!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Wind Turbines and Proximity to Homes:
The Impact of Wind Turbine Noise on Health
!
a review of the literature & discussion of the issues
!
!
!
!
by
Barbara J Frey, BA, MA (University of Minnesota)
&
Peter J Hadden, BSc (Est Man), FRICS
January 2012
Health is a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being,
and not merely the absence of disease and infirmity.
-- The World Health Organization Charter
The objective of science is not agreement on a course of action,
but the pursuit of truth.
-- John Kay (2007)
First, Do No Harm.
-- The Hippocratic Oath
!
!
"!
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements
3
Preface
4
Introduction
5
Chapter 1
Wind Turbines built near Homes: the Effects on People
8
Appendix 1: People’s Health Experiences: Additional References 21
Chapter 2
Wind Turbine Noise and Guidance
22
2.1
Wind turbine noise
22
2.2
Wind turbine noise guidance
38
2.3
Wind turbine noise: Guidance process
43
2.4
Wind turbine noise: Low frequency noise (LFN)
54
2.5
Wind turbine noise: Amplitude modulation (AM)
60
Appendix 2: Wind Turbine Noise & Guidance: Additional References 65
Chapter 3
Wind Turbine Noise: Impacts on Health
3.1
Wind turbine noise and its impacts on health, sleep, and
cognition
3.2
Wind turbine noise: Clinical studies and counterclaims
Appendix 3.1 Health: International Perspectives
Appendix 3.2 Health: Additional References
67
67
92
101
102
Chapter 4
Wind Turbine Noise and Human Rights
103
4.1
Potential violations
103
4.2
The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights 112
4.3
State Indifference to Human Rights:
The UK Planning Bill & the UK Equality &
Human Rights Commission (EHRC)
118
Appendix 4.1: Proximity to Homes: Additional References
127
Appendix 4.2: Human Rights: General Issues, Specific Cases, and
Property Values (International): Additional References
129
Chapter 5
David v Goliath
Appendix 5.1 Mr and Mrs J Davis, Lincolnshire, UK
Appendix 5.2 Mr and Mrs M Hulme, Devon, UK
Conclusions
141
Recommendations
143
Bibliography
145
131
135
139
!
Acknowledgements
#!
The authors were fortunate to have the critical support of many others, including experts
in related fields, all of whom are concerned about the adverse health impacts of wind
turbine noise on people. We are grateful for your input and interest, as you know.
With special thanks to:
David Cocks, QC
Christopher Hanning, BSc, MB, BS, MRCS, LRCP, FRCA, MD
Amanda Harry, MB ChB, PGDip ENT
Carmen Krogh, BscPharm
And with thanks to all the many individuals and families who have persisted, against the
odds, often at personal financial and emotional cost, and often for many years, to protect
the health and quality of life for their families and their communities. Their
perseverance benefits us all, by example and by accomplishment.
With special thanks to:
Mr and Mrs Julian Davis
Mr and Mrs Michael Hulme
!
Preface
$!
!
%&!"''()!*+!,-./012+3!!"#$%&'()#(*#"+&,-".&/#+)&01-2#+%$&3+$*(44%)&!%(-&5".%$6&7,,%8*$&"+&5%(4*9)!
4!,4,+5!6246!+7480&+3!62+!0&6+51+960:&!:;!62+!190+&9+!:;!49:-16091!4&3!8+3090&+!0&!:53+5!6:!.+66+5!
-&3+5164&3!*2<!,+:,/+!+7,+50+&9+3!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!41!4!5+1-/6!:;!/:&>?6+58!+7,:1-5+!6:!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!A2+!,4,+5!5+=0+*+3!4/5+43<!,-./012+3!16-30+1!4&3!5+,:561)!5+=+4/0&>!4!1+50:-1!
301,4506<!.+6*++&!49:-160904&1B!,5+3096+3!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!62+!496-4/!+;;+961!
+7,+50+&9+3!.<!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!+=+&!*2+&!3+=+/:,+51!432+5+3!6:!>:=+5&8+&6!
>-034&9+@!!%&6+5&460:&4//<)!62+5+!*41!+=03+&9+!:;!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+!*2+&!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!
*+5+!106+3!&+45!,+:,/+B1!2:8+1)!:62+5!1+&1060=+!/0=0&>!4&3!*:5C0&>!+&=05:&8+&61)!4&3!0&!1:8+!
941+1)!.5:43+5!9:88-&060+1@!
!
D+!4&6090,46+3!6246!62+1+!9:8,/40&61!4&3!,5:./+81!*:-/3!+194/46+!0;!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!
.-0/6!&+45!2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1)!-&/+11!>:=+5&8+&61!4335+11+3!62+!;40/-5+!:;!*0&3!+&+5><!
,:/09<!6:!,5:6+96!62+!,-./09B1!2+4/62@!!!E&;:56-&46+/<)!62+!*:516?941+!19+&450:!241!-&;:/3+3)!+=+&!41!
49:-160904&1!5+4/01+!6246!,5+30960&>!4&3!9:&65://0&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!8:5+!9:8,/+7!624&!
4&6090,46+3@!!F1!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!106+3!*062:-6!+7+59010&>!3-+!945+!4&3!466+&60:&!6:!62+!
&:01+!,://-60:&!4&3!9:&1+G-+&6!2+4/62!+;;+961)!8:5+!,+:,/+!45+!+7,+50+&90&>!62+!&+>460=+!+;;+961!:;!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+!190+&9+!:;!1/++,!4&3!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!:;!&:01+!:&!1/++,!4&3!
2+4/62!9:&60&-+!6:!5+=+4/!I-16!2:*!3484>0&>!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1!4&3!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!45+!6:!
2+4/62)!/+45&0&>)!4&3!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+@!!!
!
J+6)!>:=+5&8+&61!24=+!;:9-1+3!62+05!,:/090+1!:&!4920+=0&>!*0&3!+&+5><!645>+61!*20/+!:,60&>!6:!
0>&:5+!+=03+&9+!3+8:&165460&>!6246!*2+&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!/:946+3!6::!9/:1+!6:!;480/<!2:8+1)!62+!
,5:/:&>+3!+7,:1-5+!6:!62+!4-30./+!4&3!0&4-30./+!54&>+!:;!49:-1609!9245496+5016091!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!43=+51+/<!4;;+961!,+:,/+K1!2+4/62@!
!
F1!*+!4&3!84&<!:62+51!&:6+3!<+451!4>:)!4//!62+1+!,5:./+81!4&3!3019:53)!4/:&>!*062!62+!+7,+&1+!:;!
4,,+4/1!4&3!,-./09!0&G-050+1)!80>26!24=+!.++&!4=:03+3!*062!62+!108,/+16!:;!1:/-60:&1L!!/:946+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!46!4!30164&9+!;5:8!2:8+1)!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1)!4&3!9:88-&060+1)!46!4!30164&9+!6246!,5:6+961!
62+!:99-,4&61!;5:8!,5+I-30904/!2+4/62!9:&1+G-+&9+1@!!F/62:->2!6201!,4,+5!,508450/<!5+=0+*1!62+!
,:/090+1!0&!M50640&)!62+!-&*4&6+3!2+4/62!+;;+961!45+!-&0=+514/@!
!
N:=+5&8+&61!9:&60&-+!6:!5+/<!:&!49:-1609!+&>0&++51!6:!,5+,45+!:;;0904/!>-034&9+!.:62!:&!+7,:1-5+!
6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!0&9/-30&>!62+!-,,+5!/08061!:;!3:14>+!4&3!3-5460:&)!4&3!:&!62+!1+,45460:&!
30164&9+1!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!;5:8!2:8+1@!!%6!01!05:&09!6246!1+=+54/!+7,+561!:&!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62!45+!:&!
;49-/6<!46!M506012!-&0=+51060+1!??!<+6!,+5,/+70&>/<)!M50640&!9:&60&-+1!6:!5+/<!-,:&!49:-1609!+&>0&++51!
6:!43=01+!:&!62+!9:8,/+7!,5:./+8!:;!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62@!!H:5+:=+5)!4/62:->2!62+!,5:./+8!:;!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!*+//!C&:*&!6:!N:=+5&8+&6)!62+5+!01!&:!+=03+&9+!6246!N:=+5&8+&6!241!,/4&&+3!:5!
1++C1!6:!:5>4&01+!4&!0&3+,+&3+&6!4943+809)!+,03+80:/:>09!9/0&094/!16-3<!:;!62+1+!011-+1)!+=+&!
62:->2!06!241!.++&!-5>+3!6:!3:!1:@!
!
A2+!M506012!4&3!:62+5!>:=+5&8+&61!41,05+!6:!2-84&!50>261!03+4/1)!<+6!62+<!0&305+96/<!+&3:51+!62+!
0&2-84&!65+468+&6!1-;;+5+3!.<!1:8+!;480/0+1)!16+880&>!305+96/<!;5:8!N:=+5&8+&6!,:/09<!6246!
4//:*1!9:&165-960:&!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!;480/<!2:8+1@!!A201!0//-16546+1!4/1:!6246!
62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!;480/<!/0;+!4&3!061!48+&06<!4&3!2+4/62!45+!/+11!08,:564&6!6:!N:=+5&8+&6!4&3!061!
,:/09<?84C+51!624&!62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!9:88+5904/!3+=+/:,8+&6)!/4&3194,+!0&6+5+161)!4&3!.0531!4&3!
.461@!
!
D+!303!&:6!5+9+0=+!&:5!*0//!*+!5+9+0=+!4&<!5+8-&+5460:&!.<!*5060&>!6201!,4,+5@!!M<!5+=0+*0&>!62+!
+=03+&9+!;5:8!5+1+4592!.<!62:1+!*062!5+/+=4&6!+7,+5601+)!*+!2:,+!6201!,4,+5!2+/,1!62:1+!*2:!1++C!
6:!,5:6+96!,+:,/+B1!2+4/62!4&3!.4109!2-84&!50>261!4&3!6:!,5+=+&6!0&4,,5:,5046+)!+&=05:&8+&64//<!
,://-60&>)!0&3-16504/!3+=+/:,8+&6!&+45!2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1@!!A246!01!:-5!5+*453@!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Introduction
O!
!!
!
P-99+110=+!EQ!R&+5><!H0&016+51!24=+!;40/+3!6:!49C&:*/+3>+!6246!62+!2016:509!8+62:3!:;!9:&65://0&>!
62+!30164&9+!.+6*++&!,+:,/+B1!2:8+1!4&3!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!RAPE?S?T()!,-./012+3!0&!UTT()!01!:.1:/+6+!
4&3!&:!/:&>+5!,5:6+961!62+!48+&06<!:;!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!RAPE?S?T()!*5066+&!8:5+!
624&!UO!<+451!4>:)!01!&:!/:&>+5!V;06!;:5!,-5,:1+K!4&3!3:+1!&:6!,5:=03+!43+G-46+!2+4/62!,5:6+960:&!6:!
&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1@!!D2+&!RAPE!*41!,-./012+3)!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!847084//<!W'!8+65+1!64//@!!
A:34<B1!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!U"O!X!UO'!8+65+1!64//!6:!./43+!60,)!*062!84110=+!1,4604/!1-5;49+!45+41!
9:=+5+3!.<!62+!9059-8;+5+&9+!:;!62+!./43+!1*0&>)!*2092!95+46+1!10>&0;094&6!=:5609+1!:;!405!
6-5.-/+&9+!0&!.49C!4&3!0&!;5:&6!:;!62+!./43+1@!!D20/+!62+5+!45+!08,5:=+8+&61!0&!62+!6+92&:/:><!:;!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+10>&)!62+!12++5!0&95+41+!0&!10Y+!,5:3-9+1!&+*!3<&48091!0&!4/606-3+!*0&3!6-5.-/+&9+!
4&3!,2<1094/!49:-1609!,5:./+81@!!M<!;45!62+!>5+46+16!,5:./+8!;:5!,+:,/+!01!62+!0&95+41+!0&!49:-1609!
5430460:&)!*2092!,://-6+1!62+!/0=0&>!4&3!*:5C0&>!+&=05:&8+&61!:;!62:1+!*2:!/0=+!&+45!62+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!106+1@!!!ZRAPE!;:5!62+![+,4568+&6!:;!A543+!4&3!%&3-165<!\[60]@!!RAPE?S?T(L!A2+!F11+118+&6!
^!S460&>!:;!_:01+!;5:8!D0&3!`4581L!`0&4/!S+,:56@!![60!\EQ])!P+,6+8.+5!UTTW!
266,Laa*+.45920=+@&460:&4/45920=+1@>:=@-Caba266,Laa***@.+55@>:=@-Ca+&+5><a1:-59+1a5+&+*4./
+1a+7,/40&+3a*0&3a:&12:5+?:;;12:5+a,4>+"U($#@268/!c!
!
A201!,4,+5!4335+11+1!&:6!:&/<!62+!011-+1!:;!*0&3!+&+5><!,:/09<!*2+5+!06!=0:/46+1!62+!.4109!/0=0&>!
+&=05:&8+&6!:;!;480/0+1!4&3!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!.-6!4/1:!411+11+1!62+!
9:&103+54./+!&-8.+5!:;!4&+93:64/!5+,:561!;5:8!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!F1!&:6+3!0&!
62+!4-62:51B!"''(!,4,+5)!4/62:->2!62+5+!45+!84&<!*2:!3018011!4&+93:64/!5+,:561!41!
0&9:&1+G-+&604/!:5!8+4&0&>/+11)!62+1+!5+,:561!45+!;5:8!5+4/!,+:,/+)!/0=0&>!*062!5+4/!,5:./+81)!
:;6+&!*062!&:!5+9:-51+L!!62+<!,-6!B62+!2-84&!;49+!:&!190+&9+B@!!A2+!4-62:51!4/1:!+7480&+!2:*!6201!
654&1/46+1!0&6:!4!2-84&!50>261!011-+)!41!>:=+5&8+&6!,:/09<!4110>&1!8:5+!95+30.0/06<!6:!49:-160904&1K!
5+,:561!624&!6:!8+3094/!+=03+&9+)!4&3!4110>&1!8:5+!08,:564&9+!6:!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!,:/09<!624&!6:!
62+!0&30=03-4/!/0=+1!0&I-5+3!.<!6246!,:/09<@!!!
!
A2+!,4,+5!.+>0&1!*062!4!5+=0+*!:;!62+!49:-1609!08,496!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!5+,:56+3!.<!;480/0+1!
4&3!9:88-&060+1!0&!62+!EQ!41!*+//!41!1080/45!941+1!0&!d4,4&)!F-1654/4104)!62+!E&06+3!P646+1)!e4&434)!
4&3!625:->2:-6!R-5:,+@!!A201!;0516!!924,6+5!9://46+1!4&3!3+640/1!1:8+!:;!62+!+=03+&9+!:;!5+9+&6!
5+,:56+3!941+1!4&3!62+!+76+&6!:;!3019:8;:56)!30165+11)!4&3!2+4/62!,5:./+81!1-;;+5+3!.<!62:1+!
;480/0+1!*062!,5:/:&>+3!+7,:1-5+!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!
!
!e24,6+5!"!+7480&+1!62+!=0+*1!:;!/+430&>!49:-1609!+7,+561!:&!62+!5+41:&1!6246!62+!49:-1609!
B.:8.4538+&6B!08,4961!,+:,/+!,2<1094//<@!!A201!924,6+5!4/1:!5+=0+*1!62+!,5:./+81!4&3!
9:8,/+7060+1!0&!0&6+5,5+60&>!62+!EQ!RAPE?S?T(!>-034&9+!4&3!1-.1+G-+&6!4,,45+&6!30;;09-/6<!
+&;:590&>!&:01+!9:&3060:&1!6246!+8+5>+!;5:8!RAPE@!
!!
e24,6+5!#!3019-11+1!,++5?5+=0+*+3!8+3094/!5+1+4592!4&3!5+,:561!;5:8!0&6+5&460:&4//<!5+9:>&01+3!
4-62:5060+1)!+@>@)!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&)!1-,,:560&>!62+!4&+93:64/!+=03+&9+!:;!2+4/62!
,5:./+81!+7,+50+&9+3!.<!;480/0+1!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1h!62+1+!;480/0+1!+&3-5+!62+!,-/1460&>!
&:01+!41!*+//!41!,5:/:&>+3!+7,:1-5+@!!A2+5+!01!4/1:!4!>5:*0&>!.:3<!:;!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!
1-.164&60460&>!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!08,4961!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&)!,45609-/45/<!*062!
+76+&3+3!+7,:1-5+)!:;!*2092!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!4&!+748,/+@!
!
F1!*062!84&<!,-./09!2+4/62!011-+1)!62+!,5:./+81!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!16456+3!*062!4&+93:64/!
5+,:561!*2+5+!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!6:!2:8+1@!!A2+1+!9:8,/40&61!+8+5>+3!0&!4!19466+5+3!
,466+5&)!.+94-1+!:;6+&!62+!,+:,/+!4;;+96+3!303!&:6!411:9046+!62+!1-33+&!:&1+6!:;!62+05!1/++,!
3016-5.4&9+1)!2+43492+1)!:5!0&4.0/06<!6:!9:&9+&6546+!*062!62+!&:01+@!!H:16!,+:,/+!*+5+!9:&;03+&6!
*2+&!6:/3!.<!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!9:8,4&0+1!4&3!62+05!/:94/!:;;0904/1!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!&:6!
0&65-10=+)!6246!62+!&:01+!,5:3-9+3!01!+410/<!841C+3!.<!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+)!4&3!6246!62+!&:01+!
9:8,45+3!;4=:-54./<!*062!;480/045!1:-&31)!+@>@)!4!2:8+!;503>+)!:5!4!G-0+6!9:&=+51460:&!0&!62+!
/0.545<@!!%&0604//<)!+492!4;;+96+3!,+51:&!62:->26!201!:5!2+5!&+*!1<8,6:81!*+5+!-&0G-+@!
!
F1!8:5+!9:8,/40&61!+8+5>+3!;5:8!62:1+!*2:!/0=+3!&+45!&+*/<!:,+5460:&4/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!106+1)!4&3!
62:1+!*2:!,0&,:0&6+3!62+!16456!:;!62+05!&+*/<!03+&60;0+3!2+4/62!,5:./+81!*062!62+!8:=+8+&6!:;!62+!
./43+1)!1:8+!:;!62:1+!4;;+96+3!??!4&3!4!;+*!2+4/62!,5:;+110:&4/1!??!1-1,+96+3!6246!62+!1:-59+!:;!62+05!
,5:./+81!80>26!.+!411:9046+3!*062!62+!&:01+!>+&+546+3!.<!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!A201!411:90460:&!
1++8+3!8:5+!/0C+/<!.+94-1+!62+!=096081K!1<8,6:81!*+5+!5+/0+=+3!*2+&!62+<!*+5+!4*4<!;5:8!62+05!
2:8+1!:5!;4581@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+!1<8,6:81!5+9-55+3!:&9+!62+<!5+6-5&+3!2:8+@!!A2+1+!,466+5&1!
!
W!
+8+5>+3!:&/<!:=+5!608+)!4&3!495:11!84&<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!45+41)!0&6+5&460:&4//<@!!e24,6+5!#!4/1:!
5+=0+*1!1+=+54/!,0/:6!16-30+1!9:&3-96+3!.<!,2<10904&1!0&!:53+5!6:!411+11!62+!4&+93:64/!5+,:561!:;!
2+4/62!+;;+961!;5:8!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!
!
e24,6+5!$!9:&103+51!.4109!0&6+5&460:&4/!2-84&!50>261)!4,,45+&6/<!103+16+,,+3!.<!M50640&)!41!061!
+&=05:&8+&64/!,:/09<!4,,+451!6:!4110>&!>5+46+5!,50:506<!6:!62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!/4&3194,+)!.461)!
3:5809+)!4&3!*46+5!=:/+1!\62:->2!62+!4-62:51!9+5640&/<!4,,/4-3!62:1+!+;;:561]@!!A2+!P646+!4,,+451!
6:!499:53!8:5+!08,:564&9+!6:)!4&3!+&;:59+1!*062!8:5+!1650&>+&9<)!62:1+!011-+1!6:!62+!3+6508+&6!:;!
,:/09<!6246!,5:6+961!62+!2+4/62!4&3!30>&06<!:;!;480/0+1@!!F1!4!5+1-/6)!0&!62+05!48.060:&!6:!4920+=+!
5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+61)!,-./09!:;;0904/1!4-62:501+!*246!48:-&61!6:!62+!3+>5430&>!4&3!0&2-84&!
65+468+&6!:;!;480/0+1@!
!
A2+!0&;/-+&604/!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!4&3!061!/:..<0161)!,-./09!4>+&90+1)!+&=05:&8+&64/!
:5>4&01460:&1)!4&3!84&<!8+304!1:-59+1!:;6+&!+8,/:<!,+I:5460=+!/4.+/1)!1-92!41!_%HMJ!X!_:6!%&!H<!
M49C<453)!6:!3+95<!:5!160>84601+!62:1+!*2:!9:8,/40&)!41!0&1+&1060=+!6:!+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&!
4&3!>/:.4/!*4580&>)!0&!:53+5!6:!3018011!62+1+!4&+93:64/!5+,:561@!!J+6)!06!01!+11+&604/!6:!5+8+8.+5!
6246!84&<!:;!62:1+!4;;+96+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!*+5+!62:1+!148+!,+:,/+!*2:!*+/9:8+3!62+!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!192+8+1!4&3!*+5+!1C+,6094/!:;!62:1+!*2:!9:8,/40&+3!4.:-6!,:6+&604/!:5!496-4/!&:01+!
0&6+5;+5+&9+@!!H4&<!+45/<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!16-30+1!;:9-1+3!:&!4&&:<4&9+!4&3!03+&60;0+3!1/++,!
3016-5.4&9+!41!4!;5+G-+&6!,5:./+8)!.-6!62+1+!16-30+1!303!&:6!9://+96!3464!:&!2+4/62!+;;+961@!!i-./09!
2+4/62!,5:./+81!:;6+&!+=:/=+!>543-4//<!4&3!.+9:8+!8:5+!+=03+&6!:&/<!*062!62+!,4114>+!:;!608+!41!
8:5+!,+:,/+!45+!4;;+96+3!\3-5460:&!:;!+7,:1-5+]@!
!
EQ!>:=+5&8+&6!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!,:/09<!241!;:9-1+3!8:5+!:&!+7,4&30&>!62+!5:/+!:;!0&3-16504/!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!5462+5!624&!+&1-50&>!62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!62+!2+4/62!:;!62:1+!+7,:1+3!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+)!0@+@)!62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!62+!,-./09B1!2+4/62@!!A2-1)!62+!=:09+1!:;!62:1+!4;;+96+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!24=+!>5:*&!8:5+!0&1016+&6!41!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!106+1!45+!/:946+3!&+45!2:8+1!4&3!=0//4>+1@!!
A2+!1:/-60:&!241!4/*4<1!1++8+3!654&1,45+&6/<!16540>26;:5*453L!!/:946+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!;-562+5!;5:8!
2:8+1!4&3!:62+5!1+&1060=+!165-96-5+1@!!g;!9:-51+)!:&+!8-16!62+&!3+6+580&+!62+!:,608-8!30164&9+)!
4&3!62+5+!/0+1!62+!5-.)!*062!0&3-165<!,-120&>!;:5!80&084/!30164&9+1)!*20/+!84&<!:62+51!1++C!4!8:5+!
,5+94-60:&45<!164&9+)!0&!4&!+;;:56!6:!,5:6+96!2+4/62)!*+//?.+0&>)!30>&06<)!4&3!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+@!
!
D0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!4!;:58!:;!4&3!4&:62+5!94-1+!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&@!!S+9+&6!
16-30+1)!.:62!8+3094/!4&3!49:-1609)!:;;+5!3464!6:!411016!*062!62+!3+9010:&!:&!*2+5+!6:!106+!4&3!2:*!
6:!3+10>&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1@!!_:64./<)!*0&3!+&+5><!3+=+/:,+51!:;6+&!411+56!6246!62+5+!45+!
=056-4//<!&:!16-30+1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!&:!+=03+&9+!:;!061!0//!+;;+961@!!f:*+=+5)!62+5+!45+!&:6!
:&/<!16-30+1!1,+90;094//<!:&!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!62+5+!45+!4/1:!16-30+1!:&!
&:01+!*062!1080/45!:5!1245+3!49:-1609!9245496+5016091@!!D0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!+1,+904//<!9:8,/0946+3!
.+94-1+!:;!62+!V9:9C640/K!:;!,2<1094/!49:-1609!9245496+51!6246!9:8,501+!62+!&:01+!,://-60:&@!!A2+!
,-/1460&>!&:01+)!9245496+501609!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!94&!.+!8:5+!0&65-10=+!624&!:62+5!6<,+1!:;!&:01+)!
4&3!62+!,-/1460:&1!0&9/-3+!.:62!4-30./+!4&3!0&4-30./+!9:8,:&+&61)!0@+@)!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)!
0&;541:-&3)!4&3!=0.5460:&@!!_:01+!*062!62+1+!9245496+5016091!01!8:5+!0&65-10=+)!4&3!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!
g5>4&0Y460:&!\Dfg]!>-03+/0&+1!5+9:88+&3!/:*+50&>!62+!,+580110./+!3+90.+/!/+=+/1!*2+&!&:01+!
9:&640&1!62+1+!9245496+5016091@!!Dfg!84C+1!62+1+!5+9:88+&3460:&1!&:6!8+5+/<!6:!5+3-9+!
4&&:<4&9+!:5!&-014&9+@!!Dfg!84C+1!62+1+!5+9:88+&3460:&1!.+94-1+!+,03+80:/:>094/!16-30+1!
0&30946+!9/+45/<!6246!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!01!,5+I-30904/!4&3!0&I-50:-1!6:!2+4/62@!!ZDfg!UTTT)!"'U')!
"'UUc!!!!
!
DfgB1!08,45604/!5+,:561!45+!,45609-/45/<!9:8,+//0&>!.+94-1+!62+<!-&3+5>:!,+50:309!5+=0+*!4&3!
-,3460&>!.<!061!0&6+5&460:&4/!,4&+/!:;!+7,+561!;5:8!30=+51+)!5+/46+3!;0+/31@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+!,4&+/B1!
;0&30&>1!4&3!5+,:561!-&3+5>:!4!,5:9+11!:;!1650&>+&6!5+=0+*!0&6+5&4//<!48:&>16!62+!,4&+/0161)!41!
*+//!41!+76+5&4//<)!.<!5+=0+*+51!&:6!:&!62+!,4&+/@!!H:16!5+9+&6/<!Dfg!011-+3!_0>26!_:01+!
N-03+/0&+1!;:5!R-5:,+!"''T)!4&3!62+!M-53+&!:;![01+41+!;5:8!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+!"'UU)!*2092)!
*062!RE!305+960=+1!4&3!>-03+/0&+1!:&!&:01+)!:;;+5!,:/09<?84C+51!4&3!:62+5!0&=+16+3!,4560+1!*062!
3+1950,60:&1!:;!2:*!2+4/62!01!43=+51+/<!4;;+96+3!.<!&:01+)!41!*+//!41!*062!8+62:3:/:>0+1!6:!
48+/0:546+!:5!6:!,5+=+&6!0&I-5<!6:!2+4/62!;5:8!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+@!
!
A2:1+!4;;+96+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9:-/3!.+!<:-5!5+/460=+1)!;50+&31)!&+0>2.:-51)!4&3!+=+&!??!46!
1:8+!,:0&6!??!<:-@!!g;6+&!62+1+!45+!,+:,/+!*2:!C&:*!4-16+506<!0&60846+/<)!*2:!-&3+5164&3!62+!
30/+884!:;!.4/4&90&>!+&=05:&8+&64/!011-+1!1-92!41!+&+5><!1-,,/<!4&3!>/:.4/!*4580&>!*062!
9-55+&6!,:/09<!4&3!;-6-5+!3+84&31@!!%&16+43)!62+<!45+!845>0&4/01+3!4&3!843+!6:!;++/!3:/6012!4&3!
!
(!
1+/;012@!!A2+<!4/1:!;++/!301+&;54&9201+3!4&3!4.4&3:&+3!.<!62:1+!0&!*2:8!62+<!24=+!,/49+3!62+05!
65-16@!!A201!9<&09018!01!&:6!-&;:-&3+3)!41!84&<!45+!/+;6!;0&4&904//<!08,:=+5012+3!41!62+<!1++C!
43=09+!4&3!1-,,:56!0&!:53+5!6:!84C+!62+05!=:09+1!2+453@!!A2+!011-+!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!4.:-6!
5+4/!,+:,/+)!*2:!45+!>+&-0&+/<!1-;;+50&>!3+>5430&>!4&3!0&2-84&!65+468+&6@!!!
!
i/4&&0&>!;:5!0&3-16504/!+1646+1!&+45!3*+//0&>1!01!8:5+!5+1650960=+!:&!&:01+!9:&65:/)!*062!62:1+!
;490/060+1!545+/<!:,+5460&>!340/<)!"$a()!624&!62+!&:01+!9:&65:/1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!P+/+960&>!4!
80&08-8!30164&9+!:;!"C8!41!4!.-;;+5!.+6*++&!2:8+1!4&3!62+!,/49+8+&6!:;!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!X!
62:->2!4&!+=+&!>5+46+5!30164&9+!84<!.+!5+G-05+3!X!01!&:6!+79+110=+!*2+&!62+!/0=+1!4&3!*+//?.+0&>!
:;!62:1+!4;;+96+3!45+!64C+&!0&6:!499:-&6@!!A2+5+!01!160//!48,/+!:,,:56-&06<!;:5!3+=+/:,+51!6:!106+!
62+05!192+8+1!8:5+!4,,5:,5046+/<!4&3!;:5!>:=+5&8+&6!6:!5+35+11!+55:51!0&!,:/09<!6246!4//:*!62+1+!
-&6:*453)!-&,5+30964./+)!4&3!-&499+,64./+!+;;+961@!!
!
!
Chapter 1
j!
!"#$%&'()"#*+%)'",-%#*.(%/01*+2%%-3*%455*6-+%0#%7*08,*!
!!!
A2+5+!45+!1+=+54/!2-&35+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!:,+5460&>!:&12:5+!0&!62+!EQ@!!!%&!H4592!"'U')!62+!
EQ![+,4568+&6!:;!A543+!4&3!%&3-165<!\[60]!011-+3!'%$%(-89&#+*"&:%-");+(.#8&<")14(*#"+&",&/#+)&
01-2#+%&!"#$%6&=#+(4&'%>"-*)!*2092!06!9:880110:&+3!;5:8!4!6+48!2+43+3!.<![5!F&3<!H::52:-1+!46!
P4/;:53!E&0=+5106<!4&3!H5!H4/9:/8!f4<+1)!4&!49:-160904&!*2:!9:?4-62:5+3!RAPE?S?T()!09%&
:$$%$$.%+*&?&'(*#+@&",&!"#$%&,-".&/#+)&=(-.$)!;:5!62+![60@!!%&!061!4&4/<101!:;!6201!5+,:56)!62+![40/<!
A+/+>54,2!ZEQc!&:6+3)!“one in six wind farms have had complaints about noise”. [N54<!k@!!
_:01+!e:8,/40&61!4.:-6!g&+!0&!P07!D0&3!`4581@!![40/<!A+/+>54,2)!W!H4592!"'U'c!
A2+!P4/;:53!S+,:56!0&9/-3+3!4&4/<101!:;!6*+&6<?1+=+&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!6246!243!,5:=+3!
9:&6+&60:-1!.+94-1+!:;!&:01+!9:8,/40&61@!!A2+!4-62:51!:;!62+!P4/;:53!S+,:56!303!&:6!0&6+5=0+*!4&<!
:;!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!62+1+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1)!&:5!303!62+<!4,,+45!6:!-1+!62+!8:16!5+9+&6!Dfg!
>-034&9+!:5!:62+5!4=40/4./+!5+1+4592!:&!62+!43=+51+!08,496!:;!&:01+!:&!,+:,/+)!&:5!303!62+<!0&9/-3+!
9:&1-/6460:&!*062!+7,+561!0&!9/0&094/!16-30+1!:&!62+1+!1-.I+961@!!A2+5+;:5+)!06!*41!&:!1-5,501+!6246!
62+05!5+,:56!;:-&3!&:!5+41:&!6:!4/6+5!9-55+&6!164&34531@!!ZH::52:-1+!Fh!f4<+1!Hh!=:&!fl&+5.+0&h!
i0,+5!Mh!4&3!F3481!H@!!'%$%(-89&#+*"&:%-");+(.#8&<")14(*#"+&",&/#+)&01-2#+%&!"#$%6&=#+(4&'%>"-*A!!
S+,:56!.<!E&0=+5106<!:;!P4/;:53!;:5![+;54)!MRSS)![ekN)!4&3![60!\EQ])!d-/<!"''(c!
!
J+6)!4&!:+(4;$#$&",&/#+)&=(-.$&B#*9&!"#$%&C".>4(#+*$&2($%)&"+&*9%&D(4,"-)&'%>"-*!;:-&3!46!/+416!#W!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!6246!94-1+3!&:01+!,5:./+81!;:5!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45.<@!!Ze2456!9:8,0/+3!
4&:&<8:-1/<!;5:8!3464!5+650+=+3!=04!62+!`5++3:8!:;!%&;:58460:&!F96!.<!62+!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!
`:-&3460:&!\SR`]L!!e:&164./+)!d!\[5]!4&3!H:5:&+<!k!\[5]@!!E(*(&"2*(#+%)&1+)%-&*9%&=-%%)".&",&
3+,"-.(*#"+&:8*6&/#+)&01-2#+%&!"#$%&C".>4(#+*&D1-F%;&E(*(&C"44%8*%)&2;&*9%&G+#F%-$#*;&",&D(4,"-)&
1+)%-&8"+*-(8*&*"&*9%&E%>(-*.%+*&",&H1$#+%$$I&7+*%->-#$%&(+)&'%@14(*"-;&'%,"-.6&'%$%(-89&#+*"&
:%-");+(.#8&<")14(*#"+&",&/#+)&01-2#+%&!"#$%!ES_!'(aU"#O@!!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!
\SR`])!k:&3:&)!EQ)!W!`+.5-545<!"''T!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca,-./09460:&1aUOU?5+;?,-./012+1?3464?:&?*0&3?;458?&:01+?:.640&+3?-&3+5?
62+?;5++3:8?:;?0&;:58460:&?496!4&3!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca4664928+&61a45609/+aUOUaI9@/8@14/;:53@3464@9:88+&6@'(@'"@'T@9@,3;c!
!
A201!654&1/46+1!0&6:!UWm!:;!EQ!*0&3!6-5.0&+!106+1!94-10&>!10>&0;094&6!&:01+!,5:./+81)!+=+&!4;6+5!62+!
+76+&10=+!,5:9+11!:;!19:,0&>!5+,:561)!432+5+&9+!6:!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!0&3-165<!&:01+!>-034&9+!4&3!
,5+30960:&!8:3+/1)!4&3!9:&3060:&1!1+6!.<!/:94/!4-62:5060+1@!!H:5+:=+5)!0;!62+!P4/;:53!5+,:56!243!
0&9/-3+3!:&/<!62:1+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!/:946+3!&+45!2:8+1)!5462+5!624&!4/1:!0&9/-30&>!62:1+!6246!
*+5+!5+8:6+/<!106+3)!62+!,+59+&64>+!:;!106+1!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9:8,/40&61!501+1@!
!
e:8,/40&61!4.:-6!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!45+!0&6+5&460:&4/)!;:-&3!*2+5+=+5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!24=+!.++&!
106+3!0&!,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1L!0&!62+!EPF)!e4&434)!F-1654/04)!_+*!n+4/4&3)!d4,4&)!A-5C+<)![+&845C)!
A2+!_+62+5/4&31)!N+584&<)!4&3!:62+5!9:-&650+1!0&!R-5:,+@!!
!
%&!"''T)!62+!H40&+!H+3094/!F11:90460:&)!4!P646+!924,6+5!:;!62+!F8+5094&!H+3094/!F11:90460:&)!
,411+3!4!S+1:/-60:&!5+>4530&>!/#+)&7+%-@;&(+)&J124#8&5%(4*9L!
!
"Whereas, assessing the potential health impact of wind turbines has been difficult
to measure but if present would be of significant concern. This is especially
apparent regarding the noise level and other noise characteristics specific to
industrial wind turbines.
Therefore be it resolved that the Maine Medical Association work with health
organizations and regulatory agencies to bring to the publics attention the
scientific information of known medical consequences of wind development.
!
Further Resolved that the Maine Medical Association (1) encourage performance of
studies on health effects of wind turbine generation by independent qualified
researchers at qualified research institutions, (2) ensure that physicians and
patients alike are informed of evidence-based research results." [Maine Medical
Association. Resolution Re: Wind Energy and Public Health. MMA (USA), 2009]
T!
!
A2+!;://:*0&>!+748,/+1!5+,5+1+&6!62+!9:&103+54./+!0&65-10:&!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!0&6:!+=+5<34<!
/0;+!4&3!62+!3+=416460&>!9:&1+G-+&9+1!;:5!:530&45<!,+:,/+)!5+>453/+11!:;!62+05!.49C>5:-&31)!4>+1)!
4&3!945++51@!!A2+<!0//-16546+!62+!941-4/!30180110=+!4,,5:492!:;!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!41!*+//!41!
62+!5+/-964&9+!:;!>:=+5&8+&61!6:!-&3+564C+!08,45604/!4&3!0&3+,+&3+&6!190+&60;09!5+1+4592!0&6:!62+!
,5:./+81)!:5!6:!432+5+!6:!165096+5!>-03+/0&+1!5+9:88+&3+3!.<!+7,+56!5+,:561!1-92!41!62:1+!011-+3!
.<!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&@!
!
%&!d-&+!"''O)!H51!N*+&!M-5C24536!:;!_+*!o-4<)!D4/+1)!EQ)!5+,:56+3!6246!62+!625++!B84110=+B!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!6246!*+5+!.-0/6!&+45!2+5!;480/<!2:8+!0&!"''U)!243!4!10>&0;094&6!4&3!&+>460=+!08,496!:&!2+5!
2+4/62L!!!
!
"Having been in the best of health for most of my life, I couldn’t understand why I
was suddenly feeling very unwell for no apparent reason. Racing pulse, heart
palpitations, a strange churning in my head, a feeling of nausea, a terrible unease
and a need to escape. Sleep became difficult too.” [Burkhardt G. Wind Farm
Illness (letter) WalesOnline, 6 June 2005 www.walesonline.co.uk]
!
%&!"''W)!N40/!H405!4&3!2+5!2-1.4&3!1+66/+3!0&6:!62+05!&+*!2:8+!0&!P94&14&:)!%64/<@!!D0620&!;:-5!
*++C1)!62+!U'!&+*/<!+5+96+3!U"U8!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!*062!62+!&+45+16!4,,5:70846+/<!T''8!;5:8!62+05!
2:8+)!16456+3!:,+5460&>@!!D0620&!4!12:56!608+)!.:62!H51!H405!4&3!2+5!2-1.4&3!+7,+50+&9+3!4!1+50+1!
:;!2+4/62!,5:./+81!6246!*+5+!&+*!6:!62+8!.:62!X!*062!62+!:&1+6!&:6!/:&>!4;6+5!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!
*+5+!1*0692+3!:&L!!0&1:8&04h!/:11!:;!9:&9+&65460:&h!&4-1+4h!4&3!3+,5+110:&@!![-50&>!"''()!H51!
H405!C+,6!4!3045<!:;!62+!&:01+!4&3!62+!1<8,6:81!+7,+50+&9+3@!!e245496+5016094//<)!62+!1<8,6:81!
3014,,+45+3!*2+&!62+!;480/<!/+;6!62+!45+4!;:5!*:5C)!+76+&3+3!=01061)!4&3!2:/034<1@!!e:-,/+3!*062!
62+!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1)!62+!;480/<!4/1:!3+6+96+3!4!2-880&>!:5!.-YY0&>!&:01+!0&103+!62+!2:-1+)!/:-3!
+&:->2!6:!30165+11!62+8!4&3!=0106:51@!!`0&4//<)!0&!"''j)!4;6+5!1,+&30&>!+=+5!8:5+!+76+&3+3!608+1!
4*4<!;5:8!62+05!&+*!2:8+!0&!:53+5!6:!5+9-,+546+)!62+!9:-,/+!/+;6!,+584&+&6/<!X&!
!
"abandoning the work of a lifetime. Our house is unsaleable, our old age 'pension'
worthless."
[Mair G. Italian Windfarm Diary, January 2007 to December 2007.
http://docs.wind-watch.org/mair-diary.pdf]&
!
d4&+!4&3!d-/04&![4=01!/0=+!46![++,0&>!P6!_092:/41)!P,4/30&>)!k0&9:/&1205+)!EQ@!!%&!"''W)!4!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!4554<!.+>4&!:,+5460&>)!*062!62+!&+45+16!6-5.0&+!T#'8!;5:8!6*:!2:8+1L!62+051!4&3!62+!
2:8+!:;!H5![4=01B!,45+&61@!!F1!43=:946+1!:;!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><)!62+![4=01!;480/<!303!&:6!:.I+96!6:!
62+!192+8+)!,45609-/45/<!41!62+!3+=+/:,+5!411-5+3!62+!9:88-&06<!6246!&:01+!*:-/3!&:6!.+!
,5:./+84609@!!A2+!5+4/06<!*41!G-06+!30;;+5+&6@!!A2+![4=01!;480/<!C+,6!4!5+9:53!:;!62+!2+4/62!
,5:./+81!1-;;+5+3!.+94-1+!:;!62+!&:01+!;5:8!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!H:16!10>&0;094&6/<)!62+!,5:./+81!
0&9/-3+3!1+=+5+!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!4&3!3016-5.4&9+)!.-6!4/1:!2+456!,4/,06460:&1!4&3!4552<628041)!
=+560>:)!3+,5+110:&)!&:6!6:!8+&60:&!9:&103+54./+!30165+11@!!Z[4=01!d@!i+51:&4/!e:88-&09460:&)!U#!
F,50/!"''Th!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!_:01+!H:&06:50&>!N54,2!*0620&!;0516!;/::5!.+35::8!?![4=01B1!
f:-1+!?!D0&3!`458!_:01+)!O!d-/<!"''()!0&L!F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+!
[+=+/:,8+&61@!!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!H4<!"''Th![4=01!d!4&3![4=01!d@!!N+&+54/!
P646+8+&6!:;!d4&+!^!d-/04&![4=01)!UW!F,50/!"''Th![4=01!d!4&3![4=01!d@!!k+66+5!6:!Hi!S+L![++,0&>!P6!
_092:/41!D0&3;458!&:01+!&-014&9+)!U(!H4<!"'U'c!!A2+05!;480/<!,2<10904&!5+9:53+3!62+1+!,5:./+81@!!!
!
g&!U(!d-/<!"''j)!4!p4/-460:&!A50.-&4/!5+3-9+3!62+!e:-&90/!A47!M4&30&>!:&!62+05!2:8+!4&3!62+!
2:8+!:;!H5![4=01B!,45+&61@!!A2+!I-3>8+&6!1646+3L!!!
!
“It was apparent from the evidence submitted that the construction of the wind
farm 930 meters away from the appeal dwellings had had significant detrimental
effect on the Appellants quiet enjoyment of their properties. The Tribunal therefore
found that the nuisance caused by the wind farm was real and not imagined."
[Valuation Tribunal Service. Council Tax Valuation List Appeal for The Farmhouse
at Greys Farm, North Drove Bank, Spalding, Lincolnshire PE11 3JX. Appeal
Number 2525475651/032C/20, 17 July 2008 www.valuation-tribunals.gov.uk]
!
%&!"''T)!0&!g&6450:)!e4&434)!62+!H(--;K$&H(;&09#$&/%%L!5+,:56+3!6246!4!5+605+3!,245849016)!e458+&!
Q5:>2)!+7,+50+&9+3!62+!:&1+6!:;!-&*+/9:8+!1<8,6:81!;://:*0&>!62+!9:880110:&0&>!:;!4!&+45.<!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<L!!!
!
!
"Her symptoms came on quickly. She experienced bad headaches, dizziness,
queasiness, a heart rhythm sensation and a vibration inside her body…”
[Woman Tells a Tale of Turbine Torment: Retired Pharmacist Speaks to Killaloe,
Hagarty and Richards about the Effects Industrial Wind Turbines had on her
Health. Barry’s Bay This Week, 11 February 2009]
U'!
"It was just like the whole room was spinning says Lisa Michaud of Thamesville,
Ontario, as she recalled the weeks after the Kent Breeze wind farm began
operating in May. The noise at night keeps you awake. But its not just the noise
that you hear. Its something else thats comining at you constantly that you don't
hear, but you feel. It's just not right."
[Seglins D and Nicol J. Wind Farm Health Risks Claimed in $1.5M Suit: Ontario
Family Sues Suncor, Alleging Health Problems. CBC News, 21 September 2011
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/story/2011/09/21/seglinswindfarms.html; see also Seglins D and Nicol J. Ontario Wind Farm Health Risks
Downplayed: Documents. CBC News, 22 September 2011
266,Laa***@9.9@94a&+*1a2+4/62a16:5<a"'UUa'Ta"Ua*0&3?6-5.0&+1@268/. See also
Appendix 3.1 of this paper.]!
&
%&!d4&-45<!"'U')!d4,4&K1!R&=05:&8+&6!H0&0165<!0&06046+3!4!16-3<!:;!2+4/62!9:8,/40&61!.<!;480/0+1!
/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1@!!F6!#'!:;!#(W!*0&3!6-5.0&+!106+1!0&!d4,4&)!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!&+45.<!;0/+3!
9:8,/40&61!4.:-6!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,5:./+81!4&3!62+!9:&1+G-+&6!2+4/62!011-+1L!0&1:8&04)!
2+43492+1)!30YY0&+11)!4&3!60&&06-1!X!4!.-YY0&>)!50&>0&>)!4&3a:5!2-880&>!0&!62+!+451@!!D062!+492!:;!
62+1+!#'!106+1)!1+=+54/!4&3!41!84&<!41!W'!5+103+&61!/0=0&>!&+45!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!5+,:56+3!
2+4/62!,5:./+81@!!Z%6:!F!4&3!A4C+34!A@!!P09C&+11!e/4081!i5:8,6!P6-3<!:;!D0&3!A-5.0&+1@!!A2+!F1420!
P208.-&)!UT!d4&-45<!"'U'!http://www.asahi.com/english/Herald-asahi/TKY201001180410.htmlc!
!
%&!H4592!"'U')!62+!/(44&D*-%%*&M"1-+(4!5+,:56+3!:&!62+!+7,+50+&9+!:;!e245/0+!i:56+5!4&3!201!;480/<!
4;6+5!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<!16456+3!:,+5460&>!*0620&!OO'8!:;!62+05!2:8+L!
!
“In 2007, a phalanx of wind turbines were built around Charlie Porter’s property in
rural northern Missouri. Soon Mr Porter began to have trouble sleeping. So did his
wife and daughter. The noise, he told me, made sleeping almost impossible. ‘We
tried everything – earplugs, leaving the TV station on all night.’ Nothing worked.
Late last year he moved his family off their 20 acre farm... ‘I’ve spoken to nine
people in New York, Wisconsin, Ontario, New Zealand, Nova Scotia and England
who live or lived near wind turbines. All complained of the noise with sleep
deprivation being the most common complaint...’ ”
[Bryce R. The Brewing Tempest over Wind Power: People Living near Turbines
Increasingly Report Sleep Deprivation, Headaches and Vertigo. The Wind Lobby
says There’s No Proof. The Wall Street Journal, 1 March 2010]
!
%&!H4592!"'U')!62+!E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9!ZEQc!5+,:56+3!6246L!
!
“Barry Moon and Gill Haythornthwaite’s home is in the Cumbria fells on the
outskirts of the village of Askam in Furness... The seven turbines have sparked
the most complaints about wind farms in the country. Residents complain of a
noise like someone is ‘mixing cement in the sky’ or a ‘clay stuck in the tumble
dryer’, and they are not the only ones... New figures reveal that at least one in six
wind farms have had complaints about noise causing a lack of sleep or just
‘dreadfully irritating’." Ms Haythornthwaite concurred: ‘It is a dreadfully irritating
whoosh whoosh noise... It is unbearable to be outside in the garden when there is
the noise.’ ”
[Gray L. Noise Complaints about One in Six Wind Farms. Daily Telegraph, 6 March 2010]
!
F1!5+,:56+3!0&!62+!51-"+&E(#4;&0-#21+%!0&!H4<!"'U')!1076++&!f-5:&!5+103+&61!;0/+3!4!/4*1-06!6246!
3+640/+3!1+=+54/!&:01+!,5:./+81!*062!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<!0&!,5:70806<!6:!62+05!2:8+1)!0&9/-30&>!
/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!4&3!0&;541:-&3)!*2092!62:->2!0&4-30./+)!94&!654=+/!/:&>!30164&9+1!;5:8!62+!
1:-59+)!4&3!+=+&!,+&+6546+!.-0/30&>1L!
!
“Intrusions detailed in the lawsuit include: LFN and subaudible infrasound and/or
impulse noise created by and emitted from the wind turbines which range as close
as 1,000ft (333 meters) and 1,700 feet (515 meters), away from each plaintiff’s
home.”&&!
!
!
A2+!,/40&60;;1!+7,+50+&9+3&N(8*1(4&>9;$#8(4&)#$8".,"-*$N&:;!62+!C0&3!6246!*:-/3!94-1+!,2<1094/!
3019:8;:56!6:!4&!B:530&45<B!,+51:&@&&&
&
UU!
"Physical harm and negative health effects listed in the law suit included: inability
to sleep, and repeated awakening during sleep, headaches, dizziness, stress and
tension, extreme fatigue, diminished ability to concentrate, nausea, and other
physiological and cognitive effects.”
!
A2+!/4*1-06!&:6+1!6246!46!/+416!:&+!;480/<)!62+!i+,/0&1C01)!+7,+50+&9+3!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!1:!
1+=+5+!6246!62+<!/+;6!62+05!2:8+!4&3!5+&6+3!4&!4,4568+&6!4*4<!;5:8!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@&&Zf+11/0&>!
Q@!!S+103+&61!P-+!D0&3!e:8,4&0+1@!!f-5:&![40/<!A50.-&+!\H0920>4&)!EPF])!"T!H4<!"'U'h!D_RH!
ApO!\H0920>4&]!%&=+160>46+1L!i:110./+!e:&;/096!:;!%&6+5+16h!k4*1-06!4>40&16!D0&3!R&+5><!e:1L!A201!
H4&K1!`480/<!e4&K6!P/++,)!"T!H4<!"'U'c!
!
%&!d-/<!"'U')!H5!4&3!H51![+4&!5+9+0=+3!4!!"#$%&3.>(8*&:$$%$$.%+*&'%>"-*!;5:8!_:01+!
H+41-5+8+&6!P+5=09+1!i6<!k63)!M501.4&+)!3+640/0&>!62+!&:01+!08,496!:;!62+!D4-.54!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
4554<!&+45!62+05!2:8+!4&3!;458@!!A2+!9:&1-/64&6B1!5+,:56!1646+3L!
!
“Wind Farm activity appears to create a pulsating infrasound and low frequency
pattern. These patterns are illustrated in sonograms... My hypothesis at this
stage is that wind farm sound has an adverse effect on individuals due to this
pulsating nature, as well as audible noise due to the wind turbine. These effects
may be cumulative.”
!
A2+!5+,:56!&:6+1!6246!62+!+;;+961!0&9/-3+!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+)!4&70+6<)!165+11)!4&3!2+43492+1L!!
!
"I am of the opinion, based on my own research, that wind farm noise can and
does create unreasonable noise within residences and consequential adverse
effects in the sense of sleep disturbance, annoyance, and potential health effects
to residents living within 2km of large wind turbines set in a wind farm. These
risks are quantifiable and the effect is significantly more than minor.”
[Executive Summary p 6, and S.7, p 64]
!
H:5+:=+5)!62+!9:&1-/64&6K1!5+,:56!:.1+5=+3!1080/45!9:&1+G-+&9+1!46!6*:!:62+5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
4554<1)!46!H4&4*46-!4&3!H4C454)!&:60&>!6246L!!!
!
"... wind farm sound can be heard within residences situated within 3.5km of large
turbines.”
[Thorne B. _:01+!%8,496!F11+118+&6!S+,:56L!D4-.54!D0&3!`458@!!S+,:56!_:!UO#(@!!
Noise Measurement Services Pty Ltd, South Brisbane, Australia, July 2010; see
also Stateline Victoria. Claims of Wind Farm Illness, 19 February 2010 (available
online only through 20 May 2010); White L. Wind Farms Can Cause Significant
Health Problems. Weekly Times Now, 24 December 2009
http://www.weeklytimesnow.com.au/article/2009/12/24/144511_nationalnews.html; Rolfe P. Turbines Declared Nasty Neighbour as Secret Buyout is
Revealed. Sunday Herald Sun, 30 January 2011
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/victoria/turbines-declared-a-nastyneighbour/story-e6frf7kx-1225996775637; Waubra Resident Tells Court of Wind
Farm “Hell”. The Courier (Australia), 18 January 2011
http://www.thecourier.com.au/news/local/news/general/waubra-resident-tellscourt-of-wind-farm-hell/2049825.aspx]
!
F!A:550&>6:&)![+=:&)!EQ)!9:-,/+!45+!1+//0&>!62+05!2:8+!4&3!.-10&+11!;://:*0&>!62+!9:&165-960:&!:;!
625++!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!4!;0+/3!:,,:106+!62+05!.-&>4/:*L!!!
!
“Pat and Arthur Poulton say they are being kept awake at night by the noise from
a trio of giant turbines less than 500 metres from their home at Higher Darracott...
‘I can hear the turbines through my pillow at night said Mrs Poulton’.”
[Keeble A. Our Sleepless Nights with the Wind Turbines. North Devon Gazette, 8
June 2011] \_:6+L!A2+!192+8+!*41!5+;-1+3!9:&1+&6!.<!62+!/:94/!e:-&90/!.-6!4,,5:=+3!
!
:&!4,,+4/!.<!4&!%&1,+96:5)!+=+&!62:->2!62+!g;;0904/!*41!43=01+3!3-50&>!62+!i-./09!
%&G-05<!6246!62+!&:01+!0&65-10:&!*41!/0C+/<!6:!+&>4>+!4!f-84&!S0>261!=0:/460:&@]!
!
!!
F99:530&>!6:!F//+&!f441!:;!H4/:&+)!D019:&10&L!!!
!
U"!
“I have 3 wind turbines on my property and get $4,000 for each one. It’s been 2
years... People are not really mad directly at the wind turbines or even know what
they are mad about, they’re just mad, aggressive. [The nearest wind turbine is]
"3,000 feet away - way too close. You don’t get sleep at night because they roar
like an airport. I get shadow flicker in my house, but down in the village of
Johnsburg where those are about another 1,500 feet away from the turbines – oh
probably 4,500 feet total, those blades are throwing shadows right over all the
house roofs.”
“I go to my doctor and now I’m on a lot of different medications. I’ve been to the
hospital a couple of times in the past 2 years with chest pains. And they can’t
figure out what it is but now we're all being diagnosed with wind turbine
syndrome... It definitely causes depression. Memory loss is the worse issue. I
see it so bad in myself and especially my parents who are older... My dad is a
totally different person since these things went up. He stays in bed all day now.
Even if he does get up to eat, he just goes back to bed. There is no will anymore.
I ask the doctor – how are they doing this to us?”
[Haas A. To the PSC Commissioners. Malone, Wisconsin. August 2010
http://psc.wi.gov//apps35/erf_search/content/homesearch.aspx?part1=1&part2=A
C&part3=231&type=Comments and http://www.wind-watch.org/documents/tothe-psc-commissioners/]
!
A2+1+!+748,/+1!5+,5+1+&6!:&/<!4!184//!&-8.+5!:;!62+!/45>+!X!4&3!>5:*0&>!X!&-8.+5!:;!;480/0+1!
1-;;+50&>)!*:5/3*03+)!*2+5+=+5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!0&!,5:70806<!6:!;480/<!2:8+1@!!F1!
8+&60:&+3!+45/0+5)!.-6!*:562<!:;!5+,+6060:&!.+94-1+!:;!62+!1+=+506<!:;!62+!+;;+96!4&3!62+!08,-&06<!
*062!*2092!06!01!4//:*+3)!62+!,2<1094/!2458!4&3!&+>460=+!2+4/62!+;;+961!0&9/-3+!,5+=+&60&>!4!,+51:&!
;5:8!;4//0&>!41/++,)!5+,+46+3!4*4C+&0&>1!3-50&>!1/++,)!30;;09-/6<!5+6-5&0&>!6:!1/++,)!2+43492+1)!
30YY0&+11)!165+11!4&3!6+&10:&)!+765+8+!;460>-+)!3080&012+3!4.0/06<!6:!9:&9+&6546+)!4&3!:62+5!
,2<10:/:>094/!4&3!9:>&060=+!+;;+961@!
!
F6!62+!UW!F->-16!"'U'!8++60&>!:;!62+!f-5:&?Q0&/:11!A:*&120,!e:-&90/)![5!f4Y+/!k<&&)!62+!N5+<?
M5-9+!H+3094/!g;;09+5!:;!f+4/62!0&!g&6450:)!e4&434)!1403!06!01!*5:&>!6246!8-&090,4/!9:-&90/1!3:!&:6!
24=+!4&<!I-50130960:&!:=+5!1+6.49C1!.+94-1+L!
!
"...within buildings, Low Frequency Noise (LFN) which comes from wind turbines,
could cause health effects, such as inner–ear problems. She said those effects
would be less if the setbacks were longer than the provincial setback of 550
meters. She added that symptoms are the same around the world but the
problem is that not much is known about wind turbines.” !!!
!
[5!k<&&!4/1:!&:6+3!6246!I-16!.+94-1+!,+:,/+!>+&+54//<!94&&:6!2+45!k`_)!6201!3:+1!&:6!8+4&!6246!06!
241!&:!+;;+96@!![5!k<&&!5+9:88+&3+3!4!80&08-8!1+6.49C!:;!46!/+416!UC8!6:!U@OC8@!!ZifR'"c!!F1C+3!
6:!9/450;<!6201!1646+8+&6)![5!k<&&!1403L!!!
!
"... we should have longer setbacks, and if you can't have longer setbacks, well,
then maybe we shouldn't be having them [more wind turbine developments] right
now."
[Bender S. Medical Officer of Health Believes Wind Turbine Setbacks should be
Longer. Lucknow Sentinel 25 August 2010 www.lucknowsentinel.com]
!
%&!4!/+66+5!346+3!H4592!"'UU)![5!F/4&!e!D4661)!_+*!P:-62!D4/+1)!F-1654/04!*5:6+)!!!
!
"Experience around the world, including Canada, USA and Europe, is raising
questions that have yet to be fully answered and some countries are now
sufficiently concerned to cease wind turbine construction in closely populated
areas.
Claims are being made that infrasound frequencies created by turbines are
producing a suite of symptoms in people living in close proximity to wind turbines.
These include but are not limited to headaches, insomnia, feelings of confusion,
middle ear problems, nausea, tinnitus, tachycardia and panic attacks. The results
!
of these small but indicative studies and surveys are sufficient to raise serious
doubt about the continuation of turbine construction using current standards.
Although it may be argued that these symptoms can be found in populations not
subject to the effects of wind turbines, there is enough evidence to mandate
formal research."
[Watts, AC. Wind Turbines may represent a Health Hazard to Our Residents
(letter). Blayney Chronicle (NSW, Australia), 21 March 2011]
U#!
!
k:94/!,2<10904&1!4&3!2+4/62!:;;09+51!45+!:.1+5=0&>!46!62+!>5411!5::61!/+=+/!62+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!:&!62+!2+4/62!:;!62:1+!;:5!*2:8!62+<!45+!5+1,:&10./+@!!J+6)!801>-03+3!:5!,::5/<!
+&;:59+3!,:/090+1!4&3!9:&3060:&1!;40/!6:!,5:6+96!62:1+!,+:,/+!*2:!45+!=-/&+54./+!6:!+&=05:&8+&64/!
&:01+!,://-60:&)!625:->2!&:!;4-/6!:;!62+05!:*&@!
&
%&!:53+5!6:!411+11!62+!+76+&6!:;!5+,:56+3!,5:./+81!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!0&!g&6450:)!0&!"''T)!4&!
0&3+,+&3+&6!>5:-,!3+=01+3!4&3!9:&3-96+3!62+!1+/;?;-&3+3!D0&3pg0e+!1-5=+<)!*2092!;://:*+3!62+!
,50&90,/+1!:;!f+4/62!e4&434K1!C(+()(&O#@#4(+8%&J-"@-(.$!;:5!,5+1950,60:&!4&3!9:&1-8+5!,5:3-961)!
=4990&+1)!4&3!:62+5!,5:3-961@!!S+1-/61!*+5+!5+,:56+3!:&!62+!P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+!ZPDpc!
*+.106+)!4&!0&6+5&460:&4/!:5>4&01460:&!9:8,501+3!:;!2+4/62!,5:;+110:&4/1!4&3!49:-160904&1!*2:!
1245+!9:&9+5&!4.:-6!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!g;!62+!U'T!5+1,:&3+&61!6:!
62+!D0&3pg0e+!1-5=+<)!U'"!5+,:56+3!4/6+5+3!2+4/62!4&3a:5!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+@!!%&!6:64/)!("m!:;!
,456090,4&61!5+,:56+3!0&95+41+3!1<8,6:81!:;!4&70+6<)!165+11)!:5!3+,5+110:&!10&9+!62+!16456!:;!62+05!
/:94/!*0&3!,5:I+96)!*062!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+)!+79+110=+!605+3&+11)!4&3!2+43492+1!62+!8:16!9:88:&!
9:8,/40&61)!.-6!:62+5!1<8,6:81!0&9/-3+!0&&+5!+45!,5:./+81)!94530:=419-/45!9:8,/40&61!1-92!41!
4552<628041!4&3!,4/,06460:&1)!49-6+!2<,+56+&10:&)!2+43492+1)!4&3!9:>&060=+!4&3!8::3!
3016-5.4&9+1@!!Q5:>2!%*&(4!24=+!4/1:!5+,:56+3!62+05!5+1-/61!0&!62+!,++5?5+=0+*+3!I:-5&4/)!H144%*#+&",&
D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&?&D"8#%*;@!
ZQ5:>2!eHR)!N0//01!k)!Q:-*+&!_)!4&3!F5480&0!d@!!D0&3pg0e+)!4!P+/;?S+,:560&>!P-5=+<L!F3=+51+!
f+4/62!R;;+961)!%&3-16504/!D0&3!A-5.0&+1)!4&3!62+!_++3!;:5!p0>0/4&9+!H:&06:50&>@!!H144%*#+&",&
D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&?&D"8#%*;&"'UUh#UL##$?#$Oc!
!
p096081!5+,:56!3016-5.+3!/0=0&>!9:&3060:&1!4&3!/:11!:;!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+!4&3!+&I:<8+&6!:;!62+05!2:8+1!
4&3!,5:,+56<)!41!*+//!41!;0&4&904/!/:11+1!.+94-1+!:;!62+!&+>460=+!08,496!6:!62+!2+4/62!:;!62+05!
;480/0+1@!!P:8+!/+4=+!62+05!2:8+1!;:5!5+1,06+)!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!62+05!2+4/62!4&3!*+//?.+0&>h!
6<,094/!5+1,:&1+1!0&9/-3+3L!!
!
“Not only we get flickering from the towers we cannot open any windows due to
the constant noise of the blades... Biggest factor is the noise... Had to move out
of my home, just come home now to feed the cattle... Our home can’t be sold due
to the problem per real estate agent... Family events can’t take place at home...
Financial problems due to keeping two homes.”
[Krogh C; Gillis L; and Kouwen N. A Self-Reporting Survey: Adverse Health
Effects with Industrial Wind Turbines and the Need for Vigilance. WindVOiCe Wind
Vigilance for Ontario Communities, Ontario, Canada, July 2010; see also Wind
Concerns Ontario. A Self-Reporting Survey: Adverse Health Effects with Industrial
Wind Turbines and the Need for Vigilance: Abstract and Participant Comments.
Wind Concerns Ontario Community-based Health Survey, July 2009 – presented on
April 22 2009 by Dr Robert McMurtry to the Ontario Government’s Standing
Committee re: Bill 150, the Green Energy Act]
!
%&!"''T)!62+!F8+5094&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!4&3!62+!e4&4304&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!
\Fae4&DRF]!011-+3!061!5+,:56)!/#+)&01-2#+%&D"1+)&(+)&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$I&(+&7P>%-*&J(+%4&'%F#%B@!!A2+!
Fae4&DRF!i4&+/!S+=0+*!49C&:*/+3>+1!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!84<!94-1+!4&&:<4&9+)!165+11)!4&3!
1/++,!3016-5.4&9+)!4&3!6246!,+:,/+!84<!+7,+50+&9+!43=+51+!,2<10:/:>094/!4&3!,1<92:/:>094/!
1<8,6:81@!!A2+!,4&+/!62+&!9:&9/-3+1!6246!62+5+!45+!&:!1+50:-1!2+4/62!+;;+961!;:5!62:1+!/0=0&>!*062!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!+=+&!62:->2!62+!43=+51+!9:&3060:&1!*0//!,+51016!;:5!46!/+416!"'!6:!"O!<+451)!62+!
,5+3096+3!V/0;+K!:;!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+@!
!
A2+!PDp!4&4/<1+3!4&3!5+1,:&3+3!6:!62+!Fae4&DRF!5+,:56)!9:&9/-30&>!6246L!!
!
"The conclusions of the A/CanWEA Panel Review are not supported by its own
contents nor does it have convergent validity with relevant literature. It then
ignores the serious consequences. The World Health Organization identifies
annoyance and sleep disturbance as adverse health effects.1
!
In 2009, the World Health Organization released a peer-reviewed summary of
research regarding the risks to human health from noise induced sleep
disturbance. Some of the adverse health effects documented include fatigue,
memory difficulties, concentration problems, mood disorders, cardiovascular,
respiratory, renal, gastrointestinal, musculoskeletal disorders, impaired immune
system function and a reported increased risk of mortality to name a few.2
U$!
Health Canada acknowledges the health consequences of stress and considers it a
to be a risk factor in a great many diseases, such as heart disease, some types of
bowel disease, herpes, mental illness and difficulty for diabetics to control blood
sugar. It states severe stress can cause biochemical changes in the body,
affecting the immune system, which leaves the body vulnerable to disease.3
Despite the acknowledgement that wind turbine noise may cause annoyance,
stress and sleep disturbance the A/CanWEA Panel Review fails to offer any science
based guidelines that would mitigate these health risks.
On the contrary, the A/CanWEA Panel Review concludes by suggesting that the
authoritative health based noise guidelines of the World Health Organization
should be ignored and that wind turbine noise limits be based on public policy.4
The A/CanWEA Panel Review concludes by stating that it does not “advocate for
funding further studies.” 5
Others do not agree.
In November 2009, the Japanese Ministry of Environment announced a four-year
study into the effects of wind farms on health.6
In September 2009 members of the Maine Medical Association passed a resolution
which among other things calls for independent study and authoritative
guidelines.7
Preliminary findings of a controlled study (Mars Hill, Maine) conducted by Dr.
Michael Nissenbaum to investigate potential negative health effects concludes that
adults living within 1100 meters of industrial wind turbines suffer high incidences
of chronic sleep disturbances and headaches, among other somatic complaints,
and high incidences of dysphoric psychiatric symptomology, compared to a control
group living 5000-6000 meters away. This controlled study is a work in progress.8
The A/CanWEA Panel Review can only be viewed for what it is. It is an industry
association convened and sponsored attempt to deny the adverse health effects
being reported.
1 World Health Organization, Guidelines for Community Noise, 1999
http://www.euro.who.int/mediacentre/PR/2009/20091008_1
2 Night Noise Guidelines for Europe, World Health Organization (2009)
www.euro.who.int/document/e92845.pdf
3 Health Canada http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hl-vs/iyh-vsv/life-vie/stress-eng.php
4 W. David Colby, M.D. et al., Wind Turbine Sound and Health Effects, An Expert Panel Review
2009,
Prepared for American Wind Energy Association and Canadian Wind Energy Association
5 W. David Colby, M.D. et al., Wind Turbine Sound and Health Effects, An Expert Panel Review
2009,
Prepared for American Wind Energy Association and Canadian Wind Energy Association
6 http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/dy/national/20091129TDY02309.htm
7 Maine Medical Association Resolution re Wind Energy and Public Health September 2009
8 http://windvigilance.com/mars_hill.aspx”
[Society for Wind Vigilance. Wind Energy Industry Acknowledgement of Adverse Health Effects:
Part 1 Conclusion and Executive Summary of an Analysis of the American/Canadian Wind Energy
Association sponsored “Wind Turbine Sound and Health Effects”. Society for Wind Vigilance,
Ontario, CA: January 2010 http://www.windvigilance.com/news/analysis-of-a-canwea-panelreview. See also Society for Wind Vigilance. Wind Energy Industry Acknowledgement of Adverse
Health Effects: Part 2 Detailed Analysis of an Analysis of the American/Canadian Wind Energy
Association sponsored “Wind Turbine Sound and Health Effects”. Society for Wind Vigilance,
January 2010]
UO!
!
!
A2+1+!5+,:561!4&3!16-3<!5+1-/61!45+!5+,/0946+3!+/1+*2+5+@!!%&!4!"'U'!/+96-5+)!_0&4!i0+5,:&6)!H[)!
i2[)!5+,:56+3!:&!62+!;0&30&>1!:;!2+5!16-3<!:&!62+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!:&!2+4/62)!0&9/-30&>!
6201!;0&30&>!:&!/+45&0&>!4&3!9:>&060:&!0&!920/35+&L!!
!
“In my wind turbine study, 7 out of 10 school-age children and teens did worse in
school during exposure to turbines, compared to before or after, including
unexpected problems in reading, math, concentration, and test performance,
noticed by both teachers and parents. Teachers sent notes home asking what was
wrong with the children”.
[Pierpont N, MD, PhD. Wind Turbine Syndrome and the Brain. First International
Symposium on the Global Wind Industry and Adverse Health Effects: Loss of Social
Justice? Picton, Ontario, Canada, 30 October 2010, p5]
!
F!5+,:56!011-+3!.<!62+!EQ!_:01+!F11:90460:&!\EQ_F]!9:&9/-3+3!6246L!!“noise generated by wind
turbines can cause significant health problems, including stress, anxiety and depression.”
Z`06Y,46509C!Q@!!V_:01+!;5:8!D0&3;458!01!F;;+960&>!H<!f+4/62@!!H4&92+16+5!R=+&0&>!_+*1)!""!
d4&-45<!"'UUc
!
P:8+!I:-5&4/0161!4&3!4&!0&95+410&>!&-8.+5!:;!Hi1!24=+!:.1+5=+3!62+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!
:&!62:1+!0&!62+05!9:88-&060+1!4&3!9:&1606-+&90+1@!!F1!4!5+1-/6)!62+5+!241!.++&!8:5+!&+*1!9:=+54>+!
4.:-6!62:1+!-&6:*453!+;;+961@!!J+6)!:&+!:;!62+!8:5+!30165+110&>!45609/+1)!,-./012+3!0&!09%&D1+)(;&
0#.%$!ZEQc)!5+=+4/+3!6246L!!!
!
“Civil servants have suppressed warnings that wind turbines can generate noise
damaging people’s health for several square miles around. The guidance from
consultants indicated that the sound level permitted from spinning blades and
gearboxes had been set so high -- 43 decibels -- that local people could be
disturbed whenever the wind blew hard. The noise was also thought likely to
disrupt sleep."
[Leake J and Byford H. Officials Cover up Wind Farm Noise Report. The Sunday
Times (UK) 13 December 2009; see also k+1/0+!Q@!!Q+*(-#"&G+(24%&*"&0%44&#,&/#+)&
=(-.$&7P8%%)&!"#$%&R#.#*$I&:8*#F#$*$&D(;A!!A2+!N/:.+!4&3!H40/!\A:5:&6:)!e4&434])!UOaUW!
d-&+!"'UU@]!
!
e0=0/!1+5=4&61!??!,-./09!+8,/:<++1!0&!62+!,-./09B1!1+5=09+!??!1-,,5+11+3!9506094/!0&;:58460:&)!&++3+3!
.<!3+9010:&!4&3!,:/09<!84C+51)!6246!,:1+3!4!305+96!924//+&>+!4&3!625+46!6:!62+!9:&9+,6!:;!4!q;405!
3+8:954609!1:90+6<q@!!Zk+4C+!d!4&3!M<;:53!f@!!g;;0904/1!e:=+5!-,!D0&3!`458!_:01+!S+,:56@!!09%&
D1+)(;&0#.%$!\EQ]!U#![+9+8.+5!"''Tc!
!
F8:&>!62:1+!Hi1!*2:!45+!4/458+3!.<!62+05!:.1+5=460:&1!:;!62+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!!
e2501!f+46:&Xf45501!\e:&1+5=460=+)![4=+&65<])!0&!62+!f:-1+!:;!e:88:&1)!41C+3!62+!P+95+645<!:;!
P646+!;:5!R&+5><L!!
“If he will review the implementation of recommendations made to the
Government by the Hayes McKenzie Partnership in respect of wind turbine noise
nuisance and aerodynamic modulation, with a view to reducing permitted noise
levels.”
!
N5+>:5<!M45C+5!\M+720//!4&3!M466/+)!e:&1+5=460=+])!H0&016+5!:;!P646+!\e/0846+!e24&>+])!5+,/0+3L!
“The work being carried out by Hayes McKenzie Partnership is a review of how
current noise guidance is implemented in consideration of planning decisions, and
is not concerned with the guidance itself or issues such as permitted noise limits.
Hayes McKenzie are now working up their draft report which will then be
independently peer reviewed... publication.”
[House of Commons Debate: Wind Power: Noise. Hansard, 18 October 2010,
c482w] (See also: Heaton-Harris C. Onshore Wind Turbines (Proximity of
Habitation). House of Commons Debates, HC Deb 17 November 2010, c900.
(Second reading rescheduled for 20 January 2012.)
http://services.parliament.uk/bills/201011/onshorewindturbinesproximityofhabitation.html]
!
UW!
!
A201!01!9:/3!9:8;:56)!.+94-1+!62+!f4<+1!H9Q+&Y0+!i456&+5120,!,456090,46+3!0&!,5+,450&>!4&3!
*5060&>!RAPE?S?T()!4&3!5+,5+1+&61!*0&3!+&+5><!9/0+&61!3-50&>!62+!,5:9+11!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
4,,/09460:&1!4&3!4,,+4/1@!
!
F1!09%&D1+)(;&0#.%$!5+=+4/+3)!90=0/!1+5=4&61!1-,,5+11+3!62+!&46-5+!4&3!+76+&6!:;!,5:./+81!*062!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!%&!:53+5!6:!5+.-0/3!,-./09!95+30.0/06<)!62+!>:=+5&8+&6!12:-/3!24=+!1:->26!
*03+5!9:&1-/6460:&)!0&3+,+&3+&6!:;!62+!*0&3!0&3-165<)!4&3!12:-/3!24=+!+7+5901+3!8:5+!945+!*2+&!
4*4530&>!4!9:&1-/6460:&!5+>4530&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!D20/+!:&+!84<!49C&:*/+3>+!6246!62+!
4,,:0&6+3!;0581!45+!94,4./+!:;!-&3+564C0&>!6201!*:5C)!41!4!108,/+!+7+5901+!:;!,5-3+&9+!6:!+&1-5+!4!
1+9:&3!4&3!08,45604/!411+118+&6)!9+5640&/<!62+!>:=+5&8+&6!4>+&9<!5+1,:&10./+!12:-/3!1++C!4&!
49:-1609!+&>0&++50&>!4&4/<101!;5:8!4!;058!*062:-6!305+96!60+1!6:!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<@!!M+94-1+!
:;!6201!:=+510>26)!62+!EQ!,-./09!4&3!i45/048+&6!94&&:6!24=+!9:&;03+&9+!0&!62+!08,45604/06<!:;!62+!
5+,:561!011-+3!.<!62+!3+,4568+&6!5+1,:&10./+!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!>-034&9+@!
!
%&!F,50/!"'U')!i/403!e<85-!94//+3!:&!e4584562+&1205+!e:-&6<!e:-&90/!\D4/+1)!EQ]!6:!;:584//<!
43:,6!4!"C8!.-;;+5!Y:&+!,:/09<!;:5!/45>+?194/+!9:88+5904/!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,8+&61)!95+460&>!4!
.-;;+5!:;!"C8!\U@O!80/+1]!.+6*++&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!4&3!2:8+1)!-&/+11!5+103+&61!9:&1+&6+3!
:62+5*01+@!!i/403K1!D+1680&16+5!94&30346+!d:&4624&!R3*4531)!Hi!\e4584562+&!R416!4&3![0&+;*5])!
1403L!
!
“Having spoken to people that have come under a lot of strain as a result of wind
farm developments being situated very near to their homes I am left with little
doubt that some protection must be offered. I am supportive of wind energy, as
part of a holistic approach to tackling climate change, but I do believe that for the
green agenda to work we need to take people with us. Any developments should
fully take into account the impact they will have on the lives and individuals and
communities in which they are built. I hope Council recognise that and take this
proposal under serious consideration.”
[Edwards J. Plaid Call for 2km Wind Farm Buffer Zone. 9 April 2010
266,Laa***@I:&4624&+3*4531@:5>@-Ca,/403?94//?;:5?"C8?*0&3?;458?.-;;+5?Y:&+]
&
%&!62+!f:-1+!:;!e:88:&1!:&!"(!d-/<!"'U')!H5!R3*4531)!Hi)!41C+3!62+!P+95+645<!:;!P646+!;:5!
e/0846+!e24&>+!!“... whether he plans to revise the noise assessment guidance for wind
turbines (ETSUR97) (c893w).
%&!5+1,:&1+)!N5+>:5<!M45C+5)!Hi)!1403!6246L!
!
“Noise is a key issue to be taken into account in considering proposals for wind
farm development. There is no reason to believe that the protection from noise
provided for by ETSUR97 guidance does not remain acceptable, and we have no
plans to change this...”
[Hansard. Edwards J and Barker G. Wind Power. 27 July 2010, c893W]
!
%&!F->-16!"'U')!62+!U$62!k:53!S+4<)!f->2!D0//048!H49C4<)!4!;:58+5!H+8.+5!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!
i45/048+&6)!1+6!3:*&!4!M0//!0&!62+!f:-1+!:;!k:531!,5:,:10&>!4!80&08-8!30164&9+!.+6*++&!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!4&3!2:8+1!.41+3!:&!62+!2+0>26!:;!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+L!
!
“If the height of the wind turbine generator is
a) greater than 25m, but does not exceed 50m, the minimum distance
requirement is 1,000m
b) greater than 50m, but does not exceed 100m, the minimum distance
requirement is 1,500m
c) greater than 100m, but does not exceed 150m, the minimum distance
requirement is 2,000m
d) greater than 150m, the minimum distance requirement is 3,000m.
The height of the wind turbine generator is measured from the ground to the end
of the blade tip at its highest point.”!!!
!
f:*+=+5)!4!5+3-9+3!30164&9+!*:-/3!.+!4//:*+3!*062!62+!+7,5+11!4>5++8+&6!:;!+=+5<!;480/<!
2:8+:*&+5!*0620&!62+!5+165096+3!Y:&+@!!Zk:53!i5:,:1+1!e:&65:=+5104/!"C8!S+103+&604/![0164&9+!
S-/0&>!:&!D0&3!`4581@!!/%$*%-+&<"-+#+@&!%B$)!T!F->-16!"'U'c!!
!
U(!
!
%&!_:=!"'U')!e2501!f+46:&Xf45501)!Hi)!1:->26!6:!.50&>!4!1080/45!M0//!6:!62+!f:-1+!:;!e:88:&1)!
>0=0&>!/:94/!,+:,/+!4&3!9:88-&060+1!8:5+!9:&65:/!:=+5!3+=+/:,8+&6!,5:,:14/1!0&!62+05!45+4)!1-92!
41!*0&3!;4581!4&3!62+!50>26!;:5!/:94/!4-62:5060+1!6:!1+6!80&08-8!30164&9+1!;5:8!2:8+1@!!\f:*+=+5)!
k0.+54/![+8:9546!Hi!;:5!e2+/6+&248)!H4560&!f:5*::3)!:,,:1+3!6201!8:60:&@]!!Zf+46:&?f45501!e@!!
g&12:5+!D0&3!A-5.0&+1!\i5:70806<!:;!f4.06460:&]@!!f:-1+!:;!e:88:&1![+.46+1)!fe![+.!U(!
_:=+8.+5!"'U')!9T''@!!A201!.0//!*41!192+3-/+3!;:5!4!1+9:&3!5+430&>!3-50&>!"'UUh!4;6+5!
,:16,:&+8+&61)!06!01!&:*!+7,+96+3!6:!24=+!061!1+9:&3!5+430&>!3+.46+!:&!"'!d4&-45<!"'U"@c!
!
Q45+&!D206+;0+/3!\F05350+!^!P2:661)!P9:66012!k4.:-5]!1-.8066+3!4!*5066+&!G-+160:&!6:!62+!P9:66012!
i45/048+&6!:&!W![+9+8.+5!"'U'L&&
“To ask Scottish Executive what the legal set-back distances are for the
construction of wind farms from (a) individual properties & (b) settlements
(Question S3W-38080).
!!
%&!201!*5066+&!5+1,:&1+)!Q+062!M5:*&!1403L!
!
“There are no legal set-back distances. Scottish Planning Policy recommends
a 2km separation distance between areas of search for wind farms and
the edge of cities, towns, and villages. The Scottish Parliament Public
Petitions Committee has supported this position as a guide rather than a rule in
closing petition.”
[Scottish Parliament Written Answers, Question S3W-38080, 15 Dec 2010]
[Emphasis added.]
&
F&!45609/+!0&!09%&!"-*9%-+&0#.%$!\P9:6/4&3]!5+,:56+3!6246L!
!
“The local authority has forced Scottish and Southern Energy to shut down a
Sutherland wind farm after the company breached planning controls by failing to
deal with excessive noise from the development. People living close to the Achany
wind farm near Roehall are claiming their lives are being made a misery by the
constant noise, and are angry that their complaints are ignored.”
[McMorran C. Exasperated Planners Shut Wind Farm Down. The Northern Times,
9 June 2011]
!
A2+1+!;+*!+748,/+1!0//-16546+!62+!30;;09-/6<!6246!;480/0+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1!;49+!41!62+<!466+8,6!6:!
*5+16/+!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!:5!*062!+;;:561!6:!,5+=+&6!0&4,,5:,5046+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
3+=+/:,8+&6@!!F/62:->2!&:01+!,5:./+81!45+!+764&6!4&3!49C&:*/+3>+3)!4&3!62+!9-55+&6!>-034&9+!
:;;+51!/066/+!:5!&:!,5:6+960:&)!>:=+5&8+&6!01!9:&6+&6!6:!9:&60&-+!*062!62+!1646-1!G-:@!!F/62:->2!
1+=+54/!Hi1!4&3!i++51!24=+!:;;+5+3!5+4/01609!,:6+&604/!1:/-60:&1)!>:=+5&8+&6!241!&:6!12:*&!4&<!
0&6+5+16!0&!,-51-0&>!62+1+@!
!
g;6+&!;480/0+1!94&&:6!+194,+!6201!0&3-16504/!0&65-10:&!0&6:!62+05!/0=+1!.+94-1+!62+<!3:!&:6!24=+!62+!
;0&4&904/!5+1:-59+1!6:!1++C!5+1,06+!0&!4!B14;+B!2:-1+@!!P:8+!;480/0+1)!350=+&!6:!4.4&3:&!62+05!2:8+1)!
1++C!5+&6+3!:5!:62+5!499:88:3460:&!0;!62+05!;480/<!.-3>+6!4//:*1!X!4&3!1:8+608+1!+=+&!0;!06!3:+1!
&:6@!!\P++!4/1:!f+11/0&>!Q@!!S+103+&61!P-+!D0&3!e:8,4&0+1@!!51-"+&E(#4;&0-#21+%!H4<!"T)!"'U'!
266,Laa***@80920>4&162-8.@9:8a45609/+1a"'U'a'Oa"Ta&+*1a/:94/r&+*1a3:9$9'UU(;$j3U"9"O
(($jWjO@676@]!!g;6+&)!;480/0+1!1++C!62+!2+/,!:;!62+!3+=+/:,+5!:5!*0&3!;458!:,+546:5)!/:94/!
>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!:62+5!4>+&90+1)!0&!:53+5!6:!+&;:59+!&:01+!9:&3060:&1@!!S+>-/45/<)!6201!,5:=+1!;-60/+)!
0&43+G-46+)!608+?9:&1-80&>)!4&3!+7,+&10=+@!!A2+!,5:9+11!84<!64C+!<+451@!!%&!62+!EQ)!.+94-1+!62+!
N-034&9+!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!3:+1!&:6!,5:=03+!43+G-46+!,5:6+960:&)!62+!3+=+/:,+5!:5!:*&+5!
84<!496-4//<!8++6!62+!/08061!08,:1+3!.<!RAPE!:5!62+!,/4&&0&>!&:01+!9:&3060:&1@!!J+6)!&+0>2.:-50&>!
;480/0+1!1-;;+5!0&I-5<!6:!62+05!2+4/62)!9:8,5:801+3!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+)!4&3!/:11!:;!62+!48+&06<!:;!62+05!
2:8+1@!!A2-1)!&:6!+=+&!62+!,/4&&0&>!9:&3060:&1!,5:6+96!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45.<@!!A2:1+!;480/0+1!
1-;;+50&>!;5:8!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!84<!.+!9:&103+5+3!=096081!:;!
3+>5430&>!4&3!0&2-84&!65+468+&6)!4-62:501+3!.<!62+!P646+@!!
!
F99:530&>!6:![5!F06C+&!Z"'U'c!:;!62+!E&0=+5106<!:;!R30&.-5>2)!0&!62+!5+1+4592!,4,+5!/9;&/%&D*#44&
E"+S*&G+)%-$*(+)&*9%&D"8#(4&:$>%8*$&",&/#+)&J"B%-L!
!
"The literature on public attitudes to wind power is underpinned by key
assumptions which limit its scope and restrict the findings it can present.
!
Five key assumptions are that:
1. The majority of the public supports wind power.
2. Opposition to wind power is therefore deviant.
3. Opponents are ignorant or misinformed.
4. The reason for understanding opposition is to overcome it.
5. Trust is key."
!
F06C+&!9:&6+&31!6246!:,,:1060:&!6:!*0&3!,:*+5L!
!
"cannot be dismissed as ignorant or misinformed, instead it must be acknowledge
that objectors are often very knowledgeable. Public attitudes and responses to
wind power should not be examined in order to mitigate potential future
opposition, but rather in order to understand the social context of renewable
energy. Trust is identified as a key issue, however great trust must be placed in
members of the public and in their knowledge. In sum, the literature must
abandon the assumption that it knows who is 'right' and instead must engage with
the possibility that objectors to wind power are not always 'wrong'."
[Aitken M. Why We Still Don't Understand the Social Aspects of Wind Power: A
Critique of Key Assumptions within the Literature. Energy Policy 2010; 38: 18341841]
!
R//01!+6!4/!Z"''Tc!1080/45/<!:.1+5=+3!6246!4,,/09460:&1!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1L!
!
"often arouse controversy, particularly if proposals are poorly located. The
available evidence does not support the claim that planning causes undue delays in
relation to major wind energy schemes. Rather, planning should be seen as an
essential part of the democratic process -- which needs time if it is to work
effectively."
[Ellis G; Cowell R; Warren C; Strachan P; Szarka J; Hadwin R; Miner P; Wolsink M;
Nadal A. Wind Power: Is there a "Planning Problem"? Planning Theory & Practice
Dec 2009; 10(4): 521-547]
!
F/62:->2!,-./09!46606-3+1!6:!*0&3!;4581!24=+!.++&!16-30+3)!62+!5+1+4592!241!+8,24101+3!
!!
"understanding the 'problem' of objection, to the neglect of exploring the basis of
support. The ideological (i.e. unreflectively pro-wind) and epistemological (i.e.
unreflectively positivist) bias has led to poor explanatory findings, which in turn
has resulted in ineffective policy."
[Ellis G; Barry J; Robinson C. Many ways to say 'no', different ways to say 'yes':
Applying Q-Methodology to understand public acceptance of wind farm proposals.
Journal of Environmental Planning and Management July 2007; 50(4): 517-551]
!
R//01!+6!4/!Z"''(c!4/1:!&:6+!6246!62+!5+1+4592!0&6:!,-./09!46606-3+1!4&3!:.I+960:&1!6:!*0&3!;458!
3+=+/:,8+&61!20>2/0>261!
!
“the inadequacy of the NIMBY explanation of objection, which overlooks the
complexity of why people may object to a wind farm proposal...” This “fuels
conflict because of its derogatory implications and contributes to poor responses to
such disputes. There is a tendency to marginalise and denigrate oppositional
voices to schemes that are portrayed as being environmentally progressive, failing
to acknowledge that each individual's position is informed by personal and
collective values that are deeply held, aspirational and often well intentioned. This
suggests that even some of the more sophisticated explorations of objection to
wind farms may be conceptually flawed.” Indeed, the authors suggest, “the most
popularly deployed methodology, the opinion poll, has contributed to the impasse
in understanding public perception of wind farms...”
!
J+6)!+=+&!62+!,/4&&0&>!,5:9+11!1->>+161!6246!/4<!C&:*/+3>+!,/4<1!4!/0806+3!5:/+L!
!
"Local objectors were able to influence the early planning application stage.
However, this resulted in an appeals process (public inquiry), which was beyond
the influence of lay people, and within which lay knowledge played only a marginal
role... Witnesses who could not back up their evidence with 'reliable' data or
scientific reasoning were discredited as illegitimate and as having little to
contribute to the inquiry process. Thus the inquiry constructed boundaries
Uj!
!
between expert and lay knowledge, in ways which diminished the role that lay
knowledge might play.”
[Aitken M. Wind Power Planning Controversies and the Construction of 'Expert'
and 'Lay' Knowledges. Science as Culture March 2009; 18(1): 47-64]
UT!
!
F06C+&!Z"''Tc!5+;/+961!:&!:&+!,45609-/45!,/4&&0&>!4,,/09460:&)!:.1+5=0&>!6246L!!
!
“Much of the evidence put forward at the inquiry was generaliseable -- that is,
equally applicable to other potential wind farm sites around the UK. It did not
therefore reflect the particular issues relating to the single application of this case
study. Far less did it reflect the real concerns and worries of the local community
whose protest generated the public inquiry. While the local opponents may have
hoped that the inquiry would provide an impartial forum focussed on the issues
which were pressing for this particular community, they ended up as little more
than a passive audience for expert disagreements.”
!
A201!19+&450:!01!5+?+&496+3!625:->2:-6!62+!EQ!3-50&>!84&<!i-./09!%&G-050+1)!;-562+5!5+0&;:590&>!
62+!1+&1+!:;!301+&;54&9201+8+&6!.<!62+!9:88-&060+1!*2:!8-16!62+&!94,06-/46+!6:!,:/09<!3+9010:&1!
6246!&+>460=+/<!0&;/-+&9+!62+05!340/<!/0=+1@!!e+5640&/<!62+5+!01!4!3019:&&+96!.+6*++&!62+!+7,+50+&9+1!
4&3!=:09+1!:;!/:94/!>5:-,1!4&3!62+!+;;+960=+&+11!:;!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!0&3-16504/!*0&3!+&+5><!
164&34531!6:!,5:6+96!,+:,/+!;5:8!62+!-&6:*453!4&3!:;6+&!-&4&6090,46+3!&+>460=+!9:&1+G-+&9+1!:;!
0&3-16504/!3+=+/:,8+&6@!!
!
%&3++3)!F06C+&!Z"''Tc!1646+1!6246!62+!4,,+4/1!,5:9+11%“was beyond the influence of lay
people, and within which lay knowledge played only a marginal role... Lay voices
merely represented supplementary and even superfluous actors on a stage dominated by
specialist and highly experienced experts (and lawyers). Although the stage was nominally
local, the events being acted out were anything but.” [Emphasis added.]
!
e+5640&/<)!*062:-6!62+!0&,-6!:;!/:94/!,+:,/+!4&3!62+05!/:94/!C&:*/+3>+)!62+!,+:,/+!45+!
-&5+,5+1+&6+3!0&!62+!B3+8:954609B!3+9010:&?84C0&>!,5:9+11)!*2092!01!0&!62+!24&31!:;!:&+!0&1,+96:5@!!
J+6)!/:94/!9:88-&060+1!499+,6!4!8:3+/!6246!5+/0+1!:&!+7,+56!C&:*/+3>+!46!62+!+7,+&1+!:;!/:94/!
C&:*/+3>+@!!%5:&094//<)!+7,+56!C&:*/+3>+&“has secured a hegemonic position within technical
decision-making... its central role is therefore not questioned or challenged, even by those
who might suffer as a result.” [Aitken 2009]!
!
P60//)!F06C+&!:.1+5=+1!6246!,:/09<?!4&3!3+9010:&?84C+51!4&3!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!24=+!*:5C+3!
,508450/<!6:!03+&60;<!*4<1!0&!*2092!6:!1+9-5+!62+!,-./09B1!>5+46+5!499+,64&9+!:;!*0&3!,:*+5@!!
f:*+=+5)!41!/:&>!41!62+<!,5+1-8+L!
!
“that opposition is misinformed, ignorant, or deviant it can never fully understand
individual or community experiences with wind power. Moreover, by presuming
that that opposition needs to be avoided or overcome it fails to acknowledge the
potential value of objectors' points of view. Objectors are not necessarily ignorant,
but rather may be very well informed about wind power or local issues relating to
particular developments. As such, their views should not be overlooked and
participation should not be viewed as a means to overcome or mitigate opposition
but instead as valuable opportunities to incorporate multiple viewpoints and
knowledge resources. This would at times lead to the conclusion that particular
proposed developments are inappropriate or socially unacceptable...
This paper points to the irony of repeated calls for engendering greater trust within
planning processes when the literature appears so clearly wedded to a managerial
intention of overcoming opposition...”&&!
!
f:*+=+5)!,/4&&+51)!3+=+/:,+51)!4&3!9:88+&646:51!8-16!4/1:!,/49+!8:5+!65-16!0&!62+!,-./09L!!
!
!
“They should trust the public to have valid opinions and legitimate knowledge and
therefore should trust that open participation can produce positive outcomes
whether or not these are in favour of particular developments.” They “must
engage with the possibility that objectors to wind power are not always 'wrong'."
[Aitken 2010]
!
`-562+58:5+)!4&3!8:16!9506094//<)!62+1+!411-8,60:&1!24=+!;:-&3!62+05!*4<!“into policy and
practitioner debates as well as planning debates around particular proposed wind power
developments (as highlighted above in relation to NIMBYism).” [Aitken 2010]
"'!
!
A2-1)!62+!+7,+50+&9+1!5+/46+3!0&!6201!924,6+5!1+5=+!4&!08,:564&6!5:/+!41!4!94-60:&45<!64/+!;:5!:62+51!
*2:!45+!+8.5:0/+3!0&!+;;:561!6:!+&1-5+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,+51!3:!&:6!106+!6-5.0&+1!&+45!
2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1@!!A:>+62+5)!,:/09<)!62+!,/4&&0&>!,5:9+11)!4&3!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!
:;;+5!/066/+!0&!62+!*4<!:;!48+/0:5460&>!62+!0&43+G-46+!164&34531!:5!+=+&!,5:=030&>!&:01+!9:&3060:&1!
6246!45+!5+41:&4./+!4&3!+&;:59+4./+@!!R;;:561!&:*!.<!3+=+/:,+51!4&3!>:=+5&8+&6!6:!+&>4>+!,+:,/+!
4&3!62+05!9:88-&060+1!X!:;6+&!*062!;0&4&904/!:5!:62+5!0&9+&60=+1!:;;+5+3!6:!62+!9:88-&06<!X!45+!!
&:*!1++&!41!9<&094/!466+8,61!6:!+=43+!5+1,:&10./+!,/4&&0&>!6246!,5:6+961!;480/0+1!;5:8!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!4554<1!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!6:!2:8+1@!!
!
`480/0+1!*062!/0806+3!;0&4&904/!5+1:-59+1!45+!0&;:580&>!62+05!,-./09!:;;0904/1!4&3!3+9010:&!84C+51!
41!.+16!62+<!94&)!.<!1-.80660&>!+=03+&9+!0&!,4,+51!4&3!5+,:561!6246!3+1950.+!62+!1-;;+50&>!
+7,+50+&9+3!.<!;480/0+1!+/1+*2+5+@!!ZD+66+5+5!S@!P646+8+&6!i5+1+&6+3!6:!62+!P646+!:;!_+*!
f48,1205+!P06+!R=4/-460:&!e:88066++)!5+L![:9C+6!_:@!"'U'?'U)!_+*!f48,1205+)!EPF)!#U!F->-16!
"'U'c!!
!
"U!
!
Appendix 1
%
7*08,*9+%/*.,-3%4:8*("*#6*+2%
!
;$$"-"0#.,%<*5*(*#6*+%%
F/6+50!M@!
=0*+%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%;55*6-%?0'(%@,**8%0(%/*.,-3A%
/RHT&C9(++%4&U)!M4&>:5!H40&+)!EPF)!U$!H4<!"''T@!
266,Laa***@*/.Y"@9:8a&+*1a/:94/a16:5<@41,7s16:5<03tU'$(U(^94603t#!
!
N/+&![2-!i:*+5!X!D0&3!i5:I+96!\P2+45!D0&3!%&9@]@!
4#B"(0#1*#-.,%;++*++1*#-2%7(0:"1"-C%.#$%>0"+*D%
_:=4!P9:604)!e4&434)!`+.5-45<!"''jh!`+.5-45<!"''T@!
266,Laa***@>:=@&1@94a&1+a+4a>/+&@32-@*0&3@;458a>/+&@32-@*0&3@;458@F33+&3-8@P+960:&'"@i5:7
0806<@4&3@_:01+@,3;!
!
A:33!D@!
E"B"#F%G"-3%&'()"#*+%H%.%7*(+0#.,%;660'#-I%JK%L*)('.(C%MNNOD%
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a3:9-8+&61aUOUU#!
!
A:33!D@!
&*+-"10#C%-0%P."#*%E*F"+,.-'(*I%QN%;8(",%MNNRD%
266,Laa***@840&+@>:=a3+,a;6,a.+,a92#(O9060Y+&r,+6060:&a,5+?2+450&>aFS?
('m"'D+&3<m"'A:33m"'6+1608:&<@,3;!!:5!
266,Laa***@*0&3?*4692@:5>a3:9-8+&61a6+1608:&<?:;?*+&3<?6:33?6:?62+?840&+?/+>01/46-5+?
4,50/?#'?"''(a!!
!
!.')(.%<*+"$*#-%0#%MST30'(%U3*6VD%
A2+!e:-50+5!\F-1654/04])!!#U![+9+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@62+9:-50+5@9:8@4-a&+*1a/:94/a&+*1a>+&+54/a*4-.54?5+103+&6?:&?"$2:-5?
92+9Ca"'#(W'W@41,7!
!
D+.16+5!M@!
/*,"608-*(%>0"+*%U0'(-%U3.,,*#F*%50(%!"#$%L.(1+D%
09%&0#.%$!\EQ])!$!d-/<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+608+1@9:@-Ca66:a+&=05:&8+&6a45609/+#'j"j'T@+9+!
!
C h a p t e r 2 %%
%
""!
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%.#$%W'"$.#6*!
%
%MDJ%
!X>=%&Y<ZX>4%>[X@4%%
!
e24,6+5!U!0//-16546+1!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!/:946+3!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!;480/<!2:8+1!95+46+!
+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!6246!,+:,/+!84<!,+59+0=+!&:6!8+5+/<!41!4&&:<0&>!:5!4!&-014&9+)!.-6!
4/1:!+7,+50+&9+!41!0&I-50:-1!6:!2+4/62@!!A2+5+!45+!84&<!5+,:56+3!2+4/62!5+1,:&1+1)!.-6!62+!,50845<!
5+1,:&1+1!4&3!62+!650>>+5!;:5!:62+5!9:&1+G-+&9+1)!1-92!41!;460>-+!4&3!0&4.0/06<!6:!9:&9+&6546+!:&!
641C1)!45+!/:&>?6+58!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+!4&3!1/++,!3+,50=460:&@!
!
F99:530&>!6:!4!5+9+&6!45609/+!0&!:1)#"4"@;&0")(;)!4!,-./09460:&!:;!62+!F8+5094&!F943+8<!:;!
F-30:/:>0161)!62+!4-62:51!+7,5+11!9:&9+5&!6246!41!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!4//:*+3!0&!,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1!
4&3!9:88-&060+1)!62+05!&:01+!84<!>+&+546+!2+4/62!011-+1!48:&>!,460+&61)!6:!*2092!4-30:/:>0161!
12:-/3!5+840&!4/+56L!
&
“Noise from modern wind turbines is not known to cause hearing loss, but the lowfrequency noise and vibration emitted by wind turbines may have adverse health
effects on humans and may become an important community noise concern.
Evidence has been mounting over the past decade, however, that these utility
scale wind turbines produce significant levels of low frequency noise and vibration
that can be highly disturbing to nearby residents. None of these unwanted
emissions, whether audible or inaudible, are believed to cause hearing loss, but
they are widely known to cause sleep disturbances.
Inaudible components can induce resonant vibration in solids, liquids, and gases –
including the ground, houses, and other building structures, spaces within those
structures, and bodily tissues and cavities – that is potentially harmful to humans.
The most extreme of these low frequency (infrasonic) emissions, at frequencies
under about 16Hz, can easily penetrate homes.
Some residents perceive the energy as sound, others experience it as vibration,
and others are not aware of it at all. Research is beginning to show that, in
addition to sleep disturbances, these emissions may have other deleterious
consequences on health. It is for these reasons that wind turbines are becoming
an important community health issue, especially when hosted in quiet rural
communities that have no prior experience with industrial noise or urban hum.”
[Punch J, James R, and Pabst D. Wind Turbine Noise: What Audiologists Should
Know. Audiology Today July/August 2010]
!
J+6)!41!5+9+&6/<!41!"(!d-/<!"'U')!0&!5+1,:&1+!6:!4!G-+160:&!0&!62+!f:-1+!:;!e:88:&1)!e245/+1!
f+&35<!49C&:*/+3>+3L!!
!
“Noise is an issue.”!
!
A2+&!2+!433+3L!!
!
"There is no reason to believe that the protection from noise provided by the
ETSU-R-97 guidance does not remain acceptable and we have no plans to change
this.”
[Hansard. Davies P and Hendry C. Noise: Wind Farms. HC Deb, 27 July 2010,
c888w]
!
g&!62+!:&+!24&3!06!01!G-06+!-&3+5164&34./+!6246!4!,5:,+56<!3+=+/:,+5!*0//!1++C!6:!8470801+!62+!
+9:&:809!,:6+&604/!:;!4!106+!.<!12:+2:5&0&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!:&6:!4!106+!-,!6:!62+!845>0&!6246!62+!
3+=+/:,+51B!49:-1609!9:&1-/64&6!620&C1!80>26!.+!&+>:6046+3!*062!62+!4-62:5010&>!,-./09!:;;0904/1@!!
A201!01!4//!,456!:;!62+!9:88+5904/!*:5/3@!!g&!62+!:62+5!24&3)!06!01!62+!5+1,:&10.0/06<!:;!>:=+5&8+&6!
4&3!3+/+>46+3!4>+&90+1!:;!>:=+5&8+&6!6:!+&1-5+!6246!+;;+960=+!>-034&9+!,5:=03+1!62+!84708-8!
/+=+/!:;!,5:6+960:&!6:!;480/0+1!;:5!62+05!2+4/62)!48+&06<)!4&3!2-84&!50>261)!*2092!62+!N:=+5&8+&6!
241!9:&65496+3!6:!2:&:-5!0&!0&6+5&460:&4/!9:&=+&60:&1@!!e-55+&6!5+>-/460:&!01!-&5+/04./+!4&3!
0&43+G-46+!;:5!,5:6+960&>!62+!2+4/62!:;!;480/0+1!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!D2+5+!;480/<!2:8+1!45+!
"#!
!
/:946+3!*0620&!4!80&084/!"C8!.-;;+5!Y:&+!;5:8!62+!,+50,2+5<!:;!4!,5:,:1+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<)!
:&+!8-16!41CL!!%1!62+!&460:&4/!&++3!;:5!:&12:5+!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!1:!9506094/!6246!06!01!
