MYP Unit Planner Unit Title Our Relationship with Life’s Blueprint (DNA); from Modern Scientific Marvels to Mutant Monsters. Teacher(s) David Egan Subject/grade level 8th Grade Science (Biology) Time frame/duration 8 weeks Stage 1: Integrate significant concept, area of interaction and unit question. Area of interaction focus Significant concept(s) Which area of interaction will be our focus? Why have we chosen this? What are the big ideas? What do we want our students to retain for years into the future? AOI/Global Context: Scientific & Technical Innovation--Biotechnology & Ethics what is our Responsibility? Big Ideas- The importance of ethical reasoning and decision making when (applying the science of genetics) making difficult choices. We have chosen this AOI/GT because of Biotech’s growing impact on humanity. While the understanding of DNA and Genetics continues to unravel many mysteries regarding human health and behavior. It also opens the proverbial Pandora’s box to many ethical debates regarding its application. DNA is the fundamental Structure of all living things. ATL- Information Literacy There are a variety of perspectives regarding the relationship between scientific knowledge and understanding and its application. Key Concepts: Form, Structure Relationships & Perspectives Concept StatementsThe form and function of living things is related to the structure of its DNA’s. Retained into the Future- When debating the use and application of genetics, there are multiple points of view. I can make a sound ethical decision regarding my position on a range of bioethical issues. MYP Unit Question* Formerly the Guiding Question Teacher Speak Unit Question: What are the ethical implications regarding the use and application of scientific knowledge and understanding of DNA and Genetics? Turn it into a Student Speak Unit Question: How should we use Life’s Blueprint (DNA)? Statements of Inquiry: Students will discuss, evaluate and debate ethical perspectives regarding a range of biotech issues. Students will discuss, evaluate and debate the relationship between scientific understanding/capabilities and their use and application. Students will recognize the relationship between DNA’s structure and how it’s related to the form and function of all living things. Inquiry Questions: What is Life’s Blueprint DNA? What is bioethics and what is biotech? What are the positive and negative aspects of various biotechnologies? How has biotech changed our world and what is the future of biotech? How should we regulate biotech and who should regulate it? Assessment What task(s) will allow students the opportunity to respond to the unit question? What will constitute acceptable evidence of understanding? How will students show what they have understood? A piece of writing by the student of approximately 900–1,200 words in length. Criteria A and B must be used to assess this task. An end-of-unit or end-of-term test or examination. Criterion C must be one of the criteria used to assess this task. --What exemplars will students see so that they understand what is required? Each Assessment will be accompanied by a task specific rubric which students receive prior to the assessment. The rubric will be explained in detail and examples relevant to each level descriptor will be given. The One World essay will come with a detailed project outline including examples of student expectations. --What will allow students the opportunity to answer the unit question at some point during the unit? Student understanding of the underlying concepts and principles of genetics is built through labs, activities, problems, discussions and readings. This learning experience cumulates with a concept based test. Next students are introduced to ethical reasoning and decision making. This process will unfold as students discuss and debate the use and application of genetics and its ethical implications. Learning experiences include: inquiry into various bioethical issues via case studies, debates, film, current events and research. Learning cumulates in the answering of the unit question through researching and writing a One World argumentative essay on an bioethical issue of their choice --How will the assessment task be differentiated? Student understanding of the unit question will be assessed using two formats one is and argumentative essay while the other is a test of student’s conceptual understanding. Test- The concept based test will employ a variety and range of questions to assess student’s knowledge and understanding. These range from simple problems involving recall and application to complex problems involving evaluation and analysis. There will also be integration of math concepts (probabilities) in many of the problems. One World Essay- There will be flexibility and choice in terms of topic selection and word limit. Which specific MYP objectives will be addressed during this unit? Directly from MYP Subject Guide. Objective A- This objective refers to enabling students to gain a better understanding of the role of science in society. Students should be aware that science is a global endeavor and that its development and applications can have consequences for our lives. One world should provide students with the opportunity to critically assess the implications of scientific developments and their applications to local and/or global issues. • explain