TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Rina Md Anwar, Bong Kit Siang INTRODUCTION Traditionally in accounting world, accountants require pencils, papers and a basic calculator. We record all accounting transactions on T-accounts that represents Debit and Credits transaction. We use calculator to balance out the Debit side of our T-accounts to the Credit side of the same account. As the result, we will post the difference (if any) to indicate the imbalanced condition of the T-account. However, this traditional approach has been gradually changed to computerized system, which eliminates most of manual record keeping process done by human. However, the knowledge of how a manual system should operate is very fundamental so that the computerized documentation techniques will have minimal flaw after implemented. The first section of this topic describes the relationship among accounting records in forming an audit trail in both manual and computer based systems. Then, we will examine the documentation techniques used to represent system. At the end, we will look at documentation techniques for manual and computer-based systems. OBJECTIVE At the end of this chapter, you should be able to: 1. describe the documents and procedures used in AIS to collect and process transaction data; 2. describe the relationship among accounting records in forming an audit trail in both manual & computer-based systems; 3. differentiate the THREE types of document used in AIS: Source, Product and Turnaround Documents; 4. compare the function of journal with ledgers; 5. examine the documentation techniques used to represent systems; and 6. develop flowcharts based on given scenario. OUM 35 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 MIND MAP 3.1 ACCOUNTING RECORDS IN MANUAL SYSTEMS In a manual system, adequate documents and records are needed to provide an audit trail of activities within a system. In computer systems, documents might not be used to support the initiation, execution and recording of some transactions. What is the effect of this on the internal control of a company? 3.1.1 Documents Previously, most organization uses paper based documents as a common way for data collection. These data will then be transferred to the computer for the later use. Currently, these data will be directly stored in the computers through the specific system. Basically there are three types of documents; as mentioned in Figure 3.1. 36 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Figure 3.1: Documents in accounting systems Source document is the initial input to the accounting process and normally serve as an original record of a transaction. It is an early document in the accounting cycle and it captures the key data of a transaction. The examples of source documents are Purchase Orders, Time Cards, Cash Receipts and others. Figure 3.2 shows the creation of a source document. It is a part of the revenue cycle. When customers make an order, the sales clerk will prepare multiple copies of sales order. These documents then will go into the sales system. The information in these documents will be used by various departments or functions such as Credit, Billing and others. Thus, it will cause other activities to start in those departments. Example: A copy of the Sales Order will be sent to the Credit Department. It will cause the checking or approval process begins. The personnel in the department will use the information in the sales order to verify the customer’s creditworthiness. Figure 3.2: Creation of a source document (courtesy of Hall, 2001) OUM 37 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Product documents are the document that is being prepared after a transaction had happened. Product document can serve as an output for one system. Refer to Figure 3.3, the source document act as an input for Sales System while the product document which is customer’s bill will act as an output. Figure 3.3: A product development (courtesy of Hall, 2001) The final document is turnaround document. Turnaround document is a document which acts as an output for one system and become an input for another system. Figure 3.4 shows the example of turnaround document. It is based on the previous example of source and product document. We can take other example like credit card monthly statement sent by the credit card company to their customers. Most of the statements consist of two parts: 1. 2. Statement of the account Remittance Advice The Remittance Advice contains the customer’s name, account number, the total credit and also the minimum payment required for that particular month. Normally, the statement is produced by the Billing Department. When customer makes payment, they will include the Remittance Advice along with the cheque. The Remittance Advice will be received by the Accounts Department. The information in Remittance Advice such as Account Holder Name and Account Number will be used as an input to the Accounts Department. 38 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Figure 3.4: A turnaround document (courtesy of Hall, 2001) Can a turnaround document contain information that is subsequently used as a source document? Why or why not? 3.1.2 Journal A journal is an initial record in which the effects of transactions on accounts are recorded. When transactions happen, we record all relevant facts in chronological order. The data for journals come from the documents such as Sales Order. The journal will keep all records of transactions and will be posted to the specific account. Figure 3.5 shows the process of recording the sales order to the sales journal. OUM 39 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Figure 3.5: Sales order recorded in sales journal (courtesy of Hall, 2001) There are TWO types of journal: Figure 3.6: Types of journal 1. Special Journal This is used to record specific categories/classes of transactions. The specific categories/classes will be grouped in a special journal, thus can be processed efficiently. Figure 3.7 shows an example of special journal, specifically Sales Journal. The Sales Journal will only record the sales transactions. Each time processing period ends, the sales clerk will post the amounts to the specified ledger account. The frequency for processing could be either in daily, weekly or monthly basis. From Figure 3.7, we can see that these amounts are posted to account number 401. Another example of special journal includes cash receipts journal, where it will record the cash receipts transaction such as cash and credit sales. 