I-160;04./+!6:!301,+&1+!*062!62+!.4109!2-84&!50>261)!30>&06<)!4&3!2+4/62!:;!;480/0+1)!4&3!0&16+43!
14&960:&!,50:506<!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!&+45!2:8+1)!4&3!62-1!1+&6+&9+!;480/0+1!6:!3+>5430&>!4&3!
0&2-84&!65+468+&6s!!%;!62+!4&1*+5!6:!6201!G-+160:&!01!V<+1K)!62+&!06!01!;:5!62+!N:=+5&8+&6!6:!,5:=03+!
1-;;090+&6!9:8,+&1460:&!6:!62+!;480/0+1!4//:*0&>!62+8!6:!8:=+!6:!4!9:8,454./+!2:8+!4*4<!;5:8!
62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!%;!2:*+=+5)!62+!4&1*+5!01!V&:K)!62+&!06!01!0&9-8.+&6!-,:&!62+!4-62:5010&>!4>+&9<!
6:!1+6!+&;:59+4./+!9:&65:/1!:&!62+!/+=+/!:;!&:01+!6246!5+1,+961!62+!;480/<B1!48+&06<)!30>&06<)!4&3!
,50=49<h!6246!,5:6+961!62+05!.4109!2-84&!50>261h!4&3!6246!,5+=+&61!0&I-5<!6:!62+05!2+4/62@!
!
%&!4!5+9+&6!45609/+)!f45501:&!\o-++&1!E&0=+5106<)!g&6450:]!945+;-//<!3+/0&+46+1!62+!,50&90,4/!
,5:./+81L!
!
“The characteristics of turbine noise that contribute to annoyance and sleep
disturbance are as follows: The sound from turbines is amplitude modulated at the
blade passage frequency. The modulation level is typically 3 to 5 dBA (Van den
Berg 2005) but higher levels have been measured (Moorhouse, Hayes, von
Hunerbein, Piper & Adam, 2007).
Two things arise: The peak sound is higher than the average used for noise
regulation and the modulation enhances the audibility of the sound to such an
extent that the turbine noise can be detected even when the sound is below
ambient. The noise emitted by a turbine is broadband; however, at a distance of
500 meters and more, the higher frequencies have been absorbed by the
atmosphere so that it is predominantly low-frequency noise that reaches a
receptor.
This low frequency noise enhances annoyance and is more readily able to
penetrate walls and resonate inside rooms. Many people report a thumping,
rumbling, or impulsive character to the turbine noise….”
[Harrison JP. Wind Turbine Noise. Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society
2011;31:256-261]
!
%&!:62+5!*:531)!9-55+&6!>-034&9+!4=+54>+1!62+!V,+4C1K!4&3!62+!V65:->21K)!*2092!84C+1!62+!+8066+3!
1:-&3!4,,+45!/+=+/!\:&!,4,+5]@!!J+6)!6246!01!&:6!2:*!4!,+51:&!,+59+0=+1!62+!1:-&3@!!A2+!2-84&!+45!
*:-/3!2+45!62+!V,+4CK!41!30160&960=+!4&3!0&6+58066+&6@!!%6!01!62+!V,+4CK!&:01+!6246!95+46+1!62+!
V62-8,0&>K!9245496+501609!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!4&3!*2092!,+:,/+!;0&3!3015-,60=+!4&3!0&65-10=+@!!
H:5+:=+5)!62+!V,+4CK!1:-&3!80>26!496-4//<!+79++3!62+!4//:*4./+!&:01+!/0806)!.-6!*2+&!4=+54>+3!
*062!62+!V65:->2K)!62+!4=+54>0&>!84C+1!06!4,,+45!\:&!,4,+5]!6246!62+!&:01+!01!9:8,/04&6!*062!
>-034&9+!4&3!9:&3060:&1@!!ZM54<!D!4&3!d48+1!S@!![<&4809!H+41-5+8+&61!:;!D0&3!A-5.0&+!F9:-1609!
P0>&4/1)!R8,/:<0&>!P:-&3!o-4/06<!R&>0&++50&>!H+62:31!e:&103+50&>!62+!A08+!4&3!`5+G-+&9<!
P+&1060=060+1!:;!f-84&!i+59+,60:&@!!_:01+?e:&!\i:56/4&3)!g5+>:&)!EPF])!d-/<!"O!X!"()!"'UUc&
!
What is an acceptable level of noise?
A2+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&)!62+!R-5:,+4&!E&0:&)!4&3!84&<!+&=05:&8+&64/!4&3!2+4/62!
:5>4&01460:&1!24=+!03+&60;0+3!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!41!4!84I:5!4&3!*:51+&0&>!,-./09!
2+4/62!,5:./+8@!!%&!"''T)!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!,-./012+3!!#@9*&!"#$%&V1#)%4#+%$&,"-&
71-">%)!011-+3!.<!62+!Dfg!S+>0:&4/!g;;09+)!62+!R-5:,+4&!e+&65+!;:5!R&=05:&8+&64/!f+4/62)!4&3!9:?
1,:&1:5+3!.<!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:880110:&@!!g&+!>:4/!:;!62+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!\Dfg!__N]!
01!6:!,5:=03+!08,45604/!+7,+5601+!4&3!190+&60;09!43=09+!6:!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:880110:&!4&3!061!H+8.+5!
P646+1!0&!3+=+/:,0&>!/+>01/460:&!;:5!/08060&>!,+:,/+K1!+7,:1-5+!6:!&0>26!&:01+@!!F!C+<!:.I+960=+!*41!
6:!,5:=03+!>-03+/0&+!=4/-+1!;:5!&0>26!&:01+!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!62+!,-./09!;5:8!,5+I-30904/!2+4/62!
+;;+961@!!A2+!5+9:88+&3460:&1!;:5!2+4/62!,5:6+960:&!1646+L!
!
“Sleep is an essential part of human function and is recognised as a
fundamental right under the European Convention on Human Rights.
(Article 8.1, Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family
life, his home and his correspondence.) Based on the evidence of the
health effects of night noise, an overall summary of the relation between
night noise levels and health effects, and stepwise guideline values are
presented as shown in Table 5.4 and 5.5 respectively.”
!
“For the primary prevention of subclinical adverse health effects in the
population related to night noise, it is recommended that the population
should not be exposed to night noise levels greater than 30 dB of L night,
outside during the night when most people are in bed. Therefore L night,
outside 30 dB is the ultimate target of Night Noise Guideline (WHO NNGL)
to protect the public, including the most vulnerable groups such as
children, the chronically ill and the elderly, from the adverse health effects
of night noise.”
[WHO NNG 2009, p 109]
"$!
&
_:6+!6246!62+!Dfg!__N!45+!.41+3!/45>+/<!:&!&:&?08,-/10=+!&:01+)!+@>@)!5:43!4&3!540/)!4&3!01!
62+5+;:5+!&:6!165096/<!4,,/094./+!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!*2092!241!62+!,+4C1!4&3!65:->21!:;!
,-/1460:&!4&3!0&6+58066+&9<@!!!_:01+!*062!,-/1460:&!4&3a:5!0&6+58066+&9<!94&!.+!8:5+!0&65-10=+!
624&!&:&?08,-/10=+!&:01+)!1-.164&6046+3!0&!84&<!16-30+1!4&3!5+9+&6/<!9:&;058+3!.<!<+6!4&:62+5!
16-3<!0&!4!3+640/+3!8+64?4&4/<101!.<!PY4/84!4&3!f4&9:9CL!
!
“... intermittent noise is more disruptive than a continuous schedule.”
[Szalma JL and Hancock PA. Noise Effects on Human Performance: A MetaAnalytic Synthesis. Psychological Bulletin 2011, Vol. 137, No. 4, 682–707]
!
Dfg!__N!5+9:88+&3460:&1!;:5!2+4/62!,5:6+960:&!5+;+5!6:!62+!5+/460:&120,!*062!62+!+45/0+5!Dfg!
N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+)!011-+3!0&!"'''L!
!
“If negative effects on sleep are to be avoided the equivalent sound pressure level
should not exceed 30 dBA indoors for continuous noise. If the noise is not
continuous, sleep disturbance correlates best with LAmax and effects have been
observed at 45 dB or less. This is particularly true if the background level is low.
Noise events exceeding 45 dBA should therefore be limited if possible. For
sensitive people an even lower limit would be preferred. It should be noted that it
should be possible to sleep with a bedroom window slightly open (a reduction from
outside to inside of 15 dB)... The thresholds for a number of effects are now
known, and much lower than an L Amax of 45. The last 3 sentences still stand:
there are good reasons for people to sleep at night with their window open, and to
prevent sleep disturbances one should consider the equivalent sound pressure
level and the number of sound events. The present guidelines allow
responsible authorities and stakeholders to do this.”
[WHO NNG 2009, pp 110—111]
!
%&!"'UU)!Dfg!011-+3!09%&H1-)%+&",&E#$%($%&,-".&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&!"#$%!\Dfg!M[R_])!4&!+724-160=+!
16-3<!:;!9-55+&6!C&:*/+3>+!:;!62+!5+/460:&120,!.+6*++&!301+41+!4&3!&:01+)!4&3!62+!C&:*&!.+16!
>-034&9+!6:!4=:03!43=+51+!08,4961!:&!2+4/62!;5:8!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+L!
!
“The health impacts of environmental noise are a growing concern among both the
general public and policy-makers in Europe... The chapters contain the summary
of synthesized reviews of evidence on the relationships between environmental
noise and specific health effects, including cardiovascular disease, cognitive
impairment, sleep disturbance and tinnitus.”
[WHO Burden of Disease from Environmental Noise (WHO BDEN), 2011, Abstract
http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0008/136466/e94888.pdf]
“Thus, noise pollution is considered not only an environmental nuisance
but also a threat to public health.”
[WHO BDEN, 2011, Forward]
!
%&!62+!EQ)!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!*41!4&3!5+840&1!/45>+/<!5+1,:&10./+!;:5!3+=010&>!62+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!>-03+/0&+1!-1+3!.<!>:=+5&8+&6!10&9+!UTT(@!!F6!6246!608+)!62+![60!Z62+&!MRSS)!&:*!
[Reec!9:&=+&+3!4!_:01+!D:5C0&>!N5:-,!Z_DNc)!*2:1+!U$!8+8.+51!*+5+!9:8,501+3!,508450/<!.<!
49:-160904&1!9:&1-/60&>!6:!:5!*:5C0&>!;:5!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<@!!ZP++!`5+<!Md!4&3!f433+&!id)!!"#$%&
'()#(*#"+&,-".&/#+)&01-2#+%$&3+$*(44%)&!%(-&5".%$6&7,,%8*$&"+&5%(4*9)!d-&+!"''(@c!!F/62:->2!62+!_DN!243!
499+11!6:!62+!Dfg!UTTO!5+,:56!:&!C"..1+#*;&!"#$%)!06!0&9/-3+3!5+;+5+&9+!:&/<!6:!62+!8-92!:/3+5!
UTj'!\4&3!1-,+51+3+3]!Dfg!5+,:56!:&!9:88-&06<!&:01+@!!Dfg!5+>-/45/<!-,346+1!061!&:01+!4&3!
2+4/62!>-034&9+!.+94-1+!62+5+!45+!43=4&9+1!0&!62+!190+&9+!4&3!62+!-&3+5164&30&>!:;!62+!011-+1!
0&=:/=+3)!4&3!.+94-1+!06!01!4!5+1,:&10.0/06<!6:!+&1-5+!6246!,:/09<?!4&3!3+9010:&?!84C+51!24=+!62+!
8:16!9-55+&6!C&:*/+3>+!4&3!3464@!![+9010:&1!:;6+&!24=+!/:&>?6+58!9:&1+G-+&9+1!X!41!
!
3+8:&16546+3!.<!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,:/09<!0&!62+!EQ@!!D2+5+41!62+!Dfg!5+,:561!45+!
5+1+4592+3!4&3!5+=0+*+3!.<!4!,4&+/!*062!8-/6030190,/0&45<)!0&6+5&460:&4/!+7,+5601+)!0&!62+!EQ)!
RAPE!*41!3+=01+3!1:/+/<!.<!62:1+!*062:-6!8+3094/!:5!9/0&094/!+7,+5601+h!&:5)!4,,45+&6/<)!303!62+!
,4&+/!9:&1-/6!*062!:5!0&9/-3+!4&<:&+!*062!9/0&094/!:5!+,03+80:/:>094/!+7,+5601+@!!ZD:5/3!f+4/62!
g5>4&0Y460:&@!!e:88-&06<!_:01+@!Dfg)!UTTO!
266,Laa***@&:&:01+@:5>a/0.545<a*2:&:01+a*2:&:01+@268c!
!
H:16!6+//0&>)!RAPE!01!654&1,45+&6!0&!061!,-5,:1+)!41!1646+3!G-06+!3+;0&060=+/<!0&!061!7P%81*#F%&
D1..(-;)!6246!01)!6:!3+=01+!4!>-034&9+!;:5!4//:*4./+!4-30./+!&:01+!!
!
"O!
"without placing unreasonable restrictions on wind farm development or
adding unduly to the costs and administration burdens on wind farm
developers or local authorities.”!!%
ZRAPE?S?T(!R7+9-60=+!P-8845<!P@Uc!!ZR8,24101!433+3@c!!!
!
_:6+!4/1:!6246!RAPE!4335+11+1!4-30./+!&:01+!:&/<)!6:!62+!+79/-10:&!:;!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)!4!
10>&0;094&6!9:8,:&+&6!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!6246!01!/45>+/<!0&4-30./+!.-6!:;6+&!,+59+,60./+@!
!
A2+!_DN!X!*062!061!,4&+/!:;!U$!8+8.+51!4&3!62+!92405!\354*&!840&/<!;5:8!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!
0&3-165<]!X!,5:9++3+3!6:!3+10>&!4!>-034&9+!6246!X!*062!62+!411+&6!:;!62+![+,4568+&6!:;!A543+!4&3!
%&3-165<!??!9:&60&-+1!6:!./0>26!62+!/0=+1!:;!62:1+!*2:!24=+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!.-0/6!&+45!62+05!
2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1@!!F1!62+!RAPE!7P%81*#F%&D1..(-;!4/1:!1646+1L!!!
!
"We have considered whether the low noise limits which this could imply in
particularly quiet areas are appropriate and have concluded that it is not necessary
to use a margin above background approach in such low-noise environments. This
would be unduly restrictive on developments..."
[ETSU-R-97 Executive Summary S.11]
!
D2+&!62+!5+>-/46:51!45+!48:&>!62:1+!5+>-/46+3)!62+5+!01!&:!9:&65:/!:=+5!164&34531!4&3!62+05!
+&;:59+8+&6@!!!
!
“Where regulatory actions are exposed to public view, regulators are more likely to
engage in careful and reflective decision-making.”
[ICT (Information and Communications Technologies) Regulation Toolkit.
Decision-making Process and Consultation Framework. S.7.2. 16 June 2011
www.ictregulationtoolkit.org]
!
D2+&!RAPE!*41!,-./012+3)!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!4,,5:70846+/<!#'8!20>2)!*2+5+41!84&<!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!&:*!8+41-5+!U"O8!4&3!20>2+5@!!J+6)!41!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,+51016+3!0&!94-10&>!,5:./+81!
+=+&!4;6+5!62+!08,/+8+&6460:&!:;!RAPE)!62+!>:=+5&8+&6!9:&60&-+1!6:!5+/<!:&!62+!148+!9435+!:;!
9:&1-/64&61!;:5!1-.1+G-+&6!+=4/-460:&1!:;!5+,:56+3!,5:./+81!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!
!
%&!F->-16!"''W)!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!,-./012+3!<%($1-%.%+*&",&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%&(*&09-%%&GX&
/#+)&=(-.$)!*5066+&!.<!f4<+1!H9Q+&Y0+!i456&+5120,!k63!\fHi])!:&!9:&1-/6460:&!6:!62+![60@!!\H5!
f4<+1!*41!4!8+8.+5!:;!62+!_DN!6246!,5:3-9+3!RAPE?S?T(]@!!A2+05!S+,:56!8+41-5+3!/:*!
;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!46!625++!*0&3!;458!106+1!0&!62+!EQ@!!A2+!fHi!e:&9/-10:&1!G-:6+!DfgK1!UTTO!
5+,:56!:&!C"..1+#*;&!"#$%)!*2092!1646+3!6246L!
!
“ ‘There is no reliable evidence that infrasound below the hearing
threshold produces physiological or psychological effects.’ ”
[Hayes McKenzie Partnership. Measurement of Low Frequency Noise at Three UK
Wind Farms, August 2006, p66]
!
A201!fHi!S+,:56!X!,-./012+3!0&!MNNK!X!5+,+461!62+!148+!G-:6460:&!:&!,4>+1!")!U')!$W!41!*+//!41!:&!
,4>+!WW@!!f:*+=+5)!6201!G-:6460:&)!64C+&!;5:8!62+!Dfg!C"..1+#*;&!"#$%!,4,+5!JOO\)%3:+1!&:6!
4,,+45!0&!62+!JOOO!Dfg!V1#)%4#+%$&,"-&C"..1+#*;&!"#$%)!*2092!1-,+51+3+3!62+!+45/0+5!5+,:56@!!
DfgK1!UTTT!5+,:56!01!;5++/<!4=40/4./+!:&!62+!*+.!6:!3:*&/:43!4&3!*41!4=40/4./+!6:!62+!4-62:51!:;!
62+!fHi!5+,:56)!41!Dfg!5+,:561!45+!>+&+54//<!;5++/<!4=40/4./+!:&!62+!*+.@!!ZD:5/3!f+4/62!
g5>4&0Y460:&@!!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+@!!Dfg!UTTT!
266,Laa*2G/0.3:9@*2:@0&6a2GaUTTTa4WjW("@,3;c!
!
!
!
H:5+:=+5)!62+!Dfg!V1#)%4#+%$&,"-&C"..1+#*;&!"#$%&YZZZ!9/+45/<!1646+1!0&!P+960:&!#@jL!
!
"W!
“The evidence on low frequency noise is sufficiently strong to warrant
immediate concern... Health effects due to low frequency components in
noise are estimated to be more severe than for community noises in
general.”
&
<.-3*(%-3.#%]'0-*%5(01%-3*%10+-%6'((*#-%!/[%(*80(-%G"-3%-3*%10+-%(*,".),*%(*+*.(63%.#$%
*B"$*#6*T).+*$%0)+*(B.-"0#+I%/P7%]'0-*$%5(01%+'8*(+*$*$%!/[%$06'1*#-+%-3.-%
+'880(-*$%"-+%0G#%60#-*#-"0#%-3.-%,0G%5(*]'*#6C%#0"+*%3.+%#0%.$B*(+*%*55*6-+%0#%8*08,*D%%%
%
e:&65416!62+!fHi!9:&9/-10:&!*062!62+!3464!,5:3-9+3!.<!9:&1-/64&6!49:-160904&1!;5:8!HFP!
R&=05:&8+&64/!\e48.503>+)!EQ])!46!62+!2:8+!:;!62+![4=01!;480/<!:&!O!d-/<!"''(I%"#$%!&'()!
*)+,#-.%/!01%.,'-#1$!2314#$5!2#5$#6#7'$-!,14!6(/8./$79!71$-/$-@!!ZHFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!!
_:01+!H:&06:50&>!N54,2!*0620&!;0516!;/::5!.+35::8!?![4=01B1!f:-1+!?!D0&3!`458!&:01+)!O!d-/<!"''()!
0&!F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+![+=+/:,8+&61@!!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!
EQ)!H4<!"''Tc!!A2+!8+41-5+8+&6!0&103+!4!.+35::8!46!&0>26!*062!62+!*0&3:*!,456/<!:,+&)!-10&>!
kF!+G!U"O81)!0&30946+3!8:3-/460:&!.+6*++&!#j3MF!4&3!#'3MF!46!:&+!,+5!1+9:&3)!4&3!62+!
8:3-/460:&!;/-96-46+3!:=+5!608+@!!D2+5+41)!kFT'!\*2092!4=+54>+1!5+430&>1!:=+5!4!,+50:3!:;!608+)!
;/466+&0&>!62+!,+4C1!4&3!65:->21]!12:*1!4!8-92!/:*+5!3MF!5+430&>!46!#U3MF!41!4!9:&60&-:-1!;/46!
&:01+@!
!
F!1+9:&3!8+41-5+8+&6!.<!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!64C+&!46!62+![4=01K1!f:-1+L!
!
“... clearly shows wind farm Amplitude Modulation showing significant low
frequency content.”&!
!
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/!9:88+&6+3!6246L!
!
“Wind turbine noise contains considerable low frequency content (LFN).
Work funded to date by DEFRA in this area is completely inadequate and
not scientifically robust. The use of ‘A’ weighting alone for investigating
LFN is an indication of the lack of technical expertise applied to this area.
As lower frequency wave bands are analysed, as in this graph, the extent
of the modulation becomes worse, more than 10dB.
Due to the governments preferred measure for assessing the noise from
wind turbines, known as ETSU-R-97, which has the effect of averaging
noise peaks out over a period of time, there is no recourse to justice under
existing British law to assist us. We now know that although we were
initially told that less than 5% of wind farms have this problem, the
reality is likely to be in excess of 10%...”
[MAS Environmental. Assessing Noise from Proposed Wind Turbine Developments.
MAS Environmental, Cambridge, UK, May 2009] [Emphasis added.]
&
%&!6+1608:&<!6:!62+!D019:&10&!i-./09!P+5=09+!e:880110:&)!g96:.+5!"''T)!S092453!d48+1)!4!9+560;0+3!
49:-160904&)!4335+11+3!62+!011-+!:;!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+L!
!
“Dr Leventhall testifies that ‘any effect from wind turbine noise, or any other low
level of noise, which might be produced within the body is lost in the existing
background noise and vibration.’ Human beings have adapted to disregard normal
bodily noises. It is, therefore, seriously wrong of Dr Leventhall to compare
external, imposed, and unnatural fluctuating sounds with pressure levels of 40 –
70 decibels to physiologic noises within the body.
Dr Leventhall testifies that ‘higher frequency noise from wind turbines, if it is
audible, can cause disturbance to some residents, but this effect is no different
from that of noise from another source.’ On the contrary, wind turbine noise, by
virtue of its constant presence (over hours or days), dynamic modulation of ILFN
and audible frequencies, and frequent nocturnal exacerbation, is unlike other
sources of community and industrial noise. Moreover, other sources of industrial
noise are regulated in manners suitable to their nature. Given the demonstrated
increased annoyance of turbine noise, regulations must be specially formulated to
address their unique qualities and potentials for annoyance.”
!
[James R. Surrebuttal Testimony of Richard R James on Behalf of the Coalition for
Wisconsin Environmental Stewardship. Wisconsin Public Service Commission,
docket 6630-CD-302: Wisconsin Electric Power Company (WEPCO), 28 October
2009, pp SR9.16 – SR9.22] (N.B.: Dr Leventhall is an acoustician who has acted
as a consultant to Defra and other UK government agencies.)
"(!
!
S+>4530&>!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)![5!P*0&.4&C1!\HFP!S+1+4592!k63!X!H462+846094/!^!P90+&60;09!
S+1+4592])!9:55:.:546+1!d48+1K!411+118+&6!:;!k`_L!!
!
“The opinions of two UK acousticians relating to wind turbine noise differ.
Professor Ffowcs-Williams has stated, “It is known that modern, very tall turbines,
do cause problems, and many think current guidelines fail adequately to protect
the public.”
While Dr Geoff Leventhall has commented, “I can state quite categorically that
there is no significant infrasound from current designs of wind turbines.
Infrasound is not a problem, low frequency noise may be audible under certain
conditions, the regular swish is not low frequency noise.”
In practice, the transition from infrasound to low frequency sound may be blurred.
Based on my experience, the consistent reports of physical discomfort resulting
from wind turbine noise reinforce my perception that low frequency noise can
indeed be a problem. The reported effects are entirely consistent with those that I
have experienced at first hand 20-30 years ago.
Low frequency noise can induce feelings of discomfort and nausea, not unlike
seasickness. Like seasickness, the sensitivity of different individuals varies
enormously, some being immediately sensitive, while others can barely detect
anything…”
[Swinbanks MA (Dr). Submission to the Michigan Public Service Commission
(MPSC) re: Case No U-15899, 8 December 2009. MAS Environmental, Cambridge,
UK, 9 December 2009]
!
k:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!+80110:&1!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*41!4!9+&654/!6:,09!46!62+!"'UU!`:-562!
%&6+5&460:&4/!e:&;+5+&9+!:&!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!0&!S:8+@!!g&+!16-3<!.<!Hu//+5!4&3!i+3+51:&!
;:-&3L!!
!
“The noise emission from 48 wind turbines with nominal electric power up to
3.6mw is analyzed and discussed. The relative amount of LFN is higher for large
turbines (2.3 – 3.6mw) than for small turbines (!2mw), and the difference is
statistically significant.”
[Møller H and Pedersen CS. Low Frequency Noise from Large Wind Turbines.
JASA Journal of the Acoustical Society of America June 2011;129(6): 3727-3744]
(See further discussion of LFN at S.2.4, p 54.)
!
f:*+=+5)!4/62:->2!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,5:./+81)!.:62!4-30./+!4&3!0&4-30./+!\k`_]!*+5+!C&:*&!
4.:-6!/:&>!.+;:5+!62+![60!_:01+!D:5C0&>!>5:-,!9:&=+&+3)!41!&:6+3!.<!P*0&.4&C1)!62+!_DNK1!
RAPE?S?T(!0&16+43!5+9:88+&31L!
!
“Noise from the wind farm will be limited to 5 dB(A) above background for both
day-and night-time (with the exception of the lower limits and simplified method
described below), remembering that the background level of each period may be
different. It should be noted that this limit applies to the noise from the wind farm
only and not the total ambient noise with the wind farm operating... On balance it
is considered that a margin of 5dB(A) will offer a reasonable degree of protection
to both the internal and external environment without unduly restricting the
development of wind energy which itself has other environmental benefits.”
Z_:6+L!k:*!`5+G-+&9<!_:01+)!k`_)!01!3019-11+3!;-562+5!0&!P@"@$)!,!O$@c!
!
S+>4530&>!4!R"B%-&R#.#*I!62+!_DN!433+3!6246L!
!
"Applying the margin above background approach to some of the very quiet areas
in the UK would imply setting noise limits down to say 25-30 dB(A) based upon
background levels perhaps as low as 20-25dB(A). Limits of this level would
!
prove very restrictive on the development of wind energy. As demonstrated
below, it is not necessary to restrict wind turbine noise below certain lower fixed
limits in order to provide a reasonable degree of protection to the amenity.”
[ETSU-R-97, p 60] [Emphasis added.]
"j!
&
%&!_:=+8.+5!"''j)!H0924+/!P60>*::3)!4&!49:-1609!+&>0&++5!4&3!+&=05:&8+&64/!2+4/62!+&>0&++5!
*062!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!%8,0&>6:&)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!,5+1+&6+3!4!1+80&45!46!62+!E&0=+5106<!e+&65+)!
e48.503>+@!![-50&>!62+![/#+),(-.&!1#$(+8%&3+F%$*#@(*#"+&(+)&:$$%$$.%+*&D%.#+(-\I!
P60>*::3!,:0&6+3!:-6!6246!0&!UTTW)!46!62+!608+!:;!RAPE)!62+!2+0>26!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*41!#'!X!W'!
8+65+1!6:!./43+!60,)!"O'!X!O''C*!:;!,:*+5)!*062!4!./43+!1*++,!:;!#''!X!U"O'!1G-45+!8+65+1@!!
A:34<!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!9:&103+54./<!/45>+5)!*062!4!2+0>26!:;!U''!X!UO'!8+65+1!6:!./43+!60,)!U@O!X!#!
HD!:;!,:*+5)!*062!4!./43+!1*++,!:;!")j''!X!UU)'''!1G-45+!8+65+1@!!P60>*::3!4/1:!843+!62+1+!
,:0&61L!
!
“There are assumptions in ETSU that do not hold true. There are inherent defects
in the methodology developed for ETSU where the problem and errors are greater
the larger the turbines. Controls proposed in ETSU fail to address the differences
between medium and large wind turbines and thus permit greater impact the
larger the turbines.”
[Stigwood M. Windfarm Nuisance Investigation & Assessment Seminar. MAS
Environmental, University Centre, Cambridge, UK, 20 November 2008]
!
%&!>462+50&>!+=03+&9+!46!62+![++,0&>!P6!_092:/41!*0&3!;458)!*062!6-5.0&+1!U''!8+65+1!6:!./43+!60,)!
HFP!;:-&3!62+!/45>+5!6-5.0&+1!>+&+546+3!!
!
“low frequency noise impact which may dominate within dwellings even at
substantial distances. (Can modulate over a considerable range in the region of 15
– 20 dB). (This research concurs with research by Van den Berg.) Excess
Amplitude Modulation (AM) arises when measured within dwellings especially at
certain times where certain atmospheric conditions appear to prevail (up to 8dB
measured inside)...
Free field background noise level measurements as proposed in ETSU R 97
commonly will not represent background noise levels experienced immediately
outside dwellings...
The procedures and methods contained within ETSU R 97 are incapable of
identifying the range of impacts from noise generated by large wind turbines,
within nearby dwellings.”
[Stigwood M. Windfarm Nuisance Investigation & Assessment Seminar. MAS
Environmental, University Centre, Cambridge, UK, 20 November 2008]
&
%&!9:&103+50&>!R79+110=+!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!*062!/45>+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!P60>*::3!&:6+3L!
!
“In ETSU the difference between LAeq and LA90 of wind turbine noise is assumed
to be 2dB over a 10 minute period. The suggested relationship arises because of
the limited variation between peak to trough sound energy levels for medium
turbines does not apply in the case of large turbines where a far greater peak to
trough ratio can clearly occur.”
&
!F&3!0&!8+41-5+8+&61!64C+&!.<!HFP!46![++,0&>!P6!_092:/41)!T#'!8+65+1!;5:8!&+45+16!*0&3!
6-5.0&+)!P60>*::3!:.1+5=+3!6246L!
&
“The lowest to the highest point exceeds 10dB just in one minute. Max variation
for individual thump or whoosh is 8dB(A).”
&
S+>4530&>!62+!:&106+!8+41-5+8+&61!46![++,0&>!P6!_092:/41)!62+!HFP!5+,:56!&:6+3!6246L!
!
“We have repeatedly measured low frequency noise internally at different times of
the day and night. Externally the wind turbine noise can be almost completely
masked and unrecognizable. Internally the masking noise is almost completely
removed, revealing serious intrusion from the modulating noise. Significant
differences arise between the attenuation of the turbine noise and the attenuation
of nearby sources of masking noise such as trees.”
!
&
HFP!;-562+5!9:88+&6+3!:&!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!\FH]!46!62+![++,0&>!P6!_092:/41!106+L!
!!!
"T!
“Equates to the modulation or cyclic variation of sound energy emitted by wind
turbines. It is relatively broadband in character and changes or pulsates at the
frequency of the blade passage frequency, giving rise to a characteristic ‘swishing’
or ‘whooshing’ sound. At times the sound can be more pronounced as a thumping
noise. It is characterised by a regular rise and fall in sound energy denoted by the
peak to trough range. Amplitude Modulation is far greater in certain individual
sound energy third octave bands. It can be up to and exceeding 20dB – (See
variation in 160 Hz 1/3rd octave band which exceeds 20dB).”
Z_:6+L!!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!\FH]!01!3019-11+3!;-562+5!0&!P@"@O)!,!W'@c!
!
%&!3019-110&>!/#+)&D9%(-&3$$1%$)!HFP!843+!62+!;://:*0&>!:.1+5=460:&1L!!
!
“In practice the wind speed at different heights will vary most of the time and can
sometimes reverse (Inversion conditions). All methods are approximate but the
Power method is the most accurate. During background noise measurements,
wind speed measurements should be made at: (1) 10m, (2) hub height, (3) one
other height to confirm validity of the relationship. (Ideally above hub height to
confirm any ‘Nocturnal Jet’). (The latter would probably require equipment
measuring air speed using Doppler shift technology).”
&
A2+!HFP!1+80&45!4/1:!4335+11+3!*0&3!9:&3060:&1!46!&0>26L!!
!
“Clear sky and low wind gives stable atmosphere due to radiative cooling. In these
circumstances the wind profile changes and the standard formulas are no longer
relevant...
“At night there can be little or no wind generated noise at ground level or even in
the trees up to 10 meters or so but at heights of increasingly above 10 meters the
predicted relationship fails. For example: For wind at 10 meters height, the speed
is 3 m/s, then at 60 meters hub predicted is 3.7m/s. BUT under stable conditions
at night, for wind at 10 meters = 3m/s, then at 60 m hub height = 6m/s.”
&
%&!061!411+118+&6!:;!62+!RAPE!9:&65:/!8+62:31)!62+!HFP!5+,:56!:.1+5=+3!6246L!!
!
“Measurements of the LA90 are relied upon in ETSU. This is a statistical measure
of the quietest 10% of the time. It cannot reflect the potential peaks of sound
energy likely to arise.” (MAS 126)
The effect of this is that because ETSU was designed on the basis of medium size
turbines, it assumes the same laws relate to large turbines. This is not the case.
“If the same LA90 limit was placed on both it can be seen the larger turbine would
be permitted to create noise peaks almost 6 – 7dB higher than the medium ones.”
[Stigwood M. Windfarm Nuisance Investigation & Assessment Seminar. MAS
Environmental, University Centre, Cambridge, UK, 20 November 2008]
[See also Stigwood M. Public Inquiry into Proposed Construction of wind Farm at
North Dover wind park by Ecotricity: Proof of Evidence of Mike Stigwood, MAS
Environmental, for Langdon Action Group. (UK) PINS Ref:
APP/X2220/A/08/2071880/NWF, 16 December 2008, pp 43-39.]
!
F!165-96-54/!+&>0&++5!84<!94/9-/46+!*062!9:&;03+&9+!62+!+7496!10Y+!:;!4!9:&95+6+!.+48!6:!1,4&!4&!
:,+&0&>@!!f:*+=+5)!41!62+!HFP!5+,:56!1:!9/+45/<!0//-16546+1)!&:!1-92!+7496!190+&9+!01!4=40/4./+!6:!62+!
49:-1609!+&>0&++5!0&!94/9-/460&>!62+!&:01+!/+=+/1!+7,+96+3!46!2:8+1!&+0>2.:-50&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!
A2+5+!45+!84&<!-&,5+30964./+!=4504./+1!4&3!+160846+1!46!+492!16+,)!+492!,5+1+&60&>!&-8+5:-1!
,+58-6460:&1L!!62+!148+!8:3+/!*0&3!6-5.0&+)!+=+&!41!,456!:;!62+!148+!4554<)!84<!30;;+5!0&!061!
,+5;:584&9+!624&!061!&+45+16!9:-&6+5,456@!!A2+!=4504./+1!0&9/-3+!*0&3!305+960:&)!*0&3!1,++3)!*0&3!
>-161)!4&3!*0&3!4&3!6+8,+546-5+!;/-96-460:&1!;5:8!>5:-&3!/+=+/!6:!2-.!2+0>26!4&3!./43+!60,1)!62+!
=450460:&1!0&!/4&3194,+)!62+!608+!:;!<+45)!2-803!=!35<!9:&3060:&1)!6:!&48+!4!;+*!9:&;:-&30&>!
;496:51@!!A2+5+;:5+)!06!01!&:6!1-5,5010&>!6246!&:01+?8:3+/0&>!6+92&0G-+1!45+!08,5+901+)!+=+&!*2+&!
49:-160904&1!45+!411016+3!.<!9:8,-6+5!8:3+/0&>!4,,/09460:&1@!
!
#'!
!
F1!&:6+3!4.:=+)!RAPE!8+62:3:/:><!411-8+1!4!&:01+!1:-59+!;5:8!4!10&>/+!,:0&6)!62+!&49+//+)!*2092!
;:5!4!184//!*0&3!6-5.0&+!80>26!.+!"'8!46!2-.!2+0>26!*062!4!./43+!1*+,6!45+4!:;!#''!1G!8)!4&3!4!
/45>+5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!84<!24=+!4!2-.!2+0>26!:;!U''8)!*062!./43+1!5+4920&>!UW'8!20>2!4&3!*062!4!
1*+,6!45+4!:;!UU)'''!1G-45+!8+65+1!:;!&:01+!+80110:&@!!ZH4C45+*09Y!S@!!%1!4!D0&3!A-5.0&+!4!i:0&6!
P:-59+s!!M:D:&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!`+.!"'UUhU"T\"]L!O(T?OjUc!!A201!0&!061+/;!
01!I-160;09460:&!;:5!0&65:3-90&>!4!>+&+5:-1!V;496:5!:;!14;+6<K!43I-168+&6!4,,/0+3!6:!4&<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!,5+30960:&1@!!J+6)!62+5+!01!&:!+=03+&9+!:;!4!;496:5!:;!14;+6<!4,,/0+3!6:!1-92!94/9-/460:&1!0&!
RAPE?S?T(!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!:5!0&!62:1+!:;!4&<!1-.1+G-+&6!5+,:561!.<!49:-160904&1!
5+,5+1+&60&>!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!3-50&>!62+!,5:9+11!:;!84&<!4,,/09460:&1!4&3!4,,+4/1@!
!
[4=03!e:9C1)!oe)!43=01+3!.<!9:&1-/60&>!49:-160904&!H0924+/!P60>*::3)!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!
e48.503>+)!0//-16546+3!62+!*03+!92418!4.:-6!-&3+5164&30&>!4&3!,5+30960&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!
0880110:&1)!+=+&!.+6*++&!+7,+56!49:-160904&1@!!%&!201!C4"$#+@&D12.#$$#"+&*"&*9%&09-%%&<""-$&
J4(++#+@&3+W1#-;&\[+=:&]!:&!.+24/;!:;!A2+!S-54/!R78::5!F//04&9+!\ASRF]!0&!"''T)!H5!e:9C1!*5:6+L!
!
“The assessment of how much noise turbines make and whether it is below a set
limit, is controlled for the most part by ‘The Assessment and Rating of Noise from
Wind Farms’ (ETSU R 97), written by a working group of which Hayes, HMP partner
and witness for SSE and Trinick, solicitor for Coronation Power, were members.
The science of noise is complex, uncertain and inexact. In the UK it is also highly
incestuous being confined to a small number of experts, all known to each other
and mostly working for the developers.
When an outsider like Stigwood (MAS Environmental) appears to question the
consensus, it gives rise to much fierce controversy and a good deal of intemperate
abuse.
Three Moors Wind Turbines
Predicted sound levels at receiving house or ‘receptor’ are worked out by taking
the sound level at the turbine and calculating the attenuation of that sound on its
journey to the house. Sound sent out from the turbine is an emission and sound
received is an immission.
The sound level emitted by the turbine is taken to be either the warranted power
level or the measured power level with and adjustment for uncertainty of +2dB.
This amounts to the same thing because the warranted level is the measured level
+2dB correction.
In calculating immission levels one of the factors taken into account for
attenuation is the condition of the ground (G) over which the sound is transmitted.
Sound travels faster over hard ground (G=0) than over soft (G=0.5 or more). The
worst case scenario for a developer was formerly used, combining an emission
level with a +2dB correction and G = 0. This was thought fairer to the
householder.
Hayes of HMP, SSE’s consultant at Three Moors, used to be a strong proponent of
this method which was used in his Three Moors ES. Hayes has now changed his
mind on this and uses the warranted power level + G=0.5. This works in favour of
the developer and against the householder. When asked why the goalposts had
been moved he had no explanation.
The candidate turbine here is a Vestas V80 which can be run in different modes,
some noisier than others. If run to try and produce a 30% capacity factor, it will
not meet the ETSU noise limits.
A candidate turbine means what it says. There is no guarantee that such a
turbine, figuring in the ES, will be the one installed. If the installed turbine has
varying modes of operation, the temptation will be to extract the maximum power
output, at increased risk to the residents in the area.
ETSU does not cover noise propagation. The most commonly used methodology is
laid down in ISO9613. A worst case scenario is used, i.e. most favourable to the
receiver of the sound, in which there are meteorological conditions favourable to
propagation, lowest air absorption figures and hard ground (G=0).
#U!
!
Meteorological conditions.
There is disagreement amongst the experts as to whether ISO9613 has built in
provision for wind shear. Stigwood for TREA said that it does not cater for wind
shear whilst Hayes, although not explicit, inferred that it does.
The wording of ISO is clear and limited: it makes clear that it caters for downwind
propagation or propagation under a well developed moderate ground based
temperature inversion at night (conditions giving rise to possible wind shear), but
not both.
Hayes also attacked Stigwood for the use of another algorithm with the ISO
methodology, details of which need not detain us here, in which attack he made
some very unfortunate arithmetical errors giving rise to wild and wrong headed
assertions about wind shear and how he accounted for it. (See below)
G=0
Hayes has abandoned warranted power levels + G=0 and changed to G = 0.5, a
change that favours the developer. Previously he had been a stout defender of
G=0 on the basis that it was representative of noise levels that a receptor would
experience when “located in a garden with the normal facade of a dwelling house
and other structures in close proximity”. Quite; we could not have put it better
ourselves.
ISO is not an exact science. It was not designed for wind turbines and has a
number of built in reservations and margins for error.
Wind shear
In certain climatic conditions wind speed at hub height may greatly exceed that at
ground level. Since it depends on climatic conditions it is a variable phenomenon
and there is no constant relation between wind speeds at ground level and those
at hub height, particularly at night.
ETSU assumes such a constant relation and has been recognised recently as
defective in this respect. Van den Berg did the vital early research. HMP until very
recently fought a prolonged rearguard action against him. They said variable wind
shear only occurred at flat inland sites and constantly refused to account for it.
They have now been forced to recognise ETSU’s defects.
Hayes and McKenzie were members of the group of acousticians who have come to
an agreement on a new methodology to cope with wind shear. It has been
published in the Institute of Acoustics bulletin and is precisely that, an agreement.
There is no referenced evidence for the change and no peer review. It advocates:
• Acquire background noise levels
• Measure wind speed at two different speeds on site
• Correct wind speed at greater height to hub height wind speed to discover wind
shear exponent m by using power law formula
• Correct hub height wind speed to 10m height wind speed using the old ETSU
logarithm
The last step produces what McKenzie of HMP calls a ‘fictitious’ measurement.
Stigwood and Van den Berg say the method is incorrect and can lead to error. The
power law formula should be used for this step as well, and not the old discredited
ETSU logarithm.
Hayes evidence on wind shear was, to use a polite word, unconvincing. First,
during the course of an attack on Stigwood, and basing himself on some faulty
arithmetic, he came out with the ludicrous proposition that wind shear had no
application to small wind farms where the separation distances between source
and receiver were 500-800m. This would have meant that it applied to neither site
here. He had to withdraw that assertion when he discovered his sums were
wrong.
Second, he said that he had taken wind shear into account since 2002-3 (the time
of the Van den Berg research). When pressed on how he did it and in particular
!
where such calculations appeared in the ES for Three Moors he said they did not,
and wind shear was based on an estimate.
There are no outward and visible signs of it being accounted for in any of his
assessments in this inquiry.
The limited wind shear data that has been disclosed to us does not give a
comprehensive picture. It is averaged data for each month and does not represent
variations within the month. It has the fatal defect of all averaged data. We have
been denied the full data for the year to analyse.
Amplitude Modulation
The predisposing conditions for amplitude modulation, namely a high wind shear
factor and overcrowding of the site with inadequate separation distances between
turbines, both exist at Three Moors.
Stigwood says that there is a high likelihood of AM at this site and that the
appropriate penalty would be between 5-8dB
Stigwood has carried out convincing research into AM at various properties
including a house at Deeping St Nicholas owned by Jane Davis. She has described
how she and her husband were driven from the house by thumping and whooshing
sounds and forced to acquire a dormitory house elsewhere. Stigwood has
established a maximum variation, peak to trough at her house of 8dB(A) caused
by AM. Hayes says nothing about AM.
Background noise monitoring
ETSU noise limits are fixed at a certain level above background noise levels. A
higher background noise level enables the turbine to emit more noise and thus
favours the developer.
Given the central role background noise levels in noise control from wind turbines,
it is unfortunate that background noise monitoring is not a precise science-see
North Dover Inspector.
What the monitoring seeks to establish is what the background noise levels are in
the amenity area of someone’s house. Much turns therefore on the siting of the
monitoring equipment. Levels in a quiet amenity area will be lower than levels in a
field, exposed to wind and foliage noise.
None of the five sites monitored was the equipment correctly sited. If the
gathering of the data was defective, so was the plotting. There is data missing for
the lower and higher wind speeds. The background noise data undergoes a
dramatic transformation when it is transferred to charts that plot that data against
the turbine noise levels and the ETSU limits. Lines appear for wind speeds where
there was no data and, instead of heading down, they start going up.
Hayes said that this plotting without data was based on “estimates”. Just like his
alleged adjustment for wind shear. When this guesswork is removed from the
calculations, it is obvious that there are increased breaches of the ETSU limits and
the already tight margins on which the turbines are predicted to operate become
even tighter.
Stigwood says that while it is difficult to quantify the errors in background noise
levels, they will reduce the levels by several dB.
Breaches of ETSU limits
The HMP calculations show tight margins and some breaches of the ETSU limits.
When built in margins for error, penalty for AM, and corrections for HMP error are
factored in to the equation, there will be massive non-compliance with the ETSU
limits.
The best form of noise mitigation is proper separation distances between the
turbines and receivers of the noise. Nine turbines have been crammed into
insufficient space. The site has shrunk because land owners withdrawing. The
#"!
!
consequence is that there are inadequate separation distances between turbines
and houses and also between the turbines themselves.”
[Cocks D. Closing Submissions on Behalf of the Rural Exmoor Alliance: Summary.
PINS Ref: APP/X1118/A/08/2083682, LPA Ref 45489, and PINS
APP/Y1138/A/08/2084526, LPA Ref 07/02262/MFUL, 24 November 2009]
##!
&
%&![+9+8.+5!"''T)!H0924+/!P60>*::3!5+1,:&3+3!*2+&!41C+3!6:!9:88+&6!:&!4!1646+8+&6!.<!
49:-160904&1!*:5C0&>!;:5!3+=+/:,+51!*2:!9/408+3!6246!RAPE?S?T(!;://:*1!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1L!
!
“This is simply wrong as those values (WHO values) relate to steady continuous
noise dose at the facade as well as noise that is free field. Thus it includes all
noise from sources near and far and NOT just windfarm noise. Thus 3dB has to
be deducted to achieve free field (from a facade) and a further 2dB to get to dB
LA90 as opposed to LAeq. Thus 40 LAeq in the guidance (ETSU) equates to 35dB
LA90 and not just wind farm noise. However, steady noise is generally benign and
less disturbing than fluctuating noise. That leads generally to a further downwards
shift of an unspecified value, but arguably 5dB. Put another way, a fluctuating
free field noise equates to the likely impact of a steady noise at the facade that is
8dB higher. Plus the 2dB difference for converting from LAeq to LA90 and the
fluctuating noise needs to be 10dB lower i.e. to avoid health concerns it suggests
an external value of 30dB LA90. It has to be remembered this value relates to
total fluctuating noise and not just windfarm noise.
If you ignore the ‘steady’ noise point it still means that the total noise dose to
which the windfarm adds should not exceed 35dB LA90 to fall within the WHO
guidelines and not 35dB LA90 for the wind farm noise on its own. In summary it is
factually incorrect for windfarm acousticians to suggest the limits fall within the
WHO Guidelines which compounds the error the ETSU-R-97 working group made in
the first instance when they also considered the WHO values as applying just to
the wind turbine noise when they are a total noise dose value.”
[Stigwood M. Personal Communication, 29 December 2009; emphasis added.]
&
A2+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6K1!i/4&&0&>!i:/09<!P646+8+&6!;:5!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!X!iiP"")!P@""!X!1646+1!6246L!
!!
“Renewable technologies may generate small increases in noise levels... Local
planning authorities should ensure that renewable energy developments
have been located and designed in such a way to minimise increases in
ambient noise levels. Plans may include criteria that set out minimum
separation distances between different types of renewable energy projects and
existing developments. The 1997 report by ETSU-R-97 for the Dti should be used
to assess and rate noise from wind energy developments”. [Emphasis added.]
[UK Government Planning Policy Statement 22 (PPS22): Renewable Energy, 10
August 2004
http://www.communities.gov.uk/publications/planningandbuilding/pps22]
!
A2-1)!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!4//:*1!-&9:&65://+3!4&3!-&5+16540&+3!V1+/;!5+>-/460:&K!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!+80110:&1!.<!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<)!+&3:510&>!&:01+!>-03+/0&+1!6246!1+6!,5:9+3-5+1!;:5!
-10&>!:-63::5!+76+5&4/!8+41-5+8+&61!6:!+160846+!62+!&:01+!/+=+/1!0&103+!&+45.<!2:8+1@!!A2+1+!
,5:9+3-5+1!0&6+56*0&+!0&!4!;:58-/4!6246!0&9/-3+1!>-+11*:5C!\4/.+06!0&;:58+3]!4&3!1-,,:1060:&)!
*2092!9:&I:0&!0&!4!106+!,/4&!6246!&:!9:&1-/64&6!:5!3+=+/:,+5!01!*0//0&>!6:!,5:;+110:&4//<!0&3+8&0;<!
*062!4!V;06!;:5!,-5,:1+!*4554&6<K)!0@+@)!6:!>-454&6++!62+5+!*0//!&:6!.+!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+!&:5!1/++,!
0&6+55-,60:&!6:!&+45.<!;480/0+1@!!`-562+58:5+)!:&/<!4!24&3;-/!:;!49:-160904&1!24=+!4!3+640/+3!4&3!
*:5C0&>!C&:*/+3>+!:;!RAPE?S?T()!*2092!/+431!6:!0&9:&1016+&6!0&6+5,5+6460:&1!4&3!
08,/+8+&6460:&@!!!
!
[4=03!e:9C1)!oe)!9/+45/<!0//-16546+3!2:*!6*:!+7,+50+&9+3!4&3!94,4./+!,5:;+110:&4/!49:-160904&1!
94&&:6!4>5++!:&!62+!08,/+8+&6460:&!:;!62+!RAPE?S?T(!;:58-/4)!+1,+904//<!41!>-+1160846+1!
0&;/-+&9+!62+!5+1-/6)!0@+@)!411-8,60:&1!4&3!,5+30960:&1!45+!.-0/6!0&6:!62+!,5:9+11@!!A2+5+!01!&:!
+=03+&9+!N:=+5&8+&6!1:->26!4,,5:,5046+!8+3094/!:5!+,03+80:/:>094/!+7,+5601+!*2+&!;:58-/460&>!
499+,64./+!49:-1609!>-034&9+!6246!4//:*1!-&0&6+55-,6+3!1/++,@!!%&16+43)!+&>0&++51!843+!62+1+!
3+9010:&1@!!N:=+5&8+&6!241!+&9:-54>+3!62+!,:*+5;-/!4&3!0&;/-+&604/!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!6:!V1+/;?
5+>-/46+K)!.-6!6201!241!.++&!46!62+!9:16!6:!62+!2+4/62!:;!0&&:9+&6!;480/0+1!*2+5+=+5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!
45+!,+58066+3!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1@!!F1!4!5+1-/6)!>:=+5&8+&6!241!/:16!10>26!:;!061!:./0>460:&!
#$!
!
6:!,5:6+96!62+!2+4/62!:;!:530&45<!;480/0+1)!0@+@)!499:530&>!6:!62+!+=03+&9+?.41+3!Dfg!+&=05:&8+&64/!
&:01+!164&34531!4&3!5+9:88+&3460:&1@!
!
e41+!k4*)!2:*+=+5)!64C+1!4!;45!8:5+!5460:&4/!4&3!08,45604/!=0+*)!9-660&>!625:->2!-&;405!
>:=+5&8+&6!309646+1)!0>&:50&>!9:88+5904/!4&3!03+:/:>094/!,5+11-5+1@!!F!5+/+41+!.<!$?O!N54<K1!%&&!
PG-45+)!k:&3:&)!A2+!e248.+51!:;!d:&4624&!H:;;+66)!M455016+5)!1646+3L!
!
“Court of Appeal allows Windfarm Appeal.
On 24 November 2010, the Court of Appeal allowed the Welsh Ministers appeal
against a judgment of Wyn Williams J concerning a windfarm development in North
Wales.
An Inspector had dismissed an appeal lodged after a refusal of planning
permission. The basis of the refusal contended that, although the proposed
windfarm might operate within the noise limits recommended by ETSU-R-97,
residents already experienced noise disturbance from existing windfarms (also
operating within the ETSU-R-97 limits). Thus, residents would experience noise
disturbance for longer periods, with the result of unacceptable adverse effects on
residential amenity. Wyn Williams J had quashed the Inspectors decision, holding
that it was inconsistent for the Inspector to conclude that, on the one hand, the
existing and proposed windfarms would operate within relevant limits, but on the
other hand, local residents would suffer noise disturbance that was unacceptable.
The Court of Appeal held that there was no such inconsistency and allowed an
appeal against the Judge’s decision. It held that while the ETSU-R-97 limits
were a matter to which the Inspector was required to consider, he was
not bound by these limits. In particular, the ETSU-R-97 limits represented
only one view as to the appropriate balance between the adverse effects
of noise disturbance and the wider beneficial effects of wind farms. It
was for the Inspector to form his own planning judgement as to whether
the noise generated by a particular proposal would be unacceptable,
taking into account the evidence of local residents and his own
experiences on site visits. Counsel: Jonathan Moffett represented the Welsh
Ministers.”
[4-5 Gray’s Inn Square. Court of Appeal Allow Windfarm Appeal. 4-5 News, 25
November 2005] [Emphasis added.]
!
[+8:&1654./<)!RAPE?S?T(!3:+1!&:6!,5:=03+!43+G-46+!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!62+!08,496!:;!&:01+!
5430460:&!6:!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!F1!k:53!d-1609+!R/041!1403)!!
!
"As my Lord, Lord Justice Pitchford, has indicated, it seems to me that the duration
of an interference is plainly a material consideration when determining whether the
level of noise is acceptable... Plainly, the Inspector had regard to the guidance in
ETSU 97. He recognised that it would not be infringed. Nonetheless, he was
satisfied that the increase in the frequency [duration] of the noise would be
unacceptable. He had a proper evidential basis for that conclusion, he explained
his reasons adequately, and I see no error of law in his analysis.”
[S.37 & S.38, Case No: C1/2010/1426/Qbenf, Lord Justice Carnwath, Lord Justice
Elias and Lord Justice Pitchford between: Tegni Cymru Cyf Respondent - And The Welsh Ministers & ANR Appellant]
!
%&!6201!148+!I-3>+8+&6)!k:53!d-1609+!i0692;:53!4/1:!&:6+3L!!!
!
"In my judgment the Inspector is clearly correct when he says (as he does in
paragraph 21 of the decision letter) that the indicative noise levels set out in
ETSU-R-97 are guidance not absolute values. That is the clear effect of
paragraph 2.16 of TAN 8. It follows that there may be circumstances in
which it is open to a local planning authority or an Inspector to conclude
that noise levels associated with a wind farm are unacceptable
notwithstanding compliance with ETSU-R-97.”
[S.24, Case No: C1/2010/1426/Qbenf, Lord Justice Carnwath, Lord Justice Elias
and Lord Justice Pitchford between: Tegni Cymru Cyf Respondent - And - The
Welsh Ministers & ANR Appellant] [Emphasis added.]
!
`-562+58:5+)!0;!62+!/+430&>!+7,+56!49:-160904&1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!5430460:&!94&&:6!4>5++!*062!
&-8+5:-1!41,+961!:;!62+!RAPE?S?T(!;:58-/4)!06!01!-&5+41:&4./+!;:5!9+&654/!>:=+5&8+&6!6:!+7,+96!
#O!
!
6246!/:94/!4-62:506<!R&=05:&8+&64/!f+4/62!g;;09+51!24=+!62+!1,+904/016!+7,+5601+!6:!4,,5401+!62+!
&:01+!1-.80110:&!:;!4&!R&=05:&8+&64/!F11+118+&6!499:8,4&<0&>!4!,/4&&0&>!4,,/09460:&@!!A201!01!
4&!-&499+,64./+!164&3453!:;!9:&65:/!0&!4!8:3+5&!3+8:954609!1:90+6<@!!%&!;:16+50&>!-&5+165096+3!1+/;?
5+>-/460:&!.<!62+!*0&3!0&3-165<)!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!241!;40/+3!6:!+7+5901+!4!.4109!3-6<!:;!945+!
6:*4531!061!9060Y+&1@!!\[:+1!62+!N:=+5&8+&6!499+,6!1+/;?>:=+5&4&9+!;5:8!62+!,245849+-6094/!
0&3-165<s]!!_:01+!8:3+/0&>!01!&:6!4&!+7496!190+&9+)!41!0//-16546+3!.<!d48+1K!S+.-664/!A+1608:&<!6:!
62+!i-./09!P+5=09+!e:880110:&)!D019:&10&)!EPF)!g96:.+5!"''T@!!Zd48+1!S@!!P-55+.-664/!A+1608:&<!:;!
S092453!S!d48+1!:&!M+24/;!:;!62+!e:4/060:&!;:5!D019:&10&!R&=05:&8+&64/!P6+*453120,@!!D019:&10&!
i-./09!P+5=09+!e:880110:&)!3:9C+6!WW#'?e[?#'"L!D019:&10&!R/+96509!i:*+5!e:8,4&<!\DRieg])!"j!
g96:.+5!"''T)!,!PST@jc!
!!
A2+!&-8.+5!:;!*0&3!;458!106+1!0&!62+!EQ!*2+5+!&:01+!9:8,/40&61!160//!+7016!01!+=03+&9+!6246!62+!
i/4&&0&>!e:&3060:&1!6246!;/:*!;5:8!RAPE?S?T(!45+!+062+5!-&+&;:59+4./+!:5!6246!62+!:50>0&4/!3+10>&!
N-034&9+!01!&:6!V;06!;:5!,-5,:1+K!0&!,5:=030&>!43+G-46+!,5:6+960:&!;:5!;480/0+1!/0=0&>!&+45.<@!!A201!
16+81!,456/<!;5:8!/0&C0&>!62+!84708-8!&:01+!/0806!6:!62+!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+)!.-6!62+!,5:./+81!45+!
9:8,:-&3+3!.+94-1+!62+!k:94/!F-62:506<!3:+1!&:6!24=+!62+!50>26!6:!5+G-05+!62+!*0&3!;458!6:!12-6!
3:*&!*20/+!0&3+,+&3+&6!106+!8+41-5+8+&61!:;!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+!45+!5+9:53+3!4&3!4&4/<1+3@!!
!
[-50&>!4!1+80&45!0&!g96:.+5!"''j)![4=03!`:51309C)!M455016+5!:;!k4&3845C!e248.+51)!k:&3:&)!
&:6+3!6246L!!!
!
"Conditions can only be imposed when they are reasonable, necessary, precise and
enforceable. The drafting of enforceable noise conditions for wind turbines is
fraught with difficulty... Model BERR conditions are now customarily imposed –
‘Onshore Wind Energy Planning Conditions Guidance Notes October 2007'."
[Note that the Dti, reconfigured as BERR, and now DECC, had oversight of wind
turbine noise guidelines at that time.]
!
H5!`:51309C!9:&60&-+3L!!!
!
"On their face, the standard conditions seem fine – but very significant difficulties
arise when one comes to consider how, in practice, the conditions are to be
policed/enforced. The model condition imposes measurement and reporting
requirements by reference to the ETSU noise limits but there is no mechanism
contained in the conditions to ensure that the turbines close down as soon as there
is an exceedance. There is no requirement for continual monitoring and
interventions. The position is thus that on a complaint, the LA may require
monitoring in accordance with ETSU (but as I have shown above there is always
room for considerable debate as to what ETSU requires and how it will be complied
with) and may thereafter be able to identify infringements. But even if the Council
were to take enforcement action, how would a notice be worded and how would
that be enforced. Further the condition is incapable of taking into account differing
atmospheric conditions and is tied to a height of 10m without any consideration of
the impact of wind shear factor adjustment."
[Forsdick D. Noise and Wind Turbine Proposals. Landmark Chambers (London):
Renewable Energy Seminar, 1 October 2008]
!
f4&1453)!62+!EQ!i45/048+&6K1!:;;0904/!,5:9++30&>1)!5+=+4/1!62+!,:*+5;-/!0&;/-+&9+!6246!62+!*0&3!
+&+5><!0&3-165<!+7+561!:&!>:=+5&8+&6@!!g&!"(!d-/<!"'U'!\Fee'j])!i20/0,![4=0+1)!Hi)!41C+3!62+!
P+95+645<!:;!P646+!;:5!R&+5><!4&3!e/0846+!e24&>+!0;!2+!,/4&&+3!6:!5+=0+*!62+!&:01+!>-034&9+!
5+9:88+&3+3!.<!62+![60!_:01+!D:5C0&>!N5:-,!0&!RAPE?S?T()!,-./012+3!0&!UTT(@!!\T$$O]!Zfe![+.!
e@jjjDc!
!
e245/+1!f+&35<!5+1,:&3+3L!!
!
%
"Noise is a key issue to be taken into account in considering proposals for wind
farm development. There is no reason to believe that the protection from
noise provided for by ETSU-R-97 guidance does not remain acceptable,
and we have no plans to change this.”
[Hansard: [4=0+1!i!4&3!f+&35<!e)!_:01+L!D0&3!`4581)!"(!d-/<!"'U')!9jjj*c [Emphasis
added.]
#W!
!
d:&4624&!R3*4531)!Hi)!46!4!/46+5!346+)!41C+3!N5+>:5<!M45C+5)!62+!P+95+645<!:;!P646+)!*2+62+5!2+!
,/4&&+3!6:!5+=0106!:5!5+=01+!62+!&:01+!411+118+&6!>-034&9+!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!0@+@)!RAPE?S?T(@!!!
!
!
N5+>:5<!M45C+5!5+,+46+3!,5+901+/<!62+!148+!1646+8+&6!41!6246!-1+3!.<!e245/+1!f+&35<@!!!
Zf4&1453@!!R3*4531!d!4&3!M45C+5!N)!"(!d-/<!"'U')!9jT#*c!
!
F&35+*!P6+,2+&1:&)!Hi)!62+&!41C+3!4!1080/45!G-+160:&!4&3!4>40&!5+9+0=+3!62+!03+&6094/!1950,6+3!
5+1,:&1+@!!!
Zf4&1453@!!P6+,2+&1:&!F!4&3!f+&35<!e)!"(!d-/<!"'U')!OOWjc!
!
%6!01!9/+45!6246!62+!9245496+5)!3-5460:&)!4&3!3:14>+!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!3+/0=+5+3!6:!2:8+1!45+!
08,:564&6!;496:51!0&!3+6+580&0&>!*2+62+5!4!;480/<!1/++,1!46!&0>26!:5!*2+62+5!4!1+50:-1!/:11!:;!
48+&06<!+&1-+1@!!D062!4!8-/6030190,/0&45<!6+48!:;!0&6+5&460:&4/!+7,+561)!62+!08,45604/!4&3!
0&3+,+&3+&6!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!3+=01+1!>-03+/0&+1!;:5!&:01+!/+=+/1!6246)!0;!+79++3+3)!*0//!
/0C+/<!650>>+5!43=+51+!2+4/62!9:&1+G-+&9+1@!
!
%6!01!8:5+!16540>26;:5*453!6:!9:8,/<!*062!4!165096!84708-8!4//:*4./+!&:01+!/+=+/!:;!#'!3MF!0&103+!
62+!2:8+)!*062!62+!*0&3:*!,456/<!:,+&)!0&!499:534&9+!*062!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1)!5462+5!624&!6:!
499:88:346+!62+!6:56-:-1!8+62:3:/:><!:;!RAPE@!!\Dfg!__N!"''T!R7+9-60=+!P-8845<!vp%%%!
V'%4(*#"+&B#*9&V1#)%4#+%$&,"-&C"..1+#*;&!"#$%&YZZZS]!!R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!g;;09+51!94&!
8:&06:5!62+1+!/+=+/1!8:5+!+410/<@!!p0:/460:&1!12:-/3!.+!1-.I+96!6:!1*0;6!9:55+960=+!4960:&@!!`:5!
+748,/+)!0;!4&!R&=05:&8+&64/!g;;09+5!:.1+5=+1!6246!62+!&:01+!+79++31!>-034&9+!:5!9:&3060:&1)!:5!
241!+=03+&9+!6246!62+!&:01+!.5+492+3!4//:*4./+!/08061!4&3!9:&3060:&1)!62+&!62+!/:94/!4-62:506<!8-16!
24=+!62+!4-62:506<!6:!12-6!3:*&!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<!088+3046+/<!-&60/!62+!4>+&6!5+1,:&10./+!
;:5!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<!,5:=03+1!4&!499+,64./+!1:/-60:&@!!`:5!+748,/+)!4!5+9:530&>!3+=09+!9:-/3!
1-,,:56!&:01+?8+41-50&>!0&165-8+&61!0&!62+!2:8+!0&!:53+5!6:!2+/,!03+&60;<!62+!3+>5++!4&3!
9245496+5!:;!62+!&:01+@!!HFP!R&=05:&8+&6!241!3+8:&16546+3!6246!6201!8+62:3!:;!9://+960&>!&:01+!
3464!01!,5496094/@!!ZHFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!_:01+!H:&06:50&>!N54,2!8+41-5+3!*0620&!;0516!;/::5!
.+35::8!X!*0&3:*!:,+&!X![4=01K1!!f:-1+!?!D0&3!`458!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!12:*0&>!P0>&0;094&6!
k:*!`5+G-+&9<!e:&6+&6)!O!d-/<!"''()!0&L!!F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+!
[+=+/:,8+&61@!!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!H4<!"''Th!4&3!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!!
_:01+!H:&06:50&>!N54,2!*0620&!;0516!;/::5!.+35::8!?![4=01B1!f:-1+!?!D0&3!`458!_:01+)!O!d-/<!"''()!
0&L!!F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+![+=+/:,8+&61@!!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!
EQ)!H4<!"''Tc!!!!
!
%&!6201!*4<)!/:94/!4-62:5060+1!80>26!.+!4./+!6:!4=:03!62+!+7,+&1+!:;!2050&>!49:-160904&1!6:!4&4/<1+!
+=+5<!94/9-/460:&!4&3!+160846+!0&!62+!16</+!:;!4&!R&=05:&8+&64/!%8,496!P646+8+&6!ZR%Pc@!!ZKrogh C;
Gillis L; and Kouwen N. A Self-Reporting Survey: Adverse Health Effects with Industrial
Wind Turbines and the Need for Vigilance. WindVOiCe Wind Vigilance for Ontario
Communities, Ontario, Canada, July 2010; and F//+<&+!S@!!D0&3!`458!`:59+3!6:!e/:1+!4;6+5!
e:8,/40&61!:=+5!62+!_:01+!\P9:6/4&3]@!!E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9!UW!d-&+!"'UU!
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/environment/8579747/Wind-farm-forcedto-close-aftercomplaints-over-the-noise.html]
!
%&!433060:&)!06!12:-/3!.+!84&346:5<!;:5!62+!3+=+/:,+5!4&3a:5!62+!9:&1-/60&>!49:-160904&1!6:!
,5:=03+!4!3+10>&!*4554&6<!6246!+&1-5+1!6246!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+\1]!*0//!&:6!,5:3-9+!4!&:01+!+79++30&>!
#'3MF!kF847!46!&0>26)!0&!4!.+35::8)!*062!4!*0&3:*!:,+&)!4&3!6246!62+!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!4&3!
48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&!*0//!.+!165096/<!/0806+3!*062!9:&3060:&1!165096/<!8+6@!!H:5+:=+5)!1080/45!&:01+!
5+1650960:&1!8-16!4,,/<!3-50&>!62+!34<608+!2:-51!1:!6246!,+:,/+!9:&60&-+!6:!+&I:<!62+!48+&060+1!:;!
62+05!2:8+1!:5!:62+5!5+95+460:&4/!:5!.-10&+11!45+41@!
!
f:*+=+5)!0;!62+!3+=+/:,+5!4&3a:5!62+!9:&1-/60&>!49:-160904&1!94&&:6!,5:=03+!4!*4554&6<)!
5+>453/+11!:;!62+!*0&3!0&3-165<K1!1+/;?5+>-/46+3!9:88066++!;0&30&>1)!4&3!0;!62+<!94&&:6!>-454&6++!
165096!432+5+&9+!6:!62+!e:-56K1!5-/0&>1)!62+&!62+!106+!01!-&1-064./+!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!
!!
%&!H4<!"'UU)!62+5+!*41!,5:>5+11!0&!1+9-50&>!4!/+=+/!:;!08,5:=+3!,5:6+960:&!;:5!;480/0+1!.<!62+!
e:-56!:;!F,,+4/)!0&!62+!941+!9:&9+5&0&>![+&!M5::C!p4//+<!\[+=:&])!,45609-/45/<!;:5!48,/06-3+!
8:3-/460:&)!*2092!4>5++3!6246!!
!
“... the swish noise was seen as creating its own particular problem… there is an
obligation on the developers to comply with AM levels specified in Condition 20.”
!
[MW Hulme v Secretary of State & RES, 2011 EWCA Civ 638, 26.05.2011; and the
Appeal decision permitting the Den Brook wind farm APP/Q1153/A/06/2017162]
[See also S.2.5, Amplitude Modulation, p 60.]
#(!
!
A246!01)!4/62:->2!62+!e:-56!4960:&!3+903+3!0&!;4=:-5!:;!62+!3+=+/:,+5)!SRP)!0&!061!,-51-06!6:!
9:&165-96!62+![+&!M5::C!p4//+<!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!62+!e:-56!4/1:!4>5++3!*062!62+!9:&3060:&1!6:!9:&65:/!
9506094/!&:01+!/+=+/1)!*2092!62+!3+=+/:,+5a:,+546:5a:*&+5!8-16!&:6!+79++3)!,45609-/45/<!6:!,5+=+&6!
F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&@!!A2+1+!9:&3060:&1!164&3L!
!
“20. a) A change in the measured LAeq, 125 milliseconds turbine noise level of
more than 3dB (represented as a rise and fall in sound energy levels each of more
than 3dB) occurring within a 2 second period.
20.b) The change identified in (a) above shall not occur less than 5 times in any
one minute period provided the LAeq, 1 minute turbine sound energy level for that
minute is not below 28dB.
20.c) The changes identified in (a) and (b) above shall not occur for fewer than 6
minutes in any hour.”
!
F/62:->2!1:8+!49:-160904&1!45>-+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!241!&:!08,496!:&!2+4/62)!+&>0&++51!3:!
&:6!24=+!62+!G-4/0;09460:&1!6:!84C+!62+1+!411+560:&1@!!A2+!*0//0&>&+11!6:!+7,5+11!62+1+!:,0&0:&1!41!
;4961!301,/4<1!4!,5:;:-&3!,5:;+110:&4/!455:>4&9+h!62+!4-62:51!:;!1-92!1646+8+&61!08,/<!6246!62+<!
24=+!1-,+50:5!8+3094/!+7,+5601+!4&3!4-62:506<!624&)!+@>@)!62+!0&6+5&460:&4/)!8-/6030190,/0&45<!,4&+/!
:;!8+3094/!+7,+561!*2:!4-62:5+3!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!5+,:561)!41!*+//!41!+=03+&9+!:&!
&:01+!08,4961!:&!2+4/62!,-./012+3!0&!9/0&094/!5+1+4592!45609/+1@!!A2:1+!*062!8+3094/!4&3!
+,03+80:/:>09!+7,+5601+!24=+!;:-&3!6246!;480/0+1!1-;;+5!2+4/62!,5:./+81!*2+&!+7,:1+3!6:!&:01+!
3-+!6:!62+!B3:14>+B)!3-5460:&)!4&3!9245496+5!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!\+@>@)!,-/1460&>!&:01+)!/:*!
;5+G-+&9<!&:01+])!,45609-/45/<!*2+&!1/++,!01!3016-5.+3!:=+5!,5:/:&>+3!,+50:31@!!%&3++3)!,0/:6!
16-30+1!4&3!5+1+4592!45609/+1!24=+!5+=+4/+3!62+1+!,5:./+81!+7016!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!4&3!62+!
Dfg!5+,:561!-&3+519:5+!62+!0&65-10=+!&46-5+!:;!&:01+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!+720.061L!!&:01+!6246!
01!9:&60&-:-1)!*062!4!,-/1460&>!9245496+5)!*062!4!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!9:8,:&+&6)!4&3!*062!/:&>?6+58!
+7,:1-5+@!!_:01+!*062!62+1+!9245496+5016091!4;;+96!62+!1/++,)!2+4/62)!4&3!48+&060+1!:;!;480/0+1@!!!
!
!
#j!
!
MDM%
!X>=%&Y<ZX>4%>[X@4%WYX=;>U4%
%%
Dfg!3+=+/:,+3!061!!#@9*&!"#$%&V1#)%4#+%$&,"-&71-">%\"''T]!.<!94//0&>!-,:&!+7,+561!;5:8!/+430&>!
5+1+4592!0&1606-60:&1!;5:8!84&<!&460:&1)!5+,5+1+&60&>!62+!30190,/0&+1!:;!49:-16091!4&3!8+3090&+!
4&3!62+!5+/46+3!2+4/62!190+&9+1@!!F1!160,-/46+3!0&!DfgK1!>-03+/0&+1L!
!
"The key milestones of project activities were technical meetings of topic-specific
experts in the field of acoustics, exposure assessment, sleep pathology, accident
epidemiology, immunology, mental health, and health impact assessment. The
experts produced the background papers based on their review of scientific
evidence on the impacts of noise on sleep and health. These background
documents were synthesized into one document proposing health-based
guidelines.
This document was then distributed among the experts and stakeholders for final
peer-review. The final products of the project were discussed at the final meeting
of experts and stakeholders where the consensus on the guideline values was
reached."
[World Health Organization: Regional Office for Europe. Evaluation and Use of
Epidemiological Evidence for Environmental Risk Assessment: Guideline Document.
WHO, 2000, EUR/00/5020369, p 5
http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/74733/E68940.pdf]
!
DfgB1!,5:9+11!:;!3+=+/:,0&>!061!2+4/62!4&3!&:01+!>-03+/0&+1!01!50>:5:-1!4&3!1<16+84609L!
!
"In 2003, the WHO Regional Office for Europe set up a working group of experts to
provide scientific advice to the European Commission and to its Member States for
the development of future legislation and policy action in the area of control and
surveillance of night noise exposure. The review of available scientific evidence on
the health effects of night noise was carried out by an interdisciplinary team who
set out to derive health-based guideline values. The contributions from the
experts were reviewed by the team and integrated into draft reports following
discussion at four technical meetings of the working group. In 2006, all the draft
reports were compiled into a draft document on guidelines for exposure to noise at
night, which was reviewed and commented on by a number of stakeholders and
experts.
At the final conference in Bonn, Germany, on 14 December 2006, representatives
from the working group and stakeholders from industry, government and
nongovernmental organizations reviewed the contents of the draft document
chapter by chapter, discussed several fundamental issues and reached general
agreement on the guideline values and related texts to be presented as
conclusions of the final document of the WHO Night Noise Guidelines for Europe."
S+>4530&>!&:01+!0&30946:51)!!
!
"From the scientific point of view the best criterion for choosing a noise indicator is
its ability to predict an effect. Therefore, for different health end points, different
indicators could be chosen.
Long-term effects such as cardiovascular disorders are more correlated with
indicators summarizing the acoustic situation over a long time period, such as
yearly average of night noise level outside at the façade (Lnight,outside 1), while
instantaneous effects such as sleep disturbance are better with the maximum level
per event (LAmax), such as passage of a lorry, aeroplane or train.
From a practical point of view, indicators should be easy to explain to the public so
that they can be understood intuitively. Indicators should be consistent with
existing practices in the legislation to enable quick and easy application and
enforcement.
Lnight,outside, adopted by the END, is an indicator of choice for both scientific and
practical use. Among currently used indicators for regulatory purposes, LAeq (Aweighted equivalent sound pressure level) and LAmax are useful to predict shortterm or instantaneous health effects.”
!
[World Health Organization: Regional Office for Europe. Evaluation and Use of
Epidemiological Evidence for Environmental Risk Assessment: Guideline Document.
WHO, 2000, EUR/00/5020369, p 17]
#T!
&
Dfg!__N!3019-11+3!62+!:=+5/4,!*062!62+!5+9:88+&3460:&1!;5:8!62+!Dfg!V1#)%4#+%$&,"-&
C"..1+#*;&!"#$%&U]]]&\UTTT])!.+94-1+!1+=+54/!=4/-+1!*+5+!-,346+3!0&!62+!__N!6:!5+;/+96!62+!8:16!
5+9+&6!5+1+4592!;0&30&>1L!
!
"The WHO Guidelines for Community Noise, published in 2000, also address night
noise. As they are based on studies carried out up to 1995 (and a few metaanalyses some years after), important new studies have become available
since then, together with new insights into normal and disturbed sleep.
The currently recommended guideline values of Lnight,outside = 30 dB, 40dB, 55
dB are not directly comparable with the 2000 guideline value of LAmax,inside = 45
dB(A) because the sound level units are different. However, it is clear that new
information since 2000 has made more precise assessment of the risk from night
noise. The thresholds for a number of effects are now known, and this is much
lower than an LAmax,inside of 45 dB.
One important recommendation still stands: there are good reasons for
people to sleep with their windows open, and to prevent sleep
disturbances one should consider the equivalent sound pressure level and
the number of sound events. The present guidelines allow relevant authorities
and stakeholders to do this. Viewed in this way, the present guidelines may be
considered as an extension to, as well as an update of, the 2000 WHO Guidelines
for Community Noise. That also means that the recommendations contained in the
sections on noise management and control of 2000 document can be applied to
the guideline values of this document."
[WHO NNG, p 25
http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0017/43316/E92845.pdf]
[Emphasis added.]
!
DfgB1!945+;-/!4&4/<101!14<1!6246L!
!
"In one of the most sophisticated field studies (Passchier-Vermeer et al (2002)),
increased probability of instantaneous motility was found for events with a
maximum sound level LAmax > 32 dB(A), while in a meta-analysis conscious
awakening was found for events with LAmax > 42 dB(A) (Passchier-Vermeer,
2003). Above their threshold, these effects were found to increase monotonously
as a function of the maximum sound level during a noise event (aircraft noise). It
is important to note that in another recent sophisticated field study (Basner et al.,
2004), the threshold found for EEG awakening was LAmax = 35 dB(A), i.e., only a
little higher than the 32 dB(A) found for noise-induced awakenings. This
strengthens the evidence that noise starts to induce arousals at LAmax values in
the range 30 to 35 dB(A). Given the night-time noise levels to which people are
exposed, these results imply that instantaneous effects are common. Although
most studies concerned aircraft noise, the instantaneous effects can be assumed to
occur at similar levels for different types of transportation.
The above observations can be used as a basis for setting limits with respect to
night-time transportation noise. For transparency, it is useful to distinguish two
steps in choosing actual limits: the first step is the derivation of a health-based
limit, the second step is the derivation of an actual limit that takes into account the
health based limit as well as feasibility arguments. Here we are concerned with
the first step.
When deriving a health based limit, two points need to be considered: the dosedependent effects of a single noise event, and the number of events. With respect
to the dose-dependent effects of a single event, adverse effects can be
distinguished from effects that by themselves need not be adverse but can
contribute to an adverse state. We propose to classify conscious awakenings as an
adverse effect. Conscious awakenings have been estimated to occur at a baseline
rate of 1.8 awakening per night. A substantial increment of conscious awakenings
over this baseline is thought to be adverse. Since in general falling asleep after
!
conscious awakening takes some time, and this latency is longer after noise
induced conscious awakening that will often also induce an emotional reaction
(anger, fear), it will also reduce the time asleep and may affect mood and
functioning next day. Although additional, more sophisticated analyses could be
performed to refine this estimate, we propose LAmax = 42 dB(A) as the currently
best estimate of the threshold for conscious awakening by transportation noise.
This would mean that the No Observed Effect Level (NOELAmax) for transportation
noise events is at most 42 dB(A).
$'!
The most sensitive instantaneous effect that has been studied extensively in field
studies is motility. A single interval with (onset of) noise induced motility by itself
cannot be considered to be adverse. However, noise induced motility is a sign of
arousal, and frequent (micro-)arousal and accompanying sleep fragmentation can
affect mood and functioning next day and lead to a lower rating of the sleep
quality. Therefore, motility is relevant for adverse health effects, but more than a
few intervals with noise induced motility are needed for inducing such effects.
Although additional, more sophisticated analyses could be performed to refine this
estimate, we propose LAmax = 32 dB(A) as the currently best estimate of the
threshold for motility induced by transportation noise. The threshold found for
EEG awakening was LAmax = 35 dB(A), i.e., only a little higher than the 32 dB(A)
found for noise-induced awakenings. This would mean that the No Observed Effect
Level (NOELAmax) for transportation noise events is most likely at most 32 dB(A),
and definitely not higher than 35 dB(A).
It is important to note that the above given NOELAmax ~32 dB(A) and NOELAmax
~ 42 dB(A) are indoor levels, in the sleeping room. Although events below 32
dB(A) are audible, and, hence, further research may show more sensitive effects
than motility, on the basis of the presently available evidence we propose to
assume that NOELAmax = 32 dB(A) and set a health based nighttime noise limit
that is tolerant for transportation noise events with LAmax ~ 32 dB(A). On the
other hand, since adverse health effects need to be prevented by health based
limits and even though vulnerable groups may require lower limits, on the basis of
the presently available evidence we propose to assume that NOELAmax = 42
dB(A) and set a health based night-time noise limit that does not tolerate
transportation noise events with LAmax > 42 dB(A)." [WHO NNG, Ch IV, p 98]
!
Dfg!84C+1!6201!C+<!5+9:88+&3460:&!;:5!2+4/62!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!&0>26!&:01+L!
!
"For the primary prevention of subclinical adverse health effects in the
population related to night noise, it is recommended that the population
should not be exposed to night noise levels greater than 30 dB of
Lnight,outside during the night when most people are in bed. Therefore,
Lnight,outside 30dB is the ultimate target of Night Noise Guideline (NNGL)
to protect the public, including the most vulnerable groups such as
children, the chronically ill and the elderly, from the adverse health effects
of night noise. "
[WHO NNG, p 24] [Emphasis added. Note also that this recommendation is
primarily for transportation noise, which is not pulsating/intermittent like industrial
wind turbine noise; intermittent noise is more disruptive.]
!
%&!6+1608:&<!6:!62+!D019:&10&!i-./09!P+5=09+!e:880110:&!5+>4530&>!4&!4,,/09460:&!;:5!0&3-16504/!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!49:-160904&!S092453!d48+1!+7,/40&+3!62+!30;;+5+&9+1!.+6*++&!62+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!
N-034&9+!"''(!4&3!62+!Dfg!__N!"''T!8:3+/!0&!5+1,+96!6:!1/++,!0&6+5;+5+&9+L!!
!
“The WHO 2007 document states:
“Lnight,outside 30dB is the ultimate target of Night Noise Guideline (NNGL) to
protect the public, including the most vulnerable groups such as children, the
chronically ill and the elderly, from the adverse health effects of night noise.”
The WHO 2009 document states:
The LOAEL of night noise, 40 dBLnight,outside, can be considered a health-based
limit value of the night noise guidelines (NNG) necessary to protect the public,
including most of the vulnerable groups such as children, the chronically ill and the
elderly, from the adverse health effects of night noise”.
!
There is no conflict between the 2007 and 2009 documents: just a different goal.
On the one hand, the 2007 WHO guidelines set 30dBA as the target to protect the
public, while on the other hand, the 2009 WHO guidelines state that 40 dBA should
be considered as the health-based limit value. Limit values are “limits”, not
“targets”. A value of 40dBA is a not-to-exceed-without-risk-of-harm limit."
[James R. Surrebuttal Testimony of Richard R James on Behalf of the Coalition for
Wisconsin Environmental Stewardship. Wisconsin Public Service Commission,
docket 6630-CD-302: Wisconsin Electric Power Company (WEPCO), 28 October
2009, pp SR10 – SR12]
$U!
!
%&!"''U)!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:880110:&!011-+3!061!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+![05+960=+!ZR_[c)!3+640/+3!0&!
['%4(*#+@&*"&*9%&:$$%$$.%+*&?&<(+(@%.%+*&",&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&!"#$%\@!!A2+!ReK1!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+!
[05+960=+!1++C1!6:!“achieve a high level of health and environmental protection.”&&%&6+>54/!6:!
6201!>:4/!01!“protection against noise. In the Green Paper on Future Noise Policy, the
Commission addressed noise in the environment as one of the main environmental problems
in Europe.”
!
%&!061!S+1:/-60:&!:;!U'!d-&+!UTT()!62+!R-5:,+4&!i45/048+&6&&
&
“urged that specific measures and initiatives should be laid down in a Directive on
the reduction of environmental noise, and noted the lack of reliable, comparable
data regarding the situation of the various noise sources.”
Moreover, the Directive would act as a basis for “measures concerning noise
emitted by the major sources, in particular... infrastructure… and industrial
equipment... and for developing additional measures, in the short, medium and
long term.” The Directive also notes that it is essential to “establish common
assessment methods for ‘environmental noise’ and a definition for ‘limit values’, in
terms of harmonized indicators for the determination of noise levels…”
[Environmental Noise Directive 2002/49/EC, 25 June 2001]
&
A2+!Re!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+![05+960=+!*:5C1!0&!9:&9+56!*062!62+!Dfg!&:01+!>-03+/0&+1)!84C0&>!
-1+!:;!DfgK1!8-/6030190,/0&45<)!0&6+5&460:&4/!+7,+5601+)!061!:&>:0&>!+;;:561!6:!,5:=03+!>-034&9+!
.41+3!:&!9-55+&6!C&:*/+3>+)!4&3!061!0&9/-10:&!:;!0&3-165<!4&3!>:=+5&8+&6!,:/09<!4&3!3+9010:&!
84C+51!6:!43=01+!:&!,54>84609!41,+961!:;!061!>-034&9+L!
!
“The WHO Regional Office for Europe set up a working group of experts to provide
scientific advice to Member States for the development of future legislation and
policy action in the area of assessment and control of night noise exposure. The
working group reviewed available scientific evidence on the health effects of night
noise, and derived health-based guideline values. In December 2006, the working
group and stakeholders from industry, government and nongovernmental
organizations reviewed and reached general agreement on the guidance values
and key texts for the final document of the Night noise guidance for Europe…
Considering the scientific evidence on the thresholds of night noise exposure…
These guidelines are applicable to the Member States of the European Region, and
may be considered as an extension to, as well as an update of, the previous WHO
Guidelines for community noise (1999).”
&
A2+!Dfg!__N!"''T!9/+45/<!,5:=03+1!62+!>-034&9+!:&!V/08061K!5+;+55+3!6:!.<!62+!R&=05:&8+&64/!
_:01+![05+960=+!\R_[]L!
!
“The selected common noise indicators are Lden, to assess annoyance, and Lnight,
to assess sleep disturbance.
Article 1 ‘Objectives’
(1) The aim of this Directive shall be to define a common approach intended to
avoid, prevent or reduce on a prioritized basis the harmful effects, including
annoyance, due to exposure to environmental noise. To that end the following
actions shall be implemented progressively:
(c) adoption of action plans by Member States, based upon noise-mapping results,
with a view to preventing and reducing environmental noise where necessary and
particularly where exposure levels can induce harmful effects on human health and
to preserving environmental noise quality where it is good.
!
(2) This Directive shall also aim at providing a basis for developing Community
measures to reduce noise emitted by the major sources, in particular...industrial
equipment and...
Article 2 ‘Scope’
(1) This Directive shall apply to environmental noise to which humans are
exposed in particular... in quiet areas in open country... and other noise-sensitive
buildings and areas.
Article 3 ‘Definitions’
(b) ‘harmful effects’ shall mean negative effects on human health.
(j) ‘dose-effect relation’ shall mean the relationship between the value of a noise
indicator and a harmful effect.
(m) ‘quiet area in open country’ shall mean an area, delimited by the competent
authority, that is undisturbed by noise from traffic, industry or recreational
activities.
Article 6 ‘Assessment methods’
(3) Harmful effects may be assessed by means of the dose-effect relations referred
to in Annex III.
Article 8 ‘Action plans’
(1) Member States shall ensure that no later than 18 July 2008 the competent
authorities have drawn up action plans designed to manage, within their
territories, noise issues and effects, including noise reduction if necessary for (b)
such plans shall also aim to protect quiet areas against an increase in noise.
Article 11 ‘Review and reporting’
(2) (c) the protection of quiet areas in open country.
Annex III Assessment Methods for Harmful Effects.
Dose-effects – the relation between sleep disturbance and Lnight for...
Industrial noise.
If necessary, specific dose-effect relations could be presented for:
-dwellings with a quiet facade as defined in Annex VI
-vulnerable groups of the population
-tonal industrial noise
-impulsive industrial noise and other special cases.”
$"!
$#!
!
MDQ%
!X>=%&Y<ZX>4%>[X@42%%WYX=;>U4%7<[U4@@&
!
A2+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!4&3!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!30;;+5!1-.164&604//<!:&!62+!8+62:31!-1+3!
4&3!62+!,+51:&&+/!0&=:/=+3!*062!1+660&>!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!>-03+/0&+1!0&!4&!+;;:56!6:!,5:6+96!
,+:,/+!4&3!5+3-9+!62+05!+7,:1-5+!6:!62+!501C!:;!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961@!
!
`:5!061!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!>-03+/0&+1)!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!\Dfg]!5+/0+1!:&!
0&6+5&460:&4/!+7,+561!0&!62+05!;0+/31!:;!1,+904/6<)!*2:!4&4/<1+!9-55+&6!5+1+4592!;0&30&>1)!4&3!*2:!
;0&3!,54>84609!1:/-60:&1!6246!,:/09<!4&3!3+9010:&!84C+51!94&!4,,/<@!!!
!
A2+!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6!4,,+451!6:!5+/<!4/8:16!+&605+/<!:&!9:&1-/64&61!6:!4&3!+8,/:<++1!:;!62+!*0&3!
+&+5><!0&3-165<!6:!43=01+!>:=+5&8+&6!,:/09<!4&3!3+9010:&!84C+51)!41!*+//!41!6:!,5+,45+!*0&3!
+&+5><!4&3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!>-034&9+@!!A2+5+!01!&:!0&309460:&!:5!8+&60:&!6246!8+3094/!+7,+561!
*+5+!9:&1-/6+3)!&:5!01!62+5+!4&<!0&309460:&!6246!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!0&6+5=0+*+3!
;:5!4&<!:;!62+1+!9:&1-/6460:&1@!!P+/;?5+>-/460:&!0&=4504./<!,5:3-9+1!5+>-/460:&!6246!*+0>21!2+4=0/<!
0&!;4=:-5!:;!6246!,45609-/45!0&3-165<)!:;6+&!46!4!9:16!6:!62+!,-./09!X!&:6!&+9+11450/<!;0&4&904/)!41!6201!
,4,+5!3+8:&16546+1@!!F1!4!,:0&6!:;!9:8,4501:&)!:&+!84<!41C!0;!62+!>:=+5&8+&6!*:-/3!,+5806!62+!
,245849+-6094/!0&3-165<!62+!148+!:,,:56-&06<!;:5!1+/;?5+>-/460:&)!*062:-6!4,,5:,5046+!
0&3+,+&3+&6!:=+510>26!.<!8-/6030190,/0&45<!,4&+/1!:;!+7,+561@!
!
P+=+&6++&!-&0=+5106<!4&3!5+1+4592!>5:-,1!;5:8!6*+/=+!R-5:,+4&!9:-&650+1!9:&650.-6+3!6:!62+!
Dfg!__N!5+,:56)!41!*+//!41!4!&-8.+5!:;!&:6+*:562<!0&30=03-4/1)!4//!*062!+7,+5601+!0&!62+05!;0+/31)!
4&3!84&<!*062!/:&>!4&3!30160&>-012+3!945++51!0&!62+05!30190,/0&+1@!!
!
i456!:;!62+!Dfg!,5:9+11!0&!3+=010&>!62+!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!0&9/-3+3!62+1+!16+,1L!
!
“The key milestone of project activities were technical meetings of topic-specific
experts in the field of acoustics, exposure assessment, sleep pathology, accident
epidemiology, immunology, mental health, and health impact assessment. The
experts produced the background papers based on their review of scientific
evidence on the impacts of noise on sleep and health. These background
documents were synthesized into one document proposing health-based
guidelines. This document was then distributed among the experts and
stakeholders for final peer-review. The final products of the project were
discussed at the final meeting of experts and stakeholders where the consensus on
the guideline values was reached.” [WHO NNG, S.1.0, p 6]
!
%&!1645C!9:&65416)!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!9:&=+&+3!62+![60!_:01+!D:5C0&>!N5:-,)!*2:1+!U$!8+8.+51!
5+,5+1+&6+3!840&/<!62:1+!*062!4!=+16+3!0&6+5+16!0&!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,8+&6h!0@+@)!U!8+8.+5!;5:8!
>:=+5&8+&6)!#!;5:8!/:94/!>:=+5&8+&6!\U!&:*!*062!&,:*+5])!U!;5:8!4!;058!:;!1:/0906:51!\*2:!*41!
4/1:!P+95+645<!6:!S+&+*4./+EQ)!62+&!C&:*&!41!MDRF])!O!;5:8!*0&3!+&+5><!3+=+/:,8+&6!
9:8,4&0+1)!"!49:-1609!9:&1-/64&61!6:!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<)!4&3!U!;5:8!4!,2<1091!/4.:546:5<@!!
ZRAPE?S?T()!i5+;49+)!,!0c!!!
!
RAPE!3+1950.+3!061!;:5846!4&3!;:58-/4+L!
!
“.... in August 1993, the DTI [Department of Trade and Industry], facilitated the
establishment of a Working Group on Noise from Wind Turbines, consisting of
experts with experience in the environmental assessment of noise from wind
turbines. The objectives of the NWG were:
To define recent experience in the field of wind turbine noise. This was to include
an attempt to relate measured data to complaints and provide an expert
assessment of the issues relating to wind turbine noise.
To define a framework which can be used to measure and rate the noise from wind
turbines...
To provide indicative noise levels thought to offer a reasonable degree of
protection to wind farm neighbours and encourage best practice in turbine design
and wind farm siting and layout.
To encourage the widespread adoption of the Working Groups recommendations.”
!
[ETSU-R-97, Introduction, p 1]
$$!
!
%&!62+!C&:*/+3>+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!6:!;480/<!2:8+1!94-1+!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1!4&3!
:62+5!0&I-50+1!6:!2+4/62)!,-./09!:;;0904/1!4,,+45!6:!24=+!4,,5:492+3!62+!,5:./+8!.<!41C0&>!
49:-160904&1!;5:8!62+!*0&3!0&3-165<!6:!3+10>&!62+05!:*&!5+>-/460:&1)!*2092!,5:=03+3!1:8+!3+>5++!
:;!&:01+!,5:6+960:&!6:!&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1!.-6!303!&:6!,/49+!V-&5+41:&4./+K!5+1650960:&1!:&!*0&3!
;458!3+=+/:,8+&6@!!A201!*41!+G-0=4/+&6!6:!4&!V:,+&!92+G-+K!;:5!1+/;?5+>-/460:&h!4&3!*2:!94&!./48+!
62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!;:5!,5:9-50&>!4!>-034&9+!6246!,+58061!20>2!&:01+!+80110:&!;5:8!62+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!*20/+!,5:=030&>!4!8:3+16!3+>5++!:;!,5:6+960:&!;:5!&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1@!!A2+!*0&3!
+&+5><!0&3-165<!.+&+;061!.<!/:9460&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1)!62+5+.<!
84708010&>!3+=+/:,8+&6!:;!106+1)!4//!*0620&!/+>4/!8+924&0181@!!F6!62+!148+!608+)!,-./09!:;;0904/1!3:!
&:6!4,,+45!6:!24=+!9:&1-/6+3!8+3094/!+7,+561!0&!:53+5!6:!1-,,:56!+=:/=0&>!>-034&9+@!!A2-1)!:&+!01!
/+3!6:!9:&9/-3+!6246!,-./09!:;;0904/1!45+!8:5+!9:&9+5&+3!*062!4920+=0&>!*0&3!+&+5><!645>+61!5462+5!
624&!+&1-50&>!6246!&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1!45+!,5:6+96+3!;5:8!62+!2458!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!
,://-60:&@!!A2+!RAPE!N-034&9+!,5:3-9+3!6<,094/!_:01+!e:&3060:&1!6246!12:-/3!4,,/<!6:!i/4&&0&>!
i+580110:&1)!.-6!0&!,549601+)!/:94/!9:-&90/!R&=05:&8+&64/!f+4/62!g;;09+51)!;49+3!*062!4!;480/<!
9/+45/<!1-;;+50&>!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!24=+!;:-&3!06!&+45/<!08,:110./+!6:!64C+!4960:&!4&3!
5+3-9+!62+!&:01+!+80110:&)!.+94-1+!0&=4504./<)!:&106+!8+41-5+8+&61!:;!&:01+!14601;<!62+!RAPE!
9:&3060:&1@!
!
A2+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!"''T!84C+!6201!'%8"..%+)(*#"+&,"-&5%(4*9&J-"*%8*#"+L!
!
"Sleep is an essential part of human functioning and is recognised as a
fundamental right under the European Convention on Human Rights, (Article
8.1)...
For the primary prevention of subclinical adverse health effects in the population
related to night noise, it is recommended that the population should not be
exposed to night noise levels greater than 30 dB of Lnight,outside during the night
when most people are in bed. Therefore, Lnight,outside 30 dB is the ultimate
target of Night Noise Guidance (NNGL) to protect the public, including the most
vulnerable groups such as children, the chronically ill and the elderly, from the
adverse health effects of night noise.” [WHO NNG, p 23-24]
&
%&!1645C!9:&65416)!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!e:&65496:51)!RAPE)!1646+L!
!
"This document describes a framework for the measurement of wind farm noise
and gives indicative noise levels thought to offer a reasonable degree of
protection to wind farm neighbours, without placing unreasonable
restrictions on wind farm development or adding unduly to the costs and
administrative burdens on wind farm developers or local authorities.
The recommendation of the NWG is that, generally, the noise limits should be set
relative to existing background noise at nearest noise sensitive properties and that
the limits should reflect the variation in both turbine source noise and background
noise with wind speed. We have also considered whether the low noise limits
which this could imply in particularly quiet areas are appropriate and have
concluded that it is not necessary to use a margin above background approach in
such low-noise environments. This would be unduly restrictive on
developments which are recognised as having wider and global benefits.
Such low limits are, in any event, not necessary in order to offer a reasonable
degree of protection to the wind farm neighbour."
[ETSU-R-97, Executive Summary, Introduction] [Emphasis added.]
!
Dfg!84C+1!061!5+9:88+&3460:&!.41+3!:&!62+!+=03+&9+!:;!62+!2+4/62!+;;+961!:;!&0>26!&:01+!:&!
,+:,/+@!!Dfg!&:6+1!6246!#"3M!01!62+!625+12:/3!\kF!847!0&103+]!;:5!62+!.0:/:>094/!:&1+6!:;!V8:60/06<Kh!
#O3M!01!62+!625+12:/3!\kF!847!0&103+]!46!*2092!62+!.0:/:>094/!+;;+96!:;!RRN!4*4C+&0&>!:99-51h!4&3!
$"3M!01!62+!625+12:/3!\kF!847!0&103+]!46!*2092!‘waking up in the night and/or too early in the
morning’&64C+!,/49+@!!!
!
A2+5+;:5+)!Dfg!1+61!4!84708-8!&0>26608+)!:-6103+!645>+6!:;!#'!3M!\k&0>26)!:-6103+]@!!A201!645>+6!
9:=+51!4//!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+)!;:5!4//!1:-59+1)!+@>@)!0&3-16504/)!9:88+5904/)!8:6:5*4<)!:5!405,:56@!!
ZDfg!__N)!"''T)!92!#@")!,!$Tc!
$O!
!
!
%&!9:&65416)!62+!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6!4,,5:492!4,,+451!6:!.+!9:8,460./+!:&/<!*062!62+!;0&4&904/!>:4/1!:;!
62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,+5L!!V*246!01!62+!84708-8!&:01+!*+!94&!>+6!4*4<!*062!*062:-6!95:110&>!
62+!625+12:/3!:;!650>>+50&>!+7,+&10=+!&-014&9+!/060>460:&!9/4081K@!!A201!=0+*!01!0//-16546+3!G-06+!
9/+45/<!*0620&!RAPE?S?T(!061+/;L!!
!
“indicative noise levels thought to offer reasonable degree of protection
to wind farm neighbours, without placing unreasonable restrictions on wind
farm development..." And: “This would be unduly restrictive on
developments which are recognised as having wider national and global
benefits.”
[ETSU-R-97, p v & p 11]
%
g&+!80>26!=+5<!*+//!41C)!*2:!160,-/46+3!6246!62+5+!45+!V*03+5!.+&+;061Ks!!D246!,5+901+/<!01!62+!
501Ca.+&+;06!4&4/<101!-,:&!*2092!62+!4-62:51!24=+!5+/0+3s!!A2+5+!01!&:!190+&60;09!+=03+&9+!6:!
1-,,:56!6201!1646+8+&6!:62+5!624&!03+:/:><!:5!1:/+/<!+&65+,5+&+-504/!0&6+5+161@!!D20/+!4&!
0&6+5&460:&4/!4>5++8+&6!+70161!6:!+&9:-54>+!,:*+5!>+&+5460:&!;5:8!&:&?945.:&!;-+/1)!62+5+!01!&:!
+=03+&9+!6246!*0&3!+&+5><!01!4&<!.+66+5!:5!92+4,+5!624&!:62+5!4/6+5&460=+1@!!A2+!;496!5+840&1!6246!
*0&3!+&+5><!3:+1!&:6!,5:=03+!4!1+9-5+)!:&?3+84&3)!,5+30964./+)!4&3!5+/04./+!;/:*!:;!+/+9650906<!
.+94-1+!06!3+,+&31!:&!62+!*+462+5!;:5!62+!*0&3!1-,,/<h!1:8+608+1!62+!*0&3!01!&:&?+7016+&6)!6::!
*+4C)!:5!6::!,:*+5;-/)!4&3!62+!*0&3!01!4/*4<1!-&,5+30964./+L!!
!
“The nature of wind output has been obscured by reliance on “average output”
figures. Analysis of hard data from National Grid shows that wind behaves in a
quite different manner from that suggested by study of average output derived
from the Renewable Obligation Certificates (ROCs) record, or from wind speed
records which in themselves are averaged. It is clear from this analysis that wind
cannot be relied upon to provide any significant level of generation at any defined
time in the future. There is an urgent need to re-evaluate the implications of
reliance on wind for any significant proportion of our energy requirement.”
[John Muir Trust. Analysis of UK Wind Power Generation, November 2008 December 2010. Published March 2011 www.jmt.org]
“Centrica and other energy companies last week told DECC (Dept Energy and
Climate Change) that, if Britain is to spend £100 billion on building thousands of
wind turbines, it will require the building of 17 new gas-fired power stations simply
to provide back-up for all those times when the wind drops and the windmills
produce even less power than usual.” This would necessitate “an additional £10
billion on those dedicated power stations which will be kept running on ‘spinning
reserve’, 24 hours a day… This will add billions more to our fuel bills for no
practical purpose. The other absurdity, as recent detailed studies have confirmed,
is that gas-fired power stations running on ‘spinning reserve’ chuck out much more
CO2 than when they are running at full efficiency – thus negating any savings in
CO2 emissions…”
[Booker C. Proof that the PM is tilting at windmills, Sunday Telegraph, 3 July
2011]
!
A2+!6:64/!0&1+9-506<)!-&,5+30964.0/06<)!4&3!-&5+/04.0/06<!:;!5+/<0&>!:&!*0&3!,:*+5!;:5!+/+9650906<!01!
3+640/+3!0&!4!5+,:56!.<!62+!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!ZSR`c)!NR"B&/#+)&J"B%-&Q1*>1*&#+&U]Y]6&
:+&3+,"-.(*#"+&!"*%NL!
!
"Variability over short time scales has been much discussed, and it is now well
known that low wind conditions can prevail at times of peak load over very large
areas. For example, at 1730 on the 7th December 2010, when the 4th highest UK
load of 60,050 MW was recorded, the UK fleet of approximately 5,200 MW was
producing about 300 MW (i.e., it had a load factor of 5.8%).
