Telecommunications Industry Association
(TIA)
Arlington, VA
TR-30.3/05-06-016
June 13 - 15, 2005
DOCUMENT SUBMITTED TO
TR-30.3 Meeting
The document to which this cover statement is attached is submitted to a Formulating Group or sub-element thereof
of the Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA) in accordance with the provisions of Sections 6.4.1-6.4.6
inclusive of the TIA Engineering Manual dated March 2005, all of which provisions are hereby incorporated by
reference.
SOURCE:
FAL Associates
CONTACT:
Fred Lucas
FAL Associates
Telephone: 410-239-0248
Email: fred.lucas@ieee.org
TITLE:
Comments on Draft Standard PN-3-0062
PROJECT:
PN-3-0062
DISTRIBUTION:
Members of TR-30.3
INTENDED PURPOSE OF
DOCUMENT:
_X__ FOR INCORPORATION INTO A TIA PUBLICATION
____
FOR INFORMATION ONLY
____
OTHER (please describe):
____________________
ABSTRACT
This contribution provides comments on and recommended changes to Draft Standard PN-3-0062.
The following are recommended changes to the draft of PN-3-0069:
Section #
3
Type of
Comment
Editorial
Comment
3
3
Editorial
Editorial
3
Editorial
3
Editorial
3
Editorial
Move and correct version date of
V.150.1. Correct title and add
“Recommendation”.
3
Editorial
3
Editorial
3
Editorial
Add version date and
“Recommendation to Y.1541
Add revision and date to TIA/EIA810.
Add “TIA/EIA” and version date to
TSB116. Correct the title.
3
Editorial
Add “TIA/EIA”, revision and date
to TSB122. Correct the title.
3
Editorial
3
Editorial
3
Editorial
ITU-T Rec. V.152 is referenced in
the text but is not in the References
list. Add the reference.
TIA-1001 is referenced in the text
but is no in the References list.
Add the reference.
TIA differentiates between
Normative and Informative
references.
3
Editorial
4.2.8
Editorial
IS-811 is being revised and is under
ballot
Reference latest version of G.107
Add version date and
“Recommendation” to G.114
Add version date,
“Recommendation and correct title
to T.38
Move and correct version date of
V.150.0. Add “Recommendation”.
References to IEEE standards
missing.
Improper reference to ITU-T
Recommendations in the first
sentence.
Recommended change or new
wording
TIA-811-A-2005,
Telecommunications – Telephone
Terminal Equipment – Performance
and Interoperability Requirements for
Voice-over-IP (VoIP) Feature
Telephones
Change (2002) to (2005)
ITU-T Recommendation G.114
(2003), …
ITU-T Recommendation T.38 (2004),
Procedures for real-time Group 3
facsimile over IP networks
ITU-T Recommendation V.150.0
(2003), Modem-over-IP Networks –
Foundation
ITU-T Recommendation V.150.1
(2003), Modem over IP-Networks:
Procedures for the end-to-end
connection of V-series DCEs
ITU-T Recommendation Y.1541
(2002), …
TIA/EIA-810-A (2000), …
TIA/EIA TSB-116 (2000),
Telecommunications – IP Telephony
Equipment – Voice Quality
Recommendations for IP Telephony
TIA/EIA TSB-122-A (2001),
Telecommunications – IP Telephony
Equipment – IP Telephony Equipment
– Voice Router/Gateway Loss and
Level Plan Guidelines
ITU-T Recommendation V.152
(2005), Procedures for supporting
Voice-Band Data over IP Networks
TIA-1001 (2004), Transport of TIA825-A Signals over IP Networks
Break section 3 into two parts,
Normative and Informative. In
addition, TSBs are always listed under
Informative.
Add references to IEEE 802.11a,
IEEE 802.11b and IEEE 802.11g.
Reword the first sentence to read: “…
standards-based (ITU-T
Recommendations G.107 and
G.108)…”
4.1.32
Editorial
ITU-T documents are
Recommendations not Standards.
6.4
Technical
Access Rates do not reflect today’s
networks.
Reword the first sentence to read:
“…E model described in ITU-T
Recommendations G.107 and G.108.”
As of April 2005, Adelphia provides
the following rates to Home
subscribers:
Preferred Internet: toward core – 384
Kbps max.; from core – 4000 Kbps
max.
Annex C
Editorial
IEEE should precede the standards
numbers throughout the Annex.
Premier Internet: toward core – 768
Kbps max.; from core – 6000 Kbps
max.
Include IEEE before the standard
numbers.