John Milton & Seventeenth- Century Culture ARCHIVED ONLINE EXHIBIT Originally exhibited at the Thomas Cooper Library, University of South Carolina Based on an exhibit by Patrick Scott Archived November 4, 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS Archived Online Exhibit ................................................................................................................................. 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 2 Early Years ..................................................................................................................................................... 4 Italy & the 1640’s ........................................................................................................................................ 11 Civil War ...................................................................................................................................................... 19 Paradise Lost etc. ........................................................................................................................................ 25 Milton’s Reputation .................................................................................................................................... 31 Further References ..................................................................................................................................... 36 INTRODUCTION Books are not absolutely dead things, but do contain a potency of life. . . they do preserve as in a vial the purest efficacy and extraction of that living intellect that bred them . . . a good book is the precious life-blood of a master-spirit.John Milton, Areopagitica (1644) John Milton (1608-1674) was not only among the most influential of British poets. He was the most directly involved of any British poet in the centres of political power and in the great historical events of the English Revolution. He was also arguably the most learned, indeed the most bookish, of the great British poets, even in a learned and bookish century. This exhibit, drawn from the collections of Thomas Cooper Library, includes the first edition of Milton's first prose work Of Reformation (1641), the first edition of Milton's great defense of a free press Areopagitica(1644), and the first edition of his first volume of poetry Poems, English and Latin (1645, purchased by the Thomas Cooper Society in 1996). For Milton's most famous work, his epic Paradise Lost, first issued in 1667, the exhibit includes examples of the first edition in ten books (with 1669 prelims), the second edition in twelve books (1674), the third edition (1678), and the fourth edition (1688), the first with illustrations. Among Milton's later works, there are first and second editions of his volume Paradise Regain'd . . . To which is added Samson Agonistes (1671). In all, the exhibit includes twenty-three seventeenth-century Milton editions, along with important early editions of other writers, including Spenser, Shakespeare, Ariosto, Tasso, Hobbes, and Clarendon. The library has acquired these volumes over the years item by item, not from a single donor; several bear the stamp of the original South Carolina College library, while others come from the libraries of Charles Pinckney (author of the Pinckney draft of the Constitution), James Henley Hammond (through the gift of John Shaw Billings), Yates Snowden, the Presbyterian College for Women, Alfred Chapin Rogers, the Ewelme Collection of Robert Bridges, and others. Complementing the books on display are contemporary engravings of English and Italian cities where Milton lived, studied and visited, from the John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg City Views, presented to the library by Mrs. Mary Osman in 1989, and a 1647 engraving of the Parliamentary and Royalist armies at the Battle of Naseby, presented to the University by A.F. McKissick in 1937. The exhibit was mounted to coincide with the fifty-seventh annual meeting of the Southeastern Renaissance Conference, held at the University on April 14th-15th, 2000. I am indebted to the pesident and secretary of the Conference, Professors Emmanuel Seko and Gerald Snare, and the organizers, Professors Philip Rollinson and Andrew Shifflett, for their interest and encourage-ment; to Professor Rollinbson, for reviewing a draft of this catalogue; and to my co-workers in the Department of Rare Books & Special Collections, Paul Schultz, Mary Anyomi, and Sallie Ruff, for their assistance while it was in preparation. EARLY YEARS 1 London; Cambridge and Horton Viewing the Renaissance City: the Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg Georg Braun, 1541-1622, and Franz Hogenberg, c.1536-1588, title-page from Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber Primus Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1572]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. Most of the illustrative items in the upright cases are drawn from Thomas Cooper Library's John Osman Collection. The Osman Collection, donated by to the University by Mrs. Mary C. Osman, includes more than four hundred copperplate engraved maps and views of European cities, issued by the Dutch engravers Braun and Hogenberg in six volumes over the years 1572 to 1618. Milton's London Georg Braun, 1541-1622, and Franz Hogenberg, c.1536-1588, "Londinum Feracissimi Angliae Regni Metropolis," from Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber I Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1572]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. "I was born," Milton wrote, "at London, of an honest family; my father was distinguished by the undeviating integrity of his life; my mother, by the esteem in which she was held, and the alms which she bestowed." His actual birth day was December 9th, 1608, at the sign of the Spread Eagle, Bread Street, London. Milton's autobiography John Milton,1608-1674, from "The Second Defence of the People of England against an Anomymous Libel [1654]," translated from the Latin by Robert Fellowes in Charles Symmons., ed., The Prose Works of John Milton. 7 vols. London: for J. Johnson et al., 1806. Vol. VII. Milton was among the first English authors to leave an extended first-person account of his own early life, in Latin, defending his moral character against pro-monarchist attacks in the fierce disputes of the Commonwealth period. This passage from Milton's Defensio Secunda (1654) gives a gripping and coherent account of Milton's young adulthood and developing commitments in the 1630s and 1640s. Many of the annotations to later items in this exhibition are taken from this source. The translator, Robert Fellowes (1771-1847), an Oxford-educated clergyman who became editor of the Critical Review, was an active advocate of political reform and devoted a substantial inheritance to progressive causes such as the Benthamite non-sectarian University College, London. Though this is the longest and best-known of Milton's autobiographical accounts, there are also shorter passages in other prose works and in his poem Ad Patrem. A London school in the early seventeenth century Samuel Knight, 1675-1746. The life of Dr. John Colet, dean of St. Paul's in the reigns of K. Henry VII and K. Henry VIII and founder of St. Paul's school: with an appendix, containing some account of the masters and more eminent scholars of the foundation, and several original papers. New ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1823. Milton's father, also John Milton, a scrivener (a legal agent and often financial agent as well), was alert to the education of his son. "I had," Milton wrote, " from my first yeeres . . . bin exercis'd to the tongues and some sciences, as my age would suffer, by sundry masters," and from the age of seven or so he attended the nearby St. Paul's School. Shown here is the brief entry on him as one of the "more eminent scholars," from the biography of the school's founder. A center of Renaissance humanism "To the Reader," in William Lily, 1468?-1522; John Colet, 1467?-1519; Thomas Robertson, 1521-1561. [Latin grammar] London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown, 1821. Contemporary sheep. St. Paul's had a pivotal role in the development and dissemination of Renaissance classicism in Britain. The standard school texts in both Greek and Latin originated with Colet's St. Paul's, the Greek by the Dutch exile Desiderius Erasmus and the Latin (shown here in one of its innumerable later reprints) by the English scholar William Lily. When Milton came to write his own Latin grammar-book (published in 1669 as Accedence Commenc't Grammar, but probably written in the 1640s), he borrowed some 330 of his 530 illustrative quotations from Lily. Alexander Gill: the political perils of Puritan pedagogy William Douglas Hamilton, d. 1894, ed. Original papers illustrative of the life and writings of John Milton including sixteen letters of state written by him, now first published from mss. in the State paper office. With an appendix of documents relating to his connection with the Powell family. . . with the permission of the Master of the Rolls. Works of the Camden Society; no. 75. [Westminster]: Printed for the Camden Society, 1859. Milton's headmaster at St. Paul's was Alexander Gill (1564-1635), and his son Alexander Gill the younger (1597-1644), already a published poet, taught at the school. As these documents from official papers show, the younger Gill was an outspoken political critic, and in 1628 he ran into serious trouble with the authorities for criticism of the King's favorite, the Duke of Buckingham. Milton, Spenser, and the British epic Edmund Spenser, 1552?