At the same time load factors in Germany were 3% and Denmark 4%. One of the
largest wind farms in the UK, the 32 MW Whitelee Farm was producing
approximately 5MW (i.e., a load factor of 1.6%). Such figures confirm theoretical
arguments that regardless of the size of the wind fleet, the UK will never be able to
reduce its conventional generation fleet below peak load plus a margin of 10%.”
[Dr J Constable and Dr L Moroney. Low Wind Power Output in 2010: An
Information Note. Renewable Energy Foundation, 2 February 2011]
!
!
g&!"!d4&-45<!"'UU)!09%&E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9!5+,:56+3!6246!3-50&>!4!,45609-/45/<!24512!*0&65<!1,+//L!!
$W!
“Last Thursday night the amount of electricity supplied to the National Grid by
wind turbines was again a mere ‘one thousandth’ of the total. Again we (UK) are
importing 40 times that much power from France generated by nuclear reactors.”
[Gray L. Wind farms becalmed just when needed the most. Daily Telegraph 2
January 2011]
!
F99:530&>!6:!4!5+9+&6!45609/+!0&!09%&0#.%$!\EQ])!
!
“The research, published by the Committee on Climate Change, calls into question
the Government’s decision to rely heavily on wind turbines for future energy. The
committee said changes in wind speeds could undermine progress towards having
legally-binding targets to cut emissions. Heatwaves and cold snaps tend to cause
wind speeds to drop close to zero and are expected to occur more frequently as
the average temperature rises. At 5.30pm on December 7 last year, when the
country was blanketed in snow and demand for electricity was at its fourth-highest
level recorded, wind farms produced only 0.4 per cent of the power needed. On a
windy day they can supply up to 10 per cent. The average wind speed can also
vary sharply from year to year, with Britain’s 274 onshore wind farms operating at
only 21.4 per cent of their maximum potential capacity last year, compared with
27.4 per cent in 2009.”
[Webster B. Climate Change Could ‘Lead to Rise in Coal Power Plants’. The Times
15 July 2011]
!
i5:;+11:5!d48+1!k:=+/:9C)!ef)!eMR)!`SP)!4&!+45/<!4&3!45609-/46+!+&=05:&8+&64/016!4&3!95+46:5!:;!
62+!N404!2<,:62+101)!9:&6+&31!6246!8:3+5&!&-9/+45!+&+5><!,/4&61!&:6!:&/<!45+!184//+5)!14;+5)!4&3!
8:5+!+;;090+&6!624&!:/3+5!;490/060+1)!62+<!4/1:!,5:3-9+!4!,5+30964./+)!5+/04./+)!4&3!1+9-5+!;/:*!:;!
+/+9650906<@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+1+!8:3+5&!&-9/+45!+&+5><!;490/060+1!94&!8++6!+/+9650906<!3+84&31!46!4&!
4;;:534./+!9:16!6:!62+!&460:&!4&3!8++6!+&=05:&8+&64/!164&34531)!0@+@)!*062:-6!945.:&!+80110:&1@!!!
ZA2+!5+9+&6!4&3!654>09!+4562G-4C+)!61-&480)!4&3!+&1-0&>!&-9/+45!,/4&6!,5:./+81!0&!d4,4&!3:!&:6!
-&3+580&+!62+!45>-8+&6!0&!1-,,:56!:;!&-9/+45!+&+5><@!!P++!H:&.0:6!N@!!A2+!E&,4/464./+!A5-62!01!
6246!62+!F&60?_-9/+45!k:..<!241!H01/+3!E1!F//@!!09%&V1(-)#(+)!O!F,50/!"'UUh!4&3!M/49C!!S@!!
`-C-12084L!F1!M43!41!e2+5&:.</s!!HHC&!%B$)!U"!F,50/!"'UU!266,Laa***@..9@9:@-Ca&+*1a190+&9+?
+&=05:&8+&6?U#'$jTUW!!499+11+3!U$!F,50/!"'UU@!!P++!4/1:!4&!0&6+5=0+*!*062!d:2&!S0692)![05+96:5!
N+&+54/!:;!62+!D:5/3!_-9/+45!F11:90460:&)!d-/<!"'UU)!266,Laa56@9:8a,5:>5481a0&6+5=0+*a+&+5><?
;-C-12084?&-9/+45?+7,+56a!]!
!
d-16!.+94-1+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!&:6!106+3!0&!8:5+!,:,-/:-1!-5.4&!45+41)!62+5+!5+840&1!&:!&460:&4/!
.+&+;06!6246!I-160;0+1!30195080&460&>!4>40&16!5-54/!;480/0+1!X!+@>@)!;480/0+1!*062!920/35+&h!62+!;540/)!0//!
:5!=-/&+54./+h!62+!+/3+5/<!X!4&3!3+10>&460&>!62+8!41!B+7,+&34./+B!:5!B9://46+54/!3484>+B!6:!4&!
45.06545<!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+6@!!A2+5+!01!&:!&460:&4/!.+&+;06!6246!I-160;0+1!30195080&460&>!4>40&16!
5-54/!;480/0+1!4&3!+7,:10&>!62+8!6:!1-1640&+3!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:8:6+!:&+!;:58!:;!
0&3-16504/!6+92&:/:><!X!:,+5460&>!"$a()!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!62+05!2:8+1)!41!62+![+,4568+&6!:;!
R&+5><!4&3!e/0846+!e24&>+!466+8,61!6:!8++6!4&!45.06545<!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+6!.<!,5:8:60&>!
*0&3!+&+5><@!!A2+!19466+512:6!+;;+96!:;!6201!4,,5:492!.<!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!01!+=03+&9+3!.<!62+!
/45>+!&-8.+5!:;!:&12:5+!*0&3!;4581!6246!45+!62+!1-.I+96!:;!&:01+!9:8,/40&61!;5:8!&+0>2.:-50&>!
;480/0+1)!6*+&6<?1+=+&!106+1)!499:530&>!6:!+=03+&9+!;5:8!62+!P4/;:53!S+,:56!"''()!62:->2!:62+5!
;0>-5+1!1->>+16!62056<?107!106+1!41!1:-59+1!:;!9:8,/40&6@!!!
ZN54<!k@!!_:01+!e:8,/40&61!4.:-6!g&+!0&!P07!D0&3!`4581@!!E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9!W!H4592!"'U'h!4&3!!
:+(4;$#$&",&/#+)&=(-.$&B#*9&!"#$%&C".>4(#+*$&2($%)&"+&*9%&D(4,"-)&'%>"-*A!!v9+/!1,5+4312++6h!1++!
62+!M0./0:>54,2<!;:5!62+!/0&C1!6:!e:&164./+)!d!4&3!H:5:&+<!k@![464!:.640&+3!-&3+5!62+!`5++3:8!:;!
%&;:58460:&!F96L!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!e:8,/40&6!P-5=+<![464!e://+96+3!.<!62+!E&0=+5106<!:;!P4/;:53!
-&3+5!9:&65496!6:!62+![+,4568+&6!:;!M-10&+11)!R&6+5,501+!4&3!S+>-/46:5<!S+;:58L!S+1+4592!0&6:!
F+5:3<&4809!H:3-/460:&!:;!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!ES_!'(aU"#O@!!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!
\SR`])!k:&3:&)!EQ)!W!`+.5-545<!"''T@c!
!
A2+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1)!3+10>&+3!;:5!,:/09<?!4&3!3+9010:&?84C+51)!5+9:88+&3!4!
8+41-5+8+&6!6246!4=+54>+1!4//!&0>261!;:5!:&+!<+45)!+492!&0>26!9:-&60&>!41!j!2:-51)!k)&0>26)0&3::51!
\3+50=+3!;5:8!k)&0>26!:-6103+h!1++!62+!R7+9-60=+!P-8845<!v%p!4&3!62+!RE!3+;0&060:&![05+960=+!
"''"a$T]@!!!f:*+=+5)!6201!;:58-/4!3:+1!&:6!,5:=03+!62+!9:&65:/!&++3+3!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!
0&103+!62+!2:8+@!!D0&3!6-5.0&+1!,5:3-9+!+/+9650906<!:&/<!*2+&!62+!*0&3!01!./:*0&>)!*2092!01!
$(!
!
-1-4//<!*2+&!62+!84I:5!&:01+!+=+&61!:99-5@!!%&!433060:&)!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!94&!5-&!46!30;;+5+&6!8:3+1!
4&3!62+!&:01+!+80110:&1!84<!924&>+!46!1080/45!*0&3!1,++31!3+,+&30&>!-,:&!62+!8:3+@!!D0&3!
12+45)!*2092!/+431!6:!48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&!\FH])!01!0&;/-+&9+3!.<!>5:-&3!4&3!*+462+5!9:&3060:&1)!
+@>@)!6+8,+546-5+!0&=+510:&1!46!&0>26)!0&95+410&>!62+!&:01+!/+=+/1)!95+460&>!62+!9245496+501609!
V62-8,0&>K!&:01+@!
!
`:5!62+1+!5+41:&1)!64C0&>!62+!j!2:-5!&0>26/<!&:01+!5+430&>1!;:5!:&+!<+45)!4&3!62+&!4=+54>0&>!62+1+!
;0&30&>1)!*0//!&:6!499-546+/<!5+,5+1+&6!62+!&:01+!08,496!:&!62+!.+35::8!46!&0>26!&:5!62+!
3:1+a+7,:1-5+!+7,+50+&9+3@!
!
f:*+=+5)!Dfg!.41+1!061!;:58-/4!:&!62+!&++3!6:!03+&60;<!62+!3M\F]!/+=+/!:;!&:01+!+=+&61!6246!650>>+5!
1/++,!3016-5.4&9+)!4&3!62+1+!/+=+/1!:;!3M\F]!309646+!62+!8+62:3:/:><!4&3!62+!4//:*4./+!/+=+/1!4&3!
3:14>+!6246!12:-/3!&:6!.+!+79++3+3!0&!62+!.+35::8!46!&0>26!*062!62+!*0&3:*!,45604//<!:,+&@!!
!
P0>&0;094&6/<)!62+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!84C+!62+!,:0&6!6246!+=+&!*2+&!46!4!20>2+5!3M\F]!
/+=+/!624&!62+!,://-60&>!&:01+)!#.-'(.,%).6VF(0'#$%#0"+*%G",,%#0-%1.+V%-3*%80,,'-"#F%#0"+*%"5%
-3*!80,,'-"#F%#0"+*%3.+%.%$"55*(*#-%5(*]'*#6C%60180+"-"0#%-3.#%-3*%).6VF(0'#$%#0"+*@!!
ZR7+9-60=+!P-8845<!v%%%)!VA25+12:/3!;:5!:.1+5=+3!+;;+961Kc!!\U@#@W@]!!A2+1+!45+!62+!654061!6246!
3+1950.+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!*2092!241!.:62!4!,-/1460&>!9245496+5!4&3!4!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!9:8,:&+&6)!
*2092!45+!&:6!841C+3!.<!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+)!,45609-/45/<!0&!4!5-54/!4&3!654&G-0/!+&=05:&8+&6@!
!
A2+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!&:6+!6246L!
!
“If negative effects on sleep are to be avoided the equivalent sound pressure level
should not exceed 30 dBA indoors for continuous noise...”
ZR3@!&:6+L!!i5+=0:-1!+=03+&9+!+7,/40&+3!6246!:&9+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!,:*+5!-,)!62+!&:01+!01!
9:&60&-:-1)!*062!4!,-/1460&>)!8:3-/460&>!9245496+5@c!!!
!
A2+!Dfg!__N!9:8,/+8+&6!62+!Dfg!C"..1+#*;&!"#$%&V1#)%4#+%$&YZZZ!\,-./012+3!0&!"'''])!.-6!
62+!__N!-1+!62+!8:5+!9-55+&6!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!;0&30&>1!41!62+!.4101!;:5!-,3460&>!1:8+!
3+640/1L&!
!
“The 1999 guidelines are based on studies carried out up to 1995 (and a few
meta-analyses some years later). Important new studies (Passchier-Vermeer et
al. 2002; Basner et al, 2004) have become available since then, together with new
insights into normal and disturbed sleep. New information has made more precise
assessment of exposure-effect relationship. The thresholds are now known to be
lower than LA max of 45 dB for a number of effects. The last three sentences
stand... Viewed in this way, the night noise guidelines for Europe are
complimentary to the 1999 guidelines. This means that the recommendations on
government policy framework on noise management elaborated in the 1999
guidelines should be considered valid and relevant for the Member States to
achieve the guideline values of this document.”
[WHO NNG 2009: Executive Summary XVIII, ‘Relation with the Guidelines for
Community Noise 1999']
!
!
!/[%W'"$*,"#*+%6018.(*$%-0%-3*%Y^%4&@Y%W'"$.#6*%
%
RAPE)!62+!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6!9:&65496:51)!92:1+!4!8+62:3:/:><!6246!,/49+3!/08061!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!:=+5!4!54&>+!:;!*0&3!1,++31!-,!6:!U"8a1!*2+&!8+41-5+3!46!4!2+0>26!:;!U'8!46!62+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!106+@!!ZRAPE?S?T()!,@!=!U'c!!A201!8+62:3!:;!8+41-5+8+&6!95+46+1!84&<!:;!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!,5:./+81!5+;+55+3!6:!.<!H0924+/!P60>*::3!:;!HFP)!4&3![4=03!e:9C1)!oe)!0&!62+!+=03+&9+!
,5+1+&6+3!6:!62+!A25++!H::51!i/4&&0&>!%&G-05<)!3019-11+3!0&!P@"@U)!,,!#'?##@!
!
RAPE!>-034&9+!14<1!6246!&:01+!;5:8!62+!*0&3!;458!12:-/3!.+!/0806+3!6:!O3M!4.:=+!.49C>5:-&3!
&:01+!;:5!.:62!34<!4&3!&0>26608+@!!\RAPE!,@!=00!"U]!!f:*+=+5)!6201!411-8+1!6246!V.49C>5:-&3!&:01+K!
841C1!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!-,!6:!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+!/+=+/@!!M-6!41!&:6+3!4.:=+)!62+!Dfg!__N!14<1!
6246!01!&:6!4!=4/03!411-8,60:&!*2+&!62+!,://-60&>!&:01+!241!4!30;;+5+&6!9:8,:1060:&h!433060:&4//<L!
!
“The rule of thumb that a noise can be considered masked if the signal is 10 dB
below background is only valid if the noises have the same frequency composition
!
and if they actually occur at the same time. This is particularly important to stress
where LA eq levels are compared...”
[WHO NNG, Background Level, 2009, Ch. 1 S.1.3.6]
$j!
!
A2+!RAPE!4,,5:492!411-8+1!62+!&:01+!+80110:&!01!46!62+!9+&65+!:;!62+!6-5.0&+!8:6:5)!0@+@!62+!
&49+//+!:5!2-.!2+0>26@!!f:*+=+5)!6201!01!&:6!62+!941+@!!%&!;496)!62+!&:01+!1:-59+1!45+!62+!./43+!60,1!
4&3!62+!+&605+!1*++,!:;!62+!6-5.0&+!./43+1)!*2092!;:5!8:3+5&!6-5.0&+1!94&!.+!-,!6:!UU)'''!1G!
8+65+1)!4&3!4!1*+,6!2+0>26!6:!UW'!8+65+1@!!R1608460&>!4!&:01+!080110:&!46!4!2:8+!UC8!30164&9+!01!
/0C+/<!6:!.+!10>&0;094&6/<!30;;+5+&6!9:8,450&>!4!,:0&6!1:-59+!+1608460&>!+80110:&!46!U''8!20>2!*062!
4!1*+,6!45+4!+80110:&!:;!UU)'''!1G!8+65+1!-,!6:!4!2+0>26!:;!UW'!8+65+1!\O"'!;++6]@!!!
ZH4C45+*09Y!S@!!%1!4!D0&3!A-5.0&+!4!i:0&6!P:-59+s!!dFPF!M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!
`+.!"'UUhU"T\"]L!O(T?OjUc!
!
R&;:590&>!&:01+!9:&3060:&1!.41+3!:&!62+!RAPE!>-034&9+!01!30;;09-/6!.+94-1+!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!8-16!
.+!,:*+5+3!3:*&!0&!:53+5!6:!8+41-5+!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+!0&!4!=450+6<!:;!*+462+5!9:&3060:&1)!4&3!
62+&!;-//<!,:*+5+3!-,!4>40&!6:!64C+!;-562+5!8+41-5+8+&61@!!H:5+:=+5)!./43+!4&>/+1!4&3!&49+//+!
305+960:&1!4/1:!0&;/-+&9+!5+1-/61)!4&3!6201!01!;-562+5!9:8,/0946+3!*2+&!499:-&60&>!;:5!4&!4554<!:;!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!.+94-1+!62+!=:5609+1!\405!6-5.-/+&9+]!95+46+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!./43+1!4/1:!0&6+5496!0&!
924&>0&>!,466+5&1L!!!
!
“It is well known that when wind turbines are deployed in large arrays, their
efficiency decreases due to complex interactions among themselves and with the
atmospheric boundary layer (ABL).”
[Calaf M, Meneveau C, and Meyers J. Large eddy simulation study of fully
developed wind-turbine array boundary layers. Physics of Fluids
2010;22(1):015110-01--115110-16]
!
H+&+=+4-)!:;!d:2&1!f:,C0&1!E&0=+5106<!\EPF])!4&3!H+<+51)!:;!Q462:/0+C+!E&0=+5106+06!k+-=+&!
\M+/>0-8])!45+!48:&>!62:1+!*2:!;:-&3!6246!-&3+5,+5;:584&9+!46!*0&3!;4581!01!94-1+3!,456/<!.<!
106+!3+10>&h!62+!5+1+4592+51!;:-&3!6246L!!
!
“large wind farm operators are going to have to space their turbines farther
apart... placing the wind turbines 15 rotor diameters apart – more than twice as
far apart as in the current layouts – results in more cost-efficient power
generation.”
[Meneveau C and Meyers J. Optimization of Turbine Spacing in the Fully Developed
Wind Turbine Array Boundary Layer. Bulletin of the American Physical Society Nov
2010;55(16):QD.00005 http://meetings.aps.org/link/BAPS.2010.DFD.QD.5;
Kirk W. Study Yields Better Turbine Spacing for Large Wind Farms. Johns Hopkins
University Press Release.]
“For realistic cost ratios, we find that the optimal average turbine spacing may be
considerably higher than that conventionally used in current wind farm
implementations.”
[Meyers J and Meneveau C. Optimal turbine spacing in fully developed wind farm
boundary layers. Wind Energy 14 APR 2011 DOI: 10.1002/we.469]
!
A2-1)!62+!>-034&9+!5+/0+3!-,:&!.+;:5+!9:880110:&0&>!01!8:16!9506094/)!4&3!5+1+4592!10&9+!UTT(!
,45604//<!+7,/40&1!*2<!RAPE!3:+1!&:6!4&3!94&&:6!,5+3096!&:5!,5+9/-3+!&:01+!,5:./+81!46!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!106+1@!
!
!
$T!
A201!HFP!e2456!0//-16546+1!62+!48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&!9:8,:&+&6!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!*062!
8:3-/460:&1!:;!U'!3M!,+4Ca65:->2!;/-96-460:&1!:99-550&>!4,,5:70846+/<!O!608+1!,+5!80&-6+)!4&3!
62+1+!9:&60&-+!6:!;/-96-46+!:=+5!,+50:31!:;!608+@!!A201!:&>:0&>!;/-96-460:&)!:5!B62-8,0&>B)!01!62+!
1:-&3!41!496-4//<!+7,+50+&9+3!.<!,+:,/+@!!!
!
!
ZHFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!_:01+!H:&06:50&>!N54,2!*0620&!;0516!;/::5!.+35::8!?![4=01B1!f:-1+!?!D0&3!
`458!_:01+)!O!d-/<!"''()!0&L!F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+![+=+/:,8+&61@!!HFP!
R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!H4<!"''Tc!!!
!
!
A2+!e:&3060:&1!08,:1+3!.<!62+!%&1,+96:5!4&3!-,2+/3!.<!62+!e:-56!:;!F,,+4/!:&!62+!SRP!*0&3!;458!
46![+&!M5::C!64C+!62+1+!;/-96-460:&1!0&6:!499:-&6h!1++!P@"@O)!,!W'@!
!
A2+1+!e:&3060:&1!45+!0&!1645C!9:&65416!6:!62+!8+62:3!43=:946+3!.<!RAPE?S?T()!*2092!4=+54>+1!62+!
1:-&3!8+41-5+8+&61!1:!6246!62+!8+41-5+8+&6!4,,+451!41!4!16540>26!/0&+)!+/080&460&>!62+!,+4C1!
4&3!65:->21@!!\RAPE!-1+1!kFT')!U'80&)!1:!6246!:=+5!4!U'!80&-6+!,+50:3)!62+!1:-&3!01!4=+54>+3)!
*2092!3:+1!&:6!12:*!62+!;/-96-460:&1!41!+7,+50+&9+3!.<!62+!2-84&!+45@]!!A2-1)!0;!62+!8+41-5+8+&6!
12:*1!#U!3MF)!6201!301>-01+1!62+!;496!6246!62+!5+90,0+&6!;480/<!84<!+&3-5+!,+4C1!41!20>2!41!#j!3MF!
:5!20>2+5!0&!4!8:3-/460&>!2458:&09!,466+5&@!!!
!
A2-1)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!&:6!4!9:&60&-:-1!B2-8B)!*2092!62+!RAPE!8+62:31!1->>+16)!.-6!94&!.+!4!
9:&60&-:-1!1*0120&>!:5!+=+&!4!62-8,0&>)!:190//460&>!&:01+@!!`-562+58:5+)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!241!4!
/:*!;5+G-+&9<!9:8,:&+&6)!&:6!&+9+11450/<!4-30./+!6:!62+!2-84&!+45)!6246!241!4&!08,496!:&!62+!
4-306:5<!1<16+8!4&3!62+!2-84&!.:3<@!!!
!
A2+!Dfg!!#@9*&!"#$%&V1#)%4#+%$!4&3!V1#)%4#+%$&,"-&C"..1+#*;&!"#$%!45+!9/+45L!!0;!62+!,://-60&>!
&:01+!30;;+51!;5:8!62+!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+!0&!;5+G-+&9<!4&3!9245496+5)!62+&!:&+!8-16!&:6!411-8+!
6246!62+!,://-60&>!&:01+!01!841C+3!.<!62+!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+@!!!
!
e-55+&6!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6!>-034&9+!84C+1!6246!411-8,60:&)!/+430&>!6:!&:01+!,5:./+81!;:5!62:1+!
/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!`-562+58:5+)!RAPE?S?T(!3:+1!&:6!9:&103+5!62+!08,496!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!3:14>+!:&!;480/0+1!4&3!62+05!/:&>?6+58!+7,:1-5+@!!A201!01!4!1+50:-1!:80110:&!0&!62+!9:&6+76!:;!
411+110&>!061!08,496!:&!2+4/62@!
!
O'!
!
!
A2+!Dfg!__N!*+5+!3+10>&+3!;:5!-1+!.<!,:/09<?!4&3!3+9010:&?!84C+51!41!*+//!41!.<!49:-160904&1@!!
A2-1)!8:16!R&=05:&8+&64/!g;;09+51)!+=+&!46!62+!/:94/!/+=+/)!5+;+550&>!6:!62+!8:16!5+9+&6!Dfg!&:01+!
>-03+/0&+1)!12:-/3!.+!4./+!6:!411+11!,/4&&0&>!4,,/09460:&1!;:5!62+!.5+4362)!3+,62)!499-549<)!4&3!
G-4/06<!:;!62+!499:8,4&<0&>!1646+8+&61!4&3!5+,:561)!*2+62+5!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4,,/09460:&1!:5!
:62+5!,:6+&604//<!&:01+!,://-60&>!,5:,:14/1@!
!
f:*+=+5)!62+!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6B1!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,:/09<!41!3+=01+3!.<!RAPE!01!4!20>2/<!6+92&094/!
3:9-8+&6!6246!3+84&31!20>2/<!G-4/0;0+3!4&3!+7,+50+&9+3!49:-160904&1!6:!0&6+5,5+6!62+!>-034&9+!
4&3!6:!;://:*!62+!0&=:/=+3!,5:9+3-5+1!1+6!3:*&!0&!62+!3:9-8+&6@!!D20/+!62+!>-034&9+!84<!*+//!
24=+!.++&!4,,5:,5046+!46!061!0&9+,60:&)!4/62:->2!+=+&!62+&!06!*41!-&6+16+3!;:5!061!48+/0:5460:&!:;!
&:01+!,5:./+81!;:5!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!8:16!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!24=+!0&95+41+3!
354846094//<!0&!10Y+!10&9+!UTT(@!!%&!62+!0&6+508)!62+5+!01!4/1:!&:*!4!1:8+*246!.+66+5!-&3+5164&30&>!
:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9245496+5016091@!!F1!4!5+1-/6)!*2+&!&:01+!01!4!,:6+&604/!011-+!46!i/4&&0&>!
%&G-050+1!.+94-1+!62+5+!45+!2:8+1)!:5!:62+5!1+&1060=+!5+103+&604/!:5!*:5C!;490/060+1)!&+45!4!,5:,:1+3!
106+)!84&<!34<1)!8-92!608+)!4&3!9:&103+54./+!9:16!45+!9:&1-8+3!41!49:-160904&1!3+.46+!62+!RAPE!
>-034&9+)!061!0&6+5,5+6460:&)!4&3!061!4,,/09460:&@!%
!
F/62:->2!4,,5:70846+/<!"(!6:!#W!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!24=+!>+&+546+3!9:8,/40&61!4.:-6!&:01+)!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<!:*&+51!,+51016!0&!9/4080&>!6246!62+!&:01+!0880110:&1!46!2:8+1!9:8,/<!*062!62+!
i/4&&0&>!e:&3060:&1!5+9:88+&3+3!.<!RAPE@!!A201!+G-46+1!6:!64906!49C&:*/+3>+8+&6!.<!62+!*0&3!
0&3-165<!6246!RAPE?S?T(!3:+1!&:6!,5:=03+!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!2458;-/!&:01+!5430460:&!6:!&+45.<!
2:8+1@!!
!
%&!62+!,4,+5![/#+)&01-2#+%&!"#$%I&D4%%>I&(+)&5%(4*9\)![5!e25016:,2+5!f4&&0&>)!4!,2<10904&!*062!
+7,+5601+!0&!1/++,!8+3090&+)!*5:6+L!
!
“The recent RIVM and WHO reports and the draft DTI/HMP reports confirm the
potential for noise to adversely effect health through sleep disturbance and set
maximum permissible noise levels which are less than those permitted by ETSU-R97... [3.12.5]
In my expert opinion, from my knowledge of sleep physiology and a
review of the available research, I have no doubt that wind turbine noise
emissions have been clearly associated with sleep disturbances.
Further, the evidence now available is quite clear that present UK noise
guidelines are inadequate to protect the sleep of residents living too close
to wind turbines... [3.12.6]
As a guide to the limits of acceptability, ……
Overall, it is apparent that the present ETSU-R-97 noise limits are too high
to protect receptors from severe annoyance and sleep disturbance and
that a level of 35dB(A) is appropriate, in the absence of excessive
modulation. [4.4.2 Acceptable limit]
Turbines which result in external noise levels greater than 35dB(A) or are
sited closer than 1.5km from housing therefore present an unacceptable
risk of causing sleep disturbance and high levels of annoyance to those
residents and, to a smaller number, a risk to health. [4.3.5]
!
!
!
!
There is a large body of evidence also showing that ETSU-R-97 noise levels are too
high for human health and well being. These include the 2009 WHO Night Noise
Guidelines and the 2006 draft reports by HMP to DTI. It follows that it is
appropriate and reasonable for planners and decision makers not to rely
exclusively on ETSU-R-97 methodology and to take account of other material
considerations set out in this paper.” [5.1.4]
[Hanning C. Wind Turbine Noise, Sleep and Health. Society for Wind Vigilance,
April 2010 http://www.windvigilance.com/about-adverse-health-effects/windturbine-noise-sleep-and-health-by-dr-hanning] [Emphasis added.]
OU!
!
%&!d-&+!"'UU)%&3*%;'+-(.,".#%@*#.-*)!e:88-&06<!F;;4051!S+;+5+&9+!e:88066++)!0&!62+05!5+,:56)!
09%&D"8#(4&(+)&78"+".#8&3.>(8*&",&'1-(4&/#+)&=(-.$)!843+!1+=+&!S+9:88+&3460:&1)!48:&>!62+8L!
!
“Recommendation 4: The Committee recommends that the
Commonwealth Government initiate as a matter of priority thorough,
adequately resourced epidemiological and laboratory studies of the
possible effects of wind farms on human health. This research must
engage across industry and community, and include an advisory process
representing the range of interests and concerns.” [The Australian Senate:
Community Affairs References Committee. The Social and Economic Impact of
Rural Wind Farms. Commonwealth of Australia, June 2011, section 2.101]
%
X#%-3*%Y^)!62+!3:9-8+&6!:1#2/!;1,#79!<-'-/)/$-!61(!=$5,'$%!\[+;54!"'U'])!1646+1L!
&
“The Government is committed to sustainable development and Defra plays an
important role in this by working to secure a healthy environment in which we and
future generations can prosper. One aspect of meeting these objectives is the
need to manage noise for which Defra has the overall responsibility in England.
[1.1]
This Noise Policy Statement for England (NPSE) sets out the long term vision of
Government noise policy:
Noise Policy Vision: Promote good health and a good management of
noise within the context of Government policy on sustainable
development. [1.6]
This long term vision is supported by the following aims:
Noise Policy Aims:
Through the effective management and control of environmental,
neighbor and neighbourhood noise within the context of Government
policy on sustainable development:
- avoid significant adverse impacts on health and quality of life;
- mitigate and minimize adverse impacts on health and quality of life;
and
- where possible, contribute to the improvement of health and quality
of life.” [1.7]
!
e:&103+50&>!62+!+=03+&9+!*0620&!6201!,4,+5)![+;54K1!!"#$%&J"4#8;&O#$#"+!4&3!62+!!"#$%&J"4#8;&:#.$!
4,,+45!6:!24=+!.++&!0>&:5+3!.<![Ree!4&3!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!*2+&!9:&103+5+3!0&!62+!
9:&6+76!:;!&:01+!+80110:&1!;5:8!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!![+1,06+!62+!9464/:>-+!:;!1-;;+50&>!
5+,:56+3!.<!;480/0+1!*2+&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!6:!62+05!2:8+1)![+;54!3:+1!&:6!
49C&:*/+3>+!6246!62+!,5+I-30904/!2+4/62!9:&1+G-+&9+1!6:!62+1+!;480/0+1!*4554&6!4!2+4/62!%&G-05<@!!
_:5!3:+1![+;54!9:&103+5!06!10>&0;094&6!+&:->2!6:!*4554&6!4&!0&3+,+&3+&6!4&3!08,45604/!%&G-05<!
0&6:!62+!;0&4&904/!1-;;+50&>!+&3-5+3!.<!62+1+!;480/0+1)!*2:!;0&3!8-92!:;!62+05!/0;+!14=0&>1!+;;+960=+/<!
1+G-+16+5+3!.<!62+!P646+@!!A2+1+!;480/0+1!45+!12:-/3+50&>!62+!.-53+&!;:5!62+!P646+@!!Z[+,4568+&6!;:5!
R&=05:&8+&6)!`::3!4&3!S-54/!F;;4051!\[+;54]@!!_:01+!i:/09<!P646+8+&6!;:5!R&>/4&3!\_iPR]@!![+;54)!
EQ)!H4592!"'U'!266,Laa***@3+;54@>:=@-Ca+&=05:&8+&6aG-4/06<a&:01+a&,1+ac!
!
X#%4'(08*)!62+!:$$%$$.%+*&(+)&<(+(@%.%+*&",&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&!"#$%!01!1+6!:-6!0&![05+960=+!
"''"a$TaRe!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!i45/048+&6!4&3!62+!e:-&90/!:;!"O!d-&+!"''")!4/1:!C&:*&!41!R_[)!:5!
62+!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+![05+960=+L!
!
“1. It is part of Community policy to achieve a high level of health and
environmental protection, and one of the objectives to be pursued is protection
against noise...
5. This Directive should, inter alia, provide a basis for developing and completing
the existing set of Community measures concerning noise emitted by major
sources, in particular... infrastructure [and] industrial equipment...”
!
E&3+5!F5609/+!U)!62+![05+960=+!1646+1!6246L!
!
“...The following actions shall be implemented progressively... ensuring that
information on environmental noise and its effects is made available to the public.”
!
!
A2+![05+960=+!9:&60&-+1L!
“Article 2, Scope:
1. This Directive shall apply to environmental noise to which humans are exposed
in particular... in quiet areas in open country... and other noise sensitive buildings
and areas.
Article 3, Definitions:
a. ‘environmental noise’ shall mean unwanted or harmful outdoor sound created
by human activities including... sites of industrial activity...
b. ‘harmful effects’ shall mean negative effects on human health.”
!
A2+![05+960=+K1!F&&+7!U@#)!P-,,/+8+&645<!_:01+!%&30946:51)!1646+1!6246L!
!
“In some cases... it may be advantageous to use special noise indicators... e.g.:
-- The low frequency content of the noise is strong.
-- LAmax or SEL for night period protection in the case of noise peaks.
-- Extra protection weekends, day periods, evening periods.
-- A combination of noises from different sources.
-- Quiet areas in open country.
-- The noise contains strong tonal components.
-- The noise has an impulsive character.”
!
F&&+7!#!:;!62+![05+960=+)![:$$%$$.%+*&.%*9")$&,"-&9(-.,14&%,,%8*$\!1646+1!6246L!
!
“Dose-effect relations should be used to assess the effect of noise on populations”,
which includes
-- “Tonal industrial noise
-- Impulsive industrial noise and other special cases.”
[Environmental Noise Directive (END). Directive 2002/49/EC of the European
parliament and of the Council relating to the Assessment and Management of
Envrionmental Noise, 25 June 2002. Official Journal of the European Communities
1.189/12 EN, 18.7.2002 http://ec.europa.eu/environment/noise/directive.htm]
!
A2+5+!01!&:!0&309460:&!6246![Ree!241!64C+&!4&<!4960:&!6:!08,/+8+&6!:5!499:88:346+!6201!RRe!
i45/048+&6![05+960=+!5+>4530&>!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!+80110:&1@!
!
X#%_.8.#)!*2+5+!5+103+&61!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!5+,:56+3!0&903+&61!:;!0&1:8&04)!2+43492+1)!
30YY0&+11)!4&3!60&&06-1L!
!
‘The Environment Ministry will conduct its first field survey of possible health
hazards of wind turbines, covering all of more than 1,500 units in operation across
the country. The four-year study, to start in April, was planned following
complaints from neighbourhood residents about noise and environmental problems
as well as health issues.
The Ministry’s field survey will measure low frequency sounds from turbine
operations and interview residents face to face, according to officials.
At the 30 locations where complaints have been filed, 90 percent concerned health
problems. Residents say they suffer from insomnia, headaches, dizziness or
buzzing in the ear...
Izumi Ushiyama, president of the Ashikaga Institute of Technology and an expert
on wind power generation, says operators must listen to residents before pushing
their projects.
‘Some operators make light of communications with residents in carrying out their
projects, which causes friction,’ he says. ‘This has tarnished the image of wind
power generation and blocked its promotion.’ “
[Ito A and Takeda T. Sickness Claims Prompt Study of Wind Turbines. The Asahi
Shimbun, 19 January 2010. http://www.asahi.com/english/Heraldasahi/TKY201001180410.html]
O"!
O#!
!
%&!9:&65416)!1:8+!>:=+5&8+&61!,411!/+>01/460:&!4&3!+&;:59+!>-03+/0&+1!6246!+79/-3+!/:94/!
,456090,460:&)!/+4=0&>!:&/<!5+9:-51+!6:!+7,+&10=+!I-30904/!,5:9+11@!!ZP++!F,,+&307!#@U!4&3!,,!U'O!X!
U'W!:;!6201!,4,+5!;:5!4&!:=+5=0+*!:;!62+!106-460:&!0&!g&6450:)!e4&434@!!Q5:>2!e@!!%&3-16504/!D0&3!
A-5.0&+![+=+/:,8+&6!4&3!k:11!:;!P:904/!d-1609+@!!H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&?&D"8#%*;!
"'UUh#U\$]L#"U?###c!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
O$!
!
MDS%%!X>=%&Y<ZX>4%>[X@42%%E[!%L<4`Y4>U?%>[X@4%aEL>b!
!
[-50&>!4!,5+1+&6460:&!0&!g96:.+5!"'U'!:&!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!:;!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)![5!
F/+9!P4/6!3+1950.+3!2:*!62+!2-84&!4-306:5<!1<16+8!5+1,:&31!6:!k`_!4&3!2:*!62+!.540&!0&6+5,5+61!
10>&4/1!;5:8!62+!+45@!!F99:530&>!6:!P4/6)!-10&>!3MF?*+0>26+3!1,+9654!6:64//<!8015+,5+1+&61!62+!
+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!X!0&9/-30&>!061!0&;541:-&3!:5!k`_!9:8,:&+&61!X!:&!62+!4-306:5<!
1<16+8@!!P4/6!1->>+161!6246!3M\N]!*+0>260&>!499:-&61!;:5!62+!+;;+961!:;!k`_!8:5+!499-546+/<)!41!
&:6+3!0&!"''O!.<!d49:.1+&!0&![3+,-($"1+)&%.#$$#"+$&,-".&B#+)&*1-2#+%$\A!!Zd49:.1+&!d@!!%&;541:-&3!
R80110:&1!;5:8!D0&3!A-5.0&+1@!!M"1-+(4&",&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%I&O#2-(*#"+I&(+)&:8*#F%&C"+*-"4!
"''Oh"$LU$OXUOOc!!
!
P4/6K1!92456!.+/:*!9:8,45+1!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!49:-1609!/+=+/1!8+41-5+3!.<!=4&!3+&!M+5>!\"''W]!
4&3!d-&>!4&3!e2+-&>!\"''j]@!!_:01+!.+/:*!"'fY!01!.+/:*!62+!&:584/!4-30./+!/+=+/!;:5!2-84&1@!!
A2+!92456!.+/:*!12:*1!62+!8+41-5+3!49:-1609!/+=+/1!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!46!"'fY!0&30946+3!46!W'!
3M!6:!TO!3M@!!F.:=+!"'fY)!62+!49:-1609!/+=+/1!54&>+!.+6*++&!W'!3M!6:!$'3M!46!U)'''fY@!!!
!
U3.(-%JD%%!"#$%-'()"#*%>0"+*%@30G#%.+%.%@8*6-('1%
!
9'*,):(/;'*.)*%'&.)&4%A*)1&)1)&$.73/(#
!"#$%&'()*%+*,-"./0
1"))'&2*+#/34/&(5
&'''#$%
()#*+,
!"#$%
!"#$%&'
%()*+,-%.+//012%34-56
B1*),.*)C./D<)>??E
78"9%&'%
F(*D)1*,)G4.(*D<)>??H
!"#$%&'(#)%*)+,-./&.)0.1234)566.73&)%6)8*,(&3/'12)9'*,):(/;'*.&<)=73%;./))>?@?
!
!
Z[5!F/+9!_!P4/6)!i2[)!D4120&>6:&!E&0=+5106<!P92::/!:;!H+3090&+)!EPF@!!%&;541:-&3L!!J:-5!R451!f+45!
%6!M-6!A2+<![:&K6!A+//!J:-5!M540&@!!=#-$*&3+*%-+(*#"+(4&D;.>"$#1.6&09%&V4"2(4&/#+)&3+)1$*-;&(+)&
:)F%-$%&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$6&R"$$&",&D"8#(4&M1$*#8%^!g&6450:)!e4&434)!"T?#U!g96:.+5!"'U'!
266,Laa***@*0&3=0>0/4&9+@9:8a0&6+5&460:&4/?1<8,:10-8a,5:9++30&>1?;0516?0&6+5&460:&4/?
1<8,:10-8c!!!
!
!
M+94-1+!k`_!654=+/1!/:&>!30164&9+1!*062:-6!466+&-460:&)!4&3!94&!4;;+96!.-0/30&>1!4&3!62+05!
:99-,4&61)!P4/6!5+9:88+&31!1+6.49C1!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!;5:8!2:8+1!:;!46!/+416!Uw!80/+1)!4&3!0&!
2:8+!8:&06:50&>!:;!.:62!F?*+0>26+3!4&3!N?*+0>26+3!&:01+!/+=+/1)!"$!2:-51a34<)!;:5!4//!3*+//0&>1!
*0620&!"!80/+1!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!ZP4/6)!F_@!!!%&;541:-&3L!!J:-5!R451!f+45!%6!M-6!A2+<![:&K6!A+//!J:-5!
M540&@!!!
=#-$*&3+*%-+(*#"+(4&D;.>"$#1.6&09%&V4"2(4&/#+)&3+)1$*-;&(+)&:)F%-$%&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$6&R"$$&",&D"8#(4&
M1$*#8%^!!!P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+)!g&6450:)!e4&434)!"T?#U!g96:.+5!"'U'c!!
!
OO!
!
RAPE?S?T(!4&3!1:8+!EQ!49:-160904&1!432+5+!6:!62+!,5+1-8,60:&!6246!0;!4!1:-&3!01!0&4-30./+)!06!
62+5+;:5+!3:+1!&:6!24=+!4&!+;;+96!:&!2-84&1@!!f:*+=+5)!8+3094/!+7,+561!45>-+!6201!01!0&499-546+@!!
%&4-30./+!1:-&3)!0@+@)!0&;541:-&3!4&3!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)!94&!0&65-3+!:&!4*45+&+11!4&3!94-1+!
3019:8;:56!4&3!:62+5!0&I-50:-1!2+4/62!+;;+961!3+,+&30&>!-,:&!3:14>+!4&3!+7,:1-5+@!!A:!0//-16546+!
62+!;4//49<!:;!6201!411-8,60:&)!P4/6!-1+3!62+1+!+748,/+1!6:!20>2/0>26!43=+51+!+;;+961!94-1+3!.<!:62+5!
4>+&61!6246!45+!.+/:*!2-84&!3+6+960:&!+79+,6!.<!:62+5!8+4&1!:;!8+41-5+8+&6L!
!
“1. If you can’t taste it, it can’t affect you. Can you taste Salmonella?
2. If you can’t smell it, it can’t affect you. Try breathing pure CO or CO2.
3. If you can’t see it, it can’t hurt you. Ultra violet light is invisible but can
harm you.”
i5+=0:-1!5+1+4592!241!3+8:&16546+3!6246!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!3:+1!95+46+!,2<10:/:>094/!5+1,:&1+1!
0&!62+!2-84&!.:3<h!+@>@)!4!92456!;5:8!4!M5-+/!^!QI4+5!0%89+#8(4&'%>"-*!12:*+3!62+1+!8+41-5+8+&61!
0&!62+!2-84&!.:3<!0&!5+1,:&1+!6:!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+L!
!
Table 1. Human Body Vibration Exposure and its Measurement
The frequency ranges given are those where the symptoms are most predominant.
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
General feeling of discomfort
Head symptoms
Lower Jaw
Influence on speech
Chest pains
Abdominal pains
Influence on breathing movements
Muscle contractions
4
13
6
13
5
4
4
4
– 9 Hz
– 20 Hz
– 8 Hz
– 20 Hz
– 7 Hz
– 10 Hz
– 8 Hz
– 9 Hz
[Rasmussen G. Symptoms for Vibration Exposure at Frequencies of 1 -- 20 Hz, in
Human Body Vibration Exposure and its Measurement. Bruel & Kjaer Technical
Review, v. 1, 1982]
!
A201!01!62+!54&>+!:;!k`_!41!0//-16546+3!0&!U3.(-%J2%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%+30G#%.+%.%@8*6-('1)!
5+,5:3-9+3!+45/0+5!0&!6201!924,6+5@!!
!
F1!+45/<!41!UTj")!5+1+4592!.<!f-..453!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!12:*+3!6246L!
!
1) “A person inside the house can sense the impingement of noise on the external
surfaces of the house by means of the following phenomena: noise transmitted
through the structure… Vibrations of the primary components of the building
such as the floors, walls and windows; the rattling of objects…”
2) Addressing the issue of ‘whole body perception’ Hubbard refers to the ISO
Guidelines and observes that a noise level outside a building between 55 –
60dB (around 0.001 rms) in a frequency of 0.1 Hz – 80 Hz, is the most
sensitive threshold of perception of vibratory motion by humans.
[Hubbard HH. Noise induced house vibrations and human perception. Noise
Control Engineering 1982;19(2):49-55]
!
%&!V09%&3+(1)#24%&!"#$%&",&/#+)&01-2#+%$K)!4!5+,:56!.<!e+54&&4!+6!4/)!:;!62+!`+3+54/!%&1606-6+!;:5!
N+:190+&9+1!4&3!_46-54/!S+1:-59+1!\MNS)!f4&&:=+5)!N+584&<])!+/+8+&61!:;!*0&3!;458!0&;541:-&3!
*+5+!8+41-5+3!46!4!30164&9+!:;!#'C8!;5:8!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!Ze+54&&4!k)!f45684&&!N)!4&3!
f+&>+5!H@!!09%&3+(1)#24%&!"#$%&",&/#+)&01-2#+%$@!%&;541:-&3!D:5C12:,)!_:=+8.+5!"j!X![+9+8.+5!
")!"''O)!A42060c!!
!
H:5+!5+9+&6/<)!62+!H0&0165<!:;![+;+&9+!.4&&+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*0620&!4!#U?80/+!5430-1!:;!061!&-9/+45!
6+16!8:&06:50&>!16460:&!0&!R1C34/+8-05!.+94-1+!:;!1+01809!0&6+5;+5+&9+@!!ZD0&3!`4581!M4&&+3!41!
H:[!k016+&0&>!i:16![+84&31!f-12!6:![+6+96!_-9/+45!M/4161@!!09%&D8"*$.(+!U'!`+.5-45<!"'U'c!!!
!
A2+1+!+748,/+1!;-562+5!0//-16546+!62+!/:&>!30164&9+1!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!654=+/1)!0&9/-30&>!6246!:;!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!*062:-6!466+&-460:&@!
!
F!5+,:56!6:!_:01+?e:&)!0&!d-/<!"'UU)!.<!M54<!4&3!d48+1!,5+1+&6+3!62+!3<&4809!8+41-5+8+&61!:;!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!49:-1609!10>&4/1)!+8,/:<0&>!1:-&3!G-4/06<!+&>0&++50&>!8+62:31!6246!9:&103+5+3!62+!
608+!4&3!;5+G-+&9<!1+&1060=060+1!:;!2-84&!,+59+,60:&L!
!
!
“The purpose of this paper is to present wind turbine acoustic measurements at
these time-frequency scaling and to suggest that such consideration, frequently
neglected in favor of frequency resolution and long term level averages, could
augment the perceptually inappropriate averages (often A-weighted) typically
taken over much longer intervals. The authors maintain that most measurements
of wind turbines up to now have not considered, or not adequately considered,
these signals’ very complex and varying behaviors at the time/bandwidth scaling
of human perception. Although treating wind turbine noise aspects at all relevant
frequencies, this paper will concentrate on low-frequency information.”
[Bray W and James R. Dynamic Measurements of Wind Turbine Acoustic Signals,
Employing Sound Quality Engineering Methods Considering the Time and
Frequency Sensitivities of Human Perception. Noise-Con, Portland, Oregon, USA,
July 25-27, 2011]
OW!
!
[5!H!F!P*0&.4&C1!43=4&9+3!62+!-&3+5164&30&>!:;!k`_!+8066+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!3-50&>!62+!`:-562!
%&6+5&460:&4/!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!e:&;+5+&9+)!2+/3!0&!S:8+)!"'UU)!*062!201!,4,+5)!09%&:1)#2#4#*;&",&
R"B&=-%W1%+8;&/#+)&01-2#+%&!"#$%L!!
!
“A rigorous method of defining the lower limits of audibility or perception, based on
the cumulative integration of spectra of arbitrary bandwidth has been investigated.
It has been shown that for a typical wind turbine spectra, the upper frequency limit
associated with this criterion corresponds closely to the intersection of 1/3rd octave
levels with the conventional threshold of hearing. This criterion is, however, based
on comparison of the cumulative mean square energy level of the signal, and does
not take account of the much greater peak levels that occur in actual wind turbine
sound fields. Time-domain simulation of the low frequency hearing response,
using signals believed typical of wind turbines and industrial gas turbines has
shown that sound can be perceptible at significantly lower levels than those
defined solely on the basis of mean square energy.
The resultant enhanced sensitivity is related to the crest factor of the signals. The
effects are consistent with the audibility tests carried out and reported by NASA in
1982, and are also consistent with the authors own experience obtained during the
1980’s relating to industrial gas turbine installations.
Modern upwind-rotor configuration wind turbines can indeed give rise to very low
frequency impulsive sound patterns. This effect is believed to be due to wind
gradients and shadowing by obstructions, and was first identified and reported for
upwind rotor turbines by NASA in 1989.
A consequence of these results is that low frequency and infrasonic noise due to
wind turbines may be audible at significantly lower sound levels than has hitherto
been acknowledged.”
[Swinbanks MA. The Audibility of Low Frequency Wind Turbine Noise: Conclusion.
The Fourth International Wind Turbine Noise Conference, Rome, April 12-14, 2011]
!
%&!"''W)!62+!f4<+1!H9Q+&Y0+!i456&+5120,!011-+3!4!5+,:56!9:&65496+3!.<!62+![60)!S09%&<%($1-%.%+*&
",&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%&(*&09-%%&GX&/#+)&=(-.$S@!!P+=+54/!<+451!/46+5)!4;6+5!62+![60!3+&0+3!5+G-+161!
6:!5+/+41+!62+!3464!4&3!8+62:31!0&!8:5+!3+640/)!09%&D1+)(;&0#.%$!5+1:56+3!6:!62+!`5++3:8!:;!
%&;:58460:&!F96)!41!06!5+=+4/+3!0&!061!45609/+)!_Q,,#8#(4$&C"F%-&G>&/#+)&=(-.&!"#$%&'%>"-*K6!!
!
“The guidance from consultants indicated that the sound level permitted from
spinning blades and gearboxes had been set so high – 43 dB-that local people
could be disturbed whenever the wind blew hard. The noise was also thought
likely to disrupt sleep.
The report said the best way to protect locals was to cut the maximum permitted
noise to 38 dB, or 33 dB if the machines created discernable ‘beating’ noises as
they spun.
It has now emerged that officials removed the warnings from the draft report in
2006 by Hayes McKenzie Partnership, (HMP) the consultants. The final version
made no mention of them.
!
In their draft report the HMP researchers recommended that ‘Consideration be
given to a revision of the night-time absolute noise criterion’, noting that this
would fit with World Health Organization recommendations on sleep disturbance.
O(!
However, an anonymous government official then inserted remarks
attacking this idea because it would impede wind farm development. He,
or she, wrote: ‘What will the impact of this be? Are we saying that this is
the situation for all wind farms... I think we need a sense of the scale of
this and the impact.’
The final report removed any suggestion of cutting the noise limits or
adding any further penalty it turbines generated a beating noise – and
recommended local authorities to stick to the 1996 guidelines.”
[Leake J and Byford H. Officials Cover Up wind Farm Noise Report. The Sunday
Times, December 13 2009] [Emphasis added.]
!
P6</+1!+6!4/)!:;!Q++/+!E&0=+5106<!\EQ])!03+&60;0+3!k`_!41!4!9:8,:&+&6!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!0&!061!
d-/<!"''O)!5+,:56!6:!62+!EQ!Hg[)![<#8-"$%#$.#8&(+)&3+,-($"1+)&<"+#*"-#+@&",&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%&
(+)&O#2-(*#"+$&,-".&/#+),(-.$N6&
&
“When the windfarm starts to generate at low wind speeds, considerable
infrasound signals can be detected at all stations out to c. 10km. Clear harmonic
components which are the second multiple and add up of 1.4Hz (the blade passing
frequency) can be seen although interestingly and somewhat enigmatically the
blade passing frequency itself is not strongly detected. (P.66)
We have clearly shown that both fixed speed and variable speed wind turbines
generate low frequency vibrations which are multiples of blade passing frequencies
and which can be detected on seismometers buried in the ground at significant
distances away from the wind farms even in the presence of significant levels of
background seismic noise (many kilometres).” [Styles P, Stimpson I, Toon S,
England R, and Wright M. Microseismic and Infrasound Monitoring of Low
Frequency Noise and Vibrations from Windfarms: Recommendations on the Siting
of Windfarms in the Vicinity of Eskdalemuir, Scotland. Report prepared for the UK
Ministry of Defence (MoD), 18 July, 2005, p.76
http://geophysics.esci.keele.ac.uk/resources/docs/Final_Report.pdf]
!
!
P60>*::3)!41!*+//!41!:62+5!49:-160904&1)!24=+!4/1:!8+41-5+3!k`_!41!4!9:8,:&+&6!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+@!!ZHFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+![+=+/:,8+&61@!!HFP!
R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!H4<!"''Tc!!!
!
Hu//+5!4&3!i+3+51+&)!0&!62+05!45609/+!R"B&=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%&,-".&R(-@%&/#+)&01-2#+%$)!;:-&3!6246L!
!
“As wind turbines get larger, worries have emerged that the turbine noise would
move down in frequency and that the low-frequency noise would cause annoyance
for neighbours…The relative amount of low frequency noise is higher for large
turbines (2.3 – 3.6 mw) than for small turbines <2mw, and the difference is
statistically significant... It is thus beyond any doubt that the low frequency
part of the spectrum plays an important role in the noise at the
neighbours.”
[Møller H and Pedersen CS. Low-Frequency Noise from Large Wind Turbines. JASA
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America June 2011;129(6):3727-3744]
[Emphasis added.]
!
J+6)!62+![60!fHi!S+,:56!:;!F->-16!"''W!1646+1!6246!Dfg!;:-&3!'... no reliable evidence that
infrasound below the hearing threshold produce physiological or psychological effects.”
Zf4<+1!H!4&3!H9Q+&Y0+!F!\f4<+1!H9Q+&Y0+!i456&+5120,]@!!H+41-5+8+&6!:;!k:*!`5+G-+&9<!_:01+!
46!A25++!EQ!D0&3!`4581@!![+,4568+&6!:;!A543+!4&3!%&3-165<!\[60])!EQ)!F->-16!"''W)!,!WWc!
!
A2+![60!fHi!S+,:56!MNNK!5+,+461!6201!:&!,4>+1!")U')$W)!4&3!WW)!G-:60&>!;5:8!Dfg!e:88-&06<!
_:01+!JOO\@!!!
!
Oj!
!
f:*+=+5)!62+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+!JOOO!3:!&:6!0&9/-3+!62+!UTTO!1646+8+&6!-1+3!
.<!fHi!0&!"''W@!!!%&16+43)!5+1+4592!6246!01!8:5+!5+9+&6!243!9:&=0&90&>/<!3+8:&16546+3!6246!/:*!
;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!3:+1!8+506!9:&9+5&!4.:-6!+;;+961!:&!2-84&!2+4/62@!!A2+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!
e:88-&06<!_:01+!JOOO!9/+45/<!1646+!6246L!
!
“The evidence on low frequency noise is sufficiently strong to warrant
immediate concern.
Health effects due to low frequency components in noise are estimated to be more
severe than for community noises in general (Berglund et al 1996).”
[WHO Guidelines for Community Noise, S.3.8, 1999] [Emphasis added.]
!
g&+!80>26!*:&3+5!*2<!9:&1-/64&61!6:!>:=+5&8+&6)!0&!4!,4,+5!*5066+&!0&!"''W)!G-:6+!;5:8!62+!:-6?
:;?346+)!1-,+51+3+3!Dfg!5+,:56!;5:8!UTTO)!0&!:53+5!6:!1-,,:56!4&!08,:564&6!9:&9/-10:&!6246!
0&;:58+3!4&3!0&;/-+&9+3!>:=+5&8+&6!,:/09<@!!D2+62+5!0&6+&60:&4/!:5!:=+510>26)!62+!5+1-/6!01!6246!
,+:,/+B1!2+4/62!4&3!*+//!.+0&>!9:&60&-+!6:!.+!46!501C!.+94-1+!>:=+5&8+&6!,:/09<!241!5+/0+3!:&!
62+1+!5+,:561@!
!
_:6!:&/<!01!62+5+!+=03+&9+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!>+&+546+!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)!62+5+!01!4/1:!+=03+&9+!
6246!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!241!4&!08,496!:&!,+:,/+!4&3!01!3+6+964./+!,2<1094//<)!+=+&!62:->2!k`_!01!
,508450/<!0&4-30./+@!
!
H:5+!Hi1!45+!&:*!4*45+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!4&!08,:564&6!011-+!6:!62+05!9:&1606-+&61@!!
[-50&>!i45/048+&645<!o-+160:&1!4.:-6!D0&3!A-5.0&+1!41!4!f+4/62!f4Y453)!H5!N+:;;5+<!e:7)!Hi)!
oe)!41C+3!62+&62+&?P+95+645<!:;!P646+!;:5!A543+!4&3!%&3-165<L!!
!
"What qualifications Hayes McKenzie possessed in relation to infrasound emitted
by wind turbines; and what role medical experts played in the production of the
report.”
&
H4/9:/8!D09C1)!H0&016+5!;:5!R&+5><!46!6246!608+)!5+,/0+36&&
&
“The Hayes McKenzie report for DTI ‘The measurement of low frequency noise at
three wind farms’ investigated the levels of low frequency noise and infrasound
emitted by wind turbines, it was not within the remit of the study to undertake
new medical analysis.
However the study did refer to the document prepared for the World Health
Organization ‘Community Noise’ which states; “there is no reliable evidence that
infrasounds below the hearing threshold produce physiological or psychological
effects”.”
[Hansard. Cox G and Wicks M. Turbines: Health Hazards, 18 May 2007, c1003W;
and Hansard. Cox G and Wicks M. Turbines: Health Hazards, 15 June 2007,
c1418w]
!
%6!01!10>&0;094&6!6246!62+!EQ!H0&016+5!;:5!R&+5><!+=43+3!62+!G-+160:&!:&!62+!9/0&094/!5+1+4592!
G-4/0;09460:&1!:;!62+!>:=+5&8+&6B1!9:&1-/6460:&!6+48@!!!
!
%6!01!4/1:!10>&0;094&6!6246!0&!"''()!62+!EQ!H0&016+5!;:5!R&+5><!*41!43=01+3!6:!G-:6+!;5:8!62+!
:-6346+3)!1-,+51+3+3!Dfg!e:88-&06<!_:01+!UTTO!3:9-8+&6!6:!1-,,:56!62+!,:0&6!2+!*41!84C0&>)!
*062:-6!5+;+5+&9+!6:!62+!62+&!9-55+&6!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+!UTTT)!4&3!061!-,346+3!
>-034&9+!:&!5+9:>&010&>!k`_!41!4!,:6+&604/!24Y453!6:!2+4/62@!!!
!
%&!d-&+!"'UU)!62+!F-1654/04!P+&46+)!e4&.+554)!,5:3-9+3!62+!5+1-/6!:;!62+05!%&G-05<!0&6:!x09%&D"8#(4&
(+)&78"+".#8&#.>(8*&",&'1-(4&/#+)&=(-.$\@!!A2+!e:88-&06<!F;;4051!S+;+5+&9+!e:88066++K1!
5+9:88+&3460:&1!0&9/-3+3L!
!
“Recommendation 1: The Committee considers that the noise standards
adopted by the states and territories for the planning and operation of
rural wind farms should include appropriate measures to calculate the
impact of low frequency noise and vibration indoors at impacted
dwellings.”
!
[The Australia Senate: Community Affairs References Committee. The Social and
Economic Impact of Rural Wind Farms. Commonwealth of Australia, June 2011,
2.44]
OT!
!
%&!F->-16!"'UU)!62+!R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!F>+&9<!:;!62+![4&012!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6!
011-+3!&+*!>-03+/0&+1!;:5!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!+8066+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+1L!
!
“All turbines can emit low frequency noise, irrespective of their size either int erms
of electrical power (megawatts) or height... a limit value for low frequency noise
from wind turbines must be determined. Clearer and more precise regulations for
this type of noise will provide more security for people living near wind turbines...
The present limit value for noise from wind turines is 44 dB outdoors near
residences in the open country and 39 dB in residential areas, for a wind speed at
8 m/s [metres per second]...
The proposed new regulation is based on a 20 decibels (dB) limit indoors for wind
speeds of 6 and 8 m/s...
[Applications] will have to comply with both the current limit values for ‘general
noise’ and the new limit value for low frequency noise.
The municipality has an obligation to inspect wind tubines to ensure that noise
disturbance is not excessive and can require wind turbine owners to have the noise
generated by their turbines measured to ensure that regulations are complied
with. This will also apply to the new limits for low frequency noise... The new limit
values will apply to all turbines, irrespective of ownership.”
[Q&A: Low Frequency Noise from Wind Turbines. Environmental Protection
Agency, Danish Ministry of the Environment, August 2011,
http://www.mst.dk/English/Focus_areas/FAQ_low_frequency_noise_from_wind_tu
rbines.htm?wbc_purpose=b%23%23Top]
!
M+94-1+![+&845C!5+/0+1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!84&-;496-5+!4&3!+7,:56!;:5!4!10>&0;094&6!,:560:&!:;!061!
N_i)!49C&:*/+3>0&>!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!:&!62+!43=+51+!08,496!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!
5+1,:&30&>!*062!165096+5!/08061!0&!>-034&9+!5+,5+1+&6!10>&0;094&6!X!4&3!*+/9:8+!X!924&>+1!0&!
,:/09<@
W'!
!
MD\%
!X>=%&Y<ZX>4%>[X@42%%;P7EX&Y=4%P[=YE;&X[>%a;Pb%%
!
D0&3!6-5.0&+1!,5:3-9+!&:01+!9245496+5016091!6246!45+!30;;09-/6!6:!,5+3096!+=+&!*062!1:,20160946+3!
9:8,-6+5!8:3+/0&>!4&3!8+6+:5:/:>094/!3464@!!Q&:*&!41!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&)!6201!&:01+!
9245496+5!4/1:!0&65-3+1!:&!,+:,/+B1!4*45+&+11)!94-10&>!9:&103+54./+!30165+11)!4&3!0&6+5;+50&>!
10>&0;094&6/<!*062!1/++,!,466+5&1@!!FH!9:&650.-6+1!6:!62+!V62-8,0&>K!1:-&3!1:!30160&960=+!6:!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+@!
!
%&!"''W?"''()!MRSS!\62+!;:58+5![60)!&:*![Ree]!1:->26!4!9:&1-/6460:&!;5:8!P4/;:53!E&0=+5106<!:&!
48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&@!!A2+!5+,:56)!S'%$%(-89&#+*"&:%-");+(.#8&<")14(*#"+&",&/#+)&01-2#+%&!"#$%S)!
*41!9:?4-62:5+3!.<!4!6+48!;5:8!P4/;:53!/+3!.<![5!F&3<!H::52:-1+!4&3!.<!H5!H4/9:/8!f4<+1!:;!
f4<+1!H9Q+&Y0+!i456&+5120,!k63@!
!
MRSSB1!,5+11!5+/+41+!:&!62+!P4/;:53!5+,:56)!!%B&'%>"-*&7($%$&C"+8%-+$&"F%-&/#+)&01-2#+%&!"#$%)!
1646+3!;:56250>26/<!6246L!
!
“... the noise phenomenon known as aerodynamic modulation (AM) is not an issue
for the UK’s wind farm fleet...
Commenting on wind farm worries, Energy Minister Malcolm Wicks, said ‘Based on
these findings, Government does not consider there to be a compelling case for
more work into AM and will not carry out any further research at this time:
however it will continue to keep the issue under review.”
[BERR. New Report Eases Concerns over Wind Turbine Noise. Press Release.
Department for Business, Enterprise & Regulatory Reform (BERR), 1 August 2007
http://www.govnews.org/gov/uk/news/new_report_eases_concerns_over_wind_turbine/40357.ht
ml]
!
J+6!62+!MRSS!,5+11!5+/+41+!&+>/+96+3!6:!8+&60:&!e:&9/-10:&!UU!:;!62+!P4/;:53af4<+1!5+,:56)!*2092!
:&!,4>+!$(!1646+1L!
!
“On the other hand, since AM cannot be fully predicted at present, and its
causes are not understood we consider that it might be prudent to carry
out further research to improve understanding in this area.”
[Emphasis added.]
&
g&!"!F->-16!"''()![09C!M:*3/+5)!:&+!:;!62+!;+*!0&3+,+&3+&6!49:-160904&1!:&!62+!MRSS!_:01+!
D:5C0&>!N5:-,)!*5:6+!4!/+66+5!6:!MRSSB1!P4/;:53!,5:I+96!84&4>+5L!
!
“I have read the Salford Report and the Government Statement. As a result I feel
obliged to resign from the NWG.
The Salford Report says that the aims of this study are to ascertain the prevalence
of AM from UK wind farm sites to try to gain a better understanding of the likely
causes and to establish whether further research into AM is required.
This bears little relation to what we asked for which is clearly set out in minutes of
the meeting in August 2006. We all knew then (as was recorded in the original
notes of the meeting) that complaints concerning wind farm noise are currently the
exception rather than the rule. The whole reason for needing the research was
that the trend for large, more sophisticated turbines could lead to an increase in
noise from AM...
Looking at the Government Statement it is clear that the views of the NWG (that
research is needed into AM to assist the sustainable design of wind farms in the
future) have never been transmitted to Government and so the Statement is based
on misleading information.”
[Wind Expert Quits Thinktank; Resignation Hits Wind Findings. Noise Bulletin AugSept 2007;Issue 15, pp 1, 4-5]
!
g&!O!F->-16!"''()!62+![05+96:5!:;!i5:>5488+!P6546+><!46!62+!M506012!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!
\MDRF)!&:*!S+&+*4./+EQ])!62+!6543+!4&3!/:..<0&>!:5>4&01460:&!;:5!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<)!
1+&6!4!/+66+5!6:!MDRF!8+8.+51!6246!0&9/-3+3!62+1+!9:88+&61L!
!
&&
“Some excellent news from a new report, and a strong message from Government
to back it up...
Based on these findings, Government does not consider there to be a compelling
case for further work into AM and will not carry out any further research at this
time: however it will continue to keep the issue under review.
I would like to thank (The BERR Salford Project Manager) (former DTI fame) for
her efforts in driving through the work on this issue with such great result and
robust Government statement.”
WU!
&
F,,45+&6/<)!62+!MRSS!_:01+!D:5C0&>!N5:-,aP4/;:53!i5:I+96!H4&4>+5!*41!:&!1+9:&38+&6!6:!MRSS!
;5:8!4!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,8+&6!30=010:&!:;!4!84I:5!+&+5><!-60/06<@!!
!
F6!6201!608+)!H5!N+:;;5+<!e:7)!Hi)!oe)!5+/+41+3!4!1646+8+&6!&:60&>!6246!84&<!:;!62+!9:&1-/64&61!
*2:!3+=01+3!62+!&:01+!>-03+/0&+1!;:5!62+!\62+&]![60)!4&3!*2:!9:&60&-+3!6:!9:&1-/6!46!MRSS!:&!62+!
148+!011-+1)!*+5+!46!62+!148+!608+!9:&1-/64&61!6:)!4&3!+8,/:<++1!:;)!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<L!!
!
“It is astonishing that the Government has subcontracted the study of this vital
subject to the very industry which has the most to gain from allaying those
concerns.”
&
H5!e:7!+7,5+11+3!9:&9+5&!4.:-6!62+!!
!
“... apparent conflict of interest surrounding energy firms dominating a group set
up to consider the health impact of aerodynamic modulation – the swish or boom
caused by turbine blades... is it conceivable that a study of the possible health
effects of smoking would be chaired by someone on secondment from the tobacco
industry?”
[Wind Energy Staff Act As Advisors. Western Morning News, 13 August 2008]
[Onshore Wind – a Clear Conflict of Interest? North Devon Journal, 13 August
2008]
!
A2+1+!=0+*1!*+5+!+92:+3!.<!H5!i!F6C0&1:&)!Hi)!*2:!01!“deeply concerned”!4.:-6!62+!501C!6:!
N:=+5&8+&6!08,45604/06<L!
!!!!
“We face the ridiculous situation of Defra and other Government departments
saying ‘they believe there is no risk from noise because renewable energy
companies have told us so’”.
[Turbines advice ‘blowing in the wind’. The Journal, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, 18 Aug
2008]
!
A2+!148+!45609/+!G-:6+1!_:562-8.+5/4&3!e:-&6<!e:-&90/K1!/+43+5)!S:>+5!P6<50&>)!*2:!!
!
“called for greater scrutiny of those advising the Government... This indicates that
in a sense the industry is being allowed to set its own standards, which is clearly
wrong. I agree they should be consulted but there are enough other experts that
can advise here, especially in our Universities... The noise these turbines create
can have quite an impact on your standard of living..."
!
P6<50&>!*41!4/1:!!
!
“concerned that environmental health officers, who help Councillors decide on the
noise issues surrounding a planning decision, risked being guided by potentially
biased Government advice.”
[Turbines advice ‘blowing in the wind’. The Journal, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, 18 Aug
2008]
!
%&43+G-46+!:5!08,5:,+5!106+!3+10>&!94&!+749+5.46+!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!ZFHc)!+@>@)!*2+&!
3+=+/:,+51!65<!6:!,/49+!6::!84&<!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!:&!4!106+@!!%&!62+!45609/+)!xE#$*(+8%&2%*B%%+&/#+)&
01-2#+%$&D9"14)&H%&E"124%)I&'%$%(-89%-$&D(;\)!62+!4-62:51!9:88+&6L!
!
“So far, wind turbines had been considered as standalone units, with few
researchers taking into account the effects that the distances between them have
!
on their final output. Meneveau and Meyer found out that the current space of 7
rotor diameters between adjacent wind turbines is not enough to overcome the
effects of the wind turbulence created. (www.greenoptimistic.com)
W"!
Instead, they found that a distance of 15 rotor diameters would suffice (that would
be about 4,500 feet, or 1.3KM). I don’t know if the space would realistically be
enough for all the turbines to have such a setup, but the researchers say they
would be much more cost-efficient.
The two scientists found that the energy generated by a large wind farm is not
influenced as much by horizontal winds, but by the strong winds that the
turbulence created by them pulls down from higher altitudes. Their new setup
would stir the air even more and would draw more kinetic energy from those high
altitudes, a fact confirmed by wind tunnel tests in the John Hopkins wind tunnel.”
[See also Calaf M, Meneveau C, and Meyers J 2010 in S.2.3, p 43.]
[Calaf M, Meneveau C, and Meyers J. Large Eddy Simulation Study of Fully
Developed Thermal Wind-Array Boundary Layers. Geophysical Research Abstracts
2010, Vol 12 EGV]
!
M+94-1+!RAPE!3:+1!&:6!5+;/+96!9-55+&6!5+1+4592!;0&30&>1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!061!
8+41-5+8+&6)!06!/49C1!95+30.0/06<!0&!62+!+<+1!:;!62+!M506012!,-./09!*2:!;49+!+70160&>!:5!,:6+&604/!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,5:./+81@!!A2+!N:=+5&8+&6!241!;40/+3!6:!411+11!2+4/62!501C1!6246!:&12:5+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!,:1+!6:!;480/0+1!/0=0&>!&+45.<)!3+1,06+!9/+45!+=03+&9+!;5:8!0&6+5&460:&4/!4-62:5060+1!4&3!
+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+,:561!6246!&:01+!*062!62+!9:8.0&+3!49:-1609!9245496+51!+8066+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!
01!/0C+/<!6:!94-1+!0&I-5<!6:!2+4/62@!!F1!4!5+1-/6)!EQ!;480/0+1!*0//!9:&60&-+!6:!1-;;+5!+765+8+!165+11!4&3!
43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!305+96/<!94-1+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!061!0&65-10=+!9245496+5)!9:&60&-0&>!
<+45!4;6+5!<+45)!*062:-6!8060>460:&!:5!2:,+!:;!:;;0904/!0&6+5=+&60:&!6:!411+56!4&3!08,/+8+&6!
+;;+960=+!&:01+!9:&3060:&1@!
!
%&!4!i/4&&0&>!F,,+4/![+9010:&!46!VE%+&H-""LI&E%F"+K)!4/62:->2!62+!%&1,+96:5!4//:*+3!62+!
4,,/09460:&)!2+!4/1:!08,:1+3!4!&:01+!9:&3060:&!0&!:53+5!6:!8060>46+!62+!,:110.0/06<!:;!48,/06-3+!
8:3-/460:&L!
!
“Condition 20. At the request of the local planning authority… Amplitude
modulation is the modulation of the level of broadband noise emitted by a turbine
at blade passing frequency. These will be deemed greater than expected if the
following characteristics apply:
a) A change in the measured LAeq, 125 milliseconds turbine noise level of more
than 3 dB (represented as a rise and fall in sound energy levels each of more than
3 dB occurring within a 2 second period.
b) The change identified in (a) above shall not occur less than 5 times in any one
minute period provided the LAeq, 1 minute turbine sound energy level for that
minute is not below 28dB.
c) The changes identified in (a) and (b) above shall occur for fewer than 6
minutes in any hour.
Noise immissions at the complainant’s dwelling shall be measured not further than
35m from the relevant building, and not closer than within 3.5m of any reflective
building surface, or within 1.2m of the ground.
Condition 21. No wind turbine shall generate electricity to the grid until the
planning authority….has approved in writing a scheme…”
[Hulme MW. Appeal Decision permitting the Den Brook Wind Farm. Inspector A
Pykett; PINS, APP/Q1153/A/06/2017162, 11 December 2009]
!
A2+!3+=+/:,+5!924//+&>+3!62+!9:&3060:&)!.-6!0&!4!e:-56!:;!F,,+4/!3+9010:&)!"W!H4<!"'UU)!&:6!:&/<!
*+5+!62+!9:&3060:&1!-,2+/3L!
!
&
“additionally the Court held that the noise Condition 20 and 21 will also run for the
life of the wind farm.”
[M. Hulme v Secretary of State & RES 2010 EWHC 2386 Admin, 19 August 2010]
W#!
!
%6!12:-/3!.+!&:6+3!6246!62+!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:5!4-62:501+3!+76+5&4/!&0>26!608+!&:01+!/+=+/1!:;!
.+6*++&!$#!3M!kFT')!U'80&!46!U8a1+9!X!(8a1+9!*0&3!1,++3!3+50=+3!.<!;://:*0&>!1->>+16+3!
8+41-5+1!&:6!0&9/-3+3!*0620&!RAPE@!!%&3++3)!62+1+!4/6+5&46+!8+62:31!*+5+!1->>+16+3!.<!1+=+54/!
49:-160904&1)!4//!.-6!:&+!*062!60+1!6:!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<)!0&!4!&:&?,++5!5+=0+*+3!,4,+5)!0&!
*2092!62+!8+62:31!*+5+!8+5+/<!62+:5+6094/!4&3!&+=+5!6+16+3!0&!62+!;0+/3)!4&3!&+=+5!=4/0346+3!
0&3+,+&3+&6/<!.<!:62+5!5+1+4592+51!4&3!49:-160904&1@!!
!
[+50=0&>!62+!U'8!*0&3!1,++31!4//:*1!+=+&!20>2+5!/+=+/1!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!624&!0;!62+!*0&3!
1,++3!01!496-4//<!8+41-5+3!3-50&>!9:8,/04&9+!6+160&>@!
!\P++!A4./+!:;!_:01+!k08061!S+/460&>!6:!e:&3060:&!UW]@!
!
Z7)A6!!%6!01!416:-&30&>!6246!&:01+!/+=+/1!:;!OT@T!3M!kFT'!U'80&!24=+!.++&!4-62:501+3)!+1,+904//<!41!
6201!V05:&1!:-6K!62+!,-/1460:&1!:;!62+!,+4C1)!*2092!45+!+=+&!/:-3+5@!!M49C>5:-&3!&:01+!*0//!&:6!841C!
62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!62-1!+7,:10&>!62:1+!/0=0&>!4&3!*:5C0&>!&+45.<!6:!,5:/:&>+3!4&3!10>&0;094&6!
3:1+1!:;!0&3-16504/!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&@c!
!
A2+!8+62:3!6:!8+41-5+!:5!3+50=+!62+!3464!-10&>!RAPE!4&3!061!0&6+5,5+6460:&1!.<!0&3-165<!
49:-160904&1!"does not reflect the actual conditions causing complaint." A2+!8+62:31!45+!&:6!
:&/<!"unlikely to indicate adverse noise impact at the planning stage, but once the
development is operational, the article method virtually removes the ability for local
communities to enforce controls over reasonable turbine noise impact."
[Stigwood M. The Effect of a Common Wind Shear Adjustment Methodology on the
Assessment of Wind Farms when applying ETSUr-97. MAS Environmental, Cambridge, UK,
27 September 2011
266,Laa***@841+&=@9:@-Ca-,/:431aPAE[JSRigSAe:8,4501:&m"':;m"'62+45609/+4&3RAPEDU
UU''$`%_Fkr1+9@,3;!; and Stigwood M. Summary to: The Effect of a Common Wind Shear
Adjustment Methodology on the Assessment of Wind Farms when applying ETSUr-97. MAS
Environmental, Cambridge, UK, 27 September 2011
http://www.masenv.co.uk/uploads/Summary%20ETSU%20IoA%20article.pdf]!
!
!
e2456!"!0//-16546+1!4!192+84609!:;!e:&3060:&!"'L!
!
U3.(-%MD%%=".F(.11.-"6%&3(*+30,$%50(%U0#$"-"0#%MNI%=*#%Z(00V%c.,,*C%!"#$%&'()"#*%;((.C%
7(080+.,D%
!
!
!
!
W$!
!
F99:530&>!6:!4&!%&;:58460:&!_:6+!011-+3!.<!62+!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!\SR`]!0&!g96:.+5!
"'UU)!9:&3060:&1!"'!4&3!"U!:;!62+![+&!M5::C!p4//+<!I-30904/!3+9010:&!*:-/3!,5:=03+!4!=4/-4./+!
9:&650.-60:&!0;!0&9:5,:546+3!0&6:!&:01+!411+118+&61L!
!
“At first glance this condition appears complex and it has excited controversy, in
part because it has been argued that it is difficult to distinguish wind farm AM
noise from other noises in the environment.
We believe that it would be a useful contribution to the understanding of the
potential application of the Den Brook noise condition if it were used to assess
actual, i.e. real and empirical, wind farm noise data.
However there is little useful wind farm noise data in the public domain. We are
fortunate in that we have recently obtained data collected by the Hayes McKenzie
partnership as part of a Government contract in 2005 to investigate low frequency
noise at wind farms.
That this raw noise data has come into the public domain is testament to the
determination of an individual who, with the assistance of the local MP and advice
from the Campaign for Freedom of Information and the Information Commissioner,
succeeded in obtaining the data from the Department of Energy and Climate
Change in spite of a surprising unwillingness on the part of DECC (Department of
Environment and Climate Change) officials to facilitate its release.”
!
SR`!4&4/<1+3!4!1-.1+960:&!:;!62+!3464!4&3!9:&9/-3+3!6246L!
!
“... this exercise demonstrates that the Den Brook condition is straightforward and
that it is possible for this condition to be employed in a transparent and objective
manner to demonstrate the existence of excess AM in wind turbine noise.
These findings should be welcomed by both wind‐farm neighbours, developers, and
decision makers in the planning process. AM noise provokes complaints and heated
debates, and an enforceable, objective, condition to cap such noise gives all
parties clarity, as well as sparing neighbours and developers the trouble, expense,
and uncertainty of private nuisance actions. The Den Brook condition appears to
be a readily workable solution to this very real problem.”
ZH:5:&+<!k!4&3!e:&164./+!d@!!A2+![+&!M5::C!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!_:01+!e:&3060:&L!
%&;:58460:&!_:6+@!!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!\SR`])!k:&3:&)!EQ)!#U!g96:.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca,-./09460:&1a"$"?62+?3+&?.5::C?48,/06-3+?8:3-/460:&?&:01+?
9:&3060:&c!
!
!
WO!
Appendix 2
!
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%d%W'"$.#6*2%
;$$"-"0#.,%<*5*(*#6*+%
%
F/6+50!M@!
=0*+%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%;55*6-%?0'(%@,**8%0(%/*.,-3A%
/RHT&C9(++%4&U)!M4&>:5!H40&+)!EPF)!U$!H4<!"''T@!
266,Laa***@*/.Y"@9:8a&+*1a/:94/a16:5<@41,7s16:5<03tU'$(U(^94603t#!!
!
e:,,0&>!d!!4&3!N54<!S@!
@G"-63T055%50(%>0"+*%!"#$%L.(1+D%
0%4%@-(>9!\EQ])!UT!_:=+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca+4562a+&+5><a*0&3,:*+5ajT'U$#UaP*0692?:;;?;:5?&:01<?*0&3?
;4581@268/%%
%
U0'#6",%<',"#F%-0%U3.#F*%L'-'(*%05%!"#$5.(1%7,.#+%eU.(1.(-3*#+3"(*I%!.,*+fD%
09#$3$D"1*9/(4%$)!"#!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6201011:-62*4/+1@9:@-Cae:-&90/?5-/0&>?924&>+?;-6-5+?*0&3;458?,/4&1a16:5<?
U"$WUjW(?3+640/a16:5<@268/!
!
e5:1.<![@!
E*F.,%U3.,,*#F*%.F."#+-%!"#$%&'()"#*+%P0B*+%L0(G.($%G"-3%;88*.,%e7("#6*%4$G.($%U0'#-CI%
U.#.$.fD%
09%&D1+&0#.%$!\e4&434])!"'!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@:*+&1:-&31-&608+1@9:8aF5609/+[01,/4<@41,7s+t#'#WUW$!!
!
R3*4531!d@!
U.,,+%50(%;,,-G.,"+%!"#$%L.(1%-0%)*%@3'-%=0G#I%R%_',C%MNJND%
266,Laa***@I:&4624&+3*4531@:5>@-Ca94//1?;:5?4//6*4/01?*0&3?;458?6:?.+?12-6?3:*&!!
!
f4&&0&>!e!4&3!_011+&.4-8!H@!
@*,*6-"0#%05%['-601*%P*.+'(*+%"#%;++*++"#F%@,**8%="+-'().#6*%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*D%
`:-562!%&6+5&460:&4/!H++60&>!:&!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+)!S:8+)!%64/<)!U"?U$!F,50/!"'UU@!
!
d:24&11:&!H@!
!*%>0G%@**%L.1","*+%E*.B"#F%&3*"(%/01*+%e=*#1.(VfD%
k+66+5!6:!R306:5)!"W!H4<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a&+*1a"'UUa*+?&:*?1++?;480/0+1?/+4=0&>?62+05?2:8+1?
5+,:561?,2<10904&?3+&845Ca,50&6a!!
!
k+1/0+!Q@!
[#-.("0%Y#.),*%-0%&*,,%"5%!"#$%L.(1+%4:6**$%>0"+*%E"1"-+I%;6-"B"+-+%@.CD%
09%&V4"2%&(+)&<(#4!\A:5:&6:)!e4&434])!UOaUW!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+>/:.+4&3840/@9:8a&+*1a,:/06091a:&6450:?-&4./+?6:?6+//?0;?*0&3?;4581?+79++3?
&:01+?/08061?4960=0161?14<a45609/+"'W"(jTa!!
!
H4&&!A@!
Z,'1*#-3.,%Y(F*+%&0'F3%@-.#$.($+%50(%@"-"#F%05%!"#$%70G*(%7(0g*6-+D%
09%&E(;!\_+*!k:&3:&)!e:&&+9609-6)!EPF])!d4&-45<!$!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+34<@9:8a45609/+a"'UU'U'$a_DPU"a#'U'$TTUOaU'WTa511!!
!
g0C+!JA@!
_.8.#*+*%U0#5*(*#6*%0#%Z"F%!"#$2%7(*+*#-.-"0#+%)C%c"6-"1+D%e*:6*(8-+fI%QN%;8(",%MNJND%
266,Laa***@+,4*@:5>a3:9-8+&61ad4,4&+1+m"'e:&;+5+&9+m"'4>40&16m"'M0>m"'D0&3@,3;!!
!
S4<!i@!
U3.(F*+%.F."#+-%!"#$%U018.#"*+%Y83*,$D%
:4*""+(&<#--"-)!"(!H4592!"''T@!
266,Laa***@4/6::&48055:5@9:8a,4>+a9:&6+&6@3+640/a03aOU($#T@268/!!
!
!
!
S+03![@!
/*.,-3%455*6-+%05%&'()"#*+A%%!*%;,(*.$C%^#0GD%
09%&H%(8"+&5%-(4)!\g&6450:)!e4&434])!T!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@16546;:53.+49:&2+54/3@9:8aF5609/+[01,/4<@41,7s+t"T""j'j!!
!
P499:5:660!N)!i0990&0&0![)!e4-920+!k)!4&3!`0:50!%@!
@*"+1"6%>0"+*%)C%!"#$%L.(1+2%%;%U.+*%@-'$C%5(01%-3*%cX<W[%W(.B"-.-"0#.,%!.B*%
[)+*(B.-0(CI%X-.,CD%
H144%*#+&",&*9%&D%#$."4"@#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!F,50/!"'UUhU'U\"]LOWj?O(j@!
!
P*0&.4&C1!HF@!
!"#$%&'()"#*+2%%E0GTL(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%d%X#5(.+0'#$%<*B"+"-*$D%
R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!EQ!g&+?34<!D:5C12:,)!M0580&>248)!T!P+,6+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@;50+&31:;840&+18:-&640&1@:5>a-,/:431aR720.06m"'$U)m"'D0&3m"'A-5.0&+1?
m"'k:*?`5+G-+&9<m"'_:01+m"'m"'%&;541:-&3m"'S+=0106+3m"'H4/9:/8rP*0&.4&C1@,3;!
!
A:33!D@!
E"B"#F%G"-3%&'()"#*+%H%.%7*(+0#.,%;660'#-I%JK%L*)('.(C%MNNOD%
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a3:9-8+&61aUOUU#!!
!
A:33!D@!
&*+-"10#C%-0%P."#*%E*F"+,.-'(*I%QN%;8(",%MNNRD%
266,Laa***@840&+@>:=a3+,a;6,a.+,a92#(O9060Y+&r,+6060:&a,5+?2+450&>aFS?
('m"'D+&3<m"'A:33m"'6+1608:&<@,3;!!:5!
266,Laa***@*0&3?*4692@:5>a3:9-8+&61a6+1608:&<?:;?*+&3<?6:33?6:?62+?840&+?/+>01/46-5+?
4,50/?#'?"''(a!
!
&'()"#*%>0"+*%.%!"#$%=*B*,08*(%L"#$+%[)g*6-"0#.),*D%
%&3-16504/!D0&3!F960:&!N5:-,)!UO!d-&+!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a;4G1a"(j'#%
!
D+.16+5!M@!
/*,"608-*(%#0"+*%60'(-%63.,,*#F*%50(%G"#$%5.(1+D%
A2+!A08+1!$!d-/<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+608+1@9:@-Ca66:a+&=05:&8+&6a45609/+#'j"j'T@+9+!
!
%
%
!
%
%
!
WW!
!
Chapter 3
%
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*2%%X18.6-+%0#%/*.,-3%
W(!
!
QDJ%%!X>=%&Y<ZX>4%>[X@4%;>=%X&@%XP7;U&@%[>%/4;E&/I%@E447I%;>=%U[W>X&X[>%
!
A201!924,6+5!+7480&+1!*2<!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!01!,5+I-30904/!4&3!0&I-50:-1!6:!2+4/62)!0&9/-30&>!061!
08,4961!:&!9:>&060:&!4&3!1/++,@!!F/62:->2!62+!924,6+5!4335+11+1!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!1,+90;094//<)!
62+!&:01+!9245496+5016091!411:9046+3!*062!43=+51+!2+4/62!08,4961!45+!&:6!-&0G-+!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!
%&3++3)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9:8.0&+1!&:01+!9245496+5016091!6246!+&>4>+!&+>460=+!,2<10:/:>094/!4&3!
,1<92:/:>094/!5+1,:&1+1!0&!,+:,/+!:;!4//!4>+1)!0@+@)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!94&!.+!,45609-/45/<!0&65-10=+)!
3015-,60=+)!4&3!0&I-50:-1!6:!62+!2+4/62!:;!62:1+!/0=0&>)!/+45&0&>)!4&3!*:5C0&>!&+45.<@!!A2+!3-5460:&!
:;!+7,:1-5+!01!4!;496:5!0&!62+!+;;+961!:&!2+4/62!4&3!*+//!.+0&>@!!ZP++!4/1:!!"#$%&'()#(*#"+&,-".&/#+)&
01-2#+%$&3+$*(44%)&+%(-&5".%$6&7,,%8*$&"+&5%(4*9)!`5+<!^!f433+&!"''()!*2092!9:=+51!+45/0+5!
846+504/!:&!6201!6:,09@c!!!
!
“In epidemiological noise studies, higher risk estimates were found when length of
exposure was considered (years in residence).”
[WHO Burden of Disease from Environmental Noise: Quantification of Health Life
Years Lost in Europe, 2011]
!
A2+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&)!0&!061!5+=0+*!:;!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!:&!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+)!
1646+1!-&+G-0=:94//<L!!
!
“There is sufficient evidence from large-scale epidemiological studies linking the
population’s exposure to environmental noise with adverse health effects.
Therefore, environmental noise should be considered not only as a cause of
nuisance but also a concern for public health and environmental health.”
“In order to inform policy and to develop management strategies and action plans
for noise control, national and local governments need to understand and
consider this new evidence on the health impacts of environmental noise.”
[WHO Regional Office for Europe and the Joint Research Centre of the European
Commission. Burden of Disease from Environmental Noise: Quantification of
Healthy Life Years Lost in Europe, 2011 – WHO BDEN Report] (Emphasis added.)
!
A2+!Dfg!RM[!5+,:56!&:6+1!4/1:!6246!411+110&>!+7,:1-5+!6:!&:01+!0&9/-3+1!62+1+!84I:5!;496:51L!
•
•
•
•
•
“measured exposure or calculated/predicted exposure;
choice of noise indicator;
population distribution;
time-activity patterns of the exposed population;
combined exposures to multiple sources of noise”.
!
H:5+:=+5)!“... despite the considerable effort and progress made in controlling
noise from industry, there has been little improvement in the levels of noise
exposure of people across Europe.” The WHO Burden of Disease report estimated
the health impacts of environmental noise “using exposure-response relationships,
exposure distribution, background prevalence of disease and DWs [disability
weight].” [WHO BDEN Report]
!
A2+!R-5:,+4&!_:01+![05+960=+!X!R_[!X!0&9/-3+1!62+1+!,50&90,/+1L!
•
•
•
!
!
“informing and consulting the public about noise exposure, its effects and
the measures considered to address noise, in line with the principles of the
Aarhus Convention;
addressing local noise issues by requiring competent authorities to draw up
action plans to reduce noise where necessary and maintain
environmental noise quality where it is good; and,
...including objectives to reduce the number of people affected by noise.”
[European Noise Directive (END). Directive 2002/49/EC, 25 June 2002]
(Emphasis added.)
!
R_[!49C&:*/+3>+1!6246!1:8+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!1:-59+1!84<!5+G-05+!1-,,/+8+&645<!&:01+!
0&30946:51!4&3!5+/46+3!/0806!=4/-+1)!,45609-/45/<!62+!;://:*0&>L!
!
•
•
Wj!
“strong low-frequency content of the noise; and
-- LAmax or SEL (sound exposure level) for night period protection in the case
of noise peaks”.
[European Noise Directive 2002/49/EC]
!
M:62!62+1+!45+!9245496+501609!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+L!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!4&3!-&,5+30964./+)!
0&6+58066+&6!,+4C1!\,-/1460&>!&:01+]@!!_:01+)!*2+&!06!0&9/-3+1!62+1+!9:8,:&+&61!41!*+//!41!6:&4/!
G-4/060+1)!84<!0&06046+!:5!+749+5.46+!,2<1094/!4&3!,2<10:/:>094/!924&>+1)!+@>@)!0&95+41+1!0&!./::3!
,5+11-5+!4&3a:5!165+11!2:58:&+!/+=+/1)!1-92!41!9:5601:/@!!`480/0+1)!920/35+&)!62+!+/3+5/<)!4&3!:62+5!
=-/&+54./+!,:,-/460:&1!45+!-&4./+!6:!+194,+!62+!+;;+961!*2+&!62+1+!&:01+1!4;;+96!2:8+1)!192::/1)!
.-10&+11+1)!5+103+&604/!2:8+1)!4&3!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1@!!A2+!:99-,4&61!24=+!&:!5+1,06+)!&:!
8060>460:&)!,45609-/45/<!0;!62+<!4/1:!3:!&:6!24=+!62+!;0&4&904/!5+1:-59+1!6:!8:=+!4*4<!:5!6:!,-51-+!
5+1606-60:&!=04!62+!I-30904/!1<16+8@!
!
e/0&094/!4&3!/4.:546:5<!16-30+1!:&!62+!+;;+961!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!:&!,+:,/+!12:*!6246L!
!
"Noise-inducing stress can lead to release of stress hormones. Acute stress
whether physical or psychological is necessary for adaptation to change... During
long-term stress there may be impairment of immune activity... if overstimulation
due to chronic stress reaction continues, it may be damaging to the health of the
individual... Other than the noise stress acting directly , it may also have an
impact on the immune function via noise-induced sleep deprivation."
"Noise-induced stress effects on cortisol can occur during sleep, which can develop
into a chronic increase if noise exposure is repeated... High noise level may act
directly as a stressor, but low levels may also affect cortisol secretion depending
on the meaning and disturbing nature of the stimulus rather than its level."
"Exposure to noise, particularly when it is unpredictable and intermittent can lead
to noise-induced sleep disturbance."
[Prasher D. Is There Evidence that Environmental Noise is Immunotoxic?
(Report) Noise and Health 2009; 11(44):151-155]
!
R&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+)!*2092!01!4&!-&*4&6+3!:5!2458;-/!:-63::5!1:-&3)!01!8:5+!*03+1,5+43)! 'both
in its duration and geographical coverage')!*062!9:8,/40&61!:&!62+!501+@!!ZRRFL!F.:-6!_:01+!"'UU)!
R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<)!***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a62+8+1a&:01+a4.:-6?&:01+c!!
!
M+94-1+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!'is persistent and inescapable')!/45>+!&-8.+51!:;!,+:,/+!45+!
+7,:1+3!6:!06@!!%&3++3)!62+!R-5:,+4&!E&0:&!N5++&!i4,+5!=1*1-%&!"#$%&J"4#8;&1646+1!6246!
4,,5:70846+/<!'20% of the EU's population suffer from noise levels that health experts
consider to be unacceptable, i.e., which can lead to annoyance, sleep disturbance and
adverse health effects'@!!ZR-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!\RRF]L!F.:-6!_:01+)!RRF)!"'UUc!
!
_:01+!,://-60:&!01!&:6!:&/<!4.:-6!/:-3&+11)!4&&:<4&9+)!4&3!2+450&>!/:116&&&
&
“The effects of noise exposure cannot be understood only by taking mechanisms of
toxic action into account. For example, the sounds of a discotheque are music to
the dancers but noise to the neighbors. In the first case, the exposure would not
be annoying but is expected to contribute to hearing loss; for the neighbors,
hearing loss would be improbable, but annoyance would certainly occur.”
[Passchier-Vermeer W and Passchier WF. Noise exposure and public health.
Environmental Health Perspectives March 2000;108 [Suppl 1]:123-131]
!
F99:530&>!6:!62+!F8+5094&!_460:&4/!P64&3453B1!<%*9")$&,"-&7$*#.(*#"+&",&:B(L%+#+@$&:$$"8#(*%)&
B#*9&Q1*)""-&!"#$%&7F%+*$&5%(-)&#+&5".%$L!!
!
"Nearly all sleep research has concentrated on populations that were exposed to
the given noise source for a long period of time (more than one year)." Therefore,
the equations used "are likely to underestimate the probability of awakening for
sound that is new to an area... Over time, a percentage of the population
acclimates, at least in part, to nighttime noise. Another percentage of the
!
population develops coping strategies such as keeping windows closed at night.
And before a new equilibrium is obtained, some fraction of the population moves
away because they cannot cope or acclimate to the nighttime noise. Thus, it is
likely that Equation (1) underestimates the probability of awakening for sounds
that are new to an area."
[American National Standard. Quantities and Procedures for Description and
Measurement of Environmental Sound - Part 6: Methods for Estimation of
Awakenings Associated with Outdoor Noise Events Heard in Homes. ANSI/ASA
S12.9 - 2008 / Part 6]
WT!
!!
i4*/49Y<C?k-1Y9Y<&1C4!+6!4/!&:6+!6246!k`_!01!5+9:>&01+3!41!4!!
!
“special environmental pollutant, affecting mostly sensitive people in their
homes... The primary and the most frequent adverse effect of LFN is annoyance...
related to feelings described by the words: disturbance, irritation, discomfort,
dissatisfaction, bother, nuisance, uneasiness and distress.”
[Pawlaczyk-Luszczynska, M; Dudarewicz A; Szymczak W; and Sliwinska-Kowalska
M. Evaluation of annoyance from low frequency noise under laboratory conditions.
Noise and Health 2010; 12(48): 166- ]
!
H:5+:=+5)!62+!4-62:51!&:6+!6246!!
!
“Annoyance related to noise (sound) is a combination of both physical and
psychological factors... It has been shown that LFN differs from ordinary mediumor higher-frequency noise. LFN may cause different subjective symptoms and
higher ratings of annoyance than noises at comparable A-weighted sound pressure
levels (SPLs) that are not dominated by low frequencies.
Annoyance from LFN is frequently reported at relatively low SPLs (slightly above
the hearing threshold) and increases rapidly with its level.”
!
A2+1+!4-62:51!4/1:!&:6+!6246!5+1+4592!0&30946+1!!
!
“...people disturbed by LFN in their homes have shown that subjects who become
annoyed by this type of noise develop a specific sensitivity to its sources, while
they rarely consider themselves sensitive to noise in general.”
!
M+94-1+!62+!4-62:51!*+5+!,45609-/45/<!0&6+5+16+3!0&!62+!+;;+961!:;!k`_!0&!:99-,460:&4/!1+660&>1!\+@>@)!
62:1+!4;;+96+3!.<!=+&60/460:&!1<16+81)!2+460&>a405!9:&3060:&0&>!-&061])!62+<!&:6+!6246!1+=+54/!
16-30+1!!
!
“suggest that LFN at levels normally occurring in control rooms and office-like
areas (40-50 dBA) can be perceived as annoying and adversely affecting the
human mental performance, particularly when more demanding tasks have to be
executed.' LFN may affect those whose jobs require 'selective attention and/or
processing [a] high load of information.”
&
A2-1)!6201!-&6:*453!+;;+96!80>26!4/1:!0&9/-3+!84&<!16-3+&61@!!A2+!4-62:51B!5+1+4592!-,2+/3!
;0&30&>1!6246!*2+&!k`_!01!,5+1+&6)!!
!
“noise annoyance was rated higher than its loudness.”
!
A2+05!;0&30&>1!4/1:!1-,,:56!:62+5!5+1+4592!5+1-/61!6246!;:-&3!*2+&!,+5;:580&>!8:5+!3+84&30&>!
641C1)!,+:,/+!;:-&3!!
!
the “disturbing effects related to noise were significantly higher.”
!
A2+1+!;0&30&>1!45+!1-,,:56+3!4/1:!.<!A4C424120!+6!4/h!62+!4-62:51!;:-&3!6246!&:01+?0&3-9+3!
=0.5460:&!!
!
"... directly represents the effect of noise on a part of the body where some
physical symptom has occurred, and it is expected not to vary in magnitude in
long-term exposure to the noise, contrary to any psychological responses which
may be reduced in magnitude as habituating... The noise-induced vibration
!
measured on the chest is higher than the vibration measured on other parts of the
human body."
[Takahashi Y; Yonekawa Y; and Kanada K. A New Approach to Assess Low
Frequency Noise in the Working Environment. Industrial Health 2001; 39:281286]
Indeed, "... the vibrations induced in the trunk of the body (the chest and the
abdomen) really do contribute to the unpleasantness." The vibration acceleration
level (VAL) "is not related to the loudness and the A-weighted sound pressure level
is not related to the vibration... This indicates that noise content at lower
frequencies should be given more importance in evaluating high-level lowfrequency noise... Noise-induced vibrations primarily induce vibratory sensation
and through the vibratory sensation or together with some other stimulating
factors, they secondarily contribute to inducing unpleasantness." Therefore, to
evaluate the effects of LFN, "the effect of vibration should be taken into account."
[Takahashi Y; Kanada K; Yonekawa Y; and Harada N. A Study on the Relationship
between Subjective Unpleasantness and Body Surface Vibrations Induced by HighLevel Low-Frequency Pure Tones. Industrial Health 2005; 43:580-587]
('!
!
A2+1+!4-62:51!4/1:!&:6+)!41!:62+51!24=+)!6246!62+!F?*+0>26+3!1:-&3!,5+11-5+!/+=+/!"is useful for
measuring noise"!.-6!;:9-1+1!:&!4-30./+!&:01+!4&3!-&3+5+160846+1!k`_@!!g62+5!194/+1!;:5!k`_)!62+!
k`_S!:5!N?*+0>260&>!9-5=+)!"are useful for evaluating temporary psychological effects...”&!!
!
A2+1+!5+1,:&1+1!45+!"expected to be gradually reduced"!41!62+!,+51:&!24.06-46+1!6:!62+!&:01+@!!
f:*+=+5)!84&<!*:5C+51!&++3!+=4/-460:&!:;!62+!&:01+!“from the standpoint of preventing its
chronic and physical health effects.”&!F&3!6201!84<!9+5640&/<!2:/3!4/1:!;:5!62+!84&<!*2:!/0=+!&+45!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!*2092!45+!"$a(!1:-59+1!:;!&:01+!*062!4&!k`_!9:8,:&+&6)!;:5!41!62+!4-62:51!
A4C424120!+6!4/!&:6+)!62+!=0.5460:&!+=:C+1!4!,2<1094/!4&3!8+924&094/!5+1,:&1+!;5:8!62+!2-84&!
.:3<!4&3!01!&:6!+7,+96+3!6:!5+3-9+!+=+&!*062!/:&>?6+58!+7,:1-5+@!!%6!01!"induced not only on the
body surface but also in the inner body such as the internal organs".!!f:*+=+5)!62+!4-62:51!
303!;0&3!6246!.:3<!;46!9:-/3!B348,B!:5!:.165-96!62+!,5:,4>460:&!:;!k`_!625:->2!62+!.:3<@!!
ZA4C424120!Jh!J:&+C4*4!Jh!Q4&434!Qh!4&3!H4+34!P@!!F!i0/:6!P6-3<!:&!62+!f-84&!.:3<!p0.5460:&!
%&3-9+3!.<!k:*!`5+G-+&9<!_:01+@!!3+)1$*-#(4&5%(4*9!UTTTh!#(L"j?#Oc!
!
F99:530&>!6:!F/4<549!+6!4/)!!
!
"Indeed, noise annoyance studies focusing on industrial noise are not as numerous
as those on transportation noise, presumably because this noise is less
widespread. Another reason may be that industrial noise sources are
heterogeneous due to the different types of industrial activities...Nevertheless,
previous field surveys have provided information about the assessment of
industrial noise sources, such as noise immission sound levels leading to
complaints, or spectral features and non-acoustical parameters influencing noise
annoyance... In the case of a tone added to a background noise, Hellman (1982)
observed that annoyance response depends on the overall sound pressure level,
the frequency of the tone, the tone-to-noise ratio and the spectral shape of the
noise."
[Alayrac M, Marquis-Favre C, Viollon S, Morel J, and Le Nost G. Annoyance from
Industrial Noise: Indicators for a Wide Variety of Industrial Sources. JASA Journal
of the Acoustical Society of America Sept 2010;128(3):1128-1139]
!
H:5+!1,+90;094//<)!i+3+51+&!+6!4/!;:-&3!6246L!
!
"The expectation that the presence of road traffic sound would reduce the
prevalence or annoyance due to noise from wind turbines in general was not
confirmed in this systematical analysis of a large data set. The relationships
between sound levels and annoyance with the noise were in most cases separate
for wind turbine and road traffic, respectively, and not interacting... Wind turbine
sound is, as found in other studies, very easily perceived and about 80% of the
respondents in this study could hear the sound at levels as low as 35--40DB(A)
Lden when background sound levels were low." This situation prevails in many
situations when wind turbines are sited in rural or particularly tranquil areas, but
near homes.”
