ISSUES IN THE PRACTICE OF RELIGION IN NIGERIA Editor-in-Chief M.T. Yahya Editors: Ade P. Dopamu R.A. Raji E. Ade Odumuyiwa Daniel Shishima S.A. Owoeye P.O. Abioje CHRISTIAN RECOGNITION OF OTHER RELIGIONS: TOWARDS RELIGIOUS MUTUAL RESPECT IN SOCIETY P.O. Abioje Introduction Religious peace has remained elusive and intractable in many parts of the world. Typical headlines in current newspaper report include: "Hindus, Muslims clash" (The Monitor, Wednesday, May 15, 2002-.5V and "Fresh trouble brews in Kano ... over planned demolition of Churches" (Sunday Punch, August 11, 2002-.1&3). In another report, titled "Religious tension grips Yorubaland", one reads that "Religious crisis, an unusual event in Yorubaland. is now taking a centre stage in the area, as a result of militant activities of Christian and Muslim preachers" (Weekly Trust, December 7- 1 3, 2001 : 1 &3). The fear is thus not unfounded that humanity may continue to witness various forms of Jihads and Crusades. The purpose of this paper is to address the issue of mutual recognition and respect among all religions in society, toward peace and order, without which no society can progress. As the theme indicates, the study is done with regard to Christianity, but can pose a challenge to all, religions in society. The discourse opens with an examination of Christianity as a missionary religion. The Absolute Conception of Christianity Christianity mostly conceived itself as the only real religion, for many centuries, and even now many Christians still think of their religion as the absolute one. Apparently, this line of conviction and attitude has been nursed by the Bible, where Jesus is quoted as teaching that "Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water and the spirit he cannot enter into the Kingdom of God" (John 3:5). In other words, an unbaptised person cannot be a child of God. But, how can a person authentically receive baptism outside Christianity? There seems to be no answer to that question. Instead, Christians are commanded and enjoined to "Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit" (Mtt. 28:29). In his own record, St. Mark reports that upon the resurrection and final departure of Jesus Christ, the Apostles "went out and preached everywhere while the Lord worked with them". (Mark 16:19). Thus, Christianity has been a missionary religion right from inception. convinced that to be a child of God, a person must be of necessity a disciple of Jesus Christ, because "There is no other name under heaven that has been given among men by which we must be-saved" (Acts 4:12). For "God highly exalted Him, and bestowed on Him the name which is above every name, so that at the name of Jesus EVERY KNEE WILL BOW, of those who are in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and that every tongue will confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father" (Philippians 2:9-11). Those articles of faith and the accompanying command propel the Christian missionary drive. It made the Catholic Church to teach that there is no salvation outside the Church (Extra ecclesiam nulla salus), and many Protestant churches believe that there is no salvation outside the Bible. While this position may not have been officially dropped by both Catholics and Protestants, it has been reinterpreted in several quarters to mean that every person living in accordance with the will of God, virtually, if not physically, belongs to the Church, no matter the religious or social identity. This re-interpretation belongs to a period when many Christians have started to realise that the Church has no monopoly of Godly persons, and that there are both good and evil baptized persons in the church also. Karl Rahner, for one, names the non-associating and unidentified members of the church, who are found outside the registered members of the church, anonymous Christians. (Rahnner, 1980:75). In that way, it can be said that anybody in any socio-religious walk of life who is living in accordance with the will of God is moved by the spirit of Jesus Christ, and can thus be regarded as a Christian at heart, without baptism or official membership of the Church. The Good Samaritan in Luke 10:30-37 is a biblical example. There are other Christian theologians, such as John Courts, who recognize the legitimacy of non-Christian religions. Courts rightly notes, for instance, that: In the past - and sometimes today - people have been too quick to assume that those who followed other faiths were obstinate or even wicked. Yet. several Bible writers say that those who did not know of God's message to Israel might sincerely seek him. (Courts. 