the ways in which science is applied and used to address specific problems or issues • discuss the effectiveness of science and its application in solving problems or issues • describe how science and its application interact with some of the following factors: moral, ethical, social, economic, political, cultural and environmental. Objective B- This objective refers to enabling students to become competent and confident when communicating information in science. Students should be able to use scientific language correctly and a variety of communication modes and formats as appropriate. Students should be aware of the importance of acknowledging and appropriately referencing the work of others when communicating in science. • use scientific language correctly • use appropriate communication modes, such as verbal (oral, written), visual (graphic, symbolic) and communication formats (laboratory reports, essays, presentations) to effectively communicate theories, ideas and findings in science • acknowledge the work of others and the sources of information used by documenting them using a recognized referencing system. Objective C- This objective refers to enabling students to understand scientific knowledge (facts, ideas, concepts, processes, laws, principles, models and theories) and to apply it to construct scientific explanations, solve problems and formulate scientifically supported arguments. • recall scientific knowledge and use scientific understanding to construct scientific explanations • apply scientific knowledge and understanding to solve problems set in familiar and unfamiliar situations • analyze and evaluate information critically to make judgments supported by scientific understanding Which MYP assessment criteria will be used? Directly from MYP Subject Guide. Criterion A: One world Maximum: 6 One world enables students to gain a better understanding of the role of science in society and allows them to explore how scientific developments and applications are applied and used to address specific problems or issues in local and global contexts. Students should be able to: • explain the ways in which science is applied and used to address a specific problem or issue • discuss the effectiveness of science and its application in solving the problem or issue • discuss and evaluate the moral, ethical, social, economic, political, cultural and environmental implications of the use of science and its application in solving specific problems or issues. Assessment tasks should give students the opportunity to explore how science is used to address a specific problem or issue. Students are required to critically discuss and evaluate the implications associated with the use and application of science by considering moral, ethical, social, economic, political, cultural and environmental factors. Suitable assessment tasks for criterion A include: written pieces of work, essays, case studies and research projects, as well as debates, oral and multimedia presentations. Criterion B: Communication in science Maximum: 6 Communication in science enables students to develop the communication skills to become competent and confident when communicating information in science. Students should be able to use different communication modes, including verbal (oral, written) and visual (graphic, symbolic), as well as appropriate communication formats (laboratory reports, essays, and multimedia presentations) to effectively communicate scientific ideas, theories, findings and arguments in science. Students should be able to: • use scientific language correctly • use appropriate communication modes and formats • acknowledge the work of others and the sources of information used by appropriately documenting them using a recognized referencing system. Suitable assessment tasks for criterion B include: scientific investigation reports, research essays, case studies, written responses, debates and multimedia presentations among others. Criterion C: Knowledge and understanding of science Maximum: 6 Knowledge and understanding of science enables students to demonstrate their understanding of science by applying scientific knowledge to construct scientific explanations, solve problems and formulate scientifically supported arguments. Students should be able to: • recall scientific knowledge and use scientific understanding to construct scientific explanations • apply scientific knowledge and understanding to solve problems set in familiar and unfamiliar situations • critically analyze and evaluate information to make judgments supported by scientific understanding. Suitable assessment tasks for criterion C include: tests, examinations, case studies, written responses and other assignments that combine a range of problems of different complexity, and opportunities for students to makes scientifically supported judgments. Stage 2: Backward planning: from the assessment to the learning activities through inquiry Content What knowledge and/or skills (from the course overview) are going to be used to enable the student to respond to the unit question? What (if any) state, provincial, district, or local standards/skills are to be addressed? How can they be unpacked to develop the significant concept(s) for stage 1? What are the state GLCE’s or HSCE’s? -HSCE’s STANDARD B1: Inquiry, Reflection, and Social Implications B1.1- Scientific Inquiry B1.2- Scientific