-1599. The faerie queene, disposed into XII. bookes. fashioning twelue morall vertues. London: Printed by H.L. For Mathew Lownes, 1609. Speckled calf binding with banded spine. "My father," Milton stated, "destined me from a child to the pursuits of literature," and his schoolmaster Alexander Gill the elder described Edmund Spenser as the Homer of the English language. In the preface to his Poems (1645), Milton's publisher asserted he had "brought into the Light as true a birth, as the Muses have brought forth since the famous Spencer wrote." Certainly, Spenser's great Protestant epic The Faerie Queene was among the continuing influences in Milton's poetic ambition. Shown here is the opening of Spenser's Book II, Canto X, where Spenser invokes the difficulty of his chosen task of chronicling the history of the British kings from Arthur to Gloriana. Milton's reading of Shakespeare John Milton, "On the Admirable Dramatick Poet, William Shakespear," in William Shakespeare, 1564-1616. Mr. William Shakespear's comedies, histories, and tragedies. Published according to the true original copies. Unto which is added, seven plays, never before printed in folio. The fourth edition. London: Printed for H. Herringman, E. Brewster, and R. Bentley. . ., 1685. Diced calf binding. Gold decorated spine with red label lettered in gold. --Milton's tribute to Shakespeare's influence, first published anonymously in 1630 in the second folio alongside verses by Ben Jonson and others, was his first published poem, written while he was still a student at Cambridge: . . . each heart Hath, from the leaves of thy unvalued book, Those Delphic lines with deep impression took. The poem is shown here from the fourth folio, because in Thomas Cooper Library's second folio, the prelims pages with Milton's epitaph are damaged. Metrical psalms, I "Psalm 101" in George Buchanan, 1506-1582. Ecphrasis paraphraseos Georgij Buchanani in Psalmos Davidis: ab Alexandro Iulio Edinburgeno, in adoloescentiae studiosae gratiam elaborata. Londini: Excusum apud G. Eld, 1620. Contemporary vellum. --As the subtitle of this volume shows, a Renaissance education moved easily between poetry of the classical and Christian traditions. The Scottish humanist George Buchanan, a fierce protestant who in 1570-78 was tutor to the future King James the VI and I, was recognized by contemporaries as facile princeps among Renaissance Scottish poets; indeed J.C.Scaliger judged Buchanan the greatest European Latin poet of the age. Alongside his original Latin poetry and (Latin) Biblical dramas, Baptistes andJeptha (a model for Milton's own Samson Agonistes), Bucahanan translated Euripides from Greek to Latin. His Latin version of the psalms (first published in the 1560s) was widely used as a school text. Metrical psalms, II The Psalmes of David in prose and meeter. With their whole tunes in foure or mo parts, and some psalmes in reports. Whereunto is added many godly prayers, and an exact kalendar for XXV. yeeres to come. Edinburgh: Heires of Andrevv Hart, 1635. Modern brown morocco, gilt. Bookplate of Allan D. Macdonald. --In both England and Scotland, as also in Geneva, the congregational singing of metrical psalms became central to protestant church services. From the Reformation till the 19th century, Calvinists sang only the metrical psalms or scriptural paraphrases, not man-made hymns, and sang them unaccompanied, being opposed to instrumental church music. By the time this Scottish psalter was published, the repertory included over 200 pieces. The title-page reference to "Psalmes in reports" indicates that the tune was arranged in three, four or five parts in "imitative counterpoint. Metrical psalms, III John Milton, "Psalm 114," and "Psalm 136 ['Let us with a gladsome mind']," in Paradise regain'd : a poem in four books: to which is added, Samson Agonistes and Poems upon several occasions. Edinburgh: Printed by A. Donaldson and J. Reid for Alexander Donaldson, 1762. Signature of Charles Pinckney. Contemporary mottled calf. --At St. Paul's, alongside verse-translations from Horace, Milton also produced these metrical psalms. The defects of the established English metrical version by Sternhold and Hopkins, from the Prayer Book, were widely recognized, and many Renaissance writers tried their hand at psalm-versification. When he included these efforts in his 1645 Poems, he noted that they had been written when he was only fifteen years old. Milton's Cambridge Georg Braun, 1541-1622, and Franz Hogenberg, c.1536-1588, "Cantebrigia," from Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber II Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1575]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. --From 1625-1632, with one brief interval, Milton was a student at Christ's College, Cambridge. In retrospect, in his poem Lycidas, he would idealize the tranquility of academic life: . . . we were nurst upon the self-same hill, Fed the same flock by fountain, shade, and rill. . . . Look homeward, angel, now, and melt with ruth. Milton graduated B.A. in March 1629 and M.A. in July 1632. Milton at Christ's College John Le Keux, 1783-1846, "Christ's College," in Thomas Wright, 1810-1877; H.L. Jones, 1806-1870, Memorials of Cambridge: a series of views of the colleges, halls, and public buildings, with historical and descriptive accounts. London: David Bogue, 1845. --The main front of Christ's remained essentially unchanged between Milton's time and this early Victorian engraving. Cambridge and Milton's early poetry John Milton, on Thomas Hobson the University Carrier, and "L'Allegro," in The poetical works of Milton : with prefatory characters of the several pieces, the life of Milton, a glossary, and an index. 2 vols. Edinburgh: Printed by A. Donaldson, 1767. Signature of Charles Pinckney, junior, in each volume. Contemporary calf. --Milton's elegy on Thomas Hobson illustrates the playfulness of his Cambridge verse, while the more substantial "L'Allegro" and its pair "Il Penseroso" show the continuing influence on Milton of the formal debate structure used in the Cambridge public exercises or disputations. Thomas Hobson (from whose monopoly of Cambridge transport comes the phrase "Hobson's Choice") had died in 1631, leaving a substantial endowment to maintain the Cambridge water-conduit which still bears his name. Country retreat: Middlesex in the early 17th century William Camden, 1551-1623. Britain : or, A chorographicall description of the most flourishing kingdomes, England, Scotland written first in Latine by W. Camden; translated newly into English by Philemon Holland. London: Georgii Bishop & Ioannis Norton, 1610. Early nineteenth century tree calf. --Milton spent the six years following his graduation from Cambridge living in the country outside London, first at Hammersmith, and then at Horton, about a mile from Colnbroke, on the west side of Middlesex. He looked back on the period with gratitude: "I enjoyed," he wrote, "an interval of uninterrupted leisure, which I entirely devoted to the perusal of the Greek and Latin classics." The great British antiquarian William Camden had, like Milton himself, been educated at St. Paul's School. Milton's Oxford Georg Braun, 1541-1622, and Franz Hogenberg, c.1536-1588, "Oxonium," and "Windsorium," from Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber II Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1575]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. --The Braun and Hogenberg series include not only city maps, but also external views that show the close interrelation of the urban and the rural in the seventeenthcentury. One of Milton's epic similes drew on just this contrast: As one who long in populous city pent, Where houses thick and sewers annoy the air, Forth issuing on a summer's morn to breathe Among the pleasant villages and farms Adjoined, from each thing met conceives delight, The smell of grain, or tedded grass, or kine, Or dairy, each rural sight, each rural sound. Paradise Lost, Book IX Though Oxford would later be a Royalist stronghold, in contrast to the Puritan leanings of its rival Cambridge, Milton's father had received his musical education in the choir at Christ Church, Oxford, and Milton himself incorporated as an Oxford M.A. in 1634, perhaps to get access to the Bodleian library. From Milton's poetic notebook: the Trinity Manuscript John Milton, "Arcades," and "Sonnet VII: How soon hath time," from the Trinity manuscript, in Samuel Leigh Sotheby, 1805-1861, Ramblings in the elucidation of the autograph of Milton. London: Printed for the author by T. Richards, 1861. How soon hath Time, the subtle thief of youth, Stolen on his wing my three-and twentieth year! My hasting days fly on with full career But my late spring no bud or blossom show'th. Milton's growth as a poet during the 1630s is documented in two extraordinary surviving manuscripts, his poetic notebook (the Trinity manuscript, from which this page has been engraved) and his notes from extensive reading (the Commonplace Book). The lines headed "Arcades" were from a masque performed at Harefield House, in honor of the Dowager Countess of Derby; soon after leaving Cambridge, Milton was asked to contribute verses for the masque (probably by the musician Henry Lawes, 1596-1662, a friend of Milton's father). The well-known sonnet on the passing of time, and of his youth, gives a more personal glimpse of him as he determined to spend further years of study in pursuit of his poetic ambitions. Renaissance patronage: Milton and the masque John Milton, adapted by George Colman, 1732-1794. Comus: a masque, in two acts by John Milton. London: J. Cumberland, [ca. 1834] --in 1634, Milton was again asked by Lawes to collaborate on a masque, for the same aristocratic patrons. Milton was the junior partner in this collaboration, and in a sonnet to Lawes expressed great regard for the musician . . . whose tuneful and well-measured song First taught our English music how to span Words with just note and accent . . . Thou honour'st verse, and verse must lend her wing To honour thee, the priest of Phoebus' quire The new masque was Comus, an allegory of the struggle between chaste temperance and riotous intemperance, written for the installation of the Countess's stepson, the Earl of Bridgwater, as Lord President of the Council of Wales, and first performed with his children in the leading roles at Ludlow Castle on September 29th 1634. Colman's 18th century stage adaptation of Comus incorporated music by Dr. Thomas Arne, who also composed the tune of "Rule Britannia." Poetic ambition and the deferral of fame John Milton, "Lycidas," in The poetical works of John Milton. Aldine edition of the British poets. 