Through a Soldier’s Eyes—A Closer Look at WWI Mallori Demildt Prairie High School Spring 2010 Detail from a letter by Dennis J Sullivan, 1918. Dennis Sullivan Collection (AFC/2001/001/28523), Veterans History Project, American Folklife Center, Library of Congress. http://lcweb2.loc.gov/natlib/afc2001001/service/28523/ph0001001b.jpg “The most persistent sound which reverberates through man's history is the beating of war drums.” ~Arthur Koestler, Janus: A Summing Up. War has been a part of human history for thousands of years and is still a force in the world today. While weapons and tactics may change, there are always brave men and women who fight and sacrifice their very lives for their nations. What is war like for the average citizen soldier? How can a civilian cope with the horrors of war? In this unit students will examine World War I from the perspective of a civilian soldier from a European nation. They will analyze the reasons these men went to war and how they were forever changed by their time as soldiers. Overview/ Materials/LOC Resources/Standards/Procedures/Evaluation/Rubric/Handouts/Extension Overview Objectives Back to Navigation Bar Students will: Describe how international rivalries and nationalism pushed Europe toward war. Explain how the assassination in Sarajevo led to the start of WWI. Describe how technology made WWI different from earlier wars. Analyze different types of propaganda and create a poster that encourages someone from your selected nation to help with the war effort. Explain why a stalemate developed on the Western Front. Describe the importance of the battles of the Marne, Verdun, Somme, and the Gallipoli campaign. Compare and contrast fighting on the Eastern and Western Fronts. Describe how WWI became a total war and how life changed for both the soldiers and those on the home front. Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Recommended time frame Grade level Curriculum fit Materials Analyze the impact the Russian Revolution had on WWI. Analyze the cause and effects of American entry into WWI. Analyze the cost of WWI in terms of money and lives lost. Describe the issues faced by the delegates to the Paris Peace Conference and examine the goals of each nation who fought in the war. Explain why many people were dissatisfied with the Treaty of Versailles. Develop a map, propaganda poster, and journal that reflect the experience of a soldier from a European nation in World War I using the information gathered throughout this unit. 10 days (plus 2 days for a video at the end if desired) 10 This is a short unit on World War I. The culminating assessment of this unit will be a journal project that incorporates the information learned throughout this process. Photo analysis worksheet Political Cartoon analysis worksheet Document analysis worksheet Journal rubric and project sheets WWI map WWI video Paper, colored pencils Access to computers Iowa Core Curriculum Learning Standards Back to Navigation Bar Iowa Core Curriculum—Social Studies Understand cause-and-effect relationships and other historical thinking skills in order to interpret events and issues. Interpret actions taken, analyze impact experienced, and evaluate decisions made in history in the context in which they occurred. Determine the validity and accuracy of primary sources and secondary sources and evaluate them for bias. Predict how different decisions might have impacted the outcome of an event. Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Understand the role of innovation on the development and interaction of societies. Identify major technological advancements and evaluate their impact on social, political, and historical events. Understand how and why people create, maintain, or change systems of power, authority, and governance. Procedures Explore how government has reacted to problems in the past, such as social, environmental, political, and/or economic issues and how the government’s actions affected individuals. Evaluate how individuals influenced government actions in past events. Back to Navigation Bar Day 1–Introduction to the project Today students will begin their study of WWI. We will begin by brainstorming the causes and major people of WWI (which the kids should know a little about). We will discuss why they know very little about the causes of WWI. We will then go over the main causes of WWI and discuss the spark (the assassination of Franz Ferdinand) that led to the conflict. We will describe how some of the major players were pulled into the war. At this point the students will receive the journal project and rubric, and will be assigned to a country. If there are a few minutes left, they may begin working on their first entry. Day 2–WWI Recruits Today we will discuss how and why soldiers entered this conflict. We will examine 2 pieces of World War I propaganda and complete the political cartoon analysis form. We will discuss what makes a “good” piece of propaganda and where they have seen propaganda in their modern lives (commercials, etc.). They will use the remaining time to look up more WWI propaganda posters online and then design their own poster and answer the questions from the project sheet. Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Day 3–WWI Weapons Today students will look at the new weaponry that forever changed the way war was fought. Students will begin by brainstorming what types of weapons they had in WWI. They will then do part of a webquest to search for weapons that were used in this time period. They will share the information with the class. After this we will look at some primary source pictures of WWI weapons and the devastation that they caused. How would you feel if you were a soldier having to use these weapons on other people? How would you feel when you saw the devastation these weapons were causing all around you? Students will then have some time to write in their journals. Day 4–Life in the Trenches Today students will look at what life was like in the trenches. First, we will discuss why we had to fight in trenches on the Western Front (because of the new military technology). Students will then do a scavenger hunt for information about WWI trenches posted around the room. (Included are the questions for the hunt and some of the resources posted gathered from www.schoolhistory.co.uk.) After they have completed their hunt, we will discuss what conditions were like in the trenches. Next, the class will be broken into groups of 3–4 students, and they will be given WWI journals from the resource list to read and summarize. They will then share an experience from their reading with the class. Day 5–Battles Today the students will begin looking at some of the major battles of WWI. They will do this by using the battle webquest located on the other side of the weapons webquest sheet. When they have finished, we will discuss the events and impact of these battles and map them on our WWI maps. Students will have some time to work on their journals. Day 6–The Eastern Front and Russian Revolution Today we will discuss the war on the Eastern Front. First, we will discuss the conditions in Russia prior to WWI. Next, we will look at the failed Gallipoli campaign and Germany’s advance into Russia. We will then discuss the rise of Bolshevism and watch a Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University short video clip (from DE Streaming) on Rasputin and the Romanov family. Finally, we will explain how the Russian Revolution changed the Russian people and hurt the Allied cause. Day 7–U.S. Enters WWI Today students will examine why the U.S. chose to enter this conflict. We will first brainstorm why Wilson would not want to enter this conflict. Next, we will look at some of the events that drew the U.S. into the war. Students will use the document analysis worksheet to analyze the newspaper articles about the sinking of the Lusitania and the burial of 66 Lusitania victims. How would this make Americans feel about the Germans? Next we will analyze the Zimmermann telegram, also using the analysis worksheet. How would this telegram push the U.S. toward war? We will then watch a video from DE Streaming called “WWI—The War in Europe” to see what impact American soldiers and supplies had on the war effort. Day 8–The Armistice and End of the War Today students will examine Wilson’s Fourteen Points and the Treaty of Versailles. Students will first brainstorm how the leaders from the major countries of Europe would want the Treaty to be written. The students will break into small groups and write a short paragraph explaining what provisions their nation feels should be in the treaty. We will share these with the class and then look at the actual goals of the major nations involved in WWI. We will then examine Wilson’s Fourteen Points and some provisions of the Treaty of Versailles. We will analyze why these 2 documents are so different—why was Wilson willing to compromise his beliefs? Day 9–Aftermath of WWI Today we will look at the impact WWI had on the world. We will first examine the impact it had on Germany by viewing some political cartoons and analyzing them as a group. Next, we will look at the financial and human cost of the war. We will end by discussing what we should learn from this conflict. Day 10–Finish, Edit, and Turn in Journals Today students will complete their journals and Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University share them with their classmates. When they have finished this, we will turn in the journals and begin watching the movie “The Lost Battalion” to see how close their journals actually were to life on the front. Evaluation Back to Navigation Bar These students will be evaluated both formatively and summatively. The formative assessments will be the weapons and battle webquests, the Trench scavenger hunt worksheet, and the analysis worksheets that the students will fill out together in groups. The summative assessment will be the student’s journal project that will be graded on the rubric. Extension Back to Navigation Bar As an extension, have students look at an aspect of the war on the home front in the country they were assigned to. What was life like for those left behind as the soldiers went off to war? After researching this topic, the student will write a letter from a person on the home front to the soldier in their journal. This letter should incorporate information about what women and children were doing to help the war effort, morale at home, shortages, and any other topic the student may find interesting. To point them on their way, the students might start at the BBC and look at British History— Home Front: World War I http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/britain_wwone/ or home front information on WWI at firstworldwar.com http://www.firstworldwar.com/photos/homefront.htm. Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Primary Resources from the Library of Congress Back to Navigation Bar Image Description The sinking of the Lusitania in 1915. The Lusitania aftermath. Burying the remains of passengers of the Lusitania–66 coffins were buried in one huge grave. Citation URL The war of the nations: portfolio in rotogravure etching: compiled from the mid-week pictorial, New York: New York Times Co., 1919. From the Library of Congress, Rotogravure collection. sgpwar 19191231 http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.gdc/s gpwar.19191231 http://memory.loc.gov/cgibin/np_item.pl?collection=s gproto&agg=sgpwar&iss=1 9191231&page=342 Excerpt from New York Times, May 30, 1915, New York: May 30, 1915 From the Library of Congress, Rotogravure collection. sgpnyt 19150530 http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.gdc/s gpnyt.19150530 http://memory.loc.gov/cgibin/np_item.pl?collection=s gproto&agg=sgpnyt&iss=19 150530&page=7 Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Newspaper article about the new weaponry in use during World War I. The war of the nations: portfolio in rotogravure etchings: compiled from the mid-week pictorial. New York: New York Times Co., 1919. Call Number D522 .W28 1919 Repository: Library of Congress, Serials and Government Publications Division, Washington, D.C. 20540 http://memory.loc.gov/cgibin/np_item.pl?collection=s gproto&agg=sgpwar&iss=1 9191231&page=163 Poster showing a Red Cross nurse and a heavily bandaged man. What are you doing to help? Join your American Red Cross Creator(s): Grant, Gordon, 18751962, Date Created/Published: [1919]. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA http://lcweb2.loc.gov/service /pnp/cph/3g00000/3g07000/ 3g07700/3g07706r.jpg U.S. Army recruiting poster showing a soldier standing next to an American flag and blowing a bugle. The call to duty Join the Army for home and country. Created/Published: [New York]: Published by Recruiting Committee of the Mayor's Committee on National Defence, [1917] Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA http://lcweb2.loc.gov/service /pnp/cph/3g00000/3g07000/ 3g07500/3g07565r.jpg Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Red Cross recruitment poster showing a nurse on a battlefield with a wounded soldier appealing to a nurse seated at a desk; in the background, soldiers charge into battle. If I fail he dies Work for the Red Cross Creator(s): McCoy, Arthur G. Created/Published: Duluth: J.J. LeTourneau Printing Co., c1918. Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA http://lcweb2.loc.gov/service /pnp/cph/3g00000/3g07000/ 3g07700/3g07767r.jpg Poster showing a woman clutching an infant as a German soldier with bloody hands approaches. Hun or home? Buy more Liberty Bonds Creator(s): Raleigh, Henry, 1880–1945 Created/Published: Chicago: Edwards & Deutsch Litho. Co., [1918] Call Number: POS - US .R35, no. 2 (C size) [P&P] Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA The war of the nations: portfolio in rotogravure etchings: compiled from the mid-week pictorial, Created/Published: New York: New York Times, Co., 1919. Call Number D522 .W28 1919. Repository Library of Congress, Serials and Government Publications Division, Washington, D.C. 20540 http://lcweb2.loc.gov/service /pnp/cph/3g10000/3g10000/ 3g10300/3g10331r.jpg Monster Guns in use by American forces in the Argonne. http://memory.loc.gov/cgibin/np_item.pl?collection=s gproto&agg=sgpwar&iss=1 9191231&page=187 Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University 8-page article with pictures of WWI destruction in Europe. Excerpt from New York Times, October 4, 1914. Created/Published: New York: October 4, 1914. Repository Library of Congress, Serials and Government Publications Division, Washington, D.C. 20540 http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.gdc/sg pnyt.19141004 Exhibit poster showing two scenes in which men with double leg amputations are being taught to walk with prostheses. Learning to walk for the second time Date Created/Published: 1919. Reproduction Number: LC-USZC4-7372 Call Number: POS - WWI US, no. 34 (C size) [P&P] Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA http://lcweb2.loc.gov/service /pnp/cph/3g00000/3g07000/ 3g07300/3g07372r.jpg 1-page handout about British Army uniforms in WWI. Soldier’s Equipment submitted by Miss Boughey and housed at http://www.schoolhistory.c o.uk/gcselinks/wars/firstw wlinks/trenches_worksheet s.shtml http://www.schoolhistory.co .uk/gcselinks/wars/firstwwli nks/worksheets/soldiersequi pment.pdf Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University 2-page resource about military divisions in England during WWI. Soldiers in WWI submitted by Mr. Davies to http://www.schoolhistory.c o.uk/gcselinks/wars/firstw wlinks/trenches_worksheet s.shtml http://www.schoolhistory.co .uk/gcselinks/wars/firstwwli nks/worksheets/wwisoldier. pdf Resource describing how trenches were constructed. Trench Warfare in the First World War How the trench system was organized. Submitted by Mr. Moorhouse to http://www.schoolhistory.c o.uk/gcselinks/wars/firstw wlinks/trenches_worksheet s.shtml Body Lice submitted by Mr. RJ Huggins to http://www.schoolhistory.c o.uk/gcselinks/wars/firstw wlinks/trenches_worksheet s.shtml Trench Rats submitted by Mr. RJ Huggins to http://www.schoolhistory.c o.uk/gcselinks/wars/firstw wlinks/trenches_worksheet s.shtml http://www.schoolhistory.co .uk/gcselinks/wars/firstwwli nks/worksheets/trencheshigh er.pdf 2-page resource with personal accounts about lice in the trenches. 