Reflection and Social Implications STANDARD B4: Genetics L4.p1 Reproduction (prerequisite) L4.p2 Heredity and Environment (prerequisite) B4.1 Genetics and Inherited Traits B4.2 DNA B4.2x DNA, RNA, and Protein Synthesis B4.3 Cell Division – Mitosis and Meiosis B4.4x Genetic Variation B4.r5x Recombinant DNA (recommended) STANDARD B2: Will be part of a review as students prepare for the genetics unit. NGSS (Next Generation Science Standards) HS-LS3: Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits HS-LS1: From Molecules to Organisms: Structures and Processes (Includes Review Materials) Common Core Standards: ELA/LiteracyRST.11-12.1: Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of science and technical texts, attending to important distinctions the author makes and to any gaps or inconsistencies in the account. (HS-LS3-1),(HS-LS3-2) RST.11-12.9: Synthesize information from a range of sources (e.g., texts, experiments, simulations) into a coherent understanding of a process, phenomenon, or concept, resolving conflicting information when possible. (HS-LS3-1) WHST.9-12.1: Write arguments focused on discipline-specific content. (HS-LS3-2) Mathematics – MP.2: Reason abstractly and quantitatively. (HS-LS3-2),(HS-LS3-3) What skills and or concepts are embedded in those standards? ATL’s- see below Learner Profile Trait- Inquirer This LP trait has been selected for explicit focus in this unit because through the inquiry cycle students will select a specific issue that they feel passionate about, inquire into it through research and respond to the issue by supporting their position and refuting the opposing side. By taking a position and arguing against the opposing side the students are taking the first step toward action on an individual level. Skills- Analyzing, Classifying, Communicating, Defining, Evaluating, Inferring, Inquiring, Interpreting Data, Modelling, Recognizing Patterns, Reading, Synthesizing and Using Numbers Command TermsDescribe: to give a detailed account. Discuss: to give an account including, where possible, a range of arguments for and against the relative importance of various factors and comparisons of alternative hypotheses. Evaluate: to assess the implications and limitations. Explain: to give a clear account, including causes and reasons or mechanisms. State: to give a specific name, value or other brief answer without explanation or calculation. Document: to credit fully all sources of information used by referencing (or citing), following one recognized referencing system. References should be included in the text and also at the end of the piece of work in a reference list or bibliography. Analyze: to identify parts and relationships and to interpret information to reach a conclusion. Complex problems: refers to problems that are set in a familiar or unfamiliar context and require analysis. These problems can often be broken down into sub-problems or stages, each of which requires the selection and application of the appropriate principle, rule, equation or method. Simple problems: refers to straightforward problems that are clearly stated and set in a familiar context, and require the student to apply the appropriate principle, rule, equation or method. Personal, Social and Global Awareness (Attitudes and Beliefs)- Controversial Science Issues Key Concepts- Change (Constancy and Change in Life Forms); Structures, Patterns and Systems (Living Systems); Relationships, Perspectives What is it that I must teach? Related ConceptsMany of the related concepts or specific content expectations I will teach as part of the genetics unit will be adapted from the HHMI & MIT Hierarchical Biological Concept Framework. Main areas of focus include: cell division, replication, transcription and translation, classic Mendelian genetics, genetic disorders and genetic engineering. These concepts can be found at: http://web.mit.edu/bioedgroup/HBCF/CBE-Summer2004.htm Note: Many of the concepts will also be covered as a review of cell biology in order to prepare students for the genetics unit. Approaches to learning How will this unit contribute to the overall development of subject-specific and general approaches to learning skills? What Approaches to Learning are embedded in the subject-specific MYP Criteria that you are using to assess your MYP task? These ATL’s are embedded in my tasks which will assess Criteria’s A, B & C. These skills will have an implicit focus. Communication (Literacy), Thinking (Critical Thinking and Transfer) and Research (Information and media literacy, critical literacy) What general Approaches to Learning will I embed in my unit? These general ATL’s will be focused on explicitly in my unit. One of these, Research and its associated skill clusters is also implicitly contained in my assessment task. This ATL skill has a general focus because it is easily transferable across the disciplines throughout the MYP programme. Additionally, Research skills support school wide expectations in relation to use of technology and referencing. Also the Social skill of Collaboration promotes good affect within our students. It also supports a host of LP attributes such as being open-minded and exceptional communicators. Research- (Information and Media Literacy, Critical Literacy) accessing information—including researching from a variety of sources using a range of technologies, identifying