!
[Pedersen E; van den Berg F; Bakker R; and Bouma J. Can Road Traffic Mask
Sound from Wind Turbines? Response to Wind Turbine Sound at Different Levels
of Road Traffic Sound. Energy Policy 2010;38:2520-2527]
(U!
!
f:*+=+5)!i+3+51+&!+6!4/!4/1:!;:-&3!6246L!!!
!
"Wind turbines were less easily heard when road traffic sound dominated over
wind turbine sound, but this did not result in a change in annoyance: the doseresponse relationship between levels of wind turbine noise and annoyance were
about the same despite levels of road traffic sound. The exception is that high
levels of road traffic sound (>55 dB(A)) did seem to have a masking effect on wind
turbine sound, but only at moderate levels of wind turbine sound (35 -- 40
dB(A))."
!
A246!01)!+=+&!*062!62+!,5+1+&9+!:;!/:-3!654;;09!&:01+)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!43=+51+/<!4;;+961!62:1+!
*0620&!2+450&>!X!4&!08,496!>5+46+5!624&!6246!:;!62+!654;;09!&:01+L!
!
"Wind turbine sound levels do not follow the same behaviour as road traffic noise
levels. Road traffic usually calms at night, whereas modern, tall wind turbines
may produce more sound at night than in daytime."
[Pedersen E; van den Berg F; Bakker R; and Bouma J. Can Road Traffic Mask
Sound from Wind Turbines? Response to Wind Turbine Sound at Different Levels
of Road Traffic Sound. Energy Policy 2010;38:2520-2527]
!
A2+1+!5+1-/61!5+,/0946+!+45/0+5!;0&30&>1L!
!
"Noise from wind turbines was found to be more annoying than noise from several
other sources at comparable Lden sound levels...Like aircraft, wind turbines are
elevated sound sources visible from afar and hence intrude both visually and
aurally into private space."
[Pedersen E; van den Berg F; Bakker R; and Bouma J. Response to Noise from
Modern Wind Farms in The Netherlands. JASA Journal of the Acoustical Society of
America August 2009;126(2): 634-643]
!
P4/6!4&3!f-//45K1!,4,+5)!'%$>"+$%$&",&*9%&7(-&*"&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&D"1+)$I&3+,-($"1+)&(+)&/#+)&
01-2#+%$)!3019-11+1!62+!,2<10:/:><)!;-&960:&1)!4&3!5+1,:&1+1!:;!62+!+45h!62+!9:92/+4!X!62+!4-306:5<!
,456!:;!62+!+45!X!241!6*:!6<,+1!:;!1+&1:5<!9+//1)!0&&+5!4&3!:-6+5!2405!9+//1)!6246!5+1,:&3!6:!1608-/0!
4&3!654&1806!V2+450&>K!6:!62+!.540&@!!A2+!0&&+5!2405!9+//1K!1+&1060=06<!3+95+41+1!41!1:-&3!;5+G-+&9<!
01!/:*+5+3@!!%&!9:&65416)!62+!:-6+5!2405!9+//1!!
!
“are directly coupled to mechanical stimuli...At very low frequencies the OHC are
stimulated by sounds at levels below those that are heard.” The authors note
that: “There are, however, abnormal states in which the ear becomes
hypersensitive to infrasound. In most cases, the inner ear’s responses to
infrasound can be considered normal, but they could be associated with unfamiliar
sensations or subtle changes in physiology. This raises the possibility that
exposure to the infrasound component of wind turbine noise could influence the
physiology of the ear.”
!
A201!241!10>&0;094&9+!.+94-1+)!41!P4/6!4&3!f-//45!:.1+5=+)!!
!
“Infrasonic sounds are generated internally in the body (by respiration, heartbeat,
coughing etc.) and by external sources, such as air conditioning systems, inside
vehicles, some industrial processes and, now becomingly increasingly prevalent,
wind turbines.” Infrasonic sound that cannot be heard can influence inner ear
physiology. Moreover, using the A-weighted scale for wind turbine noise
“underestimates the influence of the sound on the ear. A greater effort should be
made to document the infrasound component of wind turbine sounds under
different conditions.” The authors conclude that “there is an urgent need for more
research directly addressing the physiologic consequences of long-term, low level
infrasound exposures on humans.”
[Salt AN and Hullar TE. Responses of the Ear to Low Frequency Sounds,
Infrasound and Wind Turbines. Hearing Research 2010 Sept 1;268(1-2):12-21.
The authors’ research was supported by an RO1 research grant from 2004 – 2010
!
from the National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, US
National Institutes of Health.]
("!
!
A2-1)!4,,/09460:&1!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!106+3!&+45!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1!1-92!41!192::/1!:5!
2:1,064/1)!41!*+//!41!2:8+1)!*:-/3!.+&+;06!;5:8!>5+46+5!195-60&<)!0&9/-30&>!1650&>+&6!+&;:59+4./+!
&:01+!9:&3060:&1!4&3!>5+46+5!1+6.49C!30164&9+1!;5:8!62+1+!;490/060+1@!
!
o-4&60;<0&>!62+!5+/46+3!301+41+!.-53+&!01)!41!:&+!80>26!084>0&+)!4!924//+&>+!&:6!:&/<!;:5!62:1+!*2:!
9://+96!4&3!4&4/<1+!,-./09!2+4/62!3464)!.-6!4/1:!;:5!,:/09<!84C+51@!!_:01+!+7,:1-5+!X!*2+62+5!!!
+&=05:&8+&64/)!:99-,460:&4/)!:5!5+95+460:&4/!X!/+431!6:!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1)!4&&:<4&9+)!2+450&>!
08,4058+&6)!4&3!6:!:62+5!2+4/62!,5:./+81!1-92!41!94530:=419-/45!301+41+1@!
!
[-50&>!62+!&0&+6++&62!9+&6-5<)!+&=05:&8+&64/!:5!:99-,460:&4/!0//&+11+1!*+5+!1:8+608+1!8:5+!
+410/<!03+&60;0+3!624&!0&!6:34<B1!1:90+6<)!*2092!01!8:5+!8:.0/+@!!`:5!+748,/+)!0&!6:*&1!*062!
;496:50+1!,5:3-90&>!84692+1!6246!-1+3!,2:1,2:5-1!0&!62+!,5:9+11)!4!,2:1,2:5-1?5+/46+3!301:53+5!
3+=+/:,+3)!1:8+*246!+410/<!6549C+3!6:!62+!1:-59+@!!A2+!:;;09+!*:5C+51!0&!62+!148+!;496:50+1!303!&:6!
3+=+/:,!62+!35+43+3!B,2:11<!I4*B!6246!4;;/096+3!62+!;/::5!*:5C+51)!*2:!3+=+/:,+3!62+!9:&3060:&!41!
62+!5+1-/6!:;!,2:1,2:5-1!+7,:1-5+!:&!62+!;496:5<!;/::5@!!Bi2:11<!I4*B!*41!845C+3!.<!:16+:&+95:101!
\3+462!:;!62+!.:&+])!499:8,4&0+3!.<!,40&)!1*+//0&>)!3+.0/06460:&)!4&3!+7,:1+3!.:&+!:;!62+!I4*@!!
M+94-1+!*:5C+51!/0=+3!0&!4!*+//?3+;0&+3!45+4!4&3!*+5+!:.1+5=+3!.<!62+!148+!,2<10904&1)!9/-16+51!
:5!,466+5&1!:;!0//&+11+1!9:-/3!.+!5+9:>&01+3!+45/<@!!ZH457!SR@!!E&9:=+50&>!62+!e4-1+!:;!Bi2:11<!d4*B!
90594!UjOj!6:!UT'WL!g54/!4&3!H470//:;4904/!P-5>+5<!e/:1+3!e41+!`0/+1!?!e41+!e/:1+3@!!M"1-+(4&",&Q-(4&
(+)&<(P#44",(8#(4&D1-@%-;!"''jh!WW\UU]L!"#OW?"#W#c!!
!
A2:->2!:99410:&4//<!*:5C0&>!9:&3060:&1!*+5+!08,5:=+3!.<!62+!:*&+51)!:;6+&!62+!*:5C0&>!
9:&3060:&1!*+5+!B6:/+546+3B!-&60/!924&>+1!*+5+!84&346+3@!!%&!62+!941+!:;!B,2:11<!I4*B)!62+!301+41+!
*41!;0&4//<!+5430946+3!*2+&!62+!EP!e:&>5+11!I:0&+3!*062!:62+5!&460:&1!6:!+5430946+!62+!301+41+!4&3!
,411+3!A2+!H4692!F96!0&!UTU")!,/490&>!4!647!:&!,2:1,2:5-1!84692+1)!;:590&>!84&-;496-5+51!6:!;0&3!
4!/+11!+7,+&10=+!X!4&3!&:&?6:709!X!1-.1606-6+@!!Z`+/6:&!dP@!!e/411094/!1<&35:8+1!0&!:99-,460:&4/!
8+3090&+L!,2:1,2:5-1!&+95:101!??!4!9/411094/!:99-,460:&4/!301+41+@!!:.%-#8(+&M"1-+(4&",&3+)1$*-#(4&
<%)#8#+%!UTj"h!#\U]L!((?U"'h!H<+51!Hk!4&3!H9N/:62/0&!d[@!!H469284C+51B!B,2:11<!I4*B!+5430946+3@!!
:.%-#8(+&3+)1$*-#(4&5;@#%+%&:$$"8#(*#"+&M"1-+(4!F,5!UTTWh!O(\$]L!##'?##"c!!
!
f:*+=+5)!,+:,/+!45+!&:*!8:5+!301,+51+3!0&!62+05!*:5C!4&3!/0=0&>!4554&>+8+&61h!&+0>2.:-51!3:!
&:6!&+9+11450/<!=0106!62+!148+!,2<10904&1)!4&3!0&30=03-4/!,460+&61!84<!1++!30;;+5+&6!,2<10904&1!0&!
62+!9:-51+!:;!62+!148+!2+4/62!9:8,/40&6!:5!0//&+11@!!H+3094/!945+!01!8:5+!1:,20160946+3!6:34<)!.-6!
62+!,5:=010:&!:;!945+!84<!.+!8:5+!;54>8+&6+3!624&!0&!62+!,416@!
!
A2-1)!03+&60;<0&>!4!,-./09!2+4/62!,5:./+8!??!1-92!41!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!:;!&:01+)!4&3!62+&!
16-3<0&>!62+!,5:./+8)!+@>@)!3+10>&0&>!16-30+1)!>+660&>!;-&3+3)!9://+960&>!3464)!4&3!4&4/<10&>!62+!
3464)!.+9:8+1!8:5+!9:8,/+7@!!R,03+80:/:>09!16-30+1!3:!&:6!-1-4//<!3+/0=+5!4&1*+51!088+3046+/<)!
8-92!6:!62+!924>50&!:;!84&<)!.-6!06!01!95-904/!6:!>+6!62+!190+&9+!50>26!;:5!62:1+!*2:!1-;;+5!41!*+//!41!
;:5!62:1+!*2:!24=+!6:!84C+!3+9010:&1!:&!.+24/;!:;!62+!,-./09B1!2+4/62@!
!
D062!&:01+)!,+:,/+!84<!1-;;+5!0&!10/+&9+!X!6246!01)!62+!10/+&9+!:;!:;;0904/!5+1,:&1+!4&3!4110164&9+@!!
D062!18:C0&>)!&:6!+=+5<!18:C+5!;4//1!=09608!6:!/-&>!94&9+5)!<+6!,-./09!2+4/62!4&3!>:=+5&8+&6!
948,40>&1!645>+6!18:C+51!.+94-1+!:;!62+!9:16!6:!62+!2+4/62!945+!1<16+8!4&3!62:1+!,:6+&604//<!
4;;+96+3!.<!1+9:&3?24&3!18:C+@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+5+!01!62+!9:16!6:!62+!2+4/62!945+!1<16+8!.<!62:1+!
18:C+51!*2:!3+=+/:,!5+1,0546:5<!:5!94530:=419-/45!301+41+1@!!A2+!+;;+961!:;!18:C0&>!45+!*+//?
43=+5601+3!4&3!*+//?16-30+3@!!J+6!,+:,/+!*2:!1-;;+5!;5:8!62+!43=+51+!08,496!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!
&:01+!45+!/4.+/+3!_%HMJ1!\&:6!0&!8<!.49C!<453@@@])!:5!45+!6:/3!6246!62+05!&-8.+51!45+!184//!0&!
5+/460:&!6:!62+!6:64/!&-8.+5!:;!+7,:1+3!0&30=03-4/1!:5!62+!,:,-/460:&!0&!>+&+54/)!62-1!62+05!
9:8,/40&61!3:!&:6!4,,+45!:&!62+!54345!:;!-5>+&6!9:&9+5&!.<!62:1+!*2:!84C+!4&3!+&;:59+!,:/09<@!!!
!
f:*+=+5)!5+9+&6!5+1+4592!:&!&:01+!4&3!061!43=+51+!+;;+961!:&!2+4/62!0&30946+1!6246!,+:,/+!45+!
4;;+96+3!.<!&:01+!+=+&!*2+&!62+<!1/++,!625:->2!0&65-10=+!1:-&31@!!P/++,!01!1:!08,:564&6!6:!62+!
5+16:5460=+!,5:9+11)!,+:,/+!45+!-&4*45+!:;!62+!0&65-10:&@!!A2+<!84<!&:6!&+9+11450/<!46650.-6+!62+05!
34<608+!;460>-+!:5!0&4.0/06<!6:!9:&9+&6546+!:&!62+!+76+&3+3!+7,:1-5+!6:!&0>26608+!&:01+)!.-6!62+!
&:01+!0&65-10:&1!3-50&>!1/++,!84<!0&3++3!94-1+!62+!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+!4&3!62+!5+1-/60&>!924&>+1!0&!
34<608+!9:&9+&65460:&!4&3!/+45&0&>!,+5;:584&9+@!!!!
!
!
“Public health experts agree that environmental risks constitute 25% of the burden
of disease. Widespread exposure to environmental noise from road, rail, airports
and industrial sites contributes to this burden...Epidemiological evidence indicates
that those chronically exposed to high levels of environmental noise have an
increased risk of cardiovascular diseases such as myocardial infarction. Thus,
noise pollution is considered not only an environmental nuisance but also a threat
to public health.”
[WHO Regional Office for Europe and the Joint Research Centre of the European
Commission. Burden of Disease from Environmental Noise: Quantification of
Healthy Life Years Lost in Europe, 2011; European Environment Agency EEA.
Good Practice Guide on Noise Exposure and Potential Health Effects. EEA
Technical Report No 11/2010]
(#!
!
!
%&!061!+=03+&9+?.41+3!4&4/<101!:;!62+!.-53+&!:;!301+41+!;5:8!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+)!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!
g5>4&0Y460:&!0&9/-3+3!94530:=419-/45!301+41+)!9:>&060=+!08,4058+&6)!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+)!60&&06-1)!
4&3!4&&:<4&9+@!!D2+&!62+5+!45+!20>2!/+=+/1!“of annoyance caused by environmental noise”,
then it “should be considered as one of the environmental health burdens”. !!!
ZDfg!S+>0:&4/!g;;09+!;:5!R-5:,+!4&3!62+!d:0&6!S+1+4592!e+&65+!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:880110:&@!!
M-53+&!:;![01+41+!;5:8!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+L!!o-4&60;09460:&!:;!f+4/62<!k0;+!J+451!k:16!0&!R-5:,+)!
"'UUh!R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!RRF@!!N::3!i549609+!N-03+!:&!_:01+!R7,:1-5+!4&3!i:6+&604/!
f+4/62!R;;+961@!!RRF!A+92&094/!S+,:56!_:!UUa"'U'!266,Laa***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a,-./09460:&1a>::3?
,549609+?>-03+?:&?&:01+c!
!
A2+!190+&9+!5+>4530&>!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!:;!&:01+!:&!,+:,/+!241!43=4&9+3!10>&0;094&6/<!3-50&>!62+!
,416!;+*!3+943+1)!+164./0120&>!6246!!
!
“Noise is an underestimated threat' 6246!94&!94-1+!84&<!12:56?6+58!4&3!/:&>?6+58!
2+4/62!,5:./+81@!!F8:&>!62+1+!,5:./+81!45+L 'sleep disturbance; cardiovascular
effects; poorer work or school performance; hearing impairment including tinnitus;
aberrations in social behaviour such as aggressiveness and passivity; pain and
hearing fatigue; speech problems; and hormonal responses (stress hormones) and
their consequences on human metabolism, and immune system problems.”
[WHO/Europe: Noise 2011; see also the WHO NNG for Europe.]
!
A201!+8,24101+1!4&:62+5!41,+96!:;!&:01+!6246!94&!4;;+96!2+4/62!4&3!.+24=0:-5L!!&:01+!6246!01!
0&4-30./+!6:!62+!2-84&!+45@!!\RAPE?S?T(!3:+1!&:6!0&9/-3+!0&4-30./+!&:01+!+;;+961!0&!061!,5+30960:&1!
:5!>-034&9+@]!!i+:,/+!X!*20/+!4*4C+!:5!*20/+!1/++,0&>!X!+7,+50+&9+!.:62!4-30./+!4&3!0&4-30./+!
1:-&3@!!M+94-1+!62+!4-306:5<!1<16+8!3:+1!&:6!B12-6!3:*&B!3-50&>!1/++,)!62+!.:3<!9:&60&-+1!6:!
+7,+50+&9+!4&3!5+496!6:!&:01+@!!!
ZDfg!S+>0:&4/!g;;09+!;:5!R-5:,+!4&3!62+!d:0&6!S+1+4592!e+&65+!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:880110:&@!!
M-53+&!:;![01+41+!;5:8!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+L!!o-4&60;09460:&!:;!f+4/62<!k0;+!J+451!k:16!0&!R-5:,+)!
"'UUh!R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!RRF@!!N::3!i549609+!N-03+!:&!_:01+!R7,:1-5+!4&3!i:6+&604/!
f+4/62!R;;+961@!!RRF!A+92&094/!S+,:56!_:!UUa"'U'!266,Laa***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a,-./09460:&1a>::3?
,549609+?>-03+?:&?&:01+c!
!
“In the 1960s most of the effects of sound on health and quality of life were
already known or at least hypothesized... In the 1970s, the research results were
sufficiently reviewed to allow science-based recommendations to be made for
policy measures to protect public health. In the last three decades new data have
confirmed the earlier insights [and] have made more precise assessments of
exposure-response relationships and observation thresholds possible.”
[Passchier-Vermeer W and Passchier WF. Noise exposure and public health.
Environmental Health Perspectives March 2000; 108[Suppl 1]: 123-131]
!
k:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)!*2092!94&!3016-5.!,+:,/+!+=+&!*2+&!62+!&:01+!01!0&4-30./+)!4/1:!654=+/1!/:&>!
30164&9+1!*062:-6!466+&-460:&)!4&3!*2+&!4!.-0/30&>!01!4;;+96+3)!k`_!94&!B.:-&9+B!625:->2:-6!4!
5::8)!:5!95+46+!B=0.5460:&1B!*0620&!*4//1!:5!;/::51!4&3!:62+5!.-0/30&>!;+46-5+1@!!`-562+58:5+)!4&<!
,+:,/+!*0620&!62+!165-96-5+!94&!4/1:!.+!4;;+96+3@!!k`_!01!;+/6!625:->2!62+!.:3<)!+1,+904//<!62+!6:51:@!!
D2+&!k`_!9:8.0&+1!*062!0&6+58066+&6!&:01+!\+@>@)!B62-8,0&>B!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+])!4!,+51:&!94&!
+7,+50+&9+!62+!+;;+96!4&3!5+496!,2<10:/:>094//<!*20/+!41/++,)!*062:-6!496-4//<!4*4C+&0&>@!!A2+!
+;;+96!94&!4/1:!.+!30165+110&>!*20/+!62+!,+51:&!01!4*4C+)!.+94-1+!62+5+!01!&:!+194,+!;5:8!62+!&:01+!
4&3!061!+;;+961h!4&3!0;!62+!k`_!01!0&4-30./+)!62+!,+51:&!84<!.+!-&4./+!6:!03+&60;<!62+!1:-59+!:;!62+!
($!
!
,5:./+8@!!A201!01!:&+!5+41:&!*2<!62+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!*+5+!&:6!;-//<!,5+3096+3!:5!
4&6090,46+3)!-&60/!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!.-0/6!&+45+5!8:5+!2:8+1!4&3!:62+5!1+&1060=+!
165-96-5+1@!!A2+&!62+!9:8,/40&61!+194/46+3!6:!4!8:5+!9506094/!&-8.+5!X!41!01!:;6+&!62+!941+!*062!
,-./09!2+4/62!9:&1+G-+&9+1!;5:8!+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&@!!
Ze+54&&4!kh!f45684&&!Nh!4&3!f+&>+5!H!\`+3+54/!%&1606-6+!;:5!N+:190+&9+1!4&3!_46-54/!S+1:-59+1)!
f4&&:=+5!N+584&<]@!!09%&3+(1)#24%&!"#$%&",&/#+)&01-2#+%$@!!A2+!%&;541:-&3!D:5C12:,)!A42060)!_:=!
"j!?![+9!")!"''Oh!=4&!3+&!M+5>!Ni@!!09%&H%(*&#$&V%**#+@&D*-"+@%-6&*9%&7,,%8*&",&:*."$>9%-#8&D*(2#4#*;&
"+&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&<")14(*%)&D"1+)&",&/#+)&01-2#+%$@!!d:-5&4/!:;!k:*!`5+G-+&9<!_:01+)!p0.5460:&!
4&3!F960=+!e:&65:/&"''Oh!"$\U]L!U?"$h!=4&!3+&!M+5>!Ni@!!E"&/#+)&01-2#+%$&J-")18%&D#@+#,#8(+*&R"B&
=-%W1%+8;&D"1+)&R%F%4$^!!UU62!%&6+5&460:&4/!H++60&>!:&!k:*!`5+G-+&9<!_:01+!4&3!p0.5460:&!4&3!061!
e:&65:/)!H441650926)!A2+!_+62+5/4&31)!#'!F->-16!?!U!P+,6+8.+5!"''$h!!D4<+!Q@!!7,,%8*$&",&R"B&
=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%&"+&D4%%>A!!_:01+!4&3!f+4/62!"''$h!W\"#]h!i+3+51+&!R!4&3!D4<+!Qi@!!/#+)&01-2#+%&
!"#$%I&:++";(+8%&(+)&D%4,`'%>"-*%)&5%(4*9&(+)&/%44`H%#+@&#+&E#,,%-%+*&R#F#+@&7+F#-"+.%+*$@!!g99-,!
R&=05:&!H+3!"''(h!W$L!$j'?$jWh!F/4<549!H)!H45G-01?`4=5+!e)!p0://:&!P)!H:5+/!d)!4&3!k+!_:16!N@!!
:++";(+8%&,-".&3+)1$*-#(4&!"#$%6&3+)#8(*"-$&,"-&(&/#)%&O(-#%*;&",&3+)1$*-#(4&D"1-8%$@!!d!:;!62+!
F9:-16094/!P:90+6<!:;!F8+5094!"'U'!P+,6h!U"j\#]L!UU"j?UU#Th!M54<!DS@!!<%($1-%.%+*&(+)&D"1+)&
a1(4#*;&3$$1%$&C"+8%-+#+@&R"B`=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%A!!_:01+?e:&!"''()!S+&:)!_+=434)!g96:.+5!""?"$!
"''(h!,4,+51!,5+1+&6+3!46!62+!`:-562!%&6+5&460:&4/!e:&;+5+&9+!:&!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+)!S:8+)!UU?
U$!F,50/!"'UU!***@*0&36-5.0&+&:01+"'UU@:5>c!
!
%&6+5+160&>/<)!*2+&!RAPE?S?UTT(!*41!,-./012+3)!8-92!:;!6201!0&;:58460:&!*41!4=40/4./+)!I-16!&:6!
0&9/-3+3!:5!4//-3+3!6:!0&!62+!5+,:56@!!%6!4,,+451!6246!RAPEB1!4-62:51!303!&:6!9:&1-/6!+,03+80:/:>0161!
4&3!+7,+561!0&!62+!8+3094/!;0+/31!:;!1/++,!4&3!&:01+!&:5!01!62+5+!+=03+&9+!6246!62+<!5+=0+*+3!62+!
,-./012+3!5+1+4592!0&!62:1+!;0+/31@!!A201!5+840&+3!9:&1016+&6!625:->2:-6!;-562+5!>:=+5&8+&6!
4>+&9<!9:&1-/61!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!F1!+=03+&9+3!.<!9:&=+&0&>!62+![60!_:01+!D:5C0&>!N5:-,!
\_DN])!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!*41!4&!03+&60;0+3!,5:./+8!;:5!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1@!!
J+6)!+=+&!62+&)!>:=+5&8+&6!4>+&90+1!4&3!061!&:01+!9:&1-/64&61!92:1+!6:!+79/-3+!4=40/4./+!+7,+5601+@!!
A2+!_DN!\4&3!;-6-5+!>:=+5&8+&6!9:&1-/6460:&1]!;:9-1+3!:&!4-30./+!&:01+@!!!
!
J+6!41!+45/<!41!UTj")!4!_FPF!A+92&094/!H+8:54&3-8!.<!P6+,2+&1!%*&(4!&:6+3!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!4;;+961!+=+&!62:1+!*2:!45+!0&3::51h!62+<!+7,+50+&9+!!
!
"noise modified by the house structure and may also experience noise-induced
building vibration... The recommended goal for designing and siting future
machines is that the noise and vibration levels at the receiver location be below
the respective perception threshold values when considered with the background
noise."
[Stephens DG; Shepherd KP; Hubbard HH; and Grosveld FW. Guide to the
Evaluation of Human Exposure to Noise from Large Wind Turbines. NASA
Technical Memorandum 83288, March 1982]
!
H:5+:=+5L!!
!
"Tests were conducted to determined [sic] the threshold of detection for the
impulsive 'thumping' sounds which result from blade/tower-wake interactions.
This stimulus is believed to be the dominant source of annoyance in large
downwind machines... this may be an important noise generation mechanism for
both 'upwind' and 'downwind' machines."
!
P6+,2+&1!+6!4/!9:&60&-+L!!!
!
"Since house structures have many components which are readily excited by noise
and which can be coupled, they respond as complex vibrating systems. These
dynamic responses are significant because they affect the environment of the
observers inside the house... The LF components (below 125 Hz) are thus
believed to be most significant... Thus there is an indication that there are
significant extra-auditory effects such as noise induced house vibration or that
there are localized areas in the houses where the inside noise levels are
considerably higher than the limited data indicate."
!
A2-1!06!01!&:!1-5,501+!6246!RAPE?S?T(!241!0&?.-0/6!12:569:80&>1)!41!06!8470801+1!4//:*4./+!&:01+!
/+=+/1!0&!;4=:-5!:;!*0&3!+&+5><!3+=+/:,8+&6)!;:9-1+1!:&!4-30./+!&:01+)!3:+1!&:6!499:-&6!;:5!62+!
08,-/10=+!9245496+5!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!4&3!3:+1!&:6!499:-&6!;:5!62+!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!9:8,:&+&6!
(O!
!
:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!F11-80&>!6246!8:16!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!&+45!106+1!*2+5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!/46+5!
.-0/6!45+!-&;480/045!*062!62+!P6+,2+&1!%*&(4!5+1+4592)!06!01!1650C0&>!2:*!1080/45!62+05!5+1,:&1+1!X!
.:62!,2<1094/!5+1,:&1+1!4&3!=+5.4/!3+1950,60:&1!X!*+5+)!.49C!0&6:!62+!UTj'1!4&3!UTT'1)!*062:-6!
62+!.+&+;06!:;!0&;:58460:&!12450&>!=04!62+!%&6+5&+6)!4&3!2:*!499-546+!P6+,2+&1!%*&(4!*+5+!0&!
3+1950.0&>!62+!5+4960:&1!:;!62:1+!+7,:1+3!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!f:*+=+5)!:&+!8-16!411-8+!6246!
49:-160904&1!0&!62+!UTT'1!*:-/3!24=+!243!;480/04506<!*062!62+!P6+,2+&1!%*&(4!4&3!5+/46+3!5+1+4592!
5+,:561@!
!
%&!_:=+8.+5!"'U')!P6+,2+&!A5:84&1)!oe)!:;!A2056<_0&+!R11+7!P65++6)!4!;058!6246!:;6+&!5+,5+1+&61!
62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!*062!4,,/09460:&1!4&3!4,,+4/1)!*5:6+L!
!
“The ETSU-R-97 four stage process is cumulative. Each step relies on the previous
step, and everything relies on the first...”
!
A5:84&1!62+&!49C&:*/+3>+1)!0&!4!.50+;!1-8845<!:;!62+!D+4=+562:5,+!S:43)!M543;:53!F,,+4/!
3+9010:&)!6246!%&1,+96:5!g53!243!+8,24101+3L!!!
!
“The measuring is complicated and inexact... sensitive to small physical variations
in location of the microphone, and to ambient conditions such as temperature,
humidity and rain so that the results of any two sets of background
measurements, taken on the same place on different days, are likely to vary.”
!
`-562+58:5+)!*506+1!A5:84&1L!!!
!
“Wind turbines have changed dramatically since ETSU-R-97 was drafted... ETSU
was not a government report, it was the consensus view of a limited group of
experts, produced in the context that existing guidance on noise in BS4142 was
not appropriate or adequate for wind farms, and produced a compromise which
ETSU itself acknowledges was intended in the public interest to offer a reasonable
degree of protection to neighbours without imposing unreasonable restrictions on
wind farm development or adding unduly to the costs and administrative burdens
on developers and local authorities.”
!
A201!+8,24101!:&!+410&>!62+!*4<!;:5!3+=+/:,8+&6!9:&60&-+1!6:34<)!+=+&!*062!4//!62+!94=+461!
8+&60:&+3!.<!A5:84&1L!!!
!
“... planning inspectors are generally and unsurprisingly unwilling to depart from
ETSU... With one exception, permission for wind farms is hardly ever refused on
the basis of noise impact when the inspector has accepted that the development
will be ETSU-compliant.
This is true even 'In the not unlikely event of a flawed background
survey..."
[Tromans, S, QC. Assessing the Noise Impacts of Onshore Wind Turbines.
ThirtyNine Essex Street Environmental and Planning Law Newsletter, November
2010, pp 3-4] [Emphasis added.]
!
M+94-1+!62:1+!*062!8+3094/!+7,+5601+!:&!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62!*+5+!&:6!0&9/-3+3!0&!62+!_:01+!D:5C0&>!
N5:-,)!62+!+&3:51+8+&6!.<!4-62:5060+1!:;!RAPE)!B62+!9:&1+&1-1!:;!4!/0806+3!>5:-,!:;!+7,+561B!X!
49:-160904&1!4&3!+&>0&++51)!4&!+=+&!8:5+!1+/+96!>5:-,!X!/+4=+1!62+!=096081!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!
,://-60:&!*062!/066/+!5+9:-51+)!+1,+904//<!41!,/4&&0&>!0&1,+96:51!45+!1:!-&*0//0&>!6:!3+,456!;5:8!
RAPE!4&3!+7480&+!9-55+&6!5+1+4592!4&3!9:&3060:&1!:.I+960=+/<@!!J+6)!4/62:->2!4*45+!:;!RAPE?S?T(!
12:569:80&>1)!4-62:5060+1!4&3!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!5+840&!*0//0&>!6:!+7,/:06!RAPE!5+>453/+11!
:;!62+!43=+51+!08,496!:&!,+:,/+B1!/0=+1@!
!
A201!;-562+5!+7,:1+1!62+!3019:&&+96!.+6*++&!>:=+5&8+&6!:;;0904/1!\3+9010:&?84C+51]!4&3!62+05!
5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!,:/09<!4&3!62+!,-./09B1!43=+51+!+7,+50+&9+1!*062!6246!,:/09<)!4&3!62+!0&4.0/06<!:5!
-&*0//0&>&+11!:;!>:=+5&8+&6!6:!48+&3!62+!,:/09<!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!62+!,-./09B1!2+4/62@!!H:5+:=+5)!
+=+&!41!;480/0+1!466+8,6!6:!9:,+!*062!62+!2+4/62!4&3!;0&4&904/!,5:./+81!.+94-1+!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+)!>:=+5&8+&6!:;;0904/1!45+!4,,45+&6/<!9:&6+&6!6246!62+1+!;480/0+1!12:-/3+5!62+!.-53+&!;:5!62+!
1646+@!!%6!4,,+451!41!62:->2!;480/0+1!*2:!1-;;+5!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!45+!30195080&46+3!
4>40&16)!.+94-1+!,-./09!:;;0904/1!,5+1-8+!6246!&:01+!01!&:6!4!10>&0;094&6!,5:./+8)!:62+5!624&!
(W!
!
4&&:<4&9+)!-&4*45+!6246!62+!9-8-/460=+!.:3<!:;!5+1+4592!:&!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62!,:0&61!6:!4!30160&96!
5+/460:&120,!.+6*++&!&:01+!4&3!4&!43=+51+!08,496!:&!2+4/62@!!!
!
>0"+*%.#$%@,**8%
F1!3019-11+3!,5+=0:-1/<!0&!6201!,4,+5)!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!+806!&:01+!*062!1+=+54/!9245496+5016091!??!4!/:*!
;5+G-+&9<!9:8,:&+&6)!6:&4/!G-4/060+1)!,+50:30906<!:5!0&6+58066+&9<!\B62-8,0&>B)!B*2::120&>B!41!62+!
./43+1!8:=+!625:->2!62+!405!4&3!,411!62+!6:*+5])!4&3!8+924&094/!\62+!&49+//+!4&3!62+!:190//460:&!:;!
62+!2-.]!??!1+=+54/!:;!*2092!0&30=03-4//<!94&!95+46+!&:01+!6246!01!,45609-/45/<!3015-,60=+@!!A4C+&!0&!
9:8.0&460:&)!62+1+!9245496+5016091!45+!+1,+904//<!3016-5.0&>)!4&3!62+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!
e:88-&06<!_:01+!UTTT)!4&3!061!9:8,/+8+&645<!5+,:56)!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!R-5:,+!
"''T)!5+9:88+&3!/:*+5!4//:*4&9+1!;:5!&:01+!*062!62+1+!9245496+5016091)!,45609-/45/<!46!&0>26!X!
5+>453/+11!:;!62+!1:-59+@!!
!
R,03+80:/:>094/!16-30+1!12:*!6246!!
!
“noise affects sleep in terms of immediate effects (e.g. arousal responses, sleep
stage changes, awakenings, body movements, total wake time, autonomic
responses), after-effects (e.g. sleepiness, daytime performance, cognitive function
deterioration) and long-term effects (e.g. self-reported chronic sleep
disturbance)...Environmental noise may reduce the restorative power of sleep by
means of repeatedly occurring activations (so-called sleep fragmentation). Acute
and chronic sleep restriction or fragmentation has been shown to affect, among
other things, waking psychomotor performance, memory consolidation, creativity,
risk-taking behaviour, signal detection performance and risks of accidents.”
[WHO Burden of Disease of Environmental Noise]
“Environmental sleep disorder”, as classified in the International Classification of
Sleep Disorders, “of which noise-induced sleep disturbance is an example, is a
sleep disturbance due to a disturbing environmental factor that causes a complaint
of either insomnia or daytime fatigue and somnolence.” [WHO BDEN Report]
!
F99:530&>!6:!62+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!UTTT)!!
!
“... the intermittent character of noise has to be taken into account when setting
night-time limits for noise exposure...”
[WHO Guidelines for Community Noise 1999, p 46]
!
F1!5+9:88+&3+3!0&!.:62!62+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+!\UTTT]!4&3!0&!62+!Dfg!_0>26!
_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!R-5:,+!\"'U'])!!
!
“in order to prevent sleep disturbances, one should consider the equivalent sound
pressure level and the number and level of sound events.”
[WHO BDEN Report]
!
J+6)!62+!RAPE!8+62:3:/:><!+=+&1!:-6!62+!0&6+58066+&6!9245496+5!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!.<!
B4=+54>0&>B!62+!&:01+!/+=+/)!62-1!496-4//<!4110>&0&>!0&6+58066+&9<!/+11!10>&0;094&9+!5462+5!624&!
499-546+/<!5+,5+1+&60&>!62+!;/-96-460&>!&46-5+!:;!62+!&:01+@!
!
A2+!Dfg!5+,:56!4/1:!1646+1!6246!62+!;://:*0&>!9:&3060:&1!8+506!1,+904/!466+&60:&L!
1. 'Noise sources in an environment with a low background noise level. For
example, night-traffic in suburban residential areas.'
2. 'Environments where a combination of noise and vibrations are produced. For
example, railway noise, heavy duty vehicles.'
3. 'Sources with low-frequency components. Disturbances may occur even
though the sound pressure level during exposure is below 30 dBA.'
!
%6!01!10>&0;094&6!6246L!
U@ D0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!45+!8:16!:;6+&!106+3!0&!5-54/!45+41!*062!+765+8+/<!/:*!.49C>5:-&3!
&:01+!/+=+/1)!,45609-/45/<!46!&0>26h!!
"@ D0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!,5:3-9+!&:01+!01!9245496+501+3!.<!0&6+58066+&6!=0.5460:&1h!4&3)!!
#@ D0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!,5:3-9+!&:01+!*062!4!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!9:8,:&+&6@!
!
!
!
A2+!Dfg!M[R_!S+,:56!:.1+5=+1!6246!!
!
((!
“...since night noise is assessed separately according to Directive 2002/49/EC, it
does not appear reasonable when daytime noise and nighttime noise exposures
are then combined in a weighted 24-hour indicator. With respect to health effects
it would make much more sense to clearly distinguish between real day and night
indicators...From a cardiovascular point of view, there is no rationale known for
weighing factors such as +5 dB(A) or +10 dB)A) for the evening and night periods
of the day. It would be a better approach to consider day and night exposures
separately with respect to its effects, particularly for noise sources other than road
traffic noise (where the day and night noise levels are usually highly correlated).
Studies should also try to distinguish between the exposure of the living room
(during daytime) and the exposure of the bedroom (during nighttime).”
[WHO BDEN Report]
!
A2-1)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!3+1+5=+1!,45609-/45!195-60&<)!41!62+!&:01+!01!9:8,501+3!:;!62+!9:8,:&+&61!
6246!Dfg!+7,+561!1646+!‘merit special attention’!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!2+4/62@!
!
F1!62+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!&:6+)!!
!
'... it should be possible to sleep with a bedroom window slightly open... To
prevent sleep disturbances, one should thus consider the equivalent sound
pressure level and the number and level of sound events.’
[WHO Guidelines for Community Noise, 1999, p 46]
!
F!*0&3!6-5.0&+!,5:3-9+1!1+,4546+!1:-&3!+=+&61!41!+492!:;!061!625++!./43+1!,411+1!62+!6:*+5)!62+!
B1*012B!4&3!B*2::12B!6246!,+:,/+!:;6+&!906+!41!-&5+/+&60&>!4&3!+=+&!6:56-5:-1@!!%6!01!&:6!1-5,5010&>!
6246!84&<!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!9:8,/40&!:;!08,405+3!1/++,!41!*+//!41!:62+5!1<8,6:81@!!!
!
“Chronic sleep loss is a widespread problem... Sleep is a physiologic recuperative
state... our main physiological recuperative state...”
[Zaharna M & Guilleminault. Sleep, noise and health: review. Noise and Health
2010; 12(47): 64-69]
!
P/++,!01!95-904/!6:!>::3!2+4/62!4&3!6:!*+//!.+0&>)!41!*+//!41!6:!641C!,+5;:584&9+@!!F1!4&!+748,/+)!
H42!%*&(4!;:-&3!6246!1/++,!3-5460:&!4&3!G-4/06<!9:&650.-6+1!6:!62+!,+5;:584&9+!:;!462/+6+1@!!%&!6201!
16-3<)!84/+!.41C+6.4//!,/4<+51!*062!+76+&3+3!1/++,!:=+5!8-/60,/+!*++C1!08,5:=+3!62+05!5+4960:&!
608+1)!1,50&6!608+1)!12::60&>!499-549<!\Tm])!4/:&>!*062!08,5:=+8+&61!0&!8::3!4&3!3+95+41+3!
;460>-+@!!A2+1+!924&>+1!*+5+!8+41-5+3!:&!164&345301+3!6+161)!62:->2!62+!,/4<+51!62+81+/=+1!4/1:!
5+,:56+3!08,5:=+3!;++/0&>1!:;!*+//?.+0&>@!!P/++,!G-4/06<!4&3!3-5460:&!*+5+!‘beneficial in reaching
peak athletic performance’@!!ZH42!e)!H42!QR)!Q+Y0504&!Rd)!4&3![+8+&6!De@!A2+!R;;+961!:;!P/++,!
R76+&10:&!:&!62+!F62/+609!i+5;:584&9+!:;!e://+>046+!M41C+6.4//!i/4<+51@!!D4%%>!"'UU!d-/!
Uh#$\(]LT$#?TO'c!!!
!
“The findings suggest that is important for sleep to be prioritised over a long
period of time,”!4&3!:,6084/!1/++,!01!4&!:=+5/::C+3!.-6!9506094/!;496:5!0&!5+4920&>!,+4C!
,+5;:584&9+@!!!
!
“Derk-Jan Dijk, professor of sleep and physiology at the University of Surrey, said
we should look at sleep in the same way as exercise. ‘Getting enough sleep is a
positive thing which will help you perform in all aspects of life.’”
[BBC News | Health. Sleeping Longer ‘Helps Athletes Reach Peak Performance’, 1
July 2011 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-13974130 accessed last on 13 July
2011]
“Yet fractured sleep is disturbingly prevalent in our society, partly due to insults
from a variety of noises.”
[Dang-Vu TT; McKinney SM; Buxton OM; Solet JM; and Ellenbogen JM.
Spontaneous Brain Rhythms Predict Sleep Stability in the Face of Noise. Current
Biology 10 August 2010; 20(15): R626-627]
!
X#%(*+80#+*%-0%-3*%8(*B.,*#6*%05%#0"+*T"#$'6*$%+,**8%$"+('8-"0#+I%.#$%)*6.'+*%05%-3*%
“limited appreciation of the importance of sleep disorders and sleep deprivation
for individuals and the public health”,!62+!F8+5094&!F943+8<!:;!P/++,!H+3090&+)!62+!
(j!
!
_460:&4/!e+&6+5!;:5!P/++,![01:53+51!S+1+4592!Z_eP[Sc!46!62+!_460:&4/!%&1606-6+1!:;!f+4/62!\_%f])!
62+!_460:&4/!P/++,!`:-&3460:&)!4&3!62+!P/++,!S+1+4592!P:90+6<)!41C+3!62+!%&1606-6+!:;!H+3090&+!:;!
62+!_460:&4/!F943+80+1!\D4120&>6:&)![e]!6:!(*B"*G%.#$%-0%]'.#-"5C%“the public health
significance of sleep health, sleep loss, and sleep disorders.”
Ze:/6+&!fS!4&3!F/6+=:>6!MH)!+31@!!D4%%>&E#$"-)%-$&(+)&D4%%>&E%>-#F(*#"+6&(+&G+.%*&J124#8&5%(4*9&
J-"24%.A&!e:88066++!:&!P/++,!H+3090&+!4&3!S+1+4592)!%&1606-6+!:;!H+3090&+!:;!62+!_460:&4/!
F943+80+1@!!D4120&>6:&)![eL!A2+!_460:&4/!F943+80+1!i5+11)!"''Wc!\R8,24101!433+3@]!
!
[N.B.: “The advances in sleep research are brought together by the
multidisciplinary scientific field of somnology, which is devoted to the study of the
physiology of sleep, the behavioural dimensions of sleep, and the consequences of
sleep loss and sleep disorders on an individual's and the general population's
health, performance, safety, and quality of life. As one might expect, somnology
brings together experts and specialists in fields that include internal medicine,
neurology, nursing, otolaryngology (ear, nose, throat or ENT), pediatrics,
psychiatry, psychology, and pulmonology.”
From the Glossary, Colten & Altevogt, IOM Sleep Disorders and Sleep Deprivation,
2006]
!
A2+!%&1606-6+!:;!H+3090&+!9:&9/-3+3!6246!!
!
“sleep loss and sleep disorders affect an individual's performance, safety, and
quality of life. Almost 20 percent of all serious car crash injuries in the general
population are associated with driver sleepiness, independent of alcohol effects.”
[Colten & Altevogt, IOM, p 137, ch 4: Functional and Economic Impact of Sleep
Loss and Sleep-Related Disorders]
“Compared to healthy individuals, individuals suffering from sleep loss, sleep
disorders, or both are less productive, have an increased health care utilization, an
increased likelihood of accidents” [p 137, ch 4 IOM], 4&3!4!5+3-960:&!0&!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+!
3-+!6: “nonrestorative sleep and excessive daytime sleepiness.”
[Colten & Altevogt, IOM, p 151, ch 4: Functional and Economic Impact of Sleep
Loss and Sleep-Related Disorders]
!
A2+!%gHB1!5+=0+*!;:-&3!6246)!0&3++3)!!
!
“nearly all types of sleep problems are associated with performance deficits in
occupational, education, and other settings. The deficits include attention,
vigilance, and other measures of cognition, including memory and complex
decision making ... The prevailing view until the 1990s was that people adapted to
chronic sleep loss without adverse cognitive effects...
More recent research has revealed sleep loss-induced neurobehavioral effects,
which often go unrecognized by the affected individuals. The neurobehavioral
impact extends from simple measures of cognition (i.e., attention and reaction
time) to far more complex errors in judgment and decision making... [p 138, ch 4
IOM] This includes a decline in short-term recall of working memory, a reduction
in learning cognitive tasks, slower response time, involuntary microsleeps, and
unstable attention to intensive tasks, with increased errors of omission and
commission.” [Colten & Altevogt, IOM, p 138, 140, ch 4: Functional and Economic
Impact of Sleep Loss and Sleep-Related Disorders]
!
D246!62+!%gH!;:-&3!8:16!1650C0&>!*41!6246L%!
!
“... subjects remained largely unaware of their performance deficits.”
!ZColten & Altevogt)!%gH)!,!U$")!92!$: Functional and Economic Impact of Sleep Loss
and Sleep-Related Disordersc!!ZR8,24101!433+3@c!
!
D062!08,/09460:&1!;:5!,-./09!14;+6<!4&3!*:5C!1+660&>1)!6*:!/45>+!4&3!*+//?3+10>&+3!16-30+1!;:-&3!
6246L!
!
“sleep-related fatigue is an independent risk factor in work-related injuries and
fatalities.”
!
[Colten & Altevogt, IOM, p 149, ch 4: Functional and Economic Impact of Sleep
Loss and Sleep-Related Disorders]
(T!
!
A2+!9:&1+G-+&9+1!:;!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+!4/1:!3015-,6!;480/0+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1)!.+94-1+!62+!08,4961!
+76+&3!6:!62+!2+4/62!4&3!*+//?.+0&>!:;!,456&+51!4&3!;480/<!8+8.+51h!4&3!34<608+!1/++,0&+11)!
0&43+G-46+!1/++,)!4&3!:62+5!1/++,!301:53+51!!
!
“place a significant burden on the health care system through increased utilization
of the health care system.”
A2-1)!!
“the indirect costs associated with sleep loss and sleep disorders also result in
billions of dollars of annual expenditures, including costs associated with illnessrelated morbidity and mortality, absenteeism, disability, reduction or loss of
productivity, industrial and motor vehicle accidents, hospitalization, and increased
alcohol consumption.”
!
A2+!%gH!5+,:561!6246!4!16-3<!,-./012+3!0&!"''U!5+=+4/+3!6246L!!
!
“sleep-related fatigue costs an estimated $150 billion per year to businesses in
absenteeism, workplace accidents, and other lost productivity.”
[Colten & Altevogt, IOM, p 153, 155, 158, ch 4: Functional and Economic Impact
of Sleep Loss and Sleep-Related Disorders]
!
F/62:->2!&:6!4//!62+1+!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1!45+!3-+!6:!&:01+)!62+1+!;0&30&>1!0&30946+!62+!08,:564&9+!
:;!1/++,!4&3!061!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!3015-,60:&!.<!&:01+@!!P/++,!3016-5.4&9+!94-1+3!.<!&:01+!01!&:6!:&/<!
4!10>&0;094&6!2+4/62!,5:./+8!;:5!62+!0&30=03-4/)!.-6!4/1:!:&+!*062!1-.164&60=+!08,/09460:&1!;:5!62+!
0&30=03-4/K1!;480/<)!62+!,-./09B1!2+4/62!4&3!14;+6<)!4&3!;:5!,-./09!2+4/62!,:/09<@!!H:5+:=+5)!41!
,:,-/460:&1!0&95+41+)!62+5+!01!433+3!,5+11-5+!6:!-5.4&01+!:5!0&3-16504/01+!&+*!45+41)!0&9/-30&>!
4>509-/6-54/!/4&3!4&3!;:5+161h!62-1)!62+!,+59+&64>+!:;!,+:,/+!4;;+96+3!0&95+41+1@!
!
F99:530&>!6:!Dfg)!62+!/+11!4;;/-+&6!‘are likely to suffer disproportionately'!.+94-1+!62+<!24=+!
/+11!;0&4&904/!;/+70.0/06<!4&3!62+5+;:5+!/+11!8:.0/06<!6:!+194,+!62+!&:01+!08,4961@!!!
ZDfgaR-5:,+L!!"#$%6&=(8*$&(+)&=#@1-%$)!"'UU!266,Laa***@+-5:@*2:@0&6a+&a*246?*+?3:a2+4/62?
6:,091a+&=05:&8+&6?4&3?2+4/62a&:01+a;4961?4&3?;0>-5+1c!
!
_:01+!95+46+1!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1!.<!4;;+960&>!!
!
“the number and duration of nocturnal awakenings; the number of changes in
sleep stage; the number of electroencephalographic arousals [EEGs]; global
changes in total amount of sleep stages or in their time organization (sleep
architecture).”
[WHO/Europe: Health Effects of Noise 2011 http://www.euro.who.int/en/what-wedo/health-topics/environment-and-health/noise/facts-and-figures/health-effectsof-noise]
!
A2+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!R-5:,+!Z"''Tc!5+=0+*!0&!+76+&10=+!3+640/!62+!5+/460:&120,!
.+6*++&!&:01+!4&3!1/++,!G-4/06<!4&3!2+4/62A&&
&
“Impaired sleep... is related to a number of diseases... sleep deprivation is
definitely a condition that deeply afflicts health.”
H:5+:=+5)!,+:,/+!*2:!45+!1/++,!3+,50=+3!'typically show dramatic function loss after a few
days’.!!
ZR-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!\RRF]@!!V"")&J-(8*#8%&V1#)%&"+&!"#$%&7P>"$1-%&(+)&J"*%+*#(4&5%(4*9&
7,,%8*$@!!R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<)!RRF!A+92&094/!S+,:56!_:!UUa"'U')!,!U"!
266,Laa***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a,-./09460:&1a>::3?,549609+?>-03+?:&?&:01+c!
!
[-50&>!1/++,)!62+!.:3<!.+>0&1!6:!5+496!6:!0&65-30&>!1:-&31!46!4!/:*!/+=+/)!##!3M\F]!k847)!8+41-5+3!
0&103+!62+!.+35::8@!!F/62:->2!4*4C+&0&>1!:5!0&6+5;+5+&9+!*062!62+!164>+1!:;!1/++,!45+!&:6!4&!0//!
+;;+96!:&!2+4/62!0&!62+81+/=+1)!!
!
!
“they are considered significant early warning signals when the incidence starts to
rise above background”
j'!
!
X!0@+@)!4.:=+!62+!&:58!;:5!1,:&64&+:-1!&:&?&:01+!5+/46+3!5+4960:&1@!!ZR-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!
F>+&9<!\RRF]@!V"")&J-(8*#8%&V1#)%&"+&!"#$%&7P>"$1-%&(+)&J"*%+*#(4&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$@!!R-5:,+4&!
R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<)!RRF!A+92&094/!S+,:56!_:!UUa"'U')!,!U#!
266,Laa***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a,-./09460:&1a>::3?,549609+?>-03+?:&?&:01+c!
!
i+:,/+!6+&3!6:!4*4C+&!U!:5!"!608+1!,+5!&0>26!-&3+5!&:584/!9059-8164&9+1)!1:!6246!'any increase in
awakenings is therefore to be taken seriously'@!!%&!433060:&)!.+94-1+!1/++,!01!1-92!4!9506094/!
5+16:5460=+!,2<10:/:>094/!;-&960:&)!,+:,/+!6+&3!6:!1-,,5+11!4*4C+&0&>1@!!A246!01!*2<!5+8+8.+5+3!
awakenings remain low 'even at high noise levels'. [European Environment Agency (EEA).
Good Practice Guide on Noise Exposure and Potential Health Effects. European Environment
Agency, EEA Technical Report No 11/2010, p 14
http://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/good-practice-guide-on-noise]
!
%&!6201!5+>453)!M41&+5!+6!4/!:.1+5=+!6246!!
!
"... decision making should certainly not solely be based on behavioral
awakenings, as this outcome measure is too insensitive and relevant noise effects
on sleep will be missed... There is enough evidence demonstrating that noiseinduced changes in sleep macro- and microstructure relevantly impair restoration
even if they are not accompanied by conscious awakenings."
!
A2+!4-62:51!49C&:*/+3>+!6246L!!!
!
"...limit values are not set by scientists but by politicians and legislators. However,
we still think that science should guide this process and at least define a decision
set for the political decision process. The WHO Night Noise Guidelines for Europe
(2009) are a good example in this respect. Here, experts in the field defined
consensus L [sub]night ranges that are linked to specific outcomes related to sleep
disturbance and health. These will be very helpful and may facilitate consensus
among politicians and legislators for the definition of future limit values."
[Basner M; Griefahn B; and Hume K. Comment on 'The State of the Art of
Predicting Noise-Induced Sleep Disturbance in Field Settings'. Noise and Health
2010; 12(49):283-285] (Emphasis added.)
%&!6+581!:;!434,60&>!6:!4&!0&6+58066+&6!&:01+!0&65-10:&)!4!16-3<!*062!4!,:,-/460:&!*062!4!8+4&!4>+!
:;!$W@()!;:-&3!6246L!
!
“...aircraft noise annoyance is very stable through time.”
!
A246!01)!,+:,/+!303!&:6!.+9:8+!24.06-46+3!6:!62+!&:01+!:=+5!608+@!!_:01+!*062!4&!0&6+58066+&6!
9245496+5!4,,+451!6:!.+!0&65-10=+!4&3!24=+!4&!43=+51+!08,496!.+94-1+!:;!061!,+50:30906<@!!
ZQ5:+1+&!Hh!H:/0&!Rh!4&3!D++!M@!![+6+580&0&>!62+!305+960:&!:;!94-14/06<!.+6*++&!,1<92:/:>094/!
;496:51!4&3!405954;6!&:01+!4&&:<4&9+@!!!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!d4&?H45!"'U'h!U"\$W]L!U(?"Oc!!
!
g62+5!5+1+4592!4/1:!1-,,:561!6201!;0&30&>L!!
!
“For external noise, it appears to be the noise levels of individual events that have
the most impact...”
[Ljung R; Sorqvist P; and Hygge S. Effects of road traffic noise and irrelevant
speech on children's reading and mathematical performance. Noise and Health
2009; 11(45): 194-203]]
!
D0&3!6-5.0&+1!84<!94-1+!4&&:<4&9+!46!&0>26!.+94-1+!:;!62+!9245496+5016091!4/5+43<!3+1950.+3)!.-6!
0;!62+!*0&3!1,++3!4&3a:5!305+960:&!:;!62+!*0&3!924&>+1)!1:!8-16!62+!,0692!:;!62+!./43+1!4&3!62+!
305+960:&!62+<!;49+!\62+!&49+//+!46!62+!2-.!8-16!5:646+]@!!A201!,5:9+11)!5+,+46+3!3-50&>!62+!&0>26)!
95+46+1!433060:&4/!0&6+58066+&6!&:01+!+=+&61!6246!45+!-&,5+30964./+!4&3!84<!9:&650.-6+!6:!62+!
0&65-10=+!9245496+5!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!
!
H4&<!16-30+1!6246!+7480&+!1/++,!0&6+55-,60:&!94-1+3!.<!,+50:309)!0&65-10=+!&:01+!24=+!-1+3!
&:96-5&4/!405,:56!&:01+!41!4!.4101!;:5!3464!9://+960:&!.+94-1+!84&<!405,:561!45+!0&!:5!&+45!20>2/<!
jU!
!
,:,-/46+3!45+41@!!f:*+=+5)!1:8+!:;!62+1+!16-30+1!45+!4,,/094./+!4/1:!6:!&:01+!4&3!1/++,!0&!>+&+54/!
:5!6:!1/++,!3015-,6+3!.<!1-33+&)!:5!,+50:309)!0&65-10=+!&:01+@!!`:5!+748,/+)!:&+!16-3<!;:-&3!6246!
.:62!0&!62+!;0+/3!4&3!0&!62+!/4.:546:5<L!!
!
!
“noise-induced sleep fragmentation is associated with performance impairments in
a psychomotor vigilance task (PVT) and a memory search task.' The influences of
noise on sleep and daytime performance are '... consistent and significant,
stressing the potential public health impact of nocturnal noise exposure.”
[Elmenhorst E-M; Elmenhorst D; Wenzel J; Quehl J; Mueller U; Maass H; Vejvoda
M; and Basner M@!!Effects of nocturnal aircraft noise on cognitive performance in
the following morning: dose-response relationships in laboratory and field.
International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health Oct 2010;83(7):
743-751]!
“Studies on sleep disturbance in children and in shift workers clearly show the
adverse effects such as increased accidents on the following day.” [Kim R and van
den Berg M. Summary of Night Noise Guidelines for Europe. Noise and Health
2010; 12(47): 61-63]
!
A2+5+!45+!62:1+!*2:!1->>+16!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!8:5+!.+&0>&!624&!:62+5!&:01+!1:-59+1)!
.41+3!:&!061!8060>460:&!:=+5!30164&9+!4&3!*0&3!+&+5><B1!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!95+3+&604/1)!62-1!
+&9:-54>0&>!,:/09<!6:!;4=:-5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!192+8+1!\1++!RAPE?S?T(!4&3!iiP"")!48:&>!:62+5!
:;;0904/!3:9-8+&61)!4&3!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:546+!4,,+4/!3+9010:&1]@!!J+6)!62+!,2<1091!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+)!4&3!62+!08,496!:;!6201!&:01+!:&!62:1+!&+45.<)!45+!&:!30;;+5+&6!;5:8!:62+5!&:01+!1:-59+1!*062!
1245+3!9245496+5016091)!&:5!:&!62+!43=+51+!08,496!:&!62:1+!/0=0&>!*062!62+!,5:/:&>+3!+7,:1-5+@!!
A2+!1->>+160:&!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!1:8+2:*!/+11!0&65-10=+!01!-&1-.164&6046+3!.<!,++5?
5+=0+*+3!5+1+4592!5+>4530&>!&:01+!4&3!061!43=+51+!+;;+961!:&!1/++,)!9:>&060:&)!,+5;:584&9+)!4&3!
2+4/62@!
!
A2+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+!\UTTT])!4!5+,:56!.<!4!8-/6030190,/0&45<!4&3!
0&6+5&460:&4//<!5+&:*&!,4&+/!:;!+7,+561!1-8845010&>!9-55+&6!5+1+4592)!&:6+3!6246L!!
!!
“Special attention should also be given to the following considerations... Noise
sources in an environment with a low background noise level... [and] Sources
with low-frequency components. Disturbances may occur even though the sound
pressure level during exposure is below 30 dBA...
... it should be possible to sleep with a bedroom window slightly open (a reduction
from outside to inside of 15 dB). To prevent sleep disturbances, one should thus
consider the equivalent sound pressure level and the number and level of sound
events.”
[WHO Guidelines for Community Noise 1999. Chapter 3: Adverse Health Effects of
Noise, Section 3.4: Sleep Disturbance, p 46]
!
%&!"'U')!62+!R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!ZRRFc!,-./012+3!061!BN::3!i549609+!N-03+!:&!_:01+!
R7,:1-5+!4&3!i:6+&604/!f+4/62!R;;+961B!ZRRF!A+92&094/!S+,:56!_:!UUa"'U'c)!*2092!,5+1+&61!
5+1+4592!;0&30&>1!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!1+9:&3!:&/<!6:!405954;6!*062!5+1,+96!6:!4&&:<4&9+h!!5:43)!
540/)!4&3!0&3-165<!45+!9:&103+5+3!/+11!4&&:<0&>!624&!+062+5!405954;6!:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1L!!
!
!
Zk3+&!t!34<?+=+&0&>?&0>26!+G-0=4/+&6!1:-&3c!
!
!
!
!
!
“As for the Lden threshold of 55 db, it should be noted that this does not take into
account the differences that exist between sources. Lden = 55 db is a fair
threshold for railway noise, but for other sources this leads to an underestimate of
the actual burden. [See Table 6.1, above] This shows that a sensible approach
for action planning is to make a distinction between sources when assessing the
magnitude of the impact on the population.”
[European Environment Agency (EEA). Good Practice Guide on Noise Exposure
and Potential Health Effects. European Environment Agency, EEA Technical Report
No 11/2010, p24 http://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/good-practice-guide-onnoise]
j"!
!
;##0C.#6*%$*8*#$+%0#%-3*%#0"+*%+0'(6*I%.#$%50(%+01*%+0'(6*+I%*DFDI%-(.#+80(-%#0"+*+I%%
%
“the thresholds are taken to be the same.” However, this is not true for
“special noise sources like wind-turbines and shunting yards.”
[EEA Good Practice Guide, 2010, p 9]
%
;+%#0-*$%.,+0%G"-3%(0.$%-(.55"6%.#$%(.",G.C%#0"+*>!!
!
“increased low frequency noise” leads to an “increase in annoyance”, and
“vibrations could increase annoyance.” [EEA Good Practice Guide, 2010, pp
9, 10 EEA] (Emphasis added.)
!
A2+!RRFB1!N::3!i549609+!N-03+!:&!_:01+!R7,:1-5+!4&3!i:6+&604/!f+4/62!R;;+961!*41!,-./012+3&&
&
“to assist policymakers, competent authorities and any other interested parties in
understanding and fulfilling the requirements of the EU Directive and was based on
reviews by WHO, professional organizations, and national health departments.”
[EEA Good Practice Guide, 2010, p 24; the Directive refers to the EU Directive on
Environmental Noise [END], 2002/49/EC]
!
i:/09<84C+51!4&3!4-62:5060+1!45+!1-,,:1+3!6:!9:&103+5!B3:1+?+;;+96B!5+/460:&120,1)!*2092!20>2/0>26!
!
“the potential harmful effects of noise in the population.” This “should then inform
the 'action planning' process in order to mitigate or reduce any harm to the
population under consideration.” [EEA Good Practice Guide, 2010, p 24; see also
Annex III of END]
!
_:6!:&/<!12:-/3!4!&:01+!4960:&!,/4&!0&9/-3+!B3:1+?+;;+96B!5+/460:&120,1)!62+!,/4&!12:-/3!4/1:!!
!
“make a distinction between sources when assessing the magnitude of the impact
on the population.” [EEA, 2010, p 24]
!
`-562+58:5+)!:&+!8-16!-1+!!
!
“caution against indiscriminate use (e.g., in small populations) and alertness to
ethical objections when dealing with DALYs, vulnerable groups and exposure to
extreme noise levels.”
[EEA, 2010, p 25; DALY = Disability Adjusted Life Years]
!
X#%0-3*(%G0($+I%*B*#%+1.,,%808',.-"0#+%$*+*(B*%-3*%+.1*%60#+"$*(.-"0#%.#$%8(0-*6-"0#%.+%
,.(F*(%F(0'8+D%%!"#$%-'()"#*%#0"+*%$0*+%#0-%+-08%.-%#"F3-%G3*#%0-3*(%"#$'+-("*+%#*.(%301*+%
1.C%,"*%"$,*%e80++"),C%)*6.'+*%05%8,.##"#F%.#$%#0"+*%60#$"-"0#+fD%%!"#$%-'()"#*%#0"+*%
(.$".-*+%MShR%50(%MN%-0%M\%C*.(+I%-3*%*+-"1.-*$%,"5*%05%*.63%-'()"#*D%%!
!
A2+!RRF!N::3!i549609+!N-03+!5+06+546+1!62+!Dfg!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!R-5:,+L&&
&
“Night is a special period which merits its own indicator... In recent times it has
frequently been suggested in the scientific community that Lnight should be
accompanied by an additional indicator that accounts for the maximum noise level
and/or the number of events.” [EEA, 2010, p 34]
!
A2-1)!62+!RRF!N::3!i549609+!N-03+!;:9-1+1!:&!*4<1!0&!*2092!&:01+!4960:&!,/4&1!499:-&6!;:5!62+!
-&*4&6+3!+;;+961!:;!&:01+@!!F1!62+!>-03+!&:6+1)!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!:;!&:01+!!
!
!
“occur when intended activities of the individual are disturbed... The sound level
of the acoustic stimulus, its psycho-acoustical sound characteristics, the time of its
occurrence, its time course, its frequency spectrum and its informational content
modify the reaction.” [EEA, 2010, p 5]
j#!
!
A2+!RRF!N-03+!9:&60&-+1L!!!
!
“During sleep, however, unconscious activation of the autonomous nervous system
takes place without cortical (cognitive) control, due to direct interaction between
the hearing nerve and higher structures of the central nervous system.”
[EEA, 2010, p 5]
!
A246!01)!62+!4-306:5<!1<16+8!;-&960:&1!+=+&!3-50&>!1/++,)!+=+&!0;!4&!0&30=03-4/!1/++,1!625:->2!62+!
3015-,60:&@!
!
“If a certain population is exposed to substantial noise, many people will notice it
and develop adverse feelings to this... Victims of noise pollution may experience
annoyance, connected to feelings of 'discomfort, anger, depression and
helplessness... Within a part of this exposed population, stress reactions, sleepstage changes and other biological and biophysical effects may occur. These in
turn increase risk factors like blood pressure.’” [EEA, 2010, pp 5, 9]
!
P:8+!:;!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!:;!&:01+!45+!1-884501+3!0&!62+!;://:*0&>!92456L!
!
!
ZRRF)!"'U')!,!jc!
!
!
F!95:11?1+960:&4/!16-3<!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62?5+/46+3!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+!-&3+519:5+1!62+!
2+0>26+&+3!08,496!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9:8,45+3!6:!:62+5!&:01+!1:-59+1@!!A2+!16-3<)!9:&3-96+3!
.<!P2+,2+53!%*&(4)!*41!&:6!/0806+3!6:!&:5!303!06!+8,24101+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!:=+5!:62+5!1:-59+1@!!
%&16+43)!16-3<!,456090,4&61!*+5+!G-+50+3!:&!&:01+1!62+<!;:-&3!4&&:<0&>)!!0&309460&>!62+05!3+>5++!:;!
&:01+!1+&1060=06<!4&3!62+!+;;+961!:&!48+&06<@!!E10&>!62+!.50+;!=+510:&!:;!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!
g5>4&0Y460:&!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+!194/+L!
!
“Statistically significant differences were noted in some HRQOL (Health-Related
Quality of Life) domain scores, with residents living within 2 km of a turbine
installation reporting lower overall quality of life, physical quality of life, and
environmental quality of life. Those exposed to turbine noise also reported
significantly lower sleep quality, and rated their environment as less restful.”
!
[Shepherd D, McBride D, Welch D, Dirks KN, and Hill EM. Evaluating the Impact of
Wind Turbine Noise on Health-Related Quality of Life. Noise and Health
2011;13:333-9]
j$!
`-562+58:5+)!62+!4-62:51!4/1:!;:-&3!6246L!
!
“Specifically, those residing in the immediate vicinity of a wind farm scored worse
than a matched comparison group in terms of physical HRQOL and environmental
QOL, and HRQOL in general. No differences were found in terms of psychological
and social HRQOL, or in self-rated health. The high incidence of annoyance from
turbine noise in the turbine group is consistent with the theory that exposure to
wind turbine noise is the cause of these differences.”
!
P6-3<!,456090,4&61!*2:!906+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!41!8:5+!4&&:<0&>!4/1:!19:5+3!/:*+5!:&!1/++,!
14601;4960:&!5460&>1)!“suggesting that both annoyance and sleep disruption may mediate the
relationship between noise and HRQOL. These findings are consistent with those reported in
relation to aviation noise and traffic noise.”
!
F1!62+!4-62:51!&:6+)!,5+=0:-1!5+1+4592!0&30946+1!6246L!
!
“... for equivalent noise levels, people judge wind turbine noise to be of greater
annoyance than aircraft, road traffic, or railway noise. This may be due to the
unique characteristics of turbine noise, that is, clusters of turbines present a
cumulative effect characterized by a dynamic or modulating sound as turbines
synchronise. The characteristic swishing or thumping noise associated with larger
turbines is audible over long distances, up to 5 km and beyond in some reports.
van den Berg showed that sound is the most annoying aspect of wind turbines,
and is more of a problem at night.”
!
H:5+:=+5)!62+!4-62:51!&:6+!6246!62+!&-8.+5!:;!,+:,/+!+7,:1+3!01!10>&0;094&6!4&3!0&95+410&>!41!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!0&164//460:&1!0&95+41+L!
!
“For example, in the Netherlands it is reported that 440,000 inhabitants (2.5% of
the population) are exposed to significant levels of wind turbine noise.
Additionally, policy makers are demanding more information on the possible link
between wind turbines and health in order to inform setback distances... Thus,
nations undertaking large-scale deployment of wind turbines need to consider the
impact of noise on the HRQOL of exposed individuals. Along with others, we
conclude that night-time wind turbine noise limits should be set conservatively to
minimize harm, and, on the basis of our data, suggest that setback distances need
to be greater than 2 km in hilly terrain.”
[Shepherd D, McBride D, Welch D, Dirks KN, and Hill EM. Evaluating the Impact of
Wind Turbine Noise on Health-Related Quality of Life. Noise and Health
2011;13:333-9]
!
>0"+*%.#$%U0F#"-"0#I%E*.(#"#FI%.#$%P*10(C%
%
A2+!Dfg!M[R_!5+,:56!&:6+1!6246L!!!
!
“Over 20 studies have shown negative effects of noise on reading and memory in
children: epidemiological studies report effects of chronic noise exposure...Tasks
affected are those involving central processing and language, such as reading
comprehension, memory and attention. Exposure during critical periods of
learning at school could potentially impair development and have a lifelong effect
on educational attainment.”
!
%&!1:8+!106-460:&1)!920/35+&!5+9:=+5!3+;09061!*2+&!62+<!45+!5+8:=+3!;5:8!62+!1:-59+!:;!62+!&:01+)!
:5!0;!62+!&:01+!9+41+1@!!!
&
P/++,!3016-5.4&9+!94-1+3!.<!&:01+!&+>460=+/<!4;;+961!9:>&060=+!,+5;:584&9+)!+@>@)!:&+K1!4.0/06<!6:!
/+45&)!5+43)!:5!9:&9+&6546+!:&!4!641C)!*2092!94&!5+1-/6!!
!
“in a reduction in the productivity at work and the learning performance at school.”
[World Health Organization. WHO/Europe: Health Effects of Noise 2011.
!
http://www.euro.who.int/en/what-we-do/health-topics/environment-andhealth/noise/facts-and-figures/health-effects-of-noise]
jO!
!
`:5!+748,/+)!5+1+4592+51!24=+!;:-&3!6246!!
!
“chronic exposure to aircraft noise has a negative effect on children's performance
on tests of episodic memory.”
[Matheson M; Clark C; Rocio M; van Kempen E; Haines M; Barrio I; Hygge S;
Stansfeld S. The effects of road traffic and aircraft noise exposure on children's
episodic memory: the RANCH Project (Applied aspects of auditory distraction)
(Report). Noise and Health 2010; 12(49): 244-254]
!
kI-&>!+6!4/!\"''T]!4/1:!;:-&3!6246!!
!
“Older primary school children, around 11 years of age, appear to be more
affected by noise than the younger children.”
!
A2+!4-62:51!5+06+546+!62+!;0&30&>1!6246!0&30=03-4/!\:5!0&6+58066+&6]!&:01+!+=+&61!80>26!.+!“the
most important in affecting children's performance”h!62+<!1->>+16!6246&“loud short events are
the main problem with road traffic noise”)!+@>@)!65-9C1!,4110&>!.<@!!ZkI-&>!+6!4/!"''Tc!!F!&:64./+!
4&3!:;6+&!906+3!9245496+501609!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!20>2/0>261!62+!5+,+6060=+!B62-8,0&>B!:5!
B*2::120&>B!1:-&31)!*2092!45+!4/1:!/:-3)!12:56!+=+&61)!5+9-550&>!41!+492!:;!62+!625++!./43+1!,411+1!
62+!6:*+5@!
!
J+6!4&:62+5!16-3<)!.<!d:&+1!%*&(4)!5+,/0946+1!6201!5+1-/6)!;0&30&>!6246!“the distraction from a single
sound (one deviating from a prevailing sequence) results in attentional capture”)!*2092!84<!
43=+51+/<!4;;+96!:&+1B!5+94//!:;!846+504/!.+0&>!/+45&+3!46!6246!608+@!!!
!
“Changing-state sequences were more disruptive than a steady-state sound
because the change kept evoking capture” [i.e., diverting the attention of the
person] “whilst with a steady-state sound, repetition resulted in habituation of the
capture response.”
!
%&3++3)!62+!4-62:51!;:-&3!6246!62+!+;;+96!:;!62+1+!B924&>0&>?1646+B!1:-&31!303!&:6!3080&012!&:5!
*+5+!62+!1-.I+961!24.06-46+3!6:!62+!&:01+)!41!62+!4-62:51!+7,+96+3@!!!
!
%&16+43)!62+!1-.I+961!*+5+!0&95+410&>/<!4;;+96+3!.<!62+!B924&>0&>?1646+B!1+G-+&9+1@!!`-562+58:5+)!
!
“the better participants were at the passive sequence processing task, the more
disrupted they were by irrelevant sound.”
[Jones D; Hughes R; Macken W. Auditory Distraction and Serial Memory: the
Avoidable and the Ineluctable. Noise and Health 2010; 12(49): 201-209]
!
A2-1)!192::/1!&+45!1:-59+1!:;!&:01+!*062!4&!B0&6+58066+&6B!9245496+5!,5+1+&6!30;;+5+&6!,5:./+81!
624&!62:1+!1-.I+96!6:!\,:110./<]!/+11!0&65-10=+!9:&60&-:-1!1:-&31@!!f:*+=+5)!!
!
“children do not spend all of their time within the school environment, and
consequently, whether they are exposed to noise at home, may be an important
determinant of whether they exhibit cognitive impairments... there is evidence that
exposure to nighttime road traffic noise can adversely affect children's sleep
quality and is associated with daytime sleepiness.”
[Matheson M, Clark C, Rocio M, van Kempen E, Haines M, Barrio I, Hygge S, and
Stansfeld S. The effects of road traffic and aircraft noise exposure on children's
episodic memory: The RANCH Project. (Applied Aspects of Auditory Distraction)
(Report). Noise and Health 2010;12(49):244-254]
!
%&!1:8+!5-54/!45+41)!*2+5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!-1-4//<!106+3)!920/35+&!84<!.:62!/0=+!4&3!466+&3!
192::/!&+45!6201!1:-59+!:;!B301654960&>B!&:01+@!!%;!&:01+!0&6+5;+5+1!*062!/+45&0&>)!62+1+!6<,+1!:;!
08,4058+&61!84<!24=+!/0;+/:&>!08,/09460:&1!;:5!4!920/3K1!4943+809!4920+=+8+&6!4&3!945++5!
:,,:56-&060+1)!41!*+//!41!;:5!2+4/62)!*+//?.+0&>)!4&3!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+@!!!
!
F/62:->2!Dfg!+8,24101+1!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!:;!&:01+!:&!920/35+&!4&3!:/3+5!43-/61)!+@>@)!:&!62+05!
9:>&060=+!,+5;:584&9+)!5+1+4592!.<!p4&!N+5=+&!%*&(4!;:-&3!6246!0&!6+581!:;!4&&:<4&9+)!!
!
!
“relatively young as well as relatively old individuals report less annoyance than
people of intermediate ages do.”
jW!
!
E10&>!4!/:&>?6+58)!+76+&10=+)!0&6+5&460:&4/!34641+6)!62+!4-62:51!;:-&3!6246!!
!
“... one potential determinant of age-related noise annoyance is the average level
of mental workload or cognitive challenge a person experiences in daily life. High
average workload may limit the ability of a person to adapt to uncontrollable
environmental noise.
... Although cognitive performance can be maintained in noise by investing more
mental resources, this leads to an increased physiological stress response ... the
disturbing effects of a stressor may continue even after the stressor has
disappeared. These 'after effects' might lead to a continuous lack of resources
required to cope with noise and other stressors, and thus to continuously elevated
levels of annoyance.”
!
A2+!4-62:51B!9:&9/-10:&1!24=+!,-./09!2+4/62!08,/09460:&1!;:5!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!3+9010:&?84C0&>!
.+94-1+!!
!
“... those age groups that supposedly are most resilient to environmental noise
are, on balance, most vulnerable to it [i.e., the middle aged population,
particularly those in their 40s]. This age-related vulnerability may also apply to
effects of noise on health.”
[Van Gerven PWM; Vos H; van Boxtel MPJ; Janssen SA; and Miedema HME.
Annoyance from Environmental Noise across the Lifespan. JASA Journal of the
Acoustical Society of America July 2009; 126(1): 187-194]
!
F/62:->2!1:8+!16-30+1!24=+!1,+9-/46+3!6246!&:01+!1+&1060=+!0&30=03-4/1!84<!24=+!8+&64/!2+4/62!
011-+1!1-92!41!3+,5+110:&!\62:->2!62+!B305+960:&B!:;!94-1+!4&3!+;;+96!45+!&:6!9/+45])!4&3!6246!*:8+&!
84<!5+,:56!8:5+!&:01+!1+&1060=06<!624&!8+&)!0&!4!9:8,5+2+&10=+!16-3<!P925+9C+&.+5>!%*&(4!;:-&3!
6246!“noise sensitivity is associated with self-reported physical health but not with reported
mental health.”&&&
!
A2+!4-62:51!4/1:!;:-&3!6246!62+5+!*41!/066/+!+=03+&9+!6246!&:01+!1+&1060=06<&Z_Pc!
!
“affects the perception of general environmental quality in general. This indicates
that NS is more specific and therefore a reliable predictor of responses to noise
rather than a predictor of the way in which people perceive the environmental
quality in their residential area in general.”
!
M:62!8+&!4&3!*:8+&!03+&60;<!0&65-10=+!&:01+)!+@>@)!405,:56!&:01+)!41!4!1:-59+!:;!4&&:<4&9+)!4&3!6201!
01!&:6!3-+!6:!8+&64/!2+4/62!011-+1!:5!:62+5!+&=05:&8+&64/!;496:51@!!ZP925+9C+&.+5>![h!N50+;412!Mh!
4&3!H+01!H@!!A2+!411:90460:&1!.+6*++&!&:01+!1+&1060=06<)!5+,:56+3!,2<1094/!4&3!8+&64/!2+4/62)!
,+59+0=+3!+&=05:&8+&64/!G-4/06<)!4&3!&:01+!4&&:<4&9+@!!!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$W]L!(bc!!!A2+!
4&&:<4&9+!:5!1+&1060=06<!01!3-+!6:!62+!&:01+!061+/;@!
!
>0"+*%.#$%/*.,-3%
A2+!4-306:5<!1<16+8!3:+1!&:6!24=+!4&!:&a:;;!1*0692@!!i+:,/+)!.:62!62:1+!*2:!2+45!:5!62:1+!*2:!
45+!2+450&>!08,405+3)!94&!;++/!62+!=0.5460:&1!,5:3-9+3!.<!1:-&3@!!_:01+!X!.:62!*246!:&+!2+451!4&3!
3:+1!&:6!2+45!X!84<!2458!:&+B1!2+4/62@!!_:01+!84<!4;;+96!62:1+!1/++,0&>!+=+&!0&!62:1+!1-.I+961!
6+16+3!;:5!RRN!4*4C+&0&>1!\RRNt+/+965:+&9+,24/:>548]@!!P0>&0;094&6/<)!4/62:->2!“clear subjective
habituation”&:99-51!;:5!,+:,/+!4;6+5!4!;+*!&0>261!+7,:1-5+!6:!&:01+)!62+05!4-6:&:809!5+1,:&1+1!3:!
&:6!434,6!:&!4!/:&>?6+58!.4101@!!g&+!84<!+=+&6-4//<!1/++,!625:->2!&:01+!3016-5.4&9+1)!.-6!:&+K1!
.:3<!X!62+!4-306:5<!1<16+8!4&3!:&+K1!,2<10:/:>09!5+1,:&1+1!X!9:&60&-+!6:!5+1,:&3!6:!62+1+!
+76+5&4/!&:01+!+=+&61@!!ZRRF!N::3!i549609+)!"'U')!,!U$!
266,Laa***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a,-./09460:&1a>::3?,549609+?>-03+?:&?&:01+!c!!!
!
_:&?4-306:5<!&:01+!241!4!,2<10:/:>094/!+;;+96L!
!
“either directly through synaptic nervous interactions, or indirectly through the
emotional and the cognitive perception of sound... The auditory system is
!
continuously analysing acoustic information, which is filtered and interpreted by
different cortical and sub-cortical brain structures...In the long run, chronic noise
stress may affect the homeostasis of the organism...Noise is considered a
nonspecific stressor that may cause adverse health effects in the long run.
Epidemiological studies suggest a higher risk of cardiovascular diseases, including
high blood pressure and myocardial infarction, in people chronically exposed to
high levels of road or air traffic noise.” [EEA Good Practice, 2010, p14]
j(!
&
P6-30+1!:&!62+1+!1:-59+1!24=+!.++&!:&>:0&>!;:5!84&<!<+451!.+94-1+!:;!62+!&-8.+51!:;!,+:,/+!
+7,:1+3)!+1,+904//<!0&!-5.4&!1+660&>1@!![-5460:&!:;!+7,:1-5+!01!4/1:!4!;496:5)!4&3!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!+7,:1+3!;:5!84&<!2:-51!:;!62+!34<!\4&3!10>&0;094&6/<)!46!&0>26])!:=+5!4!,+50:3!:;!
84&<!<+451@!!`-562+58:5+)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!241!4/1:!.++&!;:-&3!8:5+!4&&:<0&>!624&!5:43!&:01+)!
1:!62+1+!;0&30&>1!84<!*+//!24=+!4!5+/460:&120,!6:!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!
F33060:&4//<)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!9245496+501+3!.<!,+4C1!4&3!65:->21!\V*2::120&>K)!V62-8,0&>K])!
4&3!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)!4&3!0&!1:8+!9059-8164&9+1)!48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&@!!A2-1)!:&+!80>26!
+7,+96!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!1080/45/<!4;;+961!62+!2+4/62!:;!62:1+!+7,:1+3!6:!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!
1:-59+1!6246!1245+!62:1+!9245496+5016091@!!ZDfg!M[R_c!
!
%1924+809!2+456!301+41+1!“include angina, acute myocardial infarction, subsequent myocardial
infarctions and complications of infarctions, other acute forms of ischaemic heart disease
and chronic ischaemic heart disease”.!!R11+&604/!2<,+56+&10:&!0&9/-3+1!“hypertensive heart
failure, hypertensive renal disease and hypertensive heart and renal disease”.!!ZDfg!M[R_c!
!
J+6)!,5:6+960&>!,+:,/+!;5:8!+7,:1-5+!6:!/:-3!&:01+!01!:;6+&!62+!;:9-1!:;!5+>-/460:&)!4/62:->2!49-6+!
&:01+!+;;+961!:99-5!!
!
x46!5+/460=+/<!/:*!+&=05:&8+&64/!1:-&3!/+=+/1!*2+&!9+5640&!4960=060+1!1-92!41!
9:&9+&65460:&)!5+/47460:&!:5!1/++,!45+!3016-5.+3@@@!62+!/:&>?6+58!+7,:1-5+!6:!&:01+!84<!
/+43!6:!2+4/62!+;;+961!625:->2!62+!,5+11-5+!:&!62+!:5>4&018!=04!62+!165+11!+;;+961@@@!M:62!
/4.:546:5<!4&3!;0+/3!16-30+1!1->>+16!6246!62+5+!01!B4!.0:/:>094/!,462*4<!.+6*++&!62+!
+7,:1-5+!6:!&:01+)!=04!62+!165+11!8+924&018!6:!94530:=419-/45!301+41+1@y!!ZRRF!N::3!
i549609+)!"'U')!,!U$c!!!
!
M4.0192!4335+11+1!6201!B9419430&>B!+;;+96)!1-884501+3!0&!6201!92456L!
!
@"18,"5"*$%>0"+*%455*6-+%<*.6-"0#%@63*1*%%
!
!
ZM4.0192)!D@!!09%&+"#$%b$*-%$$&8"+8%>*I&-#$L&($$%$$.%+*&(+)&-%$%(-89&+%%)$@!!_:01+!4&3!f+4/62)!"''"h!
$\UW]L!UXUUc!
!
!
!
A2+!305+96!,462*4<!01L!!
!
jj!
“the direct interaction of the acoustic nerve with other parts of the central nervous
system... This is particularly relevant during sleep, where autonomous [i.e.,
involuntary] responses to single noise events, including changes in blood pressure
and heart rate, have been shown in subjects” *2:!0&30946+3!6246!62+<!303!&:6!620&C!
62+<!*+5+!3016-5.+3!.<!&:01+!+=+&61!3-50&>!1/++,@!!ZRRF!N::3!i549609+)!"'U')!,!U$c
!
%&!62+05!,4,+5)!P2+,2+53!%*&(4!4/1:!0//-16546+!62+!1+G-+&9+!:;!62+!08,496!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!:&!
2+4/62L!
!
/0G%>0"+*%P"F3-%U018(01"+*%/*.,-3D%%%
!
!
!
!
!
ZP2+,2+53![)!D+/92![)![05C1!Q_)!4&3!H462+*1!S@!R7,/:50&>!62+!S+/460:&120,!.+6*++&!_:01+!
P+&1060=06<)!F&&:<4&9+!4&3!f+4/62?S+/46+3!o-4/06<!:;!k0;+!0&!4!P48,/+!:;!F3-/61!R7,:1+3!6:!
R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+@!!3+*%-+(*#"+(4&M"1-+(4&",&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&'%$%(-89&(+)&J124#8&5%(4*9!
"'U'h(L#O(T?#OT$c!
%
%&!62+!;0>-5+)!62+!3412+3!/0&+1!0&30946+!62+!,2<1094/!+;;+961!:;!&:01+)!*2092!0&9/-3+!_:01+!%&3-9+3!
f+450&>!k:11!Z_%fkc)!*2092!01!&:6!62+!;:9-1!:;!6201!,4,+5@!
!
_:6+!62+!1:/03!/0&+1)!+84&460&>!;5:8!62+!.:7!/4.+/+3!P:-&3)!*2092!5+,5+1+&6!62+!&:&?,2<1094/!
+;;+961!:;!&:01+L!
!
• “The box labeled “moderating factors” represents the cumulative effect of traits,
contextual factors, and noise parameters (e.g., amplitude modulation).
• Annoyance and sleep disruption act as mediators between predisposing factors and
secondary health effects (e.g., health-related quality of life or disease).”
!
F99:530&>!6:!P2+,2+53!%*&(4)!!
!
“Noise standards emphasize noise level as the primary factor in noise-induced
health deficits, however, laboratory and epidemiological findings are increasingly
challenging this stimulus-orientated approach, and have instead sought to uncover
factors associated with the listener that predict health risk.”
!
%&!:62+5!*:531)!5+1+4592+51!&:*!+8,24101+!62+!08,496!:;!&:01+!:&!,+:,/+!4&3!16-3<!62+05!
5+4960:&1)!+@>@)!62+!,1<92:/:>094/!:5!,1<92:,2<10:/:>094/!,5:9+11+1)!5462+5!624&!9:&9+&65460&>!1:/+/<!
:&!/:-3&+11@!!!
!
!
!
!
%&!62+05!16-3<!:&!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+)!P2+,2+53!%*&(4!;:-&3!6246!62+5+!*41!&:!411:90460:&!!
!
jT!
“between years of residence and aviation noise annoyance... adverse reactions to
noise have not dampened with repeated exposures, that is, there is no evidence of
habituation.” The authors conclude that “... noise sensitivity can degrade HRQOL
through annoyance and sleep disruption, though further research is needed to
establish causation and afford greater generalizability.”
!
A2+!4-62:51!4/1:!&:6+!6246!62+05!!
!
“...aviation annoyance data are consistent with the mode of transport effect, with
severe annoyance ratings reported in studies on road traffic... generally less than
aviation and wind turbine noise.”
!
F1!P2+,2+53!%*&(4!4/1:!&:6+)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!*41!;:-&3!8:5+!4&&:<0&>!624&!5:43!654;;09!&:01+)!
*2092!*41!62+!;:9-1!:;!1+=+54/!/:&>?6+58!16-30+1)!4&3!4.:-6!*2092!62+5+!01!4!/45>+!.:3<!:;!3464!
0&6+5&460:&4//<@!!ZP2+,2+53![)!D+/92![)![05C1!Q_)!4&3!H462+*1!S@!R7,/:50&>!62+!S+/460:&120,!
.+6*++&!_:01+!P+&1060=06<)!F&&:<4&9+!4&3!f+4/62?S+/46+3!o-4/06<!:;!k0;+!0&!4!P48,/+!:;!F3-/61!
R7,:1+3!6:!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+@!!3+*%-+(*#"+(4&M"1-+(4&",&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&'%$%(-89&(+)&J124#8&
5%(4*9&"'U'h(L#O(T?#OT$c!
!
A2+!RE!_:01+![05+960=+!ZR_[cL!!
!
“recommends evaluating environmental noise exposures on the basis of estimated
noise annoyance...People annoyed by noise may experience a variety of negative
responses, such as anger, disappointment, dissatisfaction, withdrawal,
helplessness, depression, anxiety, distraction, agitation or exhaustion.
Furthermore, stress-related psychosocial symptoms such as tiredness, stomach
discomfort and stress have been found to be associated with noise exposure as
well as noise annoyance. Some public health experts feel that severe forms of
noise-related annoyance should be considered a legitimate environmental issue
affecting the well-being and quality of life of the population exposed to
environmental noise.”
[WHO BDEN Report]
!
%&3++3)!5+9+&6!5+1+4592!0&30946+1!6246!5+103+&61!/0=0&>!&+45!405,:561!X!*062!62+05!/:-3!4&3!
0&6+58066+&6!,466+5&1!:;!&:01+!X!3:!&:6!.+9:8+!499-16:8+3!:5!0&-5+3!6:!62+!&:01+!:=+5!608+)!41!:&+!
80>26!,5+1-8+@!!%&!;496)!+,03+80:/:>09!16-30+1)!*062!62+!3464!5+,/0946+3!495:11!30;;+5+&6!6+481!:;!
5+1+4592+51)!;0&3!6246!62+!4&&:<4&9+!0&95+41+1!:=+5!608+!;:5!62:1+!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!&+45!405,:561@!!%&!4!
16-3<!6246!0&9/-3+3!3464!;5:8!#$!1+,4546+!405,:561)!d4&11+&!+6!4/!5+,:56!6246L!
!
“No evidence was found for increased self-reported noise sensitivity... Annoyance due to
aircraft noise has been recognized by policy makers as a harmful effect in itself that should
be prevented or reduced... Furthermore, there is increasing evidence that exposure to
aircraft noise contributes to cardiovascular diseases such as hypertension and may affect
children’s cognitive functioning.”
[Janssen SA, Vos H; van Kempen EMM, Breugelmans ORP, and Miedema HME. Trends in
Aircraft Noise Annoyance: The Role of Study and Sample Characteristics. JASA Journal of
the Acoustical Society of America April 2011;129(4):1953-1962]
!
%&!62+!d4&-45<!"'UU!011-+!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!f+456!d:-5&4/)!P:5+&1+&!%*&(4!;:-&3!6246)!0&!62+05![4&012!
16-3<!,:,-/460:&!:;!8:5+!624&!O()'''!,+:,/+!54&>0&>!.+6*++&!62+!4>+1!:;!O'!4&3!W$L!
!
“exposure to loud traffic noise is strongly associated with stroke in people aged 65
and older.”
!
A2+!4=+54>+!;://:*?-,!608+!*41!U'!<+451@!!A2+!4-62:51!-1+3!4!&:01+!94/9-/460:&!,5:>548!6246!
499:-&6+3!;:5!84&<!;496:51!0&9/-30&>!62:1+!6246L!!
!
!
“could amplify or blunt road noise, including traffic composition and speed, road
surface and road type, nearby buildings and the position and heights of homes
above the roads.”
T'!
!
F1!&:01+!0&95+41+3!.<!U'!3+90.+/1)!4!,+51:&B1!165:C+!501C!5:1+!U$m!;:5!4//!4>+!>5:-,1@!!`:5!62:1+!
-&3+5!WO!<+451!:/3)!62+!501C!*41!&:6!1646016094//<!10>&0;094&6@!!f:*+=+5)!;:5!62:1+!W$@O!4&3!:/3+5)!62+!
501+!*41!10>&0;094&6L!!62+!501C!:;!165:C+!;:5!6201!>5:-,!5:1+!"(m!;:5!+=+5<!433060:&4/!U'!3+90.+/1!:;!
&:01+@!!F/62:->2!6201!*41!62+!;0516!16-3<!6:!+7480&+!5:43!&:01+!4&3!165:C+)!P:5+&1+&!%*&(4!*+5+!&:6!
1-5,501+3!.<!62+!411:90460:&!.+6*++&!62+!6*:)!.+94-1+!:62+5!16-30+1!24=+!;:-&3!654;;09!&:01+!
411:9046+3!*062!:62+5!94530:=419-/45!301+41+1@!!!
ZR"1)&'"()&!"#$%&R#+L%)&*"&D*-"L%&#+&Q4)%-&:)14*$@!!EP!_460:&4/!k0.545<!:;!H+3090&+)!_460:&4/!
%&1606-6+1!:;!f+4/62)!H+3/0&+i/-1)!d4&-45<!"W)!"'UUc!!!!
!
P:5+&1+&!%*&(4!.+/0+=+!6246!&:01+!,5:=:C+1!62+!165+11!5+1,:&1+!4&3!3016-5.1!1/++,)!!
!
“which might increase the risk for stroke, through mechanisms including increased
level of stress hormones, increased heart rate and blood pressure and impaired
immune system.”
[Sorensen M, Hvidberg M, Andersen ZJ, Nordsborg RB, Lillelund KG, Jakobsen J,
Tjonneland A, Overvad K, and Raaschou-Nielsen O. Road Traffic Noise and Stroke:
a prospective cohort study. European Heart Journal 2011 Mar;32(6):737-744]
!
F1!P:5+&1+&!%*&(4!&:6+)!:62+5!5+9+&6!5+1+4592!3:+1!0&30946+!4&!411:90460:&!.+6*++&!94530:=419-/45!
+;;+961!4&3!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+@!!A2+!94530:=419-/45!+;;+961!16-30+3!0&9/-3+!2<,+56+&10:&)!
8<:945304/!0&;45960:&)!9:5:&45<!2+456!301+41+!\0192+809!2+456!301+41+])!4&3!9453049!8:564/06<@!!%&!4!
5+=0+*!:;!EQ!3464!4&3!5+1+4592!:&!6201!011-+)!P64&1;+/3!4&3!e5:8.0+!;:-&3L!!
!
“There is some evidence of an association among environmental noise exposure
and hypertension and ischemic heart disease in the UK studies; further studies are
required to explore gender differences, the effects of day and night time exposure,
and exposure modifying factors.”
[Stansfeld S and Crombie R. Cardiovascular Effects of Environmental Noise:
Research in the United Kingdom. Noise and Health 2011 May-June
2011;13(52):229-233]
g62+5!16-30+1!24=+!4/1:!;:-&3!6246!&:01+!“has an influence on the normal functioning of the
cardiovascular, endocrinal, metabolic, gastrointestinal and neurological systems.”!!ZN:<4/!P)!
N-,64!p)!D4/04!k@!R;;+96!:;!_:01+!P65+11!:&!F-6:&:809!`-&960:&!A+161@!!!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!
"'U'hU"\$j]LUj"?UjWc!
!
P64&1;+/3!4&3!e5:8.0+!9:&9-5!6246!0&!62+!EQ)!41!0&!:62+5!R-5:,+4&!9:-&650+1)!!
!
“environmental noise is a pervasive problem... the quiet period during the night,
without transport noise, has become shorter as demonstrated in a comparison of
recent national noise surveys... There were no differences between men and
women for aircraft noise at night and risk of hypertension... people with an
existing disease might be more vulnerable to noise effects and that higher
annoyance responses in the absence of any disease may be a risk factor for
hypertension...
Although the auditory effects of noise on humans have been established, the nonauditory effects are not so well established. The emerging links between noise and
cardiovascular disease [CVD] have potentially important implications on public
health and policy.”
[Stansfeld S and Crombie R. Cardiovascular Effects of Environmental Noise:
Research in the United Kingdom. Noise and Health 2011 May-June
2011;13(52):229-233]
!
g62+5!5+1+4592+51!5+06+546+!62+!10>&0;094&9+!:;!4-306:5<!1608-/0!4&3!62+05!08,4961!:&!1/++,L!
!
!
!
“even if the incoming stimulus does not awaken the sleeper, it may produce a
brief-lasting micro-arousal.”
[Muller-Gass A and Campbell K. The Processing of Infrequently-Presented LowIntensity Stimuli during Natural Sleep: An Event-Related Potential Study. Noise
and Health 2010;12(47):120-128]
!
A201!4&4/<101!241!433060:&4/!08,/09460:&1!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62!4&3!,-./09!,:/09<)!
.+94-1+L!!!
!
“The extremely low-frequency nature of wind-turbine noise, in combination with
the fluctuating blade sounds, also means that the noise is not easily masked by
other environmental sounds.”
[Punch J, James R, and Pabst D. Wind-Turbine Noise: What Audiologists Should
Know. Audiology Today 2010 Jul-Aug, pp 20 – 31]
TU!
!
D246!<:-!94&&:6!1++!84<!2458!<:-L!!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!241!.++&!4!1:-59+!:;!9:8,/40&61!;:5!46!
/+416!41!/:&>!4>:!41!UTT#!\+5>:)!RAPE?S?T(h!4&3!41!3+1950.+3!0&!62+!5+1+4592!:;!P2+,2+53!%*&(4&;:5!
_FPF)!,-./012+3!0&!UTj"]@!!J+6)!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!061!6+481!:;!9:&1-/64&6!49:-160904&1!24=+!
4,,45+&6/<!843+!&:!+;;:56!6:!9:&6496!:5!0&6+5=0+*!=096081)!:5!62:1+!*2:!*:-/3!.+!4;;+96+3!.<!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!192+8+1)!:5!84C+!4&<!+;;:56!6:!3+=01+!+=+&!4!,0/:6!9/0&094/!16-3<@!
!
g&+!80>26!14<!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!BI-16B!&:01+@!!A246!01)!62+5+!01!1-.164&604/!+=03+&9+!6246!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!3:+1!&:6!3+1+5=+!1,+904/!301,+&1460:&!;:5!8:5+!/+&0+&6!>-034&9+!624&!:62+5!
1:-59+1!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!0&3-16504/!&:01+!,://-60:&@!!A201!01!+1,+904//<!08,:564&6!6:!&:6+)!.+94-1+!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9:&640&1!1+=+54/!9245496+5016091!6246!84C+!62+!&:01+!,45609-/45/<!0&65-10=+)!
+1,+904//<!3-50&>!1/++,)!&:01+!6246!Dfg!14<1!8+5061!B1,+904/!466+&60:&B@!!F&3!8:5+!5+9+&6!5+1+4592!
1->>+161!6246!5462+5!624&!3080&0120&>)!4&&:<4&9+!94-1+3!.<!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!1:-59+1!
0&95+41+1!:=+5!62+!<+451@!!J+6)!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!,+510161!0&!5+;-60&>!62+!/0&C!.+6*++&!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62)!+=+&!62:->2!:&>:0&>!5+1+4592!9:&60&-+1!6:!1-,,:56!4&3!5+0&;:59+!62+!/0&C!
.+6*++&!&:01+!4&3!061!43=+51+!+;;+961!:&!1/++,!4&3!2+4/62@!!
!
%
%
!
%%
!
!
!
!
!
T"!
QDM%%%!X>=%&Y<ZX>4%>[X@42%%UEX>XU;E%@&Y=X4@%;>=%U[Y>&4<UE;XP@%
!
A201!,4,+5!,5+1+&61!1:8+!:;!62+!4=40/4./+!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!1-.164&60460&>!62+!&+>460=+!
08,4961!:;!&:01+!:&!2+4/62;-/!1/++,!4&3!:62+5!+11+&604/!4960=060+1)!+@>@)!9:>&060:&)!/+45&0&>)!4&3!
,+5;:584&9+!:;!641C1@!!H:5+:=+5)!9:&60&-+3!0&6+5;+5+&9+!*062!1/++,!3015-,61!08,:564&6!
,2<10:/:>094/!;-&960:&1)!*2092!:=+5!608+!84<!/+43!6:!925:&09!4&3!/:&>?6+58!+;;+961!:&!62+!.:3<)!
1-92!41!,2<10:/:>09!165+11)!4&70+6<)!0&95+41+3!9:5601:/!,5:3-960:&)!2+43492+)!+/+=46+3!./::3!
,5+11-5+)!4&3!94530:=419-/45!301+41+1@!!P/++,!3015-,60:&)!;54>8+&6460:&)!4&3!3+,50=460:&!3:!&:6!
4//:*!62+!.:3<!6:!.+&+;06!;5:8!+11+&604/!5+16:5460=+!1/++,@!
!
_:01+!01!;5+G-+&6/<!4!94-1460=+!;496:5!0&!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1h!+=+&!0;!:&+!1/++,1!625:->2!&:01+!
+=+&61)!:&+K1!.:3<!160//!5+1,:&31!.+94-1+!62+!4-306:5<!1<16+8!3:+1!&:6!16:,!;-&960:&0&>!3-50&>!
1/++,)!4;;+96+3!.<!62+!/:-3&+11!4&3!9245496+5!:;!62+!&:01+)!+1,+904//<!0&6+58066+&6!+=+&61!:5!/:*!
;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!9:8,:&+&61@!
!
R=+5!10&9+!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*+5+!;0516!106+3!&+45!2:8+1!4&3!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1)!62+05!
&:01+!241!.++&!4!1:-59+!:;!9:8,/40&6@!!P2+,2+53!%*&(4!4335+11+3!6201!011-+!41!+45/<!41!UTj")!4&3!
8:5+!5+9+&6/<)!,5+1+&6+51!46!62+!`:-562!%&6+5&460:&4/!e:&;+5+&9+!:&!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!;:9-1+3!
:&!6201!=+5<!6:,09@!!Z`:-562!%&6+5&460:&4/!e:&;+5+&9+!:&!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+)!S:8+!UUzU$!F,50/!
"'UU!***@*0&36-5.0&+&:01+"'UU@:5>c!
!
F/62:->2!8:16!5+1+4592!45609/+1!;:9-1!:&!&:01+!;5:8!405,:561!4&3!5:431)!/45>+/<!.+94-1+!:;!62+!
-5.4&!08,4961!4&3!62+!&-8.+5!:;!62:1+!4;;+96+3)!62+5+!01!4!>5:*0&>!.:3<!:;!5+1+4592!5+/46+3!
1,+90;094//<!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!4,,+450&>!0&!62+!I:-5&4/!/06+546-5+!41!*+//!41!46!9:&;+5+&9+1@!!p4&!
3+&!M+5>)!i+3+51+&)!D4<+)!F06C+&)!4&3!:62+51!24=+!,-./012+3!I:-5&4/!45609/+1!03+&60;<0&>!1:8+!:;!
62+!49:-1609)!,1<92:/:>094/)!4&3!1:904/!;496:51!6246!45+!41!08,:564&6!41!62+!,:/06094/!4&3!9/0846+!
011-+1@!!E&;:56-&46+/<)!*062!9:&16540&61!:&!;-&30&>)!*062!8:5+!/0806+3!,:,-/460:&1!4;;+96+3!\62:->2!
45>-4./<!/45>+5!1*462+1!:;!/4&3!,+5!-&06!:;!+/+9650906<!,5:3-9+3])!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!241!&:6!<+6!
