GUIDELINES FOR AN INTERNSHIP IN THE PUBIC POLICY PH.D. PROGRAM Students may opt to fulfill elective credits by enrolling in an Internship Option available within the Public Policy Ph.D. Program. We strongly recommend the Active Internship for students who have little experience in the "real world" of public policy. A Prior Internship Option may also be approved for students with extensive prior experience at the policy level if they wish to go back and conduct an extensive review of a particular policy issue with which they had substantial involvement. The following Guidelines are presented in order to help students decide whether to select the Active Internship or Prior Internship Option, as well as to serve as a set of standards and guides for performance during the internship and for presentation of the Internship Paper and oral evaluation. If enough students are enrolled in Internship credits each semester, students may be required to participate in a group seminar. Please note that the Internship is optional. The Program can only guarantee to help students find unpaid internships, although we will help students try to discover paid internships. Students who choose the Internship Option should meet with our Internship Advisor (currently Robert Moran) or other designated Faculty Evaluator (typically for those in a particular Public Policy concentration) to gain approval to register. TABLE OF CONTENTS An Overview: Internship Credits, Requirements and Grade The Active Internship Option Why to Choose an Active Internship Why not to Choose an Active Internship Approval of the Active Internship Expectations during the Active Internship Other Issues The Prior Internship Option Why not to Choose a Prior Internship Approval of the Prior Internship Expectations for the Prior Internship 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 4 5 5 5 An Overview: Internship Credits, Requirements and Grades An Internship is an activity which "demonstrates applied work on a public policy issue." An Active Internship (3 credits) usually involves 20 hours of work per week over at least 25 weeks, although different amounts of commitment may be negotiated for differing amounts of credit. An Internship must be approved as outlined below. If part of a student's regular employment provides for focused policy work, an Active Internship may be approved. For a Prior Internship to be approved, it must have embodied substantial policy experience and meet the guidelines below. Evaluation for both options will be based upon presentation of an Internship Portfolio and a written paper of at least 10,000 words that addresses the organizational and political context of the policy issue, the substantive policy issues embodied in the internship and evaluates the student's role. An oral presentation, usually given as part of a group discussion of student internships, is also required. Evaluation will be pass/fail; Y (in progress) grades will be given until all requirements for the internship are met. It is assumed that most students will begin the Internship during their third year, after the comprehensive exams, but it may be possible for a student to begin earlier, or to begin an internship during the second semester of their third year and complete it by January of their fourth year. It is expected that all requirements for either Active or Prior Internships will be met, at a maximum, over the course of two semesters and a summer. Most internships will, and probably should, occur in the Boston area, but appropriate internships in other locations (e.g., Washington, DC) may be approved. The Active Internship Option Students who are considering an internship should meet with Robert Moran -- either in the Spring or Summer of their second year (preferred), or at the beginning of their third year. At this meeting they can discuss their questions and concerns about what type of internship might be appropriate, consider how to find an internship, and what the expectations will be. A student can explore internship opportunities on one’s own and confer with other faculty either before or after this meeting. Why to Choose an Active Internship It is a chance to engage and test out your theoretical learning in a real world setting or to revisit a significant personal experience in public policy work building upon new theoretical learning gained in the Program. It can serve as an entree into an area of policy that interests the student or as a way to "make connections" in the Boston area or elsewhere. It is an opportunity to make progress with one’s degree that offers the opportunity for more active learning. An opportunity arises to engage in some significant work that lends itself to the internship format. It allows a student to be employed in an appropriate setting while making progress toward the degree. 2 Why not to Choose an Active Internship A student feels confident in his/her experiential base and wants a chance for more theoretical learning. Time constraints do not allow for the requirements of a successful internship to be met. Approval of the Active Internship It is not always easy to find an Internship, but not impossible. Even if one is employed, the work setting may not provide opportunities to be involved in policy issues --because simply observing the implementation of policy development or implementation without any active role in at least gathering or preparing relevant data is not enough. So, the earlier a student begins to think about possibilities the better. The Internship Advisor plays a major role in helping students find appropriate new internships or determine whether their workplaces afford opportunities for internships. Other faculty may have ideas, especially in the areas of their professional activity. To meet the standards for a Ph.D. level Active Internship, the situation must include: The opportunity to participate in the development, implementation, or evaluation of one or more policy areas, not just to do low-level administrative work. The existence of a written Internship Description that includes at least: Duties to be performed; a statement of supervision to be received and of expectations regarding hours of work and length of time for the project. This description can be written prior to the student's application for the Internship or can be developed with the student and the supervisor at the worksite, but it must be approved by the Internship Advisor. If a student is already employed at the agency, a written description of the work that will constitute the Internship must still be approved. Approval regarding the number of credit hours to be allowed for the internship by the Internship Advisor and the Program Director. These hours will be negotiated based upon the amount of time that students can document that they will be spending in the Internship. Expectations during the Active Internship After an Internship is identified and a description of duties is approved, the following is expected of the student: Preparation of an Initial Internship Learning Plan (3-5 pages) that will include a statement of the student's individual and professional learning goals for the Internship, a summary of the prior knowledge and skills that the student brings to the placement, and a preliminary bibliography of material that may help the student understand the experience. This Plan should be completed during the first month of the Internship and must be signed by both the student's on-site supervisor and the Internship Advisor. In any case, a faculty member with expertise in the policy area relevant to the Internship may be designated as Internship Evaluator. Attendance at all the Internship Group Meetings held each semester (if applicable). If you cannot make one of these meetings, you must make a separate appointment with the Internship Advisor to review your progress. 