1990:vii). Coutts proceeds by quoting the Old Testament Prophet Malachi, to the effect that "people from one end of the world to the other honour me. Everywhere they burn incense to me and offer acceptable sacrifices (Malachi 1:11)". In the final analysis, Coutts hopes that as Christians study the beliefs of others, they "may come to know their own Lord better, and to love their neighbours more wisely than before!". (pp.vii-ix). The implication of the foregoing is that like on most issues, the Bible can be cited both for and against the existence of non-Christian religions, depending on the interest and level of understanding of the person using the Bible, One would like to study more closely, how the Bible has opposed other religions both in the old and the "New Testaments. Biblical Antagonism against Non-Christian Religions It seems to me that not much is known about Judaism as a propagating religion. A clear reference is the fact that converts to the religion (proselytes) are mentioned in the Acts of the Apostles (2:10, 6:5, 13:43). The Bible Reader's Encyclopaedia and Concordance defines proselytes as the "Gentiles won from the heathen world and converted to Judaism". (Wright, 1977:300). One's concern here is to establish the fact that it is not farfetched why the Old Testament has portrayed other religions as bad, since the writers were mostly Judaisers, or adherents of Judaism, which, as a religion, was interested in making converts. There seems to be no better way of converting people than by making them realise or feel that they are in a bad or wrong place. No wonder then that the Old Testament has several portions that are full of invectives against the religion of the Canaanites, and the religions of other peoples in the world at large. One reads, for instance, that "all gods of the nations are idols" (Psalm 9d:5), The greatest assault came when the Canaanite Prophets were said to have called in vain on their "god" (Baal) to conjure fire to consume some raw meat and firewood, in a contest said to be organised by Elijah. On the other hand, Yahweh was said to have proved Himself to be a living, active, and effective God in the life of His people, when he issued fire to consume the raw meat on wet firewood (I Kings 18). The implication was the Baal was dead, slumbering, or non-existent, and that there was no God except in Israel. Yet, one reads in the same Old Testament: "Behold, to the Lord your God belong heaven and the highest heavens, the earth and all that is in it" (Deut. 10:14). And, "The earth is the Lord's, and all it contains, the world, and those who dwell in it". (Psalm 24:1). The understanding today is that there is only one Supreme Being, diversely conceived on account of geopolitical and cultural diversity. As S.M. Michael rightly notes, "The experience of different groups of people at different places and times bring forth innumerable cultural ways. Cultures are but different answers to essentially the same human problems". (Michael, 1994:12). On another note, the principal Old Testament text that is quoted against non-Christian religions, except of course, Judaism and probably Islam, is: You shall have no other gods before me. You shall not make for yourself an idol, or any likeness of what is in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the water under the earth. You shall not worship them or serve them ... (Exodus 20:3-5a). In contemporary times, however, there is a growing consciousness that most peoples of the world recognise and acknowledge the supremacy of the Supreme Being, even though they recognise some other spiritual beings that are believed to derive their existence from Him, and not of equal status with Him. Judaism, Christianity and Islam also believe that God has angels who are at God's service, even though these may not be worshipped as in religions that have no direct affinity with the Bible. In nutshell, it must be noted that the real other gods are not the spiritual beings worshipped as agents of God in non-biblical religions, but the idols of ego, power, money, sex, and extravagance are among the gods to which much is sacrificed (including human sacrifice) by many Christians and non-Christians today. In a report, titled "Season of Ritualists", David Njoku documents how Nigeria has become a country where money-making rituals involving human lives are rampant. He describes a situation in which "it has become a daily routine to see decapitated dead human bodies dumped on roadsides, canals, swamp bushes ... most of them with their vital organs cut-off. (Sunday limes, December 9, 2001:11-13). The Weekly Trust of July 19-25,2002, reports how a Pastor, Efosa Omoregie, his wife, and younger brother, Ikponwmosa Omoregie, were arrested for armed robbery in Benin City. The Pastor denied going out for any robbery himself, but admitted enjoying from the loots, adding, as quoted by the reporter, Shehu Abubakar. "I sold two of the vehicles to some people. I normally give any vehicles brought to me to a spray painter to change the colour