STUDY ADVICE SERVICE TEST: LEARNING ABOUT PLAGIARISM ANSWERS Correct answers are given in bold with some feedback for each question. Question 1 WHAT IS PLAGIARISM? Before you can learn more about plagiarism, you need to know what it is! Listed below are some possible definitions. Tick the ones which you think define "plagiarism" most accurately. There are several correct answers. Answer Not using the correct referencing system in your essays. Taking the work of others and passing it off as if it were your own. Integrating another person's ideas into your own work. Using quotations in your work. Intentionally or unintentionally using the words or ideas of others, without also telling your reader whom those ideas and words belong to. Taking information from the Internet without also saying where that information came from. Buying essays over the Internet and submitting them for marking as your own work. Getting previous years’ work from a friend and submitting that work as though it were your own. Feedback The correct definitions of plagiarism all refer to using the ideas of others without due acknowledgement. You are expected to use the ideas of others in your work, but you MUST reference them, using your department’s guidelines. Buying essays over the Internet is closer to cheating (using unfair means) than plagiarism. 1 Question 2 HOW IMPORTANT IS IT FOR ME TO LEARN ABOUT PLAGIARISM, AND WHY? Do you know how important learning about plagiarism is, and why? To check your understanding of these issues, consider the statements below and tick the ones you think are true. There are several correct answers. Answer Plagiarism can give you an unfair advantage over other students. Nobody checks for plagiarism in your work. You can incur penalties for proven plagiarism, which ultimately could result in your expulsion from the University. To gain better marks, you need to demonstrate independent learning, rather than just repeating the ideas of others. Plagiarism is impossible for others to detect in your work. Plagiarism is a more serious offence at higher levels in your studies. Before you submit any work, you will have to sign a declaration whereby you state that the work is your own. It's OK to plagiarise if you're in a rush to finish your work and you don't have time to detail all the references you have used. Feedback The correct answers indicate the importance of learning about and understanding plagiarism, which is taken very seriously by the University. Plagiarism is unacceptable in any circumstances, and lecturers have several ways of checking for it in your work – see the next question. Question 3 HOW CAN MY LECTURERS RECOGNISE PLAGIARISM IN MY WORK? Listed below are some ways in which your lecturers might be alerted to possible plagiarism in your work. Tick the ones you think are genuine. There are several correct answers. Answer By using computer programs that have been specially developed to detect plagiarism in a piece of writing. By spotting one or more changes in your writing style or the vocabulary you use, which could indicate that you are copying information from another source. By reading everything relevant to the essay topic; being able to remember it all whenever they see it again; and knowing exactly 2 where everything they read came from. By your work getting a much higher or lower mark than work you have previously submitted. By noticing web addresses in the middle of your work, which are not part of any references. By spotting out of date statements, such as those implying that a deceased author is still alive. By identifying a lack of quotations and/or quotation marks in your work. By noticing changes in the font you use in your work, which can indicate that you have copied and pasted information from somewhere else. Feedback The correct answers show the many ways which lecturers use to check for plagiarism in your work. If they detect instances of plagiarism, they can deduct marks from your overall mark for the assignment. Question 4 HOW CAN I RECOGNISE PLAGIARISM IN MY WORK? You must not rely on your lecturers to recognise possible plagiarism in your work when they are marking it, because by then it is too late as you have already submitted and signed a plagiarism declaration relating to it. To help you learn to recognise plagiarism, look at the following ways of using the work of others in your own work. Tick the ones which are plagiarism. There are several correct answers. [Adapted from Swales, John and Feak, Chris, (1993), Academic writing for graduate students, Michigan, University of Michigan.] Answer Copying a paragraph from someone else's work into your own work, without any acknowledgment. Using no quotation marks. Copying a paragraph from someone else's work into your own work, making small changes such as replacing verbs and adjectives with similar words. Using no quotation marks. Listing the original source in the list of references at the end of your work. Cutting and pasting a paragraph into your own work by using sentences from someone else's work, but in a different order and omitting some of them. Using no quotation marks. Listing the original source in the list of references at the end of your work. Composing a paragraph in your own work by taking short phrases directly from a number of other people's work and linking them with words of your own. Using no quotation marks. Putting a reference in the text of your work and in the list of references at the end of your work. 3 Putting a paragraph from someone else's work into your own words (paraphrasing it) and then into your own work, making substantial changes in language and organisation and in the amount of detail and examples used. Putting a reference in the text of your work and in the list of references at the end of your work. Quoting a paragraph from someone else's work in your own work, by putting it in either quotation marks or block format. Putting a reference in the text of your work and in the list of references at the end of your work. Feedback The first correct answer is plagiarism because there is no acknowledgement at all that you have used the work of someone else. The second and third correct