3 vols. London: William Pickering, 1851. Original blue-green cloth with paper label. --Milton's Lycidas, an elegy for his Cambridge contemporary Edward King first published in 1638, allowed Milton to mark the increasing contrast between the pastoral idyl of student life and the growing political tensions of the 1630s; it also incorporated reflections on his own situation in deferring a career through his twenties while he pursued his poetic ambitions, asking Alas, what boots it with incessant care To tend the homely, slighted, shepherd's trade, And strictly meditate the thankless Muse! Though he rebutted his doubts firmly enough in this poem, the question is significant in pointing ahead to his non-poetic activity in the next two decades. ITALY & THE 1640’S Italy, European Intellectual Life, and the Pamphlet Wars of the 1640s Hugo Grotius, 1583-1645; Willem de Groot, 1597-1662, ed. Hug. Grotii Poemata, per Guil. Grotium denuo edita, aucta, & emendata. Lugduni Batav.: apud Hieronymum de Vogel, 1639. Contemporary red morocco, gilt. Milton concluded his six years of quiet study with a remarkable eighteen-month tour to various centers of European antiquity and intellectual life, notably Italy. Early in his tour, in Paris in April 1638, he was able to meet one of his great intellectual heroes, the Dutch legal theorist Hugo Grotius, exiled from Holland but then serving as the Swedish ambassador to France. Among Grotius's Latin writings were two significant for Milton's own later poetry, the drama Adamus Exsul (1601) and the poem Christus patiens (published 1619). (The library's earliest edition of Milton's third great neoLatin poetic influence, with Buchanan and Grotius, Marco Girolamo Vida's Christiad, first published in 1535, dates only from 1731, and was not included in this exhibit.) Milton's Florence Georg Braun, 1541-1622, and Franz Hogenberg, c.1536-1588, "Florentia," from Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber I Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1572]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. Milton's first prolonged stay in Italy was in Florence, which he reached in late summer 1638. It was a city, he recalled, "which I have always more particularly esteemed for the elegance of its dialect, its genius, and its taste." There he met the poets of the Svogliati Academy, and visited the blind, elderly Galileo, at his villa south of the city. He returned to Florence on his way back north in February 1639. Eighteen miles from Florence lay the thick "autumnal leaves that strow the brooks/Of Vallombrosa." Milton's Rome Georg Braun, 1541-1622, and Franz Hogenberg, c.1536-1588, "Roma," from Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber I Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1572]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. During the late fall of 1638, Milton spent two months in Rome, "viewing the antiquities of that renowned city." . . . an imperial city stood, With towers and temples proudly elevate On seven small hills, with palaces adorned, Porches and theatres, baths, aueducts, Statues and trophies, and triumphal arcs, Gardens and groves . . . The Renaissance basilica of St. Peter's, Rome, to which Milton alludes in the Pandemonium scene ofParadise Lost, had recently been completed, in the years since this late sixteenth-century city view was printed, and he was also able to see the classical manuscripts of the Vatican library. He returned to Rome at the very end of 1638, for a further two months, before moving north, by way of Venice, towards home. Milton's Naples Georg Braun, 1541-1622, and Franz Hogenberg, c.1536-1588, "Neapolis," from Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber I Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1572]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. In November 1638, Milton pushed south to Naples, where he was befriended by Giovanni Manso, Marquis de Villa, to whom he addressed a Latin verse-epistle, later printed in his first volume of verse,Poems English and Latin (1645). "During my stay," Milton recalled, Manso "gave me singular proofs of his regard; he himself conducted me round the city, and to the palace of the viceroy; and more than once paid me a visit at my lodgings." Naples was the southernmost point of Milton's journey; in late December, "melancholy intelligence . . . of civil commotions in England" led Milton to curtail his original plans and turn back north. "I thought it base," he wrote, "to be traveling for amusement abroad, while my fellow-citizens were fighting for liberty at home." Ariosto's Orlando Furioso Lodovico Ariosto, 1474-1533. Orlando furioso di M. Lodovico Ariosto, tutto ricorretto, & di nuove figure adornato. Edited by Girolamo Ruscelli and with a life by Giovan Battista Pigna. In Venezia: heirs of Vincenzo Valgrisi, 1580. Modern vellum, gilt. Two of Milton's great heroes as modern epic poets were Italian, Ariosto and Tasso, and Milton's commonplace notebook includes reference to Ariosto's Orlando Furioso, and he quoted (in his own translation) from the poem in his own first prose work Of Reformation (1641). On his Italian journey, Milton passed through the northern city of Ferrara, where Ariosto had enjoyed the Duke's patronage. Tasso's Gierusalemme Liberata, I Torquato Tasso, 1544-1595. La Giervsalemme liberata di Torqvato Tasso. Con le figure di Bernardo Castello, e le annotationi di Scipio Gentili, e di Giulio Gvastavini. Genova: [G. Bartoli] 1590. Engraved title page and plates by Agostino Carracci and Giacomo Franco. Old citron morocco binding, paned sides, and gilt leaves. In Naples, Milton found a more direct and personal link to his other Italian poetic hero, Tasso, through his contact with the now-elderly Manso, who had been Tasso's patron and to whom Tasso had addressed his Discourse on Friendship. Tasso's Gierusalemme Liberata, II Torquato Tasso Goffredo, overo Gierusalemme liberata, poema heroico del S.Torquato Tasso, nel quale sono state aggiunte molte stanze leuate, con le varie lettioni; & postiui gli argomenti, & allegorie a ciascun canto d'incerto auttore. Con l'aggiunta de' cinque canti del sig. Camillo Camilli, & I loro argomenti, del sig. Franceso Melchiori opitergino. In Vinegia: heirs of Francesco de' Franceschi, 1600. Disbound; bookplate of James H. Hammond. Gift of John Shaw Billings. In his The Reason of Church Government (1641), Milton would list Tasso with Homer, Virgil and the Book of Job among his models in epic poetry. Milton's epigraph from Tasso's Gierusalemme liberata in his tribute to Manso (published in his 1645 Poems) was a graceful allusion to Manso's earlier patronage of Tasso as Milton sought similar patronage for himself. Galileo and Freedom of Thought Galileo Galilei, 1564-1642; Carlo Manolessi, fl. 1659, ed.. Opere di Galileo Galilei . . . In questa nuoua editione insieme raccolte, e di varij trattati dell' istesso autore non più stampati accresciute. 19 pts. 2 vols. Bologna: per gli hh del Dozza, 1655-56 [v.1, 1656]. Contemporary calf. Bookplates of Edward Lord Suffield and Thomas Clifford Allbutt. Among the most moving incidents of Milton's Italian journey was his visit in Florence to the great astronomer Galileo, now blind and still living under restrictions for (in Milton's acerbic summary fromAreopagitica, 1644) "thinking in Astronomy otherwise than the Franciscan and Dominican licencers thought." Milton refers to one of Galileo's hand-made telescopes in Paradise Lost, Book I, when he describes the "moon, whose orb/Through optic glass the Tuscan artist views/At ev'ning from the top of Fiesole." Milton and the Phlegraean Fields Georg Hofnagel, "Oriens Mirabilium Sulphureorum Motum apud Puteolos (Campos Flegreos . . . Neapolitanae)," [heading on verso: "Forum Vulcani, vulgo Solfataria" ] from Braun and Hogenberg, Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber Tertius Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1581]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. Seest you yon dreary plain, forlorn and wild, The seat of desolation, void of light, Save what the glimmering of these livid flames Casts pale and dreadful. . . Paradise Lost, Book I As the figures in this engraving suggest, the Phlegraean Fields, a few miles south of Naples, where sulphurous smoke spurted from the hot earth, awed Renaissance travelers to Italy, and the scene has been suggested as influencing Milton's depiction of Hell. Visiting the Sibyl's Cave Georg Hofnagel, "Antrum Sybyllae Cumanae," from Braun and Hogenberg, Civitates Orbis Terrarum, Liber Tertius Frankfurt: Braun and Hogenberg, [1581]. John Osman Collection of Braun & Hogenberg. . . . once it was my dismal hap to hear A Sybil old, bow-bent with crooked age, That far events full wisely could presage, And in Times long and dark Prospective Glass Fore-saw what future dayes should bring to pass. Milton, At a Vacation Exercise. The Sybil's cave at Cumae, near Naples, in Campania, the farthest outpost of Greek settlement in mainland Italy, is described in Vergil's Aeneid, Book VI. Hofnagel's engraving, based on his visit to Italy in 1577-78, nicely captures the classical allure that sites such as this held for Renaissance travelers. The young Milton as a European poet John Milton, Poems of Mr. John Milton: both English and Latin, compos'd at several times Printed by his true copies. The songs were set in musick by Mr. Henry Lawes . . . Printed and publish'd according to order. London: Printed by Ruth Raworth for Humphrey Moseley, and are to be sold at the signe of the Princes Arms in Pauls Church-yard, 1645. First edition. Lacking portrait. Purchased for the library by the Thomas Cooper Society, 1996. It was just a few years after his Italian journey, in the middle of the English Civil War of the 1640s, that Milton published his first volume of poetry. While the volume is now treasured for such English works as "On the Morning of Christ's Nativity," "L'Allegro" and "Il Penseroso," Comus and Lycidas, the separate title-page shown here for the second section of Latin poems, Joannis Miltoni Londinensis Poemata ... nunc primum edita, is also significant in indicating Milton's ambition for a European, not merely an English, poetic readership. Religious controversy, I: Milton's first published prose work John Milton, Of reformation touching church-discipline in England: and the causes that hither-to have hindered it; two bookes written to a friend. [London]: Printed for Thomas Underhill, 1641. Bookplate of F.E. Smith, Viscount Birkenhead. The political tensions in the 1640s and the breakdown of Royal authority brought a new cultural significance to the printing press as an agent of public debate. Milton's own publisher commented that "the slightest pamphlet is nowadayes more vendible then the Works of learnedest men." Milton himself commented: "Liberty