London Bridge on a Hot Summer Day 45 Minute Lesson NJ Standards 5.2.4.E.1 / 5.2.2.E.2 – Identify the force that accelerates an object. 5.2.2.B.1 – Some properties of matter can change as a result of heating or cooling. 5.1.12.D.2 – Science involves using language, both oral and written, as a tool for making thinking public. 5.1.12.D.1 – Science involves practicing productive social interactions with peers, such as partner talk, whole-group discussions, and small group work. NJ Standard 5.2.4.E.1 5.2.2.E.2 Goal Students will understand how a bridge works structurally. 5.1.12.D.1 5.1.12.D.2 5.2.2.B.1 Students will understand how objects change in different temperatures. Resources Student Use: Gum Drops, Toothpicks, Glue, Tape, Paper, Spaghetti, Paper Clips Teacher Use: Paper Clips, Styrofoam Cup, Many pennies Pre-Requisite Knowledge Dynamics, Newton's Laws of Motion Kinetic Molecular Theory Evidence Students will use their knowledge of forces to build a rudimentary wood bridge capable of carrying a load of 15 pennies. Students will be able to make a prediction in regards to what will happen to their bridge in varying temperatures, using a microscopic model of matter. Real World Applications Thermal Expansion; Why are there small gaps on bridge connectors? Why does one heat the lid of a tight jar when attempting to open it? Bridges; Why are bridges shaped the way they are? And how can they support so much? Bridge Destruction; Buckling. Why do perfectly good structures all of a sudden fail and break? Potential Difficulties Students may have difficulties building strong supports without analysis of forces and torques. Students may have difficulties predicting the behavior of materials in different temperatures without a strong understanding of the kinetic molecular theory. Students may have difficulties justifying the use of pre-existing support structures. Students may have difficulty in choosing an adhesive material and justifying one over the other. Lesson Description A. Opening (5 minutes) Opening question: What elements go into making a bridge? Students will view a picture of a bridge connector with a gap. Why do bridges have this gap? Students will brainstorm why there is a noticeable gap on a bridge connector. [Students should easily come up with the reliability and consistency of a strong structure. Some students may identify strong materials that can withstand different climates. Students may also note the use of cables. Stress the fact that the bridge is not completely connected to the non-bridge area. Why is there a noticeable gap? Wouldn't this be a safety hazard?] B. Building a Bridge (15 minutes) Students in small groups will construct open bridge structures, 20 inches in length that can carry a load of minimum 15 pennies (in addition to the styrofoam cup supporting said pennies) . Students are permitted to use only three materials out of the following: Gum drops, Tape, Glue, Toothpicks, Spaghetti, Paper, Paper Clips Groups should document the reason they choose each material and the particular reason as to why their bridge is shaped the way it is. [Students may take inspiration from pre-existing bridge structures and or truss designs. Students may determine one adhesive to be better than the other if not use multiple adhesives.] C. Testing the bridge (5 minutes) Groups will test their bridges over a 18-inch gap with a styrofoam cup attached to the bridge. The goal is to be able to support 15 pennies without the bridge showing any visible buckling or deterioration. D. Why This or The Other? (15 minutes) Groups will have a brief discussion on their design and material choices. Students will be given a new challenge, can their bridge hold up under a cold rainy day? Groups should also make predictions on how their bridge may be affected by the hot weather. Which of the materials are good for withstanding cold and hot weather? Based on your ideas of how the adhesives behave in higher temperatures have students discuss again why there are small gaps between bridge connectors. Stress to students what happens to an object when it becomes hot. [Hot weather: Bridges made of glue may see the adhesive melt, proving catastrophic Bridges connected with gum drops will become sticky. Is this a concern? Bridges connected with paper, spaghetti, tape will curl or unfold if they are designed to be supports. Cold, Rainy Weather: Glue and gum drop bridges harden and may crack. Paper, spaghetti, paper clips and tape may show no signs of effects. Metal and wood tend to have no visible signs of wear compared to adhesives. Students can benefit from a real life example of heating a tight lid in an attempt to open it, in order to understand thermal expansion.] E. Reflection (5 minutes) Students reflect on what they have learned. What have they learned about building bridges, materials used, bridge design? Time Table Activity A – Opening Time Duration (Clock) 5 minutes (0:05) Students doing Discussion B – Building Bridges 15 minutes (0:20) C – Testing Bridges D – Why Choose That or the Other? E – Reflection 5 minutes 15 minutes 5 minutes (0:25) (0:40) (0:45) Building bridges, keeping notes on design choices Testing bridges Class discussion Reflect Teacher doing Discussion, present materials for (B) Observing Observing Discussion, Listening Discussion, Listening Formative Assessment Why do we build bridges with triangle like structures? Why not a flat road just like the road atop a bridge? Trusses (triangular like structures) have very good support compared to flat line or square structures. Exploring the structure with a force diagram is useful here. What happens to objects as they are heated? Certain objects may change physical states. But students here should recognize that heating objects increases the kinetic energy of atoms in the object. This increases the volume an object takes up (thermal expansion). Dramatic increases in volumes are seen in phase changes. Why is _____________ a good/bad material to use in constructing our Students will notice that metal and wood do not show very visible signs of change in different temperatures. However, different materials have model bridge? varying advantages and disadvantages to be taken into consideration.