Developmental Genomics and Stem Cell Biology BCH512 Fall 2010 1) Definition: The study of how the spatial and temporal readout of the genome is achieved during development, and conversely on how forced changes in gene expression patterns can affect developmental processes. Merger of Developmental Biology and Genomics. How does the Genome get read out to create the Organism. Different organism appear to use different strategies due to refinement of systems throughout evolution. Why use different organisms to study? A) Knowing how different systems work gives insight into possible mechanisms. Nature is building continuously, reusing and refining. What can happen? How did system evolve? B) Some systems are more useful than others to study specific aspects of development. Bacteria, fungi, protists, insects and nematodes, simple invertebrates, vertebrates, mammals. 2) Principals: A) Cellular continuity: Every cell comes from another cell. B) Polarity: Can be established in several ways: Prexisting in oocyte. develops by how material is transported into the developing oocyte. Drosophila oocyte development Page 1 B) Can be established by fertilization. Worms, point of sperm entry defines the posterior pole of the egg. Picture of P granules from Strome Lab a) fertilized egg with distributed P-granules b)At pronuclear migration P-granules redistribute to posterior, where sperm nucleus was located. c)After first cell division all P-granules in Posterior cell. Page 2 P granules are initially distributed throughout the cytoplasm, but then move posteriorly. C) Can be established in tissues by differential gene expression (Gradients) From Gilbert. http://www.devbio.com/article.php?ch=3&id=17 Figure 1. A hypothetical model for gradients establishing positional information. The concentration of the morphogen drops from the source. In this diagram, the receptors for the morphogen are enhancer elements of two genes that control cell fate, but the receptors could also be cytoplasmic receptors or membrane receptors. One of the receptors (in this case, the enhancer on gene A) needs a high concentration of morphogen in order to act. At high concentrations of morphogen, both genes A and B are active. In moderate concentrations, only gene B is active. Where the morphogen concentration falls below another threshold, neither gene is active. (After Wolpert, 1978.) This positional and temporal information is continuously changing in the developing embryo. Figure 3.19 Activin (Or a Closely Related Protein) Is Thought to Be Responsible for Converting Animal Hemisphere Cells into Mesoderm Page 3 Page 4 How does one study Developmental Genomics: Controlled Interference (Kaltoff). 1) Generate a hypothesis about how a process occurs. 2) Make a small controlled change that you predict will have a specific effect and 3) see what happens. Classical techniques: 1) Isolation Wilhelm Roux (1888) Destruction of 1/2 2-cell frog embryo Flaws in experiment Later studies by Oskar Herwig and others showed that separation of two cell embryos using constriction of a hair loop allowed the development of 1/2 size but essentially normal full embryos. Leaving dead cell attached to other cell apparently inhibited development. Shows both autonomy and induction. Isolation can also be done in vitro, by removal of a tissue or region and culturing it to determine whether it can develop autonomously or whether it requires co-culture with adjacent tissues. Page 5 2) Removal Hans Spemann (1901) Removed optic vesicle to ask whether lens would develop. Optic vesicle grows out from brain and lens forms from epidermal tissue overlying vesicle. To ask whether vesicle induced epidermal differentiation Spemann removed the optic vesicle from one side of an embryo. No lens appeared on the side where the Optic vesicle was removed therefore it is necessary for lens formation. Page 6 3) Transplantation: Warren H. Lewis (1904) asked whether the Optic vesicle was sufficient to induce lens formation by transplanting the vesicle under the flank and/or transplanting flank epidermis over the optic vesicle. In either case lenses formed over the vesicle, indicating that the vesicle was both necessary and sufficient to induce lens formation. Such studies indicated whether certain differentiation functions were cell-autonomous or inductive. Genetic techniques: Traditional and reverse genetics. Traditional genetics: Start with Wild-type allele. Induce mutations. Observe phenotype due to presence of mutant allele. Map and characterize gene. Isolate revertant mutations that correct phenotype (suppressor mutation) or modifier genes that intensify the phenotype. Construct genetic pathway. Mutations can be null alleles (complete loss of gene function), partial loss-of-function alleles, or gain-offunction alleles. Early studies also found Dominant-negative alleles which can overcome the effect of one or more copies of a wild-type allele. Reverse genetics: Start with a gene of interest, affect it's expression, see what happens. Transgenic and knockout techniques used in mouse development. Understanding these techniques will be important in future lectures. 