WSL111708 11/14/08 12:14 PM Page 1 NOVEMBER 17, 2008 VOL. XL, NO. 46 BOfA ANALYSTS FACE LAYOFFS FIA Futures & Options Expo See coverage, p. 8-9 At Press Time Goldman Lays Off Analysts Bloomberg Targets Taiwan 2 2 Trading NYSE Readies Alternext Exchange Performance Lags Nasdaq OMX BX Set To Launch BNY Targets European Routing NYSE Straddles Odd Lots IT Budgets Get Tighter Traders Tapped To Recruit ISE To Assign FX Permanently ICAP Urges More Transparency Tethys Adds FX Capabilities 3 3 3 4 4 4 5 5 5 6 Banc of America analysts expect layoffs before the end of the year as the bank starts its integration with Merrill Lynch over the next few weeks, according to several analysts and recruiters that have spoken with analysts there. Up to one third of the 50 BofA equity analysts could be cut. Merrill Lynch analysts are being retained because the department as a whole is more experienced and is ranked higher, one recruiter said. Merrill Lynch was ranked fifth in Institutional Investor’s recent “All-America Research Team” survey (continued on page 11) Ups Payout UBS TO LET BROKERS BECOME MANAGING DIRECTORS UBS has made financial advisors eligible for the managing director title, becoming just the second firm on the Street to do so. In order for an advisor to be eligible, he or she must produce $2.5 million for two consecutive years and meet other criteria such as length of service. One UBS employee said the new title is a direct result of many high-end Lehman Research (continued on page 12) FundQuest Boosts Team Pulse Boosts Indie Research FINRA Gets Tougher On Barriers QSG Launches Ratings 6 6 6 7 FINRA INSTITUTES ORDER PROTECTION FOR OTC STOCKS 7 7 The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority has adopted limit order protection for pink sheet and bulletin board stocks, requiring brokerages to deliver the best available price to customers. Previously, only exchange-listed securities had that protection. The rule intends to curb trade throughs intentionally made by market makers who could make more money trading with each other, explained Frank Grampone, managing director of operations and client services at Knight Capital Group. This protection is expected to attract more Retail Brokerage Indies, RIAs Woo Brokers Alts Lure Mass Affluent Departments People & Firms 10 COPYRIGHT NOTICE: No part of this publication may be copied, photocopied or duplicated in any form or by any means without Institutional Investor’s prior written consent. Copying of this publication is in violation of the Federal Copyright Law (17 USC 101 et seq.). Violators may be subject to criminal penalties as well as liability for substantial monetary damages, including statutory damages up to $100,000 per infringement, costs and attorney’s fees. Copyright 2008 Institutional Investor, Inc. All rights reserved. ISSN# 704-20040 For information regarding subscription rates and electronic licenses, please contact Dan Lalor at (212) 224-3045. (continued on page 12) Impasse Averted BOfA TO JOIN BROKER PROTOCOL A potentially major snag in Bank of America’s acquisition of Merrill Lynch has been averted as BofA decided become part of an inter-brokerage pact on brokers moving firms, according to WSL sister publication Private Asset Management. Restrictive wording regarding taking accounts and client information when moving, which is in the BofA retention offer to Merrill advisors, had many brokers reluctant to sign by the Nov. 14 deadline (continued on page 11) (wallstreetletter.com, 11/7). For breaking news and updates during the week, check www.wallstreetletter.com WSL111708 11/14/08 12:14 PM Page 2 Wall Street Letter www.wallstreetletter.com November 17, 2008 At Press Time Goldman Eliminates 13 Research Positions Goldman Sachs eliminated 13 equity research positions in the last two weeks. The analysts that left the firm Friday, Nov. 7, include Sasa Zorovic, who covered software; Peter Appert, publishing; Oscar Cabrera, consumer services; Simeon Gutman, food and staples retailing; Albert Kabili, consumer services; Michael Molnar, alternative energy and coal; and Peter Salkowski, printing, publishing and newspapers. Later departures include William Tanona, financial services; Deanne Dray, machinery; Charles Chon and Lawrence Keusch, healthcare equipment; Ajay Kejriwal, industrial materials and Peter Wahlstrom, shipping. According to memos, the firm has dropped coverage of 51 companies, including A.H. Belo Corp, Coinstar and First Solar. It has suspended coverage of fifteen companies, including ALCOA and Alpha Natural Resources. Coverage of Adobe Systems and Salesforce.com has been transferred to Sarah Friar from Zorovic The Hain Celestial Group, United Natural Foods and Whole Foods Market coverage have been transferred to John Heinbockel from Gutman. Goldman is in the middle of firm-wide job cuts. Coverage of General Electric and Tyco, formerly covered by Dray and Kejriwal, was transferred to Terry Darling. Darling has taken on 13 other companies that were previously assigned to his former colleagues, bringing his total to 30. Christopher Agnew has taken over Wahlstrom’s companies, which include Hertz Global Holdings and Avis. Many of Tanona’s companies were dropped, such as Merrill Lynch and TD Ameritrade Holdings as were Johnson & Johnson and Alcon Inc., which Keusch and Chon covered. Bloomberg Tradebook Targets Services in Taiwan Bloomberg Tradebook has begun offering connectivity to Taiwan equity markets this week. Users will have direct market access as well as advanced iceberg orders and target orders. The firm is also testing algorithms, including VWAP, TWAP, arrival price and go-along, which will be live next month. Taiwan’s markets, the Taiwan Stock Exchange and an over-the-counter market called GreTai Securities Market, have grown at a rate of 13 percent in recent years, trading US$700 billion to US$1.1 trillion annually. The Taiwan market is acutely sensitive to short selling. All buy orders have to be electronically checked on the clearing corporation to see if there is a contra. If there is none, the order is cancelled; if there is a contra, the shares are locked down to assure the same shares are not being used for multiple trades. The market is an I.D. market that requires traders’ funds to be registered locally, which can sometimes delay connectivity up to a few weeks. For firms who do voice trading in Taiwan, the wait is much shorter. Tradebook also connects to equities markets in Australia, Hong Kong, Japan, Malaysia, New Zealand, Singapore and South Korea. The firm is looking at connecting to other Asian and emerging markets; it anticipates connecting to one more region before year-end. 2 EDITORIAL PUBLISHING TOM LAMONT Editor STEVE MURRAY Deputy Editor VERONICA BELITSKI Executive Editor (212) 224-3297 ALEXANDRA ZENDRIAN Reporter (212) 224-3268 MEREDITH LEPORE Associate Reporter (212) 224-3318 STEFANIE GORDON Associate Reporter (212) 224-3968 STANLEY WILSON Washington Bureau Chief (202) 393-0728 KIERON BLACK Sketch Artist BRISTOL VOSS Publisher (212) 224-3628 LAURA PAGLIARO Marketing Manager (212) 224-3896 VINCENT YESENOSKY Senior Operations Manager (212) 