Council for International Development Kaunihera mo te Whakapakari Ao Whanui Clearing the Air: Reducing NGO Contributions to Climate Change Part A: Reducing emissions from domestic activities Clearing the Air: Reducing NGO Contributions to Climate Change Part A: Reducing emissions from domestic activities Table of Contents Page Introduction 2 Six steps to cut emissions 2 Reduce 2 Reuse 3 Recycle 4 Travel 4 The workplace 5 Purchasing 6 Considering climate in decision-making 7 Offsetting and carbon trading 8 Environmental audit 9 Policy 10 Resources 11 Notes 12 CiD Kaunihera mo te Whakapakari Ao Whanui Council for International Development P.O. Box 24-228 Wellington Aotearoa New Zealand Tel: +64-4-496 9615 E-mail: info@cid.org.nz Fax: +64-4-496 9614 www.cid.org.nz Cover: Sunset at Raoul Island. Photo: Sam Buchanan Page one REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE Introduction Human-induced climate change threatens the sustainable development of our planet. Global warming, if left unchecked, will have severe impacts on our environment, economies and communities. As international development NGOs, we should minimise our activities that contribute to this problem, including the way we manage our workplace. Leaving climate change unchecked can potentially be devastating for the communities we aim to assist, ourselves and future generations. Global warming is being fuelled by greenhouse gas emissions. Greenhouse gases include: carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), sulphur hexafluoride (SF6), and perfluorocarbons (PFCs)1. CO2 emissions from the use of fossil fuels are the main contributor to climate change generated by workplace activities. To address this we need to look at how we work, and do what we can to change those behaviours that contribute to climate change, whether directly or indirectly. This guide looks at ways Aotearoa New Zealand NGOs can take action and reduce the amount of greenhouse gas emissions generated through their domestic activities. It contains suggestions, examples, resources and steps NGOs can take to mitigate their organisation’s contribution to climate change. Six steps to cut emissions Reduce Use these six steps to ensure your NGO is acting to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from workplace activities. A major contributor to climate change is consumerism. Many materials we commonly use and consume impact on climate change through the generation of greenhouse gases from their production, transportation, consumption, disposal or reuse. Reducing what we use in the office is a simple and effective way we can act to reduce emissions. To do this is often a case of using common sense. It isn’t difficult to think of ways to reduce the amount of things we use during the working day and examples are numerous. 1. Discuss climate change. Hold a staff meeting where you can identify activities or changes in behaviour that your workplace can do immediately to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. 2. Environmental audit. Conduct a formal or informal environmental audit of the workplace that considers greenhouse gas emissions. This will provide a good understanding of where the organisation is doing well and where there are areas for improvement. 3. Implement. Put in place an action plan for the workplace that people can use immediately in their day-to-day activities. Use suggestions from these guidelines and focus on reducing, reusing and recycling. Monitor implementation of the action plan, learn from experience and consider whether new actions and targets are needed. 4. Environment policy. Develop policy that aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and fits your workplace and activities. This will show your organisation is being active in addressing climate change. 5. Publicise the efforts your organisation is doing through such means as websites or newsletters. Discuss with other NGOs. 6. Advocate. Get involved in climate change campaigns. Page two Two of the biggest consumer items we use in the workplace are paper and energy. They are also major contributors to climate change through the production of greenhouse gases. The following provides some suggestions for reducing paper use and energy consumption. Reduce paper use • Think before you print. Printing documents creates paper waste. Even recycled paper can use a lot of energy to produce, and its production is destructive to the environment. • Push buttons – not paper. Your computer is there to be used: share, store and read documents on your computer rather than printing out and filing. Use your print preview software to avoid printing mistakes and the need to re-do. • Email or use the phone when communicating. Communicating by hardcopy, such as printing out, writing letters or notes can consume a lot of paper. REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE Share and circulate reports rather than printing out multiple copies. • Double side. When you have to print, double side your documents by printing on both sides of the paper. This not only saves on paper but also reduces the amount you need to store, recycle or eventually throw out. Reuse your one-sided copies. Check printer settings to ensure double siding is standard; • Mail-outs. Try to fit as much material in your mail outs as you can to avoid multiple send outs; • Return to sender. Send unwanted mail back rather than throwing away; • Reduce the use of fax cover sheets when not needed; • Share and circulate hard