4665496+3!62+!148+!;-&30&>!:,,:56-&060+1!41!:62+5!6<,+1!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&@!!H:5+:=+5)!
.+94-1+!06!94&!64C+!<+451!;:5!+,03+80:/:>09!5+1+4592!6:!,5:=03+!5+1-/61)!16-30+1!5+/460&>!6:!405,:56!
4&3!5:43!&:01+!24=+!4!/:&>+5!2016:5<!:;!5+1+4592!,5:I+961!4&3!,5:>5488+1)!.+94-1+!62+1+!4/1:!
24=+!8:5+!08,496!:&!62+!+9:&:809!08,/09460:&1!;:5!,:/09<!4&3!,/4&&0&>!:&!4!&460:&4/!.4101@!
!
M+94-1+!:;!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+61)!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!241!.+&+;066+3!;5:8!8:5+!/+&0+&6!
65+468+&6!4&3!8:5+!>+&+5:-1!4//:*4&9+1!624&!:62+5!1:-59+1!:;!0&3-16504/!4&3!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!
,://-60:&@!!\_:6+!6246!62+!5+&+*4./+!645>+61!3:!&:6!1,+90;<!496-4/!+/+9650906<!,5:3-960:&)!:&/<!
0&164//+3!94,4906<@]!
!
R=+&!*062!62+1+!43=4&64>+1)!&:6!6:!8+&60:&!10>&0;094&6!;0&4&904/!4&3!647!0&9+&60=+1!4&3!1-.1030+1)!
62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!9:&6+&31!6246!62+5+!01!&:!+=03+&9+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!241!43=+51+!
+;;+961!:&!2+4/62@!!A2+!0&3-165<!4/1:!1->>+161!6246!4&<!5+1+4592!:;!=4/-+!*:-/3!4335+11!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!:&/<!4&3!061!+;;+961!:&!2+4/62)!*062:-6!>+&+54/01460:&!;5:8!:62+5!&:01+!1:-59+1@!!J+6)!
62+!0&3-165<!01!4/1:!G-09C!6:!3018011!4&<!+;;:561!6:!,5:=03+!9/0&094//<!1,+90;09!3464!4.:-6!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!!
!
f:*+=+5)!1+=+54/!9/0&094/!16-30+1!6246!1,+90;094//<!4335+11!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!45+!4=40/4./+)!+492!
.-0/30&>!:&)!9:8,/+8+&60&>)!4&3!+7,4&30&>!:-5!-&3+5164&30&>!:;!62+!08,496!:&!,+:,/+)!62+05!
G-4/06<!:;!/0;+)!4&3!/:&>?6+58!+;;+961!:&!1/++,!4&3!2+4/62@!![51!f455<)!i0+5,:&6)!k4-50+)!4&3!
_011+&.4-8!45+!48:&>!62:1+!*2:!24=+!16-30+3!62+!4;;+96+3!,:,-/460:&1@!!g62+5!+7,+561!24=+!
5+=0+*+3!4=40/4./+!5+1+4592!0&!:53+5!6:!4&4/<1+!4&3!1-884501+!9-55+&6!C&:*/+3>+)!+@>@)![51!
f4&&0&>)!P2+,2+53)!4&3!P4/6)!4&3!H5!d48+1)!4//!*062!+7,+5601+!0&!5+/+=4&6!45+41!:;!8+3090&+!4&3!
,1<92:49:-16091@!
!
g&+!:;!62+!;0516)!0;!&:6!62+!;0516)!+=:/=+3!;5:8!62+!9/0&094/!:.1+5=460:&1!.<!4!,2<10904&!0&!e:5&*4//)!
EQ)![5!F84&34!f455<)!:.1+5=+3!4!,466+5&!:;!1080/45!9/0&094/!011-+1!+8+5>0&>!;5:8!4!,:,-/460:&!
/0=0&>!&+45!5+9+&6/<!9:880110:&+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!![5!f455<!*41!9:&9+5&+3!&:6!:&/<!*062!2+5!
,460+&61K!2+4/62h!12+!4/1:!14*!62+!,-./09!2+4/62!011-+1!0&=:/=+3)!5+4/010&>!62+!5480;09460:&1!;:5!
:62+51)!0@+@)!62:1+!4/5+43<!4;;+96+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!41!*+//!41!62:1+!*2:!/0=+!&+45!,5:,:1+3!:5!
,:6+&604/!106+1!4&3!*2:!80>26!62+&!+7,+50+&9+!3080&012+3!*+//?.+0&>!4&3!/:&>?6+58!2+4/62!0&I-5<@!
!
!
T#!
%6!01!30165+110&>!6:!,460+&61!*2+&!62+<!3+=+/:,!1<8,6:81!6246!:99-5!1-33+&/<!4&3!*062:-6!
03+&60;04./+!94-1+1!:5!/0C+/<!:50>0&!\V030:,46209K])!4&3!06!01!30165+110&>!6:!,2<10904&1!*2:!8-16!
5+1,:&3!6:!=4>-+!:5!30;;-1+!:5!1++80&>/<!3019:&&+96+3!1<8,6:81@!!%;!4!,460+&6!,5+1+&61!*062!
9:8,/40&61!:;!1-33+&!:&1+6!1/++,!,5:./+81)!;460>-+)!4&70+6<)!0&4.0/06<!6:!9:&9+&6546+)!4&3!,:110./<!
3+,5+110:&)!4!,2<10904&!84<!,5:=03+!8+309460:&!:5!:62+5!62+54,<)!.-6!&+062+5!,460+&6!&:5!
,2<10904&!01!4335+110&>!62+!94-1+L!!9:&60&-:-1!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!4&3!3016-5.4&9+!3-+!6:!&:01+)!0&!
62+1+!941+1)!1,+90;094//<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!H+309460:&)!*2092!241!061!:*&!103+!+;;+961)!8+5+/<!
841C1!62+!94-1+!4&3!+7,:1+1!,460+&61!6:!-&&+9+1145<!8+309460:&1!4&3!,:6+&604/!103+!+;;+961)!<+6!
62+!,2<10904&!84<!24=+!&:!:,60:&!*2+&!62+!,460+&6!01!0&!30165+11!*20/+!/0=0&>!*2+5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!01!-&4=:034./+@!
!
g&+!8-16!95+306![5!f455<!*062!03+&60;<0&>!4!,466+5&!:;!9:8,/40&61!48:&>!62:1+!,460+&61!/0=0&>!&+45!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!4&3!3+9030&>!6:!3+10>&!4!,0/:6!16-3<!6:!6+16!2+5!2<,:62+101!4.:-6!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!
4&3!061!,:110./+!+;;+961!:&!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!&+45.<@!!F1!*062!8:16!,0/:6!16-30+1)!62+!f455<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!16-3<!*41!/0806+3!0&!19:,+!0&!:53+5!6:!3+6+580&+!0;!62+5+!*41!;:-&3460:&!6:!62+!,5+801+!4&3!
0;!;-562+5!5+1+4592!*41!*4554&6+3@!![5!f455<!3+10>&+3!4&3!4380&016+5+3!4!G-+160:&&405+!41!*+//!41!
9:&1-/6+3!*062!49:-160904&1!4&3!+&>0&++51!*2:!8+41-5+3!4&3!4&4/<1+3!&:01+!3464!46!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
106+1!6246!243!.++&!1-.I+961!:;!9:8,/40&6@!!A2+!f455<!,0/:6!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!16-3<!303!0&3++3!;0&3!
4!5+/460:&120,!.+6*++&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62!9:8,/40&61!4&3!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+)!;:5!62:1+!
*0620&!,5:70806<!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!6:!2:8+1!4&3!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1@!![5!f455<!9:&9/-3+3!6246!
62+!2+4/62!011-+1!0&=:/=+3!*+5+!&:6!650=04/!4&3!1245+3!1080/45060+1!*062!;0&30&>1!*062!8:5+!0&?3+,62!
+76+&10=+!+,03+80:/:>094/!16-30+1!:&!62+!08,4961!:;!&:01+!:&!2+4/62@!!A2+5+;:5+)![5!f455<!;:-&3!
6246!62+5+!*41!+=03+&9+!6246!3+1+5=+3!;-562+5!9/0&094/!16-3<@!!Zf455<!F@!!/#+)&01-2#+%$I&!"#$%&(+)&
5%(4*9@!!`+.5-45<!"''(!266,Laa***@*0&3?*4692@:5>a3:9-8+&61a*0&3?6-5.0&+1?&:01+?4&3?
2+4/62ac!
!
F/62:->2!62+5+!*41!4!;/-55<!:;!8+304!9:=+54>+!4.:-6![5!f455<K1!16-3<)!62+5+!*41!&:!08,+6-1!;5:8!
>:=+5&8+&6!+&=05:&8+&64/!2+4/62!:;;0904/1!:5!4>+&90+1!6:!,-51-+!62+!011-+)!0@+@)!6:!1++C!4&!
0&3+,+&3+&6!9/0&094/!+,03+80:/:>094/!16-3<!:&!4&!011-+!6246!80>26!24=+!4!*03+&0&>!08,496!.+94-1+!
:&12:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!*+5+!08,:564&6!9:8,:&+&61!:;!62+!62+&?>:=+5&8+&6K1!5+&+*4./+!
+&+5><!,:/09<@!!A2+!5+1,:&1+!;5:8!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!*41!30180110=+)!9060&>!6246![5!f455<K1!
16-3<!243!4!/0806+3!148,/+!10Y+)!*41!&:6!,-./012+3!0&!4!I:-5&4/)!4&3!*41!&:6!V,++5!5+=0+*+3K@!!!
!
%&16+43)!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!4&3!061!6543+!411:90460:&)!MDRF!\62+!M506012!D0&3!R&+5><!
F11:90460:&)!&:*!C&:*&!41!S+&+*4./+EQ])!906+3!62+!EQ![60!5+,:56!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!RAPE?S?
T()!41!5+.-664/@!!J+6!6246!>-034&9+)!4-62:5+3!.<!9:&1-/64&61!6:!:5!+8,/:<++1!:;!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!
0&3-165<!5+,:560&>!62+!EQ![+,4568+&6!:;!A543+!4&3!%&3-165<)!*41!3+10>&+3!6:!+&24&9+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,8+&6)!4&3!303!&:6!4335+11!2+4/62!+;;+961)!303!&:6!4335+11!0&4-30./+!&:01+)!303!&:6!
0&6+5=0+*!62:1+!4;;+96+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!4&3!303!&:6!0&9/-3+!+7,+561!:&!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!
:;!&:01+!:&!2+4/62@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+!>-034&9+!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!RAPE?S?T()!*41!&:6!,-./012+3!
0&!4!I:-5&4/)!*41!&:6!;0+/3!:5!/4.:546:5<!6+16+3!6:!419+5640&!496-4/!5+1,:&1+1!.<!,+:,/+)!4&3!*41!&:6!
,++5?5+=0+*+3@!!
!
A2+!f455<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!16-3<!*41!0&6+&3+3!41!4!,0/:6!16-3<!6:!+7480&+!4&3!4&4/<1+!4!9/0&094/!
G-+160:&@!!%6!*41!&:6!3+10>&+3!41!4!;-//?;/+3>+3!+,03+80:/:>094/!16-3<)!*2092!*:-/3!5+G-05+!8:5+!
;-&30&>!4&3!5+1:-59+1!624&![5!f455<!9:-/3!,5:=03+!:&!2+5!:*&!41!4!9:&9+5&+3!4&3!,-./09!2+4/62!
:50+&646+3!,2<10904&@!!J+6)![5!f455<K1!*:5C!*41!0>&:5+3)!4&3!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!
0&3-165<!9:&60&-+3!6:!,-51-+!4&!4>>5+110=+!:&12:5+!*0&3!+&+5><!,:/09<!*062:-6!9:&103+5460:&!;:5!
2+4/62!08,/09460:&1!4&3!,:/09<@!
!
i454//+/!6:![5!f455<K1!:.1+5=460:&1!0&!e:5&*4//)!0&!-,,+5!_+*!J:5C!P646+!\EPF])!4&:62+5!,2<10904&!
243!4/1:!03+&60;0+3!4!1080/45!4&3!,+5,/+70&>!,466+5&!:;!2+4/62!9:8,/40&61@!![5!_0&4!i0+5,:&6)!4!
,2<10904&!\d:2&1!f:,C0&1!E&0=+5106<])!*2:!4/1:!+45&+3!4!i2[!46!i50&9+6:&!E&0=+5106<)!303!&:6!
5+4/01+!*2+5+!2+5!,5:./+8?1:/=0&>!*:-/3!/+43!2+5)!.-6!12+)!6::)!1-1,+96+3!5+9+&6/<!9:880110:&+3!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!106+1!9:0&903+3!*062!62+!:&1+6!:;!1<8,6:81!5+,:56+3!.<!2+5!,460+&61@!![5!i0+5,:&6!
.+948+!0&6+5+16+3!0&!62+!f455<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!16-3<!4&3!3+903+3!6:!3+10>&!4&3!9:&3-96!4!
16-3<!6246!6::C!62+!&+76!16+,)!3+10>&0&>!4&3!9:&3-960&>!4!8:5+!9:8,/+7!4&3!+76+&10=+!16-3<!0&!
:53+5!6:!03+&60;<)!0;!,:110./+)!62+!2+4/62!08,4961)!62+05!+76+&6)!4&3!62+!5+/460:&120,)!0;!4&<)!*062!62+!
,5:70806<!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!6:!2:8+1@!
!
T$!
!
[5!i0+5,:&6K1!16-3<)!/#+)&01-2#+%&D;+)-".%)!01!4!5+845C4./+!499:8,/0128+&6!;:5!4&!0&3+,+&3+&6!
5+1+4592+5)!*2:!,+51:&4//<!;-&3+3!2+5!*:5C!4&3!9:&3-96+3!62+!0&6+5=0+*1h!62:->2!&:6+!6246!12+!
303!9:&1-/6!*062!+7,+561!41!12+!3+=01+3!2+5!16-3<!4&3!G-+160:&&405+!3+10>&1!4&3!41!12+!,5+,45+3!
2+5!84&-1950,6@!!i0+5,:&6!-1+3!4!,++5?5+=0+*+3!941+!1+50+1!95:11!:=+5!16-3<h!62+!3464!/0&C+3!
+7,:1-5+!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!*062!1<8,6:81!6246!0&9/-3+3!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1!\925:&09!1/++,!
3015-,60:&1!4&3!;54>8+&6460:&])!48:&>!:62+5!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961@!![5!i0+5,:&6!843+!62+!
3+9010:&!6:!03+&60;<!62+!9:&16+//460:&!:;!1<8,6:81!6246!12+!:.1+5=+3!41!V*0&3!6-5.0&+!1<&35:8+K@!!
D2+62+5!:5!&:6!:&+!41950.+1!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4!,466+5&!:;!1<8,6:81!6246!9:&1606-6+!4!
V1<&35:8+K)!06!01!-&3+&04./+!6246!62+!9/0&094/!9:8,/40&61!12+!3+1950.+1!9:55+1,:&3!*062!62+!
:.1+5=460:&1!4&3!43=+51+!2+4/62!08,4961!+7,+50+&9+3!.<!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+!106+1!
0&6+5&460:&4//<@!!`-562+58:5+)!62+!2+4/62!08,4961!3+1950.+3!4&3!195-,-/:-1/<!4&4/<1+3!.<!i0+5,:&6!
4/1:!4/0>&!*062!:62+5!+8,05094/!16-30+1!:&!62+!08,496!:;!&:01+!;5:8!:62+5!1:-59+1!:&!1/++,!4&3!
2+4/62@!!Zi0+5,:&6!_@!/#+)&01-2#+%&D;+)-".%6&(&-%>"-*&"+&(&+(*1-(4&%P>%-#.%+*@!!P4&64!`+)!_HL!Q?
P+/+96+3!M::C1)!"''Tc!
!
i0+5,:&6!9/+45/<!+7,/40&1!62+!165+&>621!4&3!/0806460:&1!:;!2+5!16-3<!\G-4/060+1!1245+3!.<!4//!
5+1+4592!16-30+1])!4&3!2+5!9:&9/-10:&1!4&3!5+9:88+&3460:&1!3:!&:6!:=+516+,!2+5!;0&30&>1@!!%&3++3)!
i0+5,:&6!+551!:&!62+!103+!:;!94-60:&@!!F8:&>!i0+5,:&6K1!5+9:88+&3460:&1)!*2092!9/+45/<!45+!
8:60=46+3!.<!+62094/!9:&9+5&1!;:5!62+!,-./09K1!2+4/62L!
!
Physicians practicing near wind turbine installations should incorporate “proximity
to turbines into the personal and social history in a neutral and non-suggestive
way, especially for the types of symptoms described” in Pierpont’s report, Wind
Turbine Syndrome.
“All turbine ordinances, I believe, should establish mechanisms to ensure that
turbine developers will buy out any affected family at the full pre-turbine value of
their home, so that people are not trapped between unlivable lives and destitution
through home abandonment. By shifting the burden of this expense to turbine
developers, I would hope that developers might have a stronger incentive to
improve their techniques for noise prediction and to accept noise level criteria
recommended by such agencies as the World Health Organization and the
International Standards Organization” among others. [Pierpont, 2009]
!
i0+5,:&6K1!9/0&094/!16-3<!241!.++&!=0>:5:-1/<!4&3!&+>460=+/<!95060901+3!.<!62:1+!0&!4&3!9:&1-/60&>!6:!
62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<)!0&!,/49+!:;!5460:&4/!4&3!/:>094/!190+&60;09!3019:-51+!4&3!+7924&>+@!!%&16+43!
:;!,-51-0&>!9/0&094/!3464!;5:8!16-30+1!0&!:53+5!6:!3+=01+!+&+5><!,:/09<!6246!4/1:!,5:6+961!62+!
,-./09K1!2+4/62)!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!0&3-165<!24=+!1:->26!6:!&+>46+!i0+5,:&6K1!+;;:56!6:!9://+96)!
:5>4&01+)!4&4/<1+)!4&3!16-3<!9/0&094/!3464@!!i0+5,:&6!*41!95060901+3!.+94-1+!2+5!,-./09460:&!*41!&:6!
,++5!5+=0+*+3)!.-6!2+5!16-3<!*41!,-./012+3!41!4!.::C)!&:6!41!,456!:;!4!I:-5&4/h!62+!,-./09460:&!
,5:9+11!30;;+51@!!i0+5,:&6!1-.8066+3!2+5!16-3<!3+10>&!4&3!62+&!62+!84&-1950,6!6:!+7,+561!0&!
+,03+80:/:><)!1/++,!8+3090&+)!4&3!:62+5!;0+/31)!;:5!9:88+&61)!95060G-+)!4&3!5+9:88+&3460:&1@!!!
!
g&9+!4>40&)!62+!5+,:561!011-+3!.<!62:1+!*062!=+16+3!0&6+5+16!0&!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!95060901+3!
62+!4.1+&9+!:;!,++5!5+=0+*)!<+6!62+!4-62:51!:;!62:1+!5+,:561!X!9:&1-/64&61!6:!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!
0&3-165<!X!303!&:6!0&6+5=0+*!1-.I+961!4&3a:5!,460+&61h!62+<!303!&:6!9:&3-96!9/0&094/!16-30+1h!4&3!
62+05!,4,+51!*+5+!&:6!,++5?5+=0+*+3@!!!
!
%&!62+!e4&4304&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&K1!1646+8+&6)!:))-%$$#+@&C"+8%-+$&B#*9&/#+)&01-2#+%$&(+)&
51.(+&5%(4*9)!011-+3!0&!F,50/!"''T)!eF_DRF!1403!6246![5!i0+5,:&6K1!;0&30&>1!45+!!
!
“not supported by scientists who specialize in acoustics, low frequency sound and
related human health impacts. It is important to point out that none of the work
by Dr Pierpont – or others claiming similar impacts – has been published in peerreviewed journals. This fact raises questions as to the scientific validity of these
assertions.”
[Canadian Wind Energy Association (CWEA). Addressing Concerns with Wind
Turbines and Human Health. Canadian Wind Energy Association CANWEA, April
2009]
!
A2+1+!3+;0&060=+!1646+8+&61!:=+516+,!62+05!.:-&31L!!;0516)!4/62:->2!62+5+!45+!1:8+!190+&60161!*2:!
1,+904/0Y+!0&!49:-16091)!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!1:-&3)!4&3!5+/46+3!2-84&!2+4/62!08,4961!*2:!3014>5++!*062!
i0+5,:&6K1!;0&30&>1)!62+5+!45+!:62+51!*2:!3:!4>5++h!4&3!&:!3:-.6!62+5+!45+!1:8+!*2:!45+!-&1-5+)!
TO!
!
.-6!*2:!*:-/3!/0C+!6:!1++!8:5+!9/0&094/!;0+/3!5+1+4592!.+;:5+!5+4920&>!4!9:&9/-10:&@!!F1!,:0&6+3!:-6!
+45/0+5!0&!6201!,4,+5)!62+5+!01!1-.164&60=+!+=03+&9+!6246!&:01+!4;;+961!1/++,)!2+4/62)!4&3!9:>&060:&@!!
A2+5+;:5+)!06!01!+>5+>0:-1!6:!,5+1-8+!6246!190+&9+!241!4//!62+!+=03+&9+!06!&++31!6:!,5:&:-&9+!6246!
62+5+!01!&:!,++5?5+=0+*+3!190+&60;09!+=03+&9+!0&309460&>!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!43=+51+/<!4;;+961!
2-84&!2+4/62@!
!
H:5+:=+5)!4/62:->2!eF_DRF!,/49+1!0&:530&46+!+8,24101!:&!62+!,++5?5+=0+*!,5:9+11)!8:16!:;!62+!
3:9-8+&6460:&!-,:&!*2092!06!5+/0+1!01!061+/;!&:6!,++5?5+=0+*+3)!+@>@)!62+!5+,:561!.<!061!9:&1-/64&61!
4&3!5+,:561!.<!*0&3!+&+5><!9:&1-/64&61!0&!:62+5!9:-&650+1)!0&9/-30&>!62+!EQ@!!A2+!eF_DRF!
3:9-8+&6)!;:5!+748,/+)!906+1!4&!45609/+!.<!k+=+&624//!6246!4,,+45+3!0&!4!,++5?5+=0+*+3!I:-5&4/)!
C(+()#(+&:8"1$*#8$@!!f:*+=+5)!201!45609/+!*41!4!5+=0+*!45609/+)!4&3!303!&:6!,5+1+&6!62+!5+1-/61!:;!
&+*!5+1+4592!:5!9/0&094/!16-3<!5+1-/61h!8:5+:=+5)!6201!45609/+!*41!&:6!,++5?5+=0+*+3!\9:&;058+3!.<!
,+51:&4/!9:88-&09460:&]@!!Zk+=+&624//!N@!!%&;541:-&3!;5:8!D0&3!A-5.0&+1!X!`496)!`0960:&)!:5!
[+9+,60:&s!!C(+()#(+&:8"1$*#8$!"''Wh#$\W]L"T?#$)#Wc!!
!
i0+5,:&6!3+10>&+3!4&3!+7+9-6+3!4!,0/:6!9/0&094/!16-3<!6:!3+6+580&+!0;!2+4/62!011-+1!+7016+3!6246!
*+5+!5+/46+3!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3)!:&9+!6201!*41!+164./012+3)!5+9:88+&3!;-562+5!5+1+4592!6:!
3:9-8+&6!4&3!+/-90346+!62+!5+/460:&120,!*062!/45>+5!3464!1+61@!!!
!
%&!"''T)!4/1:!,-./012+3!0&!C(+()#(+&:8"1$*#8$)!f45501:&!4335+11+1!62+!V3+()%W1(8;&",&/#+)&01-2#+%&
!"#$%&'%@14(*#"+$&(+)&*9%#-&:>>4#8(*#"+K@!!Zf45501:&!di!\i2<1091![+,4568+&6)!o-++&K1!E&0=+5106<)!
g&6450:]@!!%&43+G-49<!:;!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!S+>-/460:&1!4&3!62+05!F,,/09460:&@!!C(+()#(+&
:8"1$*#8$!P+,6!"''Th#(LUOW?UOjc!!
!
%&!4!8:5+!5+9+&6!45609/+!:&!6201!6:,09)!f45501:&!&:6+1!6246!!
!
“... a noise limit of 40 dBA will result in annoyance (rather plus very annoyed) for
about 20% of the population subject to that noise level... where rural populations
are denser and where turbines are being ‘shoe-horned’ in, this is a problem...
Noise regulation in the range 40 to 50 dBA allows turbines to be placed within 500
meters of homes and other sensitive receptors. Subsequently, in a significant
fraction of such homes, residents are being annoyed, are suffering sleep
deprivation and disturbance, and in many cases, are suffering adverse health
effects. Yet for other noise sources the limit appears reasonable... there is no
possibility of shielding the noise at source. Nevertheless, regulation without
compliance testing is unethical.
The characteristics of turbine noise that contribute to annoyance and sleep
disturbance are as follows: The sound from turbines is amplitude modulated at
the blade passage frequency... Two things arise: The peak sound is higher than
the average used for noise regulation and the modulation enhances the audibility
of the sound to such an extent that the turbine noise can be detected even when
the sound is below ambient.
The noise emitted by a turbine is broadband; however, at a distance of 500 meters
and more, the higher frequencies have been absorbed by the atmosphere so that it
is predominantly low-frequency noise that reaches a receptor. This low-frequency
noise enhances annoyance and is more readily able to penetrate walls and
resonate inside rooms.”
[Harrison JP. Wind Turbine Noise. Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society
August 2011;31(4):256-261]
!
f45501:&!84C+1!62+!08,:564&6!,:0&6)!1-,,:56+3!.<!,++5?5+=0+*+3!5+1+4592)!0&!9:&65416!*062!62+!
3:9-8+&61!011-+3!.<!S+&+*4./+EQ)!eF_DRF)!4&3!FDRF)!6246&&
&
“... the character of turbine noise makes it especially intrusive. This is
exacerbated by the fact that wind turbines are sited in rural areas where the
ambient noise level can be about 25 dBA. An intrusion of 15 DBA is too large.
Germany has a nighttime noise limit of 35 dBA; this should be the international
absolute maximum.
Turbines leave behind them a turbulent wake and a wind speed deficit. Turbulence
is known to exacerbate turbine noise... Turbulence occurs naturally in the
!
atmosphere but the wake turbulence can equal this natural turbulence out to 5
blade diameters.”
[Harrison JP, Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society, 2011, p258-9]
TW!
!
F/62:->2!RAPE!499:88:346+1!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+!:=+5!*2092!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!4//:*+3)!
[+&845C)!A2+!_+62+5/4&31)!4&3!_+*!n+4/4&3!24=+!35:,,+3!6246!4//:*4&9+@!!S+1+4592!241!
3+8:&16546+3!6246!“the turbine is generating power and noise while at ground level there is
insufficient wind to generate masking noise.”!!Zf45501:&!di)!M-//!P90!A+92!P:9)!"'UU)!,"Oj?Tc!
!
S+>4530&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!*2+62+5!06!01!841C+3!.<!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+)!62+![4&012!
R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!F96!1646+1L!
!
“In the outdoor areas most affected by the noise, such as residential areas,
institutions, summer cottages, allotments, recreational areas and other areas
sensitive to noise... limits are based on measurements and calculations of the
exact noise emission from the wind turbine. The background noise in not
taken into consideration.”
[Mortensen BOG. ‘Danish Rules on Noise and Related Issues’, p 215, in Legal
Systems and Wind Energy: a Comparative Perspective, eds. Anker HT, Olsen BE,
and Ronne A. Energy and Environmental Law and Policy Series, v2. Alphen aan
den Rijn: Kluwer Law International, 2009] (Emphasis added.)
!
D0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!94-1+1!4&&:<4&9+!0&!4.:-6!"'m!:;!5+103+&61!/0=0&>!*0620&!62+!30164&9+!6246!
5+>-/460:&1!4&3!4-62:5060+1!43=01+@!!!
!
“This is a far larger proportion than for those living with traffic and industrial noise
at the same level. The annoyance and adverse health effects are attributable to
the character of turbine noise and to deficiencies in noise regulations. Specifically,
given the amplitude modulation, the allowed intrusion above ambient is far too
high; there is no account taken of uncertainty in the prediction of noise at a home;
there is no account taken for the excess noise caused by turbulent inflow, both
natural and up-wind turbine wake; and the lack of compliance testing leaves the
adverse health effects to compound from one completed wind farm to the next one
being designed.”
[Harrison JP, Bull Sci Tech Soc, 2011, p260]
!
A2-1)!41!9:-&6+5,:0&6!6:!62+!9/4081!:;!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!4&3!061!6543+!411:90460:&1)!
f45501:&!,5:=03+1!4!1-.164&60=+)!,++5?5+=0+*+3!3019-110:&!:;!9-55+&6!5+1+4592!6246!1-,,:561!
i0+5,:&6K1!\4&3!:62+51]!5+1+4592!0&309460&>!4&!411:90460:&!.+6*++&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62)!
.41+3!:&!62+!9245496+5016091!:;!62+05!&:01+!4&3!62+!5+4/?/0;+!5+1,:&1+1!:;!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1@!
!
%&!"''T)!62+!i-./09!f+4/62!P-.9:88066++!:;!62+!H40&+!H+3094/!F11:90460:&!ZEPFc!0&06046+3!62+!;0516!
9:&65://+3!16-3<!:;!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!5+/46+3!6:!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!![5!_011+&.4-8)!4!
,2<10904&!*2:!/+43!62+!5+1+4592)!49C&:*/+3>+3!62+!,0/:6!1-5=+<!*+4C&+11+1!\41!3:+1!i0+5,:&6!
*062!2+5!,0/:6!16-3<])!,508450/<)!4!184//!148,/+!10Y+@!!f:*+=+5)!6201!01!:;6+&!62+!941+!*062!,0/:6!
16-30+1h!62+1+!6<,+1!:;!16-30+1!45+!8+4&6!6:!:;;+5!>-034&9+!;:5!;-6-5+!G-+160:&1!4&3!305+960:&1!0&!
5+1+4592@!!Z_011+&.4-8)!HF@!!<(-$&5#44&/#+)&01-2#+%&J-"c%8*&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$6&J-%4#.#+(-;&=#+)#+@$@!!
H40&+!H+3094/!F11:90460:&)!H4592!"''Th!1++!4/1:!_011+&.4-8!HF@!!<(-$&5#44&/#+)&01-2#+%&J-"c%8*&
5%(4*9&7,,%8*$6&J#4"*&D*1);@!!S-6/4&3)!p+58:&6)!EPF)!S-6/4&3!S+>0:&4/!H+3094/!e+&6+5)!W!H4<!"'U'h!
4&3!_011+&.4-8!H)!F5480&0!d)!4&3!f4&&0&>!e@!!:)F%-$%&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$&",&3+)1$*-#(4&/#+)&01-2#+%$6&&:&
J-%4#.#+(-;&'%>"-*@!!U'62!%&6+5&460:&4/!e:&>5+11!:&!_:01+!41!4!i-./09!f+4/62!i5:./+8!\%eMR_])!
k:&3:&)!EQ)!"$!X!"j!d-/<!"'UU@c!
!
%&![+9+8.+5!"''T)!62+!F8+5094&!4&3!e4&4304&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&1!011-+3!4!5+,:56)!V/#+)&
01-2#+%&D"1+)&(+)&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$6&(+&%P>%-*&>(+%4&-%F#%BK)!*2092&*41!,5+,45+3!;:5!4&3!,-./012+3!.<!
62+!FDRF!4&3!eF_DRF@!!A2+!4-62:51!;:-&3!&:!1-.164&60=+!+=03+&9+!;:5!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!
94-1+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!F>40&)!62+!/49C!:;!+=03+&9+!,-./012+3!0&!,++5?5+=0+*+3!I:-5&4/1!*41!
+8,24101+3@!!f:*+=+5)!6201!5+,:56)!4/.+06!4-62:5+3!.<!,2<10904&1!4&3!49:-160904&1)!*41!&:6!,++5?
5+=0+*+3h!&:5!*41!4&<:&+!,-5,:56+3/<!4;;+96+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!0&6+5=0+*+3h!&:5!*41!4!.4109!
0&0604/!,0/:6!16-3<!3+=01+3!4&3!5-&@!!ZF8+5094&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!4&3!62+!e4&4304&!D0&3!
R&+5><!F11:90460:&!\Fae4&DRF]@!/#+)&01-2#+%&D"1+)&(+)&5%(4*9&7,,%8*$6&(+&%P>%-*&>(+%4&-%F#%B@!!
T(!
!
i4&+/L!e:/.<!D[)![:.0+!S)!k+=+&624//!N)!k0,19:8.![H)!H9e-&&+<!Sd)!P+0/:!HA)!4&3!P:&3+5>4453!M@!!
Fae4&DRF)![+9+8.+5!"''Tc!!
!
H+4&*20/+)!,2<10904&1!45+!*:5C0&>!0&!9:88-&060+1!*2+5+!,460+&61!45+!+7,+50+&90&>!1080/45!4&3!
:;6+&!&+*/<!5+,:56+3!,5:./+81!*062!1/++,!4&3!62+!+;;+961!6246!5+1-/6!;5:8!1/++,!;54>8+&6460:&h!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!;5:8!&+*/<!9:880110:&+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!45+!:;6+&!08,/0946+3@!!%8,+//+3!
.<!4!9:&9+5&!;:5!62+!2+4/62!:;!62:1+!0&!62+05!9:88-&060+1!4&3!;:5!30164&6!9:88-&060+1!1080/45/<!
4;;+96+3)!62+1+!,2<10904&1!45+!84C0&>!4&!+;;:56!6:!16-3<!4&3!+7,/40&!62+1+!,5:./+81@!
!
_:6!6:!.+!3019:-54>+3!.<!950609018!/+=+/+3!.<!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!6543+!411:90460:&1!4&3!62+05!
9:&1-/64&61)!;://:*0&>!62+!"''T!,0/:6!16-3<!0&!H40&+)![(&4(-@%-I&."-%&)%*(#4%)I&(+)&$*(+)(-)#d%)&
8"+*-"44%)&$*1);\!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!061!43=+51+!+;;+961!:&!2+4/62!*41!-&3+564C+&!46!H451!
f0//!4&3!p0&4/24=+&)!H40&+)!-10&>!=4/0346+3!G-+160:&&405+1@!!P-.I+961!ZV+7,:1+3Kc!0&9/-3+3!""!43-/61!
/0=0&>!*0620&!#O''!;++6!:;!"j!U@OHD!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!\#jT!;++6!6:!./43+!60,]h!62+1+!V+7,:1+3K!1-.I+961!
*+5+!9:8,45+3!*062!"(!,+:,/+!:;!1080/45!4>+!4&3!:99-,460:&!/0=0&>!4,,5:70846+/<!#!80/+1!;5:8!
62+!106+!ZV&:&?+7,:1+3Kc@!!g;!62+!+7,:1+3!1-.I+961)!j"m!5+,:56+3!&+*!:5!*:51+&+3!925:&09!1/++,!
3+,50=460:&!=+51-1!$m!\U!1-.I+96]!0&!62+!&:&?+7,:1+3!9:&65:/!>5:-,@!!g;!62:1+!+7,:1+3!1-.I+961!
5+,:560&>!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1)!((m!5+,:56+3!6246!62+<!4*4C+&+3!3-50&>!62+!&0>26)!*20/+!$Om!243!
30;;09-/6<!;4//0&>!41/++,!\6:64/!:;!8:5+!624&!U''m!3-+!6:!1:8+!1-.I+961!,5:./+81!*062!.:62]@!!g;!62+!
+7,:1+3!1-.I+961)!TOm!,+59+0=+3!5+3-9+3!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+)!*2+5+41!&:&+!\'m]!:;!62+!&:&?+7,:1+3!
1-.I+961!5+,:56+3!1080/45!5+1,:&1+1@!!Z_011+&.4-8!H@!!/#+)&01-2#+%$I&5%(4*9I&'#)@%4#+%$I&(+)&
O(44%;$@!!R&+5>0Y+!p+58:&6)!H:&6,+/0+5)!p+58:&6)!EPF)!H4<!(!"'U'!266,Laa=08+:@9:8aUUO((Tj"c!
!
g;!62+!+7,:1+3!1-.I+961)!U''m!5+,:56+3!6246!62+<!243!9:&103+5+3!8:=0&>!4*4<@!!F8:&>!62+!&:&?
+7,:1+3!1-.I+961)!&:&+!5+,:56+3!9:&103+50&>!4!8:=+!3-50&>!6246!148+!608+@!!_011+&.4-8!
9:&9/-3+3!6246!.41+3!:&!62+!16-3<K1!;0&30&>1)![$#@+#,#8(+*&-#$L&",&()F%-$%&9%(4*9&%,,%8*$&(-%&4#L%4;&*"&
"881-&#+&(&$#@+#,#8(+*&$12$%*&",&>%">4%\!46!4!30164&9+!:;!46!/+416!"'''!8+65+1!;5:8!0&3-16504/!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1@!!F1!0&30946+3!.<!62+!5+1-/61!:;!6201!,0/:6!16-3<)!62+1+!84I:5!2+4/62!9:&9+5&1!+8+5>+3L!
!
“Sleep disturbances/sleep deprivation and the multiple illnesses that cascade from
chronic sleep disturbance. These include cardiovascular diseases mediated by
chronically increased levels of stress hormones, weight changes, and metabolic
disturbances... Psychological stresses which can result in additional effects
including cardiovascular disease, chronic depression, anger, and other psychiatric
symptomatology... [and] increased headaches.”
[Nissenbaum MA. Affidavit: David McKinnon (Plaintiff) and Red Lily Wind Power
Ltd Partnership, Red Lily Energy Corp, Rural Municipality of Martin, and Rural
Municipality of Moosomin (Defendants), Queen’s Bench, Judicial Centre of
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada 2010]
!
A2+!1-5=+<1!:;!H451!f0//!4&3!p0&4/24=+&!12:*!6246L!
!
“... those living within 1.4km of IWT (industrial wind turbines) have suffered sleep
disruption which is sufficiently severe as to affect their daytime functioning and
mental health... IWT noise has an impulsive character and is several times more
annoying than other sources of noise for the same sound pressure level (Pedersen
& Persson Waye 2004). It can prevent the onset of sleep and the return to sleep
after a spontaneous or induced awakening. Road, rail and aircraft noise causes
arousals, brief lightening of sleep which are not recalled. While not proven, it is
highly likely that IWT noise will cause arousals which may prove to be the major
mechanism for sleep disruption... The current ordinances determining setback are
inadequate to protect the residents and setbacks of less than 1.5km must be
regarded as unsafe. Further research is needed to determine a safe setback
distance and to investigate the mechanisms of causation.”
[Nissenbaum M, Aramini J, and Hanning C. Adverse Health Effects of Industrial
Wind Turbines: A Preliminary Report. 10th International Congress on Noise as a
Public Health Problem (ICBEN), London, UK, 24 – 28 July 2011]
!
[5!P4542!k4-50+)!4!,2<10904&!0&!1:-62+5&!F-1654/04)!241!843+!1080/45!:.1+5=460:&1!48:&>!62:1+!
/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!F-1654/04@!!F/62:->2!0&0604//<!0&!;4=:-5!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!.+94-1+!:;!
9:&9+5&1!4.:-6!84&?843+!9/0846+!924&>+)!4&3!0&!;4=:-5!:;!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,8+&6!&+45!2+5!
2:8+)!k4-50+!.+948+!9:&9+5&+3!:&/<!*2+&!4!&+0>2.:-5!4/+56+3!2+5!6:!4!5+,:56!.<![5!f455<)!:;!62+!
EQ@!!F1!&:6+3!+45/0+5)!f455<!03+&60;0+3!4!,466+5&!:;!1<8,6:81!1245+3!.<!,460+&61!*2:!*+5+!
Tj!
!
-&4*45+!:;!:&+!4&:62+5!4&3!*2:!/0=+3!&+45!&+*/<!:,+5460:&4/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!106+1@!!P2:56/<!
62+5+4;6+5)!k4-50+!.+948+!4*45+!:;![5![4=03!%1+5)!4!5-54/!F-1654/04&!,2<10904&)!;5:8!A::54!0&!
p096:504)!*2:!*41!0&1,05+3!6:!9:&3-96!201!:*&!16-3<!*2+&!2+!03+&60;0+3!4!9/-16+5!:;!1<8,6:81!
48:&>!201!,460+&61!/0=0&>!&+45!&+*/<!:,+5460:&4/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!f:*+=+5)!k4-50+!3019:=+5+3!6246!
8:16!:;!62+!4;;+96+3!1-.I+961!0&!%1+5K1!16-3<!243!/+;6!62+!45+4)!.+94-1+!1:8+!:;!62+!;:58+5!5+103+&61K!
2+4/62!!
!
“had been particularly badly impacted” and were “bought out by the developer, but
only if they signed confidentiality (“gag”) agreements, which specifically prevented
them from talking publicly about their health problems.”
[Laurie S. Submission to the Australian Federal Senate Inquiry on Rural Wind
Farms. 10 February 2011]
k4-50+K1!5+1+4592!4&3!3019-110:&1!*062!9://+4>-+1!0&6+5&460:&4//<!5+=+4/+3!6246!6201!,549609+!01!
*03+1,5+43!0&!9:-&650+1!*062!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,8+&61@!!%&!/46+!d-/<!"'U')!k4-50+!!
!
“was contacted by Mr Peter Mitchell, who had set up the structure of a not for
profit organization he had called the Waubra Foundation, to help further the
progress of facilitating and commissioning independent research into the adverse
health effects being reported in residents adjacent to wind turbines in Australia.”
!
k4-50+!I:0&+3!4&3!01!&:*!D4-.54K1!H+3094/![05+96:5@!!F1!H+3094/![05+96:5)!k4-50+!9:&3-96+3!
0&6+5=0+*1!*062!8:5+!624&!W'!4;;+96+3!5+103+&61!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,8+&61!0&!_+*!
P:-62!D4/+1!\e-//+50&)!e5::C*+//!4&3!e4,064/])!p096:504!\A::54)!e4,+!M503>+*46+5)!4&3!D4-.54])!
4&3!P:-62!F-1654/04!\H6!M5<4&!4&3!D46+5/::]@!!k4-50+!243!&:6!5+43!i0+5,:&6K1!.::C)!4&3!8:16!:;!
62+!16-3<!1-.I+961!*+5+!-&;480/045!*062!i0+5,:&6!4&3!9/0&094/!16-30+1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!
k4-50+!&:6+1!6246!62+1+!0&6+5=0+*1!“are an ongoing work in progress, and are being used to
determine future research priorities for independent researchers to pursue.”!!!
!
P<8,6:81!5+,:56+3!,508450/<!0&9/-3+L!
!
“Severe chronic sleep deprivation:
•
from the audible turbine noise,
•
from waking up anxious and hyperalert, in a panicked state, for no good
reason, and often a number of times a night. They describe being so instantly
awake that it takes a long time to get back to sleep again. These residents
often tell me that they cannot hear the audible turbine noise at the time
•
for parents, newly disturbed sleep of their children is an additional contributor
to their own sleep deprivation...
•
trying to get to sleep, or back to sleep having been woken up during the night,
in a bed which is literally vibrating
Severe frequent headaches
•
describing their head feeling as if it was ‘in a vice’ [sic]...
•
significant exacerbation of the frequency and severity of their migraines,
particularly but not exclusively from shadow flicker...
•
frequent severe headaches in children who have never previously complained of
them...”
!
k4-50+)!*2:!241!=0106+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!106+1)!9:&9-51!*062!62+!3+1950,60:&1!:;!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45.<)!
+@>@)![(&4"1)&"F%-9%()&c%*&%+@#+%I&B9#89&)"%$+K*&%F%-&4%(F%\h!k4-50+!241!:.1+5=+3!6201!+;;+96!46!4!
30164&9+!:;!$!C8!;5:8!62+!&+45+16!6-5.0&+@!!k4-50+!&:6+1!6246!62+!+45!3:+1!&:6!2+45!V4=+54>+1K)!06!
2+451!62+!,+4C1@!!Zk4-50+h!4/1:!f45501:&)!g&6450:!P<8,:10-8!"'U'c!!k4-50+K1!5+1+4592!9:55+1,:&31!
*062!62+!;0&30&>1!0&!:62+5!16-30+1h!48:&>!2+5!;0&30&>1L!
!
•
•
•
•
•
•
“Not all adjacent residents are affected
Some developments appear to have more seriously affected residents than others
Some residents are affected immediately, others are progressively affected over
weeks to months of constant exposure
Chronic exposure appears to have a cumulative effect
Not all symptoms are reversible after chronic exposure, when affected residents
move away
Elevations of blood pressure associated with proximity to operating turbines are an
emerging issue.”
!
[Laurie S. Submission to the Australian Federal Senate Inquiry on Rural Wind
Farms. 10 February 2011]
TT!
!
F99:530&>!6:!62+!Dfg!M[R_!S+,:56)!!
!
“’No exposure data’ does not mean ‘no exposure’, and ‘no scientific evidence’ does
not mean ‘no effect’.”
!
A2+1+!,0/:6!9/0&094/!16-30+1!45+!4!95-904/!16+,!0&!-&3+5164&30&>!62+!08,496!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!&:6!
:&/<!:&!62+!2+4/62!4&3!*+//!.+0&>!:;!62:1+!&:*!/0=0&>!&+45!106+1)!.-6!4/1:!0&!,5+=+&60&>!43=+51+!
+;;+961!:&!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!,5:,:1+3!106+1@!!S462+5!624&!30180110&>!62+1+!0&0604/!,0/:6!9/0&094/!
16-30+1!41!0&1-.164&604/)!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!4&3!>:=+5&8+&6!4>+&90+1!12:-/3!5+9:>&01+!62+05!
-1+;-/&+11!41!,0/:6!9/0&094/!16-30+1!6246!:;;+5!>-034&9+!;:5!/45>+5)!/:&>?6+58!+,03+80:/:>094/!16-30+1@!!!!
!
A2+1+!0&0604/!;0&30&>1!45+!1-,,:56+3!4/1:!.<!43=4&9+1!0&!62+!;0+/3!:;!,1<92:49:-16091)!62+!190+&60;09!
16-3<!:;!1:-&3!,+59+,60:&!.<!62+!2-84&!4-306:5<!1<16+8)!41!5+,:56+3!5+9+&6/<!0&!09%&!%B&e"-L&
0#.%$@!!F99:530&>!6:![5!Q<504C4C01!:;!62+!p06+5.0!P92::/!:;!R&>0&++50&>!46!62+!E&0=+5106<!:;!
P:-62+5&!e4/0;:5&04)!!
!
“It’s about the human ear and the human brain, and understanding how the
human ear perceives sound.”!!
!
[5!g7+&248)!:;!62+!E&0=+5106<!:;!H0&&+1:64)!9:&9-51L!!
“Psychoacoustics is fundamental. You need to know how the normally functioning
auditory system works – how sound relates to human perception.”
A2+!_+*!J:5C!A08+1!45609/+!9:&60&-+1L!
!
“Pitch could be measured in hertz and loudness in decibels, but other phenomena
were not so easily quantified. Human hearing can discern the movement of sound
with a surprising degree of accuracy... Despite recent advances, however,
psychoacoustics has shown engineers that they still have a long way to go.”
[Gugiotta G. Sound, the Way the Brain Prefers to Hear It. The New York Times,
September 5 2011]
!
F1!P64&1;+/3!4&3!e5:8.0+!:.1+5=+!5+>4530&>!62+!5+/460:&120,!.+6*++&!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!4&3!061!
08,496!:&!2+4/62)!+@>@)!061!08,/09460:&!0&!0&95+41+3!./::3!,5+11-5+)!!
!
“There is a need for better, future prospective studies, to take this research
forward, to gain a greater understanding of the underlying mechanisms.”
[Stansfeld S and Crombie R. Cardiovascular Effects of Environmental Noise:
Research in the United Kingdom. Noise and Health 2011 May-June;13(52):229233]
!
F1!4&!+748,/+)!5+9+&6/<!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!X!1,+90;094//<!5:43!&:01+!X!241!+8+5>+3!41!165:&>/<!
411:9046+3!*062!165:C+!;:5!62:1+!:=+5!62+!4>+!:;!W$@O!<+451!0&!4!,5:1,+960=+!9:2:56!16-3<!.<!
P:5+&1+&!+6!4/@!!ZP:5+&1+&!Hh!f=03.+5>!Hh!F&3+51+&!ndh!_:531.:5>!SMh!k0//+/-&3!QNh!d4C:.1+&!dh!
AI:&&+/4&3!Fh!g=+5=43!Qh!4&3!S44192:-?_0+/1+&!g@!!S:43!A54;;09!_:01+!4&3!P65:C+L!4!i5:1,+960=+!
e:2:56!P6-3<@!!71-">%(+&5%(-*&M"1-+(4!"'UU!H45h#"\UW]L(#(?($$c!
!
A2+!P646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!p096:504)!F-1654/04)!+164./012+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!x&:?>:!Y:&+1y!0&!F->-16!
"'UU@!!A2+!N:=+5&8+&6!0&65:3-9+3!,:/09<!6246!,5:20.061!.-0/30&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*0620&!"C8!:;!
2:-1+1)!-&/+11!62+!2:8+:*&+5!9:&1+&61!6:!4!5+3-9+3!1+6?.49C)!.-6!1:8+!45+41!45+!165096/<!:;;!
/08061@!!_:6!:&/<!3:+1!6201!5+3-9+!62+!,:6+&604/!;:5!*0&3!+&+5><!0&=+168+&6!0&!p096:504!.<!O'!6:!
('m)!62+!,:/09<!84<!5+1-/6!0&!.0//0:&1!:;!3://451!:;!/:16!0&=+168+&6@!!F1!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!F-1654/04!
8-/60,/0+3)!*062!84&<!.-0/6!&+45!2:8+1)!2+4/62!011-+1!+8+5>+3!4&3!&:01+!9:8,/40&61!+194/46+3@!!
A2+1+!924&>+1!0&!>-034&9+!4&3!,:/09<!5+;/+96!62+!9:&9/-10:&1!:;!F-1654/04&!N:=+5&8+&6!0&G-050+1!
0&6:!+=4/-460&>!9-55+&6!5+1+4592!:&!*2+62+5!:5!&:6!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9:&1606-6+1!+&=05:&8+&64/!
&:01+!,://-60:&!6246!08,4961!43=+51+/<!:&!2+4/62@!!A2+!8:5+!1650&>+&6!,:/09<!1->>+161!6246!62+!
9:88066++1!;:-&3!+&:->2!+=03+&9+!6:!64C+!4!8:5+!94-60:&45<!4,,5:492!624&!0&!62+!,416!4&3!
08,:1+!5+1650960:&1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!9:&165-960:&!&+45!2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1@!!!
!
U''!
ZP6+*456!F@!/#+)&=(-.&!"`V"&T"+%$&*"&2%&7$*(24#$9%)@!!FMe!_+*1!\F-1654/04&!M5:4394160&>!
e:5,:5460:&])!"T!F->-16!"'UUh!4&3!P646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!p096:504@!!/#+)&7+%-@;&=(8#4#*#%$I&
:.%+).%+*&OCfU@!![+,4568+&6!:;!i/4&&0&>!4&3!e:88-&06<![+=+/:,8+&6)!P646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!
p096:504)!F-1654/04)!"T!F->-16!"'UU)!!266,Laa***@3,93@=09@>:=@4-a,/4&&0&>a&+*1?4&3?
+=+&61a&+*1a48+&38+&6?=9j"?08,/+8+&61?&+*?,:/09<?:&?*0&3?+&+5><?;490/060+1?0&?=096:504c!
!
F1!&:6+3!625:->2:-6!6201!,4,+5)!62+5+!01!+&:->2!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!6246!08,/0946+1!
+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!*062!43=+51+!2+4/62!08,4961!1-92!41!94530:=419-/45!301+41+1)!4&3!:-5!
C&:*/+3>+!4.:-6!62+1+!411:90460:&1!45+!+&24&9+3!+492!<+45!.+94-1+!1:8+!:;!62+1+!5+/460:&120,1!
+8+5>+!:&/<!:=+5!/:&>?6+58!16-3<)!+@>@)!1080/45!6:!5+9:>&010&>!62+!34&>+5!:;!1+9:&3?24&3!90>45+66+!
18:C+@!!A2-1)!06!01!9506094/!;:5!,-./09!:;;0904/1!6:!4335+11!9/-16+51!:;!9:8,/40&61!4.:-6!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+@!!F/62:->2!62+!9/-16+51!84<!&:6!:99-5!1:/+/<!45:-&3!:&+!106+)!62+!;496!6246!84&<!106+1!0&!
,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1!>+&+546+!9:8,/40&61!12:-/3!,5:=:C+!4!5:.-16!5+1,:&1+!.<!62+!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!
061!4>+&61!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!62:1+!,+:,/+!4&3!6:!+&1-5+!62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45!
,5:,:1+3!106+1@!
!
!
Appendix 3.1
%
/*.,-32%
X#-*(#.-"0#.,%7*(+8*6-"B*+%
U'U!
!
!
[#-.("0I%U.#.$.%
F!5+,:56!1-.8066+3!41!+=03+&9+!0&!"'U'!.<!62+!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6!6:!62+!R&=05:&8+&64/!
S+=0+*!A50.-&4/!1646+3!6246L!
!
“The audible sound from wind turbines, at the levels experienced at typical
receptor distances in Ontario, is nonetheless expected to result in a non-trivial
percentage of persons being highly annoyed. As with sounds from many sources,
research has shown that annoyance associated with sound from wind turbines can
be expected to contribute to stress related health impacts in some persons.”
[Howe Gastmeier Chapnik Ltd. Low Frequency Noise and Infrasound Associated
with Wind Turbine Generator Systems: A Literature Review (Rfp No. Oss-78696).
Mississauga, Ontario, Canada: Ministry of the Environment, 2010]
!
F/1:!0&!"'U')!4&!0&6+5&4/!8+8:54&3-8!*0620&!62+!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6!9:&;0581!6246!62+!
9-55+&6!g&6450:!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!>-03+/0&+1!*0//!94-1+!43=+51+!+;;+961@!!A201!9:&;058460:&!:;!
62+!501C!:;!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,5:./+81!;:5!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45.<)!*062!&:01+!*0620&!
9-55+&6!>-03+/0&+1)!*41!:.640&+3!:&/<!=04!4!`5++3:8!:;!%&;:58460:&!5+G-+16L!
!
“It appears compliance with the minimum setbacks and the noise study approach
currently being used to approve the siting of WTGs [wind turbine generators] will
result or likely result in adverse effects contrary to subsection 14(1) of the EPA
(Environmental Protection Act).”
[Seglins D and Nicol J. Ontario Wind Farm Health Risks Downplayed: Documents.
CBC News, 22 September 2011.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/health/story/2011/09/21/wind-turbines.html]
!
A2-1!62+!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6!01!9/+45/<!4*45+!:;!62+!501C!6:!2+4/62!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!
;:5!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45.<@!!%&!d-/<!"'UU)!62+!R&=05:&8+&64/!S+=0+*!A50.-&4/!;:-&3!6246!0&3-16504/!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!94&!2458!,+:,/+L!
!
“While the Appellants were not successful in their appeals, the Tribunal notes that
their involvement and that of the Respondents, has served to advance the state of
the debate about wind turbines and human health. This case has successfully
shown that the debate should not be simplified to one about whether wind turbines
can cause harm to humans. The evidence presented to the Tribunal demonstrates
that they can, if facilities are placed too close to residents. The debate has now
evolved to one of degree.”
[Environmental Review Tribunal, Case Nos.: 10-121/10-122 Erickson v. Director,
Ministry of the Environment, Dated this 18th day of July, 2011 by Jerry V.
DeMarco, Panel Chair and Paul Muldoon, Vice-Chair, p 207]
!
i-51-4&6!6:!62+1+!;0&30&>1!4&3!4&4/<1+1)!g&6450:!241!<+6!6:!411+11!;-562+5!:5!6:!4/6+5!061!,:/090+1!
5+>4530&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+!9:&165-960:&!&+45!2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1@!
!
!
Appendix 3.2
%
/*.,-32%
;$$"-"0#.,%<*5*(*#6*+%%
!
!
U'"!
M5:&Y4;6!Fk@!
&3*%>0"+*%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+2%70-*#-".,%;$B*(+*%X18.6-+%0#%U3",$(*#9+%!*,,T)*"#FD%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]L"TU?!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a"TU!!
!
H9H-565<!SJ@!
&0G.($%.%U.+*%=*5"#"-"0#%05%;$B*(+*%/*.,-3%455*6-+%"#%-3*%4#B"(0#1+%05%X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%
&'()"#*+2%L.6","-.-"#F%.%U,"#"6.,%=".F#0+"+D%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]L#UW?!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a#UW!!
!
i20//0,1!ep@!
7(08*(,C%X#-*(8(*-"#F%-3*%48"$*1"0,0F"6%4B"$*#6*%.)0'-%-3*%/*.,-3%455*6-+%05%X#$'+-(".,%
!"#$%&'()"#*+%0#%>*.()C%<*+"$*#-+D%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]L#'#?!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a#'#!!
!
P4/6!F_!4&3!Q4/6+&.492!dF@!
X#5(.+0'#$%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+%U0',$%;55*6-%/'1.#+D%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]L"TW?!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a"TW!
!
P240&!H@!
7'),"6%/*.,-3%4-3"6+I%E*F"-"1.6CI%.#$%-3*%U3.,,*#F*+%05%X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%&'()"#*+2%%&3*%U.+*%
05%[#-.("0I%U.#.$.D%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]L"OW?!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a"OW!!
!
PY4/84!dk!4&3!f4&9:9C!iF@!!
>0"+*%*55*6-+%0#%3'1.#%8*(50(1.#6*2%.%1*-.T.#.,C-"6%+C#-3*+"+D%%
J$;89"4"@#8(4&H144%*#+!"'UU!d-/hU#(\$]LWj"?('(@!
!
p4&3+5.-5>!Df@!
;++*++"#F%['(%;)","-C%-0%=*+"F#%.#$%7,.#%W(**#%4#*(FC%&*630,0F"*+D%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]L"OU?!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a"OU!!
!
!"#$5.(1+I%U011'#"-"*+%.#$%460+C+-*1+@!!i456!%!\P,+904/!%11-+]@!
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]@!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$!!
!
!
!
!
!
!C h a p t e r
4
!
%
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%.#$%/'1.#%<"F3-+%
U'#!
!
SDJ%
7[&4>&X;E%cX[E;&X[>@%
A201!,4,+5!,5+1+&61!+=03+&9+!6246!&:01+!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!*2+&!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!6:!2:8+1!4&3!
:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1)!84<!94-1+!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!4&3!3016-5.4&9+1)!*062!9:&1+G-+&6!2+4/62!
,5:./+81!6:!;480/0+1)!920/35+&)!62+!+/3+5/<)!4&3!62+!=-/&+54./+@!!A201!01!4!,-./09!2+4/62!011-+!94-1+3!
.<!,5:/:&>+3!3:14>+!4&3!+7,:1-5+!6:!0&3-16504/!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&@!!A2+!,5:./+8!01!
0&6+5&460:&4/!0&!19:,+)!:99-550&>!*2+5+=+5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!9:&165-96+3!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!
2:8+1)!4;;+960&>!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!0&!=450+3!/4&3194,+1!4&3!9/0846+1)!4/62:->2!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!
0&3-165<!,+510161!0&!061!9/4081!6246!+&>0&++51!4&3!9:8,-6+5!8:3+//0&>!24=+!+11+&604//<!+/080&46+3!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!41!4!1:-59+!:;!3016-5.4&9+@!
!
J+6!&:01+!,5:./+81!,+51016@!!R=03+&9+!;5:8!84&<!49:-160904&1!4&3!62+05!9://+4>-+1!*062!8+3094/!
+7,+5601+)!4&3!+=03+&9+!;5:8!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!5+,:561!:&!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!4&3!
061!5+/460:&120,!6:!301+41+)!3+8:&16546+!6246!0&=410=+!&:01+!,://-60:&!95+46+1!,+51016+&6!1/++,!
3016-5.4&9+1!4&3!:62+5!2+4/62!011-+1@!!%&!6201!941+)!62+!94-1+!01!62+!9/:1+!,5:70806<!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!
6:!2:8+1!4&3!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1@!!
!
F99:530&>!6:!62+!_460:&4/!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!k4.:546:5<!\_SRk]!:;!62+!EP![+,4568+&6!:;!R&+5><)!
41!5+9+&6/<!41!"'U'L!
!
"... engineers have been researching methods to reduce the sounds emitted by
wind turbines".
!
A2:->2!62+5+!241!.++&!1:8+!1-99+11!*062!5+3-90&>!8+924&094/!1:-&3!1:-59+1)!1-92!41!>+45.:7+1)!
_SRk!4/1:!&:6+3!6246L!
!
"other aeroacoustic emissions are not well understood or controlled."
[National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). Wind Energy
Aerodynamics/Aeroacoustics. NREL December 2010] [Emphasis added.]
!
_SRk!9:&60&-+1!6:!9:&3-96!4+5:49:-1609!6+161!0&!:53+5!6:!03+&60;<!62+!,2<1094/!94-1+1!:;!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!
!
A2+!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6K1!;40/-5+!6:!0&65:3-9+!+;;+960=+!9:&65:/1!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!+80110:&1!
4//:*1!3+=+/:,+51!6:!/:946+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!6::!9/:1+!6:!2:8+1)!+7,:10&>!;480/0+1!6:!1+50:-1!4&3!
846+504/!=0:/460:&1!:;!;480/<!2+4/62)!6:!/:11!:;!30>&06<)!6:!0&2-84&+!65+468+&6)!4&3!6:!/:11!:;!62+!
48+&06<!:;!;480/<!2:8+1@!
!
A2-1)!62+!43=+51+!+;;+961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!45+!/0C+/<!6:!650>>+5!2-84&!50>261!=0:/460:&1)!
+&>4>0&>!;(-"6,*%\%05%-3*%Y#"-*$%>.-"0#+%Y#"B*(+.,%=*6,.(.-"0#%05%/'1.#%<"F3-+2%
!
“No one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading
treatment or punishment.”
[UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, S.4.1, Article 5, December 1984
http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/]
!
A2+5+!01!4/1:!62+!,:6+&604/!;:5!4!=0:/460:&!:;!62+!Y#"-*$%>.-"0#+%%%&0(-'(*%.#$%[-3*(%U('*,I%
X#3'1.#%0(%=*F(.$"#F%&(*.-1*#-%0(%7'#"+31*#-%\UTj(])!*2092!14<1L!
!
“Each State shall undertake to prevent in any territory under its
jurisdiction other acts of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or
punishment which do not amount to torture as defined in article 1, when
such acts are committed by or at the instigation of or with the consent or
acquiescence of a public official or other person acting in an official
capacity. In particular, the obligations contained in articles 10, 11, 12 and 13
shall apply with the substitution for references to torture of references to other
forms of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.”
!
[UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment
or Punishment, Part 1, Article 16, June 1987
http://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%201465/volume-1465-I24841-English.pdf] [Emphasis added.]
U'$!
%
%&!62+!EQ)!62+!/'1.#%<"F3-+%;6-%JOOiI%;(-"6,*%QI%@63*$',*%JI%7.(-%J)!8055:51!62+!E_!E&0=+514/!
[+9/45460:&)!4&3!01!,2541+3!62+!148+!41!;(-"6,*%S%05%-3*%4'(08*.#%U0#B*#-"0#%U3.(-*(%05%
L'#$.1*#-.,%<"F3-+%05%-3*%4'(08*.#%Y#"0#L%
!
“No one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading
treatment or punishment.”
!
;(-"6,*%Q%:;!62+%4'(08*.#%U0#B*#-"0#%0#%/'1.#%<"F3-+%F'.(.#-**+%-3"+%("F3-D%
%
A2+!P6541.:-5>!e:-56!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!E&0:&!30160&>-012+1!.+6*++&!B6:56-5+B!4&3!B0&2-84&!4&3!
3+>5430&>!65+468+&6B)!.-6!:&/<!0&!3+>5++L%
!
"In the Court's view, this distinction derives principally from a difference in the
intensity of suffering inflicted.” (S.167 Ireland v UK 1978 24EHRR 423)
!
F5609/+!#)!:;!62+!EQ!f-84&!S0>261!F96)!01!4&!4.1:/-6+!50>26!4&3!3:+1!&:6!4//:*!0&6+5;+5+&9+!:5!
8060>460:&!.<!62+!P646+L!
!
“Article 3 makes no provision for exceptions and no derogation from it is
permissible under Article 15, S.2... the Convention prohibits in absolute terms
torture and inhuman or degrading treatment.” (S.87 Gafgen v Germany)
!
S+9:>&010&>!6246!62+1+!50>261!3+50=+!;5:8!62+!0&2+5+&6!30>&06<!:;!62+!0&30=03-4/)!6201!50>26!,5:6+961!
+492!,+51:&!;5:8!95-+/)!0&2-84&)!:5!3+>5430&>!65+468+&6@!!
!
P646+!4-62:501+3!\9:&1+&6!.<!4!,-./09!:;;0904/]!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!94-1+3!.<!&:01+!01!&:6!&+*!6:!62+!
EQ)!41!0//-16546+3!.<!3-%4(+)&F&GX&7C5'&YfA]YAYZgfA&!_:01+!4&3!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!*+5+!6*:!:;!62+!
;0=+!6+92&0G-+1!-1+3!0&!:53+5!6:!B+&9:-54>+B!4380110:&1!4&3!6:!+/0906!0&;:58460:&!;5:8!,501:&+51!
4&3!3+640&++1@!!F/62:->2!496-4/!.:30/<!0&I-5<!*41!&:6!9245>+3)!,2<1094/!4&3!8+&64/!1-;;+50&>!4&3!
49-6+!,1<92046509!3016-5.4&9+1!*+5+!0&;/096+3!:&!,501:&+51@!!
!
A2+!;0=+!6+92&0G-+1!0&!3-%4(+)&F&GX!9:&1016+3!:;L!
• D4//!164&30&>h!
• f::30&>h!
• @')g*6-"0#%-0%#0"+*j%
• =*8("B.-"0#%05%+,**8h!4&3)!
• [+,50=460:&!:;!;::3!4&3!350&C@!
!
F/62:->2!62+1+!;0=+!6+92&0G-+1)!4,,/0+3!0&!9:8.0&460:&)!-&3:-.6+3/<!48:-&6+3!6:!0&2-84&!4&3!
3+>5430&>!65+468+&6)!!!
!
“within the meaning of Article 3, the techniques were also degrading since they
were such as to arouse in their victims feelings of fear, anguish and inferiority
capable of humiliating and debasing them and possibly breaking their physical or
moral resistance.” (S.167 Ireland v UK) (S.89 Gafgen v Germany) (See also:
S.79 Chahal v UK 1996; S.120 Labita v Italy; S.118 Ramirez Sanchez v France;
S127 Saadi v Italy 2008.)
“Mental harm in and of itself was a prevalent form of torture.” (S86 Gafgen v
Germany)
“In order for ill-treatment to fall within the scope of Article 3 it must attain a
minimum level of severity. The assessment of this minimum depends on all the
circumstances of the case, such as the duration of the treatment, its physical or
mental effects and in some cases, the sex, age, and state of health of the victim.
Further factors include the purpose for which treatment was inflicted together with
the intention behind it, as well as its context, such as an atmosphere of heightened
tension and emotions.” (S.88 Gafgen v Germany)
!
[European Court of Human Rights decisions may be found at:
http://www.echr.coe.int/ECHR/EN/Header/CaseLaw/Decisions+and+judgments/HUDOC+database/]
U'O!
!
=*+8"-*%-3*%4$G.($%/*.-3%F0B*(#1*#-%.##0'#6*1*#-%-0%-3*%/0'+*%05%U0110#+I%P.(63%
JORMI%).##"#F%-3*%\%-*63#"]'*+I%-3*%<*80(-%05%-3*%Z.3.%P0'+.%X#]'"(CI%@*8-*1)*(%MNJJI%
50'#$%-3*%/*.-3%$*6,.(.-"0#%3.+%#0G%1."#,C%k5.$*$%5(01%80,"6Cl%a8JSbD%%U0',$%-3"+%.,+0%
1*.#%7.(-%JI%;(-"6,*%JK%05%-3*%Y>%U0#B*#-"0#%.F."#+-%&0(-'(*I%.#$%0-3*(%U('*,I%X#3'1.#I%
=*F(.$"#FI%&(*.-1*#-I%05%_'#*%JOiRI%1"F3-%.,+0%3.B*%k5.$*$%5(01%80,"6Cl%05%F0B*(#1*#-%
055"6".,+D%%%%
ZN4>+!S6!f:&!P05!D0//048)!e240584&@!!09%&H(9(&<"1$(&J124#8&3+W1#-;&'%>"-*@!
i5+1+&6+3!6:!i45/048+&6!,-51-4&6!6:!P+960:&!"W!:;!62+!%&G-050+1!F96!"''O@!!A2+!P6460:&+5<!g;;09+!
\EQ])!fe!U$O")!=:/1!U!X!#)!j!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!!
266,Laa***@.4248:-140&G-05<@:5>a5+,:56a0&3+7@268c!
!
%&!62+!9:&6+76!:;!62+!V80&08-8!/+=+/K)!4&!0&30=03-4/!/0=0&>!&+45!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!*0//!+7,+50+&9+!
,5:/:&>+3!+7,:1-5+!\3-5460:&]!6:!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!6246!9:&60&-+1!;:5!<+451)!:;6+&!"$!
2:-51!,+5!34<)!*062!4!,+51016+&6!9:&60&-:-1!62-8,0&>)!=0.5460:&)!4&3!,+50:309!;/09C+5@!!A2:1+!*2:!
45+!+7,:1+3!+&3-5+!;460>-+!4&3!62+!9:&9-55+&6!+;;+961!:;!;460>-+)!+@>@)!3015-,6+3!9:&9+&65460:&)!
;://:*+3!.<!30165+11!4&3!;++/0&>1!:;!,:*+5/+11&+11!6:!,5:6+96!62+81+/=+1!4&3!62+05!;480/0+1!;5:8!
62+1+!-&6:*453!+;;+961@!!H4&<!=096081!45+!920/35+&!*2:!45+!20>2/<!1+&1060=+!6:!9+5640&!49:-1609!
9245496+51!4&3!*2:!94&&:6!+194,+!62+!&:01+!-&/+11!62+05!,45+&61!64C+!62+8!+/1+*2+5+@!!D062!62+05!
1/++,!3016-5.+3)!920/35+&B1!192::/*:5C!1-;;+51h!*2+&!605+3)!920/35+&!3:!&:6!,+5;:58!41!*+//!:&!
9:>&060=+!641C1!41!62+!:62+5!920/35+&!0&!62+05!9/411@!!A+492+51!84<!46650.-6+!62+05!,+5;:584&9+!:5!
46606-3+!6:!94-1+1!:62+5!624&!;460>-+@!!A2+!+/3+5/<)!62+!109C)!62:1+!*062!/0806+3!8:.0/06<)!4&3!:62+5!
=-/&+54./+!>5:-,1!94&&:6!+194,+!62+!&:01+!46!&0>26@!!
!
`:5!*246!,-5,:1+!45+!62+1+!,5+I-30904/!2+4/62!0&I-50+1!6:/+546+3!4&3!+=+&!0>&:5+3!.<!
>:=+5&8+&61s!!A2+!4-62:5010&>!4>+&90+1!4&3!,-./09!:;;0904/1!45>-+!62+!&++3!6:!4920+=+!5+&+*4./+!
+&+5><!>:4/1!41!,456!:;!1646+!,:/09<@!!f:*+=+5)!0&!,-51-06!:;!62+1+!*:562*20/+!>:4/1)!62+!>:=+5&0&>!
4-62:5060+1!9:&3:&+!4!BH49204=+//04&B!4,,5:492!\62+!+&3!I-160;0+1!62+!8+4&1]!0&!:53+5!6:!46640&!
62:1+!>:4/1)!=0:/460&>!62+!.4109!2-84&!50>261!:;!84&<!,+:,/+!0&!:53+5!6:!4920+=+!62:1+!>:4/1)!
+7,:10&>!;480/0+1!:=+5!4!,5:/:&>+3!,+50:3!6:!0&2-84&!4&3!3+>5430&>!65+468+&6@!!A2+1+!,5:./+81!
*+5+!49C&:*/+3>+3!<+451!4>:)!*2+&!62+![60!\&:*![Ree]!9:&=+&+3!62+!_:01+!D:5C0&>!N5:-,!6:!
*506+!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!5+,:56!C&:*&!41!RAPE?S?T()!,5+901+/<!.+94-1+!,+:,/+!*+5+!1-;;+50&>!
;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!*2+&!62+1+!*+5+!.-0/6!&+45!2:8+1@!
!
A2+5+!01!&:!3:-.6!*2461:+=+5!6246!62+!P646+)!62+!9+&654/!>:=+5&8+&6)!4&3!/:94/!>:=+5&8+&6!45+!
;-//<!4*45+!6246!62+5+!45+!0&!+79+11!:;!"(!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1!0&!62+!EQ!6246!45+!62+!1-.I+96!:;!
9:8,/40&61!.<!;480/0+1!=0960801+3!.<!+79+110=+!&:01+@!!\"(!fSifU')!#W!ifR'#]!!A2+!1-;;+50&>!:;!
1:8+!:;!62+1+!;480/0+1!01!*+//?3:9-8+&6+3)!0&9/-30&>!45609/+1!0&!62+!&460:&4/!,5+11h!4&3!62+5+!01!
+=03+&9+!:;!1080/45!,5:./+81!0&!:62+5!9:-&650+1@!!e:&1-/64&61!6:!>:=+5&8+&6!303!&:6!0&6+5=0+*!4&<!
:;!62:1+!5+,:560&>!43=+51+!+;;+961@!!N:=+5&8+&6!241!1:->26!6:!3+&<!:5!3:*&,/4<!62+!,5:./+8@!!
f:*+=+5)!62+!&460:&4/!,5+11!241!4//+>+3!6246!:;;0904/1!9:=+5+3!-,!;0&30&>1!;:5!4!*0&3!;458!&:01+!
5+,:56!X!4&!0&164&9+!:;!B62+!+&31!I-160;<0&>!62+!8+4&1B!X!0&!:53+5!6:!08,/+8+&6!,:/09<!4&3!645>+61!
5462+5!624&!6:!9:&103+5!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!08,4961!:&!62:1+!;480/0+1!4;;+96+3!.<!62+05!3+9010:&1@!!
Zk+4C+!d!4&3!M<;:53!f@!!g;;0904/1!e:=+5!-,!D0&3!`458!_:01+!S+,:56@!!09%&D1+)(;&0#.%$I!U#![+9!
"''Tc!!!
!
A2+!0&6+&106<!:;!1-;;+50&>!+7,+50+&9+3!.<!62+1+!0&30=03-4/1!4&3!;480/0+1!01!*+//?3:9-8+&6+3)!<+6!
62+!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6!241!;40/+3!6:!43:,6!84708-8!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,5:6+960:&!164&34531!41!
,5:,:1+3!.<!Dfg)!:5!+=+&!6:!9:&3-96!0&3+,+&3+&6!2+4/62!5+1+4592!.<!5+9:>&01+3!8+3094/!+7,+561!
0&6:!62+!&:01+!,5:./+8!1-;;+5+3!.<!;480/0+1!4&3!6:!84C+!5+9:88+&3460:&1!;:5!08,5:=+8+&6@!!
%&16+43)!62+!>:=+5&8+&6!,+510161!0&!5+/<0&>!-,:&!:-6346+3!N-034&9+!\RAPE?S?T(]!,5+,45+3!0&!62+!
UTT'1!.<!4!6+48!354*&!,508450/<!;5:8!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<@!
&
D20/+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!84<!&:6!0&;/096!62+!0&6+&106<!:;!1-;;+50&>!08,/0+3!.<!62+!3+;0&060:&!:;!
V6:56-5+K!\DAZ]&V(,@%+&F&V%-.(+;6&DYhg&?&Yhf&3-%4(+)&F&GXi)&62+5+!01!/066/+!3:-.6!6246!62+!3-5460:&!
4&3!&46-5+!:;!62+!+7,:1-5+!3:+1!9:8.0&+!6*:!:;!62+!;0=+!6+92&0G-+1!03+&60;0+3!4&3!9:&3+8&+3!0&!
Yhf&3-%4(+)&F&GXL!!_D12c%8*#"+&*"&+"#$%K!4&3!_E%>-#F(*#"+&",&$4%%>K@!!M:62!:;!62+1+!94-1+!0&6+&1+!8+&64/!
1-;;+50&>!4&3!9:&1606-6+!0&2-84&!4&3!3+>5430&>!65+468+&6@!!`-562+58:5+)!62+!e:-56!:;!F,,+4/!0&!
62+!D+/12!H0&016+51!e41+)!\eUa"'U'aU$"WaoMR_`)!_:=!"'U']!;:-&3!6246L!!
!
!
“…duration of an interference is plainly a material consideration...”
U'W!
!
%&!DAfZ&V(,@%+&F&V%-.(+;&U]Y])!62+!e:-56L!
!
“has considered treatment to be ‘inhuman’ because, inter alia, it was
premeditated, was applied for hours at a stretch and caused either actual bodily
injury or intense mental suffering, (see Labita S 120, and Ramirez Sanchez
S.118). Treatment has been held ‘degrading’ when it was such as to arouse in its
victims feelings of fear, anguish and inferiority capable of humiliating and debasing
them and possibly breaking their physical or moral resistance, or when it was such
as to drive the victim to act against his will or conscience."
(See also Keenan v UK S.110, Jalloh v Germany, as well as S.89 Gafgen v
Germany.)
&
A2+!+76+&6!:;!62+!1-;;+50&>!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!*+//!0//-16546+3!.<!62+!5+9:531!C+,6!.<!
;480/0+1)!+@>@)!6246!:;!H5!4&3!H51![4=01!4&3!;480/<!;5:8!P,4/30&>)!EQ@!!A2+1+!30450+1!3:9-8+&6!84&<!
34<1!*062!-&5+80660&>!62-8,0&>!&:01+!94-10&>!1/++,!3+,50=460:&)!*062!&:!+194,+)!4&3!62+!
9:&1+G-+&6!:&1+6!:;!1+50:-1!2+4/62!,5:./+81@!!\DYhU&3-%4(+)&F&GXI&Dff&V(,@%+&F&V%-.(+;I&DAhg&M(44"9&
F&V%-.(+;i!!%&!d-/<!"'UU)!62+!f0>2!e:-56!0&!k:&3:&!*41!41C+3!6:!9:&103+5!62+!1-;;+50&>!:;!H5!4&3!
H51![4=01!0&!E(F#$&(+)&E(F#$&F&0#+$4%;I&/(**$&(+)&=%+4(+)&/#+),(-.$&(+)&=%+&@-%%+&>"B%-&C"`">I&
84(#.&5a&Y]j]]Z]]A&&\A2+!e41+!9:&60&-+1!0&!62+!f0>2!e:-56)!k:&3:&)!:&!#'!_:=+8.+5!"'UU@]!
!
%&!4!,5+8+30646+3!3+9010:&)!62+!P646+!241!:,6+3!6:!0>&:5+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1)!*2092!0;!08,/+8+&6+3!
*:-/3!/0C+/<!5+3-9+!62+!08,496!:;!62+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!0880110:&1!4&3!62+5+.<!1-.164&604//<!
5+3-9+!1/++,!3015-,60:&@!!A2+5+!01!&:!+=03+&9+!:;!+7,/0906!4-62:506<!;5:8!i45/048+&6!6:!,+5806!
,-./09!:;;0904/1!6:!+&3:51+!;480/<!1-;;+50&>!:;!6201!0&6+&106<!4&3!3-5460:&@!!A25:->2!,/4&&0&>!
9:&65:/1!4&3!>-034&9+)!,-./09!:;;0904/1)!0&!,5+,450&>!>-034&9+!6:!0&3-165<!:&!62+!14;+!30164&9+!
.+6*++&!2:8+1!4&3!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!24=+!4110>&+3!8:5+!08,:564&9+!6:!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!
645>+61!624&!6:!62+05!3-6<!6:!,5:6+96!62+!2+4/62!4&3!0&2+5+&6!30>&06<!:;!;480/0+1@!!!
!
A2+!P646+K1!:.I+960=+1!45+!46640&4./+!.<!1+660&>!4!14;+!30164&9+!.+6*++&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!4&3!;480/<!
2:8+1)!>-03+3!.<!8+3094/!+7,+561!4&3!Dfg!5+,:561!:&!&:01+!4&3!2+4/62@!!g62+5!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!
6+92&:/:>0+1!45+!4=40/4./+)!+@>@)!1:/45)!2<35:+/+96509)!4&3!&-9/+45!+&+5><@!!E&;:56-&46+/<)!0&!62+!
i/4&&0&>!F96)!i45/048+&6!241!,5:=03+3!>5+46+5!,5:6+960:&!6:!EQ!/4&3194,+1!5462+5!624&!6:!62+!.4109!
,5:6+960:&!:;!62+!2+4/62!4&3!30>&06<!:;!;480/0+1@!!i-./09!:;;0904/1!4-62:5010&>!192+8+1!0&!62+!9+5640&!
C&:*/+3>+!6246!&+45.<!;480/0+1!*0//!1-;;+5!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!061!43=+51+!08,496!:&!1/++,!
4&3!*+//!.+0&>)!4,,45+&6/<!1++!62+1+!9:8,/40&61!.<!;480/0+1!41!4!184//!9:16!4>40&16!4920+=0&>!
5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!>:4/1@!!%6!12:-/3!.+!9/+45)!06!01!&:6!62+!V03+:/:><K!:;!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!.+0&>!
95060901+3h!06!01!62+!0&6+&60:&4/!4.1+&9+!:;!+;;+960=+!9:&65:/!:;!62+!&:01+!,://-60:&!41!4!8+4&1!6:!
.+66+5!4920+=0&>!>:4/1)!62-1!+&>4>0&>!4!=0:/460:&!:;!:&+B1!.4109!2-84&!50>261@!
!
A201!,5:./+8!01!0&6+5&460:&4/!0&!19:,+h!+@>@)!4!,4,+5!.<!Q5:>2!+7480&+1!“the loss of social justice
reported by individuals living in the environs of industrial wind turbines”!0&!g&6450:)!e4&434@!!
A2+!+7,+50+&9+1!3+1950.+3!.<!Q5:>2!8055:5!4!1080/45!3015+>453!;:5!2-84&!50>261!41!0&!62+!EQ@!!
Q5:>2!9:&9/-3+1L!
!
“In Ontario, Canada, there is a suspension of critical appraisal and due process
regarding IWTs. The lack of confidence in the political and regulatory systems will
persist if governments and industry continue to deny the existence of adverse
impacts from human exposure to IWTs.
Societies concerned with health place value on the individual: ‘A society that is
concerned with health and health equity acknowledges the existence of all its
citizens and the importance of their well-being’ (WHO, 2008, p.177).
Good governance implies that governments have a responsibility to correct policies
that result in harm. Governments have the power to halt development of IWTs in
close proximity to humans until authoritative human health research has been
completed. Facilities where there are reports of adverse health effects should be
decommissioned and health and quality of life restored.
!
The negative psychological effect of disempowerment interacting with the adverse
health effects attributed to IWTs has intensified the negative synergy of justice
lost. Impact statements indicate that the violation of procedural justice will not be
easily forgotten...”
[Krogh C. Industrial Wind Turbine Development and Loss of Social Justice.
Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society 2011;31(4):321-333]
U'(!
!
A2+5+!01!&:!,5+9:&3060:&!6:!F5609/+!#!:;!62+!f-84&!S0>261!F96!6246!061!+&>4>+8+&6!5+G-05+1!
3+6+&60:&@!!F6!6201!,:0&6)!06!01!*:562!5+=01060&>!62+!3+1950,60:&!:;!62+!43=+51+!,2<1094/!2+4/62!
08,4961)!62+!4&>-012)!4&3!62+!2-80/0460&>!4&3!3+>5430&>!+7,+50+&9+1!3+1950.+3!.<!H5!4&3!H51!
[4=01!;5:8!P,4/30&>)!41!62+05!9245496+5!4&3!8:60=460:&1!*+5+!08,->&+3@!!P:8+!;480/0+1!4.4&3:&!
62+05!2:8+1!:-6!:;!3+1,+5460:&)!.-6!8:16!;480/0+1!94&&:6!4;;:53!6246!9:16@!!%1!6201!62+!*4<!4!I-16!4&3!
3+8:954609!1:90+6<!4920+=+1!061!:.I+960=+1s!
!
%&!"''T)!i5+103+&6!g.484!49C&:*/+3>+3!6246!3-50&>!62+!,5+=0:-1!4380&0165460:&)!62+!e%F!243!
4-62:501+3!0&2-84&!65+468+&6!:;!1:8+!0&846+1!46!62+!N-4&64&48:!M4<!,501:&)!4&3!6201!
80165+468+&6!0&9/-3+3)!48:&>!:62+5!6+92&0G-+1)!+76+&3+3!,+50:31!:;!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!X!C+,6!
4*4C+!;:5!-,!6:!UU!16540>26!34<1)!0&!9:&654=+&60:&!:;!E_!S+1:/-60:&!#$O")!6:!*2092!62+!EQ!01!
10>&46:5<@!!H4&<!0&!62+!g.484!4380&0165460:&!41!*+//!41!2-84&!50>261!:5>4&01460:&1!.+/0+=+!6246!
62+1+!,549609+1!9:&1606-6+!6:56-5+@!!ZM4/3*0&!A@!!M4549C!g.484!S+/+41+1![:9-8+&61!12:*0&>!f4512!
M-12?+54!e%F!%&6+55:>460:&1@!!09%&0#.%$!\EQ])!UW!F,50/!"''Th!1++!4/1:!5+&-&90460:&!:;!62+1+!
6+92&0G-+1!0&!62+!A54&1950,6L!P+&46+!e:&;058460:&!f+450&>1!_:80&460&>!R509!f:/3+5!41!F66:5&+<!
N+&+54/@!!%B&e"-L&0#.%$)!UW!d4&-45<!"''Th!4&3!M-5&1!d`@!!M50640&![019/:1+1![464!:&!R7?[+640&++@!!
!%B&e"-L&0#.%$)!UU!`+.5-45<!"'U'c!
!
_:6+!6246!;://:*0&>!62+!3-%4(+)&F&GX&3+9010:&!4&3!1-.1+G-+&6!%&G-050+1)!62+!EQ!,5:801+3!62+!
R-5:,+4&!e:88-&06<!6246!62+!P646+!*:-/3!&+=+5!4>40&!4-62:501+!62+!0&2-84&!4&3!3+>5430&>!
65+468+&6!:;!0&30=03-4/1!=04!1/++,!3+,50=460:&@!
!
&3*%U3.(-*(%05%L'#$.1*#-.,%<"F3-+%05%-3*%4'(08*.#%Y#"0#I%U3.8-*(%J2%m="F#"-C9I%;(-"6,*%J%
1646+1!6246L!
!
“The dignity of the human person is not only a fundamental right in itself but
constitutes the real basis of fundamental rights. The 1948 Universal Declaration of
Human rights enshrined this principle in its preamble. Whereas recognition of the
inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the
human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world.”
[Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, 11 October 2000
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/charter/pdf/text_en.pdf]
!
!
&3*%Y#"-*$%>.-"0#+%Y#"B*(+.,%=*6,.(.-"0#%05%/'1.#%<"F3-+!160,-/46+1!6246L!!
!
“No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home
or correspondence, nor attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the
right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks.” [S4.2,
Article 12, December 10 1948]
&
4&3!6246L!
%
“Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and wellbeing of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing…”
[Article 25, December 10 1948 http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr]
%
%
&3*%Y^%/'1.#%<"F3-+%;6-%JOOiI%;(-"6,*%iI%<"F3-%-0%<*+8*6-%50(%7("B.-*%.#$%L.1",C%E"5*!1646+1!
6246L!
%
1) “Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his
home and his correspondence.
2) There shall be no interference by a public authority with the exercise of
this right except as in accordance with the law and as necessary in a
!
domestic society in the interests of... the economic well-being of the
country for the protection of disorder or crime, or for the protection of
health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of
others.”
U'j!
!
F5609/+!j!01!4!G-4/0;0+3!50>26!4&3!84<!.+!0&6+5;+5+3!*062!.<!62+!P646+!,5:=03+3!62+!0&6+5;+5+&9+!!
U]!01!/4*;-/h!!
"]!1+5=+1!:&+!:;!62+!/+>060846+!4081h!4&3!!
#]!01!,5:,:560:&46+@!
!
H4&<!R-5:,+4&!9060Y+&1!/::C!:&!F5609/+!j!41!4!V6::62/+11!60>+5K@!!D20/+!,456!U!,5:6+961!62+!R-5:,+4&!
;480/<!;5:8!,::5/<!9:&9+0=+3!P646+!4960:&1)!,456!"!+11+&604//<!30/-6+1!:5!5+8:=+1!6246!,5:6+960:&!
.+94-1+!62+!P646+!9:&6+&31!6246!4//!061!4960:&1!45+!/4*;-/)!/+>060846+)!4&3!,5:,:560:&46+)!4&3!62+!
P646+!4/*4<1!1++C1!6:!496!0&!62+!0&6+5+16!:;!62+!84I:506<!:;!,+:,/+)!62+5+.<!061!4960:&1!45+!,5:6+96+3!
.<!,456!"@!!ZEQ!f-84&!S0>261!F96!UTTj!\fSF!UTTj]!!
266,Laa***@/+>01/460:&@>:=@-Ca-C,>4aUTTja$"a9:&6+&61!c!
!
A2+5+!01!:;!9:-51+!9:&103+54./+!941+!/4*!:&!F5609/+!j)!,45609-/45/<!41!62+!P646+!0&=4504./<!5+/0+1!:&!
62+!,5:,:560:&4/06<!45>-8+&6!1-,,:56+3!.<!P646+!,:/09<)!*2092!241!/+;6!84&<!9060Y+&1!:;!62+!RRe!
.+/0+=0&>!62+!P646+!94&!4/*4<1!103+16+,!F5609/+!j@!!f:*+=+5)!62+!;://:*0&>!941+1!45+!10>&0;094&6!6:!
62+!:530&45<!9060Y+&!.+94-1+!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:-56!:;!f-84&!S0>261!ZRe6fSc!;:-&3!;:5!62+!0&30=03-4/)!
&:6!62+!P646+L!!
R">%d&Q$*-(&F&D>(#+&kYZZli&75''&UgggI&DAmY&?&DAmfn&
V1%--(&?&Q*9%-$&F&3*(4;&kYZZfi&Uh&75''&omggI&DAmf&?&DAh]n&
=()%;%F(&F&'1$$#(&kM1+%&U]]mi&7C5'&mmgUo&DAhlI&DYoUI&DYooI&?&DAYoln&
<"-%+"&V".%d&F&D>(#+&kYh&!"F%.2%-&U]]li&lYlob]U&DAmgI&Dh]I&?&DAhUn&(+)I&
V%",,-%;&/(44(8%&:+)-%B$&F&'%()#+@&H"-"1@9&C"1+8#4&kU]]mi&7/5C&Umh&kaHiA!
[European Court of Human Rights decisions may be found at:
http://www.echr.coe.int/ECHR/EN/Header/CaseLaw/Decisions+and+judgments/HUDOC+database/]
!
!
k::C0&>!8:5+!9/:1+/<!46!62+!EQ!f-84&!S0>261!F96)!F5609/+!j)!,456!"L!
!
“There shall be no interference by a public authority....”
A2+!,-./09!4-62:506<!0&9/-3+1!4//!4581!:;!9+&654/!4&3!/:94/!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!.:30+1!
4-62:501+3!6:!84C+!3+9010:&1!:&!.+24/;!:;!9+&654/!>:=+5&8+&6@!!
!
“...with the exercise of this right except such as is in accordance with the
law...”
F961!:;!i45/048+&6!4&3!1,+90;09!4-62:506<!;/:*0&>!;5:8!4&!F96!6:!84C+!/4*!01!*0620&!62+!
/4*@!!e41+!/4*!4-62:506<!01!9:&103+5+3!/4*;-/!-&60/!1-99+11;-//<!924//+&>+3@!!F!,/4&&0&>!
9:&1+&6!6:!-&3+564C+!3+=+/:,8+&6!84C+1!6246!3+=+/:,8+&6!/4*;-/!0;!9:&165-96+3!0&!
499:534&9+!*062!62+!9:&3060:&1!:;!6246!9:&1+&6@!
!
“... and is necessary in democratic society in the interests of:
- National security
- Public safety.”
&
“The economic well-being of the country
- For the prevention of disorder or crime
- For the protection of health or morals.”
&
“For the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.”
!
%&!9:&103+50&>!62+!+&>4>+8+&6!:;!F5609/+!j!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!62+!9:&1+G-+&6!
2+4/62!08,4961)!6201!*:-/3!&:584//<!4,,/<!:&/<!6:!*0&3!;4581!*2+5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!
/:946+3!1:!9/:1+!6:!;480/<!2:8+1!6246!62+!,50=49<!4&3!48+&06<!:;!62+!;480/<!2:8+!01!
=0:/46+3!.<!&:01+!,://-60:&@!
ZEQ!f-84&!S0>261!F96!UTTj!
266,Laa***@/+>01/460:&@>:=@-Ca-C,>4aUTTja$"a9:&6+&61c!
U'T!
!
D062:-6!,456!"!:;!F5609/+!j)!62+5+!01!/066/+!3:-.6!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!*:-/3!+&>4>+!F5609/+!j!4&3!
5+,5+1+&6!4!1+50:-1!=0:/460:&!:;!62+!.4109!2-84&!50>261!:;!0&30=03-4/1)!;480/0+1)!4&3!4;;+96+3!
9:88-&060+1@!!!
!
e:&103+50&>!,456!"!:;!F5609/+!j)!62+!,-./09!4-62:506<!*0//)!0&!A:*&!i/4&&0&>!6+581)!1++C!6:!.4/4&9+!
62+!50>261!4&3!;5++3:81!:;!62+!106+!:*&+5!6:!3+=+/:,!62+!/4&3!0&!499:534&9+!*062!62+!i/4&&0&>!F96)!
e:-&6<![+=+/:,8+&6!i/4&)!4&3!N:=+5&8+&6!i:/09<)!4>40&16!62+!50>261!:;!+70160&>!2:8+!:*&+51!:&!
43I:0&0&>!/4&3!6:!24=+!62+05!48+&06<!5+41:&4./<!,5:6+96+3@!!R=03+&9+!0&!,5+=0:-1!924,6+51!12:*1!
6246!62+!P646+!01!;-//<!4*45+!6246!62+!,5:./+81!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!5430460:&!08,496!2+4=0/<!:&!
;480/0+1!*2+5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!6:!2:8+1@!!J+6)!62+!,-./09!4-62:5060+1!9:&60&-+!6:!
;://:*!:-6346+3!>-034&9+!\RAPE?S?T(]!:&!&:01+!6246!62+<!C&:*!01!&:!/:&>+5!V;06!;:5!,-5,:1+K!0&!
,5:=030&>!,5:6+960:&!;:5!;480/0+1@!!ZP++!e24,6+5!"@c!!!
!
A2+!3+=+/:,+5!*0//!&46-54//<!1++C!6:!8470801+!62+!3+=+/:,8+&6!,:6+&604/!:;!62+!106+)!*2092!8+4&1!
.-0/30&>!41!84&<!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!41!,:110./+)!:&!41!84&<!106+1!41!,:110./+)!+=+&!0;!9/:1+!6:!
&+0>2.:-50&>!2:8+1!:5!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1@!!A2-1)!62+!,-./09!4-62:506<!01!
;40/0&>!0&!061!3-6<!6:!1650C+!4!;405!.4/4&9+!.+6*++&!62+!9:&;/0960&>!0&6+5+161!*2+&!62+!4-62:506<!
3+903+1!6246!4!184//!>5:-,!:;!;480/0+1!8-16!12:-/3+5!62+!.-53+&!:;!62+!&460:&B1!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!
,:/09<@!!A201!>5:-,!0&=:/-&6450/<!1-;;+51!62+!0&2-84&!65+468+&6!08,:1+3!.<!,5:/:&>+3!
+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!4&3!061!9:&1+G-+&6!0&I-5<!6:!2+4/62@!!g&+!84<!45>-+!6246!62+!
>:=+5&8+&6!01!&:6!4960&>!,5:,:560:&46+/<)!+1,+904//<!41!62+!&460:&4/!5+&+*4./+!645>+61!X!4!
/+>060846+!:.I+960=+!X!45+!46640&4./+!.<!8+924&0181!6246!45+!/+11!0&65-10=+!4&3!95-+/@!!A2+!
,5:./+81!45+!;-//<!0&!62+!,-./09!3:840&)!4&3!62+5+!94&!.+!&:!499+,64./+!8060>460:&!;:5!,-./09!
:;;0904/1!*2:!9/+45/<!;40/!6:!+7+5901+!62+05!3-6<!:;!945+!6:!9060Y+&1@!
!
%;!>:=+5&8+&6!9:&103+5+3!84708010&>!*0&3!,:*+5!41!=064/!6:!62+!&460:&4/!0&6+5+16)!62+&!*2<!3:+1!
>:=+5&8+&6!,5:20.06!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!&460:&4/!,45C1!\840&/<!-&0&24.06+3!4&3!/45>+)!20>2)!:,+&)!
*0&3<!/4&3194,+1]!4&3!:62+5!,5:6+96+3!/4&3194,+1)!4//!+7+8,6+3!:&!62+!>5:-&31!:;!,5:6+960&>!
=01-4/!48+&06<@!!f41!>:=+5&8+&6!3+903+3!6246!62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!=4/-4./+!/4&3194,+1!01!;45!8:5+!
08,:564&6!624&!62+!,5:6+960:&!:;!62+!/0=+1!:;!;480/0+1s!!g&+!84<!62+&!45>-+!6246!1-92!>:=+5&8+&6!
4960:&!01!301,5:,:560:&46+!6:!4920+=0&>!62+!/+>060846+!:.I+960=+@!!%6!01!30;;09-/6!6:!;0&3!62+!/4*;-/!
I-160;09460:&!;:5!,-./09!:;;0904/1!6:!4-62:50Y+!62+!1+G-+165460:&!.<!62+!P646+!:;!.4109!,5:6+960:&!:;!
;480/<!48+&06<)!2+4/62)!4&3!30>&06<)!.<!9/4080&>!Vi:/09<!:;!62+!P646+!4&3!62+!*03+5!.+&+;061!:;!*0&3!
+&+5><B!41!4!3+;+&1+!4>40&16!+&>4>0&>!F5609/+!j@!!F&!45609/+!0&!62+!%&3+,+&3+&6)!V%*&'#89&a1#8LI!
0//-16546+1!62+!0&3-9+8+&6!;:5!/4&3:*&+51!6:!0>&:5+!62+!08,496!:;!62+05!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!:&!
&+0>2.:-51A&!A2+!;0&4&904/!5+*4531!6:!/4&3!:*&+51!*2:!4//:*!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!:50>0&46+!*062!62+!
>+&+5:-1!;0&4&904/!0&9+&60=+1!4=40/4./+!;5:8!62+!P646+!6:!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,+51@!
ZM/49C+5!A@!N+6!S092!o-09C!.<!.+0&>!VN5++&K@!!3+)%>%+)%+*)!U"!d-/<!"'UUc!&!
!
F1! 4&! +748,/+)! 9:&103+5! 62+! i/4&&0&>! F,,+4/! [+9010:&)! (! d4&-45<! "'UU)! ;:5! A-&164//)! S::1)! f-//@!!
A2+![+9010:&!9:8,501+3!(T!,454>54,21)!:;!*2092!:&/<!6*:!4335+11+3!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!%&!P@UU)!
62+! %&1,+96:5! :.1+5=+3! 62+5+! 45+! 4.:-6! ""! 2:8+1! .+6*++&! (U'8! 4&3! U#''8! ;5:8! 62+! *0&3!
6-5.0&+1! 0&! :&+! 305+960:&! 4&3! 4.:-6! 4! 3:Y+&! 2:8+1! .+6*++&! j$'8! 4&3! U(''8! 0&! 62+! :62+5!
305+960:&@!!%&!P@OO)!62+!%&1,+96:5!1403L!!
!
“It was concluded at the ES [Environmental Statement] stage that the proposed
development would be able to comply with the relevant criteria included in ETSUR-97... I have no reason to question the conclusions reached in the ES… There is
no doubt the turbines would be readily audible at locations… But I consider this
adverse effect of the project is incapable of outweighing the permissive stance of
the policy.” [That is, the government's renewable energy policy.]
%&!P@T)!62+!%&1,+96:5!1646+3L!!
!
!
!
“The main issue in this case is whether any harm to landscape and visual
amenity... would be sufficient to outweigh the presumption in favour of such
proposals.”
[The Planning Inspectorate (UK). Appeal Decision: Tunstall, Roos, Hull. Inspector A
Pykett. PINS Appeal Ref APP/E20001/A/10/2130670, 7 January 2011]
!
%&!9:&65416)!62+!e:-56!:;!F,,+4/)!"$!_:=+8.+5)!"'U')!2+/3L!!
!
“...that there was no such inconsistency and allowed an appeal against the Judge’s
decision. It held that while the ETSU-R-97 limits were a matter to which the
Inspector was required to have regard, he was not bound by them. In particular,
the ETSU-R-97 limits represented only one view as to the appropriate balance to
be struck between the adverse effects of noise disturbance and the wider beneficial
effects of wind farms, and it was for the Inspector to form his own planning
judgement as to whether the noise generated by a particular proposal would be
unacceptable, taking into account the evidence of local residents and his own
experiences on site visits.”
[4-5 Gray’s Inn Square. Court of Appeal Allow Windfarm Appeal. 4-5 News, 25
November 2005, i.e., The Welsh Ministers Appeal]
UU'!
&
%&!84&<!0&164&9+1)!0&6+5;+5+&9+!;5:8!&:01+!:50>0&46+1!;5:8!84708010&>!62+!3+=+/:,8+&6!,:6+&604/!
:;!4!106+@!!A2+5+!45+!4/6+5&460=+1L!!1+660&>!>5+46+5!30164&9+1!;5:8!2:8+1)!+@>@)!4!80&08-8!:;!"C8!
*062!>5+46+5!30164&9+1!41!9:&3060:&1!5+G-05+)!:5!,5:8:60&>!:62+5!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!192+8+1)!+@>@)!
,2:6:=:/6409!9+//1!;066+3!6:!+70160&>!4&3!4//!&+*!9:&165-960:&@!!F&:62+5!4/6+5&460=+!01!6:!12-6!3:*&!
62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!46!&0>26!\5(**"+&(+)&"*9%-$&F&GX])!*062!&:01+!/+=+/!9:&65:/1!+&;:59+3!41!&+9+1145<!
4/1:!3-50&>!34<608+!2:-51@!!F!62053!:,60:&!01!6:!43:,6!+70160&>!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!43=09+!:&!
84708-8!4//:*4./+!&:01+!0880110:&1!0&!62+!2:8+)!4&3!6:!4,,:0&6!4&!0&3+,+&3+&6)!08,45604/!,4&+/!
:;!8+3094/!+7,+561!4&3!49:-160904&1!6:!43=01+!:&!84708-8!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!/+=+/1!6246!4//:*!
;480/0+1!6:!/0=+!0&!62+05!2:8+1)!;5++!;5:8!2+4/62!0&I-5<@!!
!
%&!5(**"+&F&GX&kU]]oi&og&75''&Uff)!62+!3+9010:&!0&!;4=:-5!:;!62+!P646+!*41!0&;/-+&9+3!.<!62+!
+9:&:809!&+9+1106<!:;!f+4625:*!405,:56!6:!62+!P646+@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+!3+9010:&!:;!62+!9:-56!*41!4/1:!
0&;/-+&9+3!.<!62+!,/4&!6:!0&65:3-9+!&0>26608+!&:01+!9:&65:/1!:&!405954;6!8:=+8+&61!\9-55+&6/<!
4.:-6!Om!:;!34<608+!8:=+8+&61])!*2092!4//:*1!1/++,!46!&0>26!.+6*++&!""@#'251!4&3!'(@#'251)!
4&3!62+!9:&3060:&!4,,/0+1!+=+&!62:->2!f+4625:*!405,:56!01!62+!P646+K1!0&6+5&460:&4/!/0&C!*062!62+!
*:5/3!4&3!01!:;!&460:&4/!+9:&:809!08,:564&9+!6:!62+!P646+@!!!
!
D20/+!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!01!4!,456!:;!:=+54//!P646+!i:/09<)!06!94&&:6!.+!1403!6:!.+!=064/!6:!&460:&4/!