40 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Figure 3.7: Sales journal (courtesy of Hall, 2001) 2. General journal The general ledger is a journal which is used to record the infrequent and different transactions. Figure 3.8 shows the example of the general ledger. Currently, most of the organizations have been using journal voucher system to replace the general journal. A journal voucher is a source document which contains a single entry of each account specified in the general ledger. It is used to record summaries of routine and non routine transactions. We also use this document to record the summary of adjusted and closed entries. For example, there are TWO accounts in the general ledger: Accounts Receivable; and Sales Account Hence, in the journal voucher, there will be only TWO accounts stated along with the amount in that journal voucher. OUM 41 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Figure 3.8: A general journal (courtesy of Boockholdt, 1999) Another document to be considered is the chart of accounts. Chart of accounts lists all account name and number for an organization. During the process of recording event into journals, accountant will refer to the chart of accounts. This is to make sure accounts chosen by the accountant are listed in the Accounting Information Systems. The chart of accounts is one of the most important documents we need to consider in Accounting Information Systems. The chart provides complete reference for the accounts in an organization. Hence, it is important to make sure the chart of accounts is well designed. The chart of accounts could be different within an organization since the functions and business activities might vary from one organization to another. Figure 3.9 shows a chart of accounts example. It shows the account name along with the account number. The account number consists of three digits. This is one of the coding techniques for AIS application, called Block Codes. This technique corresponds to the entire class of items by restricting each class to a particular range within the coding scheme. 42 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Figure 3.9: A chart of accounts (courtesy of Boockholdt, 1999) Table 3.1 summarizes the Block Codes representation. Table 3.1: Block Codes Representation Digit First Representation Example Account Classification 100 = Current Assets 200 = Fixed Assets 500 = Revenue Second Third OUM Primary financial category. sub-accounts within each 110 = petty cash 120 = petty cash Numbers were assigned to accounts to match the order of their appearance in financial statements 130 = accounts receivable Specific account to which the transaction data will be posted 611 = cash revenue 612 = credit revenue 43 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Another thing to be considered when building the chart of accounts is the scalability. The chart of accounts should allow the insertion of new or additional accounts. 3.1.3 Ledgers A ledger is sometimes called as a book of financial records. We use ledger to summarize the financial status of an organization such as the current balance of accounts. Normally, the various journals will post the financial transaction information to the ledgers. The information will be used to prepare the financial statements, internal reports and also to support the daily transactions. Figures 3.10 show the flow of financial information from the source document and finally end at the General Ledger. Figure 3.10: Flow of information from the economic event to the general ledger (courtesy of Hall, 2001) Basically, there are two types of ledgers: Figure 3.11: Types of ledger 1. 44 General Ledgers OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES General ledgers have the summary of activities for each account in the organization. 2. Subsidiary Ledgers Subsidiary ledger records the details for any account in the general ledger that owns many subaccounts. For example, one of the accounts in the general ledger is the Account Receivable. Subsidiary ledger for the Accounts Receivable could be the separate account for each customer. The total of account balance in the subsidiary ledger must be the same with the balance in the Accounts Receivable in the general ledger. 3.2 ACCOUNTING RECORDS IN COMPUTER-BASED SYSTEMS How about organizing an event without a planner? How about leading a nation without a minister ? And, how about running a business without a system ? Respond to the questions above by posting your answer in myLMS. Planning to record transactions in specific location may help organizing accounting transaction better. In computer-based systems, the accounting records are represented by four different types of magnetic files as summarizes by Table 3.2. Table 3.2: Different Types of Magnetic Files Type of Files Description Example 1 Master File A master file contains all accounts data. When transactions occur, the related data in the master files will be updated. General and Subsidiary Ledgers. 2 Transaction File A temporary file which contains transaction records. These records will be used to change and update data in the master file. Sales Orders Cash Receipts. 