Blood Spatter Pattern Analysis Grade Level & Duration: 11/12 2 – 50 min periods Subject: Forensics Prepared By: Carol Clinton Analyze Learners Overview & Purpose (STEMcinnati theme) Education Standards Addressed Ratios and Proportional Reasoning Beginning with surface tension, a basic property of fluids, students study the math and science of blood spatter pattern analysis. They design and conduct experiments to study the effect of variables including travel path length, angle of impact, and surface of impact. Then they analyze the resulting stains using basic trig functions to calculate the angle of impact, and graph the relationships between variables to create tools that will allow them to solve an unknown “crime scene” scenario (that is a separate activity that will be their final exam). Applications to the real world : Techniques used in this lesson are the actual laboratory methods used by government forensics labs to generate information that is used to solve crimes. (video clips from the Midwest Forensics Research Center are used as part of the lesson). MA-HS-1.4.1 Students will apply ratios, percents and proportional reasoning to solve real-world problems (e.g., those involving slope and rate, percent of increase and decrease) and will explain how slope determines a rate of change in linear functions representing real-world problems. MA-HS-2.1.3 Students will apply definitions and properties of right triangle relationships (right triangle trigonometry and the Pythagorean theorem) to determine length and angle measures to solve real-world and mathematical problems. MA-HS-3.1.11 Students will visualize solids and surfaces in three-dimensional space when given two-dimensional representations (e.g., nets, multiple views) and create two-dimensional representations for the surfaces of three-dimensional objects. MA-HS-4.1.1 Students will analyze and make inferences from a set of data with no more than two variables, and will analyze problems for the use and misuse of data representations. MA-HS-4.1.2 Students will construct data displays for data with no more than two variables. MA-HS-4.3.2 Students will design simple experiments or investigations to collect data to answer questions of interest. Societal impact: Unfortunately, we live in a world where violent crimes occur. Science and math can be used to help solve such crimes and bring justice. Career connections: Math and science concepts such as the ones in this lesson are applicable to a wide variety of fields, from all types of engineering, to law enforcement and forensics research, to accurate screen writing for hit shows like the CSI series. Select Goals and Objectives Teacher Guide Student Guide Goals and Objectives (Specify skills/information that will be learned.) Select Instructional Strategies – Information (Give and/or demonstrate necessary information) 1. Bloodstain patterns Define blood spatter patterns Calculate the impact angle of blood spots Describe the physical properties of blood that have an impact on bloodstain pattern analysis Day 1: Photos and videos of blood spatter are used to capture attention. http://www.nfstc.org/links/animations/images/blood%20spatters.swf http://files.mfrc.ameslab.gov/ 1Aa2 Blood dripping from a wrench handle.avi 3Da1a Blood drop falling 10 cm onto carpet.avi 3Fa1a Blood drop falling 10 cm onto wood.avi 3Fb2a Blood drop falling 100 cm onto wood (1).avi 4Ai2 Blood drop falling to a 90 degree target (top view).avi 4Ad1 Blood drop falling to a 40 degree target (front view).avi 4Ad1 Blood drop falling to a 40 degree target (side view).avi Materials Needed (22 students in groups of 2 = 11 groups) Clipboards – one per group Meter sticks Small rulers (mm) protractors Paper 8-1/2 x 11 graph paper Sheets of other light colored materials (e.g., fabric, wallpaper, plexiglass, plastic wrap, plywood) Pencils/pens/sharpie markers Masking tape Fake blood: - Flinn Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Kit FB1643 http://www.flinnsci.com $32.95 - (alternative kit Ward’s Blood Spatter Analysis Lab Activities $79.95 http://wardsci.com) - Or make your own from recipes at http://www.clt.uwa.edu.au/asistm/forensic_investigations/ bloodstain_pattern_analysis The Day 1 powerpoint presentation (~ 20 minutes) gives details about the principles of blood spatter pattern analysis. The lab is introduced. Teams are chosen and begin designing their experiments. Depending on length of instructional period, lab can be conducted on day 1 to generate “blood” spatter patterns under controlled conditions. Day 2: Discuss results of pattern generation lab, conduct the analysis portion (measuring stains, computing angle of impact, graphing relationships between variables). Utilize Technology Internet video clips and powerpoint presentation are used to transmit information. Students use simple equipment (fake blood, pipets, rulers, protractors, and a variety of everyday materials as the impact surfaces) to conduct experiments and generate spatter patterns. Students use calculators and graph paper to analyze resulting patterns. Other Resources (e.g. Web, books, etc.) Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Tutorial By: J. Slemko Forensic Consulting http://www.bloodspatter.com/BPATutorial.htm Require Learner Participation Activity (Describe the independent activity to reinforce this lesson) Evaluate (Assessment) (Steps to check for student understanding) Your goal is to figure out what conditions caused the patterns found at the “crime scene.” Design and conduct experiments to gather data and formulate hypothesis that will allow you to reconstruct events. Day 1: Create blood spatter patterns with drops from different angles of impact and different heights on different surfaces. Day 2 From drop patterns: Measure diameters, widths and lengths of final (dried) drops. Create tables to report data. Graph diameter of drops vs. height. Determine angle of impact from width and length of drops using the arcsine trigonometry relationship. Graph angle of impact vs. width and vs. length of drops. Essential questions: - what are some key variables in the resulting patterns of blood spatter? Drop height, surface it lands on (roughness, perviousness), angle of impact, placement of drops (on previous drops, pool, etc) - what is the effect of greater drop height? Larger stain Why? Increased energy (kinetic) allows farther spread - what is the effect of angle? Greater length of stain compared to width - how can you tell from a stain what the angle of impact was? Trig (arc sine, or “inverse sine” of width/length ratio) Additional Notes Reflection: Of course, the students loved the video clips from the Ames lab (Midwest Forensics Research Center) of blood dripping, spurting, flung, etc! And they generally enjoyed the lab. However, I discovered that several of them did not know how to read a protractor and did not understand that when you drop from height, it’s the impact surface that needs to be at an angle from horizontal. Some thought that holding the pipette at an angle would work and got frustrated when the patterns were the same no matter what angle they held the pipette (which should have been a clue for them…). I ended up creating the supplemental powerpoint presentation on impact angle that goes into more detail on this. I was surprised that some got frustrated with the freedom of being able to design their own experiments. I provided a variety of surface materials and left it to them to choose their own angles, heights, and other variables. Some wanted a “cook book” of exactly what to do and got perturbed when I wouldn’t tell them. The graphing took more time than I thought it should. And many students didn’t understand the concept of arc sine, so I had to go back and review trigonometry in more detail (see the supplementary powerpoint presentation).