a successful student vote for the transportation fee in April 2007. The program’s goal is to enable students to live a full college experience without owning a personal vehicle. Earth Week Earth Week is an annual festival celebrating Western’s commitment to sustainability while providing fun and educational opportunities for students to collaborate on environmental solutions. For the past couple of years the students have expanded the celebration to encompass a week of activities that include speakers, workshops, films, outreach, and faculty participation on various topics related to sustainability. Regional and Global Partnerships Complimentary to the growing sustainability initiatives on Western’s campus through operations, curriculum, research, and student initiatives are the local and global partnerships created and sustained through sustainability efforts at Western. Energy Resources Scarcity/Peak Oil Task Force The City of Bellingham and Whatcom County formed a community taskforce in 2008 to examine energy-related vulnerabilities for local economics, social and environmental infrastructure, and to recommend strategies to ensure individual community resiliency. Professor Gigi Berardi, faculty at Huxley College and Director of the Energy/Resiliency Institute, and Dr. Hart Hodges, faculty at College of Business & Economics and Director of the Economic and Business Research Center, were selected as members of the Bellingham and Whatcom County community task force. Sustainable Connections Sustainable Connections is a network of community-focused businesses, farms, organizations, and individuals committed to sustainable business practices, local purchasing, and economic and cultural diversity. Western is a charter member of the group and provides educational and professional support for many of its initiatives. Memberships and Affiliations Western is a member of the following sustainability-related professional national associations and organizations: 20 American Council on Renewable Energy (ACORE) Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education (AASHE) Environmental Protection Agency’s Green Power Partnership Society of College and University Planning (SCUP) The Conference Board Committee on Corporate Citizenship and Sustainability United Nations Academic Impact Partnership Program (UNAI) (in process) As a member of the these organizations Western is poised to integrate faculty and students into a variety of sustainability programs that directly address concerns and solutions for local, regional, and global settings. Part III: Current Challenges for Sustainability Education at Western Growth and development opportunities in green business practices are emerging through the integration of social, economic, and environmental components, converging under the broad banner of sustainability. However, sustainability initiatives are strategic only when they integrate with the greater vision and purpose of an organization—a whole-institute approach. Despite the many diverse and important projects related to sustainability at Western, many of the sustainability programs, research, and curricula are not articulated in relationship to one another and are seen as parts rather than parts of a whole institutional approach to sustainability education. Frank Rhodes, former president of Cornell University, suggests that the concept of sustainability offers "a new foundation for the liberal arts and sciences." Simply plugging sustainability into existing institutional models will not do. Instead, a whole-institute approach to sustainability invites universities to effectively engage principles of sustainability in their curriculum, research, governance, and infrastructure. In 2010 AASHE conducted “2010 Higher Education Sustainability Education Staffing Survey” requesting information regarding the major challenges that respondents and their institutions face in terms of implementing sustainability work. The top three most frequent reasons universities had difficulty centralizing sustainability programs were cited as a “lack of financial resources” (17%), followed by “structural barriers” (15%), and concluded with a “lack of staff” (15%). It is also noted that 5% of respondents indicated concerns for academic integration and curriculum change, bureaucracy, changing the traditional culture and formalized expectations, lack of time, and a lack of student support/focus as barriers to advancing campus sustainability projects. At Western, we are fortunate that the culture and student support for campus sustainability is not a barrier. It is, in fact, just the opposite. Students have been a leading force behind Western’s sustainability advancements through the enrollment in courses and student-led initiatives for many years. This trend is being carried forward at Western by members of the student body and faculty at Western that are leading the Sustainability Institute Initiative and unifying the disparate programs on campus to establish Western as an institutional leader of sustainability in higher education. Financial Western, along with many other universities across the country, is faced with the daunting task of making extreme cuts to its budget in the next biennium. The “old” way of doing things will have to be closely 21 examined in order for the important work of the university to continue. While some of the characteristics of a whole-institute approach to sustainability may seem unattainable during such extreme cuts, upon closer examination we might find that it is possible to build upon the innovative work being done through collaborative teaching, learning, and program development in a way that develops institutional frameworks and supporting mechanisms for promoting and facilitating sustainability through curricular and university activities. The critical challenges facing most colleges and universities today call for those of us in the academy to aggressively leave our zones of comfort and move beyond the vested higher education interests of the day. Structural Structural barriers also exist at Western when it comes to facilitating a whole institute approach to sustainability. Writing from an international perspective, Noel Entwistle concludes in his research findings about higher education that evidence supports the sustainability imperative to revisit the purpose of higher education at a time of rapid change and ‘super-complexity’ in dealing with emerging issues and new problems. The report encourages institutional support for redesigning courses and curricula through a broad agenda that requires the deconstruction of curricular constraints that often isolate content knowledge from broader questions that could serve as ‘throughlines’ for learning and encourage students to connect and configure understandings for themselves. Related to this, Western recently underwent an external examination as part of its effort to produce a brand for the second decade of the 21st century. Research for the project (conducted by the firm Lyric) yielded an overall impression that Western needs to connect across departments to create a cohesive story. President Shepard, among others, has talked about “breaking down the silos” between colleges, departments, and programs. An increasing number of faculty view this as moving beyond single disciplinary and even multi-disciplinary scholarship and toward a fusion of disciplines— transdisciplinary. As noted by Lyric, an opportunity exists to “leverage the whole of the university as it will be more impactful than the separate, though fabulous, parts.” Student Access and Defining Sustainability at Western Students have expressed another challenge to sustainability education at Western as difficulty identifying and accessing sustainability related courses and relevant degree opportunities by students wanting to pursue sustainability degrees, programs, and certificates at Western. They come to Western’s campus because it has a reputation for environmental innovation and concern, interdisciplinary studies through Fairhaven College, and sustainability initiatives launched by students, faculty, and departments. Students aware of the sustainability imperative of transdisciplinary studies and research have experienced obstacles at Western, such as difficulty knowing about courses and events on campus, difficulty registering for courses (which is going to become even more prevalent with the new wait-list policies), and identifying and connecting with faculty mentors. In addition, students are finding that they are less competitive for the sustainability-focused workforce when they graduate with a single disciplinary focus/approach. 22 Part IV: Sustainability Initiatives at Western Background of the Sustainability Initiative at Western In February 2005, President Karen Morse appointed an all-university Sustainability Committee comprised of faculty from each of the colleges, as well as knowledgeable and informed students and staff. The charge to the committee was: How can we be better, smarter, and wiser in the ways we view and use our resources and do so in a manner that helps us realize the goals we as partners, staff, faculty and administration desire? The group was asked to: Develop a unified set of sustainability metrics and indicators with the purpose of building awareness and understanding on campus; 2. Conduct a baseline assessment of present efforts at Western; 3. Create a Vision and Strategic Plan that envisions the steps needed for Western to become a leader in sustainable practices using our natural, financial and human resources, and 4. Advise on effective step-by-step implementation so that our respective academic programs and operations can become leaders by example through their efforts. 1. In a December 12, 2005 letter addressed to Dr. George Pierce, seven faculty members from across colleges requested consideration for an institutional body that provides a university-wide umbrella for sustainability related faculty and programs on Western’s campus. The letter went on to discuss how such an effort could support communication, match complimentary interests, arrange research and teaching collaborations, and provide linkages with community efforts and resources to support “greening the curriculum” by utilizing existing faculty talent [See Appendix B]. The seven faculty, in concert with faculty members of the Sustainability Committee, also circulated a “think piece” entitled Sustainability at Western Washington University, Proposed Action Steps [See Appendix C]. In this piece the faculty noted that, “...successful examples on other campuses have shown that long term progress is best ensured if the effort involves the three major campus constituencies: faculty, administration, and off-campus community. Each of the campus groups needs a permanent institutional entity or structure through which it makes coordinated contributions to sustainability. Campus sustainability calls for a systemic approach. The main groups that compose the university must have their own structures through which their contributions can be most effectively stimulated and brought into relationship.” In January 2007, the Sustainability Committee’s sub-committee on curriculum developed and distributed its recommendations in a Concept Paper entitled “Recommendations for establishing a university-wide program in sustainability literacy, experiential learning, research, and the creation of a WWU Faculty Sustainability Academy” [See Appendix D]. The concept paper defines the role of the Sustainability Academy as being “comprised of all WWU faculty members who “self declare” a research, teaching, or creative endeavor interest in sustainability studies.” In addition, the Academy would contribute to sustainability studies at Western through such activities as teaching, sponsoring research, monitoring sustainability curriculum, facilitating discussions, and engaging in interdisciplinary research and writing focusing on issues related to sustainability. 