primary and secondary sources selecting and organizing information— including identifying points of view, bias and weaknesses, using primary and secondary sources, making connections between a variety of resources referencing—including the use of citing, footnotes and referencing of sources, respecting the concept of intellectual property rights Social- (Collaboration) accepting others—including analyzing others’ ideas, respecting others’ points of view, using ideas critically Learning experiences Teaching strategies How will students know what is expected of them? Will they see examples, rubrics, templates? How will we use formative assessment to give students feedback during the unit? How will students acquire the knowledge and practise the skills required? How will they practise applying these? Do the students have enough prior knowledge? How will we know? Pre Assessment Prior Knowledge- Students prior knowledge will be activated via a review and test on cells and traits. Both of these topics have been previously covered and required the student to have a simple general understanding of DNA and Heredity. It is from this point that we will begin to build and expand student knowledge and understanding in detail. We will also have an open class discussion around an ethical dilemma in order to activate student’s prior informal understanding of ethics. We will then begin building a formal understanding from this point. Cell division, DNA & Genetics will be learned throughDirect instruction and lecture The use of visual aids Readings Online Activities and Labs Labs Collaborative Group Work Vocabulary Definition Mind Maps What different teaching methodologies will we employ? How are we differentiating teaching and learning for all? How have we made provision for those learning in a language other than their mother tongue? How have we considered those with special educational needs? Formative Assessment Cell division, DNA & Genetics will be assessed throughStudent will draw the stages of cell division (mitosis); drawings will be labelled and explained. Students will print and submit results of online activities and labs. Students will take notes on all videos and lectures. Students will be assigned section review and chapter review questions on readings. Students will be given practice questions (genetic crosses) as HW and CW all questions will be discussed as a class. Bioethics will be learned throughLecture Reading Class Discussion Assessment and Pre Assessment will be differentiated using a variety of Learning Styles/Intelligences such as: - Kinesthetic (Hands On Activities/Labs) - Visual (Drawing, Visual Aids, Animation) - Interpersonal (Group Work) - Intrapersonal (Readings and HW) - Linguistic/Audio (Books and Lecture) - Logical/Mathematical (Genetic Crosses & Word Problems) There is a heavy focus on math concepts in this unit. Answering higher level questions aimed at assessing conceptual understanding and its application (Critical Thinking & Metacognition) Students will answer questions(genetic crosses) on the smart board and explain their answers to the class. Activities will employ different types of technology (ppt., smart board, audio, visual and internet). Students will extract Identify students that are struggling and use mixed Informal Debate Open-ended Questions Differentiation Audio/Video Analysis: Current Events, Gattaca, Intellengence2 Debate Note Taking DNA from a plant and report on their procedure and results Research Students will construct Reebops and reflect on their results (Meiosis & Expression of Alleles) Expectations: Anecdotal Notes Some activities will be modelled. Class Discussion (Q & A) these are based on topics/concepts, and inquiry activities. Case Studies Collaborative Group Work Formative Assessments Students will be given clear instructions and examples (checklists, rubrics, templates, handouts) which will be discussed in class. Summative Assessments Will be accompanied by a task specific rubric which students receive prior to the assessment. The rubric will be explained in detail and examples relevant to each level descriptor will be given. The One World essay will come with a detailed project outline including examples of student expectations. Marazano’s Vocabulary Definitions Mind Map of DNA Construct DNA out of found objects Bioethics will be assessed throughIntroduction to Ethics Activities Anecdotal Notes Check Points/Deadlines for Project---Spot checking by asking students what they are working on. Peer evaluations. Class Discussion (Q & A) these are based on topics/concepts, and inquiry activities. Brain Storm for One World Essay & Bio Ethics Topics Research for One World Essay Rough Draft- One World Essay Gattaca Analysis Case Study Analysis Notes on all videos Intelligence2 Class Poll Informal Debate **End of Unit Reflection ability grouping for group work. Engage and include students who tend to be on the outside of the social group. Students have degree of choice and freedom to choose their One World Essays focus issue. The concept based test will employ a variety and range of questions to assess student’s knowledge and understanding. Identifying and correcting student misconceptions about core concepts. -The assessment tasks will be differentiated as follows: The unit question will be assessed using two formats an argumentative essay and a conceptual test. Test- The concept based