of speech was no longer subject to control . . . I saw that a way was opening for the establishment of real liberty . . . I therefore determined to relinqish the other pursuits in which I was engaged, and to transfer the whole of my talents and industry to this one important object." Milton's first published prose work, designed "To vindicate the spotless truth from an ignominious bondage," was a plea for the Reformation of the English church to be carried through more fully, rejecting the conservative countermovement towards episcopal authority under Archbishop Laud. Religious controversy, II: the debate over episcopacy [John Milton], "Poscript," in Smectymnuus redivivus: being an answer to a book, entituled An humble remonstrance, in which the original of liturgy, episcopacy is discussed: and quaeries propounded concerning both: the parity of bishops and presbyters in Scripture demonstrated, the occasion of the imparity in antiquity discovered, the disparity of the ancient and our modern bishops manifested, the antiquity of ruling elders in the church vindicated, the prelatical church bounded composed by five learned and orthodox divines. London: John Rothwell, 1660. Later three-quarter calf. Bookplate of Moses H. Grossman. First published 1641, under the title: An answer to a booke entituled An humble remonstrance to the high court of Parliament. The proepiscopalian Remonstrance had been published the previous year by the bishop and poet Joseph Hall (1574-1656). The five authors of this composite riposte were Stephen Marshall, Edmund Calamy, Thomas Young, Matthew Newcomen, and William Spurstowe, the initial letters of whose names make up the pseudonym "Smectymnvvs." Thomas Young had been Milton's tutor when he was a child and remained a friend. The "Poscript" (p. 68-[73]) has been attributed to Milton himself (see Masson, Life of John Milton; Coleridge, 267). Religious controversy, III A directory for the publique worship of God, throughout the three kingdoms of England, Scotland, and Ireland. Together with an ordinance of Parliament for the taking away of the Book of common-prayer: and for establishing and observing of this present directory throughout the kingdom of England, and the dominion of Wales. Die jovis, 13. martii, 1644. London: printed for E. Tyler [etc.] 1644 [1645] bound with: An ordinance of the Lords and Commons assembled in Parliament for the more effectuall puting in execution the Directory for publique worship: in all parish churches and chappells within the kingdome of England and dominion of Wales. [London]: Printed by T. W. for Ed. Husband, Printer for the Honourable House of Commons, 1645. Contemporary brown calf. Label of Hannah Gosling and signature of Maud Downing, 1919. The Westminster Assembly of Divines, first proposed in Parliament in 1642, was charged with the revision of the Church's articles of belief, prayer book, and method of church government. This Directory was the first product of the Assembly to be completed, with the credal standards of the better-known Westminster Confession following only at the end of 1646. The Directory preface noted that "long and sad Experience hath made it manifest, that the Leiturgie used in the Church of England, (notwithstanding all the pains and Religious intentions of the Compilers of it) hath proved an offence, not only to the Godly at home; but also to the Reformed Churches abroad." The accompanying ordinance prescribed a fine of five pounds for a first offence in using the old Prayer Book in public worship, or even in a private house, with increased fines and up to a year's imprisonment for repeat offenders. Milton had briefly supported the Presyterian reformers of the Westminster Assembly, but he soon became alienated from the "Enforcers of Conscience," denouncing "New Presbyter" as "but Old Priest writ large." Political controversy, I Leycesters Common-wealth: Conceived, Spoken And published with most earnest protestation of all dutifull good will and affection towards this Realme; For whose good onely it is made common to many. N.p.: n.p., 1641. First published in 1584, with title: The copie of a leter, vryten by a master of arte of Cambridge, to his friend in London. Engraved portrait of Leicester. Alfred Chapin Rogers Collection. The new political atmosphere signalled by the first recalling of the English Parliament for over a decade, in November 1640, brought renewed interest in early writings suggesting limits on the Royal prerogatives. Among them was this influential fiftyyear-old pamphlet about Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, that depicts Queen Elizabeth and her favorite Dudley as abusing their power by having Dudley's wife murdered. This significantly-timed republication was ordered to be suppressed as seditious in October 1641. Political controversy, II William Prynne, attrib., 1600-1669, Tom-Tell-Troth, or A free discourse tovching the murmurs of the times, directed to His Majesty, by way of humble advertisement. London: printed in the yeere 1642. Wing T 1786. Later tree-calf. One of a small collection of pamphlets from the 1640s, which also includes Prynne's Romes master-peece. Or, The grand conspiracy of the pope and his Iesuited instruments, . . . Revealed out of conscience . . . by an agent sent from Rome, London: Michael Sparke, Senior, 1643. In 1637, with two Puritan allies, Prynne was sentenced by the notorious royal court, the Star Chamber, to have his ears cut off (a second such mutilation for Prynne), to be branded, and to be imprisoned without any outside contact. In November 1640, the new Parliament ordered the three men released, and Prynne became a focal point of political dissatisfaction, first against the King and then against parliament. Domestic controversy, I John Milton, The doctrine and discipline of divorce : restor'd to the good of both sexes, from the bondage of canon law, and other mistakes, to the true meaning of Scripture in the law and gospel compar'd: wherein also are set down the bad consequences of abolishing or condemning of sin, that which the law of God allows, and Christ abolish not: now the second time revis'd, and much augmented, in two books: to the Parliament of England, with the Assembly. London : [n.p.], Imprinted in the year 1645. Among the topics to which Milton directed his polemic was the episcopal control over marriage law, through the church courts. His sudden marriage in June 1642, when he was thirty-three, to the seventeen-year-old Mary Powell, did not start well, and the two were separated for the first three years of the Civil War, though subsequently reconciled. Milton asserted that: Love in marriage cannot live or subsist unless it be mutual; and where love cannot be, there can be left of Wedlock nothing, but the empty husk of an outside Matrimony, as unpleasing to God, as any other kind of hypocrisy. . . . it is less a breach of Wedlock to part with wise and quiet consent betimes, than still to soil and profane that mystery of joy and union with a polluting sadness and perpetual distemper. . . . for wherein can God delight, wherein be worshipped, wherein be glorified by the forcible continuance of an improper and ill-yoked couple. Milton's radical protestant arguments for divorce on grounds of incompatibility were more idealistic than licentious, but to many contemporaries his tract seemed a shocking indicator of just where radicalism would lead. Domestic controversy, II Daniel Featley, 1582-1645. "The Epistle Dedicatory," in his The dippers dipt. Or, The Anabaptists duck'd and plung'd over head and eares, at a disputation in Southwark. . . . a large and full discourse . . . with an application to these times. London: Nicholas Bourne and Richard Royston, 1645. Contemporary calf. Featley had been briefly Rector of All Hallows, Bread Street, London, near Milton's home, from 1626-28, before moving to the rectory of Acton. In the body of his book (p. 29), Featley refers only in general terms among the "errors of the Anabaptists" to the teaching that "a man may put away his wife," but in the dedication he makes specific reference to Milton, citing among recent Anabaptist publications "a Tractate on Divorce" that would allow "putting away wives for many other causes than that which our Saviour only approveth." The transatlantic links of English Puritanism John Cotton, 1584-1652. The way of the churches of Christ in New England. Or the way of churches walking in brotherly equality, or co-ordination, without subjection of one church to another. Measured and examined by the Golden Reed of Sanctuary. Containing a full declaration of the church-way in all particulars. London: Printed by M. Simmons, 1645. The Cambridge-educated Cotton, the Puritan rector of the main church in Boston, Lincolnshire, had emigrated to Boston, Massachussetts in 1633. Significantly, this influential argument for the congregational church polity was printed by one of Milton's own London publishers. The 1640s and the English radical tradition John Reeve, 1608-1658, and Lodowick Muggleton, 1609-1698, A remonstrance from the eternal God: declaring several spiritual transactions unto the Parliament, and commonwealth of England, unto . . . Lord General Cromwell, the council of state, the council of war and to all that love the Second Appearing. . . . Printed in the Year, 1653. And Re-Printed. [London]: 1719. The continuing underground influence of 1640s radicalism is shown in the strange survival of one of its most radical religio-political sects. Muggletonianism, which after a contentious start (its founders had a habit of cursing blasphemers with fatal results, and were imprisoned under Cromwell) survived for over three hundred years, with a substantial resurgence in the Romantic era. In the 1970s, the British marxist historian E.P.Thompson made contact with the last surviving Muggletonian, and the accumulated stock of Muggletonian publications (in storage in apple boxes since World War II) was sold up, with Thomas Cooper Library acquiring a good selection, especially of the early nineteenth-century reprintings. The pamphlet wars and the freedom of the press John Milton, Areopagitica; A Speech of Mr. John Milton For the Liberty of Unlicenc'd Printing, To the Parlement of England. London: Printed in the Yeare, 1644. First edition. Modern marbled calf, gilt. The power of Milton as a prose-writer is most fully deployed in this still-influential argument for