World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 of 3 Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE Overview Overall days: 10 (1 day = 50-55 minutes) Purpose This unit focuses on two key developments of the early centuries CE that prepare students for study of world history in the centuries from 500 to 1750 CE. Students will first explore the basic characteristics of large states and empires that stretched across Afroeurasia from Rome in the west to the Han Chinese Empire in the east. Second, they will investigate the basic teachings and practices of Buddhism and Christianity, universalist religions that spread widely in the first five centuries CE. This unit also requires students to investigate large-scale developments in world history that cut across the boundaries of particular states and civilizations. Content to be learned Processes to be used Gather, classify, and compare knowledge about major states and empires that existed in Afroeurasia in the early centuries CE, focusing on the Roman Empire, the kingdom of Kush on the upper Nile River, Axum in Ethiopia, the Parthian Empire in Iran and Mesopotamia, and the Han Chinese Empire. Draw upon data in historical maps to identify major states and empires of the early centuries CE, and compare their political and economic characteristics. Map key routes of exchange and major trade centers in which large states participated in the early centuries CE. Analyze the ways by which large states facilitated long-distance trade. Compare the basic teachings and practices of Buddhism and Christianity in the early centuries CE. Compare and contrast differing sets of ideas, values, behaviors, and institutions in relation to Buddhism and Christianity in the early centuries CE. Analyze why both Buddhism and Christianity began to spread widely in several directions in Afroeurasia in the early centuries CE. Consider multiple perspectives of various peoples in the past by demonstrating the differing motives, beliefs, interests, hopes, and fears of people who were attracted to Buddhism or Christianity. Essential question students should be able to answer by end of unit In what ways were the growth of long-distance trade and the development of a chain of large and prosperous states across Afroeurasia in the early centuries CE related? What factors help explain why both Buddhism and Christianity spread widely beyond the lands of their birth in the early centuries CE? Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin In what ways might trade between different societies contribute to change in those societies, and what connections might there be between trade and the spread of ideas and technologies? D-9 World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 Version 2 Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE (10 days) Written Curriculum Grade-Span Expectations HP 1: History is an account of human activities that is interpretive in nature. HP 1 (5-6) –1 Students act as historians, using a variety of tools (e.g., artifacts and primary and secondary sources) by… b. using sources to support the stories of history (How do we know what we know?) National Standards for History (World History, Grades 5–12) Era 3: Classical Traditions, Major Religions, and Giant Empires, 1000 BCE–300 CE Standard 5: Major global trends from 1000 BCE–300 CE. 5A The student understands major global trends from 1000 BCE to 300 CE. Therefore, the student is able to Analyze the significance of military power, state bureaucracy, legal codes, belief systems, written languages, and communications and trade networks in the development of large regional empires. [Interrogate historical data] Analyze how new religious or ethical systems contributed to cultural integration of large regions of Afroeurasia. [Analyze cause-and-effect relationships] Analyze ways in which trade networks, merchant communities, state power, tributary systems of production, and other factors contributed to the economic integration of large regions of Afroeurasia. [Employ quantitative analysis] Era 4: Expanding Zones of Exchange and Encounter, 300–1000 CE Standard 1: Imperial crises and their aftermath, 300-700 CE 1B The student understands the expansion of Christianity and Buddhism beyond the lands of their origins. Therefore, the student is able to Assess how Christianity and Buddhism won converts among culturally diverse peoples across wide areas of Afro-Eurasia. [Demonstrate and explain the influence of ideas] Analyze the spread of Christianity and Buddhism in the context of change and crisis in the Roman and Han empires. [Analyze cause-and-effect relationships] Common Core State Standards for Literacy in History/Social Studies Reading Integration of Knowledge and Ideas RH.9-10.7 D-10 Integrate quantitative or technical analysis (e.g., charts, research data) with qualitative analysis in print or digital text. Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE (10 days) World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 Version 2 Writing Production and Distribution of Writing WHST.9-10.4 Produce clear and coherent writing in which the development, organization, and style are appropriate to task, purpose, and audience. Research to Build and Present Knowledge WHST.9-10.7 Conduct short as well as more sustained research projects to answer a question (including a self-generated question) or solve a problem; narrow or broaden the inquiry when appropriate; synthesize multiple sources on the subject, demonstrating understanding of the subject under investigation. Notes, Clarifications, and Prerequisites Students are entering grade 9 with a foundation in ancient history. This unit is intended to be used as a review of four major cornerstones from ancient history: empires/states, trade, universalist religion, and Hellenistic tradition. Historical thinking skills are being refined and further developed. The purpose of this unit is to bridge the content from sixth grade to ninth grade by surveying large-scale developments in the early centuries CE before introducing students to the major topics of the 500–1750 CE era. Since this unit considers very large-scale developments in world history in the early centuries CE, teachers should introduce students to the concept of Afroeurasia as a geographical tool—that is, the idea of Africa, Asia, and Europe together as a “place” within which historical developments that cut across the borders of particular civilizations, states, or empires occurred. (For more background information, see Ross E. Dunn, “Big Geography and World History,” Social Studies Review, Spring/Summer 2010, pp. 1418.) New to the grade span is the student use of sources to support their knowledge of an era. Instruction should include primary sources for examination. Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin D-11 World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 Version 2 Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE (10 days) Taught Curriculum Learning Objectives Resources Students will be able to: World History for Us All, http://worldhistoryforusall.sdsu.edu Identify major states and empires that existed in Afroeurasia in the early centuries CE (Rome, Kush, Axum, the Parthian Empire, and Han China) and analyze the distinctions among these states in terms of their geographical location, size, economic importance, and type of government. (4 days) Trace major land and sea trade routes that connected important trade centers throughout Rome, Kush, Axum, the Parthian Empire, and Han China in the early centuries CE. (2 days) Compare the basic teachings of Buddhism and Christianity, considering similarities and differences between their respective beliefs and practices. (2 days) Big Era Four PowerPoint Overview Presentation (Expanding Networks of Exchange and Encounter, 1200 BCE–500 CE) Big Era Four Panorama Teaching Unit, Lessons 1-4 Big Era Four Landscape Teaching Unit 4.5 (Giant Empires of Afroeurasia, 300 BCE–200 CE) Big Era Four Closeup Teaching Unit 4.4.1 (The Budding of Buddhism, 563 BCE–150 CE) World History, Pearson, 2011 Teacher Edition Chapter 3, Sections 2, 3, 5 (pp. 76-91, 101-111) Trace the early spread of Buddhism and Christianity in Afroeurasia up to 500 CE, and analyze why these two religions spread in the directions they did. (2 days) Chapter 4, Sections 4 and 5 (pp. 130-147) Chapter 5, Sections 3 and 4 (pp. 161-172, 178183) Assessment Rubrics (p. 6) The Sermon on the Mount excerpt, http://www.sacred-texts.com/bib/csj/csj019.htm The Sermon at Benares, http://www.sacred-texts.com/bud/btg/btg17.htm Facing History and Ourselves Socratic Seminar, http://www.facinghistory.org/ resources/strategies/socratic-seminar Instructional Considerations Key Vocabulary church missionary cosmopolitanism monotheism four noble truths polytheism messiah Silk Road D-12 Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE (10 days) World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 Version 2 Planning and Instructional Delivery Considerations This unit is intended to be used as a review of three major concepts from ancient history: major empires and states, long-distance trade, and universalist religions. Students will be able to compare and contrast differing sets of ideas, draw comparisons across regions, obtain historical data from a variety of sources, draw upon data in historical maps, and analyze cause-and-effect relationships. The strategies listed below represent a menu of choices and possibilities to support each learning objective. The following teaching strategies are aligned to the order of the learning objectives. To ensure that students will be able to identify major states and empires that existed in Afroeurasia in the early centuries CE (Rome, Kush, Axum, the Parthian Empire, and Han China) and analyze the distinctions among these states in terms of their geographical location, size, economic importance, and type of government (4 days): Show the PowerPoint presentation from World History for Us All, Big Era 4, for the Panorama Unit (Expanding Networks of Exchange and Encounter, 1200 BCE–500 CE). Discuss the following questions with the class: (1) Why do you think the PowerPoint presentation focuses on two particular developments? (2) How does the presentation break those developments down into different aspects of large-scale change? (3) How does the concept of “Afroeurasia” as a geographical entity help us to understand those developments and their importance? From World History for Us All, Big Era Four, teach Lesson 3 (An Age of Empires) from the Panorama Teaching Unit, and Lesson 1 (Giant Empires of Afroeurasia: Gathering/Classifying Data) from the Landscape Teaching Unit 4.5 (Giant Empires of Afroeurasia). In presenting these lessons, focus on the basic histories and characteristics of the empires of Rome, Kush, Axum, the Parthian Empire, and Han China. To ensure that students will be able to trace major land and sea trade routes that connected important trade centers throughout Rome, Kush, Axum, the Parthian Empire, and Han China in the early centuries CE (2 days): Teach Lesson 2 (Networks of Exchange) from World History for Us All, Big Era Four, Panorama Teaching Unit. In discussion, focus student learning on the Essential Question “In what ways were the growth of long-distance trade and the development of a chain of large and prosperous states across Afroeurasia in the early centuries CE related?” Standard 2: Historical comprehension To ensure that students will be able to compare the basic teachings of Buddhism and Christianity, considering similarities and differences between their respective beliefs and practices (1 day): Have pairs of students use information from the textbook to construct a Venn diagram that compares and contrasts the practices and beliefs of early Christianity and Buddhism. Have students refer to their Venn diagrams and the textbook as you lead a class discussion that addresses the following: What is distinctive to one religion but not the other? What is similar? Why have historians categorized both Christianity and Buddhism as religions of salvation? Why have both been characterized as “universalist” religions? To ensure that students will be able to trace the early spread of Buddhism and Christianity in Afroeurasia up to 500 CE, and analyze why these two religions spread in the directions they did (2 days): Show students the map on slide number 41 in the Panorama (Expanding Networks of Exchange and Encounter, 1200 BCE–500 CE) PowerPoint overview in Big Era 4 in World History for Us All. Have Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin D-13 World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 