STALLINGS SNAPSHOT OBSERVATION MANUAL JANUARY 2007 MODIFIED FOR USE IN THE WORLD BANK PROJECTS TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF EDUCATION CENTER FOR COLLABORATIVE LEARNING COMMUNITIES COLLEGE STATION TEXAS COPYRIGHT 2001 PERMISSION GRANTED FOR MODIFICATIONS Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual TABLE OF CONTENTS OVERVIEW AND INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................................... 3 CLASSROOM SNAPSHOT OBSERVATION CODING MANUAL .................................................................................. 4 DESCRIPTION ......................................................................................................................................................................... 4 PROCEDURES FOR COMPLETING THE DEMOGRAPHIC PAGE .............................................................................. 4 PROCEDURES FOR TIMING THE 10 SNAPSHOTS ......................................................................................................... 4 PROCEDURES FOR COMPLETING THE SNAPSHOT .................................................................................................... 5 STEPS TO RECORD THE SNAPSHOT PICTURE ............................................................................................................. 6 CODING OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS AND PROCEDURES ..................................................................................... 7 OTHER CODING RULES ..................................................................................................................................................... 14 CALCULATIONS ................................................................................................................................................................... 15 REVIEW YOUR CODING FOR ACCURACY ................................................................................................................... 17 APPENDIX 1: CLASSROOM INFORMATION SHEET/SNAPSHOT COVER SHEET .............................................. 18 APPENDIX 2: CLASSROOM OBSERVATION SNAPSHOTS (1-10) ............................................................................. 19 2 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual OVERVIEW AND INTRODUCTION The Stallings’ Observation System was developed in the 1970’s to evaluate how elementary teachers and students used their time in classrooms. Early findings found that, most students in the United State attended school six hours a day, but on the average, they spent less than an hour engaged in academic activities. This was a shocking finding. In many studies, student engaged rates have been positively related to student achievement. When engaged rates are low, student achievement is low. Using the Stallings Snapshot Observation, we learned that in classrooms where students were achieving academically, the teachers provided 50% or more active instruction activities and spent 35% or less of the time actively monitoring students as they did their seat work. Further, effective teachers were very efficient in managing the organization details, spending 15% or less of the class time (i.e. taking the roll, passing papers, grading papers, making assignments). Little classroom time was wasted and students spent significantly more time on academic tasks. During the 1980s and 90s the Stallings Observation System was modified for use in middle schools, high schools, and continuation schools. Data collected from the Snapshot has been used as a teacher training program to make teachers aware of how they use classroom time. By giving teachers specific, factual information about the activities they offer their students, the materials used, the groups of students with whom they work, and when their students are Off Task, teachers have significantly modified how they used their time. In 2002 Helen Abadzi, representing the World Bank, requested Dr. Stallings to provide training on the Snapshot in a variety of countries. To answer educational questions raised by the World Bank, and simplify the system so that it can be used in a wide variety of countries, some modifications have been made, while retaining the integrity of the instrument. 3 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual CLASSROOM SNAPSHOT OBSERVATION CODING MANUAL DESCRIPTION The Classroom Snapshot records the environment and the participants in the classroom as if they were being photographed at one instant. It records every person in the classroom in the activity in which they are engaged and shows with whom they are engaged. The distribution of adults and students among the activities that are occurring simultaneously are recorded as the observer places first the teacher on the grid and then going clockwise around the room places all of the students on the grid. Essentially, the Snapshot provides data to assess the teacher activities, the student activities, the materials being used, and grouping patterns. The snapshot can be implemented by computer, resulting in a database that can be used for immediate statistical analysis, by Scantron, or paper and pencil for later entry into a database. The directions that follow are for the pencil and paper-based version of the instrument. PROCEDURES FOR COMPLETING THE DEMOGRAPHIC PAGE On the first page of the Snapshot, the observer records the demographic