copies of reports and other items rather than printing out multiple copies; • Avoid paper towels. Use a cloth towel roll dispenser in the toilet and cleaning cloths in the kitchen; • Use whiteboards and electronic presentations rather than printing out hand-outs. Reduce energy consumption Electricity generation is often associated with CO2 emissions. It also contributes to other forms of environmental degradation. Reducing energy consumption reduces environmental impact and also saves money. Some simple methods for reducing electricity consumption in the workplace include: • Turn-off. Ensure electronic equipment and lights are turned off when not in use. Have a ‘turn off’ checklist in the office. Turn off computer monitors when going out of the office or if you are away from the Photo: Sam Buchanan computer for more than 15 minutes; • Switch to energy efficient light bulbs where possible. LCD monitors for computers are more power efficient than older models; • Use energy efficient modes and settings for electronic equipment and ensure they are enabled. Timers and thermostats on heating and air-conditioning should be used as well as screensavers for computers; • Take the stairs rather than the lift; • Ventilate naturally to reduce heating and air conditioning. Heat pumps are one of the most efficient methods of controlling office temperature.Ensure windows can be opened and install windows and doors that insulate. Close doors and windows when it’s cold; • Move towards renewable forms of energy such as solar power for water heating; • Fit seals around computer server rooms that need to be kept cool; • Choose an electricity provider with the best environmental record; • Save hot water. Ensure dishwashers are full before running a cycle and hand wash when possible. Re-use Reusing items is an efficient and cost effective way your office can reduce its impact on the environment and climate change. Try to purchase re-usable items Page three REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE and avoid throw-away materials. Some suggestions include: Reuse envelopes, cardboard boxes and packaging such as bubble wrap. Ask suppliers to take away packaging for reuse; Office supplies. Refill pens and tape dispensers. Reuse items like ring binders; Set-up an area in your office where unwanted paper can be re-used. Use both sides of the paper and then recycle. Examples for doing this include printing on unused sides and using scrap paper for notepads; Lunch waste. Re-use containers and recycle disposable plastic, glass or cardboard packaging. Compost any bio-degradable waste; Get rid of those plastic cups. Get cups and mugs you can wash and use over and over; Store cleaning products in re-usable containers; Use durable cloths for cleaning rather than disposable paper towels or wipes. Recycle Recycling reduces the amount of waste that enters our CO2 and methane emmitting landfills and recycled material can be re-used to make products rather than using natural resources. Some items you can recycle include: your recycling, with a little bit of effort: • Mobile phones and batteries; • Office equipment. Give your old usable equipment like computers, chairs, decks or furniture to charities or community groups rather than just dumping them; • Waste oil and chemicals; • Paint. Make it easy to recycle and deal with waste Have a waste management plan for your office that includes recycling. This can inform staff on how to deal with different types of waste, pick-up times and days and encourage re-using and recycling. Install waste separation units that are easy to use for material that must be thrown out (alongside recycling bins). Have clear posters and signs encouraging recycling so staff are aware of how to dispose of their waste suitably. Encourage staff to have and use paper recycling bins near their desks. This makes it easy for people to recycle without having to leave their desk. Start up a worm farm in your office. These aren’t as hard to set up and operate as they sound, and are cleaner and produce less smell than a compost bin. Worm farms mostly produce liquid fertiliser which is easier to use than solid composted waste. • Paper and cardboard; • Plastic; Travel • Aluminium and tin; Domestic and international travel is likely to be essential for many NGOs. Transport, especially, air travel, creates considerable amounts of CO2 emissions. Lowering the use of transportation that produces large amounts of emissions is another way your organisation can reduce its impact on climate change. Some key areas to look at include reducing both air travel and private car commuting. • Clothing and rags (use a clothing bin or take to your local op-shop); • Printer toner; • Kitchen waste. A lot of organic and other material can be composted and re-used in the office (e.g. for plants) or for staff to take home with them. Compostable wastes include: √ Food scraps; √ Tea leaves and bags, coffee grounds and filters; √ Plant trimmings and flowers; √ Paper plates and napkins; √ Paper towels and tissues. You can often recycle more than you think. Check with your local council about recycling services, times and locations. Here are a few items you can add to Page four Reduce air travel Air travel is often the easiest and most convenient means of travelling. It is also one of the most emissions-intensive activities we can do. Globally, the world’s 16,000 commercial jet aircraft generate more than 700 million tonnes of carbon dioxide per year. Aviation generates