Version 2 Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE (10 days) students read the selections in the Pearson textbook that pertain to the spread of Buddhism and Christianity. In discussion, ask students why they think Buddhism and Christianity spread in the directions that they did. Ask students why both Buddhism and Christianity later became minority religions in the lands where they started. Ask students to analyze possible connections between the spread of these religions and the existence of the Roman and Han empires. Ask students to make connections between the spread of these religions and the location of major trade routes in Afroeurasia. Standard 3: Historical analysis and interpretation Additional Teaching Strategies Socratic Seminar: Have students read the appropriate sections in the textbook concerning the Roman, Parthian, and Han empires and the kingdoms of Kush and Axum. Ask students to identify, define, and give their opinions about what caused the rise and decline of the major empires in Afroeurasia. The goal of a Socratic Seminar is for students to help one another understand the ideas, issues, and values reflected in a specific text. A Socratic seminar is not used for the purpose of debate, persuasion, or personal reflection, as the focus is on developing shared meaning of a text (see the Facing History website for more information). Use the various activities and selections in the Pearson textbook to have students understand the key teachings of the Buddha, to understand how Han rulers strengthened the economy and government of China, and to analyze why many Chinese people accepted Buddhist ideas. Teach Lesson 1 (The Life of the Buddha) from the Closeup Teaching Unit 4.4.1 (The Budding of Buddhism, 563 BCE–150 CE) in World History for Us All, Big Era Four. Have students write an article for an investigative journal explaining the ways in which Buddhism and Christianity spread to new areas and new peoples. In the article, students must address the role that monks played. Have students working in groups use readings in the textbook to investigate the relationship between the growth of long-distance trade and the early spread of Christianity and Buddhism. Have them answer the following questions in presentations: Did commercial enterprise follow or precede the expansion of these new religions? What were the possible relationships between religious preachers and merchants? Assessed Curriculum Formative Assessments Provide feedback to students through daily monitoring of student understanding using a variety of methods. For example, use exit cards. Have students answer questions on paper before they leave the class. Keep the activity prompt specific and brief to check for understanding of the day’s concepts. For instance, to check students’ comprehension of the trade routes across Afroeurasia, ask students to respond to the following prompt: “Why didn’t the Silk Road cross Asia in a straight line?” To assess the progress of understanding: D-14 how to identify major states and empires that existed in Afroeurasia in the early centuries CE (Rome, Kush, Axum, the Parthian Empire, and Han China) and analyze the distinctions among these states in terms of their geographical location, size, economic importance, and type of government, divide the class into five groups, with each assigned to a specific empire. Have each group create a “recipe” that explains the success and duration of the assigned empire. Have each Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE (10 days) World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 Version 2 group present their recipe to the class. Have each student create a “cookbook” with the recipes for each empire. As independent practice, have each student write a one-paragraph comparison of the ingredients that appear in more than one of the recipes for imperial success. Standard 3: Historical analysis and interpretation how to trace major land and sea trade routes that connected important trade centers throughout Rome, Kush, Axum, the Parthian Empire, and Han China in the early centuries CE, have students prepare a map showing the main trade routes in Afroeurasia at several periods during the 300 BCE–300 CE time span. Use symbols placed next to the routes to indicate the main items traded. Show and label the location of important centers of trade, both ports and inland cities. Indicate the location and extent of the major states and empires that traded. Standard 1: Chronological thinking how to compare the basic teachings of Buddhism and Christianity, considering similarities and differences between their respective beliefs and practices, have students read Buddha’s Sermon at Benares (Varanasi) and Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount. In a short writing assignment, have students compare and contrast the sermons, and instruct them to substantiate their claims with internal evidence from within the documents. (The primary documents are available online; see the Resources list.) how to trace the early spread of Buddhism and Christianity in Afroeurasia up to 500 CE, and analyze why these two religions spread in the directions they did, have students write a journal entry or short essay comparing the role of government and trade in explaining the spread of Buddhism and Christianity in the empires of Han China and Rome. Summative Assessment To address the Essential Questions, have groups of students create a travel brochure for the Silk Road that (1) provides an analysis of the political and religious characteristics of the empires that are encountered during travel and (2) reflects upon the origins of the people found traveling and the types of commodities and technologies that are traded and diffused along it. The brochure should include a map. When students are working on this summative assessment, this is an opportunity to implement reading standard RH.9-10.7 and writing standards for literacy in history/social studies WHST.9-10.4 and 9-10.7. Use Assessment Rubrics (p. 6) to evaluate this product. Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin D-15 World History 1, Quarter 1, Unit 2 Version 2 Large Empires and Expanding Religions, 1–400 CE (10 days) Notes D-16 Providence Public Schools, in collaboration with the Charles A. Dana Center at the University of Texas at Austin