2-page resource with personal accounts about rats in the trenches during WWI. http://www.schoolhistory.co .uk/gcselinks/wars/firstwwli nks/worksheets/bodylice.pdf http://www.schoolhistory.co .uk/gcselinks/wars/firstwwli nks/worksheets/trenchrats.pd f Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University President Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points (1918) WWI Outline Map for the Journal Project. European Alliances submitted by Mr. RJ Huggins to http://www.schoolhistory.c o.uk/gcselinks/wars/firstw wlinks/trenches_worksheet s.shtml http://www.schoolhistory.co .uk/gcselinks/wars/firstwwli nks/causes_worksheets.shtm l Zimmermann Note. Zimmermann Telegram as Received by the German Ambassador to Mexico, 01/19/1917 Record Group 59: General Records of the Department of State, 1756–1979 National Archives and Records Administration ARC Identifier 302025 http://www.archives.gov/edu cation/lessons/zimmermann/ images/coded-message-l.jpg Translated Zimmermann Note. Zimmermann Telegram Decoded Message Record Group 59: General Records of the Department of State, 1756–1979 National Archives and Records Administration ARC Identifier 302022 http://www.archives.gov/edu cation/lessons/zimmermann/ images/decoded-messagel.jpg President Wilson’s Fourteen-Point speech to Congress. Click on Transcript to read the section in the middle. President Wilson's Message to Congress, January 8, 1918; Records of the United States Senate; Record Group 46; Records of the United States Senate; National Archives http://www.ourdocuments.g ov/doc.php?flash=old&doc= 62# Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Modern History Sourcebook: Treaty of Versailles, June 28, 1919 Selected passages from the Treaty of Versailles. From The Treaty of Versailles and After: Annotations of the Text of the Treaty (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1944), Part of the Internet Modern History Sourcebook. (c)Paul Halsall Aug 1997 halsall@murray.fordham. edu http://www.fordham.edu/hal sall/mod/1919versailles.html Political Cartoon showing how Germany was impacted by the Treaty of Versailles. Cartoon Artist: Low, David (1891–1963) Published: The Star, 24 Jan 1921. British Cartoon Archive, University of Kent Reference number: LSE6501 http://www.cartoons.ac.uk/b rowse/cartoon_item/anytext =david%20low%20unlimite d%20indemnity?page=1 Political Cartoon about Germany and reparations. Cartoon Artist: Low, David (1891–1963) Published: The Star, 27 Jan 1921 British Cartoon Archive, University of Kent Reference number: LSE6497 http://www.cartoons.ac.uk/re cordimage/standard/LSE6497 Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Audio interview of a soldier being shelled and getting wounded in France. Diary of soldier Harry Frieman of his life at training and in World War I. Audio interview excerpts of Arnold Stephen Hoke, “Arnold Stephen Hoke is Wounded.” Part of the Veteran’s History Project at the Library of Congress http://lcweb2.loc.gov/digli b/vhpstories/loc.natlib.afc20010 01.31638/#vhp:clip. Typescript diary of Harry Frieman, part of the Veteran’s History Project at the Library of Congress http://lcweb2.loc.gov/digli b/vhpstories/loc.natlib.afc20010 01.23600/ http://lcweb2.loc.gov/diglib/ vhpstories/loc.natlib.afc2001001 .31638/audio?ID=d5109e98 3 http://lcweb2.loc.gov/diglib/ vhpstories/loc.natlib.afc2001001 .23600/ Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Rubric Back to Navigation Bar World War I Journal Rubric Map Labeled, Colored, with Numbers 5 3 0 Appearance—well designed, graphic, color 5 3 1 Thoroughly answers questions on the back 5 3 1 Propaganda Poster Journal Length/ 5 3 1 Each entry over ½ page, in Each entry ½ page, Entries less than ½ entries in correct page, not in correct shows a logical thought order, but order, and show no progression information is logical pattern Organization the correct order, and disconnected Spelling/ Entries have no Entries have 1 to 2 Entries have many Grammar spelling/grammar errors errors per entry spelling and grammatical errors Creativity Entries have many details Entries have only a Entries don’t show and descriptive elements few details and any creative thought covers only basic and have few details information Content- All information is correct Most information Many historical Worth 15 and thorough. Lists specific correct, has few errors and no points historical events and WWI references to references to features (weapons, historical events and weapons, people, etc. alliances, people) WWI features Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Score Handouts Back to Navigation Bar WWI Journal Project Instructions: For this project you will write a war journal from the perspective of a soldier from a nation that fought in World War I. You will write a series of 6 journal entries that will be at least ½ page each. Each of the entries must be dated in the margin, and they should also include a location of where the soldier is fighting. You will also include a map that will show where you traveled throughout the war. Lastly, you will include a propaganda poster that encourages people in your country to help the war effort. All of these items should be stapled together, with the grading rubric on the top. This project will be due on _____________. You will write from the