nearly as much CO2 annually as that from all human activities in Africa.2 Having to fly is sometimes unavoidable, especially when employing participatory approaches to development; however, there are actions that NGOs can take to reduce air travel. REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE Avoid unnecessary travel. Prioritise trips, plan carefully and consider environmental implications when making decisions that will involve air travel; Hold meetings and events in locations that minimise the distance people have to travel to attend. Consider travel distances for development partners; Avoid flying short distances. Look to use means other than air travel for domestic transport such as: √ Public transport; √ Car pooling; Look for alternatives to face-to-face meetings such as: √ Email conferences; √ Teleconferences; √ Videoconferences; Emissions reducing options for private car use If unavoidable, there are options that can reduce the generation of emissions from using a private car for commuting or other travel. Examples include: • Car pooling; • Car sharing services; • Adopting fuel efficient driving habits; • Ensuring the vehicle is regularly maintained and your tyres are properly inflated; • Purchasing fuel efficient vehicles or those that use alternatives to petrol – LPG, electric, hybrids; • Using bio-fuels or petrol/bio blends; • When renting a vehicle, choose one that is the most fuel efficient and produces the least emissions; • Keep old cars in service rather than buying new ones. √ Skype and web-based presentations. Reduce car travel Forty percent of Aotearoa New Zealand’s CO 2 emissions come from transport, with private car use being the biggest contributor. Alternatives to private car use for commuting and other work-related travel should be encouraged. ‘Active transportation’ such as walking or biking, is cheap and provides health benefits for those who are able to do it. It is also improves staff retention and productivity. Public transport, such as catching the bus or train to work is also preferable to taking the car. Some simple ways of encouraging active and public transport in the workplace include: Incentives to those who walk or bike to work e.g. subsidise cycle gear (bike locks, helmets, gloves) or personal security items (personal alarms); Secure and easy to access bike stands and ensure there is adequate security lighting for walkers; Showers and changing room facilities for staff needing to shower and change their clothes; Small items can make a difference e.g. coat racks for wet clothes and umbrellas or providing a basic bicycle repair kit at work; Consider subsidising public transport for staff; Be flexible with those staff who rely on public transport (it’s not always their fault that the bus or train was late). The workplace Worktowards having an office environment that has features that can lower workplace emissions. When choosing a new premises (due to relocation or expansion) look for locations that already have these features. These include: Access. Being close to public transport reduces private car commuting; Insulation. Good insulation and features like double glazed windows cuts down on heating and air conditioning emissions and costs; Vegetation. Gardens and other green areas not only help offset workplace emissions but also provide a pleasant environment for staff and visitors. Rooftop gardens are becoming more popular and have numerous benefits; Windows and ventilation. Windows that let in sun and other natural ways of ventilation reduce the need for heating and air conditioning. Working from home Working from home reduces transport emissions by removing the need to commute, however it can duplicate energy use (e.g. lighting and heating) which would normally be shared in the workplace. Unless enough staff work from home to enable offices to be closed, this practice can create more emissions than from the workplace alone. It can also be expensive for workers through having to cover their own energy costs. There is no clear answer on working from home as a means Page five REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE of reducing work-related CO2 emissions, but it may suit some NGOs. Flexible work hours One barrier to public transport use is its irregularity. Becoming late for work due to a hold up to buses or trains can be a big incentive to take the car. Flexible work hours make it easier for staff to access public transport and can encourage staff to make the change from private car commuting to public options. Implement flexitime or self-rostering systems of work that allow flexibility for when staff need to be in the office as a means to enable staff to use public transport. Roster part time staff to avoid purchasing duplicate equipment that may remain unused for much of the week. Dress codes Dress codes in the workplace mean people conform to a certain way of looking but they can also have environmental implications. Suits and other expensive items of clothing can be energy intensive to produce, and dry cleaning uses chemicals that are damaging if they get into the soil or water aquifers. A lack of a dress code gives staff the ability to choose work clothes that have less of an impact on the environment, such as second-hand clothing or clothes made out of recycled or environmentally friendly fibres, and which don’t require dry-cleaning. Purchasing Use your purchasing power. Almost all items you purchase or consume create greenhouse gas emissions. Simply