immediately" (p.7). The fact turned out to be that the Pastor was the patron of the eight-man gang. "Delta Police Nab woman Pastor for Robbery", is the heading of another report in the Weekly Trust of August 23-29,2002. One reads that an arrested member of the gang led police to the Church where the prophetess and the other escapees were found busy performing miracles to avoid police arrest. In the process, "one of the robbers attempted to escape and was shot dead", said ASP Obasuyi, as quoted by the paper. The Prophetess is also quoted as saying "Why should the Satan succeed over a women of God like me?" (p. 10). Coincidentally, the two stories about the Pastor armed-robbers come from two editions of the same paper, which is based in the Muslim North. But it is still nationally circulated weekly. At any rate, Christian leaders can not have the monopoly of armed robbers among their ranks. It is a different matter if other people's dirty robes are not exposed. The fact remains that money has become one of the gods of many contemporary men and women, irrespective of religious adherence. As Bucknor-Akerele is quoted to have rightly observed, it would appear that "virtually every known value in the society" has declined, giving way to "the phenomenon of graft and corruption". (Sunday Punch, July 21, 2002:16). She may well have added: armed robbery and money-making rituals that involve human lives. Tu6 Situation i5 hardly different in regard of most parts of the world. A Spanish Christian theologian, Jose Maria Gonzalez Ruiz, notfiS that. In fact, how often has the worship of God been nothing but the worship of one idol, disguised as the God of the Bible? The approach to the understanding of what an idol is begins with the understanding of what God is not. God, as the Supreme value and goal, is not man, the state, an institution, nature, power, possession, sexual power, or any article made by man. (Cfr. Cabestrero, 1981:81). Thus, it can be said that what may be most offensive to God today may not be the worship of spiritual beings that are believed to be subordinates and answerable to God, but selfishness and greed that translate into inhumanity of human beings to their own kind. Self-seeking, tyranny and greed constitute alternative gods, which obstruct human availability for worshipping God and doing His will. If God is quoted as saying He prefers mercy to sacrifice (Hosea 6:6, Mt. 9: 13), that may mean that showing mercy and compassion to one’s neighbour is of utmost concern to God than empty worship of Him or worship of any other spiritual being. This becomes more explicit when Jesus is quoted as saying: "Not everyone who says to me, 'Lord, Lord', will enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father who is in heaven" (Mt. 7:21). St. Paul also tells the Corinthians that love (or charity) is superior to faith and hope (1Cor. 13:13). Likewise, St. James wonders and asks: "How does it help, my brothers, when someone who has never done a single good act claims to have faith? Will that faith bring salvation?" (James 2:14). Thus, the essence of faith in God is good deeds. Experience would reveal that non-Christians, such as the good Samaritan (Luke 10:30-37) may do better than some Christians. Indeed, Donal Murray rightly notes that: The kingdom is not being built exclusively by Christians. It may be that many Christians are not building ii at all. But wherever in this world human potential, dignity and brotherhood are developed, no matter by whom, the world is prepared for its destiny, i Murray, 1975:80). It would thus appear that people in all religious walks of life can live lives that are pleasing to God. It may be discovered that what makes a person good is not religion, ultimately, but the grace of God in the person. The Old Testament has it that "all gods of the nations are idols" (Psalm 96:5), and many Christian missionaries were later to go about calling o adherents of other regions "idol worshippers", in the African, Asian, Chinese, Australian, European, and other contexts. Good enough, the situation is better appreciated today. As Ninian Smart rightly notes for instance, religion is not an altogether visible reality: It is true that there are temples, ceremonies, religious art. These can be seen, but their significance needs to be approached through the inner life of those who use these externals. Consider the ceremony of baptizing a baby. How can we understand it, save by knowing what the idea of baptism means to Christians and by knowing the hopes and feelings of those who participate in the occasion? We must see the way in which the externals and inner meanings of reunion are fused together (Smart, 1981:11). One can illustrate this in the African context by saying it is not enough to see people kneeling, praying, singing, and worshipping at the foot of