3 Reference File A file which has a collection of data used as standards or reference for processing the transactions. Product price lists used for preparing the customer invoices 4 Archive File Files which have records of past transactions. Lists of former employees, lists of preceding sales transactions. These files will be used for future reference in the organization. and Figure 3.12 illustrates the relationship of these files in forming an audit trail. OUM 45 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Figure 3.12: Accounting records in a computer-based system (courtesy of Hall, 2001) What is meant by “Audit Trail?” The accounting records described in the manual system or computer-based system provide an audit trail for tracing transactions from source documents to the financial 46 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES statements. The audit trails in computer-based system is still exist, although it is less noticeable than in traditional manual system. Figure 3.12 shows how computer files can function as audit trail in an organization. It begins by capturing the economic events. The sales are recorded manually using source documents. Then the data in the source documents will be transferred to the magnetic files, specifically the transaction files. However, this will depend on the organization because some organizations are no longer using the physical source documents. Hence, the transactions are directly captured on the magnetic media. The next step is to update the related master file subsidiary and also the control accounts. During this process, we may edit the account transactions. For example, the available credit for each customer will be identified by the system by referring to the credit file. Any credit problems will be rejected and stored in the error file. The remaining records will be used to update the related master files. Hence, only these transactions are added as the sales journal into the archive file. The original transaction file is not required for audit trail purposes because the valid transactions have been copied to the journal. The file then can be deleted and the system is now ready for the next batch of the sales orders. Dunn, C., Cherrington, J.O and Hollander, A.S, (2005), Enterprise Information Systems: A Pattern-Based Approach, 3rd Edition. Mc Graw Hill. Read Chapter 14: The Financing Business Process. OUM 47 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES 3.3 TOPIC 3 DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES How do you relate DFD to Activity Diagram in Unified Modeling Language? You may go to the internet and locate the answers to this question. 3.3.1 Entity Relationship Diagram ERD describe information needed and/or the type of information that is to be stored in the database Entity Relationship Diagram (ERD) is a documentation technique used to construct conceptual data model and it describes the data needed and also the type of data that is to be stored in the database. It acts as a data modeling technique that creates a graphical representation of the entities, and the relationships between entities, within an information system. ERD can be used as a tool for communication during analysis phase in the system development process. The THREE main components of an ERD and their functions are summarized in the following Table 3.3: Table 3.3: Main Components of ERD and Their Functions Item 1. Entity Symbols Descriptions Entity is an object in the real world environment. In AIS, an entity is a resource (cash), an event (receiving cash) or an agent (customer). 2. Relationship A relationship captures how two or more entities are related to one another. 3. Attributes Attributes are the properties or characteristics of an entity. Relationships may also have attributes. Attributes are drawn as ovals connected to their owning entity sets by a line. 48 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Figure 3.10 shows the symbols used for an ERD. Figure 3.13: Entity relationship diagram symbols (courtesy of Hall, 2001) The relationship between entities can also be described in terms of cardinality. Cardinality specifies the number of instances of one entity that can be associated with each instance of another entity. A relationship can be oneto-one (1:1), one-to-many (1: M) or many-to-many (M:N). Cardinality can reflect the policy of an organization. Explanations of examples in Figure 3.13 are explained in Table 3.4. Table 3.4 Example 1 Relationship Cardinality Assigned (1 : 1) Each salesperson is assigned to one automobile. Each automobile is assigned to one salesperson. Places (1: M) Each customer placed more than one order Each order is placed by one customer. (Figure 3.13a) Entities: Salesperson, Automobile 2 (Figure 3.13b) Entities: Customer, Order OUM Explanation 49 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES 3 Supply (M: N) (Figure 3.13c) Entities: Vendor, Inventory. TOPIC 3 Each vendor supplied more than one items. Each item is supplied by more than one vendor. 3.3.2 Data Flow Diagrams A Data Flow Diagram (DFD) is a graphical representation of the data flow through an information system. We also use DFD to visualize the data processing or so called structural design. It is a common practice for a system analyst/designer to firstly draw a context-level DFD which shows the interaction between the system and outside entities. This context-level DFD is then decomposed to show more detail of the system being modeled. A data flow diagram illustrates the processes, data stores, and external entities in a business or other system and the data flows between these things. Four diagrammatical components are used to develop a DFD. Table 3.5 illustrates these components: Table 3.5: Diagrammatic Components Used to Develop a DFD Item Data Flow Descriptions x x x x x x x x The work or actions performed on data so that they are transformed, stored or distributed. Represents the transformation of data in the system. This represents something that happens in the system. Represented by a circle or rounded rectangle. Should be named as a verb. External Entity x x x x The origin and/or destination of data. Also called a 'Source/Sink'. Represented by a square or oval. Should be named as a noun. Data Store x x x Repository for data. Represented by two parallel lines, sometimes connected by a vertical line. Should be named as a noun. Process x 50 Data in motion, moving from one place to another in a system. Represent the results of a query to a database, the contents of a printed report or data on a data entry computer display form. Should only represent data, not control. Represented by an arrow. Should be named as a noun. OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Figure 3.14 shows the symbols used for DFD. Basic data flow