0&6+5+16!.+94-1+)!0;!6246!*+5+!62+!941+)!4//!8::5/4&3!0&!62+!EQ!*:-/3!.+!843+!4=40/4./+!;:5!6-5.0&+1!
4&3!4//!62+!9:4164/!*46+51!*:-/3!.+!4=40/4./+)!1-,,:56+3!.<!;0&4&904/!1-.103<)!0&!:53+5!6:!8470801+!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!0&164//460:&@!!A201!01!&:6!62+!941+@!!J+6)!62+5+!01!&:!+;;+960=+!9:&65:/!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
&:01+!+80110:&1!46!&0>26@!!!
!
f:*+=+5)!0&!d4,4&)!:&!O!F->-16!"'UU)!Q4&140!R/+96509!i:*+5!e:8,4&<!4&&:-&9+3!6246!06!0&6+&3+3!
6:!5+1,+96!5+103+&61K!9:&9+5&1!4.:-6!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!Q4&140!&:6!:&/<!5+3-9+3!62+!&-8.+5!:;!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!:&!62+!106+)!06!4/1:!/0806+3!&0>26608+!:,+5460:&1@!!ZX(+$(#&74%8*-#8&C1-2$&/#+)&=(-.&
"F%-&!"#$%&C"+8%-+$@!!S+-6+51)!O!F->-16!"'UU)!
266,Laa4;@5+-6+51@9:8a45609/+a9:88:3060+1_+*1a03F`k#R(dO'`$"'UU'j'Oc!ZP++!4/1:!%6:!F!4&3!
A4C+34!A@!!P09C&+11!e/4081!i5:8,6!P6-3<!:;!D0&3!A-5.0&+1@!!09%&:$(9#&D9#.21+)!UT!d4&-45<!"'U'!
266,Laa***@41420@9:8a+&>/012af+54/3?41420aAQJ"'U''UUj'$U'@268/@c!
!
H:16!;480/0+1!/0=+!0&!62+05!2:8+1!.+;:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!,5:,:1+3!:5!9:&165-96+3@!!A2+5+!94&!.+!
&:!G-+160:&!:;!49G-0+19+&9+)!0@+@)!:;!;480/0+1!8:=0&>!6:!62+!/:9460:&!*062!62+!C&:*/+3>+!:;!,:6+&604/!
:5!496-4/!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,8+&6@!!`-562+58:5+)!62+!p4/-460:&!A50.-&4/!3+9010:&!0&!;4=:-5!:;!H5!
4&3!H51![4=01!01!:&/<!:&+!+748,/+!6246!3+8:&16546+1!,5:,+56<!=4/-+1!;4//!1-.164&604//<!0;!62+!
2:8+1!45+!1-.I+96!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,://-60:&)!4&3!06!01!&:6!,:110./+!;:5!;480/0+1!6:!8:=+!
+/1+*2+5+!*062:-6!1-;;+50&>!10>&0;094&6!;0&4&904/!/:11@!!D20/+!0&!5(**"+&F&GX!62+!e:-56!&:6+3!6246!
4/62:->2!62+!2:8+1!45+!0&!,5:70806<!6:!f+4625:*!F05,:56)!62+!/:9460:&!4/1:!84C+1!62+!2:8+1!
3+1054./+!;:5!62+05!,5:70806<!6:!k:&3:&h!62-1)!62+!2:8+1!8:5+!5+/04./<!840&640&!62+05!=4/-+!3+1,06+!
62+!&:01+!\0&!9:&65416!6:!2:8+1!&+45!*0&3!;4581])!*2092!4//:*1!405,:56!;480/0+1!6:!5+/:946+!0;!62+<!
92::1+!6:!3:!1:@!!%&!433060:&)!.+94-1+!62+!405,:56!\1:-59+!:;!&:01+]!241!+7016+3!;:5!1+=+54/!
>+&+5460:&1)!;480/0+1!45+!4*45+!:;!62+!405,:56K1!08,496!*2+&!.-<0&>!62+05!2:8+1@!!f:*+=+5)!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!:&!4!&+0>2.:-50&>!,5:,+56<!10>&0;094&6/<!5+3-9+!2:8+!=4/-+1)!/08060&>!4!;480/<K1!:,60:&1!
6:!5+/:946+@!
!
!
!
!
e:&65416!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:-56!:;!f-84&!S0>261!3+9010:&!0&!62+!941+!:;!01(/$1!?1)/@!A!<+'#$!
BCDDEF!<GHI!J!KI6&
&
UUU!
“In her additional observations of 14 Sept 2004, the applicant observed that the
level of the night-time disturbance (from 10 pm to 6.30 am) caused by more than
127 nightclubs infringed the right to health, as indeed was confirmed by the World
Health Organization’s guidelines. Unlike the position in the case of Hatton &
Others v UK, her home was neither within nor adjacent to an area of vital
importance, such as an area relevant to a strategic transport or communications
infrastructure. She stressed that her home was in an urban area, specifically, a
residential one.” [S.49]
“The facts show that the applicant suffered a serious infringement of her right to
respect for her home as a result of the authorities’ failure to take action to deal
with the night-time disturbances.” [S.61]
“In these circumstances, the Court finds that the respondent State has failed to
discharge its positive obligation to guarantee the applicant’s right to respect for
her home and her private life, in breach of Article 8 of the Convention.” [S.62]
!
`-562+58:5+)!62+!3+9010:&!.<!d-3>+!M-9C/+<!d!0&!L/$$#2!M!L/$$#2!A!-3/!0#$#2-(9!16!L/6/$7/!B0NLF&
kpU]]oq&7/5C&gZo&kaHii!01!10>&0;094&6!4&3!5+/+=4&6@!!A2+!d-1609+!;:-&3!6246!62+!+=03+&9+!:;!1+=+5+!
&:01+!&-014&9+!4&3!9:&1+G-+&6!/:11!0&!=4/-+!:;!62+!,5:,+56<!+164./012+3!4&!0&6+5;+5+&9+!*062!.:62!
F5609/+!j!4&3!F5609/+!U!:;!62+!`0516!i5:6:9:/@!!%&!62+1+!9059-8164&9+1)!62+!d-1609+!2+/3!6246!62+!
4.1+&9+!:;!9:8,+&1460:&!303!&:6!1650C+!4!;405!.4/4&9+L!
!
“I believe it is implicit in the decision S. v France, that the public interest
is greater than the individual private interests of Mr and Mrs Dennis but it
is not proportionate to pursue or give effect to the public interest without
compensation for Mr and Mrs Dennis... in my view, common fairness demands
that where the interests of a minority, let alone an individual, are seriously
interfered with because of an overriding public interest, the minority should be
compensated.”
[Dennis & Dennis v Ministry of Defence [2003] EWHC 793 (QB)
http://www.bailii.org/cgibin/markup.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2003/793.html
!
%&!&'%/9/A'!A!O.22#'!BCDDHF)!62+!e:-56!;:-&3L!!
!
“...the adverse effects of environmental pollution must attain a certain minimum
level if they are to fall within the scope of Article 8 (Lopez Ostra v Spain 1994 S.51
and also Hatton and Others v UK 2003 S.118). The assessment of that minimum
is relative and depends on all the circumstances of the case, such as the intensity
and duration of the nuisance, its physical or mental effects. The general
environmental context should be also taken into account. There would be
no arguable claim under Article 8 if the detriment complained of was negligible in
comparison to the environmental hazards inherent to life in every modern city.
[S.69] [Emphasis added.]
Thus, in order to fall under Article 8, complaints relating to environmental
nuisances have to show, first, that there was an actual interference with the
applicant’s private sphere, and, second, that a level of severity was attained.”
[S.70]
!
%&!62+!941+!:;!H5!4&3!H51![4=01)!62+!30165096!p4/-460:&!A50.-&4/!5+3-9+3!62+!=4/-+!:;!62+05!2:8+!;:5!
e:-&90/!A47!,-5,:1+1!6:!106+!=4/-+!:&/<)!5+65:4960=+!6:!62+!:,+5460:&!346+!:;!62+!*0&3!;458@!!A2+5+!
45+!:62+5!9:&654160&>!,50&90,/+1!*062!5(**"+@!!ZM-&<4&!_!4&3!M+9C;:53!H@!f:8+:*&+51!k0=0&>!
_+45!D0&3;4581!P++!i5:,+56<!p4/-+1!i/-88+6@!!09%&E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!"W!d-/<!"''jc!
!!
D20/+!1:8+!84<!1++!62+!5(**"+&F&GX&3+9010:&!41!9:&6545<!6:!R-5:,+4&!+&=05:&8+&64/!/4*)!62+!M"#+*&
E#$$%+*#+@&Q>#+#"+$&",&M1)@%$&C"$*(I&'%%$I&01-.%+I&T1>(+8#8&(+)&D*%#+%-!01!10>&0;094&6@!!%&!P@UU)!62+<!
1646+L!
!
!
"Privacy is a heterogeneous prerogative. The specific contours of privacy can be
clearly distinguished and perceived only when it is being defended against different
kinds of encroachments. Moreover, privacy is an aspect of a person’s general wellbeing and not necessarily only an end in itself. The intensity of the State’s
permissible interference with the privacy of the individual and his or her family
should therefore be seen as being in inverse relationship with the damage the
interference is likely to cause to his or her mental and physical health. The point,
in other words, is not that the sexual life of the couple whose home reverberates
with the noise of aircraft engines may be seriously affected.
UU"!
The thrust of our argument is that “health as a state of complete physical,
mental and social well-being” is, in the specific circumstances of this case, a
precondition to any meaningful privacy, intimacy etc and cannot be unnaturally
separated from it. To maintain otherwise, amounts to a wholly artificial severance
of privacy and of general personal well-being. Of course, each case must be
decided on its own merits and by taking into account to the totality of its specific
circumstances. In this case, however, it is clear that the circles of the protection
of health and of the safeguarding of privacy do intersect and do overlap.”
[Hatton and others v United Kingdom decision and dissenting opinions:
http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?item=2&portal=hbkm&action=html&s
ource=tkp&highlight="THE UNITED KINGDOM" |
hatton&sessionid=668105&skin=hudoc-en]
!
A2+!+=03+&9+!,5:=03+3!0&!e24,6+51!U)!")!4&3!#!:;!6201!,4,+5!12:*1!6246!62+!P646+!01!;40/0&>!6:!2:&:-5!
061!,5:801+1!41!4!10>&46:5<!6:!62+!E&06+3!_460:&1!-&3+5!62+!UT$j!E&0=+514/![+9/45460:&@!
!
!
!
SDM%%%&/4%Y>X&4=%>;&X[>@%Y>Xc4<@;E%=4UE;<;&X[>%[L%/YP;>%<XW/&@I%=4U4PZ4<%JOSi%
Article 17:
1. Everyone has the right to own property alone as well as in association
with others.
2. No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his property.
[http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr]
%
&3*%Y^%/'1.#%<"F3-+%;6-%JOOiI%;(-"6,*%J%05%-3*%L"(+-%7(0-060,I%7(0-*6-"0#%05%7(08*(-C)!1646+1L%
!
"Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his
possessions. No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the
public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by
the general principles of international law.
The preceding provisions shall not, however, in any way impair the right
of a State to enforce such laws as it deems necessary to control the use of
property in accordance with the general interest or to secure the payment
of taxes or other contributions or penalties."
[UK Human Rights Act 1998
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/42/contents]
!
F5609/+!U!01!4!G-4/0;0+3!50>26)!.-6!62+!845>0&!:;!4,,5+90460:&!4;;:53+3!6:!62+!P646+!3+,+&31!-,:&!62+!
9059-8164&9+1!:;!62+!941+@!!_:01+!01!9:&103+5+3!:&+!:;!62+!8:16!0&65-10=+!,://-64&61!0&!62+!
R-5:,+4&!+&=05:&8+&6h!:&+!84<!45>-+!6246!62+!P646+!12:-/3!.+!4;;:53+3!:&/<!4!&455:*!845>0&!:;!
4,,5+90460:&!0&!62+!4&4/<101@!
!
P:8+!24=+!9:88+&6+3!6246!5(**"+!84C+1!F5609/+!U!1:8+620&>!:;!4!V6::62/+11!60>+5K)!.+94-1+!:;!62+!
.4/4&9+!0&!;4=:-5!:;!62+!P646+@!!M-6![4=03!f456)!oe)!*5:6+!4!2+456+&0&>!3019-110:&!:;!62+!5+9+&6!941+!
09".($&F&H-#)@%+)&C"1+*;&H"-"1@9&C"1+8#4&kU]YYi&7/C:&C#FfhUI&C"1-*&",&:>>%(46&
&
“Conventional wisdom has it that an Article 1 Protocol 1(the human right to
peaceful enjoyment of property) environmental claim faces all sorts of difficulties.
The claimants may have a right to the peaceful possession of property, but that
right is immediately counter-balanced by the public interest of the scheme under
challenge. Furthermore, the court does not look too closely at the detail when
applying the proportionality test, as long as the scheme is lawful. Or does it?
!
Our case is a refreshing example of where manifest injustice was avoided by a
successful claim under Article 1 of the First Protocol of the ECHR. It also shows off
the muscles of the duty to interpret legislation, under section 3 of the Human
Rights Act 1998, in accordance with the ECHR. To find what it was about...”
[Hart D. Just When You Thought They Were Extinct: Human Rights
Environmental Case Succeeds. 1COR- 1 Crown Office Row, 27 July 2011
http://ukhumanrightsblog.com/2011/07/27/just-when-you-thought-they-wereextinct-a1p1-environmental-case-succeeds/]
UU#!
!
R=03+&9+!0&!6201!,4,+5!4&3!0&!62+!4-62:51B!"''(!,4,+5!12:*1!6246!62+!=4/-+!:;!;480/<!2:8+1!
3+9/0&+1!*2+5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!&+45.<@!!A2+!=4/-+!:;!4!5+103+&604/!,5:,+56<!01!62+!,509+!
4920+=+3!0&!4!;5++!4&3!:,+&!845C+6!.+6*++&!4!*0//0&>!1+//+5!4&3!4!*0//0&>!.-<+5@!!%6!4/1:!411-8+1!
;-//!+7,:1-5+!6:!62+!845C+6@!!H4&<!;496:51!0&;/-+&9+!=4/-+)!.-6!&:584//<!62+1+!0&9/-3+L!/:9460:&)!
10Y+)!4,,+454&9+)!=0+*1)!9245496+5!:;!62+!45+4)!.+0&>!94,4./+!:;!.+&+;0904/!:99-,460:&)!4&3!;480/<!
+&I:<8+&6!4&3!1+9-506<@!
!
A2+!,50845<!08,496!:&!62+!:,+&!845C+6!=4/-+!:;!4!5+103+&604/!,5:,+56<!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!.-0/6!
&+45.<!4501+1!;5:8!62+!0&=410=+!&:01+!,://-60:&!+8066+3!.<!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!`:5!6201!5+41:&)!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!-1-4//<!4;;+96!2:8+!=4/-+1!0&!4!5-54/!9:88-&06<!5462+5!624&!0&!6:*&!:5!-5.4&!
1+660&>1@!!e:88:&!;+46-5+1!:;!9:-&65<103+!,5:,+560+1!45+!:;6+&!62+!19+&+5<!4&3!62+!654&G-0/!
+&=05:&8+&6@!!F!,5:,+56<!6246!+&I:<1!4!1,+904/!=0+*!6246!,:6+&604/!.-<+51!,+59+0=+!41!8:5+!
46654960=+!624&!:62+5!,5:,+56<!0&!62+!45+4!*0//!9:884&3!4&!433060:&4/!=4/-+@!!R=03+&9+!12:*1!6246!
6201!=4/-+!01!5+8:=+3!*2+&!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!01!+5+96+3!&+45.<@!!f:*+=+5)!62+!84I:5!=4/-+)!4,456!
;5:8!10Y+!4&3!/:9460:&!01!62+!B48+&06<!=4/-+B!:;!62+!2:8+@!!i5+1-80&>!6246!62+!,5:,+56<!,5:=03+3!
;480/<!,50=49<)!48+&06<)!4&3!G-0+6!+&I:<8+&6)!*2+&!:&+!:5!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!&+45.<)!
62+&!62+!/4&3:*&+51!:;!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<!5+/+41+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!6246!
,+5=43+1!43I:0&0&>!,5:,+560+1!4&3!2:8+1!;:5!,5:/:&>+3!,+50:31@!!A2-1)!62+!43I:0&0&>!,5:,+56<!
/:1+1!061!48+&06<)!4&3!62+!=4/-+!466492+3!6:!061!48+&06<@!
!
e24,6+51!U)!")!4&3!#!84C+!06!+=03+&6!6246!62+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!5+/+41+3!0&6:!62+!
468:1,2+5+!.<!/4&3!:*&+51!.-0/30&>!*0&3!;4581!01)!0&!,50&90,/+)!&:!/+11!0&=410=+!4&3!0&I-50:-1!6:!
2+4/62!624&!0;!4!92+8094/!*:5C1!.-0/6!&+45.<!+8061!6:709!;-8+1!0&6:!62+!468:1,2+5+!0&3-90&>!
1+50:-1!2+4/62!08,4961!:&!&+0>2.:50&>!;480/0+1@!!g&+!*:-/3!&:6!*0//0&>/<!8:=+!:&+K1!;480/<!6:!4!
2:-1+!6246!01!1-.I+96!6:!4&!:&>:0&>!+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&!,5:./+8!6246!650>>+51!1+50:-1!1/++,!
4&3!2+4/62!,5:./+81!;:5!:&+B1!;480/<@!
!
A2+!1->>+160:&!6246!;480/0+1!1-;;+50&>!4!846+504/!/:11!:;!=4/-+!6:!62+05!2:8+1!.+94-1+!:;!62+!&:01+!
,://-60:&!12:-/3!1+//!4&3!8:=+!6:!4!G-0+6!45+4!01!-&=04./+!4&3!94//:-1@!!`0516)!8:16!;480/0+1!*0//!24=+!
0&=+16+3!62+05!/0;+!14=0&>1!0&!62+05!2:8+)!4&3!62+<!84<!;0&3!+062+5!6246!62+05!/0;+!14=0&>1!45+!*0,+3!
:-6!4&3!62+<!24=+!&:620&>!/+;6!6:!.-<!4&:62+5!2:8+)!:5!6246!62+05!14=0&>1!45+!1:!3+,/+6+3!6246!*246!
5+840&1!*0//!&:6!.-<!4!2:8+@!!A2:1+!*2:!;0&3!62+<!24=+!/066/+!=4/-+!/+;6!45+!/0C+/<!6:!;0&3!6201!5+/46+1!
+1,+904//<!6:!2:8+1!0&!62+!9:-&65<103+@!
!!
A2+!P646+!94&&:6!I-160;<!4!&460:&4/!0&6+5+16!45>-8+&6!.+94-1+!G"#$%-'()"#*%.((.C+%6.##0-%
8(0B"$*%.%8(*$"6-.),*%5,0G!05%*,*6-("6"-C%-0%-3*%>.-"0#.,%W("$%-3.-%*#+'(*+%.%+*6'(*%.#$%
(*,".),*%*#*(FC%+'88,CD%%F!1+9-5+)!,5+30964./+)!5+/04./+!+&+5><!1-,,/<!01!;-&348+&64/!6:!62+!
+9:&:8<!41!4!*2:/+!4&3!6:!1-1640&4./+!3+=+/:,8+&6@!!D0&3!+&+5><!94&&:6!,5:=03+!4!,5+30964./+)!
1-1640&+3!/+=+/!:;!+&+5><!1+9-506<)!*2092!8-16!.+!9:&164&6)!5+1,:&10=+)!4&3!5:.-16!46!4//!608+1)!0&!
.:62!62+!12:56!4&3!/:&>!6+58@!!g&!UU![+9+8.+5!"'U')!e25016:,2+5!M::C+5!5+,:56+3L!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
"Last Tuesday evening when many places in Britain were registering their lowest
temperatures on record, UK electricity demand was a staggering 60 gigawatts.
But the amount coming from wind turbines was just 0.2per cent – one 500th of
what we were using. Ten times as much was coming from nuclear reactors in
France, through the interconnector under the channel”.
[Booker C. Climate Change: the Warmist Demands Heat up as ‘Green’ Costs Soar.
Daily Telegraph 11 December 2010]
!
g&!"!d4&-45<!"'UU)!M::C+5!&:6+3L!!!
!
UU$!
"Last Thursday night the amount of electricity supplied to the grid by wind turbines
was again a mere one thousandth of the total. Again we were importing 40 times
that much power from France, generated by nuclear reactors.”
[Booker C. What We Need in 2011 is an Opposition. Daily Telegraph 1 January
2011]
!
M::C+5B1!45609/+1)!1-,,:56+3!.<!1646016091!4&3!5+,:561!>+&+546+3!.<!62+!_460:&4/!N503)!45+!.-6!6*:!
+748,/+1!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!0&+;;+960=+&+11!0&!608+1!:;!&++3@!!A2+<!45+!4/1:!08,:564&6!5+80&3+51!6246!
*2+&!20>2?,5+11-5+!*+462+5!1<16+81!,5+=40/!:=+5!62+!EQ)!*2092!:;6+&!9:0&903+1!*062!20>2!3+84&3!
;:5!+/+9650906<!.<!62+!&460:&)!62+5+!01!&:6!+&:->2!*0&3!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!6:!84C+!4!8+4&0&>;-/!
9:&650.-60:&!6:!62:1+!+/+9650906<!3+84&31@!!A2+5+;:5+)!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!&:6!9506094/!6:!62+!&460:&4/!
0&6+5+16)!+1,+904//<!*2+&!9:8,45+3!6:!:62+5!+&+5><!1-,,/0+1)!*2092!45+!,5+30964./+)!1-1640&+3)!4&3!
5+/04./+@!
!
i5:;+11:5!d48+1!k:=+/:9C)!ef)!eMR)!`SP)!0&!201!.::C!*45&0&>!:;!62+!9:&1+G-+&9+1!:;!9/0846+!
924&>+)!09%&'%F%+@%&",&V(#(6&/9;&*9%&7(-*9&#$&=#@9*#+@&H(8LI!9:88+&61L!!
!
“According to the Royal Society of Engineers 2004 report, onshore European wind
energy is 2-5 times, and offshore wind energy over 3 times, more expensive per
kilowatt hour than gas or nuclear energy. No sensible community would ever
support so outrageously expensive and unreliable an energy source were it not
that the true costs have been hidden from the public by subsidies and the
distortion of market forces through legislation.”
[Lovelock J. The Revenge of Gaia: Why the Earth is Fighting Back. London:
Penguin, 2006, p 83]
(See also Lipton E and Krauss C. A Gold Rush of Subsidies in Clean Energy
Search. New York Times November 11, 2011
266,Laa***@&<608+1@9:8a"'UUaUUaU"a.-10&+11a+&+5><?+&=05:&8+&6a4?9:5&-9:,04?
:;?2+/,?;:5?5+&+*4./+?+&+5><@268/s19,tU^1Gt>:/3m"'5-12^16t91+.)
!
A2+!9/:1-5+!:;!4&!:&12:5+!*0&3!;458!*:-/3!24=+!&:!+9:&:809!08,496!:&!62+!&460:&4/!+9:&:8<!4&3!
&:!10>&0;094&6!08,496!:&!62+!_460:&4/!N503@!!e:&65416!6201!*062!62+!5(**"+&(+)&"*9%-$&F&GX!3+9010:&!
6246!-&3+519:5+3!62+!10>&0;094&6!+9:&:809!4&3!9:88+5904/!&+9+1106<!:;!f+4625:*!F05,:56)!:&+!:;!
62+!*:5/3B1!.-10+16)!6:!62+!EQ!&460:&4/!+9:&:8<h!62+5+;:5+)!62+!P646+!*41!>54&6+3!4!*03+!845>0&!:;!
4,,5+90460:&@!!A201!45>-8+&6!01!&:6!I-160;0+3!*2+&!4,,/0+3!6:!:&12:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!!
!
e/+45/<)!F5609/+!U!01!+&>4>+3!*2+5+!2:8+1!1-;;+5!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,://-60:&)!.-6!6201!F5609/+!
94&!,5:=03+!;:5!,+9-&045<!3484>+1!6:!9:8,+&146+!;480/0+1!;:5!62+!3+,5+90460:&!0&!62+!=4/-+!:;!
62+05!2:8+1!+G-0=4/+&6!6:!62+!=4/-+!*062:-6!62+!192+8+)!/+11!62+!,5+1+&6!14/+!=4/-+!:;!62+!2:8+!\0;!
06!94&!.+!1:/3]@!!e:8,+&1460:&!12:-/3!0&9/-3+!62+!9:161!:;!8:=0&>!6:!4&!+G-0=4/+&6!/:9460:&!4&3!;:5!
62+!845C+6!=4/-+!:;!4!2:8+!&:6!+7,:1+3!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!%&!1:8+!941+1)!62+!2:8+!*0//!.+!
-&14/+4./+!4&3!62+!,5+1+&6!=4/-+!*:-/3!.+!{'@!!A2+!/0806+3!&-8.+5!:;!;480/0+1!4;;+96+3!\+@>@)!/0=0&>!
*0620&!#C8!:;!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1]!*:-/3!.+!3+80&08-1!0&!62+!8495:+9:&:809!194/+!:;!62+!
&460:&4/!+9:&:8<@!
!
R=+&!0;!4!1/0>26!845>0&!:;!4,,5+90460:&!01!4;;:53+3!6:!62+!P646+)!41!*062!E%++#$&(+)&E%++#$&F&<QE&
kU]]oiI&d-3>+!M-9C/+<!d!2+/3!6246!4!;405!.4/4&9+!*:-/3!&:6!.+!165-9C!0&!62+!4.1+&9+!:;!
9:8,+&1460:&L!
&
“I believe it is important in the decision of S v France that the public interest is
greater than the individual private interests of Mr and Mrs Dennis but it is not
proportionate to pursue or give effect to the public interest without compensation
for Mr and Mrs Dennis... in my view, common fairness demands that where the
interests of the minority, let alone an individual, are seriously interfered with
because of an overriding public interest, the minority should be compensated.”
[Dennis & Dennis v Ministry of Defence [2003] EWHC 793 (QB)
http://www.bailii.org/cgibin/markup.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2003/793.html]
!
UUO!
!
f:8+1!0&!62+!EQ)!+/1+*2+5+!0&!R-5:,+)!62+!EPF)!4&3!F-1654/4104)!12:*!62+!9:&1016+&6!+7,+50+&9+!:;!
;480/0+1!*2:)!*2+&!/0=0&>!&+45!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!1-;;+5!&:01+!,://-60:&@!!`480/<!2:8+1!0&9-5!1+=+5+!
5+3-960:&1!0&!845C+6!=4/-+)!5+;/+960&>!62+!2+4/62!0&I-5<!4&3!/:11!:;!48+&06<!6246!62+!;480/<!01!/0C+/<!
6:!1-;;+5!:5!01!1-;;+50&>@!!A2+5+!45+!+748,/+1!:;!;480/0+1!*2:!94&&:6!1+//!62+05!2:8+1)!*2092!8+4&1!
62+!,5:,+56<!&:!/:&>+5!241!4!5+103+&604/!=4/-+)!,+524,1!:&/<!V/4&3!=4/-+K@!!`480/0+1!*2:!;0&3!62+05!
2:8+1!-&14/+4./+!.+9:8+!,501:&+51!0&!62+05!2:8+1@!!A2+!&:01+!,://-60:&!1+=+5+/<!9:8,5:801+1!
4&3!+=+&!3+165:<1!62+05!50>26!6:!5+1,+96!;:5!,50=46+!4&3!;480/<!/0;+)!4&3!6201!01!4-62:501+3!.<!62+!
P646+@!!!
!
`480/0+1!/0=0&>!0&!5-54/!45+41!:;6+&!24=+!4//!62+05!*+4/62!60+3!-,!0&!62+05!2:8+1)!+@>@)!0&!62+!;480/<!
;458@!!%6!01!62+05!1+9-506<)!*2092!62+<!24=+!.-0/6!-,:&!*062!84&<!<+451!X!,:110./<!>+&+5460:&1!X!:;!
6:0/h!4&3!06!01!4/1:!:;6+&!62+!;480/<!/0;+/0&+!6:!1+9-50&>!4!/:4&!6:!+7,4&3!62+05!.-10&+11)!:5!6:!64C+!
/:4&1!6:!.-<!;+560/01+5!4&3!;++3!;:5!4&084/1)!:5!6:!,4<!+8+5>+&9<!8+3094/!.0//1@!!%;!8:&+<!.+9:8+1!
60>26)!62+!2:8+!01!4!=4/-4./+!5:-6+!6:!5+/+410&>!94,064/!0&!:53+5!6:!>+6!625:->2!30;;09-/6!608+1)!4&3!
;:5!84&<!;480/0+1!6201!01!62+05!:&/<!5+4/01609!8+924&018@!!A2+!P646+!241!1+G-+16546+3!62+05!1+9-506<!
.<!4-62:5010&>!,+51016+&6)!9:&60&-:-1)!,5:/:&>+3!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!6246!84C+1!62+05!
2:8+1!-&14/+4./+)!:5!5+3-9+1!62+05!=4/-+1!6:!62+!,:0&6!46!*2092!;480/0+1!94&&:6!3+50=+!4&<!.+&+;06!
;5:8!62+05!14/+1@!
!
A2+5+!01!+76+&10=+!3:9-8+&6460:&!:&!6201!011-+)!1+=+54/!+748,/+1!:;!*2092!;://:*L!
!
/01*0G#*(+%E"B"#F%>*.(%!"#$%L.(1+%@**%7(08*(-C%c.,'*+%7,'11*-&&
“Thousands of homeowners may see the value of their properties plummet after a
court ruled that living near a wind farm decreases house prices. In a landmark
case, Jane Davis was told she will get a discount on her council tax because her
£170,000 home has been rendered worthless by a wind turbine 1,000 yards away
[i.e., 1 km]... Local estate agents have acknowledged that the house, worth
£170,000 before the wind farm was built in 2006, is now so severely blighted that
no one is likely to buy it.” [Bunyan N and Beckford. Homeowners Living Near
Windfarms See Property Values Plummet. Daily Telegraph 26 July 2008]
&
_%=.B"+I%;88*#$":%J%7(08*(-C%c.,'*+%.#$%/0'+*%7("6*+&
“(1) Mounton & Russell 29.04.08 to Davis family re Grays Farm; (2) Brockington
Wade 05.03.02 to Bambridges family re Reeds Cottage; (3) Ashdales 31.03.99 to
Cuthbert family re Mill Cottage; (4) Russell Baldwin & Bright 30.05.00 not
disclosed; (5) F P D Savills 06.05.98 to Henry family re wind turbines.”
[Davis J and Davis J. Appendix 1: Property Values and House Prices. Public
Consultation on The Economics of Renewable Energy to the Select Committee on
Economic Affairs, The House of Lords, June 2008]
&
WG*#%Z'(V3.($-%,*--*(I%k!"#$%5.(1%",,#*++lI%K%_'#*%MNN\%
“Racing pulse, heart palpitations, a strange churning in my head, a feeling of
nausea, a terrible unease and a need to escape. Sleep became difficult too... I did
not want to leave home but eventually, after talking to another women who had
suffered the same symptoms as me, living near other turbines, I eventually had to
face the fact the wretched things were there to stay and that we would have to
move.” [Burkhardt G. Wind Farm Illness (letter). WalesOnline 6 June 2005
www.walesonline.co.uk]
&
Z(.$,*C+%@'(B*C0(+I%4:*-*(I%E*--*(%-0%/.#606V%L.1",CI%>0(-3%&.G-0#I%=*B0#&
“My professional opinion is that property values will fall within an area where wind
turbines are to be or have been constructed. In fact I cannot imagine anything
other than a detrimental effect to any neighbouring property resulting from a new
wind farm development.” [Davies T. Response to Enquiry regarding Devaluation of
Property from Mr P Hancock. Bradleys Chartered Surveyors, Exeter, UK, 30
August 2005]
&
!"#$5.(1%),0G+%30'+*%B.,'*%.G.C&&
&
%
“A Furness couple have won a legal ruling proving that the value of their home has
been ‘significantly diminished’ by the construction of a wind farm nearby....”
[Hawkins J. Windfarm Blows House Value Away. The Westmorland Gazette 9
January 2004]
!
Z(.$,*C+%U3.(-*(*$%@'(B*C0(+%,*--*(%-0%=*#%Z(00V%c.,,*C%;6-"0#%W(0'8&&
“Under certain circumstances it would be possible for a property within 600 – 800
meters to be devalued by some 30%, property within 1 mile possibly 20%, and
property 2 miles possibly 10%. It is important to stress that each individual
property would be affected in a different way.” [Davies T. Letter to Denbrook
Valley Action Group. Bradleys Chartered Surveyors, Exeter, UK, 5 November
2004]
&
&'("-*.%P.#%L*.(+%/*9,,%/.B*%-0%W0!
“A Turitea man says he will be forced from his home because Mighty River Power
told him noise from wind turbines in the reserve will make his house
uninhabitable... An Ashhurst family had to leave their house last year because
noise and vibration from the Te Apiti wind farm made it impossible for them to
stay.” [Harvey H. Turitea Man Fears He’ll Have to Go. New Zealand News 10
November 2006 http://stuff.co.nz]
&
&*+-"10#C%05%<'++*,,%Z0'#$+I%<.",*C%<*.,-CI%P.(C,.#$%
Question:”What is their (people living in vicinity of wind turbine) primary
complaint?”
Answer: “The primary complaint is noise. Second is the visual impact of the
turbines. Going into the house and closing the door eliminates the view. It does
not eliminate the sound. The constant drone cannot be escaped. The quiet
mountain living is gone. The greatest concern is the substantial loss of value of
their property. They do not believe they can sell without substantial loss and
cannot afford to sustain the loss and move.” [Bounds R. Testimony re: Garrett
County Wind Turbine Application. Public Services Commission, Maryland, USA, 31
August 2006, pp 7-11 http://docs.wind-watch.org/russellboundstestimony.pdf]
&
W".#-%Z,.$*+%;(*%@,"6"#F%7("6*+!
“If the experience of Cumbrian homeowners is anything to go by residents within a
mile or so of the proposed Romney Marsh wind farm will have an uphill struggle
selling their properties from now on… Kyle Blue, a Penrith estate agent… Yet
when his company auctioned Bretherdale Hall, a semi-derelict farmhouse half a
mile from the proposed turbines, it fetched £200,000 - £80,000 less that its
valuation before the plans for the wind farms were announced. Another nearby
property, a freshly restored £340,000 farmhouse, found a buyer who said the wind
farm wouldn’t bother him because he was keen on renewable energy. Then he
went away, did some research and changed his mind, says Blue. The house
remains unsold.” [Clark R. Giant Blades are Slicing Prices. Sunday Telegraph 17
October 2004]
&
7(08*(-C%c.,'.-"0#%<*80(-%0#%.%>'1)*(%05%;55*6-*$%7(08*(-"*+!
“Given a sample of properties inspected and reported as above, this represents an
immediate loss of £1,528,000 for the 8 properties mentioned, let alone all those
which may be affected by the turbines...” [Scourfield G. Report on a Sample of
Properties Inspected near a Proposed Wind Farm at Esgairwen Fawr nr Lampeter
(Wales, UK). RG Lewis & Company Estate Agents, Auctioneers and Property
Valuers, T/A ReMAX Estate Agents, Carmarthen, Summary, 11 July 2005, p 6]
!
&'()"#*%7,.#%U'-%c.,'*%05%['(%/01*%)C%.%&3"($!
“Two independent agricultural valuers, which visited the large four bedroom
bungalow in East Allington last week, both calculated that since planning
application for the turbines at Goverton was submitted earlier this year, the price
of the Lethbridge’s near £500,000 home had fallen by £165,000.” The wind
turbine will be 540mtrs from their home.” [Kirk J. Turbine Plan Cut Value of Our
Home by a Third. Western Morning News 9 December 2004] [See also: Webb C.
My Property Nightmare: Wind Farm. Sunday Telegraph 26 January 2005
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/property/mypropertynightmare/3338689/Myproperty-nightmare-wind-farm.html#disqus_thread]
&
U,0'$+%W.-3*("#F%0B*(%!"#$%L.(1%7,.#%
“ ‘Almost every property in their street, apart from those of farmers on whose land
the turbines are built, is for sale. I’ve watched my husband work all his life to
build this home,’ Mrs Cicero said. The Ciceros had their home valued at $410,000
before the wind farm was taken into account. Afterwards, the estimated value
UUW!
!
dropped to $270,000. They have not received one offer for their property in two
years.” [Clouds Gathering over Wind Farm Plan. Australian News 9 January 2006]
&
!"#$%U0#6*(#+%[#-.("02%%@*,5T<*80(-"#F%@'(B*C%Z/46+5!5+&48+3!62+!D0&3pg0e+!1-5=+<c!
“Some of these families have been forced to abandon their homes in order to
protect their health. This phenomenon is occurring worldwide, not just Canada.”
[Wind Concerns Ontario. A Self-Reporting Survey: Adverse Health Effects with
Industrial Wind Turbines and the Need for Vigilance: Abstract and Participant
Comments. Wind Concerns Ontario Community-based Health Survey, July 2009.
Presented on April 22 2009, by Dr Robert McMurtry to the Ontario Government’s
Standing Committee re: Bill 150, the Green Energy Act, S.2
http://windconcernsontario.wordpress.com/health/health-survey-information/]
&
P6U.##%;88(."+.,I%EEUI%-0%-3*%[--.G.%U"-"n*#D601!
“For example, numerous families have been forced to abandon their homes due to
the factual impacts to health, sleep disturbances and the like, which the Canadian
Wind Energy Association and the American Wind Energy Association prefer to
dismiss as ‘concerns’. Many others have been unable to sell their homes due to
the presence of nearby turbines, and which a growing list of realtors and estate
agents report as being the deciding factor in would-be buyers decisions to look
elsewhere. There is a measurable and significant loss of values within 2 to 3
miles...” [McCann MS of McCann Appraisal, LLC (Real Estate Appraisal &
Consulting), Chicago, Illinois (USA). There is a Measurable and Significant Loss of
(Property) Values within 2 to 3 Miles (letter). Ottawa Citizen (Canada) 25 January
2011]
&
X-9+%.#%X,,%G"#$%-3.-%&3(*.-*#+%7*.-,.#$+!
“The estate agent says it would knock £100,000 off the value of the property if the
turbines get built. My view is that we won’t be able to sell it at all.” (Note: The
property is 560 metres from the nearest wind turbine.) [It’s an Ill wind that
Threatens Peatlands. Yorkshire Today 12 March 2005]
&
U0'#6",%&.:%="+60'#-%G3*#%7(08*(-C%"+%.55*6-*$%)C%7(0:"1"-C%05%.%!"#$%&'()"#*!
“Mr Pickles: To ask Secretary of State Local Government if she would list each
type of local council tax discount introduced by billing authorities under
Local Government Act 2003.”
Mr Healey responded with a list that included:
“Property affected by the proximity of a electricity generating wind
turbine.” [Hansard. Pickles E (Brentwood and Ongar, Con) and Healey J
(Wentworth and Dearne, Lab). Council Tax: Tax Allowances, 13 May 2008,
c1442W,
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200708/cmhansrd/cm080513/text/8
0513w0004.htm] [Emphasis added.]
&
Z'C*(+%U,*.(,C%!"#$%<*+"+-.#-%e&00(.I%;'+-(.,".f&
“No one could have done more to try to sell our property... The capital-improved
value of our property fell 7 per cent in the same period in which the average CPI
value in the shire rose 18 per cent. Now, this seems to me to be an admission of a
decrease of 25 per cent... As well as having the enormous visual impact to contend
with, we also had to hope for a calm day so that the not inconsiderable noise did
not put people off..”
[Hurst T. Buyers Clearly Wind Resistant (letter). Weekly Times (Australia) 23 April
2003]
&
&'()"#*+%U.+-%@3.$0G%[B*(%E.#$%c.,'*+%
“The arrival of wind farms in South Gippsland threatens to seriously erode property
values, according to real estate agents. [Sellars P. Turbines Cast Shadow over
Land Values. Weekly Times (Australia) 16 April 2003]
&
&*+-"10#C%-0%;$.1+%U0'#-C%Z0.($I%X,,"#0"+I%Y@;I%)C%P6U.##%;88(."+.,I%EXU%
“Summary of Opinions, 1 – 9:
(1) Residential property values are adversely and measurably impacted by
close proximity of industrial-scale wind energy turbine projects to the
UU(!
!
residential properties, with value losses measured up to 2 miles from the
nearest turbines in some instances.
(9) A market value reduction of $6.5 million is projected for the residential
property located in the footprint and within 2-miles of the pending Prairie
Mills project located in east Adams County.”
(Recommendations: These are detailed and worthy of note.)
[McCann MS. Testimony to Adams County Board, Illinois, USA, 8 June 2010]
UUj!
!
E*--*(%5(01%W(**#%d%<")#"6V%.5-*(%B"+"-"#F%!.')(.I%;'+-(.,".%
“So when we asked about real estate values the people in Waubra laughed. They
said the real estate values have not declined, because the wind developers have
bought some properties. Therefore the statistics say that real estate values have
not declined. But the reality is something else. The only real estate that is selling
is the houses that are purchased by the wind energy industry… There are for sale
signs all over the area in Waubra. No one can sell, is what we were told.” [Green
PG and Green LA. Adverse Impacts from Wind Turbines in Waubra, Australia and
Surrounding Area. Green & Ribnick, Professional Resource Group (PRG),
Wellfleet, Massachusetts, USA, 14 January 2011]
!
!
!
!
SDQ%%%%@&;&4%X>=XLL4<4>U4%&[%/YP;>%<XW/&@2%%%
%%%%%%%%%%&/4%Y^%7E;>>X>W%ZXEE%;>=%&/4%Y^%4`Y;EX&?%;>=%/YP;>%<XW/&@%U[PPX@@X[>%%%
%
a4/<Ub%
%
%&!"''j)!4!354;6!:;!62+!,5:,:1+3!i/4&&0&>!M0//!0&9/-3+3!&+*!>:=+5&8+&6!,:/09<!6246!80>26!
,:6+&604//<!650>>+5!4!f-84&!S0>261!=0:/460:&@!!F!9/4-1+)!0&1+56+3!1+=+54/!34<1!.+;:5+!i45/048+&6K1!
1-88+5!5+9+11)!1->>+16+3!6246!62+!+7+9-60=+!:;!>:=+5&8+&6!,/4&&+3!6:!*062354*!62+!/+>4/!:,60:&!
;:5!9060Y+&1!6:!1++C!I-30904/!,5:6+960:&!*2+&!62+05!50>261!45+!625+46+&+3!:5!4.5:>46+3!.<!0&3-16504/!
+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&@!ZEQ!i/4&&0&>!M0//!"''j!266,Laa1+5=09+1@,45/048+&6@-Ca.0//1a"''(?
'ja,/4&&0&>@268/c!
!
A2+!,5:,:1+3!9/4-1+!0&!G-+160:&)!UOU)!0&9/-3+3!0&!62+!354;6!i/4&&0&>!M0//)!"j!d-/<!"''j)!1646+3L!
!
151 Legal challenges relating to nuisances etc.
“No proceedings, whether criminal or civil, in nuisance and no civil proceedings in
respect of the escape of things from land, other than proceedings for breach of
statutory duty, may be brought in relation to development, works or operations
authorised by an order granting development consent.”
&
A201!9/4-1+!4,,+45+3!6:!5+,5+1+&6!4&!466+8,6!.<!62+!P+95+645<!:;!P646+!6:!3+,50=+!62+!2016:509!
4-62:506<!:;!62+!d-309045<!:=+5!62+!9:&65:/!:;!_-014&9+!+8066+3!;5:8!43I:0&0&>!,5+801+1!4&3!62+!
08,496!:&!62+!/0=+1!:;!;480/0+1!.+94-1+!:;!6246!&-014&9+@!!A2+!9/4-1+!01!;-&348+&64//<!-&3+8:954609!
4&3!5+,5+1+&61!VS+>-/46:5<!R7,5:,50460:&K!:;!62+!.4109!,5:,+56<!50>261!:;!:530&45<!,+:,/+!4&3!
;480/0+1@!
!
A2+!;5:&601,0+9+!6:!62+!M0//!5+43L&&&
!
“EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
Baroness Andrews has made the following statement under section 19(1)(a)
of the Human Rights Act 1998:
‘In my view the provisions of the Planning Bill are compatible with the Convention rights.’”
!
A201!411-54&9+!*41!G-+160:&4./+!0&!/0>26!:;!62+!*:530&>!:;!e/4-1+!UOU@!!f4&1453!0&9/-3+1!62+1+!
5+;+5+&9+1!6:!e/4-1+!UOU!4&3!e/4-1+!"#W)!.:62!/46+!433060:&1!6:!62+!i/4&&0&>!M0//!=+5<!12:56/<!
.+;:5+!62+!1-88+5!5+9+11L!
!
“House of Commons, 25 June 2008, Column 327 – 330, Orders of the Day,
Planning Bill
The Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government (Hazel Blears):
I beg to move, That the clause be read a Second time.
New Clause 39 Legal challenges relating to nuisance etc.
!
‘No proceedings, whether criminal or civil... order granting development consent.’
(Mr. Betts)
Brought up, read the First time, and added to the Bill.”
UUT!
“House of Lords, 27 June 2008
Part 7, Chapter 3: General
Clause 151: Legal challenges relating to nuisance
236. This clause confirms that no legal proceedings either for nuisance, or
in respect of the escape of things from land, can be brought in relation to
a development authorised by a development consent order. An exception
is made for proceedings for breach of statutory duty. “ [Emphasis added.]
&
A2+!/416?80&-6+!0&9/-10:&!:;!e/4-1+!UOU!1->>+161!6246!62+!P+95+645<!:;!P646+!*41!9:&9+5&+3!4.:-6!
62+!9:&1+G-+&9+1!:;!4//:*0&>!,+:,/+!5+9:-51+!6:!62+!I-309045<!*2+&!3+=+/:,8+&61!94-1+!
+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&)!5462+5!624&!62+!,:6+&604/!08,496!:&!62+!4;;+96+3!;480/0+1@!
!
%&16+43)!62+!P+95+645<!:;!P646+!\46!6246!608+)!f4Y+/!M/+451])!12:-/3!24=+!4335+11+3!62+!011-+1!:;!
.4/4&9+!4&3!,5:,:560:&4/06<)!41!,:1+3!.<!k:53!D:/;!0&!201!.::C)!09%&J1-$1#*&",&M1$*#8%L!!!
!
‘Is the reaction of Parliament proportionate to the perceived threat?’
[Lord Woolf. The Pursuit of Justice. Campbell-Holt C, ed. Oxford University Press,
March 2008]
!
R=03+&9+!:;!P646+!0&30;;+5+&9+!6:!f-84&!S0>261!01!0//-16546+3!.<!4&!4,,+4/!6:!62+!EQ!RG-4/06<!4&3!
f-84&!S0>261!e:880110:&!\RfSe]!6:!0&=+160>46+!6201!,:6+&604/!=0:/460:&@!!%&!5+1,:&1+!6:!62+!84I:5!
1+G-+165460:&!:;!9060Y+&1K!50>261!4=40/4./+!6:!9060Y+&1!5+,5+1+&6+3!.<!9/4-1+!UOU)!0&!F->-16!"''j)!4!
EQ!9060Y+&!X!;:5!62+!14C+!:;!9:&;03+&604/06<)!H5!n!X!*5:6+!6:!62+!RG-4/!4&3!f-84&!S0>261!
e:880110:&!\RfSe])!62+!458!:;!62+!P646+!9245>+3!*062!8:&06:50&>!EQ!>:=+5&8+&6!9:8,/04&9+!
*062!f-84&!S0>261!:./0>460:&1@!!H5!n!*5:6+!6:!4/+56!62+!e:880110:&!6246!62+!,5:,:1+3!A:*&!
i/4&&0&>!M0//!"''j)!\"&3!5+430&>!.+;:5+!62+!f:-1+!:;!k:531])!9:&640&+3!P+960:&!UOU)!*2092!1:->26!
6:!+/080&46+!62+!.4109!f-84&!S0>261!:;!,+:,/+!4&3!3014//:*!62+05!5+9:-51+!6:!62+!I-309045<!0&!941+1!
:;!&-014&9+!94-1+3!.<!P646+!4-62:501+3!0&;54165-96-5+!,5:I+961@!
!
M+94-1+!:;!9:8,/40&61!.5:->26!;:5*453)!62+!RfSe!,5:=03+3!4!.50+;0&>!&:6+!6:!62+!f:-1+!:;!k:531!
43=010&>L!!
!
“The proposed wording of clause 151 is too extensive in scope and is contrary to
the provisions of the Human Rights Act and the Commission (EHRC) calls for its
removal from the Bill.”
[UK Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC)
http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/]
!
%&!4!/+66+5!346+3!UW!g96:.+5!"''j)!62+!RfSe!43=01+3!H5!n!6246!1+960:&!UOU!243!.++&!*062354*&@!
!
%&!4&:62+5!/+66+5)!346+3!UW!g96:.+5!"''j)!62+!RfSe!0&;:58+3!H5!n!6246L!
!!
“Having considered the content and context of the proposed provision, the
Commission raised concerns regarding its compliance with the Human Rights Act
2000 with the Government. Attached, for your information, is a copy of the
briefing that we prepared for second reading in the House of Lords. We have now
been informed that the clause has been withdrawn but we will continue to monitor
the passage of the Bill in the light of those concerns.”
&
&3*%4/<U%%m7,.##"#F%Z",,%7.(,".1*#-.(C%Z("*5"#F9I%[6-0)*(%MNNiI%.$B"+*$%-3*%/0'+*%05%E0($+2%
!
“8. Civil rights protected by the HRA are recognised under domestic law. In the
event of a genuine and serious dispute over one of those rights arising out of
development, works or operations authorised by an order granting development
consent, there is a right of access to a court. Clause 151 would significantly limit
that right as well as the right to an effective remedy guaranteed by Article 13
ECHR (though not contained in the HRA this is guaranteed by the ECHR). Even if
ultimately on the facts of the case, no violation of a substantive right were to be
found, the absence of an effective remedy to establish that would in itself amount
to a violation of the ECHR.
!
11. The proposed clause is unduly broad and represents a material change from
the status quo in a number of ways, for example:
‘Currently planning legislation sets out a system for appealing planning decisions
and development orders, including the ability to judicially review such decisions or
orders. Though ‘development control’ under the town and country planning
legislation is supposed to be separate from environmental control, it is recognised
that there are overlaps and so environmental issues can be valid planning reasons
to object to and appeal against planning decisions and development orders. Once
the appeal was unsuccessful, a development can proceed. However, currently, the
failure of any appeal process does not restrict a parties rights in relation to
nuisance claims under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 the Local
Government Act 1972 and the common law.
12. There is a line of case law that basically states that a planning permission can
change the character of a locality and that may impact on whether a nuisance is
committed or not – but that is a line of case law, not a provision under statute,
and it deals with whether a claim is successful as opposed to restricting the
bringing of such a claim.
13. The current wording removes the power of any regulatory authority or court
from requiring the developer to take any mitigation measures – even if such
measures could be easily taken.
14. During the course of the development should any unforeseen consequences
arise, no entity will be able to require the developers to reassess the situation.”
!
P-.1+G-+&6/<)!0&!4!/+66+5!346+3!$!d4&-45<!"'U')!H5!n!4/+56+3!62+!RfSe!6246!P@UOU!243!0&3++3!
1-5=0=+3!0&!62+!i/4&&0&>!F96!\"''j])!\S:<4/!F11+&6!"W!_:=+8.+5!"''j]L!
!
“In a letter dated 16 Oct 2008 you responded to my concern that Section 151 of
the Planning Bill 2008, as drafted, would be a violation of the ECHR...
Unfortunately, the spirit of that clause (S.151 Planning Bill) survives in the
Planning Act 2008, S.152 and 158.
To compound the loss by citizens to seek redress, this grievance is further
underscored with the consultation draft of National Policy Statement EN-1.
Specifically, Section 4.14, which derives from Sections 152 and 158 of the
Planning Act 2008, restricts these rights more decisively. Section 4.14 as
proposed in EN-1 will trigger a failure by the State in its basic human Rights
responsibilities to protect citizens.
To review the relevant Sections mentioned above:
The Planning Act 2008, Section 158 Nuisance; statutory authority states:
This section provides a defence of statutory authority in proceedings for nuisance if
a person carries out development for which consent is granted by an order
granting development consent. Such defence is available in respect of anything
else authorised by an order granting development consent.
[http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2008/29/contents]
The Planning Act 2008, Section 152: Compensation in case where no right
to claim in nuisance, states:
This section confers a right to compensation in cases where, as a result of section
158 or the terms of a development consent order, a person would not be able to
succeed in a claim for nuisance in respect of works authorised by a development
consent order. Compensation is available in relation to injurious affection to a
person’s land or depreciation in its value.
[http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2008/29/contents]
Furthermore National Policy Statement draft NPS (EN-1) section 4.14:
Common law nuisance and statutory nuisance states: (2010)
4.14.1 Applicants may include in their application, a request for the grant of a
defence of statutory authority against nuisance claims. In particular, the
application may make reference to the provisions of section 158(1) and (2) of the
Planning Act 2008, which confers a defence of statutory authority for the purpose
of providing a defence in any civil or criminal proceedings for nuisance arising from
U"'!
!
infrastructure for which development consent has been granted. For the purpose
of Section 158, the term ‘nuisance’ takes its common law definition. The defence
is also available for statutory nuisances under Part 111, Environmental Protection
Act 1990.”
[Department of Energy & Climate Change (DECC). Revised Draft Overarching
National Policy Statement for Energy (EN-1). DECC (UK), October 2010.
http://www.officialdocuments.gov.uk/document/other/9780108509346/9780108509346.pdf]
U"U!
&
A2+!/+66+5!;5:8!H5!n!:;!$!d4&-45<!"'U')!4//+>+3!6246!P+960:&!$@U$!:;!_iP!\R_?U]!01!4!=0:/460:&!:;L!
!
Article 30, The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights 10
Dec 1948:
“Nothing in this Declaration may be interpreted as implying for any State, group or
person any right to engage in any activity or to perform any act aimed at the
destruction of any of the rights and freedoms set forth herein.”
Article 8, The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights 10
Dec 1948:
“Everyone has the right to an effective remedy by the competent natural tribunals
for acts violating the fundamental rights granted him by the constitution or by
law.”
[http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/]
Article 17, Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and
Fundamental Freedoms 1959, (amended by Protocol No.11):
“Nothing in this Convention may be interpreted as implying for any State, group or
person any right to engage in any activity or perform any act aimed at the
destruction of any rights and freedoms set forth herein or at their limitation to a
greater extent than is provided for in the Convention.”
Article 13, Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and
Fundamental Freedoms 1959, (amended by Protocol No 11):
“Everyone whose rights and freedoms as set forth in this Convention are violated
shall have an effective remedy before a national authority notwithstanding that the
violation committed by persons acting in an official capacity.”
[http://conventions.coe.int/treaty/Commun/ListeTraites.asp?CM=8&CL=ENG]
Article 54, Charter of Fundamental Rights of European Union July 2003:
“Nothing in this Charter shall be interpreted as implying any right to engage in any
activity or to perform any act aimed at the destruction of any of the rights and
freedoms recognised in this Charter or at their limitation to a greater extent than
is provided for herein.”
[European Union. The Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/charter/default_en.htm]
!
D2+&!62+!i/4&&0&>!F96!"''j!*41!,-./012+3)!9/4-1+1!UO"!4&3!UOj!*+5+!0&9/-3+3)!4,,45+&6/<!
3+50=+3!;5:8!P+960:&!UOU!:;!62+!i/4&&0&>!M0//L!!62+1+!6*:!9/4-1+1!*+5+!I-16!41!3+165-960=+!6:!.4109!
2-84&!50>261!4&3!5+8:=+3!62+!:530&45<!9060Y+&B1!50>26!6:!1++C!5+35+11!0&!62+!9:-561!0;!4!&-014&9+!
*41!94-1+3!.<!4!P646+!4-62:501+3!0&;54165-96-5+!,5:I+96@!!
!
f062+56:)!62+!/4*!:;!V165096!/04.0/06<K!241!4//:*+3!0&I-5+3!;480/0+1!6:!4,,/<!6:!62+!e:-56!;:5!5+/0+;@!!%&!
62+!S-/+!:;!';4(+)$&F&=4%*89%-)!M/49C.-5&!d!1403)!!
!
“The person who for his own purposes brings on his lands and collects and keeps
there anything likely to do mischief if it escapes, must keep it in at his peril, and if
he does not do so, is prima facie answerable for all the damage which is the
natural consequence of its escape."
[Rylands v Fletcher, 3 HL 330, (1868) LR 3 HL330, [1868] UKHL 1
http://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1868/1.html]
!
A2+!3+;0&060:&!:;!V&:&!&46-54/K!-1+!:;!/4&3!241!0&9/-3+3!62+!,5:3-960:&!:;!+/+9650906<@!!F1!4&!
+748,/+)!0;!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+)!0&6+&3+3!6:!>+&+546+!+/+9650906<!:&!4&!0&3-16504/!194/+!:5!6:!;++3!
3:8+1609!,5:3-960:&!0&6:!62+!_460:&4/!N503)!01!.-0/6!:&!/4&3!6::!9/:1+!6:!43I:0&0&>!2:8+1)!62+!.<?
,5:3-96!:;!62+!84&-;496-50&>!,5:9+11!84<!95+46+!&:01+!,://-60:&@!!A201!&:01+!,://-60:&)!0;!4//:*+3!
U""!
!
6:!+194,+!0&!1-;;090+&6!=:/-8+1)!01!/0C+/<!6:!94-1+!&-014&9+!4&3!,+524,1!1+50:-1!2+4/62!
9:&1+G-+&9+1!6:!62:1+!/0=0&>!&+45.<@!
&!
A2+!i/4&&0&>!F96!"''j!,5:=03+1!62+!P+95+645<!:;!P646+!*062!62+!,:*+5!6:!,5+,45+!V_460:&4/!i:/09<!
P646+8+&61K!\_iP]!6246!1+6!62+!;548+*:5C!;:5!3+9010:&1!.<!62+!V%&;54165-96-5+!i/4&&0&>!
e:880110:&K@!A2+![+,4568+&6!:;!R&+5><!4&3!e/0846+!e24&>+!\[Ree]!011-+3!62+!;0516!_iP)!
_QF%-(-89#+@&!JD&,"-&7+%-@;&k7!`YiKI!*2092!01!9-55+&6/<!;://:*0&>!62+!9:&1-/6460:&!,5:9+3-5+!
,5:=03+3!0&!62+!i/4&&0&>!F96!"''j@!A2+!354;6!*41!5+;+55+3!6:!0&!4!/+66+5!6:!e20+;!i/4&&0&>!g;;09+51!
;5:8!e:88-&060+1!4&3!k:94/!N:=+5&8+&6)!346+3!T!_:=+8.+5!"''T@!
!
A2+!!(*#"+(4&J"4#8;&D*(*%.%+*&)-(,*&7!`Y)!0&!P+960:&!$@U$)!650>>+51!4!;40/-5+!.<!62+!P646+!0&!061!.4109!
2-84&!50>261!5+1,:&10.0/06<@!!%&!4!/+66+5!6:!62+!RfSe!346+3!$!d4&-45<!"'U')!H5!n!35+*!466+&60:&!6:!
6201!,:1060:&!\C++,0&>!0&!80&3!6246!62+!RfSe!94//+3!;:5!62+!5+8:=4/!:;!1-92!,:*+51!.+94-1+!:;!62+05!
0&;50&>+8+&6!:&!9060Y+&1K!5+9:-51+!6:!62+!I-309045<]@!
!
f062+56:)!4!9060Y+&!9:-/3!24=+!9/408+3!,5:6+960:&!-&3+5!62+!+70160&>!R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!F96!
UTT'L!
!
“Section 79 EPA 1990:
‘Noise emitted from premises so as to be prejudicial to health or a nuisance.”
[UK Environmental Protection Act 1990
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/43/section/79]
&
J+6!62+!i/4&&0&>!F96!"''j)!P+96@!UOj!+76+&31!6:!62+!P646+!+7,4&3+3!4&3!&+*!,:*+51!6246!84<!
0&16+43!,5:20.06!4!9060Y+&!;5:8!1++C0&>!5+35+11!*2+&!;49+3!*062!4!&:01+!&-014&9+L!
!
A2+!RiF!0&6+5,5+61L&‘prejudicial to health’!41&&‘likely to cause injury to health’@!
!
f:*+=+5)!62+!i/4&&0&>!F96!"''j!4&3!62+!0&0604/!354;6!_iP!R_?U!84C+!&:!8+&60:&!:;!62+!&++3!6:!
,5:6+96!2+4/62!4&3!2-84&!30>&06<@!
!
J+6)!F5609/+!U)!e24,6+5!U!:;!62+!e2456+5!:;!`-&348+&64/!S0>261!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!E&0:&!1646+1!9/+45/<L!
!
“The dignity of the human person is not only a fundamental right in itself
but constitutes a real basis of fundamental rights. The 1948 Universal
Declaration of Human Rights enshrined this principle in its preamble.
Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and
inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of
freedom, justice and peace in the world.”
[European Union. The Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/charter/default_en.htm]
%
H5!n!,5:=03+3!+=03+&9+!6:!62+!RfSe!6246!0//-16546+3!2:*!;480/0+1!*+5+!1-;;+50&>!1+=+5+!&:01+!
3016-5.4&9+)!/+430&>!6:!1/++,!3+,50=460:&!4&3!1/++,!3016-5.4&9+1)!4&3!62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!
6246!+&1-+3@!!A2+!RfSe!*41!4/1:!4/+56+3!6:!4!5+,:56!;5:8!62+!k+>01/460=+!e:-&90/!:;!62+!_+*!P:-62!
D4/+1!i45/048+&6!49C&:*/+3>0&>!6246!62+!,5:./+8!*062!&:01+!,://-60:&!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!3:+1!
+7016@!Zk+66+5!6:!RfSe)!"'!`+.5-45<!"'U'c!
!
F;6+5!*++C1!*062:-6!5+1,:&1+!;5:8!62+!RfSe)!H5!n!9:&6496+3!62+!e:880110:&!.<!/+66+5!:&!"$!F,50/!
"'U'L!!
!
A2+!RfSe!*+5+!5+80&3+3!6246!62+!&+*!_iP!R_?U!4,,+45+3!6:!5+8:=+!.4109!2-84&!50>261!
,5:6+960:&!;5:8!;480/0+1!*2+&!/45>+!0&;54165-96-5+!,5:I+961!45+!,5:,:1+3!;:5!/:9460:&1!0&!,5:70806<!
6:!2:8+1)!192::/1)!4&3!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1@!
!
A2+!RfSe!*+5+!43=01+3!:;!62+!1645C!0&+G-4/06<!;:5!5-54/!;480/0+1!:&!/0806+3!0&9:8+!*2:!*:-/3!
24=+!6:!5401+!/45>+!1-81!:;!8:&+<!0&!:53+5!6:!1++C!,5:;+110:&4/!43=09+)!*20/+!62+!0&;54165-96-5+!
3+=+/:,+51!24=+!1-.164&604/!;0&4&904/!.49C0&>)!0&!6+581!:;!80//0:&1!:;!NMi)!6:!:,,:1+!4&<!:.I+960:&!
.5:->26!.<!62+!4;;+96+3!;480/0+1)!41!*+//!41!>:=+5&8+&6!9456+!./4&92+!=04!/+>01/460:&@!
!
H:5+:=+5)!,+:,/+!45+!4/1:!-,!4>40&16!;4/1+!9/4081!.<!*0&3!+&+5><!3+=+/:,+51h!+@>@)!62+!EQ!
F3=+56010&>!P64&34531!F-62:506<!ZFPFc!,45604//<!-,2+/3!4!9:8,/40&6!4>40&16!p:/C1*0&3!k63!EQ!;:5!
U"#!
!
801/+430&>!0&;:58460:&!0&!4!.5:92-5+!,5:8:60&>!4!*0&3!;458!4,,/09460:&@!ZF3=+56010&>!P64&34531!
F-62:506<!\FPF]@!!F3I-309460:&!:&!p:/C1*0&3!EQ!k63@!!e:8,/40&6!S+;!U'$#Uj)!#U!H4592!"'U'!
266,Laa***@414@:5>@-CaFPF?4960:&aF3I-309460:&1a"'U'a#ap:/C1*0&3?EQ?
k63aA`rF[dr$j"j#@41,7|c!
!
RfSe!466+&60:&!*41!4/1:!354*&!6:!4!E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9!45609/+!6246!3019-11+3!5+=+/460:&1!6246!:&+!0&!
107!*0&3!;4581!243!9:8,/40&61!4.:-6!&:01+@!!D062!>5+46+5!624&!UWm!:;!106+1!0&9-550&>!9:8,/40&61)!
:&+!80>26!0&G-05+!0;!62+!148+!3010&6+5+16!*:-/3!+76+&3!6:!;40/-5+!546+1!0&!192::/1!:5!546+1!:;!
94&9+//460:&!;:5!192+3-/+3!,-./09!654&1,:56@!!ZN54<!k@!!_:01+!9:8,/40&61!4.:-6!:&+!0&!107!*0&3!
;4581@!E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9!W!H4592!"'U'c!
!
g&9+!4>40&)!.+94-1+!H5!n!243!&:6!<+6!243!4&<!5+1,:&1+!;5:8!62+!RfSe)!0&!4!/+66+5!346+3!j!d-&+!
"'U')!62+!RfSe!*41!41C+3!4>40&!*2+62+5!06!0&6+&3+3!6:!0&6+5=+&+!0&!62+!,:6+&604/!=0:/460:&!
.5:->26!6:!62+05!466+&60:&!0&!62+!/+66+5!:;!$!d4&-45<!"'U')!5+>4530&>!9/4-1+1!UO"!4&3!UOj!:;!62+!
i/4&&0&>!M0//)!,45609-/45/<!41!62+!RfSe!243!0&0604//<!:.I+96+3!6:!62+05!0&9/-10:&@!
!
`0&4//<)!0&!4!/+66+5!346+3!UT!d-/<!"'U')!62+!RfSe!5+1,:&3+3L!
!
“From an assessment of the information that you have sent us it has been decided
that taking action in this matter would not meet our current strategic objectives”
&
A2+!/+66+5!843+!&:!9:88+&6!-,:&!62+!,:6+&604/!f-84&!S0>261!=0:/460:&!.<!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6@!
!
%&!5+,/<)!H5!n!+7,5+11+3!3014,,:0&68+&6!4&3!0&!201!5+,/<)!5+;+55+3!6:!62+!RfSe!D*-(*%@#8&J4(+&U]]Z`
U]YU)!O!16546+>09!,50:5060+1@!!i50:506<!U!1646+1L!
!
“Protecting, promoting and mainstreaming human rights.
To promote and protect the provisions of the Human Rights Act and
ensure they are applied across government and public services,
implementing the findings of the HR Inquiry.
Findings of the Human Rights Inquiry (HRI) for England and Wales
published Q1 2009/10.
Implementation of the HR recommendations and promotion of awareness
and understanding of human rights working with Inspectorates, public
bodies and service providers.” [p 57]
[UK Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC).
http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/]
&
H5!n!924//+&>+3!62+!RfSeL!!
!
"...when the State authorises industrial development near family homes, despite
the evidence of a high potential risk for health injury, I would have thought it
reasonable to expect that the arm of the State charged with monitoring
compliance with Human Rights obligations, would feel a duty to intervene and
ensure that the rights of these families were properly protected. For a government
that openly proclaims a policy based on ‘Freedom, Families, and Responsibility’, it
is essential that the State agency charged with the responsibility of ensuring that
other departments of State properly respect the international conventions on
Human Rights, the EHRC would have wished to intervene by reminding decision
makers and the Inspectorate about the potential for violation.”
&
H5!n!62+&!41C+3!;:5!;-//!3019/:1-5+!:;!0&;:58460:&!-&3+5!62+!_=-%%)".&",&3+,"-.(*#"+&:8*K)!0&!:53+5!
6:!-&3+5164&3!62+!924&>+!0&!62+!RfSe!4,,5:492!4&3!62+!5+41:&1!;:5!6201!924&>+@!!Zk+66+5!6:!62+!
RfSe!346+3!"#!d-/<!"'U'c!
!
A2+!RfSe!5+,/0+3!:&!"'!F->-16!"'U'L!
!
&
“We do not consider it appropriate to disclose the information you have requested
under the Freedom Of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) as this is comprised of internal
documentation that is caught by the exemption under section 42 of the FOIA
(Legal Professional Privilege).”
U"$!
!
%&!5+1,:&1+!6:!6201!5+;-14/!*062:-6!+7,/4&460:&!6:!3019/:1+!0&;:58460:&!:&!4!,:6+&604/!
+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&!8466+5)!H5!n!5+G-+16+3!6246!4//!9:55+1,:&3+&9+!,5:9++3!6:!62+!&+76!164>+)!
*2092!01!4&!0&6+5&4/!5+=0+*@!!Zk+66+5!6:!RfSe)!"#!F->-16!"'U'c!
!
!
g&!U'!_:=+8.+5!"'U')!62+!RfSe!5+1,:&3+3!4&3!-,2+/3!061!,5+=0:-1!3+9010:&L!
!
“Moreover, we must draw your attention to the EHRC’s complaint policy which
states that we do not undertake reviews of decisions by the Commission (EHRC),
in which we have decided not to use our legal powers...
We refer you back to our response dated 11 October 2010, in which we provided
an explanation as to why your case did not meet our strategic priorities.
Our strategic priorities are dictated by the levels of inequality such as those
reported in our Triennial review and by our duties as a National Human Rights
institution to deal with serious breaches of Human Rights.
As you have now exhausted our review procedure and we have now closed your
file, if you remain dissatisfied with our response, we would respectfully suggest
that you contact the Parliamentary and Health service...”
!
g&!j62![+9+8.+5!"'U')!4&!F,,+4/!:&!62+!3+9010:&!.<!62+!RfSe!&:6!6:!5+/+41+!0&;:58460:&!*41!
843+!6:!62+!%&;:58460:&!e:880110:&+51!g;;09+!\%eg]!-&3+5!62+!`5++3:8!:;!%&;:58460:&!F96!\`g%]@!!
A2+!%eg!*41!4/1:!41C+3!6:!9:&103+5!62+!5+G-+16!;:5!0&;:58460:&!6246!5+/46+3!6:!62+!5+/+41+!:;!
+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&!-&3+5!62+!,5:=010:&1!:;!62+!F452-1!e:&=+&60:&!\UTTj])!6:!*2092!62+!EQ!01!
4!10>&46:5<@!
!
A2+!F452-1!e:&=+&60:&!14<1L!
!
"The preamble connects the concept that adequate protection of the environment
is essential to the enjoyment of basic human rights with the concept that every
person has the right to live in a healthy environment and the obligation to protect
the environment."
[Aarhus Convention: Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in
Decision-Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters. UN Economic
Commission for Europe (UN-ECE), Aarhus Denmark, 25 June 1998
http://ec.europa.eu/environment/aarhus]
!
A2+!F452-1!,5+48./+!62+&!9:&9/-3+1!6246!6:!411+56!6201!50>26!4&3!8++6!6201!:./0>460:&)!9060Y+&1!
8-16!24=+!499+11!6:!0&;:58460:&)!45+!+&606/+3!6:!,456090,46+!0&!3+9010:&?84C0&>)!4&3!8-16!24=+!
499+11!6:!I-1609+!0&!+&=05:&8+&64/!8466+51@!
!
R=+&6-4//<)!:&!""!d-&+!"'UU)!62+!RfSe!5+1,:&3+3!6:!H5!n)!+&9/:10&>!62+![!"*%$&",&<%%*#+@$\!!0&!
*2092!4//!62+!0&;:58460:&!243!.++&!5+3496+3@!!f:*+=+5)!:&+!3:9-8+&6)!+&606/+3![3+#*#(4&D8">%\I!
4,,+45+3!6:!43=01+!4!9:88066++@!!%6!4,,+45+3!6:!H5!n!6246!62+![3+#*#(4&D8">%\!;40/+3!6:!4335+11!62+!
Ve:8,/40&6K)!*2092!5+/46+3!6:!i/4&&0&>!F96!"''j)!P@UO"!4&3!UOj)!4&3!1-.1+G-+&6!354;6!i/4&&0&>!
i:/09<!R_?U@!!A2+!RfSe!3:9-8+&6!1646+3!6246L!!
!
“This complaint is low risk, it does not have the potential to influence systemic,
widespread change given that the number of wind farms is fairly small with several
based in Scotland, Wales and Ireland.”
“There isn’t any apparent risk to the Commission’s reputation and the
complaint does not fit any of the strategic priorities as set out in the Legal or
Human Rights strategies.” [Emphasis added.]
&
%6!6::C!&+45/<!:&+!<+45!6:!>+6!6201!0&+;;+96-4/!\4&3!1+/;?1+5=0&>]!+7,/4&460:&!;5:8!62+!RfSe!6:!
I-160;<!061!0&4960:&@!!H:5+:=+5)!06!*41!:&/<!41!4!5+1-/6!:;!62+!+;;+960=+!0&6+5=+&60:&!.<!62+!
%&;:58460:&!e:880110:&+51!g;;09+!6246!62+!RfSe!5+/+41+3!6201!0&;:58460:&@!!%&!d-/<!"'U')!62+!&+*!
>:=+5&8+&6!3+903+3!6:!5+8:=+!62+!%&;54165-96-5+!i/4&&0&>!e:880110:&!4&3!654&1;+5!62+!641C!:;!
9:&103+50&>!/45>+!0&;54165-96-5+!192+8+1!6:!62+!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:546+@!`:5!6201!5+41:&!H5!n!
9:&60&-+3!*062!+;;:561!6:!,-51-+!62+!50>26!:;!EQ!9060Y+&1!6:!1++C!I-309045<!5+9:-51+!*2+&!P646+!
U"O!
!
4-62:501+3!/45>+!0&;54165-96-5+!192+8+1)!,5:,:1+3!:5!.-0/6!&+45!2:8+1)!80>26!650>>+5!4&!
+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&!&-014&9+!,5+I-30904/!6:!2+4/62@!!A2+!3+=+/:,+51!94&!5+/<!:&!62+!3+;+&9+!:;!
VP646-6:5<!F-62:506<K!4>40&16!/+>4/!4960:&!\P646-6:5<!:5!e0=0/!&-014&9+!4960:&1])!<+6!62+!:530&45<!
,+51:&!*:-/3!24=+!&:!5+9:-51+!;:5!,5:6+960:&!:5!48+/0:5460:&@!
!
A201!+7924&>+!0//-16546+1!I-16!2:*!/:&>!06!94&!64C+!62+!:530&45<!9060Y+&!6:!1++C!+7,/4&460:&!4&3a:5!
,5:6+960:&!;5:8!>:=+5&8+&6!3+,4568+&61)!+=+&!62:1+!6246!,-5,:56!6:!,5:6+96!62+!0&6+5+161!:;!62+!
0&30=03-4/@!!A2+!,5:9+11!01!608+?9:&1-80&>)!6+30:-1)!;5+G-+&6/<!9:16/<)!4&3!:;6+&!-&,5:3-960=+@!
!
%&!_:=+8.+5!"''T)!62+!N:=+5&8+&6!,-./012+3!354;6!_460:&4/!i:/09<!P646+8+&6!;:5!S+&+*4./+!
R&+5><!%&;54165-96-5+!R_?#@!!P+960:&!"@(@WO!x%ie![+9010:&!H4C0&>y!1646+1L!
!
“The IPC should use ETSU-R-97 to satisfy itself that the noise from the operation
of the wind turbines is within acceptable levels.”
S.2.7.66 continues: “Where the correct methodology has been followed and a wind
farm is shown to comply with ETSU-R-97 it should be reasonable for the IPC to
conclude that it may give little or no weight to adverse noise impacts from
the operation of wind turbines.”
[Department of Energy & Climate Change (DECC). Draft National Policy Statement
for Renewable Energy Infrastructure (EN-3). DECC (UK), November 2009
http://www.officialdocuments.gov.uk/document/other/9780108508516/9780108508516.pdf]
[Emphasis added.]
&
[+1,06+!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!45609/+1!0&!2+4/62!190+&9+1!I:-5&4/1!4.:-6!62+!08,496!:;!&:01+!:&!
1/++,!4&3!2+4/62)!41!*+//!41!62+!+=03+&9+!,5+1+&6+3!0&!62+!4-62:51B!"''(!,4,+5)!_!"#$%&'()#(*#"+&
,-".&/#+)&01-2#+%$&3+$*(44%)&!%(-&5".%$6&7,,%8*$&"+&5%(4*9K)!62+!+=03+&9+!,5+1+&6+3!0&!6201!,4,+5)!
Dfg!5+,:561)!4&3!:62+5!3:9-8+&6460:&)!4/5+43<!*+//!C&:*&!.<!N:=+5&8+&6)!62+!,5:=010:&1!0&!R_?
#!8-16!.+!5+>453+3!41!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6K1!3010&6+5+16!0&!,5:6+960&>!62+!.4109!2-84&!50>261!:;!
:530&45<!,+:,/+!X!;480/0+1)!920/35+&)!62+!+/3+5/<)!62+!=-/&+54./+!X!*2:!45+!3+160&+3!.<!N:=+5&8+&6!
4-62:501460:&!6:!1-;;+5!62+!9:&1+G-+&9+1!:;!4!N-034&9+!\RAPE?S?T(]!6246!3:+1!&:6!,5:=03+!
43+G-46+!2+4/62!,5:6+960:&!6:!;480/0+1!*2+&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!&+45!2:8+1!4&3!:62+5!
1+&1060=+!;490/060+1@!
!
g&!"$!d4&-45<!"'UU)!62+!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!,-./012+3!061!5+1,:&1+!6:!62+![Ree!
9:&1-/6460:&!:&!62+!5+=01+3!354;6!_460:&4/!i:/09<!P646+8+&6!R_?#L!
!
“We conclude that EN-3 is still not fit for the purpose it is intended, and should not
be formally approved. (2) While we have not repeated our criticisms of first
iteration of EN-3, those observations still stand. Indeed, it is difficult to believe
that any of the previous criticisms, from REF or others, have been addressed. (7)
It is also clear that the authors of EN-3 have not read or understood ETSU R 97.
For example, para 2.7.56 states that ETSU R 97 ‘recommends noise limits that
seek to protect the amenity of wind farm neighbours’. This is incorrect. (8) In fact,
ETSU R 97 specifically does not seek to protect neighbours amenity and the
authors are clear that the noise limits suggested exceed the levels necessary to
preserve amenity (see page 62 ETSU R 97).” [REF p 2/9 Introduction (1)]
“Further Comments on EN-3
(20). Returning to EN-3, the statement at para 2.7.58 at the IPC (Infrastructure
Planning Commission) ‘should use ETSU R 97 to satisfy itself that the noise from
the operation of the wind turbines is within acceptable levels’ is irrational and
meaningless. There is no guidance in ETSU R 97 about determining operational
noise. ETSU R 97 gives information on how to quantify pre-existing background
noise over a range of wind speeds.
(21). Similarly, paragraph 2.7.59 remarks that ‘Where the correct methodology
has been followed and the wind farm has been shown to comply with ETSU R 97...
etc,’ but this is empty of meaning since there is no correct methodology for
establishing wind farm noise levels, as ETSU R 97 is silent on the key issue of
noise predictions. Without guidance on a methodology for predicting turbine noise,
!
!
!
!
there is inevitable ambiguity on whether a wind farm can be shown to comply with
any levels or not.”
[Renewable Energy Foundation. Response to DECC Consultation on the Revised
Draft National Policy Statement EN-3 Renewable Energy Infrastructure and related
documents. REF, 24 January 2011 http://www.ref.org.uk/publications/218-refresponse-to-re-consultation-on-nps-en-3]
U"W!
D2+&!9:&103+5+3!0&!62+!/0>26!:;!62+!e:-56!:;!F,,+4/!3+9010:&!Z7/C:&C#F&Yhom&\"'U']c)!62+!
BD+/12!H0&016+51!e41+B)!SR`K1!+=03+&9+!4&3!45>-8+&61!12:*!2:*!62+!4380&0165460:&!:;!
N:=+5&8+&6!X![Ree!\,5+=0:-1/<!MRSS)!4&3!.+;:5+)![60]!X!1++C1!6:!9059-8=+&6!e41+!k4*@!!
Z[+,4568+&6!:;!R&+5><!^!e/0846+!e24&>+!\[Ree])!_iP!R_?#)!P@"@(@WW!!http://www.officialdocuments.gov.uk/document/other/9780108508516/9780108508516.pdf]
U"(!
!
Appendix 4.1
%
7(0:"1"-C%-0%/01*+2%
%
;$$"-"0#.,%<*5*(*#6*+%
U0'#6",%<',"#F%-0%U3.#F*%L'-'(*%05%!"#$5.(1%7,.#+%eU.(1.(-3*#+3"(*I%!.,*+fD%
09#$3$D"1*9/(4%$)!"#!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6201011:-62*4/+1@9:@-Cae:-&90/?5-/0&>?924&>+?;-6-5+?*0&3;458?,/4&1a16:5<?
U"$WUjW(?3+640/a16:5<@268/!
!
e5:1.<![@!
E*F.,%U3.,,*#F*%.F."#+-%!"#$%&'()"#*+%P0B*+%L0(G.($%G"-3%;88*.,%e7("#6*%4$G.($%U0'#-CI%
U.#.$.fD%
09%&D1+&0#.%$!\e4&434])!"'!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@:*+&1:-&31-&608+1@9:8aF5609/+[01,/4<@41,7s+t#'#WUW$!!
!
R3*4531!d@!
U.,,+%50(%;,,-G.,"+%!"#$%L.(1%-0%)*%@3'-%=0G#I%R%_',C%MNJND%
266,Laa***@I:&4624&+3*4531@:5>@-Ca94//1?;:5?4//6*4/01?*0&3?;458?6:?.+?12-6?3:*&!!
!
f488:&31!kki@!
E*--*(%(*2%X18.6-%05%W(**#%<"FF%!"#$%&'()"#*+%0#%!.-*(5.,,+I%Z"(-,*C%!.(VI%/*:3.1I%%JJ%
_'#*%MNJND%
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>af488:&31r_:562-8.+5/4&3reerU''WUU@,3;!!
!
d:24&11:&!H@!
!*%>0G%@**%L.1","*+%E*.B"#F%&3*"(%/01*+%e=*#1.(VfD%
k+66+5!6:!R306:5)!"W!H4<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a&+*1a"'UUa*+?&:*?1++?;480/0+1?/+4=0&>?62+05?2:8+1?
5+,:561?,2<10904&?3+&845Ca,50&6a!
!
k+1/0+!Q@!
[#-.("0%Y#.),*%-0%&*,,%"5%!"#$%L.(1+%4:6**$%>0"+*%E"1"-+I%;6-"B"+-+%@.CD%
09%&V4"2%&(+)&<(#4!\A:5:&6:)!e4&434])!UOaUW!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+>/:.+4&3840/@9:8a&+*1a,:/06091a:&6450:?-&4./+?6:?6+//?0;?*0&3?;4581?+79++3?
&:01+?/08061?4960=0161?14<a45609/+"'W"(jTa!!
!
H4&&!A@!
Z,'1*#-3.,%Y(F*+%&0'F3%@-.#$.($+%50(%@"-"#F%05%!"#$%70G*(%7(0g*6-+D%
09%&E(;!\_+*!k:&3:&)!e:&&+9609-6)!EPF])!d4&-45<!$!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+34<@9:8a45609/+a"'UU'U'$a_DPU"a#'U'$TTUOaU'WTa511!
!
g0C+!JA@!
_.8.#*+*%U0#5*(*#6*%0#%Z"F%!"#$2%7(*+*#-.-"0#+%)C%c"6-"1+D%e*:6*(8-+fI%QN%;8(",%MNJND%
266,Laa***@+,4*@:5>a3:9-8+&61ad4,4&+1+m"'e:&;+5+&9+m"'4>40&16m"'M0>m"'D0&3@,3;!
!
g&6450:!R&=05:&8+&64/!S+=0+*!A50.-&4/!\RSA]@!
=(#7P21$!A!L#(/7-1(>!0#$#2-(9!16!-3/!=$A#(1$)/$-2%=*6"+"0#I%Ji%_',C%MNJJD%
g&6450:)!e4&434@!
266,Laa***@+56@>:=@:&@94a+&>/012a3+9010:&1a0&3+7@268!!
\P++!4/1:!@'11.(C%05%U.+*%.#$%=*6"+"0#I%%
L"(+-%;88*.,%05%<*#*G.),*%4#*(FC%;88(0B.,%="+1"++*$D%
A:5<1!:&!R&=05:&8+&64/)!f+4/62!4&3!P4;+6<!!UT!d-/<!"'UUhUj\(]!
266,Laa***@6:5<1@9:8ai-./09460:&1a[:9-8+&61ai-./09460:&m"'i[`1aRfP"'UU?(@,3;!h!4&3!
e248.+5/40&!F@!
L"(+-%;88*.,%=*6"+"0#%0#%<*#*G.),*%4#*(FC%;88(0B.,%50(%.%!"#$%L.(1%<*#$*(*$%)C%
[#-.("0%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%<*B"*G%&(")'#.,D%
7+%-@;&<(-L%*$&H144%*#+!d-/<!"'UU!
266,Laa***@84560&34/+@9:8a8+8.+51aF5609/+rF64928+&6@41,7s:3tU'jUTTT^03tU#Uj#Oj^;0/
+&48+t415?U#Uj#W'@`0516@,3;!@]!
!
!
S4<!i@!
U3.(F*+%.F."#+-%!"#$%U018.#"*+%Y83*,$D%
:4*""+(&<#--"-)!"(!H4592!"''T@!
266,Laa***@4/6::&48055:5@9:8a,4>+a9:&6+&6@3+640/a03aOU($#T@268/!!
!
P25+=+!R@!
&'()"#*+%W*-%E0'$*(%.-%>"F3-I%/*.("#F%&0,$D%
C9(*9(.&E(#4;&!%B$)!"O!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
!""#$%%&&&'(!)"!)*+),-./0&1'()%23",(-04,1#-).')1#560789:9;88<
U"j!
!
P,+451!d@!
E*F.,%U3.,,*#F*%U0',$%@-.,,%[#-.("0%!"#$%7(0g*6-+D%
09%&D*(-!\g&6450:)!e4&434])!O!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+1645@9:8a&+*1a:&6450:a45609/+aTUWW"'??/+>4/?924//+&>+?9:-/3?164//?:&6450:?*0&3?
,5:I+961!!
!
P,+451!d@!
&08%U0'(-%<*g*6-+%!"#$%&'()"#*%U3.,,*#F*D%
A2+!P645!\g&6450:)!e4&434])!"U!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+1645@9:8a.-10&+11a9:8,4&0+1a45609/+aU'U"W$U??6:,?9:-56?5+I+961?*0&3?6-5.0&+?
924//+&>+!!
!
&'()"#*%>0"+*%.%!"#$%=*B*,08*(%L"#$+%[)g*6-"0#.),*D%
%&3-16504/!D0&3!F960:&!N5:-,)!UO!d-&+!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a;4G1a"(j'#!!
!
A-5C+/!A@!
&'()"#*+%&'(#%"#-0%/*.$.63*%50(%c"#.,3.B*#j%>0"+*%U018,."#-+%4#*(F"n*%[880#*#-+%05%
!"#$%70G*(%.#$%U018,"6.-*%P."#*9+%<*#*G.),*%4#*(FC%4550(-+D%
J"-*4(+)&J-%$$&5%-(4))!"$!d4&-45<!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@,5+112+54/3@9:8a45920=+a6-5.0&+1?6-5&?0&6:?2+43492+?;:5?=0&4/24=+&r"'U'?'U?
"$@268/s1+45926+58t2+43492+b;:5b=0&4/24=+&!
!
n+//+5)!A!d5@!!
L0(%&30+*%>*.(I%-3*%P"+*(.),*%/'1%05%U,*.#%4#*(FCD%
!%B&e"-L&0#.%$)!O!g96:.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a&+*1a"'U'a;:5?62:1+?&+45?62+?801+54./+?2-8?:;?9/+4&?
+&+5><?&<?608+1a!
!
!
%
!
U"T!
!
Appendix 4.2
/'1.#%<"F3-+2%%
%
%
%
W*#*(.,%X++'*+I%@8*6"5"6%U.+*+I%.#$%%
7(08*(-C%c.,'*+%eX#-*(#.-"0#.,f2%%%;$$"-"0#.,%<*5*(*#6*+%
W*#*(.,%X++'*+%
F3481!_!4&3!_+0/!S@!!!
!"#$%70G*(2%7,.##"#F%7*(1"++"0#)!UU!_:=+8.+5!"'U')!9$WU*@!!
f4&1453L!!f:-1+!:;!e:88:&1@!g;;0904/!i-./09460:&!:;!62+!EQ!i45/048+&6@!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"'U'UUa9824&153a98U'UUUUa6+76aU'UUUU*'''
#@268|U'UUUUj#''''"O!
!
e:;;84&!H@!
!"#$%&'()"#*%@C#$(01*%7(018-+%@-.-*%E.G1.V*(+%-0%7(080+*%MT?*.(%k!"#$%L.(1l%
P0(.-0("'1D%
3)(9"&'%>"-*%-!\EPF])!Uj!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@0342:5+,:56+5@9:8a"'UUa2:-1+?9:88066++?9:&103+50&>?8:546:50-8?:&?*0&3?
6-5.0&+?9:&165-960:&a!!
!
e5-8!P@!
@-("6-%@-.#$.($+%c"-.,%50(%!3"-,*C%!"#$%7,.#-D%
M"1-+(4&V(d%**%!\`:56!D4<&+)!%&304&4)!EPF])!U'![+9+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@I:-5&4/>4Y+66+@&+6a45609/+a"'U'U"U'aR[%A'Oa#U"U'TTT#aU'"UaR[%A!!
N4>+!S6!f:&!P05!D0//048)!e240584&@!
@-.-*1*#-%0#%-3*%Z.3.%P0'+.%7'),"6%X#]'"(C%<*80(-I%i%@*8-*1)*(%MNJJD%
266,Laa***@.4248:-140&G-05<@:5>a/0&C+3;0/+1a.424r8:-14a5+,:56a"'UU?'T?'j?
9240584&11646+8+&6@,3;!!
P++!4/1:L!!!
N4>+!S6!f:&!P05!D0//048)!e240584&@!
&3*%Z.3.%P0'+.%7'),"6%X#]'"(C%<*80(-D%
i5+1+&6+3!6:!i45/048+&6!,-51-4&6!6:!P+960:&!"W!:;!62+!%&G-050+1!F96!"''O@!
A2+!P6460:&+5<!g;;09+!\EQ])!fe!U$O")!=:/1!U!X!#)!j!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@.4248:-140&G-05<@:5>a5+,:56a0&3+7@268!!
!
f456![@!
;#*101*-*(+I%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%"#50(1.-"0#I%.#$%E*F.,%;$B"6*2%%-3*%7,.##"#F%X#+8*6-0(.-*9+%
='-C%-0%="+6,0+*A%
EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!g;;09+!S:*!\UegS])!"O!F->-16!"'UU@!
266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'UUa'ja"Oa4&+8:8+6+51?+&=05:&8+&64/?0&;:58460:&?4&3?
/+>4/?43=09+?62+?,/4&&0&>?0&1,+96:546+1?3-6<?6:?3019/:1+a!
!
f456![@!!!
_'+-%!3*#%?0'%&30'F3-%&3*C%!*(*%4:-"#6-2%%/'1.#%<"F3-+%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%U.+*%@'66**$+D%
EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!g;;09+!S:*!\UegS])!"(!d-/<!"'UU@!!Z5+L!A2:841!=!M503>+&3!eMec!
266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'UUa'(a"(aI-16?*2+&?<:-?62:->26?62+<?*+5+?+760&96?4U,U?
+&=05:&8+&64/?941+?1-99++31a!
!
i455<!P!4&3![:->/41!R@!
X#%U3"#.I%-3*%&('*%U0+-%05%Z("-."#9+%U,*.#I%W(**#%!"#$%70G*(%4:8*("1*#-2%%70,,'-"0#%0#%.%
="+.+-(0'+%@6.,*D%
E(#4;&<(#4)!"T!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@340/<840/@9:@-Ca2:8+a8:1/0=+a45609/+?U#O'jUUa%&?e20&4?65-+?9:16?M50640&1?9/+4&?
>5++&?*0&3?,:*+5?+7,+508+&6?i://-60:&?3014165:-1?194/+@268/!!
!
!
@8*6"5"6%U.+*+%
U#'!
!
4'(08*.#%U0'(-%05%/'1.#%<"F3-+%e4U/<fD%
P@UW(!Q(/,'$%!A!RS!UT(j!"$RfSS!$"#!
Q(/,'$%!A!RS&7C5'&YfA]YAYZgf&
T1+/@!N2-('!A!<+'#$I&Z&E%8%.2%-&YZZl&
?./(('!'$%!N-3/(2!A!Q-',9I&YZ&=%2-1(-;&YZZf!
P@j(!?'65/$!A!?/()'$9I&Y&M1+%&U]Y]&
P@jj!?'65/$!A!?/()'$9&
P@jT!?'65/$!A!?/()'$9I&U]Y]&
01(/$1!?1)/@!A!<+'#$I&U]]l&
&'%/9/A'!A!O.22#'I&U]]m&
U'--1$!A!RSI&f&M14;&U]]o&
\="-&5(**"+I&$%%&(4$"!62+!d:0&6![011+&60&>!g,0&0:&1!:;!d-3>+1!e:164)!S++1)!A-58+&)!n-,4&909!4&3!
P6+0&+5)!5(**"+&(+)&"*9%-$&F&G+#*%)&X#+@)".!3+9010:&!4&3!3011+&60&>!:,0&0:&1L!
266,Laa9801C,@+925@9:+@0&6a6C,UT(a=0+*@41,s06+8t"^,:564/t2.C8^4960:&t268/^1:-59+t6C,
^20>2/0>26tm""AfRm"'E_%AR[m"'Q%_N[gHm""m"'}m"'2466:&^1+110:&03tWWjU'O^1C0
&t2-3:9?+&@]&
\D%%&(4$"L!P@(T!C9(9(4&F&GX!UTTWh!P@U"'!R(2#*(&F&3*(4;h!P@UUj!'(.#-%d&D(+89%d&F&=-(+8%h!PU"(!
D(()#&F&3*(4;!"''jh!X%%+(+&F&GX!P@UU'h!P@W(!M(44"9&F&V%-.(+;A]!
\A:!5+43!62+!3+9010:&1!:&!RefS!941+1)!;0&3!62+1+!3+9010:&1!46!!
266,Laa***@+925@9:+@0&6aRefSaR_af+43+5ae41+?
k4*a[+9010:&1b4&3bI-3>8+&61afE[geb3464.41+a@]!
!
R&>/012!S@!
@,0G%)'-%@-*.$C%0#%;66*++%-0%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%_'+-"6*%5(01%@'8(*1*%U0'(-D%
EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!g;;09+!S:*!\UegS])!U#!F,50/!"'UU@!
266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'U'aU"a"'a1/:*?.-6?16+43<?:&?499+11?6:?+&=05:&8+&64/?
I-1609+?;5:8?1-,5+8+?9:-56a!!
!
!
%
%
7(08*(-C%c.,'*+%%eX#-*(#.-"0#.,f%
_09:/!d!4&3!P+>/0&1![@!
[#-.("0%!"#$%70G*(%Z("#F"#F%=0G#%7(08*(-C%c.,'*+D%
eMe!_+*1!\e4&434])!U!g96:.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@9.9@94a&+*1a94&434a*0&31:5a16:5<a"'UUa'Ta#'a:&6450:?*0&3?,:*+5?,5:,+56<?
=4/-+1@268/!!
‘However, last February, before an environmental review tribunal in Chatham,
Environment Ministry lawyer Frederika Rotter said: "We will see in the course of this
hearing that lots of people are worried about windmills. They may not like the noise,
they may think the noise makes them sick, but really what makes them sick is just the
windmills being on the land because it does impact their property values.
"That's what makes them sick is that, you know, they'll get less money for their
properties, and that's what's causing all this annoyance and frustration and all of
that." ‘
A2+1+!*+5+!9:88+&61!843+!.<!62+!e:-&1+/!;:5!62+![05+96:5)!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6)!3-50&>!
4&!R&=05:&8+&64/!S+=0+*!A50.-&4/@!!ZR&=05:&8+&64/!S+=0+*!A50.-&4/@!!F,,+4/!:;!S+&+*4./+!
R&+5><!F,,5:=4/)!Q+&6!M5++Y+!e:5,:5460:&!4&3!H49k+:3!D0&380//!i5:I+96!%&9@!\Q+&6!M5++Y+!D0&3!
`4581]!9a:!P-&9:5!R&+5><!P+5=09+1!%&9@!!e41+!_:1@L!U'?U"U!4&3!U'?U"")!e:-&1+/!;:5!62+!H0&0165<!:;!
R&=05:&8+&6)!g&6450:)!e4&434!266,Laa***@+56@>:=@:&@94a+&>/012a3+9010:&1a0&3+7@268c!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
U#U!
!
Chapter 5 %
%
=.B"$%B%W0,".-3%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
!
D2+&!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!+70160&>!;480/<!2:8+1)!62+!3-5460:&!
4&3!3:14>+!:;!62+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!+8066+3!.<!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+\1]!94-1+1!;480/0+1!
0&6+&1+!1-;;+50&>)!8+&64/!165+11)!1/++,!3+,50=460:&)!;+45)!4&>-012!4&3!;++/0&>1!:;!,:*+5/+11&+11@!!!
!
e24,6+5!#!:;!6201!,4,+5)!5+>4530&>!2+4/62)!,5+1+&61!+=03+&9+!6246!&:01+!94&!0&6+5;+5+!*062!4!
,+51:&K1!1/++,)!0&6+5;+5+!*062!9:>&060:&!4&3!/+45&0&>)!43=+51+/<!4;;+96!,2<10:/:>094/!4&3!
,1<92:/:>094/!;-&960:&1)!4&3!84<!+=+&!/+43!6:!4&!0&95+41+!0&!49903+&61@!!A2+!,5:./+8!01!
0&6+5&460:&4/!0&!19:,+)!4&3!4/62:->2!>:=+5&8+&61!:;!62+!EQ)![+&845C)!N+584&<)!e4&434)!R-5:,+)!
d4,4&)!F-1654/04)!4&3!_+*!n+4/4&3)!45+!4//!4*45+!:;!62+!011-+!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+)!8:16!24=+!
&:6!,5:=03+3!5:.-16!,5:6+960:&!6:!62:1+!;480/0+1!4;;+96+3!:5!46!501C)!*062!62+!&:64./+!+79+,60:&1!:;!
[+&845C!4&3!p096:504)!F-1654/04)!8+&60:&+3!+45/0+5!0&!6201!,4,+5)!*2092!24=+!4/6+5+3!,:/09<!0&!
5+1,:&1+!6:!9:8,/40&61!4&3!,5:./+81!*062!&:01+@%
!
EQ!,:/060904&1!+7,:-&3!:&!V65-+!3+8:9549<K)!62+!,456090,46:5<!,5:9+11)!62+!08,:564&9+!0&!:-5!
1:90+6<!:;!.4109!2-84&!50>261)!4&3!62+!08,:564&9+!:;!62+!;480/<@!!J+6)!62+!=+&++5!120+/31!/45>+!
.-10&+11!0&6+5+161!4&3!,-./09!:;;0904/1!4960&>!:&!.+24/;!:;!62+!P646+!4>40&16!*2:8!62+!:530&45<!
9060Y+&!241!/066/+!,:*+5!:5!,5:6+960:&@!!D0&3!+&+5><!3+=+/:,+51!4&3!62+05!,:*+5;-/!0&;/-+&9+!:&!
>:=+5&8+&6!4>+&90+1!4&3!,:/090+1!1-5+/<!5+,5+1+&6!N:/0462B1!1++80&>/<!-&/0806+3!5+1:-59+1!6:!
/:..<!:&!62+05!.+24/;)!9:8,45+3!6:!62+!:530&45<!;480/<B1!V[4=03K!:;!9:&103+54./<!8:3+16!5+1:-59+1@!!
E&;:56-&46+/<)!1/0&>12:61!3:!&:6!*:5C!*+//!0&!4!20>2/<!.-5+4-954609!1:90+6<@!!\P++!4/1:!62+!
3019-110:&!4.:-6!F06C+&K1!4&3!R//01!%*&(4K1!5+1+4592!:&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!,/4&&0&>!3+9010:&1)!,,!U(?"'@]!
!
D20/+!84&<!;480/0+1!80>26!*0//0&>/<!8:=+!2:8+!0&!:53+5!6:!+194,+!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!192+8+!0;!62+<!
*+5+!9:8,+&146+3!;:5!62+!845C+6!=4/-+!:;!62+05!2:8+!.+;:5+!62+!192+8+!\,/-1!8:=0&>!4&3!5+/46+3!
+7,+&1+1])!1-92!9:8,+&1460:&!01!&+=+5!4=40/4./+!-&/+11!62+!/4&3!:&!*2092!62+!2:8+!01!.-0/6!01!
5+G-05+3!41!,456!:;!62+!3+=+/:,8+&6@!!%&16+43)!41!924,6+5!$!\F5609/+!U!`0516!i5:6:9:/]!12:*1)!62+05!
2:8+1!3+=4/-+!088+3046+/<!*062!62+!4&&:-&9+8+&6!:;!62+!192+8+)!.+94-1+!:;!,-./09!4*45+&+11!:;!
62+!&:01+!,://-60:&!+8066+3!.<!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!!R=+&!1:)!84&<!,+:,/+!*:-/3!,5+;+5!6:!164<!0&!
62+05!2:8+1!4&3!5+/<!:&!,-./09!:;;0904/1!6:!64C+!62+!,5+94-60:&45<!16+,1!6:!+&1-5+!6246!*0&3!6-5.0&+!
192+8+1!45+!&:6!106+3!&+45!2:8+1)!9:88-&060+1)!4&3!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1@!
!
%6!01!+41<!6:!3018011!62+!,5:./+8!.<!14<0&>!6246!62+!;480/<!12:-/3!5+1:56!6:!I-30904/!,5:6+960:&@!!J+6!
06!01!-&/0C+/<!6246!4!;480/<)!.5:->26!6:!3+1,405!.<!62+!0&2-84&!4&3!3+>5430&>!65+468+&6!4-62:501+3!
.<!xN:/0462y)!-&3+580&0&>!62+05!9:&;03+&9+)!2+4/62!4&3!*+//!.+0&>)!4&3!62+05!/0;+!14=0&>1)!94&!62+&!
5401+!62+!1-.164&604/!;0&4&904/!1-81!&+9+1145<!6:!0&06046+!/+>4/!,5:9++30&>1@!!`-562+58:5+)!41!
3+1950.+3!0&!e24,6+5!$@#)!xN:/0462y!5+8:=+3!62+!:,60:&!:;!I-30904/!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!x[4=03y)!=04!
P@UO"!4&3!P@UOj!:;!62+!EQ!i/4&&0&>!F96)!4&!4960:&!6246!4,,+451!6:!.+!0&!=0:/460:&!:;!x[4=03K1y!2-84&!
50>261@!
!
F!;480/<!94&!5+,:56!4,,45+&6!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!6:!62+!/:94/!4-62:506<)!*2092!-&3+5!
P+960:&!j'!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!F96!UTT')!94&!1+5=+!4&!4.46+8+&6!&:609+!*2+5+!4!
1646-6:5<!&-014&9+!+70161@!!f:*+=+5)!+=03+&9+!12:*1!6246!62+!/:94/!4-62:506<!01!-&*0//0&>!6:!64C+!
4960:&!*2+&!4!*0&3!;458!01!62+!94-1+)!.+94-1+!:;!62+!=416/<!9:8,/0946+3!V_:01+!e:&3060:&K!0&!62+!
i/4&&0&>!i+580110:&)!*2092!5+G-05+1!62+!9:?:,+5460:&!:;!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!:*&+51!4&3!:,+546:51!
.+;:5+!:&!106+!&:01+!8+41-5+8+&61!45+!64C+&@!!D0&3!6-5.0&+1!:,+546+!46!1+=+54/!30;;+5+&6!V8:3+1K)!
9:&65://+3!.<!5+8:6+!9:8,-6+5)!1:!62+5+!01!&:!,5:=010:&!6:!03+&60;<!46!*2092!5-&&0&>!8:3+!62+!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!01!1+6!3-50&>!,+50:31!:;!+765+8+!&:01+!4&3!,+50:31!*2+&!:&106+!&:01+!8+41-5+8+&61!