data i.e. the school, the teacher’s name and identification number, the observer’s name and number, the number of adults in the classroom, the number of students in the classroom, the subject being observed, the period or time of the class observed, grade level (including combination of grades in the room). The observer also records the percentage of students who have textbooks and the language or languages used in instruction in the class. The observer should obtain some of this information from the teacher before or after the observation. (See the Snapshot Cover Page in Appendix 1) PROCEDURES FOR TIMING THE 10 SNAPSHOTS Prior to starting the observation, ask the teacher how long the period will last. If it is 50 minutes, the observer will record one Snapshot every five minutes. If the period is 30 minutes in duration, the observer records a snapshot every three minutes. The point is to distribute the ten Snapshots evenly over the entire class period. To record the data for the snapshot, the observer sits at the back of the classroom or from a point where he/she can have a good view of the entire class. Allow three minutes to pass after the bell rings and take the first Snapshot. 4 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual PROCEDURES FOR COMPLETING THE SNAPSHOT Look at the Snapshot grid in Appendix 2. Across the top of the grid are 7 materials that may be used in the activities. These seven form the columns. Along the left side there is a list of 15 activities that may occur in the classroom. (The “Other” activity is reserved for some special activity. It is not often used). The 15 activities form the rows of the grid. Within each Activity row are the letters T = Teacher I = Students working independently, without a teacher The 1, S, L, and E bubbles located on the T line and on the I line indicate the number of students who are in the group that is being recorded. S, L and E vary on the basis of class size. The following table (Table 1) can be used for reference to decide the category. (Table 1: N denotes the class size or the total number of students present in the class. S, L and E refer to small group, large group and everyone (or whole group) respectively and the number of students in these groups can be calculated using Table 1. “<=” refers to less than or equal to) Table 1: Calculation of Group Sizes Class strength N<=15 16<=N<=30 31<=N<=45 N=46+ or Group size I: Individual 1 student 1 student 1 student 1 student S: Small Group 2 to 5 students 2 to 10 students 2 to 15 students 2 to 20 students L: Large Group 6 to 14 11 to 29 students 16 to 44 students 21 to (N-1) students N=30 N=45 N = 46+ students E : Whole N=15 Group 5 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual STEPS TO RECORD THE SNAPSHOT PICTURE The following steps should be implemented using the classroom snapshot during classroom observations (See Appendix 2 for the Snapshot) The observer scans the classroom going clockwise around the room. First determine where the Teacher is. In what activity is she/he involved. Find the activity row. What material is being used? Find the material column. (The activities and materials are operationally defined later in the manual). Is the teacher working with 1 child? A small group? A large group? Or everyone? Fill in the ONE bubble on the T line that indicates the Activity, Materials, and the student group with whom the teacher is involved. Now scan the room going clockwise and place all of the students on the grid. There may be several small groups of students involved in several different activities. Continue until all students and the teacher have been recorded. If you mark E, this includes the teacher and all the students. If you mark E do not mark any other code. (E= everyone) A Golden Rule 1: The Teacher must be placed only one time on each of the ten Snapshots. Golden Rule 2: If you mark E do not make any other mark on that Snapshot. E is only marked on the T line. Golden Rule 3: Never mark “1” in the co-operative column 6 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual CODING OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS AND PROCEDURES Classroom Snapshot Activities CODE ITEM OPERATIONAL DEFINITION CODING PROCEDURE & EXAMPLES ACTIVE INSTRUCTION (ACTIVITIES 1-5) 1. Reading Aloud Reading Aloud or Oral Reading. Although one person reads at a time, Teacher or Students are reading all students are coded as engaged in aloud. the oral reading activity with the One or more students are reading teacher. connected text from a textbook, This activity is usually coded on the trade book, periodical, their own T line. It can be coded on the I line writing, or reproduced material. using the 1, S, L, if the teacher is not When reading aloud, generally present and the children are reading students aloud to each other. take turns reading sections from the material. The Reading in unison is also coded as teacher or student may also read reading aloud. aloud while the rest of the class follows along in their own texts. 