Searches for Dark Matter
(the Quest)
Harry Nelson
UCSB
2003 SLAC Summer Insitute
Aug. 5-6 2003
HNN
z
z
z
UCSB
Plan
Introductory Material
Axions
Massive Particles
⟩
Direct Detection
Strongly Interacting
→ Weakly Interacting
→
⟩
z
Indirect Detection
Concluding Material
Small calculations, supporting material
interspersed… my goal is to develop a `feel’
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
2
HNN
z
Some Sources…
UCSB
M. Srednicki, 1994 SLAC Summer Institute
http://www.slac.stanford.edu/pubs/confproc/ssi94/ssi94-010.html
z
M. Perl et al., 2001
http://www.slac.stanford.edu/pubs/slacpubs/8000/slac-pub-8772.html
z
z
z
IDM 2002 http://www.shef.ac.uk/~phys/idm2002/talks/
SPIRES http://www.slac.stanford.edu/spires/hep/
NASA Astrophysics Data System
http://adswww.harvard.edu/index.html
Apologies for figures not perfectly acknowledged…
Thanks to many colleagues…
particularly Ron Ross…
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
3
HNN
UCSB
The Milky Way’s Dark Halo (?)
R is the distance from center
v
v is the speed (tangential)
Honma and Sofue, 1996
R
v
220 km/s
Without the Dark Halo
∆:v0=180 km/s
(Binney & Tremaine)
⊕
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
R
4
HNN
UCSB
The Dark Ball
Bulge
Disk
Dark Matter
`Halo’
Why haven’t dark
matter `particles’ fall
into our disk?
• Dark particles scarcely
interact with us and/or
• Dark particles very heavy
(150 passes/age of U)×(0.3 to 2) ×
10-2 gm/cm2 ∼ (0.5 to 3) gm/cm2 …
not very restrictive
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
5
HNN
UCSB
Theoretical Guidance… Caveat Emptor
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
6
HNN
8/5/03
Remainder of L. Alvarez Essay
SLAC Summer Institute
UCSB
7
HNN
Talavera … reviewed Columbus
UCSB
12,000 km (Talavera, accurate)
5,000 km (Columbus, fudged systematics)
Japan (Cipangu)
Both simplified the
intervening
region to pure ocean
Portugal/Spain
Oversimplification!
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
8
HNN
Usual Simplifications of Dark Matter
z
UCSB
Local energy density, speed of DM
km
MeV
ú 0 ø 300
v 0 ø 220
(ì 0 ø 7 â 10 à4)
3
s
cm
(ì 20 12 10 6)
0? (200-2000)
(170-270)
… from galactic astrophysics
z
Consists of one elementary particle (!)
γ , νe,µ,τ , e- , p , n - 7 in our few percent of Univ.
2 are composite… n ??
The DM particle that provides the clearest signal in
a search might not be the most abundant – a strong
argument for an eclectic mix of search techniques.
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
9
HNN
Advice of Dennis the Menace
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
UCSB
10
HNN
Usual Simplifications of Dark Matter
z
z
UCSB
DM not baryons (CBR, BBN; Eros/MACHO)
DM was once in thermal equibrium
mass > few keV (large scale structure)
mass < 340 TeV (unitarity)
cross section with us ≈ weak (10-44-10-36 cm2)…
little unknown missing energy at LEP, Tevatron… mass>10’s GeV
Weakly Interacting Massive Particles
SUSY restored just above weak scale gives WIMPS
…Attractive candidates (axions, `*zillas’, etc.)
were never in thermal equilibrium…
z
DM at rest:
8/5/03
⟨vDM⟩=0 (sun plowing through at v0 ≈ 220 km/s)
2 ⟩1/2 ≈ 300 km/s… useful to approximate ≈ 0
⟨vDM
SLAC Summer Institute
11
HNN
z
UCSB
Scope
Keep an open mind…
γ
νe,µ,τ e-
π0
p
n
-- Our Matter
Imagine arbitrary (short
distance) interaction, mass
SIMP, *zilla
χ0 (SUSY, neutralino, WIMP)
Assume >10’s GeV
X±ε
a
8/5/03
(experimental technique)
`milli’ -CHAMP
axion, couples to γγ… nonthermal, very light
SLAC Summer Institute
12
HNN
z
UCSB
Direct Detection
Momentum Transfer
v0
Convert a to photon – detect it
axion
m
v0
target
Massive
Particle
Cause target recoil – detect it
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
13
HNN
UCSB
Axions (and similar)
axion models
(Dark matter)
1.9-3.4 µeV (ADMX, LLNL-Florida-Berkeley-NRAO)
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
14
HNN
UCSB
Primakoff Conversion, Microwave Detection
Amplifier – power pours out
of cavity when B0 applied
Solenoid
LB= 50 cm
Cavity, `TM’ mode
(E parallel to B0: 0- )
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
15
HNN
UCSB
Tunable Cavity
Tuning Rods
2×Q×
80 sec/scan
≈ 1 year
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
16
UCSB
Signal Level and Noise
10-17 W from
Pioneer 10
Spacecraft,
1010 km away
∝(s/n)
HNN
HEMT
10-26 W →
∝(time)
Substantial