23 Sustainability Academy The Sustainability Academy is an informal group of faculty interested in developing sustainability as a signature theme of education at Western Washington University. In December 2008 the group identified sustainability content in current courses and proposed curricular models for development of a General Education course sequence in sustainability literacy, an overlay sustainability minor for students in all disciplines, and an eventual major program in sustainability. The first gathering of the Sustainability Academy was on December 3, 2008. Most of the 60 plus faculty in attendance supported moving forward with a series of activities including: a curriculum design charette workshop (held in February, 2009); informal “brown-bag” discussions (held during the winter 2009 and spring 2010); and a university-wide survey of faculty interests and support. Through the 2008-2009 academic year a number of faculty and academic administrators convened informally to foster sustainability education at Western by developing an inventory of existing sustainability classes, consolidating Western’s library resources on the topic, hosting bi-monthly brown bag discussions, and designing curriculum proposals for interdisciplinary studies and projects in sustainability. The February 2009 charette produced ideas for the following sustainability programs at Western: 1. A sustainability literacy GUR block of 2-3 courses; 2. A sustainability minor to involve literacy, topical skills, research seminars, and research application in sustainability; 3. A sustainability major including core requirements, transdisciplinary research skills, transdisciplinary theory and practice; disciplinary specialization and applications; and 4. A certificate program in sustainability studies. These programs initiated by the Sustainability Academy provided the framework for academic discourse between students interested in sustainability and faculty who are already engaged in sustainability related and/or focused research and curriculum design. The programs also provided an opportunity for students to contribute their ideas to the ongoing research at Western and to become the architects of their own degree pursuits as they participate with and adapt to the changing needs of a greening society and increasingly sustainability-minded culture. In winter 2009, discussions by the Sustainability Academy also led to 5 building blocks for supporting sustainability curriculum at Western. The building blocks include: 1. Formation of a faculty oversight working group (“Sustainability Studies Academy”) to participate in teaching, mentoring, and guiding the development of a sustainability curriculum at WWU; 2. A General Education program in sustainability literacy; 3. Classes that develop sustainability research skills; 4. An organizational framework that will support independent student research and community outreach; and 5. An “overlay minor” in Sustainability. These building blocks are the foundation for defining academic sustainability in research, curriculum, faculty and student collaboration, and transdisciplinary interactions between colleges. At this time, the academy continued on with its goals of supporting communication, matching complimentary interests, 24 facilitating research and teaching collaborations, developing curricular models, and partnering with community efforts and resources to create the backbone of research and teaching that would drive the work of the Sustainability Institute Initiative. With the inception of the Sustainability Institute Initiative in July 2009, and in keeping with the growing faculty and student demand for a cross-curricular sustainability umbrella at Western, administrative support was provided for the Sustainability Academy to move forward with several of its goals. The Sustainability Institute Initiative launched with oversight from a “steering group” of twelve faculty that began implementing sustainability curriculum at Western and laying the groundwork for developing a coordinating academic framework for the Institute for Sustainability. The goals and achievements of the Sustainability Institute Initiative included: Developing a pilot course in Sustainability Literacy [Literacy I], taught during Spring 2009 and Fall 2010; Developing the second course in a sequence of three [Sustainability Literacy II], offered Winter 2011; Integrating the pilot Sustainability Literacy III course into the Campus Planning Studio course, which occurred during Spring 2011; Presenting a Sustainability Literacy GUR sequence to the CUE of the Academic Coordinating Council; Forming a student “focus group” to assist in the planning and development of the Sustainability Literacy courses and to assist the instructors in the facilitation of class dialogue groups; Assisting and supporting the efforts of the Associated Students in the planning and increasing faculty participation in the yearly Earth Week events on campus; Participating in Western’s hosting of and presentation to a delegation of Russian environmental engineers and managers from Nakhodka, Bellingham’s sister city; Supporting the collaborative inter-institutional efforts of the Northwest Consortium of Colleges and Universities in Sustainability under the leadership of WWU; Supporting the Student Green Fee Educational component which would: (a) use green energy fee proposals to further campus sustainability, (b) have the student proposals receive funding through the green fee and (c) provide students with administrative experience implementing accepted project proposals; and Working with faculty to provide new research ideas furthering sustainable innovation to the campus community. Completion of this white paper for the Sustainability Institute. Sustainability Institute Initiative President Bruce Shepard established the Sustainability Institute Initiative during the spring quarter of 2009. Dr. George Pierce, formally Vice President for Business and Financial Affairs, was appointed coordinator of the project as Special Assistant for Sustainability. Dr. Pierce began work with the Provost and the Vice Provost for Undergraduate Education in monitoring and supporting the academic integration of the sustainability efforts of the faculty, departments, and colleges. The Provost asked Dr. Richard Frye, of the Office of Testing and Assessment, to assist Pierce in the Initiative’s efforts. A number of faculty, administrators, staff, and students were also involved in the planning and development of the Initiative. 25 The plans and development tasks were discussed in an August 2009 Business Plan written by Dr. Pierce [see Appendix E]. The business plan listed four primary goals of the Initiative to be completed in four phases, beginning with the “start up” during Spring to Summer Quarter of 2009 and through to the formal establishment of the Institute of Sustainability by the end of the 2010-11 academic year. Below are listed the primary goals of the Initiative followed by the accomplishments to-date: Goal #1: Increase the number and intensity of sustainability efforts on Westerns campus. Provided assistance to Facilities Management and Office of Sustainability for developing options for alternative heat and energy, including a district energy concept to tie to the waterfront development project. Coordinated joint faculty and student activities for annual Earth Week activities by serving as liaison between the AS and the Faculty Sustainability Academy. Collaborated with the Sustainability Coordinator in the Office of Sustainability to establish the Northwest Higher Education Sustainability Consortium of WWU, WCC, BTC, and NWIC. Developed the prototype of on-line social media called “Western Sustainability” by reviewing and purchasing appropriate software, working with ATUS to install the software, and coordinating communication and technology students in the design. Assisted the Office of Sustainability in the development of Western’s response to the STARS self-accreditation instrument (sponsored by AASHE) by (1) coordinating Western’s definition of Sustainability Research with member of the Faculty Sustainability Academy, (2) assessing courses, academic research and scholarly activities of faculty and students related to sustainability, (3) developing a database of grants, activities and courses undertaken at Western, and (4) listing these on the SII website for public information. Nominated Lauren Squires, AS Environmental Center Coordinator, on behalf of Western, for the Student Sustainability Leadership Award with AASHE. The Faculty Academy chose Squires through nomination and sought supporting documentation from additional faculty and staff indicating her commitment to Western’s sustainability initiative. Goal #2: Enhance the ability of WWU colleges to carry out scholarly activities and development projects in partnership with faculty and students from the broader campus community. Assisted in the organization and coordination of the Faculty Sustainability Academy [FSA] by establishing a steering committee, staffing the meetings, preparing a budget for faculty assistance, setting up brown bag discussions, and stewarding the development of course curriculum. Organized and coordinated the Student Sustainability Focus Group by seeking nominations from faculty and students, holding meetings and training sessions, and stewarding the involvement of students from a range of disciplines in the planning, design, facilitating, and assessment of the sustainability literacy courses. Established the Sustainability Community Solutions Internship Program with support from the Office of Sustainability by seeking and receiving outside funding, coordinating with Consortium members, establishing community partners, and selecting students. 