2. Instruction/ The teacher, television or some Code this activity if a teacher models Demonstration/Lecture form of media is informing a a procedure or shows students how to student or groups of students do about a subject i.e. reading, experiment, math problem, use of mathematics, science, history. materials) something (example: science To provide the instruction, the teacher may use books, manipulatives, audio paper visual pencil, tools, chalkboard, or no materials Code this category if the teacher is showing one student how to do a math problem or sound out a word 7 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual Code this category if the student(s) are learning a new song If the teacher is not present in the class a student is conducting the class or playing the role of the teacher, mark the student on the I line. 3. Discussion Students and teacher interact in This code may be used with no an academic discussion i.e. a materials verbal exchange of ideas or discussing in small groups or large opinions. This may be, slow groups, without books or any other paced questions and answers material. regarding material, cooperative group column to show that science, mathematics, political a cooperative group is discussing an science or any problem where assignment. reading and when students are It may be coded in the there is not one right answer. This could also be a check by the teacher or student for comprehension and understanding of material 4. Practice/ Drill The object here is to memorize If the teacher is leading drill and material such as multiplication practice, code on the T line. Code on tables or spelling words. the I line if two or more students are The teacher and students or several practicing groups of students interact in oral words, the alphabet, or any rote questions and answer session learning activity. where there is one right answer. may be manipulatives, the chalk board, The teacher asks the students or paper/pencil. repetitive questions in order for If students are singing a song they the students to memorize the correct answer addition spellings The materials used know already or have been taught already, code here 8 facts, Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual 5. Projects/Kinesthetic These activities are usually coded Art and craft activities e.g. Projects on the I line, since for the most include - Constructing a bird house, part, the students, individually or painting a mural, making puppets, in groups are involved in any making a pottery bowl, or creating a activity which requires them to book. use information to create a project Doing i.e. hands on activities that result agriculture projects is coded here in a product and can extend over The Projects category may often be one or more class sessions. science experiments or, coded with Cooperative Groups when Code here kinesthetic activities two or more people are involved in a which require body movement as joint project. in dance, marching to music or any physical activities (Make a note in the log describing the kinesthetic activity) PASSIVE INSTRUCTION (ACTIVITIES 6-7) 6. Silent Seatwork One or more students are writing Code Written Assignments if students papers, doing computation, or are are completing assignments. They will involved in any other silent most likely be using paper/pencils in written work at their seats. the materials column. If a student is Reading silently is also coded as writing and reading, use the Written seatwork. Assignment activity. If the teacher is not actively monitoring the seatwork, Code students on the I line. If the teacher is walking around the room actively monitoring the children as they do their seatwork, code this activity on the T line using 1, S, L, or E. E will imply that all students are working on their assignment as the 9 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual teacher monitors. If students are reading a comic book when they should be doing a mathematics assignment, code them as off task, uninvolved. Written test taking is coded here. Please note in the Log when test-taking occurs. 7. Copying Students are copying work or When the teacher is copying on the exercises from the blackboard. blackboard (not interacting with The primary purpose of the students) and the students are copying at activity is to transfer the text on their seats, code the teacher in the the board verbatim to the Teacher Management Alone (activity students’ paper or copybooks. 15) and code students on the I line (1,S, If students are interacting with the or L) with notebook or slate. material to learn or practice When the teacher is monitoring while concepts or procedures or to the students are copying, code the apply knowledge (work math teacher and students on the T line with problems, conjugate verbs), then S, L or E. code as Written Assignments on the activity line. ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT ITEM : 8, 13, AND 15 8. Verbal Instructions The teacher is verbally making Code the discussion of grades and assignments clarification of behavior expectations for the work expected during the day or for on the Assignment activity line. homework. He/she is explaining This activity does not focus on the the procedures to be followed, the amount of work to be finished, or rewards for completing 10 the academic content, but on the information that students need to carry out the assignment. Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual assignment. 