improvements in
Ts are on the
horizon (X30)
from increased
cooling, SQUIDS
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
17
HNN
UCSB
Example of Data, Expected Signal
Long resident
axions
Axions just
streamed in from
galactic periphery
(≈β2 )
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
18
HNN
µeV Axion Future
UCSB
• ADMX – SQUIDs, hope to cover 2 decades in mass
• Kyoto – single quantum detector
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
19
HNN
CAST – Axions from the Sun
UCSB
cm2 sec1 keV
1
8 × 1014
6 × 1014
4 × 1014
2 × 1014
0
0
2
LHC Dipole
y
ra tor
X ec
t
de
8/5/03
ay
r
X
4
T
ns
a
r
r
ve
E (keV)
se
6
8
ti
e
gn
a
m
B)
(
ld
e
i
cf
10
s
n
io
x
a
L
SLAC Summer Institute
20
HNN
Experiment and Expected Sensitivity
UCSB
SOLAX + COSME
Helium to suppress
momentum transfer
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
21
HNN
UCSB
Massive Particles: Recoil Kinematics - I
2/3
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
22
HNN
Recoil Kinematics - II
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
UCSB
23
HNN
UCSB
Nuclear Recoil – Cross Section
∝A4
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
24
HNN
Nuclear Recoil – Diffraction
UCSB
Iodine
(A=127)
DAMA
0 110 220 330 keV ER
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
25
HNN
UCSB
Nuclear Recoils from Massive Dark Matter
z
Deposit 10’s of keV
⟩
z
z
z
Mechanism of deposition after recoil (dE/dx) very
similar to how charged dark matter would deposit
energy directly
For target atomic weight A<160, dark matter
velocity spectrum a delta-function, recoil spectrum
flat up to an endpoint
Diffraction off nucleus, form factor of nucleus
directly appear in recoil spectrum
Cross section favorable as A increases
⟩
Haven’t focused on magnitude of cross section yet…
→10-44-10-36
8/5/03
cm2 (weak) or 10-24 cm2 (strong) still fine…
SLAC Summer Institute
26
HNN
To Penetrate the Atmosphere
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
UCSB
27
HNN
SIMP exclusion (above/below atmos.)
UCSB
Penetrate to Earth
Wandelt et al., astro-ph/0006344
8/5/03
WIMPS
SLAC Summer Institute
Baudis & Albuquerque,
astro-ph/0301188
28
HNN
UCSB
Guide to Exclusion Plots
T≥
excluded
<1 particle
penetrates
excluded:
≥
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
29
HNN
WIMP/nucleon σ≈10-42 cm2
UCSB
Exper.
CDMS
DAMA
Theory
SUSY,
various constraints
including Big Bang
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
30
HNN
UCSB
Compare with Common Background Rate
≡ DRU
• Shield (shield radioactive too!)… 1 ev/(kg d keV) typical
• Reduce the background… HDMS , IGEX , Genius
• Exploit astron. properties (year cycle, directionality) DAMA, DRIFT
• Devise detectors that can distinguish nuclear recoil from electron
recoil… Edelweiss, CDMS, Xenon..
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
31
HNN
Germanium: Quest for Lowest Background
UCSB
HDMS at Gran Sasso (3800 mwe (meters water equivalent) depth)
Inner Germanium (0.2 kg)
Outer Ge (2.1 kg) Spectrum of Inner Ge, 132.4 days
Red: No Hit in Outer Ge
0.3 DRU
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
32
HNN
UCSB
IGEX (2 kg Ge, CANFRANC, 2450 mwe)
1.0
BACKGROUND
4-10 keV background:
10-20 keV background:
25-40 keV background:
0.9
counts/keV/kg/day
0.8
0.7
0.22 c/keV/kg/day
0.10 c/keV/kg/day
0.04 c/keV/kg/day
0.6
Previous spectrum (236 kg-days)
0.5
IGEX-DM data since summer
2001 (194 kg-days)
Neutron shielding improved
0.4
0.3
Further increased neutron
shielding (82 kg-days)
0.2
0.1
0.0
0
10
20
30
40
50
Energy (keV)
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
33
HNN
UCSB
KeVee versus KeV (Recoil); Signal Shape
1.0
Only about 1/3 of energy of a nu
recoil appears in Ge as ionization
E. Simon et al., 2003
0.9
counts/keV/kg/day
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
0
0
IGEX
8/5/03
3010
30
40
6020
90
120
Energy
(keV) KeV
Recoil
Energy
(KeV)
ee
SLAC Summer Institute
50
150
34
HNN
UCSB
IGEX Exclusion Region
10-39
IGEX-DM 2000
IGEX-DM
2001& 2002
-40
σp (cm2)
10
-41
10
DAMA allowed
-42
10 1
8/5/03
5
10
50 100
m (GeV)
SLAC Summer Institute
5001000
35
HNN
Genius Program – Background Elimination
UCSB
Suspend Ge detector
in Liquid Nitrogen
L= 2 m
0.1 events/(kg KeV d)
Genius Test Facility
(under construction)
40 kg Ge
8/5/03
Baudis et al., 2001
SLAC Summer Institute
36
HNN
Ultimate Genius
8/5/03
SLAC Summer Institute
UCSB
37