put, reducing the amount of items your workplace purchases or consumes will lessen its impact on climate change. To buy, or what to buy? That is the question. Purchasing products and materials in the workplace is unavoidable. When you have to buy, think of the environmental implications of what you are purchasing and choose products or materials that are less environmentally damaging than others on the market. Make informed purchasing decisions by looking at labelling and questioning retailers. Questions to consider when choosing products: • Is it durable and designed to last? • Will it damage the environment when you use or dispose of it? • Where has it been made? Has it been sourced locally? Is it fair trade? • How was it manufactured? Was this process environmentally damaging or emissions/energy intensive? • Is it biodegradable? • Is it energy efficient? Does it have a low power mode? • Is it recyclable or does it contain recycled material? Do you have workplace facilities to recycle it? Recycling paper and maintaining a casual dress code can reduce impacts. Photo: Sam Buchanan Page six REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE • Are there other options that have less impact on the environment? • Is it ‘tree free’ (i.e. material that did not involve cutting down trees)? • Does it have a credible environmental label (e.g. the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) label on paper and timber products)? Suggestions for purchasing Buy local products. Transporting goods creates emissions. Choose products that are locally made. Buy fair trade. When you can’t buy local coffee, tea, cocoa and cotton, buy fair trade products which include environmental standards that reduce emissions. Buy second hand. Purchasing second hand equipment avoids production emissions… and is cheaper. Buy in bulk to avoid packaging and transport emissions. Repair where possible rather than purchasing a new product. Share office equipment (such as staplers, scissors and hole punches) rather than having one each. Don’t purchase unless you have to! What to look for when purchasing common workplace items: Paper. Look for 100 percent recycled paper that has a chlorine-free production, or paper from ‘tree-free’ sources (i.e. hemp, kenaf, recovered cotton etc). Avoid coloured paper. Food. Organic and vegetarian foods create fewer emissions in their production than conventional options. They are also good for you. etc); • Advertising; • Training; • Catering; • Event hosting and preparation. Questions for suppliers: When choosing a supplier, ask them about their environmental practices. • What sort of products do they use? Are they environmentally safe? • Does their sector have environmental standards? Do they adhere to them? • Are the products they supply sourced using fair trade standards? • Do they carry out any ‘environmentally friendly’ activities? (e.g. supporting an environmental cause or an environmental organisation, carbon offsetting or conducting their own environmental activities or campaigns) But be aware of greenwashing. • Do they have any environmental policy relating to the work they undertake? • What sort of greenhouse gas emissions do their activities produce? What are they doing to mitigate them? Talking to suppliers about these issues allows you to choose the one that provides the most ‘environmentally friendly’ service and produces the least emissions. It also shows suppliers that climate change is an issue consumers want them to address. This can encourage suppliers that are not already acting to reduce their emissions to do so. Services and suppliers Many companies and products do not have specific information on the emissions they create. In most cases, those companies that are implementing other aspects of corporate social responsibility will also be those who also act to reduce their climate impacts. Seek out those companies that are able to demonstrate sound practices towards the environment, their workers and their communities. At times Aotearoa New Zealand NGOs need to outsource services from external suppliers. Such services commonly used by NGOs include: Considering climate Office equipment. Purchase items that are energy efficient and have low-power modes. Check and compare energy ratings. Cleaning products. Purchase biodegradable cleaning products. Look for those that use organic rather than synthetic compounds. • Printing; • Secretarial services; • Marketing; • Production of promotional material (T-shirts, hats Combating climate change will require concerted awareness and action. Climate change needs to be an ongoing consideration for NGOs in Aotearoa New Zealand. Keep climate change high on your conscience when making decisions that have environmental implications. Page seven REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE Steam age communications technology can reduce the need to travel. Day-to-day activities: Choose options that lessen your contribution to climate change by thinking about the consequences of your activities. For example, when deciding how to get across town to attend a meeting, think about the options you can take and choose the one that causes the least emissions. Take the bus instead of a taxi, or even better, walk. Changes to these types of day-to-day activities can make a difference. Innovate: Addressing climate change will require us to come up with new ideas and ways of doing things. We need to look at how our behaviour contributes to climate change and make changes that