224-3057 DAVID SILVA Senior Fulfillment Manager (212) 224-3573 SUBSCRIPTIONS/ ELECTRONIC LICENSES One year - $2,965 (in Canada add $30 postage, others outside U.S. add $75). DAN LALOR Director of Sales (212) 224-3045 DMITRY MELNITCHOUK Account Executive (212) 224-3317 THEODORE HEALEY PRODUCTION Account Executive [London] DANY PEÑA Director LYNETTE STOCK, DEBORAH ZAKEN Managers MELISSA ENSMINGER, JAMES BAMBARA, JENNIFER BOYD, DOUGLAS LEE Associates JENNY LO Web Production & Design Director (44-20) 7779-8704 REPRINTS DEWEY PALMIERI Reprint & Permission Manager (212) 224-3675 dpalmieri@institutionalinvestor.com CORPORATE GARY MUELLER Chairman & CEO CHRISTOPHER BROWN ADVERTISING AND President BUSINESS PUBLISHING JONATHAN WRIGHT Publisher (212) 224-3566 ERIK KOLB Editor, Business Publishing (212) 224-3785 PAT BERTUCCI, MAGGIE DIAZ, LANCE KISLING, ADI HALLER Associate Publishers BRIAN GOLDMAN Advertising Production Manager (212) 224-3216 LESLIE NG Advertising Coordinator (212) 224-3212 ©Institutional Investor News 2008. Reproduction requires publisher’s prior permission. STEVE KURTZ Chief Operating Officer ROBERT TONCHUK Director/Central Operations & Fulfillment Customer Service: PO Box 5016, Brentwood, TN 37024-5016. Tel: 1-800-715-9195. Fax: 1-615-377-0525 UK: 44 20 7779 8704 Hong Kong: 852 2842 6910 E-mail: customerservice@iinews.com Editorial Offices: 225 Park Avenue South, New York, NY 10003. Tel: (212) 224-3297 Email: vbelitski@iinews.com Wall Street Letter is a general circulation newsweekly. No statement in this issue is to be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell securities or to provide investment advice. Wall Street Letter ©2008 Institutional Investor, Inc. ISSN# 704-20040 Copying prohibited without the permission of the Publisher. WSL111708 11/13/08 7:57 PM Page 3 November 17, 2008 www.wallstreetletter.com Trading NYSE Readies Alternext Equities NYSE Euronext is ready to launch the new NYSE Alternext equities market (the former American Stock Exchange) on Dec. 1. The market is being positioned as an exchange for small- and micro-cap listings, which will run parallel to NYSE Arca and other subsidiaries. The exchange has mostly Duncan migrated the market onto the new trading Niederauer system and has been holding successful testing this month. Duncan Niederauer, NYSE ceo, said on an earnings call that the Amex acquisition is expected to produce annualized cost savings of more than $100 million by the end of the next year. Options will launch in the first quarter. Alternext will feature competitive pricing. Niederauer said that since the acquisition began, Amex headcount of 471 employees has been cut by 35%. “We have planned to reduce the number of retained positions to around 100 by the middle of next year,” he added. It has retained highprofile employees from the ETF and equities divisions, though Neal Wolkoff, chairman and ceo, moved on to run the Electronic Liquidity Exchange (WSL, 11/7). Nasdaq Shines Amid Rubble Exchange Performance Gets Pummeled Stock exchanges in the FTSE/Mondo Visione index continued to see stock performance suffer amid a retrenchment of trading and listing activity. The Nasdaq OMX Group made out the best of U.S.-based exchanges last month, gaining 6.2%. The gain adjusted losses to the least painful among most exchanges, 34.4% year-to-date. The only exchange that performed better was the New Zealand Exchange, which lost 32% in local currency terms year-to-date, according to Mondo Visione. The Nasdaq reported a 27% net income growth for the third quarter over the third quarter of 2007 and 7% quarter on quarter. By contrast, NYSE Euronext net income fell more than 30% for the quarter. In the index, NYSE’s performance declined 23% last month and 65.6% year-to-date. The CME Group made out worse for the month, delivering a 24.1% loss, but did better for the year, losing 58.9%. Rival IntercontinentalExchange posted a 6% monthly gain, but still lost about 55.6% year-to-date. The worst performers in the index were BM&F Bovespa and the LSE Group. They lost 31.9% and 35.3% for the month, respectively, and saw performance declined 76.8% and 71.8%, respectively, year-to-date. Wall Street Letter ITG Sees Pre-Trade Analytics Growth ITG is seeing demand for pre-trade analytics rising amid higher volatility and sharper focus on risk management. The firm, which offers pre-trade analytics along with trading technology is seeing demand from institutions that increasingly prefer to handle trading themselves. “Pre-trade has gone from what I Robert Gasser would describe as voodoo science to become more and more accepted. The demand to integrate it into our product suite is as strong as it’s ever been,” said Robert Gasser, ceo, at the Keefe, Bruyette & Woods conference in New York last week. ITG’s pre-trade analytics play a prominent role in ITG Logic, its trading process optimization suite, and ITG Data Analytics, a portfolio optimization, transaction cost analysis and risk mitigation suite. ITG has been garnering more order flow as the buyside has been moving away from broker capital in a risky environment. Because the company has execution data from some of the largest institutional managers, it is consistently plugging the information into the pre-trade analytics models and anticipates more growth in the space. ITG’s total commission revenues increased to $121.2 million in the third quarter, up from $109.6 million in the second quarter and $117.1 million in the third quarter of last year. Nasdaq OMX BX To Launch With Low Pricing Nasdaq OMX BX, created from Nasdaq’s acquisition of the Boston Stock Exchange, is set to launch on Jan. 12 and will have low pricing. Liquidity providers will be rebated 20 cents per 100 shares and liquidity removers will be charged 22 cents per 100 shares. The Nasdaq envisioned the platform as a place to Brian Hyndman test out various pricing structures (WSL, 2/27). The exchange currently has about 50 users signed up. They are testing their technology functionality and connectivity, and it anticipates having 75 users when the exchange launches, said Brian Hyndman, senior v.p. of transaction services. All firms have to perform a basic certification test before they begin trading on the exchange. Hyndman said the pricing coupled with INET technology differentiates BX from other exchanges. Through this acquisition, Nasdaq has gotten another To receive email alerts or online access, call 800-715-9195. 