test will employ a variety and range of questions to assess student’s knowledge and understanding. These range from simple problems involving recall and application to complex problems involving evaluation and analysis. There will also be integration of math concepts (probabilities) in many of the problems. One World EssayThere will be flexibility and choice in terms of topic selection and word limit. Special NeedsStudents with special needs will be accommodated on an individual basisAccommodations may include: use of technology, tutoring, on Unit Question, ATL’s & LP change in format, amount and difficulty of work, position in class, conferencing with parents and school social worker ETC..,. Language NeedsIf a student has a language need then I will work with either a language B instructor if Arabic or a Native Speaker of the students language to accommodate that student. Resources What resources are available to us? How will our classroom environment, local environment and/or the community be used to facilitate students’ experiences during the unit? Textbook: Glencoe Science Level Green & Blue Handouts & Problems: Mendelian Genetic Crosses http://media.hhmi.org/biointeractive/posters/Genetic-Mutations-and-Disease_web.jpg http://www.dnaftb.org/41/bio.html http://web.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/posters/chromosome/index.shtml#chooser Lab: DNA Extraction Lab Materials Simulated PKU Testing Lab & Materials http://cbe.wisc.edu/assets/docs/pdf/reebops/reebops.pdf http://btc.montana.edu/ceres/html/Designer/Designer.htm Online labs and Activities: https://www.koshland-science-museum.org/explore-the-science/exhibits#.Uf8HA20VuKI http://learn.genetics.utah.edu/ http://www.hhmi.org/biointeractive/bacterial-identification-virtual-lab http://www.dnai.org/index.htm http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/lsps07.sci.life.stru.celltrans/ Resources for Teaching Ethics: http://www.biotech.iastate.edu/publications/mendel/ModuleIII.pdf http://www.pbs.org/newshour/extra/teachers/lessonplans/science/chimera_ethics.html http://science.education.nih.gov/supplements/nih9/bioethics/guide/pdf/Teachers_Guide.pdf http://www.kumc.edu/gec/lessonpl.html http://www.dnalc.org/ http://genetics-education-partnership.mbt.washington.edu/cool/tools/ethics.html http://www.genome.gov/10001744 Videos: DNA & Cell Division Animations http://intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/past-debates/item/798-prohibit-genetically-engineeredbabies http://www.hhmi.org/biointeractive/bioethics-discussion Gattaca Supreme Court Decisions on Genetics Issues http://www.dnaftb.org/ http://www.dnafiles.org/keywords/Ethics http://www.dnaftb.org/41/animation.html Audio: NPR 1,000$ Genome http://www.npr.org/templates/archives/archive.php?thingId=161373082 http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2013/10/09/229167219/proposed-treatment-to-fix-geneticdiseases-raising-ethics-issues Possible Community Members as Guest Speakers (Bio-Patent Law) Ongoing reflections and evaluation In keeping an ongoing record, consider the following questions. There are further stimulus questions at the end of the “Planning for teaching and learning” section of MYP: From principles into practice. Students and teachers What did we find compelling? Were our disciplinary knowledge/skills challenged in any way? What inquiries arose during the learning? What, if any, extension activities arose? How did we reflect—both on the unit and on our own learning? Which attributes of the learner profile were encouraged through this unit? What opportunities were there for student-initiated action? Possible connections How successful was the collaboration with other teachers within my subject group and from other subject groups? What interdisciplinary understandings were or could be forged through collaboration with other subjects? Assessment Were students able to demonstrate their learning? How did the assessment tasks allow students to demonstrate the learning objectives identified for this unit? How did I make sure students were invited to achieve at all levels of the criteria descriptors? Are we prepared for the next stage? Data collection How did we decide on the data to collect? Was it useful? Students will reflect on their experience of the unit by using select Learner Profile traits. Their goal is to write a short reflection discussing how the following LP traits are essential to the process of ethical decision making. Thinkers They exercise initiative in applying thinking skills critically and creatively to recognize and approach complex problems, and make reasoned, ethical decisions. Principled They act with integrity and honesty, with a strong sense of fairness, justice and respect for the dignity of the individual, groups and communities. They take responsibility for their own actions and the consequences that accompany them. Open-minded They understand and appreciate their own cultures and personal histories, and are open to the perspectives, values and traditions of other individuals and communities. They are accustomed to seeking and evaluating a range of points of view, and are willing to grow from the experience. Caring They show empathy, compassion and respect towards the needs and feelings of others. They have a personal commitment to service, and act to make a positive difference to the lives of others and to the environment.