mitigate our impact. Identifying new ways of doing things in the workplace that are less environmentally damaging and produce fewer emissions is important in achieving this. Look at how your workplace operates and encourage innovative ideas that will reduce the environmental impact of your office. Some suggestions that encourage innovation include: • Brainstorm. At the next staff meeting have a brainstorming session on how to reduce your workplace’s contribution to climate change. Document and investigate new ideas that come up. • Don’t scoff. Ideas that originally sound implausible might have merit. Have an open mind. • Share your ideas with others. They may also have ideas that your workplace can use. • Measure success in ways that consider environmental impact. Evaluating solely by quantity rather than Page eight Photo: Sam Buchanan quality can increase NGO impact on climate change. For example, increasing the number of subscribers to a hard copy publication is often a measure of success. An increase in emissions from the production of the publication may be disregarded as an inevitable cost of this success. If qualitative means of evaluation were used, such as how the publication was being utilised by readers, then success can be measured without increased production. More isn’t always better. • Invest ethically and choose investment options that do not involve the production of large amounts of greenhouse gases. Offsetting and carbon trading Offsetting… or putting off? Carbon offsetting is a means of mitigating climate change by engaging in activities that compensate for the production of greenhouse gas emissions. It usually involves voluntary actions and is seen as a means of addressing climate change when reducing emissions is expensive or not possible. An example is planting trees to offset emissions from activities such as air travel. Carbon trading is purchasing carbon credits from an organisation that conducts activities that reduce greenhouse gas emissions in order to offset the activities you conduct that produce emissions. This puts a monetary cost on emissions with the aim of discouraging activities that produce them because of their financial cost. An example would be an NGO purchasing carbon credits REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE from another organisation that plants trees in order to offset CO2 emissions from air travel. A carbon marketplace, where carbon credits are traded has been promoted as a means of reducing emissions. Carbon offsetting and carbon trading are aspects of the same concept and are controversial. Critics claim offsetting is too scientifically imprecise to be effective2. For example, while it is possible to measure CO2 emissions from a smokestack, it is not so easy to accurately measure the CO2 uptake of a forest planted as an offsetting measure. There is also a time lag between the CO2 produced by the smokestack now, and the CO2 the forest will absorb once the trees reach maturity. In this way offsetting could be seen as ‘putting off’– carrying on with emissions producing activities now by investing in activities that would absorb emissions at a later date. It also enables activities that are lucrative enough to bear the cost of offsetting payments to continue even though they may produce substantial emissions, thus discouraging them being phased out. Addressing climate change requires us to drastically reduce activities that create emissions now. Offsetting should be seen as a last resort for NGOs that are otherwise unable to reduce their emissions or when activities that produce high emissions, such as air travel, are essential. Offsetting should be used to complement emissions reducing activities, rather than a means of avoiding them. Look to offset when: • Your workplace has exhausted all other means of reducing emissions; • Emissions-producing activities are essential for your work and unavoidable; • The activity is of a nature that produces considerable emissions (e.g. air travel). Environmental audit An environmental audit is a systematic and comprehensive evaluation of an organisation that investigates its environmental performance. Its objective is to provide a documented overview of the organisation with regards to its impact on the environment, and identify areas of achievement and improvement. An environmental audit of your workplace: • Provides a ‘snapshot’ of an organisation’s environmental performance that enables both management and staff to identify what they are doing well and establish a baseline from which improvements can be made; • Raises awareness in the workplace on how the organisations’ activities impact on the environment and the importance of considering issues such as climate change in day-to-day operations; Air travel wrecks the planet. Stay at home or take the train. Photo:Wikimedia commons Page nine REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE • Can be used as a public relations tool. Making public the findings of an environmental audit can be used to show that an organisation takes climate change seriously and is acting to reduce its environmental impact. This may be particularly important for NGOs if they are involved in advocacy on environmental issues and wish to maintain credibility; • Encourages good environmental practices and discourages damaging activities. An environmental audit of your workplace can be done internally or be outsourced and will provide your organisation with a good understanding of how it can