3 WSL111708 11/13/08 7:57 PM Page 4 Wall Street Letter www.wallstreetletter.com protected quote and it is using BSX’s clearing operation, which will be rebranded as Nasdaq Clearing Corporation. It is set to launch in the middle of next year and it will compete with the National Securities Clearing Corporation. BNY ConvergEx Launches European SOR BNY ConvergEx Group has begun using a smart order router connected to four multi-lateral trading facilities in Europe. Those MTFs are Chi-X, Nasdaq OMX, BATS and Turquoise. The firm intends to offer more connections as more MTFs pop up. “We will connect to MTFs that provide price improvement and liquidity. There are going to be some winners and losers,” said William Capuzzi, president of BNY ConvergEx Group’s G-Trade Services. The router rebalances orders on a real-time basis and will move trades based on market movement. This could provide some latency, but Capuzzi insisted that the latency should be minimal. “Whenever you add smarts to the model, that adds latency but we are talking about milliseconds versus the opportunity to participate in much deeper pools of liquidity, oftentimes at much better prices,” he said. Capuzzi added that smart order routing can improve prices between two and 15 basis points. While the firm does not have a smart order router in Canada, it will be introducing an algorithm in January for securities that are inter-listed between the U.S. and Canada. The algo will allow traders to look into markets in both areas and will either settle in U.S. dollars or Canadian dollars, Capuzzi explained. NYSE Gains More Control Of Odd Lots The New York Stock Exchange has changed its rules to be able to quickly cancel fraudulent or manipulative odd-lot or partial roundlot transactions. DMMs who suspect these fraudulent trades can request a review of the transaction by an officer of the exchange and a representative from floor operations within 30 minutes of the last allegedly fraudulent trade. An officer will then review the transactions and supporting evidence and recommend whether they should be cancelled. These determinations can’t be made later than 3:00 p.m. the next trading day after the alleged violation. The exchange is focusing on wash sales, or orders that involve a buy-sell order coupled with an offer to buy or sell at the same or better price with no beneficial change of ownership. Wash sales are being targeted because they don’t expose the market participant to market risk and can bulk up the number of trades occurring in an otherwise illiquid security. “The effect of these transactions is to ensure that the market participant is able to access liquidity that is not naturally present in the market by 4 November 17, 2008 forcing the [designated market maker] to trade at prices that are advantageous to the participant and disadvantageous to the DMM,” according to the related rule filing. Disciplinary actions have failed to deter such activity (WSL, 9/14/07). This rule change is in line with a change made last year designed to diminish impact on specialists by firms breaking up round lots. CBOE Clarifies Obvious Error Procedures The Chicago Board Options Exchange has clarified its obvious error rules to ensure that faulty opening transactions can be nullified. Two floor officials, in consultation with a senior executive officer, may determine that an underlying security previously approved for options transactions no longer meets the requirements and could therefore make the trades invalid. If any firm believes that it participated in such a transaction at the open, it has to notify the exchange within 15 minutes of the execution, and the exchange should be able to annul the trades within an hour. The official notified can either be a trading official or a control room designee, though a trading official is the one that would be handling the nullification. Both opening purchases and sales are eligible. IT Budgets To Significantly Tighten IT budgets are expected to shrink 7% in 2009 and only grow a modest 4% in 2010, with spending levels growing 8% in 2011, according to a recent Celent study. Thanks to the credit crisis and weakening economy, some longstanding IT vendor clients could freeze their IT budgets, while potential clients will take longer to make decisions on spending and seek shorter contracts. “Flexibility, competitive pricing, modularity, leveraging crossproduct opportunities and exploiting core areas like operational trade infrastructure and risk management are essential in staying afloat,” said Cubillas Ding, senior analyst. One of the few ways to cut maintenance spending is through merging technology systems, which firms will begin next year. New spending could be cut to the bare bones. IT vendors could see reductions in new investment spending drop by 30-40% in North America. In 2010, spending in this area could rebound, especially in Asia; starting in 2011, new investment spending is expected to accelerate in North America and Europe when firms begin new IT projects, the report found. In the wake of being acquired or merging, several firms are also working on integrating their technologies and realizing those cost savings. JPMorgan and Washington Mutual along with Bear Stearns plan to integrate their systems by 2010. There will be a growth in new trading strategies and algorithms to deal with volatility in light of recent market conditions. ©Institutional Investor News 2008. Reproduction requires publisher’s prior permission. WSL111708 11/13/08 7:57 PM Page 5 November 17, 2008 www.wallstreetletter.com Derivix Boosts Risk Analytics Derivix, a broker-neutral options routing and pricing system, has launched portfolio risk analytics to let traders compare market portfolio simulations. The service uses virtual servers accessed through the internet instead of requiring a user to generate the simulation on his own system. “We tell our customers: Michael Stern don’t hire IT people, don’t maintain a server, just trade,” said Michael Barrett Stern, chief strategy officer and co-founder. The system includes pre- and post-trade shocks and simulations and tackles sectors, accounts and groups. The company says it launched the system now due to the volatile market conditions. Traders hoping to cut costs can do so without server maintenance costs. The system, which has been introduced to several select customers, will be available to all customers in the first quarter. Recruiting Firm Taps Traders Link Global Solutions, a fixed income recruiting firm, is looking to hire former traders or sales associates for two or three new recruiting positions that the firm is creating. The firm started a year ago. The search firm wants to tap those with industry experience. The firm would like to expand into equities and two or three of the four to six recruiters it will hire next year will work on equities recruiting, said Joe Messineo, founder. He is looking for staffers who have a significant amount of experience in their business and perhaps have been a recruiter for a few years. ISE Seeks Permanent FX Market Maker Arrangements The International Securities Exchange is planning to put in place a more permanent appointment process for its foreign currency options market makers, so they can quote more competitively and develop longer-term marketing strategies. The ISE, which provides options on the six most common currency pairs, picks market makers by auction; winners get a trading license for three years. Under the new proposal, those who win the auctions based on the market quality commitments and dollar bid amount will be able to retain the license as long as they wish. If approved, the proposal will go into effect Jan. 1. ISE intends to keep the requirement that there be 10 competitive market makers per currency pair, including new listings. Officials said that they expect the