natural forces, such as a river, mountain, or a big Iroko tree. It is necessary to know what the people's actual belief is. If, for instance, part of their belief is that a venerable spirit is inhabiting a natural object, such as a big Iroko tree, how can an external investigator prove them wrong or right ? In his book on West African Traditional Religion. A.B. Jacobs quotes the experience of J.H. Neal, from the latter 's book: Juju in My Life. What happened was that his company was constructing a harbour, and they could not uproot a particular tree, even with all the modern mechanical equipment. "The African foreman suggested that the tree could only be removed if the spirit living in it could be persuaded to quit the tree". In sum, an African traditional priest was approached. He prescribed offerings for sacrifice. And the tree was easily uprooted after the sacrifice. (Jacobs, 1977:196). One is, of course, free to believe these types of story or not to believe. It suffices to recognise that the world and life itself is wider than what the individual or groups of persons can encapsulate. And humanity currently longs for freedom of belief, among other forms of freedom. In Contemporary times, the enemy of Society, who is regarded as the enemy of God, is a person who unjustifiably breaches the peace, creates chaos, violence and misery in people's lives. Along with the foregoing, an interested theologian must find out how worshippers relate the spirit they worship in a natural object to the Supreme Being, in their native conviction. One would suggest that a Christian should never forget that to call Jesus Christ God is an article of faith, which is viewed as ridiculous by most Jews and Muslims. The same logic applies to the Christian view of the Muslim belief that the Qur'an was written in God's personal words, and the conviction that Prophet Muhammad is the seal of God's prophets. Thus, the adage is apt, that he who lives in a glass house must never throw stones. Objects of faith remain objects of faith for those who believe in them. John Coutts quotes William Booth, the Founder of the Salvation Army, as writing that: "In dealing with the followers of non-Christian religions, any attack upon the false should be avoided, as this would only arouse anger in those who believe it to be true" (Coutts. 1990:ix). The judgement of what constitutes "the false" is better left to the reader. But the message is clear as necessary for a peaceful co-existence, and it appears to have nothing to do with conscientious brotherly correction devoid of force It is also possible that what is "false" for a group of believers may actually be true for another set of believers. Hence. Donal Murray rightly observes that "whatever our petty illusions of superiority over one another, our hope is identical with that of the people we attempt to subject to our own ends". He has something to say on prejudice also: Prejudiced attitudes derive from many sources. In some cases they are simply inherited from the community to which we belong as is usually the case with racial, religious, or class prejudice ... The same attitudes may arise quite innocently as the result of genuine misinterpretation of another person's acts or words. (Murray, 1975:76&42). It cannot be inappropriate to take the concluding words of this section from the Bible. There are indications in the book that peoples all over the world (not only Israel) worship God. Peoples worldwide offer acceptable offerings to God. No wonder God is quoted as blessing Gentile nations along with Israel, saying, for instance, "Blessed be my people Egypt, Assyria my creation, and Israel my heritage" (Isaiah 19:25), Thus, Christians who claim, albeit legitimately, to constitute the New Israel (or the New People of God) should not make the mistake of thinking that God recognises no other children or that He can be subjected to any form of nepotism or sectarianism. One would like to examine, at this juncture, what scholars are saying about the value of other religions. Intrinsic Values in Non-Christian Religions One can note that Christianity is not a majority religion in all parts of the world. It is most prominent in Europe and the America. It is only one of the three principal religions in many parts of Africa, along with African Religion and Islam. Asia, the most populous continent of the world has other powerful religions, such as Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Confucianism. Thus, John Cobb rightly notes that: The church did establish itself in almost all countries, and in parts of the world where the dominant religions were primal, Christianity often competed with Islam in successful conversions. But where Christianity faced other axial traditions, such as Islam. Hinduism, and Buddhism, its advances were far more limited. This means that the