3 Maintenance of an Internship Portfolio that serves as a record of the student's work during the internship. The format for the portfolio may vary depending upon the setting, but minimally it will include: any written documents prepared by the student in the course of the Internship; a "monthly update" of student activities and monthly statement of the evolution of the learning goals and policy directions; relevant new bibliography; and any other material that "gives life" to the policy work being done, i.e., project reports, meeting minutes, policy memorandums received, etc. Submittal of an outline for the Internship Paper to the Internship Advisor, or the designated Internship evaluator, for approval to proceed. The Advisor /Evaluator will make sure that the student paper will fully present and analyze the policy, organizational, political ethical and personal issues raised the Internship, will relate these issues to the appropriate literature, and will thoroughly evaluate the student's and the agency's roles in regard to the issues identified. Submittal of a completed Internship Paper (10,000 words) and an accompanying Internship Portfolio to the Internship Advisor or Faculty Evaluator An oral Presentation that presents the major issues of the Internship. This will be open to the all students and faculty and each student will present a 30-minute evaluation of: ▫what they planned to learn from the internship and what they think was actually learned; ▫what the Internship Paper summarized from that experience and recommendations/assessment regarding the feasibility of this site for an internship. Other Issues Sometimes internship "opportunities" are not what they seem. Agencies can encounter a crisis and options for learning, or investigating the past, can dissolve. If this happens in an Active Internship, the student should contact the Internship Advisor, or their Evaluator, immediately. Usually it is still possible to write a credible paper about the crisis, especially one focused on organizational issues of policy implementation. If opportunities to examine a Prior Internship are reduced, then the Advisor /Evaluator will have to meet and determine if adequate evidence exists for an appropriate paper or whether other options must be pursued. The Program is sensitive to the appropriate ethical and confidentiality questions involved with writing the Internship Papers. Ideally, the papers should be specific and grounded in what really happens with policy making or implementation, but all parties must take care not to betray trusts. Students are urged to discuss such ethical guidelines with the Internship Advisor. The Prior Internship Option Students who have substantial experience at a policy level may wish to review and analyze this experience in light of what they have been learning in the Program. This can be a rich and satisfying experience, and much can be learned from "revisiting" an earlier experience. To be considered appropriate for a Prior Internship, the experience must: 4 Have occurred within six years of the time the student registers for the Internship and lasted for at least nine months; Have been at a level which allowed the student access to decision-making and to information regarding policy development and implementation; Be accessible to the student for an analysis in the present, i.e., some of the original stakeholders must be available for interview, records can be found and used, etc. Why not to Choose a Prior Internship Even if a student has appropriate prior policy experience, s/he may choose not to select a Prior Internship. Some of the reasons are: Access to old records and stakeholders is too difficult; The student feels "finished" with the experience and feels that nothing would be learned from a reassessment; Opportunities for new learning, either in an Active Internship or through coursework/independent study, seem more appealing. Approval of the Prior Internship Once a student has decided to propose a Prior Internship, s/he should present a Prior Internship Learning Proposal (5-7 pages) that will summarize why the experience is appropriate for a Prior Internship, including: A summary of the student's role and level of activity, the policy issues involved and the availability of evidence regarding what occurred, including a general summary of the number of individuals to be interviewed and the types of materials to be reviewed. A statement of the student's individual and professional learning goals for requesting a Prior Internship; A preliminary bibliography of material that the student will use to help evaluate the experience; A proposal regarding the number of credit hours that are appropriate for the Prior Internship, based both upon the amount of prior work completed, the documentation that exists, and the amount of time that will be spent re-evaluating the policy issues and process. This Plan must be approved by the Internship Advisor while the GPD must approve the number of credit hours. For any student, a faculty member with expertise in the policy area relevant to the Internship may be designated as Internship Evaluator. Expectations for the Prior Internship Once the Proposal is approved, the following is expected of the student: Attendance at all the Internship Group Meetings held each semester (if applicable). Preparation of an extensive Internship Portfolio that serves both as a record of the student's work during the Prior Internship and of the experience of investigating it. The format for the portfolio may vary depending upon the setting, but minimally, it will include appropriate written documents prepared by the student during the internship; a "monthly update" of student activities in gathering evidence and a 5 monthly statement of the evolution of how the student is experiencing the review of a prior experience; relevant new bibliography; and any other material that "gives life" to the policy work that was done, i.e. project reports, meeting minutes, policy memorandums received. Submittal of an outline for the Internship Paper to the Internship Advisor, or the designated Internship Evaluator, for approval to proceed. The Advisor/Evaluator will make sure that the student paper will fully present and analyze the policy, including any organizational, political, ethical and personal issues raised the Internship; will relate these issues to the appropriate literature, and will thoroughly evaluate both the student's and agency's roles in regard to the issues identified. For Prior Internships, it will be particularly important that students examine how their perceptions of what occurred has changed based upon questions and perspectives gained over time and through participation in the Ph.D. Program. Submittal of a completed Internship Paper (10,000 words minimum) and an accompanying Internship Portfolio to the Internship Advisor or Faculty Evaluator. If the paper needs additional work, the Advisor /Evaluator will ask for it. An Oral Presentation that analyzes the major issues of the Internship. This will be a group presentation, open to the all students and faculty, where each student will present a 30-minute evaluation of: ▫what they planned to learn from rethinking their earlier experience and what they think was actually learned. ▫what the Internship Paper summarized from that experience and recommendations/assessment regarding the best methods for engaging in a Prior Internship. 6