45+!.+0&>!64C+&@!!`-562+58:5+)!62+!164&3453!&:01+!9:&3060:&!01!20>2/<!9:8,/0946+3)!*2092!84C+1!06!
+41<!;:5!*0&3!+&+5><!49:-160904&1!6:!45>-+!6246!+=+&!1-.164&604/!4&3!3+.0/06460&>!&:01+!&-014&9+!
9:8,/<!*062!62+!164&3453!i/4&&0&>!e:&3060:&!:&!&:01+@!!\P++!F,,+&307!O@U)!H5!4&3!H51!d![4=01@]!!
\P++!4/1:!514.%&F&D%8-%*(-;&",&D*(*%!"'U'!RDfe!"#jW!\F380&])!egaT((a"'U'@]!!
!
M<!*4<!:;!P+960:&!j"!:;!62+!RiF96)!62+!;480/<!9:-/3!1+6!3:*&!,5:9++30&>1!0;!4>>50+=+3!.<!4!
1646-6:5<!&-014&9+)!.-6!;0516!6201!5+G-05+1!;0&4&9+!;5:8!62+!;480/<!;:5!/+>4/!4&3!49:-1609!+&>0&++5!
;++1)!4&3!4!&-8.+5!:;!34<1!:&106+!.<!4&!49:-160904&!6:!8+41-5+!&:01+@!!M-6!4>40&)!62+!106+!:*&+5!
*0//!45>-+!6246!62+!&:01+!/+=+/1!5+9:53+3!45+!*0620&!62+!19:,+!:;!62+!,/4&&0&>!9:&3060:&!1+6!3:*&!
.<!62+!4-62:5010&>!,-./09!:;;0904/1@!
U#"!
!
!
F!;480/<!84<!4/1:!,5:9++3!.<!*4<!:;!4!,50=46+!&-014&9+h!62+!*+//?C&:*&!941+!:;!';4(+)$&F&=4%*89%-&
\#!fk!##')!\UjWj]!kS!#!fk##')!ZUjWjc!EQfk!U]!01!62+!6+76.::C!+748,/+@!!f:*+=+5)!41!,5+=0:-1/<!
&:6+3)!62+!9:161!45+!,5:20.060=+!;:5!62+!4=+54>+!;480/<)!+1,+904//<!;:5!4!;480/<!*2+&!62+!P646+!241!
4/5+43<!+;;+960=+/<!4-62:501+3!62+!9:&;019460:&!:;!62+!;480/<!/0;+608+!14=0&>1!/45>+/<!=04!,5:,+56<!
3+=4/-460:&@!!%&!9:&65416)!62+!VN:/0462B!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!241!1-.164&604/!;0&4&904/)!164;;)!4&3!
9:&1-/64&6!5+1:-59+1)!4&3!94&!+&6+5!4!,5:65496+3!.466/+!C&:*0&>!06!241!6201!9506094/!6496094/!
43=4&64>+@!!`-562+58:5+)!;:5!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<)!6201!01!V.-10&+11Kh!;:5!62+!;480/0+1!0&=:/=+3)!
6201!01!V,+51:&4/Kh!62-1)!62+!6://!+7496+3!01!8:5+!624&!;0&4&904/@!
!
_';4(+)$&F&=4%*89%-K!;:-&3!6246L!
&
“The person who for his own purposes brings on his land and collects and keeps
anything likely to do mischief if it escapes, must keep it in at his peril, and if he
does not do so, is prima facie answerable for all the damage which is the natural
consequence of its escape.”
[Rylands v Fletcher, 3 HL 330, (1868) LR 3 HL330, [1868] UKHL 1
http://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1868/1.html]
&
A2-1)!62+!S</4&31!=!`/+692+5!,50&90,/+!,5:=03+1!6246!0;!4!/4&3:*&+5!0&65:3-9+1!:&6:!62+!,5+801+1!
4&!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!;:5!62+!,-5,:1+!:;!>+&+5460&>!+/+9650906<!.<!9://+960&>!4&3!62+&!
,5:9+110&>!62+!*0&3)!4&3!0;!3-50&>!6201!,5:9+11)!95+46+1!4&!0&3-16504/!4&3a:5!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!
,://-60:&!6246!3019245>+1!:=+5!&+0>2.:-50&>!,5:,+56<)!94-10&>!&-014&9+!4&3!2+4/62!0&I-5<!6:!
&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1!*2+5+!62+!0&3-16504/!106+!241!;40/+3!6:!9:&640&!62+!,://-60:&)!62+&!62+!
/4&3:*&+5!01!5+1,:&10./+!;:5!62+1+!9:&1+G-+&9+1@!
!
%&!62+:5<)!62+!;480/<!241!5+9:-51+!6:!62+!f-84&!S0>261!F96!UTTj)!F5609/+!#)!P92+3-/+!U)!i456!U)!4&3!
F5609/+!j!4&3!F5609/+!U!:;!62+!`0516!i5:6:9:/@!!f:*+=+5)!,5:20.060=+!9:161!84C+!6201!:,60:&!
-&5+4/01609!4&3!-&;+410./+!;:5!62+!4=+54>+!;480/<!/0=0&>!4&3!*:5C0&>!0&!62+!9:-&65<103+@!Zf-84&!
S0>261!F96!UTTj!266,Laa***@/+>01/460:&@>:=@-Ca-C,>4aUTTja$"a9:&6+&61c!
!
A2+!E_!R9:&:809!e:880110:&!;:5!R-5:,+!\E_?ReR]!4-62:5+3!62+!xF452-1!e:&=+&60:&!UTTjy)!
*2092!948+!0&6:!;:59+!0&!62+!EQ!0&!H4<!"''O)!1::&!4;6+5!5460;09460:&@!!A2+!e:&=+&60:&!1+61!:-6!5-/+1!
:&!499+11!6:!0&;:58460:&)!,-./09!,456090,460:&)!4&3!499+11!6:!I-1609+!0&!+&=05:&8+&64/!8466+51@!!
!
g&!"O!F->-16!"'U')!62+!F452-1!e:8,/04&9+!e:88066++!011-+3!354;6!5-/0&>1!:&!6*:!+&=05:&8+&64/!
924//+&>+1!4>40&16!62+!EQL!
!
\U] Feeeaea"''ja"(!
\"] Feeeaea"''ja##!
!
%&!.:62!941+1)!62+!e:88066++!;:-&3!.5+492+1!.<!62+!EQ!:;!62+!F452-1!e:&=+&60:&@!!
\P++!8:5+!3+640/!46L!!f456![4=03)!oe@!!:(-91$&H-%(89%$&:44&'"1+)@!!EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!
g;;09+!S:*)!U#!F,50/!"'UU)!266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'UUa'$aU#a4452-1?.5+492+1?4//?
5:-&3a@]!!%
!
A2+!EQ!01!10>&46:5<!6:!62+!E&06+3!_460:&1!e:&=+&60:&!:&!f-84&!S0>261!4&3!62+!E_!F452-1!
e:&=+&60:&@!!A2+1+!e:&=+&60:&1!,5:6+96!.4109!2-84&!50>261!4&3!62+!5+9:-51+!6:!62+!I-309045<!X!.-%
(*.+0#.),*%60+-!X!;:5!;480/0+1!6:!1++C!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!+&=05:&8+&64/!&-014&9+@!
!
%&!,549609+)!8:16!0&!62+!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:546+!45+!5+/-964&6!6:!49C&:*/+3>+!6246!f-84&!S0>261!45+!
+&>4>+3!:5!5+G-05+!:62+5!624&!9-51:5<!466+&60:&)!*2+&!62+!G-+160:&!:;!62+!,:6+&604/!08,496!:&!
;480/<!/0;+!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!5401+3!41!4&!011-+!46!4!i/4&&0&>!%&G-05<@!!\P++!+=03+&9+!\,!#U])!
\f-/8+]!!i/4&&0&>!F,,+4/![+9010:&)!_:562!A4*6:&)!UU![+9+8.+5!"''T)!
FiiaoUUO#aFa'Wa"'U(UW"@]!!!!
!
J+6)!:&!"$!_:=+8.+5!"'U')!62+!e:-56!:;!F,,+4/&4//:*+3!62+!D+/12!H0&016+5K1!4,,+4/!4>40&16!4!
I-3>8+&6!:;!D<&!D0//0481!d!9:&9+5&0&>!4!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,8+&6!0&!_:562!D4/+1@!!ZA+>&0!e<85-!
e<;!S+1,:&3+&6!?!F&3!?!A2+!D+/12!H0&016+51!^!F_S!F,,+//4&6@!P@"$)!e41+!_:L!
eUa"'U'aU$"WaoMR_`)!k:53!d-1609+!e45&*462)!k:53!d-1609+!R/041!4&3!k:53!d-1609+!i0692;:53!
.+6*++&L!!A+>&0!e<85-!e<;!S+1,:&3+&6!?!F&3!?!A2+!D+/12!H0&016+51!^!F_S!F,,+//4&6)!"$!
_:=+8.+5!"'U'c!&\A2+!;496!6246!AF_j!01!845>0&4//<!/+11!V0&165-960=+K!624&!iiP""!P"")!01!&:6!
U##!
!
5+/+=4&6!0&!6+581!:;!f-84&!S0>261@]!Zi/4&&0&>!i:/09<!P646+8+&6!""!\iiP""]L!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><)!U'!
F->-16!"''$@!266,Laa***@9:88-&060+1@>:=@-Ca,-./09460:&1a,/4&&0&>4&3.-0/30&>a,,1""c!!
!
%&!62+!d4&-45<!"'UU!i/4&&0&>!F,,+4/!3+9010:&!46!VA-&164//)!S::1K)!*2092!*41!5+I+96+3!:&!/4&3194,+!
>5:-&31)!:&/<!"!,454>54,21!:;!62+!(T!,454>54,2!3+9010:&!9:&103+5+3!62+!&:01+!08,496!:&!&+45.<!
;480/0+1!\PO$!X!POO]@!!J+6)!0&!:&+!305+960:&!1:8+!""!2:8+1!*+5+!.+6*++&!(U'8!X!U#''8!;5:8!62+!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!4&3!0&!4&:62+5!305+960:&!4.:-6!4!3:Y+&!2:8+1!*+5+!j$'8!X!U(''8!;5:8!62+!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1@!!A2+!3+=+/:,+5K1!R&=05:&8+&64/!P646+8+&6!,5+3096+3!9:8,/04&9+!*062!RAPE?S?T()!4&3!
6246!1++8+3!6:!14601;<!62+!%&1,+96:546+@!!%&!\P@T]!62+!%&1,+96:5!1646+3!6246L!!
!
“The main issue in this case is whether any harm to landscape and visual
amenity... would be sufficient to outweigh the presumption in favour of such
proposals.”
\_:6+L!!A2+5+!*41!&:!8+&60:&!:;!62+!08,:564&9+!:;!,5:6+960&>!62+!2+4/62!4&3!48+&06<!:;!
&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1@]!!!
ZA2+!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:546+!\EQ]@!!A-&164//)!S::1)!f-//@!F,,+4/![+9010:&@!!%&1,+96:5!F!
i<C+66@!i%_P!F,,+4/!S+;!FiiaR"''UaFaU'a"U#'W(')!(!d4&-45<!"'UUc!
!
A2+!%&1,+96:5!48,/0;0+1!201!“presumption in favour”&:;!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!4&3!*0&3!;458!
3+=+/:,8+&6!.<!5+;+5+&9+!6:!62+!3+=+/:,8+&6!,/4&)!+&+5><!,:/09<)!4&3!5+>0:&4/!645>+61)!4&3!6:!62+!
R-5:,+4&!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+61!;:5!62+!EQ!4&3!62+!e/0846+!e24&>+!F96!"''j@!!f+!4/1:!5+;+55+3!
6:!62+!354;6!+&+5><!V_460:&4/!i:/09<!P646+8+&61K@!!\P++!F,,+&307!$@"@]!!g&+!94&!:&/<!9:&9/-3+!6246!
,-./09!:;;0904/1!24=+!3+903+3!6246!0&!62+!EQ)!62+!f-84&!S0>261!:;!:530&45<!;480/0+1)!+=+&!62:->2!62+!
f-84&!S0>261!F96!UTTj!01!i45/048+&645<!k4*)!24=+!)%.#+#.1$!*+0>260&>!0&!62+!9:&6+76!:;!&460:&4/!
,:/09<!0&!:53+5!6:!8++6!45.06545<!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+61@!!A201!-&3+519:5+1!62+!08,:564&9+!:;!4&!
08,45604/!4&3!499+110./+!I-309045<!6:!62+!:530&45<!9060Y+&)!*062!061!4.0/06<!6:!*+0>2!62+!:=+54//!
.4/4&9+!:;!0&30=03-4/!,5:6+960:&!=!1646+!4-62:506<@!!M-6!xN:/0462y!C&:*1!499+110.0/06<!6:!I-30904/!
,5:6+960:&!;:5!x[4=03y!01!.+<:&3!4&<!5+4/01609!;0&4&904/!5+1:-59+1@!
!
D2+&!4!P646+!,5:;+11+1!6:!.+!4!3+8:9549<!6246!164-&92/<!-,2:/31!f-84&!S0>261)!2:*!94&!6246!
P646+!4//:*!4!106-460:&!6:!+=:/=+)!4&3!+=+&!3+6+50:546+)!*2+&!/+11!,5:6+960:&!01!+76+&3+3!6:!
:530&45<!;480/0+1!624&!+@>@)!6:!;:7+1)!.43>+51)!4&3!,5:6+96+3!/4&3194,+1!\+@>@)!_460:&4/!i45C1)!F5+41!
:;!g-6164&30&>!_46-54/!M+4-6<])!62:->2!62+1+!+;;:561!45+!20>2/<!9:88+&34./+@!!f:*!241!62+!
VN:/0462K!P646+!.+9:8+!1:!0&6+56*0&+3!*062!62+!.0>!.-10&+11!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,+51!\.-10&+11!
1++C0&>!6:!8470801+!,5:;06)!90=0/!1+5=4&61!1++C0&>!6:!8470801+!645>+61])!6246!62+!e0=0/!P+5=09+!
1-,,5+11+1!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!5+9:88+&3460:&1!.<!+7,+56!49:-160904&1)!62-1!4//:*0&>!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!9:&165-960:&!6:!9:&60&-+!0&!9/:1+!,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1s!!Zk+4C+!d!4&3!M<;:53!f@!!g;;0904/1!
9:=+5!-,!D0&3!`458!_:01+!S+,:56@!09%&D1+)(;&0#.%$!\EQ])!U#![+9+8.+5!"''Tc!!
!
EQ!e0=0/!P+5=4&61!24=+!4!9:3+!:;!9:&3-96!6246!0&9/-3+1L!
!
“Integrity, honesty, objectivity and impartiality.”
[http://www.civilservice.gov.uk/about/values/cscode/index.aspx]
!
f:*!94&!62+!e0=0/!P+5=09+!I-160;<!0>&:50&>!62+!8+&64/!165+11)!1+=+5+!1/++,!3+,50=460:&)!;+45)!4&>-012)!
4&3!62+!9:&1+G-+&6!2+4/62!,5:./+81!+7,+50+&9+3!.<!62:1+!/0=0&>!*062!,5:/:&>+3!+7,:1-5+!6:!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!,://-60:&)!4//!.+94-1+!4!N-034&9+!\RAPE?S?T(]!,+580660&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!&+45!2:8+1!
241!&:6!.++&!,5:,+5/<!-,346+3!6:!+&1-5+!6246!6201!1+50:-1!2+4/62!501C!3:+1!&:6!,+51016s!![:!90=0/!
1+5=4&61!4&3!62+!R&+5><!H0&016+5!;++/!1+9-5+!0&!62+!C&:*/+3>+!6246!&+45/<!4//!;480/0+1!;0&3!/060>460:&!
6::!34-&60&>!4&3!;:5.0330&>/<!+7,+&10=+!6:!9:&6+8,/46+!6201!9:-51+!:;!4960:&s!!%6!4,,+451!6246!
H0&016+51!:;!P646+!9:&3:&+3!,-./09!:;;0904/1!*2:!9:&9+4/+3!62+!5+1-/61!:;!62+05!9:&1-/64&61K!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!5+,:56@!!Zk+4C+!d4&3!M<;:53!f@!!g;;0904/1!9:=+5!-,!D0&3!`458!_:01+!S+,:56@!09%&
D1+)(;&0#.%$!\EQ])!U#![+9+8.+5!"''Th!4&3!f4&1453)!06+81!346+3!"(!d-/<!"'U')!9jjj*)!9jjT*)!
9jT#*c!
!
%&!A:5:&6:)!e4&434)!*20/+!1++C0&>!C+<!0&;:58460:&!4.:-6!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!4&3!14;+6<!011-+1!
;5:8!+/+=+&!;480/0+1!*2:!;:58+5/<!/0=+3!&+45!6*:!30;;+5+&6!*0&3!;4581)!62+![5+&&4&!;480/<!
/+45&+3!6246!41!,456!:;!62+!5+103+&61!.-<?:-6!4>5++8+&6!*062!62+!*0&3!;458!:*&+5)!62+<!*+5+!
,5:20.06+3!;5:8!3019-110&>!4&<!&+>460=+!+7,+50+&9+1!\4!x>4>y!9/4-1+]!5+/460&>!6:!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!
0&9/-30&>!4&<!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961@!!P-,,:56+3!.<!62+05!9:88-&06<!>5:-,)!62+!;480/<!01!41C0&>!62+!
e:-56!6:!0&=4/0346+!62+!&:&?3019/:1-5+!9/4-1+!41!;-&348+&64//<!4>40&16!62+!,-./09!0&6+5+16@!!Z`480/<!
!
U#$!
A4C+1!D0&3!A-5.0&+!e:8,4&0+1!6:!e:-56!g=+5!N4>!e/4-1+1!:&!f+4/62!R;;+961!:;!A-5.0&+1@&!E#@#*(4&
M"1-+(4!U"!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU!http://www.digitaljournal.com/pr/417812. See also Couple Settle with
Wind Farm Operators over ‘Unbearable Hum’. Telegraph (UK) 30 November 2011, in which the
November 2011 terms of settlement between Mr and Mrs Davis and a subsidiary of EDF ‘are strictly
confidential’; in the initial court session in July 2011, “the operators were accused of trying to impose
a ‘code of silence’.” http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/environment/8925467/Couple-settle-withwind-farm-operators-over-unbearable-hum.htmlc!!
!
M<!4//:*0&>!9:&165-960:&!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!,-51-06!:;!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+61!8+4&6!6:!9:&65:/!
4&625:,:>+&09!>/:.4/!*4580&>!\FND])!06!01!6+8,60&>!;:5!4&<![+8:954609!P646+!6:!8:=+!5:.-16/<!
6:*453!62:1+!:.I+960=+1!+=+&!0;!46!608+1!62+!,5:9+11!503+1!5:->212:3!:=+5!62+!3+8:954609!,5:9+11@!!!
A2+!EQ!241!+&3:51+3!6201!4,,5:492!9:&9+5&0&>!62+!3+=+/:,8+&6!:;!:&12:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!.<!
4//:*0&>!62+1+!.-0/6!0&!,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1h!,5:8:60&>!4!3<1;-&960:&4/!&:01+!>-034&9+h!+&9:-54>0&>!
1+/;?5+>-/460:&!.<!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<h!3:96:50&>!4!9:&1-/64&6K1!5+,:56h!5+;-10&>!6:!
9:880110:&!+7,+56!8+3094/!43=09+!:&!62+!2+4/62!08,/09460:&1!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!94-1+3!.<!62+!
6-5.0&+1h!4&3!+&9:-54>0&>!,-./09!:;;0904/1!6:!,+5806!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!41!,456!:;!,-./09!,:/09<!4&3!6:!
9:&103+5!/4&3194,+!4&3!*0/3/0;+!4.:=+!62+!2+4/62!4&3!*+/;45+!:;!62:1+!/0=0&>@!!!
!
F33060:&4//<)!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!+&3:51+1!/+>01/460:&!6246!4//:*1!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,+51!
x1646-6:5<!4-62:506<y!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!&-014&9+!9/4081!94-1+3!.<!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&)!
3014//:*0&>!62:1+!4;;+96+3!499+11!6:!I-30904/!5+9:-51+@!!A2+!4,,45+&6!0&466+&60:&!.<!,-./09!:;;0904/1!
6:!.5+492+1!:;!62+!F452-1!e:&=+&60:&!01!<+6!4&:62+5!0&164&9+!:;!0&1+&1060=06<!6:!62+!2-84&!50>261!:;!
62:1+!4;;+96+3@!!!
!
F//!62+1+!9:&I:0&!6:!95+46+!4!N:/0462!P646+)!0&6+&6!:&!061!>:4/1)!1*++,0&>!4103+!62+!*+/;45+!:;!62:1+!
*2:!45+!-&;:56-&46+!6:!3019:=+5!6246!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*0//!.+!9:&165-96+3!&+45!
62+05!2:8+1@!!E&06+3!*062!62+!N:/0462!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<)!62+!6*:!45+!4!,:/06094//<!4&3!;0&4&904//<!
,:*+5;-/!;:59+!6246![4=03!*:-/3!;0&3!34-&60&>!6:!9:&;5:&6@!!!A2+!,5:1,+96!:;!62+!1+G-+165460:&!:;!
;480/<!/0;+14=0&>1!4&3!2:8+1!.<!62+!P646+)!*062:-6!,5+94-60:&45<!/+>4//<!.0&30&>!,5:6+960:&!:5!+=+&!
:;!;405!9:8,+&1460:&!6:!62:1+!4;;+96+3)!5+,5+1+&61!4&!08.4/4&9+!0&!62+!1<16+8!6246!01)!0&!4!95-+/!
05:&<)!-&3+8:954609@!
!
U#O!
!
Appendix 5.1
%
=.B"$%B%W0,".-3%
%
%
%
%
!
P(%.#$%P(%=.B"+I%W(.C+%L.(1I%@8.,$"#FI%E"#60,#+3"(*%
!
!!
D+!45+!d4&+!4&3!d-/04&![4=01)!*+!;458!\:&!4!9:-&6<!9:-&90/!184//2:/30&>]!0&!P,4/30&>)!P:-62!
k0&9:/&1205+@!!d-/04&!241!4/*4<1!;458+3)!0&!62+!,/49+!6246!01!:-5!2:8+)!4&3!01!4/1:!4&!4>5:&:8016@!!
d4&+!01!4!_-51+)!H03*0;+!4&3!f+4/62!p0106:5!\5+605+3]!4&3!241!.++&!0&=:/=+3!*062!840&/<!5-54/!
9:88-&060+1!10&9+!UTj'@!!!!!
!
!g-5!2:-1+)!*2092!*+!:*&)!:&!:-5!6+&4&6+3!454./+!;458)!01!T#'8!;5:8!4!*0&3!;458)!4&3!01!
3:*&*0&3!:;!62+!,5+=40/0&>!*0&3@!!A2+!*0&3!;458)!9:8,501+3!:;!j!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!+492!U''8!20>2!
46!./43+!60,!*062!"!HD!94,4906<)!.+948+!:,+5460:&4/!0&!62+!1-88+5!:;!"''W@!!%88+3046+/<!*+!
16456+3!24=0&>!,5:./+81!*062!62+!&:01+!4&3!2-8!9:80&>!;5:8!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!
!
M<!H4<!"''(!*+!*+5+!;:59+3!6:!4.4&3:&!:-5!2:8+!41!4!,/49+!0&!*2092!6:!1/++,!4&3!/0=+h!*+!
9-55+&6/<!5+&6!4!,5:,+56<!O!80/+1!4*4<!1:!6246!:-5!;480/<!94&!/0=+!41!&+45!4!&:584/!/0;+!41!,:110./+@!!
g-5!2:-1+!01!&:*!/0C+/<!6:!24=+!4!=4/-+!:;!I-16!62+!/4&3!?!{#OQ?{O'Q!4&3!01!&:!/:&>+5!845C+64./+!41!
4!2:8+!;:5!,+:,/+!6:!/0=+!0&@!U!
!
D+!303!&:6!:.I+96!6:!62+!*0&3!;458!0&!62+!,/4&&0&>!164>+!41!*+!243!&:!5+41:&!6:!620&C!6246!62+5+!
*:-/3!.+!4&<!011-+1!;:5!-1!4&3!*+!.+/0+=+3)!46!6246!608+)!6246!*0&3!,:*+5!*41!4!>::3!*4<!:;!
8++60&>!62+!+&+5><!>4,@!
!
A2+!>:=+5&8+&6!241!;:-&3!06!&+9+1145<!6:!1+6!4!1,+90;09!8+41-5+8+&6!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!
\RAPE?S?T(]!4&3!241!,-./09/<!49C&:*/+3>+3!6246!4+5:3<&4809!8:3-/460:&!01!&:6!;-//<!-&3+516::3!
.<!190+&60161@!!A201!8+4&1!6246!&:!3+=+/:,+5!94&!946+>:5094//<!1646+!6246!62+5+!*0//!&:6!.+!4!&:01+!
,5:./+8@!
!
D+!C&:*!6246!&:6!+=+5<!*0&3!;458!95+46+1!&:01+!011-+1!.-6!62:1+!6246!3:!84C+!/0;+!08,:110./+!;:5!
62:1+!*2:!/0=+!&+45!62+8@!!M<!&+45!*+!8+4&!*0620&!U@O!80/+1)!:5!"!C8@!
!
_:01+)!*062!,:110./+!9:&1+G-+&604/!2+4/62!+;;+961)"!4&3!;/09C+5!;5:8!62+!./43+1)!9:8.0&+!6:!3080&012!
10>&0;094&6/<)!4&3!+=+&!+5430946+)!62+!4.0/06<!6:!+&I:<!62+!48+&06<!:;!:&+K1!2:8+)!/:11!:;!=4/-+!:;!62+!
2:8+!061+/;)!4//!62+1+!0&95+410&>/<!I-160;04./+!;+451!84C+!,+:,/+!=+5<!*:550+3@!%&95+410&>!C&:*/+3>+!
01!3+8:&165460&>!6246!D0&3!A-5.0&+!P<&35:8+!3:+1!+7016)!4&3!+8+5>0&>!+=03+&9+!;5:8!495:11!62+!
*:5/3!3:+1!3+8:&16546+!62+!3+=416460&>!+;;+961!6246!6201!94&!24=+#@!F!16-3<!0&6:!;/09C+5!4&3!
411:90460:&!*062!,2:6:1+&1060=+!+,0/+,1<!241!5+9+&6/<!.++&!,-./012+3@!!
!
F1!;45!41!:-5!011-+1!*062!&:01+!45+!9:&9+5&+3)!=450:-1!0&=+160>460:&1!24=+!.++&!94550+3!:-6@!A2+!
k:94/!N:=+5&8+&6!g8.-3184&!241!.++&!0&=:/=+3@!!f+5!9:&9/-10:&!01!6246!62+!&:01+!,/4&&0&>!
9:&3060:&!\*2092!01!62+!148+!41)!:5!1080/45!6:)!+=+5<!:62+5!&:01+!9:&3060:&!08,:1+3!0&!62+!9:-&65<!
;:5!D0&3!`4581)!.41+3!45:-&3!RAPE?S?T()!62+!1:!94//+3!0&3-165<!164&3453]!01!kB.F'*I%08*#%-0%
"#-*(8(*-.-"0#%"11*.+'(.),*%.#$%-3'+%'#*#50(6*.),*lD%%&!:-5!941+!,/4&&0&>!9:&3060:&1!*+5+!
4,,5:=+3!.<!62+!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:546+)!*2092!01!:-6103+!62+!I-50130960:&!:;!62+!k:94/!N:=+5&8+&6!
g8.-3184&)!1:!62+!8466+5!:;!4!&:&!1,+90;09!,/4&&0&>!9:&3060:&!01!&:*!.+0&>!0&=+160>46+3!.<!62+!
i45/048+&645<!g8.-3184&@!
!!
D+!C&:*!6246!"'m!:;!4//!9-55+&6!*0&3!;4581!24=+!1:8+!&:01+!,5:./+81)!4&3!46!62+!8:8+&6!46!
/+416!Om!:;!62+!6:64/!:,+5460:&4/!&-8.+51!94-1+!,5:./+81!6246!45+!41!.43!41!:-51@!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
U#W!
f:*+=+5!&:?:&+!5+4//<!C&:*1!*2<)!:5!4,,+451!0&6+5+16+3!0&!5+1+45920&>!4&3!;0&30&>!:-6!*4<1!6:!
1:/=+!4&!011-+!*2092!9/+45/<!241!62+!94,4906<!6:!0&95+41+)!0;!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!
6:!2:8+1@!!M+94-1+!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!94&&:6!499-546+/<!,5+3096!0;!4!106+!*0//!+7,+50+&9+!
,5:./+81!*062!&:01+)!4&3!.+94-1+!RAPE?S?T()!62+!>-034&9+!-1+3!.<!MRSS!;:5!,/4&&0&>!
4,,/09460:&1!:;;+51!&:!,5:6+960:&!6:!;480/0+1)!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!12:-/3!&+=+5!.+!106+3!&+45!2:8+1@!
!
!
&"1*%.#$%10#*CD!!D+!45+!G-06+!1-5+!6246!62+!N:=+5&8+&6!241!&:!9:&9+,6!:;!62+!088+&1+!48:-&6!
:;!608+)!8:&+<!4&3!+8:60:&4/!+&+5><!+7,+&3+3!.<!=0//4>+51)!0&!62+!=090&06<!:;!+492!0&4,,5:,5046+!
4,,/09460:&@!!i+:,/+!45+!65<0&>!&:6!:&/<!6:!,5:6+96!62+!=01-4/!48+&06<!:;!62+!45+4!0&!*2092!62+<!/0=+)!
.-6!4/1:!&:6!6:!/:1+!62+!=+5<!620&>!*2092!62+<!24=+!1,+&6!62+05!/0=+1!*:5C0&>!4&3!14=0&>!;:5)!&:64./<!
4&!+&=05:&8+&6!6246!,5:8:6+1!62+!2+4/62!4&3!*+//?.+0&>!:;!;480/0+1)!41!*+//!41!62+!,+49+)!
654&G-0//06<!4&3!48+&06<!:;!62+05!2:8+1!4&3!>453+&1@!!A2+!;0&4&904/!9:16!6:!-1!1:!;45!241!.++&L!!
{"O')'''!*41!:-5!+160846+3!/:11!-,!6:!F,50/!"''j@!!g-5!2:8+!6:?34<!*:-/3!24=+!.++&!*:562!4.:-6!
{@@@!0;!06!*+5+!&:6!;:5!62+!&:01+!;5:8!62+!*0&3!;458)!.-6!F>+&61!43=01+!06!01!-&14/+4./+!.+94-1+!:;!62+!
9/:1+!,5:70806<!:;!62+!*0&3!;458@!
!
D+!24=+!.++&!0&;:58+3!6246!0&!:53+5!6:!1++C!I-30904/!2+/,!0&!5+1:/=0&>!62+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!
,://-60:&!*+!45+!1-;;+50&>)!*+!*0//!&++3!6:!4,,:0&6!+7,+561!0&!+&=05:&8+&64/!/4*)!+7,+56!
49:-160904&1!4&3!,+524,1!:62+5!+7,+561@!!D+!*:-/3!24=+!6:!5401+!;0&4&9+!0&!62+!:53+5!:;!{@@@!,/-1!.+!
4./+!6:!8++6!9:161!4*453+3!6:!62+!:62+5!103+!0;!:-5!941+!;40/1@!!A:!4&!:530&45<!EQ!;480/<!62+!
,5:1,+96!:;!54010&>!1-92!;0&4&9+!0&!4!,+51:&4/!94,4906<!01!:-6!:;!62+!G-+160:&!*2092!+;;+960=+/<!
,5+=+&61!;480/0+1!.+0&>!4./+!6:!1++C!I-30904/!2+/,!6:!5+16:5+!62+!48+&06<!:;!;480/<!/0;+@!!A201!;496!01!
9/+45/<!5+9:>&01+3!.<!62+!P646+!4&3!.0>!.-10&+11!*2:!1++8!9:8;:564./+!0&!9:&60&-0&>!6:!1-,,:56!4!
N-034&9+!\RAPE?S?T(]!*2092!62+<!C&:*!*0//!94-1+!2+4/62!4&3!;0&4&904/!0&I-5<!6:!;480/0+1!0;!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!6::!9/:1+!6:!;480/<!2:8+1)!.-6!5+640&0&>!RAPE?S?T()!41!354*&)!*0//!2+/,!62+!P646+!
4920+=+!061!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!645>+61!.-6!46!4!9:16!.:5&+!.<!0&30=03-4/!;480/0+1!*2:!24,,+&!6:!/0=+!
0&!62+!*5:&>!,/49+!46!62+!*5:&>!608+@!
!%&!:-5!+7,+50+&9+)!+492!4&60?*0&3!6-5.0&+!948,40>&!\:5!V,5:!9:88-&06<!4&3!/:94/!+&=05:&8+&6!
948,40>&K])!9:161!=0//4>+1!4.:-6!{U'')'''!0&!5+4/!6+581@!!%;!62+!8466+5!>:+1!6:!4!,-./09!0&G-05<)!62+&!
6201!48:-&6!94&!.+!650,/+3@!!A201!65+8+&3:-1!-&1++&!9:16!5+,5+1+&61!62+!/:11!:;!08,:564&6!
5+1:-59+1!6:!/:94/!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!62+!9:88-&060+1@!!H:5+:=+5)!62+1+!,5:9+11+1!4&3!0&G-050+1!4/1:!
.5++3!10>&0;094&6!30165-16)!301/0C+)!4&3!301.+/0+;!0&!62:1+!*2:!1+6!:-5!,/4&&0&>!,:/090+1)!41!84&<!
4,,+45!6:!499+,6!41!3+!;496:!62+!5+,:561!,5:3-9+3!.<!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,+51!6:!1-,,:56!62+05!
4,,/09460:&1)!*062:-6!;-562+5!0&=+160>460:&!:5!0&3+,+&3+&6!4&4/<1+1D%%%&!6:34<K1!&460:&4/!+9:&:809!
,5:./+81)!06!01!5+41:&4./+!6:!:.1+5=+!6246!/:94/!>:=+5&8+&6)!C++&!6:!14=+!:&!+7,+&306-5+!45+!
-&/0C+/<!6:!5+;-1+!62+!>54&6!:;!i/4&&0&>!i+580110:&!;:5!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0;!.<!1:!3:0&>!06!5+1-/61!0&!62+!
/:94/!4-62:506<!24=0&>!6:!;0>26!4!;0&4&904//<!+7,+&10=+!i/4&&0&>!F,,+4/@!!!
!
A2+!+8:60:&4/!30165+11!+7,+50+&9+3!.<!62+1+!;480/0+1!01)!*+!-&3+5164&3)!8055:5+3!0&!941+1!-,!4&3!
3:*&!62+!9:-&65<@!
!
!A2+!3+=+/:,+51!,+51016!.+94-1+!62+5+!01!1:!8-92!,5:;06!6:!.+!843+!*062!SgeK1@!!A2+<!+8,/:<!
.455016+51!4&3!62+05!/+>4/!6+481)!0&!433060:&!6:!4&!4554<!:;!,/4&&0&>!9:&1-/64&61)!:;6+&!;:5!+76+&3+3!
,+50:31@!!!
!
k:94/!4-62:5060+1!4&3!948,40>&!>5:-,1!165->>/+!6:!5+,5+1+&6!/:94/!9:&9+5&1!4&3!,5:6+96!
9:88-&06<!*+//?.+0&>)!+=+&!62:->2!;0&4&904/!5+1:-59+1!45+!165+692+3!4&3!16540&+3!6:!
499:88:346+!6201!,5:9+11@!!P-92!-&+G-4/!;0&4&904/!.-53+&1!84<!4/5+43<!.+!4;;+960&>!62+!4.0/06<!:;!
84&<!9:-&90/1!6:!4335+11!1-92!5+1,:&10.0/060+1@!!H4&<!*0//!.+!-&4./+!6:!;-&3!,5:,+5!3+;+&9+!:;!
3+9010:&1!625:->2!62+!F,,+4/!e:-561@!!~&<-&(+)&<-$&M&E(F#$!!
!
!
Y8$.-*%0#%-3*%=.B"+%L.1",CI%>0B*1)*(%MNJJ%
U#(!
%
A2+!;://:*0&>!,5:=03+1!4&!-,346+!:;!62+![4=01!;480/<K1!106-460:&)!*062!4!5+1:/-60:&!6:!62+05!:53+4/!
4;6+5!,5:/:&>+3!.-5+4-954609!4&3!/+>4/!.466/+1L!!4!165096/<!9:&;03+&604/!1+66/+8+&6@!!A2+05!,-51-06!:;!
;405&+11!4&3!5+9:>&060:&!:;!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!,5:./+81!46!62+05!2:8+!45+!4/1:!0&165-960:&4/!0&!
6+581!:;!62+!F452-1!e:&=+&60:&!\1++!,!U"$!:;!6201!,4,+5]@!!`480/0+1!4&3!0&30=03-4/1!3:!&:6!-1-4//<!
24=+!499+11!6:!62+!;0&4&904/!:5!,+51:&&+/!5+1:-59+1!X!&:6!6:!8+&60:&!62+!16480&4!X!5+G-05+3!6:!
,-51-+!/+&>62<!.-5+4-954609!4&3!I-30904/!,5:9++30&>1@!!
!
&*,*F(.83%%\EQ]!
!
#'!_:=+8.+5!"'UU!
!
U0'8,*%+*--,*%G"-3%G"#$%5.(1%08*(.-0(+%0B*(%o'#)*.(.),*%3'1o%
!
F!9:-,/+!24=+!1+66/+3!4!f0>2!e:-56!3484>+1!4960:&!4>40&16!62+!:*&+51!4&3!:,+546:51!:;!4!*0&3!
;458!62+<!14<!35:=+!62+8!;5:8!62+05!;4582:-1+!2:8+!*062!061!BB-&.+454./+BB!&:01+@!
!
F!I-3>+!*41!6:/3!6:34<!62+!6+581!:;!62+!1+66/+8+&6!4>5++3!.<!6+&4&6!;458+51!P4542!d4&+!4&3!d-/04&!
[4=01!*+5+!165096/<!9:&;03+&604/@!
!
A2+!9:-,/+!8:=+3!:-6!:;!N54<1!`458!0&![++,0&>!P6!_092:/41)!&+45!P,4/30&>)!k0&9:/&1205+)!0&!
[+9+8.+5!"''W!107!8:&621!4;6+5!62+!+0>26?6-5.0&+!*0&3!;458!.+>4&!:,+5460&>!4.:-6!24/;!4!80/+!
;5:8!62+05!2:8+@!
!
A2+<!./48+3!62+!BB*2::8!*2::8!*2::8BB!4&3!62+!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!BB2-8BB!:;!>04&6!6-5.0&+!./43+1!
;:5!62+05!+70/+!0&!4!941+!6246!*41!9/:1+/<!*4692+3!.<!62+!*0&3!;458!0&3-165<@!
!
A2+<!1403!62+!BB0&6:/+54./+BB!&:01+!3015-,6+3!62+05!1/++,)!843+!62+8!;++/!0//!4&3!*41!1:!1+=+5+!6246!06!
*4554&6+3!4!5+3-960:&!0&!9:-&90/!647!4&3!5+&3+5+3!62+!{"@O!80//0:&!;4582:-1+!&:!/:&>+5!
845C+64./+!41!4!;480/<!2:8+@!
!
H5!4&3!H51![4=01!*+5+!499-1+3!:;!.+0&>!BB:=+5?1+&1060=+BB!6:!62+!&:01+!4&3!BB+74>>+5460&>!4&3!
:=+55+4960&>BB@!
!
A2+!9:-,/+!/4-&92+3!4!9/408!;:5!3484>+1!4&3!4&!0&I-&960:&!4>40&16!3+;+&34&61!0&9/-30&>!`+&/4&3!
D0&3;4581!k63!4&3!`+&/4&3!N5++&!i:*+5!e:?:,+5460=+!k63@!
!
A2+!/:&>?5-&&0&>!2+450&>!*41!3-+!6:!5+1-8+!6:34<)!.-6!6504/!I-3>+!H5!d-1609+!f09C0&.:66:8!*41!
6:/3!62+!941+!*41!1+66/+3@!
!
M:62!103+1!1403!0&!4!I:0&6!,5+11!5+/+41+L!BBA2+!6+581!:;!6246!1+66/+8+&6!45+!165096/<!9:&;03+&604/)!4&3!
62+!,4560+1!*0//!&:6!.+!4&1*+50&>!4&<!G-+160:&1!4.:-6!62+!6+581!:;!6246!4>5++8+&6@BB!
A2+!941+!*41!3+1950.+3!41!.+0&>!:;!>+&+54/!08,:564&9+!.+94-1+!2-&35+31!:;!:62+5!;480/0+1!14<!
62+<!24=+!1-;;+5+3!1080/45!3016-5.4&9+!;5:8!*0&3!;4581!-,!4&3!3:*&!62+!9:-&65<@!
!
A2+!:,+546:51!*+5+!499-1+3!46!62+!16456!:;!62+!f0>2!e:-56!2+450&>!+45/0+5!6201!<+45!:;!65<0&>!6:!
08,:1+!q4!9:3+!:;!10/+&9+q!:&!62:1+!+7480&0&>!:5!5+9:530&>!62+!&:01+!62+!6-5.0&+1!94-1+3@!
!
A2+!6+581!:;!6:34<B1!1+66/+8+&6!8+4&!6246!3+640/1!:;!62+!2:*!62+!1+66/+8+&6!*41!5+492+3!*0//!
5+840&!1+95+6@!
!
A2+!I-3>+!1403!2+!243!.++&!>0=+&!4!9:,<!:;!62+!10>&+3!4>5++8+&6!?!q&:.:3<!241!1++&!06!:62+5!624&!
8+)!4&3!%!48!>0=0&>!06!.49C!6:!<:-q@!
!
D2+&!62+!941+!*41!.+;:5+!62+!9:-56!0&!d-/<)!i+6+5!f45501:&!oe)!4,,+450&>!;:5!;:58+5!&-51+!H51!
[4=01)!OO)!4&3!2+5!2-1.4&3)!$W)!6:/3!62+!I-3>+L!qD0&3!;4581!24=+!+8,246094//<!&:6!.++&!62+!1:-59+!
:;!65:-./+?;5++)!>5++&!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!*2092!62+!;0581!,5:8:60&>!4&3!,5:;060&>!;5:8!*0&3!
+&+5><!*:-/3!24=+!62+!>+&+54/!,-./09!.+/0+=+@q!
!
A2+!9:-56!2+453!5+1+4592!1->>+16+3!62+!9:8,/40&61!5+/46+!6:!62+!q48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&q!\FH]!:;!
62+!4+5:3<&4809!&:01+!;5:8!62+!6-5.0&+!./43+1!0&!9+5640&!9:&3060:&1@!
!
!
U#j!
H5!4&3!H51![4=01)!*2:!24=+!6*:!>5:*&?-,!920/35+&)!*+5+!1++C0&>!4&!0&I-&960:&!6:!.50&>!4.:-6!
8:30;09460:&!:;!62+!:,+5460:&!:;!62+!*0&3!;458)!,/-1!{$'')'''!3484>+1!6:!9:8,+&146+!62+8!;:5!62+!
&:01+!&-014&9+@!
!
H5!f45501:&!1403L!qA2+05!/0=+1!24=+!.++&!*2://<!3015-,6+3!.<!6246!&:01+@q!
!
F/6+5&460=+/<!62+!9:-,/+!41C+3!;:5!3484>+1!,/-1!4!q/0C+!;:5!/0C+q!5+,/49+8+&6!;:5!62+05!;458!2:8+!
62+<!+160846+!01!*:562!4.:-6!{"@O!80//0:&@!
!
H51![4=01!+8,24101+3!6246!2+5!*012!*41!6:!8:=+!.49C!;5:8!5+&6+3!499:88:3460:&!0&6:!2+5!2:8+@!
!
A2+!9:-,/+!1403!62+!q2:550./+q!&:01+!,5:./+8!94-1+3!.<!62+!#"';6!\U''8]!20>2!6-5.0&+1!9:-/3!.+!
5+1:/=+3!.<!5+8:=0&>!6*:!:;!62+!6-5.0&+1!4&3!/08060&>!62+!2:-51!:;!:,+5460:&!:;!4!62053@!
!
A2+05!oe!6:/3!62+!9:-56!6246)!0&16+43!:;!+7,+50+&90&>!65:-./+?;5++)!>5++&!5+&+*4./+!+&+5><!*2+&!
62+!*0&3!;458!16456+3!:,+5460:&1)!H5!4&3!H51![4=01!;49+3!q4&!0&3-165<!:,+546:5!?!4!1-.103045<!:;!
R[`!?!*2092!241!5+;-1+3!6:!49C&:*/+3>+!62+!&:01+!62+05!6-5.0&+1!84C+!4&3!62+!+;;+96!6246!241!243!
:&!62+!/0=+1!:;!62+1+!9/4084&61q@!
!
%&16+43)!62+!840&!:,+546:5!q4,,+451!6:!24=+!650+3!6:!08,:1+!4!9:3+!:;!10/+&9+!:&!62:1+!+7480&0&>!
:5!5+9:530&>!62+!&:01+!6246!62+1+!6-5.0&+1!0&!6201!/:9460:&!24=+!94-1+3q@!
!
H5!f45501:&!433+3L!q`-562+5)!46!/+416!-&60/!5+9+&6/<!*2+&!62+05!:*&!5+9:530&>1!4&3!8:&06:50&>!
24=+!;0&4//<!;:59+3!62+!3+;+&34&61!6:!49C&:*/+3>+!62+<!45+!94-10&>!,5:./+81)!62+05!4,,5:492!241!
.++&!6:!65<!4&3!12::6!62+!8+11+&>+5q@!
!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca+4562a+&=05:&8+&6ajT"O$W(ae:-,/+?1+66/+?*062?*0&3?;458?:,+546:51?:=+5?-&.+454./+?
2-8@268/!
!
!
Appendix 5.2
%
=.B"$%B%W0,".-3%
%
U#T!
L(01%P(%.#$%P(+%/',1*I%=*#%Z(00VI%>0(-3%&.G-0#I%=*B0#%
!
g-5!1+/;?.-0/6)!+&=05:&8+&64//<!/:*!08,496!2:8+!:;!#W!<+451!/0+1!4!/066/+!:=+5!UC8!3:*&*0&3!:;!62+!
,5:,:1+3![+&!M5::C!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,8+&6@!!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!P<16+81!\SRP)!P05!
S:.+56!H9F/,0&+!k63@]!,/4&1!6:!9:&165-96!T!*0&3!6-5.0&+1)!+492!U"'8!20>2)!:&!6201!5-54/)!
1+G-+16+5+3!106+@!
!
SRP!0&0604//<!9/408+3!62+!*0&3!;458!*:-/3!&:6!95+46+!4!&:01+!&-014&9+)!4!9/408!06!/46+5!8:3+546+3!6:!
95+460&>!&:!V$*(*1*"-;K!&:01+!&-014&9+@!!A2+!0&1+560:&!:;!6201!10&>/+!*:53)!B$*(*1*"-;B)!&:6!:&/<!
,5:=03+1!62+!3+=+/:,+5!*062!4!3+;+&9+!:;!V.+16!,549609+K)!.-6!4/1:!,5:=03+1!SRP!4!/::,2:/+)!*2092!
*0//!/+4=+!&+0>2.:-51!*062!/066/+!,:110.0/06<!;:5!4&<!4.46+8+&6!0&!+=+&6!:;!62+!/0C+/<!49:-1609!
0&65-10:&!;5:8!2+4/62?625+46+&0&>!&:01+!,://-60:&@!
!
%&!d4&-45<!"''W)!62+!/:94/!i/4&&0&>!F-62:506<!5+;-1+3!,+580110:&!6:!.-0/3!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!:&!
>5:-&31!6246!:8066+3!4&<!5+;+5+&9+!6:!&:01+!08,4961!:62+5!624&!4!8019:&9+0=+3!1-.80110:&!
9/4080&>!62+!3+=+/:,+5K1!,5:,:1+3!/+=+/1!:;!,5+3096+3!&:01+!0880110:&1!,+58066+3!8:5+!&:01+!46!
&0>26!624&!3-50&>!34<!608+1@!!A2+!e:-&90/K1!:.1+5=460:&)!4/.+06!9:88:&1+&1+)!*41!1-.1+G-+&6/<!
3018011+3!41!4!5462+5!4/4580&>!801-&3+5164&30&>!:;!>:=+5&8+&6!5+9:88+&3+3!_%F!>-03+/0&+1@!!
RAPE?S?T()!62+!3:9-8+&6!5+/0+3!-,:&!.<!3+9010:&!84C+51!4&3!62+!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:546+)!*41!
-&0G-+/<!3+=01+3!1,+90;094//<!6:!4//:*!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,8+&6!4&3!8:5+!&:01+!8-92!9/:1+5!6:!
2-84&!24.06460:&!624&!4&<!9:&=+&60:&4/!0&3-16504/!&:01+!08,496!411+118+&6!,5:9+3-5+!9:-/3!
,+5806@!
!
F1!4!&+0>2.:-5!:;!62+!,5:,:1+3!106+)!8<!9:&9+5&!4/1:!;:9-1+3!:&!4&!49:-1609!,2+&:8+&:&!C&:*&!
41!48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&!ZFHc)!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!6246!SRP!\P05!S:.+56!H9F/,0&+!k63]!4&3)!
0&3++3)!62+!*0&3!0&3-165<!0&!>+&+54/)!+062+5!3+&<!41!4!,:110.0/06<!:5!80&0801+!061!08,496!:&!
5+103+&61!/0=0&>!&+45!:,+5460&>!*0&3!;4581!6246!+806!FH@!!e:&1+G-+&6/<)!62+!:99-55+&9+!:;!FH!
9:&60&-+1!6:!/49C!+8,05094/!;0+/3!5+1+4592!3+1,06+!+=+5!0&95+410&>!5+,:561!6+160;<0&>!6:!4&3!
3+8:&165460&>!061!:99-55+&9+!4&3!061!43=+51+!08,496!:&!,+:,/+B1!*+//?.+0&>@!!
!
A2-1)!62+!433060:&!:;!62+!*:53!B$*(*1*"-;B!.<!SRP!95+46+3!8:5+!4/458@!!D0&3!6-5.0&+!2+0>261!&:*!
;45!+79++3!62:1+!3+1950.+3!0&!RAPE?S?T(!\,-./012+3!0&!UTT(])!4,,5:4920&>!4&3!+=+&!+79++30&>!
U"O8!20>2@!!A2-1)!62+!5:6460:&!4&3!.5+4362!:;!62+!./43+1!5+492!;-562+5!0&6:!62+!=45<0&>!
9245496+5016091!:;!468:1,2+509!/4<+50&>!&:6!9:&103+5+3!0&!UTT()!62:->2!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!2+0>26!
4&3!+76+&6!:;!62+!./43+!1*++,!45+!&:*!*03+/<!62:->26!6:!.+!4!3+;0&0&>!;496:5!/+430&>!6:!62+!08,4961!
:;!FH!&:01+@!
!
F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!:;!62+!4+5:3<&4809!&:01+!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!\FH]!01!1080/45/<!5+,+6060=+!
.-6!845>0&4//<!41<&925:&:-1!*062!2-84&!2+456!52<6281h!4!3++,/<!05506460&>!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!01!
543046+3)!:;6+&!9:8,45+3!6:!62+!350,,0&>!64,!6:56-5+!6+92&0G-+1!1:8+608+1!-60/01+3!.<!*45608+!
0&6+55:>46:51@!!A2+1+!64//+5!0&3-16504/!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!95+46+!FH!6246!;40/1!6:!466+&-46+!0&!62+!148+!
*4<!41!62+!/0806+3!1,+965-8!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!9:&103+5+3!*0620&!62+!RAPE?S?T(!>-03+/0&+1@!!
FH!94&!4;;+96!8-92!/45>+5!>5:-&3!45+41!1-55:-&30&>!*0&3!;4581!624&!62+!>:=+5&8+&6!4&3!*0&3!
0&3-165<!9-55+&6/<!49C&:*/+3>+@!
!
%&3+,+&3+&6!4&3!08,45604/!49:-1609!+7,+561)!1-92!41!HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/!
266,Laa***@841+&=@9:@-Ca&:01+)!24=+!,/49+3!5+,:561!:&!62+!,-./09!5+9:53!6246!3+640/!4/4580&>!
8+41-5+3!/+=+/1!:;!FH!8:5+!624&!UC8!;5:8!&-8+5:-1!8:3+5&!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4554<1@!!F&3!<+6)!
1+,45460:&!30164&9+1!:;!/+11!624&!O''!8+65+1!.+6*++&!62+!&+45+16!*0&3!6-5.0&+!6:!4!;480/<!2:8+!
9:&60&-+!6:!.+!,5:,:1+3!.<!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,+51)!4&3)!,+524,1!8:5+!*:55<0&>/<)!4,,+45!
499+,64./+!6:!3+9010:&!84C+51@!!F1!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!9:&165-96+3!&+45!,+:,/+B1!2:8+1)!62+!
FH!,2+&:8+&:&!01!0&95+410&>/<!3+=416460&>!84&<!,+:,/+B1!/0=+1)!*062!&-8+5:-1!5+,:561!:;!
3015-,60:&!;5:8!45:-&3!62+!*:5/3h!30165+110&>/<)!84&<!;480/0+1!45+!/+;6!*062!&:!:62+5!:,60:&!4&3!
;:59+3!6:!=4946+!62+05!2:8+1!0&!:53+5!6:!5+9:=+5!62+05!*+//?.+0&>!4&3!62+05!30>&06<)!+=+&!62:->2!
62+<!84<!+&3-5+!1+50:-1!;0&4&904/!14950;09+1@!
!
!
U$'!
`:5!8<!,456)!%!24=+!1,+452+43+3!4!/+&>62<!948,40>&!*062!62+![+&!M5::C!d-30904/!S+=0+*!N5:-,!
\[MdSN]!408+3!46!4335+110&>!62+!FH!,5:./+8!625:->2!924//+&>0&>!12:56;4//1!*0620&!62+!
3+=+/:,+5B1!_%F)!4&3!+55:51!*0620&!-&/4*;-/!3+9010:&1!.<!62:1+!1++80&>/<!165->>/0&>!*062!62+!
9:&;-10:&!4&3!801-&3+5164&30&>1!95+46+3!.<!62+!30;;09-/6!9:8,/+7060+1!4&3!6+92&094/!&46-5+!:;!62+!
,5:./+8)!4&3!62+!;496!6246!RAPE?S?T(!01!&:!/:&>+5!V;06!;:5!,-5,:1+K!41!4!&:01+!>-03+!;:5!8:3+5&!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1@!
!
%&!/0&+!*062!62+!=0+*1!:;!S6@!f:&@!d-3>+!H0660&>!\f-/8+!=!P+95+645<!:;!P646+)!ega"$$Ta"''(!P@(h!
266,Laa***@5092453.-76:&@9:@-Ca=#@'a&:3+a#O'])!8<!+;;:561!24=+!+&9:-&6+5+3)!48:&>16!:62+51)!
-&*4554&6+3!*0622:/30&>!:;!=064/!+=03+&9+!.<!62+!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,+5@!!SRP!\P05!S:.+56!H9F/,0&+!
k63])!5+;-1+3!;:5!8:5+!624&!6*:!<+451!6:!,5:=03+!62+!3464!;:5!0&3+,+&3+&6!4&4/<101!:;!62+!54*!&:01+!
4&3!*0&3!1,++3!3464!9://+96+3!.<!62+8!46!8<!,5:,+56<@!!F6!2->+!,+51:&4/!+7,+&1+)!4&3!*062!
3:&460:&1!;5:8!/:94/!;480/0+1!4&3!,+:,/+!&460:&*03+)!*+!24=+!;:->26!625:->2!6*:!i-./09!%&G-050+1)!
*2+5+!&:01+!*41!+7480&+3!;:5!:&/<!24/;!4&!2:-5!46!62+!;0516!4&3!62+&!;:-5!34<1!3-50&>!62+!/466+5h!
4&3!6*:!f0>2!e:-56!d-30904/!S+=0+*1)!;://:*+3!.<!6*:!9:55+1,:&30&>!4,,+4/1!625:->2!62+!e:-56!:;!
F,,+4/@!
!
g-5!1+4592!;:5!62+!.4109!,5:6+960:&!:;!:-5!30>&06<!4&3!;:5!8<!;480/<!.+0&>!4./+!6:!1/++,!46!&0>26!
5://1!:&@!![MSN!&++3+3!6:!5401+!0&!62+!5+>0:&!:;!{$')'''!;5:8!,50=46+!3:&460:&1)!4&3!8<!:*&!
,+51:&4/!/:11!0&!0&9:8+!8-16!&:*!.+!*+//!0&!+79+11!:;!{(')'''@!!A2+1+!;0>-5+1)!4/62:->2!2->+!
48:-&61!;:5!0&30=03-4/1!4&3!9:88-&06<!>5:-,1)!5+,5+1+&6!&:6!:&/<!62+!*0//!:;!4!9:88-&06<!6:!
,5:6+96!061+/;!;5:8!0&4,,5:,5046+!0&3-16504/!3+=+/:,8+&6)!06!01!4/1:!4!8+5+!,0664&9+!9:8,45+3!6:!62+!
VN:/0462K!5+1:-59+1!+7,+&3+3!.<!*0&3!;458!3+=+/:,+51!0&!,-51-06!:;!,/4&&0&>!4,,5:=4/h!62+!05:&<!
.+0&>!6246!9:161!6:!62+!3+=+/:,+51!45+!1-.1+G-+&6/<!,403!.<!62+!-&1,+90;0+3!1-.1030+1!08,:1+3!:&!
4//!:-5!+/+9650906<!.0//1@!
!
%!24=+!.++&!9:8,+//+3!6:!5+?8:56>4>+!:-5!2:8+!*2092!*41!6:!24=+!.++&!5+/0+3!-,:&!;:5!:-5!
,+&10:&@!!H:5+:=+5)!8<!608+!3+=:6+3!6:!0&9:8+!>+&+5460&>!.-10&+11!4960=060+1!241!.++&!1+=+5+/<!
9-5640/+3@!!A2+!4//!9:&1-80&>!2453!*:5C!4&3!5+1+4592!45+!+11+&604/!5+G-05+8+&61!;:5!1++C0&>!
I-1609+)!*2092!4,,+451!+=+5!8:5+!+/-10=+@!
!
p+16+3!0&6+5+161!62*456!:-5!+;;:561!+=+5<!16+,!:;!62+!*4<@!!F&!-&,5+9+3+&6+3!.-6)!4/41)!08,5+901+/<!
*:53+3!R79+11!F8,/06-3+!H:3-/460:&!\RFH]!&:01+!9:&3060:&!*:&!;5:8!62+!/416!i-./09!%&G-05<!*41!
3+1950.+3!.<!62+!3+=+/:,+5B1!43=:946+!41!/0C+/<!6:!3+=41646+!62+!EQK1!*0&3!;458!0&3-165<@!!F6!62+!
608+!:;!*5060&>)!SRP!\P05!S:.+56!H9F/,0&+!k63]!01!9-55+&6/<!+&>4>+3!0&!466+8,61!6:!3:*&10Y+!62+!
,4548+6+51!1+6!:-6!;:5!RFH!*0620&!62+!08,:1+3!&:01+!9:&3060:&@!!SRP!01!62-1!65<0&>!6:!>40&!9:&1+&6!
;:5!0&;/0960&>!>5+46+5!&:01+!08,4961!:&!&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1!624&!*41!9/+45/<!0&6+&3+3!.<!62+!
%&1,+96:5@!
!
F1!62+![+&!M5::C!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:5!9:&9/-3+3)!4/62:->2!FH!01!1:8+*246!-&,5+30964./+)!06!01!4!
30160&96!,:110.0/06<@!!R=+&!0;!6246!01!&:6!+&605+/<!62+!941+)!62+!9-55+&6!49:-16094/!8+62:3:/:><!;:5!
411+110&>!4&3!,5+30960&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!6246!84<!3484>+!:&+B1!2+4/62!5+840&1)!46!.+16)!:=+5/<!
>+&+54/0Y+3!4&3!0&499-546+h!46!*:516)!06!01!3++,/<!;/4*+3@!!%&!6201!9:&6+76)![MdSN!1++C1!:&/<!6246!62+!
Vi5+94-60:&45<!i50&90,/+K!.+!,5:,+5/<!0&=:C+3!4&3!4,,/0+3)!1:!6246!:530&45<!;480/0+1!45+!3-/<!
,5:6+96+3!*2+&!:&12:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+=+/:,8+&61!45+!,5:8:6+3!.<!4&!0&3-165<!*+//?=+51+3!0&!
62+!456!:;!18:C+!4&3!8055:51@!
!
H0C+!f-/8+!
!
!
!
!
!
!
"W!d4&-45<!"'UU!!
[+&!M5::C!d-30904/!S+=0+*!N5:-,!
***@3+&.5::C=4//+<@9:@-C!!
!
Conclusions
U$U!
!
A2+!+7,+50+&9+1!:;!;480/0+1!0&6+5&460:&4//<!12:*!9:&9/-10=+/<!6246!*2+&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!0&!
,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1)!62+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!,://-60:&!43=+51+/<!08,4961!:&!,+:,/+K1!2+4/62@!!!
!
D0&3!6-5.0&+1!+806!&:01+!*062!84&<!9245496+5016091!X!,-/1460&>!&:01+)!0&6+58066+&9<)!6:&4/!
G-4/060+1)!48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&)!4&3!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+!X!*2092!10&>/<!:5!0&!9:8.0&460:&!8+506!
1,+904/!466+&60:&!4&3!/08061!.+94-1+!:;!:.1+5=+3)!-&*4&6+3!08,4961!:&!2+4/62)!499:530&>!6:!62+!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&K1!>-03+/0&+1@!
!
A2+1+!;0&30&>1!45+!5+;/+96+3!4/1:!0&!62+!,0/:6!16-30+1!9:&3-96+3!3-50&>!62+!,416!;+*!<+451!.<!
,2<10904&1!0&!62+!EQ)!62+!EPF)!4&3!F-1654/04)!*2+5+!5+1-/61!0&30946+3!6246!;480/0+1!45+!1-;;+50&>!
=450:-1!3+>5++1!:;!&+>460=+!2+4/62!4&3!1/++,!011-+1!.+94-1+!:;!+&=05:&8+&6!&:01+!;5:8!*0&3!
6-5.0&+1@!!
!
[+1,06+!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!16-30+1!6246!3+8:&16546+!4!5+/460:&120,!.+6*++&!62+!43=+51+!
08,4961!:;!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!:&!2+4/62)!1:8+!>:=+5&8+&61!X!0&9/-30&>!6246!:;!62+!EQ!X!24=+!
0&16+43!:,6+3!6:!;://:*!62+!43=09+!:;!49:-1609!+&>0&++51!;5:8!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<@!!A201!
4,,5:492!;4=:-51!0&3-16504/!3+=+/:,8+&6)!9:&165-960&>!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!0&!,5:70806<!6:!2:8+1!4&3!
:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1)!6:!62+!3+6508+&6!:;!62+!,-./09!2+4/62@!
!
F/62:->2!49:-1609!+&>0&++51!4&3!+&>0&++51!0&=:/=+3!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!3+10>&!49C&:*/+3>+!6246!
,5+30960&>!49:-1609!5430460:&!;5:8!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!01!08,5+901+)!*062!=4504./+!4&3!:;6+&!3:-.6;-/!
5+1-/61)!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6!9:&60&-+1!6:!;:16+5!1+/;?5+>-/460:&!.<!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<@!!A201!
241!/+3!6:!62+!9-55+&6!106-460:&)!*062!0&43+G-46+!164&34531!:;!,5:6+960:&!;5:8!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!
,://-60:&!;:5!&+0>2.:-50&>!;480/0+1@!
!
F1!>:=+5&8+&61!+&9:-54>+3!8:5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!0&164//460:&1)!4&3!*062!8:5+!9:&165-96+3!&+45!
2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1!.+94-1+!:;!0&43+G-46+!>-034&9+)!9:8,/40&61!4.:-6!&:01+!0&95+41+3@!!
P+=+54/!>:=+5&8+&61!24=+!5+1,:&3+3!4&3!5+9+&6/<!08,:1+3!165096+5!5+>-/460:&!:&!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!
0&3-165<!4;6+5!411+110&>!9:88-&06<!4&3!;480/<!9:8,/40&61!4&3!2+4/62!011-+1)!41!*+//!41!.<!
411+110&>!9-55+&6!+=03+&9+?.41+3!5+1+4592!4&3!5+,:561!:&!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!4&3!061!0&I-50+1!6:!
2+4/62L!![+&845C!/:*+5+3!4//:*4./+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!+80110:&1)!0&9/-30&>!165096+5!5+>-/460:&!:&!
/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+)!.:62!:-6103+!4&3!0&103+!2:8+1!4&3!:62+5!;490/060+1!4&3!45+41!
\266,Laa***@816@3CaR&>/012a`:9-1r45+41a/:*r;5+G-+&9<r&:01+r;5:8r*0&3r6-5.0&+1r`Fo@268]h!
62+!P646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!p096:504)!F-1654/04)!0&95+41+3!1+6?.49C!30164&9+1!6:!4!80&08-8!:;!"C8!
.+6*++&!4!*0&3!6-5.0&+!4&3!4!5+103+&9+h!4&3!d4,4&!241!0&06046+3!4&!+,03+80:/:>094/!16-3<!:;!62+!
08,4961!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!:&!,+:,/+@!ZP646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!p096:504@!!D0&3!R&+5><!`490/060+1)!
F8+&38+&6!pej"@%%[+,4568+&6!:;!i/4&&0&>!4&3!e:88-&06<![+=+/:,8+&6)!P646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!
p096:504)!F-1654/04)!"T!F->-16!"'UU@c!
!
!
H:5+:=+5)!62+!Dfg!5+,:561!X!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+)!_0>26!_:01+!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!R-5:,+)!
4&3!62+!M-53+&!:;![01+41+!;5:8!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+)!4/:&>!*062!+=03+&9+?.41+3!8+3094/!5+1+4592!
;0&30&>1)!0&30946+!6246!62+!0&4-30./+!+;;+961!:;!&:01+!\+@>@)!/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+])!41!*+//!41!62+!
4-30./+)!84<!24=+!10>&0;094&6!08,4961!:&!,+:,/+@!!e-55+&6!EQ!>-034&9+!01!&:6!:&/<!:-6?346+3)!06!3:+1!
&:6!0&9/-3+!62+1+!5+9+&6!>-03+/0&+1!;5:8!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&@!!%&3++3)!EQ!>-034&9+!3:+1!
&:6!0&9:5,:546+!8+62:31!6246!5+;/+96!2:*!2-84&1!,+59+0=+!4&3!5+496!6:!1:-&31!4&3!&:01+)!
+1,+904//<!3:1+?+7,:1-5+?5+1,:&1+!5+/460:&120,1@!!A2+1+!24=+!4!5+/460:&120,!6:!2:*!&:01+!4;;+961!
2+4/62!4&3!1/++,!4&3!4!1+&1+!:;!*+//?.+0&>@!
!
`-562+58:5+)!.+94-1+!62+!EQ!N:=+5&8+&6)!625:->2!061!4>+&90+1)!80&016+51)!4&3!90=0/!1+5=4&61)!01!
4*45+!:;!011-+1!*062!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!>-034&9+)!62+5+!45+!,:6+&604/!2-84&!50>261!=0:/460:&1)!
.+94-1+!62:1+!*062!2+4/62!9:8,/40&61!4,,45+&6/<!5+/46+3!6:!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!9:&165-96+3!0&!
,5:70806<!6:!62+05!2:8+1!24=+!.++&!0>&:5+3!0&!62+05!+;;:561!6:!1++C!924&>+1)!9:&65:/1)!:5!5+35+11@!!
`-562+58:5+)!5+9+&6!EQ!i/4&&0&>!k+>01/460:&!9/:1+3!4!5:-6+!6246!243!.++&!4=40/4./+!6:!:530&45<!
;480/0+1!1++C0&>!5+9:-51+!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!62+81+/=+1!;5:8!+&=05:&8+&64/!,://-60:&@!_:01+!
9:&3060:&1!45+!-&*0+/3<)!4&3!30;;09-/6!4&3!+7,+&10=+!6:!+&;:59+h!62-1)!,+:,/+!45+!+7,:1+3!6:!
-&5+80660&>!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+)!*062!62+!9:&1+G-+&6!0&I-50+1!6:!2+4/62!4&3!/:11!:;!48+&06<)!
625:->2!&:!;4-/61!:;!62+05!:*&@!
!
!
U$"!
H+4&*20/+)!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!5+,:561!4&3!8+3094/!+=03+&9+!:;;+5!8+62:31!4&3!
>-034&9+!6246!3+4/!+;;+960=+/<!*062!0&3-16504/!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!4&3!:;;+5!4!3+>5++!:;!,5:6+960:&!
6:!62+!,-./09K1!2+4/62)!0;!N:=+5&8+&6!*:-/3!92::1+!6:!5+1,:&3!6:!62+!190+&9+!:;!62+!8466+5)!5462+5!
624&!6:!,:/06094/!4&3!+9:&:809!+7,+30+&9<@!
!
Recommendations%
!
U$#!
F/62:->2!62+!-&3+5/<0&>!8+924&0181!45+!&:6!<+6!;-//<!-&3+516::3)!*2+&!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!45+!.-0/6!
&+45!2:8+1)!06!01!-&3+&04./+!6246!62+05!&:01+!94-1+1!4!9:&16+//460:&!:;!-&*+/9:8+!+;;+961)!*062!
=45<0&>!3+>5++1)!:&!2+4/62)!1/++,)!4&3!2+4/62!G-4/06<!:;!/0;+@!
!
`-562+5!16-3<!84<!5+=+4/!62+!94-1+a+;;+96)!3:1+a+7,:1-5+!5+/460:&120,1)!.-6!41!62+1+!45+!
-&3+6+580&+3)!62+!,5+94-60:&45<!,50&90,/+!12:-/3!4,,/<!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!62+!,-./09!2+4/62@!!
i5+=+&60=+!,5:4960=+!,:/09<!;-&960:&1!6:!,5+1+5=+!62+!,-./09K1!2+4/62)!*2+5+41!5+4960=+!,4//0460=+!
5+1,:&1+1!45+!:;6+&!0&43+G-46+)!&:6!6:!8+&60:&)!6::!/46+@!
!
F/62:->2!>:=+5&8+&6!4>+&90+1!4&3!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!0&3-165<!4&3!62+05!9:&1-/64&61!9:&6+&3!6246!
62+!43=+51+!2+4/62!+;;+961!45+!9:&I+96-5+!:5!&+>/0>0./+!:5!V8+5+K!4&&:<4&9+)!:&+!84<!4/1:!45>-+!
6246!62+05!94/9-/460:&1!45+!.41+3!:&!8:3+/1!6246!84C+!-&,5:=+&!,5+1-8,60:&1!4.:-6!*246!1:-&31!
45+!:5!45+!&:6!4&&:<0&>!6:!,+:,/+@!!D0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!94/9-/460:&1!*+5+!&:6!6+16+3!:&!1-.I+961!0&!
;0+/3!16-3<!19+&450:1@!!`-562+58:5+)!/+430&>!49:-160904&1!3014>5++!:&!62+!8+62:3:/:>0+1!6:!
8+41-5+)!4&4/<1+)!,5+3096)!4&3!,5+=+&6!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!e-55+&6!>-03+/0&+1!5+/<!:&!94/9-/460:&1!
6246!45+!.41+3!:&!=4504./+1!6246!5+1-/6!0&!08,5+901+!4&3!0&499-546+!,5+30960:&1!:;!496-4/!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!4&3!2:*!,+:,/+!/0=0&>!&+45.<!,+59+0=+!62+!&:01+@!!!
!
A2+5+;:5+)!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!12:-/3!&:6!.+!106+3!&+45!2:8+1!9:88-&060+1)!:5!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1)!
+@>@)!192::/1!4&3!5+103+&604/!2:8+1!;:5!1,+904/!,:,-/460:&1)!1-92!41!62+!925:&094//<!0//!4>+3@!!A2+!
,5+94-60:&45<!,50&90,4/!12:-/3!4,,/<@!
!
A2+!>-034&9+!;:5!4&3!62+!8+62:3:/:><!6:!8+41-5+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!12:-/3!.+!16540>26;:5*453!
4&3!+410/<!4,,/0+3!.<!/:94/!,/4&&0&>!4-62:5060+1!4&3!+&=05:&8+&64/!2+4/62!:;;09+51)!4&3!X!
08,:564&6/<!X!+&;:59+4./+!.<!62+8!*062:-6!3+/4<1@!![+&845C!241!0&65:3-9+3!>-03+/0&+1!;:5!*0&3!
6-5.0&+!&:01+!6246!5+3-9+1!,5+=0:-1!4//:*4./+!/+=+/1h!&:01+!8-16!&:*!5+840&!.+/:*!/08061!.:62!
0&3::51!4&3!:-63::51)!4&3!62+!>-034&9+!0&9/-3+1!4-30./+!&:01+!41!*+//!41!0&4-30./+!&:01+)!1-92!41!
/:*!;5+G-+&9<!&:01+@!![+&845CK1!>-034&9+!4/1:!49C&:*/+3>+1!6246!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+!3:+1!&:6!
841C!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+@!!A2+5+;:5+)!.49C>5:-&3!&:01+!01!&:6!4!.4101!;:5!1+660&>!4-30./+!&:01+!
/+=+/1@!!A2+1+!164&34531!9:8,/<!*062!62+!Dfg!5+,:561!4&3!62+05!;0&30&>1h!62+!EQ!12:-/3!3:!&:!/+11@!
!
A2+!3MF!8+41-5+!&:01+!;5:8!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+\1]!12:-/3!&:6!+79++3!/+=+/1!0&!62+!.+35::8!46!&0>26!
*062!62+!*0&3:*!,456/<!:,+&)!:;!&:6!8:5+!624&!#'3MF!kF847)!&:5!*0620&!48+&06<!45+41!45:-&3!
62+!2:8+!*2+5+!62+!/0806!*0//!.+!k!&0>26)!:-6103+)!#'3MF)!:5!41!,5+1950.+3!.<!62+!D:5/3!f+4/62!
g5>4&0Y460:&K1!5+1+4592!-,346+1!:&!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+@!
!
S+>4530&>!48,/06-3+!8:3-/460:&!\FH])!62+!>-034&9+!8-16!&:6!+79++3!62+!,4548+6+51!1+6!0&!
i/4&&0&>!F,,+4/![+9010:&!FiiaoUUO#aFa'Wa"'U(UW#)!P@"'L!
!
“20.a. A change in the measured LAeq, 125 milliseconds turbine noise
level of more than 3dB (represented as a rise and fall in sound energy
levels each of more than 3dB) occurring within a 2 second period.
20.b. The change identified in (a) above shall not occur less than 5 times
in any one minute period provided the LAeq, 1 minute turbine sound
energy level for that minute is not below 28dB.
20.c. The changes identified in (a) and (b) above shall not occur for fewer
than 6 minutes in any hour.”
[See Hulme, APP/Q1153/A/06/2017163]
!
i-./09!2+4/62!,:/09<!;:5!62+!+&=05:&8+&64/!&:01+!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!12:-/3!/0&C!305+96/<!6:!62+!Re!
R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+![05+960=+)!4&3!62+!Dfg!N-03+/0&+1!;:5!e:88-&06<!_:01+)!_0>26!_:01+!
N-03+/0&+1!;:5!R-5:,+)!4&3!62+!M-53+&!:;![01+41+!;5:8!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+@!!A2+1+!45+!5+,:561!.<!
0&3+,+&3+&6)!0&6+5&460:&4/)!8-/6030190,/0&45<!,4&+/1!*062!+7,+5601+!0&!62+05!;0+/31@!!F1!>-034&9+!01!
-,346+3)!&460:&4/!>-034&9+!12:-/3!924&>+!6:!5+;/+96!9-55+&6!C&:*/+3>+!4&3!,549609+@!
!
A:!+=4/-46+!62+1+!>-03+/0&+1!4&3!62+05!08,/+8+&6460:&!;:5!&460:&4/!4,,/09460:&)!62+!EQ!
N:=+5&8+&6!12:-/3!+8,4&+/!4&!0&3+,+&3+&6!9:88066++)!.41+3!:&!62+!Dfg!8:3+/)!0@+@)!9:8,501+3!
U$$!
!
:;!8+3094/!+7,+561!0&3+,+&3+&6!:;!62+!*0&3!0&3-165<)!0&!1/++,!8+3090&+)!,2<10:/:><)!
,1<92:49:-16091)!4&3!+,03+80:/:><)!4&3!6:!9:&1-/6!*062!49:-160904&1!41!3++8+3!&+9+1145<@!!
F/62:->2!49:-160904&1!:5!8+3094/!+7,+561!*:5C0&>!*0620&!:5!41!9:&1-/64&61!6:!62+!*0&3!+&+5><!
0&3-165<!*:-/3!.+!*+/9:8+!6:!1-.806!9:88+&61)!62+<!*:-/3!24=+!6:!5+9-1+!62+81+/=+1!;5:8!
,456090,460:&!0&!3+=010&>!>-034&9+!4&3!8+62:31@!A2+!,4&+/!12:-/3!.+!/+3!.<!62+!i-./09!f+4/62!
3+,4568+&6!:;!P646+)!&:6!.<!4&!4>+&9<!1-92!41![Ree)!*2:1+!:.I+960=+1!30;;+5!;5:8!62:1+!
3+,4568+&61!*2:1+!,50845<!:.I+960=+1!45+!2+4/62!,5:6+960:&!4&3!301+41+!,5+=+&60:&@!
!
M+94-1+!,5+30960:&!:;!*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!01!4&!-&9+5640&!,5:9+11)!62+!,50&90,/+1!*0620&!k:53!S+4<K1!
.0//)!xD0&3!A-5.0&+!H0&08-8![0164&9+1!;5:8!S+103+&604/!i5+801+1y)!,5+1+&6+3!6:!62+!f:-1+!:;!
k:531)!12:-/3!.+!43:,6+3!41!4!8466+5!:;!-5>+&9<)!.-6!*062!62+1+!5+3-9+3!1+6?.49C1)!*2092!
499:88:346+!8:5+!5+9+&6!5+1+4592!4&3!>-034&9+)!+@>@)!62+![4&012!RiF!>-034&9+!"'UU)!62+!P646+!:;!
p096:504)!F-1654/04!>-034&9+)!4&3!62+!Dfg!M-53+&!:;![01+41+!;5:8!R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+!"'UU@!
!
!
!
!"#$%-'()"#*%3*"F3-+%% %
%%%%%%e-0%),.$*%-"8f%
%
%
%
@*-T).6V%)*-G**#%#*.(*+-%
(*+"$*#6*%-0%-3*%G"#$%-'()"#*%
!-,!6:!!!!!"O8!
!
!"O8!!!X!#O8!
!
!#O8!X!U''8! !
N5+46+5!624&!U''8!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
UC8!
U@OC8!
"C8!
#C8!
[Lord Reay. Wind Turbines (Minimum Distances from Residential Premises) Bill [HL] 201011 http://services.parliament.uk/bills/201011/windturbinesminimumdistancesfromresidentialpremiseshl.html]
!
A2+1+!12:-/3!.+!9:&103+5+3!80&08-8!1+6.49C!30164&9+1!3+,+&30&>!-,:&)!+@>@)!/:94/!6+5540&)!62+!
10Y+!:;!62+!4554<)!6+5540&)!./43+!;/09C+5)!4&3!4>509-/6-54/!4&3!9:88-&06<!&++31@!!F1!,456!:;!62+!
4,,/09460:&!,5:9+11)!&:01+!.49C>5:-&3!/+=+/1!12:-/3!4/1:!.+!8+41-5+3!0&3::51)!0&!5::81!-1+3!.<!
;480/0+1!:5!:62+5!1+&1060=+!;490/060+1)!+@>@!62+!10660&>a/0=0&>!5::8)!:62+5!9:88-&4/!5::81)!62+!16-3<)!
41!*+//!41!.+35::81)!*062!62+!*0&3:*!:;!6246!5::8!:,+&@%
!!
e:8,/04&9+!6+160&>!4&3!+&;:59+8+&6!:;!9:&3060:&1!45+!+11+&604/h!06!01!9:88:&!,549609+!0&!0&3-16504/!
106-460:&1@!!A201!01!=064/!.+94-1+!&:01+!,5+30960:&!84<!&++3!5+94/9-/460:&@!!A2+!2:-51!:;!:,+5460:&!
84<!5+G-05+!/08061!:5!,:110./<!12-63:*&!3-50&>!62+!&0>26!:5!0&!9+5640&!8+6+:5:/:>094/!9:&3060:&1@!!
!
g&>:0&>!9:8,/04&9+!*062!>-034&9+!4&3!9:&3060:&1!01!62+!5+1,:&10.0/06<!:;!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!:*&+51@!!
F!*4554&6<!12:-/3!.+!,5:=03+3!6:!62+!/:94/!4-62:506<!6246!9+560;0+1!6246!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!*0//!&:6!
+79++3!62+!,5+1950.+3!&:01+!0880110:&!/+=+/1@!!%;!62+!6-5.0&+!&:01+!+79++31!62+!4//:*4./+!/0806)!62+&!
62+!*0&3!+&+5><!9:8,4&<!8-16!9/:1+!3:*&!62+!106+!-&60/!62+!R&=05:&8+&64/!f+4/62!g;;09+5!
4,,5:=+1!4!,/4&!;:5!48+/0:5460:&!6246!*0//!8:16!/0C+/<!8++6!62+!:50>0&4/!9:&3060:&1@!!F/6+5&460=+/<)!
62+!3+=+/:,+5!84<!4554&>+!6:!,-59241+!4//!&+0>2.:-50&>!,5:,+560+1!+7,:1+3!6:!62+!+&=05:&8+&64/!
&:01+!,://-60:&)!46!62+05!;405!845C+6!=4/-+!,50:5!6:!62+!*0&3!6-5.0&+!192+8+)!,/-1!9:8,+&1460:&!;:5!
8:=0&>!2:8+@!
!
A2+!/:94/!4-62:506<!8-16!4/1:!499+,6!5+1,:&10.0/06<!6:!0&=+160>46+!&:01+!9:8,/40&61@!
!
A:!5+06+546+)!62+!,5+94-60:&45<!,50&90,/+!12:-/3!,5+=40/@!!R062+5!/:946+!*0&3!6-5.0&+1!;-562+5!4*4<!
;5:8!2:8+1!4&3!9:88-&060+1)!:5!0&=:C+!4!8:546:50-8)!0&!:53+5!6:!,5:6+96!62+!,-./09K1!2+4/62@!!A2+!
,:/09<!4&3!62+!,549609+!12:-/3!.+!,5:4960=+)!&:6!5+4960=+@!
!
!
!
!
L"(+-I%=0%>0%/.(1!
!
!!
Bibliography
!
!
U$O!
i/+41+!&:6+L!!!
%6+81!:&/0&+!*+5+!499+11+3!*0620&!62+!,416!107!8:&621)!*062!:&/<!1+=+54/!+79+,60:&1@!!D+.106+1!45920=+!
846+504/!:5!924&>+!/0&C1!499:530&>!6:!62+05!:*&!>-03+/0&+1!4&3!94,4906<h!1:8+!106+1!:5!/0&C1!84<!.+!
3+;-&96@!!A2+5+;:5+)!9-55+&6!499+11!94&&:6!.+!>-454&6++3!.<!62+!4-62:51@!!P:8+!846+504/1!45+!4=40/4./+!
:&/0&+!.-6!5+G-05+!4!;++!6:!499+11h!/0.5450+1!45+!4&!+79+//+&6!5+1:-59+!;:5!62+1+!846+504/1@!!A2+!
.0./0:>54,2<!0&9/-3+1!06+81!0&!62+!6+76h!433060:&4/!5+;+5+&9+1!&:6+3!0&!4,,+&309+1!46!62+!+&3!:;!+492!
924,6+5@!
!
H:5+:=+5)!1:8+!=+5<!*:562*20/+!5+,:561!4&3!3:9-8+&6460:&!45+!&:6!0&9/-3+3!0&!62+!,4,+5!4&3!62+!
.0./0:>54,2<@!!A201!0&!&:!*4<!3080&012+1!62+05!08,:564&9+!0&!+3-9460&>!-1!;-562+5!4.:-6!62+!+;;+961!:;!
*0&3!6-5.0&+!&:01+!:&!2+4/62h!62+5+!*+5+!/0806460:&1!:&!62+!48:-&6!:;!846+504/!*+!*+5+!4./+!6:!
0&9/-3+@!f:*+=+5)!84&<!:;!62+!06+81!0&!62+!.0./0:>54,2<!*0//!/+43!<:-!6:!62+1+!433060:&4/!5+1:-59+1@!!
!
!
;.(3'+%U0#B*#-"0#L%
U0#B*#-"0#%0#%;66*++%-0%X#50(1.-"0#I%7'),"6%7.(-"6"8.-"0#%"#%=*6"+"0#TP.V"#F%.#$%;66*++%-0%
_'+-"6*%"#%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%P.--*(+D%
E_!R9:&:809!e:880110:&!;:5!R-5:,+!\E_?ReR])!F452-1![+&845C)!"O!d-&+!UTTj@!
266,Laa+9@+-5:,4@+-a+&=05:&8+&6a4452-1!!
!
F3=+56010&>!P64&34531!F-62:506<!\FPF]!\EQ]@!
;$g'$"6.-"0#%0#%c0,V+G"#$%Y^%E-$D%%%
e:8,/40&6!S+;!U'$#Uj)!#U!H4592!"'U'@!!
266,Laa***@414@:5>@-CaFPF?4960:&aF3I-309460:&1a"'U'a#ap:/C1*0&3?EQ?
k63aA`rF[dr$j"j#@41,7|!!
!
F06C+&!H@!!!
!"#$%70G*(%7,.##"#F%U0#-(0B*(+"*+%.#$%-3*%U0#+-('6-"0#%05%o4:8*(-o%.#$%oE.Co%^#0G,*$F*+D%%
D8#%+8%&($&C14*1-%!H4592!"''Th!Uj\U]L!$(?W$@!
!
F06C+&!H@!!!
!3C%!*%@-",,%=0#o-%Y#$*(+-.#$%-3*%@06".,%;+8*6-+%05%!"#$%70G*(2%;%U("-"]'*%05%^*C%
;++'18-"0#+%G"-3"#%-3*%E"-*(.-'(*D%%%
7+%-@;&J"4#8;!"'U'h!#jL!Uj#$?Uj$U@!
!
F/4<549!H)!H45G-01?`4=5+!e)!p0://:&!P)!H:5+/!d)!4&3!k+!_:16!N@!!!
;##0C.#6*%5(01%X#$'+-(".,%>0"+*2%X#$"6.-0(+%50(%.%!"$*%c.("*-C%05%X#$'+-(".,%@0'(6*+D%%%
M:D:&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!P+,6!"'U'hU"j\#]LUU"j?UU#T@!
!
F//+<&+!S@!!!
!"#$%L.(1%L0(6*$%-0%U,0+*%.5-*(%U018,."#-+%0B*(%-3*%>0"+*%e@60-,.#$fD%%%
E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!UW!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca+4562a+&=05:&8+&6ajO(T($(aD0&3?;458?;:59+36:?9/:1+?4;6+5?
9:8,/40&61?:=+5?62+?&:01+@268/c!
!
F/6+50!M@!
=0*+%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%;55*6-%?0'(%@,**8%0(%/*.,-3A%
/RHT&C9(++%4&U)!M4&>:5!H40&+)!EPF)!U$!H4<!"''T@!
266,Laa***@*/.Y"@9:8a&+*1a/:94/a16:5<@41,7s16:5<03tU'$(U(^94603t#!!
!
F8+5094&!_460:&4/!P64&3453@!!!
`'.#-"-"*+%.#$%7(06*$'(*+%50(%=*+6("8-"0#%.#$%P*.+'(*1*#-%05%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%@0'#$%T%7.(-%
K2%%0/-31%2!61(!=2-#)'-#1$!16!*4'P/$#$52!*2217#'-/%!4#-3!N.-%11(!:1#2/!=A/$-2!U/'(%!#$!
U1)/2D%%%
F_P%aFPF!PU"@T!?!"''j!a!i456!W@!
!
!
!
!
U$W!
F8+5094&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!4&3!62+!e4&4304&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!\Fae4&DRF]@!
!"#$%&'()"#*%@0'#$%.#$%/*.,-3%455*6-+I%.#%4:8*(-%7.#*,%<*B"*GD%
i4&+/L!!e:/.<!D[)![:.0+!S)!k+=+&624//!N)!k0,19:8.![H)!H9e-&&+<!Sd)!P+0/:!HA)!4&3!P:&3+5>4453!M@!!
Fae4&DRF)![+9+8.+5!"''T@!
266,Laa***@94&*+4@94a,3;a64/C*0&3aD0&3rA-5.0&+rP:-&3r4&3rf+4/62rR;;+961@,3;!!
!
;#.,C+"+%05%!"#$%L.(1+%G"-3%>0"+*%U018,."#-+%).+*$%0#%-3*%@.,50($%<*80(-D%
v9+/!1,5+4312++6)!,+51:&4/!9:88-&09460:&)!"''W@!
!
*$%(/42!?"!A!O/'%#$5!V1(1.53!W1.$7#,G!
f0>2!e:-56!:;!d-1609+)!o-++&K1!M+&92![0=010:&)!Z"''$c!RDfe!T('!\oM])!"T!F,50/!"''$@!
266,Laa***@.40/00@:5>a+*a941+1aRDfeaoMa"''$aT('@268/!!
!
A2+!F-1654/04!P+&46+L!e:88-&06<!F;;4051!S+;+5+&9+1!e:88066++@!!!
&3*%@06".,%.#$%460#01"6%X18.6-%05%<'(.,%!"#$%L.(1+D%%%
e:88:&*+4/62!:;!F-1654/04)!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@4,2@>:=@4-a1+&46+a9:88066++a9/49r966+a08,496r5-54/r*0&3r;4581a5+,:56a0&3+7@268!!
!
M4.0192)!D@!!!
&3*%#0"+*h+-(*++%60#6*8-I%("+V%.++*++1*#-%.#$%(*+*.(63%#**$+D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"''"h!$\UW]L!UXUU@!
!
M4/3*0&!A@!!!
Z.(.6V%[).1.%<*,*.+*+%=06'1*#-+%+30G"#F%/.(+3%Z'+3T*(.%UX;%X#-*((0F.-"0#+D%%%
09%&0#.%$!\EQ])!UW!F,50/!"''T!
!
MMe!_+*1!}!f+4/62@!!!
@,**8"#F%E0#F*(%m/*,8+%;-3,*-*+%<*.63%7*.V%7*(50(1.#6*9)!U!d-/<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@..9@9:@-Ca&+*1a2+4/62?U#T($U#'!
!
M41&+5!Hh!N50+;42&!Mh!4&3!f-8+!Q@!!!
U011*#-%0#%o&3*%@-.-*%05%-3*%;(-%05%7(*$"6-"#F%>0"+*TX#$'6*$%@,**8%="+-'().#6*%"#%L"*,$%
@*--"#F+oD%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$T]L"j#?"jO@!
!
M+&3+5!P@!!!
P*$"6.,%[55"6*(%05%/*.,-3%Z*,"*B*+%!"#$%&'()"#*%@*-).6V+%+30',$%)*%E0#F*(D%%%
R18L+"B&D%+*#+%4I!"O!F->-16!"'U'@!***@/-9C&:*1+&60&+/@9:8!!
!
MRSS!\EQh!.+948+![60h!&:*![Ree]@!
>*G%<*80(-%4.+*+%U0#6*(#+%0B*(%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*D%7(*++%<*,*.+*D%%%
[+,4568+&6!;:5!M-10&+11)!R&6+5,501+!^!S+>-/46:5<!S+;:58!\MRSS])!U!F->-16!"''(@!
266,Laa***@>:=?
&+*1@:5>a>:=a-Ca&+*1a&+*r5+,:56r+41+1r9:&9+5&1r:=+5r*0&3r6-5.0&+a$'#O(@268/!
!
M/49C!!S@!!!
L'V'+3"1.2%;+%Z.$%.+%U3*(#0)C,A%%%
HHC&!%B$)!U"!F,50/!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@..9@9:@-Ca&+*1a190+&9+?+&=05:&8+&6?U#'$jTUW!!
!
M/49C+5!A@!!
W*-%<"63%`'"6V%)C%)*"#F%mW(**#9D%%%
3+)%>%+)%+*)!U"!d-/<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@0&3+,+&3+&6@9:@-Ca:,0&0:&a9:88+&646:51a6+5+&9+?./49C+5a6+5+&9+?./49C+5?>+6?
5092?G-09C?.<?.+0&>?>5++&?"#U"'Wj@268/!!
!
M::C+5!e@!!!
U,"1.-*%U3.#F*2%-3*%!.(1"+-%=*1.#$+%/*.-%'8%.+%mW(**#9%U0+-+%@0.(D%%%
E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!UU![+9+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca9:88+&6a9:/-8&0161a925016:,2+5.::C+5ajUTW#j"ae/0846+?924&>+?
62+?*458016?3+84&31?2+46?-,?41?>5++&?9:161?1:45@268/!!
!
U$(!
!
M::C+5!e@!!!
!3.-%!*%>**$%"#%MNJJ%"+%.#%[880+"-"0#D%%%
E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!U!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca9:88+&6a9:/-8&0161a925016:,2+5.::C+5aj"#O"#jaD246?*+?&++3?
0&?"'UU?01?4&?:,,:1060:&@268/!!
!
M::C+5!e@!!!
7(005%-3.-%-3*%7P%"+%&",-"#F%.-%!"#$1",,+D%
D1+)(;&0%4%@-(>9)!#!d-/<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca9:88+&6a9:/-8&0161a925016:,2+5.::C+5ajWU"(UWai5::;?6246?62+?
N:=+5&8+&6?01?60/60&>?46?*0&380//1@268/!!
!
M:-&31!S@!!!
&*+-"10#C%(*2%W.((*--%U0'#-C%!"#$%&'()"#*%;88,"6.-"0#D%%%
i-./09!P+5=09+1!e:880110:&)!H45</4&3)!EPF)!#U!F->-16!"''W)!,,!(?UU@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>a5-11+//.:-&316+1608:&<@,3;!!
!
M54<!DS@!!!
P*.+'(*1*#-%.#$%@0'#$%`'.,"-C%X++'*+%U0#6*(#"#F%E0GTL(*]'*#6C%>0"+*D%%%
_:01+?e:&!"''()!S+&:)!_+=434)!g96:.+5!""?"$!"''(@!
!
M54<!D!4&3!d48+1!S@!!!
=C#.1"6%P*.+'(*1*#-+%05%!"#$%&'()"#*%;60'+-"6%@"F#.,+I%418,0C"#F%@0'#$%`'.,"-C%
4#F"#**("#F%P*-30$+%U0#+"$*("#F%-3*%&"1*%.#$%L(*]'*#6C%@*#+"-"B"-"*+%05%/'1.#%
7*(6*8-"0#D%%%
_:01+?e:&!"'UU)!i:56/4&3)!g5+>:&)!EPF)!d-/<!"O?"()!"'UU@!
!
M506012!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!\MDRF)!&:*!C&:*&!41!S+&+*4./+EQ]@!
E*--*(%-0%1*1)*(+%5(01%-3*%="(*6-0(%05%8(0F(.11*%@-(.-*FC)!O!F->-16!"''(@!
!
M5<9+!S@!!!
&3*%Z(*G"#F%&*18*+-%0B*(%!"#$%70G*(2%7*08,*%E"B"#F%#*.(%&'()"#*+%X#6(*.+"#F,C%<*80(-%
@,**8%=*8("B.-"0#I%/*.$.63*+%.#$%c*(-"F0D%%&3*%!"#$%E0))C%+.C+%&3*(*9+%>0%7(005D%%%
09%&/(44&D*-%%*&M"1-+(4)!U!H4592!"'U'@!
!
M-&<4&!_!4&3!M+9C;:53!H@!!
/01*0G#*(+%E"B"#F%>*.(%!"#$5.(1+%@**%7(08*(-C%c.,'*+%7,'11*-D%%%
09%&E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!"W!d-/<!"''j@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca+4562a+4562&+*1a##$j'j$af:8+:*&+51?/0=0&>?&+45?*0&3;4581?
1++?,5:,+56<?=4/-+1?,/-88+6@268/!!
!
M-5C24536!N@!!
!"#$%L.(1%X,,#*++!\/+66+5]@!!
/(4%$Q+4#+%)!W!d-&+!"''O@!
266,Laa***@*4/+1:&/0&+@9:@-Ca&+*1a/+66+51?6:?62+?+306:5a*+16+5&?840/?
/+66+51a68r:.I+9603tUOOTOWW#^8+62:3t;-//^106+03tO''j"^2+43/0&+t*0&3?;458?0//&+11?
&48+r,4>+@268/!!
!
M-5&1!d`@!!!
Z("-."#%="+6,0+*+%=.-.%0#%4:T=*-."#**D%%%
!%B&e"-L&0#.%$)!UU!`+.5-45<!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@&<608+1@9:8a"'U'a'"aUUa*:5/3a+-5:,+aUU.50640&@268/!!
!
e4/4;!H)!H+&+=+4-!e)!4&3!H+<+51!d@!!!
E.(F*%4$$C%@"1',.-"0#%@-'$C%05%L',,C%=*B*,08*$%&3*(1.,%!"#$T;((.C%Z0'#$.(C%E.C*(+D!!
V%">9;$#8(4&'%$%(-89&:2$*-(8*$!"'U')!p:/!U"!RNp@!
!
e4/4;!H)!H+&+=+4-!e)!4&3!H+<+51!d@!!
E.(F*%*$$C%+"1',.-"0#%+-'$C%05%5',,C%$*B*,08*$%G"#$T-'()"#*%.((.C%)0'#$.(C%,.C*(+D%%%
J9;$#8$&",&=41#)$!"'U'h""\U]L'UOUU'?'U??UUOUU'?UW@!
!
U$j!
!
e4&4304&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&!\eDRF]@!
;$$(*++"#F%U0#6*(#+%G"-3%!"#$%&'()"#*+%.#$%/'1.#%/*.,-3D%%%
e4&4304&!D0&3!R&+5><!F11:90460:&)!F,50/!"''T@!
266,Laa***@94&*+4@94a,3;ae4&DRFm"'?
m"'F335+110&>m"'9:&9+5&1m"'*062m"'*0&3m"'6-5.0&+1m"'4&3m"'2-84&m"'2+4/62@,3;!!
!
e+54&&4!k)!f45684&&!N)!4&3!f+&>+5!H@!!!
&3*%X#.'$"),*%>0"+*%05%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%
%&;541:-&3!D:5C12:,)!_:=+8.+5!"j!X![+9+8.+5!")!"''O)!A42060@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>aA2+r0&4-30./+r&:01+r:;rD0&3rA-5.0&+1?0&;541:-&3@,3;!!
!
e/45C!S@!!!
W".#-%Z,.$*+%.(*%@,"6"#F%7("6*+D%%
D1+)(;&0%4%@-(>9)!U(!g96:.+5!"''$@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca,5:,+56<a,5:,+56<43=09+a,5:,+56<845C+6a###W'#'aN04&6?./43+1?
45+?1/090&>?,509+1@268/!!
!
U,0'$+%W.-3*("#F%0B*(%!"#$%L.(1%7,.#D%%
:1$*-(4#(+&!%B$)!T!d4&-45<!"''W@!
!
e:9C1![@!
U,0+"#F%@')1"++"0#%-0%-3*%&3(**%P00(+%7,.##"#F%X#]'"(C%0#%)*3.,5%05%-3*%&*63#"6.,%<*80(-%
0#%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%;+8*6-+%e&<4;f2%
U,0+"#F%@')1"++"0#+%0#%Z*3.,5%05%-3*%<'(.,%4:100(%;,,".#6*2%@'11.(CD%%
i%_P!S+;L!FiiavUUUjaFa'ja"'j#Wj")!kiF!S+;!$O$jT)!4&3!!
i%_P!FiiaJUU#jaFa'ja"'j$O"W)!kiF!S+;!'(a'""W"aH`Ek)!"$!_:=+8.+5!"''T@!
266,Laa***@6*:8::51948,40>&@9:@-CaASRF?e/:10&>?P-.80110:&1?P-8845<@,3;!!
!
e:;;84&!H@!
!"#$%&'()"#*%@C#$(01*%7(018-+%@-.-*%E.G1.V*(+%-0%7(080+*%MT?*.(%k!"#$%L.(1l%
P0(.-0("'1D%
3)(9"&'%>"-*%-!\EPF])!Uj!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@0342:5+,:56+5@9:8a"'UUa2:-1+?9:88066++?9:&103+50&>?8:546:50-8?:&?*0&3?
6-5.0&+?9:&165-960:&a!!
!!
e:/6+&!fS!4&3!F/6+=:>6!MH)!+31@!!!
@,**8%="+0($*(+%.#$%@,**8%=*8("B.-"0#2%.#%Y#1*-%7'),"6%/*.,-3%7(0),*1D%%%
e:88066++!:&!P/++,!H+3090&+!4&3!S+1+4592)!%&1606-6+!:;!H+3090&+!:;!62+!_460:&4/!F943+80+1@!!
D4120&>6:&)![eL!A2+!_460:&4/!F943+80+1!i5+11)!"''W@!
266,Laa.::C1@&4,@+3-a:,+&.::C@,2,s5+9:53r03tUUWU(!!
!
e:&164./+)!d!4&3!H:5:&+<!k@!!!
=.-.%0)-."#*$%'#$*(%-3*%L(**$01%05%X#50(1.-"0#%;6-2%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%U018,."#-%
@'(B*C%=.-.!e://+96+3!.<!62+!E&0=+5106<!:;!P4/;:53!-&3+5!9:&65496!6:!62+![+,4568+&6!:;!M-10&+11)!
R&6+5,501+!4&3!S+>-/46:5<!S+;:58L!S+1+4592!0&6:!F+5:3<&4809!H:3-/460:&!:;!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!
ES_!'(aU"#O@!!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!\SR`])!k:&3:&)!EQ)!W!`+.5-545<!"''T!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca,-./09460:&1aUOU?5+;?,-./012+1?3464?:&?*0&3?;458?&:01+?:.640&+3?-&3+5?
62+?;5++3:8?:;?0&;:58460:&?496!4&3!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca4664928+&61a45609/+aUOUaI9@/8@14/;:53@3464@9:88+&6@'(@'"@'T@9@,3;!
!
e:&164./+!d!4&3!H:5:&+<!k@!!!
E0G%!"#$%70G*(%['-8'-%"#%MNJN2%%;#%X#50(1.-"0#%>0-*D%
S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!\SR`])!"!`+.5-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca,-./09460:&1a"U(?/:*?*0&3?,:*+5?:-6,-6?"'U'!!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca4664928+&61a45609/+a"U(a5+;m"':&m"'"'U'm"'*0&3m"',+5;:584&9+
m"''"m"''"m"'UU@,3;!!
!
%
%
%
!
U$T!
U0#+',-.#-2%%c"#.,3.B*#%!"#$%&'()"#*+%&00%>0"+CD%
J"-*4(+)&J-%$$&5%-(4)I&<(#+%)!EPF)!U#!P+,6+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@,5+112+54/3@9:8a&+*1ae:&1-/64&6?14<1?p0&4/24=+&?*0&3?6-5.0&+1?6::?
&:01<@268/s1+45926+58t2+43492+b;:5b=0&4/24=+&!
!
e:,,0&>!d!!4&3!N54<!S@!
@G"-63T055%50(%>0"+*%!"#$%L.(1+D%
0%4%@-(>9!\EQ])!UT!_:=+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca+4562a+&+5><a*0&3,:*+5ajT'U$#UaP*0692?:;;?;:5?&:01<?*0&3?
;4581@268/!!
%
U0'#6",%<',"#F%-0%U3.#F*%L'-'(*%05%!"#$5.(1%7,.#+%eU.(1.(-3*#+3"(*I%!.,*+fD%
09#$3$D"1*9/(4%$)!"#!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6201011:-62*4/+1@9:@-Cae:-&90/?5-/0&>?924&>+?;-6-5+?*0&3;458?,/4&1a16:5<?
U"$WUjW(?3+640/a16:5<@268/!!
!