perspective of a soldier from: __________________________ You will write journal entries about the following events: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. An entry from just before the war began. Include background information about your character. Who is he? Does he have a family? How old is he? How does your character feel about the tension in Europe? (You may discuss the assassination of Franz Ferdinand in your entry if you wish.) An entry on why you entered the war. Was your nation taken over by another power? Are you allied with another nation? Also describe one form of propaganda that influenced you to become a soldier. An entry on trench warfare. Using a specific battle, describe what life was like in the trenches. What kind of weapons were being used? How did you sleep? How did you eat? Did you see others getting killed? How did that affect you? How do you feel about the war now? (This will be closer to a page.) An entry from when the U.S. entered the war. How do you feel about the U.S. entering the war? Will it help or hurt your side? (This will be more of a paragraph than ½ page.) An entry on the end of the war. Where were you when you heard about the armistice? How did it make you feel? What do you plan to do when you get home? An entry on the Treaty of Versailles. How do you feel about this treaty? Do you feel it was fair? Do you want to punish Germany, or do you want to forgive them? For the Propaganda Poster: Design a poster that encourages people to support the war effort. This poster can either encourage men to enlist as soldiers or can tell women and children what they can do to support the war. This must have a slogan, a graphic, and specific things people can do to help. This may be done on the computer or drawn by hand. On the back of your poster, please address the following questions: 1. 2. 3. 4. Describe the symbols used in this poster. What basic value(s) is this poster trying to portray? Define your feelings and impressions when you view this poster. How effective is this poster? For the Map: Label all of the countries on your map. Next, shade in all of the countries that were in the Triple Entente, and, in a different color, shade in the countries in the Triple Alliance. (For the country that switches sides, color it with both colors.) As you write your journal entries, put a number on the map showing where your character is during each entry (for instance, for entry 1, write a 1 on the map where your person lives). After you have all 6 numbers, connect them starting at 1 and going through number 6. Teaching with Primary Sources Illinois State University Name ________________ Period________ World War I Trenches Scavenger Hunt 1. What were methods used to remove lice? 2. a. What did the army do to try to stop the soldiers from getting lice? b. Why didn’t it work? 3. What were symptoms of trench fever? 4. What was another name for lice hunting? 5. What two things attracted rats to the trenches? 6. How many offspring can a pair of rats produce in a year? 7. Which part of the body would the rats eat first? 8. How did soldiers use bacon to bait rats? 9. How many men were evacuated for trench foot and rheumatism? 10. How many Allied casualties were actually sustained in the trenches? 11. How large could brown rats grow? 12. How long did it take to recover from Trench Fever? 13. What caused trench foot? 14. List the 4 stages of the trench cycle. 15. What was the morning hate? 16. Why was an unofficial truce adopted during breakfast? 17. Why was movement restricted until nightfall? 18. Name two tasks performed in No Man’s Land. 19. Name 4 things that contributed to the appalling smell of the trenches. 20. How many men were under the following units: section under a lance corporal: battalion under a major: division under a major general: 21. Name 2 types of training given to soldiers in France. 22. Name 5 things placed in soldiers’ packs. 23. What was the minimum weight of these packs? 24. How many soldiers were in the frontline at any one time? 25. How many men were required to keep the Lewis gun in action? 26. The machine gun had the fire power of how many riflemen? 27. What were estaminets? 28. What was the only permitted address on letters and parcels? 29. Name 7 types of equipment soldiers had to use in the trenches and carry into battle. World War I Webquest You may use any useful website to help you answer these questions. Some of the dates will be different depending on which site you use— just choose a set of dates from one of the websites. Marne Verdun Somme Gallipoli Ypres 1. 1. 2. 2. Dates 3. Location What happened? How many dead/injured? Why important? 1. 1. 2. 2. 3. New Technology in World War I Research 4 new weapons used in WWI—read about how they were used and think about why they would be important to the war effort. Weapon 1 Weapon 2 What is it? How does it work? What battle was it used in? Why was it important? What was “Big Bertha”? Who used it, and why was it so effective? Weapon 3 Weapon 4 Additional Handouts The following can be found at the National Archives: 1. Document Analysis Worksheet from the National Archives http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/ 2. Photograph Analysis Worksheet from the National Archives http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/ 3. Political Cartoon Analysis Worksheet from the National Archives http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/