9. Other A special code. Use only when directed OFF TASK ACTIVITIES (ACTIVITIES 10-12) Student Off Task: 10,11,12 Teacher Off Task: 10, 14, 16 10. Social Interaction Two or more students are talking Code here if students are passing or laughing about activities or notes, or having negative interactions subjects other than what the that disrupt the class. This could include teacher expects for the class to be physical interaction between students. engaged. They could be passing notes, or having negative interactions that disrupt the class. If the teacher has a social interaction with students mark this on the T line. If a teacher interacts socially with visitors to the classroom code on Teacher Social Interaction line (14). 11. Student Uninvolved This category is recorded when If the teacher has not specified an one or more students are not instructional activity and all of the involved children are waiting, then record an L in instructional activities, for example, if a on the I line student is staring out the window, Code students who are arriving or resting the head on the desk, or departing as uninvolved. sleeping. Code students who are waiting for the teacher in order to begin an assignment or take an exam as uninvolved. 12. Being Disciplined 13. Classroom Management One or more students are being This reprimanded for their behavior or punishment. are being sent out of the room for punishment occurs please record the disciplinary reasons. incident in the snapshot log. Teachers and students 11 are may include corporal When corporal Mark No Materials. Even though Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual involved in classroom materials are being handled, they are management: passing out papers, not being used. changing activities, putting away If students are performing classroom materials, preparing to leave. management activities without the teacher involved, code this under the I line in Classroom Management 14. Teacher Social The teacher and an adult (parents/ Code T to indicate that the teacher is Interaction/Teacher visitor / community members – not working with the students. Uninvolved any one other than the students) are interacting about subjects other than class-related activities. Teacher is in the classroom but not involved in any academic activity 15. Teacher Management The teacher is alone (without Teacher correcting papers at his/her students) duties desk, copying material onto the board, related to the classroom but not setting up materials, or arranging books directly related to students who on a shelf. may be doing seatwork. This also Code T for the teacher on the right performing included the teacher talking to the principal, administrator or supervisor. hand side of the form to indicate they are not working with students. If teachers and students are involved in classroom management, use coding rules from 13. Classroom Management. 16. Teacher out of the This code should be marked if the Room. teacher is late, or the teacher leaves the room for any reason. 12 Describe what happened in your log Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual Classroom Snapshot Materials Code Item No Materials/ None Description This is coded when materials are not being used. No Materials is always coded with Social Interactions, Students Uninvolved, Being Disciplined, and Classroom Management. This category is also coded when human bodies are used as a tool in any activity Books This category refers to printed materials that students do not write-in directly. The Book category includes textbooks, anthologies, periodicals, students' own produced writing, and material copied from books or periodicals. Notebooks, Pencil and This designation refers to consumable materials that students work with to Paper/Slate develop concepts or skills and include notebooks, workbooks, worksheets, journals, sets or files of teacher or commercially prepared work, or blank sheets of paper on which students work problems, write answers, or write essays and stories. If students are copying work from the blackboard/ chalkboard onto their papers, use this category. Classroom materials such as pencils, crayons, or erasers are coded here. Chalkboard / Blackboard Code this category when teachers or students are working at the classroom chalkboard. Manipulative Code this category for hands-on materials that provide instruction or practice. Any physical object that the student or teacher uses as a learning tool. This may include: science experiments, rulers, compasses, currency, blocks, flash cards, or materials used to construct a project. Materials such as pencils, crayons, or erasers are not coded here, they are coded under the Paper/Pencil category. Visual Aides, Computers, Code this category if calculator or computer is used. Please describe the Calculators machine(s) in your log. Use this category to describe visuals or the graphical display of information used to accompany instruction and enhance student understanding. Visual aids include information written on the overhead projector, maps, charts, photos, posters, flipcharts, pocket charts, slides, or 13 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual felt boards, audio tape recorders and other teaching learning materials. This category does not include the chalkboard – activities using the chalkboard should be coded under Chalkboard. Cooperative Learning Use this category when students work together on an assignment in small groups. (Note it should be coded on the I line) The assignment should have a final intended product, such as a mural, a revised essay, a group report, a map, a science experiment done as a group, something done in shop, etc. If students are working co-operatively in small groups, without the teacher monitoring, code students on the I line (along the appropriate activity line), in small groups. Never code a 1 in the co-operative coloumn OTHER CODING RULES Be certain to calculate how many minutes can be allowed between each observation so that you will have time to collect ten Snapshots. 