26 Coordinated support of the FSA for the AS’s efforts to initiate a Green Energy Fee Education Program by providing advice and staff assistance to the Green Fee Committee as they developed the educational component to make effective use of the fee-generated monies. Participated on the advisory committee organized by Woodring for the Sustainable Development Center [SDC]. Goal #3: Attract federal and state grants and contracts, and private gifts, to enhance Western’s applied sustainability capacity. Developed a case statement for the establishment of the Institute of Sustainability. Received $3,000 grant from Puget Sound Energy Foundation for establishing the Sustainability Community Research Internship Program. Developed pilot partnership project with i-Sustain, a Seattle firm devoted to evolving global best practices in urban sustainability. Working with the Provosts Office to develop a NSF grant proposal for a global sustainability project focused on collaborations between WWU and Eastern Russia. Partnering with Whatcom Community College and the NWHEC consortium to craft a grant proposal to EPA to support sustainability, public engagement, and service learning. Received $40,000 grant from Proctor & Gamble, one of four national awards, to fund a facultyled interdisciplinary student investigation for global sustainable water resource development. Faculty international recognition in sustainable global development. Goal #4: Support the development and implementation of integrated education programs promoting sustainability throughout the curriculum. Stewarded the development of interdisciplinary curriculum in sustainability at Western in concert with the VP for Undergraduate Programs and members of the FSA by providing staff resources to plan, design, and implement Sustainability Literacy I (ESTU 197) as a highly successful pilot course in the Spring and Fall 2010. Partnered with FSA to develop Sustainability Literacy II (ESTU 297)—an interdisciplinary course focused on systems of sustainability and offered in winter 2011. Co-Designated the Campus Planning Studio (ESTU 471) for spring 2011 as Sustainability Literacy III—the third in the Sustainability Literacy Series sequence. Oversaw the development of a comprehensive assessment report of the literacy courses for future curriculum development by (1) providing staff resources, (2) coordinating student evaluations and third-party and student facilitator observations, and (3) supporting institutional research analysis and recommendations. Engaged upper-division students from several different majors as small group facilitators in the literacy classes for recruiting, training, and coordinating course activities and student involvement with each other and with the course instructor. Coordinated the FSA proposal for a Gen Ed sequence in sustainability by (1) researching existing curriculum models, (2) crafting a model for Western, (3) meetings with VP for Undergraduate Programs and CUE, (4) obtaining faculty and committee support for the program, and (5) designing three interdisciplinary courses to be offered as a sustainability sequence. 27 The completion of Goal 2 provided additional momentum for collaboration between faculty, students, and the broader campus community in sustainability-focused and related programs. With this groundwork in place the Initiative began to generate funding for sustainability projects. The Sustainability Institute continues to seek funding from federal and state grants in order to pursue and encourage new research and curriculum opportunities in sustainability on Western’s campus. The far reaching impacts the Sustainability Institute Initiative has had on the key practices of the university—teaching, research, and community service—combined with the global move toward a whole institute approach toward the “sustainable university” supports the creation of Sustainability Institute at Western. Part V: Rationale for The Sustainability Institute at Western While the nationwide movement to re-imagine and redesign higher education to meet the needs of the twenty-first century may be dominated by increasing budget cuts, the primary service offered by higher education is to remain innovative and to create learning environments that respond to ever-changing environments. The Sustainability Institute at Western directly addresses the evolving expectations placed on current and future generations of students who are being called upon to address the challenges of sustainability this century. Throughout history, higher education has been assessed on its ability to create a passion for learning that addresses the needs of the world that graduates will be facing in their work and lives. Therefore, higher education in the twenty-first century will be assessed on its ability to ensure that sustainability curriculum, research, and operations are an integral part of academic praxis. At the 2002 Summit, the United Nations General Assembly declared years 2005-2014 the “Decade of Education for Sustainable Development” as a way of signaling that education and learning lie at the heart of approaches to sustainable development. The Association of University Leaders for Sustainable Development, whose mission is to "make sustainability a major focus of teaching, research, operations and outreach at colleges and universities worldwide,” has partnered with the International Association of Universities and UNESCO. Their rationale is as follows: The partners are convinced that the leaders of higher education institutions and their academic colleagues in all disciplines must make sustainable development a central academic and organizational focus in order to create a just, equitable and ecologically sound future. This requires the generation and dissemination of knowledge through interdisciplinary research and teaching, policy-making, capacity building, and technology transfer. The Sustainability Institute at Western aligns its self well with these goals and is uniquely positioned to work across boundaries and to engage faculty and students from a range of disciplines to develop an informed and inclusive definition of sustainability at Western—one that will serve as an imprimatur for curriculum, research, and community involvement. With this in mind, the Sustainability Institute at Western would enhance (1) teaching (2) research (3) outreach, and (4) fundraising at Western. Teaching A primary function of the Sustainability Institute Initiative is to continue its efforts towards making it possible for students across the university to engage with sustainability education at different levels, 28 which may include a sequence of courses, minors, and/or concentrations in sustainability. There is a strong demand by students across disciplines, and potential employers of graduates, to have expertise integrating and addressing social, economic, and environmental challenges into their inquiry and practice. The Sustainability Institute serves as an umbrella at Western where students and faculty from all disciplines come together to create and share knowledge related to sustainability. Sustainability Literacy Course Sequence A number of curricular models were explored by the interdisciplinary steering group of the Faculty Sustainability Academy, which led to the creation of a possible General Education sequence of three courses and a series of sustainability minors to be offered in partnership with individual colleges or disciplines. The experiential and integral structure of the course sequence includes the participation of over 30 faculty from every college and 15 different disciplines. The Sustainability Literacy sequence includes 3 sections, listed as Sustainability I, II, and III. The sequence is offered consecutively beginning with Literacy I in the fall and ending with Literacy III in the spring. The courses build on one another and are to be taken in series; however, they may also be taken individually by students familiar with sustainability concepts or interested in incorporating sustainability concepts into their chosen major area. The curricular model builds the sequence around a “compelling narrative” that includes elected material from the natural sciences to explore how geophysical systems work, the life sciences to explore how living systems work interdependently with the physical world, the social and behavioral sciences to explore how people behave interdependently with the natural world, the humanities to explore the values, cultures, and ethics which guide individual and group behavior, and systems and technology to explore how intra- and inter-system problems can be approached and resolved. The sequence can be adapted for the development of minors, majors, research projects, and capstone projects as the Institute develops. It should be possible for a student in any major to construct a minor in sustainability by taking the Gen Ed sequence and a series of courses from fields outside their major area. For example, a minor in sustainability for a natural science major might include courses in social and life sciences, humanities, technology, and psychology, in addition to a core sequence which might include the Gen Ed sequence and a capstone project of some kind. Students participating in the sustainability course sequence (the number of total credits and composition of courses to be determined) could in the future obtain a minor in “Sustainability Studies” as an overlay minor to their chosen majors at Western. Courses taken in the sustainability curriculum could satisfy as “electives” in the student’s major. Sustainability Internship Program WWU Sustainability Internship Program is a collaborative effort between the Office of Sustainability and the Sustainability Institute Initiative to pair Western students with partners in Bellingham and the regional community who are looking for innovative opportunities to adopt sustainable practices. Business, government, and non-profit organizations are increasingly asked by their customers, employees, and board members to “green up” their mission and practices. Using the proposed offcampus WWU Sustainability Internship Program, community partners will benefit from Western’s 29 student’s contributions; students will in-turn gain valuable skills and credit for their work; and faculty will have the opportunity to become more integrated with their community. 