the freedom of the press, published during a divisive civil war, when the Puritan and parliamentary authorities sought to impose on public debate similar controls to those formerly exerted by the Crown and Bishops. England was changing, he told Parliament: "Methinks I see in my mind a mighty and puissant Nation rousing herself like a strong man after sleep, and shaking her invincible locks. . . . You cannot make us now lesse capable, lesse knowing, lesse eagerly pursuing of the truth." CIVIL WAR Fairfax and the Battle of Naseby, 1645 Joshua Sprigg, 1618-1684. Anglia rediviva; England's recovery: being the history of the motions, actions, and successes of the army under the immediate conduct of his excellency Sr. Thomas Fairfax . . . Compiled for the publique good. London: Printed by R. W. for John Partridge, 1647. Rebound. The conflict between King Charles I and Parliament broke into open warfare in August 1642, with the Royalist forces centred on Oxford and the Parliament strength centred in London. The turning point for the eventual triumph of the Parliament's New Model army came with the Battle of Naseby on June 14th, 1645, under the leadership of Sir Thomas Fairfax (1612-1671). Of especial interest in this adulatory contemporary account is the fold-out "Table of the Motion and Action of the Army . . . April 1645-August 1646," detailing each engagement. Milton addressed a sonnet to Fairfax in 1648: Fairfax, whose name in arms through Europe rings . . . Thy firm unshaken virtue ever brings Victory home, though new rebellions raise. . . The Battle of Naseby, June 14th, 1645 "The Description of the Armies of Horse and Foot of His Majesties, and Sir Thomas Fairfax his Excellency . . . at the Battayle of Nasebye," Printed for John Partridge. "Place this map between fol. 32 & 33." Mounted on linen. Detached from Joshua Sprigg, Anglia rediviva, London: R. W. for John Partridge, 1647. Presented by A. F. McKissick, per J. Rion McKissick, 1939. The Battle of Naseby was a turning-point in the English Civil War of the 1640s. This contemporary engraving shows the disposition of the Parliamentary New Model Army, under Fairfax, Oliver Cromwell (on the right of the map), and Henry Ireton (on the left), and their Royalist opponents commanded by King Charles (centre top) and Prince Rupert (on the Royalist right wing, off the left top of the map as displayed). Naseby was an overwhelming victory for Fairfax and the New Model Army, who captured over a thousand Royalist prisoners and most of the Royalist artillery. The rule of the Saints Richard Vines, 1600?-1656. The happinesse of Israel. As it was set forth in a sermon preached to both . . . Houses of Parliament . . . upon a solemne day of thanksgiving, March 12th 1644. London: Printed by G. M. for A. Roper, 1645. Milton was not directly involved in the War. He spent the war years in the Parliamentary stronghold of London, aware that the war could quickly turn to affect non-combatants as well as soldiers. He wrote to a friend in the Parliamentary forces: Captain, or colonel, or knight in arms, Whose chance on these defenceless doors may seize, If deed of honour did thee ever please, Guard them, and him within protect from harms. This sermon evokes the relief with which Londoners viewed any Parliamentary victory. Vines, Cambridge-educated and episcopally-ordained, was nonetheless a member of the Westminster Assembly and closely involved in the 1640s in Parliamentary plans for church reformation. Later, he would be one of the Puritan clergy assigned to persuade King Charles to accept reform, and in 1649 he was ejected from the mastership of Pembroke College, Cambridge, for refusing allegiance to the new Commonwealth, but nonetheless permitted to become minister of a London parish. This copy of Vines's sermon bears on the first leaf the autograph signature of Oliver Cromwell. The trial and execution of the king, 1649 from John Rushworth, 1612?-1690. Historical collections. The Fourth and Last Part, containing the Principal Matters which happened from the Beginning of the Year 1645, to the Death of King Charles the First 1648 . . . Impartially Related. Setting forth only Matter of Fact in Order of Time, without Observation or Reflection. Volume VII. Second edition. London: for J. Walthoe and others, 1721. King Charles I was taken prisoner in 1647. Following Colonel Pride's purge of moderates from Parliament, Charles was put on trial for treason on January 20th, 1649, before a special court of Judicial Commissioners," condemned after seven brief days of hearings, and beheaded at Whitehall three days later, on January 30th, 1649. His last speech proclaiming his innocence and declaring himself "the martyr of the people" became the basis of underground resistance to Parliamentary rule and the seed of the eventual cult of him as an Anglican quasi-saint, the Blessed Charles King and Martyr. From Commonwealth to Protectorate A declaration of the Parliament of England, in vindication of their proceedings, and discovering the dangerous practices of several interests against the present government, and peace of the commonwealth, together with the resolutions of the Parliament thereupon. London: Printed by John Field for Edward Husband, Printer to the Parliament of England, 1649. With the triumph of Parliament, and the King's execution, England became a republican Commonwealth, under a Council of State, until in a bloodless coup in 1653 the toughest of the Parliamentary military leaders, Oliver Cromwell, dissolved Parliament and took over as Lord Protector. This pamphlet, threatening death to anyone suspected of resistance to the new government, illustrates its increasing repressiveness as Parliament and the Puritan clergy struggled to control the lingering pockets of Royalists and growing numbers of radical sectaries. The Image of the (Martyred) King, I Charles, I, King of England, 1600-1649 [John Gauden, 1605-1662, attrib.], Eikon basilike, the pourtraicture of His Sacred Maiestie in his solitudes and sufferings. [N. p.: n.p.], 1648. First edition. Bookplate of Joseph Halle Schaffner. Morocco gold decorated binding by Riviere. This little book of saintly meditations, published only ten days after the King's execution, was accepted at the time as being by Charles himself, though in fact it had been ghosted by Gauden. It was an instant success in establishing the image of the King as a religious martyr, going through a reputed forty-seven editions. The Image of the King, II J. Phinn, engrv., "Carolus I," frontispiece in The works of that great monarch, and glorious martyr, King Charles I. Aberdeen: printed by J. Chalmers for William Coke, 1766. Vol. II. From the library of Yates Snowden. This eighteenth-century fold-out, typical of Stuart iconography, shows the martyrking kneeling at prayer, while in the background is the tempest-tossed ship of state. The Royal Image Smashed John Milton, Eikonoklastes, in answer to a book intitl'd Eikon basilike, the portrature of His sacred Majesty in his solitudes and sufferings. The author I. M. London: Printed by M. Simmons, 1649. First edition. "Published by authority." Bookplate of Rev. H. Randolph. Contemporary sprinkled calf. With the Parliamentary victory, Milton recognized that "The truth, which had been defended by arms, should also be defended by reason." He had already written one pamphlet, his Tenure of Kings and Magistrates, asserting the power of Parliament "to call to account a Tyrant, or wicked KING, and after due conviction, to depose, and put him to death." In March 1649 he had been appointed Latin Secretary to the Council of State, and one of his first tasks was to write this rebuttal to the popular Eikon basilike. In his words, "A book appeared soon after, which was ascribed to the king, and contained the most invidious charges against the parliament. I was ordered to answer it . . . .I did not insult over fallen majesty, as is pretended; I only preferred queen Truth to king Charles." European criticism of the new English republic Claudius Salmasius, 1588-1653, Defensio Regia pro Carolo I ad Serenissimum Magna Britannia Regem Carolum II. Filium natu majorem, Heredum & Successorum legitimum. [Lugduni Batavorum: B. & A. Elzevirius] 1649. Vellum, with later stamping from the SouthCarolina College Library. Exiled to Holland, Charles's heir, the future King Charles II, commissioned a leading French scholar (who was then a professor at Leyden) to write this attack on the legitimacy of the new English commonwealth, with a defense of his father's rule. Milton's Defense of the English People John Milton, Ioannis Miltoni Angli Pro populo anglicano defensio, contra Claudii anonymi, alias Salmasii, Defensionem regiam. Londini: Typis Du Gardianis, 1650. Contemporary calf. Milton was again commissioned to write an answer on behalf of the English government, and his Latin response to Salmasius was (at least during his life-time) the most frequently-reprinted of all his works. Though he was writing as a government agent, he strongly rebutted the inevitable accusation that he was simply a paid propagandist like Salmasius: "I was publicly solicited to write a reply to the Defense of the royal cause. . . .Nor was I ever prompted to such exertions by the influence of ambition, by the lust of lucre or of praise; it was only by the conviction of duty and the feeling of patriotism, a disinterested passion for the extension of civil and religious liberty." The dispute became bitterly personal; Salmasius asserted that Milton's blindness was divine retribution for his attack on kingship, while on Salmasius's death in mid-controversy Milton asserted a similar divine punishment for his opponent's resistance to republicanism. Bound with Milton's Defensio here are his follow-up, Defensio secunda pro populo, Hagæ-Comitum, 1654 (important for the long autobiographical section in which Milton defended his own integrity), and his further self-justification, Pro se defensio contra Alexandrum Morum, HagæeComitum, 1655. Thomas Cooper Library also has editions of Pro populo anglicano from 1651 and 1652. This 1650's edition is actually a contemporary pirated reprint, which used the earlier date in error because publication was at the break between years in the old-style calendar. John Milton, A defence of the people of England, by John Milton: in answer to Salmasius's Defence of the king. [Amsterdam?] 