hearts of most Asian cultures have never been captured by the West (Cobb. 1997:34). Yet, Christianity itself originated from Asia. Every religion must have some value for its adherents. And value here refers to objective, rather than selfish value, otherwise what is involved may be regarded as a false religion. Yet. one must remember that many positive things are open to abuse and falsification. The highest values of religion appear to be faith in God and moral rectitude. These are expectedly partronised by every religion, except that one must grant exception to human shortcomings such as lies and deceptions. In time; Christianity appropriated to itself alone terms and concepts that have existed from time immemorial. It thought, for instance, that there was no religion, properly so called, other than itself. But, as theologians, such as Karl Barth, have noted, one cannot differentiate and separate Christianity or the Church from other religions on the basis of a general concept of the nature of religion. This is because, as Barth explains: By trying to resist and conquer other religions, we put ourselves on the same level. They, too, appeal to this or that immanent truth in them. They, too, can triumph in the power of the religious selfconsciousness, and sometimes they have been astonishingly successful over wide areas. (Barth, 1980:47). Another concept appropriated by Christianity to itself alone is that of theology. Obviously, there is nothing peculiarly Christian in the Greek Theos (God) and Logos (word or study). Theology, as the study of or discourse about God is an open science. Bolaji Idowu expresses displeasure on the Christian misappropriation, noting that qualified and budding theologians still live with "the age-old erroneous notion that only one religion, namely Christianity, has theology which makes nonsense of the linguistic and connotational significance of the word". He notes aiso how the university degree of Doctor of Divinity (D.D.) is said to be an award that can be granted only in respect of Christian Theology (Idowu, 1978:10). All the foregoing indicate a recognition, on the part of a number of Christian theologians, that Christianity may not be the only religion acceptable to both God and humanity, objectively speaking. Sacred writings of other religions, such as Hinduism, Buddhism and Islam reveal that anybody who follows faithfully the essential teachings of these religions cannot be said to be without the grace of God. The same applies to non-historical religions, such as African Religions, that have no sacred texts but still value high ethico-moral standards. Pope John Paul II is among contemporary theologians who describe ancient religions as "systems of worship and also ethical systems, with a strong emphasis on good and evil". He teaches, therefore, that "Instead of marveling at the fact that providence allows such a great variety of religions, we should be amazed at the number of common elements found within them". (John Paul II, 1994:82). To buttress the foregoing, one may quote Bolaji Idowu, for example. He has this to say about Ifa priests in Yoruba religion: In Orunmila, we meet again another element of the demands and sanctions of morality in the religion of the Yoruba. It is laid down that a Baba 'lawo must not abuse his office in-any way: if he does, he will never be received into heaven ... Now that materialism is the order of the day, however, this sacred injunction is largely disregarded. (Idowu, 1977:79-80). The second part of Idowu's observation (above) refers to the unfortunate situation whereby dishonesty, selfishness and greed have taken the centre stage in an era in which Christianity and Islam pride themselves in being the dominant religions of the world - two of the three religions that claim to have been raised specifically by God to effect human liberation — the third, which is also the primal, being Judaism. A contemporary of Idowu, John Mbiti, also observes that many traditional African religious leaders are wise, intelligent and talented people, often with outstanding abilities and personalities. The leaders include, according to Mbiti, medicine men and women, diviners, mediums, seers, priests, ritual elders, rainmakers, and rulers. He is convinced that African Religion has provided valid explanations and solutions to the people's life perplexities (Mbiti, 1975:150&174). The discussion here is about the intrinsic value of non-Christian religions. Some space is allotted to African Religion, not just because the writer is an African, but also because, as E.G Parrinder rightly notes, among other scholars, "it is probably true to say that African Religion has been more misunderstood, and has suffered more at the hands of the early writers, than any other parts of African life. Unhappily old misconceptions linger with us still". What