U0'8,*%@*--,*%G"-3%!"#$%L.(1%[8*(.-0(+%0B*(%mY#)*.(.),*%/'19D%
0%4%@-(>9!\EQ])!#'!_:=+8.+5!"'UU@!
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/environment/8925467/Couple-settle-with-wind-farm-operatorsover-unbearable-hum.html !
!
e5:1.<![@!
E*F.,%U3.,,*#F*%.F."#+-%!"#$%&'()"#*+%P0B*+%L0(G.($%G"-3%;88*.,%e7("#6*%4$G.($%U0'#-CI%
U.#.$.fD%
09%&D1+&0#.%$!\e4&434])!"'!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@:*+&1:-&31-&608+1@9:8aF5609/+[01,/4<@41,7s+t#'#WUW$!!
!
e5-8!P@!
@-("6-%@-.#$.($+%c"-.,%50(%!3"-,*C%!"#$%7,.#-D%
M"1-+(4&V(d%**%!\`:56!D4<&+)!%&304&4)!EPF])!U'![+9+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@I:-5&4/>4Y+66+@&+6a45609/+a"'U'U"U'aR[%A'Oa#U"U'TTT#aU'"UaR[%A!!
!
[4&>?p-!AAh!H9Q0&&+<!PHh!M-76:&!gHh!P:/+6!dHh!4&3!R//+&.:>+&!dH@!!!
@80#-.#*0'+%Z(."#%<3C-31+%7(*$"6-%@,**8%@-.)","-C%"#%-3*%L.6*%05%>0"+*D%%%
C1--%+*&H#"4"@;!U'!F->-16!"'U'h!"'\UO]L!SW"W?W"(!
!
[4&012!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6@!!R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!F>+&9<@!
S-/+1!:&!_:01+!;5:8!D0&3!A-5.0&+1@!
266,Laa***@816@3Cap05C1:82+3r:>r8<&30>2+3aP6:+Iap0&38:+//+5a5+>/+5r;:5r16:Ir;54r=0&38://+
5a5+>/+5;:516:+I;54=0&38:+//+5@268!
!
[4&012!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6@!!R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!F>+&9<@!
`d;2%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!F>+&9<)![4&012!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6)!F->-16!"'UU@!!
266,Laa***@816@3CaR&>/012a`:9-1r45+41a`For/:*r;5+G-+&9<r&:01+r;5:8r*0&3r6-5.0&+1@268s*.
9r,-5,:1+t.m"#m"#A:,!
!
[4=0+1!A@!!!
E*--*(%-0%=*#)(00V%c.,,*C%;6-"0#%W(0'8%e=*B0#fD%
M543/+<1!e2456+5+3!P-5=+<:51)!R7+6+5)!EQ)!O!_:=+8.+5!"''$@!
!
[4=0+1!A@!!
<*+80#+*%-0%4#]'"(C%(*F.($"#F%=*B.,'.-"0#%05%7(08*(-C%5(01%P(%7%/.#606V%e>0(-3%&.G-0#I%
=*B0#feE*--*(fD%
M543/+<1!e2456+5+3!P-5=+<:51)!R7+6+5)!EQ)!#'!F->-16!"''O@!
!
[4=01!d!4&3![4=01!d@!!!
;88*#$":%J2%7(08*(-C%c.,'*+%.#$%/0'+*%7("6*+D%%%
i-./09!e:&1-/6460:&!:&!A2+!R9:&:8091!:;!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!6:!62+!P+/+96!e:88066++!:&!R9:&:809!
F;;4051)!A2+!f:-1+!:;!k:531)!d-&+!"''j@!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a/3"''('ja/31+/+96a/3+9:&4;aUTOaUTO*+Uj@268!!
!
!
UO'!
L'A#2!'$%!L'A#2!A!X#$2,/9>!"'--2!'$%!&/$,'$%!"#$%6'()2!'$%!&/$!5(//$!+14/(!W1Y1+I&&
84(#.&5a&Y]j]]Z]]!!!
\e41+!9:&60&-+1!0&!62+!f0>2!e:-56)!k:&3:&)!:&!#'!_:=+8.+5!"'UUh!92+9C!9:-56!192+3-/+!6:!=+50;<!
346+1@]!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>a[4=01?i45609-/451?:;?9/408@,3;!!
!
[4=01!d!4&3![4=01!d@!!!
W*#*(.,%@-.-*1*#-%05%_.#*%d%_',".#%=.B"+I%JK%;8(",%MNNOD%
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a16:50+1a"$O("!!
!
[4=01!d!4&3![4=01!d@!!!
E*--*(%-0%P7%<*2%=**8"#F%@-%>"630,.+%!"#$5.(1%#0"+*%#'"+.#6*I%JR%P.C%MNJND%
!
[4=01!d@!!!
7*(+0#.,%U011'#"6.-"0#%5(01%_.#*%=.B"+)!U#!F,50/!"''T@!
!
[+&!M5::C!p4//+<!D0&3!A-5.0&+1L!!1++!/',1*@!
!
L/$$#2!M!L/$$#2!A!0#$#2-(9!16!L/6/$7/!Z"''#c!RDfe!(T#!\oM]@!!
266,Laa***@.40/00@:5>a9>0?.0&a845C-,@9>0s3:9ta+*a941+1aRDfeaoMa"''#a(T#@268/!!
!
[+,4568+&6!;:5!R&=05:&8+&6)!`::3!4&3!S-54/!F;;4051!\[+;54]@!
>0"+*%70,"6C%@-.-*1*#-%50(%4#F,.#$%e>7@4fD%
[+;54!\EQ])!H4592!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@3+;54@>:=@-Ca+&=05:&8+&6aG-4/06<a&:01+a!
!
[+,4568+&6!:;!R&+5><!^!e/0846+!e24&>+!\[Ree]@!!!
<*B"+*$%=(.5-%[B*(.(63"#F%>.-"0#.,%70,"6C%@-.-*1*#-%50(%4#*(FC%e4>TJfD%%
[Ree!\EQ])!g96:.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@:;;0904/?3:9-8+&61@>:=@-Ca3:9-8+&6a:62+5aT(j'U'jO'T#$WaT(j'U'jO'T#$W@,3;!!
!
R3*4531!d@!
U.,,+%50(%;,,-G.,"+%!"#$%L.(1%-0%)*%@3'-%=0G#I%R%_',C%MNJND%
266,Laa***@I:&4624&+3*4531@:5>@-Ca94//1?;:5?4//6*4/01?*0&3?;458?6:?.+?12-6?3:*&!!
!
R3*4531!d@!!!
7,."$%U.,,%50(%MV1%!"#$%L.(1%Z'55*(%p0#*I%O%;8(",%MNJND!
266,Laa***@I:&4624&+3*4531@:5>@-Ca,/403?94//?;:5?"C8?*0&3?;458?.-;;+5?Y:&+!
!
R//01!Nh!M455<!dh!S:.0&1:&!e@!!!
P.#C%G.C+%-0%+.C%o#0oI%$"55*(*#-%G.C+%-0%+.C%oC*+o2%;88,C"#F%`TP*-30$0,0FC%-0%'#$*(+-.#$%
8'),"6%.66*8-.#6*%05%G"#$%5.(1%8(080+.,+D%%%
M"1-+(4&",&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&J4(++#+@&(+)&<(+(@%.%+*!!d-/<!"''(h!O'\$]L!OU(?OOU@!
!
R//01!Nh!e:*+//!Sh!D455+&!eh!P654924&!ih!PY45C4!dh!f43*0&!Sh!H0&+5!ih!D:/10&C!Hh!4&3!_434/!F@!!!
!"#$%70G*(2%%X+%-3*(*%.%q7,.##"#F%7(0),*1qA%%
J4(++#+@&09%"-;&?&J-(8*#8%&[+9!"''Th!U'\$]L!O"U?O$(@!
!
R/8+&2:516!R?Hh!R/8+&2:516![h!D+&Y+/!dh!o-+2/!dh!H-+//+5!Eh!H4411!fh!p+I=:34!Hh!4&3!M41&+5!H@!
455*6-+%05%#06-'(#.,%."(6(.5-%#0"+*%0#%60F#"-"B*%8*(50(1.#6*%"#%-3*%50,,0G"#F%10(#"#F2%$0+*T
(*+80#+*%(*,.-"0#+3"8+%"#%,.)0(.-0(C%.#$%5"*,$D%%%
3+*%-+(*#"+(4&:-89#F%$&",&Q881>(*#"+(4&(+)&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&5%(4*9!g96!"'U'h!j#\(]L($#?(OU@!
!
R&>/012!S@!
@,0G%)'-%@-*.$C%0#%;66*++%-0%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%_'+-"6*%5(01%@'8(*1*%U0'(-D%
EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!g;;09+!S:*!\UegS])!U#!F,50/!"'UU@!
266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'U'aU"a"'a1/:*?.-6?16+43<?:&?499+11?6:?+&=05:&8+&64/?
I-1609+?;5:8?1-,5+8+?9:-56a!!
!
!
!
!
UOU!
R&=05:&8+&64/!_:01+![05+960=+!\R_[]@!!!
="(*6-"B*%MNNMhSOh4U%05%-3*%4'(08*.#%8.(,".1*#-%.#$%05%-3*%U0'#6",%(*,.-"#F%-0%-3*%
;++*++1*#-%.#$%P.#.F*1*#-%05%4#B("0#1*#-.,%>0"+*I%M\%_'#*%MNNMD%%%
Q,,#8#(4&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&71-">%(+&C"..1+#*#%$!U@UjTaU"!R_)!Uj@(@"''"@!
266,Laa+9@+-5:,4@+-a+&=05:&8+&6a&:01+a305+960=+@268!!
!
R&=05:&8+&64/!S+=0+*!A50.-&4/)!e41+!_:1@L!U'?U"UaU'?U""!R509C1:&!=@![05+96:5)!H0&0165<!:;!62+!
R&=05:&8+&6)![46+3!6201!Uj62!34<!:;!d-/<)!"'UU!.<!d+55<!p@![+H459:)!i4&+/!e2405!4&3!i4-/!H-/3::&)!
p09+?e2405@!!g&6450:)!e4&434@!
!
4]'.,"-C%.#$%/'1.#%<"F3-+%U011"++"0#%e4/<Uf2%%%
D%%!EQ!RG-4/06<!4&3!f-84&!S0>261!e:880110:&!\RfSe]@!
!
!
RAPE!;:5!62+![60!\EQ]L!A2+!D:5C0&>!N5:-,!:&!_:01+!;5:8!D0&3!A-5.0&+1@!
4&@YT<TOR2%%&3*%;++*++1*#-%d%<.-"#F%05%>0"+*%5(01%!"#$%L.(1+2%L"#.,%<*80(-D%
[60)!P+,6+8.+5!UTTW@!
266,Laa*+.45920=+@&460:&4/45920=+1@>:=@-Caba266,Laa***@.+55@>:=@-Ca+&+5><a1:-59+1a5+&+*4./
+1a+7,/40&+3a*0&3a:&12:5+?:;;12:5+a,4>+"U($#@268/!!
X3/!"1(P#$5!?(1.+!1$!:1#2/!B:"?FL!!H+05!S!\[60]h!k+>+56:&!Hk!\RAPE]h!F&3+51:&!HM!\SRP!
S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!P<16+81]h!M+55<!M!\_460:&4/!i2<1094/!k4.:546:5<]h!M-//8:5+!F!\f:45+!k++!^!
i456&+51]h!f4<+1!H!\f4<+1!H9Q+&Y0+!i456&+5120,]h!d0>>0&1!H!\e45509C![0165096!e:-&90/h!&:*!
f:45+!k++!^!i456&+51]h!k++80&>!R!\A2+!_4-654/!i:*+5!e:!k63]h!H-1>5:=+!i!\_460:&4/!D0&3!
i:*+5!k63]h!P,:3+![d!\_:562!e:5&*4//![0165096!e:-&90/]h!A2:841!fF!\%1/+!:;!F&>/+1+<!e:-&6<!
e:-&90/]h!A:84/0&!R!\R9:N+&!k63]h!A50&09C!H!\M:&3!i+459+!P:/0906:51]h!4&3!D455+&!d!\_460:&4/!
D0&3!i:*+5!k63]@!
!
4'(08*.#%U0'(-%05%/'1.#%<"F3-+%e4U/<fD%
P@UW(!Q(/,'$%!A!RS!UT(j!"$RfSS!$"#!
Q(/,'$%!A!RS&7C5'&YfA]YAYZgf&
T1+/@!N2-('!A!<+'#$I&Z&E%8%.2%-&YZZl&
?./(('!'$%!N-3/(2!A!Q-',9I&YZ&=%2-1(-;&YZZf!
P@j(!?'65/$!A!?/()'$9I&Y&M1+%&U]Y]&
P@jj!?'65/$!A!?/()'$9&
P@jT!?'65/$!A!?/()'$9I&U]Y]&
01(/$1!?1)/@!A!<+'#$I&U]]l&
&'%/9/A'!A!O.22#'I&U]]m&
U'--1$!A!RSI&f&M14;&U]]o&
\="-&5(**"+I&$%%&(4$"!62+!d:0&6![011+&60&>!g,0&0:&1!:;!d-3>+1!e:164)!S++1)!A-58+&)!n-,4&909!4&3!
P6+0&+5)!5(**"+&(+)&"*9%-$&F&G+#*%)&X#+@)".!3+9010:&!4&3!3011+&60&>!:,0&0:&1L!
266,Laa9801C,@+925@9:+@0&6a6C,UT(a=0+*@41,s06+8t"^,:564/t2.C8^4960:&t268/^1:-59+t6C,
^20>2/0>26tm""AfRm"'E_%AR[m"'Q%_N[gHm""m"'}m"'2466:&^1+110:&03tWWjU'O^1C0
&t2-3:9?+&@]&
\D%%&(4$"L!P@(T!C9(9(4&F&GX!UTTWh!P@U"'!R(2#*(&F&3*(4;h!P@UUj!'(.#-%d&D(+89%d&F&=-(+8%h!PU"(!
D(()#&F&3*(4;!"''jh!X%%+(+&F&GX!P@UU'h!P@W(!M(44"9&F&V%-.(+;A]!
\A:!5+43!62+!3+9010:&1!:&!RefS!941+1)!-1+!62+!RefS!fE[ge!3464.41+L!!
266,Laa***@+925@9:+@0&6aRefSaR_af+43+5ae41+?
k4*a[+9010:&1b4&3bI-3>8+&61afE[geb3464.41+a@]!
!
!
R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!\RRF]@!
;)0'-%>0"+*D%
RRF)!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a62+8+1a&:01+a4.:-6?&:01+!!
!
R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!\RRF]@!!!
W00$%7(.6-"6*%W'"$*%0#%>0"+*%4:80+'(*%.#$%70-*#-".,%/*.,-3%455*6-+D%%%
RRF!A+92&094/!S+,:56!_:!UUa"'U'@!
266,Laa***@++4@+-5:,4@+-a,-./09460:&1a>::3?,549609+?>-03+?:&?&:01+!!
!
!
!
UO"!
R-5:,+4&!E&0:&@!
&3*%U3.(-*(%05%L'#$.1*#-.,%<"F3-+%05%-3*%4'(08*.#%Y#"0#D%
266,Laa***@+-5:,45/@+-5:,4@+-a92456+5a,3;a6+76r+&@,3;!
!
L.1",C%&.V*+%!"#$%&'()"#*%U018.#"*+%-0%U0'(-%[B*(%W.F%U,.'+*+%0#%/*.,-3%455*6-+%05%
&'()"#*+D&!E#@#*(4&M"1-+(4)!U"!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@30>064/I:-5&4/@9:8a,5a$U(jU"!
!
`+/6:&!dP@!!!
U,.++"6.,%+C#$(01*+%"#%066'8.-"0#.,%1*$"6"#*2%830+830('+%#*6(0+"+%TT%.%6,.++"6.,%
066'8.-"0#.,%$"+*.+*D%%%
:.%-#8(+&M"1-+(4&",&3+)1$*-#(4&<%)#8#+%!UTj"h!#\U]L!((?U"'@!
!
`06Y,46509C!Q@!!!
m>0"+*%5(01%!"#$5.(1%"+%;55*6-"#F%PC%/*.,-3D%m%
<(+89%$*%-&7F%+#+@&!%B$)!""!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa8+&8+304@9:@-Ca5:9234/+:.1+5=+5a&+*1a1aU$'W''"r&:01+r;5:8r*0&3;458r01r4;;+960&>r8
<r2+4/62!!
!
`:51309C![@!!!
>0"+*%.#$%!"#$%&'()"#*%7(080+.,+D%%%
k4&3845C!e248.+51!\k:&3:&]L!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!P+80&45)!U!g96:.+5!"''j@!
266,Laa***@/4&3845C9248.+51@9:@-Carr3464a411+61a,3;r;0/+a'''$a#"O#Ta#@"r_:01+rr4&3rrD0&3
rA-5.0&+1@,3;!!
!
L0'(-3%X#-*(#.-"0#.,%U0#5*(*#6*%0#%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*I%<01*I%JJ%H%JS%;8(",%MNJJD%
P,:&1:5+3!.<!%_eRaR-5:,+!4&3!e_S?%&1606-6+!:;!F9:-16091!4&3!P+&1:51?%[FPe)!*062!62+!F9:-16094/!
P:90+6<!:;!%64/<!4&3!62+!%&6+5&460:&4/!P:/45!R&+5><!P:90+6<?1+Y0:&+!064/04&4@!
***@*0&36-5.0&+&:01+"'UU@:5>!!
\F1!4!.0+&&04/!+=+&6)!62+!&+76!9:&;+5+&9+!01!192+3-/+3!;:5!"'U#@]!
!
$?O!N54<K1!%&&!PG-45+@!!!
U0'(-%05%;88*.,%;,,0G%!"#$5.(1%;88*.,D%%%
l`m&!%B$)!"O!_:=+8.+5!"''O@!
266,Laa***@$?O@9:@-Ca&+*1a0&3+7@9;8s03t"OO"!!
!
`5+<!Md!4&3!f433+&!id@!!!
>0"+*%<.$".-"0#%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+%X#+-.,,*$%#*.(%/01*+2%455*6-+%0#%/*.,-3D%
d-&+!"''(!\F=40/4./+!;5:8!84&<!*+.!106+1!0&9/-30&>!!
266,Laa***@*0&3?*4692@:5>a3:9-8+&61a&:01+?5430460:&?;5:8?*0&3?6-5.0&+1?0&164//+3?&+45?
2:8+1?+;;+961?:&?2+4/62a!]!
!
N4>+!S6!f:&!P05!D0//048)!e240584&@!
@-.-*1*#-%0#%-3*%Z.3.%P0'+.%7'),"6%X#]'"(C%<*80(-I%i%@*8-*1)*(%MNJJD%
266,Laa***@.4248:-140&G-05<@:5>a/0&C+3;0/+1a.424r8:-14a5+,:56a"'UU?'T?'j?
9240584&11646+8+&6@,3;!!
D%%&(4$"6&&&
N4>+!S6!f:&!P05!D0//048)!e240584&@!
&3*%Z.3.%P0'+.%7'),"6%X#]'"(C%<*80(-D%
i5+1+&6+3!6:!i45/048+&6!,-51-4&6!6:!P+960:&!"W!:;!62+!%&G-050+1!F96!"''O@!
A2+!P6460:&+5<!g;;09+!\EQ])!fe!U$O")!=:/1!U!X!#)!j!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@.4248:-140&G-05<@:5>a5+,:56a0&3+7@268!!
!
N/+&![2-!i:*+5!X!D0&3!i5:I+96!\P2+45!D0&3!%&9@]@!
4#B"(0#1*#-.,%;++*++1*#-2%7(0:"1"-C%.#$%>0"+*D%
_:=4!P9:604)!e4&434)!`+.5-45<!"''jh!`+.5-45<!"''T@!
266,Laa***@>:=@&1@94a&1+a+4a>/+&@32-@*0&3@;458a>/+&@32-@*0&3@;458@F33+&3-8@P+960:&'"@i5:7
0806<@4&3@_:01+@,3;!!
!
W00$%7(.6-"6*%W'"$*%0#%>0"+*%4:80+'(*%.#$%70-*#-".,%/*.,-3%455*6-+2%%%
D%%!R-5:,+4&!R&=05:&8+&6!F>+&9<!\RRF]@!
!
UO#!
!
N:<4/!P)!N-,64!p)!D4/04!k@!!
455*6-%05%>0"+*%@-(*++%0#%;'-0#01"6%L'#6-"0#%&*+-+D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'hU"\$j]LUj"?UjW@!
!
N54<!k@!
>0"+*%U018,."#-+%.)0'-%[#*%"#%@":%!"#$%L.(1+D%
E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!W!H4592!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca+4562a+4562&+*1a(#((W$Ua_:01+?9:8,/40&61?4.:-6?:&+?0&?107?
*0&3?;4581@268/!!
!
N54<!k@!!
!"#$%5.(1+%)*6.,1*$%g'+-%G3*#%#**$*$%-3*%10+-D%%%
E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!"!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca+4562a+&+5><a*0&3,:*+5aj"#$WUWaD0&3?;4581?.+94/8+3?I-16?
*2+&?&++3+3?62+?8:16@268/!!
!
!
N->0:664!N@!!!
@0'#$I%-3*%!.C%-3*%Z(."#%7(*5*(+%-0%/*.(%X-D%%%
!%B&e"-L&0#.%$)!P+,6+8.+5!O!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@&<608+1@9:8a"'UUa'Ta'Wa190+&9+a'W1:-&3@268/s,4>+*4&6+3t4//!!
!
f441!F@!!!
&0%-3*%7@U%U011"++"0#*(+D%%%
H4/:&+)!D019:&10&@!!F->-16!"'U'@!!
266,Laa,19@*0@>:=aa4,,1#Oa+5;r1+4592a9:&6+&6a2:8+1+4592@41,7s,456UtU^,456"tFe^,456#t"#U
^6<,+te:88+&61!4&3!!
266,Laa***@*0&3?*4692@:5>a3:9-8+&61a6:?62+?,19?9:880110:&+51a!
!
f488:&31!kki@!
E*--*(%(*2%X18.6-%05%W(**#%<"FF%!"#$%&'()"#*+%0#%!.-*(5.,,+I%Z"(-,*C%!.(VI%/*:3.1I%%JJ%
_'#*%MNJND%
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>af488:&31r_:562-8.+5/4&3reerU''WUU@,3;!!
!
f4&&0&>!e!4&3!_011+&.4-8!H@!
@*,*6-"0#%05%['-601*%P*.+'(*+%"#%;++*++"#F%@,**8%="+-'().#6*%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*D%
`:-562!%&6+5&460:&4/!H++60&>!:&!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+)!S:8+)!%64/<)!U"?U$!F,50/!"'UU@!
!
f4&&0&>!e@!!!
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*I%@,**8%.#$%/*.,-3D%%%
P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+)!F,50/!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@*0&3=0>0/4&9+@9:8a4.:-6?43=+51+?2+4/62?+;;+961a*0&3?6-5.0&+?&:01+?1/++,?4&3?
2+4/62?.<?35?24&&0&>!!
!
!
/.#+.($2%%/0'+*%05%U0110#+D%%[55"6".,%7'),"6.-"0#%05%-3*%Y^%7.(,".1*#-2%
!
• e:7!N!4&3!D09C1!H@!!&'()"#*+2%/*.,-3%/.n.($+)!Uj!H4<!"''()!9U''#D!!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"''W'(a9824&153a98'('OUja6+76a('OUj
*''U$@268!!
!
• e:7!N!4&3!D09C1!H@!!&'()"#*+2%/*.,-3%/.n.($+)!UO!d-&+!"''()!9U$Uj*!!
266,Laa***@,45/048+&6@62+?16460:&+5<?
:;;09+@9:@-Ca,4a98"''W'(a9824&153a98'('WUOa6+76a('WUO*''Uj@268|'('WUO$#'''U
TT!!
!
• i09C/+1!R!\M5+&6*::3!4&3!g&>45)!e:&]!4&3!f+4/+<!d!\D+&6*:562!4&3![+45&+)!k4.]%%%%%%%%%%%
U0'#6",%&.:2%%&.:%;,,0G.#6*+)!U#!H4<!"''j)!9U$$"D!!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"''('ja9824&153a98'j'OU#a6+76aj'OU#
*'''$@268!!
!
UO$!
!
!
!
!
!
• [4=0+1!i!4&3!f+&35<!e)!>0"+*2%!"#$%L.(1+)!"(!d-/<!"'U')!9jjj*?9!jjT*!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"'U'UUa9824&153a98U''("(a6+76aU''("
(*'''U@268!!
• R3*4531!d!4&3!M45C+5!N@!!!"#$%70G*()!"(!d-/<!"'U')!9jT#*!!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"'U'UUa9824&153a98U''("(a6+76aU''("
(*'''U@268|U''("(OU''#"'(!!
• P6+,2+&1:&!F!4&3!f+&35<!e@!!!"#$%70G*(2%>0"+*)!!"(!d-/<!"'U')!9jjj*?9jjT*!
• 266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"'U'UUa9824&153a98U''("(a6+76aU''("
(*'''U@268!!
• f+46:&?f45501!e!4&3!M45C+5!N@!!!"#$%70G*()!Uj!g96:.+5!"'U')!9$j"*!!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"'U'UUa9824&153a98U'U'Uja6+76aU'U'U
j*'''#@268!!
• F3481!_!4&3!_+0/!S@!!!"#$%70G*(2%7,.##"#F%7*(1"++"0#)!UU!_:=+8.+5!"'U')!9$WU*@!
266,Laa***@,-./09460:&1@,45/048+&6@-Ca,4a98"'U'UUa9824&153a98U'UUUUa6+76aU'UUU
U*'''#@268|U'UUUUj#''''"O!!
!
A:!1+4592!f4&1453L!!266,Laa***@,45/048+&6@-Ca.-10&+11a,-./09460:&1a24&1453a!!
!
!
f45501:&!di@!!
X#.$*]'.6C%05%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%<*F',.-"0#+%.#$%-3*"(%;88,"6.-"0#D%%%
C(+()#(+&:8"1$*#8$!P+,6!"''Th#(LUOW?UOj@!
!
f45501:&!di@!!
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*D%!!
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh#UL"OW?"WU@!
!
f455<!F@!!!
!"#$%&'()"#*+I%>0"+*%.#$%/*.,-3D%%%
`+.5-45<!"''(@!
266,Laa***@*0&3?*4692@:5>a3:9-8+&61a*0&3?6-5.0&+1?&:01+?4&3?2+4/62a!!
!
f456![@!!!
*'(3.2!V(/'73/2!*,,!O1.$%D%%%
EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!g;;09+!S:*!\UegS])!U#!F,50/!"'UU@!
266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'UUa'$aU#a4452-1?.5+492+1?4//?5:-&3a!
!
f456![@!
;#*101*-*(+I%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%"#50(1.-"0#I%.#$%E*F.,%;$B"6*2%%-3*%7,.##"#F%X#+8*6-0(.-*9+%
='-C%-0%="+6,0+*A%
EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!g;;09+!S:*!\UegS])!"O!F->-16!"'UU@!
266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'UUa'ja"Oa4&+8:8+6+51?+&=05:&8+&64/?0&;:58460:&?4&3?
/+>4/?43=09+?62+?,/4&&0&>?0&1,+96:546+1?3-6<?6:?3019/:1+a!!
!!
f456![@!!!
_'+-%!3*#%?0'%&30'F3-%&3*C%!*(*%4:-"#6-2%%/'1.#%<"F3-+%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%U.+*%@'66**$+D%
EQ!f-84&!S0>261!M/:>)!U!e5:*&!g;;09+!S:*!\UegS])!"(!d-/<!"'UU@!!
266,Laa-C2-84&50>261./:>@9:8a"'UUa'(a"(aI-16?*2+&?<:-?62:->26?62+<?*+5+?+760&96?4U,U?
+&=05:&8+&64/?941+?1-99++31a!
!
f45=+<!f@!!!
&'("-*.%P.#%L*.(+%/*9,,%/.B*%-0%W0D%%
!%B&T%(4(+)&!%B$)U'!_:=+8.+5!"''W@!!!
266,Laa16-;;@9:@&Y!!
!
!
!
!
UOO!
f4*C0&1!d@!!!
!"#$5.(1%Z,0G+%/0'+*%c.,'*%;G.CD%%
09%&/%$*."-4(+)&V(d%**%)!T!d4&-45<!"''$@!
266,Laa***@62+*+168:5/4&3>4Y+66+@9:@-Ca&+*1a$$(('W@,50&6a!!
!
f4<+1!H!4&3!H9Q+&Y0+!F@!\f4<+1!H9Q+&Y0+!i456&+5120,!k63@]@!
P*.+'(*1*#-%05%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%.-%&3(**%Y^%!"#$%L.(1+D%
[+,4568+&6!:;!A543+!4&3!%&3-165<!\[60]\EQ])!F->-16!"''W@!
266,Laa*+.45920=+@&460:&4/45920=+1@>:=@-Caba266,Laa***@.+55@>:=@-Ca+&+5><a1:-59+1a5+&+*4./
+1a+7,/40&+3a*0&3a:&12:5+?:;;12:5+a,4>+#U"W(@268/!!
!
f+46:&?f45501!e@!!!
[#+30(*%!"#$%&'()"#*+%e7(0:"1"-C%05%/.)"-.-"0#fD%%%
f:-1+!:;!e:88:&1![+.46+1)!fe![+.!U(!_:=+8.+5!"'U')!9T''@!
\P+9:&3!5+430&>!5+192+3-/+3!;:5!"'!d4&-45<!"'U"@c!
266,Laa1+5=09+1@,45/048+&6@-Ca.0//1a"'U'?UUa:&12:5+*0&36-5.0&+1,5:70806<:;24.06460:&@268/!!
!
f+11/0&>!Q@!!!
<*+"$*#-+%@'*%!"#$%U018.#"*+D%%%
51-"+&E(#4;&0-#21+%!\H0920>4&)!EPF])!"T!H4<!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@80920>4&162-8.@9:8a45609/+1a"'U'a'Oa"Ta&+*1a/:94/r&+*1a3:9$9'UU(;$j3U"9"O
(($jWjO@676!!
!
f:*+!N4168+0+5!e24,&0C!k63@!!!
E0G%L(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%.#$%X#5(.+0'#$%;++06".-*$%G"-3%!"#$%&'()"#*%W*#*(.-0(%@C+-*1+2%%;%
E"-*(.-'(*%<*B"*G!\S;,!_:@!g11?(jWTW]@!!!
H0110114->4)!g&6450:)!e4&434L!!H0&0165<!:;!62+!R&=05:&8+&6)!"'U'@!
!
f-..453!ff@!!!
>0"+*%"#$'6*$%30'+*%B")(.-"0#+%.#$%3'1.#%8*(6*8-"0#D%%%
!"#$%&C"+*-"4&7+@#+%%-#+@!UTj"hUT\"]L$T?OO@!
!
<&514.%&F&D%8-%*(-;&",&D*(*%&?&'7D!"'U'!RDfe!"#jW!F380&)!UT!F->-16!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@.40/00@:5>a+*a941+1aRDfeaF380&a"'U'a"#jW@268/!!
!
</&514.%&F&D%8-%*(-;&",&D*(*%&?&'7D)!"'UU!RDeF!e0=!W#j)!!"W!H4<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@.40/00@:5>a+*a941+1aRDeFae0=a"'UUaW#j@268/!!
!
U.,)/!0"2%%;88*.,%=*6"+"0#%8*(1"--"#F%-3*%=*#%Z(00V%!"#$%L.(1D%%%
%&1,+96:5!F!i<C+66h!i%_P)!FiiaoUUO#aFa'Wa"'U(UW")!UU![+9+8.+5!"''T@!
266,Laa***@3+&.5::C=4//+<@9:@-Ca5+1:-59+1a[+&.5::CbFiiRFkb[Re%P%g_?U@,3;!!
!
f-516!A@!!!
Z'C*(+%U,*.(,C%!"#$%<*+"+-.#-%e,*--*(fD%%
/%%L4;&0#.%$!\F-1654/04])!"#!F,50/!"''#@!
!
%eA!\%&;:58460:&!4&3!e:88-&09460:&1!A+92&:/:>0+1]!S+>-/460:&!A::/C06@!!!
=*6"+"0#T1.V"#F%7(06*++%.#$%U0#+',-.-"0#%L(.1*G0(VD%%@DRDMD%JK%%
%&;:58460:&!;:5![+=+/:,8+&6!i5:>548!\0&;:[+=]!4&3!62+!%&6+5&460:&4/!A+/+9:88-&09460:&!E&0:&!
\%AE])!d-&+!"'UU!!
***@0965+>-/460:&6::/C06@:5>!@!
!
X-9+%.#%X,,%G"#$%-3.-%&3(*.-*#+%7*.-,.#$+D%%
e"-L$9#-%&0")(;)!U"!H4592!"''O@!
266,Laa***@<:5C1205+,:16@9:@-Ca&+*1a;+46-5+1a06r1r4&r0//r*0&3r6246r625+46+&1r,+46/4&31rUr"OO
W("T!!
!
%6:!F!4&3!A4C+34!A@!!!
@"6V#*++%U,."1+%7(018-%@-'$C%05%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
09%&:$(9#&D9#.21+)!UT!d4&-45<!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@41420@9:8a+&>/012af+54/3?41420aAQJ"'U''UUj'$U'@268/!
!
UOW!
!
d49:.1+&!d@!!!
X#5(.+0'#$%41"++"0#+%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
M"1-+(4&",&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%I&O#2-(*#"+I&(+)&:8*#F%&C"+*-"4!"''Oh"$LU$OXUOO@!
!
d48+1!S@!!!
@'((*)'--.,%&*+-"10#C%05%<"63.($%<%_.1*+%0#%Z*3.,5%05%-3*%U0.,"-"0#%50(%!"+60#+"#%
4#B"(0#1*#-.,%@-*G.($+3"8D%%%
D019:&10&!i-./09!P+5=09+!e:880110:&)!3:9C+6!WW#'?e[?#'"L!D019:&10&!R/+96509!i:*+5!e:8,4&<!
\DRieg])!"j!g96:.+5!"''T)!,,!PST@UW!X!PST@""@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>ad48+1?N/490+5?f0//1?P-55+.-664/@,3;!!
!
d4&11+&!PF)!p:1!fh!=4&!Q+8,+&!RHH)!M5+->+/84&1!gSi)!4&3!H0+3+84!fHR@!!!
&(*#$+%"#%;"(6(.5-%>0"+*%;##0C.#6*2%&3*%<0,*%05%@-'$C%.#$%@.18,*%U3.(.6-*("+-"6+D%%%
M:D:&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!!F,50/!"'UUhU"T\$]LUTO#?UTW"@!
!
d:24&11:&!H@!
!*%>0G%@**%L.1","*+%E*.B"#F%&3*"(%/01*+%e=*#1.(VfD%
k+66+5!6:!R306:5)!"W!H4<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a&+*1a"'UUa*+?&:*?1++?;480/0+1?/+4=0&>?62+05?2:8+1?
5+,:561?,2<10904&?3+&845Ca,50&6a!!
!
d:&+1![h!f->2+1!Sh!H49C+&!D@!!!
;'$"-0(C%="+-(.6-"0#%.#$%@*(".,%P*10(C2%-3*%;B0"$.),*%.#$%-3*%X#*,'6-.),*D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$T]L!"'U?"'T@!
!
^.#+."%4,*6-("6%U'()+%!"#$%L.(1%0B*(%>0"+*%U0#6*(#+D%%%
S+-6+51)!O!F->-16!"'UU@!!
266,Laa4;@5+-6+51@9:8a45609/+a9:88:3060+1_+*1a03F`k#R(dO'`$"'UU'j'O!
!
Q++./+!F@!!!
['(%@,**8,*++%>"F3-+%G"-3%-3*%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
!"-*9&E%F"+&V(d%**%)!j!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@&:5623+=:&>4Y+66+@9:@-Ca&+*1a:-5r1/++,/+11r&0>261r*062r62+r*0&3r6-5.0&+1rUrTU$j
(O!!
!
Q08!S!4&3!=4&!3+&!M+5>!H@!!!
@'11.(C%05%>"F3-%>0"+*%W'"$*,"#*+%50(%4'(08*D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$(]L!WU?W#@!
!
Q05C!d@!!
&'()"#*%7,.#%U'-%c.,'*%05%['(%/01*%)C%.%&3"($D%%
/%$*%-+&<"-+#+@&!%B$)!T![+9+8.+5!"''$@!
266,Laa***@34563:51+6@:5>a,3;aDH_m"'AESM%_Rm"'ikF_m"'eEAm"'pFkERm"''TU"'$@,
3;!!
!
Q5:+1+&!Hh!H:/0&!Rh!4&3!D++!M@!!!
=*-*(1"#"#F%-3*%$"(*6-"0#%05%6.'+.,"-C%)*-G**#%8+C630,0F"6.,%5.6-0(+%.#$%."(6(.5-%#0"+*%
.##0C.#6*D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!d4&?H45!"'U'h!U"\$W]L!U(?"O@!
!
Q5:>2!eHR@!!!
X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%&'()"#*%=*B*,081*#-%.#$%E0++%05%@06".,%_'+-"6*D%%%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&?&D"8#%*;!"'UUh#U\$]L#"U?###@!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a#"U!!
!
Q5:>2!eHRh!N0//01!kh!4&3!Q:-*+&!_@!!!
;%@*,5T<*80(-"#F%@'(B*C2%%;$B*(+*%/*.,-3%455*6-+%G"-3%X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%&'()"#*+%.#$%-3*%
>**$%50(%c"F",.#6*D%%%
D0&3pg0e+!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+!;:5!g&6450:!e:88-&060+1)!g&6450:)!e4&434)!d-/<!"'U'@!
266,Laa*0&39:&9+5&1:&6450:@*:53,5+11@9:8a2+4/62a2+4/62?1-5=+<?0&;:58460:&a!!
!
UO(!
!
Q5:>2!eHR)!N0//01!k)!Q:-*+&!_)!4&3!F5480&0!d@!!!
!"#$c["U*I%.%@*,5T<*80(-"#F%@'(B*C2%;$B*(+*%/*.,-3%455*6-+I%X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%&'()"#*+I%.#$%
-3*%>**$%50(%c"F",.#6*%P0#"-0("#FD%%%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&?&D"8#%*;&"'UUh#UL##$?#$O@!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a##$!!
!
k4-50+!P@!!!
@')1"++"0#%-0%-3*%;'+-(.,".#%L*$*(.,%@*#.-*%X#]'"(C%0#%<'(.,%!"#$%L.(1+D%%%
JN%L*)('.(C%MNJJD%
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>ak4-50+?F-1654/04?P+&46+?1-.80110:&?;0&4/@,3;!:5!
266,Laa***@4,2@>:=@4-a1+&46+a9:88066++a9/49r966+a08,496r5-54/r*0&3r;4581a1-.80110:&1@268!!
!
k+4C+!d!4&3!M<;:53!f@!!!
[55"6".,+%U0B*(%'8%!"#$%L.(1%>0"+*%<*80(-D%%%
D1+)(;&0#.%$!\EQ])!U#![+9+8.+5!"''T@!
!
k+1/0+!Q@!
[#-.("0%Y#.),*%-0%&*,,%"5%!"#$%L.(1+%4:6**$%>0"+*%E"1"-+I%;6-"B"+-+%@.CD%
09%&V4"2%&(+)&<(#4!\A:5:&6:)!e4&434])!UOaUW!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+>/:.+4&3840/@9:8a&+*1a,:/06091a:&6450:?-&4./+?6:?6+//?0;?*0&3?;4581?+79++3?
&:01+?/08061?4960=0161?14<a45609/+"'W"(jTa!!
!
k+=+&624//!N@!!!
X#5(.+0'#$%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+%H%L.6-I%L"6-"0#I%0(%=*6*8-"0#A%%%
C(+()#(+&:8"1$*#8$!"''Wh#$\W]L"T?#$)#W@!
!
k0,6:&!R!4&3!Q54-11!e@!!!
;%W0,$%<'+3%05%@')+"$"*+%"#%U,*.#%4#*(FC%@*.(63D%%%
!%B&e"-L&0#.%$!_:=+8.+5!UU)!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@&<608+1@9:8a"'UUaUUaU"a.-10&+11a+&+5><?+&=05:&8+&6a4?9:5&-9:,04?:;?2+/,?;:5?
5+&+*4./+?+&+5><@268/s19,tU^1Gt>:/3m"'5-12^16t91+!!
!
kI-&>!Sh!P:5G=016!ih!4&3!f<>>+!P@!!!
455*6-+%05%(0.$%-(.55"6%#0"+*%.#$%"((*,*B.#-%+8**63%0#%63",$(*#o+%(*.$"#F%.#$%1.-3*1.-"6.,%
8*(50(1.#6*D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"''Th!UU\$O]L!UT$?"'#@!
!
E0($%7(080+*+%U0#-(0B*(+".,%MV1%<*+"$*#-".,%="+-.#6*%<',"#F%0#%!"#$%L.(1+D%%%
/%$*%-+&<"-+#+@&!%B$)!T!F->-16!"'U'@!
***@6201013+=:&@9:@-Ca&+*1ak:53?,5:,:1+1?30164&9+?5-/0&>?*0&3?;4581a45609/+t"O'#j"'?
3+640/a45609/+@268/!!!
!
E0'$%<0.$%>0"+*%E"#V*$%-0%@-(0V*%"#%[,$*(%;$',-+D%%%
EP!_460:&4/!k0.545<!:;!H+3090&+)!_460:&4/!%&1606-6+1!:;!f+4/62)!H+3/0&+i/-1)!d4&-45<!"W)!"'UU@!
!
k:=+/:9C!d@!!
&3*%<*B*#F*%05%W.".2%!3C%-3*%4.(-3%"+%L"F3-"#F%Z.6VD%%%
k:&3:&L!i+&>-0&)!"''W@!
!
H42!e)!H42!QR)!Q+Y0504&!Rd)!4&3![+8+&6!De@!!
&3*%455*6-+%05%@,**8%4:-*#+"0#%0#%-3*%;-3,*-"6%7*(50(1.#6*%05%U0,,*F".-*%Z.+V*-).,,%7,.C*(+D%%%
D4%%>&"'UU!d-/!Uh#$\(]LT$#?TO'@!
!
H40&+!H+3094/!F11:90460:&@!!!
<*+0,'-"0#%<*2%!"#$%4#*(FC%.#$%7'),"6%/*.,-3D%%%
HHF!\EPF])!"''T@!
266,Laa***@840&+8+3@9:8a4&&-4/a"''Ta"''Tri5:,:1+3rS+1:/-60:&1@,3;!!
!
!
!
!
UOj!
H405!N@!!!
X-.,".#%!"#$5.(1%=".(CI%_.#'.(C%MNNR%-0%=*6*1)*(%MNNRD%%%
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>a8405?3045<@,3;&
!
H4C45+*09Y!S@!!!
X+%.%!"#$%&'()"#*%.%70"#-%@0'(6*A%%%
M:D:&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!`+.!"'UUhU"T\"]L!O(T?OjU@!
!
H4&&!A@!
Z,'1*#-3.,%Y(F*+%&0'F3%@-.#$.($+%50(%@"-"#F%05%!"#$%70G*(%7(0g*6-+D%
09%&E(;!\_+*!k:&3:&)!e:&&+9609-6)!EPF])!d4&-45<!$!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+34<@9:8a45609/+a"'UU'U'$a_DPU"a#'U'$TTUOaU'WTa511!!
!
H457!SR@!!!
Y#60B*("#F%-3*%U.'+*%[5%o730++C%_.Go%6"(6.%Ji\i%-0%JONK2%[(.,%.#$%P.:",,05.6".,%@'(F*(C%
U,0+*$%U.+*%L",*+%T%U.+*%U,0+*$D%%%
M"1-+(4&",&Q-(4&(+)&<(P#44",(8#(4&D1-@%-;!"''jh!WW\UU]L!"#OW?"#W#@!
!
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!
;++*++"#F%>0"+*%5(01%7(080+*$%!"#$%&'()"#*%=*B*,081*#-+D%%%
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!H4<!"''T@!
!
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!!
>0"+*%P0#"-0("#F%W(.83%1*.+'(*$%G"-3"#%5"(+-%5,00(%)*$(001%H%G"#$0G%08*#%H%=.B"+9+%%
/0'+*%T%!"#$%L.(1%;18,"-'$*%P0$',.-"0#%+30G"#F%@"F#"5"6.#-%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%U0#-*#-I%\%
_',C%MNNR)!#+!
F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+![+=+/:,8+&61@!!!
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!H4<!"''T@!
!
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/@!!!
>0"+*%P0#"-0("#F%W(.83%G"-3"#%5"(+-%5,00(%)*$(001%T%=.B"+o+%/0'+*%T%!"#$%L.(1%>0"+*I%\%_',C%
MNNR)!#+L!!
F11+110&>!_:01+!;5:8!i5:,:1+3!D0&3!A-5.0&+![+=+/:,8+&61@!!!
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!H4<!"''T@!
!
P;@%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%eU.1)("$F*I%Y^fD%
7(005%05%4B"$*#6*%+')1"--*$%)C%P;@%-0%-3*%>0(-3%=0B*(%!"#$%7.(V%X#]'"(C%eY^f)!,,!$#?$T)!
[+9+8.+5!"''j@!
!
H462+1:&!Hh!e/45C!eh!S:90:!Hh!=4&!Q+8,+&!Rh!f40&+1!Hh!M4550:!%h!f<>>+!Ph!P64&1;+/3!P@!!!
&3*%*55*6-+%05%(0.$%-(.55"6%.#$%."(6(.5-%#0"+*%*:80+'(*%0#%63",$(*#o+%*8"+0$"6%1*10(C2%-3*%
<;>U/%7(0g*6-!\F,,/0+3!41,+961!:;!4-306:5<!301654960:&]!\S+,:56]@!!!
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$T]L!"$$?"O$@!
!
H9e4&&!HP!:;!H9e4&&!F,,54014/)!kke!\S+4/!R1646+!F,,54014/!^!e:&1-/60&>])!e2094>:)!%//0&:01!\EPF]@!!
&*+-"10#C%-0%;$.1+%U0'#-C%Z0.($I%X,,"#0"+I%Y@;I%i%_'#*%MNJND%
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a3:9-8+&61a"((#W!!
!
H9e4&&!HP!:;!H9e4&&!F,,54014/)!kke!\S+4/!R1646+!F,,54014/!^!e:&1-/60&>])!e2094>:)!%//0&:01!\EPF]@!!!
&3*(*%"+%.%P*.+'(.),*%.#$%@"F#"5"6.#-%E0++%05%e7(08*(-Cf%c.,'*+%G"-3"#%M%-0%Q%P",*+%\/+66+5]@%
Q**(B(&C#*#d%+!\e4&434])!"O!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@95:2@0&;:a0&3+7@,2,s:,60:&t9:8r9:&6+&6^=0+*t45609/+^03tUU'TL8994&&?4,,54014/?
//9^94603tU'L&+*1!!
!
H9H:554&!e@!!!
4:.+8*(.-*$%7,.##*(+%@3'-%!"#$%L.(1%=0G#D%%%
09%&!"-*9%-+&0#.%$)!T!d-&+!"'UU!
266,Laa***@&:562+5&?608+1@9:@-Ca_+*1aR741,+546+3?,/4&&+51?12-6?*0&3?;458?3:*&?
WT#$(O(@268!!
!
!
!
UOT!
H+&+=+4-!e!4&3!H+<+51!d@!!
[8-"1"n.-"0#%05%&'()"#*%@8.6"#F%"#%-3*%L',,C%=*B*,08*$%!"#$%&'()"#*%;((.C%Z0'#$.(C%
E.C*(D!!&
H144%*#+&",&*9%&:.%-#8(+&J9;$#8(4&D"8#%*;!_:=!"'U'hOO\UW]Lo[@''''O!
!
H+<+51!d!4&3!H+&+=+4-!e@!!!
[8-"1.,%-'()"#*%+8.6"#F%"#%5',,C%$*B*,08*$%G"#$%5.(1%)0'#$.(C%,.C*(+D%%%
/#+)&7+%-@;!U$!F,5!"'UU!![g%L!U'@U''"a*+@$WT!
!
Hu//+5!f!4&3!i+3+51+&!eP@!!!
E0GTL(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%5(01%E.(F*%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
M:D:&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!!d-&+!"'UUhU"T\W]L!#("(?#($$@!
!
H:&.0:6!N@!!!
&3*%Y#8.,.-.),*%&('-3%"+%-3.-%-3*%;#-"T>'6,*.(%E0))C%3.+%P"+,*$%Y+%;,,D%%%
09%&V1(-)#(+)!O!F,50/!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@>-45304&@9:@-Ca9:88+&601;5++a"'UUa4,5a'Oa4&60?&-9/+45?/:..<?801/+3?*:5/3!!
!
H::52:-1+!Fh!f4<+1!Hh!=:&!fl&+5.+0&h!i0,+5!Mh!4&3!F3481!H@!!!
<*+*.(63%"#-0%;*(0$C#.1"6%P0$',.-"0#%05%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*2%L"#.,%<*80(-D%%%
S+,:56!.<!E&0=+5106<!:;!P4/;:53!;:5![+;54)!MRSS)![ekN)!4&3!62+![60!\EQ])!ES_!'(aU"#O)!e:&65496!|!
_F_S"##)![60)!d-/<!"''(@!
266,Laa*+.45920=+@&460:&4/45920=+1@>:=@-Caba266,Laa***@.+55@>:=@-Ca;0/+1a;0/+$'O('@,3;!!
!
H:5:&+<!k!4&3!e:&164./+!d@!
&3*%=*#%Z(00V%;18,"-'$*%P0$',.-"0#%>0"+*%U0#$"-"0#2%X#50(1.-"0#%>0-*D%
S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!\SR`])!k:&3:&)!EQ)!#U!g96:.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca,-./09460:&1a"$"?62+?3+&?.5::C?48,/06-3+?8:3-/460:&?&:01+?9:&3060:&!!
!
H:56+&1+&!MgN@!!!
m=.#"+3%<',*+%0#%>0"+*%.#$%<*,.-*$%X++'*+9I%8%MJ\I%%
#+!k+>4/!P<16+81!4&3!D0&3!R&+5><L!4!e:8,45460=+!i+51,+960=+)!!
F&C+5!fA)!g/1+&!MR)!4&3!S:&&+!F)!+31@!!!
7+%-@;&(+)&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&R(B&(+)&J"4#8;&D%-#%$)!="@!!!
F/,2+&!44&!3+&!S0I&L!Q/-*+5!k4*!%&6+5&460:&4/)!"''T@!
!
d:2&!H-05!A5-16@!!!
;#.,C+"+%05%Y^%!"#$%70G*(%W*#*(.-"0#I%>0B*1)*(%MNNi%T%=*6*1)*(%MNJND%%%
d:2&!H-05!A5-16)!H4592!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@I86@:5>a*0&3?4&4/<101?5+,:56@41,!!
!
H-//+5?N411!F!4&3!e48,.+//!Q@!!!
&3*%7(06*++"#F%05%X#5(*]'*#-,CT7(*+*#-*$%E0GTX#-*#+"-C%@-"1',"%$'("#F%>.-'(.,%@,**82%;#%
4B*#-T<*,.-*$%70-*#-".,%@-'$CD%%%
!"#$%&?&5%(4*9!"'U'hU"\$(]LU"'?U"j!
!
PC%7(08*(-C%>"F31.(*2%!"#$%L.(1D%%%
E(#4;&0%4%@-(>9)!"O!d4&-45<!"''O@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca,5:,+56<a8<,5:,+56<&0>26845+a###jWjTaH<?,5:,+56<?&0>26845+?
*0&3?;458@268/!!
!
H<+51!Hk!4&3!H9N/:62/0&!d[@!!!
P.-631.V*(+o%o830++C%g.Go%*(.$"6.-*$D%%%
:.%-#8(+&3+)1$*-#(4&5;@#%+%&:$$"8#(*#"+&M"1-+(4!F,5!UTTWh!O(\$]L!##'?##"@!
!
_460:&4/!S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!k4.:546:5<!\_SRk]@!
!"#$%4#*(FC%;*(0$C#.1"6+h;*(0.60'+-"6+D%%%
_SRk)!EP![+,4568+&6!:;!R&+5><)![+9+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@&5+/@>:=a*0&3a,3;1a$jj#'@,3;!!
!
!
!
UW'!
_09:/!d!4&3!P+>/0&1![@!
[#-.("0%!"#$%70G*(%Z("#F"#F%=0G#%7(08*(-C%c.,'*+D%
eMe!_+*1!\e4&434])!U!g96:.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@9.9@94a&+*1a94&434a*0&31:5a16:5<a"'UUa'Ta#'a:&6450:?*0&3?,:*+5?,5:,+56<?
=4/-+1@268/!!
!
_011+&.4-8!HF@!!!
*66#%'A#-Z!L'A#%!07S#$$1$!B;,'#$-#66F!'$%!O/%!T#,9!"#$%!;14/(!T-%!;'(-$/(23#+>!O/%!T#,9!
=$/(59!W1(+>!O.(',!0.$#7#+',#-9!16!0'(-#$>!'$%!O.(',!0.$#7#+',#-9!16!01121)#$!BL/6/$%'$-2F>%%
o-++&K1!M+&92)!d-30904/!e+&65+!:;!P41C46::&)!P41C4692+*4&)!e4&434!"'U'@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>a_011+&.4-8?P41C46::&?S+3?k0/<@,3;!!
!
_011+&.4-8!HF@!
P.(+%/",,%!"#$%&'()"#*%7(0g*6-%/*.,-3%455*6-+2%%7",0-%@-'$CD%
S-6/4&3)!p+58:&6)!EPF)!S-6/4&3!S+>0:&4/!H+3094/!e+&6+5)!W!H4<!"'U'@!
!
_011+&.4-8!HF@!!!
P.(+%/",,%G"#$%-'()"#*%7(0g*6-%/*.,-3%455*6-+2%7(*,"1"#.(C%L"#$"#F+D%%%
H40&+!H+3094/!F11:90460:&)!H4592!"''T@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>a&011+&.4-8?8451?20//@,3;!!
!
_011+&.4-8!H@!!!
!"#$%&'()"#*+I%/*.,-3I%<"$F*,"#*+I%.#$%c.,,*C+D%%%
R&+5>0Y+!p+58:&6)!H:&6,+/0+5)!p+58:&6)!EPF)!H4<!(!"'U'@!
!266,Laa=08+:@9:8aUUO((Tj"!
!
_011+&.4-8!H)!F5480&0!d)!4&3!f4&&0&>!e@!
;$B*(+*%/*.,-3%455*6-+%05%X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%&'()"#*+2%%;%7(*,"1"#.(C%<*80(-D%
U'62!%&6+5&460:&4/!e:&>5+11!:&!_:01+!41!4!i-./09!f+4/62!i5:./+8!\%eMR_])!k:&3:&)!EQ)!"$!X!"j!d-/<!
"'UU@!
!
g0C+!JA@!
_.8.#*+*%U0#5*(*#6*%0#%Z"F%!"#$2%7(*+*#-.-"0#+%)C%c"6-"1+D%e*:6*(8-+fI%QN%;8(",%MNJND%
266,Laa***@+,4*@:5>a3:9-8+&61ad4,4&+1+m"'e:&;+5+&9+m"'4>40&16m"'M0>m"'D0&3@,3;!!
!
[#+30(*%!"#$%H%.%U,*.(%U0#5,"6-%05%X#-*(*+-A%%%
!"-*9&E%F"+&M"1-+(4)!U#!F->-16!"''j@!
266,Laa***@>+:;;5+<9:7@9:@-Ca9:&6+&6a45609/+?&:562?3+=:&?I:-5&4/?:&12:5+?*0&3?9/+45?9:&;/096?
0&6+5+16!!
!
g&6450:!R&=05:&8+&64/!S+=0+*!A50.-&4/!\RSA]@!
=(#7P21$!A!L#(/7-1(>!0#$#2-(9!16!-3/!=$A#(1$)/$-2%=*6"+"0#I%Ji%_',C%MNJJD%
g&6450:)!e4&434@!
266,Laa***@+56@>:=@:&@94a+&>/012a3+9010:&1a0&3+7@268!!
\P++!4/1:!@'11.(C%05%U.+*%.#$%=*6"+"0#I%%
L"(+-%;88*.,%05%<*#*G.),*%4#*(FC%;88(0B.,%="+1"++*$D%
A:5<1!:&!R&=05:&8+&64/)!f+4/62!4&3!P4;+6<!!UT!d-/<!"'UUhUj\(]!
266,Laa***@6:5<1@9:8ai-./09460:&1a[:9-8+&61ai-./09460:&m"'i[`1aRfP"'UU?(@,3;!h!4&3!
e248.+5/40&!F@!
L"(+-%;88*.,%=*6"+"0#%0#%<*#*G.),*%4#*(FC%;88(0B.,%50(%.%!"#$%L.(1%<*#$*(*$%)C%
[#-.("0%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%<*B"*G%&(")'#.,D%
7+%-@;&<(-L%*$&H144%*#+!d-/<!"'UU!
266,Laa***@84560&34/+@9:8a8+8.+51aF5609/+rF64928+&6@41,7s:3tU'jUTTT^03tU#Uj#Oj^;0/
+&48+t415?U#Uj#W'@`0516@,3;!@]!
!
i455<!P!4&3![:->/41!R@!
X#%U3"#.I%-3*%&('*%U0+-%05%Z("-."#9+%U,*.#I%W(**#%!"#$%70G*(%4:8*("1*#-2%%70,,'-"0#%0#%.%
="+.+-(0'+%@6.,*D%
E(#4;&<(#4)!"T!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@340/<840/@9:@-Ca2:8+a8:1/0=+a45609/+?U#O'jUUa%&?e20&4?65-+?9:16?M50640&1?9/+4&?
>5++&?*0&3?,:*+5?+7,+508+&6?i://-60:&?3014165:-1?194/+@268/!!
!
UWU!
!
i411920+5?p+58++5!D!4&3!i411920+5!D`@!!!
>0"+*%*:80+'(*%.#$%8'),"6%3*.,-3D%%%
7+F#-"+.%+*(4&5%(4*9&J%-$>%8*#F%$!H4592!"'''h!U'jZP-,,/!UcL!U"#?U#U@!
!
i4*/49Y<C?k-1Y9Y<&1C4)!Hh![-345+*09Y!Fh!PY<89Y4C!Dh!4&3!P/0*0&1C4?Q:*4/1C4!H@!!!
4B.,'.-"0#%05%.##0C.#6*%5(01%,0G%5(*]'*#6C%#0"+*%'#$*(%,.)0(.-0(C%60#$"-"0#+D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$j]L!UWW?!!!
!
i+3+51+&!Rh!=4&!3+&!M+5>!`h!M4CC+5!Sh!4&3!M:-84!d@!!!
U.#%<0.$%&(.55"6%P.+V%@0'#$%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+A%%<*+80#+*%-0%!"#$%&'()"#*%@0'#$%.-%
="55*(*#-%E*B*,+%05%<0.$%&(.55"6%@0'#$D%%%
7+%-@;&J"4#8;!"'U'h#jL"O"'?"O"(@!
!
i+3+51+&!Rh!=4&!3+&!M+5>!`h!M4CC+5!Sh!4&3!M:-84!d@!!!
<*+80#+*%-0%>0"+*%5(01%P0$*(#%!"#$%L.(1+%"#%&3*%>*-3*(,.#$+D%%%
M:D:&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(&!F->-16!"''ThU"W\"]L!W#$?W$#@!
!
i+3+51+&!R!4&3!D4<+!Qi@!!!
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*I%;##0C.#6*%.#$%@*,5T<*80(-*$%/*.,-3%.#$%!*,,TZ*"#F%"#%="55*(*#-%
E"B"#F%4#B"(0#1*#-+D%%%
Q881>(*#"+(4&(+)&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&<%)#8#+%!"''(h!W$L!$j'?$jW@!
!
i0+5,:&6!_@!!
!"#$%&'()"#*%@C#$(01*2%.%(*80(-%0#%.%#.-'(.,%*:8*("1*#-D%%%
P4&64!`+)!_HL!Q?P+/+96+3!M::C1)!"''T@!
266,Laa***@*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a!!
!
i0+5,:&6!_@!!
!"#$%&'()"#*%@C#$(01*%.#$%-3*%Z(."#D%%
`0516!%&6+5&460:&4/!P<8,:10-8!:&!62+!N/:.4/!D0&3!%&3-165<!4&3!F3=+51+!f+4/62!R;;+961L!k:11!:;!
P:904/!d-1609+s!i096:&)!g&6450:)!e4&434)!#'!g96:.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a08>aDAP.540&?9:/:5@,3;!!
266,Laa*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a08>aDAP.540&?MD@,3;!!
!
7,.##"#F%Z",,%eY^fL!D%%&1+)%-!EQ!i5:,:1+3!M0//1)!k+>01/460:&)!4&3!i:/09<!P646+8+&61@!
!
A2+!i/4&&0&>!%&1,+96:546+!\EQ]@!
&'#+-.,,I%<00+I%/',,D%;88*.,%=*6"+"0#D%%%
%&1,+96:5!F!i<C+66@!i%_P!F,,+4/!S+;!FiiaR"''UaFaU'a"U#'W(')!(!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>aA-&164//?S::1?[+9010:&@,3;!!
!
i5412+5![@!!!
X+%&3*(*%4B"$*#6*%-3.-%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%>0"+*%"+%X11'#0-0:"6A%%eS+,:56]!!!
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"''Th!UU\$$]LUOU?UOO@!
!
i-&92!d)!d48+1!S)!4&3!i4.16![@!!!
!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*2%%!3.-%;'$"0,0F"+-+%@30',$%^#0GD%%%
:1)#"4"@;&0")(;!!d-/<aF->-16!"'U'@!
!
S418-11+&!N@!!!
@C18-01+%50(%c")(.-"0#%4:80+'(*%.-%L(*]'*#6"*+%05%J%TT%MN%/nI%"#%/'1.#%Z0$C%c")(.-"0#%
4:80+'(*%.#$%"-+%P*.+'(*1*#-D%%%
M5-+/!^!QI4+5!0%89+#8(4&'%F#%B)!=@!U)!UTj"@!
!
S4<!i@!
U3.(F*+%.F."#+-%!"#$%U018.#"*+%Y83*,$D%
:4*""+(&<#--"-)!"(!H4592!"''T@!
266,Laa***@4/6::&48055:5@9:8a,4>+a9:&6+&6@3+640/a03aOU($#T@268/!!
!
!
!
UW"!
k:53!S+4<!\H49C4<!fD]@!!!
!"#$%&'()"#*+%eP"#"1'1%="+-.#6*+%5(01%<*+"$*#-".,%7(*1"+*+f%Z",,%a/Eb%MNJNTJJD!
266,Laa1+5=09+1@,45/048+&6@-Ca.0//1a"'U'?
UUa*0&36-5.0&+180&08-830164&9+1;5:85+103+&604/,5+801+12/@268/!
!
!
S+03![@!
/*.,-3%455*6-+%05%&'()"#*+A%%!*%;,(*.$C%^#0GD%
09%&H%(8"+&5%-(4)!\g&6450:)!e4&434])!T!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@16546;:53.+49:&2+54/3@9:8aF5609/+[01,/4<@41,7s+t"T""j'j!!
!
S+&+*4./+!R&+5><!`:-&3460:&!\SR`]@!!
<*+80#+*%-0%=4UU%U0#+',-.-"0#%0#%-3*%<*B"+*$%=(.5-%>.-"0#.,%70,"6C%@-.-*1*#-%4>TQ%
<*#*G.),*%4#*(FC%X#5(.+-('6-'(*%.#$%(*,.-*$%$06'1*#-+D%%%
SR`)!"$!d4&-45<!"'UU@!!
266,Laa***@5+;@:5>@-Ca,-./09460:&1a"Uj?5+;?5+1,:&1+?6:?5+?9:&1-/6460:&?:&?&,1?+&?#!!
!
S0.&09C!iN!4&3!N5++&!kF@!!!
;$B*(+*%X18.6-+%5(01%!"#$%&'()"#*+%"#%!.')(.I%;'+-(.,".%.#$%@'((0'#$"#F%;(*.D%%%
N5++&!^!S0.&09C)!!i5:;+110:&4/!S+1:-59+!N5:-,!\iSN])!D+//;/++6)!H411492-1+661)!EPF)!U$!d4&-45<!
"'UU@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>aS0.&09C?N5++&?F3=+51+?R;;+961?D4-.54@,3;!!
!
S0692!d@!!
X#-*(B"*GI%_',C%MNJJD%%
266,Laa56@9:8a,5:>5481a0&6+5=0+*a+&+5><?;-C-12084?&-9/+45?+7,+56a!
!
S:/;+!i@!!!
&'()"#*+%=*6,.(*$%>.+-C%>*"F3)0'(%.+%@*6(*-%Z'C0'-%"+%<*B*.,*$D%%%
D1+)(;&5%-(4)&D1+)!#'!d4&-45<!"'UU@!!
266,Laa***@2+54/31-&@9:8@4-a&+*1a=096:504a6-5.0&+1?3+9/45+3?4?&416<?&+0>2.:-5a16:5<?
+W;5;(C7?U""OTTW((OW#(!
!
O9,'$%2!A!&,/-73/(!\EQ])!#!fk!##')!\UjWj]!kS!#!fk##')!ZUjWjc!EQfk!U@!
266,Laa***@.40/00@:5>a-Ca941+1aEQfkaUjWjaU@268/!!
!
P499:5:660!N)!i0990&0&0![)!e4-920+!k)!4&3!`0:50!%@!
@*"+1"6%>0"+*%)C%!"#$%L.(1+2%%;%U.+*%@-'$C%5(01%-3*%cX<W[%W(.B"-.-"0#.,%!.B*%
[)+*(B.-0(CI%X-.,CD%
H144%*#+&",&*9%&D%#$."4"@#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!F,50/!"'UUhU'U\"]LOWj?O(j@!
!
@.,50($%<*80(-L!!1++!H::52:-1+!F@!
!
P4/6)!F_@!!
X#5(.+0'#$2%%?0'(%4.(+%/*.(%X-%Z'-%&3*C%=0#9-%&*,,%?0'(%Z(."#D%%%
`0516!%&6+5&460:&4/!P<8,:10-8L!A2+!N/:.4/!D0&3!%&3-165<!4&3!F3=+51+!f+4/62!R;;+961L!k:11!:;!
P:904/!d-1609+s!!
P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+)!g&6450:)!e4&434)!"T?#U!g96:.+5!"'U'@!!
266,Laa***@*0&3=0>0/4&9+@9:8a0&6+5&460:&4/?1<8,:10-8a,5:9++30&>1?;0516?0&6+5&460:&4/?
1<8,:10-8!!
!
P4/6!F_!4&3!f-//45!AR@!!!
<*+80#+*+%05%-3*%4.(%-0%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%@0'#$+I%X#5(.+0'#$%.#$%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
5%(-#+@&'%$%(-89!"'U'!P+,6!Uh"Wj\U?"]LU"?"U@!!!
!
P925+9C+&.+5>![h!N50+;412!Mh!4&3!H+01!H@!!!
&3*%.++06".-"0#+%)*-G**#%#0"+*%+*#+"-"B"-CI%(*80(-*$%83C+"6.,%.#$%1*#-.,%3*.,-3I%8*(6*"B*$%
*#B"(0#1*#-.,%]'.,"-CI%.#$%#0"+*%.##0C.#6*D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$W]L!(?UW@!!
!
%
!
@60--"+3%7.(,".1*#-%!("--*#%;#+G*(+D%
o-+160:&!P#D?#j'j')!UO![+9!"'U'!
!3"-*5"*,$%^%.#$%Z(0G#%^)!UO![+9+8.+5!"'U'@!
UW#!
266,Laa***@19:66012@,45/048+&6@-CaF,,1"aHFoFP+4592aoF&3HP+4592@41,7s346+;5:8tOaUa"''(m"'U
"L''L''m"'FH^346+6:t#a""a"'UUm"'U"L''L''m"'FH^346+92:09+tW^5+;+5+&9+&-8.+5tP#D?
#j'j'^C+<*:53t*0&3^81,03tUj'O^010&4&<620&>t;4/1+);4/1+^010&8:60:&t;4/1+^010&;8Gt;4/1+^010&:54/
G-+160:&t;4/1+^010&*5066+&G-+160:&t;4/1+^011:56.<54&CtS+/+=4&9+rS4&C^5+1-/61,+5,4>+tO'!!
P++!4/1:L!266,Laa***@19:66012@,45/048+&6@-Ca.-10&+11a,+6060:&1a3:91aiRU#"j@268!!
!
P9:-5;0+/3!N@!!!
<*80(-%0#%.%@.18,*%05%7(08*(-"*+%X#+8*6-*$%#*.(%.%7(080+*$%!"#$%L.(1%.-%4+F."(G*#%
L.G(%#(%E.18*-*(%e!.,*+I%Y^fD%%
SN!k+*01!^!e:8,4&<!R1646+!F>+&61)!F-960:&++51!4&3!i5:,+56<!p4/-+51)!AaF!S+HFv!R1646+!
F>+&61)!e4584562+&)!P-8845<)!UU!d-/<!"''O)!,!W@!
!
P+>/0&1![!4&3!_09:/!d@!!
[#-.("0%!"#$%L.(1%/*.,-3%<"+V+%=0G#8,.C*$2%=06'1*#-+D%%%
CHC&!%B$)!""!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@9.9@94a&+*1a2+4/62a16:5<a"'UUa'Ta"Ua*0&3?6-5.0&+1@268/!!
!
P+>/0&1![!4&3!_09:/!d@!!
!"#$%L.(1%/*.,-3%<"+V+%U,."1*$%"#%rJD\P%@'"-2%[#-.("0%L.1",C%@'*+%@'#60(I%;,,*F"#F%
/*.,-3%7(0),*1+D%%%
CHC&!%B$)!"U!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@9.9@94a&+*1a94&434a6:5:&6:a16:5<a"'UUa'Ta"Ua1+>/0&1?*0&3;4581@268/!!
!
P+//451!i@!!!
&'()"#*+%U.+-%@3.$0G%0B*(%E.#$%c.,'*+D%%%
/%%L4;&0#.%$!\F-1654/04])!UW!F,50/!"''#@!
!
P2+,2+53![)!H9M503+![)!D+/92)![05C1!Q_)!4&3!f0//!RH@!
4B.,'.-"0#F%-3*%X18.6-%05%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*%0#%/*.,-3T<*,.-*$%`'.,"-C%05%E"5*D%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!Z1+504/!:&/0&+c!"'UU!Z906+3!"'UU!g96!UchU#L###?T@!!F=40/4./+!;5:8L!!
266,Laa***@&:01+4&32+4/62@:5>a6+76@41,s"'UUaU#aO$a###ajOO'"!
!
P2+,2+53![)!D+/92![)![05C1!Q_)!4&3!H462+*1!S@!!
4:8,0("#F%-3*%<*,.-"0#+3"8%)*-G**#%>0"+*%@*#+"-"B"-CI%;##0C.#6*%.#$%/*.,-3T<*,.-*$%
`'.,"-C%05%E"5*%"#%.%@.18,*%05%;$',-+%4:80+*$%-0%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%>0"+*D%%%
3+*%-+(*#"+(4&M"1-+(4&",&7+F#-"+.%+*(4&'%$%(-89&(+)&J124#8&5%(4*9!"'U'h(L#O(T?#OT$@!
!
P25+=+!R@!
&'()"#*+%W*-%E0'$*(%.-%>"F3-I%/*.("#F%&0,$D%
C9(*9(.&E(#4;&!%B$)!"O!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
!""#$%%&&&'(!)"!)*+),-./0&1'()%23",(-04,1#-).')1#560789:9;88<
!
P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+@!!!
!"#$%4#*(FC%X#$'+-(C%;6V#0G,*$F*1*#-%05%;$B*(+*%/*.,-3%455*6-+D%
7.(-%J2%U0#6,'+"0#%.#$%4:*6'-"B*%@'11.(C%05%.#%;#.,C+"+%05%-3*%;1*("6.#hU.#.$".#%!"#$%
4#*(FC%;++06".-"0#%+80#+0(*$%k!"#$%&'()"#*%@0'#$%.#$%/*.,-3%455*6-+lD%%%
F-62:5+3!.<L!!f:5&+5!Mh!d48+1!SSh!d+;;+5<!S[h!H9H-565<!SJh!_011+&.4-8!HFh!4&3!D206+![k@!
P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+)!g&6450:)!eF)!d4&-45<!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@*0&3=0>0/4&9+@9:8a&+*1a4&4/<101?:;?4?94&*+4?,4&+/?5+=0+*!
!
P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+@!!!
!"#$%4#*(FC%X#$'+-(C%;6V#0G,*$F*1*#-%05%;$B*(+*%/*.,-3%455*6-+D%
7.(-%M2%=*-.",*$%;#.,C+"+%05%.#%;#.,C+"+%05%-3*%;1*("6.#hU.#.$".#%!"#$%4#*(FC%;++06".-"0#%
+80#+0(*$%k!"#$%&'()"#*%@0'#$%.#$%/*.,-3%455*6-+lD%%%
F-62:5+3!.<L!!f:5&+5!Mh!d48+1!SSh!d+;;+5<!S[h!H9H-565<!SJh!_011+&.4-8!HFh!4&3!D206+![k@!
P:90+6<!;:5!D0&3!p0>0/4&9+)!g&6450:)!eF)!d4&-45<!"'U'@!
266,LaaO$WjTW$OWT'U#UOj'TO?4?Uj'"($$((#(#"(""WO(?1?
106+1@>::>/+>5:-,1@9:8a106+a*0&3=0>0/4&9+9:8aFe4&DRFr,456rUr;0&4/@,3;s4664924-62tF_:J(9Gr3rUg5/:=.O'Gon?
*WW<i1%g<oH=U8n79.1_E4[g5-%`CH(CiP;kS#k85R2$Ff50-Ei:1SeR%0G_:fUA.Sgk-Ce_FAn,G64f##U`7MkM76MdD`=
!
UW$!
,diSF',NW<2P='j"1Yf,G/=U6[pJP<f-%1UiR$>>&SH"N<;%P-[0F$i9d0S#vPJ9j5D$QJO&ISHpn<MFR$dS_G-9v&=PY:FpdH
M*M+T>8UP>m#[m#[^4665+305+961t'!!:5!!
266,Laa***@*0&3=0>0/4&9+@9:8a&+*1a4&4/<101?:;?4?94&*+4?,4&+/?5+=0+*!!
!
P:5+&1+&!H)!f=03.+5>!H)!F&3+51+&!nd)!_:531.:5>!SM)!k0//+/-&3!QN)!d4C:.1+&!d)!AI:&&+/4&3!F)!
g=+5=43!Q)!4&3!S44192:-?_0+/1+&!g@!!!
<0.$%&(.55"6%>0"+*%.#$%@-(0V*2%.%8(0+8*6-"B*%6030(-%+-'$CD%%%
71-">%(+&5%(-*&M"1-+(4!"'UU!H45h#"\W]L(#(?($$@!
!
P,+451!d@!
E*F.,%U3.,,*#F*%U0',$%@-.,,%[#-.("0%!"#$%7(0g*6-+D%
09%&D*(-!\g&6450:)!e4&434])!O!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+1645@9:8a&+*1a:&6450:a45609/+aTUWW"'??/+>4/?924//+&>+?9:-/3?164//?:&6450:?*0&3?
,5:I+961!!
!
P,+451!d@!
&08%U0'(-%<*g*6-+%!"#$%&'()"#*%U3.,,*#F*D%
09%&D*(-!\g&6450:)!e4&434])!"U!d-&+!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+1645@9:8a.-10&+11a9:8,4&0+1a45609/+aU'U"W$U??6:,?9:-56?5+I+961?*0&3?6-5.0&+?
924//+&>+!!
!
P64&1;+/3!P!4&3!e5:8.0+!S@!!
U.($"0B.+6',.(%455*6-+%05%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%>0"+*2%<*+*.(63%"#%-3*%Y#"-*$%^"#F$01D%%%
!"#$%&?&5%(4*9!"'UU!H4<?d-&+!"'UUhU#\O"]L""T?"##@!
!
P646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!p096:504@!
!"#$%4#*(FC%L.6","-"*+I%;1*#$1*#-%cUiMD%%%
[+,4568+&6!:;!i/4&&0&>!4&3!e:88-&06<![+=+/:,8+&6)!P646+!N:=+5&8+&6!:;!p096:504)!F-1654/04)!"T!
F->-16!"'UU@!!!
266,Laa***@3,93@=09@>:=@4-a,/4&&0&>a&+*1?4&3?+=+&61a&+*1a48+&38+&6?=9j"?08,/+8+&61?
&+*?,:/09<?:&?*0&3?+&+5><?;490/060+1?0&?=096:504!
!
P646+/0&+!p096:504@!!!
U,."1+%05%!"#$%L.(1%X,,#*++I%JO%L*)('.(C%MNJND%
!
P6+,2+&1![Nh!P2+,2+53!Qih!f-..453!ffh!4&3!N5:1=+/3!`D@!!!
W'"$*%-0%-3*%4B.,'.-"0#%05%/'1.#%4:80+'(*%-0%>0"+*%5(01%E.(F*%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
_FPF!0%89+#8(4&<%."-(+)1.!j#"jj)!H4592!UTj"@!
266,Laa04(''O'(@-1@45920=+@:5>aU"a06+81a&414r6+923:9rUTj"''UWU(OaUTj"''UWU(O@,3;!:5!
266,Laa***@45920=+@:5>a3+640/1a&414r6+923:9rUTj"''UWU(O!!
!
P6+*456!F@!!
!"#$%L.(1%>0TW0%p0#*+%-0%)*%4+-.),"+3*$D%%%
:HC&!%B$!\F-1654/04&!M5:4394160&>!e:5,:5460:&])!"T!F->-16!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@4.9@&+6@4-a&+*1a"'UU?'j?"Ta*0&3?;458?&:?>:?Y:&+1?6:?.+?+164./012+3a"jOT('j!!
!
P60>*::3!H@!
&3*%455*6-%05%.%U0110#%!"#$%@3*.(%;$g'+-1*#-%P*-30$0,0FC%0#%-3*%;++*++1*#-%05%!"#$%
L.(1+%G3*#%.88,C"#F%4&@YT<TORD%%%
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!"(!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@841+&=@9:@-Ca-,/:431aPAE[JSRigSAe:8,4501:&m"':;m"'62+45609/+4&3RAPEDU
UU''$`%_Fkr1+9@,3;!!
!
P60>*::3!H@!!!
7'),"6%X#]'"(C%"#-0%7(080+*$%U0#+-('6-"0#%05%G"#$%L.(1%.-%>0(-3%=0B*(%G"#$%8.(V%)C%
460-("6"-C2%7(005%05%4B"$*#6*%05%P"V*%@-"FG00$I%P;@%4#B"(0#1*#-.,I%50(%E.#F$0#%;6-"0#%
W(0'8D%%%
\EQ]!i%_P!S+;L!Fiiav"""'aFa'ja"'(Ujj'a_D`)!UW![+9+8.+5!"''j)!,,!$#?#T@!
!
!
!
!
!
UWO!
P60>*::3!H@!
@'11.(C%-02%%&3*%455*6-%05%.%U0110#%!"#$%@3*.(%;$g'+-1*#-%P*-30$0,0FC%0#%-3*%
;++*++1*#-%05%!"#$%L.(1+%G3*#%.88,C"#F%4&@YT<TORD%%%
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!"(!P+,6+8.+5!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@841+&=@9:@-Ca-,/:431aP-8845<m"'RAPEm"'%:Fm"'45609/+@,3;!!
!
P60>*::3!H@!!
!"#$5.(1%>'"+.#6*%X#B*+-"F.-"0#%d%;++*++1*#-%@*1"#.(D%%%
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!E&0=+5106<!e+&65+)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!"'!_:=+8.+5!"''j!
!
P6</+1!i)!P608,1:&!%)!A::&!P)!R&>/4&3!S)!4&3!D50>26!H@!!!
P"6(0+*"+1"6%.#$%X#5(.+0'#$%P0#"-0("#F%05%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%.#$%c")(.-"0#+%5(01%
!"#$5.(1+2%<*6011*#$.-"0#+%0#%-3*%@"-"#F%05%!"#$5.(1+%"#%-3*%c"6"#"-C%05%4+V$.,*1'"(I%
@60-,.#$D%%%
S+,:56!,5+,45+3!;:5!62+!EQ!H0&0165<!:;![+;+&9+!\H:[])!Uj!d-/<)!"''O@!
266,Laa>+:,2<1091@+190@C++/+@49@-Ca5+1:-59+1a3:91a`0&4/rS+,:56@,3;!!
!
P*0&.4&C1!HF@!!!
&3*%;'$")","-C%05%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%!"#$%&'()"#*%>0"+*2%U0#6,'+"0#D%%%
A2+!`:-562!%&6+5&460:&4/!D0&3!A-5.0&+!_:01+!e:&;+5+&9+)!S:8+)!F,50/!U"?U$)!"'UU@!
!
P*0&.4&C1!HF@!
@')1"++"0#%-0%-3*%P"63"F.#%7'),"6%@*(B"6*%U011"++"0#%eP7@UI%Y@;f!5+L!e41+!_:!E?UOjTT@!
HFP!R&=05:&8+&64/)!e48.503>+)!EQ)!T![+9+8.+5!"''T@!
266,Laa+;0/+@8,19@1646+@80@-1a+;0/+a3:91aUOjTTa''OU@,3;!
!
P*0&.4&C1!HF@!
!"#$%&'()"#*+2%%E0GTL(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%d%X#5(.+0'#$%<*B"+"-*$D%
R&=05:&8+&64/!i5:6+960:&!EQ!g&+?34<!D:5C12:,)!M0580&>248)!T!P+,6+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@;50+&31:;840&+18:-&640&1@:5>a-,/:431aR720.06m"'$U)m"'D0&3m"'A-5.0&+1?
m"'k:*?`5+G-+&9<m"'_:01+m"'m"'%&;541:-&3m"'S+=0106+3m"'H4/9:/8rP*0&.4&C1@,3;!!
!
A4C424120!Jh!Q4&434!Qh!J:&+C4*4!Jh!4&3!f45434!_@!!!
;%@-'$C%0#%-3*%<*,.-"0#+3"8%)*-G**#%@')g*6-"B*%Y#8,*.+.#-#*++%.#$%Z0$C%@'(5.6*%
c")(.-"0#+%X#$'6*$%)C%/"F3TE*B*,%E0GTL(*]'*#6C%7'(*%&0#*+D%%%
3+)1$*-#(4&5%(4*9!"''Oh!$#LOj'?Oj(@!
266,Laa***@I&0:12@>:@I,a+&a0&3-r2+/a,3;a$#?#?"$@,3;!!
!
A4C424120!Jh!J:&+C4*4!Jh!4&3!Q4&434!Q@!!!
;%>*G%;88(0.63%-0%;++*++%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%"#%-3*%!0(V"#F%4#B"(0#1*#-D%%%
3+)1$*-#(4&5%(4*9!"''Uh!#TL"jU?"jW@!
266,Laa***@I&0:12@>:@I,a+&a0&3-r2+/a,3;a%f#Tr$'@,3;!!
!
A4C424120!Jh!J:&+C4*4!Jh!Q4&434!Qh!4&3!H4+34!P@!!!
;%7",0-%@-'$C%0#%-3*%/'1.#%)0$C%c")(.-"0#%X#$'6*$%)C%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%>0"+*D%%%
3+)1$*-#(4&5%(4*9!UTTTh!#(L"j?#O@!
266,Laa***@I:-5&4/45920=+@I16@>:@I,aI&/,3;@,2,s93I:-5&4/t0&32+4/62UTW#^93=:/t#(^&:011-+tU^
16456,4>+t"j^/4&>t+&^;5:8tI&/4.165496!!
!
X/5$#!W9)(.!W96!O/2+1$%/$-!Y!*$%!Y!X3/!"/,23!0#$#2-/(2!M!*:O!*++/,,'$-G!
P@"$)!e41+!_:L!eUa"'U'aU$"WaoMR_`)!k:53!d-1609+!e45&*462)!k:53!d-1609+!R/041!4&3!k:53!d-1609+!
i0692;:53!.+6*++&L!!A+>&0!e<85-!e<;!S+1,:&3+&6!?!F&3!?!A2+!D+/12!H0&016+51!^!F_S!F,,+//4&6)!
"$!_:=+8.+5!"'U'@!
!
A2:5&+!M@!
>0"+*%X18.6-%;++*++1*#-%<*80(-2%!.')(.%!"#$%L.(1D%%<*80(-%>0%J\QRD%
_:01+!H+41-5+8+&6!P+5=09+1!i6<!k63@!\_HP!i6<!k63])!P:-62!M501.4&+)!F-1654/04)!d-/<!"'U'@!
!
!
!
!
!
UWW!
A2:5&+!M@!
&3*%7(0),*1+%G"-3%k>0"+*%>'1)*(+l%50(%!"#$%L.(1%>0"+*%;++*++1*#-D%
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&?&D"8#%*;!"'UUh#U\$]L"W"?"T'@!
266,Laa.16@14>+,-.@9:8a9:&6+&6a#Ua$a"W"!!
!
A:33!D@!
E"B"#F%G"-3%&'()"#*+%H%.%7*(+0#.,%;660'#-I%JK%L*)('.(C%MNNOD%
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a3:9-8+&61aUOUU#!!
!
A:33!D@!
&*+-"10#C%-0%P."#*%E*F"+,.-'(*I%QN%;8(",%MNNRD%
266,Laa***@840&+@>:=a3+,a;6,a.+,a92#(O9060Y+&r,+6060:&a,5+?2+450&>aFS?
('m"'D+&3<m"'A:33m"'6+1608:&<@,3;!!:5!
266,Laa***@*0&3?*4692@:5>a3:9-8+&61a6+1608:&<?:;?*+&3<?6:33?6:?62+?840&+?/+>01/46-5+?
4,50/?#'?"''(a!!
!
&(.#+6("8-2%@*#.-*%U0#5"(1.-"0#%/*.("#F+%>01"#.-"#F%4("6%/0,$*(%.+%;--0(#*C%W*#*(.,D%%
!%B&e"-L&0#.%$)!UW!d4&-45<!"''T@!
266,Laa***@&<608+1@9:8a"''Ta'UaUWa-1a,:/06091aUW6+76?2:/3+5@268/!!
!
A5:84&1!P@!!!
;++*++"#F%-3*%>0"+*%X18.6-+%05%[#+30(*%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
A2056<_0&+!R11+7!P65++6!7+F#-"+.%+*(4&(+)&J4(++#+@&R(B&!%B$4%**%-)!_:=+8.+5!"'U')!,,!#?$@!
266,Laa***@#T+11+7@9:8a3:91a&+*1a+4&3,&:=U'@,3;!!
!
&'()"#*%>0"+*%.%!"#$%=*B*,08*(%L"#$+%[)g*6-"0#.),*D%
%&3-16504/!D0&3!F960:&!N5:-,)!UO!d-&+!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@*0&34960:&@:5>a;4G1a"(j'#!!
!
&'()"#*+%.$B"6*%m),0G"#F%"#%-3*%G"#$9D%%%
09%&M"1-+(4!\_+*9416/+?E,:&?A<&+])!Uj!F->!"''j@!
266,Laa***@I:-5&4//0=+@9:@-Ca&:562?+416?&+*1a6:34<1?&+*1a"''ja'jaUja6-5.0&+1?43=09+?
./:*0&>?0&?62+?*0&3?WUW#$?"UOO"O'"a!!
!
A-5C+/!A@!
&'()"#*+%&'(#%"#-0%/*.$.63*%50(%c"#.,3.B*#j%>0"+*%U018,."#-+%4#*(F"n*%[880#*#-+%05%
!"#$%70G*(%.#$%U018,"6.-*%P."#*9+%<*#*G.),*%4#*(FC%4550(-+D%
J"-*4(+)&J-%$$&5%-(4))!"$!d4&-45<!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@,5+112+54/3@9:8a45920=+a6-5.0&+1?6-5&?0&6:?2+43492+?;:5?=0&4/24=+&r"'U'?'U?
"$@268/s1+45926+58t2+43492+b;:5b=0&4/24=+&!!
!
EQ!e0=0/!P+5=09+@!
U0$*%05%U0#$'6-D%
266,Laa***@90=0/1+5=09+@>:=@-Ca4.:-6a=4/-+1a919:3+a0&3+7@41,7!!
!
Y^%4]'.,"-C%.#$%/'1.#%<"F3-+%U011"++"0#%e4/<UfD%
266,Laa***@+G-4/06<2-84&50>261@9:8a!!
!
Y^%>0"+*%;++06".-"0#%eY^>;fD%
""!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa8+&8+304@9:@-Ca84&92+16+5+=+&0&>&+*1a&+*1a1aU$'W'"#r*0&3;458r*:550+1r*:84&r.
+/0+=+1r6-5.0&+1r46r19:-6r8::5r45+r84C0&>r2+5r0//!!
***@-C&4@:5>@-C!!
!
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
!
UW(!
Y^%7(080+*$%Z",,+I%E*F"+,.-"0#I%.#$%70,"6C%@-.-*1*#-+2%
!
• 4#B"(0#1*#-.,%7(0-*6-"0#%;6-%JOON%%
266,Laa***@/+>01/460:&@>:=@-Ca-C,>4aUTT'a$#a1+960:&a(T!!
!
• /'1.#%<"F3-+%;6-%JOOi%
266,Laa***@/+>01/460:&@>:=@-Ca-C,>4aUTTja$"a9:&6+&61!
!
• 7,.##"#F%Z",,%MNNi%
266,Laa1+5=09+1@,45/048+&6@-Ca.0//1a"''(?'ja,/4&&0&>@268/!
!
• &3*%7,.##"#F%;6-%MNNiI%@*6-"0#%J\i%%>'"+.#6*%
266,Laa***@/+>01/460:&@>:=@-Ca-C,>4a"''ja"Ta9:&6+&61!!!
!
• &3*%7,.##"#F%;6-%MNNiI%@*6-"0#%J\M%%U018*#+.-"0#%
266,Laa***@/+>01/460:&@>:=@-Ca-C,>4a"''ja"Ta9:&6+&61!!!
!
• >.-"0#.,%70,"6C%@-.-*1*#-%$(.5-%>7@%e4>TJf%+*6-"0#%SDJS2%U0110#%,.G%#'"+.#6*%.#$%
+-.-'-0(C%#'"+.#6*%eMNJNf%
266,Laa***@:;;0904/?
3:9-8+&61@>:=@-Ca3:9-8+&6a:62+5aT(j'U'jO'T#$WaT(j'U'jO'T#$W@,3;!
!
• >.-"0#.,%70,"6C%@-.-*1*#-%$(.5-%>7@%e4>TQf%
266,Laa***@:;;0904/?
3:9-8+&61@>:=@-Ca3:9-8+&6a:62+5aT(j'U'jO'jOUWaT(j'U'jO'jOUW@,3;!!
!
• 7,.##"#F%70,"6C%@-.-*1*#-%MM%e77@MMf2%<*#*G.),*%4#*(FCI%JN%;'F'+-%MNNSD%
266,Laa***@9:88-&060+1@>:=@-Ca,-./09460:&1a,/4&&0&>4&3.-0/30&>a,,1""!!
!
• D%%&(4$"!/*.-0#T/.(("+h!4&3!k:53!<*.C!;:5!/0&C1!6:!62+05!,5:,:1+3!.0//1!:&!30164&9+1!;:5!
*0&3!6-5.0&+1!;5:8!2:8+1@!
!
!
E&06+3!_460:&1!\E_]@!
U0#B*#-"0#%.F."#+-%&0(-'(*%.#$%[-3*(%U('*,I%X#3'1.#%0(%=*F(.$"#F%&(*.-1*#-%0(%
7'#"+31*#-D%
E&06+3!_460:&1)!d-&+!UTj(@!
266,Laa65+460+1@-&@:5>a3:9ai-./09460:&aE_APap:/-8+m"'U$WOa=:/-8+?U$WO?%?"$j$U?
R&>/012@,3;!!
!
E&06+3!_460:&1!\E_]@!
Y#"B*(+.,%=*6,.(.-"0#%05%/'1.#%<"F3-+D%%
E&06+3!_460:&1)![+9+8.+5!UTj$@!
266,Laa***@-&@:5>a+&a3:9-8+&61a-325!!
!
p4/-460:&!A50.-&4/!P+5=09+@!!!
U0'#6",%&.:%c.,'.-"0#%E"+-%;88*.,%50(%&3*%L.(130'+*%.-%W(*C+%L.(1I%>0(-3%=(0B*%Z.#VI%
@8.,$"#FI%E"#60,#+3"(*%74JJ%Q_sD%%%
F,,+4/!_-8.+5!"O"O$(OWOUa'#"ea"')!U(!d-/<!"''j!!
***@=4/-460:&?650.-&4/1@>:=@-C!
!
=4&!3+&!M+5>!Ni@!!!
&3*%Z*.-%"+%W*--"#F%@-(0#F*(2%-3*%455*6-%05%;-10+83*("6%@-.)","-C%0#%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%
P0$',.-*$%@0'#$%05%!"#$%&'()"#*+D%%%
M"1-+(4&",&R"B&=-%W1%+8;&!"#$%I&O#2-(*#"+&(+)&:8*#F%&C"+*-"4&"''Oh!"$\U]L!U?"$@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>a=4&3+&.+5>?.+46>+660&>165:&>+5@,3;!!
!
!
!
!
!
!
UWj!
=4&!3+&!M+5>!Ni@!!!
=0%!"#$%&'()"#*+%7(0$'6*%@"F#"5"6.#-%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%@0'#$%E*B*,+A%%%
UU62!%&6+5&460:&4/!H++60&>!:&!k:*!`5+G-+&9<!_:01+!4&3!p0.5460:&!4&3!061!e:&65:/)!!
H441650926)!A2+!_+62+5/4&31)!#'!F->-16!?!U!P+,6+8.+5!"''$@!
266,Laa3:91@*0&3?*4692@:5>a=4&3+&M+5>?/:*;5+G&:01+@,3;!!
!
p4&!N+5=+&!iDHh!p:1!fh!=4&!M:76+/!Hidh!d4&11+&!PFh!4&3!H0+3+84!fHR@!!!
;##0C.#6*%5(01%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%>0"+*%.6(0++%-3*%E"5*+8.#D%%%
M:D:&M"1-+(4&",&*9%&:8"1$*#8(4&D"8#%*;&",&:.%-#8(!d-/<!"''Th!U"W\U]L!Uj(?UT$@!
!
D4661)!Fe@!!!
!"#$%&'()"#*+%1.C%(*8(*+*#-%.%/*.,-3%/.n.($%-0%['(%<*+"$*#-+%\/+66+5]@%%%
H4(;+%;&C9-"+#84%!\_PD)!F-1654/04])!"U!H4592!"'UU@!
!
!.')(.%<*+"$*#-%0#%MST30'(%U3*6VD%
09%&C"1-#%-!\F-1654/04])!!#U![+9+8.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@62+9:-50+5@9:8@4-a&+*1a/:94/a&+*1a>+&+54/a*4-.54?5+103+&6?:&?"$2:-5?
92+9Ca"'#(W'W@41,7!!
!
!.')(.%<*+"$*#-%&*,,+%U0'(-%05%!"#$%L.(1%m/*,,9D%
09%&C"1-#%-!\F-1654/04])!Uj!d4&-45<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+9:-50+5@9:8@4-a&+*1a/:94/a&+*1a>+&+54/a*4-.54?5+103+&6?6+//1?9:-56?:;?*0&3?
;458?2+//a"'$Tj"O@41,7!!
!
D4<+!Q@!!!
455*6-+%05%E0G%L(*]'*#6C%>0"+*%0#%@,**8D%%%
!"#$%&(+)&5%(4*9!F,50/ad-&+!"''$h!W\"#]Lj(?TU@!
!
D+..!e@!!!
PC%7(08*(-C%>"F3-1.(*2%!"#$%L.(1D%%%
D1+)(;&0%4%@-(>9)!"W!d4&-45<!"''O@!
266,Laa***@6+/+>54,2@9:@-Ca,5:,+56<a8<,5:,+56<&0>26845+a###jWjTaH<?,5:,+56<?&0>26845+?
*0&3?;458@268/|301G-1r625+43!!
!
D+.16+5!M@!!
U,"1.-*%U3.#F*%U0',$%mE*.$%-0%<"+*%"#%U0.,%70G*(%7,.#-+9D%%%
09%&0#.%$!\EQ])!UO!d-/<!"'UU@!
!
D+.16+5!M@!
/*,"608-*(%>0"+*%U0'(-%U3.,,*#F*%50(%!"#$%L.(1+D%
09%&0#.%$!\EQ])!$!d-/<!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@62+608+1@9:@-Ca66:a+&=05:&8+&6a45609/+#'j"j'T@+9+!
!!
D+66+5+5!S@!!
@-.-*1*#-%8(*+*#-*$%-0%-3*%@-.-*%05%>*G%/.18+3"(*%@"-*%4B.,'.-"0#%U011"--**)!5+L![:9C+6!
_:@!"'U'?'U)!_+*!f48,1205+)!EPF)!#U!F->-16!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@&21+9@&2@>:=a"'U'?'Ua3:9-8+&61aU''j#U*+66+5+5r"@,3;!!
!
D206+!k@!!!
!"#$%L.(1+%U.#%U.'+*%@"F#"5"6.#-%/*.,-3%7(0),*1+D%%%
/%%L4;&0#.%$&!"B)!"$![+9+8.+5!"''T@!
266,Laa***@*++C/<608+1&:*@9:8@4-a45609/+a"''TaU"a"$aU$$OUUr&460:&4/?&+*1@268/!
!
D0&3!e:&9+5&1!g&6450:@!
;%@*,5T<*80(-"#F%@'(B*C2%%;$B*(+*%/*.,-3%455*6-+%G"-3%X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%&'()"#*+%.#$%-3*%
>**$%50(%c"F",.#6*2%%;)+-(.6-%.#$%7.(-"6"8.#-%U011*#-+D%%%
D0&3!e:&9+5&1!g&6450:!e:88-&06<?.41+3!f+4/62!P-5=+<)!d-/<!"''T@!
i5+1+&6+3!:&!F,50/!""!"''T)!.<![5!S:.+56!H9H-565<!6:!62+!g&6450:!N:=+5&8+&6K1!P64&30&>!
e:88066++!5+L!M0//!UO')!62+!N5++&!R&+5><!F96@!
266,Laa*0&39:&9+5&1:&6450:@*:53,5+11@9:8a2+4/62a2+4/62?1-5=+<?0&;:58460:&a!
!
!
UWT!
!"#$%4#*(FC%@-.55%;6-%;+%;$B"+0(+D%%%
/%$*%-+&<"-+#+@&!%B$)!U#!F->-16!"''j@!
266,Laa***@920//4?4>40&16?6-5.0&+1@9:@-Ca0&3+7"@,2,s:,60:&t9:8r9:&6+&6^3:r,3;tU^03tU'$!!
!
!"#$%4:8*(-%`'"-+%&3"#V-.#Vj%<*+"F#.-"0#%/"-+%!"#$%L"#$"#F+D%%
!"#$%&H144%*#+!F->?P+,6!"''(h%11-+!UO)!,,!U)!$?O@!
!
!"#$%L.(1+%Z.##*$%.+%P0=%E"+-*#"#F%70+-%=*1.#$+%/'+3%-0%=*-*6-%>'6,*.(%Z,.+-+D%%%
09%&D8"*$.(+I!U'!`+.5-45<!"'U'@!
!
!"#$5.(1+I%U011'#"-"*+%.#$%460+C+-*1+@!!i456!%!\P,+904/!%11-+]@!
H144%*#+&",&D8#%+8%I&0%89+"4"@;&(+)&D"8#%*;!"'UUh!#U\$]@!
!
D_RH!ApO!%&=+160>46+1@!
70++"),*%U0#5,"6-%05%X#-*(*+-j%E.G+'"-%.F."#+-%!"#$%4#*(FC%U[+2%&3"+%P.#9+%L.1",C%U.#9-%
@,**8I%%
D_RH!ApO!\H0920>4&)!EPF])!"T!H4<!"'U'@!
!
!01.#%&*,,+%.%&.,*%05%&'()"#*%&0(1*#-2%<*-"(*$%73.(1.6"+-%@8*.V+%-0%^",,.,0*I%/.F.(-C%
.#$%<"63.($+%.)0'-%-3*%455*6-+%X#$'+-(".,%!"#$%&'()"#*+%3.$%0#%3*(%/*.,-3D%%%
H(--;K$&H(;&09#$&/%%L)!UU!`+.5-45<!"''T@!
266,Laa***@.455<1.4<6201*++C@9:8aF5609/+[01,/4<@41,7s+tU$#'O#"!
!
k:53!D::/;@!!!
&3*%7'(+'"-%05%_'+-"6*D%%%
e48,.+//?f:/6!e)!+3@!!
g7;:53!E&0=+5106<!i5+11)!H4592!"''j@!
!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&!S+>0:&4/!g;;09+!;:5!R-5:,+!4&3!62+!d:0&6!S+1+4592!e+&65+!:;!62+!
R-5:,+4&!e:880110:&@!!!
Z'($*#%05%="+*.+*%5(01%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%>0"+*2%%`'.#-"5"6.-"0#%05%/*.,-3%E"5*%?*.(+%E0+-%"#%
4'(08*D%%\Dfg!M[R_]!
Dfg!4&3!4&3!62+!d:0&6!S+1+4592!e+&65+!:;!62+!R-5:,+4&!e:880110:&)!"'UU@!
266,Laa***@+-5:@*2:@0&6arr3464a411+61a,3;r;0/+a'''jaU#W$WWa+T$jjj@,3;!!
!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&@!
U011'#"-C%>0"+*D%
Dfg)!UTTO@!
266,Laa***@&:&:01+@:5>a/0.545<a*2:&:01+a*2:&:01+@268!:5!
266,Laa***@*2:@0&6a3:916:5+a,+2a&:01+a_:01+:/3@268/!!
!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&@!!!
W'"$*,"#*+%50(%U011'#"-C%>0"+*D%%%
M+5>/-&3!M)!k0&3=4//!A)!4&3!P92*+/4![f)!+31@!
Dfg)!"'''!\UTTT]@!
266,Laa*2G/0.3:9@*2:@0&6a2GaUTTTa4WjW("@,3;!!
!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&@!!!
>"F3-%>0"+*%W'"$*,"#*+%50(%4'(08*D%%%
Dfg)!"''T@!
266,Laa***@+-5:@*2:@0&6arr3464a411+61a,3;r;0/+a''U(a$##UWaRT"j$O@,3;!!
\Dfg!__N]!
!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&L!S+>0:&4/!g;;09+!;:5!R-5:,+@!!
4B.,'.-"0#%.#$%Y+*%05%48"$*1"0,0F"6.,%4B"$*#6*%50(%4#B"(0#1*#-.,%<"+V%;++*++1*#-2%
W'"$*,"#*%=06'1*#-D%%%
Dfg)!"'''@!
266,Laa***@+-5:@*2:@0&6arr3464a411+61a,3;r;0/+a'''Wa($(##aRWjT$'@,3;!!
!
!
!
!
U('!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&@!
!/[h4'(08*2%%/*.,-3%455*6-+%05%>0"+*%MNJJD%
266,Laa***@+-5:@*2:@0&6a+&a*246?*+?3:a2+4/62?6:,091a+&=05:&8+&6?4&3?2+4/62a&:01+a;4961?
4&3?;0>-5+1a2+4/62?+;;+961?:;?&:01+!!
!
D:5/3!f+4/62!g5>4&0Y460:&@!
!/[h4'(08*2%>0"+*2%L.6-+%.#$%L"F'(*+I%MNJJD%
266,Laa***@+-5:@*2:@0&6a+&a*246?*+?3:a2+4/62?6:,091a+&=05:&8+&6?4&3?2+4/62a&:01+a;4961?
4&3?;0>-5+1!!
!
n4245&4!H!^!N-0//+80&4-/6@!!!
@,**8I%#0"+*%.#$%3*.,-32%(*B"*GD%%%
!"#$%&?&5%(4*9!"'U'h!U"\$(]L!W$?WT@!
!
n+//+5)!A!d5@!!
L0(%&30+*%>*.(I%-3*%P"+*(.),*%/'1%05%U,*.#%4#*(FCD%
!%B&e"-L&0#.%$)!O!g96:.+5!"'U'@!
266,Laa***@*0&36-5.0&+1<&35:8+@9:8a&+*1a"'U'a;:5?62:1+?&+45?62+?801+54./+?2-8?:;?9/+4&?
+&+5><?&<?608+1a!!!
!!
!