1. Teacher can be placed only once for each snapshot 2. When completing the Snapshot, first record the teacher, and then going clock wise around the room, record the students involved in activities or are off task. 3. Do not code the students who are working with the teacher on a separate line – remember they are included in the teacher code. 4. More than one student, more than one small group of students or large groups of students can be marked on the “I” line in the same or different activities. 5. E = Everyone. If you code E, Do not mark any other code. E includes the teacher and must be coded on the T line. 6. Do not code in the Other line (Category 9), unless otherwise instructed 14 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual CALCULATIONS Activities are grouped as: a) Active Instruction, b) Passive Instruction c) Classroom Management d) Teacher Off-Task e) Student Off-Task. a) Active Instruction: Active Instruction includes activities where the teacher is directly involved with students in one of the activities listed below. Active Instruction also occurs among students if more than one of them are interacting with each other in activities such as projects. (Refer Appendix 2, activities 15) 1. Reading Aloud 2. Instruction/Demonstration/Lecture 3. Discussion 4. Practice/Drill 5. Kinesthetic/Projects b) Passive Instruction: Passive Instruction activities are those where the teacher may be monitoring for example: moving around the room and looking over shoulders, but the teacher is not directly involved as the students do their seatwork or copying. (Refer Appendix 2, activities 6-7) 1. Copying 2. Silent Seatwork c) Classroom Management: (Refer Appendix 2, activities 8,12, 13, 15) 1. Verbal Instruction 2. Classroom Management 3. Discipline 4. Teacher Managing Alone d) Teacher Off-Task: (Refer Appendix 2, activities 10, 14, 16) 1. Social Interaction (with students) 2. Teacher Social Interaction /Uninvolved 3. Teacher out of the Room e) Student Off-Task: (Refer Appendix 2, activities 10, 11, 12) 1. Social Interaction 15 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual 2. Student Uninvolved 3. Discipline 16 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual REVIEW YOUR CODING FOR ACCURACY Look at the cover page of each booklet. Have you recorded the correct teacher number? Have you entered your observer number? Have you recorded the date and time? Have you completed each line of the form? Look at each of the ten observations. Do you have only one T marked on each Snapshot? Do you account for all of the children? If you marked an E on the T line, do you have any other marks on the form? Erase and change any errors you find during your review of the coding. Did you complete all ten observations? Did you describe any unusual event in the log? (Punishments, kinesthetics, tests) Are your coding marks clear so that the data recorder can read them easily? 17 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual APPENDIX 1: CLASSROOM INFORMATION SHEET/SNAPSHOT COVER SHEET CLASS ROOM INFORMATION SHEET (SNAPSHOT COVER SHEET) Day Month 1.DATE OF OBSERVATION (MM/DD/YY) 2. DURATION OF OBSERVATION Year Minutes 3. NAME & ADDRESS OF SCHOOL_____________ ____________________________________________ ____________________________________________ 4. SCHOOL CODE 5. STATE/REGION_________________________ 6. OBSERVER NAME _________________________ 7. OBSERVER CODE 8. TEACHER NAME __________________________ 9. TEACHER CODE 10. GRADE OBSERVED 11. SUBJECT______________________________ To 12. NO. OF STUDENTS ENROLLED IN CLASS Total 13. NO. OF STUDENTS PRESENT IN THE CLASS Of Which Girls Total Of Which Girls 14. PERCENTAGE OF STUDENTS USING TEXTBOOKS 15. WHAT TIME WAS CLASS SUPPOSED TO BEGIN : 16. WHAT TIME DID CLASS ACTUALLY BEGIN : 17. WHAT TIME WAS CLASS SUPPOSED TO END : 18. WHAT TIME DID CLASS ACTUALLY END : 19. Log: Mention any special events, problems with coding this sheet, abnormal activities etc 18 Stallings Snapshot Observation Manual APPENDIX 2: CLASSROOM OBSERVATION SNAPSHOTS (1-10) Snapshot 1 Classroom Observation Snapshot MATERIALS 1. Reading Aloud T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE Visual Aides/ Compu ter/Cal culator 1SLE 1SLE 2. Instruction/Demonstration/Lect T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 3. Discussion T I T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 5. Kinesthetic/Projects T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 6. Silent Seatwork T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 7. Copying T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 8. Verbal Instruction T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 9. Other T I 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 1SLE 10. Social Interaction T I 1SLE 1SLE 11. Student Uninvolved I 1SLE 12. Discipline T 1SLE 13. Classroom Management T I 1SLE 1SLE No Materia l/None Books Notebo ok/Pap er/Penc il ACTIVITY 4. Practice/Drill 14. Teacher Social Interaction/Uninvolved T 15. Teacher Mgmt. 19 Chalk board/ Blackb oard Manip ulative T Cooperativ e 1SLE 1SLE 16. Teacher out of Room T