1692. Morocco binding with gold lettering on spine. This English translation of Milton's Defense, by Joseph Washington, appeared significantly soon after the Revolution of 1688 had again asserted the right of Parliament to depose an unacceptable King. The English political scene in the 1650s Thomas Hobbes, 1588-1679, Leviathan; or, The matter, forme, and power of a common-wealth, ecclesiasticall and civill. London: Printed for A. Ckooke, 1651. Contemporary blind-tooled calf. The displacement of the radical enthusiasm of the 1640s by a sterner, more realistic political scepticism is perhaps best exemplified by the Baconian political philosopher Thomas Hobbes. Displayed here is Hobbes's bitter assessment that, without government, "the life of man is solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." The two men were poles apart politically. Milton thought Hobbes "a man of great parts, a learned man," but "did not like him at all," while Hobbes would write in his Behemoth (1679) of Milton'sDefensio that it was "very good Latin" but "very ill reasoning." In addition to the "Bear" edition ofLeviathan shown here, Thomas Cooper Library also has a copy of the "ornaments" edition, from the library of Alfred Chapin Rogers. The perspective of the Restoration, I Edward Hyde, Earl of Clarendon, 1609-1674. The history of the rebellion and Civil Wars in England, begun in the year 1641. With the precedent passages, and actions, that contributed thereunto, and the happy end, and conclusion thereof by the king's blessed restoration, and return upon the 29th of May, in the year 1660. First edition, 3 vols. Oxford, Printed at the Theater, 1702-1704. The new English constitutional experiment did not long outlast the death of Cromwell in 1659. Though Milton himself published further pamphlets advocating republican government and church reform, the political void left by Cromwell was filled by the return of Charles II from exile and the restoration of both monarchy and episcopacy. Clarendon was Charles's Lord Chancellor, both in exile and on his return, though he fell from favor in 1667. His manuscript history, begun in exile, and presented to the University of Oxford after his death, was a resounding success, and the profits established the university press that still bears his name. The perspective of the Restoration, II Thomas Skinner, 1629?-1679. The life of General Monk: duke of Albemarle, containing, I. A faithful account of his unparallel'd conduct. II. A particular relation of that most memorable march from Coldstream to London. III. Many mistakes committed by our historians Particularly the Earl of Clarendon) rectified. Second edition. London: for J. Graves, 1724. Contemporary panelled calf. The major role in bringing back the monarchy had been played by a Parliamentary general, George Monck (1608-1670), soon ennobled as Duke of Albemarle. Monck's brother-in-law and the Puritan poet Andrew Marvell were among the members of parliament who intervened to protect Milton after the Restoration. Interestingly, both Clarendon and Albemarle were rewarded with royal grants as two of the original Lords Proprietors of South Carolina. The perspective of the Restoration, III The Book of common prayer. London: printed by John Bill, & Christopher Barker [1662]. Engraved title-page with undated imprint, by David Loggan. Contemporary red morocco by Samuel Mearne , for Charles II, and bearing his royal cypher. The return of Charles II restored not only the monarchy, but also the Prayer Book, which now prescribed special services of national repentance each January 30th, lamenting how "our late martyred Sovereign . . . had fallen "into the hands of violent and blood-thirsty men, . . . barbarously to be murthered by them." The pages are shown here from Thomas Cooper Library's fine folio 1662 Common Prayer, with the Loggan title-page, bound in red morocco by Samuel Mearnes for Charles II and bearing his cypher. PARADISE LOST ETC. Paradise Lost and Later Years Milton's contract with his publisher for Paradise Lost from The works of John Milton, in verse and prose, printed from the original editions with a life of the author by the Rev. John Mitford. 8 vols. London: William Pickering, 1851. Volume III. At the Restoration, Milton's writings against monarchy left him in at least potential danger of the dreadful penalties of disembowelling, death and dismemberment exacted against seventeenth-century traitors and actually carried through against the Regicides who signed the King's death warrant. In his words, "though I did not participate in the toils or dangers of the war, yet I was at the same time engaged in a service not less hazardous to myself." In the event, influential friends protected him, though some of his political writings were suppressed. Now totally blind, he seemed to accept his reverses philosophically, as in his sonnet "To Mr. Cyriack Skinner upon his Blindness": . . . I argue not Against Heaven's hand or will, nor bate a jot Of heart or hope; but still bear up and steer Right onward. Indeed, he could even find comfort in his enforced withdrawal from public affairs: "in my blindness, I enjoy in no inconsiderable degree the favour of the Deity, who regards me with more tenderness and compassion in proportion as I am able to behold nothing but himself." He had already been engaged on his great epic poem, "of man's first disobedience," and he completed it in manuscript by 1665, meekly submitting it to the official licenser for clearance. Under this contract, signed on April 27th, 1667, Samuel Simmons (d. 1687), the son of his former publisher Matthew Simmons (d. 1654), was to pay Milton just five pounds for the right to publish one of the great works of Western literature, "things unattempted yet in prose or rhyme." The first edition of Paradise Lost John Milton, Paradise lost. A Poem in Ten Books. London: Printed by S. Simmons, and are to be sold by T. Helder at the Angel in Little Brittain. 1669. First edition, seventh issue. Morocco binding. Bookplates of Arthur B. Spingarn and Roger H. West. Of man's first disobedience, and the fruit Of that forbidden tree, whose mortal taste Brought death into the world . . . . Sing heav'nly Muse . . . . . . what in me is dark Illumine; what is low, raise and support; That, to the height of this great argument, I may assert Eternal Providence And justify the ways of God to men. Paradise Lost, Book I. While Simmons printed some 1300 copies of the ten-book first edition, and had them ready for sale by August 1667, he issued them gradually over the next two years or so, with differently dated title-pages and varying preliminary matter. This copy has the fifth of the six variant title-pages (as in Coleridge,Descriptive Catalogue, reproduction 43), with the address "The Printer to the Reader," signed S. Simmons, in three lines. The revised, second edition of Paradise Lost John Milton, Paradise lost : a poem in twelve books. Second edition, revised and augmented by the same author. London: S. Simmons, 1674. Signature, bookplate and stamp of Charles Wotton. Bookplate of William Melin Roscoe. Nineteenth century panelled calf. For this edition, Milton broke his original ten books into twelve, on the model of Virgil. The new edition added Marvell's verse tribute to Milton, as well as the frontispiece engraving from the portrait by William Dolle, as well as Marvell's verse tribute to Milton's blank verse. The younger poet Marvell, M.P. for Hull, befriended Milton in the 1660s. Milton's unrhymed blank verse had seemed sufficiently strange on first publication for the publisher to add a defensive preface and for Dryden to offer to turn it into rhyme. The third edition of Paradise Lost John Milton, Paradise lost. A poem in twelve books. The third edition, revised and augmented by the same author. London: Printed by S. Simmons, 1678. Nineteenth century calf binding. This third edition, while not uncommon, is in relative terms the rarest of the early editions of Milton's major work. The fourth edition of Paradise Lost John Milton, Paradise lost. A poem in twelve books. The fourth edition, adorn'd with sculptures. London: Printed by Miles Flesher, for Richard Bently and Jacob Tonson, 1688. Calf with banded spine. This was the first illustrated edition, with twenty full-page engravings by Robert White (1645-1703), who also reengraved the frontispiece portrait. The verses below the portrait, linking Milton with Homer and Vergil, were by John Dryden, the poet laureate, signalling the way that Milton's achievement overcame the political stigma still attached to his prose writing: Three Poets, in three distant Ages born, Greece, Italy, and England did adorn. The First in loftiness of thought surpass'd; The Next in Majesty; in both the Last. The force of Nature cou'd no farther goe: To make a s she joynd the former two. With this, it has been estimated, some 4000 copies of the poem had reached print. The first edition of Paradise Regained John Milton, Paradise regain'd : a poem in IV books to which is added Samson Agonistes. London: Printed by J.M. for John Starkey, 1671. First edition. Black morocco binding by Riviere. Bookplate of Roger H. West. I, who ere while the happy garden sung By one man's disobedience lost, now sing Recover'd Paradise to all mankind, By one man's firm obedience fully tried Through all temptation, and the tempter foil'd In all his wiles, defeated and repulsed Paradise Regain'd, Book I Milton's Quaker friend Thomas Elwood recounted that, when he returned to the manuscript of Paradise Lost, he had asked the poet, "Thou hast said much of paradise lost, but what hast thou to say of paradise found?" Milton followed up his version of the fall of Adam and Eve with this complementary though much shorter epic poem on Christ's resistance in the wilderness to Satan's temptings, among them the temptation to worldly power, which Christ must reject. Samson Agonistes, shown from the second edition John Milton, Paradise regain'd. A poem. In IV books. To which is added Samson Agonistes. London: Printed for John Starkey, 1680. Second edition. Calf binding with restored spine. The second major item in Milton's 1671 volume was his Biblical tragedy Samson Agonistes. Though some scholars have argued that Milton had written the play much earlier, in the late 1640s, most readers immediately identify the situation of the nowblind and powerless Samson, "eyeless in Gaza, grinding at the mill with slaves," as at least in part autobiographical, reflecting Milton's own blindness and his frustration as the once-free English submitted again to the Philistian yoke of the restored monarchy. The second edition of Milton's shorter poems John Milton, Poems, &c. Upon Several Occasions. By Mr. John Milton: Both English and Latin, &c. Composed at several times. With a small Tractate of Education to Mr. Hartlib. London: printed for Thomas Dring at the White Lion next Chancery Lane End, in Fleetstreet, 1673.Purchased for the library by the Thomas Cooper Society. The reputation of Paradise Lost encouraged a new edition of Milton's Poems, English and Latin, and Milton took the opportunity to include both a number of the sonnets and other shorter poems that he had written since 1645, and his prose essay On Education, originally been published in 1644, when he had been running his own small school. Shown here is one of the new poems, his sonnet on his blindness, written in the mid 1650s, but here published for the first time. Milton's contemporary fame Edward Phillips, 1630-1696? "John Milton," in his Theatrum poetarum, or A compleat collection of the poets, especially the most eminent, of all ages. The antients distinguish't from the moderns in their several alphabets. With some observations and reflections upon many of them, particularly those of our own nation. 