market to become more competitive as a result of the new auction process. “A permanent allocation will allow FXPMMs to create and execute a Wall Street Letter long-term strategy to promote growth and trading in the foreign currency product that has been allocated to it,” they wrote in a related rule filing. Those that fail to meet their obligations will be reviewed for extenuating circumstances; if they fail to improve, they will be terminated. ICAP Urges More Electronic Trading, Transparency Efforts to improve the over the counter equities and derivatives markets infrastructure should be consolidated and intensified, according to Mark Yallop, chief operating officer of ICAP. The Committee on Payment and Settlement Processes Working Group worked on deal confirmation and documentation, collateral usage and central party clearing usage, among other things. Other efforts have recently cropped up as well to improve regulation and transparency. Yallop quashed the idea that OTC derivatives trading should be transferred onto exchanges, calling that unrealistic and undesirable. “You impose the obligation to accept basis risk when users from the OTC markets go to exchanges,” explained Yallop. Instead, he suggested an overhaul of the OTC infrastructure and simplification to help create more transparency. Some suggested improvements suggested included more clearing and use of central counterparties, more electronic trading and quicker settlement cycles. API Gains Prominence For Faster Trades Traders who are more latency sensitive are beginning to demand Application Programming Interfaces more than FIX messages. An API allows the user to access an offering more directly, without adding the FIX communication protocol in the middle, explained Meaghan Mullins, managing director of electronic services at Knight Capital Group. While Mullins doesn’t see FIX messages being significantly phased out, more traders are requesting API. Traditionally, statistical arbitrageurs and high-frequency traders were using APIs to reduce latency. “As lower latency becomes a very common theme Street-wide, the more traditional buy- and sell-side customers are now asking about the availability for a proprietary API,” said Mullins. Previously she would receive one request a month about getting an API system; she is now getting those requests on a weekly basis. APIs usually require fewer messages than FIX. Venue-specific APIs are used in markets without another messaging protocol. In Europe, the exchanges use specific APIs while the multi-lateral trading facilities mainly use FIX. To receive email alerts or online access, call 800-715-9195. 5 WSL111708 11/13/08 7:57 PM Page 6 Wall Street Letter www.wallstreetletter.com Tethys Adds FX Trading Capabilities Tethys Technology has rolled out an extension of its Execta platform for high volume foreign exchange trading desks, which cuts out excess trading workflow. The FX offering now cuts FX trades down to their essential executions and automatically allocates gross executions back to the source accounts. Traders can now trade FX on a net basis, reducing the number of currency pairs traded and the amount of bid/ask spread crossed, explained Mary Cogger, sales director. It simplifies the trading process and reduces transaction costs for traders; it also allows traders dealing with FX exposures such as spot, forwards and swaps, to reduce their costs. It was developed based on client demand. Arca Extends Passive Liquidity Credit NYSE Arca is extending credit for mid-point passive liquidity executions to those traders dealing in Nasdaq-listed Tape C securities. Previously, the $0.0015 per share credit was only extended for New York Stock Exchange-listed posts that resulted in executions for the Tape A securities. The incentive is for resting orders that are matched against incoming orders at midpoint; these order types have been gaining more traction at exchanges as many institutions prefer the entire quantity of their order to be executed over achieving a specific price. Arca is applying the new pricing schedule retroactively to Nov. 3. “The exchange believes that the proposed credit will foster additional flexibility and increased system functionality for NYSE Arca users,” officials wrote in a related rule filing. Research FundQuest Expands Research Team FundQuest, a wealth management solution division of BNP Paribas, has hired analyst Matthew Whitbread and plans to expand its research team in upcoming months. It has been gradually adding to the investment research management team to support an increase in the number of advisory firms it serves and the new projects. Two analysts have been hired in the past year, bringing the team to 48, said a spokeswoman. Whitbread is a Chartered Financial Analyst and previously worked at Pyramis Global Advisors and MFS Investment Management. The company is also seeing more interest in its ongoing ActivePassive Funds study. It looks at the performance results of active and passive investment management over various time periods, analyzing over 16,000 actively managed investments in 58 investment categories and representing over $7 trillion in asset value. Many advisors are also adopting FundQuest’s unified managed account, a portfolio with investment vehicles such as 6 November 17, 2008 managed accounts, mutual funds and exchange traded funds. Both ActivePassive Funds and UMA are approaching their oneyear anniversary. Indie Joins Up With Pulse Trading Furey Research Partners, a research boutique specializing in small-cap strategy, has joined Pulse Trading’s group of independent securities research providers. James Furey, managing partner and founder of the recently launched Furey Research, said the entire model of how research is provided and paid for is changing, which has given major leeway to independent boutiques. “The need for research is greater because of the volatility in the market and the indies are going to fill that void,” said Furey. “I am confident that this evolving model, driven by technology and structural forces, will overcome many of the buy-side’s frustrations with traditional practices.” The Pulse research platform offers broker-dealer registration, regulatory guidance, trading and execution and commission management to boutiques. In the past, there was not an explicit price on research, said Furey. Someone paying $1 million was getting the same amount of information as someone paying $10 million, but technology has put a price on research and provided digital rights, he said. “The value of research has never gone down. What has changed is the mechanism to pay for it and the cost of delivering it,” he added. FINRA Gets Tougher On Trading, Research Links The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority is planning to require firms to establish and maintain procedures preventing communication between the research department and the proprietary trading desk to prevent non-public information leaks. Before, such information barriers were optional. Policies and procedures should be reasonably designed to prevent the trading department from getting and using non-public information