answers are plagiarism because although you have altered someone else’s work in some way, you have still used it, and this requires a reference not only at the end of your work but also in the text of your work. In addition, the third correct answer indicates the use of quotations, which requires quotation marks as well as a reference in the text of your work. The fourth correct answer is plagiarism because you have used quotations but without quotation marks. This is still plagiarism even though you have referenced the quotations in the text and at the end of your work. The remaining two ways of using the work of others in your own work are not plagiarism, because you have fully referenced either the paraphrasing or the quotation, and enclosed the quotation in quotation marks Question 5 HOW CAN I RECOGNISE PLAGIARISM IN THE WORK OF OTHERS? [PRACTICE QUESTION 1] Being able to recognise plagiarism in the work of others will help you to recognise it in your own work. Have a look at the following pieces of writing, and tick the ones which ARE plagiarism. There are several correct answers. [Adapted from Carroll, Jude, (2000), 'Academic Dishonesty and the Internet', in SEDA, Reaching Out: SEDA Spring Conference 2000, London, SEDA, cited in Drew, Sue and Bingham, Rosie, (2001, 2nd edn), The Student Skills Guide, Aldershot, Gower.] Answer "There is a view that the world and its economy is changing rapidly, and that a nation's success is dependent on individuals who are flexible, able to continue to learn and have skills which are transferable between situations." (Drew, 1998, p15) There is the view that the world and its economy is changing rapidly, and that a nation's success is dependent on individuals who are flexible, able to continue to learn and have skills which are transferable between situations. There are various reasons why Key Skills have been seen as important by governments. There is a view that the world and its economy is changing rapidly, and that a nation's success depends on flexible people with skills which transfer between situations. HE 4 is expensive and should justify that expense by developing individuals' skills (Drew, 1998) Drew (1998) suggests that an assumption behind the Key Skills movement is that, in a rapidly changing world, a nation's economy depends on the skills of individuals. An assumption behind the Key Skills movement is that, in a rapidly changing world, a nation's economy depends on the skills of individuals. Feedback The first correct answer is plagiarism because although it is a quotation of the passage above it, it has no quotation marks around it and no reference. The passage above it is not plagiarism because it has quotation marks and a reference. The second correct answer draws on Drew’s work, and is plagiarism because it has a quotation in the middle of it which is not enclosed in quotation marks and not referenced. The reference that is there is in the wrong place, because it should come immediately after the part of the passage that draws on Drew. Instead, it comes at end of the whole paragraph. The third correct answer is plagiarism because Drew’s work has been paraphrased and should therefore be referenced. The passage above it is a correct example of this. Question 6 HOW CAN I RECOGNISE PLAGIARISM IN THE WORK OF OTHERS? [PRACTICE QUESTION 2] Being able to recognise plagiarism in the work of others will help you to recognise it in your own work. Here is a piece of original text, taken from page 1 of Williams, J., (2001), Lizzie Borden: a Casebook of Family and Crime in the 1890s, New York, Star Books. The rise of industry, the growth of cities, and the expansion of the population were the three great developments of late nineteenth century American history. As new, larger, steam-powered factories became a feature of the American landscape in the East, they transformed farm hands into industrial laborers, and provided jobs for a rising tide of immigrants. With industry came urbanization: the growth of large cities (like Fall River, Massachusetts, where the Bordens lived) which became the centers of production as well as of commerce and trade. Listed below are three examples of pieces of writing based on this text. Tick the ones which are NOT plagiarism. There are two correct answers. [Adapted from Indiana University Writing Tutorial Services, (2004), Plagiarism: What it is and How to Recognize and Avoid it, Bloomington, Indiana University, < www.indiana.edu/~wts/pamphlets/plagiarism.shtml>, accessed 08/08/2005] Answer Fall River, where the Borden family lived, was typical of northeastern industrial cities of the nineteenth century. Steam-powered production had shifted labor from agriculture to manufacturing, and 5 as immigrants arrived in the US, they found work in these new factories. As a result, populations grew, and large urban areas arose. Fall River was one of these manufacturing and commercial centers (Williams, 2001, p1). Fall River, where the Borden family lived, was typical of northeastern industrial cities of the nineteenth century. As steampowered production shifted labor from agriculture to manufacturing, the demand for workers "transformed farm hands into industrial laborers" and created jobs for immigrants. In turn, growing populations increased the size of urban areas. Fall River was one of these hubs "which became the centers of production as well as of commerce and trade" (Williams, 2001, p1). The increase of industry, the growth of cities, and the explosion of the population were three large factors of nineteenth century America. As steam-driven companies became more visible in the eastern part of the country, they changed farm hands into factory workers and provided jobs for the large wave of immigrants. With industry came the growth of large cities like Fall River where the Bordens lived, which turned into centers of commerce and trade as well as production. Feedback The first correct answer, which paraphrases Williams’ work, is not plagiarism because it is correctly referenced. The same applies to the second correct answer, which includes direct quotations enclosed in quotation marks and a page number in the reference. The