1) Standard Transgenic mice: This technique is used to make a mouse that expresses any gene of interest in any tissue of interest. A recombinant DNA construct is make where the coding region of a gene is placed downstream of the control elements (promoter and enhancer elements) needed to express the gene in a tissue of interest. A poly adenylation signal is placed after the coding region in the construct. This DNA is linearized and injected into the male pronucleus of a fertilized oocyte (see figure). The DNA integrates randomly, sometimes multiple copies in multiple places in the genome. The embryo develops in vitro and is introduced into the uterus of foster mice. The progeny mice are screened to identify those that integrated the DNA and then the organs of interest are harvested to see whether the transgene is expressed in the animal. Because integration is random in each embryo, only some animals of the initial litter will contain the transgene (these are called founder mice) and different levels of expression are seen with integration at different sites in the genome. Several founder mice are bred to see that they transmit the transgene and that stable expression is obtained. Sometimes, transgenes are expressed in the first generation but then silenced in future generations due to modification of the chromatin structure at the site of integration. This is not something that one likes to see, as it complicates analysis. Most transgenes are stably expressed in all future generations. Page 7 2) Tet-On "conditional" transgenic mice: These are more complicated to make than a standard transgenic, but have the advantage that you can then express the transgene in whatever tissue in which you can express the rtTA (reverse tetracycline tranasactivator protein) protein by breeding 2 transgenic mouse strains together. With this system you need to make a minimum of 2 transgenic mouse lines. 1) The first we will call the operator mice. To make this mouse you place the coding region of any gene that you want to express (in the diagram a dominant-negative NFIA protein is used) downstream of a special promoter sequence containing binding sites for the rtTA protein. In the diagram this promoter region is shown as the tetO7-CMV fragment which has 7 copies of the tetO (tetracycline operator) sequence next to a minimal promoter region from human cytomegalovirus (CMV). A polyadenylation site is put downstream (BGHpA for example). Once you've done the cloning, you make a transgenic mouse as above. However, this promoter is normally inactive in mice, so you can only test for the presence of the transgenic DNA in the progeny mice, not for expression of the transgene. These mouse will have no phenotype because the transgene is not being expressed. You then put these mice containing the integrated operator transgene aside and make the second transgenic mouse, the rtTA expressing activator mice. 2) For the rtTA expressing mice (we'll call these the activator mice) you clone the coding sequence for the rtTA (reverse tetracycline TransActivator) protein downstream of a promoter/enhancer region that will express the rtTA protein in the tissue that you want to study. We'll use lung as an example and clone the rtTA coding sequence downstream of the CCSP promoter that express only in lung. So you now make another standard transgenic with the rtTA protein being expressed from the CCSP promoter. In this transgenic mouse line, you can screen for expression of the rtTA protein with antibodies or the mRNA for the rtTA protein using reverse transcription and PCR. Again, these mice will have no phenotype because they are expressing only the rtTA protein in a tissue of interest, in this case lung. The rtTA protein is a site-specific DNA-binding protein that binds to tetO sequences only in the presence of the drug tetracycline. It then activates transcription from transgene promoters that contain tetO sequences. In this single activator transgenic mouse there are no promoters to which rtTA can bind. Now you begin the experiment, you breed mice the operator mice with the activator mice and screen for mice that contain BOTH transgenes. These bi-transgenic mice still have no phenotype because while the rtTA protein is being expressed from the activator transgene in lung, there is no tetracycline (actually the related doxycycline is used in animals) to bind to the protein and therefore rtTA cannot activate transcription from operator transgene. If you take mice containing both transgenes and feed them doxycycline (labeled d in lower figure) it binds to the rtTA protein (shown as a black box/arrow), the rtTA protein binds to the tetO sequences and activates transcription from the operator transgene, expressing your protein of interest. While this seems very complicated, there are currently many laboratories producing their own strains of activator mice that express rtTA in different tissues. Therefore, if you decide to study the role of a given gene (such as the NFI-A engrailed dominant negative gene shown) in another tissue, you just have to breed your operator mouse with different activator mice that express rtTA if different tissues and you can ask