about research reports for its own gain. FINRA is making the change as part of several tweaks to its interpretive material on trading ahead of research reports, which is being folded into the consolidated FINRA rulebook. At the same time, the regulator is clarifying several rule aspects to ensure that it’s not overly restrictive. For example, if a trading desk happens to maintain public information on a research report that has not yet been made public by its own firm, it is not prohibited from trading on that information. Lately, many news stories have focused on expectations of how a certain research report will rank a company, based on the trends in analyst’s coverage. FINRA doesn’t want firms to be unfairly excluded. “However, having knowledge of a publicly discernible trend is ©Institutional Investor News 2008. Reproduction requires publisher’s prior permission. WSL111708 11/13/08 7:57 PM Page 7 November 17, 2008 www.wallstreetletter.com not a viable alternative basis trading desk to adjust its inventory position when [it is] also the recipient of non-public advance knowledge of the content or timing of the research report in that security,” officials warned in a related rule filing. FINRA also extended the application of the rules to cover inventory positions for any securities, regardless of whether it’s exchange-listed. QSG Launches Stock Rating Offering Quantitative Services Group has launched its QSG Edge, a webbased stock ranking research offering. The automated research service provides daily ranking alerts, tracking drivers of risk and return across strategies such as earnings momentum, deep value, price momentum, relative value and historic growth. The offering is geared toward portfolio managers, equities traders and analysts. Traders can get in or out of positions faster based on the offering’s rankings. “Wall Street analysts can sometimes make their buy/sell decisions based on hearsay or emotion along with their fundamental research, whereas one of the advantages of our system is that our models are based on facts and figures without the conflict of emotion,” said Marty Donnelly, product consultant. Retail Brokerage Indies, RIA Firms Woo Brokers Top producers are being presented with appealing offers from registered independent advisor firms and independent broker-dealers. According to a study by Fidelity Investments’ National Financial, 34% of brokers have been offered a sign-on bonus to switch firms from September 29-October 8. The study used 127 Sandy Metraux advisors working at national wirehouses, regional brokerages, insurance brokerages and banks. “Brokerdealer firms and RIAs understand that in the current market environment attracting top brokers and advisors can be a critical component to their business growth efforts, as loyal high-networth clients may often follow their trusted advisors,” said Sandy Metraux, executive v.p. of National Financial. Brokers believe that 60% of their clients, on average, would follow them to a new firm. It found that 46% of wirehouse and regional firm brokers reported the highest percentage of sign-on bonuses. One recent Charles Schwab ad said “Independent adviser’ suddenly has a nice ring to it,” and a new Fidelity ad said “Want to be your own boss?” Gail Graham, executive v.p. of Fidelity Institutional Wealth Services said, “With the unprecedented events on Wall Street in the past couple of months, we are seeing brokers evaluate the independent model at a very rapid pace.” The increase is the result of a combination of factors, such as a Wall Street Letter dramatic decrease in the value of brokers’ long-term compensation and investors needing independent, objective advice in this market. Fidelity Investments plans on absorbing $14 billion in new assets from its registered investment advisor division by the end of the year (WSL, 9/24). To Lure FAs, Upgrade Tech The technology a firm offers is the most important factor for the majority of advisors when they are looking at new firms, an Aite Group study found. About 72% of advisors consider technology important or essential in their decision to work for a given firm, particularly as a large share of brokers goes independent, said Alois Pirker, senior analyst. The study used 201 financial advisors. Almost half of advisors ranked financial planning tools as their most important application. “If they can increase their client service level and become more efficient, then they can get a bigger book,” said Pirker. The study found that the way to increase efficiency is to increase integration between brokerage and wealth-management functions, providing a bundled technology package in areas such as customer service and account setup. Firms that have done this recently include Wachovia Securities and Envision. “Technology laggards risk losing high-producing employees or face a lower chance of competing for the 25% of brokers considering leaving their existing firm,” said Pirker. FAs Turn To Alternative Investments Advisors are directing their portfolios and clients to alternative investments. A Morningstar study of 1,180 financial advisors found that among advisors who work with individual investors, almost 80% use alternative investments. “With this downturn in the markets, advisors’ favors are shifting, and they are looking for different strategies for investors,” said Steve Deutsch, director of separate accounts and collective investment trusts. About 40% of advisors had more than half of their high-networth clients’ assets in some alternative investments. Almost half of the institutions surveyed allocate more than 10% of their portfolios to alternative investments. “The line between traditional and alternative money management is becoming very hard to define,” said Deutsch. There are more alternative investment strategies in mutual funds and exchange traded funds, a higher prevalence of retail and alternative money managers competing for assets under management, and traditional money managers acquiring, merging with, or recruiting alternative investment expertise. The trend of advisors moving towards alternative investments like oil and gas limited partnerships, church bonds and equipment leasing will continue, said Deutsch. To receive email alerts or online access, call 800-715-9195. 