diagram elements are shown in Figure 3.15. The external entities are A, J and K, where A is the source and J, K are the destination. The system starts at A where it generates data flow B which is then goes to process C. The outputs for process C are data flows D and E. E then goes to J, while D goes to process F. Process F uses data flow D and G and later on process the data. The process then will produce output G and I. The data flow I is sent to the external entity or data destination, K. Figure 3.16 shows the data flow diagram of customer payment which is related to Figure 3.15. Figure 3.14: Data flow diagram symbols (courtesy of Romney, 2003) OUM 51 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Figure 3.15: Basic data flow diagram elements (courtesy of Romney, 2003) Figure 3.16 Data flow diagram of customer payment process (courtesy of Romney, 2003) 52 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Data flow may consist of more than one data element. Therefore it is important to decide on the number of line required for the data flow. For example, sometimes customer has made payment and would like to query regarding their payment. So, here the different data flow should be used because the payment and inquiries is different in terms of the purposes. Refer to Figure 3.16. Figure 3.17: Splitting customer payments and inquiries (courtesy of Romney, 2003) Decomposition of DFD can be defined as the act of going from a single system to its component processes or in other words from the highest level DFD to the lowest level. The highest level view of the system is a context diagram. A context diagram is a special DFD that is designed to show the system and the external entities that send data to and/or receive data from the information system. It contains only one process, no data stores, data flows and the external entities (sources/sinks). The sources/sinks represent its environmental boundaries. Figure 3.18 shows the context diagram of a payroll processing procedure. The employee data is received from the human resource department, while the time card received from various departments. These data then will be processed and the system produces four different data that are: 1. 2. 3. 4. OUM Tax report and payment for government agencies. Employee payment for employees. Payroll account deposit at the bank. Payroll report for the management. 53 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Figure 3.18: Context diagram for payroll processing (courtesy of Romney, 2003) Table 3.6 shows the major processing activities and data flows involved in payroll processing. Using the information in the table, the context diagram is decomposed into lower level or we called it as Level 0 diagram as shown in Figure 3.19. The data coming from the human resources department were grouped together and named as “employee data”. 54 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Table 3.6: Activities and Data Flows in Payroll Processing (Courtesy of Romney, 2003) Activities Data Inputs Data Outputs Update employee/payroll file New employee form Employee change form Employee / payroll file Updated employee / payroll file Pay employees Time cards Employee / payroll file Tax rates table Employee checks Payroll register Updated employee / payroll file Payroll check Payroll cash disbursements voucher Prepare reports Employee/payroll file Payroll report Pay taxes Employee/payroll file Tax report Tax payment Payroll tax cash disbursements voucher Updated employee / payroll file Update general ledger Payroll tax cash disbursements voucher Payroll cash disbursements voucher Updated General Ledger OUM 55 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Figure 3.19: DFD for payroll processing (courtesy of Romney, 2003) The level 1 for Process 2.0 (pay employees) is shown in Figure 3.18. It expands employees pay process into more detail process. Each of the process in Figure 3.16 can be decomposed into their own level 1 diagram to show the detail processes. Figure 3.20: DFD for process 2.0 in payroll processing (courtesy of Romney, 2003) 56 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES 3.3.3 Flowcharts A flowchart is a formalized graphic representation of a program logic sequence, work or manufacturing process. It describes the physical relationship between the entities or components. Figure 3.21 shows the symbols used to create flowcharts. Each symbol represents different processes or tasks. Besides flow charts use special connector symbols to jump between positions on a same page and from other page to another page. This are very useful to lessen the mess happened when the flow lines go across each other. OUM 57 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Figure 3.21: Common flowcharting symbols (courtesy of Romney, 2003) 58 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES Figure 3.21: Common flowcharting symbols (cont) OUM 59 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Basically there are three types of flowchart that are: 1. Document flowchart Document flowchart shows the flow of documents through the system. It illustrates the relationship among processes and the documents that flow between them. This flowchart is much more details if compare to data flow diagrams. We can see the separation of functions in one system. The flowchart is very useful to refer when analyzing whether the control procedures are sufficient or not. It can disclose any weaknesses in the system such as lack of communication flows. Figure 3.22 is the example of flowchart which clearly shows the departments/functions involved in a system. Figure 3.22 Flowchart showing areas of activity (courtesy of Romney, 2003) 2. System flowchart System flowcharts are used to represent the relationship between parts of a system that are the inputs, processes and outputs. It also shows the type of media that is being used for a particular system such as magnetic disks and file. Figure 3.23 shows the example of system flowchart for sales processing. Sales terminal are used to capture sales. The terminals will edit the sales data and print out receipt for customer. The sales data will be stored in the sales data file