what effect your gene has in that tissue, and you can control when the gene is expressed by Page 8 giving doxycycline. This technique has revolutionized the ability to express a gene in a temporally controlled (by dox) and spacially controlled (by transgene promoter) manner. It's easier to breed 2 mouse strains together than to create a new transgene that expresses in a specific tissue. Similarly, you could use your activator mouse and it's transgene to drive the expression of different operator transgenes in lung, thus eliminating the need to make multiple transgenes that express in lung. This mixing of different activator and operator mice is very flexible and allows one to express a transgene in multiple tissues just by interbreeding different pairs of mice. 3) Traditional mouse knockouts: A traditional knockout deletes the function of a gene in every cell of the organism. Loss of genes that are required for early development cause the embryos to die early, preventing analysis of the role of the gene at later stages of development. To make a traditional knockout (figure at right): 1) Create DNA construct with neo-resistance gene flanked by genomic sequences (attach negative selectable marker to one or both ends, see diagram next page). 2) Electroporate into Embryonal stem cells, select for neo gene and loss of flanking negative selection marker. 3) Screen for homologous recombination (targeted integration) as opposed to random insertion. See figure on next page for pictoral description of this process. 4) Inject correctly targeted ES cells into Blastocysts of mouse strain with different coat color (C57 Black). Check chimeric animals (usually males are used) with altered coat color for ability to transmit the targeted gene. If coat color is transmitted to progeny then sperm have been derived from ES cells. 5) Screen appropriately colored progeny of chimera for disrupted gene and breed heterozygous animals to achieve homozygosity. Correctly colored progeny from the male chimera will carry one copy either the normal gene or the disrupted gene from the ES cells, with the other copy coming from the normal female parent. 6) Observe phenotype in mice carrying one or two copies of the mutant gene compared to mice with 2 copies of the normal gene. Homologous recombination in step 3 will result in correctly targeted genes in only a fraction of the neo-resistant colonies. This diagram shows the structure of a targeting construct, a wild-type gene, and a correctly targeted allele from a recent paper of ours. The large Xs mark the regions in which homologous recombination occured. Correct targeting was screened for by Southern blot looking for a 23kb Sac1 restriction fragment from the normal gene but an 8kb fragment from the correctly targeted gene. Page 9 Modification of Knockout: Conditional Knockout (also considered a Knockin) In this technique, instead of deleting part of a gene one specifically integrates a region that contains an essential part of the gene that is flanked on either side by a sitespecific recombination site (Cre or Flp). This is usually an essential exon with the recombination sites within intronic sequences. Specifically integrate this region replacing the normal region of the gene and make a mouse that contains this altered gene. The goal is to have a "normal" animals where the gene can be deleted at will from specific locations. The Cre and Flp recombinases mediate highly efficient recombination reactions between specific short DNA sites know as loxP sites (for Cre) or FRT sites (for Flp). The figure on the right shows a targeted allele (TA) with FRT sites as small open rectangles and loxP sites as open triangles. The targeting vector would look like the targeted allele but contain a negative selection marker at one end. The "conditional allele" (CA) has removed the neo resistance gene by treatment with Flp recombinase leaving one FRT site and 2 loxP sites surrounding the essential exon. The deleted allele (TSNA) has been treated with Cre recombinase and has lost the essential 2nd exon leaving only a single loxP site in the gene. Two ways to conditionally "knockout" the gene. 1) Treat organs or tissues with an adenovirus that expresses the appropriate recombination protein. 2) Breed this mouse with a mouse in which the Cre or FLP protein is expressed in a cell or region of interest from a specific transgene (developmental specific knockout). Generally this transgenic mouse also need to carry a disruption in the gene being studied so that when it breeds with the Conditional knockout the offspring will have one KO allele and one conditional KO allele. Versions of Cre recombinase are now available that are conditionally active, only activate with steroid hormone analogs. This allows turning on the recombinase at specific times, while spatial expression of the recombinase is regulated with a specific promoter. The FLP (yeast) recombinase is also being used for conditional deletions. The diagram below shows the Cre recombinase transgene being driven by a liver-specific albumin enhancer/promoter region so that in most cells the gene will remain intact, but in liver cells that