30 Sustainability Courses and Research In addition to innovative curricular development, the Sustainability Institute Initiative at Western has also facilitated campus-wide research on sustainability curriculum, research, and community outreach and makes this information available to the campus community through publicity, outreach, and the maintaining of the Sustainability Institute Initiative web site [http://www.wwu.edu/sii]. During the 2010-2011 academic year, the Sustainability Institute Initiative estimates that of the 5,500 total courses offered at Western that about 22 are sustainability focused with 900 being sustainability related (meaning those with “sustainable “ in the title or course description)—approximately 15 percent. Sustainability focused courses at Western Washington University address sustainability in local, regional, national, or international settings and contexts as a primary component of the course. Sustainability related courses at Western Washington University promote cultural studies and community development in local, regional, national, and global contexts with attention to language, economics, small business, security, and the interconnection between human and non-human environments. These courses are currently involved with interdisciplinary studies at the academic level, translate easily into other disciplines, colleges, and departments, or actively interface with local and global demographic interests. The Initiative also found that thirty percent of the total research grants received by the university since 2008 fit a broad definition of “sustainability.” Likewise, thirty-six percent of press releases from the Office of Communication relate to scholarship and activities of faculty, students, and staff in sustainability efforts locally, nationally, and internationally. And, 150 different faculty indicated an interest in sustainability scholarship and identified with the Sustainability Academy in a total of three surveys administered since 2008. In total, nearly one third of Western's academic research and scholarly/community based activities are involved with what is commonly regarded as “sustainability/environmental education.” Without the Sustainability Institute, curriculum, research, and activities, such as those documented above, run the risk of becoming self-absorbed and isolated when they are not in conversation with each other. In contrast, when the curriculum, research, and activities that support sustainability education at Western are articulated as a whole, they reflect an integrated concept of sustainability at Western—a sum greater than its parts. Research documenting sustainability initiatives at Western will be useful for pursuing funding opportunities, as well as for national or global recognition. During the 2010-2011 academic year, the Sustainability Institute Initiative worked in collaboration with the Office of Sustainability for one such national recognition—the Sustainability Tracking, Assessment and Rating System [STARS] maintained by the Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education [AASHE]. STARS The STARS program is a transparent, self-reporting framework for colleges and universities across the United States and Canada and is designed to measure sustainability performances on participating campuses. A collaboration of the Office of Sustainability and the Sustainability Institute Initiative began completing the STARS rating survey instrument in 2010. Based on the accomplishments of the Office of Sustainability and the Sustainability Institute Initiative to articulate a unified front of 31 sustainability at Western in both operations and curriculum, Western is ranked as a leader in initiative and self-direction for sustainability development. STARS also applauded Western’s undertaking of the task of defining sustainability in academics. This recognition was specifically supported by the work of the Sustainability Academy and the Sustainability Literacy course sequence, something that few other universities have attempted at this point. A high rating in the STARS program marks Western as a leader in sustainable education, strategy, programs, and innovation, distinguishing the campus among peer universities across the United States. Western’s ranking as a sustainable university also indicates our interest in the future of sustainability research, education, and lifestyle, which are aspects of Western’s mission and goals as a university that prospective students are considering before they choose their higher education. The STARS program is also important to Western because it assists with determining where the university stands in terms of sustainability programs on campus, as well as in relationship to the national and international sustainability movement. STARS is concurrently a framework that is designed to assist and direct a university in taking new steps toward higher achievement in sustainability. Community Outreach Academic Impact Initiative The Sustainability Institute Initiative and the Sustainability Academy aided Western’s participation in the United Nation’s Academic Impact Initiative, joining colleague universities in promoting sustainability education worldwide. At the Academy’s request, Huxley College also endorsed this action. In February 2011, the Faculty Senate unanimously passed a resolution to join the Academic Impact and to support ten universally accepted principles in the areas of human rights, literacy, sustainability, and conflict resolution. The recommendation has been approved by Provost Catherine Riordan and Western is in the process of enrolling. Earth Days The Sustainability Institute Initiative has dramatically increased the number of faculty that will be participating in the 2011 Earth Week activities on campus. Close to 30 faculty members will offer opportunities for students and community members to participate and interact with the Western community through events such as: “The Future of Sustainability in the Curriculum”—A faculty panel with presentations on four academic initiatives: Business Sustainability, from the College of Business & Economics; Renewable Energy, from the Huxley College of the Environment; the Center for Sustainability Education, from the Woodring College of Education; and the Institute of Sustainability, from the Faculty Sustainability Academy; “The Sustainability Literacy Course Sequence”—A faculty presentation on the three newly developed courses aimed at lower division undergraduates; and A range of faculty and student presentations about their academic work in sustainability and the environment. In addition, several faculty teaching courses related to sustainability will open their classes to the public during Earth Days. 32 Bellingham Innovation Zone The Sustainability Institute Initiative will partner with the Port of Bellingham, the Bellingham Technical College, and private companies under the auspices of the Northwest Consortium for Technological Innovation and Development (NCTID) to carry out research and development projects in partnership with regional technology-driven industries. The sustainable nature of this enterprise is the balancing of economic vitality, environmental stewardship, and community livability, concentrating on the Marine Trades industries. Northwest Higher Education Sustainability Consortium The Sustainability Institute Initiative has contributed to collaborations between Western Washington University, Whatcom Community College, Bellingham Technical College, and the Northwest Indian College to form a Consortium for collaboration and partnership in promoting sustainability on campuses and in the community of Whatcom County and in the northwest region of the State through four over-arching goals: 1. Facilitating communication and dissemination of knowledge and information among the various campus communities; 2. Developing a working understanding of sustainability among the diverse Consortium communities; 3. Promoting partnerships for advancing sustainability among the broader Consortium communities; and 4. Increasing capacity for the practice of sustainability on Consortium campuses and communities, by building skills, transforming attitudes, and sharing resources. Russian Delegation The Russian delegation’s visit in December 2010 from Nadhodka, a port-town on the western coast of Russia and considered to be Bellingham’s sister-city, was funded by a grant from the Open World Program. The funding was obtained by Whatcom Community College, is partnership with the City of Bellingham, Whatcom County, Sustainable Connections, and Western Washington University. Through the auspices of the Sustainability Institute Initiative, a follow-up project is being considered including the funding for the exchange of several faculty members and students with their counterparts in northwest Russia in order to continue the dialogue of best practices in environmental and sustainability education. The Sustainability Institute will continue building a relationship Nakhodka and developing shared interests in sustainability. The delegation has already been introduced to members of the Sustainability Academy from industrial design, environmental planning and policy, writing, business and economics, transportation, campus operations, and involved students. Maintaining Organizational Frameworks for Sustainability The development of the Sustainability Institute Initiative will require an ongoing and engaged discussion among the entire Western community to articulate the values, vision, structure, and processes of the Institute. In particular, the academic element of the Institute will be guided by the Faculty Sustainability Academy, which today and in the future consists of all Western faculty who wish to be involved. 