improve its practices in order to reduce its impact on climate change. It also positively reinforces behaviours that help reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Involve staff as much as possible. Ecological footprint Measuring your ecological footprint is one way of auditing your workplace or your own activities and lifestyle. Your ecological footprint shows how much land is required to support your lifestyle and your CO2 emissions. Policy is a tool for organisations to address issues and guide decision making. An environment or climate change policy can be used to steer organisational behaviour towards reducing emissions and demonstrates that your organisation is acting to address climate change. Again, involve staff in the process as much as possible. Develop a policy that: • Explicitly aims to address climate change and reduce the emissions your organisation creates; • Looks at issues includes reducing, reusing and recycling, energy, procurement, travel, work, conditions, the work environment, carbon offsetting and monitoring and evaluation; • Is simple to read and implement; • Is continually reviewed and updated; • Has input from staff and management; • Is measured and reported on; • Is adhered to and not ignored. Policy Framework NGOs often have policies for many aspects of work such as travel, communications and procurement. Review your organisations’ policy framework to ensure it is coherent and does not contradict emissions reducing initiatives. Photo: Sam Buchanan Ecological footprint calculators have limitations and are not as comprehensive as a formal audit that is tailored for your workplace. A number of ecological footprint calculators have been developed and are available on the internet (see Resources). Policy Stairs are nature’s cardiac monitor and a means of changing altitude without using fossil fuels. Page ten REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE Make the effort Changing workplace practices to reduce emissions won’t happen overnight. Make the effort and do what is practical and possible from these guidelines. No effort is wasted. Resources Climate Change Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) http://www.ipcc.ch Driving more efficiently (US Dept of Energy) http://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/driveHabits.shtml United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change http://unfccc.int Reuse Rooftop Gardens http://rooftopgardens.ca New Zealand Climate Change Ministry for the Environment http://www.mfe.govt.nz/issues/climate Worm Farms http://www.ccc.govt.nz/Waste/Composting/ WormFarming.asp 4 Million Careful Owners (Ministry for the Environment) http://www.climatechange.govt.nz Reduce Greenpeace New Zealand Only Planet Guide http://www.greenpeace.org/new-zealand/only-planet Greenpeace New Zealand Clean Energy Guide: http://www.cleanenergyguide.org.nz Reduce Rubbish http://www.reducerubbish.govt.nz CarbonZero (Landcare) http://www.carbonzero.co.nz/ Greenpeace International: Your energy savings http://www.greenpeace.org/international/campaigns/ climate-change/take_action/your-energy The Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority (EECA) http://www.eeca.govt.nz EnergyWise (Energy Management for homes) http://www.energywise.org.nz Emprove (Energy Management for businesses) http://www.emprove.org.nz EECA Business http://www.eecabusiness.govt.nz/ Transport Motor Vehicles (Ministry for the Environment) http://www.mfe.govt.nz/issues/transport/sustainable/ vehicles.html Transport (Ministry for the Environment) http://www.mfe.govt.nz/issues/transport Recycle Plastic identification codes http://www.reducerubbish.govt.nz/recycle/plasticid.html Can recycling: http://www.canzbac.co.nz The Carbon Gym http://carbongym.cat.org.uk/carbongym Carbon zero http://www.carbonzero.co.nz Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) http://www.fscus.org Environmental Audit Simple Guide to Environmental Audit http://www.epd.gov.hk/epd/english/how_help/ tools_ea/audit_1.html Environment Policy Development Resource Centre http://www.drc.org.nz/environpol.htm Campaigns Be the Change http://www.bethechange.org.nz/ Climate Defence Network http://www.climatedefence.org.nz Climate Action Network http://www.climatenetwork.org Campaign Against Climate Change http://www.campaigncc.org Page eleven REDUCING NGO CONTRIBUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE Ecological Footprint Footprint of Nations http://www.ecologicalfootprint.org Ecological Footprint quiz http://www.myfootprint.org Calculate your personal ecological footprint (Ministry for the Environment) http://www.mfe.govt.nz/withyou/do/footprint The Office Footprint Calculator h t t p : / / w w w. t h e g r e e n o f f i c e . c o m / c a r b o n / our_calculator.php Global Ecological Footprint Calculator h t t p : / / w w w. e c o l o g i c a l f o o t p r i n t . o r g / Global%20Footprint%20Calculator/GFPCalc.html carboNZero Business h t t p : / / w w w. c a r b o n z e r o . c o . n z / c a l c u l a t o r s / calculators_smallbusiness.asp Notes 1 http://www.carbonzero.co.nz/faq.asp#Whatgases 2 George Monbiot, The scam of global warming is that we pay others for our complacency. The Guardian, January 17 2006. Page twelve Trampers in the Mount Arthur region of the South Island. Responding to climate change may require cultural and behavourial changes. Photo: A. B. McGillicuddy. Council for International Development Kaunihera mo te Whakapakari Ao Whanui Aotearoa New Zealand