7 WSL111708 11/13/08 7:57 PM Page 8 Wall Street Letter www.wallstreetletter.com November 17, 2008 Futures & Options Expo ‘08 Over 5,000 traders, exchange executives and technology providers packed into the Hyatt Regency Chicago last week for the Futures Industry Association’s Futures & Options Expo. The exhibit also attracted 180 vendors, culminating in the biggest gathering in years. The entertainment portion of the program was also lavish, prompting some to wonder whether the exchanges were immune to the credit crisis. Associate Reporter Stefanie Gordon covered the event for WSL. Lukken: Int’l Regulators Should Share Data Departing Commodity Futures Trading Commission chairman Walter Lukken called for standardized sharing of market data among regulators in his address to a packed room at the Futures Industry Association’s Futures and Options Expo yesterday. Such a framework would allow Walter Lukken international regulators to better police violations. Lukken cautioned that for the proposal to be effective, regulators would have to agree to use the same data format, such as XML. He also urged better cooperation on bankruptcy treatment of customer assets. Lukken also pushed for an overhaul of the regulatory system into a new systemic risk regulator, a new market integrity regulator, and a new investor protection regulator. He rejected calls to merge the Securities and Exchange Commission and the CFTC, an issue he’s sounded off on many times in the past. “If change is in the air, we should start from scratch with the new regulatory vision. Regulatory framework will take months, maybe years to implement,” he said. In the short term, Lukken suggested regulators should advance efforts by market participants to create clearinghouses for credit default swaps. NYSE Euronext Revs Up Global Futures NYSE Euronext is betting that closer ties with China will help it compete in the global futures market. It recently signed two memoranda of understanding with the Dalian Commodity Exchange and the Zhengzhou Commodity Exchanges, two of the four futures exchanges in China, and will help the exchanges develop their options and futures markets. “These MOU’s are an important stake in the ground. They will put us on level footing with other key futures exchanges across the world,” said Hugh Freedberg, head of global derivatives at NYSE Euronext. The two MOUs allow the exchanges to share market research and market structure info. NYSE Euronext will also supply Dalian and Zhengzhou 8 electronic trading and market data distribution technology. NYSE’s European derivatives platform, Liffe, has fallen on some hard times amid market volatility. According to NYSE’s third quarter earnings report, it saw transaction volumes decline 10.3% for the quarter. Ballista Sees Silver Lining In Volatility Having finally rolled out its alternative trading system for block options and delta neutral orders to the public, Ballista Securities is betting on high volatility levels to help its trading volume. “Trading volatility is at an all-time high and gives an incentive for people to trade. Whenever you see a decrease in retail volume like we’re seeing now, there is a small uptake in institutional volume,” said Robert Newhouse, ceo. With a minimum order size of 500 contracts, the Ballista ATS system is intended for an institutional client base. The system electronically matches buyers and sellers of blocksized option and volatility orders. 3D Markets has also been working on its block trading system as well as crossing at a volume-weighted average price (WSL, 5/23). Deriv’s Continue Reeling From Short-Sale Ban Despite the Securities and Exchange Commission’s short-sale ban being lifted, derivatives trading executives are still feeling its effects. Options transactions were severely impacted by the short-sale ban as the regulations made it harder to execute puts and other strategies that would have shorted the stock (WSL, 10/10). “Short sale volume is still down 50%. For one, retail and institutional clients are afraid they’ll get caught out of the blue. They’ve also heard so much about the ban that they were chased away, and then didn’t hear much when the ban was lifted. They still think restrictions are out there,” said Andrew Kolinsky, head of sales and client services at Citadel. The effects are not just limited to U.S. markets. “Some countries that banned short-selling are continuing the ban, months after ours ended. There was no coordination with it,” said William Easley, vice chairman of the Boston Options Exchange. ©Institutional Investor News 2008. Reproduction requires publisher’s prior permission. WSL111708 11/13/08 7:59 PM Page 9 November 17, 2008 www.wallstreetletter.com Repoter’s Notebook Wall Street Letter In The Crowd “What Recession?” The Futures Industry Association opened the Expo opening reception with a wine tasting at the Art Institute of Chicago’s Stock Exchange Trading Room. Guests trekked through the museum to find a spread of wine and hors d’oeuvres awaiting them in a cavernous room. The spread was lavish enough to prompt one amused bystander to wonder “Recession? What recession?” Bottles of wine from North and South America dotted the room, with enough cheese and dips to allow every dairy farmer in the Midwest to sell the silos and collect for an early retirement. Rob Mowry of Trading Technologies challenges co-worker Jamie Ricks to a game of foosball at the exhibit hall. A Side of Foosball The basement of the Hyatt Regency overflowed with beer, sushi, hot dogs, and gifts as more than 130 exhibitors poured out their wares at the expo. Sports buffs could practice their swing with Wii golf at Maron Structure Technologies booth, or give foosball a shot at the Montreal Exchange’s spot. In light of recent economic woes, both NYSE Liffe and Business Only Broadband offered chocolate half dollar coins at their booths. Spectators in need of a little R&R could treat themselves to back and neck massages courtesy of LCH Clearnet, followed by a good shoe shine from RSM McGladrey. Smokers could pick up a cigar, hand-rolled on the spot, from Dow Jones. CME Group reception at River Arts Center. Kseniya Wright and Joe Desnoyers of RTS at the opening reception wine tasting. Artistic Sidecar The CME Group Reception held at the River East Art Center showcased both art and libations for conference attendees after the last panel discussion came to a close. The two floors of the center were packed, with blue lights creating the illusion of water dripping down the walls. Taking an educational walk around the various exhibits seemed to take a backseat to finding a spot around the mammoth wet bar on the ground floor. They Said It… “We didn’t get a Board of Trade, but we did get a Clearing Corporation.”—Jeffrey Sprecher, chairman and ceo of Gene Koziarz of Logical Information Machines and Mark Haraburda of Barchat.com. Magnus De Let and Warren Geers of Johannesburg Stock Exchange. “They don’t call it payment for order flow. They call it marketing fees.”—Andrew Kolinsky, head of sales and client services at Citadel, on options market structure. Intercontinental Exchange, on growth prospects despite missing out on the Chicago Board of Trade acquisition a year ago. “Well, in your case, the answer seems to be “cowboy boots.”— Matt “What’s the difference between a bond and a bond salesman? Bonds mature.”—Brad Hintz, senior analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein. panelist on the question of differentiation. “We are the only unsocialized part of the financial industry.”— Richard Sandor, chairman and ceo of the Chicago Climate Exchange, on less regulation in the futures markets. Andresen, co-ceo of Citadel Derivatives Group, answering a “We’re going to launch four more exchanges, so next year here we’ll have our own panel.”—Gary Katz, ceo of the International Securities Exchange, on the high number of exchanges in the options industry. To receive email alerts or online access, call 800-715-9195. 