33 In addition to the Sustainability Institute Initiative’s web site [http://www.wwu.edu/sii], the Initiative has established an online forum for facilitating a series of ongoing community discussions among faculty, across topics and interest groups. The forum can be accessed from the index of the main site. Fundraising In 2010, Dr. George Pierce submitted a concept paper for potential funding for the Sustainability Institute Initiative through the Western Foundation. The concept paper listed a number of programs and projects that the Sustainability Institute could sponsor, including funding for faculty teaching and scholarship, as well as for student support and professional development to the students and faculty. Part VI: Considerations for Funding During the 2010-2011 biennium, the Sustainability Institute Initiative was funded through the President’s Office as one of the 5 or 6 University initiatives for the two years. A total of $100,000 yearly funded the special assistant for sustainability, research and administrative support, and office communications. The Institute proposal calls for a phased-in approach over the next one or two biennium. The next, or second phase, proposes establishing a coordinator or director position. In addition, honoraria support is proposed for faculty involved in the sustainability literacy courses, with a small amount for student support. Each program/project and initiative was costed out separately. The total funding figure for a fully established Institute requires an endowment in the amount of $2.5 million or $100,000 annually [See Appendix F]. PART VII: Recommendations For Western to continue its progress toward being recognized for its innovative sustainability efforts, our primary recommendation is for the development of a Sustainability Institute at Western that will comprehensively focus Western’s sustainability efforts in the three common higher education functions of education, research, and community outreach. The Sustainability Institute would take advantage of similar growth and development opportunities as those in the business sector by integrating social, economic, and environmental components under the broad banner of Sustainability. However, sustainability initiatives only become strategic when they incorporate sustainability with the greater vision and purpose of the organization. With this in mind, the Sustainability Institute at Western would serve (1) teaching (2) research (3) outreach function, and (4) fundraising function. Recommendation One: Interim Director of Institute Successful models of institutes of sustainability throughout the country build around a senior faculty member who brings experience and strong expertise to the teaching and scholarship of sustainability. Such an individual integrates classroom and research strengths with the ability to bridge across departments and colleges. The work of the director would be to interrelate the broad spectrum of external constituencies that harbor desires for assistance and educational support for their private and public enterprises. Support is recommended in the form of a salary and compensation base for the director/senior professor and course release similar to other departmental chair positions. 34 Recommendation Two: Sustainability General Education Sequence For the integrative “interdisciplinarity” of sustainability to be adequately addressed at Western, new models for course development must be supported and further developed. The successfully piloted sustainability general education sequence that includes Sustainability Literacy I, II, and III are currently offered as experimental courses through Huxley. The experiential and integral structure of the course sequence includes the participation of over 30 faculty from every college and 15 different disciplines. This course sequence lays the groundwork for students to major or minor in sustainability-related programs. With the addition of 2-3 existing companion courses to compliment the Sustainability Literacy sequence, an interdisciplinary General Education sequence can be offered to Western students. Because of the new forms of pedagogical approaches taken in these courses, we recommend support for a Faculty Sustainability Curriculum Coordinator, for participating faculty honoraria, and for student teaching assistance. Recommendation Three: Sustainability Curriculum Development Over 85 Western faculty representing all colleges at WWU have been conducting classes and/or engaging in the research of sustainability in their fields for years. Support for faculty engaged in sustainability curriculum development is recommended in the form of honoraria, fellowships, or release time. Our vision of sustainability education at Western is to build new models for integrated and active learning by using the best available practices in student learning and engagement, which demands the redesign of courses and curricula through a broad sustainability agenda that transcends curricular constraints that currently isolate content knowledge from broader student-learning goals. Recommendation Four: Student Support We recommend the Institute’s coordination of student research under work-study, internships, class projects, and leadership opportunities to further individual and team student learning in applied sustainability research. Recommendation Five: Research Initiatives and Knowledge Creation The scope of sustainability research at Western is multi-faceted and portrays a commitment to the multidisciplinary collaborative style of problem solving essential to addressing environmental, social, and economic needs. Within this framework lies the need to further define what and how sustainability research contributes to the varied disciplines and professions that Western engages. Equally as timely is the need for Western to collect data regarding the market demand for sustainability education in regards to graduate employment for students and in relationship to global scholarship for students and faculty. The Sustainability Institute would serve as a resource for developing and sharing applied research that informs the practices of faculty and students. Support is recommended to provide grants to faculty for the development of applied research projects that investigate the critical academic and societal questions invoked by sustainability practices in higher education 35 Recommendation Six: Service Learning and Local and Global Partnerships Because sustainability is more a way of thinking and behaving than a science, there is a need for innovative and flexible pathways to provide students and faculty opportunities for global study and collaboration. In addition to the many opportunities available at Western for students to engage in actionlearning locally and globally, there has been an enormous increase in sustainability education programs offered outside of Western that students are increasingly integrating into their course of study through study abroad programs or independent learning credits. In addition to student interest in these emerging programs of study, faculty teaching sustainability-related topics understand the need for global partnerships that can be facilitated through regional projects facilitated through Western that are aligned with global initiatives. We recommend the Sustainability Institute as a hub where these partnerships can be identified, assessed, and integrated among faculty and students. Recommendation Seven: Public Model of Sustainability Education We are a sustainability leader in many ways among state universities like us, but we are not as competitive in our initiatives as private colleges and universities. One of the criteria for a public model of sustainability education is accessibility, which may require Western to be creative with credits, enrollment, extended education, and tuition-based programs. We recommend the Sustainability Institute as a resource for conducting up-to-date research on existing models at other state universities and doing benefit-analysis for incorporating similar models at Western based on student initiated feedback. Recommendation Eight: Outreach As part of their market and branding research two years ago, the Lyric Company of Seattle highlighted the result of their research under five categories. In each of the five, sustainability was a focal point for Lyrics recommendations. There is a “powerful desire to make a difference and have an impact... in the community… (and) for the environment”. “The Western Hook” is sustainability and environmental stewardship (which is) embedded deeply in the consciousness with opportunities for hands-on student involvement. The Institute can play a key role in coordinating efforts of making community connections between service learning opportunities and academic internships and projects and public and private partners in matters related to sustainable solutions. Recommendation Nine: Sustainability Recognition and Promotional Development Although Western has a long tradition of being a leader in environmental education and stewardship, further recognition and communication of Western Sustainability amidst the larger global conversation on sustainability education is necessary. The Institute would serve as a clearinghouse of programs and projects, faculty expertise, and student involvement for articulating how these goals are supported through sustainability initiatives at Western. The Sustainability Institute would also serve as a boundary-spanning entity reaching across colleges and out into governments, businesses, non-profits, and institutions to articulate collaborative efforts and potential partnerships toward reimagining and redesigning higher education to meet the context of the 21st century. Recommendation Ten: Capitalize on Funding Opportunities 36 The broadest need for the development of the Sustainability Institute is to capitalize on the growing awareness among all sectors of society that in order to meet the great challenges of the 21st century there needs to be more sustainable thinking and practices. Colleges and universities are uniquely positioned to bring together a collective of complimentary resources and knowledge particularly suited to solving large complex issues like sustainability. The colleges and universities that have broadly and deeply embraced sustainability efforts are succeeding in reputation and fund-raising. They have become the recognized leaders in the race to infuse the values of sustainability into their institutional culture; they have moved sustainability from good intentions to realizing the vision of meeting the challenges of this century. Western’s Institute of Sustainability has the potential to move an already strong operational program and expand Western’s fundraising efforts to serve a public increasingly looking for answers and the faculty, students, and institutions that seek to lead the efforts to find the answers. List of Figures Figure 1: Sustainability Institute Organizational Model Figure 2: Sustainability Triad: The Triple Bottom Line Figure 3: Sustainability Timeline at Western Washington University List of Appendices Appendix A: Sustainability Timeline at Western Appendix B: December 12, 2005 letter addressed to Dr. George Pierce Appendix C: Sustainability at Western Washington University, Proposed Action Steps Appendix D: Concept Paper, Recommendations for establishing a university-wide program in sustainability literacy, experiential learning, research, and the creation of a WWU Faculty Sustainability Academy Appendix E: August 2009 Business Plan Appendix F: Funding Resource Chart 37 Appendix A: Sustainability Timeline at Western 38 Appendix B: December 12, 2005 letter addressed to Dr. George Pierce 39 40 41 Appendix C: Sustainability at Western Washington University, Proposed Action Steps 42 43 44 Appendix D: Concept Paper, Recommendations for establishing a university-wide program in sustainability literacy, experiential learning, research, and the creation of a WWU Faculty Sustainability Academy WWU Sustainability Committee Subcommittee on Curriculum and Programs Sustainability Curriculum Concept Paper February 15, 2007 Subcommittee Members: Victor Nolet (Woodring College), Gary Bornzin (Fairhaven College), Dan Hagen (College of Business and Economics), Sara Singleton (Political Science), Linda Smeins (Art), Nicholas Zaferatos (Huxley College), Seth Vidana (Campus Sustainability Coordinator) Re: Recommendations for establishing a university-wide program in sustainability literacy, experiential learning, research, and the creation of a WWU Faculty Sustainability Academy 1. Background and History: The Curriculum and Programs Subcommittee met on several occasions in 2006 to discuss strategies for fostering sustainability education at WWU. The subcommittee forwarded its suggestions to the WWU Sustainability Committee in the winter of 2006, and held an open forum Roundtable Discussion on May 16, 2006 to review these suggestions with WWU students, faculty and staff. The suggestions were as follows: 1.1 Suggestions for WWU Sustainability Curriculum “Evaluate, assess, and develop recommendations regarding general university requirements to strengthen student literacy in the areas of environmental science and policy, planning and design.” "Investigate the desirability and feasibility of developing a university-wide Interdisciplinary Major in 'Sustainability'" that brings together studies in the natural sciences, social sciences, and humanities." Accompanying the suggestions, the Subcommittee forwarded several action items to the WWU Sustainability Committee: 1.2 Preliminary Concepts and Action Activities 1. Inventory existing WWU classes that contribute towards environmental/sustainability literacy; 2. Solicit student, faculty and staff interest and input on ways to improve WWU sustainability education. 