express albumin and the albumin promoter-Cre transgene the essential exon is deleted. These conditional knockouts are being used routinely to ask what function a given gene has in a specific celltype or tissue. Page 10 RNAi and microRNAs RNAi: Short dsRNAs oligos homologous to endogenous mRNAs that induce degradation of mRNA and loss of gene expression. Generated by dicer enzymes from exogenous dsRNA. Discovered in C. elegans by attempting to use antisense RNA to inhibit gene expression. MicroRNAs (miRNAs): Short duplex RNAs homologous to endogenous mRNAs that affect message translation or stablilty. Required for stable cell differentiation and epigenetic regulation. Mechanisms of RNAi and miRNAs Tang, TIBS, vol. 30 (2005) siRNA and miRNA: an insight into RISCs Page 11 Tang, TIBS, vol. 30 (2005) siRNA and miRNA: an insight into RISCs Page 12 Definitions to know in Developmental Genomics. Many biochemical and molecular biological assays are performed in homogenous solutions. In contrast, within cells, tissues and organs there is often restriction of diffusion and organization of materials in defined spatial patterns. Many of the terms below are used to describe such patterns and will help you understand papers in developmental biology. Polarity: The finding of differences between different regions of a single cell or a group of cells. For example, polarity can be induced in an oocyte by fertililization. Polarity can be established in embryos by gradients of gene expression in specific groups of cells. Gradients: Distributions of molecules that are higher in one region than another. Gradients can be established by Organizers. Organizers: A cell or group of cells that express diffusible signalling molecules that can form gradients and can induce polarity in a tissue. Such Organizers can also induce changes in nearby cells. Organizers are compnonents of “morphogenic fields”. Partitioning: A change in the distribution of a molecule or cell from being homogenous to being localized to a specific area of a single cell or tissue. For example, specific RNAs and proteins are partitioned into different cells during early cell divisions in mammalian embryos and other RNAs and proteins are partitioned differentially in mother cells or daughter cells during yeast cell division. Cell autonomous vs. inductive phenotypes: A cell-autonomous defect or phenotype is one due to an intrinsic defect within the cell that is affected. For example, in many human thallasemias there is a mutation in a globin gene that causes a failure of globin synthesis in reticulocytes. The failure of globin synthesis in these cases would be cell-autonomous defects in the reticulocyte since the defective genes are expressed only within the reticulocyte. However it is also possible to generate anemias (loss of red blood cells) by the deletion or loss of hormones produced elsewhere such as erythropoeitin. In this case the cells themselves are not defective but the phenotype is caused by failure to induce proper growth and differentiation of reticulocytes. Giving back the hormone would "cure" the defect. Epithelial-mesenchymal inductions: In many organ systems the development of the organ or tissue is dependent upon the different layers of the tissue sending signals to each other that regulate specific differentiation events. In specific cases it has been shown by transplantation studies (also called tissue recombination studies) that the specific underlying mesenchyme of an organ is essential to induce differention events in overlying epithelial cells. Conversely, specific regions of epithelium have also been shown to induce underlying mesenchyme. In many tissues these are referred to as "reciprocal epithelial-mesenchymal interactions or inductions". Reverse genetics and "traditional" genetics: Traditional genetics involves the generation of random mutations and selection or screening for a specific phenotype (the observed property of an organism). Thus one alters the genotype at random and observes a phenotype. In reverse genetics, one selects a specific gene of interest, deletes or modifies it, and then observes the phenotype obtained. Thus in traditional genetics one obtains a number of previously unknown genes involved in a specific phenotype and can put together genetic pathways involved in a phenotype. In reverse Page 13 genetics, one addresses the specific role of a given gene in all developmental processes in an organism. Each technique has it's strengths and weaknesses and each is suitable to ask specific questions about the role of genes in development. Knockouts, knockins and transgenes: It is important to distinguish between these three types of genetic modification in the mouse. Transgenes are randomly integrated genes usually containing a promoter and a coding sequence to be expressed. Sometimes coding sequences lacking elements essential for expression are randomly integrated in order to "trap" elements required for expression of a gene. This is called promoter (or sometimes enhancer or polyA site) trapping. A knockout is a site-specific integration that usually deletes an essential part of a gene of interest. A knockin