9 WSL111708 11/13/08 7:57 PM Page 10 Wall Street Letter www.wallstreetletter.com November 17, 2008 People & Firms Smith Barney Staffs Up Jon Lonske, Jon Hyett and Justin Fuery, formerly of Morgan Stanley, have joined Smith Barney’s Boston office. They will be reporting to Jon Malarney. The team has $5 million in production and $347 in assets under management. In Boca Raton, Fla., William Cappeller and Carole Marko will be reporting to Steve Sapirstein. Capeller and Marko come from Merrill Lynch and have $1.41 million in production and $178 million in assets under management. The St. Paul, Minn., Smith Barney branch has just added Kevin Cunningham and Kenneth Last. They came from Wachovia and will be reporting to Dennis Rowland. They have $1 million in production and $150 million in assets under management. In Houston, Ben Cravens, formerly of UBS, will be reporting to John Hantak. He has a little more than $1.1 million in production and nearly $150 million in assets under management. JPMorgan Lures Hirshman Back Susan Hirshman has returned to JPMorgan as a wealth advisor. She had left her practice management position at the firm just last spring to work on her personal finance book for women, which will be released early next year. She will be reporting to David Bloom, head of wealth advisory practice for the Northeast. Hirshman will advise clients on wealth transfer strategies, business succession, charitable giving and retirement planning. v.p. of business development from FirstMark Capital (formerly Pequot Ventures), where he worked as associate focused on data, analytics and infrastructure businesses. Paul McCabe joined as v.p. in the private equity market from JPMorgan’s wholesale mortgage group. Michael Moro joined as v.p. of data & analytics. He was previously part of Citigroup’s global fixed income group. Liquidnet Hires Tech Head Neal Goldstein has been hired by Liquidnet as the head of enterprise technology services. He will be responsible for establishing global infrastructure standards and will report to Kevin Lupowitz, chief information officer. Goldstein worked for CIBC World Markets, where he was U.S. regional head of technology. Pragma@Weeden, Fidessa Get Buy-Side Tech Honors OnePipe optimal liquidity management system was named Best Buy-Side Newcomer in the Buy-Side Technology awards. OnePipe, offered by Pragma@Weeden, was introduced in January to maximize efficiency and access non-displayed liquidity. In July, OnePipe launched Lifeguard, which offered advanced gaming logic, to detect and deter price manipulation strategies. Fidessa LatentZero’s Sentinel was named best compliance solution at the same awards. Sentinel ensures pre and post-trade compliance for over the counter derivatives including accurate measurement of counterparty and global exposure. OTC Valuations Snares CTO OTC Valuations Limited, a valuation company focusing on OTC derivatives, has tapped Paul Bergbusch, former quant analyst on the equity derivatives desk of hedge fund BlueCrest Capital Management, as chief technology officer. He will be leading efforts to expand coverage of structured products and exotic derivatives out of Vancouver. At BlueCrest, he was responsible for modeling volatility instruments, development and analysis of trading strategies and front-office system integration. CEP Firm Taps FIG Execs Coral8, a complex event processing provider, has tapped two executives for its expanding financial services division. Colin Clark joined as executive v.p. of financial services to lead the group. He was previously v.p. of customers at StreamBase and founding CTO of Kaskad Technology. Michael DiStefano joined as v.p. of architecture, responsible for advancing missioncritical CEP systems to banks and brokerages. He was previously the founder of Integrasoft and v.p. of architecture at GemStone. SecondMarket Expands Reach SecondMarket, the illiquid marketplace formerly known as Restricted Stock Partners, has brought on five new v.p.s to support expansion into new asset classes. Michael Anderson joined as v.p. of the bankruptcy claims market. He was previously assistant v.p. of business development in the global structures products group at Dominion Bond Rating Services. Owen Dolan joined as v.p. of the public equity market. He was previously a trader and analyst for ProMed Management, a long/short healthcare hedge fund. Samuel Hodges joined as 10 Investars Names New Director Investars, an integrated research management company, has named Danny Murray to its board of directors. Murray is the founding principal and ceo of DMC Worldwide, and also acts as senior advisor for political and government affairs. He has more than 40 years of experience as an attorney and on the Hill. Kei Kianpoor, ceo of Investars, said that Murrays expertise will be invaluable next year as the company rolls out new offerings and expands into global markets. ©Institutional Investor News 2008. Reproduction requires publisher’s prior permission. WSL111708 11/14/08 12:14 PM Page 11 November 17, 2008 www.wallstreetletter.com BOfA TO JOIN (continued from page 1) While BofA was not part of the protocol, Merrill Lynch was— which also led to confusion over the enforceability of the restrictions. The protocol acts as a truce between firms and allows brokers to take clients’ names, addresses, e-mails and phone numbers to contact them about transferring their accounts after a certain time. Prior to the protocol, which came about in 2004 and was championed by Merrill Lynch, UBS and Smith Barney, lawsuits between brokerage firms were more rampant and the protocol agreement has stemmed these lawsuits. Other firms that also have the protocol agreement include Morgan Stanley, Raymond James, Wachovia, and Focus Financial. The restriction was especially concerning for Merrill’s Private Banking & Investment Group and Wealth Management advisors because they typically have larger books of business and are concerned about being able to leave the firm after the BofA merger is finalized. Although still unhappy with the terms of their retention offer, Merrill advisors are feeling more at ease with signing the retention deal since the BofA/Merrill announcement about Wall Street Letter joining the protocol, according to a former Merrill Lynch advisor who opted not to sign his retention deal. Recruiter Darin Manis, ceo of RJ & Makay, noted that the protocol announcement is part of a larger issue related to the BofA merger. “[The combined platform] joining the protocol is a good sign for Merrill advisors because if BofA had no intent of being part of protocol that would go way beyond just the issues of protocol and actually be a symbol of saying ‘not only are our cultures completely opposite but we have no interest at all in compromising,’” he said. Calls to John Thain, Merrill ceo, were referred to a Merrill spokeswoman who did not return calls by press time. Although no plans to amend the retention offer have been released, a BofA spokesman said that the plan for the combined brokerage platform to join the protocol for recruiting brokers would allow Merrill Lynch advisors to continue moving between protocol member firms but did not