3. Evaluate the range of skills and competencies that all WWU students should acquire in their undergraduate education as well as for students majoring in a new “sustainability” degree program; 4. Develop an inventory of WWU faculty dedicated to sustainability principles through teaching, research, service, and other creative endeavors; 5. Evaluate curricula changes to strengthen sustainability literacy among all Western students; 6. Evaluate the desirability, feasibility and design for a new degree major in “sustainability”, including structures for administering the program and ways to incorporate “areas of emphasis” (such as a Major in Sustainability with emphasis in 45 7. Evaluate alternatives for incorporating into the curriculum a diversity of perspectives on sustainability. WWU Sustainability Subcommittee on Curriculum and Programs: Recommendations 2/15/07 1 Based upon these prior activities and subsequent discussions held at the fall 2006 Sustainability Committee meeting, the Subcommittee met on November 30, 2006 to formulate the following recommendations for implementing a WWU-wide sustainability curriculum: 2. Overview of Sustainability Curriculum Recommendations The following recommendations seek to promote a developing curriculum and program in sustainability at WWU comprised of 1) classes in sustainability literacy, 2) classes in sustainability research skills, 3) a framework supporting independent student research and seminars in sustainability, 4) the creation of a university “overlay minor” in sustainability, and 5) the formation of a faculty oversight working group (“Sustainability Studies Academy”) to participate in teaching, mentoring, and guiding the development of a sustainability curriculum at WWU. The curriculum structure is intended to support sustainability studies serving freshman through graduate students. The curriculum could be developed in phases and comprised of a series of introductory classes (priority), a series of skills/development classes, seminar/independent research classes, and upper division/graduate research in sustainability. 2.1. Classes in Sustainability Literacy (a 100-level course structure) GUR Freshman/Sophomore Education Format: WWU could establish a GUR class in sustainability, initially serving as an optional GUR class; eventually it could become a separate GUR track requiring sustainability literacy for all WWU students. The initial class could be designed as a large format lecture class for 400 students, offered each quarter. The course would have a capacity to serve 1200 students each year, about 50% of the incoming freshman class. Curriculum: Multi-disciplinary, comprised of up to 10 faculty members sharing teaching responsibilities from throughout the disciplines. Faculty, who are members of the WWU Sustainability Academy, could teach 1 or 2 weeks, introducing their particular discipline’s relationship to sustainability issues. Thematic: The course could be designed to address WWU’s impact, locally, regionally, and globally, on sustainability issues (i.e. global warming; carbon neutrality) as well as to the impact of sustainability issues on WWU and its students. Students would examine the impact of their personal decisions and behaviors in the larger context of the communities to which they belong. They should come out of the class with several foundational understandings: sustainability issues are complex and interdisciplinary; each of us makes decisions that have impact beyond our immediate situation and into the future (therefore, we need to think “upstream and downstream” when we make those decisions); all disciplines have a stake in sustainability and there are ways that each discipline can contribute to creating a greener WWU and more sustainable planet. 2.2. Classes in Sustainability Research, Methods, Skills (a 200-level course structure). Format: Mid-size classes offered by the Sustainability Studies Academy faculty introduce students to sustainability research methods, interdisciplinary studies, and working group problem solving skills. The class serves students advancing from the GUR WWU Sustainability Subcommittee on Curriculum and Programs: Recommendations 2/15/07 46 2 class interested in furthering knowledge in sustainability. The course provides skills for future independent research studies in sustainability. Thematic: Applied research skills in a cross disciplinary environment. Experiential learning emphasizes topics relating to understanding sustainability through WWU’s institutional as well as individual impacts. 2.3. Framework for Experiential Learning (300-400-500-level structures). Experiential Learning / Independent Research / Seminars / Service Learning Format: Faculty mentored small group seminars and independent research. Thematic: Faculty developed seminars in applied sustainability studies. Faculty guided student independent research could address a wide range of sustainability topics of concern to WWU which are identified by the Sustainability Academy. Research products could be managed, published, and distributed through the WWU Campus Sustainability Office. Graduate Research: Independent research studies can include graduate thesis research. 2.4. Overlay “Minor” in sustainability studies. Students participating in the sustainability course sequence (the number of total credits and composition of courses to be determined) could obtain a “WWU minor in Sustainability Studies”, as an overlay minor to their chosen WWU majors. Courses taken in the sustainability curriculum could satisfy as “electives” in the student’s major. 2.5. Faculty Sustainability Academy A Sustainability Studies Academy could be established comprised of all WWU faculty members who “self declare” a research, teaching, of creative endeavor interest in sustainability studies. The Academy could contribute in several ways to WWU sustainability studies: 1. Serve as faculty in the GUR (100) and Research/Methods (200) courses 2. Sponsor student independent research 3. Teach Seminars (300 – 500 level) 3. Mentor student-faculty research projects 4. Serve on committees for “self-design sustainability majors” 5. Identify suitable research topics 6. Monitor and refine the sustainability curriculum 7. Sponsor open colloquy and panel discussions to address emerging and controversial issues that pertain to sustainability and WWU’s impacts. 8. Engage in interdisciplinary research and scholarly writing focusing on issues related to sustainability. Organization: A “call for faculty” could be announced, inviting faculty to self-declare their qualifications as a member of the Academy, identifying their particular area of emphasis. Research Products: In collaboration with the Sustainability Office, topics of interest to WWU’s sustainability program could be identified and the research topics could form a framework for studies in the sustainability curriculum. Funding could support publication of research projects, and disseminate on the WWU sustainability website. WWU Sustainability Subcommittee on Curriculum and Programs: Recommendations 2/15/07 47 3 Appendix E: August 2009 Sustainability Institute Business Plan DRAFT (8/30/09) BUSINESS PLAN The Western Washington University Institute of Sustainability Initiative Vision Statement The vision of the Institute of Sustainability is: ‘To foster the collaborative, interdisciplinary education of critical thinkers who will lead, inspire and engage their communities toward sustainability”. Mission Statement The Institute will work across boundaries to promote efforts that lead to better understanding of the concepts and importance of sustainability today and in the future. Development Principles The Institute of Sustainability Institute Initiative (ISI) will be undertaken in concert with existing campus and community resources and support. Within one year, it is expected the Institute will be fully established; educational and outreach programs serving the public, business, and non-profit enterprises will be underway. The goal is to have the Institute selfsufficient and sustainable by the end of year 3 (spring, 2012). Distinct features of the Initiative will include: - Meet the intent of the Mission of the University, the Institutional Master Plan, and the Action Steps of the Strategic Plan. - Adopt Western visions and expositions that call for the engagement its students in the vitality of our community, see the present economic environment as an opportunity, and provide University avenues toward solving the many challenges of our time. - Be transparent and inclusive in the process of establishing and operating the Institute thereby affording broad on-campus and community opportunities for participation. The University’s Sustainability Committee in 2006 chose an operational definition of sustainability to make it goal-oriented. The resultant definition reads: “A sustainable WWU: Protects local and global ecology; Upholds social equity; Creates economic vitality; and Maintains human health.” 48 Throughout the Initiative to establish the Institute, conversations with faculty, students, and staff will provide the grist for a more informed and inclusive definition of sustainability, one that will serve as the imprimatur for the programs to be included within the Institute’s umbrella. Goals The sustainability initiative will have these overarching goals: 1. Increase the number and intensity of sustainability efforts on Western’s campus. 