is jargon for replacement of a specific part of a known gene with a new element, either a new gene or a mutation in the gene of interest. Germ layers of vertebrate embryos: Ectoderm (ectos "outside"), the outermost layer which forms the nervous system and skin; Endoderm (endon "within") the innermost layer that forms the lining of the digestive tract and associated organs; Mesoderm (mesos "middle"), the middle layer gives rise to the skeleton, muscle, heart, vasculature, kidneys and reproductive organs. Many organs are made up of contributions by more than one germ layer. Page 14 Some general cell types: epithelial, endothelial, mesenchymal, blood cells, secretory, others. There are many specific cell types, both circulating and tissue-associated. Epithelial and mesenchymal cells make up much of the solid structure in vertebrates but are specialized in function in different tissues and organs. Epithelial-mesenchymal interactions are important in the formation of many tissues. Morphogenesis and Organogenesis: Frequently groups of cells will undergo morphological rearrangement or restructuring to make things like limbs or organs like the lung, liver, heart, brain, etc. When the final tissue is an organ such transformations are called organogenesis and when they're not organs it's referred to as simply morphogenesis. When organs are formed from preexisting groups of cells or tissue the "preorgan" is frequently referred to as an organ primordium or primordial organs. Anlagen: Of German origin the term anlagen refers to any group of relatively undifferentiated cells that is destined to become a particular group of differentiated cells at a later time in development. It is used to identify distinct cell groups in fly development and also in vertebrate development for example the "optic anlagen" is the group of cells that will become the eye in many vertebrates. The term is related to fatemaps, defined cell lineages, and differentiation. Lineages: In some organisms (C. elegans (referred to hereafter as worms) is a good example) individual cells are destined from their time of creation to become specific regions or cells of the final organism. In worms the entire map of cell divisions from the fertilized ovum to the complete adult animals is known. This map is referred to as the Lineage map. In worm jargon, to observe and record the entire cell division pattern of a worm is called "lineaging" the worm. Such lineage maps are useful to determine where in development a specific mutation affects the organism and generates the final phenotype. In vertebrates the cell lineages are somewhat less defined but there are still regions of the early embryo which become destined to differentiate into specific tissues or organs. Later in development the term lineage in used to define the continuous line of distinct cell types that make up the immune system, the hematopoietic system, the skin and other continuously differentiating cells and tissues. Germ cells vs. somatic cells: Germ cells are those that are used in reproduction such as mature sperm and oocytes but also their progenitors. Taken together these cells are known as the germline of the organism and represent a specific cell lineage. Somatic cells are all other cells not functioning in reproduction such as general epithelial cells, mesenchymal cells and blood cells. Stem cells: Stem cells are cells that are capable of both self-renewal and the generation of other differentiated cell types. The term is derived from the stem of a plant, which gives rise by branching events to the more differentiated parts of the plant (leaves). Stem cells come in a number of forms, the best known being pluripotent embryonal stem cells (ES cells) which can differentiate into many different cell types. It appears that stem cells or "stem-like" cells exist in many tissues as part of normal growth and repair processes. It is important to remember that not all "stem cells" are alike and some appear to have restricted lineages into which they can develop. Some labs are referring to some stem cells as "multipotent progenitor cells" to avoid the recent stigma associated with the name stem cells. Differentiating/Differentiation: Changing from one form to another. New properties are expressed and old properties are extinguished. While the term morphogenesis is usually reserved for gross remodeling of multicellular structures, differentiation of the individual cells frequently coincides with morphogenic events. Both individual cells and groups of cells can be said to differentiate into something else. Page 15 Endocrine, Paracrine and Autocrine effects: Hormones or growth factors can be expressed and have their effects in at least three distinct manners. Endocrine secretion of hormones is secretion into the blood stream so that effects can be had at distal locations. Paracrine effects are one cell secreting a hormone or growth factor locally so that neighboring cells are affected. Autocrine effects are where a cell secretes a substance that then binds back to the same cell, a type of autostimulation. A fourth "crine" effect is Exocrine where a substance is secreted outside of the