2 vols. in 1. London, Printed for Charles Smith, at the Angel near the Inner Temple-Gate in Fleet-street. Anno Dom. 1675. The author of this pioneering mini-dictionary of literary biography, curiously alphabetized by first rather than last name, was not only Milton's nephew, but also his former pupil. Phillips is suitably reticent about over-praising his famous uncle, but his comment on Milton's contemporary fame ("sufficiently known to all the Learned of Europe") is clear. The Theatrum's entry on Shakespeare has traditionally been attributed to Milton himself. Milton as historian Milton, John, 1608-1674. The History of Britain, That part especially now call'd England. From the first Traditional Beginning, continu'd to the Norman Conquest. Collected out of the antientest and best Authours thereof. London: printed by J.M. for James Allestry, at the Rose and Crown in St. Paul's Churchyeard, 1670. First edition, first issue, with errata leaf but lacking portrait. Purchased for the library by the Thomas Cooper Society. In addition to the poetry on which his fame rests, during the last decade of his life Milton completed and took to press a number of works written or begun years before that for one reason or another had lingered unpublished. As a young man, he had projected a national epic based on the history of King Arthur, and he had started this prose history of early Britain in the 1640s, completing four books before becoming Latin Secretary, and writing a further two in the 1650s. The North of England in the seventeenth-century Georg Braun and Franz Hogenberg, "Yorke, Shrowesbury, Lancaster, Richmont," from Theatrum Praecipuarum Totius Mundi Urbium, Liber Sixtus. Frankfurt: Hierat and Hogenberg, 1618. John Osman Collection. The course of the English civil war pivoted, not just on London and Oxford, but on provincial county towns such as these. As the two sample 1663 issues of Newes Published for Satisfaction and Information of the People (donated by William M. Jordan) show, even after the Restoration of the monarchy in 1660, there were continuing rumours of plots and rebellions, especially in these provincial centers. The historical figures on the right of the Braun & Hogenberg engraving closely parallel the periods covered in Milton's History of Britain (1670), while those on the right illustrate the social hierarchy that, especially in the late 1640s, seemed to be breaking apart. Government control in the late 17th century The two issues displayed here from the official London Gazette, in June 1684 and May 1687, illustrate both the complex European diplomatic context in which seventeenth-century governments had to operate and (in the petition of the Anabaptists in 1687) the way in which, to the end of Milton's life, the restored monarchy continued to identify religious difference with a renewed political threat. The pirated republication of Milton's republican past John Milton. Literæ pseudo-senatûs anglicani, Cromwellii, reliquorumque perduellium nomine ac jussu / conscriptae a Joanne Miltono. [London: printed by Blaeu for Moses Pitt?,] Impressæ anno 1676. Contemporary mottled calf. Shown with: John Milton, Literæ pseudo-senatus anglicani, Cromwellii, reliquorumque perduellium nomine ac jussu conscriptæ a Joanne Miltono. [Brussels]: [E. Fricx], Impressæ anno 1676. Title-page inscription: R. Ward. Trin: Coll: Alumn:." Modern brown calf. The eddies and cross-currents of English politics in the later 17th century regularly rekindled interest in Milton's republican writings. In 1676, the first, "fruit," edition shown here of this surreptitious republication of Milton's dispatches as Latin secretary (printed abroad for the London bookseller) (Coleridge 29) was intriguing enough to attract a rival piracy (the second, "face" edition, Coleridge 30, also printed abroad). Milton as contemporary geographer John Milton,. A brief history of Moscovia: and other less-known countries lying eastward of Russia as far as Cathay. Gathered from the writings of several eye- witnesses. London: Printed by M. Flesher, for Brabazon Aylmer, 1682. Contemporary calf, rebacked. Like his History of Britain, Milton's compilation from travelers to Russia had been written in the late 1640s, though it remained unpublished till after his death. Milton's textbook of Ramist logic John Milton, "Artis Logicae Plenior Instituto, Ad Petri Rami Methodum concinnata. Adjecta est Praxis Analytica & Petri Rami Vita," in Joannis Miltoni Opera Omnia Latina. . . . Nunc primum junctim edita. Amstelodami [London]: 1698 The new anti-scholastic logic or "method" of the French scholar Peter Ramus was particularly influential among his fellow-protestants. Milton had written this Ramistic logic text in the 1640s, and first published it in 1672. Interestingly, the life of Ramus appended to Milton's Logic included a letter from Ramus to Milton's old schoolmaster at St. Paul's Alexander Gill. It is shown here from the first collected edition of Milton's prose, A complete collection of the historical, political, and miscellaneous works of John Milton, both English and Latin. With som papers never before publish'd, edited by the Irish-born freethinker John Toland (1670-1722). Milton as radical theologian John Milton, Joannis Miltoni Angli De doctrina christiana: libri duo posthumi, quos ex schedis manuscriptis deprompsit, et typis mandari primus curavit Carolus Ricardus Sumner. Cantabrigiae: Typis Academicis, excudit Joannes Smith, 1825. Bookplate of Conyngham. Modern dark blue half calf. One work that Milton himself never published was his Latin manuscript on Christian doctrine, first discovered in 1823. Milton probably wrote it in the 1650s, and completed it by 1661. While Milton compiled his argument entirely on the basis of Scriptural texts, he built from them a broad, liberal theology that even in the 1820s was widely condemned as shocking and heretical. MILTON’S REPUTATION Milton's Posthumous Reputation and Later Responses The first Latin Paradise Lost William Hogg, b. ca. 1652, transl., Paraphrasis poetica in tria Johannis Miltoni . . . poemata, viz. Paradisum amissum, Paradisum recuperatum, et Samsonem Agonisten. Londini: typis Johannis Darby, 1690. Later blind-tooled calf. This first translation of Milton's English poems for the fast-diminishing international community of neo-Latinists is actually rarer than any of the early English editions of Paradise Lost. Hogg, a Scot from Gowrie in Perthshire, based his translation on the original ten-book version, not the twelve-book revision. The volume remains fascinating evidence of the learned context within which Milton's reputation was achieved. Milton's earliest biographers Edward Phillips, "The Life of Milton [1694]," in William Godwin, 1756-1836, Lives of Edward and John Philips, nephews and pupils of Milton. Including various particulars of the literary and political history of their times. London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown, 1815. From the library of William Beckford (1760-1844), with his manuscript notes, and later in the library of Lord Roseberry (1847-1929). Along with the contemporary inquiries of the dyspeptic Oxford antiquary John Aubrey, the accounts of Milton's life by his two nephews provide the fullest early biographical evidence. John Phillips's life long remained anonymous, but Edward's was first published as early as 1694, in his edition of his uncle's State Letters. This life of the Phillips brothers themselves, by Mary Shelley's anarchist father, exemplifies the post-French Revolution surge of interest in Milton as a harbinger of literary radicalism. An early eighteenth-century literary reference book Giles Jacob, 1686-1744, "Mr. John Milton," in Poetical register: or the Lives and Characters of the English Dramatick Poets. Volume II. London: W. Mears, 1724. Contemporary calf. Jacob, an unsuccessful playwright and poet but an indefatigable compiler of legal reference texts, was blasted by Pope in the Dunciad as the "Blunderbuss of Law." This work (the first volume had been differently titled as An historical account of the lives and writings of our most considerable English poets) is fairly representative of general 18th century knowledge about Milton and his works. Milton in fact occurs in both volumes; here Jacob concludes that "He was the fullest and loftiest Poet we ever had." Dr. Johnson on Milton, I Samuel Johnson, 1709-1784, "Prologue, Spoken by Mr. Garrick, April 5, 1750, before the Masque of Comus," in his Poetical Works. London: W. Osborne . . . Gainsborough: J. Mozley, 1785. Johnson's prologue was composed for a special benefit performance at Drury Lane, on behalf of Milton's granddaughter. Dr. Johnson on Milton, II Samuel Johnson, "Milton," in his Lives of the English Poets; and a criticism on their works. 