2. Enhance the ability of WWU colleges to carry out scholarly activities and development projects in partnership with faculty and students from the broader campus community. 3. Attract federal and state grants and contracts, and private gifts, to enhance Western’s applied sustainability capacity. 4. Support the development and implementation of integrated education programs promoting sustainability throughout the curriculum. Need The broadest need for the Initiative in development of the Institute of Sustainability is to capitalize on the growing awareness among all sectors of society, in this country and across the world, that in order to meet the great challenges of the 21st century there needs to be more sustainable thinking and practices. Universities, such as Western, recognize that higher education is the nation’s incubator for future leaders and the channel by which new practices and experimentation can be implanted. Western’s Mission of “Engaged Excellence” explicitly states its intent is to provide “a high quality environment that compliments the learning community on a sustainable and attractive campus intentionally designed to support learning and environmental stewardship”. (WWU Strategic Plan, 2006) While there have been significant changes in physical plant, resident halls and dining, and campus operations at Western, the more important changes in teaching and learning are not as prevalent. Western is not alone. As determined by a recent survey of over 1,000 schools, “a relatively small percentage of campuses offer interdisciplinary degree opportunities in environmental and sustainability studies. Moreover, considerably fewer campuses today require all students to take courses on environmental or sustainability topics.” (National Wildlife Federation, 2008) The colleges and universities that have broadly and deeply embraced sustainability efforts are succeeding in reputation and fund-raising. They have become the recognized leaders in the race to infuse the values of sustainability into their institutional culture; they have moved sustainability from good intentions to realizing the vision of meeting the challenges of this century. Upon its development, the Institute of Sustainability has the capacity to expand 49 Western’s efforts to serve a public increasingly looking for answers and the students who seek to lead the efforts to find the answers. There is not a more important and critical time to begin a concerted engaged effort than now when economic realities call for genuine and innovative approaches to a more sustainable future. Development Phases The Initiative will be conducted in four phases with the following objectives: Phase 1, Start-Up: Spring Quarter, 2009 – summer, 2009 Secure seed funding to support the startup of the project. This will be completed during the Spring Quarter. Establish an assessment/steering committee to assist in the development efforts. The committee will report to the Sustainability Committee on a quarterly basis. This will be completed by the end of the summer. Develop a fund-raising plan with national, regional, and local sustainability partners and professional groups. This will be completed by the end of the summer, 2009, through coordinated efforts with the Western Foundation, and the colleges. Participate in formative efforts to develop a faculty sustainability academy. This will be on-going through the summer and into the Fall Quarter in concert with the 40 to 60 interested faculty members, students, and deans. Review models of broad-based university and/or college entities that include sustainability elements of research, instructions, operations, and community outreach. Based on the models, develop a social-based communications software program. This will be completed by the end of the summer. In concert with the Sustainability Coordinator and the Vice Provost for Undergraduate Education, to develop an internship program in sustainability. This will be completed by the end of the summer. Phase 2, Fall Quarter, 2009 – Spring Quarter, 2010 Initiate the Sustainability Internship Program on a pilot basis, an effort composed of recruitment, training, academic year employment, and faculty supervision and administration. The pilot will run through the Spring Quarter. 50 Participate in broad conversations about the curricular efforts of sustainability in academe. This will be completed by the end of the Fall Quarter, 2009, through the efforts of the University’s Sustainability Committee, faculty sustainability academy, and other interested parties. Through campus meetings and on-line communications, review the possible models most appropriate for Western’s Institute. This will be completed by the end of Fall Quarter. Prepare a concept document (“White Paper”) of the Institute of Sustainability for Western. Circulate widely and gather input. The document will be completed by the end of Winter Quarter. Seek academic governance approval of curriculum additions and modifications for the better integration of sustainability courses and practicum. Phase 3, Summer, 2010 Prepare a final business plan for the Institute. Circulate widely and gather input. The draft will be crafted during the summer and circulated during the Fall Quarter. Phase 4, Fall Quarter, 2010 – Spring Quarter, 2011 Begin to implement curricular changes as approved. This will run throughout the academic year. Finalize Business Plan. This will be completed by the end of Winter Quarter. Undergo final review and assessment by the Sustainability Committee and the governance of the University. This will be completed by the end of the Spring Quarter. Issue final report of the Institute of Sustainability Initiative. Context for Sustainability Most leading sustainable institutions have developed initiatives of integrating sustainability throughout the University and beyond the campus into the community. These initiatives are in the arenas of: research; education and instruction; outreach; and, campus business practices. Western will advance its Strategic Plan – “Engaged Excellence”, which 51 includes Sustainability efforts. In so doing, Western will continue to strive for successful and sustainable programs in all institutional arenas. Western is uniquely positioned. It can build upon the decades of environmental and sustainable leadership of the Huxley College of the Environment. For three years, the Office of Sustainability has been providing programs and activities for the engagement of students, both on campus and in the community. Faculty from across the colleges and disciplines, who have been conducting classes and research of sustainability in their fields, are forming an academy to advance curricular efforts. Furthermore, the broad visions and expositions found in the Strategic Plan call upon Western to become a University that: first, engages its students, and its resources, in the social, cultural, and economic vitality of our community, state, and nation; second, sees the economic crisis as an opportunity and moves to build environmental and economic models that will thrive; and, three, produces avenues toward solving the many challenges of our time. Research has shown that campus sustainability calls for a systemic approach. The main constituent groups that compose the University should have the opportunity to create ideas for sustainability programs. Those programs which contribute to the University’s mission and Strategic Plan should have a structure through which their contributions toward sustainability can be most effectively stimulated, brought into relationship, and supported. To date, Western staff, faculty, and students have made many contributions to the campus and community. They are summarized below. (A more complete listing is found in the Appendix to this Plan.) 1. Dean Brad Smith of Huxley co-chaired the Governor’s Task Force of Sustainability, a state-wide group of educators, business people, students, and representatives from the tribes, community, and governmental agencies. Their report and recommendations have formed the framework for recent gubernatorial and legislative action in the broad arena of sustainability and environmental action. 2. The Office of Sustainability has been created, staffed by the Sustainability Coordinator, Seth Vidana, and seven student employees. They provide staff assistance and some resources to a myriad of programs and activities with a strong focus on student engagement and initiative. Examples are assessment of the University’s carbon footprint and energy saving programs in the residence halls. 3. Sustainable business practices have been incorporated into the day-to-day operations of Business and Financial Affairs and Student Affairs. Examples are pesticide-free fertilizers, green cleaning methods throughout the buildings, and locally-grown food in the dining halls. 4. Collaborations with off-campus groups have been formed. Faculty, students, and staff have been involved in providing expertise, excitement, and products to support the many community efforts aimed at sustainability. Examples are involvements with City of Bellingham neighborhood planning, Brenthaven Manufacturing, and the Northwest Higher Education Sustainability Consortium. 52 5. The Bellingham/Whatcom Sustainable Strategies Council has recently been formed with the vision to create a center of excellence combining value proposition and a new economic model based on a vibrant local economy built on green principles. Membership includes the cities of the county, the Port of Bellingham, Technology Alliance Group, Opportunity Council, Sustainable Connections, Whatcom Community Foundation, Whatcom Community College, Bellingham Technical College, Lummi Nation, Western Washington University, and a number of businesses in the region. 6. A Faculty Sustainability Academy is being established. A faculty-initiated program through the auspices of the University Sustainability Committee, it seeks to provide a University-wide umbrella for faculty who have teaching or scholarly interest in some aspect of sustainability. Through such activities as the Sustainability Design Charrette Workshop the Academy hosted in December, 2008, the Academy hopes to support the communication and the matching of complimentary interests in teaching and research. 