remaining answer is plagiarism because it paraphrases Williams’ work but is not referenced. Question 7 HOW CAN I RECOGNISE PLAGIARISM IN THE WORK OF OTHERS? [PRACTICE QUESTION 3] Being able to recognise plagiarism in the work of others will help you to recognise it in your own work. Here is a piece of original text, taken from page 77 of Greenfield, S., (2000), The Private Life of the Brain, Harmondsworth, Penguin. Recreational drugs are self administered to change consciousness in a dramatic way, to create a sustained and different sensation. Despite their very different modes of action, these drugs presumably all have one final effect in common - the subjective emotion, presumably of some sort of pleasure. Listed below are four pieces of writing relating to the topic covered in the above text. Tick the ONE example of plagiarism. [Adapted from Nottingham Trent University Student Support Services, (n.d), Plagiarism 6 Badger, Nottingham, Nottingham Trent University, <www2.ntu.ac.uk/sss/studysupport/tests/>, accessed 08/08/05] Answer The range of drugs used in the UK is widespread; some are legal such as alcohol and tobacco, whilst others are illegal such as cannabis and heroin. They share a common effect, namely "to change consciousness in a dramatic way, to create a sustained and different sensation" (Greenfield, 2000, p77) Drug users in the UK administer recreational drugs to change their consciousness in a dramatic way and to create a long-term, different sensation. These drugs, despite their very different modes of action, presumably all have one final effect in common - the subjective emotion, presumably of some sort of pleasure. The purpose of a recreational drug is to alter how the user feels. This may be brought about by the use of legal drugs such as alcohol and tobacco; illegal drugs such as cannabis, heroin or cocaine; or the misuse of prescription drugs or solvents. The impact on the brain will vary: some drugs will bring about feelings of ecstasy and bliss, others cause hallucinations, and others bring about the sensation of detachment. Addiction to these sensations can be a serious problem, and whether the addict craves alcohol or heroin, the social impact can be the same. Despite their different methods of use, Greenfield (2000, p77) suggests that recreational drugs all share the same key characteristics: they create a pleasurable change that alters the brain physically and emotionally. Feedback The correct answer is plagiarism because it paraphrases Greenfield’s work and also includes a quotation (at the end of the passage), but there are no references. The remaining answers all either paraphrase or quote Greenfield’s work (or both), but are not plagiarism because they are correctly referenced. Question 8 HOW CAN I RECOGNISE PLAGIARISM IN THE WORK OF OTHERS? [PRACTICE QUESTION 4] Being able to recognise plagiarism in the work of others will help you to recognise it in your own work. Here is a piece of original text, taken from page 107 of Lodge, D., (1988), Modern Criticism and Theory: a Reader, London, Longman. "Structure, Sign and Play" marks the moment at which post-structuralism as a movement begins, opposing itself to classical structuralism as well as to traditional humanism and empiricism: the moment as Derrida himself puts it "when the structurality of structure had to begin to be thought". 7 Here is a piece of writing based on this text. It has been argued that post-structuralism begins with Derrida's essay "Structure, Sign and Play"; the movement set itself in opposition to the preceding dominant traditions of literary criticism, namely traditional humanism and empiricism. (Lodge, 1977, p107) Listed below are four statements about this piece of writing. Tick the ONE statement which is correct. [Adapted from Nottingham Trent University Student Support Services, (n.d.), Plagiarism Badger, Nottingham, Nottingham Trent University, <www2.ntu.ac.uk/sss/studysupport/tests/>, accessed 08/08/05] Answer It IS plagiarism, because the writer has used a direct quotation from the original source. It IS plagiarism, because the rewritten passage is over 25 words long. It is NOT plagiarism, because although the writer has paraphrased the original text, they have also shown where their ideas came from. It is NOT plagiarism, because the writer has rewritten the information in their own words, and there is no need for a reference if the original text has been greatly altered. Feedback The correct answer illustrates the need to reference not only direct quotations, but also any passage of the original text which you have rewritten in your own words. The length of such passages is irrelevant. Using a quotation does not in itself constitute plagiarism, but would be plagiarism if the quotation was not correctly referenced. Question 9 HOW DO I AVOID PLAGIARISM IN MY WORK? So far, you have been asked to consider what plagiarism is; why it is important to know about it; how your lecturers can recognise it ; and how to recognise it in your own work and in that of others. This question asks you about how you can avoid plagiarism in your work. Tick those ways which you think may help you to avoid plagiarism in your work. There are several correct answers. Answer Learn to write in your own style, trying not to copy someone else's. When you are reading and making notes, write down exactly where the information comes from as you go along. Avoid using anyone else's work or ideas in your writing. 8 If you use someone else's ideas in your writing, make sure you reference them. Check your paraphrasing against the original text, to make sure that you haven't accidentally used the same words or phrases that the original writer uses. Avoid using quotations in your writing. Make notes in your own words, except when you want to use a quotation. Feedback You are expected to use the work of others in your own work, including quotations and the correct answers show that there are several methods you can use to ensure that you do not plagiarise. You should get into the habit of using these methods. Materials developed by Chris Pinder, Study Advice Service, University of Hull, August 2005. www.hull.ac.uk/studyadvice. 9