confirm the date for when this would go into affect. “BofA financial advisors are not currently a member of the protocol but our efforts are currently underway to determine the specifics of how and when they would become a member of the protocol,” he added. —Melissa Karsh BOFA ANALYSTS Where Are The II-Ranked Analysts? (continued from page 1) Sector and BofA was ranked sixth, but the latter bank is now lagging behind in research due to overcutting the department earlier this year (WSL, 3/14). On Nov. 7, BofA said in an internal memo that Candace Browning, head of global securities research and economics for Merrill, would be head of global research after the deal goes through. The bank has yet to determine who would be leading U.S. equity research. Michael Rietbrock is the head of equity research at BofA. Browning, Rietbrock and a BofA spokesman did not return repeated calls by press time. The two research departments overlap the most in restaurants, banks/midcap and wireless/telecom equipment coverage. One East Coast recruiter said Merrill management will most likely go by sector rankings to deduce which analysts should stay and which should go. This process is comparable to what JPMorgan and Bear Stearns did when they were putting together the research department after the combination in March (WSL, 5/9). Merrill is better ranked in the education, electric power, healthcare, housing sector, transportation and utilities sectors. BofA ranked better in public facilities and development sectors. Merrill also has twice as many II-ranked analysts as BofA (see chart). —Meredith Lepore Paper and Packaging Capital Goods and Industrials Airlines Autos Beverages Restaurants Tobacco Energy: Oil Services & Equipment Banks/Midcap Financial Institutions REIT’s Healthcare Healthcare Tech & Distribution Media Technology Wireless/Telecom Equipment Telecom Services Macro Merrill Lynch Bank Of America George Staphos Kenneth Hoexter Michael Morin John Inch Jonathan Ellis Michael Linenberg John Murphy Rachel Rothman David Adelman Alan Laws Heather Wolf Guy Moszkowski Kenneth Bruce Edward Spehar Jay Cohen Stephen Sakwa & Team Thomas Gallucci Thomas Gallucci David Risinger Gregory Gilbert Jessica Reif Cohen* Steven Fox Jay Vleeschhouwer Justin Post Kasturi Rangan Tal Liani* Bryan Spillane Joseph Buckley Kenneth Usdin Robert Willoughby Timothy Long David Barden Tatyana Hube & Team David Rosenberg Heiko Ebens team Richard Bernstein Steven DeSanctis Mary Ann Bartels *Ranked in two subsectors To receive email alerts or online access, call 800-715-9195. 11 WSL111708 11/14/08 12:14 PM Page 12 Wall Street Letter www.wallstreetletter.com FINRA INSTITUTES (continued from page 1) customers to the market. Now that the market has grown to more $160 billion traded on Pink OTC Markets and $42 billion traded on OTC Bulletin Board last year, regulators are taking notice. Knight saw an average daily volume of three trillion equity shares in September, compared to 832 million listed equity shares, though those share prices are much higher. Pink OTC Markets expects to see volume increase as much as 50% in the next three years, said Cromwell Coulson, chairman and ceo. More companies could begin to list as a result, explained Matt Samelson, Aite Group analyst. “Each trade is more important because they’re less liquid,” he said. Knight incorporated the limit order protection rule into its system starting Nov. 3 and it has also extended this same protection to market orders. “If more companies list on the pinks, then Nasdaq OMX Group and [the New York Stock Exchange] could get more listings in the future,” said an exchange executive. While companies don’t have to list on pink sheets before listing on an exchange, many find it easier to attract liquidity on the platforms. —Alexandra Zendrian UBS TO LET (continued from page 1) Brothers producers coming over to UBS and wanting to be recognized as they were at Lehman. He said the private wealth management unit alone at UBS has brought in around $56 billion in assets from former Lehman Brothers advisors in the last few months. “This is the Lehmanization of wealth management at UBS. It was a big deal to be a managing director at Lehman,” said the employee. Currently, Credit Suisse is the only other firm to offer brokers managing directorships. Merrill Lynch does not allow financial advisors to become managing directors but they can qualify for a senior v.p. title if they have $20 million in production credits over 10 years. A spokeswoman for Morgan Stanley declined to comment on its title eligibility policy. The announcement about managing directors came as part of a memo to brokers on a new payout grid. All advisors who produce more than $440,000 will get one to twopercent across the board. The has reduced the number of pay grids to 10 from 16. For details, please visit www.wallstreetletter.com. —M.L., Melissa Karsh 12 November 17, 2008 In the Bull’s Eye Unemployment Vultures Stake Out Party As Wall Street attempted to get its Pink Slip party underway last Tuesday, more than dozen members of the media invaded the space, camera crew in tow. That made the first half of the party difficult to navigate, as people almost smacked their heads against cameras. Despite the bother, the publicity drew recruiters who wouldn’t pick up calls before. As the organizers gave out glow-in-the dark bracelets to distinguish between attendees, recruiters’ function-appropriate green shone throughout the bar. And with good reason: more than 500 people attended, with the line sometimes wrapping around the block. The Public House restaurant divided into the networking bar area and “the pit,” where recruiters set up shop to interview the candidates. Wonder how many hit the wrong area first. Quote Of The Week “[The combined platform] joining the protocol is a good sign for Merrill advisors because if BofA had no intent of being part of protocol, that would go way beyond just the issues of protocol and actually be a symbol of saying ‘not only are our cultures completely opposite but we have no interest at all in compromising.’”— Darin Manis, ceo of RJ & Makay, on BofA relaxing restrictions on Merrill broker movement (see story, page 1). One Year Ago In Wall Street Letter The American Stock Exchange planned to increase its annual listing fees to cover listing development costs and better match the Nasdaq Stock Market’s level. [Since then, Amex has become part of NYSE Euronext. For the latest on the now-renamed NYSE Alternext, please go to page 3.] Five Years Ago The Philadelphia Stock Exchange had been notified by the State of Pennsylvania that it owed $1.12 million, representing five years of unpaid corporate income taxes including interest and penalties. [Phlx dealt with the matter and has since been acquired by the Nasdaq OMX Group.] 10 Years Ago Bear Stearns reportedly laid off a handful of professionals from its equities business, joining the swelling ranks of firms to shed staffers amid hard times on Wall Street. [Bear Stearns was acquired by JPMorgan in a rescue sale this March.] ©Institutional Investor News 2008. Reproduction requires publisher’s prior permission.