7. Woodring College of Education, along with the Superintendent of Public Instruction, and Facing the Future, is sponsoring the Sustainability Education Summer Institute at Islandwood in July, 2009. The purpose of this teacher education conference is to allow teachers, school administrators, and teacher educators to develop a deeper understanding of sustainability education as it applies to K-12 schools. These, and many other activities and programs (see Appendix), with continued and consistent coordination and direction, will lay the foundation for a broad-based Institute will promote Western as an educational leader in sustainability. The Institute of Sustainability Development Philosophy “Facing Changes” could be the theme of the Western Washington University Institute of Sustainability Initiative. Because sustainability is more a way of thinking than a science and universities are complex systems, the Institute will be developed to provide clear pathways toward a definable end. Efforts at producing a more sustainable organization and environment have tended to focus on operations that can yield immediate and tangible results (energy conservation, recycling and purchasing). The development of the Institute, therefore, will recognize the need to move beyond result-based results and comprehensively penetrate the three common higher education functions of education, research, and community outreach/service. It will afford mission-directed academic programs and activities to gain full traction and critical mass. Furthermore, the Institute of Sustainability Initiative will define the leadership role of Western and design common internal pathways for change so it will not be difficult to craft a blueprint for change that will have a wide applicability to other schools. 53 The Institute Administrator and Coordinator Dr. George A. Pierce, formally Vice President for Business and Financial Affairs, is serving as the coordinator of the project as Special Assistant for Sustainability. Dr. Pierce will work with the Provost and the Vice Provost for Undergraduate Education in monitoring and supporting the academic integration of the sustainability efforts of the colleges. In addition, Dr. Pierce will be working closely with the deans of the seven colleges and with the Coordinator of Sustainability. It is planned for the Sustainability Coordinator’s role to increase in fostering the co-curricular programs so important to the successful implementation of the Institute. A number of faculty, administrators, staff, and students will be involved in the planning and development and eventual operation of the Institute. Many of these individuals have been leaders in supporting and nurturing sustainability in their operations, studies, and research. Many form the membership of Western’s Sustainability Committee, a University-wide group cochaired by Dean Brad Smith and Dr. Pierce. Many faculty members, instrumental in establishing what is being called Western’s Faculty Academy for Sustainability, will be instrumental in designing the specific curricular efforts for sustainability. Competitive Environment There are many indicators that point to a growing sustainability movement in higher education, both in the United States and throughout the world. The greatest gains to date have occurred in campus operations. The large number of schools working toward carbon reduction commitments is driving many of these gains. The other Washington four-year public institutions participate in this movement, as envisioned in their web sites: 1. Central Washington University has the intended goal to “prepare students for responsible citizenship, responsible stewardship of the earth, and enlightened and productive lives”. Central states it is sustainable by efforts such as: promoting carbon reduction; continuing energy conservation and efficiency efforts; and, planting native landscapes. It is also developing environmentally focused majors and curriculum. 54 2. Eastern Washington University is in the process of strategic planning. It will be through these efforts that a program of sustainability will be developed and subsequently infused in the University 3. The Evergreen State College’s vision for a sustainable future states that it will “be a laboratory for sustainability as demonstrated in our operations, curriculum, and quality of life for employees and students. We will nurture values and practical skills that motivate a lifetime commitment to a sustainable, intergenerationally (sic) just way of living on a healthy planet.” Their strategic plan notes the commitment to carbon neutrality, waste reduction, and the pursuit of environmental stewardship and social justice. 4. University of Washington has created the College of the Environment in June, 2008, which is seen as “the unifying, catalyzing hub for multidisciplinary environmental research, education, and application” in the university. The college structure is vital as it provides: Scale (college is highest level of academic organization); Focus and collaboration (faculty, students, and practitioners); Unrivaled capabilities (critical mass to make unprecedented contributions); and, Degree-granting educational programs (range of environment-linked educational opportunities across and within academic disciplines). 5. Washington State University’s Faculty Senate in 2006 approved a faculty-led initiative to create a system-wide interdisciplinary Center for Environmental Research, Education and Outreach. In January, 2009, an executive policy was issued called the “Washington State University Sustainability Initiative” which articulated five sustainability and university goals, including: achieve preeminence in innovation, discovery, and creativity; provide an education and transformative experience for students; lead in outreach and engagement; and, embrace diversity, integrity, and transparency. The following list provides a broad context of the many aspects of sustainability. Funding Under the recent Federal stimulus funding, an emphasis has been placed on sustainability by President Obama’s administration. While most of this falls within the domain of job training and green manufacturing, there are opportunities for universities to partner with the public and private sectors to receive funding. Higher educational Opportunity Act of 2008 – Authorizes the University Sustainability Program at the Department of Education. Will offer competitive grants to institutions and associations to develop, implement, and evaluate sustainability curricula, practices, and academic programs. Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 – Authorizes $250 million in grants and $500 million in loans for renewable energy and energy efficiency projects in institutions, public schools and local governments. 55 A number of state, national, and international networks support broad-based efforts in economic, environmental, and social sustainability (U. S. Citizens Network, U. N. Environment Programme, Washington Center Curriculum for the Bioregion). A number of local and regional private foundations and companies provide start-up and programmatic funding for education, research, and student support (Russell Family Foundation, Bullitt Foundation, Rocky Mountain Institute Grant Program). Local and regional utility companies provide support of efforts that reduce energy or benefit alternative energy sources (Puget Sound Energy, Endeavor Wind Project). Associations Several national non-profit organizations and programs are formed especially to make sustainability a foundation of learning/or practice in higher education. (Second Nature, U.S. Green Building Council) More than a dozen mainstream higher education associations now include advancement of sustainability in their agenda and core programs. (NACUBO, SCUP) 20 national disciplinary associations have formed the Disciplinary Association Network for Sustainability to jointly develop curricula, standards, and professional development programs. (Civil Engineers, Architects, Psychology) Corporate America has formed alliances and centers aimed assisting in sustainability efforts directed to businesses (Apollo Alliance, The Conference Board, ACORE). Higher Education Activities Over 600 college and university presidents have signed the American College and University Presidents Climate Commitment. More than 300 campuses have conducted campus sustainability assessments with hundreds planning to. At least 250 campuses have sustainability coordinators or offices and more than 1,000 expected to have by the end of the decade. More than 500 schools have institution-wide sustainability committees. With the past 3 years, several dozen universities have attracted multi-million dollar gifts for their sustainability efforts, with several getting gifts exceeding $20 million to establish sustainability centers or institutes. The latest were Portland State University which received $25 million and Stanford which received $20 million. 56 The Aspen Institute found 239 broadly defined applied sustainability centers across the globe. Conclusion: they are attracting significant resources and their leadership provides an increasing edge in attracting top students, faculty and company support. At least 27 institutions launched sustainability-themed degrees, certificates, or academic programs in 2007, up from 22 in 2006 and 3 in 2005. In 2006 at least 18 schools established new research and academic institutes or centers dedicated to studying aspects of environmental sustainability – alternative energy, environmental education, organic agriculture and transportation. Another 10 research centers started in 2007 with a focus on renewable energy. There are plans for another 6 with a focus on energy technologies. More than 350 large campus buildings have or are “in line” for LEED certification. The combined purchases of EPA’s Top 10 green power purchasers in higher education (including WWU) exceeds 758 million kilowatt hours of green power annually (equivalent to the electricity needed to power 78,000 average American homes). Often as a result of student demand, higher education is now the largest purchaser of wind energy in the United States. Last January, Focus the Nation (now the National Teach-in on Global Warming Solutions) organized the biggest national teach-in in history, engaging a million students at more than 1,900 institutions in a day-long teach-in about global warming. Initiative Operating Budget The University administration will be committing a .40 FTE professional staff coordinator position and start-up operational support for the project. Included in the operational costs will be the establishment of an office for the coordinator and one or two student interns. In addition, a senior member of the Institutional Research staff will be assigned to the Initiative for the initial research and assessment. A support budget for faculty, student, and staff will be committed from proceeds from the Wilder Gift for Sustainability. The total annual cost is approximately $45,000. Included in the support funding will be travel to professional workshops and conferences and internships for selected students. In-kind contributions will be committed from local and state businesses, as well as gifts and grants for specific development and program efforts aimed at assisting in the development of the Institute. The total annual contribution is estimated to be $30,000 during the first year and $100,000 by year three. 57 Appendix E: Funding Resource Chart 58