body of the organism either through the skin or into the intestinal tract. Programmed cell death: The first genetic evidence for programmed cell death (apotosis) was found in the nematode C. elegans with the ced (C. elegans death) mutations. These mutations decreased the normal cell death that occurs during C. elegans development. C. elegans adult hemaphrodites contain 959 somatic cells (together with hundreds of germ cells) and during development to the adult stage 131 cells die and are degraded. Thus almost 1/8 of all cells that are made during development are deliberately lost. Many of the genes defined in the ced pathway have been shown to function during apotosis in mammalian cells. Tissue recombination or transplant studies: To demonstrate inductive interactions between epithelial and mesenchymal tissues or between any groups of cells tissue recombination (aka transplant) studies have been performed. Such studies involve either grafting of one piece of tissue to another in vivo or the placement of two tissues abutting each other in vitro. Recently beads soaked in specific growth factors/hormones have been useful to study the inductive signals generated by tissues. Parts of an an embryo: One of the most frustrating things about learning developmental genomics is the huge number of defined parts of embryos that are generated and lost during development. All of the instructors will try to minimize the number of terms that you need to learn, but the fact is that to understand what is going on you need to understand the players involved and that requires remembering a large number of specific embryo parts and a large number of genes. For your own research the number of parts you will need to learn will likely be fewer because you'll be studying a specific subset of developmental processes. A very abbreviated list is below. Germ layers: see above. Neural fold: a region of early vertebrate embryos that is formed from the neural plate and eventually folds together and fuses to become the neural tube, which eventually forms the brain and spinal cord. Page 16 MHP= medial neural hinge point DLHP= dorsolateral hinge point Page 17 Neural crest cells: These are found only in vertebrates and arise from the tops of the neural folds and then migrate to and seed various regions of the embryo to form large numbers of tissues including cartilage elements of the head, portions of the teeth, pigment cells of the epidermis, several types of neurons, hormone-producing gland cells and smooth muscle cells. They are very versatile! Pharyngeal arches: These are groups of cells that form on the developing "neck" region of vertebrate embryos and are formed from the pharyngeal pouches that bulge from the pharyngeal endoderm and generate pharyngeal clefts. Each arch (I-VI) forms distinct regions of the jaw, ear, larynx and trachea of the term embryo. Neural crest cells migrate into the pharyngeal arches. Below are pharyngeal arches (branchial arches and gill arches) in Salamander. Ectoderm has been removed. Rhombomers: These groups of cells are formed within the neural tube from the segmentation of the hindbrain (Rhombencephalon). Each rhombomere goes on to become a nerve ganglion. Neural crest cells migrate into the rhombomers. Ectodermal Placodes: Regions of tissue that form in the Ectodermal layer of the head region and form the inner ear (Otic Placode), the lens (Lens Placode), the olfactory epithelium (Nasal Placode) and the sensory ganglia of cranial nerves. Somites: These are groups of cells that form just outside of and along the neural tube (from paraxial mesoderm) and go on to generate the cells of connective tissue and muscle. The somites are Page 18 numbered 1-28 in the chicken from head to tail and each somite forms distinct regions of the term embryo. The mouse has ~60 somites. Positions within an embryo: Sometimes it's hard to know what all the various terms are that describe the 3 dimensional position within an embryo. Here are a few examples: Dorsal: the back of an embryo, sometimes easier to think of as the top of an embryo thats lying on it's "stomach". Think dorsal fin of a fish. Ventral: the "front" of an embryo, where the stomach would be if it had one yet. Anterior (top, cranial, rostral): the "tip of the nose", in front of. Posterior (caudal): the "end of the tail", think posterior, behind. Proximal: the region closest in to the body (referring to limbs) or site or origin. Distal: the region farthest out from the body (referring to limbs) or site of origin. Sectioning of embryos: Some of these mean different things whether you're talking about a whole embryo or just a portion of the embyo (like the brain). Sigittal or parasagittal: sections parallel to the long anterior-posterior axis of an embryo from top to bottom (dorsal to ventral) dividing the left and right halves of the embryo. I think of these as "longways" sections. Transverse or cross section: any sections cut perpendicular to the anterior-posterior axis. Coronal: sections perpendicular to the dorsal-ventral axis. In brain anatomy, coronal sections go from the front to the back of the brain. Also known as frontal sections. Page 19