3 vols. Dublin: Whitestone, Williams, Colles, Wilson, 1779-1781. Signatures of Charles Pinckney, dated April 18, 1791, Charleston, vols. 1 and 3. In spite of Dr. Johnson's dislike of Milton's politics, and his stringent criticism of such early poems asLycidas, his life, originally intended simply as the preface to a bookseller's reprint series, remained among the most widely-disseminated introductions to Milton well into the next century. Milton in France, I Nicolas François Dupré de Saint-Maur, 1695-1774, transl. Le Paradis perdu de Milton. Poeme heroique, traduit de l'anglois, avec les remarques de Mr. Addisson. 2 ed., revûe & corrigée. 3 vols. Pari: Cailleau [etc.], 1729. Original rust-coloured, paste paper boards. Dupré's was the first French translation, originally published in 1727. Until Dupré, Addison's essay on Milton had been excluded from French editions of the Spectator, because there was no French translation of the poetry he was discussing. Milton in France, II Voltaire, 1694-1778. An essay upon the civil wars of France, extracted from curious manuscripts : And also upon the epick poetry of the European nations from Homer down to Milton by Mr. de Voltaire, author of the Henriade. 2d ed., corrected by Himself. London : Printed for N. Prevost and Comp., 1728. This startling French tribute to the stature of Milton as epicist expresses surprise that an achievement such as Milton's should be possible in English and praises him particularly, not for his treatment of religious themes but for realism in human description. Milton in France, III John Milton, Le Paradise perdu: poëme par Milton; édition en anglais et en français; ornée de douze estampes imprimées en couleur d'après les tableaux de M. Schall. 2 vols. Pari: Chez Defer de Maisonneuve . . . 1792. Modern brown quarter calf binding, marbled boards. Hail, wedded love, mysterious law. . . . Perpetual fountain of domestic sweets Paradise Lost, Book IV Each generation rereads Milton for itself, as this engraving of Eden exemplifies. This handsome edition is notable not only for its chronological link to the French revolution, but for having the illustrations colored uniformly from engraved plates rather than by hand after printing was completed. Milton and Romantic literary biography William Hayley, 1745-1820. The life of Milton, in three parts. To which are added, Conjectures on the origin of Paradise lost: with an appendix.. The second ed., considerably enlarged. London: T. Cadell, junior [etc.] 1796. Hayley, a minor poet and the friend and patron of several artists, including Blake, also wrote an influential biography of William Cowper. His life of Milton was originally published in 1794 for a new Milton edition, and then expanded for separate publication two years later. Hayley was concerned especially to move beyond mere biographical narrative into critical comment and quotation from the poems themselves. Illustrating Milton in the 19th century Richard Westall, 1765-1836. "L'Allegro," Original pencil illustration 1822?]. Signed: R. W. 14 x 12 cm. This signed pencil illustration does not appear to correspond to any of the engravings for "L'Allegro" in William Hayley's earlier large-format 3-volume Milton edition (1794-1797), to which Westall had contributed the illustrations. The quest for biographical documents Henry John Todd, 1763-1845. Some account of the life and writings of John Milton, derived principally from documents in His Majesty's State-paper office, now first published. London: C. and J. Rivington [etc.] 1826. Calf: South Carolina College Library Collection. The attempt to ground Milton biography firmly in original evidence had begun with the redoubtable Dr. Thomas Birch (1705-1766), who included a new life in his edition of Milton's prose, 1738, and Francis Peck, who published his New Memoirs in 1740. Todd, who had published an expanded variorum Milton in 1801, was the first biographer to make full use of the Trinity Manuscript, as well as of government documents. Milton and early Victorian reform Joseph Ivimey, 1773-1834. John Milton: his life and times, religious and political opinions: with an appendix, containing animadversions upon Dr. Johnson's life of Milton, etc., etc. London: Effingham Wilson, 1833. Original cloth, paper spine label. The subtitle of Ivimey's book indicates the political focus of his interest, as does his publisher: Effingham Wilson was Shelley's publisher and a strong proponent of Parliamentary reform. A pocket Paradise Lost from the 1820s John Milton, Paradise lost : a poem in twelve books. London : Jones & Company, 1829. Jones's Diamond poets. Original raised ripple grain purple silk, gold printed black paper lettering-label on spine. Gilt edges. The greater exactness of printing with the iron press, cheaper thinner papers, and the development of publisher's cloth bindings combined to make technically feasible these tiny gift or pocket editions in diamond' type. Brydges on Milton Sir Egerton Brydges, 1762-1837. The life of John Milton. London: J. Macrone, 1835. Original brown cloth, blind-stamped. Brydges's numerous literary publications included his revision of Phillips's Theatrum Poetarum (1800) and his British Bibliographer (1810-1814). This brief life, originally issued as volume 1 of Brydges's Milton edition, is part of Thomas Cooper Library's extensive collection of Brydges's writings. Milton and the Victorian literary pilgrimage William Howitt, 1792-1879. Homes and haunts of the most eminent British poets. The illustrations by W. and G. Measom. 2 vols. London: R. Bentley, 1847. Rebound. Although a great deal of documentary evidence survives about Milton, because he was primarily a Londoner, very few of the buildings in which he lived reached even the Victorian period. The cottage at Chalfont St. Giles, outside London in Buckinghamshire, to which Milton had moved briefly in 1665 to avoid the Great Plague, fitted the rather sentimental image mid-Victorians like Howitt preferred for the poet, but was hardly representative of most of his life. The phantasmagoric Milton Gustave Doré, 1832-1883, illus., Milton's Paradise lost. Chicago: Thompson & Thomas, [1880?]. Original maroon pictorial cloth. Among artists who illustrated Milton, or drew on him for inspiration, most attention has been paid to William Blake, though other illustrators (Westall, Birket Foster) were arguably more influential in their time. The French illustrator Gustave Dore (who also illustrated Dante, Coleridge and Tennyson, as well as producing haunting images of Victorian city slums) developed a distinctively phantasmagoric take on Milton's poetry, though his work is often undervalued because of the relatively cheap materials from which his widely-selling books were manufactured. Tennyson pays tribute to Milton Alfred, Lord Tennyson, 1809-1892' "Milton. Alcaics," in Enoch Arden, etc. London: Edward Moxon, 1864. Original cloth. Tennyson, like Milton, had been a student at Cambridge, and his greatest poem, In Memoriam (1850) consciously echoes Milton's Cambridge elegy Lycidas. In this brief tribute, Tennyson acknowledges Milton's epic power, the "God-gifted organ voice of England," but prefers his gentler, more idyllic poetry, in "the bowery loveliness of Eden." Robert Bridges on Milton Robert Seymour Bridges, 1844-1930. On the prosody of Paradise regained and Samson Agonistes. Being a supplement to the paper On the elements of Milton's blank verse in Paradise lost, which is printed in the Rev. H. C. Beeching's edition of Paradise lost, bk. I, Clarendon Press, Oxford. London: B. H. Blackwell, 1889. Original gray wrappers. Ewelme Collection of Robert Bridges. As Gerard Manley Hopkins's correspondent and editor, the future poet laureate Robert Bridges had a special interest in prosodic analysis. Thomas Cooper Library's Ewelme Collection contains several forms of this item, of which this is the earliest. FURTHER REFERENCES Additional Resources on Milton Selected References • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • K. A. Coleridge, A Descriptive Catalogue of the Milton Collection in the Alexander Turnbull Library, Wellington, New Zealand (Oxford: Oxford University Press for the Alexander Turnbull Library, National Library of New Zealand, 1980) Stephen B. Dobranski, Milton, Authorship, and the Book Trade (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999). Grolier Club, Catalogue of an Exhibition Commemorative of the Tercentenary of the Birth of John Milton 1608-1908 (New York: Grolier Club, 1908; repr. Norwood, PA: Norwood Editions, 1976). James Holly Hanford, A Milton Handbook, 4th ed. (New York: Appleton-CenturyCrofts, 1946). Christopher Hill, Milton and the English Revolution (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1979). Robert W. Karrow, Mapmakers of the Sixteenth Century (Chicago: Speculum Orbis Press for the Newberry Library, 1993). John Milton, "The Second Defence of the People of England against an Anonymous Libel [1654]," translated by Robert Fellowes, in Charles Symmons., ed., The Prose Works of John Milton, 7 vols (London: for J. Johnson et al., 1806), VII, 361-447. D.F. McKenzie, "Milton's Printers: Matthew, Mary and Samuel Simmons," Milton Quarterly, 14:3 (October 1980), 87-91. Carl Moreland & David Bannister, Antique Maps, A Collector's Handbook (London: Longman, 1983). William Riley Parker, Milton, A Biography, 2 vols., 2nd ed. rev. Gordon Campbell (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1996). John Peile, C.G. Williamson, and A. H. Sayle, Milton Tercentenary. The Portraits, Prints and Writings of John Milton. Exhibited at Christ's College, Cambridge (Np.: n.p., 1908). Lois Potter, Secret rites and secret writing: royalist literature, 1641-1660 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990). David A. Randall, An Exhibit of Seventeenth-Century Editions of Writings by John Milton, preface by William Riley Parker (Bloomington, IN: The Lilly Library, 1969) John T. Shawcross, ed., Milton 1732-1801, the Critical Heritage (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1972). _______________, Milton, a Bibliography for the Years 1624-1700 (Binghamton, NY: Medieval & Renaissance Texts & Studies, 1984). --Addenda and Corrigenda issued from same publisher, 1990. _______________, The Collection of the Works of John Milton and Miltoniana in the Margaret I. King Library University of Kentucky, Occasional Papers, no. 8 (Lexington, KY: University of Kentucky Libraries, 1985). • • Robin Skelton, introduction, in Georg Braun and Franz Hogenberg, Civitates orbis terrarum, 1572-1618, 6 pts. in 3 vols. (Amsterdam : Theatrum Orbis Terrarum, 1965). Don M. Wolfe, Milton and his England (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1971).