is more unhappy may be the fact that "The modern African himself has not infrequently been taught to misunderstand the religion of his ancestors, so that it comes as a surprise to him to learn that their beliefs can be studied fairly and even with sympathy". (Parrinder, 1975:13). Many scholars have noted the resilience of ancient religions, such as African Religion. A plausible explanation may be that the religions have values for people theologically, philosophically, emotionally, spiritually, socially, psychologically, and otherwise. Beyond that, there are Christian theologians, such as Modupe Oduyoye, who believe that Christianity can learn certain things from non-Christian religions. Speaking specifically about African Religion, she maintains that "Christian Theology might benefit from a knowledge of traditional statements concerning God. nature and human nature which might help clarify the statements that Christianity has been groping for." (Oduyoye, 1986:6). Likewise, John Taylor believes that by dialoguing with people who possess primal worldviews, Christians may overcome "our usual superiority complexes and might teach us new humility and openness towards our neighbour". Moreover, he hopes: It may be possible to recover from primal societies the importance of human relationships in 'caring', 'coping' and 'curing' so that more people may find release from modern alienation and fragmentation in family loyalties and local communities that give them real support and comfort (Taylor, 1976:vii-viii). In another respect, Christianity may need to learn about religious cooperation from age-old religions, such as African religion. In most African communities, each denomination of African Religion worship and celebrates peacefully with the cooperation and social participation of many non-adherents of the particular divinity involved. There is hardly any competition or rivalry, which may lead to division, hatred, animosity and violence, in the name of religious diversity. Awolalu and Dopamu rightly note that in African perspective, "God is the cohesive factor of the society ... and religion binds the community together." China is reputed to be the most populous nation on earth. Yet, she is not weighed down by her heavy population, instead she is to reckon with, economically and technologically. Huston Smith observes that: Part of the reason for China's success may lie in the way she positioned her religions as partners rather than antagonists... As the then-going adage had it. every black-haired child of Han wears a Confucian hat, a Taoist robe, and Buddhist sandals. (Smith, 2001:207-208). That bothers on the overall concern of this paper: religious mutual recognition, respect and cooperation. Religion appears often abused by selfish political leaders to subdue, exploit, divide and rule the people. Hence, one hears of religious violence, despite the fact that hardly any religion is known to preach hatred. For instance, the elements of religious superiority complex that may be found in the Bible are also countered by other teachings of the Bible, which recognise God's ownership of all creation, and all earthly and heavenly beings. A typical example of the latter is St. Peter, the Prince of the Apostles, who admits: "The truth I have now come to realise is that God does not have favourites, but that anybody of any nationality who fears God and does what is right is acceptable to him". (Acts 10:34-35). Conclusion As a propagating religion, Christianity sets for itself the task of making converts. That is a religio-humanitarian duty, in as much as Christianity, like Islam, considers itself to be the absolute religion to which every human being must belong in order to be saved. In the course of this study, it is discovered that when a religion sees itself as absolute, it tends to blackmail other religions in an attempt to convert their adherents. But there has been a growing realisation that no religion has monopoly of divine qualities, and there may be many ways to the same God. Not less important is the fact that most contemporary men and women cherish religious freedom, and they abhor religious aggression and violence. They regard enforcement of religion as barbaric and anti-civilization. They think that the religious terrain in the twenty-first century should be characterised not by different forms of Jihads and crusades, but mutual respect, brotherly dialogue, negotiation, and societal team spirit. The expectation today is that all men and women of good will from all religious walks of life should unite to instill sanity into a corrupt and crime infested society. Religious bigotry, group egotism and clique practice cannot breed peace, universal love and advancement. It cannot ensure truth, objectivity and justice. In the final analysis, it is not religion as such but the grace