on a 60 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES disk. At the end of each day, the sales data will be summarized and the batch totals will be printed. Example of batch total is the total sales for all sales transactions. The summarized data will be processed again and same goes to the batch total that will be generated and printed once more. The amount of batch totals then will be compared with the batch totals generated from the earlier processing. All errors and exceptions will be reconciled. The accounts receivable, inventory, sales marketing databases and the general ledger will be updated. Users can use the inquiry processing system in order to know the account and inventory status and also the sales analysis. Figure 3.23 System flowcharts of sales processing (courtesy of Romney, 2003) OUM 61 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES 3. TOPIC 3 Program flowchart A program flowchart illustrates the logic used in programs. This flowchart shows the detail of each process for each program that exists in a system flowchart. Figure 3.24 shows the relationship between system and program flowchart. Figure 3.24 Relationship between system and program flowcharts (courtesy of Romney, 2003) Differentiate System Flowchart to Program’s Flowchart. below for your comparison. System’s Flowchart Fill in the table Program’s Flowchart Exercise 3.1 1. Would the write down of obsolete inventory be recorded in a special journal or the general journal? Why? 2. Discuss the relationship between the balances in the accounts payable general ledger control account and what is found in the accounts payable subsidiary ledger? 62 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES SUMMARY Previously, most businesses used paper source document to initially collect data about their business activities and then transferred the data into the computer. However, it has changed now where most of the data about business activities are recorded directly through computer data entry screens. Documentation includes the narratives, flowcharts, diagrams, and other written material that explain how a system works. Each one of the documentation serves different functionality for the organization. GLOSSARY Archive File Files which have records of past transactions. Attributes Properties or characteristics of an entity. Batch A group of similar transactions accumulated over time and then processed together Chart of accounts Lists all account name and number for an organization. Cardinality Specifies the number of instances of one entity that can be associated with each instance of another entity. Data Flow Diagram Graphical representation of the data flow through an information system. Document Flowcharts The flow of documents through the system. It illustrates the relationship among processes and the documents that flow between them. This flowchart is much more details if compare to data flow diagrams. Entity An object in the real world environment. ERD A documentation technique used to construct conceptual data model and it describes the data needed and also the type of data that is to be stored in the database. Flowcharts Formalized graphic representation of a program logic sequence, work or manufacturing process. General Ledgers Summarize activities for each account in the organization General Journal A journal which is used to record the infrequent and different transactions. Journal An initial record in which the effects of transactions on accounts are recorded. Master File File containing all accounts data OUM 63 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES TOPIC 3 Product Document Document that is being prepared after a transaction had happened. Product document can serve as an output for one system. Reference File A file which has a collection of data used as standards or reference for processing the transactions. Special Journal This is used to record specific categories/classes of transactions. The specific categories/classes will be grouped in a special journal, thus can be processed efficiently. Sales Journal Only recording sales transactions. Subsidiary Ledgers Records the details for any account in the general ledger that owns many sub accounts. System Flowcharts System flowcharts are used to represent the relationship between parts of a system that are the inputs, processes and outputs. It also shows the type of media that is being used for a particular system such as magnetic disks and file. Source Document Initial input to the accounting process and normally serve is an original record of a transaction. It is an early document in the accounting cycle and it captures the key data of a transaction. Transaction File A temporary file which contains transaction records. These records will be used to change and update data in the master file. TEST 1 Instruction: Answer all questions in 15 min. 1. Are large batch sizes preferable to small batch sizes? Explain. (5 marks) 2. What form can source documents take in a computer-based system? (5 marks) TEST 2 Instruction: Answer all questions in 15 min. 1. Develop a flowchart for the process of paying hourly employees. Assume time-sheets are used and the payroll department must total the hours. Each hour worked by an employee must be charged to some account ( a cost center). Each week, the manager of each cost center receives a report listing the employee’s name and the number of hours charged to this center. The manager is required to verify that this information is correct by signing the form and/noting any discrepancies and then 64 OUM TOPIC 3 ACCOUNTING RECORDS & DOCUMENTATION TECHNIQUES sending this form back to payroll. Any discrepancies noted must be corrected by the payroll department. (10 marks) 2. Should an auditor wishing to access the adequacy of separation of functions examine a data flow diagram, document flowchart or a system flowchart? Why? (5 marks) REFERENCE Boockholdt J.L., (1999). Accounting Information Systems. Singapore: McGraw-Hill. James A. Hall, (2001). Accounting Information Systems. Ohio: Thomson Learning. Romney & Steinbart. Accounting Information Systems 9/E. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. OUM 65