of God in a person, together with personal disposition and character trait matter. Experience reveals that Christians can no longer love only Christians, because many non-Christians are loveable, based on their character and attitude, some Christians are hardly loveable. Besides, God makes His rain and sun for Christians and non-Christians indiscriminately (Mtt. 4:45). One's observation is that many naturally nice persons portray and effect their goodness in the name of God and religion, while many bad persons, including tyrants and sadists also try to exhibit and practicalise their wicked and selfish traits in the name of God and religion. Historical experiences would seem to have abundantly revealed that no religion (including Christianity and Islam) is impervious to this situation. There seems to be no rule to guarantee, in practical terms, that all Christians are of the same quality moral and intellectually. Even those who belong to no religion at all seem to encompass both nice and bad persons also. Thus, the best thing would seem to be that good persons from all walks of life put their heads together to establish a Godly reign wherever they find themselves, in the nation, in a family, in other institutions, societies and establishments, rather than encouraging any form of unholy alliance and chauvinism. In African tradition, such as in Yorubaland. it is believed that every religion belongs to God, and has a positive role to play in the life of persons and communities. Human beings are however categorised into good and bad persons. The Yoruba would call bad persons: eniyan buruku, while they call good persons: omoluwabi (literally- God's child). But they also realise that a good person may sometimes do evil, just as a bad person may sometimes do good. Thus, one may not be too rigid, but the traits are unmistakable. And that is what necessitates the need for good persons to team up, irrespective of religion, to ensure justice and good order in all areas of human interactions and relationships. On a particular note, Nigeria, as a highly pluralistic society requires the Principle Of Unity in diversity, and ethnico-religious and cultural mutual respect, to advance and progress in all fields of human and societal endeavour. It is rightly said that there can be no progress without peace, and there cannot be peace without justices Religious enforcement negates Godgiven human freedom, and breeds, strife and division. It smothers democracy and human advancement. Bibliography Awolalu, J.O. and P. Ade Dopamu, West African Traditional Religion, Revised Edition (Ibadan: Macmillan), 2005. Barth, K. "The Revelation of God as the Abolition of Religion" in Hick. J. and B. Hebblethwaite, (eds.), Christianity and other Religions. (Fount Paperbacks. Collins. 1980, Glasgow). Cabestrero, T. (ed.), Faith: Conversations with Contemporary Theologians, (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, 1981, New York). Cobb, J.B Jr., Reclaiming the Church: Where the Mainline church Went Wrong and What to Do About It (Westminster John Knox Press, 1979, Louisville, Kentucky). Coutts, J., Our Faith and Theirs, (The Campfield Press, 1983 St. Albans, Herts). Idowu, E.B., Olodumarre: God in Yoruba Belief, (Longman Nigeria Ltd., 1977, Ikeja). Idowu, E.B., African Traditional Religion: A Definition, (SCM Press Ltd., 1978 London). Jacobs, A.B., A Textbook on West African Traditional Religion. (Aromolaran Publishing Company Ltd., 1978, Ibadan). John Paul II, Crossing the Threshold of Hope, Edited by Vittorio Mesori (Alfred A . Knopf, 1 994, New York). Mbiti, J.S., Introduction to African Religion, (Heinemann: 1975 London). Michael, S.M. "What Do We Mean by the Term Culture?", in Kavunkal, J. and F. Hrangkhuma, (eds.), Christ and Cultures, (St. Pauls Bandra, 1994 Bombay). f\ Murray, D. Jesus is Lord: Introduction to Christian Theology, 1975, (Verita Publications, 1975 Dublin). Oduyoye, M. ed., The State of Christian Theology in Nigeria, 1980-81, 1986, (Daystar Press, Ibadan). Parrinder, E.G., African Traditional Religion, (Sheldon Press, 1 975 London). Rahner, fC. "Christianity and the Non-Christian Religions" in Hick, J. and B. Hebblethwaite, eds., Christianity and other Religions, (Fount Paperbacks, 1980 Collins, Glasgow). Smart, N., The Religious Experience of Mankind, (Fount Paperbacks, 1981 Collins, Glasgow). Smith. H. Why Religion Matters: The Fate of the Human Spirit in an Age of Disbelief, 2001, (Harpersanfransisco). Taylor, J.B., Primal World Views: Christian Dialogue with Traditional Thought Forms, (DayStar, 1976, Ibadan). Taylor, J.V., “The Theological Basis of Interfaith Dialogue” In Hick, J. and B. Hebblethwaite, Christianity and other Religions, (Fount Paperbacks, 1980 Collins, Glasgow). Wright, C.H., The Bible Reader’s Encyclopedia and Concordance, (Collins’ ClearrType Press, 1997, London).